1
500
76
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/026b6b619f9a16e1089713aa9c996711.pdf
2aa56a33dd2768955b79255ee6d03a22
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Sweatshops
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
White House Office of Records Management
Office of Cabinet Affairs
Office of Chief of Staff to the President
Office of Communications
Domestic Policy Council
National Economic Council
Office of Policy Development
Office of Public Liaison
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
National Security Council
NSC Cables
NSC Email
NSC Records Management System
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/100517 ">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2018-1072-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consist of records regarding sweat shop abuses and administration efforts to combat them. It includes articles, cables, drafts, emails, letters, lists, memos, notes, press releases, proposed legislation, reports, schedules, speech cards, and transcripts. Some of the subjects covered include the apparel industry, Central American labor laws, child labor, China, El Salvador, the Fair Labor Association, fashion industry, garment factories, Haiti, human rights abuses, human trafficking, immigration, Indonesia, international agreements, labor laws, Saipan, sweatshops, Vietnam, and wages.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Office of Records Management
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
143 files in 12 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[05/22/1997 – 11/29/1999]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2018-1072-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 5
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26444786">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/100517">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20181072F-005-006-2019
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/9/2019
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/4b9cee35be23b3354cbfbcafa483b15f.pdf
8f724774c98777723948f5c0edacf0e3
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Robert “Ben” Johnson and Racial Disparities in the Criminal Justice System
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
President’s Initiative for One America
Ben Johnson
Office of Public Liaison
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-2000
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<strong><a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/58586">Collection Finding Aid</a></strong>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2018-0997-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records related to drugs, crime, justice in minority communities, racial attitudes and relations, legislation pertaining to cocaine mandatory minimum sentencing, Office on the President’s Initiative for One America agenda, action plan, and weekly reports, discrimination in the criminal justice system, improving the criminal justice system, Ben Johnson’s speaking engagements and meetings with civil rights leaders, and President’s Advisory Board to the President’s Initiative on Race press materials. It contains correspondence, memoranda, reports, drafts, statements, news articles, publications and emails.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
35 folders in 4 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[03/04/1999]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2018-0997-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 3
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26444786" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/58586">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20180997F-003-003-2019
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/11/2019
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/4d86e945740a842597ef858e7445796f.pdf
2da258473fe6167dbfb057b8567144ea
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Hope Scholarship
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
White House Office of Records Management
Office of Cabinet Affairs
Office of Chief of Staff to the President
National Economic Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Scheduling (1997-2001)
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1997
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/57640"><strong>Collection Finding Aid</strong></a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2017-1073-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records related to the HOPE Scholarship program in Georgia. It contains budget proposals, materials related to the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997, the 1998 budget, Hope Scholarship tax credits, the Lifetime Learning tax credit, Pell Grant increases, student loan reform, and education policy discussions between the White House Office of Policy Development, the Department of Education, and the Department of the Treasury. It contains emails, memoranda, correspondence, press materials, briefing materials, drafts of legislation, and notes.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Office of Records Management
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
99 folders in 13 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[07/02/1997 – 12/30/1997]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2017-1073-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 11
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26444786" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/57640">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20171073F-011-001-2018
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
11/6/2018
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/840ff86093a9a63b6fc92c7501504cfc.pdf
0c661dda50a82f99e55c84e39b3459a0
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
1998 Higher Education Act Reauthorization
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
White House Office of Records Management
Council of Economic Advisers (CEA)
Domestic Policy Council
National Economic Council
Office of Public Liaison
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1996-1998
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<strong><a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/57561">Collection Finding Aid</a></strong>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2017-1076-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of material related to the 1998 Higher Education Act Reauthorization. It was originally enacted as part of Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society domestic program in 1965. It contains correspondence, memoranda, newspaper articles, handwritten notes, charts, reports, lists, press releases, agendas, and emails. Topics of these documents include student loan proposals, Pell Grants, loan forgiveness, schools as lenders, and the role of community service in student loan deferment.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Office of Records Management
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
50 folders in 5 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[12/05/1997 – 09/29/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2017-1076-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 4
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26444786" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/57561">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20171076F-004-005-2018
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
10/16/2018
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/4296571d78961a9cff4b8bf2d07c29a0.pdf
369e99c47473fb5074d3a39c9a195d99
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency Act [ISTEA] and National Economic Crossroads Transportation Efficiency Act [NEXTEA]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
White House Office of Records Management
Office of Chief of Staff to the President
Council of Economic Advisers
Domestic Policy Council
Office of Intergovernmental Affairs
Office of Legislative Affairs
National Economic Council
Office of Public Liaison
Women's Initiative Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/56721">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2015-0463-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records related to the re-authorization of the Intermodal Surface Transportation Efficiency ACT (ISTEA) and the Clinton Administration’s proposed bill to address reauthorization, the National Economic Crossroads Transportation Efficiency Act (NEXTEA). The collection contains material concerning ISTEA, NEXTEA, BESTEA and TEA-21. The records include briefing papers, correspondence, charts, emails, memoranda, handwritten notes from briefings and meetings, press clippings, publications, reports, talking points and speeches, remarks, and statements by the President.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Office of Records Management
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
226 folders in 19 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[12/16/1996 - 03/03/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2015-0463-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 15
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26444786">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/56721">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20150463F-015-004-2017
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/14/2017
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/cba15db3f357669817cf539310e6e4c1.pdf
fa93b59c2437f737c86d4ea012af4e7c
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Earmarks
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
White House Office of Records Management
Millennium Council
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
NSC Emails
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48801">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0659-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection concerns the term “earmark” as it pertains to communications about specific project funding between US Congressional Representative(s) and the President or a White House staff office. The records consist of briefing papers, drafts, emails, letters, memos, and routing forms. Topics include aircraft simulator procurement, bridge and highway construction, deficit reduction, foreign aid appropriations, nuclear research facilities, radioactive tailing cleanup, Saving America’s Treasures program, state and territory land and water conservation, tourism, and youth employment programs.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Office of Records Management
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cables, Emails, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
121 folders in 14 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[03/12/1997 - 01/10/2000] [Earmarks]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0659-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 2
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/40491442">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48801">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070659F-002-007-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/22/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/7c112375faa04b6d42064df75e41bb62.pdf
35c1b4a769e949739ac2900a76efa967
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[12/12/2000 - 01/18/2001] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 15
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219479" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-015-007-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/f04cfff79397043e4079f9894d688512.pdf
f42ef586d240f4d0025963dd7fdc4a33
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[09/15/2000 - 12/11/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 15
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219478" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-015-006-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/d171146217cddab035459ee1019d7279.pdf
2e39e7cff2916af92e49cdfc25628e28
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[08/26/2000 - 09/07/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 15
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219477" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-015-005-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/9ffc7fcc3b1b5ae65d181929e991f914.pdf
608e5d997b71bf7b82de4f29f1b10b2d
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[08/03/2000 - 08/25/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 15
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219476" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-015-004-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/990e1f2ee1779808688d0291efd60748.pdf
edfe0f9513971c835e50fa0526f9899c
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[07/27/2000 - 08/02/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 15
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219475" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-015-003-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/b68ef356ffe2ff9bbd274f18bb739c69.pdf
277b0052c44a9fc864b75d511c690e4a
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[07/26/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 15
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219474" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-015-002-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/8995ebe48a72e02737ec1ffaf391b296.pdf
dded627aa452eb2a26134ef5b46219ef
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[07/21/2000 - 07/25/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 15
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219473" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-015-001-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/ac9ed449904192f9d370a72f0229deb1.pdf
942b1c0138255460dc64d08ee4d26ce7
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[07/05/2000 - 07/21/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 14
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219472" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-014-009-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/6e345f7d30e9f36c9d7e47369210d0ee.pdf
9f8e12c17caeab8be181272a89058095
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[06/14/2000 - 06/26/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 14
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219471" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-014-008-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/b42b8d65751b474c45c099836a069139.pdf
12ff0a1e3b094830f01f02e0e743e29e
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[05/25/2000 - 06/14/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 14
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219470" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-014-007-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/0f652b5a510d365ccaa9c624d2aa2f2a.pdf
c2dfc2c7fa2a97b0d9c211a4956ee4ba
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[05/11/2000 - 05/24/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 14
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219469" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-014-006-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/f59ca5e5b9ad2726eb09399aac30bf86.pdf
06b8d08a4f3035f97a8e15e4bf027813
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[02/24/2000 - 05/11/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 14
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219468" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-014-005-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/67614880de04ec81fb4aaa33d59485f5.pdf
7218ed1f1712b57edaad7b2f0ed7bc30
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[02/07/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 14
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219467" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-014-004-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/7f43bd76a172054bc869bbd4dec823e0.pdf
40d729952f42b335326e593b3ee886d9
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[01/14/2000 - 02/03/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 14
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219466" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-014-003-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/23cd559db81a5118c1a9779063d10d5f.pdf
ee16d678263808e0b72c2dd1c10ecb4e
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[12/17/1999 - 01/14/2000] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 14
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219465" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-014-002-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/5a4eb009d0abad91f4f85e45dccad945.pdf
83ff46d209badb7360606b011961fbfc
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[11/18/1999 - 12/15/1999] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 14
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219464" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-014-001-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/b72e70d91c7fcf8c82cd1808d43b4487.pdf
3da3d2b8d0352d80602649ce4e76c941
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[09/21/1999 - 11/18/1999] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 13
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219463" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-013-008-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/219ed8abf97f670a1cc169ab72127322.pdf
4f95c2c1bb654d1de0efd06a290821e2
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[07/27/1999 - 09/08/1999] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 13
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219462" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-013-007-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/6036da2b0616f66c6257d5da95359825.pdf
0f6f01bcc51203a01067dc1fa56e4db7
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[04/19/1999 - 07/19/1999] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 13
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219461" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-013-006-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/9e50aace78ee1e4da7b7020767e448e5.pdf
7ccd80f478489d29050ec02afe09e9e5
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[02/16/1999 - 04/15/1999] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 13
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219460" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-013-005-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/cd15173a5ae62473c66db090a510c218.pdf
342fae2d27f104e9cd77ed7c615232c4
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[02/08/1999 - 02/16/1999] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 13
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219459" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-013-004-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/9ec172c3d88d115eef84620854e1c5e2.pdf
e913006ec70a7b86198f2dac576fdd4e
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[12/17/1998 - 01/22/1999] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 13
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219458" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-013-003-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/3d667ad7ef65d0f36dc95fdf4390a102.pdf
29a1543aef3cf731b50e9b73762256cd
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[08/11/1998 - 12/13/1998] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 13
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219457" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-013-002-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/a1f5f823d4af0e0460dad5adc10380ba.pdf
deb80afb21eb650e737a776f8b5be318
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Disability Civil Rights and the Disability Movement (Segment 2)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of Counsel to the President
Office of Management and Administration
National Security Council
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records of the Clinton Administration’s work with disability civil rights and the disability movement, both foreign and domestic.The collection contains correspondence, memos, daily briefings, emails, weekly and legislative reports, budget background material, award ceremony and conference setup, Q and As, speech and interview transcripts, agendas, conference invitations, informational packets, legislation, manuals, press clippings, proclamations, signing and veto statements, routing sheets, and schedules. Subjects include the Americans with Disabilities Act, the Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund, disability outreach, Disability and the Presidency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, proposed changes to DOD and VA disability payments and benefits, federal employment and national hiring policy, the Summit of the Americas and the Conference on Disability, UN-brokered agreements, and human rights as a foreign policy issue.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
202 folders in 26 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[02/02/1997 - 08/03/1998] [Disabilities]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-0143-F Segment 2
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 13
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/42219456" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48958">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20070143F-Seg2-013-001-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
8/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/65596fdcac26e1e382926af7a92da374.pdf
518fd74edaef15986ed3aefdbe04a4f2
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Cloning
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
White House Office of Records Management
White House Office of Records Management (OP)
President Has Seen
Office of Agency Liaison
Office of Cabinet Affairs
Office of Chief of Staff to the President
Office of Communications
Office of Correspondence
Office of Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
Office the First Lady (First Lady's Office)
Health Care Task Force
Office of Legislative Affairs
Millennium Council
National Aids Policy Office
National Economic Council
Office of Presidential Personnel
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Women's Initiative & Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2013-0365-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection deals with records addressing the issues of cloning, stem cells, family planning, and other related matters. These papers document the efforts of the Clinton Administration to expand family planning on both the domestic and international level, to put restrictions and limitations on cloning, and to arrive at some sort of agreement that would make it possible for stem cells to be used in research. The collection contains press releases, emails with attachments focusing on scheduling and legislation, drafts, executive orders, reports, correspondence, memoranda, and newspaper clippings.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Office of Records Management
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
584 files in 32 boxes
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48932">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[3/6/1997 - 8/7/2000] [Family Planning]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2013-0365-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 27
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/41052085">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48932">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20130365F-027-004-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
10/27/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/4374183783ac495cd68eb49cfafcc512.pdf
463afc3d41e0fb2ee7fb49d70c8631e6
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Cloning
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
White House Office of Records Management
White House Office of Records Management (OP)
President Has Seen
Office of Agency Liaison
Office of Cabinet Affairs
Office of Chief of Staff to the President
Office of Communications
Office of Correspondence
Office of Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
Office the First Lady (First Lady's Office)
Health Care Task Force
Office of Legislative Affairs
Millennium Council
National Aids Policy Office
National Economic Council
Office of Presidential Personnel
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Women's Initiative & Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2013-0365-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection deals with records addressing the issues of cloning, stem cells, family planning, and other related matters. These papers document the efforts of the Clinton Administration to expand family planning on both the domestic and international level, to put restrictions and limitations on cloning, and to arrive at some sort of agreement that would make it possible for stem cells to be used in research. The collection contains press releases, emails with attachments focusing on scheduling and legislation, drafts, executive orders, reports, correspondence, memoranda, and newspaper clippings.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Office of Records Management
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
584 files in 32 boxes
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48932">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[6/5/1997 - 9/14/1999] [Cloning]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2013-0365-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 19
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/41052029">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48932">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20130365F-019-004-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
10/25/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/24ed264d5b96c137ffe25052d75ad1cb.pdf
baea965e5a848b869fe91897b5858d6b
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Jose Cerda III
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
Jose Cerda III
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1993-2000
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48942">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2012-0192-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of email created by Jose Cerda III from 1993 until 2001. Jose Cerda III served in many capacities at the White House. He served as Senior Policy Analyst, Special Assistant to the President, and Special Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy in the Domestic Policy Council; Special Assistant to the Director of the Office of the National Drug Control Policy; and Interagency Affairs Director in Public and Legislative Affairs. He also worked on the domestic policy staff of the 1992 Clinton-Gore campaign and of the 1992 Presidential Transition. The emails created by Jose Cerda III cover major issues within the Domestic Policy Council of the Clinton Administration, specifically drugs, crime, and community empowerment. Beyond specific issues and events his emails concern meeting coordination and scheduling, speech drafts, collaboration with other agencies and offices, congressional correspondence, statements of administration policy, talking points for President Clinton, and White House visitors.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
58 folders in 9 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[11/4/1997]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
Jose Cerda III
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2012-0192-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 9
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/52874832" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48942">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20120192F-009-005-2017
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
1/19/2017
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/727a95bd7b6f4d2be067251f47ca124c.pdf
a0e496682b68b0fd1cc8e09e470b003d
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Global AIDS Crisis
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of the Staff
Office of the Counsel to the President
National AIDS Policy Office
National Security Council
Office of the Public Liaison
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1994-2000
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48956">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of material regarding the Clinton Administration’s handling of the global AIDS crisis. It contains correspondence, memoranda, talking points, drafts, invitations, background material, agendas and minutes, executive orders, speeches, informational packets, travel documents, emails, cables, reports, and press materials regarding a variety of issues related to the fight against HIV/AIDS. The topics addressed include the Haitian detention crisis, federal budget, foreign aid, collaboration with other governments, international agencies (such as WHO and the UN) and NGOs, international conferences, a Presidential Mission to Africa, pharmaceutical companies, tuberculosis, individual countries, and some crossover domestic issues, such as dealing with HIV positive persons in the US military and the inclusion of the virus as an excludable illness under the Immigration and Naturalization Act. The records of the National AIDS Policy Office make up the bulk of the collection.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: WHORM: Alpha Project
Clinton Presidential Records: WHORM: Subject File
Clinton Presidential Records: WHORM: (OP)
Clinton Presidential Records: WHORM: Various Offices
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System [Email]
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project [Email]
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management Systems
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
915 folders in 57 boxes
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-1550-F Segment 1
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[6/8/1999 - 9/12/2000]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2007-1550-F Segment 1
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 53
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/54977340" target="_blank" rel="noreferrer">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48956">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444785
42-t-26444785-20071550F-053-003-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System [Email]
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
7/19/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/1e898080ad22244942ba64c2f3d63057.pdf
cb0592d35017ac83af71fe1729c953b4
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Eric Holder
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
White House Office of Records Management
Agency Liaison
Office of Correspondence
Automated Records Management System
National Security Council
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48924">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-0238-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records related to Eric H. Holder, Jr. President Clinton appointed United States Attorney for the District of Columbia Eric H. Holder, Jr. as the first African-American Attorney General in 1997.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Office of Records Management
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
49 folders in 5 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[10/02/1997] [To: Eric Holder]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-0238-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 2
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/41028247">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/48924">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20090238F-002-002-2016
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
5/11/2016
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/db31354fdc70de5a5c5d961f3e718db8.pdf
ec1ec719e7694a799e002a12e11781b7
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Agriculture Market Transition Act (AMTA)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
04/06/1999 - 01/18/2001
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/47929">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2012-0191-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection primarily addresses farming and agricultural topics to include the 1996 Farm Bill, Agricultural Market Transition Act (AMTA), world market price of cotton and rice, agricultural reports on markets and perspectives, agricultural assistance programs, proposed USDA
Marketing Loan changes, disaster aid, Economic Injury Disaster Loans for drought victims, federal response to 1999 drought and heat wave, FY 2000 agriculture appropriations conference, and H.R. 3194, the Consolidated Appropriations Act for FY 2000.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System [Email]
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
6 folders in 1 box
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[8/4/1999-8/20/1999]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2012-0191-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 1
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26444786">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/47929">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20120191F-001-003-2015
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
9/11/2015
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/056802d7c63a03e817cb289199a11a07.pdf
589c151e5fe61abfc986bdad9b0b2cd3
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Brett Kavanaugh
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Subject File
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-2001
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2018-0907-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection primarily consists of emails sent to or concerning Brett Kavanaugh. Kavanaugh served as Associate Counsel in the Office of Independent Counsel and responsive email is related to the “Starr Investigation.” Many of the responsive emails in this collection contain material that is in the public domain, such as press transcripts and news articles. This collection also consists of Worker and Visitor Entry System (WAVES) records containing logs of Brett Kavanaugh’s visits to the White House from 1994-1996.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: WHORM: Subject File
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System [Email]
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project (TRP) [Email]
Clinton Presidential Records: Electronic WAVES Search System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
11 folders in 1 box
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/57630">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[06/16/1999]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2018-0907-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 1
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26444786">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/57630">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444786
42-t-26444786-20180907F-001-006-2018
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
12/10/2018
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/79133f6447fb8fc21eb4fa1dcc856a68.pdf
3e51ed06f8026b04364577223252e0bb
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Enniskillen and County Fermanagh
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
White House Office of Records Management
Agency Liaison
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
NSC Cables
NSC Email
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/57170">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2016-0402-F
Description
An account of the resource
This collection consists of records mentioning the city of Enniskillen or the surrounding County Fermanagh, in southwestern Northern Ireland. Due to this location, the area was regularly involved in the 40 year sectarian conflict in Northern Ireland known as “The Troubles.” The Clinton Administration assisted in ending this conflict through the 1998 Good Friday Peace Agreement. President Clinton traces his ancestry through his mother to County Fermanagh. The collection includes emails, correspondence, press materials, and Presidential speeches that reference Northern Ireland.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Office of Records Management
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Clinton Presidential Records: NSC Cable, Email, and Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library and Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
32 folders in 3 boxes
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Paper
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[09/04/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Tape Restoration Project
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2016-0402-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 2
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/26444829">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
<a href="https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/57170">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
26444829
42-t-26444829-20160402-F-002-001-2017
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
7/18/2017
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/d84ca330a7cf2124eafcd45d46a68839.pdf
6a9f1c17b696ca93ed5f8005bf15a34a
PDF Text
Text
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 1
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: jgonderOecon.Berkeley.EDU@INET@LNGTWY ( jgonderOecon.Berkeley.EDUOINETOLNGTWY
CREATION DATE/TIME:21-NOV-1997 18:17:00.00
SUBJECT:
Regents & Domestic P a r t n e r s (fwd)
TO: Aaron S. EdlinOEOP
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Voila--the
( Aaron S. EdlinOEOP [ CEA ] )
vote!
Forwarded message
Date: F r i , 21 Nov 1997 14:51:08 -0700
From: L e s l i e Leonard <Leslie_Leonard@LS.berkeley.edu>
To: dm_ls@LS.berkeley.edu
S u b j e c t : Regents & Domestic P a r t n e r s
>X-Sender: b a r n a t o O a s t r o . b e r k e l e y . e d u
>Mime-Version: 1.0
>Date: F r i , 21 Nov 1997 14:13:37 -0800
>From: J u l e n e C h i l s o n < j u l e n e @ u c l i n k 4 . b e r k e l e y . e d u > (by way o f
> Maureen B a r n a t o )
> S u b j e c t : Regents & Domestic P a r t n e r s
>
>TO:
CSO - FYI
>
>In a v o t e o f 13 t o 12 The Regents have approved a m o t i o n t o o f f e r
>to Domestic P a r t n e r s .
benefits
L e s l i e Leonard
A s s i s t a n t Dean, C o l l e g e o f L e t t e r s and Science
University of California
B e r k e l e y , C a l i f o r n i a 94720-2920
Phone: 510-642-3081
Fax: 510-642-7578
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
RFC-822-headers:
Received: from conversion.pmdf.eop.gov by PMDF.E0P.GOV (PMDF V5.0-4 #6879)
i d <01IQA49MQMYO00YLOF@PMDF.EOP.GOV> f o r "Aaron S. Edlin"@oa.eop.gov; F r i ,
21 Nov 1997 18:09:35 -0500 (EST)
Received: from storm.eop.gov (storm.eop.gov)
by PMDF.E0P.GOV (PMDF V5.0-4 #6879) i d <01IQA49JZRXSOllNHXOPMDF.EOP.GOV> f o r
Aaron_S ._Edlin@oa. eop.gov,- F r i , 21 Nov 1997 18:09:31 -0500 (EST)
Received: from econ.Berkeley.EDU ( [ 1 2 8 . 3 2 . 1 0 5 . 2 ] )
by ST0RM.E0P.GOV (PMDF V5.1-7 #6879)
w i t h ESMTP i d <01IQA490PSMY0025QM@STORM.EOP.GOV> f o r
Aaron_S._Edlin@oa.eop.gov; F r i , 21 Nov 1997 18:09:07 -0500 (EST)
Received: from econ205 (econ205.Berkeley.EDU [128.32.105.205])
by econ.Berkeley.EDU (8.8.5/8.8.5) w i t h SMTP i d PAA08747; F r i ,
21 Nov 1997 15:08:25 -0800 (PST)
X-Sender: jgonder@econ.berkeley.edu
================== END ATTACHMENT
1 ==================
[ Ul
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ann O'Leary ( CN=Ann O'Leary/OU=OPD/0=EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME:13-DEC-1999 17:22:01.00
SUBJECT:
Domestic P a r t n e r S t a t s
TO: Andrew R. Feldman ( CN=Andrew R. Feldman/OU=CEA/0=EOP@EOP
READ:UNKNOWN
[ CEA ] )
TEXT:
Andy I was hoping t o e m a i l you t h e a r t i c l e , b u t t h e HRC w e b s i t e i s down r i g h t
now. The i n f o r m a t i o n t h a t I sent e a r l i e r was p u l l e d from an a r t i c l e
e n t i t l e d , "How t o Achieve Domestic P a r t n e r B e n e f i t s i n Your Workplace" p u t
out by HRC's WorkNet. The a u t h o r , D a r y l H e r r s c h a f t , p u l l e d t h e s t a t s from
the "Current P o p u l a t i o n Survey," U.S. Census Bureau, Washington 1994-1998.
Please l e t me know y o u r f a x number i f you would l i k e me t o f a x you t h e
article.
Thanks.
-Ann (6-6275)
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 1
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrew R. Feldman
( CN=Andrew R. Feldman/OU=CEA/0=EOP [ CEA ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME:13-DEC-1999 17:26:56.00
SUBJECT:
Re: Domestic P a r t n e r S t a t s
TO: Ann O'Leary ( CN=Ann O'Leary/OU=OPD/0=EOP@EOP [ OPD ] )
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Ann -- t h e HRC w e b s i t e i s back up & I found t h e doc you mentioned.
much!
Thanks
Andy
Ann 0'Leary
12/13/99 05:21:57 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
cc:
Andrew R. Feldman/CEA/EOP@EOP
Subject:Domestic P a r t n e r S t a t s
Andy I was hoping t o e m a i l you t h e a r t i c l e , b u t t h e HRC w e b s i t e i s down r i g h t
now.
The i n f o r m a t i o n t h a t I sent e a r l i e r was p u l l e d from an a r t i c l e
e n t i t l e d , "How t o Achieve Domestic P a r t n e r B e n e f i t s i n Your Workplace" p u t
out by HRC's WorkNet.
The a u t h o r , D a r y l H e r r s c h a f t , p u l l e d t h e s t a t s from
the "Current P o p u l a t i o n Survey," U.S. Census Bureau, Washington 1994-1998.
Please l e t me know y o u r f a x number i f you would l i k e me t o f a x you t h e
article.
Thanks.
-Ann
(6-6275)
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sarah L. Rosen ( CN=Sarah L. Rosen/OU=CEA/0=EOP [ CEA ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME:23-MAY-2000 11:10:18.00
SUBJECT:
TO: j a c k i e _ g r a n ( jackie_gran@labor.senate.gov @ i n e t
READ:UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN ] )
TEXT:
I'm s e a r c h i n g on Thomas f o r b i l l s r e l a t e d t o t a x c r e d i t s and/or d e d u c t i o n s
f o r h e a l t h i n s u r a n c e and I came a c r o s s "To p r o v i d e b e n e f i t s t o
domestic p a r t n e r s o f F e d e r a l employees."
progressive b i l l
t o be coming o u t o f Congress, u n t i l I l o o k e d t o t h e
sponsor and saw Barney Frank.
Sarah
I t h o u g h t t h a t was q u i t e a
You've g o t t o l o v e him....
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
1996 Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
Clerk's Office
Correspondence Office
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
Office of Intergovernmental Affairs
Office of Legislative Affairs
National AIDS Policy Office
Office of Oval Office Operations
Office of the Press Secretary
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2013-0028-F
Description
An account of the resource
President Clinton signed the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) into law on September 21, 1996. The Act declared that no state shall be required to recognize a same-gender marriage performed in another state. DOMA also defined marriage as only between a man and a woman for purposes of Federal law. This collection consists of files and email accounts from the White House staff related to The Defense of Marriage Act. The collection also contains records related to Hawaii Supreme Court’s Baehrs vs. Lewin, and California’s Proposition 22. The collection consists of clippings, emails, letters, memoranda, notes, press releases, and talking points concerning DOMA, same sex marriage, and domestic partnerships.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Office of Records Management
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
112 folders in 7 boxes
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/36606">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[11/21/1997/1997 – 05/23/2000]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2013-0028-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 7
<a href="clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/36606" target="_blank">Collection Finding Aid</a>
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
5/19/2015
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
574745
42-t-20130028F-007-010-2015
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/bbb1ff36b0b2c983929a8a1f1d026e64.pdf
1205015ef1aa683538d3947c85d873a2
PDF Text
Text
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Eugenia Chough ( CN=Eugenia Chough/OU=OPD/0=EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-DEC-1999 17:02:18.00
SUBJECT:
Comments on Econ Report, Chap 5, F a m i l i e s
TO: Audrey Choi
READ:UNKNOWN
( CN=Audrey Choi/OU=CEA/0=EOP@EOP [ CEA ] )
CC: Ann O'Leary ( CN=Ann O'Leary/OU=OPD/0=EOP@EOP [ OPD ] )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: C y n t h i a A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/0=EOP@EOP [ OPD ] )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/0=EOP@EOP [ OPD ] )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Andrew R. Feldman ( CN=Andrew R. Feldman/OU=CEA/0=EOP@EOP [ CEA ] )
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Here are our comments on t h e "The Changing American Family" c h a p t e r o f t h e
Econ Report.
New language i s i n CAPS, and suggested d e l e t i o n s a r e s t r u c k
out.
Please l e t me know i f you have q u e s t i o n s . Thanks!
Page 1, 1st paragraph -- What i s t h e r e s t o f the breakdown i n f a m i l i e s ?
You mention t h a t n e a r l y 1/2 l i v e i n "two-earner nonfarm f a m i l i e s " and more
t h a n 1/4 l i v e i n " s i n g l e p a r e n t f a m i l i e s " -- does t h i s mean t h a t t h e
r e m a i n i n g q u a r t e r l i v e i n a f a m i l y s i t u a t i o n l i k e t h e 1900s' "two-parent
r u r a l f a m i l y where t h e f a t h e r [ i s ] the breadwinner and the mother [ i s ] a
homemaker"?
Page 2, 1st graph, sentence 6: "As we approach...marriage remains a
f a i r l y u n i v e r s a l e x p e r i e n c e . . . " and bottom o f page 4, "Throughout t h e
c e n t u r y over 90 p e r c e n t o f a l l women aged 55-64 have been m a r r i e d a t some
p o i n t , and i n 1997, t h a t p r o p o r t i o n s t o o d a t 95.3%." While t h i s i s an
i n t e r e s t i n g and l o n g e r - t e r m way t o l o o k a t t h i s i s s u e , doesn't i t miss
decrease i n m a r r i a g e among those c u r r e n t l y under 55. I t a l s o seems t o
c o n f l i c t w i t h a n e a r l y 4 - f o l d i n c r e a s e i n s i n g l e p a r e n t f a m i l i e s shown on
p. 3, which i s what most people focus on when t h e y t h i n k about t h e d e c l i n e
i n marriage. I t h i n k our c r e d i b i l i t y on t h i s i s s u e may be q u e s t i o n e d i f
we l e a d w i t h the statement t h a t marriage remains f a i r l y u n i v e r s a l .
Page 3, s e c t i o n on "Women i n t h e Workforce" -- The sentence i n d i c a t i n g
t h a t more women are l i v i n g i n d e p e n d e n t l y p r i o r t o m a r r i a g e " l e a d i n g t o
g r e a t e r l a b o r f o r c e attachment t h a t c o u l d c o n f l i c t w i t h f a m i l y
o b l i g a t i o n s " has a n e g a t i v e c o n n o t a t i o n s u g g e s t i n g t h a t attachment t o t h e
labor force i s not h e l p f u l .
Could you re-phrase t o say t h a t t h e
attachment t o t h e l a b o r f o r c e " c o u l d impact f a m i l y o b l i g a t i o n s
t r a d i t i o n a l l y assumed by women."
Page 4, s e c t i o n on "Family Formation and D i s s o l u t i o n "
- - I t would be v e r y
p o w e r f u l i f you c o u l d p a i n t a p i c t u r e up f r o n t o f t h e changing n a t u r e o f
the American f a m i l y (much o f which i s d i s c u s s e d l a t e r i n t h e c h a p t e r ) .
For example, I would move t h e s e c t i o n on "the r o l e o f g r a n d p a r e n t s " from
the " e l d e r care" s e c t i o n t o t h i s s e c t i o n . Grandparents r a i s i n g c h i l d r e n
i s more o f a dynamic o f t h e changing f o r m a t i o n o f f a m i l i e s t h a n an i s s u e
�ARMS Email System
of
Page 2 of 5
elder care.
Page 6, l a s t sentence
o f t o p graph: Delete "famous".
Page 6-7, same s e c t i o n : The d i s c u s s i o n of " i n d i v i d u a l s choosing t o l i v e
t o g e t h e r o u t s i d e o f f o r m a l m a r r i a g e , " does not appear t o i n c l u d e
i n f o r m a t i o n on domestic p a r t n e r s of the same sex. A c c o r d i n g t o t h e Human
R i g h t s Campaign WorkNet, "From 1994 t o 1998, t h e number of m a r r i e d couple
households i n the US i n c r e a s e d by j u s t 2 p e r c e n t , w h i l e t h e number o f
unmarried p a r t n e r households i n c r e a s e d by 11 p e r c e n t . I n 1998, t h e r e were
5.9 m i l l i o n people i n t h e US l i v i n g w i t h a domestic p a r t n e r . Of these,
a p p r o x i m a t e l y 28 p e r c e n t , o r 1.7 m i l l i o n people, were i n same-sex
relationships."
I t would be h e l p f u l t o add i n t h e changing p a t t e r n s o f
recognized same-sex domestic p a r t n e r s h i p s .
Page 7, 2nd graph.
I n g e n e r a l , we suggest u s i n g t h e l a t e s t a v a i l a b l e data
and u s i n g data from a c o n s i s t e n t p e r i o d . A l s o , t h i s l o n g - t e r m p e r s p e c t i v e
o v e r l o o k s the f a c t t h a t t h e t r e n d s i n out o f wedlock c h i l d b e a r i n g have
l e v e l e d o f f i n t h e p a s t fews and t h e r e have been h i s t o r i c drops i n t e e n
b i r t h rates i n recent years.
Here are some s u g g e s t i o n s ,
"Then number of b i r t h s per 1,000 unmarried women aged 15-44 i n c r e a s e d from
7.1 i n 1940 t o 46.9 44 i n 1994 1997. [Note f o r CEA -- source i s NCHS
N a t i o n a l V i t a l S t a t i s t i c s Report on B i r t h and Death Data, 10/99. You may
a l s o want t o r e f e r t o NCHS Stephanie Ventura's t e s t i m o n y on t h i s s u b j e c t
f o r a more h i s t o r i c a l p e r s p e c t i v e -- I ' l l f a x t o you.]
The r a t e f o r b l a c k
women...a d e c l i n e t o 75.9 73.4 i n 1994 1997.
The r a t e f o r w h i t e women
aged 15-44 i n c r e a s e d most p r e c i p i t o u s l y a f t e r 1980, r i s i n g from 17.6 t o
37.5 25.9 i n 1995 1997.
[Note f o r CEA -- what about H i s p a n i c
women/girls? THE RATE FOR UNMARRIED HISPANIC WOMEN WAS 91.4 IN 1997] The
p e r c e n t of b i r t h s t o unmarried women o f a l l ages...32.6 32.4 i n 1994
1997....The p e r c e n t o f b i r t h s t o unmarried teens rose from 31.9 p e r c e n t t o
75.7 78.2 p e r c e n t over t h e p e r i o u d 1970-1994 1997.
From 1980 t o 1990 1997
the b i r t h r a t e t o teens aged 15-19 climbed DECREASED from 53.0 t o 59.8
52.3 (per 1,000) t e e n s ) ; t h e unmarried teen b i r t h r a t e rose from 16.5 t o
30.6 25.9 f o r w h i t e s and DECREASED FROM 87.9 t o 106.0 86.4 f o r b l a c k s over
the same p e r i o d . . . [Note f o r CEA: THE HISPANIC TEEN BIRTH RATE was 75.2 i n
1997.] HOWEVER, IN MORE RECENT YEARS THESE TRENDS ARE IMPROVING. TEEN
BIRTHS HAVE DECLINED NATIONWIDE BY 18 PERCENT FROM 1991 TO 1998, AND HAVE
FALLEN IN EVERY STATE AND ACROSS ETHNIC AND RACIAL GROUPS. FOR GIRLS AGES
15-17, THE 1998 BIRTH RATE IS AT ITS LOWEST IN FOUR DECADES. IN ADDITION,
TEEN PREGNANCY RATES ARE AT THE LOWEST SINCE W FIRST BEGAN COLLECTING
E
DATA IN 1976.
IN ADDITION, THE BIRTH RATE PER 1,000 UNMARRIED WOMEN HAS
DECREASED BY 2 PERCENT BETWEEN 1991 AND 19 98.
Page 11, 2nd graph, sentence 1: The money c r u n c h . . . . i s f e l t by d i f f e r e n c e
f a m i l y types f o r d i f f e r e n t reasons."
T h i s a s s e r t i o n s seems t o c o n f l i c t
w i t h statement on p r e v i o u s page s a y i n g t h a t t h e money crunch a f f e c t s
single-headed households and l e s s educated households.
Page 11, 2nd graph, sentence 4: " S i m i l a r l y , the median income o f
female-headed f a m i l i e s has been n e a r l y f l a t . . . " T h i s statement appears t o
s h o r t s h r i f t r e c e n t improvement such as 99 CPS numbers.
Page 12, 1st graph, sentence 2: "Corresponding t o t h e f a m i l y
c h a r t 5-7, t h e share o f f a m i l i e s t h a t are headed by a s i n g l e
i n c r e a s e d v e r y s i g n i f i c a n t l y over time -- from xx p e r c e n t i n
p e r c e n t of a l l f a m i l i e s . "
I s t h i s 23% f i g u r e d i f f e r e n t t h a n
page 8 and c h a r t 5-6?
groups i n
p a r e n t has
1969 o 23
t h e 27% on
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of 5
Page 13, 1 s t graph: Seems awkward t o focus on c o r d l e s s phones as opposed
t o phones i n g e n e r a l .
Page 14, 1 s t graph, sentence 2: " . . . o n l y 19.1 p e r c e n t o f s i n g l e - h e a d e d
households i n 1998 a r e f a m i l i e s " -- what does t h i s mean?
Page 14, 1 s t graph: While fewer, t h e percentage o f s i n g l e - p a r e n t f a m i l i e s
headed by f a t h e r s has i n c r e a s e d d r a m a t i c a l l y and s h o u l d a t l e a s t be
mentioned.
Page 14, 2nd graph: Add t o end o f graph, "AND TOUGH CHILD SUPPORT
ENFORCEMENT."
Page 14, 3 r d graph, 3 r d sentence: 44 p e r c e n t versus 73 p e r c e n t i n 1993
s t a t i s t i c (on p r o p o r t i o n o f never m a r r i e d vs d i v o r c e s mothers w i t h s u p p o r t
o r d e r s ) doesn't seem t o add. A l s o , do we have more r e c e n t #s?
Page 14, 3 r d graph, 4 t h sentence: " O v e r a l l , r o u g h l y h a l f o f a l l women who
are s i n g l e p a r e n t s r e c e i v e p u b l i c a s s i s t a n c e " . I s t h i s a p o i n t i n t i m e -i f so, when?
Page 15, 1 s t graph, 1 s t sentence:
" R e f l e c t i n g these poor e a r n i n g s . . . "
T h i s doesn't seem t o f l o w w i t h graph above which i s n ' t about e a r n i n g s .
A l s o , r e v i s e t o read, " . . . ( t h o u g h these p o v e r t y r a t e s a r e based on A
DEFINITION OF income t h a t does n o t i n c l u d e FOOD STAMPS, EITC AND OTHER
NON-CASH INCOME)."
Page 17, 1 s t graph, sentence 3: Revise t o read, " A l l TYPES OF f a m i l i e s
experiences a d e c l i n e . . . "
Page 18, s e c t i o n on "Time Use and P a r e n t a l Care" -- I t might be h e l p f u l t o
add a d i s c u s s i o n o f t h e economic impact o f l o n g - t e r m c a r e g i v e r s . I n
Monday's NYT (11/29) r e p o r t e d on a s t u d y r e l e a s e d by t h e N a t i o n a l Center
f o r Women and Aging a t Brandeis and t h e N a t i o n a l A l l i a n c e f o r C a r e g i v e r s ,
which r e p o r t e d t h a t " t w o - t h i r d s o f those a c t i n g as c a r e g i v e r s f o r e l d e r l y
r e l a t i v e s lose o u t a t work by f o r g o i n g promotions, pay r a i s e s , and
training opportunities."
Page 21, as mentioned above, I would suggest t h a t you move t h e box on " t h e
Role o f Grandparents" o u t o f t h e e l d e r l y care s e c t i o n and i n t o t h e f a m i l y
formation section
Page 22, Please change header " S u p p o r t i n g F a m i l i e s AMERICANS i n t h e i r
E f f o r t s t o Balance Work and Family" [ s t r i c t l y e d i t o r i a l - t o a v o i d s a y i n g
Families twice]
Page 25, 1 s t graph under w e l f a r e r e f o r m s e c t i o n .
the f i r s t 2 sentences w i t h :
We recommend r e p l a c i n g
"THE 1996 WELFARE REFORM LAW DRAMATICALLY CHANGED THE NATION'S
WELFARE SYSTEM INTO ONE THAT REQUIRES WORK I N EXCHANGE FOR TIME-LIMITED
ASSISTANCE. THE LAW CONTAINS STRONG WORK REQUIREMENTS, COMPREHENSIVE
CHILD SUPPORT ENFORCEMENT AND SUPPORTS FAMILIES MOVING FROM WELFARE TO
WORK. 27 STATES WERE AWARDED BONUS FUNDS FOR THEIR SUPERIOR RESULTS I N
REFORMING WELFARE, AND RECENT STUDIES S O THE FOLLOWING FINDINGS:
HW
MORE THAN 1.3 MILLION WELFARE RECIPIENTS NATIONWIDE WENT TO WORK I N JUST
THE ONE YEAR PERIOD BETWEEN OCTOBER 1997 AND SEPTEMBER 1998.
RETENTION RATES ARE ALSO PROMISING: 80 PERCENT OF THOSE WHO GOT JOBS WERE
STILL WORKING THREE MONTHS LATER.
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of 5
STATES ALSO REPORTED AN AVERAGE EARNINGS INCREASE OF 2 3 PERCENT FOR FORMER
WELFARE RECIPIENTS, FROM $2,088 I N THE FIRST QUARTER OF EMPLOYMENT TO
$2,571 IN THE THIRD QUARTER.
ALL 50 STATES MET THE WORK PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS, AND THE PERCENTAGE
OF ALL WELFARE RECIPIENTS WORKING HAS NEARLY QUADRUPLED SINCE 1992, FROM 7
PERCENT IN 1992 TO 27 PERCENT I N 1998, WITH THE REMAINDER FULFILLING THEIR
PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS THROUGH JOB SEARCH, EDUCATION AND TRAINING.
INDEPENDENT STUDIES CONFIRM THESE CONCLUSIONS, FINDING THAT NEARLY 70
PERCENT OF RECIPIENTS LEFT WELFARE FOR WORK (URBAN INSTITUTE AND GAO) .
The A d m i n i s t r a t i o n ' s t e e n pregnancy i n i t i a t i v e TO PREVENT TEEN
PREGNANCY c o u l d a l s o playS a s u p p o r t i n g r o l e by r e d u c i n g t h e i n c i d e n c e o f
t h a t p a r t i c u l a r source o f s t r a i n IN BREAKING THE CYCLE OF DEPENDENCY AND
INCREASING THE WELL BEING OF FAMILIES BY REDUCING THE NUMBER OF CHILDREN
BORN TO TEEN MOTHERS.
Page 25, Box 5-2, f i r s t b u l l e t : "The law s u p p o r t s ENCOURAGES t h e c r e a t i o n
of Second Chance Homes, which SUPPORTIVE AND SUPERVISED LIVING
ARRANGEMENTS THAT p r o v i d e teen p a r e n t s . . . The w e l f a r e law a l s o p r o v i d e s $50
m i l l i o n a year f o r f i v e years i n new f u n d i n g f o r a b s t i n e n c e e d u c a t i o n
programs. The Balanced Budget Act o f 1997 p r o v i d e s f u n d i n g f o r a n a t i o n a l
e v a l u a t i o n o f t h e program. F i n a l l y , the new w e l f a r e law i n c l u d e tough
c h i l d support enforcement measures which w i l l send t h e s t r o n g e s t p o s s i b l e
messaage t o young g i r l s and boys t h a t they should not have c h i l d r e n u n t i l
they are ready t o p r o v i d e f o r them.
Page 25, Box 5-2,
4 t h b u l l e t : delete "intended".
Page 25, Box 5-2, l a s t b u l l e t : "The n a t i o n a l s t r a t e g y p l a c e s a s p e c i a l
emphasis on sending a s t r o n g a b s t i n e n c e message. THE WELFARE LAW ALSO
PROVIDES $50 MILLION A YEAR FOR FIVE YEARS I N NEW FUNDING FOR ABSTINENCE
EDUCATION PROGRAMS."
Page 26, Replace 1st graph b e g i n n i n g
"Recent p o l i c y changes..." w i t h :
"THE ADMINISTRATION HAS ALSO IMPLEMENTED SEVERAL INITIATIVES TO
MOVE LOW-INCOME INDIVIDUALS FROM WELFARE TO WORK AND TO SUPPORT WORKING
FAMILIES, INCLUDING:
$4 BILLION INCREASE OVER SIX YEARS I N CHILD CARE ASSISTANCE TO FAMILIES
MOVING FROM WELFARE TO WORK.
THE CREATION OF THE CHILDREN'S HEALTH INSURANCE PROGRAM (CHIP) TO EXTEND
HEALTH CARE COVERAGE TO UNINSURED CHILDREN.
NEW RULES THAT ALLOW STATES TO EXPAND MEDICAID TO COVER MORE LOW-INCOME
FAMILIES WHO WORK, INCLUDING MORE TWO-PARENT FAMILIES.
$3 BILLION I N WELFARE-TO-WORK GRANTS TO HELP STATES AND COMMUNITIES MOVE
LONG-TERM WELFARE RECIPIENTS AND CERTAIN NONCUSTODIAL PARENTS INTO
LASTING, UNSUBSIDIZED JOBS. THESE FUNDS CAN BE USED FOR JOB CREATION,
PLACEMENT AND RETENTION EFFORTS, INCLUDING WAGE SUBSIDIES TO PRIVATE
EMPLOYERS AND OTHER CRITICAL POST-EMPLOYMENT SERVICES.
IN 1999, 50,000 NEW WELFARE TO WORK HOUSING VOUCHERS WENT TO WELFARE
RECIPIENTS WHO NEED HOUSING ASSISTANCE TO GET OR KEEP A JOB.
FAMILIES
WILL USE THESE VOUCHERS TO MOVE CLOSER TO A NEW JOB, REDUCE A LONG
COMMUTE, OR SECURE MORE STABLE HOUSING.
THE WELFARE TO WORK TAX CREDIT PROVIDES A CREDIT EQUAL TO 35 PERCENT OF
THE FIRST $10,000 I N WAGES I N THE FIRST YEAR OF EMPLOYMENT, AND 50 PERCENT
OF THE FIRST $10,000 I N WAGES I N THE SECOND YEAR, TO ENCOURAGE HIRING AND
RETENTION OF LONG-TERM WELFARE RECIPIENTS. THE CREDIT COMPLEMENTS THE
WORK OPPORTUNITY TAXK CREDIT WHICH PROVIDES A CREDIT OF UP TO $2,400 FOR
THE FIRST YEAR OF WAGES FOR EIGHT GROUPS OF JOB SEEKERS.
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of 5
INDIVIDUAL DEVELOPMENT ACCOUNTS (IDAs) EMPOWER LOW-INCOME FAMILIES TO SAVE
FOR A FIRST HOME, POST-SECONDARY EDUCATION, Or TO START A NEW BUSINESS.
TO HELP THOSE ON WELFARE GET TO WORK, THE PRESIDENT'S JOB ACCESS
INITIATIVE AND REVERSE COMMUTE GRANTS PROVIDES FUNDS TO COMMUNITIES AND
STATES THAT DEVELOP FLEXIBLE TRANSPORTATION ALTERNATIVES, SUCH AS VAN
SERVICES FOR WELFARE RECIPIENTS AND OTHER LOW-INCOME WORKERS.
NEW GUIDANCE THAT MAKES I T EASIER FOR LOW-INCOME WORKING FAMILIES TO OWN A
CAR AND STILL RECEIVE FOOD STAMPS, AND NEW RULES THAT MAKE I T EASIER FOR
STATES TO SERVE FAMILIES BY SIMPLIFYING REPORTING REQUIREMENTS."
Page 28, s e c t i o n on FMLA, a t t h e end o f t h e s e c t i o n on t h e P r e s i d e n t ' s
p r o p o s a l s , you might add t h a t t h e P r e s i d e n t i s l o o k i n g f o r ways t o p r o v i d e
p a r t i a l wage replacement f o r new p a r e n t s when they t a k e advantage o f
FMLA. You c o u l d add i n t h e DOL proposed r e g u l a t i o n (announced y e s t e r d a y )
a l l o w i n g s t a t e s t o use U I t o p a r t i a l l y compensate new p a r e n t s .
Page 30, s e c t i o n on "Work Arrangements t h a t Promote F l e x i b i l i t y , " you
might add a r e f e r e n c e t o t h i s d i s c u s s i o n o f p a r e n t s telecommuting t o t h e
childcare section
Page 31, s e c t i o n on " C h i l d Care" -- need t o add i n c r e a s e s i n Head S t a r t
and t h e f a c t t h a t t h e A d m i n i s t r a t i o n i s on i t s way t o meeting t h e
P r e s i d e n t ' s g o a l o f s e r v i n g 1 m i l l i o n c h i l d r e n by 2002
Page 34, Conclusion,
sentence 2: change " l i t t l e "
t o "FEW".
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 5
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
CREATOR: Audrey Choi
(NOTES MAIL)
( CN=Audrey Choi/OU=CEA/0=EOP [ CEA ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-DEC-1999 17:22:07.00
SUBJECT:
DPC Comments on Econ Report, Chap 5, F a m i l i e s
TO: Sandra F. D a i g l e ( CN=Sandra F. Daigle/OU=CEA/0=EOP@EOP [ CEA ] )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Robin L. Lumsdaine ( CN=Robin L. Lumsdaine/OU=CEA/0=EOP@EOP [ CEA ] )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Michael J. B r i e n ( CN=Michael J. Brien/OU=CEA/0=EOP@EOP [ CEA ] )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn L. Shaw ( CN=Kathryn L. Shaw/OU=CEA/0=EOP@EOP [ CEA ] )
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
here are DPC comments on f a m i l i e s
Forwarded by Audrey Choi/CEA/EOP on 12/06/99 05:21
p
M
Eugenia Chough
Record Type:
12/06/99 05:02:13 PM
Record
To:
Audrey Choi/CEA/EOP@EOP
cc:
Andrew R. Feldman/CEA/EOP@EOP, C y n t h i a A. Rice/OPD/EOP@EOP,
Andrea Kane/OPD/EOP@EOP, Ann O'Leary/OPD/EOPOEOP
Subject:Comments on Econ Report, Chap 5, F a m i l i e s
Here are our comments on t h e "The Changing American Family" c h a p t e r o f t h e
Econ Report.
New language i s i n CAPS, and suggested d e l e t i o n s are s t r u c k
out.
Please l e t me know i f you have q u e s t i o n s . Thanks!
Page 1, 1st paragraph -- What i s t h e r e s t o f the breakdown i n f a m i l i e s ?
You mention t h a t n e a r l y 1/2 l i v e i n "two-earner nonfarm f a m i l i e s " and more
t h a n 1/4 l i v e i n " s i n g l e p a r e n t f a m i l i e s " -- does t h i s mean t h a t t h e
remaining q u a r t e r l i v e i n a f a m i l y s i t u a t i o n l i k e the 1900s' "two-parent
r u r a l f a m i l y where t h e f a t h e r [ i s ] the breadwinner and t h e mother [ i s ] a
homemaker"?
Page 2, 1st graph, sentence 6: "As we approach...marriage remains a
f a i r l y u n i v e r s a l e x p e r i e n c e . . . " and bottom o f page 4, "Throughout t h e
c e n t u r y over 90 p e r c e n t o f a l l women aged 55-64 have been m a r r i e d a t some
p o i n t , and i n 1997, t h a t p r o p o r t i o n s t o o d a t 95.3%." While t h i s i s an
i n t e r e s t i n g and l o n g e r - t e r m way t o l o o k a t t h i s i s s u e , doesn't i t miss
decrease i n m a r r i a g e among those c u r r e n t l y under 55. I t a l s o seems t o
c o n f l i c t w i t h a n e a r l y 4 - f o l d i n c r e a s e i n s i n g l e p a r e n t f a m i l i e s shown on
p. 3, which i s what most people focus on when t h e y t h i n k about the d e c l i n e
i n marriage. I t h i n k our c r e d i b i l i t y on t h i s i s s u e may be q u e s t i o n e d i f
we l e a d w i t h t h e statement t h a t marriage remains f a i r l y u n i v e r s a l .
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 5
Page 3, s e c t i o n on "Women i n the Workforce"
The sentence i n d i c a t i n g
t h a t more women are l i v i n g i n d e p e n d e n t l y p r i o r t o marriage " l e a d i n g t o
g r e a t e r l a b o r f o r c e attachment t h a t c o u l d c o n f l i c t w i t h f a m i l y
o b l i g a t i o n s " has a n e g a t i v e c o n n o t a t i o n s u g g e s t i n g t h a t attachment t o t h e
l a b o r f o r c e i s not h e l p f u l .
Could you re-phrase t o say t h a t the
attachment t o the l a b o r f o r c e " c o u l d impact f a m i l y o b l i g a t i o n s
t r a d i t i o n a l l y assumed by women."
Page 4, s e c t i o n on "Family Formation and D i s s o l u t i o n "
-- I t would be v e r y
p o w e r f u l i f you c o u l d p a i n t a p i c t u r e up f r o n t o f t h e changing n a t u r e o f
the American f a m i l y (much o f which i s d i s c u s s e d l a t e r i n t h e c h a p t e r ) .
For example, I would move t h e s e c t i o n on "the r o l e o f g r a n d p a r e n t s " from
the " e l d e r care" s e c t i o n t o t h i s s e c t i o n . Grandparents r a i s i n g c h i l d r e n
i s more o f a dynamic o f the changing f o r m a t i o n o f f a m i l i e s t h a n an i s s u e
of e l d e r care.
Page 6, l a s t sentence
o f t o p graph: D e l e t e "famous".
Page 6-7, same s e c t i o n : The d i s c u s s i o n o f " i n d i v i d u a l s choosing t o l i v e
t o g e t h e r o u t s i d e o f f o r m a l m a r r i a g e , " does not appear t o i n c l u d e
i n f o r m a t i o n on domestic p a r t n e r s o f t h e same sex. A c c o r d i n g t o t h e Human
R i g h t s Campaign WorkNet, "From 1994 t o 1998, the number o f m a r r i e d couple
households i n t h e US i n c r e a s e d by j u s t 2 p e r c e n t , w h i l e t h e number o f
unmarried p a r t n e r households i n c r e a s e d by 11 p e r c e n t . I n 1998, t h e r e were
5.9 m i l l i o n people i n t h e US l i v i n g w i t h a domestic p a r t n e r . Of these,
a p p r o x i m a t e l y 28 p e r c e n t , o r 1.7 m i l l i o n people, were i n same-sex
relationships."
I t would be h e l p f u l t o add i n the changing p a t t e r n s o f
r e c o g n i z e d same-sex domestic p a r t n e r s h i p s .
Page 7, 2nd graph.
I n g e n e r a l , we suggest u s i n g t h e l a t e s t a v a i l a b l e data
and u s i n g data from a c o n s i s t e n t p e r i o d . A l s o , t h i s l o n g - t e r m p e r s p e c t i v e
o v e r l o o k s the f a c t t h a t t h e t r e n d s i n out o f wedlock c h i l d b e a r i n g have
l e v e l e d o f f i n t h e p a s t fews and t h e r e have been h i s t o r i c drops i n t e e n
b i r t h rates i n recent years.
Here are some s u g g e s t i o n s ,
"Then number o f b i r t h s per 1,000 unmarried women aged 15-44 i n c r e a s e d from
7.1 i n 1940 t o 46.9 44 i n 1994 1997. [Note f o r CEA -- source i s NCHS
N a t i o n a l V i t a l S t a t i s t i c s Report on B i r t h and Death Data, 10/99. You may
a l s o want t o r e f e r t o NCHS Stephanie Ventura's t e s t i m o n y on t h i s s u b j e c t
f o r a more h i s t o r i c a l p e r s p e c t i v e -- I ' l l f a x t o you.]
The r a t e f o r b l a c k
women...a d e c l i n e t o 75.9 73.4 i n 1994 1997.
The r a t e f o r w h i t e women
aged 15-44 i n c r e a s e d most p r e c i p i t o u s l y a f t e r 1980, r i s i n g from 17.6 t o
37.5 25.9 i n 1995 1997.
[Note f o r CEA -- what about H i s p a n i c
women/girls? THE RATE FOR UNMARRIED HISPANIC WOMEN WAS 91.4 I N 1997] The
p e r c e n t o f b i r t h s t o unmarried women o f a l l ages...32.6 32.4 i n 1994
1997....The p e r c e n t o f b i r t h s t o unmarried teens rose from 31.9 p e r c e n t t o
75.7 78.2 p e r c e n t over t h e p e r i o u d 1970-1994 1997.
From 1980 t o 1990 1997
the b i r t h r a t e t o teens aged 15-19 climbed DECREASED from 53.0 t o 59.8
52.3 (per 1,000) t e e n s ) ; t h e unmarried teen b i r t h r a t e rose from 16.5 t o
30.6 25.9 f o r w h i t e s and DECREASED FROM 87.9 t o 106.0 86.4 f o r b l a c k s over
t h e same p e r i o d . . . [Note f o r CEA: THE HISPANIC TEEN BIRTH RATE was 7 5.2 i n
1997.] HOWEVER, I N MORE RECENT YEARS THESE TRENDS ARE IMPROVING. TEEN
BIRTHS HAVE DECLINED NATIONWIDE BY 18 PERCENT FROM 1991 TO 1998, AND HAVE
FALLEN I N EVERY STATE AND ACROSS ETHNIC AND RACIAL GROUPS. FOR GIRLS AGES
15-17, THE 1998 BIRTH RATE IS AT ITS LOWEST I N FOUR DECADES. I N ADDITION,
TEEN PREGNANCY RATES ARE AT THE LOWEST SINCE WE FIRST BEGAN COLLECTING
DATA IN 1976.
I N ADDITION, THE BIRTH RATE PER 1,000 UNMARRIED WOMEN HAS
DECREASED BY 2 PERCENT BETWEEN 1991 AND 1998.
Page 11, 2nd graph, sentence
1: The money c r u n c h . . . . i s f e l t by d i f f e r e n c e
�ARMS Email System
f a m i l y types f o r d i f f e r e n t reasons." T h i s a s s e r t i o n s seems t o c o n f l i c t
w i t h statement on p r e v i o u s page s a y i n g t h a t t h e money crunch a f f e c t s
single-headed households and l e s s educated households.
Page 11, 2nd graph, sentence 4: " S i m i l a r l y , t h e median income o f
female-headed f a m i l i e s has been n e a r l y f l a t . . . " T h i s statement appears t o
s h o r t s h r i f t r e c e n t improvement such as 99 CPS numbers.
Page 12, 1 s t graph, sentence 2: "Corresponding t o t h e f a m i l y groups i n
c h a r t 5-7, t h e share o f f a m i l i e s t h a t a r e headed by a s i n g l e p a r e n t has
i n c r e a s e d v e r y s i g n i f i c a n t l y over t i m e -- from x x p e r c e n t i n 1969 o 23
percent of a l l f a m i l i e s . "
I s t h i s 23% f i g u r e d i f f e r e n t t h a n t h e 27% on
page 8 and c h a r t 5-6?
Page 13, 1 s t graph: Seems awkward t o focus on c o r d l e s s phones as opposed
t o phones i n g e n e r a l .
Page 14, 1 s t graph, sentence 2: " . . . o n l y 19.1 p e r c e n t o f s i n g l e - h e a d e d
households i n 1998 a r e f a m i l i e s " -- what does t h i s mean?
Page 14, 1 s t graph: While fewer, t h e percentage o f s i n g l e - p a r e n t f a m i l i e s
headed by f a t h e r s has i n c r e a s e d d r a m a t i c a l l y and s h o u l d a t l e a s t be
mentioned.
Page 14, 2nd graph: Add t o end o f graph, "AND TOUGH CHILD SUPPORT
ENFORCEMENT."
Page 14, 3 r d graph, 3 r d sentence: 44 p e r c e n t versus 73 p e r c e n t i n 1993
s t a t i s t i c (on p r o p o r t i o n o f never m a r r i e d vs d i v o r c e s mothers w i t h s u p p o r t
o r d e r s ) doesn't seem t o add. A l s o , do we have more r e c e n t #s?
Page 14, 3 r d graph, 4 t h sentence: " O v e r a l l , r o u g h l y h a l f o f a l l women who
are s i n g l e p a r e n t s r e c e i v e p u b l i c a s s i s t a n c e " . I s t h i s a p o i n t i n t i m e -i f so, when?
Page 15, 1 s t graph, 1 s t sentence:
" R e f l e c t i n g these poor e a r n i n g s . . . "
T h i s doesn't seem t o f l o w w i t h graph above which i s n ' t about e a r n i n g s .
A l s o , r e v i s e t o read, " . . . ( t h o u g h these p o v e r t y r a t e s a r e based on A
DEFINITION OF income t h a t does n o t i n c l u d e FOOD STAMPS, EITC AND OTHER
NON-CASH INCOME)."
Page 17, 1 s t graph, sentence 3: Revise t o read, " A l l TYPES OF f a m i l i e s
experiences a d e c l i n e . . . "
Page 18, s e c t i o n on "Time Use and P a r e n t a l Care" -- I t might be h e l p f u l t o
add a d i s c u s s i o n o f t h e economic impact o f l o n g - t e r m c a r e g i v e r s . I n
Monday's NYT (11/29) r e p o r t e d on a s t u d y r e l e a s e d by t h e N a t i o n a l Center
f o r Women and Aging a t Brandeis and t h e N a t i o n a l A l l i a n c e f o r C a r e g i v e r s ,
which r e p o r t e d t h a t " t w o - t h i r d s o f those a c t i n g as c a r e g i v e r s f o r e l d e r l y
r e l a t i v e s l o s e o u t a t work by f o r g o i n g p r o m o t i o n s , pay r a i s e s , and
training opportunities."
Page 21, as mentioned above, I would suggest t h a t you move t h e box on " t h e
Role o f Grandparents" o u t o f t h e e l d e r l y care s e c t i o n and i n t o t h e f a m i l y
formation section
Page 22, Please change header " S u p p o r t i n g F a m i l i e s AMERICANS i n t h e i r
E f f o r t s t o Balance Work and Family" [ s t r i c t l y e d i t o r i a l - t o a v o i d s a y i n g
Families twice]
Page 3 of 5
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of 5
Page 25, 1st graph under w e l f a r e r e f o r m s e c t i o n .
the f i r s t 2 sentences w i t h :
We recommend r e p l a c i n g
"THE 1996 WELFARE REFORM LAW DRAMATICALLY CHANGED THE NATION'S
WELFARE SYSTEM INTO ONE THAT REQUIRES WORK I N EXCHANGE FOR TIME-LIMITED
ASSISTANCE. THE LAW CONTAINS STRONG WORK REQUIREMENTS, COMPREHENSIVE
CHILD SUPPORT ENFORCEMENT AND SUPPORTS FAMILIES MOVING FROM WELFARE TO
WORK. 27 STATES WERE AWARDED BONUS FUNDS FOR THEIR SUPERIOR RESULTS I N
REFORMING WELFARE, AND RECENT STUDIES S O THE FOLLOWING FINDINGS:
HW
MORE THAN 1.3 MILLION WELFARE RECIPIENTS NATIONWIDE WENT TO WORK I N JUST
THE ONE YEAR PERIOD BETWEEN OCTOBER 1997 AND SEPTEMBER 1998.
RETENTION RATES ARE ALSO PROMISING: 8 0 PERCENT OF THOSE W O GOT JOBS WERE
H
STILL WORKING THREE MONTHS LATER.
STATES ALSO REPORTED AN AVERAGE EARNINGS INCREASE OF 2 3 PERCENT FOR FORMER
WELFARE RECIPIENTS, FROM $2,088 I N THE FIRST QUARTER OF EMPLOYMENT TO
$2,571 I N THE THIRD QUARTER.
ALL 50 STATES MET THE WORK PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS, AND THE PERCENTAGE
OF ALL WELFARE RECIPIENTS WORKING HAS NEARLY QUADRUPLED SINCE 1992, FROM 7
PERCENT IN 1992 TO 27 PERCENT I N 1998, WITH THE REMAINDER FULFILLING THEIR
PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENTS THROUGH JOB SEARCH, EDUCATION AND TRAINING.
INDEPENDENT STUDIES CONFIRM THESE CONCLUSIONS, FINDING THAT NEARLY 7 0
PERCENT OF RECIPIENTS LEFT WELFARE FOR WORK (URBAN INSTITUTE AND GAO).
The A d m i n i s t r a t i o n ' s teen pregnancy i n i t i a t i v e TO PREVENT TEEN
PREGNANCY c o u l d a l s o playS a s u p p o r t i n g r o l e by r e d u c i n g t h e i n c i d e n c e o f
t h a t p a r t i c u l a r source o f s t r a i n I N BREAKING THE CYCLE OF DEPENDENCY AND
INCREASING THE WELL BEING OF FAMILIES BY REDUCING THE NUMBER OF CHILDREN
BORN TO TEEN MOTHERS.
Page 25, Box 5-2, f i r s t b u l l e t : "The law s u p p o r t s ENCOURAGES t h e c r e a t i o n
of Second Chance Homes, which SUPPORTIVE AND SUPERVISED LIVING
ARRANGEMENTS THAT p r o v i d e t e e n p a r e n t s . . . The w e l f a r e law a l s o p r o v i d e s $50
m i l l i o n a year f o r f i v e years i n new f u n d i n g f o r a b s t i n e n c e e d u c a t i o n
programs. The Balanced Budget Act o f 1997 p r o v i d e s f u n d i n g f o r a n a t i o n a l
e v a l u a t i o n o f t h e program. F i n a l l y , t h e new w e l f a r e law i n c l u d e tough
c h i l d support enforcement measures which w i l l send t h e s t r o n g e s t p o s s i b l e
messaage t o young g i r l s and boys t h a t they should not have c h i l d r e n u n t i l
they are ready t o p r o v i d e f o r them.
Page 25, Box 5-2,
4 t h b u l l e t : d e l e t e "intended".
Page 25, Box 5-2, l a s t b u l l e t : "The n a t i o n a l s t r a t e g y p l a c e s a s p e c i a l
emphasis on sending a s t r o n g a b s t i n e n c e message. THE WELFARE LAW ALSO
PROVIDES $50 MILLION A YEAR FOR FIVE YEARS IN NEW FUNDING FOR ABSTINENCE
EDUCATION PROGRAMS."
Page 26, Replace 1st graph b e g i n n i n g "Recent p o l i c y changes..." w i t h :
"THE ADMINISTRATION HAS ALSO IMPLEMENTED SEVERAL INITIATIVES TO
MOVE LOW-INCOME INDIVIDUALS FROM WELFARE TO WORK AND TO SUPPORT WORKING
FAMILIES, INCLUDING:
$4 BILLION INCREASE OVER SIX YEARS I N CHILD CARE ASSISTANCE TO FAMILIES
MOVING FROM WELFARE TO WORK.
THE CREATION OF THE CHILDREN'S HEALTH INSURANCE PROGRAM (CHIP) TO EXTEND
HEALTH CARE COVERAGE TO UNINSURED CHILDREN.
NEW RULES THAT ALLOW STATES TO EXPAND MEDICAID TO COVER MORE LOW-INCOME
FAMILIES W O WORK, INCLUDING MORE TWO-PARENT FAMILIES.
H
$3 BILLION IN WELFARE-TO-WORK GRANTS TO HELP STATES AND COMMUNITIES MOVE
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of 5
LONG-TERM WELFARE RECIPIENTS AND CERTAIN NONCUSTODIAL PARENTS INTO
LASTING, UNSUBSIDIZED JOBS. THESE FUNDS CAN BE USED FOR JOB CREATION,
PLACEMENT AND RETENTION EFFORTS, INCLUDING WAGE SUBSIDIES TO PRIVATE
EMPLOYERS AND OTHER CRITICAL POST-EMPLOYMENT SERVICES.
IN 1999, 50,000 NEW WELFARE TO WORK HOUSING VOUCHERS WENT TO WELFARE
RECIPIENTS WHO NEED HOUSING ASSISTANCE TO GET OR KEEP A JOB.
FAMILIES
WILL USE THESE VOUCHERS TO MOVE CLOSER TO A NEW JOB, REDUCE A LONG
COMMUTE, OR SECURE MORE STABLE HOUSING.
THE WELFARE TO WORK TAX CREDIT PROVIDES A CREDIT EQUAL TO 3 5 PERCENT OF
THE FIRST $10,000 I N WAGES I N THE FIRST YEAR OF EMPLOYMENT, AND 50 PERCENT
OF THE FIRST $10,000 I N WAGES I N THE SECOND YEAR, TO ENCOURAGE HIRING AND
RETENTION OF LONG-TERM WELFARE RECIPIENTS. THE CREDIT COMPLEMENTS THE
WORK OPPORTUNITY TAXK CREDIT WHICH PROVIDES A CREDIT OF UP TO $2,400 FOR
THE FIRST YEAR OF WAGES FOR EIGHT GROUPS OF JOB SEEKERS.
INDIVIDUAL DEVELOPMENT ACCOUNTS (IDAs) EMPOWER LOW-INCOME FAMILIES TO SAVE
FOR A FIRST HOME, POST-SECONDARY EDUCATION, Or TO START A NEW BUSINESS.
TO HELP THOSE ON WELFARE GET TO WORK, THE PRESIDENT'S JOB ACCESS
INITIATIVE AND REVERSE COMMUTE GRANTS PROVIDES FUNDS TO COMMUNITIES AND
STATES THAT DEVELOP FLEXIBLE TRANSPORTATION ALTERNATIVES, SUCH AS VAN
SERVICES FOR WELFARE RECIPIENTS AND OTHER LOW-INCOME WORKERS.
NEW GUIDANCE THAT MAKES I T EASIER FOR LOW-INCOME WORKING FAMILIES TO OWN A
CAR AND STILL RECEIVE FOOD STAMPS, AND NEW RULES THAT MAKE I T EASIER FOR
STATES TO SERVE FAMILIES BY SIMPLIFYING REPORTING REQUIREMENTS."
Page 28, s e c t i o n on FMLA, a t t h e end o f the s e c t i o n on t h e P r e s i d e n t ' s
p r o p o s a l s , you might add t h a t t h e P r e s i d e n t i s l o o k i n g f o r ways t o p r o v i d e
p a r t i a l wage replacement f o r new p a r e n t s when t h e y t a k e advantage o f
FMLA. You c o u l d add i n t h e DOL proposed r e g u l a t i o n (announced y e s t e r d a y )
a l l o w i n g s t a t e s t o use U I t o p a r t i a l l y compensate new p a r e n t s .
Page 30, s e c t i o n on "Work Arrangements t h a t Promote F l e x i b i l i t y , " you
might add a r e f e r e n c e t o t h i s d i s c u s s i o n o f p a r e n t s telecommuting t o t h e
childcare section
Page 31, s e c t i o n on " C h i l d Care" -- need t o add i n c r e a s e s i n Head S t a r t
and the f a c t t h a t t h e A d m i n i s t r a t i o n i s on i t s way t o meeting t h e
P r e s i d e n t ' s g o a l o f s e r v i n g 1 m i l l i o n c h i l d r e n by 2002
Page 34, Conclusion,
sentence 2: change " l i t t l e "
t o "FEW".
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
1996 Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA)
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
Clerk's Office
Correspondence Office
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
Office of Intergovernmental Affairs
Office of Legislative Affairs
National AIDS Policy Office
Office of Oval Office Operations
Office of the Press Secretary
Office of Public Liaison
Office of Speechwriting
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2013-0028-F
Description
An account of the resource
President Clinton signed the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) into law on September 21, 1996. The Act declared that no state shall be required to recognize a same-gender marriage performed in another state. DOMA also defined marriage as only between a man and a woman for purposes of Federal law. This collection consists of files and email accounts from the White House staff related to The Defense of Marriage Act. The collection also contains records related to Hawaii Supreme Court’s Baehrs vs. Lewin, and California’s Proposition 22. The collection consists of clippings, emails, letters, memoranda, notes, press releases, and talking points concerning DOMA, same sex marriage, and domestic partnerships.
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Office of Records Management
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
112 folders in 7 boxes
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
<a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/36606">Collection Finding Aid</a>
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[12/06/1999]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2013-0028-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Box 7
<a href="clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/show/36606" target="_blank">Collection Finding Aid</a>
<a href="https://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
William J. Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Preservation-Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
5/19/2015
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
574745
42-t-20130028F-007-004-2015
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/07bd3cfd2ab7fa16092d0a620735c697.pdf
a4a94de043e135bb62f40e9757e015a9
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC-KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
TRP - BOX 101 - FOLDER -007
[09/04/1998]
�'.. '
A~S Email System
Page 1 of 24
.u
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(TRP NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Christopher Edley, Jr.
( "Christopher Edley, Jr." <edley@law.harvard.edu>
CREATION DATE/TIME: 4-SEP-1998 21:19:45.00
SUBJECT:
Draft POTUS memo on race book
TO: aedmonds1
READ: UNKNOWN
aedmonds1@home.com [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Edward W. Correia ( CN=Edward W. Correia/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S.·Redburn/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Michele Cavataio ( CN=Michele Cavataio/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
[
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of24
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Terry.Edmonds ( terry.edmonds@ssa.gov [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
cc:
)
David Campt ( CN=David Campt/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR]
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Jacinta Ma ( CN=Jacinta Ma/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Jane T. Price-Smith ( CN=Jane T. Price-Smith/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
cc:
John M. Goering ( CN=John M. Goering/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Lin Liu ( CN=Lin Liu/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Michael Wenger ( CN=Michael Wenger/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
cc: Michele Cavataio ( CN=Michele Cavataio/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Scott R. Palmer ( CN=Scott R. Palmer/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Comrades:
Have a good weekend. You will enjoy it more if you take a look at the
attached draft memorandum, which has been sent to the Staff Secretary for
clearance. Maria is holding a clearance meeting on Tuesday afternoon at 4
pm, but comments are welcome before or after that. The memo is due in to
POTUS mid-week. Sorry I couldn't finish this earlier in the day.
- Memo-v6.wpd==================== ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
1 ====================
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D56]ARMSZZOOOSF4R.OOO to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504305630000010A0201000000020500000052840100000200000B07C5FE67E807EE65E852
CB3D35DC586A6738F72CBIB6ECA51C659D7FDB5C8FFD266DFB99A551D293E6CE0902536A495F97
632F9992D4928B507D27D72FEC13E2DB9C85BI0787F5D693B47697F02911724C40B6F5D5EII04B
5CC662E6B3DE2E2893630459A22613A0894E0336817809C735B589OF93018CEE17C55812FA5DEO
6ADAOE83877BDFF44230D7539C35162AOC09C48AAI0563F790E35632744E9C64D2D65528549524
�••
Draft v6
September 9, 1998
MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT
From:
Christopher Edley, Jr.
Professor of Law
Through:
Maria Echaveste
Deputy Chief of Staff
Re:
Progress Report on the Race Book, and Request for Interim Guidance
This memorandum is organized in the following sections:
I.
II.
III.
IV.
V.
Introduction, process and organization of the effort
The Vision (book chapter 2), and basic themes
The Workplan (chapter 6)
Leadership (chapter 7)
Next steps, and summary of decisions requested
L lNTRODUCl'lON, PROCESS AND ORGANIZATION OF THE EFFORT
The purpose of this memorandum is to review our progress, confirm our general direction, and
solicit interim guidance on a few substantive matters. Most important, Part II is a first attempt
to sketch your "vision" of One America with racial justice and equal opportunity in the 21 st
century. Then, Part III adds some flesh to key· portions of the "workplan" chapter outline you
have already seen, offering a partial menu of ideas.! We want to know if this conceptual
IThe current detailed (and daunting) outline of the book is at Tab A. The chapter outline is:
Introduction:
One America in the 21" Century
Where Is America On Race, And Where Are We Going?
Chapter 1:
p.l
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
framework makes sense, and if we are heading for the right mix of bold and pedestrian, thematic
and programmatic. White House policy staff are fully engaged and have both contributed to
this workplan material and reviewed this memorandum. Important disagreements and special
concurrences are noted in this document or accompanying memoranda.
We hope to complete the workplan menu within two weeks and, based on your tentative
approval of several ideas, proceed with more detailed policy development between now and early
November. This is key: I want these first stages of developing the workplan to emphasize
thoughtfulness and boldness in the selection of the challenges, goals, themes and general
strategies, connecting those to the vision. The next step, for greater detail over the next two
months, is to figure out more concretely what ought to be done by whom (federal government?
parents?). Throughout, Maria Echaveste will ensure that the interests of the policy councils are
well regarded, that the formal clearance process is used when appropriate, and that I can appeal
to you with any conflicts we cannot resolve in a timely way.
We have four working groups to help prepare the policy, or "workplan" chapter. These are
co-led by the appropriate NEC or DPC staff and me. As yet, they do not span the entire range of
subjects you may want to cover, but they are a good start:
Education
Economic Development and Employment Opportunity
Criminal Justice and Community Security
Civil Rights Enforcement
We also have less elaborate collaborative discussions moving forward on: Health, Strengthening
Families, Native Americans, and Democracy/Civic Engagement. The "book team" includes a
handful of PIR staff, and the addition soon of Terry Edmonds. I'm confident that several White
House and OMB staff will also play critical roles, as they have in preparation of this document.
Outreach: Finally, Maria has assigned Minyon Moore and OPL the overall responsibility for
coordinating external consultations by the outreach offices and, through Cabinet Affairs,
conversations with key appointees in the agencies. Throughout September, many members of
your staff will be making calls or conducting meetings with some 400 individuals, asking about
Chapter 2:
Chapter 3:
Chapter 4:
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
5:
6:
7:
8:
More Than A Dream: Racial And Ethnic Justice In The 21" Century
Wrestling Lessons: Honest, Constructive Engagement Of Our Vexing Differences
Promising Pradices: How To Build Bridges That Conned People Across Lines Of Class And
Color, Creating Community And Opportunity
The Record Of The Clinton-Gore Administration
A Workplan For Our Nation
Leadership For One America
Conclusion
p.2
�Automated Records Management Systerr,
Hex-Dump Conversion
the proposed framework for your report, the most important actions you should take after the
Advisory Board's work, and any elements they think it is especially important for you to
communicate in your report. We will share some of the substantive responses with you, but all of
them will be weighed by the book team.
**
II
THE VISION CHAPTER, AND BASIC THEMES
This section summarizes my best sense of your central vision for the book -- chapter 2 in the
current outline, It builds on earlier material sent to you by Sidney Blumenthal and by me, as well
as previous statements by you. In the book, the vision discussion will be preceded by an
introduction and by the chapter describing where America has been and is on race, including
demographics, discrimination, disparities, and intergroup relations. While not yet in your
language, what follows is an effort to capture the key ideas and their interrelationships. At the end
of the section, we also want to engage you on some cross-cutting questions, such as the role of
government.
(a)
Why is this subject so important for us to tackle?
Renewing America for the new century: For six years, I have worked to prepare America
for the challenges of the 21 st century. We have put our fiscal house in order, taken
important steps to strengthen the international economic system, worked at home and
abroad to create a post-cold war national security framework, launched an investment
program in vital areas of education, training, new technologies and environmental
protection. One additional area, without which we cannot succeed in the decades ahead,
is overcoming the divisions of race and ethnicity so that we can be One America, united
in a web of mutuality that gives us the strength to be our best as individuals, as
communities and as a nation.
Global and historical context" The difficulty of the problem is evident not only from our
own national history, but from events around the world - even today. The conflict is
commonplace, as differences give rise to hatreds and then bloodshed. As President, I've
seen it over and over again, and struggled to find ways that, through our actions and
example, this nation could help troubled societies see their shared humanity and find
peace. But make no mistake: This struggle to build peace and strength out of differences
is a struggle against deep failings and sinfulness that seem inherent in the human spirit. In
p.3
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
my own religious tradition, sin can be overcome through struggle and faith, and it is a
never-ending struggle. We should expect no easier a task when it comes to dealing with
our differences here in America.
The stakes: On a more practical plane, making diversity a source of strength rather than
division promises great rewards in social peace and home and economic success globally.
New complexity: The civil rights movement of three and four decades ago was largely
framed in black and white, but led to bursts of energy and progress for other minorities
and for women. Today's diversity gives us great opportunities, but also more complex
challenges.
Cause [or confidence: There is cause for confidence, because our ideals and values are far
more than words locked behind glass in the National Archives. They are an incandescent
beacon for peoples worldwide, and the lodes~ar by which we chart our own course and
criticize our missteps. Our noblest moments and wisest leaders are marked not by the .
exploitation of difference, but by recalling us to the commitments of equality, tolerance,
opportunity and justice. In my life, I have seen this most profoundly in the struggle
against racial segregation and bigotry. No nation matches our capacity for moral
greatness.
(b)
What would it mean to have a full measure of racial justice and opportunity in America?
What would our relationships be like, and what would society look like?
Vision o[ community: [Celebration of our diversity, not mere tolerance of our differences;
building inclusive communities and organizations to take advantage of the benefits and
strengths that flow from diversity. (Examples from forums, correspondence, etc.)]
"One America" does not mean that we lose our ethnic identities, becoming some
homogenized undifferentiated mass. We can be proud of our cultural identities and
distinctiveness, and at the same time be proud of and loyal to America - indeed, that is
one of the most important elements of our nation's greatness.
In religion, for example, scholars tell us that we are the most observant of developed
nations, and that freedom of religion and separation of church and state are important
parts of the explanation. We are a nation full of religious individuals, yet we do not all
worship in the same way. Indeed, our civic values are that we tolerate and respect
different religious traditions, and celebrate the legal and civic values that make diversity
p.4
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
possible. We are proud of that diversity, and together with tolerance, recognize it as a
defining greatness of America. And much of the rest of the world recognizes this too.
So, too, with our racial and ethnic diversity. Our greatness in the decades ahead depends
not merely on overcoming prejudice and bigotry rooted in our differences, and not only
in tolerating differences. We must instead celebrate those differences as a source of
richness and strength. Our personal lives are enriched by this diversity, and our society
and economy are strengthened by it.
In the community of America, the things that connect us must be stronger than those that
divide us. A "community" means shared interests. But we must also have a shared
concern for our collective advancement, and mutual concern for each other. Transcending
differences, while respecting them, is part of creating such a community.
So there is a delicate balance, because we have far too much to lose if we retreat into
ethnic enclaves - walled off from one another by prejudice, stereotypes or even simple
ignorance and misunderstanding. We sacrifice greatness and goodness, richness and
riches, if by circumstance or choice we separate ourselves into subcommunities along the
very fracture lines that have traced our national racial tragedies since Europeans arrived on
these shores.
Vision of opportunity: [Opportunity enjoyed so equally that there is no discernable legacy
of slavery, colonization or conquest; of Jim Crow or internment. (Examples from forums,
correspondence etc.)]
We have legacies of slavery, conquest and colonialism; of Jim Crow and racist
immigration quotas. The inheritance is evident in the patterns of our lives: the racially
isolated communities, the gaping disparities in educational achievement, employment,
criminal victimization and wealth; the still too-rare close friendships across lines of race.
This inheritance is a burden to our spirits and a tax on our prosperity. Perhaps most
tragically, for too many of our fellow citizens, the legacy has shackled dreams that are
every American's inalienable right. This is wrong, and we can do better.
One way our children and grandchildren will know when we have achieved racial justice
and opportunity is that the evidence of America's legacy of inequality will be found only
in history books, and not in brutal social and economic disparities surrounding them.
Vision ofresponsibility: Responsibilities of citizenship; responsibility to reach out to
others; responsibility of each of to combat whatever' stereotypes and fears we may have;
P R4FSOOOZ CEA HTML IfI]
-
-
-
-
p.5
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
and responsibility to take advantage of opportunities. (Examples from forums, letters, etc.)
We must do this for our children and their children. We must do this to honor those
who have sacrificed over the generations in earlier battles, including civil rights battles, to
put our sacred civic values into practice. And I believe we must do this to honor the God
who has created us all equal, and blessed our nation in so many countless ways.
(c)
Why is this vision preferable to alternative, competing visions?
Why embracing "equal opportunity" is necessary, but insufficient alone to produce a full
measure of justice and fairness in One America.
Why color blindness makes· sense, and why it doesn't.
Why assimilation as Americans is important, but not an assimilation that seeks to erase
our diverse identities. Is tolerance of differences sufficient, or must there be more?
**
III
THE WORKPLAN CHAPTER
The purpose of this chapter is to explain the most important steps the nation must take over the
next decade in pursuit of your vision of racial justice and opportunity, as described earlier in the
book. As with the promising practices chapter, you want to provide inspiring "news you can
use" to people in communities and organizations across the nation who are looking for ideas.
The workplan is organized by policy sectors, and within each sector it will contain federal, state,
local, private and personal elements. This is not just about the federal government, or
government generally. Few items will have FY 2000 budget impads, although several will have
"down payments" in Administration accomplishments and earlier proposals. (The ideas which
follow reflect substantial contributions from DPC, NEC and OMB; this memorandum has been
through an accelerated clearance process. Comments from your advisors are noted in this
document or in appended memoranda.)
The book should be highly thematic, avoiding an exhaustive and mind-numbing recitation of
comprehensive programmatic details. But it must contain just enough pointed recommendations
to leave the reader with a sense that you have provided concrete direction, not just rhetoric. This
also entails being very selective - not evelY good idea for addressing evelY important problem.
In areas where thoughtfulness or clarity requires more program detail, the final document can use
p.6
�textual boxes set apart from the flow of the narrative.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Two final points. The boldness you have requested in policy ideas seems in some cases to come
in the statement of a national goal ("close disparities in education achievement by X percent"),
and in other cases may not be evident until we offer specific public or private interventions to
advance the goal. Relatedly, in the stating the goals we have repeatedly between brave aspirations
and statements that are more cautious and achievable. We need your general guidance on this.
*
§ 6.2
THE EDUCATION SECTION OF THE WORKPLAN
Apart from the economy, I assume that education will be the clear first-among-equals in your
workplan for the nation, receiving disproportionate emphasis throughout the book. Despite
improvements over the last several decades, racial disparities in opportunity and achievement
persist throughout the education pipeline, and these disparities are powerful obstacles to
achieving your vision. We've tolerated it for too long. It is wrong. Therefore, the workplan
focuses on areas of significant disparity that have the greatest im'pact on educational outcomes.
It also emphasizes the instrumental and ethical necessity of heightened responsibility and
accountability.
In addition, racial isolation, often in combination with poverty concentration, remains a problem
both among and within our schools, presenting barriers to achievement, excellence, and to your
vision of mutual understanding and community. This is the third pillar of the education
workplan.
-- Outline of the section
Introduction/Context
•
Education is primary [only central?] to achieving my vision. This requires:
(1)
(2)
(3)
eliminating racial disparities in educational opportunity and achievement;
reinforcing responsibility and strengthening accountability for
administrators, teachers and students, as well as for the political
institutions governing education; and
promoting racial and economic integration in education.
p.7
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
•
•
(a)
These problems have long gone unsolved because they are difficult and because
race has divided us, but also because we need to reassess the roles of the different
levels of government and of the family in education. The old formulas need
revision, the old problems need new thinking, and the old values need new life.
We need to provide every family, regardless of race or zip code, with an
Education Bill ofRights. 2
Close the racial gap in opportunity and achievement. Notwithstanding important
progress, significant racial disparities in achievement persist. We must close these gaps
and raise the bar for everyone. This means overcoming racial disparities in the
educational opportunity available to every child - including both resources and
expectations - and simultaneously insisting on high standards for achievement. Beyond
this, we must improve our ability to make targeted, individualized efforts to ensure that
every child succeeds to his or her full potential. Among the key elements of an education
bill of rights for equal opportunity and achievement:
Parenting and early childhood: Ensure that every child has a parent or other adult
actively engaged in that child's learning, and that every young child has access to early
learning opportunities.
Teaching: Improve the quality of teacher training, ensure that high-quality teachers are
equitably distributed, and ensure that teachers promote high expectations for students of
all races.
Curriculum and standards: Ensure that every child has access to challenging curricula
tied to high standards, and that tracking does not prevent any child from achieving his or
Such a Bill of Rights might include the following:
(1)
Every child shall have a parent or other adult actively engaged in his/her learning and have access to support
services to help that child achieve to his/her full potential.
(2)
Every child shall have access to early learning opportunities.
(3)
All parents have the right to send their children to equitably funded schools that are accountable for their
child's learning.
(4)
Every child shall have access to high-quality teachers.
(5)
Every child shall be held to high expectations and standards and have access to challenging curricula.
(6)
Every child shall have access to adequate facilities and modern technology.
(7)
Every LEP child shall have access to the tools necessary to help him/her learn English within three years.
(8)
Every child shall learn in a safe environment.
All parents and children shall have the right to choose to attend racially and ethnically integrated schools.
(9)
(10)
Every high school graduate shall have the financial support and opportunity to go to college.
2
p.B
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
her full potential. Students of color are often tracked into special education and out of
honors courses.
English acquisition: Guarantee each LEP child an effective opportunity to master
English, and hold students and educators accountable for success.
Infrastructure: Close the racial disparity in full access to adequate facilities and modem
technology.
Post-secondary attainment: Overcome racial disparities in high school graduation rates,
and in college participation, retention and graduation rates.
(b)
Institute greater accountability and heightened responsibility for administrators,
teachers, students and public officials. Without much stronger mechanisms for
accountability, the goals of closing disparities in opportunity and achievement are mere
aspirations, not commitments. Moreover, to break the back of inertia and complacency
we will have to design interventions that target the political, bureaucratic and
jurisdictional impediments to sustained reform. The Voluntary National Test is such an
intervention, as is public school choice, and we must build on such approaches while
providing needed safeguards against abuses.
Tests and accountability: Use the best assessment methods, including national tests, to
build broader and deeper systems that will hold administrators, teachers, and students
accountable for educational achievement. The accountability should flow "up" from
parents and "down" from Federal taxpayers and presidential leadership. The range of
tools, both carrots and sticks, should stretch from more effective parental action, to
political mobilization, to school reconstitution or receivership, to fiscal incentives - and
everything in between.
Governance and leadership: If eliminating the disparities in opportunity and achievement
require modifications of our traditional structure of roles and authority, so be it. We need
new ways to think about old problems.
(c)
Promote integration and diversity in education to enrich the learning experience for
all students. We also care about integration, so that students have the opportunity to
learn together in ways that dissolve stereotypes and improve race relations. Parents and
students should have a right to chose an integrated education. But, after a burst of
progress in the late 1960s and early 1970s, segregation in K-12 education is worsening.
For example, a recent study reports that one-third of black and Hispanic students attend
schools with more than 90 percent minority enrollment, and almost nine in 10 of those
p.9
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
schools are predominantly poor. High-quality integrated schools provide a more
complete educational experience for all students than high-quality segregated schools.
Conversely, ineffective, racially isolated schools in high-poverty areas present our
greatest obstacle to closing the disparities in opportunity and achievement.
Educate the public on the value of inclusion, diversity and integration -- reviving that
ideal: An inclusive community of students and educators can: improve teaching and
learning by enriching the learning environment with diverse perspectives; strengthen
students' critical-thinking skills by challenging their existing perspectives; teach students
how to interact comfortably with people different from themselves and thereby how to
function as good neighbors, colleagues and citizens in our diverse democratic society;
improve students' preparation for employment by teaching them the value of diverse
perspectives, how to function in diverse business settings, and how to communicate
effectively in our increasingly diverse domestic marketplace and the expanding global
marketplace; and foster the advancement of knowledge by spurring study in new areas of
concern.
Reduce racial segregation and isolation among schools: This is not a call for massive,
federally mandated strategies where there is no constitutional violation demanding
court-supervised remedies. Instead, parents and educators should make use of a range of
measures such as magnet schools, multidistrict transfer programs, and so forth. Most
important, we must better appreciate the important stake we have in making diversity
work in the world of our children. Schools of unquestioned excellence are the easiest to
make and keep diverse.
Reduce segregation within schools: Even in diverse schools, evidence shows that
students are often resegregated into racially homogenous classes through tracking and
other mechanisms, thereby reducing their opportunities to learn together and have
positive cross-racial interactions.
Inclusion in higher education: Promote access and diversity in higher education, and
foster the educational benefits of diversity. Mend, don't end, affirmative action. And
wherever possible, use creative race-neutral mechanisms in admissions and in the K -12
pipeline. Ensure that in sustaining the crucial role ofHBCUs, HSls, and Tribal colleges
(which are integrated) we don't "excuse" historically white institutions from the principle
of excellence-through-inclusion.
- Discussion issues on the education workplan
Are you comfortable with the three major pillars: closing the race gap in opportunity and
achievement; accountability and governance; attacking racial isolation?
plO
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
Do the bulleted items capture your personal priorities? Are any high priorities missing?
Can any of them be demoted for attention in textual boxes rather than in your narrative?
Can we explore some rethinking of the federal role in order to tackle these disparities?
*
§ 6.4
CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND COMMUNITY SECURITY
From hate crimes to crack houses, from police misconduct to police hiring, from disparate
incarceration rates to racial profiling -- barely a week goes by without some aspect of crime and
criminal justice standing as a lightening rod for racial and ethnic tensions. No area is more
freighted with divisive stereotypes and misunderstanding. Yet it must be tackled with vigor
because victimization and criminality destroy communities and families, just as they fuel
alienation and division.
- Outline of the section
Introduction/Context
•
Racial disparities exist in both the realities and perceptions of crime and the .
administration of justice: communities of color disproportionately bear the social,
economic, and personal costs of crime, and, according to polls, have less
confidence in the fairness of the criminal justice system than do whites.
•
Building One America requires building a criminal justice system that serves and
treats Americans of all races fully and fairly, and thereby closes the trust gap
while making community security a right enjoyed equally.
(a)
Community Security: Eliminate racial disparities in victimization. The right to be
secure cannot be discounted by race. Every American is entitled to live in a safe
community, and the race of residents shouldn't tell us the crime rate. From 1992 to
1997, rates of violent crime in America have decreased, but disparate victimization rates
persist. Tackling this problem directly is part of the opportunity agenda, as well as a
matter of decent fairness. The Administration's record has numerous elements, which
we can build upon and target to close the disparities.
(b)
Keep young people out of the criminal justice system, and for those who have
contact with it, make it their last. Racial minorities, especially young, black males, are
more likely than whites to be both the offenders and victims of certain crimes, including
p.ll
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
violent crimes. Furthennore, one third of young, black men are presently under the
supervision of the criminal justice system (on probation, in prison, or on parole), and the
chance that a young, black male will go to prison during his lifetime is nearly 30%. The
realities are flatly inconsistent an American vision of racial justice and equal opportunity.
(c)
Build greater fairness and trust in the criminal system. Several past and present
factors contribute to mistrust in our criminal justice system among persons of color,
including negative interactions, disparities in the administration of justice (incarceration,
sentencing, death penalty), and lagging diversity in law enforcement (police, prosecutors,
judges, juries). Without more trust, creating safe communities is impossible, because
legitimacy, support and cooperation don't come free.
Prohibit the use ofracial profiling.) No American should be subject to disparate
application of the state's policing power because ofhislher race. Statistically efficient
allocation of resources, some claim, justifies impositions on innocent persons, while
perpetuating stereotypes and contributing to tensions. Targeting based on color, without
individualized evidence, is rarely if ever fair and just.
Pursue zero tolerance for racially suspect police misconduct and brutality: While the
vast majority of police are dedicated public servants who deserve our respect and support,
several high-profile cases illustrate that incidents of police misconduct and brutality
motivated by racial animus still occur. We are deeply divided in perceptions of the
magnitude of the problem.
Eliminate racial discrimination and unjustified disparities in incarceration, sentencing,
and imposition of the death penalty.
Increase diversity and representation in the criminal justice system.
- Discussion issues on the criminal justice workplan
Can we speak of community safety as a "right", and the racial disparities in victimization
as flatly inconsistent with your vision? If so, are disparities a fair index of this aspect of
racial justice and opportunity?
.
Should we "prohibit" racial profiling, or "restrict" it?
3Proftling will also be considered in the "Wrestling Lessons" chapter, as one of the hard questions that forces us to
think about differences in values and perceptions.
p.12
�Automated Records Management SYSl6,:
Hex-Dump Conversion
Similarly, should we tackle disparities in rates of incarceration, presumably with targeted
attention to prevention, diversion and post-incarceration?
Can we assume that the primary public sector role is state and local, or do you envision
continued growth in the federal role?
*
,§ 6.7
THE CIVIL RIGHTS ENFORCEMENT SECTION OF THE WORKPLAN
We have considered distributing the civil rights law enforcement issues in several sectoral
subsections - as components of the education or jobs strategies, for example. But for now, I want
to press ahead as sketched below because the audience will appropriately expect some attention
to the traditional antidiscrimination enforcement agenda. This also permits you to teach about
this unfinished work. Moreover, the best opportunities for boldness are in cross cutting issues,
among them: policy judgments about the lawfulness under Title VI of persistent resource
disparities; retooling agency enforcement strategies to emphasize proactive technical assistance
and voluntary action; and rethinking the legal framework and enforcement priorities to reflect our
21 sl century diversity.
Weare joined at the hip with Chuck Ruff, and will cooperate in his effort to put before you
suggested civil rights enforcement priorities for the next two years.
.
- Outline of the section
Introduction/Context
Persistence of discrimination, and of enforcement backlogs.
We have opportunities to strengthen and more aggressively enforce civil rights principles,
and also support appropriate voluntary actions that promote equal opportunity and access.
This includes defending disparate impact doctrine, and defending affirmative action.
The traditional agenda needs renovation to (i) increase its efficiency at handling the retail
problem of discrimination; (ii) contribute more directly to the opportunity agenda in
education, jobs and community economics; (iii) reflect our 21 sl century diversity.
(a)
Overcome racial disparities in opportunity by expanding the use of civil rights
enforcement. Civil rights enforcement can play an especially important role in
p.13
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
overcoming barriers to educational and economic opportunity, and we should strengthen
and focus civil rights enforcement to complement the opportunity agenda.
Strengthen antidiscrimination laws and enforcement procedures: For example, we
could amend Title II, which prohibits discrimination in public accommodations, to
include businesses that provide goods and services. At present, racial discrimination in
retail sales (e.g., the Eddie Bauer case in which a black teenager was ordered by a security
guard to strip off his shirt because he did not have a sales receipt) does not raise a strong
federal cause of action. We nearly abandoned pattern and practice investigations during
the 1980s. That was wrong.
Use Title VI to address racial disparities: No federal money should be spent in a
manner that supports unjustified racial disparities in opportunity. For example, in
education, Title VI prohibits policies and practices that have an unjustified disparate
impact on select racial groups in terms of access to educational resources, tracking into
challenging courses, the use of unvalidated high stakes tests, and more. We should
strengthen Title VI enforcement.
How much discrimination is there? We should expand research on the" extent of racial
discrimination, using the best available methodologies (testers where appropriate), in
such areas as employment, housing, and access to capital. The results of such testing
should be published in an annual report card.
(b)
Fully address all forms of discrimination affecting our increasingly diverse
population by strengthening civil rights laws and enforcement. We must retool our
civil rights laws and refocus enforcement efforts to fully address civil rights issues
affecting our diverse citizenry.
New immigrants: Strengthen laws and enforcement to promote the rights of new
immigrants. For example, in immigration and employment, we could expand
enforcement against labor abuses in "sweatshops," the victims of which are often new
immigrants of Hispanic or Asian origin, and amend present laws to stabilize the
immigration status of persons who report labor abuses so those persons do not fear
reprisal, official or private.
Language acquisition: Promote the rights of LEP populations. For example, in
education, we could develop regulations to clarify the Lau standard concerning what legal
requirements schools must meet in educating LEP students.
Learning your rights: Educate immigrant and LEP populations about civil rights laws
and mechanisms. We should promote outreach to immigrant and LEP populations
whose rights are protected but who are underutilizing civil rights laws.
p.14
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
(c)
Address discrimimition and disparities by promoting voluntary efforts in
conjunction with enforcement of civil rights laws. In addition to reacting to civil
rights complaints, civil rights enforcement agencies should act proactively to encourage
and support voluntary compliance with civil rights laws and values.
Expand civil rights consultations and clarify legal standards: There are civil rights
areas where both the law and policy are unclear and where people of good will may be
managing inappropriate programs. We should act to clarify legal standards and to
encourage actors to seek guidance concerning their civil rights obligations. We could
promote laws or regulations encouraging voluntary consultations with civil rights
agencies. If an actor voluntarily submits hislher practice for civil rights review, he/she is
safe harbored and/or any agreement approved by the civil rights agency following that
review would be defended by the federal government if later challenged by a third party.
Expand proactive enforcement: Absent a formal complaint, where potential civil rights
violations are discovered, civil rights agencies should follow up with the party to correct
the injustice. If discussions are not fruitful, the enforcement agency reserves the right to
launch a more formal civil rights enforcement examination. For example, in education,
the Department of Education's Office of Civil Rights (OCR) recently learned of a
Georgia education policy that placed students into gifted and talent programs based solely
on IQ test scores, despite the fact that the IQ test was not validated for that purpose nor
validated to be the sale factor for any purpose. This policy led to a disproportionately
low number of minority students being admitted to gifted and talented programs. OCR
consulted with Georgia officials, and the policy was properly amended.
(d)
Mend, don't end, affirmative action as enforcement remedy and voluntary measure
to promote access and inclusion
(e)
[Hate crimes.]
-- Discussion issues on the civil rights workplan
Mter further interagency discussion, we will need policy guidance about a number of
Title VI issues.
Should we develop a package addressing "the new diversity"?
p.1S
�Automated Records Management Sysrer;
Hex-Dump Conversion
How much technical assistance should be done proactively to implement "mend don't
end" in various sectors?
**
IV.
THE LEADERSHIP CHAPTER
Following the workplan chapter, you can challenge leaders in a range of sectors to do their part,
and combine this with a vision of locally-based efforts to use the promising practices and devise
locally-oriented workplans. Finally, in this chapter you should describe the ongoing mechanism
within the White House to help support the sectoral leadership, community-based leadership, and
the Federal government elements of your workplan.
(a)
Challenges for sectoral leadership
We expect, by the publication date, to have worked successfully with leadership groups in a few
sectors, prompting them to develop a list of action steps tailored to their sector, and a practical
strategy for implementation. A brief status report on what we have initiated follows.
Higher Education: With staff support from the American Council on Education, a core
group of college and university presidents is working to establish a broader coalition that
will lead a coordinated campaign to educate the public about the value of diversity in
higher education and to share campus practices that promote diversity. We expect them to
launch the effort, designed with Frank Greer as lead consultant, sometime this fall.
(There is a possibility of using a White House event to bless the undertaking.)
Faith CommunitY: Sandy Cloud of the National Conference for CommuQity and
Justice has agreed to lead a steering committee in convening, on October 22 and
October 23, an implementation summit at which a group of faith leaders will write
and commit to a practical work plan for both national and community-based action, and
devise a coalition mechanism for follow through. This will include special efforts to reach
those faith communities that have not traditionally been leaders in racial justice. In
addition, at your September 11 breakfast for religious leaders, you will have an
opportunity to mention Sandy Cloud's leadership, and encourage those in the room to
respond positively to the effort.
p.16
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Corporate: Secretary Daley will informally convene a group of CEOs in October to
a
identify the most appropriate elements of corporate sector initiative, and strategies for
enlisting support from key executives. In preparation for that session, White House and
agency staff will brainstorm with some current and former Administration officials in
corporate leadership.
Youth: We are organizing a team of White House staff and representatives from national
youth-oriented organizations to prepare a workplan intended for widespread endorsement
and dissemination. (The outside collaborators will include USSA, Young Democrats,
Young Republicans, the youth divisions of the NAACP, Urban League, La Raza and the
Congress of Asian Pacific American Youth.) Tentatively, we think the plan's three major
components will be: (i) a national campaign to educate the youth sector about the
intricacies and history of race and racism; (ii) an initiative to improve race-related
curriculum and teaching in grades K-16; and (iii) a mechanism to ensure youth sector
involvement.
.
(b)
Options for an ongoing structure to carry out your work plan
While the work plan is not yet completed, we know that there will be some general components
which will require continuity and should compose the major responsibilities of the new entity:
~
~
~
~
Policy making (including research and data collection)
Outreach and leadership development (including technical assistance to communities)
Communication campaign (including an awards program)
Support for promising practices (such as a clearinghouse, conferences, grant funding)
The work plan lays out an ambitious agenda that will require the involvement of several players.
With such an extensive scope of work, a coordinating body for the federal sector, and for liaison
with non-federal actors is needed to ensure continued momentum and follow up from outside
efforts. Non-federal'leaders engaged on the workplan will expect a central point of contact and
technical assistance.
Option A:
A1:
President's Council for One America
President's Council for One America Plus an External Advisory Committee
The continuing effort could take a form similar to the Council for Environmental Quality
or the Office of Science and Technology Policy. This arrangement would be short of
the ONDCP model which has a large staff, a significant budget, and substantial operating
p.17
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
authority. The council, created by Executive Order, would be run by an Assistant to the
President (as Executive Director) with a small staff and a blue ribbon advisory committee.
A council staff should include a policy component, which would work with existing
White House policy offices and federal agencies to promote data collection and research
and to develop and monitor policies to overcome disparities and eliminate discrimination.
It would also have a communications component, which would help lead a public
education campaign, support a promising practices clearinghouse, and conduct outreach
to help improve race relations.
Pros:
•
Location places the Presidency squarely behind racial reconciliation effort
Relatively stable structure
Staff appointed by you ensures White House control
Advisory committee offers opportunity for showcasing diverse leadership,
provides credibility in building partnerships
•
•
•
Cons: •
Location and staffing make the stakes high
Advisory committee requires support and nurturing; the familiar headaches
•
A2:
President's Council for One America, No Advisory Committee
This option would be the same as option Al but it would not include an Advisory
Committee.
Pros:.
Staff would not be distracted by the day-to-day demands of managing an
Advisory Committee
Cons: •
Option B:
Lacks the outside validation that an Advisory Committee can provide
Dedicated Staff reporting to the Office of the Chief of Staff
An Assistant to the President with a small staff, reporting to the Chief of Staff s
office, could take responsibility for managing Administration efforts.
Pros:
•
Closely linked to you and the White House
At the center of activity
•
Cons: •
Not a formal structure, may not be stable
May not be viewed publicly as a significant enough commitment
•
Option C:
Private Foundation Model
P R4FSOOOZ CEA HTML l[lJ
-
-
-
-
p.18
�Automated Records Management System
. Hex-Dump Conversion
Cl:
One America Foundation
The structure could take the fonn of a private foundation, established at your urging and
supported to varying degrees by the federal government, similar to the Points of Light
Foundation. The goals of the foundation could include promoting research on issues of
race, promoting a public education campaign to support racial reconciliation, and
supporting community efforts to improve race relations. Such a foundation could perhaps
best complement a separate policy-making effort within the federal government.
Pros: •
•
•
Cons: •
•
C2:
Serves as umbrella to coordinate several areas of activity
Independence
Ability to raise money
May not be viewed as closely connected to the White House
Requires someone's time and attention to pull together
Clinton Library Model
This option is similar to the Foundation model above except that it would be an endeavor
for you after your final tenn ends, possibly as part of the Clinton library. Staff could
begin immediately to design the structure.
Pros: •
•
Cons: •
•
More time to put together the funding and structure
You will have more time to devote to it
Delays significant Presidential involvement for a few more years
May be partisan resistance to participating in activities because of close
alignment with this Administration
V.
NEXT STEPS
Attachments:
Current book oudine.
p.19
�NEe memorandum on employment issues
???
Automated ReCOrds Management System
Hex.IJump ConvelSion
P R4FSOOOZ CEA HTML 1[IJ
-
-
-
-
p.20
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[09/04/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Tape Restoration Project
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Tape Restoration Project
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
TRP - Box 101 - Folder 007
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/f845cb7f48137c012d886556b37c6d72.pdf
fe63c70601dc39d087a6f1f8eb0736c2
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 100 - FOLDER -004
[06/15/1999-07/29/1999]
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Oscar Gonzalez ( CN=Oscar Gonzalez/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:1S-JUN-1999 16:18:46.00
SUBJECT:
REMINDER on LRM OGG21 - - LABOR Testimony on OSHA's Draft Safety and Healt
TO: Brian S. Mason ( CN=Brian S. Mason/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Yvette M. Dennis ( CN=Yvette M. Dennis/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian V. Kennedy ( CN=Brian V. Kennedy/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven D. Aitken ( CN=Steven D. Aitken/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward A. Brigham ( CN=Edward A. Brigham/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This is a reminder that your comments on the Labor testimony on OSHA's
Draft Safety and Health Program Rule (LRM ID OGG21) were due today.
I
just got word that the OSHA hearing has been postponed, so I'm extending
the dealine until 3pm tomorrow. Please provide any comments to me by
then.
If I don't hear from you, I'll assume you have no objection to the
testimony in its current form.
Thanks
~I
�~RMS
Email System
Page 1 of 3
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 16-JUN-1999 17:18:11.00
SUBJECT:
Daily Report
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Loretta M. Ucelli ( CN=Loretta M. Ucelli/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Cahill ( CN=Mary E. Cahill/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Glyn T. Davies
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Glyn T. Davies/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff ( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�~RMS
Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN;Bob J. Nash/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN;Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neal Lane ( CN;Neal Lane/OU;OSTP/O;EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN;Robert B. Johnson/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: George T. Frampton ( CN;George T. Frampton/OU;CEQ/O;EOP@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN;Sidney Blumenthal/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D@Al
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D@Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN;Maria Echaveste/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN;Barbara A. Barclay/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Edward A. Rice ( CN;Edward A. Rice/OU;NSC/O;EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Leslie Bernstein ( CN;Leslie Bernstein/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn T. Wu ( CN;Carolyn T. Wu/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Lael Brainard ( CN;Lael Brainard/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nina L. Hachigian ( CN;Nina L. Hachigian/OU;NSC/O;EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa G. Green ( CN;Melissa G. Green/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN;Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN;Marjorie Tarmey/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Rebecca L. Walldorff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN;Rebecca L. Walldorff/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN;Mindy E. Myers/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN;Kris M Balderston/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�•
.
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Sorry for the late notice, but John would like to pull together a daily
report today for the President. He'll need to review it and may not be
here much longer, so
Please submit bullet points to Catie Pacific (with a cc: to me) ASAP.
Thanks.
Page 3 of3
�A~S
Email System
Page 1 of 3
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:17-JUN-1999 09:42:12.00
SUBJECT:
Daily Reports
TO: Joel Johnson ( CN=Joel Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Loretta M. Ucelli
READ; UNKNOWN
( CN=Loretta M. Ucelli/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Cahill ( CN=Mary E. Cahill/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Glyn T. Davies ( CN=Glyn T. Davies/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of3
AR¥S Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN=Bob J. Nash/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neal Lane ( CN=Neal Lane/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: George T. Frampton ( CN=George T. Frampton/OU=CEQ/O=EOP@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D@Al
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D@Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ann C. Hertelendy ( CN=Ann C. Hertelendy/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Edward A. Rice ( CN=Edward A. Rice/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO , 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn T. Wu ( CN=Carolyn T. Wu/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nina L. Hachigian ( CN=Nina L. Hachigian/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Justin L. Coleman ( CN=Justin L. Coleman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Courtney M. Manning ( CN=Courtney M. Manning/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1· )
�Page 3 of3
ARJvlS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Rebecca L. Walldorff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Rebecca L. Walldorff/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We'll be preparing a daily report for the President again today.
Please
email bullet points (just simple paragraphs, please, no separate memos or
formatting; a Word attachment is best) to Barbara Barclay with a cc: to
me, by 3:00 p.m.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN;Sean P. Maloney/OU;WHO/O;EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 18-JUN-1999 13:42:45.00
SUBJECT:
daily report
TO: Joel Johnson ( CN;Joel Johnson/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN;Janet L. Yellen/OU;CEA/O;EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Loretta M. Ucelli ( CN;Loretta M. Ucelli/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN;Todd Stern/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN;Gene B. Sperling/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN;Bruce N. Reed/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN;Minyon Moore/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN;Ann F. Lewis/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN;Ron Klain/O;OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN;Mickey Ibarra/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Cahill ( CN;Mary E. Cahill/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Glyn T. Davies ( CN;Glyn T. Davies/OU;NSC/O;EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN;Jacob J. Lew/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN;Karen Tramontano/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN;Christopher C. Jennings/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN;Sylvia M. Mathews/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN;Michael Waldman/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of3
A){MS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN=Bob J. Nash/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neal Lane ( CN=Neal Lane/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: George T. Frampton ( CN=George T. Frampton/OU=CEQ/O=EOP@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D@Al
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D@Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (NSC)
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ann C. Hertelendy ( CN=Ann C. Hertelendy/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Edward A. Rice ( CN=Edward A. Rice/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn T. Wu ( CN=Carolyn T. Wu/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nina L. Hachigian ( CN=Nina L. Hachigian/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Justin L. Coleman ( CN=Justin L. Coleman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�.
ARMS Emaii System
Page 3 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Courtney M. Manning ( CN=Courtney M. Manning/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Rebecca L. Walldorff ( CN=Rebecca L. Walldorff/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP .[ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham
READ: UNKNOWN
Cr=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TEXT:
please submit items for today's daily report by email to me (with a cc: to
barbara barclay) by 3:00 p.m.; thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. MaloneyjOU=WHOjO=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:21-JUN-1999 14:19:26.00
SUBJECT:
Daily Report
TO: Joel Johnson ( CN=Joel JohnsonjOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. YellenjOU=CEAjO=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Loretta M. Ucelli ( CN=Loretta M. UcellijOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd SterniOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. SperlingjOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. ReedjOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon MoorejOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [.WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
">
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. LewisjOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron KlainjO=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey IbarrajOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Cahill ( CN=Mary E. CahilljOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Glyn T. Davies ( CN=Glyn T. DaviesjOU=NSCjO=EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. JenningsjOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN=Bob J. Nash/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshal·l Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neal Lane ( CN=Neal Lane/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: George T. Frampton ( CN=George T. Frampton/OU=CEQ/O=EOP@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D@Al
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D@Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ann C. Hertelendy ( CN=Ann C. Hertelendy/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Edward A. Rice ( CN=Edward A. Rice/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn T. Wu ( CN=Carolyn T. Wu/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nina L. Hachigian ( CN=Nina L. Hachigian/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Justin L. Coleman ( CN=Justin L. Coleman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Courtney M. Manning ( CN=Courtney M. Manning/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Rebecca L. Walldorff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Rebecca L. Walldorff/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
A reminder . . . please send daily report items to me by 3:00 p.m. today.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. MaloneyjOU=WHOjO=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:22-JUN-1999 08:56:11.00
SUBJECT:
Daily Report
TO: Joel Johnson ( CN=Joel JohnsonjOU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Loretta M. Ucelli ( CN=Loretta M. Ucelli/Ou=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon MoorejOU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. LewisjOU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Cahill ( CN=Mary E. Cahill/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Glyn T. Davies ( CN=Glyn T. Davies/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
.TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN=Bob J. Nash/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neal Lane ( CN=Neal Lane/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
.READ : UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: George T. Frampton ( CN=George T. Frampton/OU=CEQ/O=EOP@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D@Al
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D@Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robert L. Nabors ( CN=Robert L. Nabors/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ann C. Hertelendy ( CN=Ann C. Hertelendy/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP r.WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Edward A. Rice ( CN=Edward A. Rice/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn.T. Wu ( CN=Carolyn T. Wu/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nina L. Hachigian ( CN=Nina L. Hachigian/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
�~RMS
Email System
Page 3 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Adrienne C. Erbach ( CN=Adrienne C. Erbach/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Justin L. Coleman ( CN=Justin L. Coleman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Courtney M. Manning ( CN=Courtney M. Manning/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Rebecca L. Walldorff ( CN=Rebecca L. Walldorff/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We'll be doing a daily report again today.
me, as usual, by 3:00 p.m. Thanks.
Please send report items to
�AR.MS Email System
Page 1 of3
•
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-JUL-1999 11:20:44.00
SUBJECT:
Daily Report
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 J
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Mary E. Cahill ( CN=Mary E. Cahill/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Glyn T. Davies ( CN=Glyn T. Davies/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eric P. Liu ( CN=Eric P. Liu/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joel Johnson ( CN=Joel Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�.
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Loretta M. Ucelli ( CN=Loretta M. Ucelli/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN=Bob J. Nash/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neal Lane ( CN=Neal Lane/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: George T. Frampton ( CN=George T. Frampton/OU=CEQ/O=EOP@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D@Al
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D@Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (NSC)
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lisel Loy ( CN=Lisel Loy/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ann C. Hertelendy ( CN=Ann C. Hertelendy/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP .[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Edward A. Rice ( CN=Edward A. Rice/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn T. Wu ( CN=Carolyn T. Wu/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nina L. Hachigian ( CN=Nina L. Hachigian/OU=NSC/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of3
I
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
David R. Goodfriend ( CN=David R. Goodfriend/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Justin L. Coleman ( CN=Justin L. Coleman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Courtney M. Manning ( CN=Courtney M. Manning/OU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Rebecca L. Walldorff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Rebecca L. Walldorff/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
CC: Sara M.· Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We'll be preparing a daily report for the President today.
Please submit
bullet points to my office (via email to me or Barbara Barclay) by 3:00
p.m.
Thanks.
�A'RMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
023
D640l50000E5D940l5000070BB40l500203AE3400900BDOOlEOOOCOBOl0015000000l040l50000
804340150000C05640l5007FlBBC04040006001BOOOCOB0500150086EB51B8AA97F74008000DOB
05FF05000lDAOA0500BD001EOOOCOB06001500C04DD1401500COlED5401500008DBC401500EOC4
E0400900BDOOlEOOODOB010015000000F03F15000080434015000000574015005F65C404040006
00 lBO 0 ODOBO 5 0 0 15 0 0 8 6EB51B8 6A4 8F64 0 0 8 0 0 OEOBO 5FFO 5 0'0 0 lDAOAO 5 0 OBDO 0 lEO 0 ODOBO 6 0 0 15
0080A8D140150080E5D64015000043BE4015004062DE400900BDOOlEOOOEOBOl00150000000040
l50000804340l500000057401500608l08READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Kim B. Widdess ( CN=Kim B. Widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith 'A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Miriam H. Vogel
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�Page 2 of2
RRMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We are having a meeting at llam in room 476 to plan for today's VP NARAL
lunch. Please pass this message on to anyone I might have missed. Thanks.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[06/15/1999 – 07/29/1999]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 100 - Folder 004
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/fc51ca31b533974b2abf17cc8dc0906d.pdf
d48c6d84a2ae84d8ce82096d4fc8c452
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC-KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 100 - FOLDER -003
[04/29/1999-06/14/1999 ]
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE!TIME:29-APR-1999 18:02:10.00
SUBJECT:
Daschle set to introduce new equal pay bill tomorrow
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers!OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carl Haacke ( CN=Carl Haacke!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [.OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Caroline Fredrickson just called and said that Daschle is .expected to
introduce the new Paycheck Fairness Act with the data collection provision
tomorrow.
They aren't planning on doing any press on it.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 10
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-APR-1999 12:27:11.00
SUBJECT:
Final Version of the Revised Daschle Equal Pay bill
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Carl Haacke ( CN=Carl Haacke/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
. READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Daschle's staff has confirmed that they will introduce it today.
---------------------- Forwarded by Mary L. Smith/OPD/EOP on 04/30/99
12:26 PM -----.---------------------
Carmel_Martin @ daschle.senate.gov (Carmel Martin)
04/30/99 12:22:52 PM
Record Type: Record
To: Mary L. Smith/OPD/EOP, Caroline R. Fredrickson/WHO/EOP
cc:
Subject: Final Version
- Bai99.fin.wpd
Let me know if you would like a hard copy.
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D69]ARMS23065653E.136 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504357060000010A02010000000205000000754C0000000200009DC2498949596CDA316A6C
DA9B321CDl198F7A097424DA98EA9D4B228A54CA72ECD89C7CD88BB5A011B20F2D387E2F1FC01E
F82E6C1992214FFD927FC2DFD77BD9ADE819817A8790B9B52873F9BCA92CDCC896E835CE38DCF5
31863C197541EC6760936B622924057124A6E4FCC5EB25E23EF25C1465AD778159D8821B67EDE1
E889581648BC125D49BC120EC2C4C1668734945A1D960DBF3C43BO10092EF39B04A14D39E36638
�106th CONGRESS
1st Session
s.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
74
IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
Mr. Daschle (for himself, Mr. Kerry, Mr. Leahy, Ms. Mikulski, Mrs.
Murray, Mr. Reid, Mr. Wyden, Mrs. Boxer, Mr. Lautenberg, Mr. Kennedy,
Mr. Kerrey, Mr. Durbin, Ms. Landrieu, Mr. Reed, Mr. Robb, Mr.
Torricelli, Mr. Breaux, Mr. Wells tone , Mrs. Feinstein, Mr. Hollings,
Mr. Dodd, Mr. Akaka, Mr. Feingold, and Mr. yohnson) introduced the
following bill; which was read twice and referred to the Committee
on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions
A BILL
OTo amend the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 to provide more
effective remedies to victims of discrimination in the payment of
wages on the basis of sex, and for other purposes.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the
United States of America in Congress assembled,
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the "Paycheck Fairness Act".
SEC. 2. FINDINGS.
Congress makes the following findings:
(1) Women have entered the workforce in record numbers.
(2) Even in the 1990's, women earn significantly lower pay than
men for work on jobs that require equal skill, effort, and
responsibility and that are performed under similar working
conditions. These pay disparities exist in both the private and
governmental sectors. In many instances, the pay disparities can
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
only be due to continued intentional discrimination or the lingering
effects of past discrimination.
(3) The existence of such pay disparities_
(A) depresses the wages of working families who rely on the wages
of all members of the family to make ends meet;
(B) prevents the optimum utilization of available labor resources;
(C) has been spread and perpetuated, through commerce and the
channels and instrumentalities of commerce, among the workers of
the several States;
(D) burdens commerce and the free flow of goods in commerce;
(E) constitutes an unfair method of competition in commerce;
(F) leads to labor disputes burdening and obstructing commerce
and the free flow of goods in commerce;
(G) interferes with the orderly and fair marketing of goods in
commerce; and
(H) in many instances, may deprive workers of equal protection
on the basis of sex in violation of the 5th and 14th amendments.
(4) (A) Artificial barriers to the elimination of discrimination
in the payment of wages on the basis of sex continue to exist more
than 3 decades after the enactment of the Fair Labor Standards Act
of 1938 (29 U.S.C. 201 et seq.) and the Civil Rights Act of 1964
(42 U.S.C. 2000a et seq.).
(B) Elimination of such barriers would have positive effects,
including_
(i) providing a solution to problems in the economy created by
unfair pay disparities;
(ii) substantially reducing the number of working women earning
unfairly low wages, thereby reducing the dependence on public
assistance; and
(iii) promoting stable families by enabling all family members
to earn a fair rate of pay;
(iv) remedying the effects of past discrimination on the basis
of sex and ensuring that in the future workers are afforded equal
protection on the basis of sex; and
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
(v) ensuring equal protection pursuant to Congress' power to
enforce the 5th and 14th amendments.
(5) With increased information about the provisions added by the
Equal Pay Act of 1963 and wage data, along with more effective
remedies, women will be better able to recognize and enforce their
rights to equal pay for work on jobs that require equal skill, effort,
and responsibility and that are performed under similar working
conditions.
(6) Certain employers have already made great strides in
eradicating unfair pay disparities in the workplace and their
achievements should be recognized.
SEC. 3. ENHANCED ENFORCEMENT OF EQUAL PAY REQUIREMENTS.
(a) Required Demonstration for Affirmative Defense._Section
6 (d) (1) of the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (29 U.S.C. 206 (d) (1))
is amended by striking "(iv) a differential" and all that follows
through the period and inserting the following: "(iv) a differential
based on a bona fide factor other than sex, such as education, training
or experience, except that this clause shall apply only if
"(I) the employer demonstrates that
"(aa) such factor
"(AA) is job-related with respect to the position in question;
or
"(BB) furthers a legitimate business purpose, except that this
item shall not apply where the employee demonstrates that an
alternative employment practice exists that would serve the same
business purpose without producing such differential and that the
employer has refused to adopt such alternative practice; and
"(bb) such factor was actually applied and used reasonably in
light of the asserted justification; and
"(II) upon the employer succeeding under subclause (I), the
employee fails to demonstrate that the differential produced by the
reliance of the employer on such factor is itself the result of
discrimination on the basis of sex by the employer.
"An employer that is not otherwise in compliance with this
paragraph may not reduce the wages of any employee in order to achieve
such compliance. ' , .
(b) Application of Provisions._Section 6(d) (1) of the Fair Labor
Standards Act of 1938 (29 U.S.C. 206(d) (1)) is amended by adding
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
at the end the following: "The provisions of this sUbsection shall
apply to applicants for employment if such applicants, upon
employment by the employer, would be subject to any provisions of
this section.".
(c) Elimination of Establishment Requirement ._Section 6 (d) of the
Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (29 U.S.C. 206(d)) is amended_
(1) by striking", within any establishment in which such employees
are employed,' '; and
(2) by striking "in such establishment"
each place it appears.
(d) Nonretaliation provision._Section 15(a) (3) of the Fair Labor
Standards Act of 1938 (2.9 U.S.C. 215(a) (3)) is amended
(1) by striking "employee"
the first place it appears and
inserting "employee (or applicant for employment in the case of
an applicant described in section 6(d))' ';
(2) by inserting "(or applicant)"
place it appears;
(3) by striking
"has' '; and
or has"
after "employee"
the second
each place it appears and inserting
(4) by inserting before the semicolon the following: " , has
inquired about, discussed, or otherwise disclosed the wages of the
employee or another employee, or because the employee (or applicant)
has made a charge, testified, assisted, or participated in any manner
in an investigation, proceeding, hearing, or action under section
6 (d) , , .
(e) Enhanced Penalties._Section 16(b) of the Fair Labor Standards
Act of 1938 (29 U.S.C. 216(b)) is amended
(1) by inserting after the first sentence the following: "Any
employer who violates section 6 (d) shall additionally be liable for
such compensatory or punitive damages as may be appropriate, except
that the United States shall not be liable for punitive damages.";
(2) in the sentence beginning "An action to' " by striking "either
of the preceding sentences"
and inserting "any of the preceding
sentences of this subsection' ';
(3) in the sentence beginning "No employees shall' " by striking
"No employees' , and inserting' 'Except with respect to class actions
brought to enforce section 6(d), no employee' ';
(4) by inserting after the sentence referred to in paragraph (3),
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
the following: "Notwithstanding any other provision of Federal law,
any action brought to enforce section 6(d) may be maintained as a
class action as provided by the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. ' , ;
and
(5) in the sentence beginning "The court in' '_
(A) by striking "in such action" and inserting "in any action
brought to recover the liability prescribed in any of the preceding
sentences of this subsection' '; and
(B) by inserting before the period the following:
expert fees".
including
(f) Action by Secretary ._Section 16 (c) of the Fair Labor Standards
Act of 1938 (29 U.S.C. 216(c)) is amended
(1) in the first sentence
(A) by inserting "or, in the case of a violation of section 6 (d) ,
additional compensatory or punitive damages,"
before "and the
agreement' '; and
(B) by inserting before the period the following:
compensatory or punitive damages, as appropriate' ';
, or such
(2) in the second sentence, by inserting before the period the
following: "and, in the case of a violation of section 6(d),
additional compensatory or punitive damages' ';
(3) in the third sentence, by striking "the first sentence' , and
inserting "the first or second sentence' '; and
(4) in the last sentence
(A) by striking "commenced in the case"
"commenced
and inserting
, , (1) in the case' , ;
(B) by striking the period and inserting
or' '; and
(C) by adding at the end the following:
"(2) in the case of a class action brought to enforce section
6(d), on the date on which the individual becomes a party plaintiff
to the class action".
SEC. 4. TRAINING.
�Automated Records Management System
.
Hex-Dump Conversion
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and the Office of
Federal Contract Compliance Programs, subject to the availability
of funds appropriated under section 9(b), shall provide training
to Commission employees and affected individuals and entities on
matters involving discrimination in the payment of wages.
SEC. 5. RESEARCH, EDUCATION, AND OUTREACH.
The Secretary of Labor shall conduct studies and provide
information to employers, labor organizations, and the general public
concerning the means available to eliminate pay disparities between
men and women, including_
(1) conducting and promoting research to develop the means to
correct expeditiously the conditions leading to the pay disparities;
(2) publishing and otherwise making available to employers, labor
organizations, professional associations, educational institutions,
the media, and the
general public the findings resulting from studies and other
materials, relating to eliminating the pay disparities;
(3) sponsoring and assisting State and community informational
and educational programs;
(4) providing information to employers, labor organizations,
professional associations, and other interested persons on the means
of eliminating the pay disparities;
(5) recognizing and promoting the achievements of employers, labor
organizations, and professional associations that have worked to
eliminate the pay disparities; and
(6) convening a national summit to discuss, and consider approaches
for rectifying, the pay disparities.
SEC. 6. TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE AND EMPLOYER RECOGNITION PROGRAM.
(a) Guidelines.
(1) In general._The Secretary of Labor shall develop guidelines
to enable employers to evaluate job categories based on objective
criteria such as educational requirements, skill requirements,
independence, working conditions, and responsibility, including
decisionmaking responsibility and de facto supervisory
responsibility.
(2) Use._The guidelines developed under paragraph (1) shall be
designed to enable employers voluntarily to compare wages paid for
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
different jobs to determine if the pay scales involved adequately
and fairly reflect the educational requirements, skill requirements,
independence, working conditions, and responsibility for each such
job with the goal of eliminating unfair pay disparities between
occupations traditionally dominated by men or women.
(3) Publication._The guidelines shall be developed under paragraph
(1) and published in the Federal Register not later than 180 days
after the date of enactment of this Act.
(b) Employer Recognition._
(1) Purpose._It is the purpose of this subsection to emphasize
the importance of, encourage the improvement of, and recognize the
excellence of employer efforts to pay wages to women that reflect
the real value of the contributions of such women to the workplace.
(2) In general._To carry out the purpose of this subsection, the
Secretary of Labor shall establish a program under which the Secretary
shall provide for the recognition of employers who, pursuant to a
voluntary job evaluation conducted by the employer, adjust their
wage scales (such adjustments shall not include the lowering of wages
paid to men) using the guidelines developed under subsection (a)
to ensure that women are paid fairly in comparison to men.
(3) Technical assistance._The Secretary of Labor may provide
technical assistance to assist an employer in carrying out an
evaluation under paragraph (2).
(c) Regulations ._The Secretary of Labor shall promulgate such rules
and regulations as may be necessary to carry out this section.
SEC. 7. ESTABLISHMENT OF THE NATIONAL AWARD FOR PAY EQUITY IN THE
WORKPLACE.
(a) In General. There is established the Robert Reich National
Award for Pay Equity in the Workplace, which shall be evidenced by
a medal bearing the inscription "Robert Reich National Award for
Pay Equity in the Workplace' '. The medal shall be of such design
and materials, and bear such additional inscriptions, as the
Secretary of Labor may prescribe.
(b) Criteria for Qualification. To qualify to receive an award
under this section a business shall
(1) submit a written application to the Secretary of Labor, at
such time, in such manner, and containing such information as the
Secretary may require, including at a minimum information that
demonstrates that the business has made substantial effort to
eliminate pay disparities between men and women, and deserves special
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
recognition as a consequence; and
(2) meet such additional requirements and specifications as the
. Secretary of Labor determines to be appropriate.
(c) Making and Presentation of Award.
(1) Award. After receiving recommendations from the Secretary of
Labor, the President or the designated representative of the
President shall annually present the award described in subsection
(a) to businesses that meet the qualifications described in
subsection (b).
(2) Presentation._The President or the designated representative
of the President shall present the award under this section with
such ceremonies as the President or the designated representative
of the President may determine to be appropriate.
(d) Business. In this section, the term "business"
includes
(1) (A) a corporation, including a nonprofit corporation;
(B) a partnership;
(C) a professional association;
(D) a labor organization; and
(E) a business entity similar to an entity described in any of
subparagraphs (A) through (D);
(2) an entity carrying out an education referral program, a training
program, such as an apprenticeship or management training program,
or a similar program; and
(3) an entity carrying out a joint program, formed by a combination
of any entities described in paragraph (1) or (2).
SEC. 8. COLLECTION OF PAY INFORMATION BY THE EQUAL EMPLOYMENT
OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION.
Section 709 of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (42 U.S.C. 2000e-8)
is amended by adding at the end the following:
"(f) (1) Not later than 18 months after the date of enactment of
this subsection, the Commission shall
"(A) complete a survey of the data that is currently available
to the Federal Government relating to employee pay information for
use in the enforcement of Federal laws prohibiting pay discrimination
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
and, in consultation with other relevant Federal agencies, identify
additional data collections that will enhance the enforcement of
such laws; and
"(B) based on the results of the survey and consultations under
subparagraph (A), issue regulations to provide for the collection
of pay information data from employers as described by the sex, race,
and national origin of employees.
"(2) In implementing paragraph (1), the Commission shall have
as its primary consideration the most effective and efficient means
for enhancing the enforcement of Federal laws prohibiting pay
discrimination. Other factors that the Commission shall consider
include the imposition of burdens on employers, the frequency of
required reports (including which employers should be required to
prepare reports), appropriate protections for maintaining data
confidentiality, and the most effective format for the data
collection reports.' '.
SEC. 9. AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.
There are authorized to be appropriated such sums as may be
necessary to carry out this Act.
�,,'\RMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 12-MAY-1999 09:33:29.00
SUBJECT:
5:30 Deputies mtg canceled
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark F. Lindsay ( CN=Mark F. Lindsay/OU=OA/O=EOP @ EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles M. Brain ( CN=Charles M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul D. Glastris ( CN=Paul D. Glastris/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David R. Goodfriend ( CN=David R. Goodfriend/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shirley S. Sagawa ( CN=Shirley S. Sagawa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Glyn T. Davies ( CN=Glyn T. Davies/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne F. Donovan ( CN=Anne F. Donovan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alphonse J. Maldon ( CN=Alphonse J. Maldon/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Dankowski ( CN=John Dankowski/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal ( CN=Fred DuVal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Today's 5:30 Deputies.meeting is canceled.
Please pass the word.
�· - ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN;Cathy R. Mays/OU;OPD/O;EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-MAY-1999 11:30:43.00
SUBJECT:
Meeting Today
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN;Janet L. Yellen/OU;CEA/O;EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN;Sylvia M. Mathews/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN;Gene B. Sperling/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN;John Podesta/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN;Lawrence J. Stein/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN;Jacob J. Lew/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN;Karen Tramontano/OU;WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn T. Wu ( CN;Carolyn T. Wu/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN;Mindy E. Myers/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN;Peter A. Weissman/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN;Laura Emmett/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Alice H. Williams ( CN;Alice H. Williams/OU;CEA/O;EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN;Katharine Button/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sandra L. Via ( CN;Sandra L. Via/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
CC: Dawn L. Smalls ( CN;Dawn L. Smalls/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN;Nicole R. Rabner/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�ARMS Email System
You are invited to participate in a meeting Bruce Reed is holding today -a discussion of Presidential action on FMLA and Unemployment Insurance.
This meeting will be held in the Roosevelt Room at 3:00 p.m.
There will
also be representation from the Departments of Labor and Treasury.
Page 2 of2
�. ARMs Email System
Page 1 of8
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-MAY-1999 22:27:43.00
SUBJECT:
URGENT -- DRAFT MEMO TO POTUS
TO: Carl Haacke ( CN=Carl Haacke/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Brian V. Kennedy ( CN=Brian V. Kennedy/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Caroline R. Fredrickson ( CN=Caroline R. Fredrickson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Bruce N. Reed
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD ] )
CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD ] )
TEXT:
Per this afternoon's meeting, attached below please find a draft decision
memorandum to the President on UI/Paid Leave.
Please provide written
comments to me no later than 10 am Frid~y.
Also, please consider this
draft a "close hold." Thank you very much.
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT:'[ATTACH.D33]ARMS23297235A.136 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
DOCFIIEOAIBllAEI000000000000000000000000000000003E00030OFEFF090006000000000000
0000000000010000001100000000000000001000001200000001000000FEFFFFFFOOOOOOOOI000
OOOOFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
)
�DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
DRAFT
May 21,1999
DECISION MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT
Automated Records Management SysterTl
Hex-Dump Conversion
FROM:
BRUCE REED
SUBJECT:
POLICY ANNOUNCEMENTS FOR GRAMBLING SPEECH
Your Grambling State University commencement address this Sunday focuses on the'
need to empower parents in this new economy with greater tools to balance their responsibilities
to their jobs and their families. You will release a new study by the Council of Economic
Advisors that analyzes the "time crunch" that parents increasingly feel. In addition, you will
announce a new policy that addresses this challenge for federal workers. You will direct the
Office of Personnel Management to revise its regulations to allow federal workers to use up to 12
weeks of accrued sick leave to care for a spouse, child, or parent with a "serious health
condition," as defined under the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA). Currently, federal
workers are allowed to use only 13 days of sick leave to care for an ill relative. This new policy
will enable federal workers to use the sick leave they have earned on the job to take care of a
loved one with a serious health condition.
The DPC has also led a policy process to examine non-legislative options for action to
enable States on a voluntary basis to use their Unemployment Insurance systems to provide
benefits to workers on some fonn ofFMLA-covered leave. This year, four States with surpluses
in their UI trust funds - Massachusetts, Vermont, Maryland, and Washington - had bills
introduced in their State legislatures that would do this. Three of the four States, anticipating
confonnity problems, have asked for comment from the Department of Labor (DOL). While
many question the prospects of State legislative efforts, DOL has been pressured from Senators
Kennedy, Dodd, Leahy, and Murray, the AFL-CIO, and women's groups to allow States this
flexibility; business groups have predictably weighed in strongly against opening up UI for this
purpose.
Taking a non-legislative step to advance paid leave for American workers would be a
bold way to enable workers to spend more time with their families in important times. The 1996
FMLA Study, A Workable Balance, found that lost wages are a significant barrier to taking leave,
particularly for lower income workers. Even ifno State elected to use its UI system in this way
(as many argue is very likely), advancing a proposal that would allow State experimentation
would send a strong message that making leave affordable for workers is a new priority and that
States should consider creative ways to provide paid leave benefits.
However, the challenges and risks to embracing an expansive change to the UI system are
considerable. First, the expense of such a system, if ever fully implemented in all States, would
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
be significant (estimates begin at $2 billion annually). Second, the breadth of purposes covered
by the FMLA raises concerns. The majority of FMLA-covered leave is taken by workers caring
for their own serious health conditions, and advancing a policy of providing UI benefits for this
category ofleave might transfonn the VI system into a paid sick leave program and lead to
significant and regressive substitution effects (employers may abandon their sick leave benefit
programs). Third, while today most UI tax collection is "experience rated" (meaning that
employers pay into the system based on their workers' use of it), the cost of this new policy
should be borne as broadly as possible to guard against unintended labor force repercussions on
women of child-bearing age.
Your advisors have considered various ways of advancing the policy of paid leave while
also mitigating the potential for unintended negative consequences. Ideally, we would issue a
regulation that confines the allowance of new VI benefits to parents following birth or adoption
(and, perhaps, other analogous, limited categories) and ensures that these new benefits are not
"experience rated." The DOL Solicitor's office advises that, while issuing regulations will
enable us to set important parameters for State programs, we may not have the authority to limit
them in these ways (the question is under review). Even if we do not have this authority,
however, we believe that we can accomplish much the same goal with a broader regulation
encompassing all FMLA applications if (a) you focus on new parents in a directive to DOL
initiating the regulatory process, and (b) DOL accompanies the regulation with model State
legislation that guides States in program design, confining this program to new parents and
ensuring that the new benefit is not "experience rated."
This construct does not mitigate all danger of unintended consequences. We cannot
ensure, for instance, that States would follow the model legislation we would propose and elect
only to grant VI benefits to new parents, rather than the full category of FMLA covered leave.
However, we would send clear signals about what the Administration believes is an appropriate
new use ofUI benefits and use the model State legislation to guide States in the right direction.
Furthennore, you would only be on record as supporting this narrow new use of VI trust funds.
This option allows us the benefit of moving forward the important debate of making leave
affordable for new parents, while also mitigating many potential downsides. All of the offices
involved in this process - the NEC, OMB, DOL, CEA, and the First Lady's Office - agree that
this is an exciting and responsible approach to addressing this issue.
PROCEED
HOLD OFF AT THIS TIME
LET'S DISCUSS
�(. ("....ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 3
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN:Sean P. Maloney/OU:WHO/O:EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-MAY-1999 12:26:55.00
SUBJECT:
Daily Report
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN:Sylvia M. Mathews/OU:OMB/O:EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN:Michael Waldman/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN:Karen Tramontano/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN:Todd Stern/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN:Gene B. Sperling/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN:Charles F. Ruff/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN:Bob J. Nash/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN:Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neal Lane ( CN:Neal Lane/OU:OSTP/O:EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN:Robert B. Johnson/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: George T. Frampton ( CN:George T. Frampton/OU:CEQ/O:EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN:Sidney Blumenthal/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY ,[ UNKNOWN 1.)
TO: Steve Ricchetti
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
( CN:Steve Ricchetti/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN:Elena Kagan/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN:Janet L. Yellen/OU:CEA/O:EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Loretta M. Ucelli ( CN:Loretta M. Ucelli/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN:Stephanie S. Streett/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�" .. ..ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Cahill ( CN=Mary E. Cahill/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Glyn T. Davies ( CN=Glyn T. Davies/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: David R. Goodfriend ( CN=David R. Goodfriend/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Rebecca L. Walldorff ( CN=Rebecca L. Walldorff/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�•
~_ARjy1S
Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Edward A. Rice ( CN=Edward A. Rice/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Carolyn T. Wu ( CN=Carolyn T. Wu/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nina L. Hachigian ( CN=Nina L. Hachigian/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We'll be putting together the Podesta Daily Report today for the
President. We'd like to keep it short and simple; so, it'd be nice to
have a high threshold for submitting bullet points.
If there's something
you think he needs to know today, please send it electronically (in
WordPerfect) to me (w/ a cc: to Barbara Barclay) before 4 p.m.
Thanks.
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 31
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-MAY-1999 12:27:07.00
SUBJECT:
FINAL HOUSE PAPER --PLS DISTRIBUTE ASAP ASAP
TO: Kelley L. O'Dell ( CN=Kelley L. O'Dell/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason H. Schechter ( CN=Jason H. Schechter/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann C. Hertelendy ( CN=Ann C. Hertelendy/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Clay Reed ( CN=Clay Reed/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert L. Nabors ( CN=Robert L. Nabors/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Linda Ricci ( CN=Linda Ricci/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian A. Barreto ( CN=Brian A. Barreto/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John A. Gribben ( CN=John A. Gribben/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark D. Neschis ( CN=Mark D. Neschis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: 'Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha E. Berry ( CN=Marsha E. Berry/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori A. Wiener ( CN=Lori A. Wiener/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Schnur ( CN=Jonathan H. Schnur/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 0f31
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa J. Levin ( CN=Lisa J. Levin/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Beverly J. Barnes ( CN=Beverly J. Barnes/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas D. Janenda ( CN=Thomas D. Janenda/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Charissa L. Smith ( CN=Charissa L. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard L. Siewert ( CN=Richard L. Siewert/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorothy Robyn
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Dorothy Robyn/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
[ OPD 1 }
TO: Ashley L. Raines ( CN=Ashley L. Raines/OU=OA/O=EOP@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alison Muscatine ( CN=Alison Muscatine/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Julie E. Mason ( CN=Julie E. Mason/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 3 of31
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP ( OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
( OPD 1 )
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP ( OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP ( OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eli P. Joseph ( CN=Eli P. Joseph/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP ( WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel D. Heath ( CN=Daniel D. Heath/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP ( OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP ( OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Betty W. Currie ( CN=Betty W. Currie/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP ( WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP ( WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP ( WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP ( WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard B. Bavier ( CN=Richard B. Bavier/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP ( OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP ( WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Miridy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP ( WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP ( OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP ( WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP ( OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Adrienne C. Erbach ( CN=Adrienne C. Erbach/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP ( OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Richard P. Emery Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Richard P. Emery Jr./OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP ( OMB 1
TO: Deborah Akel ( CN=Deborah Akel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP ( WHO 1 )
�Page 4 of31
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William A. Halter ( CN=William A. Halter/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrei H. Cherny ( CN=Andrei H. Cherny/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neera Tanden ( CN=Neera Tanden/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leanne A. Shimabukuro ( CN=Leanne A. Shimabukuro/OU=OPO/O=EOP@EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia M. Terzano ( CN=Virginia M. Terzano/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William H. White Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=william H. White Jr./OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPO/O=EOP@EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara o. Woolley ( CN=Barbara o. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mariah.Hatta@do.treas.gov ( Mariah.Hatta@do.treas.gov [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of31
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald L. Silberman ( CN;Ronald L. Silberman/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN;Laura D. Schwartz/OU;WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN;Bruce N. Reed/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: John Podesta ( CN;John Podesta/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN;Bob J. Nash/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN;Janet Murguia/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN;Joseph J. Minarik/OU;OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews
READ: UNKNOWN
CN;Sylvia M. Mathews/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN;Bruce R. Lindsey/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN;Ann F. Lewis/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert ,D. Kyle ( CN;Robert D. Kyle/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Konigsberg ( CN;Charles Konigsberg/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN;Thomas A. Kalil/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN;Christopher C. Jennings/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN;Nancy V. Hernreich/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN;Thomas L. Freedman/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: daley_ william@ustr'. gov@INET@VAXGTWY@VAXGTWY ( daley_ william@ustr . gov@INET@VAXGTW
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney C. Crouch ( CN;Courtney C. Crouch/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: uNKNOWN
TO: Dominique L. Cano ( CN;Dominique L. Cano/OU;WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carol L. Capece ( CN;Carol L. Capece/OU;CEA/O;EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 6 of31
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
In this order:
Priorities
Education and Training
Environment and Oublic Health
Law Enforcement
Urban America
Assumptions
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D92]ARMS2728877SN.136 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
DOCF11EOA1B11AE1000000000000000000000000000000003E00030OFEFF090006000000000000
0000000000010000002D00000000000000001000002F00000001000000FEFFFFFF000000002COO
OOOOFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF
FFFFFFFFFFECASC1007100090400000012BF000000000000100000000000040000331200000EOO
626A626A742B742B00000000000000000000000000000000000009041600292200001641010016
410100330EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOFFFFOFOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOFFFFOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOFFFFOFOOOOOOOO000000000000000000000000
00SD00000000007602000000000000760200007602000000000000760200000000000076020000
000000007602000000000000760200001400000000000000000000008A020000000000008A0200
00000000008A020000000000008A020000000000008A0200000COO0000960200002C0000008A02
000000000000660FOOOOB6000000CE02000000000000CE02000000000000CE02000000000000CE
02000000000000CE02000000000000AD03000000000000AD03000000000000AD03000000000000
2BOF0000020000002DOF0000000000002DOF0000000000002DOFOO00000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOO
002DOF0000000000002DOF0000240000001C100000F40100001012000066000000S10F00001500
0000000000000000000000000000000000007602000000000000ADO30000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000A903000004000000AD03000000000000AD03000000000000AD030000
00000000S10FOOOOOOOOOOOOES0300000000000076020000000000007602000000000000CE0200
00000000000000000000000000CE020000DBOOOOOOCE02000000000000ES03000000000000ES03
000000000000ES03000000000000AD030000160000007602000000000000CE0200000000000076
02000000000000CE020000000000002BOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000000000000000
8A020000000000008A020000000000007602000000000000760200000000000076020000000000
007602000000000000AD030000000000002BOFOOOOOOOOOOOOES03000090040000ES0300000000
00007S080000A60100009COD00006B010000760200000000000076020000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000002BOFOOOOOOOOOOOOCE02000000000000C20200000C00000010S0B9
A621A9BE018A020000000000008A02000000000000C303000022000000070F0000240000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000·00
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
�'WI<..U
l'feCOrds Ma
HOUSE BUDGET ALLOCATIONS
Hex-Dum{)Co~;f~'!1 tSystem
DRAMATICALLY CUT KEY PRIORITIES
10,
May 28, 1999
The House Appropriations Committee has issued its 302(b) allocations - the annual allocations to the 13
subcommittees. After factoring in commitments made in the House budget for defense, NIH, Census, mass transit,
and highway construction, and freezing key priorities of special education and VA medical care at 1999 levels - the
remaining programs would have to be slashed. If we assume across-the-board cuts in remaining programs, the
allocations under the House budget could mean cuts from FY 1999 levels, such as the following:
Education and Training
•
The Reading Excellence program which helps children learn to read by the 3rd grade could be cut $47
million, from the $260 million FY 1999 enacted level, and could serve 93,000 fewer students.
•
The 21 st Century Community Leaming Centers could be cut by $36 million from the $200 million FY 1999
enacted level, denying after school and summer school programs to more than 85,000 students.
•
Over 100,000 summer jobs and training opportunities could be eliminated for low-income young people.
•
Between 50,000-85,000 low income children could lose access to Head Start compared to FY 1999 level, a
reduction of almost 100,000 low income children from the level proposed for FY 2000, making it impossible
to reach the goal of serving one million children by 2002.
Environment and Health
•
Cuts to Health Resources and Services Administration's health services for women and children, uninsured
people and people with AIDS could mean as many as 5.3 million fewer people receiving needed health care
services from FY 1999 enacted level and a cut of 6.2 million people served from the FY 2000 request.
•
Funding could be eliminated for the clean-up of 15 Superfund toxic waste sites below the FY 1999 level -needlessly jeopardizing public health for citizens living near affected sites and making it more difficult to
meet the 900-site cleanup goal in 2002.
Crime, Housing, and Other Priorities
•
Rental assistance under the Home Block Grant Program could be cut by $144 million and deny tenant-based
assistance to over 2, I 00 families compared to FY 1999. Further, funds could be lost for new construction,
rehabilitation, or acquisition of about 15,000 affordable housing units.
•
The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) could be cut over $300 million from the FY 1999 enacted
(outside the Violent Crime Reduction Trust Fund) level of$2.8 billion, a reduction of over 2,700 FBI agents
below the FY 1999 enacted level. The FY 2000 request level could be cut by over $600 million and over
5,000 agents.
•
The Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) would be cut $144 million from the FY 1999 enacted
level (outside the Violent Crime Reduction Trust Fund) of $1.2 billion for border enforcement. This cut
could result in a reduction of approximately 1,300 Border Patrol agents. From the FY 2000 request, this
would be a cut of$378 million and 3,500 agents.
•
The National Park Service operating budget could be cut by $240 million below FY 1999. Most seasonal
workers could not be hired, resulting in widespread cutbacks in visitor services, seasonal programs, and
hours of operations at 378 park units serving almost 300 million visitors annually.
If we assume they are not going to be able to keep their priorities, the effect of across-the-board cuts could reduce the
NllI budget by $1.9 billion. And the 7 percent across-the-board cut to the Veterans AffairslHUD appropriations bill
could seriously hinder the delivery of vital medical care to hundreds of thousands of our Nation's veterans.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
House 302(b) Allocations
Shortchange Education and Training
May 28, 1999
. Overall the House 302(b) allocation to the LaborlHHS Subcommittee would require a 18 percent cut from
FY 1999 and 21 percent reduction from the President's request in 2000 for many discretionary programs.
Assuming across the board cuts to LaborlHSS subcommittee, this would have a devastating impact on critical
education, training, and other programs for children:
•
21 st Century Community Learning Centers, funded at $200 million in FY 1999, could be cut by $36 million,
denying after school and summer school programs to more than 85,000 students.
•
The Reading Excellence program which helps children learn to read by the 3rd grade could be cut $47 million,
from the $260 million FY 1999 enacted level, and could serve 93,000 fewer students.
•
Head Start funding could be $840 million less than FY 1999 levels. A reduction of this magnitude could cut
services by between 50,000 and 85,000 low income children below the FY 1999 level, a reduction of almost
100,000 low income children from the level proposed for FY 2000, making it practically impossible to reach
the goal of serving one million children in Head Start by 2002.
•
Work Study could be cut by $157 million from the FY 1999 level of $870 million, to the lowest level since
FY 1996. The number of students served would decrease by approximately 172,000 below the FY 1999 level
and the funding would not support the President's goal of serving 1 million work study students by 2000.
•
GEAR-UP could be reduced by $22 million, from $120 million in FY 1999 denying 21,000 young people
services to help them prepare for and succeed in college.
•
Safe and Drug Free Schools and Communities funding could be reduced by nearly $102 million from the
$566 million FY 1999 enacted level, reducing funds for drug and violence prevention that benefits children in
97 percent of the nation's schools. It could also eliminate funding for emergency resources and assistance,
including crisis counseling and increased security, in schools experiencing violent events, such as the recent
tragic shootings in Littleton, Colorado and Conyers, Georgia.
•
Title I, Education for the Disadvantaged could be slashed by nearly $1.4 billion, from $7.7 billion in FY
1999, cutting up to 2.2 million disadvantaged youth from services to help them reach high standards.
•
Dislocated Worker Assistance could be cut by $253 million below the FY 1999 enacted level, denying
training, job search assistance, and support services to about 133,200 dislocated workers.
•
Over 100,000 training and summer job opportunities for low-income youth could be eliminated.
•
This reduction could terminate Jobs Corps' planned 4-center expansion and/or force Job Corps to close 11-12
other centers compared to FY 1999. This could eliminate about 8,000 residential training slots for extremely
disadvantaged youth in FY 2000. In addition, this would reduce program effectiveness by postponing
necessary repairs, terminating the relocation of dilapidated centers, and modernizing the vocational training
programs.
•
The Child Care and Development Block Grant (CCDBG) would be reduced by $140 million from FY 1999
enacted level and could provide child care assistance to almost 50,000 fewer children.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
House 302(b) Allocations
Sacrificing Our Environment and Public Health
May 28, 1999
The House 302(b) allocation slashes funding by 12 percent for priority domestic programs from their
1999level. Assuming across-the-board cuts in affected subcommittees, V AlHUD, LaborlHHS,
Agriculture, Interior, and Energy and Water, this could have devastating impacts on public health and the
environment in such programs as toxic waste clean-up, water and public health programs, global warming
prevention, and national parks:
•
Stopping 15 Toxic Waste Cleanups -EPA's Superfund program could be cut by $135 million from
FY 1999 enacted levels. This could eliminate funding for 15 new federally-led cleanups due to begin
during FY 2000, needlessly jeopardizing public health for citizens living near affected sites and
making it more difficult to meet the 900-site cleanup goal in 2002.
•
Shutting Down National Parks - Cuts to the National Park Service could reduce services and hours
of operation at 378 parks and other facilities serving almost 300 million visitors a year. The $240
million below FY 1999 enacted level could shut smaller parks and back-country areas in larger parks,
and jeopardize visitor safety by preventing vital maintenance and repairs.
•
Squandering Our Lands Legacy - By failing to support the President's Lands Legacy initiative, the
House allocation could cripple Federal efforts to preserve natural treasures, and deny states and
communities $588 million to protect fannland, coastland, urban parks and other green spaces.
•
Slashing Water and Public Health Protections - The reduction to EPA operations from the FY
1999 enacted level could severely hamper implementation of the Clean Water Action Plan, which
helps communities clean up the 40 percent of surveyed waters still too polluted for fishing or
swimming; and could let polluters off the hook by severely limiting EPA's ability to enforce public
health protections.
•
Gambling with Global Warming - Cuts to the Department of Energy and EPA could gut efforts
toward cleaner, more efficient energy for homes, transportation, and industry; and keep the
Partnership for a New Generation of Vehicles from meeting its goal of new cars three times more
fuel-efficient than today's models by 2004.
•
Crippling Wildlife Protections - Cuts to the Fish and Wildlife Service, National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration, and Army Corps of Engineers could hamper salmon restoration in the
Pacific Northwest, shut down some wildlife refuges, and reduce efforts to restore endangered species.
•
Raising the Risk of Deadly Wildfires - Cuts to the Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management
(19 percent below FY 1999) could close some lands to the public and reduce firefighting capabilities.
A total decrease of about $160 million below FY 1999 in the wildland firefighting requests for
Agriculture and Interior in FY 2000 could severely hamper their capabilities to suppress wild fires,
jeopardizing lives and property throughout the West.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
House 302(b) Allocations
Shortchange Law Enforcement
May 28, 1999
The House 302(b) allocation for Commerce, Justice, State Subcommittee could require a 12 percent
cut from the FY 1999 enacted level to many discretionary programs, assuming minimum essential
funding for the 2000 Decenial Census. This could have a devastating impact on critical law enforcement
programs such as the Drug Enforcement Agency, INS, FBI, prisons, and drug control programs:
•
The Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) could be cut $100 million from the FY 1999 enacted
(outside the Violent Crime Reduction Trust Fund) level of$835 million. This cut could result in a
reduction of approximately 780 agents.
•
The Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) could be cut $144 million from the FY 1999
enacted level for border enforcement of $1.2 billion (outside the Violent Crime Reduction Trust
Fund). This cut could result in a reduction of approximately 6,400 detention beds necessary to
incarcerate criminal aliens and illegal border crossers, or over 1,300 Border Patrol agents.
•
The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) could be over $300 million from the FY 1999 enacted
level of$2.8 billion (outside the Violent Crime Reduction Trust Fund). This cut could result in a
reduction of approximately 2,700 agents below the FY 1999 enacted level.
•
The Federal Prisoner Detention program run by the U.S. Marshals Service could be cut by $51
million from the FY 1999 enacted level of $425 million. This cut could result in a reduction of
approximately 2,450 criminal detention beds.
•
Drug Control Programs. The State Department's drug control programs could be cut by $29 million
compared with FY 1999 enacted levels. This could underfund the State Department programs recently
authorized in the Western Hemisphere Drug Elimination Act and could necessitate grounding
operating aircraft and stop the deployment of assets newly acquired with 1999 drug supplemental
funds. As a result, efforts to diminish illicit crop cultivation in Peru, Columbia, and Bolivia could
suffer.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
House 302(b) Allocations
Shortchange Urban America
May 28, 1999
The House 302(b) allocations reflect a 9 percent cut in funding from the FY 1999 enacted level to
discretionary programs and would have a devastating impact on programs critical to our urban areas.
Assuming across the board cuts to VA1HUD appropriations subcommittee, key programs such as rental
assistance, housing vouchers, and community development efforts would be cut.
•
From the FY 1999 enacted level of$1.6 billion, $144 million could be cut denying tenant-based
rental assistance to over 2,100 families. Further, funds could be lost for new construction,
rehabilitation, or acquisition of about 15,000 affordable housing units.
•
It could eliminate 50,000 welfare to work housing vouchers enacted in the FY 1999 budget. The
cuts could wipe out the Administration's proposal of adding 100,000 new housing vouchers,
including 25,000 to help move families from welfare to work, 18,000 for the homeless, and 15,000
for extremely low-income elderly.
•
The Community Development Financial Institutions Fund (CDFI) could be reduced by nearly
$9 million from the FY 1999 enacted level of$95 million. This could result in 12 fewer
community development institutions (CDFIs) receiving capital funding and 9 fewer financial
institutions receiving Bank Enterprise Act grants compared with the FY 1999 enacted level.
•
Community Development Block Grant Program (CDBG) could be cut by 9 percent or $428
million from the FY 1999 enacted level and could translate into a loss of assistance to over 35,000
homes and loss of support for over 54,000 jobs in low-income areas. The CDBG Program is one
of the most popular and flexible sources of funds that mayors and governors use to improve
economic opportunity and housing in low-income communities. Thousands oflocal neighborhood
improvement efforts could be jeopardized.
•
A cut of9 percent in HUD's discretionary housing subsidy puts low-income tenants at risk of
losing their housing subsidies and virtually eliminates the Administration's efforts to assist more
needy families and the elderly. In addition, the Administration's successful effort to reform public
housing by tearing down boarded-up units and replacing them with proper housing could be
jeopardized.
•
A cut of9 percent to HUD's Brownfields funding could severely slow the efforts in cities to
revitalize vacant, abandoned, or underutilized commercial and industrial sites. In tum, this could
hamper efforts to create more jobs and revitalize urban areas.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
302(b) ALLOCATION ASSUMPTIONS
•
Total Defense spending for all subcommittees will be what the House and Senate
Appropriations Committees indicated in their 302(b) allocations.
•
Highways, transit, and crime (Violent Crime Reduction Trust Fund) will all be funded at the
level of the caps. The appropriators have no discretion to change these amounts, which
appear in separate sub-caps. (The highway and transit funding is above 1999, crime is
below.)
•
Census will be funded at the minimum amount needed to conduct the census.
•
VA medical care will be frozen at the FY 99 level. (See, e.g., statements of Rep. Chambliss
in the Congressional Record of April 14, 1999, at page H1990, Rep. Stump at page H1995,
and Rep. Hill at page H1988.)
•
NIH will be increased by $2 billion. (See, Subcommittee Chairmen Porter and Specter's
cosponsorship of the "Biomedical Revitalization Resolution of 1999," H. Res. 89 and S.Res.
19 respectively, which call for a $2 billion increase.)
•
Special education will be frozen at 1999 levels.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 19
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Oscar Gonzalez ( CN=Oscar Gonzalez/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 14-JUN-1999 16:25:32.00
SUBJECT:
LRM OGG21 - - LABOR Testimony on OSHA's Draft Safety and Health Program Ru
TO: Janet R. Forsgren
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Brian S. Mason ( CN=Brian S. Mason/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. Timberlake/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart Shapiro ( CN=Stuart Shapiro/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen Wartell ( CN=Sarah Rosen Wartell/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven D. Aitken ( CN=Steven D. Aitken/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward A. Brigham ( CN=Edward A. Brigham/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: jwedekind ( jwedekind @ nlrb.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: cIa ( cIa @ sba.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@
inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: lrm@os.dhhs.gov ( lrm@os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 19
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: justice.lrm (justice.lrm@ usdoj.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@ inet
[UNKNOWN 1
(OA)
TEXT:
Following is LRM ID: OGG21.
Please read and respond to it by 3:00 p.m.,
Tomorrow, Tuesday, June 15, 1999.
NOTE TO EOP STAFF: You will not receive a hard copy of this document.
---------------------- Forwarded by Oscar Gonzalez/OMB/EOP on 06/14/99
04:18 PM --------------------------LRM ID: OGG21
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Monday, June 14, 1999
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution
TO:
below
FROM:
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for
Legislative Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Oscar Gonzalez
PHONE: (202) 395-7754 FAX: (202) 395-6148
SUBJECT:
LABOR Testimony on OSHA's Draft Safety and Health Program
Rule
DEADLINE:
3:00 Tuesday, June 15, 1999
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: Attached is prepared testimony to be presented before the House
Committee on Small Business by Charles Jeffress, the Assistant Secretary
of Labor for Occupational Safety and Health, on Thursday, June 17 at 10:30
am.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - Jon P. Jennings - (202) 514-2141
SO-National Labor Relations Board - John E. Higgins Jr. - (202) 273-2910
52-HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
107-Small Business Administration - Jane P. Merkin - (202) 205-6700
EOP:
Larry R. Matlack
Melissa N. Benton
Daniel J. Chenok
Stuart Shapiro
Edward A. Brigham
Courtney B. Timberlake
Cordelia W. Reimers
Karen Tramontano
�Page 3 of 19
ARMS Email System
Steven D. Aitken
Elena Kagan
Sarah Rosen Wartell
Brian S. Mason
Broderick Johnson
Janet R. Forsgren
LRM ID: OGG21
SUBJECT:
Health Program Rule
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
LABOR
Testimony on OSHA's Draft Safety and
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst'S line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Oscar Gonzalez Phone:
395-7754
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant):
395-7362
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
_______ No Objection
_______ No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
_ _ _ Other:
FAX RETURN of ___ pages, attached to this response sheet
- shptest4.wpd==================== ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
1 ====================
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D14]ARMS26365527X.136 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
�Automated Records Man
Hex-Dump Con:~~%;nt System
draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
STATEMENT OF CHARLES N. JEFFRESS
ASSIST ANT SECRETARY OF LABOR
FOR OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH
before the
HOUSE COMMITTEE ON SMALL BUSINESS
June 17, 1999
Mr. Chainnan, Members ofthe Committee, thank you for inviting me to testify about
OSHA's effort to promulgate a rule on safety and health programs. Safety and health programs
are systematic, common sense approaches to managing workplace safety and health to provide
effective protection for workers: They are widely recognized as fruitful ways to reduce the
number of job-related injuries and illnesses and the number of job-related fatalities. And in the
words of Occidental Chemical's Vice President for Health, Safety and Responsible Care,
Stephen Kemp, safety and health programs "not only help you improve safety, but [also help] in
many other areas of your business. We finnly believe that good safety perfonnance leads to
higher productivity, better product quality and overall improved perfonnance as a company."
However, even with OSHA's growing emphasis on safety and health programs, widespread
action at the State level, and strong insurance company encouragement, many employers either
are not aware of the benefits of such programs or have not elected to establish their own
programs voluntarily.
OSHA's interest in workplace safety and health programs has grown steadily since the
early 1980's, when the Agency first developed its Voluntary Protection Program (VPP) to
recognize companies in the private sector with outstanding records in the area of worker safety
and health. It became apparent that these worksites, which had achieved injury and illness rates
1
�Automated Records Management System
Hex.Dump Conversion
draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
markedly below those of other companies in their industries, were relying on safety and health
programs to produce those results. At VPP worksites, which today routinely achieve injury and
illness rates as much as 60 percent below those of other firms in their industry, safety and health
programs--and thus the protection of the safety and health of the workforce--have become
self-sustaining systems that are fully integrated into the day-to-day operations of the facility. At
these worksites, worker safety and health, instead of being relegated to the sidelines or delegated
to a single individual, is a fundamental part of the company's business, a value as central to
success as producing goods and services or making a fair profit.
The evidence has continued to accumulate as OSHA's stakeholders from industry, labor,
State governments, small businesses, trade associations, insurance companies and safety and
health organizations have all gained experience with safety and health management systems.
OSHA has applied what it learned about safety and health programs from VPP companies and
our ·other stakeholders to smaller businesses, through the addition of the agency's Safety and
Health Achievement Recognition Program (SHARP), which is directed at high hazard businesses
with 250 or fewer employees.
In 1989, OSHA published its voluntary Safety and Health Programs Management
Guidelines to help employers establish and maintain management systems to protect their
workers. OSHA's guidelines and others like them have helped thousands of companies adopt
systematic, ongoing approaches to safety and health, which achieve injury and illness rates
markedly below those of other companies in their industries, reduce their workers' compensation
costs, improve employee morale, and increase worksite productivity. In fact, OSHA has found
2
�..
draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
Automated Records Management SysterT'
Hex-Dump Conversion
that programs implemented by individual employers reduce total job-related injuries and illnesses
by an average of 45 percent and lost worktime injuries and illnesses by an average of 75 percent.
For example, Mereen-Johnson Machine Co. worked with its 95 employees in Minneapolis,
Minnesota to implement a program and achieve a lost workday injury rate 60 percent below the
industry average. Applied Engineering, Inc., a manufacturer of specialties materials with 74
employees, located in Yankton, SD, reduced its lost workday injury rate from 6.0' in 1993 to 0.0
in 1997, a success the company's president attributes to implementing a safety and health
program.
Today, thirty-two states have some form of safety and health program provision, though
few are as comprehensive as OSHA's draft proposed rule. In four States that mandate
comprehensive programs that have core elements similar to those in OSHA's draft proposal and
that cover businesses of all sizes within the State, injury and illness rates fell by nearly 18% over
the five years after implementation, in comparison with national rates over the same period.
Several States have studied the effectiveness of these programs and found that average workers'
compensation costs were reduced by as much as 20 percent per year, and that these benefits were
even greater several years later when the program had matured. For example, Colorado
evaluated a program that provides premium discounts to firms instituting safety and health
programs. Over 50 percent of the more than 500 participants had fewer than 100 employees.
Colorado's review found that in all of the five years after the program was established, lost.
work-time injury rates declined by at least 10% per year and the costs of workers' compensation
claims declined by at least 20% per year. The State of North Dakota determined that participants
3
�draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
in its program, which provided premium discounts to employers who implemented safety and
health programs, reduced lost work-time injury claims by 42 percent over 4 years, with
significant reductions occurring in each year of the program. The Texas Workers'
Compensation Commission implemented requirements for safety and health programs for firms
identified as "extra-hazardous." The program averaged 325 participants per year, and these
employers reduced injuries and illnesses by an average of61 percent in each year of the
program's existence.
Experience with safety and health programs demonstrates that systematic, common sense
efforts to protect workers have a direct impact on workplace injury and illness rates and on
compliance with existing worker protections. However, more than 6 million reportable injuries
and illnesses continue to occur each year. More than 6000 job-related fatalities are reported to
BLS annually, with tens of thousands more job-related fatalities resulting from chronic
occupational illnesses. The common sense advantages provided by safety and health programs
will reduce these injuries, illnesses, fatalities and associated workers' compensation costs,
bringing a clear new benefit to the many establishments that have yet to establish such programs.
COMMON SENSE SOLUTIONS
It is common sense to apply proven solutions to basic problems. Common sense has not
only led many businesses to implement safety and health programs, but has also encouraged
business associations to adopt their own model programs and recommend them to their members.
The National Federation ofIndependent Business's (NFIB) Ohio chapter has developed a
4
�Automated Records Management Systel11
Hex-Dump Conversion
draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
comprehensive document entitled Workplace Safety Program Guidelines, which explains to
NFIB members how to design and implement an effective safety program.
The guidelines
include the same elements that OSHA has identified as the keys to a successful program:
leadership by top management; responsibility and accountability by managers, supervisors and
employees; training in safety and health; identifying, reporting, investigating and controlling
hazards; and involvement of employees. According to the NFIB guidelines, "Serious accidents
or injuries can be very disruptive to any successful operation and to the lives of people involved.
An important step that an employer can take to effectively prevent these losses is the
development of an organized safety plan or accident prevention program."
The Synthetic Organic Chemical Manufacturers Association (SOCMA) has also
developed SOCMA 's Model Safety and Health Program, a document intended to help member
companies, many of which are small, implement their own safety and health programs. Like the
NFIB guidelines, SOCMA's model program calls for: management commitment and employee
involvement; worksite analysis; hazard prevention and control; and safety and health training.
The manual recommends that a company tailor its safety and health program to the company's
site-specific needs and argues that "SOCMA member companies who incorporate this program
into their operations will receive benefits by:
»
»
»
»
»
»
reducing injuries, illnesses, accidents and property loss;
saving time and resources by not having to develop a program from scratch;
demonstrating management commitment to safety and health;
giving employees an alternative means to address safety and health concerns before
calling OSHA
avoiding a wall-to-wall OSHA inspection;
assisting in conforming with the Responsible Care Employee Health and Safety Code."
5
�draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
Automated Records Management Systerr,
Hex-Dump Conversion
Similar approaches are found in the safety and health programs advanced by other
professional associations, trade associations and employers. The National Fire Protection
Association, the American Society of Safety Engineers, the American Dental Association, the
National Spa & Pool Institute, the BF Goodrich Specialty Chemicals division, the American
Industrial Hygiene Association, and Argonaut Insurance Company have all developed model
safety and health programs. OSHA has borrowed directly from these associations and
employers in fashioning our draft safety and health programs rule. In fact, many companies
have already put such model programs to good use. For example, in 1994 the Ryder Company
instituted a safety and health program modeled after programs advocated by the International
Loss Control Institute, the National Safety Council, and OSHA's own 1989 Safety and Health
Program Guidelines. Between 1994 and 1998, Ryder reduced lost time cases by 50 percent, lost
workdays by 58 percent and its lost workday incidence rate by 42 percent.
Earlier this year, the National Association of Manufacturers, in testimony before the
Senate Subcommittee on Employment, Safety and Training, echoed the sentiments of those who
proclaim the value of safety and health programs. At the hearing, Robert Cornell from Mon
Valley Petroleum in McKeesport, Pennsylvania, told the subcommittee that, "Today, we have an
effective safety program resulting in fewer injuries and reduced workers' compensation costs."
Mr. Cornell's company used a comprehensive analysis of its safety and health violations and
employee involvement proactively to address potential hazards. As a result, they reduced lost
workdays from 70 between 1992 and 1994 to zero from 1995 through
199~.
Mr. Cornell did not
testify on behalf of OSHA's proposal. However, he illustrated quite effectively the value of
6
�Automated Records Management SVBter
Hex-Dump Conversion
draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
instilling safety and health in the culture of his workplace.
Although the preceding examples generally involve companies that implemented
programs voluntarily, the results for mandatory programs are equally impressive. Data from the
four States with mandates covering most employers in the State show an 18 percent decline in
injury and illness rates relative to national rates in the 5 year period after they required employers
to adopt safety and health programs. OSHA's enforcement experience, which has emphasized
safety and health programs during inspections at establishments of all sizes and in many different
industries, also points overwhelmingly to the effectiveness of the programmatic approach. The
General Accounting Office, in 1992, concurred with earlier OSHA assessments of the value of
comprehensive safety and health programs. GAO also said consideration should be given to
requiring high risk employers to have safety and health programs "because the potential number
oflives saved or injuries and illnesses averted is high." OSHA believes that every employer, not
just high risk employers, should be covered by such a requirement, but is continuing to examine
this issue.
At its heart, a safety and health program promotes the exercise of reasonable diligence in
the workplace in order to protect workers. When Congress enacted and President Nixon signed
the bipartisan OSH Act in 1970, they imposed on employers a general duty to provide employees
with a workplace free of serious recognized hazards and a specific duty to adhere to rules
promulgated by OSHA. Because State occupational safety and health and workers'
compensation laws provided insufficient incentive to protect workers, the OSH Act, as some
courts have held, required employers to exercise reasonable diligence in complying with these
7
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
duties. Through its draft proposed rule, OSHA seeks to assure that employers exercise
reasonable diligence in protecting their workers.
THE DRAFT PROPOSED RULE
OSHA has worked extensively with stakeholders from industry, labor, safety and health
organizations, State governments, trade associations, insurance companies and small businesses
to develop its draft proposal. The draft rule reflects the experience and suggestions of many of
these participants and would require that safety and health programs include five "core"
elements: management leadership and employee participation; hazard identification and
assessment; hazard prevention and control; training; and evaluation of the program's
effectiveness. The elements are simple and straightforward. Reduced to their basic level, the
. elements require an employer to work credibly with its employees to find workplace hazards and
fix them, and to ensure that workers, supervisors and managers can recognize a hazard when they
see it. The rule creates no new obligations for employers to control hazards that they have not
already been required to control under the General Duty Clause of the OSH Act or existing
OSHA standards .
. The required elements in OSHA's draft mirror those included in the models produced by
the NFIB of Ohio, SOCMA, and many other associations, insurance companies and employers.
As those on the front lines have found, the elements all support each other. All five must be
present to ensure success. They are common sense.
The Agency recognizes that many companies have already embraced the program
8
�draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
approach to managing safety and health in their workplaces. Because the draft proposed rule
only includes those elements that are essential for program effectiveness, and because the rule is
framed in broad and flexible perfonnance language, OSHA believes that existing programs that
are effective will already meet the proposal's requirements. To reassure those employers,
OSHA has incorporated a grandfather clause 'into the draft proposed rule that would allow such
programs to be "grandfathered in."
Program Elements
Management Leadership and Employee Involvement. A safety and health program
will only work if management is fully committed to it and communicates that commitment to the
entire organization. According to Michael Seitel from Norwalt Design, a 38-employee, New
Jersey company that manufactures high-speed assembly machinery for the plastics industry, "One
of the biggest things, I think, in regard to the safety and health program that a company needs is
management commitment ... you're going to save money on your insurance and on workers not
being out due to injury."
Employee involvement means actively engaging front-line employees, who are closest to
workplace operations and have the highest stake in preventing job-related accidents, in
developing, implementing and evaluating the safety and health program. In the words of Bill
Harvey, Senior Vice President of Alliant (fonnerly Wisconsin Power & Light), "you must build a
corporate culture that conditions employees to think of safety as their job, not someone else's
job." According to the NFIB of Ohio's guidelines, "Many times employees who are most
9
�draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
familiar with a job will be excellent sources of solutions to safety problems, just as they are for
production or quality problems." Employee involvement spreads the responsibility for safety
and health and ensures that more eyes seek and identify problems and more perspectives are used
to develop solutions.
When OSHA held stakeholder meetings on the draft proposal in 1996,
there was widespread agreement that employee participation is crucial to an effective safety and
health program.
Hazard Identification and Assessment. Hazard identification and assessment means,
among other things, that the employer reviews workplace safety and health information, inspects
the workplace, identifies hazards, and prioritizes covered hazards for elimination or control.
Front-line employees are empowered to avert injuries and accidents by identifying and bringing
hazards to the attention of their supervisors. In essence, this element calls on employers to look
for hazards, decide how serious they are, and prioritize their control or elimination.
Hazard Prevention and Control. Once hazards covered by OSHA standards and the
general duty clause are identified and assessed, they must be controlled. Put simply, the element
calls for a workplace to obey the law as it already exists--fix identified hazards in accordance
with the relevant OSHA standards or the general duty clause. Hazard prevention and control
provides the solutions to the safety and health problems discovered by the program's hazard
identification and assessment activities. Unless hazards are prevented, controlled or eliminated,
workers who are exposed to them will continue to be killed, hurt, or made ill.
Information and Training. Infonnation and training ensure that both workers and
management have the information, knowledge and skills to recognize identified hazards,
10
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion·
draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
understand what controls are in place to prevent exposure, and understand their roles in
preventing or minimizing exposures. People need to know hazards when they see them, so they
can protect themselves and their co-workers.
Program Evaluation. Program evaluation simply tells an employer to assess how well
its safety and health program works, to ensure that it protects workers. Where the employer
identifies deficiencies, they should be corrected.
ISSUES RAISED BY SMALL BUSINESS
Since OSHA last testified before the Small Business Committee regarding this issue, a
Small Business Advocacy Review Panel has reviewed the draft proposed rule, as required by the
Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act. The Panel, which consisted of personnel
from OSHA, SBA's Office of Advocacy and OMB's Office of Inforrnation and Regulatory
Affairs, submitted its report to me on December 18, 1998. The panel report was based in part on
the advice and recommendations provided by18 small entity representatives (SERs).
The version analyzed by the SBREFA panel was different from the one OSHA described
to you when last we testified before your Committee. At that hearing, members of the
Committee raised a number of questions about the rule. Since that time, OSHA has continued to
respond to suggestions made by members of this Committee, small businesses and other
stakeholders. OSHA incorporated a number of changes into the draft proposed rule the agency
ultimately provided to the SBREF A panel. For example, when OSHA testified before you two
years ago, the draft called for employers to conduct hazard assessments at a frequency
11
�draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
"appropriate to safety and health conditions at the workplace." The draft discussed by the
SBREF A panel provided that such assessments should occur at least every 2 years and when
changes in workplace conditions indicate that a new or increased hazard may be present. The
agency also added the "grandfather clause" discussed earlier in my testimony to the version of the
draft proposal provided to the SBREF A panel. The grandfather clause responded to concerns
raised by the Chairinan and various small businesses that employers who already operate
effective programs should not be required to change them.
OSHA has been clarifying the regulatory text wherever possible. In part because of the
flexibility the rule provides, some small businesses questioned whether it incorporated sufficient
guidance to help them comply without unnecessary difficulty. Several recommendations in the
Panel's report suggested that OSHA further clarify certain portions of the rule and its
accompanying analyses. For example, the Panel suggested that OSHA should clarify in its
preamble how the Safety and Health Program rule interacts with other OSHA rules, with the
existing requirements of the General Duty Clause, and with National Labor Relations Act
(NLRA) requirements. The Panel also recommended that OSHA "solicit comment on the
possibility of providing guidance that contains all cross-references in the rule and explains such
concepts as the General Duty Clause so that small firms can understand these issues without
having to go to other sources."
OSHA is responding to the issues raised by SERs and the Panel as it readies the proposal
for publication in the Federal Register. In some cases, we will provide additional explanations
in the preamble to the proposed rule and in the accompanying analyses. In other cases, we are
12
�draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
clarifying language in the rule that some SERs thought to be too vague. For example, the draft
provided to the SBREF A panel required training to be provided "as often as necessary to ensure
that employees are adequately informed and trained." OSHA is considering a modification that
would require training when the employer "has reason to believe" that employees lack the.
knowledge or understanding they need. With regard to evaluating program effectiveness, the
Panel draft included language requiring an evaluation "as often as necessary to ensure program
effectiveness." We likely will replace this requirement with language calling for a review
"when the employer has reason to believe" that all or part of the program is ineffective. These
changes both clarify that an employer need not guess when a reevaluation or new training should
be conducted, but instead must exercise reasonable care. Issues concerning cost and coverage
also were raised. The issues raised by SERs and the Panel are important and OSHA is
considering them all carefully.
In addition, when the final rule is published in a few years, OSHA will provide a variety
of informational and outreach materials to simplify compliance. Materials will include
checklists, model programs, decision logics and other materials to help employers determine how
to comply and when they have met their obligations under the rule. For example, the agency is
already developing a new "Expert Advisor" to provide computerized guidance to employers who
are attempting to implement or improve safety and health programs. Last year, OSHA released
its Hazard Awareness Advisor, which has received excellent reviews from small businesses and
is referenced on the Home Page of the National Federation of Independent Business. In addition
to this extensive array of informational materials, small businesses will continue to have
13
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
available to them free consultation services through OSHA's 50 state consultation programs.
OSHA will also provide intensive training to its compliance officers to ensure that their
enforcement of the rule is consistent with OSHA's intent to provide maximum flexibility to
employers.
Because OSHA has drafted a performance-based rule rather than a one-size-fits all
requirement, it has not specified every action a business must take to comply. Nor should it.
However, the agency is committed to providing the most instructive materials possible to help
small businesses comply with ease. As Bill Pritchard from MASCO, which has facilities
ranging in size from 5 to 2,700 employees, points out, "The program must be performance
oriented. Give companies the flexibility to allow them to develop the process which will work
for each facility. Don't specify the process, specify the key elements ... let companies decide the
way to implement the elements." Many models similar to the one OSHA is proposing already
exist and should prove invaluable as businesses develop their own programs. Clearly, the
flexibility OSHA has built into its draft proposal is preferable to a one-size-fits-all approach.
A particular area of interest to small businesses where the rule will provide significant
flexibility is documentation. The program for small businesses, for example, need not be
written. And employers with fewer than 10 employees are exempt even from those minimal
requirements. Although some small businesses have expressed skepticism, feeling they will
need to maintain written records regardless of this exemption, that is emphatically not OSHA's
intent. Small businesses will have many ways to demonstrate their compliance. For example,
they can simply describe to a compliance officer the hazards that have been or are being
14
�draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
identified and what has been or is being done to identify, assess and control them. They may
also demonstrate their compliance using receipts, order forms and other documents developed or
obtained in the normal course of business.
Some small business stakeholders have questioned whether the rule should be universally
applicable. OSHA believes there is strong evidence to support such coverage. Many
stakeholders have expressed a similar point of view. For example, John Cheffer of the Travelers
Insurance Company testified in 1995 before the National Advisory Committee on Occupational
Safety and Health that, "We consider any proposed safety and health standard to be the
centerpiece from which all other rules and standards flow, in effect, the ultimate safety and health
guideline document for the nation. If that view is accepted, by its very nature it must be generic,
flexible and universally applicable." Another significant reason for applying the rule to
establishments of all sizes is the risk currently posed to employees working in small businesses ..
Although small businesses with 10 or fewer employees account for only about 15 percent of
employees, 30 percent of all work-related fatalities reported to the BLS in 1997 occurred in these
very same workplaces. By comparison, businesses with 100 or more employees accounted for
approximately 45 percent of employees, but experienced only 20 percent of all work-related
fatalities in 1997. Based on these numbers, the risk of fatalities in businesses with 10 or fewer
employees is 4 to 5 times higher than the risk in businesses with 100 or more employees.
Although most stakeholders opposed exempting small businesses from coverage, they agreed
with OSHA that every effort should be made to ease compliance burdens for small businesses.
The compliance assistance materials that OSHA is now developing will address that need.
15
�•
draft -- June 14, 1999 -- 11:15 am
Automated Records Management Systerrr
Hex-Dump Conversion
CONCLUSION
Safety and health programs already make a significant difference in the lives of many of
our nation's workers and in the financial bottom line of many businesses .. But many businesses
have yet to recognize their value. To fill this gap, OSHA is designing a rule that provides a
general framework for employers to follow but leaves each individual employer free to add
workplace-specific procedures and to adopt management practices that suit the characteristics of
that particular workplace. Safety and health programs are common sense for the workplace:
OSHA is committed to working with employers of all sizes, both during and after development
of its rule, to ensure that the rule provides sufficient flexibility, OSHA's compliance guidance
furnishes suitable information to meet the compliance needs of employers, and that workers are
protected.
16
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[04/29/1999 – 06/14/1999]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 100 - Folder 003
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/16992cee19c717668d339270d99676c1.pdf
c25eaf9ba56ddd92d37b60dd3e22c329
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 100 - FOLDER -002
[04/12/1999-04/26/1999 ]
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 22
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. BentonjOU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:12-APR-1999 14:51:30.00
SUBJECT:
LRM MNB44 - - LABOR Qs and As on S385 Safety Advancement for Employees (SA
TO: Janet R. Forsgren
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Peter Rundlet ( CN=Peter RundletjOU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Caroline R. Fredrickson ( CN=Caroline R. FredricksonjOU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. ReimersjOU=CEAjO=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa B. Fairhall ( CN=Lisa B. FairhalljOU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. ChenokjOU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Iratha H. Waters ( CN=Iratha H. Waters/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. Timberlake/OU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. TurmanjOU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart Shapiro ( CN=Stuart ShapirojOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. BondjOU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
,.
Page 2 of22
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM JUSTICE ( LRM JUSTICE [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM HHS ( LRM HHS [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM National Labor Relations Board ( LRM National Labor Relations Board [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM COMMERCE ( LRM COMMERCE [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM Small Business Administration ( LRM Small Business Administration [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM Office of Personnel Management ( LRM Office of Personnel Management
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1
TEXT:
Note to EOP staff: you will not receive a hard copy of this LRM.
The attachment is II pages long.
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 04/l2/99
02:45 PM --------------------------LRM ID: MNB44
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-000l
Monday, April l2, 1999
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395-6l48
SUBJECT:
LABOR Qs and As on S385 Safety Advancement for Employees
(SAFE) Act of 1999
DEADLINE:
II a.m.
Wednesday, April l4, 1999
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS:
DISTRIBUTION LIST
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of22
AGENCIES:
80-National Labor Relations Board - John E. Higgins Jr. - (202) 273-2910
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
61-JUSTICE - Dennis Burke - (202) 514-2141
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
88-0ffice of Government Ethics - Jane Ley - (202) 208-8022
92-0ffice of Personnel Management - Harry Wolf - (202) 606-1424
52-HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES - Sondra S. wallace - (202) 690-7760
EOP:
Barbara Chow
Iratha Waters
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Daniel J. Chenok
Stuart Shapiro
Lisa B. Fairhall
John E. Thompson
Karen Tramontano
Sarah Rosen
Cordelia W. Reimers
Elena Kagan
Sandra Yamin
Richard J. Turman
Caroline R. Fredrickson
Robert G. Damus
Peter Rundlet
Courtney B. Timberlake
Janet R. Forsgren
LRM ID: MNB44
SUBJECT:
LABOR
Employees (SAFE) Act of 1999
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
Qs and As on S385 Safety Advancement for
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
FROM:
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
�ARMS Email System
,.
Page 4 of22
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
====================
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D73]MAIL41635061D.136 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043720F0000010A0201000000020500000036A500000002000084FC690C3AABB478B677A1
59683E52874AD2B14A38152AOA237926ABE8396B5DE5FBE92C696BC294D2FAED2DC12E25005289
096746C71EDF458A6F11E4BE2AC68F2ECFBCFA4F4F4EC8734AC14CE1D1531BC94D18B78381AF14
3EBD22C75976B7395DA5FC763CFB962FB30090FDA8A505FC73461105626B3EF5FC23D17CD51ECB
D12579BFF402E5DBC2F38B1D21401B027EOD59270C3B6D07BDB21CF059BODC5FF40C49159EAEDD
03B1A7A03057F2D48CFFA36B77303AD6BFDEB4B82BC6272BFE0525BF07COE4BBB20F111492852D
4AA86CFEF3DF921956385E5BCE341CB172C2E5EA6DC6DCBOB32F32833BD867A04A65675FOC8C51
3B7ACDFEOCAB2D204F34ACOOD19E82D3DAED4FOBFAFCD83426B8372B15E2CF09D1E8B03EB40FC9
71CCEA70DE83985223136ED4DBA19C31F1BFE281888B50CDAB304A5D920F5087E7937CC9CAD9C3
35A54206751139D70A6F83F96292A5A68C5636CA119DOC50A730FEB4247CA09D6184B0330962FC
A06FF6A7A5201F7DEDE5D70F19CCED6279F4820EB3DOC8D32EA51898BD4A29B9EF67A8C9B7361B
1356E51E3E1C5E55F69C53AC530B59B1D70F5D4075113688DBA472FA4079F4206BD1C4716E6899
76143ADB6F05FA43FD0322C54CA3FOD66C727E87D9737C4881D7616159817E0069F6DB5A300688
2DCD73627F02003B00000000000000000000000823010000000B0100003A050000005516000000
4E0000004506000009250100000006000000930600000B3004000000280000009906000000550E
0000003EOOOOOOC10600000055010000003COOOOOOFF0600000055060000004E0000003B070000
OB3001000000440000008907000008770100000004000000CD07000008340100000014000000D1
0700000802010000000FOOOOOOE507000009680100000042000000F40700000B30010000006COO
0000360800000B300100000044000000A208000000000000000000000000A20800000B300COOOO
0063000000E60800000066020000000200000049090000006101000000140000004B0900000931
020000006D0000005F0900000B300600000077000000CC0900000B30060000008A000000430AOO
000B3006000000AOOOOOOOCDOAOOOOOB3006000000B40000006DOB00000B3006000000C7000000
210COOOOOB3006000000DBOOOOOOE80COOOOOB3006000000EFOOOO00C30D000009310300000089
000000B20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000000B20EOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000000000B20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB20EOOOOOOOOOO00000000000000B20EOOOOOO
000000000000000000B20E00000942020000001D0000003BOFOOOO000000000000000000003BOF
0000000000000000000000003BOF0000000000000000000000003BOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
003BOF0000000000000000000000003BOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00003BOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000003BOF0000000000000000000000003BOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000000003BOFOOOOOOOOOO
000000000000003BOF0000000000000000000000003BOFOOOOOOOO00000000000000003BOFOOOO
000000000000000000003BOF0000000000000000000000003BOFOO00000000000000000000003B
OF0000000000000000000000003BOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO3BOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00003BOF0000000000000000000000003BOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO0000003BOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00000000003BOFOOOOOOOOOO~00000000000003BOFOOOOOOOOOOOO0000000000003BOF00000943
040000001A000000580F000000984800500020004C0061007300650072004A0065007400200034
00200050006C00750073002000280043006F007000790020003400290000000000000000000000
�The Honorable Michael B. Enzi
Subcommittee on Employment, Safety and Training
Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions
United States Senate
Washington, DC 20510-3202
Dear Senator Enzi:
Thank you for the opportunity to testify before the Subcommittee regarding S.385, the SAFE
Act. OSHA is committed to working collaboratively with labor and industry to seek the most
effective ways to keep America's workplaces safe and healthy.
I enclose OSHA's responses to the questions posed by the Subcommittee members in your
March 24, 1999 letter. I hope that these responses will be helpful in clarifying OSHA's views.
I look forward to continuing our discussion about how best to improve workplace safety and
health.
Sincerely,
Charles N. Jeffress
Assistant Secretary
Enclosure
�Automated Records Management Systerrl
Hex-Dump Conversion
Endosure
Please explain your hearing testimony which strongly suggests that you believe that
government employees (e.g. OSHA compliance officers) have more integrity when it comes to
protecting worker safety and health than private consultants who are bound by the strict codes of
ethics of their profession. Evidence of such a beliefis reDected in the following statements of
your testimony:
1.
<7T}he private sector is driven by the marke~ not a mandate to protect employee safety
and health.
«The consultant would feel pressured to sell penalty exemptions without rigorously
inspecting workplaces in ord,er to create business.
JJ
JJ
My testimony should not be interpreted to mean that I believe .OSHA compliance officers have
more integrity than private consultants. We believe that private consultants, as a whole, provide
a valuable resource to employers and execute their responsibilities in a highly professional
manner. We encourage employers to use private sector consultants to help them improve the
safety and health conditions of their workplaces whenever possible.
The issue here is not one of integrity; it is an issue of neutrality and accountability. The issue is
the avoidance of conflicts of interest.
OSHA inspectors, as Federal employees, are governed by the Standards of Ethical Conduct for
Employees of the Executive Branch. These Standards, among other things, bar Federal
employees from engaging in activities that impair their ability to perform their official duties
impartially or result in conflicting financial relationships. Violations of the standards may result
in civil and criminal sanctions. A Federal employee who accepted money from an employer
whose facility he or she inspected would be guilty of violating the criminal conflict of interest
laws even if the inspection was conducted with the utmost of professionalism.
OSHA has similar concerns about the need to ensure the impartiality of consultants as the
Congress has for Federal employees. These private consultants, who are paid by an employer
and whose work under the legislation would result in penalty exemptions for that employer, may
not remain neutral and objectively perform their duties. The legislation would create an inherent
conflict of interest. For example, they risk alienation of future income if they issue strict
interpretations of compliance.
We encourage the use of professional safety and health consultants. However, even though
professionals may be covered by their professions' ethical codes, the rules applicable to Federal
employees are designed to ensure their neutrality and to hold them accountable if they do not
remain neutral. Weare, therefore, opposed to the use of paid consultants whose services, as
envisioned by your legislation, may result in penalty exemptions because of the consultants'
I
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
inherent conflicts of interest.
2. Your tesdmony states that OSHA can discipline OSHA inspectors who are not perfonning
"to our standards, " yet cannot adequately discipline "unconsciendous consultants" who could
inDict hann on "thousands of working Americans. " (P7) Please explain why a consultant
would not be deterred fi-om such behavior by criminal penaldes under Secdon 17(g) of the OSH
Act for making "any mIse statemen~ representadon, or cerdficadon, " and would not be deterred
by the revocadon of a license by the professional cerdfjing body for such behavior?
OSHA does not believe that the OSH Act's current provisions would effectively combat
fraudulent behavior by private consultants, because resource constraints, combined with high
burdens of proof and classification of the crime involved as a misdemeanor, make it extremely
unlikely that unconscientious consultants will be detected, prosecuted, and convicted.
First of all, the burden of proof is high. Section 17(g) states that a defendant's falsification must
be "knowing," presenting U.S. Attorneys with complex issues of proof regarding state of mind.
As Section 17(g) is a criminal provision, the defendant's state of mind must be proven beyond a
reasonable doubt. Second, even if a defendant is f~)Und guilty, a conviction under Section 17(g)
is only a misdemeanor and, thus, provides an insufficient deterrent. Finally, the percentage of
private consultants engaging in criminal activity would undoubtedly be small. Given the large
number of private consultants that would seek certification under this bill, however (OSHA
estimates the number of private consultants to be in the tens of thousands), it is unrealistic to
In fact,
expect that OSHA would be able to detect a significant proportion of the violations.
very few cases have been prosecuted under Section 17(g), precisely because the threat of criminal
prosecution is too remote to serve as an effective deterrent.
Nor do we believe that the license revocation provision in the bill serves as an adequate deterrent.
OSHA retains a level of authority over its own inspectors because of the employer-employee
relationship. OSHA has implemented regular training and yearly evaluations of its inspectors,
and can terminate an inspector's employment or take other appropriate personnel action when the
inspector's work is subpar. Therefore, OSHA has the means to ensure that its inspectors are
fairly and conscientiously applying its standards. On the other hand, OSHA could not discipline
or dismiss consultants who have demonstrated a lack of ability in applying OSHA standards. As
explained above, OSHA would also be unable to hold private consultants to the ethical standards
addressed by the Standards of Ethical Conduct for Employees of the Executive Branch. Nor is it
reasonable to assume that OSHA could exert sufficient influence over a licensing body to
persuade it to initiate license revocation proceedings.
While undoubtedly only a few consultants might make false statements and certifications, it is far
more likely that consultants seeking to continue a cooperative consultant relationship will temper
their advice in accord with the employer's opinion. S. 385 does not address the impact that this
relationship between the employer and the private consultant will have over the consultant's
independent exercise of judgement.
2
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Many standards promulgated pursuant to the OSH Act require OSHA inspectors to independently
assess an employer's compliance with a standard. Under OSHA's construction standard, for
example, an OSHA inspector is required to detennine, pursuant to 29 C.F.R. §1926.20(b)
(Accident prevention responsibilities), whether an employer has instituted regular and frequent
inspections of a job site and, pursuant to § 1926.21 (b )(2) (Employer responsibilities), whether
employees have been instructed in the recognition and avoidance of unsafe hazards. OSHA
inspectors also assess whether an employer falls within an exception to a requirement. Pursuant
to § 1910. 120(a)(1) (Hazardous waste operations and emergency response), for example, if an
OSHA inspector concludes that there is no reasonable possibility that the employer's operation
will expose employees to safety or health hazards resulting from hazardous waste, the employer
will not be required to implement the provisions of the hazardous waste standard. Obviously, an
OSHA inspector's detennination of such issues involves the exercise of professional judgment
(derived, in part, from institutional compliance knowledge) and potentially has a significant
effect on the employer's operations.
3. Please explain how the following statement in your testimony could be considered accurate
given the following language taken expressly from S.385:
Jeffress Testimony: " [UJnder the language of the legislation, it is entirely possible that
an employer and consultant would agree to an Action Plan in which the employer is not required
to come into full compliance with the OSH Act for many years. "
S.385: "(4) Reinspection.-- At a time agreed to by the employer and the consultant, the
consultant may reinspect the workplace of the employer to verifY that the required elements in
the consultation report have been satisfied. If such requirements have been satisfied, the
employer shall be provided with a certificate of compliance for that workplace by the qualified
consultant. "
The language of the reinspection section ofS.385 allows the employer and consultant to agree to
conduct a reinspection at any time or not at all. This legislation sets no deadline regarding when
reinspection activity must be conducted. Under this provision, it would be possible for an
employer and a consultant to agree to reinspect in two weeks or in two years. Moreover, the
provision contains pennissive, not mandatory, language. The bill states that the consultant may
reinspect, not that he or she must reinspect. OSHA is concerned that, in practice, this
pennissive language would pennit a consultant to detennine that an employer has met the tenns
of the Action Plan without reinspecting the worksite at all.
4. I agree that all employers should be encouraged to have safety and health programs in
place. But as a former small business owner, I am concerned that OSHA's draft safety and
health program rule that requires a program "appropriate" to conditions in the workplace, an
employer to evaluate the effectiveness of the program "as often as necessary," and "where
appropriate, " to initiate corrective action. I am concerned that these requirements are overly
broad, overly vague, and at their core, are totally unachievable.
3
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
My feeling is that OSHA may do what it likes to an employer who intentionally shirks his safety
responsibility. But I have serious concerns when good faith employers- and particularly small
businesses- feel that OSHA is a foe rather than an ally in promoting safety.
What guarantees can you give that enforcement of this rule would not be a kick in the teeth to
good faith employers? What guarantees are there that OSHA's enforcement would remain
flexible and fair?
OSHA has drafted the requirements in the present version of the proposed rule in very broad
language to provide employers with great flexibility to develop and implement safety and health
programs. OSHA, however, also was concerned that the program evaluation provisions in
earlier drafts of the proposed rule did not give employers sufficient notice of its requirements.
In its current draft of the proposed rule, therefore, OSHA sets forth specific parameters for
program evaluation, directing employers to evaluate the program's effectiveness at least once
within twelve months of the rule's compliance deadline, and thereafter (1) whenever the.
employer has reason to believe that all or part of the program is ineffective, (2) whenever there is
a major change in the operations, and (3) at least once every three years. In addition to making
the rule more specific, OSHA plans to provide many forms ofnonmandatory compliance
assistance materials, such as model programs and decision logics, and to work with trade
associations and unions to help employers know what they have to do to comply with the rule.
Under the enforcement policy envisioned by OSHA in the current version of its draft policy
directive, it is difficult to see how good faith employers could be issued serious citations or
penalties for violating the proposed rule. A failure to comply with a requirement of the
proposed Safety and Health Program rule will be treated as an "other than serious violation," and
no penalty will be assessed as long as the employees are not exposed to a pattern of serious
hazards. An employer will be cited for a serious violation of the proposed rule and a penalty
will be assessed, if (1) the violation involves the failure to implement a safety and health program
or a core element of a program, and (2) as a result of that violation, his or her employees are
exposed to a pattern of serious hazards.
Finally, the Agency is also developing a comprehensive training program to assure that
compliance officers understand there are many ways for employers to implement safety and
health programs and that it would be improper to narrowly interpret the proposal's broad
language to transform it through the enforcement process into a specification rule. The Agency
will also publish a statement of its enforcement policy simultaneously with any final regulation to
guide employers and compliance officers alike.
5. I have additional concerns about the draft enforcement policy of this rule, which also
contains ''performance-based'' language similar to the draft rule. OSHA's draft eriforcement
policy states that employers will be cited for a serious violation when employees are exposed to a
''pattern ofserious hazards." Please explain what you mean by the term ''pattern ofserious
hazards, " which is undefined anywhere in the draft rule or enforcement policy. Does it mean
4
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
two violations? Three violations? And what must the violations be? .
Additionally, could you have a "pattern" just by having one substantive violation ofan OSHA
rule or regulation? Could OSHA ''piggyback'' one citation of a substantive OSHA standard
onto another citation for not including that same substantive OSHA standard into the safety and
health program? For example, could an OSHA inspector issue a citation to an employer for a
particular violation of the lockout/tagout rule, and then issue another citation for not including
that same, particular section of the lockout/tagout rule in the safety and health program?
The current draft enforcement policy for this proposed rule follows the "New OSHA" policy of
distinguishing between employers who make a: good faith effort to comply with the rule and
those who do not. Thus,
A failure to comply with a requirement of the safety and health program rule will be
treated as an "other than serious violation" and no penalty will be assessed as long as the
employees are not exposed to a pattern of serious hazards.
However, an employer will be cited for a serious violation and a penalty will be assessed
if:
(i)
( ii )
the violation involves the failure to implement a safety and health program or a
core element of a program, and
as a result of that violation, his or her employees are exposed to a pattern of
serious hazards.
OSHA's current working definition of a "pattern of serious hazards," for purposes of the draft
safety and health program rule, is: I) A number of covered hazards of the same or similar type or
covered hazards resulting from the same or similar deficiencies in the safety and health program;
or 2) a variety of covered hazards resulting from various deficiencies in the program and
representing a general failure to control hazards. Thus, a violation of a particular OSHA
standard or the General Duty Clause does not automatically constitute a violation of the safety
and health program rule. A single violation of an OSHA standard would not constitute a
"pattern" and OSHA would not "piggyback" one citation for violation of a substantive standard
(e.g. the lockoutJtagout rule) onto another citation for not including that same OSHA standard in
the safety and health program.
Questions from Senator Tim Hutchinson:
1. How many charges are brought by OSHA against employers in a typical year?
Please see chart below.
5
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
2. Does OSHA categorize the investigation 0/ these charges by size 0/ employer?
For each inspection, OSHA identifies the number of employees in the establishment being
inspected, the total number of employees covered by the inspection and the total number of
employees who are employed by the employer. This last figure is especially important, because
it affects the amount of penalty reduction given to the employer if citations are proposed. An
employer with between 1 and 25 employees normally receives a 60 percent reduction in the
penalty; an employer with 26 to 100 employees receives a 40 percent reduction; and an
employer with 101 to 250 employees normally receives a 20 percent reduction. (There is no
reduction on account of size for employers with more than 250 employees, but all employers are
eligible for additional reductions of up to 35 percent for good faith and past history.)
3. How many o/these charges are against employers with 100 or less employees?
Please see chart below.
4. How many o/these charges are against employers with 50 or less employees?
Please see chart below.
5. How many o/these charges are against employers with more than 50 but less than 100
employees?
76,980
51,765
18,764
-
Total
Violations
Cited
FY98
22,959
Totals l
Total
Inspections
Conducted
FY98
34,443
Establishment Size By Number of Employees
Controlled Nationwide
42,589
4,195
9,176
all Federal OSHA Inspections Nationwide
Employers With 100 or Fewer Employees Nationwide
Employers With 50 Or Fewer Employees Nationwide
Employers With Between 50 and 100 Employees
Nationwide
ITotals include numbers of inspections conducted and violations cited for all employers, including those employing more than 100 employees.
6
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
6. How many of these charges are contested and then considered by the Occupational Safety
and Health Review Commission?
In 1998,2,061 Federal OSHA inspections resulting in citations were contested. Of the contested
cases, 1,081 involved employers with 100 or fewer employees nationwide, 815 involved
employers with 50 or fewer employees nationwide, and 266 involved employers with between 50
and 100 employees nationwide. Most cases are settled or withdrawn before the Review
Commission issues a final decision. Review Commission judges adjudicated 158 cases,
following a full hearing, during FY 1998.
7. How much in fines did OSHA collect in 1998?
In FY 1998, OSHA collected $54,626,890 in penalties, which were deposited into the U.S.
Treasury.
8.
How much in fines did OSHA assess in 1998?
In FY 1998, OSHA assessed $61,281,264 in penalties.
9. Please state any and all benefits that OSHA realizes when employers within the scope ofits
jurisdiction employ third-party safety consultants.
In the abstract, apart from S. 385, if an employer successfully uses the knowledge gained from
the private consultant, everyone benefits: the company becomes a safer and healthier workplace
and can be more profitable as a result; the employees work in a safer environment; and OSHA
may deploy its resources to other, more hazardous workplaces. It is more difficult to gauge the
benefits OSHA as an agency might gain. Certainly, if an industry sector experiences measurable
improvement in illness and injury rates as a result of widespread use of consultants, OSHA
would eventually be able. to redirect its compliance resources elsewhere.
Under the scheme provided in S.385, however, we believe any benefits to OSHA's worker
protection program would be far outweighed by the regulatory confusion which would be
created and by the significant resource drain which implementing the bill would entail.
10. In your testimony, you stated that you believed that collusion would result from the use of
third-party safety consultants by employers within the scope of OSHA's jurisdiction.
Accordingly, please state: (1) what percentage or likelihood do you suspect this would happen in
the workplace?; and (2) given that percentage and the fact that whatever system we employ to
govern workplace safety cannot possibly be perfect, don't you feel the advantages far outweigh
the disadvantages?
OSHA believes that the number of private consultants engaging in cri)1linal activity would
7
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
undoubtedly be small. OSHA is concerned about the potential for a consultant's independent
judgment to be undermined by his or her consideration of a future financial relationship with the
employer being evaluated. OSHA also is concerned that the legislation would create an
incentive for employers to "forum shop" to find a friendly consultant. Clearly, as indicated in
the response to question 9, private consultants have a legitimate role to play in advancing safety
and health, and many safety conscious employers are using them. However, tying a private
consultation to a penalty exemption goes too far. In short, OSHA believes that the benefits
would not outweigh the disadvantages of allowing private individuals to grant penalty
exemptions.
11. Please describe in detail the efforts, if any, made to recruit individuals who are experts in
the industry in which they will inspect or regulate.
The Department of Labor/OSHA is a competitive agency, which means that our vacancies are
announced under open, competitive merit staffing procedures. Our vacancies are routinely listed
on the Internet under the Office of Personnel Management's (OPM's) website and are listed
under the Department of Labor's website. In addition, OSHA has developed a mailing list
consisting of professional organizations, colleges and universities, and labor organizations/trade
unions, to which many of our key vacancies are referred. We also advertise many of our key
vacancies in professional magazines and publications. OSHA does not recruit individuals in
specific industries. See our responses to questions 12 and 13 for additional information.
12. How many years ofeducation are required to become an OSHA inspector?
OSHA vacancies are primarily comprise compliance officer (inspector) positions. The generic
term "OSHA compliance officer" encompasses several job series, including industrial hygienists,
safety engineers and safety and occupational health specialists. The minimum qualifications for
these series of jobs are:
Industrial Hygienist - Successful completion of a full four-year course of study in an accredited
. college or university creditable towards a bachelor's or higher degree in industrial hygiene, or a
branch of engineering, physical science, or life science. This study must have included, or have
been supplemented by twelve (12) semester hours of course work in chemistry, including organic
chemistry, and eighteen (18) additional semester hours of courses in any combination of the
following fields: chemistry, physics, engineering, health physics, environmental health,
biostatistics, biology, physiology, toxicology, epidemiology, or industrial hygiene.
Safety Engineer - A degree in professional engineering from a school of engineering with at
least one curriculum accredited by the Accreditation Board for Engineering and Technology
(ABET).
Safety and Occupational Health Specialist - Successful completion of a full 4-year course
above high school leading to a bachelor's degree in safety and occupational health fields (safety,
8
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
occupational health, industrial hygiene), or bachelor's or higher degree in other related fields that
included or was supplemented by at least 24 semester hours of study from among the following
disciplines: safety, occupational health, industrial hygiene, occupational medicine, toxicology,
public health, mathematics, physics, chemistry, biological sciences, engineering, and industrial
psychology.
13. Would you agree that experience in, understanding of, and familiarity with a particular
industry allows an inspector to better identifY safety and health risks and potential violations?
OSHA agrees that familiarity with a particular industry allows inspectors to better identify health
and safety risks and potential violations, and many journeyman level OSHA inspectors are
experts in specific areas such as maritime and construction. However, all OSHA inspectors
have the necessary education and/or experience to conduct inspections and perform duties to
enforce Federal safety and health standards, and to provide technical assistance and consultation
to employers and employees to ensure the safety and health of the American worker.
Questions from Senator Chuck Hagel:
1. Nebraska's employers have expressed considerable concern about OSHA's proposal to
require "employee participation" as a core element ofa safety and health program. In particular,
employers are worried tha~ in complying with OSHA's requirement they may be forced to
violate the National Labor Relations Act. What can you tell us that will ease or refute their
concerns?
Employee participation in employer-sponsored health and safety programs is not inherently
unlawful under the NLRA. Many employers, in a variety of industries, have successfully
implemented safety and health programs with employee involvement, which indicates that
worker participation in employer-sponsored workplace safety and health programs can be
structured in ways which comply with the requirements of the NLRA.
In unionized workplaces, labor-management health and safety committees constituted under
collective bargaining agreements are, of course, lawful under the NLRA. Moreover, even in
nonunion workplaces, NLRB decisions make clear that an employer may communicate about
health or safety issues with individual employees, or groups of employees, or with all of its
employees, so long as no employee is put in the position of representing other workers, which
might bring the group within the NLRA definition of a labor organization. Communicating
individually with employees or holding all-employee safety sessions would appear to be a
practical means of compliance for small employers, especially those with 20 or fewer workers,
which constitute 85% of covered employers.
Delegating an employee the responsibility for monitoring a particular hazard or for implementing
certain precautions or safety procedures in the workplace, with no expectation the employee will
9
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
represent other workers, would appear to be an ordinary job assignment and not an unfair labor
practice. It is clear that "brainstorming" groups or information gathering committees, whose job
is to assemble ideas or factual information which will be forwarded to management for
decisionrnaking, do not involve "dealing with" and are similarly lawful under the NLRA.
Periodic safety conferences at which employees discuss and develop suggestions to be submitted
to management or to a union-management safety committee have specifically been upheld by the
NLRB.
2. (A) What specific criteria do you expect employers and OSHA inspectors to use to measure
the "effectiveness" of their safety and health program? (B) the number of injuries? (C) the
number of accidents?
The effectiveness of the program will be determined by each employer's ability to establish and
maintain a safety and health program to systematically achieve compliance with OSHA standards
and the General Duty Clause. The program must be appropriate to conditions in the workplace,
such as the hazards to which employees are exposed and the number of employees there. The
purpose of this rulemaking is to reduce the number of job-related fatalities, injuries and illnesses,
as well as a number of "near misses," by requiring employers to establish a workplace safety and
health program. The success of such a program may be judged in part by the extent of reduction
in the number and seriousness of workplace hazards. The proposed draft was devised broadly
and flexibly to allow employers in diverse situations to comply with its requirements as
appropriate to the hazards, size, and other conditions of their own workplaces. The proposed
draft simply requires employers to implement good consensus management practices on safety
and health. As an integral part of applying the rule, the Agency will provide checklists, model
programs, decision logics, and other materials to help employers determine how to comply and
what constitutes compliance with its requirements.
3. OSHA acknowledges the low incidence rates by small businesses as indicated by the Bureau
ofLabor Statistics. OSHA's explanation for these low numbers rests on one study which found
that under-reporting as a reason for the low numbers. How did the study come to the
conclusion that under-reporting is indeed occurring at small businesses regarding injuries and
illnesses? Furthermore, how is this proposed rule going to prevent the injuries and illnesses of
these unreported cases?
BLS data show that establishments with 10 or fewer employees have less than half the average
illness and injury rate. Small businesses with 11 to 49 employees have 85 percent ofthe average
injury and illness rates, and small business with 50 to 249 employees have a higher injury and
illness rate than the average for all establishments. Thus the phenomenon of very low reported
injury and illness rates is limited to firms with fewer than 10 employees that OSHA does not
inspect unless there is a complaint.
In an effort to understand why smaller firms might have lower injury and illness incidence rates, .
the authors of one study examined whether smaller firms differed from larger firms in workforce
10
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
composition, in working conditions for specific industries and occupations, in labor turnover
rates, and in access to preventive safety training and safety monitoring. The authors were unable
to attribute differences in reported injury and illness rates to differences in any of these factors by
employment size. Therefore, they concluded small employers as a group may routinely
underreport workplace injuries, perhaps because their recordkeeping systems are inadequate:
With the rejection of alternative explanations, there is a strong likelihood of
underreporting as the explanation, and we estimate that the annual [BLS] survey
substantially undercounts injuries in small establishments (Oleinick et aI., "Establishment
Size and Risk of Occupational Injury," Am. J. Ind. Med., 28(1): 2-3 (1995))
NIOSH reached an essentially identical position: "recent literature comparing Annual Survey
data and workers compensation data questions the validity of the estimated rates for small
employers obtained through the BLS Annual Survey" (NIOSH comments on OSHA's Proposed
Recordkeeping Rule, June 28, 1996, Docket ..... , Exh.15-407, p. 2).
The proposed rule seeks to reduce all non-minor illnesses and injuries, whether reported or
unreported, by requiring employers to conduct self inspections of their facilities. Such self
inspection can find hazards that accident investigations alone would not reveal.
4. In estimating the costs ofcreating and maintaining records of the results ofhazard
identification and assessment, OSHA used the average national wage rate of clerical personneL
Is this an accurate reflection for small businesses where almost all the work involved in setting up
a safety and health program will be performed by a manager whose time value is much more
. than that of an average clerical personnel?
The proposed safety and health program rule exempts employers with fewer than ten
employees--approximately 75% of all covered workplaces--from hazard identification,
assessment, and control documentation requirements. Therefore, nearly three quarters of all
workplaces do not have to create and maintain any records pursuant to the proposed rule. Of
those larger workplaces that are not included in the exemption, many have already implemented
similar hazard assessment programs. Furthermore, larger workplaces that do not have programs
in place are likely to have clerical staff available to create and maintain records pursuant to the
proposed rule, and will not have to use managerial hours in order to comply.
11
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Mary E. Jones ( CN=Mary E. Jones/OU=CEA/O=EOP
[ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 19-APR-1999 10:02:07.00
SUBJECT:
TANF & Food Stamp Caseload Update
TO: Jennifer M. Luray ( CN=Jennifer M. Luray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carl Haacke ( CN=Carl Haacke/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ 8MB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan!OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edwin Lau ( CN=Edwin Lau!OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: J. Eric Gould ( CN=J. Eric Gould/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anil Kakani ( CN=Anil Kakani/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard B. Bavier ( CN=Richard B. Bavier/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eugenia Chough ( CN=Eugenia Chough/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Andrew R. Feldman ( CN=Andrew R. Feldman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robert F. Schoeni ( CN=Robert F. Schoeni/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The TANF & Food Stamp Caseload Update, 4th Quarter 1998 Report you
received last week should be treated as a "CLOSE HOLD" document.
If you
have questions or need further assistance, please call Bob Schoeni
(x54597) or Andy Feldman (x53114).
Thank you.
Page 2 of2
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of31
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:21-APR-1999 15:05:19.00
SUBJECT:
LRM MNB51 - - LABOR Report on S192 Fair Minimum wage Act of 1999
TO: Janet R. Forsgren
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
TO: Andrew ·Abrams ( CN=Andrew Abrams/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John A. Koskinen ( CN=John A. Koskinen/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah S. Lee ( CN=Sarah S. Lee/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Caroline R. Fredrickson ( CN=Caroline R. Fredrickson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey L. Farrow ( CN=Jeffrey L. Farrow/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Iratha H. Waters ( CN=Iratha H. Waters/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jasmeet K. Seehra ( CN=Jasmeet K. Seehra/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet E. Irwin ( CN=Janet E. Irwin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart Shapiro ( CN=Stuart Shapiro/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of31
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry WhiteIOU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: ocl ( ocl @ ios.doi.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: cla ( cla @ sba.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@
inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: lrm@os.dhhs.gov ( lrm@os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: justice .lrm ( justice .lrm @ usdoj. gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@ inet [ UNKNOWN 1
(OA)
TEXT:
NOTE: Senator Kennedy intends to offer his minimum wage bill (S. 192) as
an amendment to Y2K liability legislation being considered by the Senate
tomorrow.
Labor therefore requests expedited clearance of its letter.
The deadline is 5 p.m. TODAY.
EOP STAFF: You will not receive a hard copy of this LRM.
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 04/21199
03:03 PM --------------------------LRM ID: MNB51
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Wednesday, April 21, 1999
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution
below
FROM:
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for
Legislative Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395 -7887 FAX: (202) 395 - 6148
SUBJECT:
LABOR Report on S192 Fair Minimum Wage Act of 1999
DEADLINE:
5 p.m. Wednesday, April 21, 1999
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the' above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of31
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: NOTE: Senator Kennedy intends to offer his minimum wage bill (S.
192) as an amendment to Y2K liability legislation being considered by the
Senate tomorrow.
Labor therefore requests expedited clearance of its
letter.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - Jon P. Jennings - (202) 514-2141
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
59-INTERIOR - Jane Lyder - (202) 208-4371
52-HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
EOP:
Barbara Chow
Iratha H. Waters
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Cordelia W. Reimers
Sarah Rosen
Jeffrey L. Farrow
Karen Tramontano
Caroline R. Fredrickson
Elena Kagan
Andrea Kane
Cynthia A. Rice
Jack A. Smalligan
Stuart Shapiro
Sarah S. Lee
Janet E. Irwin
John A. Koskinen
Lisa M. Kountoupes
Andrew Abrams
Jasmeet K. Seehra
Janet R. Forsgren
LRM ID: MNB51
SUBJECT:
of 1999
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
LABOR
Report on S192 Fair Minimum Wage Act
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7887
Office of Management and Budget
Fax:
395-6148
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of31
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant):
395-7362
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
______ No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
______ Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
- Minwage.wpd
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D44]ARMS21997582L.136 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750430F050000010A020100000002050000003A17000000020000842A194621CAD38E8DACDF
6D560644A73618435D8CC94C54450F8CC6BDAFF789B8FAEDAE71D4E8723091EE3F0593F52ECFDD
CF4B0889ECDAD2D9B80C48857326C13993AAD530DA2BIOE4ECDBEOBOD04FA3AF7A2F659746892D
DFFC76AD24F2A81F23EEA99DEB584F70288233BDC2F13F597D83E26B4DC62A099D2D8EB60CA20B
F738B2C286FEFDBDE3BCEB97E23BDIC61C3C49D64E4EC5EC650478817FB7AD094F85B1862D928B
EBE53A29DBFED7BOAOD3COECIDE2F33050D4206C3265CAAOFE669559C2A30F16C2CA4C38578987
6B028929BI030C3824855FB445E3DB7FFD35F969A73BAC7C381DIE1612B2CB12734EB390D9F7BF
D137AEE411DB6FB5C6321AEFCEA823CF6F4879BE86843ECAA25A76032BC6356528EAC588EB792F
OB9C2B3E3F48823634AB2BD2C7A3B6D66D0644710BEFD73CCD683093D3FOAD43E063EDCDEF73F3
CC5DC1COCD44D961C5C61A3800929B7E6E3A84EB33E3B17E7B44136D4AAED457632FD46872A2C5
221C8972DF477801259B6BE97AE28B635D79316513559C51B4C3893260BOF384CB5CDAD633CC11
B84ADOBCFA6E46288D34990C443231AF572CF231EA7C215153850A84305AE63806414F8B50EC28
F71DFBEB45C4661CD76CAED9E8E16B1250D303E32D4AB76D901D48121D35D9625EE6B247BD2346
50E6B8189702000F00000000000000000000000823010000000B010000D2020000005507000000
4EOOOOOODD030000092501000000060000002B0400000B30020000002800000031040000084E01
0000000200000059040000081001000000020000005B040000096D01000000170000005D040000
087701000000040000007404000008340100000014000000780400000802010000000F0000008C
040000080501000000080000009B040000085E010000000COOOOOOA30400000055040000003AOO
0000AF04000008050100000026000000E904000000984800500020004C0061007300650072004A
006500740020003400200050006C00750073000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000485050434C354D5300000000002C01F0002C012C01
2C012C012C01F00030000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
�DRAFT 4/20/99
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Honorable Edward Kennedy
Ranking Member
Committee on Labor and Human Resources
United States Senate
Washington, D.C. 20510
Dear. Senator Kennedy:
I am writing in strong support of your amendment to legislation under consideration in
the Senate that would increase the minimum wage by $1 to $6.15 an hour by
September 1, 2000. Earlier this year, President Clinton strongly endorsed raising the
minimum wage by a dollar an hour over the next two years to "do more to support the
millions of parents who give their all every day at home and at work. The most basic
tool of all is a decent income."
We now have the strongest economy in a generation: inflation and unemployment are
low and steady, and family incomes are on the rise. But millions of people are still
struggling to make ends meet -- the people who clean our offices, sew our clothes,
serve our food, and care for our children and our infirm parents. Your amendment
offers more than 11 million Americans a greater opportunity to share in our nation's
prosperity. Seventy percent of all workers who would benefit are adults, age 20 or
over, and about three out of five are women, many of whom are the sole breadwinners
for their families.
When we last raised the minimum wage and expanded the earned-income tax credit,
we took important steps to reward work and help millions of Americans raise their
families with dignity. Because of our actions, a full-time working parent with two children
does not have to live in poverty. We must ensure that this continues to be the case
even as costs rise, and that we continue to make progress towards ensuring that all
working families are lifted out of poverty. That is why we must increase the minimum
wage.
As Americans move from welfare to work, one of the most important lessons they can
learn is that work pays. A full-time worker earning the current minimum wage for 50
weeks of work receives only $10,300. This is not enough to move families from
dependency to self-sufficiency and create a long-term attachment to the workforce.
The real value of the minimum wage had fallen to nearly a 40-year low by the time
President Clinton signed the last increase in 1996. But even after that increase, the
minimum wage's purchasing power remains below its value in the 1960's and 1970's.
The minimum wage should be the first rung on the ladder of opportunity, not a dead
end for the working poor.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
A one-dollar increase in the minimum wage would make an enormous difference in the
lives of these workers and their families. It would mean an additional $2,000 a year for
someone working year-round, full-time at the minimum wage -- enough to buy a family
of four groceries for 6 months or pay for 7 months rent.
Evidence from the last minimum wage increase clearly shows that we can increase the
minimum wage without hurting the economy. Since President Clinton signed the last
minimum wage increase into law in August 1996, the economy has created more than
seven and a half million new jobs, and the inflation rate has been cut nearly in half. The
unemployment rate is at 4.2 percent and has been below 5 percent for 21 consecutive
months. Unemployment rates this low have not been seen for almost three decades.
For African Americans, Hispanics, and women, unemployment is trending down and
employment rates are trending up. And the news is also good for teenagers --.:
725,000 more teenagers are employed now than in August 1996, and employment is
up by more than 100,000 for African-American teens.
I strongly support your amendment to increase the minimum wage. Our efforts to
overhaul the education and job training system and expand the earned income tax
credit have significantly advanced our common goal of assuring every worker a good
job at a fair wage. Working together, we can make work pay for America's minimum
wage workers.
Sincerely,
Alexis M. Herman
2
�Automated Records Management System
He)(-Dump Conversion
II
106TH CONGRESS
1ST SESSION
S.192
To amend the l<'air Labor Standards Act of 1938 to increase the Federal
minimum wage.
IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
JA,'1UARY 19, 1999
Mr. KENNEDY (for himself, Mr. DASCIILE, Mr. LEAHY, 1vIr. SARBANES, Mr.
MOYNIIL\,,'1, Mr. LEVIN, Mr. DODD, Mr. J,JAUTENBERG, Mr. BINGA~1fu'l,
Mr. KERRY of Massachusetts, Mr. HAHTGN, Ms. MIKULSJa, Mr. AKAKA,
Mr. \VEI,LSTONE, Mrs. FEINSTEIN, Mrs. BOXER, Mrs. MURRAY, Mr.
FEINGOLD, Mr. \VYDEN, Mr. DURBIN, Mr. TOHHTCELLI, Mr. R~;ED, and
Mr. SCHu~mR) introduced the following bill; which was read twice and
referred to the Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions
A BILL
To amend the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 to increase
the .B'ederal minimum wage.
1
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representa-
2 tives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,
3
4
SECTION L SHORT TITLE_
This Act may be cited as the "Fair Minimum Wage
5 Act of 1999".
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
2
1
2
SEC. 2. MINIMUM WAGE INCREASE.
(a) WAGE.-Paragraph (1) of section 6(a) of the Fair
3 Labor Standards Act of 1938 (29 U.S.C. 206(a)(1)) is
4 amended to read as follows:
"(1) except as otherwise provided in this sec-
5
6
tion, not less than-
7
"(A) $5.65 an hour during the year begin-
8
ning on September 1, 1999; and
"(B) $6.15 an hour beginning on Septem-
9
bel' 1,2000;".
10
11
(b) EFFECTIVE DATE.-The amendment made by
12 subsection (a) takes effect on September 1, 1999.
13
SEC. 3. APPLICABILITY OF MINIMUM WAGE TO THE COM-
14
MONWEALTH OF THE NORTHERN MARIANA
15
ISLANDS.
16
The provisions of section 6 of the Fair Labor Stand-
17 ards Act of 1938 (29 U.S.C. 206) shall apply to the Com18 monwealth of the Northern Mariana Islands.
o
.S 192 IS
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 0[20
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton (
CN~Melissa
N.
[ OMB 1 )
Benton/OU~OMB/O~EOP
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-APR-1999 10:46:06.00
SUBJECT:
LRM MNB53 - - LABOR Report on S385 Safety Advancement for Employees (SAFE)
TO: Janet R. Forsgren
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter Rundlet (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Janet
R.
Forsgren/OU~OMB/O~EOP@EOP
CN~Peter Rundlet/OU~WHO/O~EOP@EOP
TO: Caroline R. Fredrickson (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Caroline
R.
[ OMB 1 )
[ WHO 1 )
Fredrickson/OU~WHO/O~EOP@EOP
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN~Sandra Yamin/OU~OMB/O~EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers (
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Cordelia
W.
Reimers/OU~CEA/O~EOP@EOP
[ CEA 1 )
CN~Karen Tramontano/OU~WHO/O=EOP@EOP
[ WHO 1 )
Fairhall/OU~OMB/O~EOP@EOP
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Lisa B. Fairhall ( CN=Lisa B.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack (
READ:UNKNOWN
CN~Larry
TO: Iratha H. Waters (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Iratha
R.
Matlack/OU~OMB/O=EOP@EOP
[ OMB 1 )
H. Waters/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [OMB 1 )
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. Timberlake/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G.
READ: UNKNOWN
Damus/OU=OMB/O~EOP@EOP
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson (,
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart Shapiro (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~John
CN~Stuart
E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
Shapiro/OU=OMB/O~EOP@EOP
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Debra J'. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of20
.'
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry white ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: OPBRE ( CN=OPBRE/OU=ONDCP/O=EOP [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: lrm@os.dhhs.gov ( lrm@os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: cIa ( cIa @ sba.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@
inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: ca. legislation ( ca. legislation @ gsa.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: ola ( ola @ opm.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: justice.lrm ( justice.lrm @ usdoj.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OA)
CC: jwedekind ( jwedekind @ nlrb.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
NOTE: DEADLINE IS 4 p.m. TODAY.
EOP staff: you will not receive a hard copy of this LRM. The attachment
is approximately 9 pages long.
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 04/26/99
09:29 AM --------------------------c
LRM ID: MNB53
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Monday, April 26, 1999
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution
below
FROM:
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for
Legislative Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395-6148
SUBJECT:
LABOR Report on S385 Safety Advancement for Employees
(SAFE) Act of 1999
DEADLINE:
4 p.m. Monday, April 26, 1999
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
�Page 30[20
ARMS Email System
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: The Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions Committtee is
scheduled to consider S. 385 on Wednesday, April 28th.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
80-National Labor Relations Board - John E. Higgins Jr. - (202) 273-2910
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
61-JUSTICE - Dennis Burke - (202) 514-2141
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
8S-0ffice of Government Ethics - Jane Ley - (202) 208-8022
92-0ffice of Personnel Management - Harry Wolf - (202) 606-1424
52-HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
51-General Services Administration - William R. Ratchford - (202) 501-0563
S9-0ffice of National Drug Control Policy - John Carnevale - (202)
395-6736
EOP:
Barbara Chow
Iratha H. Waters
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Daniel J. Chenok
Stuart Shapiro
Lisa B. Fairhall
John E. Thompson
Karen Tramontano
Sarah Rosen
Cordelia W. Reimers
Elena Kagan
Sandra Yamin
Richard J. Turman
Caroline R. Fredrickson
Robert G. Damus
Peter Rundlet
Courtney B. Timberlake
Janet R. Forsgren
LRM ID: MNB53
SUBJECT:
LABOR
for Employees (SAFE) Act of 1999
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
Report on S385 Safety Advancement
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
'comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
�ARMS Email System
TO:
Page 4 0[20
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7BB7
Fax:
395-614B
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant):
395-7362
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D37]ARMS20060213U.136 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750436BOA0000010A0201000000020500000032930000000200005ED6FOOB905EFCB1DB7BCE
2CEFC32BFA5CBOA214E79C697CB311BB4BFOD455641F8EF07C3CF1CA4E57F10BFC3B3190FB7E73
F3165D14AB7FAC61ADA180A3F093FC141D44BECOEE3465CA01A99B2AAB5F892D91A9D1A1B52BCA
003E125BF683450A166CA7104B46ED40529FC225CBC1AF3570D8FFD722CA9E4A1BOCA04BCAD242
107C7D23EF2F4DE160400293AB3E8174EF39EB51392A90FFAF1B2E76EBF495B23B7649A09E490B
D9E2BAC23CE2D677FA9B4DC5DCA4730FDDBCC391C46D06495EBAB64DBOCAD3AC70E4BAB631FAFB
82FFB7D5CD00300BOB19B8C205576DB37BC7C5ABDAD46CB7206C951DE16645329B90E3DE6EA9C7
2COA26659DOOAD95A2D44DABF9BB6F33720421E670EA7A373C77CDA6A6EC199653C435EB14F21D
EA1EAE1CB4F5955AB47BDDEDD5E7F4242FC20E24527D5B3C09210FD7529E1A4019760313A07B65
222F7C4223519A76EOCE5193A723E4EBB79BDDA6EEEF4E2528EF0204BFFOBDB1B45675FC6AB610
F3A1A43BEEBAD1DC9370BA21B34170E62F9DDDEAOFA0454E561FF48B6FC374D029292B4B09A23E
7D4F6E1EE6EE97BDF3437D2F7B14E6F05B6959B797775493090COO115F0459EF9C0907B0590537
109B5B61DFFC355DF1340DOAB52FD75C94BBB5F905877532E1C5912C03FDDC17B06595AAC5B653
BDOB3DC4C102005700000000000000000000000B23010000000B010000C2060000005501000000
4EOOOOOOCD070000092501000000060000001BOBOOOOOB30030000002B000000210BOOOOOB5E01
0000000C000000490BOOOOOB770100000004000000550B00000834010000001400000059080000
0802010000000F0000006DOB0000081Q01000000020000007COBOO00096D01000000170000007E
0800000B05010000000B0000009508000000550C000000460000009DOB00000055040000004EOO
0000E30B00000055070000004E000000310900000208010000005B0000007F0900000B30020000
0044000000DA090000006501000000010000001EOAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOlEOAOOOOOOOO
00000000000000001EOA0000000000000000000000001EOAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOlEOAOO
00000000000000000000001EOA0000000000000000000000001EOA000000000000000000000000
1EOA0000000000000000000000001EOAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOlEOAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
�draft -- March 3, 2010
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
The Honorable James Jeffords
Chairman
Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions
United States Senate
Washington, DC 20510-6300
Dear Chairman Jeffords:
I understand that the Committee on Health, Education, Labor and
Pensions has scheduled a mark-up session for April 28, 1999 on S.
385, the "Safety Advancement for Employees Act of 1999" (SAFE Act) .
I am writing to reiterate the Department's view that the SAFE Act,
if passed, would unintentionally undermine OSHA's ability to protect
workers. As Assistant Secretary for Occupational Safety and Health
Charles Jeffress testified on March 4, 1999, before the Subcommittee
on Employment, Safety and Training, if S. 385 is passed by Congress
and presented to the President, I will recommend that he veto the
legislation.
The effort to enact S. 385 ignores the very real successes that have
been achieved since the bipartisan sponsorship and enactment of the
Occupational Safety and Health Act nearly 30 years ago.
The
successes of the 1990's are particularly compelling.
Workplace
injuries and illnesses have declined for five consecutive years.
The rate for 1997 was the lowest since the Bureau of Labor Statistics
began reporting this information in the early 1970s.
OSHA and the
OSH Act have been catalysts for these achievements by private sector
employers and workers.
OSHA is having success through results-driven enforcement efforts,
compliance assistance and standard setting.
The agency has
developed a broad range of successful partnership programs that
promote cooperative efforts among employers, workers and government.
OSHA also is making its enforcement programs smarter and fairer
by spending more time at the most hazardous workplaces and less time
at safer ones.
Finally, OSHA is measuring results, where possible,
not by numbers of citations or penalties, but by real improvements
in the lives of working people, such as reduced injury and illness
rates.
The five-year decline in injury and illness rates' is evidence
that this combination of approaches is working.
The SAFE Act focuses
on old problems that OSHA has moved beyond, not new challenges the
agency, workers and employers will face in the future.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
draft -- March 3, 2010
We all agree that more must be done to protect workers.
Too many
workers continue to die or suffer injuries or illnesses because of
work-related causes. Any legislation must increase workplace safety
and health.
The Department is concerned that S. 385 would, instead,
place workers at increased risk.
The overwhelming majority of discussion relating to S. 385 has focused
on the third-party certification provisions of the bill, about which
the Department has made its position clear. As we have previously
stated, private consultants, as a whole, provide a valuable service
to employers and execute their responsibilities in a highly
professional manner.
OSHA encourages employers to use consul tat ions
to help detect and control hazards.
But S. 385 provides only a
marginal incentive for employers to hire third-party consultants,
while creating significant conflict-of-interest problems by enabling
employers to hire private, for-profit consultants to, in effect,
exempt them from OSHA penalties.
The SAFE Act also limits the
accountability of consultants and employers.
Under S. 385, OSHA
has little recourse against consultants whose improper
certifications put workers at risk. The SAFE Act also allows employers
and consultants to negotiate the terms and time frames of compliance
and fails to guarantee that all hazards will be corrected before
a certificate of compliance is granted.
Although the Department is pleased that S. 385 emphasizes the
importance of safety and health programs, it differs from OSHA's
Safety and 'Health Achievement Recognition Program (SHARP) in
significant ways.
For example, while OSHA's SHARP program enables
employers to receive a one-year exemption from programmed
inspections, it does not provide a penalty exemption.
In addition,
employers participating in SHARP only receive their exemption from
programmed inspections after they have received significant
attention from OSHA and demonstrate the highest commitment to safety
and 'health. Moreover, if OSHA is called in for a complaint or
fatality investigation and discovers uncorrected violations, the
SHARP employer is subject to citation and penalties.
In addition to the SAFE Act's third-party certification provisions,
other provisions of the bill pose a significant threat to workplace
safety and health.
The Department's position on each of those
provisions is detailed in the attached analysis.
For the convenience
of the Committee, I will highlight some, but by no means all, of
the most significant issues that concern the Department:
2
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
draft -- March 3, 2010
Expanded Inspection Methods_ Although investigation of
complaints by telephone, facsimile and other similar methods
is desirable in many situations, section 6 would enable those
methods to be used at the expense of the fundamental worker
right to an inspection.
Worksite-Specific Compliance_ Section 7, which would require
OSHA to vacate citations if the employer had at least as
effective a means of protecting its employees as those required
by the OSH Act, could render OSHA standards academic. This
new employer defense could convert every enforcement action
into a time-consuming litigation effort, imposing substantial
burdens on agency resources and the court system.
OSHA
standards would. become guidelines for open debate each time
an employer received a citation.
Technical Assistance _ The Department is concerned that section
8 runs counter to the agreement reached last year to codify
OSHA's consultation program. Last year, the Congress enacted
H.R. 2864 with bipartisan and Administration support and
codified OSHA's consultation program with enhanced employee
protections.
The Department was proud of that cooperative
effort and believes it is premature to amend this new law.
In addition, the fee-for-service element of S. 385 would give
priority to those who can afford to pay for consultation, not
those who need it most.
Consultation is and should remain
prioritized for small, high-hazard industries, not for large,
wealthy ones.
Discretionary Compliance Assistance_ Section 11 would allow
OSHA to issue warnings in lieu of citations, even for violations
that. have killed employees, as long as the employer agrees to
abate the violation promptly. The Department believes that
such unlimited discretion is inappropriate and sends a message
that employers need not take preventive steps to protect their
workers prior to an OSHA inspection.
The attached analysis discusses these issues in greater detail, along
with the Department's position on Sections 4, 5, 9 and 10 of the
bill.
Mr. Chairman, S. 385 would greatly diminish the ability of the
Occupational Safety and Health Administration to administer and
enforce the OSH Act.
The bill would undermine OSHA's effort to
achieve the Act's stated purpose: "to assure so far as possible every
working man and woman in the Nation safe and healthful working
3
�Automated Records Management"System
Hex-Dump Conversion
draft -- March 3, 2010
condi tions and to preserve our human resources. " The SAFE Act would
result in an increased risk of occupational injuries and illnesses,
jeopardizing the lives and well-being of our Nation's workers and
their families.
This legislation, drafted in the name of retooling
and augmenting compliance-related resources, is a step backward and
would require OSHA to devote valuable resources to monitoring private
consultants rather than workplace safety and health.
Accordingly,
the Administration opposes its enactment.
The Office of Management and Budget advises that there is no objection
to the submission of this report and that enactment of S. 385 would
not be in accord with the Administration's program.
Sincerely,
Alexis M. Herman
Enclosure
4
�draft -- March 3, 2010
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Enclosure
DEPARTMENT OF LABOR ANALYSIS OF S. 385
April 1999
Section 3. Third Party Consultation Services Program
Section 3 requires the Secretary to establish a program to "qualify" individuals who could then
serve as consultants to employers to assist them in identifying and correcting safety and health
hazards in their workplaces. An employer who contracted for and received such services and
who was declared by the consultant -- after the initial visit to the workplace, agreement on an
Action Plan, and a possible follow-up "reinspection" visit -- to be in compliance with the Act,
would be exempt from any assessment of a civil penalty under the Act for a period of one year,
with certain limited exceptions.
The Department of Labor strongly opposes this section.
Initially, although we agree that employee safety and health are paramount, the Department is
compelled to object to the new "purpose" that has been added to this section. The new
"purpose" statement would codify the erroneous opinion that all employers are unable to read,
understand and comply with the OSH Act. It would further codify the opinion that OSHA is
unable to satisfy the compliance needs of each employer and employee within its jurisdiction.
The addition of such sentiments to the OSH Act is, at best, inappropriate.
The incentives created by coupling the third party consultation provision with a penalty
exemption leave the program extremely vulnerable to conflict-of-interest and accountability
problems. At the most obvious level, a consultant paid by an employer would be likely to feel
pressured to approve the employer's program or to fail to recommend costly engineering controls
even when they were necessary to prevent an injury or illness. Likewise, businesses may feel
obligated to purchase unnecessary services proposed to them by their consultant in order to
ensure being granted a certificate of compliance. In addition, the provision permitting
employers and consultants to agree upon the terms of the Action Plan would invite abuses that
could result in seriously delayed abatement, if abatement is agreed to at all. Further, there is no
provision in the bill that would prevent an employer from utilizing one of its own employees, or
a former employee, to provide consulting services. Though this is no doubt not the intent of the
bill's authors, section 3 would in effect enable employers to "purchase" immunity from OSHA
inspections and penalties.
Reliance on the private sector for compliance declarations, coupled with exemptions from the
possibility of civil money penalties for those employers who receive such declarations, would
leave the agency without sufficient recourse if an inspection is necessary within the exemption
1
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
draft-- March 3, 2010
period. For example, even if conditions in a certified workplace had undergone major change
during the exemption period, a penalty could only be levied if OSHA could demonstrate the
occurrence of a "fundamental change in the hazards" of the workplace or that the employer had
not made a good faith effort to remain in compliance. The only large-scale study to date that
correlates worksite injury data with worksite inspection history over time has shown that
inspections in which penalties are assessed result in a significant reduction in injuries at the
inspected site for three years following the inspection, and that inspections without penalties
have no appreciable impact (Wayne Gray and John Scholz, "Does Regulatory Enforcement
Work? A Panel Analysis of OSHA Enforcement," Law and Society Review, pages 177-213 (July
1993».
The new version of the SAFE Act has been modified to include a safety and health program
component. This is a positive addition to the bill, but does not cure flaws inherent in the third
party consultation proposal. OSHA's Safety and Health Achievement Recognition Program
(SHARP), part of OSHA's consultation program, exempts employers from aprogrammed
inspection only after the employer requests and receives a full-service consultation visit, and
works with the consultation program for a period of at least a year from the date of the initial
visit to correct and abate all hazards, implement a fully effective worksite safety and health
program and lower the lost workday and accident rates to a level at or below the national average
for their industry. Unlike S.1237 in the lOS th Congress, S. 385 incorporates a requirement for
employers to implement a safety and health program before they can receive a certificate of
compliance. However, unlike OSHA's SHARP program, there is no guarantee that all hazards
will be abated before a certificate is granted. In addition, the ability of private, for-profit
consultants to provide penalty exemptions, rather than the exemptions from programmed
inspections that the SHARP program provides, gives those private, for-profit consultants power
well beyond any power granted to an OSHA compliance officer or a state consultant. SHARP
companies never receive blanket exemptions from penalties. Finally, under the SHARP
program, OSHA has the final say over whether companies should receive SHARP recognition.
This system provides an additional check to ensure that a workplace is safe and has an effective
safety and health program before it becomes exempt from a programmed inspection.
The Department remains concerned that the bill is completely silent about a consultant's
obligations when an employer is found NOT to be in compliance. This means that the
consultant then has the option of refusing to provide a declaration, which leaves the employer
free to seek out another consultant. While the bill now requires the consultant to identify
violations of the OSH Act and possible corrective measures, there is still no clear requirement
that employers abate the identified hazards or that consultants report to OSHA in the event of an
employer's refusal to abate. Moreover, because reinspections are not necessarily required, there
is no way for the consultant, employees or OSHA to verify either abatement or whether the
elements of an effective safety and health program have been fully implemented.
2
�draft -- March 3, 2010
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
The Department is concerned that the bill could allow an employer to receive a certificate of
compliance even ifit has not yet completed the process of hazard abatement. This would allow
an employer that is out of compliance with the law to be declared in compliance. The problem
is further compounded because an employer with a certificate of compliance who has not yet
abated hazards identified in the written plan could not be penalized by OSHA for one year.
Finally, unlike OSHA's abatement verification rule, the employer would not have to "inform
affected employees and their representatives about abatement activities" the employer had
promised to undertake. Elimination of a mandatory reinspection requirement worsens this
problem. Without reinspection, an employer could obtain a certificate without having to show
that it has abated a single hazard. In the event that a reinspection does actually occur, there is no
provision for further action if the employer has not satisfied all the elements in the consultation
report.
In addition, relying on the private sector for such certifications, while at the same time exempting
the employer's worksite from the possibility of a penalty, would deprive the agency of sufficient
"quality control" over both certifications and the safety and health audits performed by
Federally-sanctioned, certified individuals. The only oversight granted to OSHA under this bill
is meaningless. The bill requires OSHA to maintain a registry of safety and health consultants it
deems qualified, but hamstrings the agency in the event problems occur. In addition,
maintaining a registry would place a substantial burden on the agency's already limited
resources. Those resources should be targeted toward making workplaces and workers safer, not
toward policing a new army of consultants.
These problems are compounded because the disciplinary action anticipated by this legislation is
insufficient to redress or deter the abuses for which S.385 creates an incentive. Removal of a
consultant from participation in the program is simply not enough to .prevent or punish abuses
such as fraud or collusion. Further, the circumstances under which an employer or consultant
could be disciplined are so limited that the bill would permit a consultant to continue to
participate where injuries and illnesses continue to occur as a result of incompetence or simple
negligence. In addition, it appears that a consultant's failure to identify a hazard would exempt
the employer from penalties for that hazard.
Further compounding these problems is the bill's failure to clearly identify the minimal
qualifications for a consultant. For example, section 8A(b)(2)(A) identifies practitioners of
certain state-licensed occupations as "eligible to be qualified" as consliltants, but neglects others
and does not specify what experience in hazard identification and occupational safety and health
eligible consultants must have. OSHA is further concerned that this provision requires states to
create licensing programs for safety and health professionals. We believe that this requirement
may impose a significant burden upon the states.
The Department is unaware of any concrete evidence that a third party certification program
would be successful. At the outset of this Administration, the idea of third-party audits was
3
�Automated Records Management Systerr.
Hex-Dump Conversion
draft -- March 3, 2010
raised at a meeting of OSHA's stakeholders, where it met with little enthusiasm from either labor
or business representatives. More recently, a State of North Carolina survey demonstrated a
resounding preference on the part of employers for an OSHA consultant over a private
consultant. Cost, as well as suspicion that the private consultant might attempt to sell an
employer unnecessary services, were among the reasons given in support of OSHA consultants.
Section 4. Establishment of Special Advisory Committee
Section 4 would require the Secretary to establish a new advisory committee consisting of
employees, employers, members of the general public, and an official from a state plan state~
The committee would advise and make recommendations to the Secretary concerning the
establishment and implementation of third-party consultation services programs under section 8A
of the bill.
Section 7(a) of the current statute establishes the National Advisory Committee on Occupational
Safety and Health· (NACOSH), which exists to make recommendations on matters relating to the
administration of the current Act. Mandating the establishment of a new advisory committee
dealing with the new consultation program in section 8A of the bill would duplicate part of the
existing jurisdiction ofNACOSH and, as such, would be redundant and not in keeping with the
concept of reinvention and streamlining. In the event the Secretary needs to consult with experts
on the specifics of consultation programs, Sections 7(c)(1) and (2) of the OSH Act now give the
Secretary broad powers to hire consultants and experts, and to utilize the services of experts from
other Federal agencies and states. If the Secretary wishes to obtain advice through the
instrumentality of an advisory committee, she may establish such a committee pursuant to the
requirements of the Federal Advisory Committee Act.
Section 5. Continuing Education and Professional Certification for Certain Occupational Safety
and Health Administration Personnel
Section 5 requires Federal employees who enforce the Act to meet the eligibility requirements
established under new section 8A(b)(2) for third-party consultants. In addition, these employees
must receive professional education and training every five years.
OSHA agrees that effective training of enforcement personnel is vitally important. OSHA and
the State Plans conduct a wide range of training programs to ensure that compliance officers
conduct fair and effective investigations.
The OSH Act is not industry-specific; it applies to a wide variety of workplaces throughout the
nation. Therefore, it has been OSHA's experience that individuals with broad professional
backgrounds become the best inspectors. During their first three years of employment, new
4
�draft -- March 3, 2010
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Compliance Safety and Health Officers (CSHOs) are teamed with experienced inspectors and are
given over 250 hours of training on investigative techniques at the OSHA Training Institute
(OT!) in Des Plaines, Illinois. Additional training is mandatory for experienced CSHOs at least
once every three years. Finally, whenever new standards are promulgated, OT! offers
specialized training in these standards.
As this discussion illustrates, OSHA does train and educate its employees, but not in a manner
that matches the bill's inflexible requirements. We are concerned that the bill is unclear about
which employees would be required to receive this training. For example, would the agency's
attorneys be considered "responsible for enforcing this Act"? Weare further concerned about
the cost of providing the required training.
Finally, we note that the bill contains no specific training requirements for the consultants for the
program created under section 5, whose inspections and reports may result in employer
exemptions from civil money penalties.
Section 6. Expanded Inspection Methods
Section 6 of the bill would allow OSHA to investigate an alleged violation or danger by
telephone or facsimile. The bill also states that OSHA is not required to conduct complaint
inspections if "a request for inspection was made for reasons other than the safety and health of
the employees of an employer" or if OSHA determines that workers are not at risk.
OSHA has two primary concerns about this section. First, although investigation of complaints
by telephone, facsimile and other similar methods is desirable in many situations, these methods
should not replace a worker's fundamental right to an inspection. In the past two years, OSHA
has reduced the time from the filing of a complaint to the time hazards are abated by using
telephone and facsimile methods for investigating informal complaints. In addition, several
offices have experimented with these methods for investigatingformal worker complaints, but
only where the complaining worker agrees. However, these methods should not be allowed to
interfere where a worker seeks to exercise his or her statutory right to an inspection.
Second, section 6 would allow OSHA to forgo a formal complaint inspection if it determines that
the complaint was made for reasons other than safety and health -- even if the information
provided by the complainant suggests that the workers in question may be facing substantial risk.
Again, the agency's determination as to whether to inspect following a formal complaint should
be based on the likelihood that workers are at risk -- not on the motivation ofthe complainant.
Where workers face substantial hazards, OSHA should act -- and is compelled by statute to act -to protect them. Moreover, it would be very difficult for OSHA to determine the complainant's
motivation. This exercise would consume scarce agency resources and delay inspections.
5
�Automated Records Management SysterHex-Dump Conversion .
draft -- March 3, 2010
Ultimately, the agency should continue to inspect where it has reasonable cause to believe that
workers are at risk.
Section 7. Worksite-Specific Compliance Methods
Section 7 would create an entirely new statutory defense to an OSHA citation, based on an
employer's demonstration that employees were protected by alternate methods equally or more
protective than those required by the standard the employer violated.
The OSH Review Commission and the courts have held repeatedly that when OSHA's standards
require employers to adopt specific precautions for protecting employees, employers must
comply in the manner specified. Under current law, employers have the right to select
alternative means of compliance when literal compliance is impossible or would pose a greater
hazard to employees. In" greater hazard" cases, the Commission requires an employer to show
that a variance has either been sought or would be inappropriate.
Under these rules, the contest rate has remained relatively low; less than ten percent of all
citations are currently contested. Under this provision of S. 385, however, virtually every
employer cited for violations of the OSH Act or OSHA standards could claim that an alternative
means of compliance was as effective as the standard in question. In effect, standards would
become guidelines, subject to challenge -- and potential waiver -- in every individual contested
case. This provision could seriously undermine OSHA's standards, tum every enforcement
action into a costly and time-consuming variance proceeding, and impose substantial burdens
upon agency resources, the OSH Review Commission, and the Federal courts.
Section 8. Technical Assistance Program
Section 8 amends the OSH Act's "Training and Employee Education" provision to require.
cooperative agreements between OSHA and States to provide consultation programs. The
Department objects to amending the new consultation law Congress passed less than a year ago
with bipartisan support after extensive negotiations between Congress and the Department «P.L.
105-197, 112 Stat. 638 (July 16, 1998) (the "Occupational Safety and Health Administration
Compliance Assistance Authorization Act of 1998"».
We are particularly concerned with further amending the program in the way contemplated by
section 8. Under section 8, the Secretary must establish a pilot program in three states for a
duration of up to two years, the purpose of which would be to test a fee-for-service system. The
fifty state agencies that already administer the consultation program have expressed very strong
reservations about charging fees in the consultation program. The Administration shares these
6
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
draft -- March 3, 2010
concerns. Those who could pay would be visited first, defeating the philosophy that this service
is aimed at small or highly hazardous businesses that cannot afford to hire other consultants.
Section 9. Voluntary Protection Program
Section 9 attempts to codify OSHA's Voluntary Protection Program, requiring the Secretary to
establish cooperative agreements with employers, who would create and maintain comprehensive
safety and health management systems. The bill requires enhanced OSHA efforts to include
small businesses in the VPP. Participation in this program would result in exemptions from
inspections and certain paperwork requirements.
OSHA has supported codifying the VPP program, but we do not support this provision as
drafted. The VPP has traditionally been, and should remain, a program for work sites, not
employers. Although there are references to "the worksite" in the section, this vital mainstay
of the program must be emphasized. OSHA is also concerned that codification could jeopardize
the high standards of the program currently in operation. As drafted, this provision does not
reflect the idea that the VPP program is reserved exclusively for those employers who have
demonstrated the highest commitment to worker safety and health. Ideally, any codifi~ation of
this program should limit participation to employers who have truly superior safety and health
records, but should allow OSHA the flexibility to define (and modify as necessary) the specific
criteria for participation in the program. We further note that the bill does not include a program
requirement for VPP participants to provide meaningful employee involvement in safety and
health matters, which we believe to be an important component of the program. These changes
must be made before OSHA would withdraw its objections.
Section 10. Prevention of Alcohol and Substance Abuse
Section 10 authorizes the Secretary to test employees and management for drugs and alcohol
following any work-related fatality or serious injury. It also permits employers to institute their
own testing programs conforming to HHS and Federal workplace guidelines. Testing is
permissible on a for-cause basis, as part of a scheduled medical 'examination, where an accident
involving actual or potential loss of human life, bodily injury, or property damage has occurred,
during participation in a drug treatment program, or on a random basis.
OSHA strongly supports measures that contribute to a drug-free work environment and
reasonable programs of drug testing within a comprehensive workplace program for certain
workplace environments, such as those involving safety-sensitive duties, and which take into
consideration employee rights to privacy. However, OSHA is concerned that it may not have
the resources to oversee drug and alcohol programs.
7
�Automated R
d
Hex~~~pS M ge'!1ent System
cana
draft -- March 3, 2010
onverslon
Section 11. Discretionary Compliance Assistance
This section provides that the Secretary may issue warnings in lieu of citations where the
violation has no significant relationship to safety or health or where the employer has acted in
good faith to promptly abate the violation. The Secretary may not exercise this discretion where
the violation has a "significant relationship to employee safety or health" or where the violation is
willful or repeated.
Currently, the OSH Act provides that OSHA "shall" issue a citation for each violation it
discovers during an inspection. This provision would change this provision to "may." As a
practical matter, the impact of this proposed change is unclear. Federal case law demonstrates
that OSHA possesses a greater degree ofprosecutorial discretion than was recognized in the early
years of the agency's existence. The agency has discretion under existing law to establish
programs in which it does not issue a citation for every violation it finds. For example, OSHA
has used this discretion to establish programs such as Maine 200.
Among other things, OSHA is particularly troubled by paragraph 3(B), which allows the issuance
of a "warning in lieu of a citation" for violations that the employer "acts promptly to abate[.]"
Even though it allows OSHA the discretion to issue citations in such circumstances, this
provision may signal employers that they need not take preventive steps to protect their workers
prior to an OSHA inspection. As such, this provision could undennine both the preventive
purpose as well as the deterrent effect of OSHA's enforcement program.
Prompt abatement of hazards should be encouraged, but it should be encouraged through penalty
reductions, not by eliminating any citations whatsoever for violations. Otherwise, employers
who make good faith efforts to protect workers before an OSHA inspector arrives at their door
will be treated the same as neglectful employers who have ignored their workers' safety until the
inspection.
Finally, the limitations on the Secretary's discretion are so narrow that they could lead to
outrageous results. For example, the Secretary's discretion is not limited to cases in which an
employer has shown good faith by implementing a safety and health program or in which no
employee has been killed or seriously injured because of the employer's violation. Rather, the
bill authorizes the Secretary to issue a warning in lieu of a citation if the employer "acts promptly
to abate the violation" even if the employer has a long history of previous violations and causes
the death of several employees.
8
�· .ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-APR-1999 15:11:15.00
SUBJECT:
Reminder--commetns on LABOR Report on S385 Safety Advancement for Employee
TO: Peter Rundlet ( CN=Peter Rundlet/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Caroline R. Fredrickson ( CN=Caroline R. Fredrickson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa B. Fairhall ( CN=Lisa B. Fairhall/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Iratha H. Waters ( CN=Iratha H. Waters/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. Timberlake/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart Shapiro ( CN=Stuart Shapiro/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
clrm@doc.gov ( clrm@doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
justice.lrm@usdoj.gov ( justice.lrm@usdoj.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
READ: UNKNOWN
cla@sba.gov ( cla@sba.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
lrm@os.dhhs.gov ( lrm@os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
ca.legislation@gsa.gov ( ca.legislation@gsa.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM AGRICULTURE ( LRM AGRICULTURE [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This is a reminder that your comments on the subject report are due at 4
p.m. today.
Please provide any comments via fax (395-6148), e-mail, or phone
(395-7887) no later than the deadline.
If we do not hear from you by the
deadline, we will assume you have no comments.
Please call if you have any questions.
Thanks!
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 7
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. BentonjOU=OMBjO=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:26-APR-1999 17:26:17.00
SUBJECT:
LRM MNB54 - - LABOR report on Increasing the minimum wage
TO: Janet R. Forsgren
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Janet R. ForsgrenjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. SmalliganjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea KanejOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick JohnsonjOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey L. Farrow ( CN=Jeffrey L. FarrowjOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. ReimersjOU=CEAjO=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. MatlackjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
OMB 1
TO: Iratha H. Waters ( CN=Iratha H. WatersjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra YaminjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart Shapiro ( CN=Stuart ShapirojOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. RicejOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen TramontanojOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah RosenjOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. BondjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry WhitejOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara ChowjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: lrm@os.dhhs.gov ( lrm@os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of7
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: cla ( cla @ sba.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: llr@do·. treas. gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@
inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
llr@do.treas.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: clrm ( clrm @ doc. gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: justice.lrm (justice.lrm @usdoj.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
)
@ inet [UNKNOWN 1
(OA)
TEXT:
Note to EOP staff: you will not receive a hard copy of this LRM.
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 04/26/99
05:15 PM --------------------------LRM ID: MNB54
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Monday, April 26, 1999
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution
TO:
below
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for
FROM:
Legislative Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395 - 6148
SUBJECT:
LABOR Statement for the Record on Increasing the minimum
wage
DEADLINE:
11 a.m.
Tuesday, April 27, 1999
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: The Department of Labor wants to submit this statement for the
record for a House Education and the Workforce hearing tomorrow afternoon
(April 27th) .
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
52-HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
61-JUSTICE - Jon P. Jennings - (202) 514-2141
EOP:
Barbara Chow
Iratha H. Waters
Barry White
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of7
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Cordelia W. Reimers
Sarah Rosen
Jeffrey L. Farrow
Karen Tramontano
Broderick Johnson
Elena Kagan
Andrea Kane
Cynthia A. Rice
Jack A. Smalligan
Stuart Shapiro
Sandra Yamin
Janet R. Forsgren
LRM ID: MNB54
SUBJECT:
LABOR Statement for the Record on
Increasing the minimum wage
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7887
Fax: 395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant):
395-7362
FROM:
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of7
______ FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet.
- Minwagty.wpd
==================== ATTACHMENT 1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D21]ARMS277847132.136 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX'DUMP:
FF57504337050000010A02010000000205000000971A000000020000701F0133AD7AF993B4A86B
4060F87577CA6364A163658D01F36594ED068946994E2A5034BC6DBB9088F39B45E5B54C074510
2015D61362CFCCAOA3772CCA87E628F627806AE94C91F938DB14B5F144BF98BBE085E96FEF7C12
D4BC112A8A865899CB5575443EBC4E133D1F894AE61A335114D97E843465609A6F42F8B08216A4
07EE026B5F80504EA067D5A59D720D743COA48EE65BE24107571D872474F714128FBD4F9D12ACF
9E6B7829309303CA47EA86A0018A570FB81D792DE6A81D162EECA5566730A0157695AD186F40BC
59AA1AF8BE90581EFOA7214A81EF1C580B12A643CE2476430A765EO06FB9D628DAF1AA16DOD713
C98503289C632E2A5014BC6C9FF2E787E49AEA06C209CAC912B159ECFOBODFB7ECF67136A3559C
5C8B4E31B7F288E6DCDA7D33D2972E2586766B84C36390BA0917875FEA02F4A2D530CEOF403887
933BOD7A2379F6C4729CA3278F7C86D35EEB9947AA2B7F10B321DF8D6EB487F6BC2FE7B3FD82BA
F3266B84246B5569759F98D7270DB183F46E893109FC4DA79AAE79048D383DB5E9FE55BA94C9D7
BDE9FE7612DAE7B6E09F9C54C823E1D94A92D2C2CCBCCE2E2697164AC4A52B56A9A72B7C44A51D
E4B05E3C8C4F1A1AF8C58242765EADDE01F40BC818D785ED443E6BB3263FOC3A79E9C1AE383732
D5C7A0544502001100000000000000000000000823010000000B010000EE020000005504000000
4EOOOOOOF903000009250100000006000000470400000B3002000000280000004D040000087701
000000040000007504000008340100000014000000790400000802010000000F0000008D040000
084E01000000020000009C040000085E010000000C0000009E040000081001000000,02000000AA
040000096D0100000017000000AC04000000620100000008000000C3040000084D010000000400
0000CB0400000055010000003EOOOOOOCF040000080501000000080000000D0500000608010000
00220000001505000000984800500020004C0061007300650072004A0065007400200034002000
50006C007500730000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000485050434C354D5300000000002C01F0002C012C012C012C012C01F000300000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000006E
4CF2CF2800D61EC30F3908000011090000005AOOOB01008B143600540069006D00650073002000
4E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E00200052006500670075006C00610072000000000000
000000010002005802010000000400280000000000000000000000000000000000000001120200
2400A1000000A100000000000000AB9A8D26000000007F470000000001006000B00008337C0078
0000020000000000000303004AA797266302000000000800040002000000000000000000000000
FF551A8BFFOOOOCOCOC02D0020F92D000000010000001BOOF41A5C121A09000011090000006000
18110000102600540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006EOOOOOO
000000000000010004000200000001000A00000018000000D10FOD000003000000000DOOD1D113
OB00000100000BOOD1DDOA10008301040003000200211000DDDDOBOB00030000040BOODD9BD45F
10000006000002000000001000D4D1180F0080010COOOOOOOOOOOF00D1D1033700800100001600
762B010000580206000058020000000000000064ECOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000000000000000
64C8003700D1D45F10000006000003000200001000D4D11511008001100004002A1802001100D1
8080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080F2
OCF28053544154454D454E54804F4680414C45584953804D2E804845524D414E2CD0041500000B
00090001B0040000000001201500DOD301120007040000000200000001001200D3808080808080
808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080
808080808080534543524554415259804F46804C41424F52CCD305OC0000010002000COOD34245
464F524580544845CC434F4D4D4954544545804F4E80454455434154494F4E80414E4480544845
80574F524B464F524345D30116000604000000010000000200FOOO00001600D3CC484F55534580
4F4680524550524553454E54415449564553CCCC415052494C8032372C8031393939CCCCF30CF3
CCD3050C0000010000020COOD3D301120000040000000200000001001200D34980616D80706C65
6173656480746F8062658061626C6580746F806F66666572806D798072656D61726B7380746F64
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
STATEMENT OF ALEXIS M. HERMAN,
SECRETARY OF LABOR
BEFORE THE
COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION AND THE WORKFORCE
HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
APRIL 27, 1999
I am pleased to be able to offer my remarks today in strong support of the President's proposal to
increase the minimum wage. For more than 11 million American workers, increasing the
minimum wage from $5.15 an hour to $6.15 a hour over two years is not an academic debate
among economists. Instead, it is about paying the rent, buying the groceries, and keeping the
kids in clothes. Seventy percent of those who would benefit are adults, 20 and over. Three-fifths
are women, many of whom are the sole breadwinners in their families. Mr. Chairman, these
hard-working Americans - some of whom work 2 and 3 jobs -- deserve a raise.
When we last raised the minimum wage and expanded the earned income tax credit, we took
important steps to reward work and help millions of Americans raise their families with dignity
and move off welfare. Because of our actions, a full-time working parent with two children does
not have to live in poverty. But more must be done to ensure that all working families are lifted
out of poverty.
The minimum wage is not enough to make ends meet for many families. Working 40 hours a
week, 50 weeks a year, a minimum wage worker still earns just $10,300 a year. For these
-1-
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
workers and their families, a one-dollar increase would make a real difference. It would mean
another $2,000 a year. That's enough to buy a family offour groceries for 7 months or pay for 5
months' rent.
Opponents of an increase in the minimum wage overlook these benefits, and claim an increase
will hurt those it's intended to help. When we last raised the minimum wage, opponents claimed
that jobs would be lost throughout the economy -- especially in lower-wage sectors such as retail
stores and restaurants. They predicted that unemployment rates would skyrocket for teenagers
and disadvantaged workers. Some claimed that inflation would go through the roof.
The facts have proven the critics were wrong. Unemployment and inflation are the lowest they
have been in roughly 30 years. Since President Clinton signed the last increase into law, over 7
million new jobs have been added. More than one million new retail jobs have been added, and
restaurant jobs have grown by over 270,000.
Unemployment has also declined significantly over the same period. The unemployment rate
for African-Americans has dropped frpm 10.6% to 8.1 %. Unemployment for Hispanics is at a
record low of 5.8% -- down from 8.3% in September 1996. For high school dropouts,
unemployment dropped from 8.2% to 6.1 % -- another record low. Teenage unemployment
declined from 15.7% to 14.3%, while African-American teen unemployment went from 33% to
31%.
-2-
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Employment has increased dramatically as well. Employment among African-American women
has risen from 57.2% to 60.9%. And employment for welfare recipients and single mothers with
children is continuing to climb, at least partly because of policies that "make work pay" such as a
higher minimum wage.
Some critics claim that these employment increases might have been even greater in the absence
of the minimum wage increases, but it is hard to take these claims seriously. Many surveys of
employers currently show that, instead of facing pools of qualified applicants whom they refuse
to hire, they are having difficulty finding applicants to fill jobs that they've already created.
This
simply doesn't fit the picture of an economy in which moderate increases in the minimum wage
have led to fewer jobs and lost employment opportunities.
The minimum wage increase would help, not hurt, poor families. Most studies show that
minimum wage increases disproportionately benefit workers in low-income families. While a
majority of those who earn the minimum wage live in families with incomes above the poverty
line, these incomes are often below the average level of family income in the United States. An
increase in the minimum wage would therefore help a wide range of families with low-wage
workers who need a raise.
Mr. Chairman, we know who will benefit from this bill. We see minimum wage workers every
day when we buy a cup of coffee on the way to work.
-3-
We see them cleaning our offices as we
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
leave. We see them as we pick up our <;hildren from the child care center, or visit our parents in
the nursing home. Our nation's extraordinary prosperity rests on the efforts of all these workers.
They deserve to be treated with dignity. They deserve a fair share of our prosperity. They
deserve an increase in the minimum wage, and I urge you to adopt the President's proposal.
-4-
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[04/12/1999 – 04/26/1999]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 100 - Folder 002
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/9001bc8ad4478b46c1ffa5c148c7b965.pdf
4dea56d86f4eb2132941e0e84326358f
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 100 - FOLDER -001
[03/19/1999-04/06/1999 ]
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 22
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:19-MAR-1999 18:44:46.00
SUBJECT:
Additional budget paper
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William A. Halter ( cN=william A. Halter/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: jgreen ( jgreen @ pfaw [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrei H. Cherny ( CN=Andrei H. Cherny/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth·R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey A. Forbes ( CN=Jeffrey A. Forbes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William H. White Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=william H.
Wh~te
Jr./OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of22
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald L. Silberman ( CN=Ronald L. Silberman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N .. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN=Bob J. Nash/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOym
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Robert D. Kyle ( CN=Robert D. Kyle/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Konigsberg ( CN=Charles Konigsberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of22
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diane M. Goldberg ( CN=Diane M. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MCrisci ( MCrisci @ arnellgroup.com @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David Belsky ( CN=David Belsky/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Marsha E. Berry ( CN=Marsha E. Berry/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eli G. Attie ( CN=Eli G. Attie/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ oVP 1 )
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jackson T. Dunn ( CN=Jackson T. Dunn/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona K. Sutphen ( CN=Mona K. Sutphen/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra L. Via ( CN=Sandra L. Via/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Victoria A. Wachino ( CN=Victoria A. Wachino/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert L. Nabors ( CN=Robert L. Nabors/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan E. Smith ( CN=Jonathan E. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of22
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn L. Smalls
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria E. S,oto
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Dawn L. Smalls/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
CN=Maria E. Soto/OU=WHO/O=EOP
@
i )
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Dario J. Gomez ( CN=Dario J. Gomez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard M. Samans ( CN=Richard M. Samans/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel D. Heath ( CN=Daniel D. Heath/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Doris Parker ( CN=Doris Parker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard L. Siewert ( CN=Richard L. Siewert/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sonyia Matthews ( CN=Sonyia Matthews/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: HorwitzR ( HorwitzR @ sec.gov @ INET @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dominique L. Cano ( CN=Dominique L. Cano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian A. Barreto ( CN=Brian A. Barreto/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark D. Neschis ( CN=Mark D. Neschis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neera Tanden ( CN=Neera Tanden/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of22
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leanne A. Shimabukuro ( CN=Leanne A. Shimabukuro/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia M. Terzano ( CN=Virginia M. Terzano/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Lisa J. Levin ( CN=Lisa J. Levin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beverly J. Barnes (CN=Beverly J. Barnes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas D. Janenda ( CN=Thomas D. Janenda/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian D. Smith ( CN=Brian D. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein
READ: UNKNOWN
J~.
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorothy Robyn ( CN=Dorothy Robyn/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ashley L. Raines ( CN=Ashley L. Raines/OU=OA/O=EOP @ EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kelley L. O'Dell ( CN=Kelley L. O'Dell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alison Muscatine ( CN=Alison Muscatine/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas R. Matties ( CN=Douglas R. Matties/OU=OA/O=EOP @ EOP [ OA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 6 of22
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason ( CN=Julie E. Mason!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew!OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eli P. Joseph ( CN=Eli P. Joseph!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Betty W. Currie (' CN=Betty W. Currie!OU=WHO!O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jill M Blickstein
READ: UNKNOWN
Jill M Blickstein @ Ianmail.fanniemae.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1
TO: Richard B. Bavier ( CN=Richard B. Bavier!OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Ricci ( CN=Linda Ricci!OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Lowell A. Weiss ( CN=Lowell A. Weiss!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca L. Walldorff ( CN=Rebecca L. Walldorff!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams!OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves!OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Adrienne C. Erbach ( CN=Adrienne C. Erbach!OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracy
Pakuln~ewicz
( CN=Tracy Pakulniewicz!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 7 of22
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn T. Wu ( CN=Carolyn T. Wu/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Heather M. Riley ( CN=Heather M. Riley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jade L Riley ( CN=Jade L Riley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason H. Schechter ( CN=Jason H. Schechter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1. )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sharon H. Yuan ( CN=Sharon H. Yuan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dora Kale ( CN=Dora Kale/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKN:OWN
TO: Malcolm R. Lee ( CN=Malcolm R. Lee/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Sherman ( CN=David J. Sherman/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MITSLER E
READ:UNKNOWN
MITSLER E @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ EOP 1 )
NSC 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Gay L. Joshlyn ( CN=Gay L. Joshlyn/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Chandler G. Spaulding ( CN=Chandler G. Spaulding/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua S. Gottheimer ( CN=Joshua S. Gottheimer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa G. Green/OPD/EOP on 03/19/99
06:44 PM ---------------------------
Charles R. Marr
03/19/99 06:32:52 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Melissa G. Green/OPD/EOP
cc:
Subject:
Additional budget paper
Melissa -- can you blast email.
These are additional one-pagers on Republican budget:
�ARMS Email System
Page 8 of22
Urban
Environment
Education and Training
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D78)ARMS16175688P.036 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750439FOFOOOOOIOA020100000002050000008D2A000000020000514A90A8E365055FFCA328
EA8A021DB05FADE67D7FOFFF3E9ABCFIF1528D0675A7499388D585C37CA2D23BC3DIE654F04312
7D62332D4D41A9634C6624EDA45BA54262C4BB68751FCAC61F316ACIEB3CAC59EE8D19AOOB6365
FEF424AA1219276921CBD380F2A975915FAOD8FOCA600C8D47953554B57AF621AA198E08A5A55E
F075F1573E566F305E28EB7B6BF2296710405AAED673468549D897676FD982C8A072EB0674FA94
54F26E5FA9F04605DEB7F773362AB556A3F4883BF245A4FF6F9D5B8EDDIAF36654BOCBOF8AC7Fl
FID60398C308C832394C7CAF6053F910B3DE24FF20D9414A89CFEC3179ED241E4D08BA37A9664C
2CE195970B80DOD56F9C4911BEF6B93469E19182A0357378E36916CF28F60F93428B69836F70BO
A82CBOF2EC2A557496EIE589C26D46AC40El12B33DF4BOE4DA7887CE25DAI078326945729F575D
2FDA98EC12D52CDD59ACIA28E5D469BAC629DCD8C803BIC2C30442B121F03844C07C2B14D371A2
D35689DIII0083FDOBE7F07513F2105CD814D27B4D05F734919B176E78EID9EBED85028D3B531A
397FIB2A2ED4DDE711027A20229CF86C71B24DC4FE7CB47E51F906AEOBD8FIOB7CA02FF6C4553D
7669654E3AB5B3C7BFODED7E7C7CC7506972466A4571F43262ACD44B1893965EFAOF7A8F9A8F63
4A5E29DE5D0200A500000000000000000000000823010000000BOI0000060B0000005509000000
4EOOOOOOIIOC0000092501000000060000005FOCOOOOOB300200000028000000650C0000087701
000000400000008DOC000008340100000014000000CDOC00000802OlOOOOOOOFOOOOOOEIOCOOOO
08050100000008000000FOOC000000550100000048000000F80COO000045020000000200000040
OD000006080100000022000000420DOOOOOB300200000063000000640D00000055020000004EOO
0000C70DOOOOOB300C0000004C000000150E00000931010000006D000000610EOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000000000610E00000055030000003COOOOOOCEOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCEOEOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCEOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCEOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCEOEOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCEOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCEOE000000000000000000000000
CEOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCEOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCEOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOCEOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOQOCEOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCEOEOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000000000CEOEOOOOOB30010000004EOOOOOOOAOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAOFOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAOF
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOAOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOAOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000000AOF00000942010000001D000000580FOOOOOOOOOOOOOO0000000000580FOOOOOOOOOO
00000000000000580F000000000000000000000000580FOOOOOOOO0000000000000000580FOOOO
00000000000000000000580F000000000000000000000000580FOO000000000000000000000058
OF000000000000000000000000580FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO580FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000580F000000000000000000000000580FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000580FOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000000000580F000000000000000000000000580FOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000580FOOOOOOOO
0000000000000000580F000000000000000000000000580FOOOOOO000000000000000000580FOO
0000000000000000000000580F000000000000000000000000580F000000000000000000000000
580F000000000000000000000000580FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00580FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000580F000000000000000000000000580FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000000580FOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000000000580F000000000000000000000000580FOOOOOOOOOO00000000000000580FOOOOOO
000000000000000000580F000000000000000000000000580FOOOO00000000000000000000580F
000000000000000000000000580F00000000000000000000000058OFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00580F000000000000000000000000580FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO0000580FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00000000580F000000000000000000000000580FOOOOOOOOOOOOOO0000000000580FOOOOOOOOOO
00000000000000580F000000000000000000000000580FOOOOOOOO0000000000000000580FOOOO
00000000000000000000580F000000000000000000000000580FOO000000000000000000000058
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversign
Republican Budget Shortchanges Urban America
March 19, 1999
Building on the success of six years of fiscal discipline and the virtuous economic cycle it created, President
Clinton has proposed a budget that includes a more than $3.4 trillion debt reduction lock-box that extends the
solvency of Social Security until 2055 and extends Medicare's solvency for more than a decade. It invests in
e.ducation and a cleaner environment, and a stronger urban America.
To build on the President and Vice President's strong foundation of community empowerment initiatives -which includes programs to promote greater access to capital and credit, more affordable housing, and spur the
creation of private investment and job creation -- the FY2000 budget includes proposals to:
_
_
_
Expand the Low Income and Housing Tax Credit.
Make the brownfields tax expensing provision permanent.
Create Better America Bonds to allow communities to create parks and open spaces.
Spur private investment in distressed neighborhoods through a new markets initiative.
Expand the welfare-to-work housing voucher program.
The Republicans have responded with a proposal that puts top priority on a tax cut which explodes in cost and is
targeted away from the middle class. Because the tax cut is so large and consumes the entire on-budget
surplus, the funds available for critical investments in urban America are squeezed dramatically:
The Republican budget would require a more than 10 percent cut in 2000 and over 20 percent cut in 2004
unprotected discretionary programs. This would have a devastating impact on programs critical to our
urban areas:
•
The cut to HUD's HOME program would deny tenant-based rental assistance to 1,300 families.
Further, funds would be lost for new construction, rehabilitation, or acquisition of over 10,000
affordable housing units.
•
The Republicans' reductions would wipe out the Administration's proposal of adding 100,000 new
housing vouchers, including 25,000 to help move families from welfare to work, 18,000 for the
homeless, and 15,000 for extremely low-income elderly.
•
The Community Development Financial Institutions Fund (CDFI) would be reduced by over $11
million, with the result that 16 fewer community development institutions (CDFIs) would receive capital
funding and 12 fewer financial institutions would receive Bank Enterprise Act grants. By 2004, the
Republican budget would reduce CDFI's funding by $26 million, eliminating federal assistance to 37 CDFIs
and 28 commercial CDFI lenders.
Programs critical to urban America would be at risk because of
A low priority in the Republican budget:
the squeeze on the overall discretionary funds proposed. The assumptions made in the Republican budget
resolutions show that programs important to urban America would be a low priority in competition for those
funds:
•
The Senate Budget Resolution proposes $5.3 billion in 2000 for community and regional development,
$3.4 billion or 39.2 percent less than a freeze and $3.6 billion or 40.7 percent less than the President's
budget. This would mean a massive reduction to the Community Development Block Grant Program
(CDBG), one of the most popular and flexible sources of funds that mayors and governors use to
improve economic opportunity and housing in low-income communities. Thousands of local
neighborhood improvement efforts would be jeopardized. Cuts of 40 percent in this set of HUD
programs would translate into a loss of assistance to 82,000 homes and loss of support for 114,000
jobs in low-income areas.
�Automated Recorcls Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
The Republican Budget:
Sacrificing Our Environment and Public Health
President Clinton is proposing a record $33.9 billion in FY 2000 to protect our environment and public
health, including major new initiatives to preserve America's lands legacy, combat air pollution and
global warming, and help build livable communities/or the 21st century~
The Republican budget not only fails to fund these environmental priorities. but imposes drastic cuts
that would stop toxic waste cleanups. shut down national parks. cripple water quality programs. and
heighten the risk of deadIv wildfires.
The Republican budget slashes funding for priority domestic programs 12 percent in FY 2000 and 28
percent in 2004. Across-the-board cuts would have these devastating impacts on public health and the
environment:
>
Stopping 135 Toxic Waste Cleanups - The Republican budget would cut Superfund by a total of
$1.5 billion over the next five years, needlessly jeopardizing public health by preventing as many
as 135 priority cleanups nationwide -- 92 percent of the federally led cleanups planned.
Shutting Down National Parks - Cuts to the National Park Service would reduce services and
hours of operation at 378 parks and other facilities serving almost 300 million visitors a year. In
FY 2004, $575 million in cuts would shut down many smaller parks and backcountry areas in
larger parks, and jeopardize visitor safety by blocking vital maintenance and repairs.
Squandering Our Lands Legacy - By failing to fund the President's Lands Legacy initiative, the
Republican budget would block federal efforts to preserve natural treasures, and deny states and
communities $588 million to protect farmland, coastland, urban parks and other green spaces.
Slashing Water and Public Health Protections - By FY 2004, cuts to the Environmental
Protection Agency would eliminate funding for the Clean Water Action Plan, which helps
communities clean up the 40 percent of surveyed waters still too polluted for fishing or swimming;
and let polluters off the hook by crippling EPA's ability to enforce public health protections.
Gambling with Global Warming - Cuts to the Department of Energy and EPA would gut efforts
toward cleaner, more efficient energy for homes, transportation, and industry; and keep the
Partnership for a New Generation of Vehicles from meeting its goal of new cars three times more
fuel-efficient than today's models by 2004.
Crippling Wildlife Protections - Cuts to the Fish and Wildlife Service, National Oceanic and
Atmospheric Administration, and Army Corps of Engineers would hamper salmon restoration in
the Pacific Northwest, shut down wildlife refuges, and halt efforts to restore endangered species.
Raising the Risk 0/ Deadly Wildfires - FY 2000 cuts to the Forest Service and Bureau of Land
Management would close some lands to the public and reduce firefighting capabilities. A total of
$700 million in FY 2004 cuts for these two agencies would cripple firefighting capabilities,
jeopardizing lives and property throughout the West.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Republican Budget
Shortchanges Education and Training
March 19, 1999
Building on the success of six years of fiscal discipline and the virtuous economic cycle it created,
President Clinton has proposed a budget that includes a more than $3.4 trillion debt reduction lock-box
that extends the solvency of Social Security until 2055 and extends Medicare's solvency for more than a
decade. The President's budget continues to place top priority on investments in education, including:
Performance Accountability: $200 million in Title I to hold States and school districts more
accountable for raising student achievement.
21st Century Community Learning Centers/After-School and Summer School Programs:
$600 million for the 21 st Century/After-School program, an increase of $400 million over the FY
1999 level to help schools end social promotion through extended learning time.
New Qualified Teachers and Smaller Class Sizes: $1.4 billion as the second installment of the
President's plan to help schools recruit, hire, and train 100,000 new teachers by 2005 and reduce
class size in the early grades.
Tax Credits to Build Modern Schools for Our Children. A centerpiece of the President's tax
cut agenda is to provide Federal tax credits to support nearly $25 billion in bonds to build and
renovate public schools at a cost of $3.7 billion over 5 years.
_ A $963 Million Three-Part Initiative To Close America's Skills Gap: 1) $190 million
increase for adult education and family literacy initiative. 2) $368 Million increase for a
universal re-employment initiative. 3) $405 million increase for a youth employment initiative.
Expanding Head Start: A $607 million increase that will add 42,000 new slots for young
children, including 7,000 Early Head Start slots, for total emollment of 877,000 and on track to
meet the one million participation goal by 2002.
The Republicans have responded with a proposal that puts top priority on a tax cut which explodes in cost
and is targeted away from the middle class. Republicans have talked about making education a higher
priority, but the actions in this budget are in the other direction. Because the tax cut is so large and
consumes the entire on-budget surplus, the funds available for critical investments in education would be
squeeze dramatically.
The Republican budget would require a more than 10 percent cut in 2000 and over 20 percent cut
in 2004 unprotected discretionary programs. This would have a devastating impact on critical
education, training, and other programs for children:
Head Start funding would be less than FY 1998 levels, a reduction of $1.1 billion from the FY 2000
Budget. . A reduction of this magnitude would roll back all expansion progress made under the
Clinton Administration, cutting services to up to 100,000 children, and making it practically
impossible to reach the goal of serving one million children in Head Start by 2002. By 2004, Head
Start emollment would drop below FY 1999 levels by over 230,000 children.
Work Study would be cut by $106 million from the FY 1999 level of$870 million, to the lowest
level since FY 1996. The number of students served would decrease by 112,000, from 930,000 in FY
1999. If the Republican plan were assumed to continue through FY 2004, over a quarter of a million
fewer students (257,000) would have the chance to work their way through college than in FY 1999.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
•
•
TRIO funding would decrease by $73 million, from $600 million in FY 1999. As a result,
approximately 117,000 fewer students would receive college preparation and support services in FY
2000 than in FY 1999. By FY 2004, the Republican plan would cut 224,000 disadvantaged students
from TRIO programs.
GEAR-UP would be reduced $15 million, from $120 million in FY 1999. This funding level would
not be sufficient to fund non-competing continuation awards from FY 1999. Approximately 5,900
fewer low-income students would receive early intervention services in FY 2000 than in FY 1999.
The Republican plan would further cut GEAR-UP so that more than 36,000 fewer students would
receive services in FY 2004 than in FY 1999.
.•
Dislocated Worker Assistance would be cut by $171 million below FY 1999, denying training, job
search assistance, and support services to about 90,200 dislocated workers. In FY 2004, the
Republican plan would deny services to over 205,600 dislocated workers.
About 73,100 training and summer job opportunities for low-income youth would be eliminated.
In FY 2004, about 166,000 low-income youth would be denied training and summer job
opportunities.
•
This reduction could terminate Jobs Corps' planned 4-center expansion and/or force Job Corps to
close 5-6 other centers in 2000. This could eliminate about 5,000 residential training slots for
extremely disadvantaged youth in 2000. In 2004, this could result in over 11,000 students being
denied the opportunity to participate in Job Corps.
The Child Care and Development Block Grant (CCDBG) would be reduced by $122 million,
eliminating child care assistance for up to 34,000 low-income children. By 2004, the number of
children receiving assistance would drop below FY 1999 levels by up to 79,000 children.
WIC funding would be cut to below FY 1995 levels, a reduction of over $480 million from the FY
1999 level of$3.9 billion, eliminating nutrition assistance for over 875,000 low income women,
infants, and children each month. Furthermore, if the Republican plan were assumed to continue
through FY 2004, funding for the program would be reduced by $1.1 billion below the FY 1999
funding level, cutting approximately 1.9 million participants from the program.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 22-MAR-1999 15:10:21.00
SUBJECT:
George will and equal pay
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena. Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
George will has a column in today's Newsweek saying the equal pay figures
are "lies" and quoting Furchtgott-Roth and Stolba.
It is an argument we
have had in the past, but will now be raised more prominently and with
academic support.
Could you at CEA take a look at the column and propose
a fact-based rebuttal to Will's assertion: the wage gap is small,
voluntary and doesn't require government involvement.
Thanks.
�Page 1 of 1
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-MAR-1999 11:06:34.00
SUBJECT:
Furchtgott-Roth & Stolba book
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Tom & Elena -- the Furchtgott-Roth and Stolba book "Women's Figures" is
having a big press event today at AEI.
(This is the book George will
wrote about in his column last week, which ridicules the idea of a gender
pay gap.)
I suspect this means there will be more articles and press
attention over the week.
I really think we need to respond to this
publicly in some way.
Have you guys talked about this at DPC? How about
an editorial somewhere, at a minimum? Let's chat about this, if it seems
useful.
Becky
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 15
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES
~IL)
CREATOR: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-MAR-1999 12:51:12.00
SUBJECT:
Updated Welfare Reform Accomplishments
TO: Beach-Benjamin ( Beach-Benjamin @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Heyman-Stephen ( Heyman-Stephen @ dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mastrand ( Mastrand @ opm.gov @ inet
READ: UNJ(NOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: mkharfen ( mkharfen @ acf.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: pbravo ( pbravo @ acf.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: zina.pierre
READ: UNKNOWN
zina.pierre @ sba.gov @ inet
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Daniel I. Werfel ( CN=Daniel I. Werfel/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: pruggles ( pruggles @ osaspe.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: dahm-emily ( dahm-emily @ dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: kamela-william ( kamela-william @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: art_foley ( art_foley @ fcs.usda.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: corine.hegland ( corine.hegland @ ost.dot.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: deborah_greenstein ( deborah_greenstein @ hud.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: michael.barr ( michael.barr @ ms01.do.treas.sprint.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: betsy.myers ( betsy.myers @ sba.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: nancy_kirshner-rodriguez ( nancy_kirshner-rodriguez @ hud.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: ljenning ( ljenning @ dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dario J. Gomez ( CN=Dario J. Gomez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of 15
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew R. Feldman ( CN=Andrew R. Feldman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [' CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William H. White Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( cN=william H. White Jr./OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: YAMIN_S ( YAMIN S @ Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(OMB)
TO: Barbara D. woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO, 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph C. Fanaroff ( CN=Joseph C. Fanaroff/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: efurd-laura ( efurd-laura @ dol.gov [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen_J. Yank ( Stephen_J._Yank @ hud.gov [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: edahl ( edahl @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Ahyman ( Ahyman @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: eparker ( eparker @ acf.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Lori Schack ( CN=Lori Schack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: cpian ( cpian @ osaspe.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: xavier_briggs ( xavier_briggs @ hud.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: bonny_o'neil ( bonny_o'neil @ fcs.usda.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
john_f._bohm @ hud.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of 15
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: linda. lawson ( linda. lawson @ ost.dot.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: irma. tucker ( irma. tucker @ treas.sprint.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: uhalde-raymond ( uhalde-raymond @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JMONAHAN ( JMONAHAN @ ACF.DHHS.GOV @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: dana.colarulli
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN]
( dana.colarulli @ sba.gov @ inet
TO: Charles M. Brain (
READ: UNKNOWN
C~=Charles
[ UNKNOWN]
)
)
)
[ UNKNOWN]
)
M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
TO: Anil Kakani ( CN=Anil Kakani/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Robert F. Schoeni ( CN=Robert F. Schoeni/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lee Ann Brackett ( CN=Lee Ann Brackett/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Chandler G. Spaulding ( CN=Chandler G. Spaulding/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: J. Eric Gould ( CN=J. Eric Gould/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Here's updated document for your use -- it's also posted on White House
welfare reform web site
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to ,convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D87]MAIL452556994.036 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043BA060000010A02010000000205000000AD680000000200000D23A865B05E74DDF7296E
IB5674C72BFF03280EAF2A215F85A9BAAD025E73CA2F56C41BFOB5E58A46AE5IFBE8FCDDD8B6C9
972C505BID7239D26E90F3B19D8EF5C9B8124CF7CEA1394EB437F7A4A168D811C99DE9EDDB5AOE
OE632AC754522301DA73F8698E5EF761D460CBFB9DIDFFA450083849AA67EBBOA242677DF6D9C8
90D037B907FDAC3D32069C274E77594E78CAD697E849AD3FFIC7ABB25AEF8C5D20DB65BDE779CB
)
�03/23/99
CLINTON-GORE ACCOMPLISHMENTS
REFORMING WELFARE
On August 22, 1996, President Clinton signed the Personal Responsibility and
Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act, fulfilling his longtime commitment to 'end
welfare as we know it. ' As the President said upon signing, "". this legislation
provides an historic opportunity to end welfare as we know it and transform our
broken welfare system by promoting the fondamental values of work,
responsibility, and family. "
TRANSFORMING THE BROKEN WELFARE SYSTEM
•
Overhauling the Welfare System with the Personal Responsibility Act: In 1996, the
President signed a bipartisan welfare plan that is dramatically changing the nation's
welfare system into one that requires work in exchange for time-limited assistance. The
law contains strong work requirements, performance bonuses to reward states for moving
welfare recipients into jobs and reducing illegitimacy, state maintenance of effort
requirements, comprehensive child support enforcement, and supports for families
moving from welfare to work -- including increased funding for child care. State
strategies are making a real difference in the success of welfare reform, specifically in
job placement, child care and transportation.
Law Builds on the Administration's Welfare Reform Strategy: Even before the.
Personal Responsibility Act became law, many states were well on their way to changing
their welfare programs to jobs programs. By granting Federal waivers, the Clinton
Administration allowed 43 states -- more than all previous Administrations combined -to require work, time-limit assistance, make work pay, improve child support
enforcement, and encourage parental responsibility. The vast majority of states have
chosen to continue or build on their welfare demonstration projects approved by the
Clinton Administration.
Welfare Rolls Decline as More Recipients go to Work: In January 1999, the President
released state-by-state data (from September 1998) showing that welfare caseloads are at
their lowest level in 30 years and that the welfare rolls have fallen by nearly half since he
took office. Since January 1993, 36 states have had caseload declines of more than 40
percent and nationwide the rolls have fallen by 44 percent, from 14.1 million to just
below 8 million. This historic decline occurred in response to the Administration's
grants of Federal waivers to 43 states, the provisions ofthe new welfare reform law, and
the strong economy. Recent information released by the Department of Health and
Human Services also shows that the percentage of welfare recipients working has tripled
since 1992, that an estimated 1.5 million people who were on welfare in 1997 were
working in 1998, and that all states met the first overall work participation rates required
under the welfare reform law.
�Automated Records M.
Hex-Dump Canagement SYste
MOVING PEOPLE FROM WELFARE TO WORK
on version
m
•
Mobilizing the Business Community: At the President's urging, the Welfare to Work
Partnership was launched in May 1997 to lead the national business effort to hire people
from the welfare rolls. Founded with 105 participating businesses, the Partnership grew
to 5,000 within one year, and in his 1999 State of the Union address, the President
announced that the Partnership now inCludes over 10,000 businesses who have hired
hundreds of thousands of people. Since 1997, these businesses have hired over 410,000
welfare recipients, more than meeting the challenge the President set in May of 1998. The
Partnership provides technical assistance and support to businesses around the country,
including: a toll-free number, a web site, a quarterly newsletter, and a "Blueprint for
Business" hiring manual. The Partnership also published The Road to Retention, a
report of companies that have found higher retention rates for former welfare recipients
for other new hires, and strategies they used to achieve this success.
•
Connecting Small Businesses with New Workers: The Small Business Administration
is addressing the unique and vital role of small businesses who employ over one-half of
the private workforce, by helping small businesses throughout the country connect with
job training organizations and job-ready welfare recipients. In addition, SBA provides
training and assistance to welfare recipients who wish to start their own businesses.
SBA provides assistance to businesses through its 1-800-U-ASK-SBA number, as well
through its network of small business and women's business centers, one-stop capital
shops, district offices, and its home page.
•
Mobilizing Civic, Religious and Non-profit Groups: The Vice President created the
Welfare to Work Coalition to Sustain Success, a coalition of national civic, seryice, and
faith-based groups committed to helping former welfare recipients succeed in the
workforce. Working in part~ership with public agencies and employers, Coalition
members provide mentoring, job training, child care, transportation, and other support to
help these new workers with the transition to self sufficiency. Charter members of the
Coalition include: Alpha Kappa Alpha, the Boys and Girls Clubs of America, the Baptist
Joint Committee, Goodwill, Salvation Army, the United Way, Women's Missionary
Union, the YMCA, the YWCA, and other civic and faith-based groups.
•
Doing Our Fair Share with the Federal Government's Hiring Initiative: Under the
Clinton Administration, the Federal workforce is the smallest it has been in thirty years.
Yet, this Administration also believes that the Federal government, as the nation's largest
employer, must lead by example. The President asked the Vice President to oversee the
Federal government's hiring initiative in which Federal agencies have committed to
directly hire at least 10,000 welfare recipients in the next four years. On March I st, the
Vice President announced that the federal government has hired over 10,000 welfare
recipients nearly two years ahead of schedule. As a part of this effort, the White House
pledged to hire six welfare recipients and has already exceeded this goal.
•
Funds to Help Move More People from Welfare to Work, with a Focus on Fathers:
Because of the President's leadership, the 1997 Balanced Budget Act included the total
funding requested by the President for the creation of his $3 billion welfare to work fund.
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
This program helps states and local communities move long-tenn welfare recipients, and
certain non-custodial parents, into lasting, unsubsidized jobs_ These funds can be used for
job creation, job placement and job retention efforts, including wage subsidies to private
employers and other critical post-employment support services. The Department of
Labor provides oversight but most of the dollars are placed, through the Private Industry
Councils, in the hands of the localities who are on the front lines of the welfare refonn
effort. In addition, 25 percent of the funds are awarded by the Department of Labor on
a competitive basis to support innovative welfare to work projects. The President
announced the first round of 49 competitive grants in May, and the Vice President
announced the second round of75 competitive grants in November 1998. In January
1999, the Department of Labor announced the availability of $240 million in competitive
grants for FY 1999. These funds will support innovative local welfare-to-work strategies
for noncustodial parents, individuals with limited English proficiency, disabilities,
substance abuse pro~lems, or a history of domestic violence.
The President's FY 2000 budget includes $1 billion for the Welfare-to-Work program to
help 200,000 long-tenn welfare recipients in high-poverty areas move into lasting
unsubsidized employment. This is an extension of the two-year $3 billion
Welfare-to-Work program the President secured in the Balanced Budget Act. The
initiative, as reauthorized, will provide at least $150 million to ensure that every state helps
fathers fulfill their responsibilities by working, paying child support, and playing a
responsible part in their children's lives. Under this proposal, states and communities
will use a minimum of 20 percent of their fonnula funds to provide job placement and job
retention assistance to low-income fathers who sign personal responsibility contracts
committing them to work and pay child support. This effort will further increase child
support collections, which have risen 80 percent since the President took office, from $8
billion in 1992 to $14.4 billion in 1998. Remaining funds will go toward assisting
long-tenn welfare recipients with the greatest barriers to employment to move into lasting
jobs. The reauthorized program also will double the welfare-to-work funding available
for tribes.
•
Tax Credits for Employers: The Welfare to Work Tax Credit, enacted in the 1997
. Balanced Budget Act, provides a credit equal to 35 percent of the first $10,000 in wages
in the first year of employment, and 50 percent of the first $10,000 in wages in the second
year, to encourage the hiring and retention of long tenn welfare recipients. This credit
complements the Work Opportunity Tax Credit, which provides a credit of up to $2,400
for the first year of wages for eight groups of job seekers. The Omnibus Budget Act
included an extension through June 30, 1999 and the President's FY 2000 budget
proposes to extend both credits for an additional year.
•
Welfare-to-Work Housing Vouchers: In his FY 1999 budget, the President proposed
$283 million for 50,000 new housing vouchers for welfare recipients who need housing
assistance to get or keep ajob, and Congress approved full funding for this new initiative.
Families will use these housing vouchers to move closer to a new job, to reduce a long
commute, or to secure more stable housing to eliminate emergencies that keep them from
getting to work every day on time. Nearly all of these vouchers will be awarded to
communities on a competitive basis, to communities who create cooperative efforts
among their housing, welfare and employment agencies to assure the most effective use
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
of this flexible new tool to help people make the transition from welfare to work. The
President's FY 2000 budget provides $430 million for 75,000 welfare-to-work vouchers,
including $144 million in new funds for 25,000 additional vouchers.
•
Welfare-to-Work Transportation: One ofthe biggest barriers facing people who
move from welfare to work -- in cities and in rural areas -- is finding transportation to get
to jobs, training programs and child care centers. Few welfare recipients own cars.
Existing mass transit does not provide adequate links to many suburban jobs at all, or
within a reasonable commute time. In addition, many entry level jobs require evening or
weekend hours that are poorly served by existing transit routes. To help those on welfare
get to work, President Clinton proposed a $100 million a year welfare to work
transportation plan as part of his ISTEA reauthorization bill. The Transportation Equity
Act for the 21st Century (TEA-21) authorized $750 million over five years for the
President's initiative and reverse commute grants. Of this amount, $50 million is
guaranteed funding in FY 1999, rising to $150 million in 2003. The Omnibus Budget Act
included $75 million for this program in FY 1999 and the Department of Transportation
is currently reviewing applications for this first year funding. The President's budget
proposes to double funding for FY 2000, bringing it to the full authorized level of $150
million. The Job Access competitive grants will assist states and localities in developing
flexible transportation alternatives, such as van services, for welfare recipients and other
low income workers.
•
Eliminating Anti-Work and Anti-FamiJy Rules that Denied Families Health Coverage: In
August 1998, the President eliminated a vestige of the old welfare system by announcing
that the Department of Health and Human Services will revise its regulations to allow all
states to provide Medicaid coverage to working, two-parent families who meet State
income eligibility. Under the old welfare regulations, adults in two-parent families who
worked more than 100 hours per month could not receive Medicaid regardless of income
level, while there were no such restrictions on single-parent families. Because these
regulations provided disincentives to marriage and full-time work, the Administration
allowed a number of states to waive this rule. The new regulation eliminates this rule
for all States, providing health coverage for more than 130,000 working families to help
them stay employed and off welfare.
PROMOTING PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY
•
Enforcing Child Support -- 80% Increase in Collections: The Clinton Administration
collected a record $14.4 billion in child support in 1998 through tougher enforcement, an
increase of$6.4 billion, or 80% since 1992. Not only are collections up, but the number
of families that are actually receiving child support has also increased. In 1997, the
number of child support cases with collections rose to 4.2 million, an increase of 48%
fom 2.8 million in 1992. In addition, a new collection system proposed by the President
in 1994 and enacted as part of the 1996 welfare reform law located one million
delinquent parents in its first nine months of operation. This National Directory of New
Hires helps track parents across state lines by enabling child support officials to match
records of delinquent parents with wage records from throughout the nation.
Approximately one-third of all child support cases involve parents living in different
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
states. In June 1998, the President signed the Deadbeat Parents Punishment Act, a law
based on his 1996 proposal for tougher penalties for parents who repeatedly fail to
support children living in another state or who flee across state lines to avoid supporting
them. This new law creates two new felonies, with penalties of up to two years in
prison, for egregious child support evaders who travel across state or country lines to
evade child support obligations, or who have an unpaid obligation to a child living in
another state that is more than $10,000 or has remained unpaid for more than two years.
Increasing Parental Responsibility: The President's unprecedented and sustained
campaign to ensure parents financially support their children is working. Paternity
establishment, often the crucial first step in child support cases, has dramatically
increased, due in large part to the in-hospital voluntary paternity establishment program
begun in 1994 by the Clinton Administration. In 1997, the number of paternities
established or acknowledged rose to a record 1.3 million, two and a half times the 1992
figure of 512,000. In addition to tougher enforcement including a strong partnership
with states, President Clinton has taken executive action including: directing the Treasury
Department to collect past-due child support from Federal payments including Federal
income tax refunds and employee salaries, and taking steps to deny Federal loans to any
delinquent parents. The Federal government collected over $1.1 billion in delinquent
child support from federal income tax refunds for tax year 1997, a 70 percent increase
since 1992. The welfare reform law contains tough child support measures that President
Clinton has long supported including: the national new hire reporting system; streamlined
paternity establishment; uniform interstate child support laws; computerized state-wide
collections; and tough new penalties. These five measures are projected to increase child
support collections by an additional $24 billion over the next ten years.
•
Breaking the Cycle of Dependency -- Preventing Teen Pregnancy: Significant
components of the President's comprehensive effort to reduce teen pregnancy became law
when the President signed the 1996 Personal Responsibility Act. The law requires
unmarried minor parents to stay in school and live at home or in a supervised setting;
encourages "second chance homes" to provide teen parents with the skills and support
they need; and provides $50 million a year in new funding for state abstinence education
activities. Since 1993, the Clinton Administration has supported innovative and
promising teen pregnancy prevention strategies, including working with boys and young
men on pregnancy prevention strategies. The National Campaign to Prevent Teen
Pregnancy, a private nonprofit organization, wa!l formed in response to the President's
1995 State of the Union. In 1997, the President announced the National Strategy to
Prevent Teen Pregnancy, mandated in the welfare reform law. The first annual report on
this Strategy reported that HHS-supported programs already reach at least 31 percent or
1,470 communities in the United States. Notably, data shows we are making progress in
reducing teen pregnancy -- teen births have fallen six years in a row, by 15 percent from
1991 to 1997. And, teen pregnancy rates are at their lowest level in 20 years.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
•
RESTORING FAIRNESS AND PROTECTING THE MOST VULNERABLE
The President made a commitment to fix several provisions in the welfare refonn law that had
nothing to do with moving people from welfare to work. In 1997, the President fought for and
ultimately was successful in ensuring that the Balanced Budget Act protects the most vulnerable.
In 1998, the President continued to reverse unfair cuts in benefits to legal immigrants. The
Administration's FY 2000 budget would build on this progress by restoring important disability,
health, and nutrition benefits to additional categories of legal immigrants, at a cost of $1.3 billion
over five years.
•
Disability and Health: The Balanced Budget Act of 1997 restored disability and health
benefits to 420,000 legal immigrants who were in this country before welfare refonn
became law (August 22, 1996), at an estimated cost of $11.5 billion. The
Administration's new budget would restore eligibility for SSI and Medicaid to legal
immigrants who enter the country after that date ifthey have been in the U.S. for five
years and become disabled after entering the United States. This proposal would cost
approximately $930 million and assist an estimated 54,000 legal immigrants by 2004,
about half of whom would be elderly.
•
Nutritional Assistance: The Agricultural Research Act of 1998 provided Food Stamps
for 225,000 legal immigrant children, senior citizens, and people with disabilities who
came to the United States by August 22, 1996. The Administration's budget would
extend this provision by allowing legal immigrants in the United States on August 22,
1996 who subsequently reach age 65 to be eligible for Food Stamps at cost of $60
million.
•
Childrens' Health Care and Maternal Care for Pregnant Women: States currently
can provide health coverage to immigrant children who .entered the country before August
22, 1996. The President's FY 2000 budget would give states the option to provide health
coverage to legal immigrant children who entered the country after August 22, 1996.
Under this proposal, states could provide health coverage to those children through
Medicaid or their CHIP allotment. The proposal would cost $220 million and serve
approximately 55,000 children by FY 2004. Furthennore, the budget proposes to give
states the option to provide Medicaid coverage to legal immigrant women who entered
the country after August 22, 1996 and subsequently became pregnant. Such coverage
would help reduce the number of high-risk pregnancies, ensure healthier children, and
lower the cost of emergency Medicaid deliveries. This proposal would cost $105 million
and serve approximately 23,000 women by FY 2004.
•
Helping PeopJe Who Want to Work but Can't Find a Job:
The Balanced Budget Act
(BBA), as amended by the Agricultural Research Act, also restored $1.3 billion in food
stamp cuts. The welfare refonn law restricted food stamps for able-bodied childless
adults to only 3 out of every 36 months, unless they were working. This move ignored
the fact that finding a job often takes time. The BBA provided funds for work slots and
food stamp benefits to help those who are willing to work but, through no fault of their
own, have not yet found employment. In addition, the BBA allows states to exempt up to
15 percent of the food stamp recipients (70,000 individuals monthly) who would
�otherwise be denied benefits as a result of the "3 in 36" limit.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:31-MAR-1999 13:18:45.00
SUBJECT:
Headsup
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPDl
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Cahill ( CN=Mary E. Cahill/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Stuart Shapiro ( CN=Stuart Shapiro/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Memo was signed on Friday, March 26, 1999.
MEMORANDUM FOR JOHN PODESTA
THROUGH:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Jacob J. Lew
Sylvia Mathews
Don Arbuckle
Heads-Up Clearance of Regulations
Within the next several days we will be clearing four high profile
regulations.
DO
HHS
Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF) final regulation from
We have completed our review of the Department of Health and Human
ServiceD,s (HHSD,) Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (TANF)
regulations on Friday, March 26th. This final rule implements the 1996
welfare reform statute. The TANF rule as proposed in November 1997,
generated significant criticism from States and advocates for poor
families. They argued that the proposal was overly burdensome, discouraged
State innovation, and demonstrated a mistrust of how States will exercise
the discretion that the statute intended to provide.
In response to these
comments, HHS has revised the final rule significantly to increase
flexibility and reduce burden while maintaining accountability.
The final rule will likely receive significant attention.
Reaction is expected to be mostly favorable given the changes from the
NPRM, although the rule could still receive criticism for excessive
requirements on States. A rollout is being planned by DPC for mid-April.
DO
OFHEO Risk Based Capital Regulation
OMB completed its review of the Office of Federal Housing
Enterprise Oversight Risk-Based Capital Regulation for Fannie Mae and
Freddie Mac on Thursday, March 25th. The rule was sent to the. Hill
Friday afternoon, March 26th. At about the same time, OFHEO issued a
press release.
Congress will have 15 calendar days to comment on the rule
before it is published in the Federal Register and the public will have
120 days after that to comment on the proposed rule.
The rule specifies the risk-based capital stress test that will
determine the amount of capital each Enterprise is required to hold to
maintain positive capital throughout a ten-year period of economic
stress. There is great interest in Congress and the financial community
in seeing the proposed rule and determining its impact on the Enterprises
and mortgages markets.
Fannie Mae has publically expressed concern about
the possible impact on its operations and mortgage markets, while Freddie
Mac has called for its publication.
�ARMS Email System
DO
Workforce Investment Act (WIA) Regulations from DOL
On Thursday, March 25th.OMB completed its review of the Department
of LaborD,s (DOL) interim final regulation implementing the Workforce
Investment Act (WIA) of 1998. Based on the PresidentD,s G.I. Bill for
AmericaD,s Workers proposal, WIA reforms and streamlines the nation's
employment and training system by consolidating numerous publicly funded
job training and employment .programs.
Key WIA reforms include the
development and implementation of a network of one-stop centers that
provides a central point of entry to services, and individual.training
accounts, or vouchers, to finance adult training.
The interim final rule may receive some attention from locally
elected officials who have lobbied DOL for a greater role in the
governance of the system. Also, members of both the minority and majority
on Hill sent a letter to the President (11/24/98) stressing the importance
of coordination between the Federal agencies in providing services though
the one-stop.
In response to this letter, DOL conducted extensive
consultations with its Federal partners and State and locals in developing
this interim final rule, and will continue this consultative process
during WIA implementation, which begins on July 1, 1999. DOL expects to
publish a final rule in December 1999.
DO
DOL D&HelpersD8 Regulation
OMB will be completing its review of the Department of LaborD,s
proposed D&helpersD8 regulation during the early part of the week of
March 29th. The proposed regulation governs the use of semi-skilled
helpers, who assist skilled journeymen on Davis-Bacon construction
projects.
The proposal would place into regulation the DepartmentD,s
current policy of strictly limiting the use of helpers. This issue has
been the subject of Congressional riders and court decisions over the past
15 years, which for all but a short period in 1992-93 also had the effect
of strictly limiting the use of helpers on Federal construction contracts.
Please let us know if you have any questions or concerns on any of these
regulations.
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of II
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:31-MAR-1999 16:31:44.00
SUBJECT:
LRM MNB37 - - REVISED LABOR Draft Bill on Alien Labor Certification User F
TO: Robert J. Pellicci ( CN=Robert J. Pellicci/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. Timberlake/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susanne D. Lind
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
CN=Susanne D. Lind/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Rosemarie W. Dale ( CN=Rosemarie W. Dale/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert F. Mahaffie ( CN=Robert F. Mahaffie/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Harry E. Moran ( CN=Harry E. Moran/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: J. Eric Gould ( CN=J. Eric Gould/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Robert F. Schoeni ( CN=Robert F. Schoeni/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James J. Jukes
READ: UNKNOWN
OMB 1 )
( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer E. Brown ( CN=Jennifer E. Brown/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Irene Bueno ( CN=Irene Bueno/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 11
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter Rundlet ( CN=Peter Rundlet/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark J. Schwartz ( CN=Mark J. Schwartz/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah S. Lee ( CN=Sarah S. Lee/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Justine F. Rodriguez ( CN=Justine F. Rodriguez/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM STATE ( LRM STATE [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM TREASURY ( LRM TREASURY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM COMMERCE ( LRM COMMERCE [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
LRM Small Business Administration ( LRM Small Business Administration [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM JUSTICE ( LRM JUSTICE
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TEXT:
NOTE TO EOP STAFF: YOU WILL NOT RECEIVE A HARD COPY OF THIS LRM.
LRM ID: MNB37
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Wednesday, March 31, 1999
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
SUBJECT:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395-6148
REVISED LABOR Draft Bill on Alien Labor Certification
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of 11
User Fees
DEADLINE:
1 p.m.
Friday, April 2, 1999
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: The deadline is firm.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - Dennis Burke - (202) 514-2141
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - ,(202) 622-0650
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin 114-STATE - Paul Rademacher - (202) 647-4463
EOP:
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Andrea Kane
Cordelia W. Reimers
Robert F. Schoeni
Justine F. Rodriguez
J. Eric Gould
Elena Kagan
Harry E. Moran
Sarah S. Lee
Karen Tramontano
Mark J. Schwartz
Robert F. Mahaffie
Peter Rundlet
Rosemarie W. Dale
Irene Bueno
Susanne D. Lind
Robert G. Damus
Jennifer E. Brown
David J. Haun
Steven M. Mertens
Courtney B. Timberlake
Janet R. Forsgren
James J. Jukes
LRM ID: MNB37
SUBJECT:
Certification User Fees
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
REVISED LABOR
(202) 205-6700
Draft Bill on Alien Labor
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of 11
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of
pages, attached to this response sheet
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D43]MAIL44905230S.136 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043CF040000010A02010000000205000000353C0000000200003B504153E056BB3909224F
COF82CC5AC039BB246305270212A2EOBCD7435504E61FC6933301D01150BC90D435BEB2F7328DO
972851E88DA346E14204A2195B711E29D9B56857573C7C7C5EC2Dl22FFEBFDC55135B~93697144
50B537F30F3E10960ED25D5368AA60813C5952F28A8081FOAA332F5460A3COEFD13B7D5EB38B39
27B1B372AB12793126C703E53A23CB5A5B74F584575C4D6262DF4AB39DE1D95441F352F890BCE1
23811F4D797FCA3DB630C5536415BC3FECE59D98618996AFFEA8B3BE09EOCF15B8DOC972BFAA56
1COOB2CADA5F8FC9407EAE28162296534F5CEA463DCAF6B5298546CEA710C23F9112333B15E2F3
440B33Al12547BEA322EEE53EB38725FADC3F6BC184C10DC6DFD639BCDB98EC49768887DC82640
A5A7C4F19EBACE43E86AE121497FBB41354F8EB06CA985B23ECFD850407225DC4CD715C36D40C1
43FC26FC6565B8237752C76321DBE8C46CBOD5DOF65D3359E29F5580852FEABBC750E4701A617F
CB76B7E6786CD04B85EEODC201313D969187FE044ACFFF9CD33FBD3B8869D9258CB283FD12C212
978D1D544BEBC5AA1854296946E95C6CB52720946D4A10560B726E6262B06C605FCE25AB54C73C
AB7348A59969C206BC20DOA4B62FFA4086A05A968ADB43AE3F3D80708ACE3C9D45D1F9B9778000
0144B4C7BE02000C000000000000000000000008230100000021010000A8020000005501000000
4EOOOOOOC903000009250100000006000000170400000B3002000000280000001D040000087701
000000400000004504000008340100000014000000850400000802010000000F00000099040000
084E0100000002000000A8040000085E010000000COOOOOOAA04000008100100000002000000B6
040000096D0100000017000000B804000000980000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
DRAFT 3/31/99
SUBTITLE G-- ALIEN LABOR CERTIFICATION USER FEES
SEC.
ESTABLISHMENT OF FEES.
(a) PERMANENT IMMIGRANT APPLICATION FEES.-- Section 212(a)(5)(A) of the
Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1182(a)(5)(A) is amended-(1) in clause (i), by-(A) striking "and" at the end of subclause (I),
(B) striking the period at the end of subclause (II) and inserting ", and",
and
(C) by adding at the end the following:
"(III) the employer has submitted an application for certification of
the alien under this paragraph and has paid an application fee in
accordance with clause (iv)."; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
"(iv)(I) The Secretary of Labor shall impose a fee of$500 on an employer
that-"(aa) submits an application to the Secretary of Labor for
certification under this subparagraph on or after October 1, 1999, or
"(bb) requests that the Secretary of Labor review an application
1
�Automated Records Management Sysfem
Hex·Dump Conversion
that was submitted to the Secretary of Labor for certification under this
subparagraph prior to October 1, 1999, using the same review procedures
applicable to applications submitted under sub-subclause (aa).
"(II)(aa) The employer submitting the application under this subparagraph
shall not require or accept payment, directly or indirectly, of the fees established
pursuant to subclause (I) by the alien who is the beneficiary of the certifioation.
"(bb) If the Secretary of Labor determines, after notice and opportunity for
a hearing, that a violation of sub-subclause (aa) has occurred, the Secretary of
Labor may impose a civil penalty in an amount not to exceed $1,000 per violation
and an administrative order requiring the return of any amounts received in
violation of sub-subclause (aa) to the alien, or if the alien cannot be located, to the
general fund of the Treasury.
"(III) Fees collected under this clause shall be deposited in the Treasury in
accordance with section 286(u).".
(b) H-2B NONIMMIGRANT APPLICATION FEES.-- Section 214(c) of the Immigration
and Nati<;mality Act (8 U.S.C. 1184(c» is amended by adding at the end the following:
"(10)(A) Pursuant to the consultation process described in paragraph (1), the
Secretary of Labor shall impose a fee of $500 on employers that submit an application to
the Secretary of Labor for certification of a nonimmigrant temporary worker as described
In
section 101 (a)(15)(H)(ii)(b) on or after October 1,1999.
"(B)(i) The employer submitting the application under this subsection shall not
require or accept payment of the fee established under subparagraph (A), directly or indirectly, by
2
�Automated Records Management Systerp
Hex-Dump Conversion
the alien who is the beneficiary of the certification.
"(ii) If the Secretary of Labor detennines, after notice and opportunity for a
hearing, that a violation of clause (i) has occurred, the Secretary of Labor may impose a civil
penalty in an amount not to exceed $1,000 per violation and administrative order requiring the
return of any amounts received in violation of clause (i) to the alien, or if the alien cannot be
located, to the general fund ofthe Treasury.
"(C) Fees collected under this paragraph shall be deposited in the Treasury in
accordance with section 286(u).".
SEC.
. ESTABLISHMENT OF ACCOUNT AND USE OF FUNDS.
Section 286 of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1356) is amended by
adding at the end the following:
"(u) ALIEN LABOR CERTIFICATION USER FEE ACCOUNT.
"(1) ESTABLISHMENT.-- There is established in the general fund of the
Treasury a separate account, which shall be known as the 'Alien Labor Certification User Fee
Account'. Notwithstanding any other section of this title, there shall be deposited as offsetting
receipts into the account all fees collected under sections 212(a)(5)(A) and 214(c)(1O).
"(2) USE OF FEES.-- The fees deposited into the Alien Labor
Certification User Fee Account shall be used by the Secretary of Labor for the costs of
administering alien labor certification activities, including the costs of enforcement, under
sections 212(a)(5)(A) and 214(c)(10). In addition, if, in any fiscal year, the Secretary of Labor
detennines that there are amounts in the account in excess of the amounts necessary to carry out
3
�Automated Records Management Systen"
Hex-Dump Conversion
the certification activities for such year, the Secretary of Labor may use the excess amounts to
carry out activities for dislocated workers in accordance section 171 (d) of the Workforce
Investment Act of 1998.
"(3) A VAILABILITY
O~
FUNDS.-- The fees deposited into the Alien
Labor Certification User Fee account under this subsection shall remain available until expended
for the activities described in paragraph (2).".
4
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
DRAFT 3/31/99
STATEMENT IN EXPLANATION OF SUBTITLE G
ALIEN LABOR CERTIFICATION USER FEES
This subtitle would require the Secretary of Labor to impose a fee of $500 on employers
submitting applications for certification of aliens for permanent employment or for H-2B
temporary visas (i.e. visas for temporary employment in occupations other than agriculture,
logging, or registered nursing). A similar $500 fee was established for employers submitting
petitions for H-1B temporary visas (i.e. visas for employment in "specialty" occupations) last
year under the American Competitiveness and Workforce Improvement Act.
For aliens to be eligible for permanent employment or H-2B temporary employment, the
Secretary must certify, pursuant to an application submitted by an employer, that there are not
sufficient workers available at the place the alien is to be employed and that the employment
would not adversely affect the wages or working conditions of similarly employed workers in the
u.S. Currently, the administrative costs of the Secretary of Labor in carrying out these labor
certification activities are funded from appropriations out of general revenues and employers are
not charged a fee for the processing of the application. However, since employers significantly
benefit from the admission of these workers, it is appropriate that they assist in paying for these
activities.
This subtitle would provide that the Secretary of Labor is to charge a fee of $500 for
applications for permanent immigrants submitted on or after October 1, 1999. In addition,
employers who have filed an application prior to that date would be able to receive a review of
that application under the same procedures used to review the applications submitted on or after
October 1 if they pay a $500 fee. The Department of Labor is currently developing and will be
implementing a new, streamlined adjudicative process for certification of applications for
permanent workers, and this provision would offer employers with pending applications the
option of using the streamlined process. The Secretary would also be required to charge a $500
fee for applications for H-2B temporary nonimmigrant labor certifications submitted on or after
October 1, 1999.
The fees collected under this authority would be deposited as offsetting receipts into a
special account in the U.S. Treasury. These funds would be available to the Secretary to, first,
pay the costs of administering the labor certification process, including enforcement activities.
Amounts in the account in excess of the amount needed in any fiscal year for administration
would be available to the Secretary to carry out projects to assist dislocated workers in
accordance with provisions of the Workforce Investment Act of 1998 (WIA). This additional use
offunds is appropriate as a means for providing American workers who have lost their jobs with
training and other assistance needed to obtain reemployment and for reducing the need for the
5
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
admission of additional aliens to fill these jobs.
Specifically, this subtitle contains two sections. The first section provides for the
establishment of the fees.
Subsection (a) applies to fees relating to applications for labor certification of permanent
immigrants. Paragraph (1) amends section 212(a)(5)(A) of the Immigration and Nationality Act
(INA) to provide that submission of the application and payment of the fee is a condition for
receiving certification. Paragraph (2) further amends this section of the INA by adding a new
clause requiring the Secretary of Labor to impose a fee of$500 on employers submitting
applications for permanent immigrants on or after October 1, 1999, and on employers who
submitted such applications prior to that date who request a review by the Secretary of Labor
using the same review procedures applicable to the later applications. This clause also
prohibits an employer from requiring or accepting payment of the fee by the alien who is the
beneficiary of the certification. The Secretary is authorized to impose a civil penalty of up to
$1000 and order return of the payment to the alien if the Secretary determines that an employer
has violated this prohibition. In addition, this clause provides that the fees are to be deposited
into a special account in the U.S. Treasury.
Subsection (b) applies to H-2B nonimmigrant labor certification application fees. This
provision amends section 214(c) of the INA by adding a new paragraph. The paragraph provides
that the Secretary of Labor is to impose a fee of $500 on employers submitting an application for
certification ofH-2B nonimmigrant temporary employment on or after October 1, 1999. The
paragraph also contains the prohibition against employers requiring or accepting payment of the
fee from an alien who is a beneficiary of the certification and authorizes the Secretary to impose
a civil penalty of up to $1000 on an employer violating the prohibition. The paragraph further
provides that these fees are also to be deposited in the special account in the U.S. Treasury.
The second section of this subtitle relates to the establishment of the special account and
the use of account funds. This section amends section 286 of the INA to add a new subsection.
This new subsection establishes a special account in the general fund of the U.S. Treasury to be
known as the Alien Labor Certification User Fee Account. All fees collected for the labor
certification of permanent immigrant and H-2B temporary nonimmigrants are to be deposited as
offsetting receipts into the account. This subsection further provides that the funds in the account
are to be used by the Secretary of Labor for the costs of administering the labor certifications. In
addition, amounts that the Secretary of Labor determines are in excess of the amount needed for
administration may be used to carry out activities for dislocated workers in accordance with
section 171(d) of the WIA. Finally, this subsection provides that the fees in the account are to
remain available until expended for the authorized activities.
6
�•
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
7
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 5-APR-1999 09:45:25.00
SUBJECT:
My mistake
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
I misunderstood the equal pay issue - there is no question about our not
supporting the Harkin bill - my apologies to all -
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 5-APR-1999 15:16:33.00
SUBJECT:
Reminder--comments on Revised Labor Draft bill on Alien Labor Certificatio
TO: llr@do.treas.gov ( llr@do.treas.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Peter Rundlet ( CN=Peter Rundlet/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert F. Schoeni ( CN=Robert F. Schoeni/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: rademachpr@state.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
(rademachpr@state.gov
TO: justice.lrm ( justice.lrm @ usdoj.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
@ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OA)
TO: Robert F. Mahaffie ( CN=Robert F. Mahaffie/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Justine F. Rodriguez ( CN=Justine F. Rodriguez/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This is a reminder that your comments on the subject draft bill are due.
please provide any comments no later than 10 a.m. Tuesday, April 6th, via
fax (395-6148), e-mail, or phone (395-7887).
If we do not hear from you,
we will assume you have no comments.
Please call if you have any questions.
Thanks!
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 12
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-APR-1999 16:50:15.00
SUBJECT:
LRM MNB39 - - REVISED LABOR Draft Bill on Employer Tax Credit User Fees
TO: Janet R. Forsgren
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Justin D. Sullivan ( CN=Justin D. Sullivan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert F. Mahaffie ( CN=Robert F. Mahaffie/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah S. Lee ( CN=Sarah S. Lee/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: J. Eric Gould ( CN=J. Eric Gould/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer E. Brown ( CN=Jennifer E. Brown/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anil Kakani ( CN=Anil Kakani/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter Rundlet ( CN=Peter Rundlet/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 12
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Harry E. Moran ( CN=Harry E. Moran/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Elena Kagan/Ou=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/o=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carole Kitti ( CN=Carole Kitti/ou=OMB/o=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry white/Ou=OMB/o=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow
READ:UNKNOWN
CN=Barbara Chow/ou=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
Karen DORSEY ( Karen DORSEY
READ: UNKNOWN
UNKNOWN 1 )
LRM TREASURY ( LRM TREASURY
READ: UNKNOWN
UNKNOWN 1 )
LRM JUSTICE ( LRM JUSTICE [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM HHS ( LRM HHS
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
Sondra Wallace ( Sondra Wallace [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Kenneth CLARK ( Kenneth CLARK [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM COMMERCE
READ:UNKNOWN
LRM COMMERCE [ UNKNOWN 1 )
LRM Small Business Administration ( LRM Small Business Administration [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This is a slightly revised version of the draft bill that was previously
circulated (LRM MNB24).
In addition to the revised bill, Labor has
provided answers to the questions that were included in OMB's passback.
Note to EOP staff: you will not receive a hard copy of this LRM.
The
attachments are approximately 5 pages total.
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 04/06199
04:44 PM --------------------------LRM ID: MNB39
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Tuesday, April 6, 1999
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of 12
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
SUBJECT:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202)395-7887 FAX: (202)395-6148
REVISED LABOR Draft Bill on Employer Tax Credit User Fees
DEADLINE:
3 p.m. Wednesday, April 7, 1999
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS:
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
52-HEALTH & HUMAN SERVICES - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690~7760
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
61-JUSTICE - Dennis Burke - (202) 514-2141
EOP:
Barbara Chow
Sandra Yamin
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Carole Kitti
Cynthia A. Rice
Andrea Kane
J. Eric Gould
Elena Kagan
Cordelia W. Reimers
Harry E. Moran
Sarah S. Lee
Karen Tramontano
Robert F. Mahaffie
Joseph J. Minarik
Sarah Rosen
Charles R. Marr
Robert G. Damus
,Peter Rundlet
Jack A. Smalligan
Anil Kakani
Justin D. Sullivan
Jennifer E. Brown
Janet R. Forsgren
LRM ID: MNB39
SUBJECT:
User Fees
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
REVISED LABOR
Draft Bill on Employer Tax Credit
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of12
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
- Wotcqna.wpd==================== ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
1 ====================
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D40]MAIL42065190U.136 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043C9040000010A0201000000020500000004300000000200OOA0965B156378CA22D50594
ADC9CEF24180FOA2C5E34C28194B1721550A1A30E5D5C46BAEE042465269991E5DE208BA218693
47910FDDB61E21E6A474231FD5C2EED350F25E1FAOE14BAB3B3E52BF05DE4D96FA4462B04AAF5B
05615CF7E56A9CEAOABF8D45CAD1C9FDECEABOF2CC510FFAFOA5E7B265EBA171759937A59E157E
06997504F8E7D9D29FB16107A13F37E239CBAAABECC9BF75E2EFEEBD3E2FFFC879174F6710334D
C70EEB5269FA691155EEE2143DA49B1E53C63BED23575E401617E26738DE5F243D05C8B4BAFEAD
5BE8E4CC3B49442E733A63DABAA5B5D72BB0129987FEC6EBF0745580AF39CE4DD6016D9CCD3820
07F3F14205BB8EBBB47E1476841D9Dl1320351A98367254D177800DEA06AF7C641E047C74A6D36
5A02C6D7DC2E72AD2A773EC94F54B499A24815F334F15A6560200320359BE4C046E1EFEC221693
916706DF1AC9D054C6B4C4CBA748E5645C80E152E11A14DF1025FE7F5F28905CA25687C476763F
DA4906A1613072184B1C31BF922815FF053E6031F5D95B09925A5A2A3ECOE1F476CCBBF1E70FBE
D98D05FFA3EEED27BB6E086E6D2F8BA66FBEAB50EFDC9FC1A79B2E408D3D4723200501Al1249FA
�Automated Records Manage~ent Systen"
Hex-Dump Conversion
DRAFT 4/6/99
SUBTITLE H-EMPLOYER TAX CREDIT USER FEES
SEC. WORK OPPORTUNITY CREDIT AND WELFARE-TO-WORK CREDIT USER FEES.
(a) ESTABLISHMENT.- Subject to subsection (e), the Secretary of Labor is authorized
to impose a fee on employers submitting applications for certification of individuals as members
of target groups under sections 51(d)(12) or 51A(d)(1) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 (26
U.S.C. 51(d)(12) and 51A(d)(1», relating to the Work Opportunity Credit and the
Welfare-to-Work Credit, respectively. The fees imposed under this section shall not be paid,
directly or indirectly, by the individual who is the subject of the certification.
(b) AMOUNT OF FEE.-The amount of the fee imposed under this section shall be
determined by the Secretary of Labor based on the Secretary's estimate of the amounts needed
to fully fund the costs of administering the requirements relating to the certification of target
group members under sections 51 and 51A of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 (26 U.S.C. 51
and 51A). The Secretary of Labor is authorized to establish a fee for employers with fewer than
100 employees at an amount that is less than the fee established for employers with 100 or more
employees.
(c) COLLECTION AND DEPOSIT.-The fees imposed under this section shall be
collected by the Secretary of Labor through the designated local agency specified in section
51(d)(11) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 (26 U.S.C. 51 (d)(ll» and deposited as offsetting
receipts in the State Unemployment Insurance and Employment Service Operations account of
the Treasury of the United States.
�Automated Records Management Sysrer.
Hex-Dump Conversion
(d) USE OF FUNDS.-The funds deposited pursuant to subsection (c) shall be available to
the Secretary of Labor to pay the costs of administering the requirements relating to the
certification of individuals as target group members under sections 51 and 51A of the Internal
Revenue Code of 1986 (26 U.S.C. 51 and 51A). The Secretary of Labor shall allocate the funds
. among the States based on the relative workload of the States in processing the certifications.
(e) APPROPRIATIONS ACTION REQUIRED.- The fees authorized under this section
shall be collected and available for obligation only to the extent and in the amount provided in
advance in appropriations acts. The fees are authorized to be appropriated to remain available
until expended ..
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
DRAFT 4/6/99
STATEMENT IN EXPLANATION OF SUBTITLE H
EMPLOYER TAX CREDIT USER FEES
Subtitle H would authorize the Secretary of Labor, subjectto approval provided in
advance in appropriations acts, to impose a fee on employers submitting applications for
certification of individuals as target group members under the Work Opportunity Tax Credit
(WOTC) and the Welfare-to-Work Tax Credit (WtW) programs.
These two employer tax credits are administered by the Secretary of Labor and the
Secretary of the Treasury and allow employers to claim a credit for wages paid to individuals
hired by the employer who are certified as being members of one or more target groups specified
in the law. There are eight target groups specified under the WOTC (e.g., qualified welfare
recipients, qualified veterans) and the one target group oflong-term family assistance recipients
specified under the WtW credit. The Secretary of Labor is responsible for accepting and
processing applications submitted by employers to certify that an individual to be hired is a
member of a target group. Under current law, the Secretary carries out the certification
responsibilities through the State employment security agencies.
Currently, employers are not charged a fee for the processing of the application and the
administrative costs are funded from appropriations out of general revenues. However, since
employers are able to claim significant benefits under these programs, it is appropriate that they
assist in funding these administrative costs. Specifically, employers are able to claim a credit of
up to $2400 for the first $6000 in wages paid to a target group member under the WOTC, up to
$3500 for the first $10,000 in wages paid to a target group member under WtW in the first year
of employment, and up to $5,000 for the first $10,000 paid to the member under WtW in the
second year of employment.
The amount of the fee would be based on the Secretary of Labor's estimate of the amount
necessary to fully fund the administration of the certification process. For example, based on
current information relating to the number of certifications processed and related administrative
costs, the fee would likely be an average of $75 per application if the amount was presently
determined. When weighed against the amounts of the credits, it is unlikely that such a fee would
be a significant burden on employers or deter employer participation in the programs. However,
in order to minimize the burden on small employers, this section would authorize the Secretary to
establish a lower fee for employers with fewer than 100 employees.
The funds collected would be deposited as offsetting receipts in the State Unemployment
Insurance and Employment Service Operations account in the U.S.Treasury (the account that
contains the funds approriated to carry out the current certification activities and other UIIES
activities) and would be available to the Secretary of Labor for the administration of the WOTC
and WtW credit target group certification process. The Secretary of Labor would allocate the
funds among States based on the relative workload of each State. This approach would assist in
providing for a stable source of funding for these administrative activities and in ensuring that
�Automated Records Management SysterHex-Dump Conversion
funds are distributed based on the relative administrative burdens on the States.
This subtitle contains one section with five subsections. Subsection (a) authorizes the
Secretary of Labor to impose the fee on employers submitting the application for certifications
under the WOTC and WtW credit programs and provides that the fee is not to be paid, directly or
indirectly, by the individual who is the subject of the certification.
Subsection (b) provides that the amount of the fee is to be determined by the Secretary of
Labor based on the Secretary's estimate of the amounts necessary to fully fund the certification
. process. In addition, the Secretary is authorized to establish a fee for employers with fewer than
100 employees that is lower than the fee established for larger employers.
Subsection (c) provides that the fee is to be collected by the Secretary of Labor through
the designated local agency under the WOTC (i.e., the State employment security agencies) and
deposited as offsetting receipts in the State Unemployment Insurance and Employment Service
Operations account ofthe U.S. Treasury.
Subsection (d) provides that funds deposited in the account are available to the Secretary
of Labor to pay the costs of administering the certification processes under the WOTC and WtW
credit. The Secretary is to allocate the funds based on the relative workload of the States in
processing the certifications.
Finally, subsection (e) provides that the fees under this section may only be collected and
available for obligation to the extent and in the amounts provided for in advance by
appropriations acts. This subsection also provides that the fees are authorized to be appropriated
to remain available until expended.
�Automated Records Management Syslen
Hex-Dump Conversion
Questions/General Comments on the Legislation:
1.
The draft bill would allow the DOL to charge a lower fee for employers with less
than 50 employees. Why did the Department of Labor choose this cutoff level, as
opposed to a larger one (e.g. 500, as is generally used under other statutes)?
The Department settled upon the threshold of 50 workers since more than 85% of all
employers have a workforce of less than 50 employees. However, the Department is
willing to establish an employer threshold at 100 or fewer workers since employers are
aware that employees are generally covered by the Worker Adjustment and Retraining
Notification (WARN) Act if they have at least 100 employees.
2.
What is the rationale for allowing a smaller fee (as opposed to uniformly
establishing a smaller fee) for small employers? Why not establish a requirement
that the fee be waived or reduced by a certain percentage? A requirement would.
provide more certainty for small businesses.
The Department will establish uniform non-discretionary nationwide fees -- one for
large employers and a significantly reduced fee for small employers.
3
How would the size cutoff pertain to franchises (e.g. fast food restaurants)? Would
they qualify based on the size of the establishment or the size of the parent
company?
Both tax liability and number of employees will determine the applicable fee for a
particular franchisee. In addition, the Department will work with Internal Revenue
Service, to modify IRS Form 8850 to include firm size.
2.
The bill does not state whether the fee would be imposed in cases where an employer
submits an incomplete form.
The entire user fee will be assessed upon the employer request for the tax credit, despite
the submittal of incomplete forms. Since States incur an immediate administrative cost
upon initial receipt ofIRS Form 8850, fragmentary or subsequent payments will inflate
the administrative cost and will minimize the States capacity to efficiently and
effectively manage the tax credit program.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[03/19/1999 – 04/06/1999]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 100 - Folder 001
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/56f4f0cde253acc0c6224e88973f5687.pdf
bf74c6a3ceee75bcb1f7404988d6d1b8
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 099 - FOLDER -011
[02/26/1999-03/15/1999 ]
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 40
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN;Melissa N. Benton/OU;OMB/O;EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-FEB-1999 17:09:44.00
SUBJECT:
LABOR Testimony on S385 Safety Advancement for Employees (SAFE) Act of 199
TO: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN;Janet R. Forsgren/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Kamensky ( CN;John Kamensky/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William H. White Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN;William H. White Jr./OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Daniel LaPlaca ( CN;Daniel LaPlaca/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce D. Long ( CN;Bruce D. Long/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter Rundlet ( CN;Peter Rundlet/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN;John E. Thompson/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN;Kate P. Donovan/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN;Karen Tramontano/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN;Sarah Rosen/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN;Daniel J. Chenok/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN;Sandra Yamin/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James J. Jukes ( CN;James J. Jukes/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO, Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN;Cordelia W. Reimers/OU;CEA/O;EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
·TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN;Richard J. Turman/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah S. Lee ( CN;Sarah S. Lee/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa B. Fairhall ( CN;Lisa
READ: UNKNOWN
B~
Fairhall/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN;Courtney B. Timberlake/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 2 of40
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Caroline R. Fredrickson ( CN=Caroline R. Fredrickson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart Shapiro ( CN=Stuart Shapiro/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: ola ( ola @ opm.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: dodlrs ( dodlrs @ osdgc.osd.mil @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: John T. Carnevale ( CN=John T. Carnevale/OU=ONDCP/O=EOP@EOP [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: cla ( cla @ sba.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@
inet
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: lrm ( lrm @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: valrm ( valrm @ mail.va.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: dot. legislation ( dot.legislation @ ost.dot.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: oshrc ( oshrc @ oshrc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: justice.lrm ( justice.lrm @ usdoj.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OA)
TEXT:
NOTE TO EOP STAFF: YOU WILL NOT RECEIVE A HARD COPY OF THIS LRM.
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 02/26/99
05:04 PM --------------------------Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: MNB22
�Page 3 of40
ARMS Email System
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Friday, February 26,' 1999
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395-6148
SUBJECT:
LABOR Testimony on S385 Safety Advancement for Employees
(SAFE) Act of 1999
DEADLINE:
3 p.m. Monday, March 1, 1999
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: To follow is testimony to be delivered by Labor (Jeffress)
before the Employment, Safety, and Training Subcommittee of Senate Health,
Education, Labor, and Pensions on Thursday, March 4th.
Please note veto threat on p. 4 of the testimony.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - Dennis Burke - (202) 514-2141
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
94-0ccupational Safety & Health Rev Comm - William J. Gainer - (202)
606-5380
89-0ffice of National Drug Control policy - John Carnevale - (202) 395-6736
117 & 340-TRANSPORTATION - Tom Herlihy - (202) 366-4687
29-DEFENSE - Samuel T. Brick Jr. - (703) 697-1305
129-VETERANS AFFAIRS - John H. Thompson - (202) 273-6666
92-0ffice of Personnel Management - Harry Wolf - (202) 606-1424
EOP:
Barbara Chow
Sandra Yamin
Larry R. Matlack
Daniel J. Chenok
Stuart Shapiro
Sarah Rosen
Elena Kagan
Karen Tramontano
Caroline R. Fredrickson
Kate P. Donovan
David J. Haun
John E. Thompson
Robert G. Damus
Peter Rundlet
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 0[40
courtney B. Timberlake
Bruce D. Long
Lisa B. Fairhall
Daniel LaPlaca
Sarah S. Lee
William H. White Jr.
Richard J. Turman
John Kamensky
Cordelia W. Reimers
Janet R. Forsgren
James J. Jukes
LABOR
LRM ID: MNB22
SUBJECT:
Employees (SAFE) Act of 1999
Testimony on S385 Safety Advancement for
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7887
Fax: 395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
FROM:
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
_______ No Objection
_______ No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
_______ Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
====================
ATTACHMENT
1
====================
�4utomatedR
eCOl'dsM,
Hex-Dump c;;age'!lent System
STATEMENT OF CHARLES N. JEFFRESS
.
versIon
ASSISTANT SECRETARY FOR OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
BEFORE
THE SUBCOMMITTEE ON EMPLOYMENT, SAFETY AND TRAINING
HEALTH, EDUCATION, LABOR AND PENSIONS COMMITTEE
UNITED STATES SENATE
March 4, 1999
Mr. Chairman, Members of the Subcommittee, thank you for inviting me to testify about S. 385,
the SAFE Act, a proposal to amend the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970.
I
appreciate the opportunity to express OSHA's views on this bill. I would also like to take this
opportunity to express my appreciation to you, Mr. Chairman, for your efforts to find common
ground on these important issues. Although you have modified your proposal, the Department
remains unable to support your bill.
OSHA Works
OSHA's core mission is to ensure a safe and healthy workplace for every working man and
woman in the Nation.
We are most pleased by the latest occupational injury and illness
statistics. For the fifth consecutive year the rate of injuries and illness declined. In fact, the rate
for 1997 was the lowest since the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) began reporting this
information in the early' 1970s.
The improvement is particularly impressive in a booming
economy when many new and inexperienced workers are coming into the workforce.
Historically, new employees have been more likely to get hurt on the job than more experienced
workers. Much of the credit for the improvement can be attributed to millions of employers and
employees working every day to eliminate on-the-job hazards. I am proud that OSHA has been
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
a catalyst to help these private sector efforts, using results-driven enforcement efforts,
compliance assistance and standard setting to bring about workplace improvements.
Many challenges remain, but this message is clear. The New OSHA works. In the 4 years
since President Clinton announced the "New OSHA" initiative, which combines targeted
enforcement with partnerships and compliance assistance, we have developed a broad range of
successful partnership programs.
The New OSHA is doing more to promote cooperative
partnership efforts between employers, workers and government.
OSHA joined with industry last November to hold a partnership conference celebrating
the positive impact strategic partnerships, the Safety and Health Achievement Recognition
Program (SHARP) and the Voluntary Protection Program (VPP) have on protecting employees
and lowering workers' compensation costs for employers. In one success highlighted during the
conference, OSHA worked with the Steel Erectors' Safety Association of Colorado (SESAC) to
change a historically adversarial relationship into an effective partnership. According to the
president of Ridge Erectors, a SESAC participant, the partnership has "effectively taken an
adversarial position that's been historic between business and OSHA and turned it into a
partnership agreement where we work together to enhance education and we work together to
provide a safe workplace." Many of the SESAC members have reduced injuries and illnesses at
their workplaces and have lowered their workers' compensation costs. Ca1con Constructors, for
example, reduced their workers' compensation rate by almost two-thirds (saving sixty-three cents
on every dollar in workers' compensation costs) as a result of its partnership with OSHA.
2
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Another successful partnership is happening in Port Arthur, Texas where the Huntsman
Petrochemical Aromatics and Olefins Plant is a member of OSHA's Voluntary Protection
Programs (VPP). Workers at this site have repeatedly credited VPP participation as one vital
factor contributing to improved management and employee relations.
The plant's current
three-year injury incidnence rate is 74 percent below the industry average and its lost workday
rate is 99 percent below average.
Many companies are commenting that their impression of OSHA has changed. In one example,
an employer in OSHA's Maine 200 program said, "When I have a question for OSHA, I'll call
them." He said that when other agencies call him, "I'll call my lawyers first[.]" Similarly, in
New Jersey, the head of Barnard Construction said, "I think OSHA is trying to get on a path of
not just knocking people out of business, but educating them." He went on to add, "Their
attitude has definitely changed." Comments like these demonstrate OSHA is making progress.
In addition to partnership efforts,· OSHA is making enforcement programs smarter and fairer by
spending more time at the most hazardous workplaces and less time at safer ones. OSHA is
using BLS data to identify industries with the highest injury and illness rates and is using
information gathered from our own Data Initiative to target inspections at specific workplaces.
In doing so, we have been able to discover serious violators in less time. At the same time,
employers whose attention to safety has already paid off in the form of lower injury and illness
rates are less likely to see an OSHA inspector.
3
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Over the past several years, we also have measured results, where possible, not by numbers of
citations or penalties, but by real improvements in the lives of working people, such as reduced
injury and illness rates. The five-year decline in injury and illness rates is evidence that this
combination of approaches is working.
Finally, OSHA has redoubled its commitment to small business. Immediately after I leave this
hearing, I will be participating in a forum that OSHA is holding, entitled "OSHA and Small
Business: New Ways of Working." The forum will showcase information and services available
to help small businesses improve workplace safety and health. The program will involve a
half-day seminar and a question-and-answer session with a panel of OSHA senior staff. We will
cover several topics, including how small businesses can receive compliance assistance and
technical advice, the role of the Small Business Regulatory Enforcement and Fairness Act, and
partnership opportunities.
The SAFE Act
Mr. Chairman, while I appreciate your cooperative spirit and hope that we can continue to work
together to improve worker safety and health, OSHA cannot support the legislation before the
Subcommittee today. Last year, the Department stated its intent to recommend a veto if the
SAFE Act passed the Congress.
Despite the changes that have been made since then, we
believe the new SAFE Act, if enacted, would undermine the agency's ability to protect workers.
Consequently, if S. 385 were passed, as written, the Department would recommend a veto.
4
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Third Party Consultation
S. 385 would establish a new system for OSHA to certify private-sector, for-profit, third party
consultants. Consultants would contract with employers and provide them with a certificate that
would exempt them from OSHA civil penalties for one year.
OSHA opposes the third party consultation provision. First, OSHA strongly disagrees with the
opinions stated in the new "Purpose" section, which we believe are wholly inappropriate and
inaccurate.
Second, the provision creates conflict-of-interest and accountability problems.
Finally, we are concerned that employers could, in effect, negotiate compliance agreements that
fail to meet the requirements of the OSH Act.
Purpose
The seemingly innocuous "Purpose" section of the third party coqsultation provision could
cripple the agency.
This section would codify the erroneous opinion that employers are
incapable of compliance with OSHA regulations and that OSHA is unable to enforce them.
Some employers would attempt to use this provision to avoid compliance. While we strongly
agree that employee safety and health are "of paramount concern," subsections two and three of
this section would undermine that spirit.
Conflicts of Illterest
Private safety and health consultants provide an important service and OSHA encourages
employers to use them as a valuable resource. OSHA also provides free consultation for small
5
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
businesses in each of the fifty states, the District of Columbia and three territories. However,
there are significant differences between employers using consultants voluntarily to self-inspect
and using them to purchase immunity from OSHA penalties.
While OSHA encourages
employers to make use of non-OSHA consultants, the private sector is driven by the market, not
a mandate to protect employee safety and health. Therefore, the program would be vulnerable to
conflict of interest and accountability problems.
The third party consultation provision creates a powerful incentive for consultants to please
employers in order to create and maintain business.
The consultant's business interest in
conducting inspections and granting penalty exemptions could place him or her at odds with the
interests of employee safety and health.
This tension could ultimately cast doubt on the
legitimacy of the exemptions the consultant grants. The consultant would feel pressured to sell
penalty exemptions without rigorously inspecting workplaces in order to create business ..
Likewise, employers may feel obligated to purchase unnecessary services in order to curry favor
with the consultant.
Accountability
The bill provides OSHA with little recourse against consultants whose improper certifications
put workers at risk. Under this provision, the only option OSHA would have for dealing with
consultants who commit fraud, collusion, malfeasance or gross negligence would be to expel
them from the program.
program.
Such serious offences warrant more than mere removal from the
Worse yet, OSHA would have no meaningful recourse against a consultant who was
6
�Aurom3ted Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
overly generous in granting penalty exemptions due to incompetence or negligence.
Even
though workers would continue to be exposed to hazards in the workplace, the consultant could
continue to grant exemptions and the certificates of compliance he or she issued would still
stand. If, on the other hand, OSHA finds that one of its compliance officers is not performing to
our standards,. we have the ability to correct the situation. The disciplinary provisions of this
program are simply insufficient to redress the harm consultants could inflict on thousands of
working Americans.
Employer- Negotiated Compliance
Section 3 would allow an employer whose workplace was found to have safety and health
hazards to negotiate compliance efforts and requirements with the consultant. The provision
requires that the employer and consultant agree to the terms and timeframes of the Action Plan.
Agreements necessitate compromise.
It is entirely possible that, under the language of this
legislation, an employer and consultant would agree to an Action Plan in which the employer is
not required to come into full compliance with the OSH Act for many years. For example, an
employer and consultant may compromise on how quickly a guardrail must be fixed although
employees would remain exposed to a significant fall hazard in the meantime. OSHA cannot
support legislation that would allow an employer to avoid compliance and endanger workers.
Safety and Health Programs
OSHA is pleased that the new bill emphasizes the importance of safety and health programs by
including many elements of OSHA's
SHARP program.
7
However, this change does not
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
overcome OSHA's significant objections to the third party consultation provision.
The bill encourages employers to use third party consultants by offering them a one-year
moratorium on penalties for violations of the law.
We strongly disagree with this approach.
If
employers, acting in good faith, engage qualified consultants and correct all of the violations the
consultants find, they should have no reason to be concerned about penalties and fines.
A
penalty waiver will be an incentive only to an employer who does not intend to put an effective
safety program in place and who does not intend to correct all violations.
The SHARP
program, on which section 3 is modeled, does not offer a penalty waiver.
Rather, in
recognition of the fact that the participating employer has received significant attention from
OSHA, SHARP provides for a one-year exemption from programmed inspections.
If,
however, OSHA is called in for a complaint or fatality investigation and discovers uncorrected
violations, the SHARP employer will be subject to citation and penalties.
I believe that
employers will be less likely to comply with the law if we tell them in advance that they may
violate the law without fear of a penalty. In addition, the proposal in S. 385 would allow a
company with an injury and illness rate twice the average for its industry to receive a certificate
of compliance and the resulting penalty exemption.
I would like to take this opportunity to highlight several of OSHA's other concerns with
SAFE Act.
the
I will limit my comments to a few provisions that I· find particularly troubling.
Among these are the technical assistance, worksite-specific compliance, and discretionary
8
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
compliance assistance
provIsions.
My limited discussion of these few provisions of the bill,
should not be taken to imply that OSHA supports the remainder of the bill.
interest of time, I will
forgo commenting on those issues in my testimony.
But
in the
The Department's
comprehensive analysis of the bill is attached to my testimony.
Technical Assistance
Section 8 would amend the recently enacted provIsions that govern OSHA's consultation
program.
Just months ago, OSHA supported enactment of H.R. 2864, a bipartisan bill
sponsored by Congressman Cass Ballenger of North Carolina, that codified OSHA's consultation
program with enhanced employee protections.
OSHA consultation to the Act.
this time.
We are proud that our cooperative efforts added
We believe that no amendments to the new law are needed at
The fee-for-service element of S. 385 would give priority to those who can afford to
pay for consultation, not those who need it most.
Consultation is and should remain
prioritized for small, high-hazard employers, not for large, wealthy ones.
Worksite-Specific Compliance
Section 7 would require citations to be vacated if the employer can prove that its employees were
protected "by equally or more protective" means than those required by OSHA standards.
This new employer defense could turn every enforcement action into a time-consuming standards
litigation effort, imposing substantial burdens on agency resources and the court system. OSHA
standards would become mere guidelines 'open for debate whenever an employer wants to contest
9
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
OSHA standards, and routine enforcement cases would be turned into exercises in rulemaking.
For this and other reasons, courts have held repeatedly that employers must comply with OSHA
standards in the manner specified in the standards. As the United States Court of Appeals for
the Eleventh Circuit has noted, "An employer must follow the law even if it has a good faith
belief that its own policy is wiser."
Discretionary Compliance Assistance
Section 11 would allow OSHA to issue warnings in lieu of citations, even for violations that have
killed employees, as long as the employer agrees to abate the violation promptly. This section is
unnecessary and could lead to reductions in employer compliance with the law. OSHA already
has the discretion to decline to issue citations in appropriate circumstances.
OSHA has used this discretion to establish programs such as Maine 200.
For example,
In addition, OSHA
has created a "quick fix" policy in which a compliance officer does not issue citations where the
employer immediately abates a hazard that was not likely to cause harm to an employee.
This provision sends a message that employers need not necessarily concern themselves with
potential OSHA fines for violating its law .. If employers believe that OSHA's enforcement
•
ability is weakened, they will be less likely to comply with OSHA standards.
Further, if
employers believe they get one free pass before receiving a penalty, many could be lulled into
complacency regarding safety and health requirements until finally being inspected.
This
provision is particularly troubling because it could actually influence employers not to remain in
compliance with the OSH Act.
10
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
When I evaluate legislative proposals to amend the aSH Act, my first question is always the
same: will the change tend to make workers safer and healthier? There is no doubt in my mind
that a provision that removes an important incentive for employers to comply with the law fails
that simple test.
Mr. Chairman, I believe you have made a good faith effort to improve upon last year's version
of the SAFE Act by eliminating certain controversial provisions. Unfortunately, the remaining
provisions continue to raise serious concerns that would necessitate a veto recommendation by
the Secretary of Labor.
Protecting Workers Better
Mr. Chairman, there are a variety of ways to strengthen the protection provided to workers
under the OSH Act.
We would, for example, support legislation that strengthens the
whistleblower protection of the OSH Act.
It is fundamental that workers must feel free to
inform their employer or the government when dangerous working conditions threaten their life
or safety. There is a good deal of evidence, however, that many employees do not feel free to
complain about unsafe conditions and that too many employers feel they can retaliate against
whistleblowers with impunity. The provisions in place today in section 11 (c) of the Act are too
weak and too cumbersome to discourage employer retaliation or to provide an effective remedy
for the victims of retaliation. A recent report by the Inspector General of the Department of
11
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Labor found that "whistleblowers" frequently face retaliation for exposing unsafe or unhealthy
working conditions. A nurse at Skyline Terrace Nursing Home, for example, complained about
the home's lack of gloves, which are required to protect employees from bloodbome pathogens.
Four days after an inspection, she was fired in retaliation for the complaint. Another company,
Hahner, Foreman & Hamess, Inc., fired an employee for refusing to go up in a gondola three or
four stories above the ground. The gondola had been malfunctioning and the employee believed
it to be unsafe. When the employee refused to risk his safety, his superintendent instructed him
that if he did not go back up into the malfunctioning gondola, somebody else would. He was
fired for his refusal. If you wish to strengthen the safety and health protection available to
workers, I suggest this as a place to begin.
In 1993, the North Carolina legislature, in a comprehensive review of our State plan following
the Hamlet fire, took several steps that greatly strengthened whistleblower protection. The
changes included a longer statute of limitations, a private right of action and a provision for
treble damages. I believe these changes have played an important part in the progress North
Carolina has made in reducing injury, illness and fatality rates over the last five years.
A second area this Subcommittee may want to consider is protections for public employees.
The OSH Act currently does not effectively protect Federal employees and, in states that do not
operate an OSHA-approved State plan, does not protect state and local employees (maintenance
workers, construction workers, firefighters, etc.).
Consequently, with the exception of the 25
states that actively provide public sector coverage under State OSHA programs, OSHA has little
12
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
ability to reqUIre positive change on the part of public employers.
As a consequence, this
limited authority hinders OSHA's success in reducing illness, injuries and fatalities on the job.
Congress last year enacted legislation supported by the Chairman and the Administration to
subject the U.S. Postal Service to OSHA penalties.
Experience with this new requirement has
shown that future action in expanding OSHA protections is not only feasible but advisable.
There are numerous examples of on-the-job tragedies that occurred primarily because safety and
health protections do not apply to public employees.
prevented by compliance with OSHA rules.
These tragedies could have been·
In addition, studies have shown that the overall
cost of providing OSH Act coverage for these employees is small, especially compared with the
amount of money which would be saved by reducing the cost of worker injuries.
Finally, the Subcommittee should increase the criminal penalty for an employer whose willful
conduct causes the death of an employee.
We would urge that these violations not be classified
as misdemeanors, but felonies, which carry with them the possibility of incarceration for periods
in excess of one year.
Classifying willful workplace safety and health violations that lead to an
employee's death as misdemeanors is woefully inadequate to address the harm caused.
Classifying such crimes as felonies would more justly reflect the severity of the offense.
Condusion
While OSHA appreciates the Chairman's attempts to improve this bill, those attempts have not
13
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
overcome OSHA's opposition to the SAFE Act. By diminishing OSHA's enforcement authority,
the bill weakens worker safety and health. We believe the Subcommittee's efforts would be
better directed toward efforts on which a consensus is possible. Such discussion can most
effectively help achieve our mandated goal of safer and healthier workplaces.
Attachment
14
�DRAFT-
ANALYSIS OF S. 385
Automated 0
f1ecordsM,
Hex-Dum'P Canagement S
onllers;on rstem
Section 3. Third Party Consultation Services Program
Section 3 requires the Secretary to establish a program to "qualify" individuals who could then
serve as consultants to employers to assist them in identifYing and correcting safety and health
hazards in their workplaces. An employer who contracted and received such services and who
was declared by the co~sultant, after the initial visit to the workplace, agreement on an Action
Plan, and a possible follow-up "reinspection" visit, to be in compliance with the Act, would be
exempt from any assessment of a civil penalty under the Act for a period of one year, with certain
limited exceptions.
The Department of Labor strongly opposes this section. While the proposal presents numerous
problems, the Department is most concerned about the one-year exemption that the bill would
provide from civil penalties for violations of the OSH Act.
The incentives created by coupling the third party consultation provision with a penalty
exemption leave the program extremely vulnerable to conflict-of-interest and accountability
problems. At the most obvious level, a consultant paid by an employer would be likely to feel
pressured to approve the employer's program or to fail to recommend costly engineering controls
even when they were necessary to prevent an injury or illness. Likewise, businesses may feel
obligated to purchase unnecessary services proposed to them by their consultant in order to
ensure being granted a certificate of compliance. In addition, the provision permitting
employers and consultants to agree upon the terms of the Action Plan would invite abuses that
could result in seriously delayed abatement, if abatement is agreed to at all. Further, there is no
provision in the bill that would prevent an employer from utilizing one of its own employees, or
a former employee, to provide consulting services. Though this is no doubt not the intent of the
bill's authors, section 3 would in effect enable employers to "purchase" immunity from OSHA
inspections and penalties.
Reliance on the private sector for in-compliance declarations, coupled with exemptions from the
possibility of an OSHA inspection with penalties for employers who receive such declarations,
would leave the agency without sufficient recourse if an inspection is necessary within the
exemption period. For example, even if conditions in a certified workplace had undergone
major change during the exemption period, a penalty could only be levied if OSHA could
demonstrate the occurrence of a "fundamental change in the hazards" of the workplace or that the
employer had not made a good faith effort to remain in compliance. The only large-scale study
to date that correlates worksite injury data with worksite inspection history over time has shown
that inspections in which penalties are assessed result in a significant reduction in injuries at the
inspected site for three years following the inspection, and that inspections without penalties
have no appreciable impact (Wayne Gray and John Scholz, "Does Regulatory Enforcement
Work? A Panel Analysis of OSHA Enforcement," Law and Society Review, pages 177-213 (July
1993».
15
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
The new version of the SAFE Act has been modified to include a safety and health program
component. This is a positive addition to the bill, but does not clire flaws inherent in the third
party consultation proposal. OSHA's Safety and Health Achievement Recognition Program
(SHARP), part of OSHA's consultation program, exempts employers from a programmed
inspection only after the employer requests and receives a full-service consultation visit, and
works with the consultation program for a period of at least a year from the date of the initial
visit to correct and abate all hazards, implement a fully effective worksite safety and health
program and lower the lost workday and accident rates to a level at or below the national average
for their industry. Unlike S.1237 in the lO~th Congress, S. 385 incorporates a requirement for
employers to implement a safety and health program before they can receive a certificate of
compliance. However, unlike OSHA's SHARP program, there is no guarantee that all hazards
will be abated before a certificate is granted. In addition, the ability of private, for-profit
consultants to provide penalty exemptions, rather than the exemptions from programmed
inspections that the SHARP program provides, gives those private, for-profit consultants power
well beyond any power granted to an OSHA compliance officer or a state consultant. SHARP
companies never receive blanket exemptions from penalties. Finally, under the SHARP
program, OSHA has the final say over whether companies should receive SHARP recognition.
This system provides an additional check to ensure that a workplace is safe and has an effective
safety and health program before it becomes exempt from a programmed inspection.
The Department remains concerned that the bill is completely silent about a consultant's
obligations when an employer is found NOT to be in compliance. This means that the
consultant then has the option of refusing to provide a declaration, which leaves the employer
free to seek out another consultant. While the bill now requires the consultant to identify
violations of the OSH Act and possible corrective measures, there is still no clear requirement
that employers abate the identified hazards or that consultants report to OSHA in the event of an
employer's refusal to abate. Moreover, because reinspections are not necessarily required, there
is no way for the consultant, employees or OSHA to verify either abatement or whether the
elements of an effective safety and health program have been fully implemented.
The Department is concerned that the bill could allow an employer to receive a certificate of
compliance even ifit has not yet completed the process of hazard abatement. This would allow
an employer that is out of compliance with the law to be declared in compliance. The problem
is further compounded because an employer with a certificate of compliance who has not yet
abated hazards identified in the written plan could not be penalized by OSHA for one year.
Finally, unlike OSHA's abatement verification rule, the employer would not have to "inform
affected employees and their representatives about abatement activities" the employer had
promised to undertake. Elimination of a mandatory reinspection requirement augments this
problem. Without reinspection, an employer could obtain a certificate without having to show
that it has abated a single hazard. In the event that a reinspection does actually occur, there is no
provision for further action if the employer has not satisfied all the elements in the consultation
report.
16
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
In addition, relying on the private sector for such certifications, while at the same time exempting
the employer's worksite from the possibility of a penalty, would deprive the agency of sufficient
"quality control" over both certifications and the safety and health audits performed by federally
sanctioned, certified individuals. The only oversight granted to OSHA under this bill is
meaningless. The bill requires OSHA to maintain a registry of safety and health consultants it
deems qualified, but hamstrings the agency in the event problems occur. In addition,
maintaining a registry would place a substantial burden on the agency's already limited
resources. Those resources should be targeted toward making workplaces and workers safer, not
toward policing a new army of consultants.
These problems are compounded because the disciplinary action anticipated by this legislation is
insufficient to redress or deter the abuses for which S.385 creates an incentive. Removal of a
consultant from participation in the program is simply not enough to prevent or punish abuses
such as fraud or collusion. Further, the circumstances under which an employer or consultant
could be disciplined are so limited that the bill would permit a consultant to continue to
participate where injuries and illnesses continue to occur as a result of incompetence or simple
negligence. In addition, it appears that a consultant's failure to identify a hazard would exempt
the employer from penalties for that hazard.
Further compounding these problems is the bill's failure to clearly identify the minimal
qualifications for a consultant. For example, section 8A(b)(2)(A) identifies practitioners of
certain state-licensed occupations as "eligible to be qualified" as consultants, but neglects others
and does not specify what experience in hazard identification and occupational safety and health
eligible consultants must have. OSHA is further concerned that this provision may create an
unfunded mandate for states to create licensing programs for safety and health professionals.
The Department is unaware of any concrete evidence that a third party certification program
would be successful. At the outset of this Administration, the idea of third-party audits was
. raised at a meeting of OSHA's stakeholders, where it met with little enthusiasm from either labor
or business representatives. More recently, a State of North Carolina survey demonstrated a
resounding preference on the part of employers for an OSHA consultant over a private
consultant. Cost, as well as suspicion that the private consultant might attempt to sell an
employer unnecessary services, were among the reasons given in support of OSHA consultants.
Finally, the Department is compelled to object to the new "purpose" that has been added to this
section. The new "purpose" statement would codify the erroneous opinion that all employers
are unable to read, understand and comply with the OSH Act. It would further codify the
opinion that OSHA is unable to satisfy the compliance needs of each employer and employee
within its jurisdiction. The addition of such sentiments to the OSH Act is, at best, inappropriate.
Section 4. Establishment of Special Advisory Committee
17
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Section 4 would require the Secretary to establish a new advisory committee consisting of
employees, employers, members of the general public, and an official from a state plan state.
The committee would advise and make recommendations to the Secretary concerning the
establishment and implementation of third-party consultation services programs under section 8A
of the bill.
Section 7(a) of the current statute establishes the National Advisory Committee on Occupational
Safety and Health (NACOSH), which exists to make recommendations on matters relating to the
administration of the current Act. Mandating the establishment of a new advisory committee
dealing with the new consultation program in section 8A of the bill would duplicate part of the
existing jurisdiction ofNACOSH and, as such, would be redundant and not in keeping with the
concept of reinvention and streamlining. In the event the Secretary needs to consult with experts
on the specifics of consultation programs, Sections 7(c)(1) and (2) of the OSH Act now give the
Secretary broad powers to hire consultants and experts, and to utilize the services of experts from
other federal agencies and states. If the Secretary wishes to obtain advice through the
instrumentality of an advisory committee, she may establish such a committee pursuant to the
requirements of the Federal Advisory Committee Act.
Section 5. Continuing Education and Professional Certification for Certain Occupational Safety
and Health Administration Personnel
Section 5 requires Federal employees who enforce the Act to meet the eligibility requirements
established under new section 8A(a)(2) for third-party consultants. In addition, these employees
must receive professional education and training every five years.
OSHA agrees that effective training of enforcement personnel is vitally important. OSHA and
the State Plans conduct a wide range of training programs to ensure that compliance officers
conduct fair and effective investigations.
The OSH Act is not industry-specific; it applies to a wide variety of workplaces throughout the
nation. Therefore, it has been OSHA's experience that individuals with broad professional
backgrounds become the best inspectors. During their first three years of employment, new
Compliance Safety and Health Officers (CSHOs) are teamed with experienced inspectors and are
given over 250 hours of training on investigative techniques at the OSHA Training Institute
(OTI) in Des Plaines, Illinois. Additional training is mandatory for experienced CSHOs at least
once every three years. Finally, whenever new standards are promulgated, on offers
specialized training in these standards.
As this discussion illustrates, OSHA does train and educate its employees, but not in a manner
that matches the bill's inflexible requirements. We are concerned that the bill is unclear about
which employees would be required to receive this training. For example, would the agency's
attorneys be considered "responsible for enforcing this Act"? Weare further concerned about
18
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
the cost of providing the required training.
Finally, we note that the bill contains no specific training requirements for the consultants for the
program created under section 5, whose inspections and reports may result in employer
exemptions from civil monetary penalties.
Section 6. Expanded Inspection Methods
Section 6 of the bill would allow OSHA to investigate an alleged violation or danger by
telephone or facsimile. The bill also states that OSHA is not required to conduct complaint
inspections if "a request for inspection was made for reasons other than the safety and health of
the employees of an employer" or if OSHA determines that workers are not at risk.
OSHA has two major concerns about this section. First, although investigation of complaints by
telephone, facsimile and other similar methods is desirable in many situations, these methods
should not replace a worker's fundamental right to an inspection. In the past two years, OSHA
has reduced the time from the filing of a complaint to abatement of hazards by using telephone
and facsimile methods for investigating informal complaints. In addition, several offices have
experimented with these methods for investigatingformal worker complaints, but only where the
complaining worker agrees. However, these methods should not be allowed to interfere where a
worker seeks to exercise his or her statutory right to an inspection.
Second, section 6 would allow OSHA to forgo a complaint inspection if it determines that the
complaint was made for reasons other than safety and health -- even if the information provided
by the complainant suggests that the workers in question may be substantial risk. Again, the
agency's determination as to whether to inspect following a formal complaint should be based on
the likelihood that workers are at risk -- not on the motivation of the complainant. Where
workers face substantial hazards, OSHA should act -- and is compelled by statute to act -- to
protect them. Moreover, it would be very difficult for OSHA to determine the complainant's
motivation. This exercise would consume scarce agency resources and delay inspections.
Ultimately, the agency should continue to inspect where it has reasonable cause to believe that
workers are at risk.
Section 7. Worksite-Specific Compliance Methods
Section 7 would create an entirely new statutory defense to an OSHA citation, based on an
employer's demonstration that employees were protected by alternate methods equally or more
protective than those required by the standard the employer violated.
The OSH Review Commission and the courts have held repeatedly that when OSHA's standards
require employers to adopt specific precautions for protecting employees, employers must
comply in the manner specified. Under current law, employers have the right to select
19
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
alternative means of compliance when literal compliance is impossible or would pose a greater
hazard to employees. In "greater hazard" cases, the Commission requires an employer to show
that a variance has either been sought or would be inappropriate.
Under these rules, the contest rate has remained relatively low; less than ten percent of all
citations are currently contested. Under this provision ofS. 1237, however, virtually every
employer cited for violations of the OSH Act or OSHA standards could claim that an alternative
means of compliance was as effective as the standard in question. In effect, standards would
become guidelines, subject to challenge -- and potential waiver -- in every individual contested
case. This provision could seriously undermine OSHA's standards, tum every enforcement
action into a costly and time-consuming variance proceeding, and impose substantial burdens
upon agency resources, the OSH Review Commission, and the federal courts.
Section 8. Technical Assistance Program
Section 8 amends the OSH Act's "Training and Employee Education" provision to require
cooperative agreements between OSHA and States to provide consultation programs. The
Department questions the wisdom of amending the new consultation law Congress passed last
year with bipartisan support after extensive negotiations between Congress and the Department.
We are particularly concerned with further amending the program in the way contemplated by
section 8. Under section 8, the Secretary must establish a pilot program in three states for a
duration of up to two years, the purpose of which would be to test a fee-far-service system. The
fifty state agencies that already administer the consultation program have expressed very strong
reservations about charging fees in the consultation program. The Administration shares these
concerns. Those who could pay would be visited first, defeating the philosophy that this service
is aimed at small or highly hazardous businesses that cannot afford to hire other consultants.
Section 9. VoluntarY Protection Program
Section 9 attempts to codify OSHA's Voluntary Protection Program, requiring the Secretary to
establish cooperative agreements with employers, who would create and maintain comprehensive
safety and health management systems. The bill requires enhanced OSHA efforts to include
small businesses in the VPP: Participation in this program would result in exemptions from
inspections and certain paperwork requirements.
OSHA has supported codifying the VPP program, but we do not support this provision as
drafted. The VPP has traditionally been, and should remain, a program for work sites, not
employers. Although there are references to "the worksite" in the section, this vital mainstay
ofthe program must be emphasized. OSHA is also concerned that codification could jeopardize
the high standards of the program currently in operation. As drafted, this provision does not
20
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
.
reflect the idea that the VPP program is reserved exclusively for those employers who have
demonstrated the highest commitment to worker safety and health. Ideally, any codification of
this program should limit participation to employers who have truly superior safety and health
records, but should allow OSHA the flexibility to define (and modify as necessary) the specific
criteria for participation in the program. We further note that the bill does not include a program
requirement for VPP participants to provide meaningful employee involvement in safety and
health matters, which we believe to be an important component of the program.
Section 10. Prevention of Alcohol and Substance Abuse
Section 10 authorizes the Secretary to test employees and management for drugs and alcohol
following any work-related fatality or serious injury. It also permits employers to institute their
own testing programs conforming to HHS and federal workplace guidelines. Testing is
permissible on a for-cause basis, as part of a scheduled medical examination, where an accident
involving actual or potential loss of human life, bodily injury, or property damage has occurred,
during participation in a drug treatment program, or on a random basis.
OSHA strongly supports measures that contribute to a drug-free work environment and
reasonable programs of drug testing within a comprehensive workplace program for certain
workplace environments, such as those involving safety-sensitive duties, and which take into
consideration employee rights to privacy. However, OSHA is concemed that it may not have
the resources to oversee drug and alcohol programs.
Section 11. Discretionarv Compliance Assistance
This section provides that the Secretary may issue warnings in lieu of citations where the
violation has no significant relationship to safety or health or where the employer has acted in
good faith to promptly abate the violation. The Secretary may not exercise this discretion where
the violation has a "significant relationship to employee safety or health" or where the violation is
willful or repeated.
Currently, the OSH Act provides that OSHA "shall" issue a citation for each violation it
discovers during an inspection. This provision would change this provision to "may." As a
practical matter, the impact of this proposed change is unclear. Federal case law demonstrates
that OSHA possesses a greater degree of prosecutorial discretion than was recognized in the early
years of the agency's existence. The agency has discretion under existing law to establish
programs in which it does not issue a citation for every violation it finds. For example, OSHA
has used this discretion to establish programs such as Maine 200.
Nonetheless, OSHA is concerned that the change proposed in this section might be
misunderstood by some employers as a limitation on OSHA's authority to issue citations.
Among other things, OSHA is particularly troubled by paragraph 3(8), which allows the issuance
21
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
of a "warning in lieu of a citation" for violations that the employer "acts promptly to abate[.]"
Even though it allows OSHA the discretion to issue citations in such circumstances, this
provision may signal employers that they need not take preventive steps to protect their workers
prior to an OSHA inspection. As such, this provision could undermine both the preventive
purpose as well as the deterrent effect of OSHA's enforcement program.
Prompt abatement of hazards should be encouraged, but it should be encouraged through penalty
reductions, not by eliminating any citations whatsoever for violations. Otherwise, employers
who make good faith efforts to protect workers before an OSHA inspector arrives at their door
will be treated the same as neglectful employers who have ignored their workers' safety until the
inspection.
Finally, the limitations on the Secretary's discretion are so narrow that they could lead to
outrageous results. For example, the Secretary's discretion is not limited to cases in which an
employer has shown good faith by implementing a safety and health program or in which no
employee has been killed or seriously injured because of the employer's violation. Rather, the
bill authorizes the Secretary to issue a waming in lieu of a citation if the employer "acts promptly
to abate the violation" even if the employer has a long history of previous violations and causes
the death of several employees.
22
�Page 28 of40
ARMS Email System
==================== ATTACHMENT 2 ====================
o 00:00:00.00
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
TEXT:
S 385 IS
106th CONGRESS
1st Session
S. 385
To amend the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 to further improve
the safety and health of working environments, and for other purposes.
IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
February 6, 1999
Mr. ENZI introduced the following bill; which was read twice and referred
to the Committee on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions
A BILL
To amend the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 to further improve
the safety and health of working environments, and for other purposes.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United
States of America in Congress assembled,
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; REFERENCE.
(a) SHORT TITLE- This Act may be cited as the 'Safety Advancement for
Employees Act of 1999' or the 'SAFE Act'.
(b) REFERENCE, Whenever in this Act an amendment or repeal is
expressed in terms of an amendment to, or repeal of, a section or
other provision, the reference shall be considered to be made to a
section or other provision of the Occupational Safety and Health Act
of 1970 (29 U.S.C. 651 et seq.).
SEC. 2. PURPOSE.
Section 2(b) of the Act (29 U.S.C. 651(b))
is amended--
(1) in paragraph (13), by striking the period and inserting'
and'; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
'(14) by increasing the joint cooperation of employers,
employees, and the Secretary of Labor in the effort to ensure
safe and healthful working conditions for employees. ' .
SEC. 3. THIRD PARTY CONSULTATION SERVICES PROGRAM.
(a) PROGRAM- The Act
(29 U.S.C. 651 et seq.) is amended by inserting
�ARMS Email System
Page 29 of40
after secti.on 8 the f.oll.owing:
'SEC. 8A. THIRD PARTY CONSULTATION SERVICES PROGRAM.
'(a) PURPOSE- Rec.ognizing that-'(I) empl.oyee safety is .of param.ount c.oncern;
'(2) empl.oyers are .overburdened by regulati.ons and are unable t.o
read thr.ough, understand and effectively c.omply with the
v.olumin.ous requirements .of this Act; and
'(3) the Secretary is unable t.o individually satisfy the
c.ompliance needs .of each empl.oyer and empl.oyee within its
jurisdicti.on;
it is the purp.ose .of this secti.on t.o enc.ourage empl.oyers t.o c.onduct
v.oluntary safety and health audits using the expertise .of qualified
safety and health c.onsultants and t.o pr.oactively seek individualized
s.oluti.ons t.o w.orkplace safety and health c.oncerns.
'(b) ESTABLISHMENT OF PROGRAM'(I) IN GENERAL- N.ot later than 18 m.onths after the date .of
enactment .of this secti.on, the Secretary, in c.onsultati.on with
the advis.ory c.ommittee established under secti.on 7(d), shall
establish and implement, by regulati.on, a pr.ogram that qualifies
individuals t.o pr.ovide c.onsultati.on services t.o empl.oyers t.o
assist empl.oyers in the identificati.on and c.orrecti.on .of safety
and health hazards in the w.orkplaces .of empl.oyers.
'(2) ELIGIBILITY- The f.oll.owing individuals shall be eligible t.o
be qualified under the pr.ogram under paragraph (1) as certified
safety and health c.onsultants:
'(A) An individual wh.o is licensed by a State auth.ority as a
physician, industrial hygienist, pr.ofessi.onal engineer,
safety engineer, safety pr.ofessi.onal, .or .occupati.onal nurse.
'(B) An individual wh.o has been empl.oyed as an inspect.or f.or
a State plan State .or as a Federal .occupati.onal safety and
health inspect.or f.or n.ot less than a 5-year peri.od.
'(C) An individual wh.o is qualified in an .occupati.onal
health .or safety field by an .organizati.on wh.ose pr.ogram has
been accredited by a nati.onally rec.ognized private
accreditati.on .organizati.on .or by the Secretary.
'(D) Other individuals determined t.o be qualified by the
Secretary.
'(3) GEOGRAPHICAL SCOPE OF CONSULTATION SERVICES- A c.onsultant
qualified under the pr.ogram under paragraph (1) may pr.ovide
c.onsultati.on services in any State.
'(4) LIMITATION BASED ON EXPERTISE- A c.onsultant qualified under
the pr.ogram under paragraph (1) may .only pr.ovide c.onsultati.on
services t.o an empl.oyer with respect t.o a w.orksite if the w.ork
perf.ormed at that worksite c.oincides with the particular
expertise .of the individual.
�ARMS Email System
Page 30 of40
'(c) SAFETY AND HEALTH REGISTRY- The Secretary shall develop and
maintain a registry that includes all consultants that are qualified
under the program under subsection (b) (1) to provide the consultation
services described in subsection (b) and shall publish and make such
registry readily available to the general public.
'(d) DISCIPLINARY ACTIONS- The Secretary may revoke the status of a
consultant qualified under subsection (b), or the participation of an
employer under subsection (b) in the third party consultation program,
if the Secretary determines that the consultant or employer-'(I) has failed to meet the requirements of the program; or
'(2) has committed malfeasance, gross negligence, collusion or
fraud in connection with any consultation services provided by
the qualified consultant.
'(e) PROGRAM REQUIREMENTS'(I) FULL SERVICE CONSULTATION- The consultation services
described in subsection (b), and provided by a consultant
qualified under the program under subsection (b) (1), shall
include an evaluation of the workplace of an employer to
determine if the employer is in compliance with the requirements
of this Act, including any regulations promulgated pursuant to
this Act. Employers electing to participate in such program shall
contract with a
consultant qualified under subsection (b) (2) to perform a full service
visit and consultation covering the employer's establishment,including a
complete safety and health program review. Following the guidance as
specified in this section, the consultant shall discuss with the employer
the elements of an effective program.
'(2) CONSULTATION REPORT'(A) IN GENERAL- After a consultant conducts a comprehensive
survey of an employer under a program under this section,
the consultant shall prepare and submit to the employer a
written report that includes an action plan identifying any
violations of this Act, and any appropriate corrective
measures to address the violations that are identified using
an effective safety an~ health program.
'(B) ELEMENTS- A consultation report shall contain each of
the following elements.
'(i) ACTION PLAN'(I) IN GENERAL- An action plan under subparagraph
(A) shall be developed in consultation with the
employer as part of the initial comprehensive
survey. The consultant and the employer shall
jointly use the onsite time in the initial visit
to the employer's place of business to agree on
the terms of the action plan and the time frames
for achieving specific items.
'(II) REQUIREMENTS- The action plan shall outline
�ARMS Email System
Page 31 of 40
the specific steps that must be accomplished by
the employer prior to receiving a certificate of
compliance. The action plan shall address in
detail--(aa) the employer's correction of all identified safety and health
hazards, with applicable time frames;
-(bb) the steps necessary for the employer to implement an effective safety
and health program, with applicable time frames; and
-(cc) a statement of the employer's commitment to work with the·
consultation project to achieve a certificate of compliance.
-(ii) SAFETY AND HEALTH PROGRAM- An employer electing
to participate in a program under this section shall
establish a safety and health program to manage
workplace safety and health to reduce injuries,
illnesses and fatalities that complies with paragraph
(3). Such safety and health program shall be
appropriate to the conditions of the workplace
involved.
-(3) REQUIREMENTS FOR SAFETY AND HEALTH PROGRAM-(A) WRITTEN PROGRAM- An employer electing to participate
shall maintain a written safety and health program that
contains policies, procedures, and practices to recognize
and protect their employees from occupational safety and
health hazards. Such procedures shall include provisions for
the identification, evaluation and prevention or control of
workplace hazards.
-(B) MAJOR ELEMENTS- A safety and health program shall
include the following elements, and may include other
elements as necessary to the specific worksite involved and
as determined appropriate by the qualified cOnsultant and
employer:
-(i) EMPLOYER COMMITMENT AND EMPLOYEE INVOLVEMENT-(I) IN GENERAL- The existence of both management
leadership and employee participation must be
demonstrated in accordance with subclauses (II)
and (III).
-(II) MANAGEMENT LEADERSHIP- To make a
demonstration of management leadership under this
subclause, the employer shall--(aa) set a clear worksite safety and health policy that employees can
fully understand;
-(bb) set and communicate clear goals and objectives with the involvement
of employees;
-(cc) provide essential safety and health leadership in tangible and
recognizable ways;
-(dd) set positive safety and health examples; and
�Page 32 of40
ARMS Email System
-(eel perform comprehensive reviews of safety and health programs for
quality assurance using a process which promotes continuous correction.
-(III) EMPLOYEE PARTICIPATION- With respect to
employee participation, the employer shall
demonstrate a commitment to working to develop a
comprehensive, written and operational safety and
health program that involves employees in
significant ways that affect safety and health. In
making such a demonstration, the employer shall--(aa) provide for employee participation in actively identifying and
resolving safety and health issues in tangible ways that employees can
clearly understand;
-(bb) assign safety and health responsibilities in such a way that
employees can understand clearly what is expected of them;
-(cc) provide employees with the necessary authority and resources to meet
their safety and health responsibilities; and
-(dd) provide that safety and health performance for managers, supervisors
and employees be measured in tangible ways.
-(ii) WORKPLACE ANALYSIS- The employer, in consultation
with the consultant, shall systematically identify and
assess hazards in the following ways:
-(I) Conduct corrective action and regular expert
surveys to update hazard inventories.
-(II) Have competent personnel review every
planned or new facility, process material, or
equipment.
-(III) Train all employees and supervisors,
conduct routine joint inspections, and correct
items identified.
-(IV) Establish a way for employees to report
hazards and provide prompt responses to such
reports.
-(V) Investigate worksite accidents and near
accidents.
-(VI) Provide employees with the necessary
information regarding incident trends, causes and
means of prevention.
-(iii) HAZARD PREVENTION- The employer, in consultation
with the consultant, shall--(I) engage in timely hazard control, working to
ensure that hazard controls are fully in place and
communicated to employees, with emphasis on
engineering controls and enforcing safe work
procedures;
�ARMS Email System
Page 33 of40
-(II) maintain equipment using operators who are
trained to recognize maintenance needs and perform
or direct timely maintenance;
-(III) provide training on emergency planning and
preparation, working to ensure that all personnel
know immediately how to respond as a result of
effective planning, training, and drills;
-(IV) equip facilities for emergencies with all
systems and equipment in place and regularly
tested so that all employees know how to
communicate during emergencies and how to use
equipment; and
-(V) provide for emergency medical situations
using employees who are fully trained in emergency
medicine.
-(iv) SAFETY AND HEALTH TRAINING- The employer, in
consultation with the consultant, shall--(I) involve employees in hazard assessment,
development and delivery of training;
-(II) actively involve supervisors in worksite
analysis by empowering them to ensure physical
protections, reinforce training, enforce
discipline, and explain work procedures; and
-(III) provide training in safety and health
management to managers.
-(4) REINSPECTION- At a time agreed to by the employer and the
consultant, the consultant may reinspect the workplace of the
employer to verify that the required elements in the consultation
report have been satisfied. If such requirements have been
satisfied, the employer shall be provided with a certificate of
compliance for that workplace by the qualified consultant.
-(f) EXEMPTION FROM CIVIL PENALTIES FOR COMPLIANCE-(1) IN GENERAL- If an employer enters into a contract with an
individual qualified under the program under this section, to
provide consultation services described in subsection (b), and
receives a certificate of compliance under subsection (e) (4), the
employer shall be exempt from the assessment of any civil penalty
under section 17 for a period of 1 year after the date on which
the employer receives such certificate.
-(2) EXCEPTIONS- An employer shall not be exempt under paragraph
(1) --
-(A) if the employer has not made a good faith effort to
remain in compliance as required under the certificate of
compliance; or
-(B) to the extent that there has been a fundamental change
in the hazards of the workplace.
�ARMS Email System
Page 34 of 40
'(g) RIGHT TO INSPECT- Nothing in this section shall be construed to
affect the rights of the Secretary to inspect and investigate
worksites covered by a certificate of compliance.
'(h) RENEWAL REQUIREMENTS- An employer that is granted a certificate
of compliance under this section may receive a 1 year renewal of the
certificate if the following elements are satisfied:
'(1) A qualified consultant shall conduct a complete onsite
safety and health survey to ensure that the safety and health
program has been effectively maintained or improved, workplace
hazards are under control, and elements of the safety and health
program are operating effectively.
'(2) The consultant, in an onsite visit by the consultant, has
determined that the program requirements have been complied with
and the health and safety program has been operating effectively.
'(i) NON-FIXED WORK SITES- With respect to employer worksites that do
not have a fixed location, a certificate of compliance shall only
apply to that worksite which satisfies the criteria under this section
and such certificate shall not be portable to any other worksite. This
section shall not apply to service establishments that utilize
essentially the same work equipment at each non-fixed worksite. ' .
SEC. 4. ESTABLISHMENT OF SPECIAL ADVISORY COMMITTEE.
Section 7 of the Act (29 U.S.C. 656) is amended by adding at the end
the following:
'(d) (1) Not later than 6 months after the date of enactment of this
subsection, the Secretary shall establish an advisory committee
(pursuant to the Federal Advisory Committee Act (5 U.S.C. App.»
to
carry out the duties described in paragraph (3).
'(2) The advisory committee shall be composed of-'(A) 3 members who are employees;
'(B) 3 members who are employers;
'(C) 2 members who are members of the general public; and
'(D) 1 member who is a State official from a State plan State.
Each member of the advisory committee shall have expertise in
workplace safety and health as demonstrated by the educational
background of the member.
'(3) The advisory committee shall advise and make recommendations to
the Secretary with respect to the establishment and implementation of
a consultation services program under section SA. ".
SEC. 5. CONTINUING EDUCATION AND PROFESSIONAL CERTIFICATION FOR CERTAIN
OCCUPATIONAL SAFETY AND HEALTH ADMINISTRATION PERSONNEL.
Section 8 of the Act (29 U.S.C. 657) is amended by adding at the end
the following:
'(h) Any Federal employee responsible for enforcing this Act shall,
�ARMS Email System
Page 35 of 40
not later than 2 years after the date of enactment of this subsection
or 2 years after the initial employment of the employee involved, meet
the eligibility requirements prescribed under subsection (b) (2) of
section SA.
'(i) The Secretary shall ensure that any Federal employee responsible
for enforcing this Act who carries out inspections or investigations
under this section, receive professional education and training at
least every 5 years as prescribed by the Secretary. '.
SEC. 6. EXPANDED INSPECTION METHODS.
(a) PURPOSE- It is the purpose of this section to empower the
Secretary of Labor to achieve increased employer compliance by using,
at the Secretary's discretion, more efficient and effective means for
conducting inspections.
(b) GENERAL- Section 8(f) of the Act (29 U.S.C. 657(f) is
amended~-
(1) by adding at the end the following:
'(3) The Secretary or an authorized representative of the Secretary
may, as a method of investigating an alleged violation or danger under
this subsection, attempt, if feasible, to contact an employer by
telephone, facsimile, or other appropriate methods to determine
whether-'(A) the employer has taken corrective actions with respect to
the alleged violation or danger; or
'(B) there are reasonable grounds to believe that a hazard
exists.
'(4) The Secretary is not required to conduct an inspection under this
subsection if the Secretary determines that a request for an
inspection was made for reasons other than the safety and health of
the employees of an employer or that the employees of an employer are
not at risk.'.
SEC. 7. WORKSITE-SPECIFIC COMPLIANCE METHODS.
Section 9 of the Act (29 U.S.C. 65S) is amended by adding at the end
the following:
'(d) A citation issued under subsection (a) to an employer who
violates section 5, any standard, rule, or order promulgated pursuant
to section 6, or any other regulation promulgated under this Act shall
be vacated if such employer demonstrates that the employees of such
employer were protected by alternative methods that are equally or
more protective of the safety and health of the employees than the
methods required by such standard, rule, order, or regulation in the
factual circumstances underlying the citation.
'(e) Subsection (d) shall not be construed to eliminate or modify
other defenses that may exist to any citation.'.
SEC. S. TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE PROGRAM.
(a) IN GENERAL- Section 21(c) of the Act
amended--
(29 U.S.C. 670(c)) is
�ARMS Email System
Page 36 of40
(1) by striking , (c) The' and inserting '(c) (1) The' ;
(2) by striking , (1) provide' and inserting , (A) provide' ;
(3 )
by striking , (2) consult' and inserting , (B) consult' ; and
(4 )
by adding at the end the following:
'(2) (A) The Secretary shall, through the authority granted under
section 7(C) and paragraph (1), enter into cooperative agreements with
States for the provision of consultation services by such States to
employers concerning the provision of safe and healthful working
conditions.
'(B) (i) Except as provided in
reimburse a State that enters
subparagraph (A) in an amount
incurred by the State for the
such agreement.
clause (ii), the Secretary shall
into a cooperative agreement under
that equals 90 percent of the costs
provision of consultation services under
'(ii) A State shall be reimbursed by the Secretary for 90 percent of
the costs incurred by the State for the provision of-'(I) training approved by the Secretary for State personnel
operating under a cooperative agreement; and
'(II) specified out-of-State travel expenses incurred by such
personnel.
'(iii) A reimbursement paid to a State under this subparagraph shall
be limited to costs incurred by such State for the provision of
consultation services under this paragraph and the costs described in
clause (ii).'.
(b) PILOT PROGRAM- Section 21 of the Act (29 U.S.C.
adding at the end the following:
670) is amended by
'(d) (1) Not later than 90 days after the date of enactment of this
subsection, the Secretary shall establish and carry out a pilot
program in 3 States to provide expedited consultation services, with
respect to the provision of safe and healthful working conditions, to
employers that are small businesses (as the term is defined by the
Administrator of the Small Business Administration). The Secretary
shall carry out the program for a period of not to exceed 2 years.
'(2) The Secretary shall provide consultation services under paragraph
(1) not later than 4 weeks after the date on which the Secretary
receives a request from an employer.
'(3) The Secretary may impose a nominal fee to an employer requesting
consultation services under paragraph (1). The fee shall be in an
amount determined by the Secretary. Employers paying a fee shall
receive priority consultation services by the Secretary.
'(4) In lieu of issuing a citation under section 9 to an employer for
a violation found by the Secretary during a consultation under
paragraph (1), the Secretary shall permit the employer to carry out
corrective measures to correct the conditions causing the violation.
The Secretary shall conduct not more than 2 visits to the workplace of
�ARMS Email System
Page 37 of 40
the employer to determine if the employer has carried out the
corrective measures. The Secretary shall issue a citation as
prescribed under section 5 if, after such visits, the employer has
failed to carry out the corrective measures.
-(5) Not later than 90 days after the termination of the program under
paragraph (1), the Secretary shall prepare and submit a report to the
appropriate committees of Congress that contains an evaluation of the
implementation of the pilot program. ' .
SEC. 9. VOLUNTARY PROTECTION PROGRAMS.
(a) COOPERATIVE AGREEMENTS- The Secretary of Labor shall establish
cooperative agreements with employers to encourage the establishment
of comprehensive safety and health management systems that include--
(1) requirements for systematic assessment of hazards;
. (2) comprehensive hazard prevention, mitigation, and control
programs;
(3) active and meaningful management and employee participation
in the voluntary program described in subsection (b); and
(4)
employee safety and health training.
(b) VOLUNTARY PROTECTION PROGRAM-
(1) IN GENERAL- The Secretary of Labor shall establish and carry
out a voluntary protection program (consistent with subsection
(a)) to encourage and recognize the achievement of excellence in
both the technical and managerial protection of employees from
occupational hazards.
(2) PROGRAM REQUIREMENT- The voluntary protection program shall
include the following:
(A) APPLICATION- Employers who volunteer under the program
shall be required to submit an application to the Secretary
of Labor demonstrating that the worksite with respect to
which the application is made meets such requirements as the
Secretary of Labor may require for participation in the
program.
(B) ONSITE EVALUATIONS- .There shall be onsite evaluations by
representatives of the Secretary of Labor to ensure a high
level of protection of employees. The onsite visits shall
not result in enforcement of citations under the
Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 (29 U.S.C. 651 et
seq.) .
(C) INFORMATION- Employers who are approved by the Secretary
of Labor for participation in the program shall assure the
Secretary of Labor that information about the safety and
health program of the employers shall be made readily
available to the Secretary of Labor to share with employees.
(D) REEVALUATIONS- Periodic reevaluations by the Secretary
of Labor of the employers shall be required for continued
participation in the program.
�ARMS Email System
Page 38 of40
(3) EXEMPTIONS- A site with respect to which a program has been
approved shall, during participation in the program be exempt
from inspections or investigations and certain paperwork
requirements to be determined by the Secretary of Labor, except
that this paragraph shall not apply to inspections or
investigations arising from employee complaints, fatalities,
catastrophes, or significant toxic releases.
(4) INCREASED SMALL BUSINESS PARTICIPATION- The Secretary of
Labor shall establish and implement, by regulation, a program to
increase participation by small businesses (as the term is
defined by the Administrator of the Small Business
Administration) in the voluntary protection program through
outreach and assistance initiatives and developing program
requirements that address the needs of small businesses.
SEC. 10. PREVENTION OF ALCOHOL AND SUBSTANCE ABUSE.
The Act (29 U.S.C. 651 et seq.) is amended by adding at the end the
following:
'SEC. 35. ALCOHOL AND SUBSTANCE ABUSE TESTING.
'(a) PROGRAM PURPOSE- In order to secure a safe workplace, employers
may establish and carry out an alcohol and substance abuse testing
program in accordance with subsection (b).
'(b) FEDERAL GUIDELINES'(1) REQUIREMENTS- An alcohol and substance abuse testing program
described in subsection (a) shall meet the following
requirements:
'(A) SUBSTANCE ABUSE- A substance abuse testing program
shall permit the use of an onsite or offsite testing.
'(B) ALCOHOL- The alcohol testing component of the program
shall take the form of alcohol breath analysis and shall
conform to any guidelines developed by the Secretary of
Transportation for alcohol testing of mass transit employees
under' the Department of Transportation and Related Agencies
Appropriations Act, 1992.
'(2) DEFINITION- For purposes of this section the term 'alcohol
and substance abuse testing program' means any program under
which test procedures are used to take an analyze blood, breath,
hair, urine, saliva, or other body fluids or materials for the
purpose of detecting the presence or absence
of alcohol or a drug or its metabolites. In the case of urine testing, the
confirmation tests must be performed in accordance with the mandatory
guidelines for Federal workplace testing programs published by the
Secretary of Health and Human Services on April 11, 1988, at section 11979
of title 53, Code of Federal Regulations (including any amendments to such
guidelines). Proper laboratory protocols and procedures shall be used to
assure accuracy and fairness and laboratories must be subject to the
requirements of subpart B of the mandatory guidelines, State certification,
the Clinical Laboratory Improvements Act of the College of American
Pathologists.
�ARMS Email System
Page 39 0[40
-(c) TEST REQUIREMENTS- This section shall not be construed to
prohibit an employer from requiring--(1) an applicant for employment to submit to and pass an alcohol
or substance abuse test before employment by the employer; or
-(2) an employee, including managerial personnel, to submit to
and pass an alcohol or substance abuse test--(A) on a for-cause basis or where the employer has
reasonable suspicion to believe that such employee is using
or is under the influence of alcohol or a controlled
substance;
-(B) where such test is administered as part of a scheduled
medical examination;
-(C) in the case of an accident or incident, involving the
actual or potential loss of human life, bodily injury, or
property damage;
-(D) during the participation of an employee in an alcohol
or substance abuse treatment program, and for a reasonable
period of time (not to exceed 5 years) after the conclusion
of such program; or
-(E) on a random selection basis in work units, locations,
or facilities.
-(d) CONSTRUCTION- Nothing in this section shall be construed to
require an employer to establish an alcohol and substance abuse
testing program for applicants or employees or make employment
decisions based on such test results.
-(e) PREEMPTION- The provisions of this section shall not preempt any
provision of State law to the extent that such State law is
inconsistent with this section.
-(f) INVESTIGATIONS- The Secretary is authorized to conduct testing of
employees (including managerial personnel) of an employer for use of
alcohol or controlled substances during any investigations of a
work-related fatality or serious injury.'.
SEC. 11. DISCRETIONARY COMPLIANCE ASSISTANCE.
Subsection (a) of section 9 of the Act (29 U.S.C. 658(a)} is amended
to read as follows:
-(a) (1) Nothing in this Act shall be construed as prohibiting the
Secretary or the authorized representative of the Secretary from
providing technical or compliance assistance to an employer in
correcting a violation discovered during an inspection or
investigation under this Act without issuing a citation.
-(2) Except as provided in paragraph (3), if, upon an inspection or
investigation, the Secretary or an authorized representative of the
Secretary believes that an employer has violated a requirement of
section 5, of any regulation, rule, or order promulgated pursuant to
section 6, or of any regulations prescribed pursuant to this Act, the
�ARMS Email System
Page 40 of40
secretary may with reasonable promptness issue a citation to the
employer. Each citation shall be in writing and shall describe with
particularity the nature of a violation, including a reference to the
provision of the Act, regulation, rule, or order alleged to have been
violated. The citation shall fix a reasonable time for the abatement
of the violation.
'(3) The Secretary or the authorized representative of the Secretary-'(A) may issue a warning in lieu of a citation with respect to a
violation that has no significant relationship to employee safety
or health; and
'(B) may issue a warning in lieu of a citation in cases in which
an employer in good faith acts promptly to abate a violation if
the violation is not a willful or repeated violation. ' .
END
==================
END ATTACHMENT
2
==================
�ARMS Email System
_ i,
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 7
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-MAR-1999 19:36:10.00
SUBJECT:
LABOR Draft Bill on Alien Labor Certification User Fees
TO: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susanne D. Lind ( CN=Susanne D. Lind/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Justin D. Sullivan ( CN=Justin D. Sullivan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rosemarie W. Dale ( CN=Rosemarie W. Dale/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert F. Mahaffie ( CN=Robert F. Mahaffie/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah S. Lee ( CN=Sarah S. Lee/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Justine F. Rodriguez ( CN=Justine F. Rodriguez/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=AndreaKane/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Irene.Bueno ( CN=Irene Bueno/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer E. Brown ( CN=Jennifer E. Brown/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter Rundlet ( CN=Peter Rundlet/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark J. Schwartz ( CN=Mark J. Schwartz/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of7
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Harry E. Moran ( CN=Harry E. Moran/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: J. Eric Gould ( CN=J. Eric Gould/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Barry White
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM JUSTICE ( LRM JUSTICE [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM TREASURY ( LRM TREASURY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Karen DORSEY ( Karen DORSEY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM STATE ( LRM STATE [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM COMMERCE ( LRM COMMERCE [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
LRM Small Business Administration ( LRM Small Business Administration [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: MNB26
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Wednesday, March 3, 1999
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
SUBJECT:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395-6148
LABOR Draft Bill on Alien Labor Certification User Fees
DEADLINE:
1 p.m.
Friday, March 5, 1999
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of7
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS:
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - Dennis Burke - (202) 514-2141
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
107-Smal1 Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin 114-STATE - Paul Rademacher - (202) 647-4463
EOP:
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Andrea Kane
Cordelia W. Reimers
Justine F. Rodriguez
J. Eric Gould
Elena Kagan
Harry E. Moran
Sarah S. Lee
Karen Tramontano
Robert G. Damus
Mark J. Schwartz
Robert F. Mahaffie
Peter Rundlet
Rosemarie W. Dale
Jennifer E. Brown
David J. Haun
Steven M. Mertens
Justin D. Sullivan
Irene Bueno
Susanne D. Lind
Janet R. Forsgren
James J. Jukes
LRM ID: MNB26
SUBJECT:
User Fees
LABOR
(202) 205-6700
Draft Bill on Alien Labor Certification
,RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
�ARMS Email System
TO:
Page 4 of7
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
______ No Objection
______ No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
______ Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
==================== ATTACHMENT 1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D15]MAIL40689766L.036 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750431E040000010A02010000000205000000E21E000000020000197BEF1AOAFE7F5DECF678
69087ECD2AD5312391BFCE7C2F2966D433AC61B46D55E6F82E01353CEFF86B2AA1727A84D9545F
5135AD5E277098720F9B3A86CCC882F21DOB445E5562538A4EC56D300CF269F205965A6660967B
ADDA9FOC42CB6E4AB2461D8504725C809A3D881056A3F3893D2CF05027FDF7C30C3FE92684ACA1
8823E2D4D1F62C227436E97BD623025DE9790DC9BCFF1891A58BBD1C026EE6F9B900D55A5C583A
EE271EC72B9647541C0170E5675173823B871DC2D589E1505AFDOE167521219C16B271E85B940E
6387BF38CEC17E35B3152BD394865FD189F5C87C2A22054A64B3B6OCFE6C41D7B4F55C9E5CF06F
FCB9C77132567DAC821366D159EF730BB2FE9EA033A0548AEOA9441DC3DF24E1FD4649FAD40909
2873998E9COB940B17882130C4D1295137370052ACOBB8F89B36FEC1415848F9512030F1EC6050
A9B6AD609E98970AA9E96447C2D9D9AE4B5BEFD03A9F44427D78E976368FF2C76C66EDA21B81E4
9C39A29BC37A5C1DCC2165DDBB44DACFB937FCOC77D165D502AF5F1914EDCDF4CC87BB74FD8087
E4F5463D715878D3B3678C49FAC58AFF25ADEC22BB4B4E78093CE034168BE1EE27FAOFF79BC7EE
F92353C486D8294393F054FA9DE0389A1D15789BAA26D65A987739CE5D74FEEOA9BD69AF59DFD9
035C56A23502000800000000000000000000000823010000000B01000070020000005501000000
4E0000007B03000009250100000006000000C90300000B300200000028000000CF030000087701
00000004000000F703000008340100000014000000FB0300000802010000000FOOOOOOOF040000
00984800500020004C0061007300650072004A006500740020003400200050006C007500730000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000004850
50434C354D5300000000002C01F0002C012C012C012C012C01FOOO300000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000006E4CFOCF2800C8196810
480D000011090000005AOOOB010000103600540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052
006F006D0061006E00200052006500670075006C00610072000000000000000000010002005802
�Automated Records Managel!'ent System
. Hex-Dump ConversIon
DRAFT 3/3/99
SUBTITLE G-- ALIEN LABOR CERTIFICATION USER FEES
SEC.
ESTABLISHMENT OF FEES.
(a) PERMANENT IMMIGRANT APPLICATION FEES.-- Section 212(a)(5)(A) of the
Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1l82(a)(5)(A) is amended-(1) in clause (i), by-(A) striking "and" at the end of subclause (I),
(B) striking the period at the end of subclause (II) and inserting ", and",
and
(C) by adding at the end the following:
"(III) the employer has submitted an application for certification of
the alien under this paragraph and has paid an application fee in
accordance with clause (iv)."; and
(2) by adding at the end the following:
"(iv)(I) The Secretary of Labor shall impose a fee of $500 on an employer
that-"(aa) submits an application to the Secretary of Labor for
certification under this subparagraph on or after October 1, 1999, or
"(bb) requests a review pursuant to an expedited process
1
�AutOmated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
established by the Secretary of Labor of an application that was submitted
to the Secretary of Labor for certification under this subparagraph prior to
October 1, 1999.
"(II)(aa) The employer submitting the application under this subparagraph
shall not require or accept payment, directly or indirectly, of the fees established
pursuant to subclause (I) by the alien who is the beneficiary of the certification.
"(bb) If the Secretary of Labor determines, after notice and opportunity for
a hearing, that a violation of sub-subclause (aa) has occurred, the Secretary of
Labor may impose a civil penalty in an amount not to exceed $1,000 per violation
and an administrative order requiring the return of any amounts received in
violation of sub-subclause (aa) to the alien, or if the alien cannot be located, to the
general fund of the Treasury.
"(III) Fees collected under this clause shall be deposited in the Treasury in
accordance with s.ection 286(u).".
(b) H-2B NONIMMIGRANT APPLICATION FEES.-- Section 214(c) of the Immigration
and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1184(c)) is amended by adding at the end the following:
"(10)(A) Pursuant to the consultation process described in paragraph (1), the
Secretary of Labor shall impose a fee of $500 on employers that submit an application to
the Secretary of Labor for certification of a nonimmigrant temporary worker as described
in section 101(a)(15)(H)(ii)(b).
"(B)(i) The employer submitting the application under this subsection shall not
require or accept payment of the fee established under subparagraph (A), directly or
2
�Automated ~tlcords Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
indirectly, by the alien who is the beneficiary of the certification.
"(ii) If the Secretary of Labor detennines, after notice and opportunity for a
hearing, that a violation of clause (i) has occurred, the Secretary of Labor may impose a
civil penalty in an amount not to exceed $1,000 per violation and administrative order.
requiring the return of any amounts received in violation of clause (i) to the alien, or if the
alien cannot be located, to the general fund of the Treasury.
"(C) Fees collected under this paragraph shall be deposited in the Treasury in
accordance with section 286(u).".
SEC.
. ESTABLISHMENT OF ACCOUNT AND USE OF FUNDS.
Section 286 of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1356) is amended by
adding at the end the following:
"(u) ALIEN LABOR CERTIFICATION USER FEE ACCOUNT.
"(1) ESTABLISHMENT.-- There is established in the general fund of the
Treasury a separate account, which shall be known as the' Alien Labor
Certification User Fee Account'. Notwithstanding any other section of this title,
there shall be deposited as offsetting receipts into the account all fees.
collected under sections 212(a)(5)(A) and 214(c)(10).
"(2) USE OF FEES.-- The fees deposited into the Alien Labor
Certification User Fee Account shall be available to the Secretary of Labor for the
costs of administering alien labor certification activities under sections
212(a)(5)(A) and 214(c)(lO). In addition, if, in any fiscal year, the Secretary of
3
�I'
,j
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Labor determines that there are amounts in the account in excess of the
amo~nts
necessary to carry out the certification activities for such year, the excess shall be
available to the Secretary of Labor to carry out activities for dislocated workers in
accordance section 171(d) of the Workforce Investment Act of 1998.
"(3) AVAILABILITY OF FUNDS.-- The fees deposited into the Alien
Labor Certification User Fee account under this subsection shall remain available
until expended for the activities described in paragraph (2).".
4
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 5-MAR-1999 14:01:37.00
SUBJECT:
Decision Meeting on Comparable Worth
TO: Jennifer M. Luray ( CN=Jennifer M. Luray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: jorszag ( jorszag @ doc.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
WHO 1 )
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CEA 1 )
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Caroline R. Fredrickson ( CN=Caroline R. Fredrickson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dawn V. Woollen ( CN=Dawn V. Woollen/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Elena Kagan is holding a meeting on Wednesday, March 10 at 4p.m. in Room
211 to discuss the Administration's position on comparable worth as
contained in Senator Harkin's bill. We will also discuss positions on
collecting wage data.
Thanks, Mary
�• . ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page I of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 12-MAR-1999 11:59:28.00
SUBJECT:
pay data from Census
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lynda.delavina@treas.sprint.com ( lynda.delavina@treas.sprint.com [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Mat'lack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nora E. Gordon ( CN=Nora E. Gordon/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Montgomery-Edward ( Montgomery-Edward @ dol.gov [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Carr ( CN=Susan M. Carr/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ : UNKNO~
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mark.McClellan@MS01.DO.treas.sprint.com ( Mark.McClellan@MS01.DO.treas.sprint.co
READ: UNKN9WN
CC: holzer-harry ( holzer-harry @ dol.gov [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Harry Holzer has pointed out something very interesting:
The decennial Census has data that in some ways is even better than the
proposed EEO-1 could generate, for creating a "profile" of wages by gender
and race/ethnicity within occupation, industry, and local labor market.
The Census has hundreds of 3-digit occupations, within 3-digit industry
and city or metro area, whereas the proposed EEO-1 would have only 15
occupational categories. The full Census has this information for an
approximately 15% random sample of all workers in firms of all sizes, and
the Public Use Microdata Sample (PUMS) has it on 5% of them.
The Census' disadvantage is that it gets as much as 12 years out of date
before the next Census data are available, it does not have information on
firm size (so one can't separate firms with over 100 employees from
smaller ones), and it is a sample rather than all workers.
This suggests that EEOC could creat "screening" profiles without having
pay data on the EEO-1s from every firm with over 100 employees.
It could
collect the pay data from a firm against which a complaint is filed, and
compare it with the profile from the most recent Census for that
�AE.,.MS Email System
occupation, industry, and local labor market area.
Page 2 of2
�..
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 15-MAR-1999 15:36:22.00
SUBJECT:
focusing pay data collection
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: holzer-harry ( holzer-harry @ dol.gov [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Mark.McClellan@MS01.DO.treas.sprint.com ( Mark.McClellan@MS01.DO.treas.sprint.co
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nora E. Gordon ( CN=Nora E. Gordon/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Montgomery-Edward ( Montgomery-Edward @ dol.gov [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
)
TO: lynda.delavina@treas.sprint.com ( lynda.delavina@treas.sprint.com [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Carr ( CN=Susan M. Carr /OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] .)
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Attached is a proposal by CEA to use Census data to focus collection of
pay data on problematic industries.
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D68]MAIL450756970.036 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750435A040000010A02010000000205000000A71100000002000051BOCF076476523839AD2D
74CB8575A576AAB32ED3C033ABD23BA6DAE1953BEEE72D39E49DD30ED13718E6BFC11F57BD630D
A1E95875DE416AA9066EOD8FB39D7368523363731116221DB1C5A2F1A9D223B6DD1FA7A4287D4F
10DF95920BOD7DA8F3096556AF4CBD4535502C3D6D300FD3791A4B3E77581EC2A2C409A762BOA6
52CFOAA927848C5E75A03943D88EBFE2EC53C2CA37997D91CEEA7457754F2B61C56C4756EB7CF5
E3B7B5E9DCF6B5EB3F3E33B9237A6E8871E937AB5241CF723590CC9F7794035428B6F95D4603DF
OD05EC8098841F26AE687280276724290EC69182548C45022AF973DFC03032FCOC7B9859B4EB82
B44B6E7E6AA86CE46333BEA71A4B82D1513A91C6D8B037C315EA53C9B9C7E8D100496E4B223CD7
)
�".
A.utomated Re
.
cards Ma
Hex.Dump Co:;jrse'!'ent SYstem
" Jon
CEA Proposal to use Census data to focus collection of pay data on problematic industries:
Collection of pay data from all firms in the EEO-I universe, or even half of all Federal
contractors (which would be 30% of the EEO-I universe), would be very expensive. It would
be better to target any additional data collection where existing data indicate that there may be a
problem. The value of the data could be enhanced and the collection cost reduced by targeting
on the top 10% of industries that have problematic gender pay differentials, as indicated by the
micro data from the decennial Census.
The 1990 Census Public Use Microdata Sarnple (PUMS) data file could be used as described
below, to create profiles of gender differences in wages by narrowly defined occupation,
industry, and labor market area, adjusted for differences in educational attainment and age.
Then those industries that have unusually large gender differences in wages within occupation
and area could be identified, and firms in those industries could be required to submit pay data on
a revised EEO-I, 60/2, or other form.
The Census PUMS data, while somewhat dated, are still useful for preliminary screening to
identify those industries that warrant closer scrutiny. Gender wage differentials within
. industries do not change very rapidly over time. In some ways, the Census is more useful for
identifying suspicious gender gaps than the proposed revised EEO-I form would be, because it
identifies hundreds of detailed (3-digit) occupations and includes workers' education and age. It
contains data on a 5% random sample of individuals (about 5 million workers) and is publicly
available for anyone to use.
For each individual the 1990 Census PUMS file includes:
annual earnings, weeks worked, and hours worked per week -- from which average hourly
earnings can be calculated
3-digit occupation
3-digit industry
residence (state, metro area, city)
place of work (state, metro area, city)
gender
race, Hispanic origin group, birthplace, date of immigration, ancestry
educational attainment
age
and other demographic characteristics
There is rio information on firm size, actual work experience, or fringe benefits. Despite the
lack of firm-level data, however, the Census data are still useful for identifying problematic
industries.
There is considerable doubt about the usefulness of any pay data that would be collected on the
proposed revised EEO-I, because the few (IS?) broad occupational categories would cover many
different job titles at different skill levels and rates of pay, and because the data would lack
information on workers' qualifications, experience, fringe benefits, and working conditions.
This information is essential to determining whether pay differences may be the resuit of illegal
�.J
discrimination. However, if any such additional data are to be collected, the use of Census data
as described above would focus the collection more cost-effectively.
Automated ReCOrds M
Hex-Dump Canage'!1ent SYsterr
onversfon
,.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[02/26/1999 – 03/15/1999]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 099 - Folder 011
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/45b2ad31ffc6cc25e6da1f7b2507f5cf.pdf
b2da9a3319acfa53ad0c2c1e5048ca6f
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 099 - FOLDER -010
[01/08/1999-02/09/1999]
�Withdrawal/Redaction Sheet
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
AND TYPE
001. email
SUBJECTfflTLE
DATE
Email to Rosina Bierbaum et al from Jodi Sakol. Subject: Job
Placement (8 pages)
01/08/1999
RESTRICTION
Personal Misfile
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management System [Email]
CEA ([Kagan])
OAiBox Number:
950000
FOLDER TITLE:
[01/08/1999 - 02/09/1999]
2009- J006-F
jm53
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act - 144 U.S.c. 2204(a)1
Freedom of Information Act -15 U.S.c. 552(b)1
PI National Security Classified Information 1(8)(1) of the PRAI
P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office l(a)(2) of the PRAI
P3 Release would violate a Federal statute l(a)(3) of the PRAI
b(l) National security classified information l(b)(I) of the FatAl
b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
an agency l(b)(2) of the FOIAI
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute l(b)(3) of the FOIAI
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial
information l(b)(4) of the FOIAI
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(b)(6) of the FOIAI
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes l(b)(7) of the FOIAI
b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
financial institutions l(b)(8) of the FatAl
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
concerning wells l(b)(9) of the FOIAI
P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
financial information l(a)(4) of the PRAI
P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President
and his advisors, or between such advisors la)(5) of the PRAI
P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(a)(6) of the PRAI
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
of gift.
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.c.
2201(3).
RR. Document will be reviewed upon request.
�Withdrawal/Redaction Marker
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
AND TYPE
001. email
SUBJECTrrITLE
DATE
Email to Rosina Bierbaum et al from Jodi Sakol. Subject: Job
Placement (8 pages)
01/0811999
RESTRICTION
Personal Misfile
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management System [Email]
CEA ([Kagann
OAlBox Number: 950000
FOLDER TITLE:
[01/0811999 - 02109/1999]
2009-1006-F
jm53
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act - 144 U.S.c. 2204(a)l
Freedom of Information Act - 15 U.S.c. 552(b)\
PI National Security Classified Information l(a)(l) of the PRAI
P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office l(a)(2) of the PRAI
P3 Release would violate a Federal statute l(a)(3) of the PRAI
b(l) National security classified information l(b)(l) of the FOIAI
b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
an agency l(b)(2) of the FOIAI
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute l(b)(3) of the FOIAI
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial
information l(b)(4) of the FOIAI
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(b)(6) of the FOIAI
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes l(b)(7) of the FOIAI
b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
financial institutions l(b)(8) of the FOIAI
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
concerning wells l(b)(9) of the FOIAI
P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
financial information l(a)(4) of the PRAI
PS Release would disclose confidential advice between the President
and his advisors, or between such advisors la)(5) of the PRAI
P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(a)(6) of the PRAI
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
of gift.
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.c.
2201(3).
RR. Document will be reviewed upon request.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
I,
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:13-JAN-1999 12:53:14.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Shirley S. Sagawa ( CN=Shirley S. Sagawa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN
TO: Skye S. Philbrick ( CN=Skye S. Philbrick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN .
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=E6p @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kelley L. O'Dell
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Kelley L. O'Dell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Jennifer M. Luray ( CN=Jennifer M. Luray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
.,
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:30am in Room 100. Thanks.
Page 2 of2
�Page 1 of2
· 4.RMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-JAN-1999 18:07:25.00
SUBJECT:
WOMEN'S MTG
TO: Shirley S. Sagawa ( CN=Shirley S. Sagawa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Skye S. Philbrick ( CN=Skye S. Phi1brick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP' [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP,@ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kelley L. O'Dell ( CN=Kelley L. O'Dell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Luray ( CN=Jennifer M. Luray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�I~
j}RMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Tracey E. Thornton
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks
�I..
•
AR.MS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-JAN-1999 18:07:53.00
SUBJECT:
CHANGE- WOMEN'S MTG
TO: Shirley S. Sagawa ( CN=Shirley S. Sagawa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T .. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/O=Ovp
READ: UNKNOWN
@
OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Skye S. Philbrick ( CN=Skye S. Philbrick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD 1 .)
[ WHO 1
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kelley L.O'Dell ( CN=Kelley L. O'Dell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Luray ( CN=Jennifer M. Luray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�AR,MS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha .Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: EllenM. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
9:30am. Thursday. Room 100. Thanks.
---------------------- Forwarded by Ruby Shamir/WHO/EOP on 01/20/99 06:07
PM ---------------------------
Ruby Shamir
01/20/99 06:05:21 PM
Record Type: Record
To: See the distribution list at the bottom of this message
cc:
Page 2 of3
�ARMS Email System
Subject: WOMEN'S MTG
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks
Message Sent
To:
Ell-e-n-M~.~L-ov--e7l7l~/~W~H~O~/~E~O~P------------------------------------------
Lucia F. Gilliland/OVP @ OVP
Lynn G. Cutler/WHO/EOP
Minyon Moore/WHO/EOP
Maria Echaveste/WHO/EOP
Elena Kagan/OPD/EOP
Tracey E. Thornton/WHO/EOP
Janet Murguia/WHO/EOP
Marsha Scott/WHO/EOP
Robin Leeds/WHO/EOP
Stacie Spector/WHO/EOP
Rebecca M. Blank/CEA/EOP
Sandra Thurman/OPD/EOP
Virginia Apuzzo/WHO/EOP
Sylvia M. Mathews/OMB/EOP
Katharine Button/WHO/EOP
Marjorie Tarmey/WHO/EOP
Laura Emmett/WHO/EOP
Nicole R. Rabner/WHO/EOP
Jennifer L. Klein/OPD/EOP
Mona G. Mohib/WHO/EOP
Francine P. Obermiller/CEA/EOP
Mindy E. Myers/WHO/EOP
Leslie Bernstein/WHO/EOP
Janet L. Graves/OMB/EOP
Maureen T. Shea/WHO/EOP
Sondra L. Seba/WHO/EOP
Skye S. Philbrick/WHO/EOP
Jennifer M. Luray/WHO/EOP
Audrey T. Haynes/OvP @ OVP
Kelley L. O'Dell/WHO/EOP
Shirley S. Sagawa/WHO/EOP
Page 3 of3
�AR.~S
Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of4
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:2S-JAN-1999 08:31:24.00
SUBJECT:
Caseload analysis
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Robert F. Schoeni ( CN=Robert F. Schoeni/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: edahl ( edahl @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Jennings-Lynn ( Jennings-Lynn @ dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: mkharfen ( mkharfen @ acf.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Updated
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
analysis of national caseload trends
Bob, note Sept 98 numbers got revised slightly -- HHS will send revised
month by month chart so you can update your database.==================== ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D211MAIL49243742G.036 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
00001A0002100400000000002BOOOOOS2S002000010AOOOOOOOOOO0000001F0008000000013000
002B001F00080000010130020020001F0008000002013002002BOO1F0008000003013002002BOO
1F0008000004013002001C001F000800000S013002001C000300060001000000010004001C0001
010100000006164S040400B72COE0001000000FAF2991607266AOOOSOOl0000000171C2C000300
1A0000002000000006000S00000077110907000E0000007711010C020C030C040COSOCOA001AOO
0000194342434FSOS900SF080000000000001900000S1900000S21000100000B000100000E0020
00000000000000000000000000000000000080FF3FOOOOOOOOOOOOF8FFOB4001000FOOS6000100
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000010000000000000000010000000000000000000004004C00020002004200
4C00420000001100B2000100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000101010101010000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000001000EOOOEOOOE000000000000000000000071
00002B7100002B7100002BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001BOOIBOOFOOF08
000COOOC00000000000000002000000000FF417269616C001BOOIB00FOOF20000COOOCOOOOOOOO
000000002000000000FF417269616C001B004800E60F1000000110000E00000011080000000000
�',.
,
FOIA Number:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management
System [EMAIL]
This is not a presidential record. This is used as an
administrative markerby the William J. Clinton Presidential
Librarv Staff.
Hex Dump file is not in a recognizable format, has been incorrectly
decoded or is damaged.
Attachment Number: [ATTACH.D21]MAIL49243742G.036 to ASCII
Kagan 03
�A~MS
Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-JAN-l999 l5:45:23.00
SUBJECT:
WOMEN' MTG
TO: Shirley S. Sagawa ( CN=Shirley S. Sagawa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Skye S. Philbrick ( CN=Skye S. Philbrick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena
READ: UNKNOWN
Kagan/OU=~PD/O=EOP @
EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kelley L. O'Dell ( CN=Kelley L. O'Dell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Luray ( CN=Jennifer M. Luray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�~S
Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:30am in room 100. Thanks.
�Page 1 of18
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 5-FEB-1999 09:53:08.00
SUBJECT:
LABOR Draft Bill on Unemployment Compensation Amendments of 1999
TO: kclark ( kclark @ doc.gov @ inet [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: justice.lrm ( justice.lrm @ usdoj.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@ inet
[ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
TO: karen. dorsey ( karen. dorsey @ treas.sprint.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward M. Rea ( CN=Edward M. Rea/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart Shapiro ( CN=Stuart Shapiro/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Justine F. Rodriguez ( CN=Justine F. Rodriguez/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susanne D. Lind ( CN=Susanne D. Lind/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: gregory.m.jones
READ: UNKNOWN
gregory.m.jones @ usdoj.gov
@ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: lrm ( lrm @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: agc.llr ( agc.llr @ treas.sprint.com @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers ( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edwin Lau ( CN=Edwin Lau/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 18
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J.
READ: UNKNOWN
Chenok/OU=O~B/O=EOP@EOP
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Sarah S. Lee ( CN=Sarah S. Lee/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carole Kitti ( CN=Carole Kitti/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
NOTE TO EOP STAFF: YOU WILL NOT RECEIVE A SEPARATE HARD COPY OF THIS LRM.
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 02/04/99
06:41 PM --------------------------Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: MNBB
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Friday, February 5, 1999
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
SUBJECT:
of 1999
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395 - 614B
LABOR Draft Bill on Unemployment Compensation Amendments
DEADLINE:
Noon
Wednesday, February 10, 1999
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS:
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES: .
61-JUSTICE - Dennis Burke - (202)
11B-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro 52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202)
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt EOP:
514-2141
(202) 622-0650
690-7760
(202) 482-3151
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of IS
f.
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Carole Kitti
Jonathan Orszag
Elena Kagan
Susanne D. Lind
Sarah S. Lee
Justine F. Rodriguez
Daniel J. Chenok
Stuart Shapiro
Edwin Lau
Edward M. Rea
Cordelia W. Reimers
Robert G. Damus
James J. Jukes
Janet R. Forsgren
LRM ID: MNB8
SUBJECT:
Amendments of 1999
LABOR
Draft Bill on Unemployment Compensation
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
FROM:
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
�ARMS Email System
Page 40f18
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
1 ====================
==================== ATTACHMENT
o 00:00:00.00
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D51]MAIL43184293G.036 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750436E050000010A02010000000205000000228000000002000050B162D75FEF4E87312351
9050EF5EE041190F6C126AA3785C6FC1239010040C9AB2C8D5D3E8EAOD3D4B73DFE9DCEE650246
D32623E2174C70DAB287CA7E3B9B2388A42161D573F95BC91F91700EC8B58399717FE237998C3A
7A6E5580807887C3330DOECOB594BBCE84E75462B59EB3E71AF10099C3CA5CBE9EEEOF0288CF98
C09D098BAC945304733EAEOEC7AB2302D68E54CFCBBDC5B2D9EABAFCO4F7B51F27CE5029E40F3C
299EF7BD1C72419BA63792FDDAE555E5E2C27DE83407E0816AD9021073972DDCBOD91CA1445CDD
OF3BB8714EB46E5B96609598763BC2E15D09065664A9B78EF1CEF26AOBOE53FE53DAA3AOC4BF60
6EA21CE90C857A61A5F3C1B8749EAF98CEODC9BF5FCC1A4F4CBC97B7B1A06539EE3DB867C382AF
2ADOBE2210D448COFF567B41F95B7A85AEDD362D6F3F2F989F7B409EC94292828A6A93FD9EDE8C
4D728683DF7D47E833B094B93AC76BE94147F9EB3EC5369F4BAC7784D18A30F45AFCD94493E1B7
03E8F8BE945482AE21C1A4CCDF993FCE63A91EAD940A17D8F3070F0150A3A52806A99F2FB23EAB
CF75DFB4C4BEE01B543ADCDB9FCC290AEB8011E8C992D3E9DD60889DE9314A8AA49AA7689809A8
98DOA92F6F90A5CBBDCF7E53DEA1E66D73176255310B505D6847CACC8188C15DDOD9453C6D96A9
D451AFB49202001000000000000000000000000823010000000B010000E0020000005503000000
4EOOOOOOEB03000009250100000006000000390400000B3002000000280000003F040000087701
000000400000006704000008340100000014000000A70400000802010000000FOOOOOOBB040000
08050100000008000000CA04000000000000000000000000CA0400OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOCA
04000000000000000000000000CA04000000000000000000000000CA0400000000000000000000
0000CA0400000055040000004EOOOOOOD20400000055010000004E0000002005000000985C005C
004F004D0042002D00500053002D00320038002D00320039005COO370032003000320042000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F
4COOOOOOOOOOC800C8002C012C012C012C01C800C8003000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000B0100002800D61EC30F3908000011
090000005AOOOB01008B143600540069006D006500730020004EOO65007700200052006F006DOO
61006E00200052006500670075006C006100720000000000000000000100020058020100000004
002800000000000000000000000000000000000000011202002400A1000000A10000000AOOOOOO
010001005600020002001300030001005600040007001300050002009D00060001004400070002
005B00080002009D000900010044000A0001000200F688442600000000005401000000D41AOOOO
B35F08337C007800000200000A0000000301000400020000002800D61EC30F3908000011090000
005AOOOB01008B143600540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E
00200052006500670075006C006100720000000000000000002800D61EC30F3908000011090000
005AOOOB01008B143600540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E
00200052006500670075006C00610072000000000000000000DDOA100083010400030002002110
00DDDDOBOB00030000040BOODDD10337008001000016004DE40100005802060000580200000000
00000064F000000000000000000000000000000000000064C8003700D1D1060C0000010001000C
00D1D1020D00000100FDOOOAODOOD1D41A1F0080010E00080058024DE400005802000058020200
580200001FOOD4D41A1F0087010F00080058024DE400005802000058020E0058024DE41FOOD4F2
OCF280808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080
808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080
808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080808080
80808080808080808080808080808080F30CF3445241465480322F342F3939F20CF2D004150000
OB00090001B0040000000001201500DOCC9BE0110C000000000807OCOOE09C5355425449544C45
804484554E454D504C4F594D454E5480434F4D50454E534154494F4E80414D454E444D454E5453
804F4680313939399BF30CF3D0141500000B000900019006E001020001201500DOE0110COOOOOO
�Automated Records Management S t
Hex-Dump Conversion ys em
DRAFT 2/4/99
SUBTITLE D-UNEMPLOYMENT COMPENSATION AMENDMENTS OF 1999
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This subtitle may be cited as the "Unemployment Compensation Amendments of 1999".
SEC 2. AMENDMENTS TO EXTENDED BENEFIT PROGRAM.
(a) REPEAL OF CERTAIN STATE LAW REQUIREMENTS.(1) Section 202(a) of the Federal-State Extended Unemployment Compensation
Act of 1970 (26 U.S.C. 3304 note) is amended by striking paragraphs (3),(4),(5),(6), and (7) .
. (2) Subsection (c) of section 202 of such Act is repealed.
(b) ESTABLISHMENT OF MANDATORY TRIGGERS BASED ON TOTAL
UNEMPLOYMENT.(1) Section 203(d) of such Act is amended to read as follows:
"(d) For purposes of this section-"(1) There is a State "on" indicator for. a week if-"(A)(i) the average rate of total unemployment in such State (seasonally adjusted)
for the period consisting of the most recent 3 months for which data for all States are published
before the close of the week equals or exceeds 7.5 percent, and
"(ii) the average rate of total unemployment in such State (seasonally adjusted) for
the 3-month period referred to in clause (i) equals or exceeds 110 percent of such average for
either (or both) of the corresponding 3-month periods ending in the two preceding calendar years;
or
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
"(B) the average rate of total unemployment for such State (seasonally adjusted)
for the period consisting of the most recent 3 months for which data for all States are published
before the close of the week equals or exceeds 10 percent.
"(2) There is a State "off' indicator for a week unless the requirements of subparagraphs
(A) or (B) of paragraph (1) are satisfied.".
(2) Section 203(e) of such Act is amended-(A) by amending the heading to read "DETERMINATION OF RATES OF
TOTAL UNEMPLOYMENT AND INSURED UNEMPLOYMENT", and
(B) in paragraph (1) by-(i) striking "subsection (d)" and inserting "subsection (f)(2)",
(ii) redesignating subparagraphs (A) and (B) as clauses (i) and (ii), and
(iii) redesignating paragraph (1) as paragraph (2)(B);
(C) in paragraph (2) by--
(i) by striking "subsection (d)" and inserting "subsection (f)(2)", and
(ii) by redesignating paragraph (2) as paragraph (2)(C); and
(D) by inserting the following new paragraphs (1) and (2)(A):
"(1) For purposes of this Act, determinations of the rate oftotal unemployment in
any State for any period (and of any seasonal adjustments) shall be made by the Secretary.
"(2)(A) For purposes of subsection (f)(2), the rate of insured unemployment for
any thirteen-week period shall be determined by reference to the average monthly covered
employment under the State law for the first four of the most recent completed six calendar
quarters.".
2
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
(c) REQUIREMENTS FOR SUPPLEMENTAL BENEFITS DURING HIGH
UNEMPLOYMENT PERIODS.-Section 202(b)(3)(B) of such Act is amended to read as follows:
"(B) For purposes of subparagraph (A), the term "high unemployment period" means any
period during which an extended benefit period would be in effect if-"(i) section 203(d)(I)(A)(i) was applied by substituting "10 percent" for "7.5
percent";
"(ii) section 203(d)(I)(B) was applied by substituting "12.5 percent" for "10
percent"; or
"(iii) in the event a State has enacted the indicator specified in section 203(f)(I),
section 203(f)(I)(A)(i) was applied by substituting "8 percent" for "6.5 percent".
(d) AMENDMENTS TO ALTERNATIVE TRIGGER-Section 203(f) of such Act is
amended-(1) in paragraph (1), by striking" Effective with respect to compensation for weeks of
employment beginning after March 6, 1993, the" and inserting" In lieu of applying the indicator
specified in subsection (d)(I)(A), a";
(2) by amending paragraph (2) to read as follows:
"(2) A State may by law provide for the purpose of beginning or ending any
extended period under this section that, in addition to the indicators specified in subsection (d)
and paragraph (1) of this subsection, there is a State "on" indicator for a week if the rate of
insured unemployment under State law for the period consisting of such week and the
immediately preceding twelve weeks equals or exceeds 6 percent.".
3
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
SEC. 3. SPECIAL DISTRIBUTIONS TO THE STATES.
Section 903(a)(3) of the Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. 1103(a)(3» is amended-(1) in subparagraph (A), by amending clauses (i) and (ii) to read as follows:
"(i) be subject to subparagraphs (B) and (C) to the extent such amounts
are not in excess of the sum of-"(I) $20,000,000, plus
"(II) the amount determined by the Secretary of Labor to be the
difference between-"(aa) the amount necessary
for the proper and efficient
administration of the unemployment compensation program
succeeding fiscal year (taking into account workload and other
for the
appropriate factors), and
"(bb) $2,419,000,000;
"(ii) be subject to subparagraph (D) to the extent such amounts are in excess of
the sum of subclauses (1) and (II) of clause (i).";
(2) in subparagraph (B) by striking "(A)(i)" and inserting "(A)(i)(11)";
(3) by redesignating subparagraphs (B) and (C) as subparagraphs (C) and (D),
respectively; and
(4) by inserting the following new subparagraph (B):
"(B) The Secretary of Labor shall reserve the amount specified in subparagraph
(A)(i)(I) (at the close of fiscal years 1999,2000, and 2001) to award grants to the States in fiscal
years 2000, 2001, and 2002 to assist in the implementation of alternative base periods for
4
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
determining the eligibility of claimants. Such alternative base periods shall reduce the period of
time between the end of the base period for a claimant and the filing of a claim for compensation.
The amounts reserved pursuant to this subparagraph shall be available to the Secretary of Labor
for obligation through fiscal year 2002.".
SEC.4. SOLVENCY REQUIREMENTS.
Section 903(b) ofthe Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. I 103 (b» is amended by adding
the following new paragraph:
"(3)(A) If the Secretary of Labor finds that on December 31,2001, a State has not
achieved, or made substantial progress towards achieving, the solvency target established
pursuant to subparagraph (B), then, subject to the limitation described in subparagraph (C), the
amount available under this section for transfer to such State account for the succeeding fiscal
year shall, in lieu of being so transferred, be transferred to the States meeting the requirements of
this subsection. The transfers shall be made to such States based on the share of funds of each
such State under subsection (a)(2), except that for purposes of this subparagraph the ratio under
subsection(a)(2) shall be adjusted by excluding the wages attributable to the States failing to
meet the requirements of this subparagraph.
"(B)(i) For December 31,2001, the solvency target shall be an average high cost
multiple of 1.0. For purposes of this subparagraph, the average high cost multiple
represents the number of years a State could pay unemployment compensation (based on
the reserve ratio of such State) if the State paid such compensation at a rate equivalent to
the average benefit cost rate such State paid in the three calendar years during the
5
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
preceding 20 calendar years (or, iflonger, during the period consisting of the preceding
three recessions as determined by the National Bureau of Economic Research) that the
benefit cost rates were the highest. For purposes of making this determination-"(I) the term "reserve ratio" means the ratio determined by dividing the
balance in the State account at the end of the calendar year by the total covered wages in
the State for such year;
"(II) the term "benefit cost rate" means the rate determined by dividing the
unemployment compensation paid during a calendar year by the total covered wages in
the State for such year; and
"(III) the ratio and rates determined under subclauses (I) and (II) shall
exclude the wages and unemployment compensation paid by employers covered under
section 3309 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986.
"(ii) For December 31, 2001, substantial progress towards achieving the solvency target
shall mean that a State has reduced any difference between 1.0 and the average high cost multiple
of such State ( if such multiple is less than 1.0) that the Secretary found to exist on December 31,
1998, by an amount equal to or exceeding 5 percent of such difference.
"(iii) The Secretary may adjust the solvency target specified in clause (i), or the criteria
for determining whether there is substantial progress towards achieving the solvency target
specified in clause (ii), for States that experience significant increases in unemployment during
the period between December 31, 1998 and December 31, 2001. The Secretary shall establish
objective criteria for making such adjustments.
6
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
"(iv) A State shall include, as part of the annual State plan relating to the administration
of grants under this title, such information as the Secretary may request relating to the manner in
which the State intends to achieve the solvency target established pursuant to this paragraph.
"(C) The requirements of subparagraph (A) shall apply to excess amounts
(referred to in subsection (a)(I)) remaining in the employment security account at the close of
fiscal year 2002 that are equal to or less than $2,900,000,000. Such requirements shall not apply
to any such excess amounts that are greater than $2,900,000,000.".
SEC.S. TREATMENT OF SHORT-TIME COMPENSATION PROGRAMS.
(a) GENERAL RULE.-- Section 3306 ofthe Internal Revenue Code of 1986
(26 U.S.C. 3306) is amended by adding at the end thereof the following new subsection:
"(u) SHORT-TIME COMPENSATION PROGRAM.-- For purposes of this chapter, the
term 'short-time compensation program' means a program under which-"(1) the participation of an employer is voluntary;
"(2) an employer reduces the number of hours worked by employees in lieu of
temporary layoffs;
"(3) such employees whose workweeks have been reduced by at least 10 percent
are eligible for unemployment compensation;
"(4) the amount of unemployment compensation payable to any such employee is
a pro rata portion of the unemployment compensation which would be payable to the employee if
such employee were totally unemployed;
7
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
"(5) such employees are not required to meet the availability for work or work
search test requirements while collecting short-time compensation benefits, but are required to be
available for their normal workweek; .
"(6) eligible employees may participate in an employer-sponsored training
program to enhance job skills if such program has been approved by the State agency;
"(7) the State agency may require an employer to continue to provide health
benefits and retirement benefits under a defined benefit pension plan (as defined in section
4140)) to any employee whose workweek is reduced pursuant to the program as though the
workweek of such employee had not been reduced;
"(8) the State agency may require an employer (or an employers' association
which is party to a collective bargaining agreement) to submit a written plan describing the
manner in which the requirements of this subsection will be implemented and containing such
other information as the Secretary of Labor determines is appropriate; and
"(9) the program meets such other requirements as the Secretary of Labor
determines are appropriate.".
(b) CONFORMING AMENDMENTS.-(1) Subparagraph (E) of section 3304(a)(4) of such Code (26 U.S.c. 3304(a)(4)(E)) is
amended to read as follows:
"(E) amounts may be withdrawn for the payment of short-time compensation
under a short-time compensation program (as defined under section 3306(u));".
(2) Paragraph (5) of section 3306(f) of such Code (26 U.S.c. 3306(f)(5)) is amended to
read as follows:
8
�!\utomateCl Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
"(4) amounts may be withdrawn for the payment of short-time compensation under a
short-time compensation program (as defined under subsection (u));".
(3) Section 303(a) (5) ofthe Social Security Act (42 U.S.C. 503(a)(5)) is amended by
striking "the payment of short-time compensation under a plan approved by the Secretary of
Labor" and inserting "the payment of short-time compensation under a short-time compensation
program (as defined in section 3306(u) ofthe Internal Revenue Code of 1986).".
SEC. 6. EFFECTIVE DATE
(a) IN GENERAL- Except as provided in subsection (b) , the provisions of this subtitle
shall take effect on the date of enactment.
(b) EXTENDED BENEFIT AMENDMENTS.(1) Except as provided in paragraph (2), the provisions of section 2 of this subtitle
shall take effect for the weeks beginning after the date that is two years after the date of
enactment of this Act.
(2) Pursuant to the enactment of appropriate provisions of the State law the
provisions of section 2 may take effect for weeks which begin earlier than the weeks specified in
paragraph (1), but not earlier than 60 days after the enactment of this subtitle.
9
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
DRAFT 2/4/99
SECTION-BY-SECTION ANALYSIS OF SUBTITLE D
THE UNEMPLOYMENT COMPENSATION AMENDMENTS OF 1999
Section 1 provides that the short title is the "Unemployment Compensation Amendments
of 1999".
Section 2 contains amendments to the Federal-State Extended Benefit (EB) program.
Section 2(a) amends the program to repeal certain special Federal requirements relating to
eligibility of claimants for extended benefits. The effect of the repeal is to apply the State
unemployment compensation law provisions regarding eligibility for regular compensation to the
EBprogram.
Section 2(b) replaces the current "triggers" that result in the program taking effect in a
State, which are based on the rate of insured unemployment (IUR), with triggers based on the
total unemployment rate (TUR) of States. The rationale for this change is that the TUR better
reflects the general labor market conditions in a State than the IUR, which is a measure limited to
insured workers. Specifically, this subsection provides that a State is to trigger on the EB
program if: (1) the State TUR for th~ most recent 3-month period equals or exceeds 7.5% and the
TUR equals or exceeds 110 percent of the average TUR for either of the corresponding 3-month .
10
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
periods in the two preceding years; or (2) the TUR for the most recent 3-month period equals or
exceeds 10 percent.
Section 2(c) provides that during high unemployment periods in a State the EB program
is to provide claimants with up to 20 weeks of extended benefits (under the regular triggers,
claimants are eligible for up to 13 weeks of benefits). Currently, only claimants in States that
have enacted an alternative TUR "trigger" under the program qualify for 20 weeks of benefits.
This subsection therefore makes the 20-week benefit "tier" available in all States that meet the
high unemployment period criteria. That criteria is defined as: (1) an average TUR for the most
recent 3-month period of 10 percent (with a "lookback" requirement that such rate equal or
exceed 110 percent of the rate for such period in either of the preceding two years); (2) an
average TUR for the most recent 3-month period that equals or exceeds 12.5 percent; or (3) in
those States that have enacted the alternative TUR trigger, an average TUR of 8 percent (with the
110 percent "lookback" for the two preceding years). This third measure is in current law.
Section 2(d) clarifies that States will continue to have the option of two alternative
triggers for the EB program. The first alternative trigger is a TUR rate of 6.5 percent with 110
percent lookback (this would substitute for the 7.5 percent with the 110 percent lookback under
section 2(b) of the bill). The second alternative trigger (which would be in addition to rather
than in lieu of any other trigger) is an insured unemployment rate equal to or exceeding 6 percent
for the previous I3-week period. (Under current law, States may add this 6 percent lUR trigger
to the mandatory trigger, which is a 5 percent lUR with a two-year "lookback" of 120 percent.
Section 3 amends the Reed Act (section 903 ofthe Social Security Act) to facilitate full
funding for the administration by the States of the unemployment compensation program for
11
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
fiscal years 2000-2002. It also provides for $20 million in grants to the States in each of fiscal
years 2000, 2001, and 2002 to assist in the implementation of alternative base periods for
determining the eligibility of claimants. Under current law, most States have established the
base period for determining whether a claimant has earned sufficient wages to qualify for
unemployment compensation as the first four of the preceding five completed quarters. The
effect of not including the more recent quarter's wages is to exclude many low-wage workers and
new entrants to the workforce from eligibility. These grants are designed to assist States in
voluntarily implementing a base period that will count those claimants more recent wages and
thereby expand eligibility.
Specifically, section 3 amends the current Reed Act provisions that limit distributions to
the States to $100 million in fiscal years 2000-2002. This section would provide for a
distribution that would equal the difference between the amount the Secretary estimates (based
on workload projections and other factors) the States will need to administer the unemployment
compensation program for each of the fiscal years 2000-2002 and $2.419 billion, which was the
amount requested on the discretionary side of the budget for fiscal year 2000 (after adjusting for
special activities). This section also includes $20 million in each of fiscal year 2000- 2002 to be
used by the Secretary to award grants to States to assist in the implementation of alternative base
periods.
Section 4 provides for the establishment of a solvency target for State accounts in the
Unemployment Trust Fund.
Specifically, section 4 provides that a State is to meet, or make substantial progress in
meeting, the solvency target established for December 31, 2001 in order to be eligible to receive
12
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
its share of the first $2.9 billion in Reed Act distributions in the succeeding fiscal year (FY
2003). If a State fails to meet this requirement, its share ofthe distribution would be transferred
to the States that meet the requirement.
For December 31,2001 this section prescribes the solvency target as being an "average
high cost multiple" of 1.0. The average high cost multiple represents the number of years a
State could pay unemployment compensation (based on its "reserve ratio") if the State paid such
compensation at a specified "benefit cost rate." The specified rate is the benefit cost rate that is
the average of the three years during the previous 20 years (or, iflonger, during the period
consisting of the previous three recessions) in which the benefit cost rates were the highest. The
"benefit cost rate" is determined by dividing the unemployment compensation paid during a
calendar year by the total covered wages in the States for the same year. In essence, this formula
is designed to determine whether there are sufficient funds in a State account to cover benefit
payments during periods of high unemployment.
This section also prescribes what constitutes "substantial progress" towards meeting the
solvency target for December 31, 2001. Ifby this date a State has reduced by 5 percent or more
any difference between its average high cost multiple (if less than 1.0) and 1.0 that existed as of
December 31, 1998, the State would be deemed to have made substantial progress and would be
eligible for the fiscal year 2003 Reed Act distribution. In addition, this section provides that
States are to include in the State Quality Service Plan, which is submitted pursuant to the
administrative grants under this title, such information as the Secretary may request relating to
the manner in which States intend to achieve the solvency target. Finally, this section provides
that the solvency requirements apply to a State's eligibility for the first $2.9 billion in Reed Act
l3
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
distributions for FY 2003, which is approximately one-half of projected total distribution for that
year. The remainder would be distributed in accordance with current State eligibility
requirements.
Section 5 clarifies the requirements relating to short-time compensation
(worksharing) programs. Currently 18 States are carrying out such programs under which
employers reduce the workweeks of employees in lieu of temporary layoffs, and the affected
employees receive partial unemployment compensation for the reduction in hours. The
authority for the program originated in 1982, but there has been some question as to the
permissible elements of the program. This provision clarifies those elements in a manner
consistent with the current State programs.
Section 6 provides that except for the amendments to the Extended Benefit program, the
provisions of the subtitle will take 'effect on the date of enactment. The EB program changes,
which require amendments to be made to State unemployment compensation laws, will take
effect not later than 2 year after the date of enactment. States may implement the changes earlier
than this date by enacting the necessary changes to their State laws.
14
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
DRAFT 2/4/99
EXPLANATORY STATEMENT FOR POSSIBLE INCLUSION IN TRANSMITTAL
LETTER FOR SUBTITLE D- UNEMPLOYMENT COMPENSATION AMENDMENTS
OF 1999
Subtitle D is entitled the "Unemployment Compensation Amendments of 1999." This
legislation represents an important step toward ensuring that the unemployment compensation
program fulfills its mission in today's changing economy and that it remains on a sound financial
footing for the 21 st Century.
The subtitle has several major components. First, the subtitle would provide incentives to States
to implement administrative systems that will make the program more accessible to low-wage
workers. By enhancing access for low wage workers, this proposal would assist in increasing
the proportion of unemployed workers receiving unemployment compensation, which has
declined from a high of 49% in the 1950s to 35% in the 1990s. This would not only strengthen
the ecop.omic safety net for these workers, but would also enhance the ability of the
unemployment compensation program to meet one of its major objectives -- economic
stabilization. This proposal would provide $20 million in grants to States in each of fiscal years
2000, 200 I ,and 2002 to voluntarily implement a base period for determining eligibility of certain
claimants that takes into account the claimant's most recent earnings. Currently, most States do
not include an individual's earnings from the most recent quarter in the base period, which
results in excluding many low-wage workers and recent entrants to the labor market from
eligibility for unemployment compensation.
Second, the subtitle would enhance the Federal-State Extended Benefit (EB) program by revising
the program triggers to make extended benefits more readily available during a recession. In
addition to providing important assistance to unemployed workers, this change is intended to
avoid the situation that arose in the early 1990s when, despite a recession, so few States triggered
on the EB program that Congress enacted five successive versions of an Emergency
Unemployment Compensation program at a cost of$28.5 billion, financed entirely at Federal
expense. The proposal would use triggers based on total unemployment rates that are more
responsive to rising State unemployment and more accurately reflect when it is most difficult to
find work.
Third, the subtitle would encourage States to voluntarily improve the solvency of their
unemployment trust fund accounts and thereby their ability to pay benefits if unemployment
increases. Currently, State trust fund account balances represent a lower proportion of covered
wages than in earlier periods. In the event of a recession, inadequate balances could lead to such
actions by States as increasing taxes, reducing benefits, or significant borrowing of Federal
funds. In order to avoid this result, the subtitle proposes to provide an incentive to States with
15
�.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
inadequate trust fund reserves to improve solvency by conditioning receipt of a portion of funds
distributed under the Reed Act in fiscal year 2003 on State trust fund accounts meeting or
making substantial progress towards a solvency target.
Fourth, the subtitle would strengthen the funding of the States for administration of the
unemployment compensation program. There has been significant underfunding of
administration for the program in recent years. This proposal would increase the amount of
funding available to States under the Reed Act (which is on the mandatory side of the budget) for
fiscal years 2000-2002 to an amount generally equal to the difference between the administrative
needs ofthe States and $2.419 billion, which is the amount requested on the discretionary side of
the budget for such activities for fiscal year 2000. This would facilitate full funding,
significantly improving the ability of States to effectively serve claimants.
Finally, the subtitle would also clarifY the requirements relating to short-time compensation
programs, under which employers reduce the workweek of their employees in lieu of temporary
layoffs and the affected employees receive partial unemployment compensation.
In summary, the significant refonns proposed by this subtitle would result in increasing the
access, equity and solvency of the unemployment compensation program.
In addition, as stated in the President's budget, the Administration is also interested in further
discussions with stakeholders and the Congress to develop broader, bipartisan refonns to the
Unemployment Compensation system which addresses the following principles: expanding
coverage and eligibility for benefits; streamlining filing and reducing tax burden where possible;
emphasizing reemployment; combatting fraud and abuse; and improving administration.
16
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page I of4
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-FEB-1999 14:09:48.00
SUBJECT:
Headsup Memo
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ : UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis (,CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Cahill ( CN=Mary E. Cahill/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of4
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The memo below was signed on February 9 by Sylvia Mathews and Don
Arbuckle.
MEMORANDUM FOR JOHN PODESTA
Sylvia Mathews
THROUGH:
Don Arbuckle
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Regulation
SSA Substantial Gainful Activity Proposed
Later this week (Thursday or Friday), the Vice President is
planning to announce an increase in the Social Security Administration's
Substantial Gainful Activity (SGA) guidelines.
SGA guidelines indicate
the amount a disabled individual can earn and still be eligible for
Supplemental Security Income (SSI) or Disability Insurance (DI) benefits.
SSA is planning to publish a proposed rule in time for the event, which
would raise the SGA level from $500 to $700 per month.
groups.
The increased SGA level will be strongly favored by disability
We do not anticipate any opposition.
There are several good reasons to increase the SGA level at this
time.
The SGA level has not been updated since 1990. The proposed
increase will roughly account for the increase in wage growth since 1990.
The increase in SGA is a way to encourage work among people with
disabilities.
SSA estimates that this change will affect 42,000 people and will
cost $1.2 billion over five years (SSI, DI, Medicaid, and Medicare).
SSA
is planning for the change to take effect June 1, 1999. The increase has
been included in the President's Budget and will be paid for through
increasing the number of eligibility redeterminations of recipients and
through a change in the regulations.
OMB has been working with the DPC and NEC on this issue.
let us know if you have any questions or comments.
cc:
Maria Echaveste
Doug Sosnik
Larry Stein
Ron Klain
Thurgood Marshall, Jr.
Ann Lewis
Sally Katzen
Minyon Moore
Mary Beth Cahill
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Paul Begala
Elena Kagan
Barry Toiv
Michael Waldman
Janet Yellen
Mickey Ibarra
Please
�,,,
ARMS Email System'
Page 3 of4
Barbara Chow
====================. ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
o 00:00:00.00
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D15]MAIL46842614S.036 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043E8040000010A020100000002050000001D100000000200009FFDE90BDE1B8D9C30FDC4
OBBD89D3A3A7D4191C4EAFA51F4B46AD62B60ED09A50F601145F24953AC250E5AC99C27593DBF3
CCE901D81DF2A36BF45D78FOEC67276E668D3BD7CA8912312E1D531288860341DFE7C9B7740871
B5095A7D35AD6A724F988C3EE12C1F7598CE12CB1F5C89E92B5DD9552A275COCC5DD378C20C94A
346D5401399A1D1F013E2727841BDC8C1D761AB10E14E267CA2305C9A45C7D16524FCDFD46F032
F762568B99CB5E45D9D6FC3A246B812476604FCBA389363F9590C3768B03E8551F35C49F27B749
BBE80AC90304B1D5FF512F90E209BFE4D96EBA8ACC85035C9D3F5F4B653BD619C292F4C1B7C2B6
7E71AD939253C422DB96B3E9277E08EF5A3ABA5E6CA204EB29BB698C7C95A189B8E3F337290ECB
B219EAA6B5F03E144FFD96FE992FAA09FOB73FOA1DB309F90A9BB96EOB7DDC96113A71FOAECCE5
10CBA43FEAB03B6B5C1B406CF36A70E8CA4362C9A3A9356F553E18FC311264FDF490D2BF7CFACC
C2DD7A719AF33F1EF41BF8FCB63062E58CCA9F45EF1F99751BDA17FAB4236FB7FD4D1D0489A03D
E30B47735300B7EFB693D9D0102C63DC36B307C7ECD36AB2A8263A2A82ECEE479A75FE844CODFO
F4D3707E71094F96D7CEBB4D09E3AEE42611F9F5576BBEF82D21B72C6C49BED5BC98FE2AF3EB3F
96BE549B5C02000B00000000000000000000000823010000000B0100009A020000005501000000
4EOOOOOOA503000009250100000006000000F30300000B300200000084000000F9030000080501
000000080000007D040000000000000000000000007D040000000000000000000000007D040000
OB770100000040000000B504000008340100000014000000C50400000B02010000000FOOOOOOD9
04000000985C005C004F004D0042002D00500053002D00320038002D00320039005COO.33003500
300042000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800CB002C012C012C012C01C800C800300000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000B0100002800C8
1968104BOD000011090000005AOOOB010000103600540069006DOO6500730020004E0065007700
200052006F006D0061006E00200052006500670075006C00610072000000000000000000010002
005802010000000400280000005COOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000112F4C42400AIOOOOOO
A1000000D3050COOOOOIOOOOOOOCOOD3D1060C0000010001000COOD1DI033700B00100001600DD
460100005B020600005B020000000000000064CB000100005B0206000058020000000000000064
EC003700D1DI020DOOOOOI00010I050DOOD101000400020000000A0000007C00010002007D0002
007B037EOOOI0002007F0002007B03800001000200810002007B03820001000200830002007B03
840001000200B50002007B0398912C260000000000000000000000000000000008337C00780000
0200008500000003DDOA1000830104000300F4C4211000DDD3050C0000010000000COOD3D1060C
0000010001000COOD1D10337008001000016007CDF010000580206000058020000000000000064
F000000000000000000000000000000000000064C8003700D1D102ODOOOOOIOOOI00050DOOD1DD
OBOB00030000040BOODDD3042A0000160001B00406002C0100580282580200990C00100E965802
01B004020000009C58022AOOD3EOIIOC0000000008070COOEOE011OC00000000990COCOOEOE011
OC00000000100EOCOOEOE0110C0000000068100COOE080F1027COOFIBOFI037COOF1F1027EOOFl
BOF1037EOOF1F1028000F180FI038000F1F1028200F180FI038200FIF1028400F180F1038400Fl
BOF1007DOOF1F1027BOOF14665627275617279F1037BOOF1FI017D00F1FI007FOOF1F1027DOOFl
4665627275617279FI037DOOFIF1017FOOF1F1008100F1F1027FOOF14665627275617279F1037F
00FIF1018100F1F1008300F1FI028100F14665627275617279FI038100F1F1018300FIF1008500
FIFI028300F14665627275617279F1038300F1F1018500F1FI028500F14665627275617279F103
B500F180392C8031393939CCCCE0110C0000000008070COOEOE011OC00000000990COCOOEOE011
OCOOOOOOOOIOOEOCOOEOE0110C0000000068100COOE0808080BOCCCCCCCCCC4D454D4F52414E44
554D9B80464F52804A4F484E809C504F44455354419BCCCC5448524F5547483AE0110COOOOOOOO
990COCOOE09C53796C766961804D6174686577739BD0041500000B00090001200D700809000120
1500DOCC46524F4D3AEOI10C00000000990COCOOE0446F6E809C41726275636B6C659BD0041500
000B00090001000F500AOB0001201500DOCC5355424A4543543A8080E0110C00000000990COCOO
E0535341805375627374616E7469616C804761696E66756C8041637469766974798050726F706F
�February 9, 1999
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
MEMORANDUM FOR JOHN PODESTA
THROUGH:
Sylvia Mathews
FROM:
Don Arbuckle
SUBJECT:
SSA Substantial Gainful Activity Proposed Regulation
Later this week (Thursday or Friday), the Vice President is planning to announce an
increase in the Social Security Administration's Substantial Gainful Activity (SGA) guidelines.
SGA guidelines indicate the amount a disabled individual can earn and still be eligible for
Supplemental Security Income (SSI) or Disability Insurance (DI) benefits. SSA is planning to
publish a proposed rule in time for the event, which would raise the SGA level from $500 to
$700 per month.
The increased SGA level will be strongly favored by disability groups.
anticipate any opposition.
We do not
There are several good reasons to increase the SGA level at this time. The SGA level
has not been updated since 1990. The proposed increase will roughly account for the increase in
wage growth since 1990. The increase in SGA is a way to encourage work among people with
disabilities.
SSA estimates that this change will affect 42,000 people and will cost $1.2 billion over
five years (SSI, DI, Medicaid, and Medicare). SSA is planning for the change to take effect June
1, 1999. The increase has been included in the President's Budget and will be paid for through
increasing the number of eligibility redeterminations of recipients and through a change in the
regulations.
OMB has been working with the DPC and NEe on this issue. Please let us know if you
have any questions or comments.
cc:
Maria Echaveste
Doug Sosnik
Larry Stein
Ron Klain
Thurgood Marshall, Jr.
Ann Lewis
�Sally Katzen
Minyon Moore
Mary Beth Cahill
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Paul Begala
Elena Kagan
Barry Toiv
Michael Waldman
Janet Yellen
Mickey Ibarra
Barbara Chow
AutlJms/aa Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[01/08/1999 – 02/09/1999]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 099 - Folder 010
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/2f326bad01ed303af8bd1cbbdde5f69b.pdf
a8a6059d3368b0ed77c6b6434d3a0000
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 099 - FOLDER -009
[11/30/1998-01/08/1999]
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of28
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon MasonjOU=OPDjO=EOP [ OPD ]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-NOV-1998 17:58:28.00
SUBJECT:
Farm Safety Net paper
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M.. KountoupesjOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. FreedmanjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen TramontanojOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elise H. Golan ( CN=Elise H. Golan/OU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. BeierjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Frazierp ( Frazierp @ midusa.net @ inet [ UNKNOWN]
READ:UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura EmmettjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Rhonda Melton ( CN=Rhonda Melton/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
)
TEXT:
Here is the revised version of the ag safety net paper.
Please review and
send any comments to Mark Weatherly with a cc to Sally Katzen COB tomorrow
(12/1). Also, please indicate your department or agency's view on each of
the options.
Thanks.==================== ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
1 ====================
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D13]MAIL457385431.326 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504332060000010A020100000002050000002BD80000000200003BB670CA8C2D14FBC65E51
D230ED6DDE56C70E5FCF7B66CBF2D2B521520BC446872407C33284F4EAF61816D15BABFA422ADB
26CB36BD65380FE0831DB95E8DA621BF48BB918D7EFC5BECFDBFFClD834011BD51COB2C23F9BD4
E42191B5FF8E49E9992F2F64BCA4699EF653CBD4A9A4215Dl1D39119435371FA4E6DED32074689
�.,
Automated Records Manage,!,ent System
Hex-Dump Conversion
DRAFT
11/30/98
HOW TO FIX THE FARM INCOME SAFETY NET
I.
Introduction
For more than a decade bipartisan farm policy has directed producers to seek income increasingly
from markets rather than from Federal subsidies. The 1994 Crop Insurance Reform and 1996
Farm Bills attempted to create a farm income safety net of market-oriented crop insurance and
commodity marketing loan programs, rather than ad hoc disaster, market intervention, and price
support programs. Farm income reached a record $61 billion in 1997 as export demand grew
and world commodity stocks tightened from 1995.
In 1998 in the US, regional inadequacies of crop insurance (including low coverage and
participation), weather and multi-year production problems, and nation-wide low prices for many
commodities provoked sharp criticisms of the 1996 Farm Bill and crop insurance. Proposals
appeared in July to revive price-setting Federal subsidy programs, mainly through raising
USDA's "marketing loan rate" to boost crop payments to farmers (see Appendix B for
discussion).
II. Administration Proposals
In response, an NEC-led interagency group this summer crafted a package of proposals to
address the specific areas of need throughout the nation's farmland. This included targeted
assistance for regions of need, primarily through a supplemental crop insurance benefit for
multi-year losses.
Second, the President announced on July 18th the purchase and donation overseas of 2.5 million
tons of wheat to boost US farm prices and to relieve hunger around the world, using existing
USDA authorities and mandatory funding. In November, the President announced an additional
food-aid package of3.1 million tons of wheat and other commodities for Russia.
Finally, the Administration agreed to support Sens. Harkin's and Daschle's proposal to remove
the 1996 Farm Bill limitation on marketing loan rate levels.
III.
Status of Farmer Assistance
The Administration negotiated a $6 billion disaster assistance package in the FY 1999 Omnibus
Appropriations Bill to boost farm income. The President further charged Secretary Glickman
with addressing the "gaps" in the farm safety net that were exposed during the 1998 crop year.
Recently, the Congressional Agriculture Committees have announced their intention to address
the problems through the crop insurance program.
1
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
The marketing loan provisions of the 1996 Farm Bill did work to the extent of providing $2
billion to farmers under existing authority, spending that was not projected in the FY 1998
Mid-Session Review of the Budget. The $6 billion in additional assistance should maintain farm
income in crop-year 1998 near the 1997 record level. The issue is how much enhancement does
the safety net need? Should Federal programs prevent any farmer's income from falling below
the five-year average level? Should income supplements be targeted to smaller, low-income
farmers? Total additional USDA outlays for production agriculture approved since July, above
those assumed in the FY 1999 Budget, amount to approximately $10 billion, including the costs
of the recent food-aid programs.
IV. Problems in Farm Country and Options for Dealing with Them
In its FY 2000 Budget request, USDA proposes to continue the path of the 1996 Farm Bill, and
Administration policy, by helping farmers to manage risk. It recommends a series of program
changes to: make crop insurance more attractive by covering more risk at reduced costs;
enhancing emergency programs; and expanding risk-management education. A proposal could
also re-establish the requirement that farmers purchase crop insurance, and send a message to
farmers that these increased insurance subsidies would negate the likelihood of future emergency
payments such as those provided through the FY 1999 Omnibus bill.
Gaps in the Safety Net
This section lists the five main problems with the current farm income safety net, then analyzes
the options, in addition to the USDA proposals. The options can be dialed by benefits and costs.
Also, to achieve targeting by income or gross revenues, means-testing could be overlaid on most
options.
Problem One:
Crop loss due to natural disaster -- crop insurance can fail to indemnify enough
of the loss because:
a) Too little acreage is insured (i.e., too few farmers participate); and
b) Insured acreage is covered at too Iowa percent of expected revenue (i.e.,
too little coverage is purchased by the average farmer).
Problem Two: Multi-year crop loss due to natural disaster, where:
a) Poor production history hurts "good" fanners by raising premiums and
lowering the insurable yield; and
b) Even higher, "buy-up" coverage levels, after consecutive loss years, may
indemnify too little to sustain the farm operation.
Problem Three: Low prices nationally, as much as 40 percent below the 5-year average,
primarily due to large harvests and reduced export demand.
Problem Four:
High producer expenses, where:
2
�Automated Records Management Syslerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
a) certain regions have high production costs arising from natural factors; or
b) exogenous shocks raise input costs like fuel, or livestock feed from a small
crop.
Problem Five:
Insufficient payments to neediest or smallest farmers while most payments
continue to go to relatively wealthy and large-scale fanners.
Options:
Enhance Crop Insurance. Increase crop insurance subsidies on all Federal crop
insurance products, both "yield insurance" and "revenue insurance" plans. This would be
achieved by increasing coverage on free Catastrophic (CAT) policies and increasing premium
subsidies on higher levels of yield and revenue insurance. (See Appendix A for background
on crop yield and revenue insurance.)
1.
2000
Estimated costs:
(outlays in millions of dollars)
1,684 1,734
2001
2002 2003 2004
1,541 1,587 1,635
The proposed increases hold two strong attractions for fanners: a) the obvious attraction of
increasing the value of their insurance policy at no extra cost, and b) increasing the likelihood
that they will receive an indemnity payment. In other words, instead of simply decreasing the
amount of fanner-paid insurance premium cost at current coverage levels (which would have no
impact on the probability of receiving an indemnity payment), the USDA proposal would both
avoid cost increases to the fanner and raise the level of indemnity payments.
Revenue insurance policies are currently subsidized by USDA at a lower percentage than
comparable yield insurance policies. This option would increase the USDA premium subsidy
for revenue insurance on par with yield coverage, increasing the incentive to purchase this
expensive, but more comprehensive, coverage. It also has the added positive effect of increasing
the fanners' incentive to sell their crops on the forward market.
Fanners are notoriously reluctant to forward contract much of their crops out of fear that prices
will increase after they have locked in their forward price. Crop Revenue Coverage (CRC)
allows fanners to forward contract with the confidence that if prices go up after they have
obligated themselves to deliver at a lower price, they will not miss out on higher revenues
because CRC indemnifies against missing out on higher prices. The commodity exchanges find
this aspect of revenue coverage attractive because trading volume would increase. However,
they also have expressed some concern over the extent to which subsidized revenue coverage
might compete with their futures and options contracts.
Ensuring Participation
3
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Because this option is in large part a marketing strategy to increase program participation, its
success ultimately hinges on its impact on buyer behavior. Insurance is not currently required of
producers, and they will have to make their own risk management decisions -- to buy or not to
buy. However, large media advertising campaigns (also proposed by USDA) combined with a
program structure that would virtually eliminate the lower coverage range of buy-up insurance
would help to ensure the expected response on the part of farmers, as long as they can be
convinced that the government will not once again revert to ad hoc disaster payments as future
"disasters" arise.
However, to reduce the uncertainty associated with buyer behavior, the Administration could
reimpose the provision of the 1994 Crop Insurance Reform Act which required producers to
purchase some level of crop insurance in order to receive any other USDA program benefits,
especially the basic AMTA payments. This so-called "linkage" provision was in effect for one
year, the 1995 crop year, and resulted in nearly doubling the amount of crop insurance sales.
Linkage was not particularly controversial, and its abolition in the 1996 Farm Bill in response to
some producers' objections was accomplished without serious policy review by the
Administration or Congress.
Pro:
•
Consistent with the market-oriented farm policies of the 1996 Farm Bill.
•
The President explicitly noted the need to fix crop insurance.
•
Has best chance of enactment, given congressional Agriculture Committees' stated plan
to propose major improvements in crop insurance.
•
Would significantly increase crop insurance participation ifnot undermined by ad hoc
disaster spending, and particularly if "linkage" is re-established (requirement that a
producer buy crop insurance in order to participate in other USDA programs).
•
Crop insurance is more inclusive than many other USDA programs, covering nearly 70
different crops.
•
Crop insurance is more friendly to the beginning farmer. Other programs (e.g., AMT A
payments) have more cumbersome eligibility hurdles.
•
Avoids sending a "mixed message" on the economic structure of farm policy (the hope of
future ad hoc disaster spending or direct price/income. support), and encourages producers
to actively manage their risk, albeit on very concessional terms.
•
More revenue insurance purchases would increase the number of producers protected
against both weather risk and market risk.
4
�Automated Records Management Systerr'
Hex-Dump Conversion
•
Private commodities exchanges expect to benefit from increased trading volume.
•
Could be used as a "transitional" fix: Subsidies could be dialed down as future conditions
and policies warrant.
Con:
•
Because the program does not guarantee benefits or require participation, its efficacy is
ultimately dependent on buyer behavior (unless "linkage" is re-established).
•
Increasing coverage at the CAT level could result in a "buy-down" effect; i.e., farmers
who previously paid for buy-up insurance opt for free CAT coverage.
•
Budget "watchdog" groups may protest the new subsidies to U.S. agriculture as
unnecessary.
•
Private commodity exchanges might object to perceived competition from
government-subsidized price risk management tools, i.e., revenue insurance.
2. Fix Multi-year Crop Insurance. Introduce a new multi-year loss insurance provision as
an optional add-on to the crop insurance policy. A version of this was included in the
Administration's summer '98 farm disaster aid package and enacted in the Omnibus bill. This
proposal would make the availability of multi-year coverage permanent.
. Estimated Costs
(outlays in millions of dollars)
192
2000
2001
2002 2003
171 176
2004
181
187
The development of this provision is only in the discussion stages at USDA but the product could
be rolled out by the 2000 crop year. OMB would work with USDA to ensure that no duplicate
benefits would be paid through these provisions to either new insureds or producers who
received 1998 emergency assistance for multi-year losses.
The 1998 emergency multi-year loss benefits simply provided supplemental indemnity payments
to qualified insured farmers equal to 25 percent of the indemnities received over the relevant crop
years. The new policy provisions would likely have a similar effect, i.e., retroactively increase
coverage levels for consecutive-loss years (if the farmer was insured in each year) and payout
supplemental indemnities. The actual structure of the coverage has yet to be proposed by
USDA.
It would be for multiple years or losses but not in perpetuity (e.g., cap at 5 or 6 years).
Pro
•
Consistent with the market-oriented farm policies of the 1996 Farm Bill.
5
�Automated Records Management SysterHex-Dump Conversion
•
Directly responds to one of the most vocal constituencies, (the Dakotas) during the debate
on 1998 emergency assistance.
•
Crop insurance covers more crops and is more available to new farmers than most other
USDA commodity assistance programs.
Con
•
•
Because the program does not guarantee benefits or require participation, its efficacy is
ultimately dependent on buyer behavior.
Moral hazard, while true for subsidized crop insurance gener~lly, could be greater.
3. Cover More Non-insured Crops. Increase support for non-insured crops covered by the
Non-insurance Crop Assistance Program (NAP).
Estimated costs:
(outlays in millions of dollars)
535
2000
2001
2002 2003
475 489
2004
504
519
Despite the growth in the number of crops covered by the insurance program over the last
decade, many crops remain for which no insurance is available, e.g., artichokes, lettuce, ginseng,
mushrooms, and many more. This option proposes to increase NAP coverage on par with
coverage increases of CAT insurance; i.e, guarantee about 42 percent of expected revenue, and
includes livestock among "non-insured" commodities covered under NAP.
Benefits can be targeted, such as through USDA's proposal to increase crop-loss assistance on
non-insured crops for small farms, and provide increased incentives for private companies to
seek out and "sell" free CAT coverage to limited resource farmers.
Pro:
•
•
Con:
•
Addresses the vulnerability of producers who raise crops and livestock for which no
insurance exists.
Could be perceived as unfair if CAT coverage is raised while NAP is not.
Costly to cover more minor crops, mostly vegetables, which was not a source of national
farmer dissatisfaction in summer '98.
4.
Promote Commodity Options. Increase USDA's current educational options pilot
programs (OPP) and other risk management education and outreach efforts.
6
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
2000 2001
21 22
Estimated costs: (outlays in millions of dollars)
OPPs on two commodities
Education and outreach
33
29
2002 2003 2004
22
23
24
30
31
32
Options on futures contracts are often cited as the equivalent of price insurance. Producers who
purchase "put" options have effectively purchased a price floor. When prices go up, they can
still enjoy the benefits of higher prices, but they are protected if prices fall below the floor, or
"strike price", they purchased.
USDA has recently implemented a program to teach dairy farmers how to use these markets that
provides a short term, hands-on trading experience with USDA sharing the cost ofthe options
contracts. The program lasts only for six-months per producer and allows the producer to buy
options on a limited quantity of milk. The producer leams the markets, the terminology,
hedging strategy, and how to select and deal with a broker.
The program vision is not for permanent subsidies. Its sole objective is to educate the producer
in the hope that the producer will continue to manage price risk using options after "graduating"
from the short term, subsidized program. For OPPs to succeed, legislation would require a
change to remove language requiring budget neutrality. The 1996 Farm Bill stipulates that
OPPs must be budget neutral "to the maximum extent practicable". USDA interprets that to
mean that recipients of USDA program payments who participate in an OPP must forego in
program payments the amount of the subsidies they will receive under the OPP. This provision
does not apply in USDA's current dairy opp because dairy farmers are not currently receiving
program payments. Thus, the offset is not "practicable".
In addition, USDA would conduct aggressive outreach programs to organize county-level
workshops, develop university curricula, and a multimedia advertising campaign.
Pro:
•
Consistent with the market-oriented reforms of the 1996 Farm Bill.
•
Futures/options markets exist for most of the eight major "program crops".
•
Complements the other options such as increased insurance coverage by alerting and
introducing farmers to risk management tools.
Con:
•
Futures/options markets exist for only a limited number of crops.
5. Permit Risk Management Accounts. Provides a tax advantage for building financial
reserves to be used for farm contingencies. In its "Bluebook" of policy guidance for the 1996
Farm Bill, the Administration proposed "income stabilization accounts". Treasury
representatives suggest that the permanent tax relief measures for farmers in the FY 1999
7
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
Omnibus Appropriations Bill are sufficient. These included: extending loss-carryback
provisions in "good" years for fanners, and pennanent extension of income averaging. These
were scored by Treasury as reducing tax receipts by $36 million annually, but the actual effect of
these changes in the tax code on fann income is not yet known. (A similar, "FARRM" IRA
proposal was nearly adopted in the FY 1999 Omnibus bill.)
Risk management or income stabilization accounts could be designed to provide benefits for only
relatively small or low-income fanners. Such accounts are being tried in Canada and France.
They nonnally pennit pre-tax deposits into the account up to a certain amount. Incentives such
as a government contribution component could be considered as well. In the event of a disaster,
the fanner is pennitted to withdraw the funds without penalty. The withdrawals would help
support the fanner until the next crop year and would likely be taxed in a lower bracket than the
fanner's nonnal income.
The income amounts deposited, the withdrawal triggers (e.g., decreases in gross revenues, net
income, price index below moving average, etc.), eligibility and consequent costs are widely
adjustable. This concept could be announced as a pilot program for a specific commodity or
reglOn.
2000 2001
200 200
Estimated costs: (outlays in millions of dollars)
Pro:
•
2002
200
2003
200
2004
200
Encourages prudent savings while reducing the impact of future disasters on both the
fanner and the Federal budget.
•
Builds on producers' current ability to manage their income streams by savings and
timing of input and capital purchases for tax purposes, popular approaches for fanners.
•
Makes more comprehensive an Administration safety net policy of "various solutions
appropriate to segments and conditions in fann country".
Con:
•
•
Treasury representatives believe this option would - if not targeted - disproportionately
aid large, wealthy fanners while providing little assistance to small fanners.
Low fanner participation would be expected.
6. Strengthen Standing Emergency Programs. USDA's proposal includes assistance for
livestock, and would allow fanners to receive both CAT and NAP benefits, USDA disaster loans,
and other USDA fann credit. Some were included in Summer '98 Administration package.
Estimated costs
(outlays in millions of dollars)
8
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
a) Emergency livestock feed
27
b) Allowing both CAT and NAP benefits
c) Small agriculture-related business loans (discretionary)
Pro:
•
•
Con:
•
24
10
(50)
25
25
10
(52)
11
(54)
26
11
11
(56) (58)
Small farm- and small business-oriented.
CAT and NAP can be re-structured to also limit benefits to larger, well-capitalized
operations.
Without proper limits in place, CAT and NAP are subject to abuse by larger businesses:
7.
Land Retirement. Some producers farm land that encounters natural disabilities (like
excessive wetness or disease) that persist longer than one year, but that is likely to return to
production. USDA could enter medium-term contracts (3 - 5 years non renewable) to retire such
land, including land in the Upper Plains that is diseased or under water, or land in the southwest
that is quarantined due to kamal bunt. Payments would be made for "environmental benefits",
including conservation practices aimed to restore the land to production. An area"wide problem
could be required to trigger in a farm's land for eligibility. USDA's Conservation Reserve
Program (CRP) retires land for 1O-year periods, but not when they are made unproductive due to
natural afflictions. A version of this proposal was included in Administration's Summer '98
package and in the 11/13 USDA budget letter, but was not enacted.
2000
50
Estimated costs: (outlays in millions of dollars)
Pro:
•
Con:
•
8.
2001
75
2002
100
2003
100
2004
100
Would fill a gap in the current program structure, since there is no program aimed at this
problem.
Unlikely need for medium-term retirement program; land problems better ameliorated
through farming practices or a program that would permanently retire land.
Marketing Loans.
Uncap 1996 Farm Bill levels. (See Appendix B)
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
4,000 4,000 4,000 3,000 3,000
Estimated costs
(outlays in millions of dollars)
Removing the 1996 Farm Bill's limitation on marketing loan rates (85 percent of a five-year
moving average minus high and low years, but not more than the 1995 level) would enable the
loan rates to rise to a level that practically guarantees regular annual payments in the years ahead.
9
�Automated Records Management Svstef'"
Hex-Dump Conversion
This would turn the marketing loan program into a type of "deficiency payment," a program
abolished by the 1996 Farm Bill. As a general commodity program, it would apply to all major
field crops for the 1.8 million participants in USDA crop subsidy programs. This was proposed
by Sens. Harkin and Daschle in the summer, and by the Administration in some forms, but
defeated in Congress on six occasions.
A targeted version, a "two-tier marketing loan", was proposed by Sen. Daschle in the 1996
Farm Bill deliberations. This proposal would offer a higher loan rate for a minimum volume of
production per farmer, e.g., the first 10,000 bushels. Production above that level would receive
a lower loan rate or none at all. This regime would provide relatively greater benefit to smaller
producers.
Pro
•
Popular with many populist supporters of the Administration.
•
Would be perceived as supporting smaller, less efficient farmers.
Con
•
Would return farm policy back to failed, costly past programs that hurt US exports and
would lead to production supply controls, widely unpopular with farmers.
•
Untargeted version would provide gratuitous financial windfall to many farmers.
•
Targeted version would be opposed by many larger farmers, especially of cotton and rice.
•
Would compete/conflict with market-oriented programs (e.g., revenue insurance, OPPs).
•
Fails to help individual farmers with diminished or failed crop.
9.
Federal Assistance for Exports_
Estimated costs (outlays in millions)
Donations and support for faltering export markets.
2000
2,500
2001
2,500
2002
2,500
2003
2,500
2004
2,500
The humanitarian food aid packages of July for wheat and November for Russia could be
extended so long as the commodity to be donated remains in surplus in the US. While sufficient
funding usually is not an obstacle for the mandatory programs and emergency authorities
involved, this action is limited by GATT rules on subsidies, our trading partners' complaints, and
the undermining of US commercial exports. The actual impact of Federal donations on US farm
prices is in dispute, but the announcements of donations are seen as popular among many
farmers, ifnot commodity markets. The Administration's active role in managing the Asian
economic crisis--a major cause of reduced demand for US agricultural exports--is viewed as a
general form of help to US farmers, but indirect and longer-term.
10
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
Pro:
•
Perceived in farm country as positive action.
•
Can cause "additional" exports to those countries unable to purchase food.
Con
•
Need for bulk commodities is limited. Truly hungry people not already being supplied
by standing government programs tend to need consumer-ready foodstuffs.
•
Limited by tendency to displace US commercial exports.
•
Unpredictable impact on markets means unreliable domestic farm support program.
v. Offsets
USDA has not proposed any offsets to date. OMB recommends PAYGO offsets from cuts in
guaranteed Agriculture Market Transition Act (AMTA) payments. The shift in funding would
effectively redistribute funds guaranteed to producers who have not experienced crop losses and
rewards those who have actively managed their yield risk and paid a share of the associated costs.
AMTA payments are only authorized through FY 2002; however, baseline rules extend the
authorization and baseline spending indefinitely.
The distribution of AMTA payments by state compares favorably to the expected redistribution
of funds through increased crop insurance subsidies. Some discrepancies arise among certain
Midwestern states (Iowa, Illinois, Indiana, Nebraska) that receive significant AMTA payments
and whose proportion of benefits would likely be eroded and shifted toward states with higher
crop insurance losses. Many of the states experiencing increases in their proportional benefits
are those with particular problems over the most recent period (Texas, North Dakota, Minnesota,
Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina). In effect, the redistribution takes benefits from areas
with a lower incidence of crop losses and moves them to areas that have been harder-hit in the
past year and have had historically higher levels of uninsured or underinsured producers.
Further, in a loss-year similar to the one experienced in 1998, the redistribution of benefits
channels funds much more dramatically to areas in the most need.
However, crop insurance indemnities are not guaranteed as are AMTA payments. Coverage
begins at specified loss levels verified at the individual farm level. The same number of dollars
is projected to be disbursed over the long run, but wide variations in year-to-year outlays will
occur. The proposal channels funds to farmers who have taken proactive steps to manage their
risk and suffered verified losses, at the cost of guaranteed payments withdrawn from farmers
holding AMTA contracts. Using AMTA payments as an offset achieves some targeting of
AMTA benefits.
11
�Automated Records Management Sysrerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
BACKGROUND
Appendix A:
Crop Insurance
Yield Insurance (USDA's staridard multi-peril crop insurance products)
Crop insurance coverage is made up of two components, yield coverage and price coverage.
The buyer can choose among various coverage combinations of both yield and price. The
minimum coverage level insures 50 percent of average yield at 60 percent of a USDA-set price.
This plan is known as Catastrophic Risk Protection (CAT), or "50/60" coverage. The highest
coverage available nationally is the 7511 00 level. The most popular coverage to date is the
6511 00 level. At this level of coverage, if the insureds suffer a 50 percent yield loss, they are
made whole on the lost production up to 65 percent (or 15 percent in this case) and the indemnity
payment would amount to the 15 percent of covered loss times 100 percent of the USDA-set
pnce.
USDA offers two general levels of insurance coverage; Catastrophic Risk Protection (CAT), and
so-called "buy-up" coverage which is all coverage levels higher than CAT. CAT premium is
100 percent subsidized and the farmer only pays a nominal administrative fee for it. CAT
covers only 30 percent of expected revenue. Buy-up coverage is available at levels between 60
and 75 percent of expected revenue and is subsidized on a scale that slides downward as
coverage increases. In other words, 65 percent coverage involves a 40 percent premium subsidy,
and 75 percent coverage involves a 24 percent subsidy.
USDA has performed marketing analysis to estimate how much an average producer is willing to
pay for buy-up crop insurance. That amount is $5.30 for each $100 ofliability insured. USDA
proposes to apply that farmer-paid amount to a coverage level that is considered high enough to
restore credibility to the crop insurance program in the wake of the harsh criticisms last summer.
That level is 70 percent of expected revenue.
The following example illustrates how the insurance coverage works:
a)
b)
c)
d)
a com grower with 1,000 acres and an average yield of 100 bushels per acre has an
expected yield of 100,000 bushels;
the insured price set by USDA is $2.30 per bushel;
"7011 00" coverage is purchased, so the farmer has insured $161,000 ofliability
(70,000 bushels at $2.30/bu.);
if the farmer experiences a 40 percent yield loss (i.e., a harvest of 60,000 bushels) an
indemnity of$23,000 would be paid (i.e., the 10,000 bushels that would make the
farmer whole up to 70 percent of average production multiplied by 100 percent of the
$2.30/bu. price);
12
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
e)
t)
the total insurance premium for the coverage would likely be around $13,000, of
whic::h 32 percent, $4,160, is currently paid by USDA;
USDA also reimburses the private insurers' administrative expenses at a rate of 24.5
percent of gross premium, or in this case $3,185.
Revenue Insurance
Standard crop insurance policies do not indemnify producers who have not experienced crop
losses due to natural causes. However, even a producer who harvests 100 percent of expected
yield can be put on difficult financial footing through price declines. The Federal crop insurance
program currently offers three policies that provide indemnities in the event of falling prices
regardless of crop losses ("revenue insurance"). These products are all less than three years old .
. Two are struggling to become established but one has been very successful. Crop Revenue
Coverage (CRC), developed by one of the private crop insurance companies, now accounts for
16% of the crop insurance market (nearly $300 million in annual premium). This is a very high
growth rate over just three years, particularly in light of its price tag -- CRC premiums are 30
percent higher than comparable yield insurance on average.
Revenue insurance policies are subsidized by USDA at a lower percentage than yield coverage.
It is worth noting that, in light of this lower subsidy on a high-priced policy, CRC's growth tends
to contradict the notion that farmers are unwilling to pay significant premium costs for crop
insurance. This, in tum, further supports options that retain market-oriented safety net
programs, with an eye toward dialing down subsidies over the long term.
CRC's success in the market is attributable to one unique component of its coverage; CRC
indemnifies if prices fall and if prices rise; CRC will indemnify yield loss at the current market
price if it has gone up during the insurance period. To summarize, revenue policies work much
like standard policies but payout indemnities in more circumstances:
a)
b)
c)
d)
yield loss when prices remain unchanged (like standard policies);
yield loss when prices fall (like standard policies);
yield loss when prices rise (CRC pays out at the higher market price);
no yield loss but prices fall (revenue policies only).
The following is an example of revenue insurance, scenario "d" above:
a)
b)
c)
d)
a com grower with 1,000 acres and an average yield of 100 bushels per acre has an
expected yield of 100,000 bushels;
the insured price, established by the average price of December com futures during the
month of February, is $2.45 per bushel;
"7011 00" coverage is purchased, so the farmer has insured $171,500 ofliability (70,000
bushels at $2.45/bu.);
by December, the farmer has no yield loss (i.e., a harvest of 100,000 bushels)
13
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
e)
t)
g)
but, the average price of that same December com futures contract at harvest time
(November) has dropped to $2.00lbushel (i.e., down 45 centslbushel). An indemnity of
$31,500 would be paid (i.e., the 70,000 bushels insured multiplied by 100 percent of the
$0.45lbu. price decline);
the total insurance premium for the coverage would likely be around $17,000, of which
24 percent, or $4,160, is currently paid by USDA;
USDA also reimburses the private insurers' administrative expenses at a rate of23.5
percent of gross premium, or in this case $3,995.
Appendix B: Boosting Farm Income Through Marketing Loans
A major goal of some farm interests is to increase USDA's "marketing loan rate" so it would
guarantee farm income robust enough to cover the relatively higher costs of production of some
U.S. farmers. Sens. Daschle and Harkin were chief proponents of increasing ("uncapping")
marketing loan rates during the summer's debate on ho:", to improve the farm income safety net.
How marketing loans work
USDA's marketing crop loans, a program to enable farmers to avoid selling during the
lowest- price (harvest) period of the year, basically set a price floor for the crop, backed by the
Treasury. Farmers take out a 9-month loan from USDA at harvest time based on a statutory
"loan rate" or
price per bushel. If market prices drop below the loan rate, farmers can repay the loan at the
lower market price per bushel. USDA absorbs (loses) the difference between the market price
and the (higher) loan rate price, and the farmer keeps the crop to sell on the market. Marketing
loans are available for the major US field crops, like wheat and com. Payments under the
program are limited to $75,000 per person per crop year.
Current issue
The 1996 farm bill capped the loan rate at 85 percent of the five-year moving average price for
the commodity, but not more than 1995 levels. The 1990 farm bill gave the Secretary of
Agriculture discretion to reduce the loan rate from the five-year average, depending on market
conditions and budget costs. That bill also required that supply controls be imposed appropriate
to those market conditions to determine the size of the crops produced and the cost to the
government. Uncapping loan rates would raise them (by 22 percent for wheat, 15 percent for
com) to an average price level that would be unusually high at present, because it would include
the historic record high price period of 1995 and 1996. Farm interests have not suggested
reimposing supply controls, which is unpopular with farmers.
For example, a wneat farmer with 100,000 bushels in 1998 faced a capped loan rate of
$2.58lbushel, an average price of$2.65, but a low price of$2.35. He received $23,000 (100,000
times the 23 cent gap between the low price and the loan rate) by asking USDA for a "loan
14
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
deficiency payment" when the low price prevailed. (A loan deficiency payment is a common
variation of a marketing loan. Foregoing entirely aUSDA crop loan, the farmer gets a cash
payment from USDA for the difference between the loan rate and the prevailing market price.)
The farmer then held onto the crop for 10 weeks and sold it at $2.70 and received $270,000.
The marketing loan boosted the farmer's 1998 income by 9 percent under the current loan rate
regime ($23,000 divided by $270,000). If the wheat loan rate had been uncapped, the USDA
loan deficiency payment would have been $81,000 (100,000 times the 81 cent gap between the
low price and the uncapped loan rate of$3.16 for 1998), a boost of30 percent to the farmer's
income.
Costs
USDA to-date has paid about $1.6 billion in marketing loan gains on the 1998 crop for all major
commodities. Probably the costs for this crop under current loan rates will total about $2 billion
this year. Uncapping loan rates for one year only on the 1998 crop, as Sens. Daschle and Harkin
proposed, would have cost an additional $5 billion in FY 1999. The cost for uncapping on the
1999 crop only, with outlays largely in FY 2000, probably would be about $4 billion according
to current price projections.
Policy significance
Federal attempts in the 1960s and 1980s to protect farmers from market cycles demonstrated that
USDA price-support loan rates that are within about 25 percent of commodity market prices
distort markets by:
- setting an effective floor on market prices for producers;
- stimulating US production;
- increasing taxpayer costs;
- leading to production controls, reduced exports and greater foreign production.
Loan rates that are low relative to market prices avoid these distortions, but can provide an
income safety net in case of a price collapse. An NEe interagency process concluded in 1994
that raising loan rates slightly was dubious policy because of its market effects even when it
would cost much less than under current price conditions.
Budgetary costs and policy problems could be reduced when raising marketing loan rates by
targeting the payments to those producers in greatest need. For example, this could be done by .
excluding high-income farmers and limiting the higher loan rate to each producer's first few
thousand bushels of grain.
15
�FOIA Number:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management
System [EMAIL]
This is not a presidential record. This is used as an
administrative marker by the William J. Clinton Presidential
Librarv Staff.
Hex Dump file is not in a recognizable format, has been incorrectly
decoded or is damaged.
Attachment Number: [ATTACH.D13]MAIL487385432.326 to ASCII
Kagan 02
�Page 1 of24
ARMS Email System
'"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sally Katzen ( cN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME: I-DEC-1998 12:16:32.00
SUBJECT:
revised ag paper - table stays the same
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Elise H. Golan ( CN=Elise H. Golan/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Frazierp ( Frazierp @ midusa.net @ inet [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Rhonda Melton ( CN=Rhonda Melton/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TEXT:
Please disregard the previous draft ag paper and replace it with this.
It is only slightly different from the earlier one,
we should all be on
the same page. Sorry for any inconvenience. ==========='========= ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
1
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D6]MAIL47229253P.326 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504332060000010A02010000000205000000EOCE000000020000DA29A9A834EAB755DC5E30
ADC0903C92618F717DA347B9C04F58872B882ACE70FIBBIDFC5CFEF5C474A937B467D09572E368
3C273F7011F257E5FC55F9CA27567B18EFF97A5E9C905E4B40BBA624E564C3C4A55E2B2E08ABD8
3304E6CE739496BD21C9423392359AC8E25ADD8666D15EOD489EIB9FA8735F97442CCA27DDFB2B
CEB418FDB28BCDE7F86927DA802D1630D3994E2052917922C3AESBA531461ABAASB2D4E638DA27
54FFFD49D3E68DAICA93608AF76842AB59CCCD2DB7BE80459F77COClA183ACFFFABSE23900DE4A
A43DF6S73CD763833BB789CD2AEAA4703767EIADF3E6876B53CF1483E12264B6247A53EBS7C144
D3E2D350372A2FF08D2866D8B27BOF7BS98C12261F9AI0ID33ESDSEEA29F2027A97383DF90425A
AEC313EC26CCSESFE3A5C80051A6AC61FS06E2369767S81454FE180IBD7D2CA07FE72B6S773S3F
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
DRAFT
11130/98
HOW TO FIX THE FARM INCOME SAFETY NET
I.
Introduction
For more than a decade bipartisan farm policy has directed producers to seek income increasingly
from markets rather than from Federal subsidies. The 1994 Crop Insurance Reform and 1996
Farm Bills attempted to create a farm income safety net of market-oriented crop insurance and
commodity marketing loan programs, rather than ad hoc disaster, market intervention, and price
support programs. Farm income reached a record $61 billion in 1997 as export demand grew
and world commodity stocks tightened from 1995.
In 1998 in the US, regional inadequacies of crop insurance (including low coverage and
participation), weather and multi-year production problems, and nation-wide low prices for many
commodities provoked sharp criticisms of the 1996 Farm Bill and crop insurance. Proposals
appeared in July to revive price-setting Federal subsidy programs, mainly through raising
USDA's "marketing loan rate" to boost crop payments to farmers (see Appendix B for
discussion).
II. Administration Proposals
In response, an NEC-led interagency group this summer crafted a package of proposals to
address the specific areas of need throughout the nation's farmland. This included targeted
assistance for regions of need, primarily through a supplemental crop insurance benefit for
multi-year losses.
Second, the President announced on July 18th the purchase and donation overseas of2.5 million
tons of wheat to boost US farm prices and to relieve hunger around the world, using existing
USDA authorities and mandatory funding. In November, the President announced an additional
food-aid package of 3.1 million tons of wheat and other commodities for Russia.
Finally, the Administration agreed to support Sens. Harkin's and Daschle's proposal to remove
the 1996 Farm Bill limitation on marketing loan rate levels.
III.
Status of Farmer Assistance
The Administration negotiated a $6 billion disaster assistance package in the FY 1999 Omnibus
Appropriations Bill to boost farm income. The President further charged Secretary Glickman
with addressing the "gaps" in the farm safety net that were exposed during the 1998 crop year.
Recently, the Congressional Agriculture Committees have announced their intention to address
the problems through the crop insurance program.
1
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
The marketing loan provisions of the 1996 Farm Bill did work to the extent of providing $2
billion to farmers under existing authority, spending that was not projected in the FY 1998
Mid-Session Review of the Budget. The $6 billion in additional assistance should maintain farm
income in crop-year 1998 near the 1997 record level. The issue is how much enhancement does
the safety net need? Should Federal programs prevent any farmer's income from falling below
the five-year average level? Should income supplements be targeted to smaller, low-income
farmers? Total additional USDA outlays for production agriculture approved since July, above
those assumed in the FY 1999 Budget, amount to approximately $10 billion, including the costs
of the recent food-aid programs.
IV_ Problems in Farm Country and Options for Dealing with Them
In its FY 2000 Budget request, USDA proposes to continue the path of the 1996 Farm Bill, and
Administration policy, by helping farmers to manage risk. It recommends a series of program
changes to: make crop insurance more attractive by covering more risk at reduced costs;
enhancing emergency programs; and expanding risk-management education. A proposal could
also re-establish the requirement that farmers purchase crop insurance, and send a message to
farmers that these increased insurance subsidies would negate the likelihood of future emergency
payments such as those provided through the FY 1999 Omnibus bill.
Gaps in the Safety Net
This section lists the five main problems with the current farm income safety net, then analyzes
the options, in addition to the USDA proposals. The options can be dialed by benefits and costs.
Also, to achieve targeting by income or gross revenues, means-testing could be overlaid on most
options to address the recurring issue that insufficient payments go to the neediest or smallest
farmers while most payments continue to go to relatively wealthy and large-scale farmers.
Problem One:
Crop loss due to natural disaster -- crop insurance can fail to indemnify enough
of the loss because:
a) Too little acreage is insured (i.e., too few farmers participate); and
b) Insured acreage is covered at too Iowa percent of expected revenue (i.e.,
too little coverage is purchased by the average farmer).
Problem Two: Multi-year crop loss due to natural disaster, where:
a) Poor production history hurts "good" farmers by raising premiums and
lowering the insurable yield; and
b) Even higher, "buy-up" coverage levels, after consecutive loss years, may
indemnify too little to sustain the farm operation.
Problem Three: Low prices nationally, as much as 40 percent below the 5-year average,
primarily due to large harvests and reduced export demand.
2
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Problem Four: High producer expenses, where:
a) certain regions have high production costs arising from natural factors; or
b) exogenous shocks raise input costs like fuel, or livestock feed from a small
crop.
Options:
1. Enhance Crop Insurance. ([Agency name)
supports;
recommends against
because ...) Increase crop insurance subsidies on all Federal crop insurance products, both
"yield insurance" and "revenue insurance" plans. This would be achieved by increasing coverage
on free Catastrophic (CAT) policies and increasing premium subsidies on higher levels of yield
and revenue insurance. (See Appendix A for background on crop yield and revenue
insurance.)
2000
Estimated costs:
(outlays in millions of dollars)
1,684 1,734
2001
2002 2003 2004
1,541 1,587 1,635
The proposed increases hold two strong attractions for farmers: a) the obvious attraction of
increasing the value oftheir insurance policy at no extra cost, and b) increasing the likelihood
that they will receive an indemnity payment. In other words, instead. of simply decreasing the
amount of farmer-paid insurance premium cost at current coverage levels (which would have no
impact on the probability of receiving an indemnity payment), the USDA proposal would both
avoid cost increases to the farmer and raise the level of indemnity payments.
Revenue insurance policies are currently subsidized by USDA at a lower percentage than
comparable yield insurance policies. This option would increase the USDA premium subsidy
for revenue insurance on par with yield coverage, increasing the incentive to purchase this
expensive, but more comprehensive, coverage. It also has the added positive effect of increasing
the farmers' incentive to sell their crops on the forward market.
Farmers are notoriously reluctant to forward contract much of their crops out of fear that prices
will increase after they have locked in their forward price. Crop Revenue Coverage (CRC)
allows farmers to forward contract with the confidence that if prices go up after they have
obligated themselves to deliver at a lower price, they will not miss out on higher revenues
because CRe indemnifies against missing out on higher prices. The commodity exchanges find
this aspect of revenue coverage attractive because trading volume would increase. However,
they also have expressed some concern over the extent to which subsidized revenue coverage
might compete with their futures and options contracts.
Ensuring Participation
3
�Automated Records Management System
.
Hex-Dump Conversion
Because this option is in large part a marketing strategy to increase program participation, its
success ultimately hinges on its impact on buyer behavior. Insurance is not currently required of
producers, and they will have to make their own risk management decisions -- to buy or not to
buy. However, large media advertising campaigns (also proposed by USDA) combined with a
program structure that would virtually eliminate the lower coverage range of buy-up insurance
would help to ensure the expected response on the part of farmers, as long as they can be
convinced that the government will not once again revert to ad hoc disaster payments as future
"disasters" arise.
However, to reduce the uncertainty associated with buyer behavior, the Administration could
reimpose the provision of the 1994 Crop Insurance Reform Act which required producers to
purchase some level of crop insurance in order to receive any other USDA program benefits,
especially the basic AMTA payments. This so-called "linkage" provision was in effect for one
year, the 1995 crop year, and resulted in nearly doubling the amount of crop insurance sales.
Linkage was not particularly controversial, and its abolition in the 1996 Farm Bill in response to
some producers' objections was accomplished without serious policy review by the
Administration or Congress.
Pro:
•
Consistent with the market-oriented farm policies of the 1996 Farm Bill.
•
The President explicitly noted the need to fix crop insurance.
•
Has best chance of enactment, given congressional Agriculture Committees' stated plan
to propose major improvements in crop insurance.
•
Would significantly increase crop insurance participation ifnot undermined by ad hoc
disaster spending, and particularly if "linkage" is re-established (requirement th~t a
producer buy crop insurance in order to participate in other USDA programs).
•
Crop insurance is more inclusive than many other USDA programs, covering nearly 70
different crops.
•
Crop insurance is more friendly to the beginning farmer. Other programs (e.g., AMT A
payments) have more cumbersome eligibility hurdles.
•
Avoids sending a "mixed message" on the economic structure of farm policy·(the hope of
future ad hoc disaster spending or direct price/income support), and encourages producers
to actively manage their risk, albeit on very concessional terms.
•
More revenue insurance purchases would increase the number of producers protected
against both weather risk and market risk.
4
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
•
Private commodities exchanges expect to benefit from increased trading volume.
•
Could be used as a "transitional" fix: Subsidies could be dialed down as future conditions
and policies warrant.
Con:
•
Because the program does not guarantee benefits or require participation, its efficacy is
ultimately dependent on buyer behavior (unless "linkage" is re-established).
•
Increasing coverage at the CAT level could result in a "buy-down" effect; i.e., farmers
who previously paid for buy-up insurance opt for free CAT coverage.
•
Budget "watchdog" groups may protest the new subsidies to U.S. agriculture as
unnecessary.
•
Private commodity exchanges might object to perceived competition from
government-subsidized price risk management tools, i.e., revenue insurance.
2. Fix Multi-year Crop Insurance. ([Agency name] _ _ supports; _ _ recommends
against because ...) Introduce a new multi-year loss insurance provision as an optional add-on
to the crop insurance policy. A version of this was included in the Administration's summer
'98 farm disaster aid package and enacted in the Omnibus bill. This proposal would make the
.
availability of multi-year coverage permanent.
Estimated Costs
(outlays in millions of dollars)
192
2000
2001
2002 2003
171 176
2004
181
187
The development of this provision is only in the discussion stages at USDA but the product could
be rolled out by the 2000 crop year. OMB would work with USDA to ensure that no duplicate
benefits would be paid through these provisions to either new insureds or producers who
received 1998 emergency assistance for multi-year losses.
The 1998 emergency multi-year loss benefits simply provided supplemental indemnity payments
to qualified insured farmers equal to 25 percent of the indemnities received over the relevant crop
years. The new policy provisions would likely have a similar effect, i.e., retroactively increase
coverage levels for consecutive-loss years (if the farmer was insured in each year) and payout
supplemental indemnities. The actual structure of the coverage has yet to be proposed by
USDA.
It would be for multiple years or losses but not in perpetuity (e.g., cap at 5 or 6 years).
Pro
•
Consistent with the market-oriented farm policies of the 1996 Farm Bill.
5
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
•
Directly responds to one of the most vocal constituencies, (the Dakotas) during the debate
on 1998 emergency assistance.
•
Crop insurance covers more crops and is more available to new farmers than most other
USDA commodity assistance programs.
Con
•
•
Because the program does not guarantee benefits or require participation, its efficacy is
ultimately dependent on buyer behavior:
Moral hazard, while true for subsidized crop insurance generally, could be greater.
3. Cover More Non-insured Crops. ([Agency name)
supports; _ _recommends
against because ...) Increase support for non-insured crops covered by the Non-insurance Crop
Assistance Program (NAP).
Estimated costs:
(outlays in millions of dollars)
535
2000
2001
2002 2003
475
489
2004
504
519
Despite the growth in the number of crops covered by the insurance program over the last
decade, many crops remain for which no insurance is available, e.g., artichokes, lettuce, ginseng,
mushrooms, and many more. This option proposes to increase NAP coverage on par with
coverage increases of CAT insurance; i.e, guarantee about 42 percent of expected revenue, and
includes livestock among "non-insured" commodities covered under NAP.
Benefits can be targeted, such as through USDA's proposal to increase crop-loss assistance on
non-insured crops for small farms, and provide increased incentives for private companies to
seek out and "sell" free CAT coverage to limited resource farmers.
Pro:
•
•
Con:
•
Addresses the vulnerability of producers who raise crops and livestock for which no
insurance exists.
Could be perceived as unfair if CAT coverage is raised while NAP is not.
Costly to cover more minor crops, mostly vegetables, which was not a source of national
farmer dissatisfaction in summer '98.
6
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
4.
Promote Commodity Options. ([Agency name]
supports;
recommends
against because...) Increase USDA's current educational options pilot programs (OPP) and other
risk management education and outreach efforts.
2000
21
Estimated costs: (outlays in millions of dollars)
OPPs on two commodities
Education and outreach
33
2001
22
29
2002 2003 2004
22
23
24
30
31
32
Options on futures contracts are often cited as the equivalent of price insurance. Producers who
purchase "put" options have effectively purchased a price floor. When prices go up, they can
still enjoy the benefits of higher prices, but they are protected if prices fall below the floor, or
"strike price", they purchased.
USDA has recently implemented a program to teach dairy farmers how to use these markets that
provides a short term, hands-on trading experience with USDA sharing the cost of the options
contracts. The program lasts only for six-months per producer and allows the producer to buy
options on a limited quantity of milk. The producer learns the markets, the terminology,
hedging strategy, and how to select and deal with a broker.
The program vision is not for permanent subsidies. Its sole objective is to educate the producer
in the hope that the producer will continue to manage price risk using options after "graduating"
from the short term, subsidized program. For OPPs to succeed, legislation would require a
change to remove language requiring budget neutrality. The 1996 Farm Bill stipulates that
OPPs must be budget neutral "to the maximum extent practicable". USDA interprets that to
mean that recipients of USDA program payments who participate in an OPP must forego in
program payments the amount of the subsidies they will receive under the OPP. This provision
does not apply in USDA's current dairy opp because dairy farmers are not currently receiving
program payments. Thus, the offset is not "practicable".
In addition, USDA would conduct aggressive outreach programs to organize county-level
workshops, develop university curricula, and a multimedia advertising campaign.
Pro:
•
Consistent with the market-oriented reforms of the 1996 Farm Bill.
•
Futures/options markets exist for most of the eight major "program crops".
•
Complements the other options such as increased insurance coverage by alerting and
introducing farmers to risk management tools.
Con:
•
Futures/options markets exist for only a limited number of crops.
7
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
5. Permit Risk Management Accounts. ([Agency name]
supports;
_ _recommends against because ...) Provides a tax advantage for building financial reserves
to be used for fann contingencies. In its "Bluebook" of policy guidance for the 1996 Fann Bill,
the Administration proposed "income stabilization accounts". Treasury representatives suggest
that the permanent tax relief measures for fanners in the FY 1999 Omnibus Appropriations Bill
are sufficient. These included: extending loss-carryback provisions in "good" years for
fanners, and permanent extension of income averaging. These were scored by Treasury as
reducing tax receipts by $36 million annually, but the actual effect of these changes in the tax
code on fann income is not yet known. (A similar, "FARRM" IRA proposal was nearly adopted
in the FY 1999 Omnibus bill.)
Risk management or income stabilization accounts could be designed to provide benefits for only
relatively small or low-income farmers. Such accounts are being tried in Canada and France.
They normally permit pre-tax deposits into the account up to a certain amount. Incentives such
as a government contribution component could be considered as well. In the event of a disaster,
the fanner is permitted to withdra\V the funds without penalty. The withdrawals would help
support the farmer until the next crop year and would likely be taxed in a lower bracket than the
farmer's normal income.
The income amounts deposited, the withdrawal triggers (e.g., decreases in gross revenues, net
income, price index below moving average, etc.), eligibility and consequent costs are widely
adjustable. This concept could be announced as a pilot program for a specific commodity or
regIon.
2000
200
Estimated costs: (outlays in millions of dollars)
Pro:
•
2001
200
2002 2003
200 200
2004
200
Encourages prudent savings while reducing the impact of future disasters on both the
farmer and the Federal budget.
•
Builds on producers' current ability to manage their income streams by savings and
timing of input and capital purchases for tax purposes, popular approaches for fanners.
•
Makes more comprehensive an Administration safety net policy of "various solutions
appropriate to segments and conditions in farm country".
Con:
•
•
Treasury representatives believe this option would - if not targeted - disproportionately
aid large, wealthy farmers while providing little assistance to small farmers.
Low fanner participation would be expected.
8
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
6. Strengthen Standing Emergency Programs. ([Agency name]
supports;
_ _ recommends against because ...) USDA's proposal includes assistance for livestock, and
would allow fanners to receive both CAT and NAP benefits, USDA disaster loans, and other
USDA fann credit. Some were included in Summer '98 Administration package.
Estimated costs
(outlays in millions of dollars)
a) Emergency livestock feed
27
b) Allowing both CAT and NAP benefits
c) Small agriculture-related business loans (discretionary)
Pro:
•
•
Con:
•
2000
24
10
(50)
2001
2004
25
25
10
(52)
2003
2002
11
(54)
26
11 11
(56)(58)
Small fann- and small business-oriented.
CAT and NAP can be re-structured to also limit benefits to larger, well-capitalized
operations.
Without proper limits in place, CAT and NAP are subject to abuse by larger businesses.
Land Retirement. ([Agency name]
supports;
recommends against
7.
because ...) Some producers fann land that encounters natural disabilities (like excessive wetness
or disease) that persist longer than one year, but that is likely to return to production. USDA
could enter medium-term contracts (3 - 5 years non renewable) to retire such land, including land
in the Upper Plains that is diseased or under water, or land in the southwest that is quarantined
due to kamal bunt. Payments would be made for "environmental benefits", including
conservation practices aimed to restore the land to production. An area-wide problem could be
required to trigger in a fann's land for eligibility. USDA's Conservation Reserve Program
(CRP) retires land for 10-year periods, but not when they are made unproductive due to natural
afflictions. A version of this proposal was included in Administration's Summer '98 package
and in the 11113 USDA budget letter, but was not enacted.
Estimated costs: (outlays in millions of dollars)
Pro:
•
Con:
•
2000
50
2001
75
2002
100
2003
100
2004
100
Would fill a gap in the current program structure, since there is no program aimed at this
problem.
Unlikely need for medium-term retirement program; land problems better ameliorated
through fanning practices or a program that would pennanently retire land.
9
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
8.
Marketing Loans. ([Agency namel
supports;
recommends against
because ...) Uncap 1996 Farm Bill levels. (See Appendix B for background.)
2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
4,000 4,000 4,000 3,000 3,000
Estimated costs
(outlays in millions of dollars)
Removing the 1996 Farm Bill's limitation on marketing loan rates (85 percent ofa five-year
moving average minus high and low years, but not more than the 1995 level) would enable the
loan rates to rise to a level that practically guarantees regular annual payments in the years ahead.
This would tum the marketing loan program into a type of "deficiency payment," a program
abolished by the 1996 Farm Bill. As a general commodity program, it would apply to all major
field crops for the 1.8 million participants in USDA crop subsidy programs. This was proposed
by Sens. Harkin and Daschle in the summer, and by the Administration in some forms, but
defeated in Congress on six occasions.
A targeted version, a "two-tier marketing loan", was proposed by Sen. Daschle in the 1996
Farm Bill deliberations. This proposal would offer a higher loan rate for a minimum volume of
production per farmer, e.g., the first 10,000 bushels. Production above that level would receive
a lower loan rate or none at all. This regime would provide relatively greater benefit to smaller
producers.
Pro
•
Popular with many populist supporters of the Administration.
•
Would be perceived as supporting smaller, less efficient farmers.
Con
•
Would return farm policy back to failed, costly past programs that hurt US exports and
would lead to production supply controls, widely unpopular with farmers.
•
Untargeted version would provide gratuitous financial windfall to many farmers.
•
Targeted version would be opposed by many larger farmers, especially of cotton and rice.
•
Would compete/conflict with market-oriented programs (e.g., revenue insurance, OPPs).
•
Fails to help individual farmers with diminished or failed crop.
9.
Federal Assistance for Exports. ([Agency namel _ _ supports; _ _ recommends
against because ...) Donations and support for faltering export markets.
Estimated costs (outlays in millions)
2000
2,500
10
2001
2,500
2002
2,500
2003
2,500
2004
2,500
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
The humanitarian food aid packages of July for wheat and November for Russia could be
extended so long as the commodity to be donated remains in surplus in the US. While sufficient
funding usually is not an obstacle for the mandatory programs and emergency authorities
involved, this action is limited by GATT rules on subsidies, our trading partners' complaints, and
the undermining of US commercial exports. The actual impact of Federal donations on US farm
prices is in dispute, but the announcements of donations are seen as popular among many
farmers, ifnot commodity markets. The Administration's active role in managing the Asian
economic crisis--a major cause of reduced demand for US agricultural exports--is viewed as a
general form of help to US farmers, but indirect and longer-term.
Pro:
•
Perceived in farm country as positive action.
•
Can cause "additional" exports to those countries unable to purchase food.
Con
•
Need for bulk commodities is limited. Truly hungry people not already being supplied
by standing government programs tend to need consumer-ready foodstuffs.
•
Limited by tendency to displace US commercial exports.
•
Unpredictable impact on markets means unreliable domestic farm support program.
V_ Offsets
USDA has not proposed any offsets to date. OMB recommends P AYGO offsets from cuts in
guaranteed Agriculture Market Transition Act (AMTA) payments. The shift in funding would
effectively redistribute funds guaranteed to producers who have not experienced crop losses and
rewards those who have actively managed their yield risk and paid a share of the associated costs.
AMTA payments are only authorized through FY 2002; however, baseline rules extend the
authorization and baseline spending indefinitely.
The distribution of AMTA payments by state compares favorably to the expected redistribution
of funds through increased crop insurance subsidies. Some discrepancies arise among certain
Midwestern states (Iowa, Illinois, Indiana, Nebraska) that receive significant AMT A payments
and whose proportion of benefits would likely be eroded and shifted toward states with higher
crop insurance losses. Many of the states experiencing increases in their proportional benefits are those with particular problems over the most recent period (Texas, North Dakota, Minnesota,
Georgia, North Carolina, South Carolina). In effect, the redistribution takes benefits from areas
with a lower incidence of crop losses and moves them to areas that have been harder-hit in the
past year and have had historically higher levels of uninsured or underinsured producers.
11
�Automated Records Management Systerr.
Hex-Dump Conversion
Further, in a loss-year similar to the one experienced in 1998, the redistribution of benefits
channels funds much more dramatically to areas in the most need.
However, crop insurance indemnities are not guaranteed as are AMTA payments. Coverage
begins at specified loss levels verified at the individual fann level. The same number of dollars
is projected to be disbursed over the long run, but wide variations in year-to-year outlays will
occur. The proposal channels funds to farmers who have taken proactive steps to manage their
risk and suffered verified losses, at the cost of guaranteed payments withdrawn from farmers
holding AMTA contraCts. Using AMTA payments as an offset achieves some targeting of
AMTA benefits.
12
�Automated ReCOrd
.
Hex-Dumps Mcoanage'!lent System
nverslon
BACKGROUND
Appendix A:
Crop Insurance
Yield Insurance (USDA's standard multi-peril crop insurance products)
Crop insurance coverage is made up of two components, yield coverage and price coverage.
The buyer can choose among various coverage combinations of both yield and price. The
minimum coverage level insures 50 percent of average yield at 60 percent of a USDA-set price.
This plan is known as Catastrophic Risk Protection (CAT), or "50/60" coverage. The highest
coverage available nationally is the 7511 00 level. The most popular coverage to date is the
6511 00 level. At this level of coverage, if the insureds suffer a 50 percent yield loss, they are
made whole on the lost production up to 65 percent (or 15 percent in this case) and the indemnity
payment would amount to the 15 percent of covered loss times 100 percent of the USDA-set
price.
USDA offers two general levels of insurance coverage; Catastrophic Risk Protection (CAT), and
so-called "buy-up" coverage which is all coverage levels higher than CAT. CAT premium is
100 percent subsidized and the farmer only pays a nominal administrative fee for it. CAT
covers only 30 percent of expected revenue. Buy-up coverage is available at levels between 60
and 75 percent of expected revenue and is subsidized on a scale that slides downward as
coverage increases. In other words, 65 percent coverage involves a 40 percent premium subsidy,
and 75 percent coverage involves a 24 percent subsidy.
USDA has performed marketing analysis to estimate how much an average producer is willing to
pay for buy-up crop insurance. That amount is $5.30 for each $100 of liability insured. USDA
proposes to apply that farmer-paid amount to a coverage level that is considered high enough to
restore credibility to the crop insurance program in the wake of the harsh criticisms last summer.
That level is 70 percent of expected revenue.
The following example illustrates how the insurance coverage works:
a)
b)
c)
d)
a com grower with 1,000 acres and an average yield of 100 bushels per acre has an
expected yield of 100,000 bushels;
the insured price set by USDA is $2.30 per bushel;
"7011 00" coverage is purchased, so the farmer has insured $161,000 ofliability
(70,000 bushels at $2.30/bu.);
if the farmer experiences a 40 percent yield loss (i.e., a harvest of 60,000 bushels) an
indemnity of$23,000 would be paid (i.e., the 10,000 bushels that would make the
farmer whole up to 70 percent of average production multiplied by 100 percent of the
$2.30/bu. price);
13
�"
Automated Records Management Svsrer
Hex-Dump Conversion
e)
t)
the total insurance premium for the coverage would likely be around $13,000, of
which 32 percent, $4,160, is currently paid by USDA;
USDA also reimburses the private insurers' administrative expenses at a rate of24.5
percent of gross premium, or in this case $3,185.
Revenue Insurance
Standard crop insurance policies do not indemnify producers who have not experienced crop
losses due to natural causes. However, even a producer who harvests 100 percent of expected
yield can be put on difficult financial footing through price declines. The Federal crop insurance
program currently offers three policies that provide indemnities in the event of falling prices
regardless of crop losses ("revenue insurance"). These products are all less than three years old.
Two are struggling to become established but one has been very successful. Crop Revenue
Coverage (CRC), developed by one of the private crop insurance companies, now accounts for
16% ofthe crop insurance market (nearly $300 million in annual premium). This is a very high
growth rate over just three years, particularly in light of its price tag -- CRC premiums are 30
percent higher than comparable yield insurance on average.
Revenue insurance policies are subsidized by USDA at a lower percentage than yield coverage.
It is worth noting that, in light of this lower subsidy on a high-priced policy, CRC's growth tends
to contradict the notion that farmers are unwilling to pay significant premium costs for crop
insurance. This, in tum, further supports options that retain market-oriented safety net
programs, with an eye toward dialing down subsidies over the long term.
CRC's success in the market is attributable to one unique component of its coverage; CRC
indemnifies if prices fall and if prices rise; CRC will indemnify yield loss at the current market
price if it has gone up during the insurance period. To summarize, revenue policies work much
like standard policies but payout indemnities in more circumstances:
a)
b)
c)
d)
yield loss when prices remain unchanged (like standard policies);
yield loss when prices fall (like standard policies);
yield loss when prices rise (CRC pays out at the higher market price);
no yield loss but prices fall (revenue policies only).
The following is an example of revenue insurance, scenario "d" above:
a)
b)
c)
d)
a com grower with 1,000 acres and an average yield of 100 bushels per acre has an
expected yield of 100,000 bushels;
the insured price, established by the average price of December com futures during the
month of February, is $2.45 per bushel;
"701100" coverage is purchased, so the farmer has insured $171,500 ofliability (70,000
bushels at $2.45/bu.);
by December, the farmer has no yield loss (i.e., a harvest oflOO,OOO bushels)
14
�,\
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
e)
t)
g)
but, the average price of that same December com futures contract at harvest time
(November) has dropped to $2.00lbushel (i.e., down 45 centslbushel). An indemnity of
$31,500 would be paid (i.e., the 70,000 bushels insured multiplied by 100 percent of the
$0.45lbu. price decline);
the total insurance premium for the coverage would likely be around $17,000, of which
24 percent, or $4,160, is currently paid by USDA;
USDA also reimburses the private insurers' administrative expenses at a rate of23.5
percent of gross premium, or in this case $3,995.
Appendix B: Boosting Farm Income Through Marketing Loans
A major goal of some farm interests is to increase USDA's "marketing loan rate" so it would
guarantee farm income robust enough to cover the relatively higher costs of production of some
U.S. farmers. Sens. Daschle and Harkin were chief proponents of increasing (''uncapping'')
marketing loan rates during the surnmer's debate on how to improve the farm income safety net.
How marketing loans work
USDA's marketing crop loans, a program to enable farmers to avoid selling during the
lowest- price (harvest) period of the year, basically set a price floor for the crop, backed by the
Treasury. Farmers take out a 9-month loan from USDA at harvest time based on a statutory
"loan rate" or
price per bushel. If market prices drop below the loan rate, farmers can repay the loan at the
lower market price per bushel. USDA absorbs (loses) the difference between the market price
and the (higher) loan rate price, and the farmer keeps the crop to sell on the market. Marketing
loans are available for the major US field crops, like wheat and com. Payments under the
program are limited to $75,000 per person per crop year.
Current issue
The 1996 farm bill capped the loan rate at 85 percent of the five-year moving average price for
the commodity, but not more than 1995 levels. The 1990 farm bill gave the Secretary of
Agriculture discretion to reduce the loan rate from the five-year average, depending on market
conditions and budget costs. That bill also required that supply controls be imposed appropriate
to those market conditions to determine the size of the crops produced and the cost to the
government. Uncapping loan rates would raise them (by 22 percent for wheat, 15 percent for
com) to an average price level that would be unusually high at present, because it would include
the historic record high price period of 1995 and 1996. Farm interests have not suggested.
reimposing supply controls, which is unpopular with farmers.
For example, a wheat farmer with 100,000 bushels in 1998 faced a capped loan rate of
$2.58lbushel, an average price of$2.65, but a low price of$2.35. He received $23,000 (100,000
times the 23 cent gap between the low price and the loan rate) by asking USDA for a "loan
15
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
deficiency payment" when the low price prevailed. (A loan deficiency payment is a common
variation of a marketing loan. Foregoing entirely a USDA crop loan, the farmer gets a cash
payment from USDA for the difference between the loan rate and the prevailing market price.)
The farmer then held onto the crop for 10 weeks and sold it at $2.70 and received $270,000.
The marketing loan boosted the farmer's 1998 income by 9 percent under the current loan rate
regime ($23,000 divided by $270,000). If the wheat loan rate had been uncapped, the USDA
loan deficiency payment would have been $81,000 (100,000 times the 81 cent gap between the
low price and the uncapped loan rate of$3.16 for 1998), a boost 0[30 percent to the farmer's
Illcome.
Costs
USDA to-date has paid about $1.6 billion in marketing loan gains on the 1998 crop for all major
commodities. Probably the costs for this crop under current loan rates will total about $2 billion
this year. Uncapping loan rates for one year only on the 1998 crop, as Sens. Daschle and Harkin
proposed, would have cost an additional $5 billion in FY 1999. The cost for uncapping on the
1999 crop only, with outlays largely in FY 2000, probably would be about $4 billion according
to current price projections.
Policy significance
Federal attempts in the 1960s and 1980s to protect farmers from market cycles demonstrated that
USDA price-support loan rates that are within about 25 percent of commodity market prices
distort markets by:
- setting an effective floor on market prices for producers;
- stimulating US production;
- increasing taxpayer costs;
- leading to production controls, reduced exports and greater foreign production.
Loan rates that are low relative to market prices avoid these distortions, but can provide an
income safety net in case of a price collapse. An NEe interagency process concluded in 1994
that raising loan rates slightly was dubious policy because of its market effects even when it
would cost much less than under current price conditions.
Budgetary costs and policy problems could be reduced when raising marketing loan rates by
targeting the payments to those producers in greatest need. For example, this could be done by
excluding high-income farmers and limiting the higher loan rate to each producer's first few
thousand bushels of grain.
16
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
'.
-.
I~
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 1-DEC-1998 18:47:29.00
SUBJECT:
WOMEN'S MTG CANCELLED
TO: Skye S. Philbrick ( CN=Skye S. Philbrick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
!-<
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Sorry! The Women's Mtg is cancelled this week. Please pass this
information on to the outside people that come in. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 4-DEC-1998 07:35:18.00
SUBJECT:
POTUS / Albright Budget Meeting
TO: Robert L. Nabors ( CN=Robert L. Nabors/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dominique L. Cano ( CN=Dominique L. Cano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Scott R. Hynes ( CN=Scott R. Hynes/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra L. Via ( CN=Sandra L. Via/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert D. Kyle ( CN=Robert D. Kyle/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracy Pakulniewicz ( CN=Tracy Pakulniewicz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona K. Sutphen ( CN=Mona K. Sutphen/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Sarah Salton ( CN=Sarah Salton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
In case you did not hear last night, today's State Department Budget
Meeting with the President will now take place from 11:00 to 11:45 am.
The 11:30 to 1:30 meeting is canceled.
�'.
Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-DEC-1998 18:19:53.00
SUBJECT:
REMINDER: WH Women's Welcome!
TO: Amy Weiss ( CN=Amy Weiss/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl D. Mills ( CN=Cheryl D. Mills/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Capricia P. Marshall ( CN=Capricia P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Betty W. Currie ( CN=Betty W. Currie/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�AR.MS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia ApuzzO/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Don't forget to drop by and help us give a warm welcome to the new
director of the Women's Office!
Message Copied
TO:~~________~__~_______________________________________________
Virginia ApuzzO/WHO/EOP
Rebecca M. Blank/CEA/EOP
Barbara Chow/OMB/EOP
Betty W. Currie/WHO/EOP
Lynn G. Cutler/WHO/EOP
Audrey T. Haynes/OVp @ OVP
Nancy V. Hernreich/WHO/EOP
Elena Kagan/OPD/EOP
Sally Katzen/OPD/EOP
Ann F. Lewis/WHO/EOP
Ellen M. Lovell/WHO/EOP
capricia P. Marshall/WHO/EOP
Sylvia M. Mathews/OMB/EOP
Cheryl D. Mills/WHO/EOP
Linda L. Moore/WHO/EOP
Minyon Moore/WHO/EOP
Janet Murguia/WHO/EOP
Jennifer M. Palmieri/WHO/EOP
Maureen T. Shea/WHO/EOP
Stephanie S. Streett/WHO/EOP
Karen Tramontano/WHO/EOP
Amy Weiss/WHO/EOP
Katharine Button/WHO/EOP
Page 2 of2
�t,..
ARMS Email System
(.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jonathan E. Smith ( CN;Jonathan E. Smith/OU;WHO/O;EOP [ WHO]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 14-DEC-1998 10:39:53.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Meeting
TO: Jennifer M. Luray ( CN;Jennifer M. Luray/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Skye S. Philbrick ( CN;Skye S. Philbrick/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN;Maureen T. Shea/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN;Leslie Bernstein/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN;Francine P. Obermiller/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN;Jennifer L. Klein/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN;Laura Emmett/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Katharine Button ( CN;Katharine Button/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN;Virginia Apuzzo/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN;Rebecca M. Blank/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN;Robin Leeds/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
)
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN;Janet Murguia/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN;Karen E. Skelton/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN;Maria Echaveste/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN;Lynn G. Cutler/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
)
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN;Lucia F. Gilliland/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kelley L. O'Dell ( CN;Kelley L. O'Dell/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN;Sondra L. Seba/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [WHO-]
)
)
)
)
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
,~
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. ·Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg at 9am on Thursday in room 100. Thank you!
�ARMS Email System
r
:~
Page 1 of 2
':"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:23-DEC-1998 18:45:38.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg - Cancelled
TO: Skye S. Philbrick
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Skye S. Philbrick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
WHO 1 )
TO: Francine P.·Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Luray ( CN=Jennifer M. Luray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra.L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
'J
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Saridra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Stacie Spector
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Marsha Scott
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
)
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO']
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Yet again, the Women's Mtg
has been cancelled. Sorry and
)
)
Happy Holidays!!
�ARMS Email System
Page I of2
. - fl.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-DEC-1998 11:32:51.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg Cancelled
TO: Skye S. Philbrick ( CN=Skye S. Philbrick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CEA 1 )
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
I WHO 1 )
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Luray ( CN=Jennifer M. Luray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
~
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Yet again, the Women's Mtg is cancelled this week. Happy New Year! Thanks.
Page 2 of2
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN;Ruby Shamir/OU;WHO/O;EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-JAN-1999 16:43:09.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Kelley L. O'Dell ( CN;Kelley L. O'Dell/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Luray ( CN;Jennifer M. Luray/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN;Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN;Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU;WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU;WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN;Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
WHO 1 )
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN;Sandra Thurman/OU;OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN;Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN;Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Skye S. Philbrick ( CN=Skye S. Philbrick/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Ar~S
Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia ApuzzO/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at a brand new time: 9:30am, still
in room 100. Thanks.
�'.
h..RMS Email System
Page 1 of5
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 8-JAN-1999 11:50:39.00
SUBJECT:
Announcement of/invitation to the Atlanta Women's History Commission meeti
TO: humphrey.mary ( humphrey.mary @ osd.pentagon.mil @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: joan.e.wainwright ( joan.e.wainwright @ ssa.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: sherrye.henry ( sherrye.henry @ sba.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: althea.harris ( althea.harris @ gsa.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1
TO: greenberg.frankee ( greenberg.frankee @ epamail.epa.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: leslie thornton
READ: UNKNOWN
leslie thornton @ ed.gov @ inet
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: mbrown ( mbrown @ usia.gov @ inet [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: nuria.fernandez ( nuria.fernandez @ fta.dot.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: rwerbel ( rwerbel @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: lester-yvette ( lester-yvette @ dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: theda zawaiza
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: mari barr
READ: UNKNOWN
theda zawaiza @ ed.gov @ inet
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
mari barr @ ios.doi.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Kathleen d. malliarakis
READ: UNKNOWN
Kathleen d. malliarakis @ oa.eop.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl Mills ( Cheryl Mills @ 202-456-6279 @ Fax [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandy Thurman ( Sandy Thurman @ 202-632-1096 @ Fax [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( Minyon Moore @ 202-456-7929 @ Fax [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Vanessa Weaver ( Vanessa Weaver @ 202-456-6294 @ Fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia Mathews ( Sylvia Mathews @ 202-456-2883 @ Fax [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janice Kearney ( Janice Kearney @ 202-456-2883 @ Fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy Henreich ( Nancy Henreich @ 202-456-2883 @ Fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann McCoy ( Ann McCoy @ 202-456-2370 @ Fax [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Capricia Marshall ( Capricia Marshall @ 202-456-6235 @ Fax [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann Lewis ( Ann Lewis @ 202-456-1213 @ Fax [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jen Klein ( Jen Klein @ 202-456-6244 @ Fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia Gilliland ( Lucia Gilliland @ 202-456-6298 @ Fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Yellen ( Janet Yellen @ 202-395-6958 @ Fax [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Skye S. Philbrick ( CN=Skye S. Philbrick/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Luray ( CN=Jennifer M. Luray/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jackson T. Dunn ( CN=Jackson T. Dunn/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ilia V. Velez ( CN=Ilia V. Velez/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christine A. Stanek ( CN=Christine A. Stanek/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard Socarides ( CN=Richard Socarides/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jena V. Roscoe ( CN=Jena V. Roscoe/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maritza Rivera ( CN=Maritza Rivera/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Victoria A. Lynch ( cN=Victoria A. Lynch/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
Page 2 of5
�Page 3 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Deborah B. Mohile ( CN=Deborah B. Mohile/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M.
READ: UNKNOWN
Carter/OU~WHO/O=EOP
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: bailey.elizabeth ( bailey. elizabeth @ osd.pentagon.mil @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: leanne.powell ( leanne.powell @ usda.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne. sullivan ( Suzanne. sullivan @ ost.dot.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ross-lisa ( ross-lisa @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: furjoa ( furjoa @ mail.va.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lplewis ( lplewis@ opm.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: joan_f._kenny ( joan_f._kenny @ hud.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: v.lovell.brigham ( v.lovell.brigham @ ssa.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rhoda_ j._glickman
READ: UNKNOWN
Rhoda
j. glickman @ hud.com @ inet
TO: skovner ( skovner @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Ebloom ( Ebloom @ doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: martinezil ( martinezil @ iow.pou.us_state.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: liz.montoya ( liz.montoya @ hq.doe.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Kelley_L._O'Dell ( Kelley_L._O'Dell @ who.eop.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( Elena Kagan @ 202-456-2878 @ Fax [ OPD 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Skelton ( Karen Skelton @ 202-456-7929 @ Fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn Cutler ( Lynn Cutler @ 202-456-2889 @ Fax [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( Marsha Scott @ 202-456-5558 @ Fax [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen Lovell ( Ellen Lovell @ 202-456-6244 @ Fax [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bettie Currie ( Bettie Currie @ 202-456-2883 @ Fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debi Schiff ( Debi Schiff @ 202-456-2883 @ Fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melinda Bates ( Melinda Bates @ 202-456-2370 @ Fax [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( Janet Murguia @ 202-456-2604 @ Fax [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole Rabner ( Nicole Rabner @ 202-456-6244 @ Fax [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Melanne Verveer ( Melanne Verveer @ 202-456-6266 @ Fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheri Carter ( Cheri Carter @ 202-456-6218 @ Fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( Maria Echaveste @ 202-456-2983 @ Fax [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: allen. kent ( allen. kent @ mail.va.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kelley L. O'Dell
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
( CN=Kelley L. O'Dell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer M. Luray ( CN=Jennifer M. Luray/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kelley L. O'Dell
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Kelley L. O'Dell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Please feel free to use this letter of announcement/invitation to the last
meeting of the President' Commission on the Celebration of Women in
American History takig place in Atlanta on January 22 (details in letter)
�ARMS Email System
to pass along to your constituents/associates that might be interested in
attending.
THE WHITE HOUSE
To Our Women Leaders:
On July 2, President Clinton established the President's Commission on the
Celebration of Women in American History.
Its goal is to broaden and
deepen our understanding of our Nation's history in order to represent the
contributions and experiences of all.
The Commission will submit their
recommendations in a report to the President in March of this year.
The Commission is reaching out to individuals across the country for ideas
and suggestions on how best to celebrate the role of women in American
history.
In that spirit, we cordially invite you to the LAST Commission
meeting to take place in Atlanta, GA, on Friday, January 22, from 9:00 AM
to 5:00 PM, at the Martin Luther King, Jr. National Historic Site, 450
Auburn Avenue, NE.
Please pass along this letter of invitation to your
friends or associates who you think may be interested in attending.
You
will have an opportunity during the public comment portion of this meeting
to voice your ideas and/or suggestions OR you may submit them to the
Commission's web page: http://www.gsa.gov/staff/pa/whc.htm.
We plan to hear testimony from these individuals at the Atlanta meeting:
Edith P. Mayo, Curator Emeritus, National Museum of American History,
Smithsonian Inst., and Consultant to the National Museum of WomenD,s
History Foundation;
Allida Black, Historian and Visiting Assistant Professor of American
Studies, Franklin and Marshall College;
Linda Chavez-Thompson, Executive Vice President, AFL-CIO;
Judy Heuman, Assistant Secretary, Department of Education;
Deborah Morman, Director of Membership, Association for Women in Science;
Leslie Sharp, Historic Preservationist;
Jeannie Jew, National President, Organization of Chinese American Women;
Ali P. Crown, Director, Emory Women's Center, Emory University;
Elizabeth Enlehardt, 5th year PhD. student, Women's Studies, Emory
University; and
June Griffin, Bill of Rights Bicentennial Commission and Medal of Honor
winner.
Thank you in advance for seizing this wonderful opportunity to be part of
history in the making.
Hope to see you in Atlanta!
Sondra Seba
Agency Representative
White House Office for Women's Initiatives and Outreach
PageSofS
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[11/30/1998 – 01/08/1999]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 099 - Folder 009
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/07b5c7fd67db99aa889b8c0d5f2e621a.pdf
5233d2e5a396489144fa27ae6a700e7c
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 099 - FOLDER -008
[10/14/1998-11/23/1998]
�'11.
__
ARMS Email System
!,
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 4
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin KullmanjOU=WHojO=EOP
[ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:14-0CT-199B 12:39:30.00
SUBJECT:
State of the Union
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. MathewsjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda I. Hilliard ( CN=Brenda I. HilliardjOU=NSCjO=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. violajOU=CEQjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO, Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa RobinsonjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Monica M. Dixon ( CN=Monica M. DixonjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa A. Berg ( CN=Lisa A. Berg/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David R. Goodfriend ( CN=David R. Goodfriend/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles J. Payson ( CN=Charles J. PaysonjOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. NewmanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN=Bob J. Nash/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. SmithjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia ApuzzojOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. GibsonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal ( CN=Fred DuValjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of4
ARMS Email System
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. CutlerjOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine D. Kincaid ( CN=Katherine D. Kincaid/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kim B. Widdess ( CN=Kim B. Widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason ( CN=Julie E. Mason/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas J. Band ( CN=Douglas J. BandjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl D. Mills ( CN=Cheryl D. Mills/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan TamagnijOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. LewisjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO l. )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracy Pakulniewicz ( CN=Tracy PakulniewiczjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle CriscijOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria EchavestejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. LathamjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Adrienne C. Erbach ( CN=Adrienne C. ErbachjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Ricci ( CN=Linda Ricci/OU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAVIES G
DAVIES G @ Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
�~RMS
Page 3 of4
Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wendy Hartman ( CN=Wendy Hartman/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Beverly J. Barnes ( CN=Beverly J. Barnes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. Malone ( CN=Michael D. Malone/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
TO: Patrice L. Stanley ( CN=Patrice L. Stanley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Sharon K. Gill ( CN=Sharon K. Gill/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Capricia P. Marshall ( CN=Capricia P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Patricia Solis-Doyle ( CN=Patricia Solis-Doyle/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
)
�Page 4 of4
ARMS Email System
',-
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa M. Murray ( CN;Melissa M. Murray/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn M. Chirwa ( CN;Dawn M. Chirwa/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua S. Gottheimer ( CN;Joshua S. Gottheimer/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN;Michael Waldman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN;Stacie Spector/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN;Kris M Balderston/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN;Dan K. Rosenthal/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN;Paul E. Begala/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We are looking to nail down a date for the 1999 State of the Union
speech.
The dates for previous State of the Union addresses were:
Tuesday,
Tuesday,
Tuesday,
Tuesday,
Tuesday,
January 25,
January 24,
January 23,
February 4,
January 27,
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
The President is confirmed to greet the Pope on his arrival in St. Louis
on Tuesday, January 26, and the Vice President has been asked to greet the
Pope on his departure on Wednesday, January 27.
Therefore, we would like to look at the following dates as options for
this year's State of the Union address:
Tuesday, February 2, 1999
OR
Wednesday, February 3, 1999
Please note that the annual National Prayer Breakfast on Capitol Hill will
take place the morning of Thursday, February 4, 1999.
PLEASE EMAIL KARIN KULLMAN WITH ANY COMMENTS OR CONFLICTS WITH THIS DATEBY
COB TODAY.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 14
I.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: PostMaster ( CN=PostMaster/O=EOE
OA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-0CT-1998 10:24:59.00
SUBJECT:
Rose Garden Announcement
TO: DAVIES G
READ: UNKNOWN
DAVIES G @ Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles J. Payson ( CN=Charles J. Payson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan Ryan ( CN=Evan Ryan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Antoinette D. Marchette ( CN=Antoinette D. Marchette/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kelli R. McClure ( CN=Kelli R. McClure/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June Shih ( CN=June Shih/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracy Pakulniewicz ( CN=Tracy Pakulniewicz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David R. Goodfriend ( CN=David R. Goodfriend/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marisa Luzzatto ( CN=Marisa Luzzatto/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Clyde E. Williams ( CN=Clyde E. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rajiv Y. Mody ( CN=Rajiv Y. Mody/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Glen M. Weiner ( CN=Glen M. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/o=ovp @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�Page 2 of14
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kay Casstevens ( CN=Kay Casstevens/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura S. Marcus ( CN=Laura S. Marcus/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn T. Wu ( CN=Carolyn T. Wu/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Clara J. Shin ( CN=Clara J. Shin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne F. Donovan ( CN=Anne F. Donovan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steve Richetti ( CN=Steve Richetti/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: SAMORE G
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MCCARTHY M
READ: UNKNOWN
SAMORE G @ Al@CD@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
MCCARTHY M @ Al@CD@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: DOBBINS J
READ: UNKNOWN
DOBBINS J @ Al@CD@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: KERRICK D
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D @ Al@CD@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: jblumenthal ( jblumenthal @ whitehousefellows.gov@INET@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry R. McCaffrey ( CN=Barry R. McCaffrey/OU=ONDCP/O=EOP @ EOP [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: G. E. DeSeve ( CN=G. E. DeSeve/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Winston ( CN=Lisa M. Winston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO, Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen A. Popp ( CN=Karen A. Popp/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally P. Paxton ( CN=Sally P. Paxton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 3 of 14
ARMS Email System
'r
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ira C. Magaziner (CN:Ira C. MagazinerjOU:OPDjO:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Adam W. Goldberg ( CN:Adam W. GoldbergjOU:WHOjO:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward W. Correia ( CN:Edward W. CorreiajOU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark Childress ( CN:Mark Childress/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lanny A. Breuer ( CN:Lanny A. Breuer/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ ,UNKNOWN
TO: William H. White Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN:William H. White Jr./OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN:Christopher Wayne/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard Socarides ( CN:Richard Socarides/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN:Jake Siewert/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura E. Schiller ( CN:Laura E. Schiller/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorothy Robyn ( CN:Dorothy Robyn/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann A. McCoy ( CN:Ann A. McCoy/OU:WHO/O:EOP'@ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Heather M. Marabeti ( CN:Heather M. Marabeti/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth Lieberthal ( CN:Kenneth Lieberthal/OU:NSC/O:EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN:Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janis F. Kearney ( CN:Janis F. KearneyjOU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan L. Hazard ( CN:Susan L. Hazard/OU:WHOjO:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D Holly Hammonds ( CN:D Holly Hammonds/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul D. Glastris ( CN:Paul D. Glastris/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN:Julie A. Fernandes/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles N. Duncan ( CN=Charles N. Duncan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Dankowski ( CN=John Dankowski/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel W. Burkhardt ( CN=Daniel W. Burkhardt/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melinda N. Bates ( CN=Melinda N. Bates/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy Weiss ( CN=Amy Weiss/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano (CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl D. Mills ( CN=Cheryl D. Mills/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Capricia P. Marshall ( CN=Capricia P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. Malone ( CN=Michael D. Malone/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal ( CN=Fred DuVal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 5 of14
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha E. Berry ( CN=MarshaE. Berry/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff ( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: John A. Koskinen ( CN=John A. Koskinen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason ( CN=Julie E. Mason/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ashley L. Raines ( CN=Ashley L. Raines/OU=OA/O=EOP @ EOP [ OA 1 )
�Page 6 of14
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas R. Matties ( CN=Douglas R. Matties!OU=OA/O=EOP @ EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brooks E. scoville ( CN=Brooks E. Scoville!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lowell A. Weiss ( CN=Lowell A. Weiss/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dominique L. Cano ( CN=Dominique L. Cano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian A. Alcorn ( CN=Brian A. Alcorn!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jaycee A. Pribulsky ('CN=Jaycee A. Pribulsky/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas D. Janenda ( CN=Thomas D. Janenda/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier!O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Betty W. Currie ( CN=Betty W. Currie/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Salton ( CN=Sarah Salton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan M. Prince ( CN=Jonathan M. Prince/OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: SCHWARTZ E
SCHWARTZ E @ Al@CD@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
�ARMS Email System
Page 7 of14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: RUDMAN M
READ: UNKNOWN
RUDMAN M @ Al@CD@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (NSC)
TO: MALLEY R
READ: UNKNOWN
MALLEY R @ Al@CD@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (NSC)
TO: BAKER JA
READ: UNKNOWN
BAKER JA @ Al@CD@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (NSC)
TO: gbritton ( gbritton @ whitehousefellows.gov@INET@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: barshefsky_charlene ( barshefsky_charlene @ ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN;Joshua Gotbaum/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN;Sylvia M. Mathews/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ada L. Posey ( CN;Ada L. posey/OU;OA/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OA 1 )
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN;Janet L. Yellen/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara Wilson ( CN;Sara Wilson/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karl A. Racine ( CN;Karl A. Racine/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Peterson ( CN;Michelle Peterson/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dimitri J. Nionakis ( CN;Dimitri J. Nionakis/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael X. Imbroscio ( CN;Michael X. Imbroscio/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leon S. Fuerth ( CN;Leon S. Fuerth/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn M. Chirwa ( CN;Dawn M. Chirwa/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Meredith E. Cabe ( CN;Meredith E. Cabe/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN;Barbara D. Woolley/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
(CN;Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN;Jordan Tamagni/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 8 of14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Guy Smith ( CN=Guy Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey A. Shesol ( CN=Jeffrey A. Shesol/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeff B. Liebman ( CN=Jeff B. Liebman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David C. Leavy ( CN=David C. Leavy/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald Goldberg ( CN=Donald Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Veronica DeLaGarza ( CN=Veronica DeLaGarza/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP,@ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Antony J. Blinken ( CN=Antony J. Blinken/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 90f14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Doris O. Matsui ( CN=Doris O. Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alphonse J. Maldon ( CN=Alphonse J. Maldon/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1
TO: Jeffrey A. Forbes ( CN=Jeffrey A. Forbes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patricia Solis-Doyle ( CN=Patricia Solis-Doyle/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kelly Craighead ( CN=Kelly Craighead/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles M. Brain ( CN=Charles M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Beverly J. Barnes ( CN=Beverly J. Barnes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN=Bob J. Nash/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 10 of14
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neal Lane ( CN=Neal Lane/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gregory B. Craig ( CN=Gregory B. Craig/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Gregory W. Chang ( CN=Gregory W. Chang/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robin M. Roland ( CN=Robin M. Roland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Eric P. Hothem ( CN=Eric P. Hothem/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Justin Coleman ( CN=Justin Coleman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: chernish_carol
READ: UNKNOWN
chernish carol @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: RYE_B ( RYE_B @ Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
CC: Betty J. Fountain ( CN=Betty J. Fountain/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OSTP 1 )
CC: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Teresa M. Jones ( CN=Teresa M. Jones/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Essence P. Washington ( CN=Essence P. 'Washington/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Wanda D. Lindsey ( CN=Wanda D. Lindsey/OU=ONDCP/O=EOP @ EOP [ ONDCP 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 11 of 14
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sandra L. Via ( CN=Sandra L. Via/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sterling A. Washington ( CN=Sterling A. Washington/OU=OA/O=EOP @ EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: ALBERT R
READ: UNKNOWN
ALBERT R @ Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
CC: Mary Ann T. Silva ( CN=Mary Ann T. Silva/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Natalie S. Wozniak ( CN=Natalie S. Wozniak/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Christina L. Burrell ( CN=Christina L. Burrell/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elaine M. Mitsler ( CN=Elaine M. Mitsler/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ardenia R. Hawkins ( CN=Ardenia R. Hawkins/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:• Nancy H. Maxfield ( CN=Nancy H. Maxfield/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Patricia A. Battenfield ( CN=Patricia A. Battenfield/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ NSC 1
CC: Sharon V. Storey ( CN=Sharon V. Storey/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Charles J. Payson ( CN=Charles J. Payson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Victoria A. Lynch ( CN=Victoria A. Lynch/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jocelyn A. Bucaro ( CN=Jocelyn A. Bucaro/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Demeo ( CN=Laura K. Demeo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Antoinette D. Marchette ( CN=Antoinette D. Marchette/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1
�Page 12 ofl4
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Emory L. Mayfield ( CN=Emory L. Mayfield/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa M. Murray ( CN=Melissa M. Murray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Joshua S. Gottheimer ( CN=Joshua S. Gottheimer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jonathan E. Smith ( CN=Jonathan E. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia L. Cearley ( CN=Virginia L. Cearley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dominique L. Cano ( CN=Dominique L. Cano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
1 )
CC: Leslie Bernstein
READ: uNKNOWN
CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Carole A. Parmelee
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Doug Babcock ( CN=Doug Babcock/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Skye S. Philbrick ( CN=Skye S. Philbrick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Phyllis Kaiser-Dark ( CN=Phyllis Kaiser-Dark/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: einhellig_wendy ( einhellig_wendy @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: BAKER JE
READ:UNKNOWN
BAKER JE @ Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
CC: Dawn V. Woollen ( CN=Dawn V. Woollen/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sharon H. Yuan ( CN=Sharon H. Yuan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Chantell S.
READ: UNKNOWN
Lon~
( CN=Chantell S. Long/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 13 of14
ARMS Email System
,t>
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Adrienne C. Erbach ( CN=Adrienne C. Erbach/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mary M. Chuckerel
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet L. Graves
READ: UNKNOWN
(,CN=Mary M. Chuckerel/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
CC: LETTS_K ( LETTS K @ Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
CC: Wendy E. Gray ( CN=Wendy E. Gray/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cheryl E. Barnett ( CN=Cheryl E. Barnett/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Joan K. Edwards
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Joan K. Edwards/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
CC: Joan Hunerwadel ( CN=Joan Hunerwadel/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Brenda J. Kinser-Kidane ( CN=Brenda J. Kinser-Kidane/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn J. Dollar ( CN=Carolyn J. Dollar/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janice M. Langley ( CN=Janice M. Langley'/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marc I. Hurwitz
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Marc I. Hurwitz/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
CC: Nancy Marlow ( CN=Nancy Marlow/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ CEQ 1 )
CC: Sandra F. Daigle ( CN=Sandra F. Daigle/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Scott R. Hynes ( CN=Scott R. Hynes/O=Ovp @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jena V. Roscoe ( CN=Jena V. Roscoe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Abigail C. Smith ( CN=Abigail C. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
[ NSC 1
�ARMS Email System
Page 14 of14
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Maria E. Soto ( CN=Maria E. Soto/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Melissa J. Prober ( CN=Melissa J. Prober/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Ora Theard ( CN=Ora Theard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Maya Seiden ( CN=Maya Seiden/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tracy Pakulniewicz ( CN=Tracy Pakulniewicz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dawn L. Smalls ( CN=Dawn L. Smalls/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President and Chief of Staff request your attendance in the Rose
Garden for a special announcement this morning.
Please arrive in the Rose
Garden between 11:00 and 11:1Sam.
You may enter the Rose Garden by
passing the Press Lobby on the north grounds and entering through the West
Garden Room.
This event is by invitation only to senior staff and other
invited guests. No interns, volunteers or outside guests will be
admitted. We strongly encourage your attendance at this announcement.
�f< ....
Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
- "
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:21-0CT-1998 18:22:23.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O~EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
,
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN;Mona G. Mohib/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN;Nicole R. Rabner/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN;Marjorie Tarmey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN;Sylvia M. Mathews/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN;Sandra Thurman/OU;OPO/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN;Judith A. Winston/OU;PIR/O;EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN;Robin Leeds/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN;Marsha Scott/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN;Tracey E. Thornton/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN;Minyon Moore/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN;Susan M. Liss/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN;Ellen M. Lovell/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:00am in room 100. Thanks.
Page 2 of2
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of14
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Joseph C. Fanaroff ( CN=Joseph C. Fanaroff/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:22-0CT-1998 13:52:52.00
SUBJECT:
DAILY TALKING POINTS -- PRESIDENT CLINTON: A BUDGET THAT STRENGTHENS AMERI
TO: AllisonM. Wright ( CN=Allison M. Wright/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Natalie S. wozniak ( CN=Natalie S. Wozniak/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David Wippman ( CN=David Wippman/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary C. Williams ( CN=Mary C. Williams/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ted Widmer ( CN=Ted Widmer/OU=NSC/O=EOP [.NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William F. Wechsler ( CN=william F. wechsler/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elaine P. Wasserman ( CN=Elaine P. Wasserman/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven R. Ward ( CN=Steven R. Ward/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Valon J. Wadsworth ( CN=Valon J. Wadsworth/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roderick K. vonLipsey ( CN=Roderick K. vonLipsey/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gwenyth E. Todd ( CN=Gwenyth E. Todd/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen C. Thompson ( CN=Kathleen C. Thompson/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona K. Sutphen ( CN=Mona K. Sutphen/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sharon V. Storey ( CN=Sharon V. Storey/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tali T. Starks ( CN=Tali T. Starks/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie A. Snyder ( CN=Julie A. Snyder/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Ann T. Silva ( CN=Mary Ann T. Silva/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Sherman ( CN=David J. Sherman/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn L. Scott-Perez ( CN=Marilyn L. Scott-Perez/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel R. Sanborn ( CN=Daniel R. Sanborn/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC I )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith P. Russ
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Judith P. Russ/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
TO: Beverly J. Roundtree ( CN=Beverly J. Roundtree/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Quinn ( CN=Mary E. Quinn/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gidell P. Porter ( CN=Gidell P. Porter/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer C. Poole ( CN=Jennifer C. Poole/OU=NSC/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
NSC 1
TO: Steven J. Naplan ( CN=Steven J. Naplan/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sheila K. Moretz ( CN=Sheila K. Moretz/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark C. Montgomery ( CN=Mark C. Montgomery/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lester H. Miyaoka ( CN=Lester H. Miyaoka/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy L. Millison ( CN=Cathy L. Millison/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy E. McEldowney ( CN=Nancy E. McEldowney/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy H. Maxfield ( CN=Nancy H. Maxfield/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph H. Marty ( CN=Joseph H. Marty/OU=NSC/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ NSC 1 )
TO: Thomas S. Marsh ( CN=Thomas S. Marsh/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Betty A. Marshall ( CN=Betty A. Marshall/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael R. Lowden ( CN=Michael R. Lowden/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth Lieberthal ( CN=Kenneth Lieberthal/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: LEAVY D@Al@CD@VAXGTWY
LEAVY D@Al@CD@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
�Page 3 of14
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janice M. Langley ( CN=Janice M. Langley/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Vinca S. LaFleur
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=vinca S. LaFleur/OU=NSC/O=EOP
TO: Brenda J. Kinser-Kidane
READ: UNKNOWN
[ NSC 1 )
CN=Brenda J. Kinser-Kidane/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
TO: Sandra L. Kelly ( CN=Sandra L. Kelly/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dean M. Kaplan
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dora Kale
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Dean M. Kaplan/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
CN=Dora Kale/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
TO: M. Kay Joshi ( CN=M. Kay Joshi/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kristine A. Jordan ( CN=Kristine A. Jordan/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Felicia A. Jones ( CN=Felicia A. Jones/OU=NSC/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ NSC 1 )
TO: David T. Johnson ( CN=David T. Johnson/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anthony Johnson ( CN=Anthony Johnson/OU=NSC/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ NSC 1 )
TO: Sheyda Jahanbani ( CN=Sheyda Jahanbani/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey A. Jacobson ( CN=Tracey A. Jacobson/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marc I. Hurwitz ( CN=Marc I. Hurwitz/OU=NSC/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ NSC 1 )
TO: Joan Hunerwadel ( CN=Joan Hunerwadel/OU=NSC/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ NSC 1 )
TO: Roseanne M. Hill ( CN=Roseanne M. Hill/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas W. Hillman ( CN=Thomas W. Hillman/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda I. Hilliard ( CN=Brenda I. Hilliard/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Newell L. Highsmith ( CN=Newell L. Highsmith/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leonard R. Hawley ( CN=Leonard R. Hawley/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of 14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ardenia R. Hawkins ( CN=Ardenia R. Hawkins/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas M. Hasman ( CN=Thomas M. Hasman/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David Halperin ( CN=David Halperin/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nina L. Hachigian ( CN=Nina L. Hachigian/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan J. Gregory ( CN=Susan J. Gregory/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wendy E. Gray ( CN=Wendy E. Gray/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Matt Gobush ( CN=Matt Gobush/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher L. George ( CN=Christopher L. George/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen J. Flanagan ( CN=Stephen J. Flanagan/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John W. Ficklin ( CN=John W. Ficklin/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joan K. Edwards ( CN=Joan K. Edwards/OU=NSC/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ NSC 1 )
TO: Shawn L. Dupuy ( CN=Shawn L. Dupuy/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn J. Dollar ( CN=Carolyn J. Dollar/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary B. DeRosa ( CN=Mary B. DeRosa/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donna Dejban ( CN=Donna Dejban/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan W. Dean ( CN=Susan W. Dean/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Victoria J. Darnes ( CN=Victoria J. Darnes/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Philip J. Crowley ( CN=Philip J. Crowley/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen H. Cooper ( CN=Kathleen H. Cooper/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Carteret ( CN=Charles Carteret/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 0f14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christina L. Burrell ( CN=Christina L. Burrell/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charlene C. Bolinski ( CN=Charlene C. Bolinski/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Philip C. Bobbitt ( CN=Philip C. Bobbitt/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Antony J. Blinken ( CN=Antony J. Blinken/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher L. Bell ( CN=Christopher L. Bell/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ralph C. Bellamy ( CN=Ralph C. Bellamy/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patricia A. Battenfield ( CN=Patricia A. Battenfield/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June Bartlett ( CN=June Bartlett/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl E. Barnett ( CN=Cheryl E. Barnett/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey Bader ( CN=Jeffrey Bader/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alexander A. Arvizu ( CN=Alexander A. Arvizu/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Allen ( CN=Charles Allen/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dale W. Akers ( CN=Dale W. Akers/OU=N·SC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Ahmed ( CN=Sarah Ahmed/OU=NSC/O=EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sharon H. Yuan ( CN=Sharon H. Yuan/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Essence P. Washington ( CN=Essence P. Washington/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd A. Summers ( CN=Todd A. Summers/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 6 of 14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert M. Shireman ( CN=Robert M. Shireman/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leanne A. Shimabukuro ( CN=Leanne A. Shimabukuro/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Schnur ( CN=Jonathan H. Schnur/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorothy Robyn ( CN=Dorothy Robyn/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Matthew Murguia ( CN=Matthew Murguia/Ou=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Daniel C. Montoya ( CN=Daniel C. Montoya/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elaine M. Mitsler ( CN=Elaine M. Mitsler/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce McNamer ( CN=Bruce McNamer/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary M May ( CN=Mary M. May/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1
..
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sonyia Matthews ( CN=Sonyia Matthews/OU=OPD/O=EOP
[ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 7 of14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPO/O=EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tanya E. Martin ( CN=Tanya E. Martin/OU=OPO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPO 1 )
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPO 1 )
TO: Ira C. Magaziner ( CN=Ira C. Magaziner/OU=OPO/O=EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Chantell S. Long ( CN=Chantell S. Long/OU=OPO/O=EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeff B. Liebman ( CN=Jeff B. Liebman/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Malcolm R. Lee ( CN=Malcolm R. Lee/OU=OPO/O=EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPO/O=EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPO/O=EOP [ OPO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPO 1 )
[ OPO 1 )
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPO/O=EOP [ OPO 1 )
TO: Gay L. Joshlyn ( CN=Gay L. Joshlyn/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPO 1 )
TO: Teresa M. Jones ( CN=Teresa M. Jones/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPO/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPO 1 )
TO: Sarah T. Holewinski ( CN=Sarah T. Holewinski/OU=OPO/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul R. Dimond ( CN=Paul R. Dimond/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole L. Davison ( CN=Nicole L. Davison/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia Dailard ( CN=Cynthia Dailard/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pamela Cicetti ( CN=Pamela Cicetti/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gregory W. Chang ( CN=Gregory W. Chang/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah A. Bianchi ( CN=Sarah A. Bianchi/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian A. Barreto ( CN=Brian A. Barreto/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William J. Antholis ( CN=william J. Antholis/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan P. Clements ( CN=Susan P. Clements/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Summer L. Scott ( CN=Summer L. Scott/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven N. Braun ( CN=Steven N. Braun/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra F. Daigle ( CN=Sandra F. Daigle/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ryan D. Edwards ( CN=Ryan D. Edwards/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rosalind V. Rasin ( CN=Rosalind V. Rasin/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert F. Schoeni ( CN=Robert F. Schoeni/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
Page 8 of 14
�Page 9 of14
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Raymond P. Guiteras ( CN=Raymond P. Guiteras/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Quindi C. Franco ( CN=Quindi C. Franco/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nouriel Roubini ( CN=Nouriel Roubini/OU=CEA/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ CEA 1 )
TO: Nora E. Gordon ( CN=Nora E. Gordon/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael S. Kosoff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Michael S. Kosoff/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Matthew R. McBrady ( CN=Matthew R. McBrady/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Fibich ( CN=Mary Fibich/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Jones ( CN=Mary E. Jones/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary A. Thomas ( CN=Mary A. Thomas/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark N. Levine ( CN=Mark N. Levine/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa D. Branch ( CN=Lisa D. Branch/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda A. Reilly ( CN=Linda A. Reilly/OU=CEA/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ CEA 1 )
TO: Joseph E. Aldy ( CN=Joseph E. Aldy/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey A. Frankel ( CN=Jeffrey A. Frankel/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason K. Nuzzo ( CN=Jason K. Nuzzo/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James M. Treadway ( CN=James M.' Treadway/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Howard A. Shelanski ( CN=Howard A. Shelanski/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ : UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1
�Page 10 of14
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elise H. Golan ( CN=Elise H. Golan/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Douglas W. Elmendorf ( CN=Douglas W. Elmendorf/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cordelia W. Reimers
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Cordelia W. Reimers/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
TO: Christel M. Sice ( CN=Christel M. Sice/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Catherine H. Furlong ( CN=Catherine H. Furlong/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carol L. Capece ( CN=Carol L. Capece/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Brian A. Amorosi ( CN=Brian A. Amorosi/OU=CEA/O=EOP [CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bert I. Huang ( CN=Bert I. Huang/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
)
TO: Andrew R. Feldman ( CN=Andrew R. Feldman/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Alan S. Polasky ( CN=Alan S. Polasky/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D11]MAIL46701459B.226 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504370040000010A02010000000205000000AD1D0000000200004EOB99COA01473D9B846E3
7DB2DB8CCF37FE4BDD0161A60996D22146502C6143F5EEF4DE6E50A1B3CC904A7922AEAAB985AB
BF2B9417C1DD4B6F11008565DAOCF06C646ACOF52547DA0886DA024A3644F693DDDDFCC2D47BF4
6AD7368F52CCB4528B5E3CA69DECF644EOB8CFC0274ECAF4F9C332692A1CE5ED329985B125B16A
9F45EFA79A68270FFOA271BE03AED6CA8135CD3A14BAOBD2DD78483A86AF33EFAOACC8C34A410D
AF93103E7BF9557ACDB78E8D65B488F9C6AE93B7E682FBA2B1DD643EOA2F8BBE5EA1FD9030ED3D
8C03721EDA03B318592E9652F252A38529A37275769559EA508084AA831A048CDAB4E9885C93CF
DC5335E31DABEADCF48F4E4A5C772CAFDD05123ED8920B765F43246CC4BA75BCB08BD7F059B4DA
EC564806FC76071E4EBDFE47120ABF1A5D92F5FEDC2E06B1E32DC180753ECF6C52592BE217DCB9
8DED13B57D28DFBB219AC5EF1FC6908A33ED48E15583DBF42B5161EOACE132BF4363602AA58223
74BF63E7B2C754422B43B43C99AOFB3706EA96BC4BE508F4005D27525FEA61DA29E34BE5A3B61D
798DA9E5AFDFOC1DC21D3AA48ED7302AF521BC9AB2E8359B3CF0171C7A401E9004E59683D8E627
27866964D086E3AD083B8FD01C1877B201135B7227D9FCAFD094BBD70A6176D9539AB4B3747216
80BC8C1A0602000900000000000000000000000823010000000B0100007E020000005509000100
�PRESIDENT CLINTON:
III/tOfT/ate,
A BUDGET THAT STRENGTHENS AMERICA'S FUTURE
Recol'ds R4
JeX·Dil
IV/anage,
'fTIp Convers:;nt SYstem
October 22, 1998
"We have to remember that on the things that really count, whether it's cancer research, or saving Social Security, or
educating our children, this country needs to be united. This country needs to be reconciled to one another -- all of us -- across all
the lines that divide us. "
-- President Bill Clinton
AN AGENDA THAT SUPPORTS AND HONORS AMERICA'S FAMILIES,. Yesterday, President Clinton signed a budget bill
that reflects the priorities of our nation and helps ensure that we continue to prosper. The President fought for and won
key agreements on education, the environment, aid to farmers, and full funding for the IMF. In addition, as we close the
books on the first budget surplus in a generation, the budget agreement honors the President's commitment to save the
budget surplus until Social Security is reformed for the 21 st Century, allowing the President and Congress to start making
important decisions on how to ensure the solvency of Social Security for years to come.
AN EDUCATION AGENDA FOR THE 21ST CENTURY. The President fought for legislation that will ensure that our
children receive a first-class education in safe classrooms with well-prepared teachers:
•
•
•
Encouraging States To Open More Charter Schools. Today, the President signed legislation keeping us on
track to 3,000 charter schools by the turn of the century. These schools allow for innovation while demanding
accountability and can serve as a model of how we can best strengthen our public schools;
More High-Quality Teachers With Smaller Classes. The President fought for and won funding to begin hiring
100,000 new, well-prepared teachers to help reduce class size in grades 1-3 to a national average of 18;
Expanding Educational Technology. This year's budget includes a 20 percent increase for educational
technology to ensure that every child has access to computers, the Internet, high-quality educational software, and
teachers that can use technology effectively in the classroom.
PROTECTING OUR ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC HEALTH. President Clinton won significant new investments to protect
our environment and defeated anti-environmental "riders" that would have rolled back protections already in 'place:
•
•
•
•
Clean, Safe Water For America. A 16 percent increase in funding for the President's Clean Water Action Plan to
help clean-up the 40 percent of surveyed waterways that are still too polluted for swimming and fishing;
. Preserving Precious Lands. Additional funding to acquire dozens of natural and historic sites around the
country;
Leading The Fight Against Global Warming. Increased funding to support research investments that will
reduce greenhouse gas emissions, oil consumption, and energy costs for consumers and businesses by promoting
increased energy efficiency and clean energy technology;
Defending Our Environment Against Stealth Attacks. The President forced Congress to drop special-interest
riders that would have: forced overcutting of timber in national forests, blocked common-sense actions to reduce
greenhouse gas emissions, hindered salmon restoration in the Pacific Northwest, denied municipalities the funds
they need to undertake clean-up efforts at brownfield sites, and carved the first road ever through designated
wilderness.
RESPONDING To THE FARM CRISIS AT HOME, MEETING OUR RESPONSIBILITIES ABROAD. The President fought for
additional funding to help America's farmers and the final budget includes a significant increase in total emergency
assistance to farmers and ranchers, including additional funds for crop and economic loss compensation. Although
America's fiscal house is in order, some nations around the world are experiencing economic upheaval, hurting our
exports, farmers, and ranchers. The President fought for and won full funding for the International Monetary Fund, a
critical part of his strategy to help address the global financial crisis and keep our economy strong.
THE NEXT CONGRESS MUST PUT PROGRESS AHEAD OF PARTISANSHIP. On too many issues, Congress' failure to act
has affected our families. President Clinton is calling on the next Congress to work with him to pass: (1) targeted, fully
paid for, tax cuts to build or modernize 5,000 schools; (2) a Patients' Bill of Rights, to extend important medical
protections; (3) legislation to crack down on teen smoking; (4) an increase in the minimum wage; (5) campaign finance
�• reform; and (6) legislation to make child care more affordable for working families.
�ARMS Email System
"
Page 1 of2
-"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra YaminjOU=OMBjO=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:27-0CT-1998 14:05:08.00
SUBJECT:
FYOO Entitlements Meeting
TO: Martha Foley ( CN=Martha FoleyjOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea KanejOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick JohnsonjOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan OrszagjOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. BlankjOU=CEAjO=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. RicejOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Iratha H. Waters ( CN=Iratha H. WatersjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Wayne Upshaw ( CN=Wayne UpshawjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. MatlackjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara ChowjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. SmalliganjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Barry White ( CN=Barry WhitejOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Please join Barbara Chow and Staff on Mon., Nov 2 from 1:30 - 3:00PM in
OEOB 260 to discuss FYOO Entitlements.
Please confirm your attendance.
We have scheduled one session from 1:30PM - 3:00PM to cover the topics
listed in the sequence below, with each of the sections below allotted
about 20 minutes (allowing for a little slippage).
You are more than
welcome to participate in any of these sections.
TANF (including contingency and supplemental growth); Welfare to Work;
WTOC and WTW tax credits; Independent Living; Child Support Enforcement
Food stamps; child nutrition
�ARMS Email System
r,.
UI; TAA; PBGC
Page 2 of2
�" __ ~S Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-0CT-1998 07:57:42_00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Maureen T. 'Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO:' Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�A!{MS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman (CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a women's mtg today [thursl at 9am in room 100.
unfortunately though, Ann will not be able to make it". Thanks
�'f
.A~S Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Charles J. Payson ( CN=Charles J. Payson/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 4-NOV-1998 09:04:03.00
SUBJECT:
Scheduling proposal Mtg TODAY
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Heather L. Davis ( CN=Heather L. Davis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David R. Goodfriend ( CN=David R. Goodfriend/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Clyde E. Williams ( CN=Clyde E. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorinda A. Salcido ( CN=Dorinda A. Salcido/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Timothy W. Emrich ( CN=Timothy W. Emrich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maya Seiden ( CN=Maya Seiden/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patrice L. Stanley ( CN=Patrice L. Stanley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dominique L. Cano ( CN=Dominique L. Cano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia L. Cearley ( CN=Virginia L. Cearley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patricia Solis-Doyle ( CN=Patricia Solis-Doyle/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�A~S
Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MILLISON C
READ: UNKNOWN
MILLISON C @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Martha A. Livingston ( CN=Martha A. Livingston/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ruth A. Eaglin ( CN=Ruth A. Eaglin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kim B. Widdess ( CN=Kim B. Widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rachel A. Redington ( CN=Rachel A. Redington/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacquelyn J. Bennett
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Jacquelyn J. Bennett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Susan L. Hazard ( CN=Susan L. Hazard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ELKON_N ( ELKON N @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAVIES G
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
DAVIES G @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=WHCCTF/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHCCTF 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa A. Berg ( CN=Lisa A. Berg/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�'iRMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN;Phillip Caplan/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. Malone ( CN;Michael D. Malone/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN;Virginia N. Rustique/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN;Cecily C. Williams/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: EricP. Hothem ( CN;Eric P. Hothem/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN;Noa A. Meyer/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN;Katharine Button/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas J. Band ( CN;Douglas J. Band/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN;Michael Waldman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ruby Shamir ( CN;Ruby Shamir/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN;David S. Beaubaire/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN;Kris M Balderston/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas D. Janenda ( CN;Thomas D. Janenda/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN;June G. Turner/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN;Nancy V. Hernreich/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anthony R. Bernal ( CN;Anthony R. Bernal/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN;Aviva Steinberg/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN;Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wendy Hartman ( CN;Wendy Hartman/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracy Pakulniewicz ( CN;Tracy Pakulniewicz/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
'.
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua S. Gottheimer ( CN:Joshua S. Gottheimer/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN:Elizabeth R. Newman/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marisa Luzzatto ( CN=Marisa Luzzatto/OU=WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: George G. Caudill ( CN:George G. Caudill/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN:Carole A. Parmelee/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph C. Fanaroff ( CN:Joseph C. Fanaroff/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Doris O. Matsui ( CN:Doris o. Matsui/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Chandler G. Spaulding ( CN:Chandler G. Spaulding/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Ricci ( CN:Linda Ricci/OU:OMB/O:EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Margaret L. Buford ( CN:Margaret L. Buford/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jaycee A. Pribulsky
READ: UNKNOWN
CN:Jaycee A. Pribulsky/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN:Dan K. Rosenthal/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan Ryan ( CN:Evan Ryan/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian A. Barreto ( CN:Brian A. Barreto/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Dankowski ( CN:John Dankowski/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN:Jake Siewert/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elisabeth Steele ( CN:Elisabeth Steele/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey M. Smith ( CN:Jeffrey M. Smith/OU:OSTP/O:EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OSTP 1 )
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN:Bob J. Nash/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter A. Weissman ( CN:Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�AuRMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Grace A. Garcia ( CN=Grace A. Garcia/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: HILLIARD B
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D
READ: UNKNOWN
HILLIARD B @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 }
(NSC)
KERRICK D @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (NSC)
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This week's Scheduling Proposal Meeting (formerly the Short Term
Scheduling Meeting)
will be held TODAY at 2 pm in the Roosevelt Room.
See you then.
�_A~S
Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 4-NOV-1998 15:19:47.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie ,Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
Page 2 of2
�I;ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 11-NOV-1998 11:56:29.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews .( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Skye S. Philbrick ( CN=Skye S. Philbrick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P.
READ: UNKNOWN
Obe~miller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @
EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg at 9am on Thursday in room 100. Thanks.
�AJ.3.MS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN;Ruby Shamir/OU;WHO/O;EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:18-NOV-1998 10:28:30.00
SUBJECT:
WOMEN'S MTG CANCELLED
TO: Skye S. Philbrick ( CN;Skye S. Philbrick/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN;Maureen T. Shea/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN;Leslie Bernstein/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN;Francine P. Obermiller/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN;Jennifer L. Klein/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN;Laura Emmett/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN;Katharine Button/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN;Virginia Apuzzo/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN;Rebecca M. Blank/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN;Robin Leeds/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN;Janet Murguia/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN;Karen E. Skelton/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN;Maria Echaveste/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN;Lynn G. Cutler/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN;Lucia F. Gilliland/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN;Sondra L. Seba/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN;Janet L. Graves/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN;Mindy E. Myers/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�A~S
Page 2 of2
Email System
r'
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ BOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP. [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be no Women's Mtg this Thursday. Please pass this information
on to those who come in from outside the White House. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 1
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:23-NOV-1998 13:12:32.00
SUBJECT:
Ag Safety Net meeting
TO: Rhonda Melton
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Rhonda Melton/O=OVP
~
OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: David A. Bernell ( CN=David A. Bernell/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elise H. Golan ( CN=Elise H. Golan/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel D. Heath ( CN=Daniel D. Heath/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elwood Holstein ( CN=Elwood Holstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Sally Katzen will host an Ag safety net meeting at 9:30 AM tomorrow
(11/24) in Sally's office, Room 231.
paper will be distributed later today.
Plea'se confirm your attendance.
Thanks.
��
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[10/14/1998 – 11/23/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 099 - Folder 008
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/1be0e4642a32230b7da2f592d07a7282.pdf
920e27e714bc94fd6268db8c08dcf239
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 099 - FOLDER -007
[09/23/1998-10/14/1998]
�Page I of2
ARMS Email System
I~,
...
Li
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:23-SEP-1998 17:49:31.00
SUBJECT:
WOMEN"S MTG CANCELLED
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F.Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
I"
READ : UN~OWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The Women's Meeting will be cancelled this.week. However, Ann will be
travelling to New Mexico for the second Women's History Commission meeting.
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 24-SEP-1998 11:16:14.00
SUBJECT:
Revised Q&A on Welfare for Poverty Briefing
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
TO: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TEXT:
fixed a typo in background
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D64]MAIL43671666T.226 to ASCII,
The follqwing is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043F2040000010A020100000002050000001EOC00000002000051388F9AE19E4435526A2A
0907EBBA203BC9CB08COC4691C6F57542AOEAED36AF5F0888D5D7EB335A5B9A1706726E43E2DD3
928494C7056431089249C28726984A31266AAOCF58AAB19CA2F85F54CE740841E131323BCC1315
7758B48DA8D6D739487FD1AABFB7CDB6FBOA2DB29C2D8E76F339BE6ED187BFAB2C214E60FA8CFE
958608A632ACA7C57977CE2F03F7DB6A290D1D1FA3A7096D6E02FF992CFBDC35EB56501E2C1FFA
8E1E2FB3965AA3C32A26C1BE45E5918D7675AAC054C4801FEF69F78C781F63CCOBBE1452BCBC40
824629401F30D5D209AF09585C359ACD2487BFD3942160A927D17115E9FB9B4DB540543D944713
DC1A863C2AD1BBD5625A201EDA3700D1F525CD7CEOA8462479E648962B8F71F6BDA8BF08FEAF59
B161F7269BAE6BCE97499EC7E568B07EF3CAA563D9B67BC1838A1C685324B0109F23981127C85E
C46A6525F2C09488C18A4C3ADDB0073BD3AOB5AOF8C40B237A4D5ADE63446B391BF7457388D13F
1CC9BFE806E3F23629608B8240677367E83D1528D4CBC55F9C156A427BBBCD66A922B7C51672E4
750BCC3848831CE263A57332A1B6A1EE788BOFAF674B5AE5E61A76C6BDC82BOA2D6F9A26060DBC
5909C56A6B3D693F154574350E86D6B5A0757D01B86993175947FEA845A6632CBC5FB94650C89D
72EDA17EAE02000B00000000000000000000000823010000000B0100009A020000005502000000
4EOOOOOOA503000009250100000006000000F30300000B300200000028000000F9030000081601
0000003200000021040000081D0100000000000000530400000055010000003C00000053040000
087701000000400000008F04000008340100000014000000CF0400000802010000000FOOOOOOE3
04000000984C006F00630061006COOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800C8002C012C012C012C01C800C800300000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000005E0037132800C8
196810480DOOOOII090000005AOOOBOI0000103600540069006DOO6500730020004E0065007700
200052006F006D0061006E00200052006500670075006C00610072000000000000000000010002
0058020100000004002800000000000000000000000000000000000000011202002400A1000000
AI00000043003A005C00500052004F00470053005C00570050005C005300540041004E00440041
�·
'.
4utoms!ed R,
,
/i, eCOrds M.
eX-Durn snsgem,
'IJ COnv. . en!8m
Welfare Reform Q&A on 1998 Census Income and Poverty Numbers erslon
em
September 24, 1998
Q:
A:
What do these new numbers tell us about the impact of welfare reform?
While it is still early to see the full effects of welfare refonn, the evidence so far is very
encouraging. Clearly there is no increase in poverty; poverty has decreased. In fact,
the Census data show continued strong trends in the movement from welfare to work: the
percentage of people on welfare in one year who were working in the following year has
increased by nearly one-third since 1996, the year the President signed the welfare refonn
law. This is occuring at the same time that welfare caseloads continue to decline
dramatically.
Background
The percentage of people who were on welfare in one year and working the following year
increased by 28% -- from 26.5% in March 96 to 33.8% in March 1998. The 3/98 figure
reflects people who said they were receiving welfare during 1997 and were working in March
1998. These data are included in the CPS files, but are not part of the infonnation Census
released publicly today.
Caseloads have declined 41 % since the President took office, and 32% since he signed the
welfare refonn law (using most recent data from June 98, which HHS released in August 98).
�Page 1 of3
ARMS Email System
•
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:24-SEP-1998 13:05:26.00
SUBJECT:
Today's Women Leaders Press Conference
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 0f3
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO 1)
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jena V. Roscoe ( CN=Jena V. Roscoe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Today at 12 pm at the National Press Club Betty Friedan, Pat Ireland/NOW,
Eleanor Smeal/Feminist Majority, Dorothy Height/NCNW, Susan Bianchi
-Sand/National Council, Delores Huerta/UFW, Sheila Coates/BWUFA, Kathy
Rodgers/NLDEF, Jane Smith/NCNW, Lina Frescas Dobbs/WOW, Yvonne
Scruggs-Leftwich/Black Leadership Forum, Karen Narasaki/Nat'l Asian
Pacific Legal Consortium and Donna Allen/Women's Institute for Freedom of
the Press joined together to deliver a united statement in support of
POTUS, "Women Leaders Take Action to Stop Impeachment, Warn What's at
�.
ARMS Email System
"
Stake for Women",
The statement is very strong and supportive, I have faxable copies in our
office may have it on e-mail this afternoon which we will circulate.
Let
me know if you want a hard copy.
Page 3 of3
�AR.,MS Email System
Page 1 of 4
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:24-SEP-1998 10:28:32.00
SUBJECT:
OTAG SIP Call Heads Up Memo
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: T J. Glauthier ( CN=T J. Glauthier/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yelien/oU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Alan S. Polasky ( CN=Alan S. Polasky/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
�Page 2 of4
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Frances Sharples ( CN=Frances Sharples/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Linda Lance ( CN=Linda Lance/OU=CEQ/O=EOP@EOP [ CEQ ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The attached document went out last night (September 23, 1998).
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D32]MAIL42577566J.226 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043CC040000010A02010000000205000000CE14000000020000D984366B49DE74C63EA912
905EA58858B44C8403514D8275DE174C5127108FECE1B778A15D3A6848A627E198676A1C14039A
9675E43CCOFC1E67C9B2894710F767E31D39951F8C3D676EEF7972FB68778F6CA987EC35FAC52E
CC346EOE29BEDABD310C941684F730C092433B30A6390FB3DE34DFAF26CE1CFA8DD6587F923634
D74396DF3D7006450F8B65A6515E87D039A6D46FA8AA7D2694AA3B68838EOA954373A94FD28BF4
9741BEOFCBCA7CB8053EE67233A2D87E3D6A435A3FE3A59D58C7908B709713FEEE12057B40A540
42CF9AE98AF3A7DE6D0913EEFOA4A7CCBC9AB83EA63DFF506F46F8ECOFEBC54BE587E68B9D3E95
BDE1A307FFDF3CAEB860424CB6FE032A39DEOB66CDE4ACBBEE8257D8BD93F15AFA49C6EF54EDDE
82B6409048A398A34B7F40D5669698B767CB8A6374BAE398EF097D564087F8446019AF58123CF1
26293A3F815BDB50A483E2757F175A8887FAFE285394814935C805D5C4F2E06BD3C250C8B4A90D
9B8305AE7D372CC9A6341DD8845ADD14DC3396544652FF4C3152DA8C405E6F739DEDOB88F9C7DE
B09CC17527DFF01FA7E25B51C6B57C1B55767307773125D6D9AB4EE5AAF74547FFD4FB29850B9D
EODD6C57064BBD04FEAA2896751BCB8669BF8B52B7AF66660A6A06622702D97692DDB5CDB56881
6B51B0606302000900000000000000000000000823010000000B0100007E020000005501000000
4E0000008903000009250100000006000000D70300000B300200000084000000DD030000087701
000000400000006104000008340100000014000000A10400000802010000000FOOOOOOB5040000
08050100000008000000C404000000985C005C004F004D0042002D00500053002D00320038002D·
00320039005C003300350030004200000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800C8002C012C012C012C01C800
C80030000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000B0100002800C8196810480D000011090000005AOOOB010000103600540069006D0065
00730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E00200052006500670075006C0061007200
0000000000000000010002005802010000000400280000005COOOO000000000000000000000000
000112F4C42400A1000000A1000000D3050C0000010000000COOD3D1060C0000010001000COOD1
D1033700800100001600DD46010000580206000058020000000000000064C80001000058020600
0058020000000000000064EC003700D1D1020D000001000101050D00D10A000000610004001300
620002005B0063000200020064'0003004500650005000200660002000B00670001001300680001
0017006900280065816A00010002004C86A8240000000058020000000000000064EC0008337COO
7800000200006A000000030100040002000000DDOA1000830104000300F4C4211000DDD3050COO
00010000000COOD3D1060C0000010001000COOD1D10337008001000016004CCE01000058020600
0058020000000000000064FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000064C8003700D1D1020D
000001000100050DOOD1DDOBOB00030000040BOODDF1026900F19BF1036900F1F1006900F19BF1
016900F1F1026900F1F1036900F1D10337008001000016004CCE01000058020000005802000000·
0000000064F000010000580206000058020000000000000064FOOO3700D1CCCCCCCCCCCC4D454D
4F52414E44554D80464F52804552534B494E4580F1006900F19C9CF1016900F1424F574C4553F1
006900F19B9BF1016900F1CCD3042A0000160001B00406002C0100580283580200990C00100E96
580201B004020000009C58022AOOD3CCF1006900F19CF1016900F1F1006600F146524F4D3AE011
OC0000000060090COOEOE0110C00000000990COCOOE09CF1026300F1446F6EF1036300F1F10166
00F1F1006400F1F1026300F1616C6480F1036300F1F1016400F1F1006600F1F1026500F1804172
6275636B6C65D0041500000B00090001300C8007080001201500DOCCF1036500F1F1016600F1F1
�Automated R,
H, eCCrdsMa
eX-Dump Conn:!rse'!7ent SYste
Ion
",
lh
MEMORANDUM FOR ERSKINE BOWLES
THROUGH:
Jack Lew
FROM:
Don Arbuckle
SUBJECT:
Heads Up Memo --EPA's OTAG SIP Call
On Thursday, EPA will announce its final rule for the Ozone Transport Assessment
Group (OTAG) State Implementation Plan (SIP) Call. The rule will address the interstate
transport of pollutants associated with elevated ozone levels in many of the nation's major cities.
This initiative was identified as a key next step in the President's memo of July 16, 1997 to EPA
on the implementation of the revised ambient air quality standard for ozone.
, The OTAG SIP Call will require 22 eastern States and the District of Columbia to prepare
State Implementation Plans to obtain substantial additional reductions in NO x emissions in order
to meet EPA-specified State NO x budgets. EPA has structured this regulatory initiative to focus
on reductions in the NO x emissions from fossil-fired --especially coal-fired-- electric utility
plants. EPA estimates the rule will impose costs of roughly $1.7 billion per year; electric
utilities would incur costs of $1.4 billion per year. EPA reports estimated benefits for the rule
ranging from one billion to four billion dollars per year. We completed our review Tuesday
evening and the Administrator plans to sign the package (and make a press announcement)
Thursday afternoon.
This is a controversial rulemaking. EPA is using for the first time its authority under
Clean Air Act Section 110 to require States to control emissions that "significantly contribute" to
nonattainment problems in downwind States. Because of the importance of this rule, we expect
that some of the Midwestern and Southern States (~, West Virginia, North and South Carolina,
Kentucky) and electric utilities operating in these areas will criticize the rule and challenge it in
Court. We understand that EPA has been reaching out to the Midwestern and Southern
governors and utilities over the last several weeks. They believe that they have succeeded in
tempering the response to the final rule. Some States (Georgia, Tennessee) will support the final
rule while other States in this area will remain neutral. The Northeast States strongly support
the rule.
�•
cc:
Maria Echaveste
Rahm Emanuel
Larry Stein
Ron Klain
Thurgood Marshall, Jr.
Ann Lewis
Sally Katzen
Minyon Moore
John Podesta
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Elena Kagan
Barry Toiv
Michael Waldman
Janet Yellen
Mickey Ibarra
T. J. Glauthier
Automated Records M
Hex-Dump coanagement Sysrem
nvers/on
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
l. . _ ,.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP
WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:24-SEP-1998 16:21:53.00
SUBJECT:
Women Leaders Press Statement
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia ApUZZO/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
'READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania
READ: UNKNOWN
I. Lopez/OU=WHojO=EOP
@
EOP [ WHO
1 )
CC: Jena V. Roscoe ( CN=Jena V. Roscoe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kelley L. O'Dell
( CN=Kelley L. O'Dell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Attached is the press statement released today at the Women Leaders Press
Conference in support of POTUS.
�A~S
Email System
Page 1 of 11
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: OASISMGR@A1@CD@LNGTWY ( OASISMGR@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OA)
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-SEP-1998 02:53:19.00
SUBJECT:
Extension of Deadline for Submitting Names for Holiday Cards
KENNEDY B@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 }
TO: KENNEDY B@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KAZEL J@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (OMB)
TO: KAZEL J@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JURITH E@A1@CD@LNGTWY' ( JURITH E@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
JONES K@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 }
TO: JONES K@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(DON)
(STP)
JACOBSON T@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (NSC)
TO: JACOBSON T@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN.
TO: HUNGERFORD T@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: HORN S@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(WHO)
HUNGERFORD T@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (OMB)
HORN S@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (WHO)
TO: dhodge@ostp.eop.gov@INET@LNGTWY ( dhodge@ostp.eop.gov@INET@LNGTWY [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: HILL CM@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
HILL CM@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (OA)
TO: HEATH D@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
HEATH D@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (OMB)
TO: HASMAN_T@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
HASMAN T@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (NSC)
TO: ghane@ostp.eop.gov@INET@LNGTWY ( ghane@ostp.eop.gov@INET@LNGTWY [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: HAINES M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: GUIDE L@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
HAINES M@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 }
GUIDE L@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (CEQ)
TO: Farooq Khan@EOP ( Farooq Khan@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann Kendrall@EOP (
READ: UNKNOWN
Ann
(NSC)
Kendrall@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Kenneth S. Kelly@EOP ( Kenneth S. Kelly@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alexander S. Keenan@EOP ( Alexander S. Keenan@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 11
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stanley Kaufman@EOP ( Stanley Kaufman@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth V. Katze@OVP@EOP ( Elizabeth V. Katze@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Olga H. Kasaskeris@EOP ( Olga H. Kasaskeris@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jody J. Kaplan@eop ( Jody J. Kaplan@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William A. Kane@eop ( William A. Kane@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Kamensky@eop ( John Kamensky@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil@eop ( Thomas A. Kalil@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anil Kakani@eop ( Anil Kakani@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian G. Kahin@eop ( Brian G. Kahin@eop [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul A. Jutton@eop ( Paul A. Jutton@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James E. Judd@eop ( James E. Judd@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gay L. Joshlyn@eop ( Gay L. Joshlyn@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Eli P. Joseph@eop ( Eli P. Joseph@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne A. Jones@EOP ( Wayne A. Jones@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ronald e. jones@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
ronald e. jones@eop [ OMB 1 )
TO: Lindsay R. Jones@eop ( Lindsay R. Jones@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Jones@eop ( Lisa M. Jones@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Felicia A. Jones@eop ( Felicia A. Jones@eop [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Deborah A. Jones@eop ( Deborah A. Jones@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carlos C. Jones@EOP ( Carlos C. Jones@EOP [ OA 1 )
�Page 3 of 11
ARMS Email System
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jones@EOP ( Christopher C. Jones@EOP [ OA
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin@EOP ( Michele Jolin@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne C. Johnson@EOP ( Wayne C. Johnson@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rose M. Johnson@eop (" Rose M. Johnson@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson@eop ( Robert B. Johnson@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Y. Johnson@EOP ( Michelle Y. Johnson@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OA 1 )
TO: Kim I. Johnson@EOP ( Kim I. Johnson@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darrell A. Johnson@EOP ( Darrell A. Johnson@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cornelius F. Johnson@EOP ( Cornelius F. Johnson@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anthony Johnson@eop ( Anthony Johnson@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ NSC 1 )
TO: Christopher S. Johns@eop ( Christopher S. Johns@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carol D. Jenkins@eop ( Carol D. Jenkins@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
OMB 1 )
TO: Janie L. Jeffers@eop ( Janie L. Jeffers@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
OMB 1 )
TO: Thomas D. Janenda@EOP ( Thomas D. Janenda@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby@eop ( Peter G. Jacoby@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Norwood J. Jackson Jr@eop ( Norwood J. Jackson Jr@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KEVIN JACKSON@EOP ( KEVIN JACKSON@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven J. Isakowitz@eop ( Steven J. Isakowitz@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Chin-Chin Ip@eop ( Chin-Chin Ip@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diane Ikemiyashiro@eop ( Diane Ikemiyashiro@eop
[ WHO 1 )
�A~S
Email System
Page 4 of 11
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh@eop ( Phu D. Huynh@eop [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toni S. Hustead@EOP ( Toni S. Hustead@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marc I. Hurwitz@eop ( Marc I. Hurwitz@eop [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thaddeus J. Hunt@eop ( Thaddeus J. Hunt@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OA 1 )
TO: Joan Hunerwadel@eop ( Joan Hunerwadel@eop [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bernard E. Huff@eop ( Bernard E. Huff@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen A. Hudson@eop ( Maureen A. Hudson@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Howes@eop ( Sarah Howes@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert C. Houser@eop ( Robert C. Houser@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eric P. Hothem@eop ( Eric P. Hothem@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Valerie D. Hopkins@EOP ( Valerie D. Hopkins@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: walter L. Holton@eop ( walter L. Holton@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ ONDCP 1 )
TO: Christine P. Holmes@EOP ( Christine P. Holmes@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jean W. Holcombe@EOP ( Jean W. Holcombe@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Adam Hoffberg@EOP ( Adam Hoffberg@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Hobbs@EOP ( Karen Hobbs@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joanne M. Hilty@OVP@EOP ( Joanne M. Hilty@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sheree Hillian@eop ( Sheree Hillian@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jefferson B. Hill@eop ( Jefferson B. Hill@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich@eop ( Nancy V. Hernreich@eop [ WHO 1 )
�Page 5 of 11
AR¥S Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth K. Hembree@EOP ( Kenneth K. Hembree@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Renee P. Helm@EOP ( Renee P. Helm@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael P. Hegarty@eop ( Michael P. Hegarty@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes@OVP@EOP ( Audrey T. Haynes@OVP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Eric M. Haxthausen@eop ( Eric M. Haxthausen@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen O. Hawkins@eop ( Stephen O. Hawkins@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun@eop ( David J. Haun@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bernard E. Harvey@eop ( Bernard E. Harvey@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wendy Hartman@OVP@EOP ( Wendy Hartman@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald P. harriott@eop ( Ronald P. harriott@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynnda J. Harley@eop ( Lynnda J. Harley@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca J. Hardy@eop ( Rebecca J. Hardy@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Bruce Harding@OVP@EOP ( Bruce Harding@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin@eop ( Kirk T. Hanlin@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patricia S. Haney@eop ( Patricia S. Haney@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dianne M. Ham@eop ( Dianne M. Ham@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David Halperin@eop ( David Halperin@eop [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John S. Hale@eop ( John S. Hale@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Haas@OVP@EOP ( Lawrence J. Haas@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Holly L. Gwin@eop ( Holly L. Gwin@eop [ OSTP 1 )
�Page 6 of 11
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Gunia@eop ( Daniel J. Gunia@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK_D@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: KERRICK D@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: hkelly@ostp.eop.gov@INET@LNGTWY ( hkelly@ostp.eop.gov@INET@LNGTWY [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: NOTESREFLECT@Al@CD@LNGTWY ( NOTESREFLECT@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (SYS)
READ: UNKNOWN
JORDAN JF@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OMB)
TO: JORDAN_JF@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JOHNSON TD@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
JOHNSON TD@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(DON)
JACKSON H@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
TO: JACKSON H@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: HUANG B@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
HUANG B@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
()
TO: HOGAN A@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
HOGAN A@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(STP)
HITTLE L@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: HITTLE L@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
HICKS D@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: HICKS D@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(DON)
(WHO)
TO: HAZARD S@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
HAZARD S@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: HARRIS E@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
HARRIS E@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: HALL_A@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
HALL A@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: GUITERAS R@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: GUHA S@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(WHO)
(CEQ)
GUITERAS_R@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
GUHA S@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: James E. Kennedy@eop ( James E. Kennedy@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra L. Kelly@eop ( Sandra L. Kelly@eop [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John W. Kelly@EOP ( John W. Kelly@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Kaufmann@EOP ( Karen E. Kaufmann@EOP [ OA 1 )
(DON)
()
�Page 7 of 11
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen@eop ( Sally Katzen@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart R. Kasdin@eop ( Stuart R. Kasdin@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan@EOP ( Jonathan A. Kaplan@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Kapla@eop ( Robert S. Kapla@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane@eop ( Andrea Kane@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andris Kalnins@eop ( Andris Kalnins@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David E. Kalbaugh@EOP ( David E. Kalbaugh@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aram H. Kailian@OVP@EOP ( Aram H. Kailian@OVP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan@eop ( Elena Kagan@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James J. Jukes@eop ( James J. Jukes@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele R. Joy@EOP ( Michele R. Joy@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: M. Kay Joshi@eop ( M. Kay Joshi@eop [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Walter F. Jones@eop ( Walter F. Jones@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Jones@EOP ( Mary E. Jones@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura C. Jones@EOP ( Laura C. Jones@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Jones@eop ( Jennifer L. Jones@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth C. Jones@eop ( Elizabeth C. Jones@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cyril Jones@eop ( Cyril Jones@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Crystal B. Jones@eop ( Crystal B. Jones@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ansley Jones@OVP@EOP ( Ansley Jones@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�A~S
Page 8 of 11
Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Heather A. Johnston@eop ( Heather A. Johnston@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Renee M. Johnson@eop ( Renee M. Johnson@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
[ OSTP 1 )
TO: Rochester M. Johnson@eop ( Rochester M. Johnson@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phalia Johnson@EOP ( Phalia Johnson@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lee R. Johnson@eop ( Lee R. Johnson@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald G. Johnson@eop ( Donald G. Johnson@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carol S. Johnson@eop ( Carol S. Johnson@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Barbara A. Johnson@eop ( Barbara A. Johnson@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angela Johnson@EOP ( Angela Johnson@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings@eop ( Christopher C .. Jennings@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: carline m jelsma@eop ( carline m jelsma@eop [ OMB 1
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno@eop ( Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Theodoric C. James Jr.@eop ( Theodoric C. James Jr.@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laurence R. Jacobson@EOP ( Laurence R. Jacobson@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn W. Jackson@eop ( Kathryn W. Jackson@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OA 1 )
TO: Marilyn R. Jacanin@eop ( Marilyn R. Jacanin@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Janet E. Irwin@eop ( Janet E. Irwin@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael X. Imbroscio@eop (.Michael X. Imbroscio@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra@eop ( Mickey Ibarra@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: virgina A. Huth@EOP ( Virgina A. Huth@EOP
[ OMB 1 )
�Page 9 of 11
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence W. Hush@eop ( Lawrence W. Hush@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James C. Hurban@eop ( James C. Hurban@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: alexander t. hunt@eop ( alexander t. hunt@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward F. Hughes@eop ( Edward F. Hughes@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul W. Huelskamp@eop ( Paul W. Huelskamp@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: kathy M. Hudgins@eop ( kathy M. Hudgins@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert F. Housman@eop ( Robert F. Housman@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Everett D. Houser@eop ( Everett D. Houser@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah G. Horrigan@EOP ( Sarah G. Horrigan@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edith D. Hopkins@eop ( Edith D. Hopkins@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel S. Holt@eop ( Daniel S. Holt@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gloria K. Holland@EOP ( Gloria K. Holland@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marty J. Hoffmann@eop ( Marty J. Hoffmann@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jurg E. Hochuli@EOP ( Jurg E. Hochuli@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shannon M. Hinderliter@eop ( Shannon M. Hinderliter@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda I. Hilliard@eop ( Brenda I. Hilliard@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ NSC 1 )
TO: Roseanne M. Hill@eop ( Roseanne M. Hill@eop [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda W. Hicklin@eop ( Linda W. Hicklin@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gregory G. Henry@eop ( Gregory G. Henry@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert D. Helms@EOP ( Robert D. Helms@EOP [ OA 1 )
�Page 10 of 11
AR¥S Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karl H. Heissner@eop ( Karl H. Heissner@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul Hegarty@OVP@EOP ( Paul Hegarty@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William C. Haymes@eop ( William C. Haymes@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan C. Hawthorne@EOP ( Susan C. Hawthorne@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ardenia R. Hawkins@eop ( Ardenia R. Hawkins@eop [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melinda D. Haskins@eop ( Melinda D. Haskins@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Colleen N. Hartman@eop ( Colleen N. Hartman@eop [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey E. Harris@eop ( Jeffrey E. Harris@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda F. Harper@eop ( Brenda F. Harper@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin M. Harkins@eop ( Kevin M. Harkins@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dionne M. Hardy@eop ( Dionne M. Hardy@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Mary E. Hanson@eop ( Mary E. Hanson@eop [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie S. Hankins@eop ( Marjorie S. Hankins@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mae E. Haney@eop ( Mae E. Haney@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William A. Halter@EOP ( William A. Halter@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sheryl L .. Hall@eop ( Sheryl L. Hall@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert W. Haas@eop ( Robert W. Haas@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie L. Haas@eop ( Julie L. Haas@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John A. Gunter@eop ( John A. Gunter@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey D. Gulko@eop ( Jeffrey D. Gulko@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
�ARMS Email System
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Due to the large volume of users accessing the Holiday Card Database this
morning, we are experiencing maj or delays with the system..
These delays
are
also seriously affecting t~e WAVES application.
To alleviate this
problem, the
deadline for submitting names for Holiday Cards has been extended to next
Wednesday, September 30.
Because of the last minute submission of names and the errors it has
caused,
please do not submit anymore names today.
We will be providing more
information
to' administrative contacts regarding the best time for your agency to
access the
Holiday Card Database next week.
We apologize for the problems and appreciate your understanding and
cooperation.
Page 11 of 11
�ARMS Email System
~
Page 1 of7
(I
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ronald E. Jones ( CN=Ronald E. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-SEP-1998 09:44:39.00
SUBJECT:
OMB Letter to Conferees on Bankruptcy Bills -- comments due today by 3:00
TO: Linda Ricci ( CN=Linda Ricci/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Ahern ( CN=Michele
READ:UNKNOWN
Aher~/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Toni S. Hustead ( CN=Toni S. Hustead/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua H. Raymond ( CN=Joshua H. Raymond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John S. Radzikowski ( CN=John S. Radzikowski/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pamula L. Simms ( CN=Pamula L. Simms/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas P. Stack ( CN=Thomas P. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark A. Weatherly ( CN=Mark A. Weatherly/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice Veenstra ( CN=Alice Veenstra/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
R,EAD : UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of7
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert L. Nabors ( CN=Robert L. NaborsjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet E. Irwin ( CN=Janet E. IrwinjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gary L. Bennethum ( CN=Gary L. BennethumjOU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edwin Lau ( CN=Edwin LaujOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S. RedburnjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen J. Balis ( CN=Ellen J. BalisjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne Upshaw ( CN=Wayne UpshawjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. TimberlakejOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward A. Brigham ( CN=Edward A. Brigham(OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. RicejOU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. ParkerjOU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPDjO=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas W. Elmendorf ( CN=Douglas W. Elmendorf/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. BlankjOU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Peterson ( CN=Michelle PetersonjOU=WHOjO=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. JukesjOU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:
CC:
Jeffrey A. Weinberg ( CN=Jeffrey A. Weinberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 3 of7
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
NO HARD COpy OF THE ATTACHED WILL BE SENT -- please respond even if you
have no comments
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: REJ602
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Monday, September 28, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Jeffrey A. Weinberg (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
SUBJECT:
1998
OMB
Ronald E. Jones
DEADLINE:
PHONE: (202) 395- 3386 FAX: (202) 395 -3109
Report on S1301 Consumer Bankruptcy Reform Act of
3:00 PM today
Monday, September 28, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: We expect additional letters from DOJ, Interior, and Treasury.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - L. Anthony Sutin - (202) 514-2141
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
7-AGRICULTURE - Marvin Shapiro - (202) 720-1516
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
30-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
35-Farm Credit Administration - Eileen McMahon - (703) 883-4056
34-Export-Import Bank of the United States - David Carter - (202) 565-3203
54-HUD - Jeff Lischer - (202) 708-1793
18-Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer
(202) 395-5084
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
27-ConsumerProduct Safety Commission - Robert J. Wager - (301) 504-0515
32-ENERGY - Bob Rabben - (202) 586-6718
59-INTERIOR - Jane Lyder - (202) 208-4371
129-VETERANS AFFAIRS - John H. Thompson - (202) 273-6666
EOP:
Michelle Peterson
Robert N. Weiner
�Page 4 of7
ARMS Email System
Roger S. Ballentine
Maureen T. Shea
Rebecca M. Blank
Elena Kagan
Douglas W. Elmendorf
Maria Echaveste
Audrey T. Haynes
Sarah Rosen
Jonathan Orszag
Nicole R. Rabner
Joseph J. Minarik
Diana Fortuna
Emil E. Parker
Jennifer L. Klein
Cynthia A. Rice
John E. Thompson
Edward A. Brigham
Alice Veenstra
Courtney B. Timberlake
Mark A. Weatherly
Wayne Upshaw
Thomas P. Stack
Ellen J. Balis
Pamula L. Simms
Francis S. Redburn
John S. Radzikowski
Edwin Lau
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Joshua H. Raymond
Gary L. Bennethum
Toni S. Hustead
Janet E. Irwin
Michele Ahern
LRM ID: REJ602 SUBJECT:
Act of 1998
OMB
Report on S1301 Consumer Bankruptcy Reform
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
FROM:
Ronald E. Jones phone:
395-3386
Fax:
395-3109
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant)
395-3454
(Date)
�Page 5 of7
ARMS Email System
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
LETTER TO CONFEREES TO BE SENT TO EACH HOUSE AND SENATE CONFEREE.
CONSIDER WHETHER, SIMULTANEOUSLY WITH CONFEREE LETTER, THE WHITE HOUSE
SHOULD RELEASE SHORT STATEMENT FROM PRESIDENT PRAISING SENATE VOTE AS A
RESOUNDING CALL FOR MODERATION AND URGING CONFEREES TO ADOPT SENATE
APPROACH.
September 28, 1998 -- DRAFT
Dear
I write to share the AdministrationD,s views on H.R. 3150 and S.
1301 -- the two bankruptcy reform bills before the conference committee.
The President shares the CongressD, concern about the sharp
increase in consumer bankruptcy filings -- an especially puzzling increase
in the face of our extraordinarily strong economy. However, the President
rejects any attempt to scapegoat American consumers.
There is evidence of
abuse by both debtors and creditors, but many others factors also may be
involved in the stark rise in bankruptcies. The President hopes we can
avoid finger pointing and instead focus on completing a bill that will
best serve the American people.
The American people will be best served by reform that is both
balanced and moderate -- addressing the abuses of· both creditors and
debtors, making prudent, well conceived improvements to our Bankrutpcy
system, and protecting and enhancing the collection of debtorsD, child
support and alimony in the context of bankruptcy. Thus, essential reforms
contained in the Senate bill include:
a discretionary approach to, and higher thresholds for, shifting
borrowers from Chapter 7 to Chapter 13;
.
new nondischargeable debts limited only to debts incurred with an
intent to defraud or for luxuries immediately preceding bankruptcy;
�ARMS Email System
Page 6 of7
adequate protection against coercive reaffirmations; and
disclosure requirements to ensure that consumers receive the
information they need to manage their budgets.
The extraordinary bipartisan support for the Senate bill was a
unified endorsement of balance and moderation. Unfortunately, the House
bill fails to meet this standard.
If the House bill were sent to the
president, his senior advisors would recommend that he veto the bill.
The Administration cannot support a bill that includes a rigid and
arbitrary approach to determining whether a debtor can use Chapter 7 or
must establish a repayment plan under Chapter 13. We should deny access
to Chapter 7 only to those who genuinely have the capacity to repay a
portion of the debts successfully under a Chapter 13 plan. Thus,
bankruptcy courts must have discretion to consider the specific
circumstances of a debtor in bankruptcy, and the thresholds they consider
should be high enough to ensure that only those with a strong likelihood
of success are affected.
If we deny access to Chapter 7 to the wrong
debtors, and those debtors fail to complete required repayment plans, they
will return to Chapter 7 with a diminished ability to repay their
nondischarged debt -- including child support and alimony.
The Administration does agree that a creditor should be permitted
to bring a motion under Section 707(b) to ask the court to determine
whether a debtor has the capacity to repay, provided that protections
against coercive reaffirmations are included in the bill. However, the
Administration cannot support a bill that allows unrestricted creditor
motions based on traditional 707(b) allegations of abuse, which may be
more subjective than a test for oneO,s capacity to repay. Allowing these
motions could make more unequal the balance of power and information
between creditor and debtor, especially for lower income debtors who would
have the least power to defend themselves against unjustified motions.
The Administration also cannot support legislation that creates new,
nondischargeable debts that could pit, post-bankruptcy, credit card debt
against child support, alimony, educational loans, and taxes.
For debt
incurred to pay nondischargeable debt, the Senate bill appropriately makes
the debt nondischargeable only when a court finds that the debtor intended
to avoid the debt through bankruptcy.
Similarly, for debt incurred within
90 days of bankruptcy, the Senate bill makes the debt nondischargeable
only if there is more than $400 of debt to a single creditor for luxury
goods or services.
Making debt for necessities subject to a cap, as does
the House bill, is simply unacceptable.
[CHECK FINAL SENATE BILL
LANGUAGE.]
Finally, the Administration cannot support legislation that does not curb
abuse by creditors as well as debtors. Greater competition and dramatic
changes in how creditors grant credit, while beneficial for many, have
allowed more consumers to get in over their heads.
In response, credit
card companies must give consumers more and better information so that
they can understand and better manage their debts. Similarly, we must
protect debtors against predatory creditor tactics to coerce inappropriate
and unwise reaffirmations of unsecured debt and secured personalty debts
for items that are likely to have little resale value.
This letter sets for our views on some of the central consumer
bankruptcy issues in these bills. However, the bill contain hundreds of
provisions on which we have views.
We will supplement this letter with
additional comments as the process moves forward.
�,.
ARMS Email System
Page 70f7
We look forward to working with the Congress to enact moderate and
balanced bankruptcy reform legislation.
Sincerely,
Jack Lew
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Francine P. Obermiller (CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-SEP-1998 10:46:30.00
SUBJECT:
OCT 14-CPI BRIEF BY KATHARINE ABRAHAM
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald R. Arbuckle ( CN=Donald R. Arbuckle/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Rebecca Blank invites you to a CPI Brief on Wednesday, October 14,
10:30-11:30am,
Old EOB, Room 324, to be given by the Bureau of Labor
Statistics Commissioner Katharine Abraham, and her staff.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of6
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ronald E. Jones ( CN=Ronald E. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-SEP-1998 11:20:50.00
SUBJECT:
REVISED OMB LETTER ON BANKRUPTCY BILLS -- COMMENTS BY 1:00 PM PLEASE
TO: Robert L. Nabors ( CN=Robert L. Nabors/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet E. Irwin ( CN=Janet E. Irwin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gary L. Bennethum ( CN=Gary L. Bennethum/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edwin Lau ( CN=Edwin Lau/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S. Redburn/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen J. Balis ( CN=Ellen J. Balis/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne Upshaw ( CN=Wayne Upshaw/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. Timberlake/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward A. Brigham ( CN=Edward A. Brigham/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
. TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas W. Elmendorf ( CN=Douglas W. Elmendorf/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Ricci ( CN=Linda Ricci/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System.
Page 2 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Ahern
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Michele Ahern/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO; Toni S. Hustead ( CN=Toni S. Hustead/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua H. Raymond ( CN=Joshua H. Raymond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John S. Radzikowski ( CN=John S. Radzikowski/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Pamula L. Simms ( CN=Pamula L. Simms/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas P. Stack ( CN=Thomas P. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark A. Weatherly ( CN=Mark A. Weatherly/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice Veenstra ( CN=Alice Veenstra/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
. READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jeffrey A. Weinberg ( CN=Jeffrey A. Weinberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�A~S
Page 3 of6
Email System
NO HARD COPY WILL BE SENT
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: REJ606
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Monday, September 28, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Jeffrey A. Weinberg (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
SUBJECT:
of 1998
REVISED
Ronald E. Jones
DEADLINE:
PHONE: (202) 395- 3 386 FAX: (202) 395- 3109
Report on S1301 Consumer Bankruptcy Reform Act
1:00 PM TODAY
Tuesday, September 29, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: NEC has requested that this letter be sent to the conferrees
prior to a meeting this afternoon. This includes NEC edits.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - L. Anthony Sutin - (202) 514-2141
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
7-AGRICULTURE - Marvin Shapiro - (202) 720-1516
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
30-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
35-Farm Credit Administration - Eileen McMahon - (703) 883-4056"
34-Export-Import Bank of the United States - David Carter - (202) 565-3203
54-HUD - Jeff Lischer - (202) 708-1793
18-Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer
(202) 395-5084
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
27-Consumer Product Safety Commission - Robert J. Wager - (301) 504-0515
32-ENERGY - Bob Rabben - (202) 586-6718
59-INTERIOR - Jane Lyder - (202) 208-4371
129-VETERANS AFFAIRS - John H. Thompson - (202) 273-6666
EOP:
Michelle Peterson
Robert N. Weiner
Roger S. Ballentine
Maureen T. Shea
�A~S
Page 4 of6
Email System
Rebecca M. Blank
Elena Kagan
Douglas W. Elmendorf
Maria Echaveste
Audrey T. Haynes
Sarah Rosen
Jonathan Orszag
Nicole R. Rabner
Joseph J. Minarik
Diana Fortuna
Emil E. Parker
Jennifer L. Klein
Cynthia A. Rice
John E. Thompson
Edward A. Brigham
Alice Veenstra
Courtney B. Timberlake
Mark A. Weatherly
wayne Upshaw
Thomas P. Stack
Ellen J. Balis
Pamula L. Simms
Francis S. Redburn
John S. Radzikowski
Edwin Lau
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Joshua H. Raymond
Gary L. Bennethum
Toni S. Hustead
Janet E. Irwin
Michele Ahern
Robert L. Nabors
Linda Ricci
LRM ID: REJ606 SUBJECT:'
Reform Act of 1998
REVISED
Report on S1301 Consumer Bankruptcy
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
FROM:
Ronald E. Jones Phone:
395-3386
Fax:
395-3109
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
(Date)
�Page 5 of6
ARMS Email System
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
LETTER TO CONFEREES TO BE SENT TO EACH HOUSE AND SENATE CONFEREE.
CONSIDER WHETHER, SIMULTANEOUSLY WITH CONFEREE LETTER, THE WHITE HOUSE
SHOULD RELEASE SHORT STATEMENT FROM PRESIDENT PRAISING SENATE VOTE AS A
RESOUNDING CALL FOR MODERATION AND URGING CONFEREES TO ADOPT SENATE
APPROACH.
September 28, 1998 -- DRAFT
Dear
I write to share the AdministrationO,s views on H.R. 3150 and S.
1301 -- the two bankruptcy reform bills before the conference committee.
The President shares the CongressO, concern about the sharp
increase in consumer bankruptcy filings -- an especially puzzling increase
in the face of our extraordinarily strong economy. The President supports
reform that is both balanced and moderate -- addressing the abuses of both
creditors and debtors, making prudent, well conceived improvements to our
Bankrutpcy system, and protecting and enhancing the collection of
debtorsO, child support and alimony in the context of bankruptcy.
There is evidence of abuse by both debtors and creditors, but many
others factors also may be involved in the stark rise in bankruptcies. We
should avoid a bill that takes indiscriminate aim at debtors and fails to
address some troubling practices of creditors.
The extraordinary bipartisan support for the Senate bill was a
unified endorsement of balance and moderation.
Unfortunately, the House
bill fails to meet this standard. . If the House bill were sent to the
President, his senior advisors would recommend that he veto the bill.
The Administration cannot support a bill that includes a rigid and
arbitrary approach to determining whether a debtor can use Chapter 7 or
must establish a repayment plan under Chapter 13. We should deny access
�ARMS Email System
Page 60f6
to Chapter 7 only to those who genuinely have the capacity to repay a
portion of the debts successfully under a Chapter 13 plan.
Thus,
bankruptcy courts must have discretion to consider the specific
circumstances of a debtor in bankruptcy, and the thresholds they consider
should be high enough to ensure that only those with a strong likelihood
of success are affected.
If we deny access to Chapter 7 to the wrong
debtors, and those debtors fail to complete required repayment plans, they
will return to Chapter 7 with a diminished ability to repay their
nondischarged debt -- including child support and alimony.
The Administration does agree that a creditor should be permitted
to bring a motion under Section 707(b) to ask the court to determine
whether a debtor has the capacity to repay, provided that protections
against coercive reaffirmations are included in the bill.
However, the
Administration cannot support a bill that allows unrestricted creditor
motions based on traditional 707(b) allegations of abuse, which may be
more subjective than a test for oneD,s capacity to repay.
Allowing these
motions could make more unequal the balance of power and information
between creditor and debtor, especially for lower income debtors who would
have the least power to defend themselves against unjustified motions.
The Administration also cannot support legislation that creates
new, nondischargeable debts that could pit, post-bankruptcy, credit card
debt against child support, alimony, educational loans, and taxes.
For
debt incurred to pay nondischargeable debt, the Senate bill appropriately
makes the debt nondischargeable only when a court finds that the debtor
intended to avoid the debt through bankruptcy.
For debt incurred within
90 days of bankruptcy, the Senate bill makes the debt nondischargeable
only if there is more than $400 of debt to a single creditor for goods or
services 0, reasonably necessary for the support of the debtor or a
dependant child.DB While, at a minimum, the Senate provision should allow
for debt reasonably necessary to support the debtorD,s household, the
House provision, subjecting debt for necessities to a cap, is simply
unacceptable
Finally, the Administration cannot support legislation that does
not curb abuse by creditors as well as debtors.
Credit card companies
must give consumers more and better information so that they can
understand and better manage their debts.
Similarly, we must protect
debtors against predatory creditor tactics to coerce inappropriate and
unwise reaffirmations of unsecured debt and secured debts for personalty
that are likely to have little resale value.
This letter sets forth our views on some of the central consumer
bankruptcy issues in these bills. However, the Administration has other
concerns about the many provisions in these bills. We will share
additional comments as quickly as possible.
We look forward to working with the Congress to enact moderate and
balanced bankruptcy reform legislation.
Sincerely,
Jack Lew
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-SEP-1998 11:39:15.00
SUBJECT:
OCT 14-CPI DISCUSSION
TO: PATRICIA RUGGLES ( PATRICIA RUGGLES @ 690-6562 @ FAX [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey A. Frankel ( CN=Jeffrey A. Frankel/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven N. Braun ( CN=Steven N. Braun/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lisa D. Branch ( CN=Lisa D. Branch/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ophelia D. West ( CN=Ophelia D. West/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: ABRAHAM K
READ: UNKNOWN
ABRAHAM K @ BLS.GOV
UNKNOWN 1
TEXT:
Katharine G. Abraham, Commissioner, Bureau of Labor Statistics, will,
discuss planned changes in the methods used to construct the CPI at a
technical briefing sponsored by the CEA on October 14, 10:30-11:30am.
briefing will be held in the Old EOB, Room 324.
The
Since early in 1971, the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) has considered
modifications made to some consumer items--principally automobiles--to
meet air pollution standards to be improvements in the quality of those
items.
Price increases resulting from such modifications over this time
period have not been reflected as increases in the Consumer Price Index
(CPI). Beginning in 1999, modifications to goods and services made solely
for purposes of meeting air pollution standards, and that do not otherwise
provide direct value to consumers, will no longer be treated as quality
improvements in the CPl.
Price increases associated with such
modifications will be reflected as increases in the index.
�ARMS Email System
---- ~
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of6
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ronald E. Jones ( CN=Ronald E. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-SEP-1998 15:46:39.00
SUBJECT:
DRAFT TREASURY LETTER FOR COMMENT BY NOON, TUESDAY, 9/29
TO: Janet E. Irwin ( CN=Janet E. Irwin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gary L. Bennethum ( CN=Gary L. Bennethum/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edwin Lau ( CN=Edwin Lau/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S. Redburn/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen J. Balis ( CN=Ellen J. Balis/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne Upshaw (CN=Wayne Upshaw/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. Timberlake/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Edward A. Brigham ( CN=Edward A. Brigham/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas W. Elmendorf ( CN=Douglas W. Elmendorf/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Ahern ( CN=Michele Ahern/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toni S. Hustead ( CN=Toni S. Hustead/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua H. Raymond { CN=Joshua H. Raymond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack { CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John S. Radzikowski { CN=John S. Radzikowski/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pamula L. Simms { CN=Pamula L. Simms/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas P. Stack { CN=Thomas P. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark A. Weatherly .{ CN=Mark A. Weatherly/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice Veenstra { CN=Alice Veenstra/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson { CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein { CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik { CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag { CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste { CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan { CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea { CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner { CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes { CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Jeffrey A. Weinberg { CN=Jeffrey A. Weinberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
Karen DORSEY { Karen DORSEY [ UNKNOWN 1 }
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
NO HARD·COPY OF THE FOLLOWING DRAFT LETTER WILL BE SENT
Total Pages:
�Page 3 of6
ARMS Email System
LRM ID: REJ607
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Monday, September 28, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Jeffrey A. Weinberg (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
SUBJECT:
of 1998
TREASURY
Ronald E. Jones
DEADLINE:
PHONE: (202) 395-3386 FAX: (202) 395-3109
Report on S1301 Consumer Bankruptcy Reform Act
Noon
Tuesday, September 29, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS:
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - L. Anthony Sutin - (202) 514-2141
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
7-AGRICULTURE - Marvin Shapiro - (202) 720-1516
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
3D-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
35-Farm Credit Administration - Eileen McMahon - (703) 883-4056
34-Export-Import Bank of the United States - David Carter - (202) 565-3203
54-HUD - Jeff Lischer - (202) 708-1793
18-Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer - (202) 395-5084
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
27-Consumer Product Safety Commission - Robert J. Wager - (301) 504-0515
32-ENERGY - Bob Rabben - (202) 586-6718
59-INTERIOR - Jane Lyder - (202) 208-4371
129-VETERANS AFFAIRS - John H. Thompson - (202) 273-6666
EOP:
Robert N. Weiner
Roger S. Ballentine
Maureen T. Shea
Rebecca M. Blank
Elena Kagan
Douglas W. Elmendorf
Maria Echaveste
Sarah Rosen
Jonathan Orszag
�Page 4 of6
ARMS Email System
Nicole R. Rabner
Joseph J. Minarik
Emil E. Parker
Jennifer L. Klein
Cynthia A. Rice
John E. Thompson
Edward A. Brigham
Alice Veenstra
Courtney B. Timberlake
Mark A. Weatherly
Wayne Upshaw
Thomas P. Stack
Ellen J. Balis
Pamula L. Simms
Francis S. Redburn
John S. Radzikowski
Edwin Lau
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Joshua H. Raymond
Gary L. Bennethum
Toni S. Hustead
Janet E. Irwin
Michele Ahern
LRM ID: REJ607 SUBJECT:
Reform Act of 1998
TREASURY
Report on S1301 Consumer Bankruptcy
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
FROM:
Ronald E. Jones Phone:
395-3386
Fax:
395-3109
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of6
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
DRAFT TREASURY LETTER TO BANKRUPTCY CONFEREES ON BUSINESS BANKRUPTCY
PROVISIONS
Dear
I am writing to share the AdministrationO,s views on certain
business bankruptcy provisions in S. 1301, the bankruptcy reform bill
before the conference committee, and related provisions in H.R. 4393, the
D&Financial Contract Netting Improvement Act of 1998.08
The Administration supports the financial contract netting
provisions in S. 1301. These provisions are based on a proposal from the
PresidentO,s Working Group on Financial Markets, which was the result of
an intensive, multi-year interagency effort to improve the regime
governing the recognition of netting of certain financial contracts in
insolvency situations. As I noted when we transmitted our recommendations
to Congress, the proposed legislation would reduce systemic risk in our
financial markets, reducing the risk that a failure of a single firm would
cause significant disruption and danger to our financial markets.
In
particular, this proposal will help to reduce systemic risk arising out of
activities in the derivatives market.
The Administration also encourages the conferees to include
similar provisions amending the bank insolvency laws, which are contained
in H.R. 4393 as approved by the House Banking Committee. One of the goals
of the working Group effort was to harmonize, where appropriate,
provisions under the Bankruptcy Code and the bank insolvency laws.
The
bank insolvency provisions in H.R. 4393 would accomplish that
harmonization and would also clarify the power of the Federal Deposit
Insurance Corporation to transfer qualified financial contracts to another
financial institution. This clarification will help ensure that the
resolution of a failed depository institution can be accomplished at the
lowest possible cost to the deposit insurance funds administered by the
FDIC.
We look forward to working with the conferees to enact these
desirable reforms, in conjunction with moderate and balanced consumer
bankruptcy reform legislation.
Sincerely,
�ARMS Email System
Page 6 of6
Robert E. Rubin
�0_
.ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-SEP-1998 18:23:26.00
SUBJECT:
DRAFT SENATE TAX SAP (HR 4579)
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Peterson ( CN=Michelle Peterson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dario J. Gomez ( CN=Dario J. Gomez/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Gore ( CN=Elizabeth Gore/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles M. Brain ( CN=Charles M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Zweig ( CN=Lisa Zweig!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Konigsberg ( CN=Charles Konigsberg!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This week, the Senate
Taxpayer Relief Act.
9/25/98 into a Senate
your review).
Please
(Thurs.).
Thank you.
is expected to begin consideration of H.R. 4579 We turned the House floor SAP that was released on
SAP. The only change is in the 2nd par (in bold for
providecomments!clearance by 11am tomorrow
september 30, 1998
(Senate)
H.R. 4579 - Taxpayer Relief Act of 1998
(Archer (R) Texas)
The Administration strongly opposes H.R. 4579.
If the bill were presented
to the President, either as a stand-alone bill or combined with other
legislation, he would veto it. By draining billions out of projected
budget surpluses, this bill violates the PresidentD,s unwavering
commitment to save Social Security first.
None of the surpluses should be
touched until the long-term solvency of Social Security has been fully
secured. We must not squander this unique opportunity to save Social
Security.
Last February in the FY 1999 Budget, the President proposed tax cuts
targeted to help American families -- and proposed offsets to fully pay
for the tax cuts. The Administration urges the Congress to consider tax
cuts only if we can do so in a manner that -- like the Democratic
substitute -- adheres to the budget rules, maintains fiscal discipline,
and meets the President's commitment to reserve the entire surplus until
we have strengthened Social Security.
H.R. 4579 would cut taxes by $85 billion over five years and $176 billion
over 10 years. Virtually none of the billD,s costs have been paid for.
This blatantly violates the pay-as-you-go fiscal discipline of the Budget
Enforcement Act -- discipline which has been an essential component of our
remarkable economic revival.
The bill's exemption from the Budget Enforcement Act evades this fiscal
discipline. The Administration strongly opposes this exemption from the
fundamental budget laws.
* * * * * * * *
�'" __ t.f-MS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page I of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 1-0CT-199B 07:54:37.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba (.CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�....
,
Page 2 of2
,AJ,ThfS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Yes!! There will be a Women's Mtg this morning at 9:00am in room 100.
Sorry for the late notice, Ann and I were out yesterday!
�(...
ARMS Erriail System
Page 1 of 2
• .- li1
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: ·S-OCT-199S 07:02:51.00
SUBJECT:
WOMEN'S MTG
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [. WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
- I'
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP' @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman!OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg TODAY at 9am in Room lOO!!
�'.
Page 1 of5
.ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 8-0CT-1998 15:50:48.00
SUBJECT:
URGENT: DRAFT SAP FOR HR 10
TO: RUDMAN_M@Al@CD@VAXGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
RUDMAN M@Al@CD@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dario J. Gomez ( CN=Dario J. Gomez/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Zweig ( CN=Lisa Zweig/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Konigsberg ( CN=Charles Konigsberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Theodore Wartell ( CN=Theodore Wartell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: FARRAR- J@Al@CD@VAXGTWY
.
FARRAR J@Al@CD@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
�..
ARMS Email System
,.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles E. Kieffer ( CN=Charles E. Kieffer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheree D. Peterson ( CN=Cheree D. Peterson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ :.UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles M. Brain ( CN=Charles M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Gore ( CN=Elizabeth Gore/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
It is possible that HR 10 - Financial Services Act will be on the Senate
floor anytime now.
Please review the SAP and provide comments/clearance
by cob today.
This SAP should be shared with all of the principals.
The
position: if the bill is presented to the President in its current form,
he would veto it. Thank you.
October 8, 1998
(Senate)
H.R. 10 - Financial Services Act of 1998
Page 2 of5
�A~S
Page 3 of5
Email System
(Leach (R)
Iowa and.3 cosponsors)
The Administration strongly opposes H.R. 10, and if the bill were
presented to the President in the form reported by the Senate Committee on
Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs, he would veto it.
As reported by the Senate Banking committee, H.R. 10 would harm the safety
and soundness of the national banking system and would reduce the role of
this Administration, and any future Administration, in banking policy -an important area of economic policy-making.
In addition, the bill in its
current form would have an adverse impact on the Community Reinvestment
Act (CRA) and raises a number of other significant policy issues.
H.R. 10 would deny banking organizations the choice of how to structure
their business by dictating that all new principal financial activities
for example, securities underwriting and merchant banking -- be conducted
exclusively in affiliates of banks rather than subsidiaries of banks.
In addition, H.R. 10 grants the Federal Reserve exclusive regulatory
authority over a new type of financial institution, the wholesale
financial institution (WFI).
The bill also grants the Federal Reserve
unprecedented authority to contravene the judgements of other banking
regulators about the banks they regulate.
The current and past three
chairs of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation have each objected to
this dictate on the grounds that the subsidiary structure better protects
the safety and soundness of Federally insured banks and better shields the
deposit insurance funds, and ultimately the taxpayer, from loss.
The bill would also have an adverse impact on the CRA, which has helped
spur billions of dollars of loans to communities across the United
States.
First, the transfer of new financial activities out of bank
subsidiaries will take those activities out of consideration under CRA,
'effectively reducing funds available to meet the needs of local
communities. Second, the newly created WFIs will be exempt from CRA
unless the institution chooses to have a federally insured affiliate.
Given that some of the Nation's largest banks may become WFIs, their
assets would be lost for CRA purposes.
The Administration urges the Senate not to move forward on this
controversial, exceedingly complex, and harmful legislation.
pay-As-YOu-Go-Scoring
H.R. 10 would decrease direct spending and decrease receipts; therefore it
is subject to the pay-as-you-go requirements of the Omnibus Budget
Reconciliation Act of 1990. OMB's preliminary scoring of the bill is that
it would result in a net budget savings of $333 million over FYs
1999-2003.
Fiscal Years
(In millions of dollars)
1999
2001
2002
Changes in Outlays
-70
-70
Changes in Receipts
-4
-4
2000
2003
-70
-70
-1
-4
-70
-4
�A.RMS Email System
* * * * * * *
(DO Not Distribute Outside Executive Office of the President)
This Statement of Administration Policy was developed by the Legislative
Reference Division (Englund), in consultation with the Departments of
Agriculture (Allen) and the Treasury (Dorsey), the US Trade Representative
(Papovich), Farm Credit Administration (McMahon), Office of Personnel
Management (Wolf), Small Business Administration (Cupp) and HTF
(Enger/Veenstra) .
OMB/LA clearance:
The Departments of Commerce, Housing and Urban Development, Labor,
Justice, and State did not respond to our request for views on this SAP.
On May 13, 1998, H.R. 10 passed the House with an amendment in the nature
of a substitute by a vote of 214 - 213.
On September 18, 1998, the Senate Banking Committee reported H.R. 10 with
an amendment in the nature of a substitute.
Administration position to Date
On August 7, 1998, the Chief of Staff sent a letter to the Chairman of the
Senate Banking Committee stating that the President will veto H.R. 10 if
it includes provisions that would "stifle innovation and efficiency in the
national banking system and impose needless costs on small banks."
In
addition, the letter opposed H.R. 10 because it would deprive national
banks of power and erode Executive Branch policy-making ability.
On June 17, 1998, the Department of the Treasury testified before the
Senate Banking Committee in opposition to the House-passed version of H.R.
10.
On May 7, 1998, the Treasury sent a letter to the House Leadership and
relevant Committee members restating that the Secretary would recommend
that the President veto the Republican Leadership's version of H.R. 10 and
included a copy of the House SAP.
The House SAP on H.R. 10, issued on March 31, 1998, stated that the
Administration opposed H.R. 10 because it would:
(1) stifle innovation
and efficiency in the national banking system; (2) undermine the Community
Reinvestment Act by forcing financial innovation to occur in holding
company affiliates rather than in bank subsidiaries; (3) diminish the
ability of communities and consumers to benefit from the financial system;
(4) eliminate advantageous features of the current thrift charter; and (5)
impose needless costs on small banks. The SAP also stated that if H.R. 10
were presented to the President in the form of the Republican Leadership
substitute, the Secretary of the Treasury would recommend that it be
vetoed.
Provisions of H.R. 10
Time did not permit a summary of the manager's amendment to H.R. 10.
The Small Business Administration advises that H.R. 4179, the Program for
Investments in Microentrepreneurs Act of 1998 (PRIME Act), will be added
to H.R. 10 as part of the manager's amendment. This bill would authorize
Page 4 of5
�ARMS Email System
qualified organizations to provide technical assistance and capacity
building services to microenterprise development organizations and
programs and to disadvantaged entrepreneurs using funds from the Community
Development Financial Institutions Fund.
Pay-As-You-Go Scoring
According to HTF (Enger) and BASD (Lee), H.R. 10 is subject to the
pay-as-you-go (PAYGO) provisions of the Omnibus Reconciliation Act of
1990. H.R. 10 would decrease direct spending and decrease receipts and
result in a net budget savings of $333 million over FYs 1999-2003. CBO
scores the bill as resulting in a net budget savings of $337 million over
FYs 1999-2003.
Legislative Reference Division
October 8, 1998
Page 5 of5
�ARMS Email System
-
Page 1 of3
L,
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP·[ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: B-OCT-199B 17:16:16.00
. SUBJECT:
URGENT: CONFEREES LETTER ON HR 3150
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiqer/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Zweig ( CN=Lisa Zweig/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Konigsberg ( CN=Charles Konigsberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Peterson ( CN=Michelle Peterson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Theodore Wartell ( CN=Theodore Wartell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles E. Kieffer ( CN=Charles E. Kieffer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Gore ( CN=Elizabeth Gore/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pa~l J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E.Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
NEC has asked that we clear the letter below on HR 3150 - Bankruptcy
Reform Act of 1998 in order to be release early this evening.
House Rules
& Floor action is expected shortly. position: senior Advisers would
recommend veto.
Please provide comments/clearance as soon as possible.
Thanks.
The Honorable Orrin G. Hatch
Chairman
Committee on the Judiciary
united States Senate
washington, D.C. 20510
Dear Mr. Chairman:
I write to provide the AdministratiqnD,s views on the conference
report to H.R. 3150, the Bankruptcy Reform Act of 1998.
The Senate worked on a bipartisan basis to produce a balanced bill
that. would have reduced abuses of the bankruptcy system and required
debtors and creditors alike to act responsibly. Unfortunately, H.R. 3150,
as agreed to by the Conference Committee, contains many flawed aspects of
the House bill, and if this version of the bill is presented to the
President, his senior advisors will recommend that he veto it.
On the central issue of means-testing, the Conference Report uses
the Senate framework but would, like the House bill, impose a rigid rule
that denies bankruptcy judges adequate discretion to decide whether the
debtor has the capacity to repay successfully a portion of debts under
Chapter 13. The bill would require a moderate income debtor to
demonstrate that each monthly expense for housing, clothing,
transportation, and food that exceeds a predetermined level is necessary
due to D&extraordinary circumstancesD8 before that person could get their
debts discharged under Chapter 7.
At the same time H.R. 3150 produces a rigid system to ensure
moderate-income debtors repay their debts, it does not impose meaningful
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of3
limits on the homestead exemption -- the mechanism used by the wealthy to
shield hundreds of thousands of dollars of wealth from their creditors.
The Senate bill took laudable steps to enhance consumer
protections from coercive and predatory behavior by creditors.
This
version of H.R. 3150, however, fails to limit adequately abusive creditor
practices such as coercive affirmations and violations of the automatic
stay, and rolls back consumer protections. The bill would also deny
consumers the most effective remedy for harm from such practices -- class
action liability -- and eliminate the current authorization for punitive
damages against creditors for intentional violations of borrower rights.
Finally, the bill does not include the provisions of the Senate
bill that would discharge debts that could compete with child support and
alimony payments after a debtor has been declared bankrupt.
In addition,
the bill would make nondischargeable any debt that was incurred within 90
days of bankruptcy to pay nondischargeable debt and any debt resulting
from certain cash advances.
This, in effect, puts some debt owed to
credit card companies in competition with social priorities like child
support and alimony, taxes, and educational loans. All too often
pressures from an aggressive creditor trying to collect a nondischargeable
debt can keep a struggling debtor from making child support and alimony
payments.
The overwhelming vote on the Senate
legislation that body produced demonstrates
responsible bankruptcy reform is possible.
developed by the Conference Committee, does
floor for the balanced
that reasonable and
Unfortunately, H.R. 3150 as
not provide such reform.
Sincerely,
Jacob J. Lew
Director
Identical Letter Sent to The Honorable Orrin G. Hatch,
The Honorable Charles E. Grassley, The Honorable Jeff Sessions,
The Honorable Patrick J. Leahy, The Honorable Richard J. Durbin,
The Honorable Henry Hyde, The Honorable John Conyers,
The Honorable George W. Gekas, and The Honorable Jerrold Nadler
�f.RMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:14-0CT-1998 17:58:17.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of2
_ t-RMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 }
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[09/23/1998 – 10/14/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 099 - Folder 007
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/0f49ebc6c71526b76af4bcef9a4ec3d8.pdf
397d65fc7d60e6278d4648591a31ad5c
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 099 - FOLDER -006
[09/09/1998-09/18/1998]
�.. _. A~S Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP
WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-SEP-1998 15:44:47.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@'
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia ApuzzO/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. GreenejOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�, ~S Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ tEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:00am in room 100. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of5
I,
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-SEP-1998 16:46:22.00
SUBJECT:
LABOR Report on Amendment to Increase the Minimum wage
TO: John E. Thompson
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@¥OP [ OMB 1 )
TO: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven N. Braun ( CN=Steven N. Braun/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Gore ( CN=Elizabeth Gore/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan
READ: UNKNOWN
Orszag/OU=OPD/O~EOP@EOP
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald E. Jones ( CN=Ronald E. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Justine F. Rodriguez ( CN=Justine F. Rodriguez/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian S. Mason ( CN=Brian S. Mason/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 2 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: MNB225
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Wednesday, September 9, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
SUBJECT:
JanetR. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202)395-7887 FAX: (202)395-6148
LABOR Report on Amendment to Increase the Minimum Wage
DEADLINE:
11 a.m.
Thursday, September 10, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: The subject amendment may be offered by Senator Kennedy to the
consumer bankruptcy reform bill (S. 1301) being considered by the Senate.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin 118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
61-JUSTICE - L. Anthony Sutin - (202) 514-2141
EOP:
Barbara Chow
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Sarah Rosen"
Jonathan Orszag
Elena Kagan
Tracey E. Thornton
Brian S. Mason
Elizabeth Gore
Justine F. Rodriguez
Joseph J. Minarik
Karen Tramontano
Steven N. Braun
Janet R. Forsgren
James J. Jukes
Ronald E. Jones
(202) 205-6700
�ARMS Email System
John E. Thompson
LRM ID: MNB225 SUBJECT:
Minimum Wage
Page 3 of5
LABOR
Report on Amendment to Increase the
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this. request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will ibe
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
FROM:
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
______ No Objection
______ No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
Honorable James Jeffords
Edward Kennedy
Chairman
Ranking Member
Committee on Labor and Human Resources
Resources
United States Senate
United States Senate
Honorable
Committee on Labor and Human
�ARMS Email System
Washington, D.C. 20510
D.C. 20510
Page 4 of5
Washington,
Dear Chairman Jeffords/Senator Kennedy:
I am writing in strong support of [Senator KennedyD,s/your] amendment to
legislation under consideration in the Senate that would increase the
minimum wage to $6.15 an hour by January 1, 2000. Earlier this year,
president Clinton strongly endorsed raising the minimum wage to "help
ensure that we pay people a decent wage and that parents who work hard and
play by the rules can lift their children and themselves out of poverty.
ItO,s right for America and right for AmericaD,s workers."
When we last raised the minimum wage and expanded the earned-income tax
credit, we took important steps to reward work and help millions of
Americans raise their families with dignity.
The real value of the
minimum wage had fallen to nearly a 40-year low by the time President
Clinton signed the last increase in 1996. But even after that increase,
the minimum wageD,s purchasing power remains well below its historic value
in the 1960's and 1970's.
It does not provide enough to lift a family of
[three or two ?] out of poverty. The time has come to give our lowest
paid working families this raise.
Many of us are benefitting from the strongest economy in a generation, and
we can well afford to share our prosperity through another increase in the
minimum wage.
Inflation and unemployment are low and steady, and family
incomes have begun to grow with corporate profits. But millions of people.
are still struggling to make ends meet -- the people who clean our
offices, sew our clothes, serve our food, and care for our children and
our infirm parents. [The Kennedy/your] amendment offers 12 million
Americans a greater opportunity to share in our nationD,s prosperity.
Seventy percent of all workers who would benefit are adults, age 20 or
over, and about three out of five are women, many of whom are the sole
breadwinners for their families.
As people move from welfare to work, one of the most important lessons
they can learn is that work pays. A full-time worker earning the current
minimum wage for 50 weeks of work receives only $10,300.
This is not
enough to move families from dependency to self-sufficiency and create a
long-term attachment to the workforce. Without this minimum wage increase,
too many of these hard-working families will continue to fall below the
poverty line. The minimum wage should be the first rung on the ladder of
opportunity, not a dead end for the working poor.
A one-dollar increase in the minimum wage would make an enormous
difference in the lives of these workers and their families.
It would
mean an additional $2,000 a year for someone working year-round, full-time
-- enough to buy an average family of four 6.5 months of groceries, or pay
for almost 7.5 months rent, or three-quarters of the tuition and fees at a
two-year college.
Opponents of a minimum wage increase argued two years ago, and seemingly
in every previous debate over increasing the minimum wage, that it would
cause inflation and job loss. But since President Clinton signed the last
minimum wage increase into law in August 1996, the economy has created
more than 6 million new jobs, and the inflation rate has been cut nearly
in half.
The unemployment rate is at 4.5% and has been below 5% for more
than 14 consecutive months. Unemployment rates this low have not been seen
for almost three decades.
For teenagers, African Americans, and women,
unemployment is trending down and employment rates are trending up. In
�ARMS Email System
Page50fS
fact, almost 330,000 more teenagers are employed than in October 1996, and
employment is up by nearly 90,000 for African-American teens.
[I urge.you to support Senator KennedyD,s
your amendment.]
Our bipartisan efforts
job training system and expand the Earned
significantly advanced our common goal of
at a fair wage. Working together, we can
minimum wage workers.
amendment/1 strongly support
to overhaul the education and
Income Tax Credit have
assuring every worker a good job
make work pay for AmericaD,s
The Office of Management and Budget advises that there is no objection to
presentation of this report from the standpoint of the AdministrationD,s
program.
Sincerely,
Alexis M. Herman
�- .
ARMS Email System
to'
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. FernandesjOU=OPDjO=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:11-SEP-1998 20:01:22.00
SUBJECT:
H2A Deputy's Meeting -- MONDAY AT 2PM
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally KatzenjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. SteinjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet MurguiajOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. BlankjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara ChowjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon MoorejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. JacobyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. WeinerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. BeierjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. MathewsjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. GibsonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. ObermillerjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura EmmettjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra YaminjOU=OMBjO=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP' [ OMB 1 )
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. MyersjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon MasonjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Adrienne C. Erbach ( CN=Adrienne C. ErbachjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�A.,RMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Deputy's meeting on Monday, September 14th at 2:00pm in
Room 211 reo reform to the H2A agricultural guestworker program.
I hope
to see you there.
Outside Participants
Richard Rominger -- USDA
Kitty Higgins -- DOL
James Castello -- DOJ
Robert Bach -- INS
Page 2 of2
�Page 1 of4.
· ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:14-SEP-1998 11:19:58.00
SUBJECT:
Heads-up Memo
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. Mendelson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of4
The attached memo was signed on Friday, September 4th.
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D90]MAIL452175652.226 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504370040000010A020100000002050000002D110000000200003C27A0877E4CFBE5D86ACO
EEEBEFCAF5BC5284724EBF5D04FOA15F6D71F2D3543C7AC059E1EF53045DB42E55FDB72543933E
86416EC4B3CBA27E17F99732B72175DD6015CFC3DOC90A566A7A72FA73ED8B3BB0758304D98DBC
42834A540262C70F97CB86763572C6831B014AOC695DF7E4A9AA731OF22E18CB02032C2761AFB1
11EB31680516700FCE7BOC5E18CC16D42D309C7EBAE224B600F73218D5BDB82F9BF63F06D9EA8F
EBED54DAFF40191A84BBACA49607F93AAC72A9B997DC22CD6390D78930D95486B27E307A6D1E67
3 F5 81C3 6BCCOB1 OCB9 7D19 5 0 3 7DC2 84D1CF96 3 54 8B2 8A3 6A3 8 3D4DFF9AB.6 9FFOAAAA3 F9 3D7 7FC6
89E5AOEEF7B4A23944BOF5A7419E150388DC912157E3EB367477747370FE6158EED874D046D7C4
E9369F0736CE35426CFB9D1213A3D10991FBDE7EAF01AD48B26549795F79BC5A1D4723BE1B9F45
DF601C135E9DC643B895A994CB175E6032A3994138D3479BAOF75F9956CB90D5C633B66E60BEA4
7962A541091AE058FC8E1B016B792B730D6F956B1E654E374654E7881CAD83AFOCC4E66B63B7ED
7AD75B012B729CBE5F2953BDF9B3AFA5CA4B0198A237EEC8C99730D5E3BAD5CB5119F181COB323
C01821CA56BF942DAA316EEB08F8E1F3BAC7871BF492346D92FCD18B73AED77AF5ED6142744EEO
90078C332302000900000000000000000000000823010000000B0100007E020000005501000000
4E0000008903000009250100000006000000D70300000B300200000028000000DD030000087701
000000400000000504000008340100000014000000450400000802010000000F00000059040000
080501000000080000006804000000985C005C004F004D0042002D00500053002D00320038002D
00320039005C003300350030004200000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800C800FOOOFOOOFOOOFOOOC800
C80030000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000B0100002800C8196810480D000011090000005AOOOB010000103600540069006D0065
00730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E00200052006500670075006C0061007200
000000000000000001000200580201000000040028000000000000000000000000000000000000
00011202002400A1000000A10000000A0000003F01010002004001190065814101020072824201
020055004301010044004401020002004501010055004601010045004701010002004801030055
004C86A8240000000000000000000000000000000008337C007800000200004801000003010004
0002000000DDOA10008301040003000200211000DDDDOBOB00030000040BOODDF1024801F1CCCC
F1034801F1F1004801F1F1024001F19BF1034001F1F1014801F1F1004001F19B9CF1014001F1F1
024201F1CCF1034201F1F1004801F19BF1014801F1F1024201F1CCF1034201F19BCCCCCC4D454D
4F52414E44554DF1004001F19BF1014001F180464F52804552534B494E4580424F574C4553CCCC
5448524F5547483AE0110C0000000060090COOEOE0110COOOOOOOOB80BOCOOE0808080804A6163
6B804C6577D0041500000B00090001200D7008090001201500DOCC46524F4D3AE0110COOOOOOOO
60090COOEOE0110COOOOOOOOB80BOCOOE080808080446F6E616C6480522E8041726275636B6C65
D0041500000B00090001000F500AOB0001201500DOCC5355424A4543543AE0110C000000006009
OCOOEOE0110COOOOOOOOB80BOCOOE0808080804865616473807570806F6E804848538050726F70
6F7365648052756C65806F6E804D65646963616964804D616E616765648043617265E0110COOOO
OOOOD0200COOEOD0041500000B00090001E010300COD0001201500DOE0110C0000000008070COO
EOCCCCE0110C0000000008070COOE048485380697380707265706172696E6780746F807375626D
697480618070726F706F7365648072756C65807768696368807375627374616E7469616C6C7980
616C7465727380746865804D65646963616964CF6D616E6167656480636172658070726F677261
6D2C80696D706C656D656E74696E67806B65798070726F766973696F6E7380696E807468658042
616C616E6365648042756467657480416374802842424129806F66CF313939372E808080546865
8072756C658073747265616D6C696E6573807468658061646D696E697374726174696F6E806F66
807468658070726F6772616D80666F72805374617465732C80616464738070617469656E748070
726F74656374696F6E73CF616E6480637265617465738061806E756D626572806F66806E657780
7175616C6974798472656C6174656480726571756972656D656E7473806F6E806D616E61676564
8063617265806F7267616E697A6174696F6E73CF284D434F73292E8080805468658072756C6580
697380636F6D706C69636174656480626563617573658069748077617380646576656C6F706564
80776F726B696E6780776974688074687265652C806F6674656E80646966666572696E67CF636F
�MEMORANDUM FOR ERSKINE BOWLES
THROUGH:
Jack Lew
FROM:
Donald R. Arbuckle
SUBJECT:
Heads up on HHS Proposed Rule on Medicaid Managed Care
HHS is preparing to submit a proposed rule which substantially alters the Medicaid
managed care program, implementing key provisions in the Balanced Budget Act (BBA) of
1997. The rule streamlines the administration of the program for States, adds patient
protections and creates a number of new quality-related requirements on managed care
organizations (MCOs). The rule is complicated because it was developed working with three,
often differing constituencies: beneficiaries (advocates), States and MCOs. Chris Jennings
(DPC) is organizing an event on the 17th around the rule. HHS is hoping to submit the rule to
OMB
early next week but is struggling to gain closure on a number of issues.
Relying on both the BBA and the Patient Bill of Rights, the rule establishes new
beneficiary protections in areas such as quality assurance, grievance rights and coverage of
emergency services. The rule eliminates the waiver process, leaving States free to mandate
enrollment of beneficiaries into managed care (with the exception of vulnerable populations,
such as the disabled) and other impediments to managed care such as the enrollment composition
requirement. As required by law, the rule also creates a quality assessment and perfonnance
improvement program to monitor and evaluate the quality ofMCO service provided.
Although HHS has done fairly extensive outreach to affected constituencies, it is unclear
how patient advocates, States, and the managed care industry will react. Patient advocates will
be pleased with the adoption of the patient and consumer rights provisions. States, although
happy to avoid waivers, have expressed concern over the remaining conditions and limitations on
them. The MCOs may find the quality assessment provisions somewhat burdensome, but have
indicated that they are pleased that these provisions are consistent with the Medicare Plus Choice
regulations promUlgated earlier this year.
�cc:
Maria Echaveste
Rahm Emanuel
Larry Stein
Ron Klain
.
Thurgood Marshall, Jr.
Ann Lewis
Sally Katzen
Minyon Moore
John Podesta
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Elena Kagan
Barry Toiv
Michael Waldman
Janet Yellen
Mickey Ibarra
Danny Mendelson
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
�3\RMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of9
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION
SUBJECT:
DATE/TI~E:14-SEP-1998
11:24:02.00
Background for H-2A Meeting
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
•
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Anthony J. Gibson ( CN=Anthony J. Gibson/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of9
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Adrienne C. Erbach ( CN=Adrienne C. Erbach/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Attached is background for today's Deputies meeting on the H-2A
agricultural guestworkers program at 2pm in Room 211.
-- Ceci
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ==================~=
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D9]MAIL49347565X.226 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504345080000010A02010000000205000000223D00000002000022DE7796DB6D59D859A94D
86CFFAE9FFD0947B911CA90A84A98C07D816737EE15BB61CEEEC51538A5DFOE22FD0415CC2A199
IlB77981BA272CA428D99A40BA4F92E7DD19B788EA33F9EFD6D303ED6062DEF1E5COCD293868EO
95A5CEDFBOF0996237D3E8323810FAOCCB644B2EB52954D5E2E5B94AD7EF4EF8364E62A4107080
003B880E9D326238D6B79DCBA7F347AD35A9611AFAF5FA2CFEFEC9FOB7EB56EE9006522AB77C45
65AF964F2A0560E9C9F8DDB8D1C98069F7754C8F257AOCAOEC8EBA14549CFA465757BAC07BF516
BB2BF26218500179E99C3C6579BA44CE4COEA6F03D1B9747D1215F7B2A99B760B28888A60E31B2
DBE9B2B0444DD316FCBAE86E4D86E38FBD9B51ADDBCEE16DD58278F405D042DD85E34C2D17703C
EE5511275BACD425B7960E6D24C256FBF043F1C8972531F26541AB41150592C13FDE863B51933E
FCF3DF2A16EFD279BABD235C6386F099577FB8548686498BOF256DD5012E1C68A980BC3EC411AE
94A28B8684CC19C8AD5270D32F8E4C9743D49368CA62DD5B0270FF403A1F9598327FCD9DOFA466
OD2B69C6529EB44DAE802F2266C6B4BE1FB7A227046813D5563C05B69E0294649E6B1DA31AD3F9
OC3131DBDE9E6FA9CAFD8521DB575341ED5750E262EF81CF4CD7EBAF19E45DB93E4C59D3A580A5
192AOD214002002B00000000000000000000000823010000000B0100005A040000005501000200
4E0000006505000009250100000006000000B30500000B300300000028000000B9050000087701
00000040000000E105000008340100000014000000210600000802010000000F00000035060000
000000000000000000003506000000650100000001000000440600000000000000000000000044
0600000B30010000006C000000450600000B300100000044000000B10600000000000000000000
0000B1060000081103000000C6000000F50600000B300100000065000000BB0700000805010000
000800000020080000000000000000000000002008000000000000000000000000200800000000
000000000000000020080000000000000000000000002008000000000000000000000000200800
000000000000000000000020080000000000000000000000002008000000000000000000000000
200800000000000000000000000020080000000000000000000000002008000000000000000000
000000200800000000000000000000000020080000000000000000000000002008000000000000
000000000000200800000000000000000000000020080000000000000000000000002008000000
000000000000000000200800000000000000000000000020080000000000000000000000002008
000000000000000000000000200800000000000000000000000020080000000000000000000000
002008000000000000000000000000200800000000000000000000000020080000000000000000
00000000200800000942010000001D0000002808000000984C006F00630061006C002000500072
0069006E0074006500720000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800C8002C01
2C012C012C01C800C8003000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000B0100002800C8196810480D00001l090000005AOOOB0100001036
00540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052006F006DOO61006E002000520065006700
75006C006100720000000000000000000100020058020100000004002800000000000000000000
000000000000000000011202002400A1000000A10000000AOOOOOO410E01000B00420E01000BOO
430E02004500440E02004400450EOI005500460E01005500470EOI004400480EOI004400490E01
0055004AOE08006581369CC72200000000D400F41FOOOOOOOOF333000008337C00780000020000
4AOE00000300010000000400280000001C0000002800000000000000000000000133FCDD2400A4
�"
[IHI:'>
1~ MO\)j:I'1'~
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
March 3, 2010
H-2A Discussion Document
The purpose oftoday's meeting is to detennine general Administration guidelines for H-2A
refonn.
Background
Agricultural "guestworkers" are admitted on H-2A visas for temporary jobs. Under the
current program, in order hire H-2A workers, an employer must demonstrate to the DOL that (a)
there are not sufficient U.S. workers able, willing, qualified and available to perfonn the
services; and (b) there will be no adverse effect on the wages and working conditions of
similarly-employed U.S. workers. Employers also are required to pay workers an "adverse
effect wage rate" (AEWR), detennined by the average wage paid to non-managerial agricultural
workers in the state; provide free housing to workers outside the commuting area; reimburse
workers' inbound transportation if they complete half the contract, outbound also if they
complete the contract; guarantee 3/4 of the hours of the contract; and hire any qualified U.S.
worker who applies during the first half of the work contract. There is no cap on the number of
H-2A visas granted. Out of the 1.6 million farmworkers in the United States, approximately
600,000 are unauthorized to work, and approximately 20,000 are in the H-2A program.
In June 1995, in response to efforts in Congress to pass legislation that would create a
new guestworker program (without the worker protections present in the existing program) and
agreeing with the recommendation of the Commission on Immigration Refonn, the President
stated his opposition to a "new guestworker program." However, he also stated that if the
crackdown on illegal immigration contributes to labor shortages, he would direct the
Departments of Labor and Agriculture to work cooperatively to improVe and enhance the existing
H-2A program.
Grower advocates argue that they continue to experience difficulties in finding domestic
farmworkers and that the H-2A program is slow, cumbersome, and expensive. However, a
recent (December 1997) GAO study ,concluded that agribusiness does not now and will not soon
face an agricultural labor shortage. The GAO's finding ofa labor surplus echoes the
conclusions ofthe U.S. Commission on Agricultural Workers (1992), and the U.S. Commission
on Immigration Refonn reports (1995 and 1997). While the GAO report suggested that there
could develop localized labor shortages, it noted the widespread belief that employers should
respond to the market place by increasing wages, improving recruitment and modernizing their
labor practices. Further, the GAO report cited a study which concluded that substantial wage
increases would have little effect on consumer produce prices or international competitiveness.
Many growers blame the INS's recent crackdown on undocumented fannworkers for the
shortages of domestic farmworkers and their need to rely on a dysfunctional H-2A program.
On March 12th of this year, the House Judiciary Subcommittee on Immigration approved
legislation, sponsored by Rep. Robert Smith (R-OR), that provide,s for a new pilot guestworker
program that erodes existing worker protections. In a letter to Chainnan Lamar Smith, Secretary
�"
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Hennan stated that if this legislation were presented to the President, she would recommend a
veto. This bill was voted out ofthe subcommittee on a voice vote, but has not been taken to the
full House Judiciary Committee.
Soon after this bill was introduced, we initiated a process with the Departments of Labor
and Agriculture to detennine what kinds of regulatory and/or administrative refonns we could
put into place before the next growing season. We developed a set of regulatory refonns that
respond to the growers' concern that the program needs to be streamlined (i.e., improved
processes; reduced paperwork and delay). The Department of Labor and the Justice Department
(which handles the immigration aspects of the program) have developed a package of proposed
rulemaking changes that we hope will go in effect by the end of January. However, though
some grower advocates were pleased with the set of administrative refonns, they continue to
press for a legislative package that would fundamentally alter the way the program is operated.
On July 22, 1998, Senators Ron Wyden, Bob Graham and Gordon Smith (R-OR)
introduced an amendment to the CJS appropriations bill that would make significant changes to
the current H-2A program. On that same day, the Secretary of Labor sent a letter to Senator
Wyden stating her strong opposition to his amendment which creates a new guestworker program
that erodes labor protections for migrant fannworkers. The overall concern with the
Wyden-Graham bill is that it shifts costs and risks from employers to workers and/or the
government.
Issues Regarding H-2A Reform
Issue #1
Use of the Adverse Effect Wage Rate
Whether we would consider eliminating the adverse effect wage rate and replacing it with an
enhanced prevailing wage rate.
Current Law:
Under the current program, growers who employ H-2A workers are required to pay their workers
the higher of the prevailing wage (detennined by the average wage for the crop in the local area),
the federal, state or local minimum wage or an "adverse effect wage rate" (AEWR) (equal to the
average statewide agricultural wage rate). Because foreign workers can sometimes dominate a
local labor market, this wage depression is often reflected in the local prevailing wage. The
AEWR partially corrects for this depressive effect by measuring farmworker wages on a
statewide basis -- thus dissipating the impact of foreign workers on the wage.
Wyden-Graham Bill:
Under the Wyden-Graham bill, the worker is required to be paid either the prevailing wage or the
AEWR (capped at 105% of the prevailing wage).
�"
Automated Records Management SystelTl
Hex-Dump Conversion
Issue #2
Employer Recruitment -- Use of Proposed Registry
Whether we support the creation of a registry system for matching growers to farmworkers that
totally replaces an employer's obligation to conduct positive recruitment.
Current Law:
Under current law, if the grower is seeking to employ H-2A workers, he must affirmatively
recruit in the private marketplace (know as "positive recruitment") and use the federal-state Job
Service to circulate job offers to areas where migrant workers may be located. Thus, the
responsibility for farmworker recruitment is shared between the prospective employer and the
U.S. Employment Service.
Wyden-Graham Bill:
Under the Wyden-Graham bill, growers seeking to employ H-2A workers would have no
obligation to attempt to recruit legal U.S. farmworkers except through a newly-created "job
registry." Thus, all responsibility for the recruitment of domestic farmworkers would shift to a
new, untried, process for which the government and low-wage workers are entirely responsible.
This registry would take years to create, but H-2A workers could be hired within 6 months ofthe
enactment of the bill. Further, because growers would no longer have an obligation to recruit
domestically, they would be free to concentrate their worker recruitment efforts abroad.
Issue #3
Housing
Whether H-2A employers should continue to have an obligation to provide housing to their
workers. Also, whether this obligation is met by the issuance of housing vouchers.
Current Law:
Current law requires growers who employ H-2A workers to provide them with free housing.
Wyden-Graham Bill:
The Wyden-Graham bill allows growers to provide a payment voucher (equal to 114 of the Fair
Market Rate in the applicable county for a two bedroom apartment) in lieu of housing, unless the
State certifies that adequate housing is not available in the area. Under this approach, the
grower employing H-2A workers would have no obligation to assure that housing is actually
available and could be obtained with the voucher.
Issue #4
The 3/4 Guarantee
Whether we support the continued use of the 3/4 guarantee.
Current Law:
�"
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
.
Under current law, workers must be paid for at least 75% of the work contract period for which
they were recruited, except when there is an "act of God." This "three-fourths guarantee" gives
migrant workers some indication of their potential earnings and discourages employers from
over-recruiting to secure a labor surplus and drive down wages. Under the MSP A (which
applies to u.s. migrant farmworkers, but not H-2A workers), workers enjoy a 100% guarantee.
Wyden-Graham Bill:
The Wyden-Graham bill would eliminate this work guarantee for H-2A workers. This change
will encourage growers to lure workers from hundreds or thousands of miles away with the
promise of potentially high earnings without any obligation to fulfill any part of that promise.
This may also encourage growers to recruit more workers than they actually need to hedge
against uncertainties.
Issue #5
Repatriation Incentive
Whether we support wage-withholding as an incentive for H-2A workers to repatriate.
Current Law:
Under current law, there is no mechanism for ensuring that H-2A workers return to their home
country.
Wyden-Graham Bill:
Permits employers to withhold 20% of a worker's wages, to be reclaimed upon the worker's
return to his home country.
Issue #6
Transportation Reimbursement
Whether employers should continue to be required to provide reimbursement to workers for
inbound transportation if they complete 50% of the contract, and for outbound transportation if
they complete 100% of the contract.
Current Law:
Under current law, the employer must reimburse the H-2A worker for inbound transportation
costs if the worker completes 50% of the contract and for outbound transportation costs if the
worker completes 100% of the contract.
Wyden-Graham Bill:
Under the Wyden-Graham proposal, workers may receive such reimbursement from their
employer, but the employer is under no obligation to pay. This change would simply shift the
cost of transportation to and from the job from the grower to the worker.
�"
~R¥S
Page 1 of6
Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: 'Ronald E. Jones ( CN=Ronald E. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 15-SEP-1998 10:47:30.00
SUBJECT:
Draft SAP for Senate Bankruptcy Bill -- No hard copy will be sent
TO: Janet E. Irwin ( CN=Janet E. Irwin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gary L. Bennethum ( CN=Gary L. Bennethum/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edwin Lau ( CN=Edwin Lau/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S. Redburn/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen J. Balis ( CN=Ellen J. Balis/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne Upshaw ( CN=Wayne Upshaw/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. Timberlake/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward A. Brigham ( CN=Edward A. Brigham/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan'Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toni S. Hustead ( CN=Toni S. Hustead/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua H. Raymond ( CN=Joshua H. Raymond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�AR¥S Email System
Page 2 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John S. Radzikowski ( CN=John S. Radzikowski/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pamula L. Simms ( CN=Pamula L. Simms/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas P. Stack ( CN=Thomas P. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark A. Weatherly ( CN=Mark A. Weatherly/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice Veenstra ( CN=Alice Veenstra/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas W. Elmendorf ( CN=Douglas W. Elmendorf/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Peterson ( CN=Michelle Peterson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jeffrey A. Weinberg ( CN=Jeffrey A. Weinberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: REJ573
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Tuesday, September 15, 1998
�Page 3 of6
AR¥S Email System
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
Jeffrey A. Weinberg!OMB!EOP (for) Assistant Director for
FROM:
Legislative Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Ronald E. Jones
PHONE: (202) 395 - 3386 FAX: (202) 395- 3109
SUBJECT:
Statement of Administration Policy on S1301 Consumer
Bankruptcy Reform Act of 1997
DEADLINE:
4:00 PM
Tuesday, September 15, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: We understand S. 1301 will be brought up on the Senate floor
tomorrow. Therefore, if we do not hear from you by the 4:00 PM deadline
we will assume you have no objection to the proposed SAP.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - L. Anthony Sutin - (202) 514-2141
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
7-AGRICULTURE - Marvin Shapiro - (202) 720-1516
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
30-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
35-Farm Credit Administration - Eileen McMahon - (703) 883-4056
34-Export-Import Bank of the United States - David Carter - (202) 565-3203
54-HUD - Jeff Lischer - (202) 708-1793
18-Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer
(202) 395-5084
76"National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
27-Consumer Product Safety Commission - Robert J. Wager - (301) 504-0515
32-ENERGY - Bob Rabben - (202) 586-6718
59-INTERIOR - Jane Lyder - (202) 208-4371
129-VETERANS AFFAIRS - John H. Thompson - (202) 273-6666
EOP:
Michelle Peterson
Robert N. Weiner
Roger S. Ballentine
Maureen T. Shea
Rebecca M. Blank
Elena Kagan
Douglas W. Elmendorf
Maria Echaveste
Audrey T. Haynes
Sarah Rosen
Jonathan Orszag
Nicole R. Rabner
Joseph J. Minarik
Diana Fortuna
�.
ARMS Email System
Page 4 of6
Emil E. Parker
Jennifer L. Klein
Rice Cynthia
Lisa M. Kountoupes
John E. Thompson
Edward A. Brigham
Alice Veenstra
Courtney B. Timberlake
Mark A. Weatherly
wayne Upshaw
Thomas P. Stack
Ellen J. Balis
Pamula L. Simms
Francis S. Redburn
John S. Radzikowski
Edwin Lau
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Joshua H. Raymond'
Gary L. Bennethum
Toni S. Hustead
Janet E. Irwin
LRM ID: REJ573 SUBJECT:
Statement of Administration Policy on S1301
Consumer Bankruptcy Reform Act of 1997
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Ronald E. Jones Phone:
395-3386
Fax: 395-3109
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
FROM:
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telepho~e)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
�Page 5 of6
ARMS Email System
"
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
DRAFT -- NOT FOR RELEASE
September
?,
1998
(Senate)
S. 1301 - Bankruptcy Reform Act of 1998
(Grassley (R) Iowa and Sen. Durbin (D) Illinois)
The Administration supports bankruptcy reform that asks responsibility of
debtors and creditors alike. Debtors who genuinely have the ability to
repay a portion of their debts should remain responsible for those debts.
But creditors must also be responsible in their treatment of debtors,
recognizing the inherent inequality of information and bargaining power
that the two possess.
As initially reported from committee, S. 1301 focused primarily on
purported debtor abuse, with little to curtail abuses by creditors.
However, if changes incorporated in the managersD, package of amendments
are adopted, the Senate bill will take significant steps to address
abusive practices by both debtors and creditors.
Essential changes
include new disclosure requirements to ensure that credit card companies
provide consumers with the information about their accounts that they need
to manage their budgets and procedural protections to avoid inappropriate
and unwise reaffirmations of unsecured and certain secured consumer
debts. We particularly appreciate modifications made to the
nondischargeability provisions in the bill so that the bill no longer in
appropriately puts credit card debt in competition with child support,
alimony, and other societal priorities like educational loans and taxes.
The Administration also prefers the discretionary approach to limiting
access to Chapter 7 used in S. 1301 over the rigid and arbitrary approach
in the House bill. We appreciate changes made by the Senate bill to
ensure that those debtors denied access to Chapter 7 under Section 707(b}
of the Bankruptcy Code are those that have a strong likelihood of success
under a Chapter 13 plan.
More can and should be done to produce a truly balanced bill. We must
address the potentially coercive effect of allowing creditors to bring
707(b} motions for any reason, improve consumer understanding of the
effect of granting security interests, and ensure that the protections
against coercive reaffirmations are effective.
The Administration would support passage of S. 1301, if it is further
amended in conference to improve the balance between reforms targeting
debtors and reforms targeting creditors, and if the essential reforms
incorporated by the managersD, package of amendments are preserved.
�ARMS Email System
The Administration also SUpports financial contract netting provisions in
the bill that are important to reducing systematic risk in our financial
markets.
Finally, the Senate will vote on an amendment to raise wages of 12 million
Americans and help ensure that parents who work hard and play by the rules
do not have to raise their children in poverty.
Two years ago, the
President signed into law a similar moderate increase in the minimum
wage.
The results of that action are clear: it raised wages and did not
cost jobs. Now we must continue to take actions to ensure that all
Americans are benefitting from our prospering economy.
That is why the
Administration strongly supports raising the minimum wage by $1 over two
years.
*****
Page 6 of6
�__ _A~S Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:15-SEP-1998 11:31:24.00
SUBJECT:
Heads-up memo
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�A~S
Email System
Page 2 of3
Memo was signed on Monday, September 14, 1998
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D2]MAIL414335755.226 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043BA040000010A020100000002050000007A10000000020000274D6EA60154EF73E37AA4
4826A7EF518FB963FB34BA030628F26EFE808265EOFABOCFAAD14F753F2311AAEFD1A769C5047A
8E4036C669EE350070B29B5AA4CCE3FA468DC3A814C04EBOC01F59BD3C7926C28A8CA9A8D1D43C
2210DOEE1533012855D7B398555FCBOF247428502F14E15B8DD4F78B856D95A3942C2CA4012296
799060F981898382803A196120D4B65DFB7A661A91B43E22293387648918C4A484FDE931736C61
05A2B4209968202B2513CF330EBB9587BC12AD77EBOD85703DE7565CE384FD4FB2F16CBF020ADO
F80DF46400AFCE8E99DF5F9670B3FF785EF06DA0067C79BA7B9ABA87E044084BB4A7E108CBC096
C859FD8C3B9379B2A72FE9B78CA49E02F39A9B6B03E70D40288B73C49C7BDAECDA32D0993CEOCF
E9CB541EE7AF4DBB40E758A657AECCB722BAD149E3F49205C5E943C79850CFEDAC1316DC86F926
AFF5857BFD12D412A6CAD1019A577125D8BEDF15FF2A7C5A197DF946D5DFDBBE2661C253E8216F
C43765547AE50A896156E4D5D6D3FAA4849879C944AB23AAAAA457F250554A4783417FB09FB7FC
4AD9E1C54BFDEC88F5C31FAB85835660A2952FCBD294D3B18717CD91817FEB2B415ED190196F6C
1B08B228COAAD3C433F41B309190903FFAC01A5D93917B59F2237CBD2COA4ED7741899F8B4A3BB
BBOB7BC09B02000A00000000000000000000000823010000000B0100008C020000005502000000
4E0000009703000009250100000006000000E50300000B300200000028000000EB030000080501
00000008000000130400000055010000003C0000001B0400000877010000004000000057040000
08340100000014000000970400000802010000000FOOOOOOAB04000000985C005C004F004D0042
002D00500053002D00320038002D00320039005C00330035003000420000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000~000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOO
C800C8002C012C012C012C01C800C8003000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000B0100002800C8196810480D000011090000005AOO
OB010000103600540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E002000
52006500670075006C006100720000000000000000000100020058020100000004002800000000
000000000000000000000000000000011202002400A1000000A100000001000400020000001BOO
F41A5C121A0900000000000000600018110000102400540069006D006500730020004E00650077
00000052006F006D0061006EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOA0000004C00010045004D00020002004E000100
45004F0001000200500007005000510001004500520003000200530002007B0354000200020055
00010045004C86A8245C121A0900000000000000000000000008337C0078000002000055000000
03DDOA10008301040003000200211000DDDDOBOB00030000040BOODDD41A1F0087010600080058
024CA800005802000058020200580200001FOOD4F1025000F1E011OC0000000008070COOEOF103
5000F1F1025000F1E0110C0000000060090COOEOF1035000F1F1025000F1E0110COOOOOOOOB80B
OCOOEOF1035000F1F1025000F1E0110C00000000100EOCOOEOF1035000F1F1025000F1E0110COO
00000068100COOEOF1035000F1F1025000F1808080F1035000F1F1005100F1F1025000F14453F1
035000F1F1015100F1F1005300F1F1025200F153657074656D626572F1035200F1F1015300F1F1
025200F1F1035200F1F1025300F153657074656D626572F1035300F1F1025200F180F1035200F1
F1025400F131342C8031393938F1035400F1F1005500F1F1025400F12EF1035400F1F1015500F1
D0041500000B00090001B0040000000001201500DOCC9BCCCCCCCCCC9C4D454D4F52414E44554D
80464F52804552534B494E4580424F574C4553CCCC5448524F5547483AE0110C0000000060090C
00EOE0110COOOOOOOOB80BOCOOE0808080804A61636B804C65779BD0041500000B00090001200D
7008090001201500DOD3042A0000160001B0040600F00000580282580200990C00100E96580201
B004020000009C58022AOOD3CC46524F4D3A80E0110C0000000099OCOCOOE0446F6E616C648052
2E8041726275636B6C65D0041500000B00090001000F500AOB0001201500DOCC5355424A454354
3AE0110C00000000990COCOOE09CF1004COOF1F1024BOOF1486561647384757080F1034BOOF1F1
014COOF1F1024DOOF1444F5480F1034DOOF1F1004EOOF1F1024DOOF172756CF1034DOOF1F1014E
00F1F1024FOOF152756C65806F6E80F1034FOOF1496E746572636974798042757365739BD00415
00000B00090001E010300COD0001201500DOCCE0110C0000000008070COOEOE0110C0000000099
OCOCOOEOCCE0110C0000000008070COOE057658068617665806E6561726C7980636F6D706C6574
6564806F757280726576696577806F6680618066696E616C804465706172746D656E74806F6680
�September 14, 1998
Automated R
.
Hex~~~~ ~;~:~~~~nt Systerr
MEMORANDUM FOR ERSKINE BOWLES
THROUGH:
Jack Lew
FROM:
Donald R. Arbuckle
SUBJECT:
DOT Rule on Intercity Buses
We have nearly completed our review of a final Department of Transportation
(DOT) rule that will provide improved access for wheelchair-bound passengers to intercity
buses. The rule will require intercity fixed-route bus companies (i.e., Greyhound, Peter
Pan) to provide wheelchair lifts on their buses. At least one-half of each company's buses
must be made wheelchair accessible within 6 years, with the remainder accessible within 12
years. Small companies are subject to much less stringent requirements. The costs of the
rule have been reduced substantially from the proposal-- about $25 million in annual costs
as compared to $50 million at the proposed stage. Most of this reduction is in relief to
smaller carriers and charters.
I have talked with representatives of both the disabled community and the industry.
The disability community strongly supports the rule and has been fighting ardently for the
wheelchair lift requirement for years. Smaller companies and charter operators (about
3500 companies) will also be reasonably satisfied. However, the largest companies, such as
Greyhound, who have argued most strongly against the rule, will not be happy.
Greyhound has been advocating a much less costly plan that would provide reasonable
accommodation to the disabled on 48 hours notice. Disability groups regard this as
"discriminatory", since non-handicapped passengers can purchase tickets without a
48-hour notice. In addition, these groups do not believe Greyhound's plan will work.
DOT agrees.
The fmal rule is under a September 15 court ordered deadline and we are working
with DOT to complete our review asap.
�'.
2
cc:
Maria Echaveste
Rahm Emanuel
Larry Stein
Ron Klain
Thurgood Marshall, Jr.
Ann Lewis
Sally Katzen
Minyon Moore
John Podesta
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Elena Kagan
Barry Toiv
Michael Waldman
Janet Yellen
Mickey Ibarra
Michael Deich
Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
�._ __ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ronald E. Jones ( CN;Ronald E. Jones/OU;OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:1S-SEP-1998 17:17:32.00
SUBJECT:
Bankruptcy vote has been put off until next week --per Sarah Rosen
TO: Janet E. Irwin ( CN=Janet E. Irwin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gary L. Bennethum ( CN=Gary L. Bennethum/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN;Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Edwin Lau ( CN;Edwin Lau/OU;OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S. Redburn/OU;OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen J. Balis ( CN;Ellen J. Balis/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne Upshaw ( CN=Wayne Upshaw/OU;OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. Timberlake/OU=OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward A. Brigham ( CN;Edward A. Brigham/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN;Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN;Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN;Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: karen.dorsey ( karen.dorsey @ treas.sprint.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toni S. Hustead ( CN;Toni S. Hustead/OU=OMB/O;EOP@EOP
OMB 1 )
�AP.MS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua H. Raymond ( CN=Joshua H. Raymond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John S. Radzikowski ( CN=John S. Radzikowski/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pamula L. Simms ( CN=Pamula L. Simms/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas P. Stack ( CN=Thomas P. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark A. Weatherly ( CN=Mark A. Weatherly/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice Veenstra
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Alice Veenstra/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas W. Elmendorf ( CN=Douglas W. Elmendorf/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Peterson ( CN=Michelle Peterson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jeffrey A. Weinberg ( CN=Jeffrey A. Weinberg/Ou=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�.. - ARMS Email System
.. -
Page 1 of 2
"';~
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 16-SEP-1998 15:00:12.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Butt.on ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
Jl.EAD : UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 2 of2
AR¥.S Email System
'·9
.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:00am in room 100. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
'-.
. '.
Page I of 2
I'!
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 18-SEP-1998 11:54:34.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Reports
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EQP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�.
ARMS Email System
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
David R. Goodfriend ( CN=David R. Goodfriend/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Because of the President's travel/weekend schedule, we'd like to ask that
all offices submit weekly reports before tomorrow morning (i.e.,sometime
this evening) so that the President can have time to see them early
tomorrow.
Thanks for your help; please let me know if this'll be a
problem.
Page 2 of2
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
CREATOR:
Page I of 19
(NOTES MAIL)
"Christopher Edley, Jr." <edley@law.harvard.edu> ( "Christopher Edley, Jr."
CREATION DATE/TIME: 18-SEP-1998 19:18:30.00
SUBJECT:
Draft POTUS memo on race book
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward W. Correia ( CN=Edward W. Correia/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Cavataio ( CN=Michele Cavataio/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S. Redburn/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff ( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: terry.edmonds@ssa.gov ( terry.edmonds@ssa.gov [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP
[ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of19
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: aedmondsl@home.com ( aedmondsl@home.com [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Jane T. Price-Smith ( CN;Jane T. Price-Smith/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR]
)
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Lin Liu ( CN;Lin Liu/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
cc: Michael Wenger ( CN;Michael Wenger/OU=PIR/O;EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Jacinta Ma ( CN;Jacinta Ma/OU;PIR/O;EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
David Campt ( CN;David Campt/OU;PIR/O;EOP [ PIR ]
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
John M. Goering ( CN;John M. Goering/OU;PIR/O;EOP [ PIR]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Michele Cavataio ( CN;Michele Cavataio/OU;PIR/O=EOP [ PIR ]
'READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Scott R. Palmer ( CN;Scott R. Palmer/OU;PIR/O;EOP [ PIR]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TEXT:
Comrades:
Have a good weekend. You will enjoy it more if you take a look at the
attached draft memorandum, which has been sent to the Staff Secretary for
clearance. Maria is holding a clearance meeting on Tuesday afternoon at 4
pm, but comments are welcome before or after that. The memo is due in to
POTUS mid-week. Sorry I couldn't finish this earlier in the day.
- Memo-v6.wpd;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
1 ;;;=;;;==;;;;;=;;;;;
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D97]MAIL48152516A.226 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504305630000010A0201000000020500000052840100000200000B07C5FE67E807EE65E852
CB3D35DC586A6738F72CBIB6ECA51C659D7FDB5C8FFD266DFB99A551D293E6CE0902536A495F97
632F9992D4928B507D27D72FEC13E2DB9C85BI0787F5D693B47697F02911724C40B6F5D5EII04B
5CC662E6B3DE2E2893630459A22613A0894E0336817809C735B589OF93018CEE17C55812FA5DEO
6ADAOE83877BDFF44230D7539C35162AOC09C48AAI0563F790E35632744E9C64D2D65528549524
D86A617E6E55B281F281FDBD17CC4ACFCA2304793FBEEE3223DBF38CA9AC4D4F39486BB233283A
EECEFIA71E9D43B2C8249ED4DB34097F58BCF33A2244582ACAB25388386CD35BD64FC9F22BACB5
4EE978F3037D5DD2EE2B40785276BBCF7137D691A016CF4829BC89666C8481AC6AA08D460ADBFF
2059648B5D6A409A406F41CD19EA85B82D393656E28957B6CCFF626717CD533C6388CAADEB42FF
E5AC18476346265E58F80AD757D3134F16FCIDE3348A46764428C27993FC8A06F98ECIE6CF2B8A
FBC02COD27BDF30662F9C2A439A9755FE244596E1320C7608DEE3753FDFEDAD2AE14956EBF768B
8C59A4527907BD515E9680D2BEFF5168177B0060575A94850EFB0598186Bll16554E99E4D4C98E
46E7FA265E578606E39532EDD24E40BA64DD7EBAFE504234B17B55B7F07CFC7950AB4B5CB09D7B
DBB92DE43B0200940000000000000000000000084DOI00000004000000180A0000005546000000
�••
Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
Draft v6
September 9, 1998
MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT
From:
Christopher Edley, Jr.
Professor of Law
Through:
Maria Echaveste
Deputy Chief of Staff
Re:
Progress Report on the Race Book, and Request for Interim Guidance
This memorandum is organized in the following sections:
I.
II.
III.
IV.
V.
Introduction, process and organization of the effort
The Vision (book chapter 2), and basic themes
The Workplan (chapter 6)
Leadership (chapter 7)
Next steps, and summary of decisions requested
L INTRODUCTION, PROCESS AND ORGANIZATION OF THE EFFORT
The purpose of this memorandum is to review our progress, confirm our general direction, and
solicit interim guidance on a few substantive matters. Most important, Part II is a first attempt
to sketch your "vision" of One America with racial justice and equal opportunity in the 21"
century. Then, Part III adds some flesh to key portions of the "workplan" chapter outline you
have already seen, offering a partia.l menu of ideas. l We want to know if this conceptual
lThe current detailed (and daunting) outline of the book is at Tab A. The chapter oudine is:
Introduction:
One America in the 21" Century
Chapter 1:
Where Is America On Race, And Where Are We Going?·
P_ 96152517.. CEA_ HTML_1[l]
p.1
�Automated Records Management Systerr.
Hex-Dump Conversion
framework makes sense, and if we are heading for the right mix of bold and pedestrian, thematic
and programmatic. White House policy staff are fully engaged and have both contributed to
this workplan material and reviewed this memorandum. Important disagreements and special
concurrences are noted in this document or accompanying memoranda.
We hope to complete the workplan menu within two weeks and, based on your tentative
approval of several ideas, proceed with more detailed policy development between now and early
November. This is key: I want these first stages of developing the workplan to emphasize
thoughtfulness and boldness in the selection of the challenges, goals, themes and general
strategies, connecting those to the vision. The next step, for greater detail over the next two
months, is to figure out more concretely what ought to be done by whom (federal government?
parents?). Throughout, Maria Echaveste will ensure that the interests of the policy councils are
well regarded, that the formal clearance process is used when appropriate, and that I can appeal
to you with any conflicts we cannot resolve in a timely way.
We have four working groups to help prepare the policy, or "workplan" chapter. These are
co-led by the appropriate NEC or DPC staff and me. As yet, they do not span the entire range of
subjects you may want to cover, but they are a good start:
Education
Economic Development and Employment Opportunity
Criminal Justice and Community Security
Civil Rights Enforcement
We also have less elaborate collaborative discussions moving forward on: Health, Strengthening
Families, Native Americans, and Democracy/Civic Engagement. The "book team" includes a
handful of PIR staff, and the addition soon of Terry Edmonds. I'm confident that several White
House and OMB staff will also play critical roles, as they have in preparation of this document.
Outreach: Finally, Maria has assigned Minyon Moore and OPL the overall responsibility for
coordinating external consultations by the outreach offices and, through Cabinet Affairs,
conversations with key appointees in the agencies. Throughout September, many members of
your staff will be making calls or conducting meetings with some 400 individuals, asking about
Chapter 2:
Chapter 3:
Chapter 4:
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
5:
6:
7:
8:
More Than A Dream: Racial And Ethnic Justice In The 21" Century
Wrestling Lessons: Honest, Constructive Engagement Of Our Vexing Differences
Promising Practices: How To Build Bridges That Connect People Across Lines Of Class And
Color, Creating Community And Opportunity
The Record Of The Clinton-Gore Administration
A Workplan For Our Nation
Leadership For One America
Conclusion
p.2
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
the proposed framework for your report, the most important actions you should take after the
Advisory Board's work, and any elements they think it is especially important for you to
communicate in your report. We will share some of the substantive responses with you, but all of
them will be weighed by the book team.
**
II THE VISION CHAPTER, AND BASIC THEMES
This section summarizes my best sense of your central vision for the book -- chapter 2 in the
current outline. It builds on earlier material sent to you by Sidney Blumenthal and by me, as well
as previous statements by you. In the book, the vision discussion will be preceded by an
introduction and by the chapter describing where America has been and is on race, including
demographics, discrimination, disparities, and intergroup relations. While not yet in your
language, what follows is an effort to capture the key ideas and their interrelationships. At the end
of the section, we also want to engage you on some cross-cutting questions, such as the role of
government.
(a)
Why is this subject so important Jar us to tackle?
Renewing America for the new century: For six years, I have worked to prepare America
for the challenges of the 21 st century. We have put our fiscal house in order, taken
important steps to strengthen the international economic system, worked at home and
abroad to create a post-cold war national security framework, launched an investment
program in vital areas of education, training, new technologies and environmental
protection. One additional area, without which we cannot succeed in the decades ahead,
is overcoming the divisions of race and ethnicity so that we can be One America, united
in a web of mutuality that gives us the strength to be our best as individuals, as
communities and as a nation.
Global and historical context" The difficulty of the problem is evident not only from our
own national history, but from events around the world - even today. The conflict is
commonplace, as differences give rise to hatreds and then bloodshed. As President, I've
seen it over and over again, and struggled to find ways that, through our actions and
example, this nation could help troubled societies see their shared humanity and find
peace. But make no mistake: This struggle to build peace and strength out of differences
is a struggle against deep failings and sinfulness that seem inherent in the human spirit. In
p.3
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
my own religious tradition, sin can be overcome through struggle and faith, and it is a
never-ending struggle. We should expect no easier a task when it comes to dealing with
our differences here in America.
The stakes: On a more practical plane, making diversity a source of strength rather than
division promises great rewards in social peace and home and economic success globally.
New complexity: The civil rights movement of three and four decades ago was largely
framed in black and white, but led to bursts of energy and progress for other minorities
and for women. Today's diversity gives us great opportunities, but also more complex
challenges.
Cause [or confidence: There is cause for confidence, because our ideals and values are far
more than words locked behind glass in the National Archives. They are an incandescent
beacon for peoples worldwide, and the lodestar by which we chart our own course and
criticize our missteps. Our noblest moments and wisest leaders are marked not by the
exploitation of difference, but by recalling us to the commitments of equality, tolerance,
opportunity and justice. In my life, I have seen this most profoundly in the struggle
against racial segregation and bigotry. No nation matches our capacity for moral
greatness.
(b)
What would it mean to have a full measure of racial justice and opportunity in America?
What would our relationships be like, and what would society look like?
Vision o[ community: [Celebratiori of our diversity, not mere tolerance of our differences;
building inclusive communities and organizations to take advantage of the benefits and
strengths that flow from diversity. (Examples from forums, correspondence, etc.)]
"One America" does not mean that we lose our ethnic identities, becoming some
homogenized undifferentiated mass. We can be proud of our cultural identities and
distinctiveness, and at the same time be proud of and loyal to America - indeed, that is
one of the most important elements of our nation's greatness.
In religion, for example, scholars tell us that we are the most observant of developed
nations, and that freedom of religion and separation of church and state are important
parts of the explanation. We are a nation full of religious individuals, yet we do not all
worship in the same way. Indeed, our civic values are that we tolerate and respect
different religious traditions, and celebrate the legal and civic values that make diversity
pA
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
possible. We are proud of that diversity, and together with tolerance, recognize it as a
defining greatness of America. And much of the rest of the world recognizes this too.
So, too, with our racial and ethnic diversity. Our greatness in the decades ahead depends
not merely on overcoming prejudice and bigotry rooted in our differences, and not only
in tolerating differences. We must instead celebrate those differences as a source of
richness and strength. Our personal lives are enriched by this diversity, and our society
and economy are strengthened by it.
In the community of America, the things that connect us must be stronger than those that
divide us. A "community" means shared interests. But we must also have a shared
concern for our collective advancement, and mutual concern for each other. Transcending
differences, while respecting them, is part of creating such a community.
So there is a delicate balance, because we have far too much to lose if we retreat into
ethnic enclaves - walled off from one another by prejudice, stereotypes or even simple
ignorance and misunderstanding. We sacrifice greatness and goodness, richness and
riches, if by circumstance or choice we separate ourselves into subcommunities along the
very fracture lines that have traced our national racial tragedies since Europeans arrived on
these shores.
Vision of opportunity: [Opportunity enjoyed so equally that there is no discernable legacy
of slavery, colonization or conquest; of Jim Crow or internment. (Examples from forums,
correspondence etc.)]
We have legacies of slavery, conquest and colonialism; of Jim Crow and racist
immigration quotas. The inheritance is evident in the patterns of our lives: the racially
isolated communities, the gaping disparities in educational achievement, employment,
criminal victimization and wealth; the still too-rare close friendships across lines of race.
This inheritance is a burden to our spirits and a tax on our prosperity. Perhaps most
tragically, for too many of our fellow citizens, the legacy has shackled dreams that are
every American's inalienable right. This is wrong, and we can do better.
One way our children and grandchildren will know when we have achieved racial justice
and opportunity is that the evidence of America's legacy of inequality will be found only
in history books, and not in brutal social and economic disparities surrounding them.
Vision ofresponsibility: Responsibilities of citizenship; responsibility to reach out to
others; responsibility of each of to combat whatever stereotypes and fears we may have;
Pj615251Z CEA_HTMLj[lJ
p.5
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
and responsibility to take advantage of opportunities. (Examples from forums, letters, etc.)
We must do this for our children and their children. We must do this to honor those
who have sacrificed over the generations in earlier battles, including civil rights battles, to
put our sacred civic values into practice. And I believe we must do this to honor the God
who has created us all equal, and blessed our nation in so many countless ways.
(c)
Why is this vision preferable to alternative, competing visions?
Why embracing "equal opportunity" is necessary, but insufficient alone to produce a full
measure of justice and fairness in One America.
Why color blindness makes sense, and why it doesn't.
Why assimilation as Americans is important, but not an assimilation that seeks to erase
our diverse identities. Is tolerance of differences sufficient, or must there be more?
**
IlL THE WORKPLAN CHAPTER
The purpose of this chapter is to explain the most important steps the nation must take over the
next decade in pursuit of your vision of racial justice and opportunity, as described earlier in the
book. As with the promising practices chapter, you want to provide inspiring "news you can
use" to people in communities and organizations across the nation who are looking for ideas.
The workplan is organized by policy sectors, and within each sector it will contain federal, state,
,
local, private and personal elements. This is not just about the federal government, or
government generally. Few items will have FY 2000 budget impacts, although several will have
"down payments" in Administration accomplishments and earlier proposals. (The ideas which
follow reflect substantial contributions from DPC, NEC and OMB; this memorandum has been
through an accelerated clearance process. Comments from your advisors are noted in this
document or in appended memoranda.)
The book should be highly thematic, avoiding an exhaustive and mind-numbing recitation of
comprehensive programmatic details. But it must contain just enough pointed recommendations
to leave the reader with a sense that you have provided concrete direction, not just rhetoric. This
also entails being very selective - not evelY good idea for addressing every important problem.
In areas where thoughtfulness or clarity requires more program detail, the final document can use
p.6
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
textual boxes set apart from the flow of the narrative.
Two final points. The boldness you have requested in policy ideas seems in some cases to come
in the statement of a national goal ("close disparities in education achievement by X percent"),
and in other cases may not be evident until we offer specific public or private interventions to
advance the goal. Relatedly, in the stating the goals we have repeatedly between brave aspirations
and statements that are more cautious and achievable. We need your general guidance on this.
*
THE EDUCATION SECTION OF THE WORKPLAN
§ 6.2
Apart from the economy, I assume that education will be the clear first-among-equals in your
workplan for the nation, receiving disproportionate emphasis throughout the book. Despite
improvements over the last several decades, racial disparities in opportunity and achievement
persist throughout the education pipeline, and these disparities are powerful obstacles to
achieving your vision. We've tolerated it for too long. It is wrong. Therefore, the workplan
focuses on areas of significant disparity that have the greatest impact on educational outcomes.
It also emphasizes the instrumental and ethical necessity of heightened responsibility and
accountability.
In addition, racial isolation, often in combination with poverty concentration, remains a problem
both among and within our schools, presenting barriers to achievement, excellence, and to your
vision of mutual understanding and community. This is the third pillar of the education
.
workplan.
-- Outline of the section
Introduction/Context
•
Education is primary [only central?] to achieving my vision. This requires:
(1)
(2)
(3)
eliminating racial disparities in educational opportunity and achievement;
reinforcing responsibility and strengthening accountability for
administrators, teachers and students, as well as for the political
institutions governing education; and
promoting racial and economic integration in education.
Pj6152517.. CEA_HTMLj[l}
p.?
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
•
•
(a)
These problems have long gone unsolved because they are difficult and because
race has divided us, but also because we need to reassess the roles of the different
levels of government and of the family in education. The old formulas need
revision, the old problems need new thinking, and the old values need new life.
We need to provide every family, regardless of race or zip code, with an
Education Bill ofRights. 2
Close the racial gap in opportunity and achievement. Notwithstanding important
progress, significant racial disparities in achievement persist. We must close these gaps
and raise the bar for everyone. This means overcoming racial disparities in the
educational opportunity available to every child - including both resources and
expectations - and simultaneously insisting on high standards for achievement. Beyond
this, we must improve our ability to make targeted, individualized efforts to ensure that
every child succeeds to his or her full potential. Among the key elements of an education
bill of rights for equal opportunity and achievement:
Parenting and early childhood: Ensure that every child has a parent or other adult
. actively engaged in that child's learning, and that every young child has access to early
learning opportunities.
Teaching: Improve the quality of teacher training, ensure that high·quality teachers are
equitably distributed, and ensure that teachers promote high expectations for students of
all races.
Curriculum and standards: Ensure that every child has access to challenging curricula
tied to high standards, and that tracking does not prevent any child from achieving his or
Such a Bill of Rights might include the following:
(1)
Every child shall have a parent or other adult actively engaged in hisJher learning and have access to support
services to help that child achieve to hisjher full potential.
(2)
Every child shall have access to early learning opportunities.
(3)
All parents have the right to send their children to equitably funded schools that are accountable for their
child's learning.
(4)
Every child shall have access to high-quality teachers.
(5)
Every child shall be held to high expectations and standards and have access to challenging curricula.
(6)
Every child shall have access to adequate facilities and modern technology.
(7)
Every LEP child shall have access to the tools necessary to help himjher l~arn English within three years.
(8)
Every child shall learn in a safe environment.
All parents and children shall have the right to choose to attend racially and ethnically integrated schools.
(9)
(10)
Every high school graduate shall have the financial support and opportunity to go to college.
2
Pj615251Z CE~HTMLj[lJ
p.B
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
her full potential. Students of color are often tracked into special education and out of
honors courses.
English acquisition: Guarantee each LEP child an effective opportunity to master
English, and hold students and educators accountable for success.
Infrastructure: Close the racial disparity in full access to adequate facilities and modern
technology.
Post-secondary attainment: Overcome racial disparities in high school graduation rates,
and in college participation, retention and graduation rates.
(b)
Institute greater accountability and heightened responsibility for administrators,
teachers, students and public officials. Without much stronger mechanisms for
accountability, the goals of closing disparities in opportunity and achievement are mere
aspirations, not commitments. Moreover, to break the back of inertia and complacency
we will have to design interventions that target the political, bureaucratic and
jurisdictional impediments to sustained reform. The Voluntary National Test is such an
intervention, as is public school choice, and we must build on such approaches while
providing needed safeguards against abuses.
Tests and accountability: Use the best assessment methods, including national tests, to
build broader and deeper systems that will hold administrators, teachers, and students
accountable for educational achievement. The accountability should flow ''up'' from
parents and "down" from Federal taxpayers and presidential leadership. The range of
tools, both carrots and sticks, should stretch from more effective parental action, to
political mobilization, to school reconstitution or receivership, to fiscal incentives - and
everything in between.
Governance and leadership: If eliminating the disparities in opportunity and achievement
require modifications of our traditional structure of roles and authority, so be it. We need
new ways to think about old problems.
(c)
Promote integration and diversity in education to enrich the learning experience for
all students. We also care about integration, so that students have the opportunity to
learn together in ways that dissolve stereotypes and improve race relations. Parents and
students should have a right to chose an integrated education. But, after a burst of
progress in the late 1960s and early 1970s, segregation in K-12 education is worsening.
For example, a recent study reports that one-third of black and Hispanic students attend
schools with more than 90 percent minority enrollment, and almost nine in 10 of those
P_9615251ZCEA_HTML_lflJ
p.9
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
schools are predominantly poor. High-quality integrated schools provide a more
complete educational experience for all students than high-quality segregated schools.
Conversely, ineffective, racially isolated schools in high-poverty areas present our
greatest obstacle to closing the disparities in opportunity and achievement.
Educate the public on the value of inclusion. diversity and integration -- reviving that
ideal: An inclusive community of students and educators can: improve teaching and
learning by enriching the leaming environment with diverse perspectives; strengthen
students' critical-thinking skills by challenging their existing perspectives; teach students
how to interact comfortably with people different from themselves and thereby how to
function as good neighbors, colleagues and citizens in our diverse democratic society;
improve students' preparation for employment by teaching them the value of diverse
perspectives, how to function in diverse business settings, and how to communicate
effectively in our increasingly diverse domestic marketplace and the expanding global
marketplace; and foster the advancement of knowledge by spurring study in new areas of
concern.
Reduce racial segregation and isolation among schools: This is not a call for massive,
federally mandated strategies where there is no constitutional violation demanding
court-supervised remedies. Instead, parents and educators should make use of a range of
measures such as magnet schools, multidistrict transfer programs, and so forth. Most
important, we must better appreciate the important stake we have in making diversity
work in the world of our children. Schools of unquestioned excellence are the easiest to
make and keep diverse.
Reduce segregation within schools: Even in diverse schools, evidence shows that
students are often resegregated into racially homogenous classes through tracking and
other mechanisms, thereby reducing their opportunities to leam together and have
positive cross-racial interactions.
Inclusion in higher education: Promote access and diversity in higher education, and
foster the educational benefits of diversity. Mend, don't end, affirmative action. And
wherever possible, use creative race-neutral mechanisms in admissions and in the K-12
pipeline. Ensure that in sustaining the crucial role ofHBCUs, HSIs, and Tribal colleges
(which are integrated) we don't "excuse" historically white institutions from the principle
of excellence-through-inclusion.
- Discussion issues on the education workplan
Are you comfortable with the three major pillars: closing the race gap in opportunity and
achievement; accountability and governance; attacking racial isolation?
P_ 96152517.. CEA_ HTML_1[lJ
p.10
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Do the bulleted items capture your personal priorities? Are any high priorities missing?
Can any of them be demoted for attention in textual boxes rather than in your narrative?
Can we explore some rethinking of the federal role in order to tackle these disparities?
*
§ 6.4
CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND COMMUNITY SECURITY
From hate crimes to crack houses, from police misconduct to police hiring, from disparate
incarceration rates to racial profiling -- barely a week goes by without some aspect of crime and
criminal justice standing as a lightening rod for racial and ethnic tensions. No area is more
freighted with divisive stereotypes and misunderstanding. Yet it must be tackled with vigor
because victimization and criminality destroy communities and families, just as they fuel
alienation and division.
- Outline of the section
Introduction/Context
•
Racial disparities exist in both the realities and perceptions of crime and the
administration of justice: communities of color disproportionately bear the social,
economic, and personal costs of crime, and, according to polls, have less
confidence in the fairness of the criminal justice system than do whites.
•
Building One America requires building a criminal justice system that serves and
treats Americans of all races fully and fairly, and thereby closes the trust gap
while making community security a right enjoyed equally.
(a)
Community Security: Eliminate racial disparities in victimization. The right to be
secure cannot be discounted by race. Every American is entitled to live in a safe
community, and the race of residents shouldn't tell us the crime rate. From 1992 to
1997, rates of violent crime in America have decreased, but disparate victimization rates·
persist. Tackling this problem directly is part of the oppo'rtunity agenda, as well as a
matter of decent fairness. The Administration's record has numerous elements, which
we can build upon and target to close the disparities.
(b)
Keep young people out of the criminal justice system, and for those who have
contact with it, make it their last. Racial minorities, ·especially young, black males, are
more likely than whites to be both the offenders and victims of certain crimes, including
P_ 96152517.. CEA_ HTML_1[1]
p.ll
�Automated Records Management System
. Hex-Dump Conversion
violent crimes. Furthennore, one third of young, black men are presently under the
supervision of the criminal justice system (on probation, in prison, or on parole), and the
chance that a young, black male will go to prison during his lifetime is nearly 30%. The
realities are flatly inconsistent an American vision of racial justice and equal opportunity.
(c)
Build greater fairness and trust in the criminal system. Several past and present·
factors contribute to mistrust in our criminal justice system among persons of color,
including negative interactions, disparities in the administration of justice (incarceration,
sentencing, death penalty), and lagging diversity in law enforcement (police, prosecutors,
judges, juries). Without more trust, creating safe communities is impossible, because
legitimacy, support and cooperation don't come free.
Prohibit the use ofracial projiling: 3 No American should be subject to disparate
application of the state's policing power because ofhislher race. Statistically efficient
allocation of resources, some claim, justifies impositions on innocent persons, while
perpetuating stereotypes and contributing to tensions. Targeting based on color, without
individualized evidence, is rarely if ever fair and just.
Pursue zero tolerance for racially suspect police misconduct and brutality: While the
vast majority of police are dedicated public servants who deserve our respect and support,
several high-profile cases illustrate that incidents of police misconduct and brutality
motivated by racial animus still occur. We are deeply divided in perceptions of the
magnitude of the problem.
Eliminate racial discrimination and unjustified disparities in incarceration, sentencing,
and imposition of the death penalty.
Increase diversity and representation in the criminaljustice system.
- Discussion issues on the criminal justice workplan
Can we speak of community safety as a "right", and the racial disparities in victimization
as flatly inconsistent with your vision? If so, are disparities a fair index of this aspect of
racial justice and opportunity?
Should we "prohibit" racial profiling, or "restrict" it?
3Proftling will also be considered in the "Wrestling Lessons" chapter, as one of the hard questions that forces us to
think about differences in values and perceptions.
Pj615251ZCEA_HTMLj[lJ
p.12
�Automated Records Management Systerr,
Hex-Dump Conversion
Similarly, should we tackle disparities in rates of incarceration, presumably with targeted
attention to prevention, diversion and post-incarceration?
Can we assume that the primary public sector role is state and local, or do you envision
continued growth in the federal role?
*
§ 6_7
THE CIVIL RIGHTS ENFORCEMENT SECTION OF THE WORKPLAN
We have considered distributing the civil rights law enforcement issues in several sectoral
subsections - as components of the education or jobs strategies, for example. But for now, I want
to press ahead as sketched below because the audience will appropriately expect some attention
to the traditional antidiscrimination enforcement agenda. This also permits you to teach about
this unfinished work. Moreover,the best opportunities for boldness are in cross cutting issues,
among them: policy judgments about the lawfulness under Title VI of persistent resource
disparities; retooling agency enforcement strategies to emphasize proactive technical assistance
and voluntary action; and rethinking the legal framework and enforcement priorities to reflect our
21 51 century diversity.
We are joined at the hip with Chuck Ruff, and will cooperate in his effort to put before you
suggested civil rights enforcement priorities for the next two years.
- Outline of the section
Introduction/Context
Persistence of discrimination, and of enforcement backlogs.
We have opportunities to strengthen and more aggressively enforce civil rights principles,
and also support appropriate voluntary actions that promote equal opportunity and access.
This includes defending disparate impact doctrine, and defending affirmative action.
The traditional agenda needs renovation to (i) increase its efficiency at handling the retail
problem of discrimination; (ii) contribute more directly to the opportunity agenda in
education, jobs and community economics; (iii) reflect our 21 51 century diversity.
(a)
Overcome racial disparities in opportunity by expanding the use of civil rights
enforcement. Civil rights enforcement can play an especially important role in
Pj61525lZ CEA_HTMLj[IJ
p.13
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
overcoming barriers to educational and economic opportunity, and we should strengthen
and focus civil rights enforcement to complement the opportunity agenda.
Strengthen antidiscrimination laws and enforcement procedures: For example, we
could amend Title II, which prohibits discrimination in public accommodations, to
include businesses that provide goods and services. At present, racial discrimination in
retail sales (e.g., the Eddie Bauer case in which a black teenager was ordered by a security
guard to strip off his shirt because he did not have a sales receipt) does not raise a strong
federal cause of action. We nearly abandoned pattern and practice investigations during
the 1980s. That was wrong.
Use Title VI to address racial disparities: No federal money should be spent in a
manner that supports unjustified racial disparities in opportunity. For example, in
education, Title VI prohibits policies and practices that have an unjustified disparate
impact on select racial groups in tenus of access to educational resources, tracking into
challenging courses, the use of unvalidated high stakes tests, and more. We should
strengthen Title VI enforcement.
How much discrimination is there? We should expand research on the extent of racial
discrimination, using the best available methodologies (testers where appropriate), in
such areas as employment, housing, and access to capital. The results of such testing
should be published in an annual report card.
(b)
Fully address all forms of discrimination affecting our increasingly diverse
popUlation by strengthening civil rights laws and enforcement. We must retool our
civil rights laws and refocus enforcement efforts to fully address civil rights issues
affecting our diverse citizenry.
New immigrants: Strengthen laws and enforcement to promote the rights of new
immigrants. For example, in immigration and employment, we could expand
enforcement against labor abuses in "sweatshops," the victims of which are often new
immigrants of Hispanic or Asian origin, and amend present laws to stabilize the
immigration status of persons who report labor abuses so those persons do not fear
reprisal, official or private.
Language acquisition: Promote the rights ofLEP populations. For example, in
education, we could develop regulations to clarify the Lau standard concerning what legal
requirements schools must meet in educating LEP students.
Learning your rights: Educate immigrant and LEP populations about civil rights laws
and mechanisms. We should promote outreach to immigrant and LEP populations
whose rights are protected but who are underutilizing civil rights laws.
Pj6152517.. CEA_HTMLj[lJ
p.14
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
(c)
Address discrimination and disparities by promoting voluntary efforts in
conjunction with enforcement of civil rights laws_ In addition to reacting to civil
rights complaints, civil rights enforcement agencies should act proactively to encourage
and support voluntary compliance with civil rights laws and values.
Expand civil rights consultations and clarify legal standards: There are civil rights
areas where both the law and policy are unclear and where people of good will may be
managing inappropriate programs. We should act to clarify legal standards and to
encourage actors to seek guidance concerning their civil rights obligations. We could
promote laws or regulations encouraging voluntary consultations with civil rights
agencies. If an actor voluntarily submits hislher practice for civil rights review, he/she is
safe harbored and/or any agreement approved by the civil rights agency following that
review would be defended by the federal government if later challenged by a third party.
Expand proactive enforcement: Absent a formal complaint, where potential civil rights
violations are discovered, civil rights agencies should follow up with the party to correct
the injustice. If discussions are not fruitful, the enforcement agency reserves the right to
launch a more formal civil rights enforcement examination. For example, in education,
the Department of Education's Office of Civil Rights (OCR) recently learned ofa
Georgia education policy that placed students into gifted and talent programs based solely
on IQ test scores, despite the fact that the IQ test was not validated for that purpose nor
validated to be the sale factor for any purpose. This policy led to a disproportionately
low number of minority students being admitted to gifted and talented programs. OCR
consulted with Georgia officials, and the policy was properly amended.
(d)
Mend, don't end, affirmative action as enforcement remedy and voluntary measure
to promote access and inclusion
(e)
[Hate crimes.]
-- Discussion issues on the civil rights workplan
After further interagency discussion, we will need policy guidance about a number of
Title VI issues.
Should we develop a package addressing "the new diversity"?
Pj61525lZ CEA_HTMLj[IJ
p.15
�Automated Records Management Systep"
Hex-Dump Conversion
How much technical assistance should be done proactively to implement "mend don't
end" in various sectors?
**
IV.
THE LEADERSHIP CHAPTER
Following the workplan chapter, you can challenge leaders in a range of sectors to do their part,
and combine this with a vision of locally-based efforts to use the promising practices and devise
locally-oriented workplans. Finally, in this chapter you should describe the ongoing mechanism
within the White House to help support the sectoral leadership, community-based leadership, and
the Federal government elements of your workplan.
(a)
Challenges for sectoral leadership
We expect, by the publication date, to have worked successfully with leadership groups in a few
sectors, prompting them to develop a list of action steps tailored to their sector, and a practical
strategy for implementation. A brief status report on what we have initiated follows.
Higher Education: With staff support from the American Council on Education, a core
group of college and university presidents is working to establish a broader coalition that
will lead a coordinated campaign to educate the public about the value of diversity in
higher education and to share campus practices that promote diversity. We expect them to
launch the effort, designed with Frank Greer as lead consultant, sometime this fall.
(There is a possibility of using a White House event to bless the undertaking.)
Faith Community: Sandy Cloud ofthe National Conference for Community and
Justice has agreed to lead a steering committee in convening, on October 22 and
October 23, an implementation summit at which a group of faith leaders will write
and commit to a practical work plan for both national and community-based action, and
devise a coalition mechanism for follow through. This will include special efforts to reach
those faith communities that have not traditionally been leaders in racial justice. In
addition, at your September 11 breakfast for religious leaders, you will have an
opportunity to mention Sandy Cloud's leadership, and encourage those in the room to
respond positively to the effort.
p.16
�Automated Records Management Systen
Hex-Dump Conversion
Corporate: Secretary Daley will informally convene a group of CEOs in October to
identify the most appropriate elements of a corporate sector initiative, and strategies for
enlisting support from key executives. In preparation for that session, White House and
agency staff will brainstorm with some current and former Administration officials in
corporate leadership.
Youth: We are organizing a team of White House staff and representatives from national
youth-oriented organizations to prepare a workplan intended for widespread endorsement
and dissemination. (The outside collaborators will include USSA, Young Democrats,
Young Republicans, the youth divisions of the NAACP, Urban League, La Raza and the
Congress of Asian Pacific American Youth.) Tentatively, we think the plan's three major
components will be: (i) a national campaign to educate the youth sector about the
intricacies and history of race and racism; (ii) an initiative to improve race-related
curriculum and teaching in grades K-16; and (iii) a mechanism to ensure youth sector
involvement.
(b)
Options for an ongoing structure to carry out your work plan
While the work plan is not yet completed, we know that there will be some general components
which will require continuity and should compose the major responsibilities of the new entity:
~
~
~
~
Policy making (including research and data collection)
Outreach and leadership development (including technical assistance to communities)
Communication campaign (including an awards program)
Support for promising practices (such as a clearinghouse, conferences, grant funding)
The work plan lays out an ambitious agenda that will require the involvement of several players.
With such an extensive scope of work, a coordinating body for the federal sector, and for liaison
with non-federal actors is needed to ensure continued momentum and follow up from outside
efforts. Non-federal leaders engaged on the workplan will expect a central point of contact and
technical assistance.
Option A:
A1:
President's Council for One America
President's Council [or One America Plus an External AdVisory Committee
The continuing effort could take a form similar to the Council for Environmental Quality
or the Office of Science and Technology Policy. This arrangement would be short of
the ONDCP model which has a large staff, a significant budget, and substantial operating
p.17
�Automated Records Management Sysler
Hex-Dump Conversion
authority. The council, created by Executive Order, would be run by an Assistant to the
President (as Executive Director) with a small staff and a blue ribbon advisory committee.
A council staff should include a policy component, which would work with existing
White House policy offices and federal agencies to promote data collection and research
and to develop and monitor policies to overcome disparities and eliminate discrimination.
It would also have a communications component, which would help lead a public
education campaign, support a promising practices clearinghouse, and conduct outreach
to help improve race relations.
Pros:
•
•
•
•
Cons: •
•
A2:
Location places the Presidency squarely behind racial reconciliation effort
Relatively stable structure
Staff appointed by you ensures White House control
Advisory committee offers opportunity for showcasing diverse leadership,
provides credibility in building partnerships
Location and staffing make the stakes high
Advisory committee requires support and nurturing; the familiar headaches
President's Council [or One America, No Advisory Committee
This option would be the same as option AI but it would not include an Advisory
Committee.
Pros: •
Staff would not be distracted by the day-ta-day demands of managing an
Advisory Committee
Cons: •
Option B:
Pros:
Dedicated Staff reporting to the Office of the Chief of Staff
An Assistant to the President with a small staff, reporting to the Chief of Staff's
office, could take responsibility for managing Administration efforts.
•
•
Cons: •
•
Option C:
Lacks the outside validation that an Advisory Committee can provide
Closely linked to you and the White House
At the center of activity
Not a formal structure, may not be stable
May not be viewed publicly as a significant enough commitment
Private Foundation Model
pl8
�Automated Records Management Syster
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cl:
One America Foundation
The structure could take the fonn of a private foundation, established at your urging and
supported to varying degrees by the federal government, similar to the }>oints of Light
Foundation. The goals of the foundation could include promoting research on issues of
race, promoting a public education campaign to support racial reconciliation, and
supporting community efforts to improve race relations. Such a foundation could perhaps
best complement a separate policy-making effort within the federal government.
Pros: •
•
•
Cons: •
•
C2:
Serves as umbrella to coordinate several areas of activity
Independence
Ability to raise money
May not be viewed as closely connected to the White House
Requires someone's time and attention to pull together
Clinton Library Model
This option is similar to the Foundation model above except that it would be an endeavor
for you after your final tenn ends, possibly as part of the Clinton library. Staff could
begin immediately to design the structure.
Pros: •
•
Cons: •
•
More time to put together the funding and structure
You will have more time to devote to it
Delays significant Presidential involvement for a few more years
May be partisan resistance to participating in activities because of close
alignment with this Administration
V.
NEXT STEPS
Attachments:
Current book outline.
Pj615251Z CEA_HTMLj[lJ
p.19
�NEC memorandum on employment issues
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
???
P_9615251Z CEA_HTML_l[lJ
p.20
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[09/09/1998 – 09/18/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 099 - Folder 006
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/4341f5bbd547ac6eb4040b32c39dde7f.pdf
5190ad1d5ceb7e5dc60c179ba4a8b837
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC-KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 099 - FOLDER -005
[07/20/1998-09/04/1998]
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-JUL-1998 10:11:17.00
SUBJECT:
poverty/Income mtg
TO: Daniel D. Heath ( CN=Daniel D. Heath/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul Bugg ( CN=Paul Bugg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ophelia D. West ( CN=Ophelia D. West/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Just a reminder: Sally will host an income/poverty meeting today at 2:00
PM in her office, Room 231.
If you have a conflict, please let me know
ASAP.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
,.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:22-JUL-1998 13:50:40.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Meeting
TO: marti.thomas ( marti.thomas @ ms01.do.treas.sprint.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Grundman-Stacey ( Grundman-Stacey @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: sheketoff-emily ( sheketoff-emily @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: kburke1 ( kburke1 @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JONATHAN.GRUBER ( JONATHAN.GRUBER @ MS01.DO.treas.sprint.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer.moore ( Jennifer.moore @ justice.usdoj.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: guzy.gary ( guzy.gary @ epamail.epa.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: johara ( johara @ osophs.dhhs.gov @ inet
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
,.
READ : UNKNOWN
TO: William H. White Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=William H. White Jr./OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. Mendelson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
J OPD 1 )
CC: Gina C. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will not be a Weekly Tobacco Meeting this week, but it will be
scheduled for Thursday, July 30, at 2:45 in Room 211 OEOB.
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
<:.'"
-
-
~ ..
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:22-JUL-1998 18:45:02.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1
�ARMS Email System
...
Page 2 of2
.~
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
cc: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:00am in room 100. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
--
--
Page 1 of5
f;t
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN;Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU;OMB/O;EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-JUL-1998 09:56:15.00
SUBJECT:
LRM #IMS388 - Statement of Administration Policy on HR872 Biomaterials Acc
TO: US@2;TELEMAIL@3;GOV+TREAS@5;DO@4;MS01@7;LLR@6;TREASURY@mrx@lngtwy ( 1;US@2;TELEM
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: cla ( cla @ sba.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@
inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian S. Mason ( CN;Brian S. Mason/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN;Kate P. Donovan/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen J. Balis ( CN;Ellen J. Balis/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN;Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN;Robert N. Weiner/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN;william P. Marshall/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy B. Rudd ( CN;Jeremy B. Rudd/OU;CEA/O;EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Brown ( CN;Lisa M. Brown/O;OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN;Sarah Rosen/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard J. Turman
READ: UNKNOWN
CN;Richard J. Turman/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN;Robert G. Damus/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN;Michael Deich/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN;David J. Haun/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
"
TO: lrm ( lrm @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: cpsc-cr ( cpsc-cr @ cpsc.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@S=JMD@7=Deborah@6=Clifton@mrx@lngtwy
READ: UNKNOWN
1=US@2=TELEMAIL@S=JMD@7=Deb
TO: Lisa Zweig ( CN=Lisa Zweig/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert J. Pellicci ( CN=Robert J. Pellicci/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Burson ( CN=Charles W. Burson/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. Mendelson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marc Garufi ( CN=Marc Garufi/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven D. Aitken ( CN=Steven D. Aitken/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Theodore Wartell ( CN=Theodore Wartell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Julia E. Yuille ( CN=Julia E. Yuille/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The manager's amendment will be faxed to you seperately.
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
\,
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: IMS388
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Sunday, July 26, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
James J. Jukes (for) Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
Ingrid M. Schroeder
PHONE: (202) 395-3883 FAX: (202) 395-3109
SUBJECT:
Statement of Administration Policy on HR872
Biomaterials Access Assurance Act of 1997
FROM:
OMB CONTACT:
DEADLINE:
11am
Monday, July 27, 1998 -- FIRM
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990·.
COMMENTS: House floor action (suspension of the rules) is scheduled for
Today, Monday, July 27th (as early as Noon). Therefore the above deadline
is firm.
If we do not hear from you by the above deadline we will assume
that you have no objection to the attached SAP.
The manager's amendment
to H.R. 872 will be faxed to you seperately.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - L. Anthony Sutin - (202) 514-2141
52-HHS - Sondra S. wallace - (202) 690-7760
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer 76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews 27-Consumer Product Safety Commission - Robert J.
EOP:
John E. Thompson
David J. Haun
Theodore Wartell
Michael Deich
Steven D. Aitken
Robert G. Damus
Marc Garufi
Richard J. Turman
Daniel N. Mendelson
Barbara Chow
Sandra Yamin
Sarah Rosen
Gene B. Sperling
Lisa M. Brown
Swedin -
(202) 205-6700
(202) 395-5084
(202) 456-6630
Wager - (301) 504-0515
�Page 4 of5
..
ARMS Email System
Charles W. Burson
Jeremy B. Rudd
Peter G. Jacoby
William P. Marshall
Bruce R. Lindsey
Robert N. Weiner
Elena Kagan
Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
Christopher C. Jennings
Ellen J. Balis
Robert J. Pellicci
Kate P. Donovan
Lisa Zweig
Brian S. Mason
John Podesta
Statement of Administration Policy on HR872
LRM ID: IMS388 SUBJECT:
Biomaterials Access Assurance Act of 1997
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Fax:
395-3109
Ingrid M. Schroeder Phone:
395-3883
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
�ARMS Email System
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
DRAFT -- NOT FOR RELEASE
July 27, 1998
(House)
H.R. 872 - Biomaterials Access Assurance Act of 1998
(Gekas (R) Pennsylvania and 133 cosponsors)
The Administration supports House passage of H.R. 872 in the form of the
manager's amendment which would protect certain biomaterials supplier from
liability for harm caused by an implant. This protection would not apply
to suppliers:
(1) who are registered manufacturers of the implant; (2)
who are sellers of the implant and who held title to the implant at the
time of sale (or is related by common ownership or control to such a
seller); (3) who furnish raw materials or components that fail to meet
applicable contractual requirements or specifications; or (4) whose
negligence or intentionally tortious conduct was a cause of the harm, if
the manufacturer's liability should be reduced because of that negligence
or intentionally tortious conduct or the manufacturer is insolvent.
* * * * * * *
Page 5 of5
�'..
ARMS Email System
_..
'P>
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP
[ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-JUL-1998 14:42:32.00
SUBJECT:
Headsup memo
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
'TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�'. AR¥,S Email System
Memo was signed on Friday, July 24.
MEMORANDUM FOR ERSKINE BOWLES
THROUGH:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Jack Lew
Donald R. Arbuckle
Increase in User Fees for Immigration Services
We are about to complete review of a final rule from the
Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) that would raise user fees
for nearly two dozen INS services. Such services in9lude naturalization
applications, work authorization requests, and adoption of overseas
children. The final rule is based on a 1995 analysis of costs for these
services and is intended to fully fund the costs providing these
services. The overall cost effect of this change could add as much as
$272 million per year to INSD, Immigration Examinations Fee Account.
The
budget effects of this policy are reflected in the FY 99 Budget, and
senior Administration officials have told Congress that we need to publish
this rule to ensure solvency at the INS and to reduce the backlog of n
aturalization applications.
The proposed rule received over 2,000 comments, most of which
opposed the increase
in fees.
Immigrant advocates are upset that INS continues to provide poor
service and that .the naturalization backlog continues to grow - - yet
applicants will have to pay more under the new INS fee schedule. Most
immigrant groups believe that the fee increase should take effect only
after the INS significantly reduces the naturalization backlog. Groups
are seeking a one-time appropriation of funds to increase INSD,s backlog
reduction efforts. Jack Lew recently spoke with Congressman Becerra,
Chairman of the Hispanic Caucus, who accepts the need for an immediate fee
increase but believes strongly that the higher fee should be used only to
process new applicants, while the backlog should be financed by some other
means.
Congressman Becerra agreed to work with us on an appropriate
strategy to resolve these issues.
We believe that the benefits from this rule -- including program
solvency and, ultimately,
faster processing of applications -- justify
the increase in fees. We would like to clear this'rule by COB Monday.
If
you have any questions or concerns, please let me know immediately.
cc:
Maria Echaveste
Rahm Emanuel
Larry Stein
Ron Klain
Thurgood Marshall, Jr.
Ann Lewis
Sally Katzen
Minyon Moore
John Podesta·
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Elena Kagan
Barry Toiv
Michael Waldman
Janet Yellen
Mickey Ibarra
Michael Deich
Page 2 of2
�ARMS Email System
\.
-
Page 1 of2
II.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-JUL-1998 16:49:36.00
SUBJECT:
Headsup Memo
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Michael waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. Mendelson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�ARMS Email System
I..
(.
The memo was dated Friday, July 24th.
MEMORANDUM FOR ERSKINE BOWLES
THROUGH:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Jack Lew
Donald R. Arbuckle
FDA Final Rule on MedGuides
We are about to conclude review of a final FDA rule requiring the
distribution of patient labeling (known as medication guides or
D&MedGuidesD8) for selected prescription drugs and biological products.
The labeling is intended to provide patients necessary information so that
they can use their medications more safely and effectively.
FDAD,s
proposed MedGuide rule, published in August of 1995, would have applied to
all prescription drugs and biological products.
However, following
intense criticism from health professionals and industry officials, and
legislation enacted by Congress which limited FDAD,s ability to regulate
in this area, FDA has revised the rule to apply only to products that pose
a serious and significant public health concern (only approximately 4-5
new products or product classes a year) .
FDA believes that opposition to the rule will be minimal. Most
health professionals have known that FDA was moving forward with the rule
and have not provided significant feedback.
FDA also has stated that
Congress, at the time the MedGuide legislation was enacted, had agreed
that this part of the rule could go forward.
Please let me know if you have any additional questions.
cc:
Maria Echaveste
Rahm Emanuel
Larry Stein
Ron Klain
Thurgood Marshall, Jr.
Ann Lewis
Sally Katzen
Minyon Moore
John Podesta
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Elena Kagan
Barry Toiv
Michael Waldman
Janet Yellen
Mickey Ibarra
Danny Mendelson
Page 2 of2
�Page 1 of3
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert
( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-JUL-1998 11:50:27.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Meeting
TO: marti.thomas ( marti.thomas @ ms01.do.treas.sprint.com @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
inet
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: sheketoff-emily ( sheketoff-emily @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Grundman-Stacey ( Grundman-Stacey
READ: UNKNOWN
@
dol. gov
@
TO: kburke1 ( kburke1 @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
TO: mark. mcclellan ( mark. mcclellan @ treas.sprint.com @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
EOP .[ OPD 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: JONATHAN.GRUBER ( JONATHAN.GRUBER @ MS01.DO.treas.sprint.com @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer.moore ( Jennifer.moore @ justice.usdoj.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: guzy.gary ( guzy.gary @ epamail.epa.gov @ inet
[ UNKNOWN 1
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
�Page 2 of3
ARMS Email System
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: johara ( johara @ osophs.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=William H. White Jr./OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: William H. White Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. MendelsonjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARRC
REl:\D : UNKNOWN
@
Al
CD
@
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua GotbaumjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. WoolleyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. MandejOU=OSTPjO=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. SmithjOU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
christine.devlin ( christine.devlin @ treas.sprint.com [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Gina C. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. MooersjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
@
ustr.gov
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
INET
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY_MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. TaylorjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�ARMS Email System
.,
The Weekly Tobacco Meeting scheduled for Thursday, 7/30 @ 2:45 has been
moved to 3:15 in Room 211 OEOB.
Page 3 of3
�Page I of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 29-JUL-1998 18:08:12.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
."
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jocelyn Neis
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
,
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:00 am in room 100.
�'. ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 7
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-JUL-1998 17:09:00.00
SUBJECT:
URGENT - COB TODAY DEADLINE - LRM #IMS391 - Statement of Administration Po
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@3=GOV+TREAS@S=DO@4=MS01@7=LLR@6=TREASURY@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEM
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm ( lrm @ ostp. eop. gOY @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1. )
TO: dodlrs ( dodlrs @ osdgc.osd.mil [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ascher_bernard@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY ( ascher_bernard@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY [ UN
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: dol-sol-leg ( dol-sol-Ieg @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@S=JMD@7=Deborah@6=Clifton@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEMAIL@S=JMD@7=Deb
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Zweig ( CN=Lisa Zweig/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles M. Brain ( CN=Charles M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�Page 2 of7
· AlU.;1S Email System
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Fox ( CN=Charles W. Fox/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Jo Siclari ( CN=Mary Jo Siclari/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Louisa Koch ( CN=Louisa Koch/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph G; pipan ( CN=Joseph G. Pipan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm ( lrm @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm ( lrm @ nsf.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: ogc_legislation ( ogc_legislation @ ed.gov @inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: mjtaylor ( mjtaylor @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Ellen J. Balis ( CN=Ellen J. Balis/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Konigsberg ( CN=Charles Konig?berg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=William P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�· ARMS Email System
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine M. Tyer ( CN=Katherine M. Tyer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Gregory G. Henry ( CN=Gregory G. Henry/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald L. Silberman ( CN=Ronald L. Silberman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan T. Farley ( CN=Evan T. Farley/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Julia E. Yuille ( CN=Julia E. Yuille/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ronald E. Jones ( CN=Ronald E. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
You will be rece1v1ng by fax a copy of the substitute amendment to H.R.
3736 which is scheduled for House floor consideration tomorrow morning,
Friday, July 31st.
The deadline of COB, Today, July 30th is firm.
Please note the senior advisors veto recommendation in the attached draft
SAP.
Total Pages: ____
Page 3 of7
�Page 4 of7
ARMS Email System
LRM ID: IMS391
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Thursday, July 30, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
Ronald E. Jones (for) Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
Ingrid M. Schroeder
PHONE: (202) 395- 3883 FAX: (202) 395 - 3109
SUBJECT:
Statement of Administration Policy on HR3736 Workforce
Improvement and Protection Act of 1998
FROM:
OMB CONTACT:
DEADLINE:
COB
Thursday, July 30, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject .before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: House and Senate floor action on H.R. 3736 is expected on
Friday, July 31st.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - L. Anthony Sutin - (202) 514-2141
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
128-US Trade Representative - Fred Montgomery - (202) 395-3475
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
30-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
29-DEFENSE - Samuel T. Brick Jr. - (703) 697-1305
84-National Science Foundation - Lawrence Rudolph - (703) 306-1060
95-0ffice of Science and Technology Policy - Jeff Smith - (202) 456-6047
114-STATE - Paul Rademacher - (202) 647-4463
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer - (202) 395-5084
EOP:
Debra J. Bond
Larry R. Matlack
Barry White
Sandra Yamin
Barbara Chow
Steven M. Mertens
David J. Haun
Daniel J. Chenok
Evan T. Farley
Joseph G. Pipan
Ronald L. Silberman
Louisa Koch
Richard J. Turman
�Page 5 of7·
_ AIUv,IS Email System
Mary Jo Siclari
Gregory G. Henry
Charles W. Fox
Katherine M. Tyer
Jack A. Smalligan
Julie A. Fernandes
Elena Kagan
Thomas A. Kalil
Cecilia E. Rouse
Sally Katzen
Gene B. Sperling
Peter G. Jacoby
Janet Murguia
Broderick Johnson
Charles M. Brain
Tracey E. Thornton
Maria Echaveste
Emil E. Parker
Robert N. Weiner
William P. Marshall
Karen Tramontano
Rebecca M. Blank
Maria J. Hanratty
Kate P. Donovan
Lisa Zweig
Charles Konigsberg
James J. Jukes
Ellen J. Balis
LRM ID: IMS391 SUBJECT:
Statement of Administration Policy on HR3736
workforce Improvement and Protection Act of 1998
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this·
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
FROM:
Ingrid M. Schroeder Phone:
395-3883
Fax:
395-3109
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
�_ AR11S Email System
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
DRAFT -- NOT FOR RELEASE
July 30, 1998
(House)
H·.R. 3736 - Workforce Improvement and Protection Act of 1998
(Smith (R) Texas and 3 cosponsors)
The Administration strongly opposes House passage of H.R. 3736, the
"Workforce Improvement and Protection Act of 1998," as amended.
If this
bill is presented to the President, his senior advisors will recommend
that he veto it.
This bill is intended to respond to a skills shortage in the information
technology industry by increasing the annual cap on the number of
temporary visas for foreign "specialty" workers under the H-1B program.
Regrettably, H.R. 3736, as amended, emphasizes providing opportunities for
foreign workers rather than providing opportunities for and protecting
U.S. workers.
The Administration supports sound and balanced legislative efforts to
address shortages of skilled workers within certain sectors of our
economy.
The most important way to increase the availability of skilled
workers must be to improve the skills of u.S. workers and ensure that
employers seek U.S. workers first. While it may be necessary in the
short-term to increase the number of visas for temporary foreign workers,
this must only be done in conjunction with additional efforts to increase
the skill level of U.S. workers and meaningful reforms to the H-1B program.
Although this bill provides for certain employers to attest to recruitment
and lay-off provisions, the attestations are too weak to adequately
protect U.S. workers and far too many employers are exempt from their
obligations. Moreover, the bill, as structured, will not generate
sufficient funds for increased training opportunities for U.S. workers.
Finally, rather than strengthening enforcement to prevent employer abuses
of the H-1B program, H.R. 3736, as amended, undermines some of the
programD,s important enforcement provisions.
The Administration wants to work with the Congress to develop a bill that
addresses the growing demand for highly skilled workers, while effectively
protecting and promoting the interests of U.S. workers and enhancing the
international competitiveness of important U.S. industries.
Page 6 of7
�,
A~S
Email System
* * * * * * *
Page 7 of7
�"
A~S
Page 1 of6
Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 5-AUG-1998 09:36:59.00
SUBJECT:
LRM #IMS398 - REVISED Statement of Administration Policy on HR3736 Workfor
TO: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Zweig ( CN=Lisa Zweig/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Peterson ( CN=Michelle Peterson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=Ovp@ovp [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JUfie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie S. Mustain ( CN=Leslie S. Mustain/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Fox ( CN=Charles W. Fox/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Jo Siclari ( CN=Mary Jo Siclari/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Louisa Koch ( CN=Louisa Koch/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph G. Pipan ( CN=Joseph G. Pipan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�Page 2 of6
AR¥S Email System
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Konigsberg ( CN=Charles Konigsberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles M. Brain ( CN=Charles M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jim Kohlenberger ( CN=Jim Kohlenberger/O=OVP@OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine M. Tyer ( CN=Katherine M. Tyer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gregory G. Henry ( CN=Gregory G. Henry/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald L. Silberman ( CN=Ronald L. Silberman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�Page 3 of6
ARMS Email System
TO: Evan T. Farley ( CN=Evan T. Farley/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Rachel E. Levinson ( CN=Rachel E. Levinson/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: dodlrs ( dodlrs @ osdgc.osd.mil [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: ogc_legislation ( ogc_legislation @ ed.gov @inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: dol-sol-Ieg
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
dol-sol-Ieg @ dol.gov @ inet
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Darlene o. Gaymon ( CN=Darlene O. Gaymon/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: lrm ( lrm @ nsf.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: lrm ( lrm @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: US@2=TELEMAIL@3=GOV+TREAS@S=DO@4=MS01@7=LLR@6=TREASURY@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEM
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: mjtaylor ( mjtaylor @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: US@2=TELEMAI~@5=JMD@7=Deborah@6=Clifton@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEMAIL@5=JMD@7=Deb
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ronald E. Jones ( CN=Ronald E. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: IMS398
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
�Page 4 of6
ARMS Email System
Wednesday, August 5, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
Ronald E. Jones (for) Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
Ingrid M. Schroeder
PHONE: (202) 395-3883 FAX: (202) 395-3109
SUBJECT:
REVISED
Statement of Administration Policy on HR3736
workforce Improvement and Protection Act of 1998
FROM:
OMB CONTACT:
DEADLINE:
2pm
Wednesday, August 5, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: HR 3736 is scheduled for House floor action on Thursday, August
6th. Therefore the above deadline is firm.
The attached SAP comments on
the version of H.R. 3736 which was circulated on July 30th and is
identical to the SAP circulated on July 30th.
Please note the senior
advisors veto recommendation in the first paragraph.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - L. Anthony Sutin - (202) 514-2141
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
128-US Trade Representative - Fred Montgomery - (202) 395-3475
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
30-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
29-DEFENSE - Samuel T. Brick Jr. - (703) 697-1305
84-National Science Foundation - Lawrence Rudolph - (703) 306-1060
95-0ffice of Science and Technology Policy - Jeff Smith - (202) 456-6047
114-STATE - Paul Rademacher - (202) 647-4463
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer - (202) 395-5084
EOP:
Debra J. Bond
Larry R. Matlack
Barry White
Sandra Yamin
Barbara Chow
Steven M. Mertens
David J. Haun
Daniel J. Chenok
Evan T. Farley
Joseph G. Pipan
Ronald L. Silberman
Louisa Koch
Richard J. Turman
Mary Jo Siclari
Gregory G. Henry
Charles W. Fox
Katherine M. Tyer
�Page 5 of6
ARMS Email System
Leslie S. Mustain
Jack A. Smalligan
Julie A. Fernandes
Elena Kagan
Thomas A. Kalil
Jim Kohlenberger
David W. Beier
Cecilia E. Rouse
Sally Katzen
Gene B. Sperling
Peter G. Jacoby
Janet Murguia
Broderick Johnson
Charles M. Brain
Tracey E. Thornton
Maria Echaveste
Emil E. Parker
Robert N. Weiner
Michelle Peterson
Karen Tramontano
Rebecca M. Blank
Kate P. Donovan
Lisa Zweig
Charles Konigsberg
James J. Jukes
LRM 10: IMS398 SUBJECT:
REVISED
Statement of Administration Policy on
HR3736 Workforce Improvement and Protection Act of 1998
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
FROM:
Ingrid M. Schroeder Phone:
395-3883
Fax:
395-3109
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
�.
ARMS Email System
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
DRAFT -- NOT FOR RELEASE
August 5, 1998
(House)
H.R. 3736 - Workforce Improvement and Protection Act of 1998
(Smith (R) Texas and 3 cosponsors)
The Administration strongly opposes House passage H.R. 3736, the
D&Workforce Improvement and Protection Act of 1998,08 as amended.
If this
bill is presented to the President, his senior advisors will recommend
that he veto it.
This bill is intended to respond to a skills shortage in the information
technology industry by increasing the annual cap on the number of
temporary visas for foreign 0&specia1ty08 workers under the H-1B program.
Regrettably, H.R. 3736, as amended, emphasizes providing opportunities for
foreign workers rather than providing opportunities for and protecting
u.S. workers.
The Administration supports sound and balanced legislative efforts to
address shortages of skilled workers within certain sectors of our
economy.
The most important way to increase the availability of skilled
workers must be to improve the skills of u.S. workers and ensure that
employers seek u.s. workers first. While it may be necessary in the
short-term to increase the number of visas for temporary foreign workers,
this must only be done in conjunction with additional efforts to increase
the skill level of u.S. workers and meaningful reforms to the H-1B program.
Although this bill provides for certain employers to attest to recruitment
and lay-off provisions, the attestations are too weak to adequately
protect u.S. workers and far too many employers are exempt from their
obligations. Moreover, the bill, as structured, will not generate
sufficient funds for increased training opportunities for u.S. workers.
Finally, rather than strengthening enforcement to prevent employer abuses
of the H-1B program, H.R. 3736, as amended, undermines some of the
programO,s important enforcement provisions.
The Administration wants to work with the Congress to develop a bill that
addresses the growing demand for highly skilled workers, while effectively
protecting and promoting the interests of u.S. workers and enhancing the
international competitiveness of important U~S. industries.
* * * * * * *
Page 6 of6
�ARMS Email System
Page I of2
'/I
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 5-AUG-1998 16:04:20.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�. ARMS Email System
~
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:00am in Room 100. Thanks.
�.ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP
[ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 5-AUG-1998 17:23:36.00
SUBJECT:
See memo below
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: T J. Glauthier ( CN=T J. Glauthier/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein (CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�Page 2 of2
.. ARMS Email System
This memo was signed on Tuesday, August 4th.
MEMORANDUM FOR ERSKINE BOWLES
Jack Lew
THROUGH:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Donald R. Arbuckle
Heads-up Consumer Confidence Rule
EPA will issue by the statutory deadline of August 6th a final
rule requiring all community drinking water systems to provide their
customers with D&consumer confidenceD8 reports.
These reports must
contain information on contaminant levels detected in the systemsD,
drinking water, as well as on the EPA standards against which the detected
levels are compared to determine if they pose a" health risk.
The reports
must also contain various health warnings and information on the potential
sources of detected contaminants.
In this final rule, EPA has added a number of requirements in
response to criticisms at the proposed stage by the environmental
community. These changes include additional mandatory health warnings and
a requirement to report the range of detection levels as well as the
annual average (the average is generally used to determine compliance with
the standards). We understand that environmental groups have held press
conferences today (Tuesday) in more than 20 cities heralding the as yet
unpublished final rule but describing it as weak, and urging states and
local governments to go beyond the minimum requirements.
We concluded review yesterday so that EPA could meet its statutory
deadline.
The rule is a high priority of Administrator Browner who was
personally involved in its development, and is tentatively scheduled as
the subject for next SaturdayD,s radio address.
cc:
Maria Echaveste
Rahm Emanuel
Larry Stein
Ron Klain
Thurgood Marshall, Jr.
Ann Lewis
Sally Katzen
Minyan Moore
John Podesta
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Katy McGinty
Elena Kagan
Barry Toiv
Michael Waldman
Janet Yellen
Mickey Ibarra
T. J. Glauthier
�.
..
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 12-AUG-1998 16:39:18.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/dU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E, Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�.
• ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell
READ:UNKNOWN
( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in Room 100. Thanks.
�Page 1 of8
A,I.tMS Email System
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
OPD ] )
CREATOR: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea "Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP
CREATION DATE/TIME:13-AUG-1998 19:46:21.00
SUBJECT:
Racial Analysis of Caseload
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Robert F. Schoeni ( CN=Robert F. Schoeni/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Hrolston ( Hrolston @ acf.dhhs.gov [ UNKNOWN]
)
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Here is the information we've gathered to date.
I've included data tables
so it's 4 pages.
Elena, Bob Schoeni at CEA has all the backup data and
is happy to answer questions next week in my absence.
He is also: doing
some additional runs of characteristics associated with long-term welfare
receipt from 96 and 97 CPS data, working on backing out child-only cases,
and calculating welfare dependency by race as a way to control for
population changes (i.e. what % of total white, black and hispanic
population were on welfare in 94 vs 97) .==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ========
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D99]MAIL40792382G.226 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504365120000010A02010000000205000000F93D0000000200002D04A7175A48C47ABDD146
11628703BBE6984588C74F08B7D4C16B6F03EA6BEE8F09642DIBAB717CAOF91557DDCBD2118107
5203EBDEC946FC162806E2602D492EFA5B6B8141A234955BOC5341882D4E3BOC5C674A5CBC7157
0950510F5E5DE216B48C23BE74EF57D1754BD09BB96039FAD44B142EAC414CD34A9746E4CC6B25
OBDDB49CD77CDB2D36D4568D4E376AC41F435A5D3256677C597150BD7D21D9822DFFD8294DEB7B
2A37429C07A79BAEAA670501A2860E53AF4EBF7AE5EC6D8DCAC94FC3A6580E56EBD73945D22BB8
6DED166AC7705D2847C582642CBF26B3B8A7A6CDBBBB1048944CBCAC9B70D99CFE5590604EB680
FE79D5AA08F3C655E5670CC7247EEB1FBEBBDEBE49849E44731D547EB23A64391DD093A1C46928
B0577CEEID596F983BC117126AC9B84D04CCE3D72B24699993970F4205CD9B3EB5DA267E75743C
26DOF91CA059E408E452B90248A11CCAE2748626B35AF329AEF53673C4DA3D2F18724DF4121EOA
D94B503262AD2B6445D974002B9AAF30C64A4D1D5398F8D036B2ECA57B66AC83DF8D3C1BOEE513
46114F91E13EA7C8807F22D57AIOAFC9F0837932C7C4472F054781A7CDFD491663174123C3DE3B
C6B1E85FBC16~11B804D4F34B212398B2A24114F77201CFCE4D09B4FE44943C8B0315847A46AB4
E6D10F403402002B00000000000000000000000823010000000BOl00005A040000005504000000
4E0000006505000009250100000006000000B30500000B300200000028000000B9050000087701
00000040000000E105000008340100000014000000210600000802010000000F00000035060000
0055030000004E000000440600000805010000000800000092060000006602Q00000020000009A
060000006602000000020000009C060000006101000000i40000009E0600000066020000000200
0000B206000000610100000014000000B406000000660200000002000000C80600000061010000
�'.
Automated R,
H, ecorrJs Ma
eX-DumpConn;::~~ntSystem
WELFARE CASELOAD ANALYSIS
There are a number of factors that appear to contribute to the different rates at which the
caseloads are declining for different racial and ethnic groups. The primary factors are listed
below, along with currently available data. Staff are continuing to do additional analysis to
determine the magnitude of these factors.
The racial/ethnic composition of welfare caseloads has been changing gradually over the
last 25 years: whites rose from 38 percent in 1973 to a peak of 42 percent in 1983 and have
dropped steadily to 35 percent in 1997. The proportion of blacks has generally declined, from 46
percent in 1973 to 37 percent in 1997. The most significant trend is the increase in the Hispanic
portion ofthe caseload, from 13 percent in 1973 to 23 percent in 1997. However, this is not too
surprising given the rapid increase in the Hispanic population overall.
TOTAL
WHITE
BLACK
HISPANIC
OTHER
% Change in Total
Population 7/92-6/98
6%
2%
9%
24%
22%
% of Total Pop 6/98
100%
72%
12%
11%
4%
The question is how welfare reform may be affecting these historic trends. National data on the
racial/ethnic characteristics of welfare recipients are only available through June 1997, so it is
hard to gauge the impact of the past year when welfare reform efforts accelerated so rapidly.
States provided more recent data to the Times (generally through June 1998), but HHS has
concerns that some of these data may have problems, particularly NY and CA. They are
working with states to verify the data.
It is also worth noting that the caseload data only tells who is currently on the rolls; it does not
tell the rate at which different groups are entering and exiting. Analysis of entries and t;xits will
be conducted in the near future.
The number of white, black and Hispanic families receiving welfare have all dropped since
1994 (when caseloads peaked nationally, but the rate of decline has been greater for whites
than blacks, with an even slower decline for Hispanics.
% Change
-26%
1.4 M
Whites 1.9M
-18%
l.8M
1.5 M
Blacks
l.OM
.9M
-9%
Hispanics
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
The changes are more dramatic than the actual mix of who is left on the caseloads, at least
on a national basis.
Whites 37%
Blacks
Hispanics
35%
36%
20%
37%
23%
There is some encouraging evidence from Census data that the employment rates of former
welfare recipients are increasing even faster for minorities than for whites, although the
actual rates and the disparity between groups remains disturbing. Between 1996 and 1997, the
percentage of all prior year welfare recipients who were employed in the next year increased by
28%. The increase was highest for blacks (33%), followed by Hispanics (22%) and whites
(21 %).
Minorities on welfare disproportionately share characteristics that may make it harder to
leave the rolls. These factors include: lower education levels, lower marriage rates, larger
families, isolation from areas with jobs, and employment and housing discrimination. March 95
Current Population Survey Data shows the following characteristics for public assistance
recipients in 1994:
TOTAL
WHITE
BLACK
HISPANIC
% with <HS
diploma
42%
33%
40%
64%
%.never married
43%
31%
61%
40%
> 2 children
30%
20%
38%
38%
Live in central
city
51%
31%
71%
63%
CEA is running comparable data for the March 1996 and 1997 CPS.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Historical data confirms that minorities are more likely to remain on the welfare rolls
longer. At the same time, the proportion oflong-tenn recipients on the rolls is increasing
slightly. This would partially explain why the current rate of caseload decline is slower for
minorities and why they are making up an increasing share of the welfare caseload.
% of cases in each group
on welfare for 61-120
months (in current spell)
FY 1995
FY 1996
FY 1997 (9 mos)
White
12%
14%
14%
Black
16%
17%
20%
Hispanics
14%
18%
19%
The trends in marriage rates and births to unmarried women could contribute to an
increasing proportion of minority families going on welfare. While the proportion of
never-married single mothers is increasing for the entire population, the rate of is largest for
Hispanic women (based on CPS data).
% Change
1992
1997
30%
35%
17%
White
17%
21%
24%
Black
51%
55%
8%
Hispanic
33%
42%
27%
% of all single mothers who were
never married
Never-married single mothers by
race:
In addition, the rate of births to unmarried teenagers remains much higher for blacks and
Hispanics than for whites. And, while the rate is decreasing significantly for blacks and slightly
for whites, it continues to increase for Hispanics. For example, between 1991 and 1996, the rate
of births to unmarried teenagers decreased 18% for blacks and 4% for whites, but increased 3%
for Hispanics.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Minorities are a disproportionately represented in child-only cases. To the extent that child
only cases are decreasing more slowly than cases headed by adults, this would appear to
contribute to the increasing proportion of minorities on the caseload.
FY96
% of child only
cases by race
FY96
% of cases
headed by adults
by race
FY 97 (9 mos)
% of child only
cases by race
FY96
% of cases
headed by adults
by race
915,500
TOTAL #
978,300
WHITE
28%
36%
27%
35%
BLACK
40%
37%
40%
37%
HISPANIC
26%
21%
27%
23%
HHS is working on additional analysis of child only cases, by state and by reason, to determine
whether the magnitude of this factor on the changing racial composition of the caseloads
nationally and in specific states.
�ARMS Email System
Page I of 2
- \.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-AUG-1998 16:48:51.00
SUBJECT:
CANCELLED-Women's Mtg
TO: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be no Women's Meeting this week! Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
t.
•
_
Page 1 of 3
._~I
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-AUG-1998 15:29:40.00
SUBJECT:
Advanced Airbags proposed rule Heads-up
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
.READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP.[ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 }
CC: victoria Wassmer ( CN=victoria Wassmer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
Linda Ricci ( CN=Linda Ricci/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
August 28,1998
MEMORANDUM FOR ERSKINE BOWLES
THROUGH:
Jack Lew
FROM:
Donald Arbuckle
SUBJECT:
Heads-up -- Department of TransportationD,s proposed rule
on Advanced Airbags
We have just received the Department of TransportationD,s National
Highway Traffic
AdministrationD,s (NHTSA) proposed rule that requires the development of
advanced airbag
technology and their introduction in vehicles over a phase in period from
MY 2003-MY 2006.
This rule is part of the long-term solution NHTSA has designed to address
the adverse side
effects of airbag technology. Although airbags have saved 3,148 lives
since their introduction in
1986, they have also caused 105 known fatalities.
The proposed advanced
airbag standard is
flexible and allows auto manufactures a broad range of technological
possibilities, from weight
sensors to dual-stage airbags, which are estimated to cost between $4-$162
per vehicle. The
preliminary analysis indicates that the significant cost of the rule, up
to $2.5 billion annually
(based on predicted costs of the high cost technological option and annual
sales of 15.5 million
vehicles) is balanced by substantial benefits - - the avoidance of
fatalities to the high risk
population -- infants, children under the age of 12, and small stature
adults - - and the avoidance
of property damage expenses due to unnecessary airbag deployment.
The proposal also includes other noteworthy provisions that
require auto manufacturers
to: test using a 5th percentile (small stature) adult female, 12-month old
infant, and 3 and 6-year
old dummies, in addition to the 50th percentile male dummy currently
required;- add several new
crash tests, including a choice among three low-speed tests and a dynamic
offset crash test; and,
sunset the sled test option after advanced airbags are introduced by the
industry.
These new
provisions should not surprise the interested public; in fact the American
Automobile
Manufacturers Association petitioned NHTSA to include additional dummies
in the test
Page 2 of3
�ARMS Email System
requirements. However, sunsetting the sled test is controversial. The
auto companies favor the
sled test because it is cheap, repeatable, and as opposed to the barrier
crash test, a vehicle is not
destroyed. NHTSA is fearful that the safety benefits of airbags are
compromised by the sled test
because the test is a simulation of a crash, not an actual crash; and, as
manufactures change their
airbag design to optimize for the sled test, the consequence could be
smaller bags that protect
less surface area.
NHTSA is anxious for the rule to be published to meet the
September 1st statutory
deadline. We believe the agency has written a technology forcing proposed
rule that is focused
on the problems with current airbag technology and, at this proposed
stage, maintains a great
deal of flexibility for new developments in technology.
Page 3 of3
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
,.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 2-SEP-1998 16:56:15.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
'TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G.
READ: UNKNOWN
Cutler/OU~WHO/O=EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sondra L. Seba ( CN=Sondra L. Seba/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
,.
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leslie. Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
�''\.~
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of24
1 , ..
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
CREATOR:
(NOTES MAIL)
"Christopher Edley, Jr." <edley@law.harvard.edu> ( "Christopher Edley, Jr."
CREATION DATE/TIME: 4-SEP-1998 17:22:11.00
SUBJECT:
Draft POTUS memo on race book
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward W. Correia ( CN=Edward W. Correia/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 ')
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Cavataio ( CN=Michele Cavataio/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S. Redburn/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Charles F, Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: terry.edmonds@ssa.gov ( terry.edmonds@ssa.gov [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD
�ARMS Email System
"
Page 2 of24
fl
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: aedmondsl@home.com ( aedmondsl@home.com [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Jane T. Price-Smith ( CN=Jane T. Price-Smith/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lin Liu ( CN=Lin Liu/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michael Wenger ( CN=Michael Wenger/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jacinta Ma ( CN=Jacinta Ma/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: David Campt ( CN=David Campt/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: John M. Goering ( CN=John M. Goering/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michele Cavataio ( CN=Michele Cavataio/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Scott R. Palmer ( CN=Scott R. Palmer/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TEXT:
Comrades:
Have a good weekend. You will enjoy it more if you take a look at the
attached draft memorandum, which has been sent to the Staff Secretary for
clearance. Maria is holding a clearance meeting on Tuesday afternoon at 4
pm, but comments are welcome before or after that. The memo is due in to
POTUS mid-week. Sorry I couldn't finish this earlier in the day.
- Memo-v6.wpd==================== ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
1 ====================
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D26]MAIL46818274N.226 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504305630000010A0201000000020500000052840100000200000B07C5FE67E807EE65E852
CB3D35DC586A6738F72CBIB6ECA51C659D7FDB5C8FFD266DFB99A551D293E6CE0902536A495F97
632F9992D4928B507D27D72FEC13E2DB9C85BI0787F5D693B47697F02911724C40B6F5D5EII04B
5CC662E6B3DE2E2893630459A22613A0894E0336817809C735B589OF93018CEE17C55812FA5DEO
6ADAOE83877BDFF44230D7539C35162AOC09C48AAI0563F790E35632744E9C64D2D65528549524
D86A617E6E55B281F281FDBD17CC4ACFCA2304793FBEEE3223DBF38CA9AC4D4F39486BB233283A
EECEFIA71E9D43B2C8249ED4DB34097F58BCF33A2244582ACAB25388386CD35BD64FC9F22BACB5
4EE978F3037D5DD2EE2B40785276BBCF7137D691A016CF4829BC89666C8481AC6AA08D460ADBFF
2059648B5D6A409A406F41CD19EA85B82D393656E28957B6CCFF626717CD533C6388CAADEB42FF
E5AC18476346265E58F80AD757D3134F16FCIDE3348A46764428C27993FC8A06F98ECIE6CF2B8A
FBC02COD27BDF30662F9C2A439A9755FE244596E1320C7608DEE3753FDFEDAD2AE14956EBF768B
8C59A4527907BD515E9680D2BEFF5168177B0060575A94850EFB0598186Bll16554E99E4D4C98E
46E7FA265E578606E39532EDD24E40BA64DD7EBAFE504234B17B55B7F07CFC7950AB4B5CB09D7B
DBB92DE43B0200940000000000000000000000084DOI00000004000000180A0000005546000000
�••
AutoMated Records Managel!'ent System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft v6
September 9, 1998
MEMORANDUM FOR THE PRESIDENT
Jr.
From:
Christopher Edley,
Professor of Law
Through:
Maria Echaveste
Deputy Chief of Staff
Re:
Progress Report on the Race Book, and Request for Interim Guidance
This memorandum is organized in the following sections:
I.
II.
III.
IV.
V.
Introduction, process and organization of the effort
The Vision (book chapter 2), and basic themes
The Workplan (chapter 6)
Leadership (chapter 7)
Next steps, and summary of decisions requested
L INTRODUCTION, PROCESS AND ORGANIZATION OF THE EFFORT
The purpose of this memorandum is to review our progress, confirm our general direction, and
solicit interim guidance on a few substantive matters. Most important, Part II is a first attempt
to sketch your ''vision'' of One America with racial justice and equal opportunity in the 21 st
century. Then, Part III adds some flesh to key portions of the "workplan" chapter outline you
have already seen, offering a partial menu of ideas. l We want to know if this conceptual
IThe current detailed (and daunting) outline of the book is at Tab A. The chapter outline is:
Introduction:
One America in the 21" Century
Where Is America On Race, And Where Are We Going?
Chapter 1:
p.l
�\.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
framework makes sense, and if we are heading for the right mix of bold and pedestrian, thematic
and programmatic. White House policy staff are fully engaged and have both contributed to
this workplan material and reviewed this memorandum. Important disagreements and special
concurrences are noted in this document or accompanying memoranda.
We hope to complete the workplan menu within two weeks and, based on your tentative
approval of several ideas, proceed with more detailed policy development between now and early
November. This is key: I want these first stages of developing the workplan to emphasize
thoughtfulness and boldness in the selection of the challenges, goals, themes and general
strategies, connecting those to the vision. The next step, for greater detail over the next two
months, is to figure out more concretely what ought to be done by whom (federal government?
parents?). Throughout, Maria Echaveste will ensure that the interests of the policy councils are
well regarded, that the formal clearance process is used when appropriate, and that I can appeal
to you with any conflicts we cannot resolve in a timely way.
We have four working groups to help prepare the policy, or "workplan" chapter. These are
co-led by the appropriate NEC or DPC staff and me. As yet, they do not span the entire range of
subjects you may want to cover, but they are a good start:
Education
Economic Development and Employment Opportunity
Criminal Justice and Community Security
Civil Rights Enforcement
We also have less elaborate collaborative discussions moving forward on: Health, Strengthening
- Families, Native Americans, and Democracy/Civic Engagement. The "book team" includes a
handful of PIR staff, and the addition soon of Terry Edmonds. I'm confident that several White
House and OMB staff will also play critical roles, as they have in preparation of this document.
Outreach: Finally, Maria has assigned Minyon Moore and OPL the overall responsibility for
coordinating external consultations by the outreach offices and, through Cabinet Affairs,
conversations with key appointees iri the agencies. Throughout September, many members of
your staff will be making calls or conducting meetings with some 400 individuals, asking aboutChapter 2:
Chapter 3:
Chapter 4:
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
Chapter
5:
6:
7:
8:
More Than A Dream: Racial And Ethnic Justice In The 21" Cenmry
Wrestling Lessons: Honest, Constructive Engagement Of Our Vexing Differences Promising Practices: How To Build Bridges That Connect People Across Lines Of Class And
Color, Creating Community And Oppormnity
The Record Of The Clinton-Gore Administration
A Workplan For Our Nation
Leadership For One America
Conclusion
p.2
�,.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
the proposed framework for your report, the most important actions you should take after the
Advisory Board's work, and any elements they think it is especially important for you to
communicate in your report. We will share some of the substantive responses with you, but all of
them will be weighed by the book team.
**
II THE VISION CHAPTER, AND BASIC THEMES
This section summarizes my best sense of your central vision for the book -- chapter 2 in the
current outline. It builds on earlier material sent to you by Sidney Blumenthal and by me, as well
as previous statements by you. In the book, the vision discussion will be preceded by an
introduction and by the chapter describing where America has been and is on race, including
demographics, discrimination, disparities, and intergroup relations. While not yet in your
language, what follows is an effort to capture the key ideas and their interrelationships. At the end
of the section, we also want to engage you on some cross-cutting questions, such as the role of
government.
(a)
Why is this subject so important for us to tackle?
. Renewing America [or the new century: For six years, I have worked to prepare America
for the challenges of the 21 st century. We have put our fiscal house in order, taken
important steps to strengthen the international economic system, worked at home and
abroad to create a post-cold war national security framework, launched an investment
program in vital areas of education, training, new technologies and environmental
protection. One additional area, without which we cannot succeed in the decades ahead,
is overcoming the divisions of race and ethnicity so that we can be One America, united
in a web of mutuality that gives us the strength to be our best as individuals, as
communities and as a nation.
Global and historical context' The difficulty of the problem is evident not only from our
own national history, but from events around the world - even today. The conflict is
commonplace, as differences give rise to hatreds and then bloodshed. As President, I've
seen it over and over again, and struggled to find ways that, through our actions and
example, this nation could help troubled societies see their shared humanity and find
peace. But make no mistake: This struggle to build peace and strength out of differences
is a struggle against deep failings and sinfulness that seem inherent in the human spirit. In
p.3
�"
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
my own religious tradition, sin can be overcome through struggle and faith, and it is a
never-ending struggle. We should expect no easier a task when it comes to dealing with
our differences here in America.
.
The stakes: On a more practical plane, making diversity a source of strength rather than
division promises great rewards in social peace and home and economic success globally.
New complexity: The civil rights movement of three and four decades ago was largely
framed in black and white, but led to bursts of energy and progress for other minorities
and for women. Today's diversity gives us great opportunities, but also more complex
challenges.
Cause for confidence: There is cause for confidence, because our ideals and values are far
more than words locked behind glass in the National Archives. They are an incandescent
beacon for peoples worldwide, and the lodestar by which we chart our own course and
criticize our missteps. Our noblest moments and wisest leaders are marked not by the
exploitation of difference, but by recalling us to the commitments of equality, tolerance,
opportunity and justice. In my life, I have seen this most profoundly in the struggle
against racial segregation and bigotry. No nation matches our capacity for moral
greatness.
(b)
What would it mean to have afull measure of radaJ justice and opportunity in America?
What would our relationships be like, and what would sodety look like?
Vision ofcommunity: [Celebration of our diversity, not mere tolerance of our differences;
building inclusive communities and organizations to take advantage of the benefits and
strengths that flow from diversity. (Examples from forums, correspondence, etc.)]
"One America" does not mean that we lose our ethnic identities, becoming some
homogenized undifferentiated mass. We can be proud of our cultural identities and
distinctiveness, and at the same time be proud of and loyal to America - indeed, that is
one of the most important elements of our nation's greatness.
In religion, for example, scholars tell us that we are the most observant of developed
nations, and that freedom of religion and separation of church and state are' important
parts of the explanation. We are a nation full of religious individuals, yet we do not all
worship in the same way. Indeed, our civic values are that we tolerate and respect
different religious traditions, and celebrate the legal and civic values that make diversity
pA
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
possible. We are proud of that diversity, and together with tolerance, recognize it as a
defining greatness of America. And much of the rest of the world recognizes this too.
So, too, with our racial and ethnic diversity. Our greatness in the decades ahead depends
not merely on overcoming prejudice and bigotry rooted in our differences, and not only
in tolerating differences. We must instead celebrate those differences as a source of
richness and strength. Our personal lives are enriched by this diversity, and our society
and economy are strengthened by it.
In the community of America, the things that connect us must be stronger than those that
divide us. A "community" means shared interests. But we must also have a shared
concern for our collective advancement, and mutual concern for each other. Transcending
differences, while respecting them, is part of creating such a community.
So there is a delicate balance, because we have far too much to lose if we retreat into
ethnic enclaves - walled off from one another by prejudice, stereotypes or even simple
ignorance and misunderstanding. We sacrifice greatness and goodness, richness and
riches, if by circumstance or choice we separate ourselves into subcommunities along the
very fracture lines that have traced our national racial tragedies since Europeans arrived on
these shores.
Vision of opportunity: [Opportunity enjoyed so equally that there is no discernable legacy
of slavery, colonization or conquest; of Jim Crow or internment. (Examples from forums,
correspondence etc.)]
We have legacies of slavery, conquest and colonialism; of Jim Crow and racist
immigration quotas. The inheritance is evident in the patterns of our lives: the racially
isolated communities, .the gaping disparities in educational achievement, employment,
criminal victimization and wealth; the still too-rare close friendships across lines of race.
This inheritance is a burden to our spirits and a tax on our prosperity. Perhaps most
tragically, for too many of our fellow citizens, the legacy has shackled dreams that are
every American's inalienable right. This is wrong, and we can do better.
One way our children and grandchildren will know when we have achieved racial justice
and opportunity is that the evidence of America's legacy of inequality will be found only
in history books, and not in brutal social and economic disparities surrounding them.
Vision ofresponsibility: Responsibilities of citizenship; responsibility to reach out to
others; responsibility of each of to combat whatever stereotypes and fears we may have;
p.5
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
and responsibility to take advantage of opportunities. (Examples from forums, letters, etc.)
We must do this for our children and their children. We must do this to honor those
who have sacrificed over the generations in earlier battles, including civil rights battles, to
put our sacred civic values into practice. And I believe we must do this to honor the God
who has created us all equal, and blessed our nation in so many countless ways.
(c)
Why is this vision preferable to alternative, competing visions?
Why embracing "equal opportunity" is necessary, but insufficient alone to produce a full
measure of justice and fairness in One America.
Why color blindness makes sense, and why it doesn't.
Why assimilation as Americans is important, but not an assimilation that seeks to erase
our diverse identities. Is tolerance of differences sufficient, or must there be more?
**
IlL THE WORKPLAN CHAPTER
The purpose of this chapter is to explain the most important steps the nation must take over the
next decade in pursuit of your vision of racial justice and opportunity, as described earlier in the
book. As with the promising practices chapter, you want to provide inspiring "news you can
use" to people in communities and organizations across the nation who are looking for ideas.
The workplan is organized by policy sectors, and within each sector it will contain federal, state,
local, private and personal elements. This is not just about the federal government, or
government generally. Few items will have FY 2000 budget impacts, although several will have
"down payments" in Administration accomplishments and earlier proposals. (The ideas which
follow reflect substantial contributions from DPC, NEC and OMB; this memorandum has been
through an accelerated clearance process. Comments from your advisors are noted in this
document or in appended memoranda.)
The book should be highly thematic, avoiding an exhaustive and mind-numbing recitation of
comprehensive programmatic details. But it must contain just enough pointed recommendations
to leave the reader with a sense that you have provided concrete direction, not just rhetoric. This
also entails being very selective - not every good idea for addressing evelY important problem.
In areas where thoughtfulness or clarity requires more program detail, the final document can use
p.6
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
textual boxes set apart from the flow of the narrative.
Two final points. The boldness you have requested in policy ideas seems in some cases to come
in the statement of a national goal ("close disparities in education achievement by X percent"),
and in other cases may not be evident until we offer specific public or private interventions to
advance the goal. Relatedly, in the stating the goals we have repeatedly between brave aspirations
and statements that are more cautious and achievable. We need your general guidance on this.
*
§ 6.2
THE EDUCATION SECI'ION OF THE WORKPLAN
Apart from the economy, I assume that education will be the clearfirst-among-equals in your
workplan for the nation, receiving disproportionate emphasis throughout the book. Despite
improvements over the last several decades, racial disparities in opportunity and achievement
persist throughout the education pipeline, and these disparities are powerful obstacles to
achieving your vision. We've tolerated it for too long. It is wrong. Therefore, the workplan
focuses on areas of significant disparity that have the greatest impact on educational outcomes.
It also emphasizes the instrumental and ethical necessity of heightened responsibility and
accountability.
In addition, racial isolation, often in combination with poverty concentration, remajns a problem
both among and within our schools, presenting barriers to achievement, excellence, and to your
vision of mutual understanding and community. This is the third pillar of the education
workplan.
-- Outline of the section
Introduction/Context
•
Education is primary [only central?] to achieving my vision. This requires:
(1)
(2)
(3)
eliminating racial disparities in educational opportunity and achievement;
reinforcing responsibility and strengthening accountability for
administrators, teachers and students, as well as for the political
institutions governing education; and
promoting racial and economic integration in education.
p.7
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
•
•
(a)
These problems have long gone unsolved because they are difficult and because
race has divided us, but also because we need to reassess the roles of the different
levels of government and of the family in education. The old formulas need
revision, the old problems need new thinking, and the old values need new life.
We need to provide every family, regardless of race or zip code, with an
Education Bill ofRights. 2
Close the racial gap in opportunity and achievement. Notwithstanding important
progress, significant racial disparities in achievement persist. We must close these gaps
and raise the bar for everyone. This means overcoming racial disparities in the
educational opportunity available to every child - including both resources and
expectations - and simultaneously insisting on high standards for achievement. Beyond
this, we must improve our ability to make targeted, individualized efforts to ensure that
every child succeeds to his or her full potential. Among the key elements of an education
bill of rights for equal opportunity and achievement:
Parenting and early childhood: Ensure that every child has a parent or other adult
actively engaged in that child's learning, and that every young child has access to early
learning opportunities.
Teaching: Improve the quality of teacher training, ensure that high-quality teachers are
equitably distributed, and ensure that teachers promote high expectations for students of
all races.
Curriculum and standards: Ensure that every child has access to challenging curricula
tied to high standards, and that tracking does not prevent any child from achieving his or
Such a Bill of Rights might include the following:
(1)
Every child shall have a parent or other adult actively engaged in hisJher learning and have access to support
services to help that child achieve to hisJher full potential.
(2)
Every child shall have access to early learning opportunities.
(3)
All parents have the right to send their children to equitably funded schools that are accountable for their
child's learning.
(4)
Every child shall have access to high-quality teachers.
(5)
Every child shall be held to high expectations and standards and have access to challenging curricula.
(6)
Every child shall have access to adequate facilities and modern technology.
(7)
Every LEP child shall have access to the tools necessary to help himJher learn English within three years.
(8)
Every child shall learn in a safe environment.
(9)
All parents and children shall have the right to choose to attend racially and ethnically integrated schools.
(10)
Every high school graduate shall have the financial support and opportunity to go to college.
2
p.8
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
her full potential. Students of color are often tracked into special education and out of
honors courses.
English acquisition: Guarantee each LEP child an effective opportunity to master
English, and hold students and educators accountable for success.
Infrastructure: Close the racial disparity in full access to adequate facilities and modem
technology.
Post-secondary attainment: Overcome racial disparities in high school graduation rates,
and in college participation, retention and graduation rates.
(b)
Institute greater accountability and heightened responsibility for administrators,
teachers, students and public officials. Without much stronger mechanisms for
accountability, the goals of closing disparities in opportunity and achievement are mere
aspirations, not commitments. Moreover, to break the back of inertia and complacency
we will have to design interventions that target the political, bureaucratic and
jurisdictional impediments to sustained reform. The Voluntary National Test is such an
intervention, as is public school choice, and we must build on such approaches while
providing needed safeguards against abuses.
Tests and accountability: Use the best assessment methods, including national tests, to
build broader and deeper systems that will hold administrators, teachers, and students
accountable for educational achievement. The accountability should flow "up" from
parents and "down" from Federal taxpayers and presidential leadership. The range of
tools, both carrots and sticks, should stretch from more effective parental action, to
political mobilization, to school reconstitution or receivership, to fiscal incentives - and
everything in between.
Governance and leadership: If eliminating the disparities in opportunity and achievement
require modifications of our traditional structure of roles and authority, so be it. We need
new ways to think about old problems.
(c)
Promote integration and diversity in education to enrich the learning experience for
aU students. We also care about integration, so that students have the opportunity to
leain together in ways that dissolve stereotypes and improve race relations. Parents and
students should have a right to chose an integrated education. But, after a burst of
progress in the late 1960s and early 1970s, segregation in K-12 education is worsening.
For example, a recent study reports that one-third of black and Hispanic students attend
schools with more than 90 percent minority emollment, and almost nine in 10 of those
p.9
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
schools are predominantly poor. High-quality integrated schools provide a more
complete educational experience for all students than high-quality segregated schools.
Conversely, ineffective, racially isolated schools in high-poverty areas present our
greatest obstacle to closing the disparities in opportunity and achievement.
Educate the public on the value of inclusion, diversity and integration -- reviving that
ideal: An inclusive community of students and educators can: improve teaching and
learning by enriching the learning environment with diverse perspectives; strengthen
students' critical-thinking skills by challenging their existing perspectives; teach students
how to interact comfortably with people different from themselves and thereby how to
function as good neighbors, colleagues and citizens in our diverse democratic society;
improve students' preparation for employment by teaching them the value of diverse
perspectives, how to function in diverse business settings, and how to communicate
effectively in our increasingly diverse domestic marketplace and the expanding global
marketplace; and foster the advancement of knowledge by spurring study in new areas of
concern.
<
Reduce racial segregation and isolation among schools: This is not a call for massive,
federally mandated strategies where there is no constitutional violation demanding
court-supervised remedies. Instead, parents and educators should make use of a range of
measures such as magnet schools, multidistrict transfer programs, and so forth. Most
important, we must better appreciate the important stake we have in making diversity
work in the world of our children. Schools of unquestioned excellence are the easiest to
make and keep diverse.
Reduce segregation within schools: Even in diverse schools, evidence shows that
students are often resegregated into racially homogenous classes through tracking and
other mechanisms, thereby reducing their opportunities to learn together and have
positive cross-racial interactions.
Inclusion in higher education: Promote access and diversity in higher education, and
foster the educational benefits of diversity. Mend, don't end, affirmative action. And
wherever possible, use creative race-neutral mechanisms in admissions and in the K-12
pipeline. Ensure that in sustaining the crucial role ofHBCUs, HSIs, and Tribal colleges
(which are integrated) we don't "excuse" historically white institutions from the principle
of excellence-through-inclusion.
- Discussion issues on the education workplan
Are you comfortable with the three major pillars: closing the race gap in opportunity and
achievement; accountability and governance; attacking racial isolation?
p.lO
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Do the bulleted items capture your personal priorities? Are any high priorities missing?
Can any of them be demoted for attention in textual boxes rather than in your narrative?
Can we explore some rethinking of the federal role in order to tackle these disparities?
*
§ 6.4
CRIMINAL JUSTICE AND COMMUNITY SECURITY
From hate crimes to crack houses, from police misconduct to police hiring, from disparate
incarceration rates to racial profiling -- barely a week goes by without some aspect of crime and
criminal justice standing as a lightening rod for racial and ethnic tensions. No area is more
freighted with divisive stereotypes and misunderstanding. Yet it must be tackled with vigor
because victimization and criminality destroy communities and families, just as they fuel
alienation and division.
- Outline of the section
Introduction/Context
•
Racial disparities exist in both the realities and perceptions of crime and the
administration of justice: communities of color disproportionately bear the social,
economic, and personal costs of crime, and, according to polls, have less
confidence in the fairness of the criminal justice system than do whites.
•
Building One America requires building a criminal justice system that serves and
treats Americans of all races fully and fairly, and thereby closes the trust gap
while making community security a right enjoyed equally.
(a)
Community Security: Eliminate racial disparities in victimization. The right to be
secure cannot be discounted by race. Every American is entitled to live in a safe
community, and the race of residents shouldn't tell us the crime rate. From 1992 to
1997, rates of violent crime in America have decreased, but disparate victimization rates
persist. Tackling this problem directly is part of the opportunity agenda, as well as a
matter of decent fairness. The Administration's record has numerous elements, which
we can build upon and target to close the disparities.
(b)
Keep young people out of the criminal justice system, and for those who have
contact with it, make it their last. Racial minorities, especially young, black males, are
more likely than whites to be both the offenders and victims of certain crimes, including
p.ll
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
violent crimes. Furthermore, one third of young, black men are presently under the
supervision of the criminal justice system (on probation, in prison, or on parole), and the
chance that a young, black male will go to prison during his lifetime is nearly 30%. The
realities are flatly inconsistent an American vision of racial justice and equal opportunity.
(c)
Build greater fairness and trust in the criminal system. Several past and present
factors contribute to mistrust in our criminal justice system among persons of color,
including negative interactions, disparities in the administration of justice (incarceration,
sentencing, death penalty), and lagging diversity in law enforcement (police, prosecutors,
judges, juries). Without more trust, creating safe communities is impossible, because
legitimacy, support and cooperation don't come free.
Prohibit the use of racial profiling.) No American should be subject to disparate
application of the state's policing power because ofhislher race. Statistically efficient
allocation of resources, some claim, justifies impositions on innocent persons, while
perpetuating stereotypes and contributing to tensions. Targeting based on color, without
individualized evidence, is rarely if ever fair and just.
Pursue zero tolerance for racially suspect police misconduct and brutality: While the
vast majority of police are dedicated public servants who deserve our respect and support,
several high-profile cases illustrate that incidents of police misconduct and brutality
motivated by racial animus still occur. We are deeply divided in perceptions of the
magnitude of the problem.
Eliminate racial discrimination and unjustified disparities in incarceration, sentencing,
and imposition of the death penalty ..
Increase diversity and representation in the criminal justice system.
- Discussion issues on the criminal justice workplan
Can we speak of community safety as a "right", and the racial disparities in victimization
as flatly inconsistent with your vision? If so, are disparities a fair index of this aspect of
racial justice and opportunity?
Should we "prohibit" racial profiling, or "restrict" it?
3Proflling will also be considered in the "Wrestling Lessons" chapter, as one of the hard questions that forces us to
think about differences in values and perceptions.
p.12
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Similarly, should we tackle disparities in rates of incarceration, presumably with targeted
attention to prevention, diversion and post-incarceration?
Can we assume that the primary public sector role is state and local, or do you envision
continued growth in the federal role?
*
§ 6.7
THE CIVIL RIGHTS ENFORCEMENT SECTION OF THE WORKPLAN
We have considered distributing the civil rights law enforcement issues in several sectoral
subsections - as components of the education or jobs strategies, for example. But for now, I want
to press ahead as sketched below because the audience will appropriately expect some attention
to the traditional antidiscrimination enforcement agenda. This also permits you to teach about
this unfinished work. Moreover, the best opportunities for boldness are in cross cutting issues,
among them: policy judgments about the lawfulness under Title VI of persistent resource
disparities; retooling agency enforcement strategies to emphasize proactive technical assistance
and voluntary. action; and rethinking the legal framework and enforcement priorities to reflect our
21 51 century diversity.
We are joined at the hip with Chuck Ruff, and will cooperate in his effort to put before you
suggested civil rights enforcement priorities for the next two years.
- Outline of the section
Introduction/Context
Persistence of discrimination, and of enforcement backlogs.
We have opportunities to strengthen and more aggressively enforce civil rights principles,
and also support appropriate voluntary actions that promote equal opportunity and access.
This includes defending disparate impact doctrine, and defending affirmative action.
The traditional agenda needs renovation to (i) increase its efficiency at handling the retail
problem of discrimination; (ii) contribute more directly to the opportunity agenda in
education, jobs and community economics; (iii) reflect our 21 51 century diversity.
(a)
Overcome racial disparities in opportunity by expanding the use of civil rights
enforcement. Civil rights enforcement can play an especially important role in
p.13
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
overcoming barriers to educational and economic opportunity, and we should strengthen
and focus civil rights enforcement to complement the opportunity agenda.
Strengthen antidiscrimination laws and enforcement procedures: For example, we
could amend Title II, which prohibits discrimination in public accommodations, to
include businesses that provide goods and services. At present, racial discrimination in
retail sales (e.g., the Eddie Bauer case in which a black teenager was ordered by a security
guard to strip off his shirt because he did not have a sales receipt) does not raise a strong
federal cause of action. We nearly abandoned pattern and practice investigations during
the 1980s. That was wrong.
Use Title VI to address racial disparities: No federal money should be spent in a
manner that supports unjustified racial disparities in opportunity. For example, in
education, Title VI prohibits policies and practices that have an unjustified disparate
impact on select racial groups in terms of access to educational resources, tracking into
challenging courses, the use of unvalidated high stakes tests, and more. We should
strengthen Title VI enforcement.
How much discrimination is there? We should expand research on the extent of racial
discrimination, using the best available methodologies (testers where appropriate), in
such areas as employment, housing, and access to capital. The results of such testing
should be published in an annual report card.
(b)
Fully address all forms of discrimination affecting our increasingly diverse
population by strengthening civil rights laws and enforcement. We must retool our
civil rights laws and refocus enforcement efforts to fully address civil rights issues
affecting our diverse citizenry.
New immigrants: Strengthen laws and enforcement to promote the rights of new
immigrants. For example, in immigration and employment, we could expand
enforcement against labor abuses in "sweatshops," the victims of which are often new
immigrants of Hispanic or Asian origin, and amend present laws to stabilize the
immigration status of persons who report labor abuses so those persons do not fear
reprisal, official or private.
Language acquisition: Promote the rights of LEP populations. For example, in
education, we could develop regulations to clarify the Lau standard concerning what legal
requirements schools must meet in educating LEP students.
Learning your rights: Educate immigrant and LEP populations about civil rights laws
and mechanisms. We should promote outreach to immigrant and LEP populations
whose rights are protected but who are underutilizing civil rights laws.
p.14
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
(c)
Address discrimination and disparities by promoting voluntary efforts in
conjunction with enforcement of civil rights laws. In addition to reacting to civil
rights complaints, civil rights enforcement agencies should act proactively to encourage
and support voluntary compliance with civil rights laws and values.
Expand civil rights consultations and clarifY legal standards: There are civil rights
areas where both the law and policy are unclear and where people of good will may be
managing inappropriate programs. We should act to clarify legal standards and to
encourage actors to seek guidance concerning their civil rights obligations. We could
promote laws or regulations encouraging voluntary consultations with civil rights
agencies. If an actor voluntarily submits hislher practice for civil rights review, he/she is
safe harbored and/or any agreement approved by the civil rights agency following that
review would be defended by the federal government if later challenged by a third party.
Expand proactive enforcement: Absent a formal complaint, where potential civil rights
violations are discovered, civil rights agencies should follow up with the party to correct
the injustice. If discussions are not fruitful, the enforcement agency reserves the right to
launch a more formal civil rights enforcement examination. For example, in education,
the Department of Education's Office of Civil Rights (OCR) recently learned of a
Georgia education policy that placed students into gifted and talent programs based solely
on IQ test scores, despite the fact that the IQ test was not validated for that purpose nor
validated to be the sale factor for any purpose. This policy led to a disproportionately
low number of minority students being admitted to gifted and talented programs. OCR
consulted with Georgia officials, and the policy was properly amended.
(d)
Mend, don't end, affirmative action as enforcement remedy and voluntary measure
to promote access and inclusion
(e)
[Hate crimes.]
-- Discussion issues on the civil rights workplan
Mter further interagency discussion, we will need policy guidance about a number of
Title VI issues.
Should we develop a package addressing "the new diversity"?
p.1S
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
How much technical assistance should be done proactively to implement "mend don't
end" in various sectors?
**
IV.
THE LEADERSHIP CHAn'ER
Following the workplan chapter, you can challenge leaders in a range of sectors to do their part,
and combine this with a vision of locally-based efforts to use the promising practices and devise
locally-oriented workplans. Finally, in this chapter you should describe the ongoing mechanism
within the White House to help support the sectoral leadership, community-based leadership, and
the Federal government elements of your workplan.
(a)
Challenges for sectoralleadership
We expect, by the publication date, to have worked successfully with leadership groups in a few
sectors, prompting them to develop a list of action steps tailored to their sector, and a practical
strategy for implementation. A brief status report on what we have initiated follows.
Higher Education: With staff support from the American Council on Education, a core
group of college and university presidents is working to establish a broader coalition that
will lead a coordinated campaign to educate the public about the value of diversity in
higher education and to share campus practices that promote diversity. We expect them to
launch the effort, designed with Frank Greer as lead consultant, sometime this fall.
(There is a possibility of using a White House event to bless the undertaking.)
Faith Community: Sandy Cloud of the National Conference for Community and
Justice has agreed to lead a steering committee in convening, on October 22 and
October 23, an implementation summit at which a group of faith leaders will write
and commit to a practical work plan for both national and community-based action, and
devise a coalition mechanism for follow through. This will include special efforts to reach
those faith communities that have not traditionally been leaders in racial justice. In
addition, at your September 11 breakfast for religious leaders, you will have an .
opportunity to mention Sandy Cloud's leadership, and encourage those in the room to
respond positively to the effort.
p.16
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-DurnP Conversion
Corporate: Secretary Daley will infonnally convene a group of CEOs in October to
identify the most appropriate elements of a corporate sector initiative, and strategies for
enlisting support from key executives. In preparation for that session, White House and
agency staff will brainstonn with some current and fanner Administration officials in
corporate leadership.
Youth: We are organizing a team of White House staff and representatives from national
youth-oriented organizations to prepare a workplan intended for widespread endorsement
and dissemination. (The outside collaborators will include USSA, Young Democrats,
Young Republicans, the youth divisions of the NAACP, Urban League, La Raza and the
Congress of Asian Pacific American Youth.) Tentatively, we think the plan's three 'major
components will be: (i) a national campaign to educate the youth sector about the
intricacies and history of race and racism; (ii) an initiative to improve race-related
curriculum and teaching in grades K-16; and (iii) a mechanism to ensure youth sector
involvement.
(b)
Options for an ongoing structure to carry out your work plan
While the work plan is not yet completed, we know that there will be some general components
which will require continuity and should compose the major responsibilities of the new entity:
~
~
~
~
Policy making (including research and data collection)
Outreach and leadership developmem (including technical assistance to communities)
Communication campaign (including an awards program)
Support for promising practices (such as a. clearinghouse, conferences, grant funding)
The work plan lays out an ambitious agenda that will require the involvement of several players.
With such an extensive scope of work, a coordinating body for the federal sector, and for liaison
with non-federal actors is needed to ensure continued momentum and follow up from outside
efforts. Non-federal leaders engaged on the workplan will expect a central point of contact and
technical assistance.
Option A:
A1:
President's Council for One America
President's Council [or One America Plus an External Advisory Committee
The continuing effort could take a fonn similar to the Council for Environmental Quality
or the Office of Science and Technology Policy. This arrangement would be short of
the ONDCP model which has a large staff, a significant budget, and substantial operating
p.17
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
authority. The council, created by Executive Order, would be run by an Assistant to the
President (as Executive Director) with a small staff and a blue ribbOn advisory committee.
A council staff should include a policy component, which would work with existing
White House policy offices and federal agencies to promote data collection and research
and to develop and monitor policies to overcome disparities and eliminate discrimination.
It would also have a communications component, which would help lead a public
education campaign, support a promising practices clearinghouse, and conduct outreach
to help improve race relations.
Pros:
•
•
•
•
Cons: •
•
A2:
Location places the Presidency squarely behind racial reconciliation effort
Relatively stable structure
Staff appointed by you ensures White House control
Advisory committee offers opportunity for showcasing diverse leadership,
provides credibility in building partnerships
Location and staffing make the stakes high
Advisory committee requires support and nurturing; the familiar headaches
President's CounciJ [or One America) No Advisory Committee
This option would be the same as option AI but it would not include an Advisory
Committee.
Staff would not be distracted by the day-to-day demands of managing an
Pros: •
Advisory Committee
Cons: •
Option B:
Pros:
Dedicated Staff reporting to the Office of the Chief of Staff
An Assistant to the President with a small staff, reporting to the Chief of Staffs
office, could take responsibility for managing Administration efforts.
•
•
Cons: •
•
Option C:
Lacks the outside validation that an Advisory Committee can provide
Closely linked to you and the White House
At the center of activity
Not a fonnal structure, may not be stable
May not be viewed publicly as a significant enough commitment
Private Foundation Model
p.18
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cl:
One America Foundation
The structure could take the fonn of a private foundation, established at your urging and
supported to varying degrees by the federal government, similar to the Points of Light
Foundation. The goals of the foundation could include promoting research on issues of
race, promoting a public education campaign to support racial reconciliation, and
supporting community efforts to improve race relations. Such a foundation could perhaps
best complement a separate policy-making effort within the federal government.
Pros: •
•
•
Cons: •
•
C2:
Serves as umbrella to coordinate several areas of activity
Independence
Ability to raise money
May not be viewed as closely connected to the White House
Requires someone's time and attention to pull together
Clinton Library Model
This option is similar to the Foundation model above except that it would be an endeavor
for you after your final tenn ends, possibly as part of the Clinton library. Staff could
begin immediately to design the structure.
Pros: •
•
Cons: •
•
More time to put together the funding and structure
You will have more time to devote to it
Delays significant Presidential involvement for a few more years
May be partisan resistance to participating in activities because of close
alignment with this Administration
V.
NEXT STEPS
Attachments:
Current book outline.
p.19
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
NEe memorandum on employment issues
???
p.20
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[07/20/1998 – 09/04/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 099 - Folder 005
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/e83dbafa4a4b50748289e0bc9e4c6f07.pdf
94fb919251e6270df5cde766d4d7a69a
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC-KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 099 - FOLDER -004
[07/07/1998-07/17/1998]
�,._. _ AIt~1S Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-JUL-1998 23:08:06.00
SUBJECT:
Education Poll briefing
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cqhen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP"@ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen T. Shea ( CN=Maureen T. Shea/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eli G. Attie ( CN=Eli G. Attie/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ansley Jones ( CN=Ansley Jones/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�'.
Page 2 of2
AR¥S Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M, Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Schnur ( CN=Jonathan H. Schnur/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Doris o. Matsui ( CN=Doris
READ: UNKNOWN
o. Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP
@
EOP [ WHO 1
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Nancy Zurkin of the American Association of University Women recently
commissioned a poll to be conducted by Celinda Lake on "The Attitude of
Women toward the role of Federal Government in Education."
In discussing
the poll results with Nancy, 78% of the women felt that the government
should have a strong federal role in education.
The poll will cover such
issues as block grants, school safety, standards, etc.
On Tuesday, July 14, 1998 at 3:00 p.m. in the Roosevelt Room,
Celinda and
Nancy have agreed to brief the White House staff on the results of the
poll before they become pUblic.
They will hold their official press
conference on July 16th.
If you are interested in attending, please confirm your participation
with TANYA LOPEZ in the Women's office at X67395.
Thanks ...... MM
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN:Ruby Shamir/OU:WHO/O:EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 8-JUL-1998 16:12:16.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN:Sylvia M. Mathews/OU:OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN:Sandra Thurman/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN:Judith A. Winston/OU:PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN:Robin Leeds/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN:Roberta W. Greene/OU:WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN:Janet Murguia/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN:Karen E. Skelton/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN:Maria Echaveste/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN:Lynn G. Cutler/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN:Lucia F. Gilliland/O:OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN:Virginia Apuzzo/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN:Rebecca M. Blank/OU:CEA/O:EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN:Stacie Spector/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN:Audrey T. Haynes/OU:WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN:Marsha Scott/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN:Tracey E. Thornton/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN:Elena Kagan/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN:Minyon Moore/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M.·Liss!O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller!OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:
cc: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jocelyn Neis ( CN=Jocelyn Neis!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
�,.
Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUL-1998 07:14:12.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: marti.thomas ( marti.thomas @ ms01.do.treas.sprint.com @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Grundman-Stacey ( Grundman-Stacey @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: sheketoff-emi1y ( sheketoff-emily @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: kburke1 ( kburke1 @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD_C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAILARD C
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JONATHAN. GRUBER ( JONATHAN. GRUBER
READ: UNKNOWN
@
MS01. DO. treas .',sprint. com
TO: Jennifer.moore ( Jennifer.moore @ justice.usdoj.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: guzy.gary ( guzy.gary @ epamail.epa.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: johara ( johara @ osophs.dhhs.gov @ inet
inet
[ UNKNOWN 1
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
@
�,-
Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William H. White Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=William H. White Jr./OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. Mendelson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
CC: Gina C. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY_MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY
UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This meeting is scheduled for Thursday, July 9, at 2:45 in Room 100 of
OEOB.
�ARM~ Email System
\
Page 1 of 22
"'"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUL-1998 14:43:55 ..00
SUBJECT:
REVISED LABOR Draft Bill on Trade Adjustment Assistance Reform Act of 1998
TO: Laurence R. Jacobson ( CN=Laurence R. Jacobson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon D. Haveman ( CN=Jon D. Haveman/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer E. Brown ( CN=Jennifer E. Brown/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donna M. Rivelli ( CN=Donna M. Rivelli/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy E. Schwartz ( CN=Nancy E. Schwartz/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Randolph M. Lyon ( CN=Randolph M. Lyon/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. Carroll/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah S. Lee ( CN=Sarah S. Lee/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
,
TO: Louisa Koch ( CN=Louisa Koch/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rodney G. Bent ( CN=Rodney G. Bent/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 ) .
�Page 2 of22
ARMS Email System
f't
"
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Carole Kitti/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Carole Kitti
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP' [ OMB 1 )
TO: Barry White
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Barbara Chow
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
ce: mmorin ( mmorin @ dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The document has been redlined to indicate changes made to the earlier
version.
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 07/09/98
02:39 PM --------------------------Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: MNB199
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Wednesday, July 8, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Janet R. Forsgren (for). Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202 i 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395 - 6148
SUBJECT:
REVISED LABOR Draft Bill on Trade Adjustment Assistance
Reform Act of 1998
DEADLINE:
Noon
Monday, July 13, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: To follow is the Department of Labor's revised draft of the
Trade Adjustment Assistance Reform Act of 1998.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
�ARMS Email System
\
Page 3 of22
\.
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
128-US Trade Representative - Fred Montgomery - (202) 395-3475
61-JUSTICE - L. Anthony Sutin - (202) 514-2141
7-AGRICULTURE - Marvin Shapiro - (202) 720-1516
110-Social Security Administration - Judy Chesser - (202) 358-6030
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
3D-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
EOP:
Barbara Chow
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Carole Kitti
Jonathan Orszag
Cecilia E. Rouse
Karen Tramontano
Elena Kagan
Robert G. Damus
Rodney G. Bent
Nancy E. Schwartz
Louisa Koch
Donna M. Rivelli
Sarah S. Lee
Jennifer E. Brown
Christopher D. Carroll
Jon D. Haveman
Randolph M. Lyon
Laurence R. Jacobson
Daniel J. Chenok
Janet R. Forsgren
James C. Murr
LRM ID: MNB199 SUBJECT:
REVISED LABOR
Assistance Reform Act of 1998
Draft Bill on Trade Adjustment
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
FROM:
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
(Date)
(Name)
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of22
h
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
______ No Objection
______ No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
______ Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D64]MAIL41108598R.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750436C050000010A02010000000205000000DBA10000000200005D87DFC63AD19D84543ECB
AOAOA8E07F2DOOF76334AFBBE972FA870CCBFA38A700BECDA999D9F58DD687CCC3B657A813E228
7ADCFE2D1C6EDCC64624FC2A9DBDBE43522646332846298816C612A68F68D55C05C19C9455F424
0704792B94008496E1A6E310C5AC34578A6008BF44248D36788D9E3C8980688552C3112A28A2AB
02F5702A9C26385E30BC99F622DE6B8612C4F3FE859BE3A7A73E7CB08A371EAEOOC67126C51605
6395257A37F64163A133D66AB6F8E51B93FCB7DA71BB463C2BE887D6CB52A9714E9F58F7D08825
74B5B892F24DDE15E6A78F1853E7344FF1DBAEC16886078F5038D19A3B69862A5CE6BEA9CF9S08
9A475C041BF8E4E21DEE3A87BBC5450F3029BE8F648F1668DC56D34B163616449A7C9F3C373AB5
8CA3C8ACC29C29DE843623B9724A65BOC2C8305AE551AE38634A7712AFA726AOAFBA5528AB4890
F088DF195349F251249E21CDB21EACE2C3087DB3295482AAC7909B61AC5E6B04AD75B8A065FF8A
3761D137802D46AAFD1CD8A5568324055A49AB2087767CAA5EE56703F8F979783BOEOAEA46079D
CFE2B7C26EB5B738003A072DE6AB4ACAF10AD2ADA1FF75632B40B9BBAC400EOB674EA380448795
A7AB513931E75147AEAA245375B8057CFEC34D654D21FDFC829F3E38AFOFD5DECA62E6ADEA55D6
F5E5FEF79502000C00000000000000000000000823010000000BOI0000A8020000005507000000
4EOOOOOOB303000009250100000006000000010400000B30020000002800000007040000081601
000000320000002F040000087701000000400000006104000008340100000014000000A1040000
0802010000000FOOOOOOB50400000608010000002DOOOOOOC40400000055080000004EOOOOOOFI
0400000608010000002D0000003F05000000985C005C004F004DOO42002D00500053002D003200
38002D00320039005C003700320030003200420000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOO00C800C8002C012C012C012C
01C800C80030000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000B0100002800C8196810480D00001109000000SA000B01000010360054006900
6D006500730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E00200052006500670075006C0061
007200000000000000000001000200580201000000040028000000000000000000000000000000
00000000011202002400A1000000A100000043003A005C00500052004F00470053005C00570050
005C005300540041004E0044004100520044002E0057005000540000000A000000020001005600
030003001300040001005600050007001300060001004400070001004400080001004400090001
0045000A00010045000B0001000200C38EE624000000000000D40060074800D400F41F08337COO
7800010200000B0000000301000A00000023000000D10323008001000016000200010000580206
FFFF0000000000000000006400002300D12800D61EC30F3908000011090000005AOOOB01008B14
�h
Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
DRAFT
7/8/98
DRAFT TRANSMITTAL LETTER FROM SECRETARY
HERMAN TO THE CONGRESS
I enclose for the consideration of the Congress a draft bill entitled the "Trade Adjustment
Assistance Reform Act of 1998." By combining the best features of the existing Trade
Adjustment Assistance (TAA) and the NAFTA Transitional Adjustment Assistance
(NAFTA-TAA) programs into a consolidated T AA program, this draft bill would provide
effective, comprehensive assistance to workers adversely affected by international trade.
This legislation follows through and expands upon the commitment made by the
President last fall to improve and expand Trade Adjustment Assistance to workers. The draft
bill would authorize the consolidated T AA program for five years, through fiscal year 2003.
The consolidated program would expand eligibility to workers who lose their jobs due to shifts in
production by their firm to other countries. Currently, T AA eligibility is restricted to workers
adversely affected by imports and NAFTA-T AA is limited to workers adversely affected by
imports from or shifts in production to Mexico or Canada. This expanded eligibility will
ensure comprehensive assistance is available to workers who lose their jobs due to imports from
or shifts in production to any foreign country.
The bill also ensures that re(ij:l:lires the immediate pFOvisisa sf rapid response and basic
readjustment services will be made available to workers upon the filing of a petition for T AA
eligibility. These services are critical to facilitating rapid reemployment of workers and provide
important information to those workers relating to the resources available at the Federal, State
and local level to assist them. In addition, the legislation requires a one-third reduction in the
�h
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
time period for the Department of Labor to process petitions for certification of eligibility under
T AA; increases the annual cap on training expenditures to $150 million; and provides
contingency funds should the program exhaust appropriated funds in any fiscal year.
The draft bill also harmonizes the differing rules of the programs relating to requiring
enrollment in training as a condition for receiving income support. These rules would retain the
program's emphasis on linking income support to training while allowing specified, limited
exceptions where appropriate to assist certain workers. In addition, the bill would assist workers
by expanding the period for scheduled breaks in a training program during which a worker may
continue to receive income support.
The draft bill also contains provisions enhancing coordination between the consolidated
T AA program and the dislocated worker program under the Job Training Partnership Act
(JTP A). In particular, the bill would significantly enhance the accountability of the consolidated
program by ensuring that T AA and the dislocated worker program have common performance
outcome measures and information, which would include information on the placement in
employment, eamings (including wage replacement) and retention in employment of participants.
The bill would also require coordination to ensure workers have access to employment-related
services available in one-stop career centers and would authorize the use of funds to provide
supportive services. Finally, the bill assures that information will eeHtiffile te be collected and
maintained identifying the countries to which production is shifted and erfrom which articles are
imported that result in certifications and the number of certifications relating to each country.
This will include information on the number of certifications relating to imports from or shifts in
products to Mexico or Canada, which will assist in making eligibility determinations under
2
�r·
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
related NAFTA programs and in assessing the adequacy of the consolidated program. This
consolidation of the existing programs would therefore result in a program that responds to the
needs of workers adversely affected by trade in a more rapid, comprehensive, and accountable
manner.
It should be noted that this legislation would build on administrative efforts already
undertaken by the Department to improve the programs. In addition, the legislation would be
supplemented by the Administration's commitment to make funds available under the National
Reserve Account in the JTP A dislocated worker program to address the needs of workers in
firms that are secondarily affected by international trade -- that is suppliers to directly affected
firms and assemblers and final processors of articles . produced by such firms. These workers
would be eligible to receive the same assistance available to workers under the consolidated
TAA program.
Together, these reforms would provide critical assistance to help workers who lose their
jobs due to international trade to obtain reemployment and would help to ensure that all
Americans can benefit from economic change.
In addition, at the request of the Department of Commerce, the draft bill includes a
provision extending for the same five year period the trade adjustment assistance for firms
program administered by that Department under chapter 3 of title II of the Trade Act of 1974.
3
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
I urge the Congress to give the draft bill prompt and favorable consideration.
[INSERT OMB PARAGRAPHS ON PAYGO]
The Office of Management and Budget advises that...
Sincerely,
Alexis M. Herman
Enclosures
4
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft
7/898
A BILL
To consolidate and enhance the Trade Adjustment Assistance and NAFTA Transitional
Adjustment AssIstance programs, and for other purposes.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives ofAmerica in Congress_
assembled,
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE
This Act may be cited as the "Trade Adjustment Assistance Reform Act of 1998".
SEC.2. AUTHORIZATION OF CONSOLIDATED TRADE ADJUSTMENT
ASSISTANCE.
(a) AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.-Section 245 of the Trade Act of 1974
(19 U.S.C. 2317) is amended to read as follows:
"Sec. 245. AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.- There are authorized to
be appropriated to the Department of Labor for each of fiscal years 1999, 2000,2001,
2002, 2003, such sums as may be needed to carry out the purposes of this chapter. •
(b) TERMINATION.-Section 285(c) of such Act (19 U.S.C. 2271, preceding note) is
amended to read as follows:
�,.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
"(c) No assistance, vouchers, allowances or other payments may be provided
under chapter 2, and no technical assistance may be provided under chapter 3, after
September 30, 2003.".
(c) REPEAL OF SUBCHAPTER D.- Section 250 of the Trade }\6t of 1974such Act (19
U.S.C.~
2331) is repealed.
@CONFORMING AMENDMENT.- Section 249A of such Act (19 U.S.C. 2322) is
repealed.
SEC.3. FILING OF PETITIONS AND PROVISION OF RAPID RESPONSE
ASSISTANCE.
(a) FILING OF PETITIONS- Section 221 (a) of the Trade Act of 1974 (19U.S.C.
227l(a» is amended to read as follows:
"(a) FILING OF PETITIONS AND RAPID RESPONSE ASSISTANCE."(1) FILING OF PETITIONS.-A petition for certification of eligibility to apply for
adjustment assistance under this chapter may be filed by a group of workers (including
workers in an agricultural firm or subdivision of any agricultural firm) or by their
certified or recognized union or other duly authorized representative _with the Governor
of the State in which such workers' firm or subdivision is located. For purposes of this
paragraph, the duly authorize representative may include entities such as the workers'
firm, the State dislocated worker unit, other State agencies, and one-stop career centers.
"(2) STATE RESPONSIBILITIES AND RAPID RESPONSE.-Upon receipt of a
petition filed under paragraph (1), the Governor shall"(A) immediately transmit the petition to the Secretary of Labor
6
�,.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
(hereinafter in this chapter referred to as the "Secretary");
"(B) ensure that rapid response assistance and basic readjustment services
authorized under other Federal law are made available to the workers covered by the
petition to the extent authorized under such law; and
"(C) assist the Secretary in the review of the petition by verifying such
infonnation and providing such other assistance as the Secretary may request.
"(3) PUBLICATION.- Upon receipt of the petition, the Secretary shall promptly publish
notice in the Federal Register that the Secretary has received the petition and initiated an
investigation." .
(b) EXPEDITED REVIEW OF TAA PETITION BY THE SECRETARY.- Section
223(a) of such Act (19 U.S.C. 2273(a)) is amended by striking "60 days" and inserting "40 days".
SEC.4. ADDITION OF SHIFf IN PRODUCTION AS BASIS FOR TAA ELIGIBILITY.
Section 222(a) ofthe Trade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.C. 2272(a)) is amended to read as
follows:
"(a) IN GENERAL- A group of workers (including workers in any agricultural
finn or subdivision of an agricultural finn) shall be certified by the Secretary as eligible to
apply for adjustment assistance under this chapter pursuant to a petition filed under
section 221 if the Secretary detennines that a significant number or proportion of the
workers in such workers' finn or an appropriate subdivision of the finn have become
totally or partially separated, or are threatened to become totally or partially separated,
and either-
"(1) that-
7
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
"(A) the sales or production, or both, of such finn or subdivision
have decreased absolutely,
"(B) imports of articles like or directly competitive with articles
produced by such finn or subdivision have increased, and
"(C) the increase in imports under subparagraph (B) contributed
importantly to such workers' separation or threat of separation and to the
decline in the sales or production of such finn or subdivision; or
"(2) that there has been a shift in production by such workers' finn or
subdivision to a foreign country of articles like or directly competitive with
articles which are produced by the finn or subdivision.".
SEC. 5. ENROLLMENT IN TRAINING REQUIREMENT.
Section 231(a)(5)(A) ofthe Trade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.C. 2291(a)(5)(A) is amended to
read as follows:
"(A)(i) is enrolled in a training program approved by the Secretary under section 236(a);
and
"(ii) the enrollment required under clause (i) occurs no later than the latest of-"(I) the last day of the 16th week after the worker's most recent total
separation from adversely affected employment which meets the requirements of
paragraphs (1) and (2) of section 231(a);
"(II) the last day of the 8th week after the week in which the Secretary
issues a certification covering the worker; or
"(III) 45 days after the later of subclause (I) or (II), if the Secretary
8
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
determines there are extenuating circumstances that justify an extension in the
enrollment period;".
SEC.6. WAIVERS OF TRAINING REQUIREMENTS.
(a) IN GENERAL- Section 231(c) of the Trade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.C.
~2291(c))
is
amended to read as follows:
"(c)(I) The Secretary may issue a written statement to a worker waiving the
enrollment in training requirement of subsection (a)(5)(A) if the Secretary determines that"(A) the worker has been notified that the worker will be recalled by the
firm
from which the qualifying separation occurred;
"(B) the worker has marketable skills as determined pursuant to an
assessment of the worker, which may include an assessment under the profiling system
under section 303(j) of the Social Security Act, carried out in accordance with
guidelines
issued by the Secretary;
"(C) the worker is within two years of qualifying for retirement benefits
under the Social Security Act;
"(D) the worker is unable to participate in training due to health of the
worker, except that a waiver under this subparagraph shall not be construed to exempt a
worker from requirements relating to availability for work, active search for work, or
refusal to accept work under State or Federal unemployment compensation laws;
"(E) the first available enrollment date for the approved training program
of the worker is within 45 days of the determination made under this paragraph; or
"(F) there are insufficient funds available for training under this chapter,
9
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
taking into account the limitation under section 236(a)(2)(A) .
. "(2)lfthe Seeretary detefHl:iRes the basis for issuiRgThe Secretary shall specify the
duration for the _waiver under paragraph (1) is RO lORger Ilflplieable to a worker,and shall
periodically review the waiver to determine whether the basis for issuing the Seeretary shall issue
a ",;ritteR statemeRt to the worker re'lokiRg the waiver remains applicable. If at any time the
Secretary determines such basis is no longer applicable to the worker, the Secretary shall revoke
the waiver..
"(3) Pursuant to the agreement under section 239, the Secretary may
authorize the State or State agency to carry out activities described in paragraph (1)
(except for the determination under paragraph (1 )(F» and paragraph (2).
Such agreement shall
include a requirement that the State or State agency submit to the Secretary the written
statements provided pursuant to paragraph (1) and a statement of the reasons for the waiver.
"(4) The Secretary shall submit a annual report to the Finance Committee of the
Senate and the Ways and Means Committee of the House of Representatives identifying the
number of workers who received waivers Uflder paragraph (1) and the flUIR-berand the average
duration ofwai'lers revoked Uflder paragrllflh (2)such waivers issued under this subsection during
the preceding year.".
(b) CONFORMING AMENDMENT.- Section 231(a)(5)(C) of such Act (19
u.s.c. 2291
(a)(5)(C» is amended by striking "certified".
SEC.7. PROVISION OF TRADE READJUSTMENT ALLOWANCES DURING BREAKS
IN TRAINING.
Section 233(t) of the Trade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.C. 2293(t) is amended by striking "14
10
�Automate~ Reo Management System
COrds
ex· ump ConvelSion
days" and inserting "30 days".
SEC-S. INCREASE IN TAA TRAINING CAP.
Section 236(a)(2)(A) of the Trade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.C.2296(a)(2)(A)) is amended by
striking "$80,000,000" and inserting "$150,000,000".
SEC 9. ELIMINATION OF QUARTERLY REPORT.
Section 236(d) of the Trade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.C. 2296(d)) is amended by striking the
last sentence of such subsection.
SEC.tO. COORDINATION WITH JTPA AND ONE-STOP CAREER CENTERS.
(a) COORDINATION WITH JTPA.- Section 239(e) of the Trade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.C.
2311(e)) is amended by inserting after the first sentence of such subsection the following
sentence:
"Such coordination shall include common reporting systems and elements,
including common elements relating to participant data and performance
outcomes.".
(b) COORDINATION WITH ONE-STOPS.- Section 235 of such Act (19 U.S.C.
2295) is amended by inserting ",including the services provided through one-stop career
centers," before the period at the end of the first sentence.
SEC. 1 1. SUPPORTIVE SERVICES.
Section 235 of the Trade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.C. 2295) is further amended by adding at
the end the following sentences:
"In addition, the Secretary may authorize the use of funds available under this chapter to
provide supportive services to enable adversely affected workers to participate in or complete
11
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
training. For purposes of this section, the Secretary shall issue guidance on the provision of
supportive services that is consistent with the provision of such services under the dislocated
worker program under title III of the Job Training Partnership Act.".
SEC.12.PERFORMANCE INFORMATION.
Section 239 of the Trade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.C. 2311) is amended by adding the
following new subsection:
"(g) PERFORMANCE INFORMATION.
Any agreement entered into under this section shall include a requirement that the
State report such performance information as the Secretary may require. At a minimum, such
information shall include the rates of entered employment, wage replacement, earnings 6 months
after termination, and retention in employment 6 months after termination for participants in the
program under this chapter.".
SEC.13. AVAILABILITY OF CONTINGENCY FUNDS.
Section 245 of the Trade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.C.
~2317)
is amended by adding at the
end of the following subsection:
"(c) CONTINGENCY FUNDS.- Subject to the limitation contained in
section 236(a)(2), if in any fiscal year the funds available to carry out the
programs under this chapter are exhausted, there shall be made available -from
funds in the Treasury not otherwise appropriated amounts sufficient to carry out
such programs for the remainder ofthe fiscal year."
-
.
SEC. 14. INFORMATION ON CERTAIN CERTIFICATIONS.
Section 223 of the tfadeTrade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.C. 2273) is amended by adding the
12
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
following subsection:
"(e) COLLECTION OF CERTAIN INFORMATION.- The Secretary shall collect
and maintain information --relatiRg to
(1) identifying the ffilmber of eertifieatioRs umler this ehapter that are
bases OR shifts ofcountries to which firms have shifted production to Mel,ieo ans
CaRasa, aRS, to the el,teRtresulting in certifications under section 222(a)(2), and
the number of such certifications relating to each such country;
(2) to the extent feasible, the RUHlber ofeertifieatioRs bases OR imports of
artieles identifying the countries from Mel,ieo aRa Canasa."which imports of
articles have resulted in certifications under section 222(a)(1l), and number of
certifications relating to each such country.
SEC.I5. AUTHORIZATJ[ON OF APPROPRIATIONS FOR TRADE ADJUSTMENT
ASSISTANCE FOR FIRMS ADMINISTERED BY THE DEPARTMENT OF
COMMERCE.
Section 256(b) of the Trade Act of 1974 (19 U.S.c. 2346(b» is amended to read as
follows:
"(b) AUTHORIZATION OF APPROPRIATIONS.- There are hereby authorized to be
approporiated to the Secretary of Commerce for fiscal years 1999,2000,2001, 2002, and 2003
such sums as may be necessary to provide technical assistance under section 253. "
13
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
SEC.16. EFFECTIVE DATE AND TRANSITION.
(a) EFFECTIVE DATE.- The provisions of this Act shall take effect on October 1,1998.
(b) TRANSITION.- The Secretary is authorized to establish such rules as may be
appropriate to provide for an orderly transition from the provisions of law amended or repealed
by this Act.
14
�Automated Records Manage~ent System
Hex.Dump ConversIOn
DRAFT
7/8/98
SECTION-BY-SECTION ANALYSIS OF THE TAA
AND NAFTA-TAA CONSOLIDATION ACT OF 1998
Section 1 provides that the short title of the Act is the "Trade Adjustment Assistance
Refonn Act of 1998".
Section 2 contains the authorization for the consolidated Trade Adjustment Assistance
(TAA) program.
Section 2(a) authorizes such sums as may be necessary to be appropriated to the
Department of Labor to carry out the program for each of the five succeeding fiscal years -- FY
1999 through FY 2003.
Section 2(b) provides a tennination date for assistance under the consolidated program
and for the trade adjustment assistance for finns administered by the Department of Commerce
of September 30,2003.
Section 2(c) repeals the NAFTA Transitional Adjustment Assistance (NAFTA-TAA)
program.
Section 3 relates to the filing of petitions and the provision of rapid response assistance
by the States.
15
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
Section 3(a) provides that a petition for certification of eligibility to apply for assistance is
to be filed by a group of workers or by their union or other representative with the Governor of
the State in which the workers' firm is located. The other representatives who may file the
petition on behalf of the workers include entities such as the workers' firm, the State dislocated
worker unit, other State agencies, and one-stop career centers. The Governor is to immediately
transmit the petition to the Secretary of Labor; ensure that rapid response assistance and basic
readjustment services authorized under other Federal law are made available to workers covered
by the petition; and assist the Secretary in reviewing the petition by verifying information and
providing such other assistance as the Secretary may request. The Secretary is to publish a
notice in the Federal Register upon receipt of an petition that an investigation has been initiated.
This provision is a hybrid ofthe current petition procedures under the two programs. Currently
under T AA the petition is filed with the Secretary rather than the State and there is no
requirement that the State provide appropriate rapid response services. Rapid response
assistance and basic readjustment services provide critical information and services that can
often facilitate coordinated planning and more rapid reemployment for affected workers.
Therefore, it is essential that this assistance be included in the consolidated program. Currently,
under NAFTA-T AA the petition is filed with the Governor, who has ten days to make a
preliminary determination of eligibility, and then transmits the petition to the Secretary for a final
determination. Rapid response assistance is required upon an affirmative finding. The
consolidated provision relieves the burden on the States of making a preliminary determination
and avoids unnecessary delay in the provision of rapid response assistance. Under the
16
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
consolidated provision, the State is also to provide such assistance in reviewing the petition as
the Secretary may request, which should assist in expediting the review process.
Section 3(b) accelerates the time period in which the Secretary is to complete a review of
the petitions from the current 60 days after a petition is filed under T AA to 40 days after a
petition is filed under the consolidated program.
Section 4 adds as a basis for eligibility under the consolidated TAA program job loss due
to the shift in production by the workers' firm to another country. Currently, TAA eligibility is
limited to workers who are adversely affected by imports. NAFTA-TAA eligibility is based on
workers already affected by imports from Mexico and Canada or a shift in production to either of
those two countries. The consolidated TAA program will base eligibility on workers adversely
affected by either imports from or shifts in production to any foreign country.
.
Specifically, the amended section 222(a) ofthe Trade Act of 1974 would provide that a
group of workers filing a petition will be eligible for assistance if the Secretary determines that a
significant number or proportion of the workers in the workers' firm or subdivision have become
separated, or are threatened with separation, and either: (1) the sales or production of the firm
have decreased absolutely, imports of articles like or directly competitive with the articles
produced by the firm or subdivision have increased, and the increase in imports contributed
importantly to the workers' separation and to the decline in sales or production by the workers'
firm, or (2) there has been a shift in production by the workers' firm or subdivision to a foreign
country of articles like or directly competitive with the articles produced by the firm or
subdivision.
Section 5 would apply to the consolidated TAA program an enrollment in training
17
�Automated Records Management Systerr·
Hex-Dump Conversion
requirement for income support similar to the requirement that is currently included under
NAFT A-T AA. Under this requirement, in order to be eligible to receive income support under
the program while in training, a worker must be enrolled in training not later than either the last
day of 16th week of a worker's most recent total qualifying separation or the 8th week after a
certification of eligibility is issued. The Secretary may extend these periods by 45 days if there
are extenuating circumstances, such as a course is cancelled or the first available enrollment date
for a particular program is later. This requirement encourages workers to make training
decisions early in their spell of unemployment which will accelerate reemployment and enhance
the adjustment process.
Section 6 specifies the conditions under which a waiver may be issued from the general
requirement that a worker be enrolled in training to receive income support. This provision is a
hybrid between the TAA program, which provides general waiver authority where training is
deemed to be not "feasible or appropriate" for a worker, and NAFTA-TAA which does not allow
any waivers of the requirements.
Specifically, the new provision allows a waiver under the following six conditions: (1)
the worker has been notified that the worker will be recalled to employment; (2) the worker has
marketable skills as determined pursuant to an assessment; (3) the worker is within two years of
qualifying for retirement benefits under the Social Security Act; (4) the worker is unable to
participate in training due to health (except this does not exempt the worker from available for
.work requirements otherwise applicable to the receipt of income support); (5) the first available
enrollment date is within 45 days; or (6) there are insufficient funds for training under the
chapter. The Secretary is to specify the duration of each waiver and periodically review the
18
�Automated Records Man
Hex-Dump C agement SystefTi
on versIOn
waiver to ensure the basis for granting it remains applicable to the worker.
These requirement§ are intended to ensure that the primary purpose of income support
under the Act -- to assist workers while they are participating in training -- is maintained while
allowing for reasonable exceptions under certain circumstances.
Section 7 would expand the period for which a worker may continue to receive income
support during breaks in training. Currently, a worker may not receive income support during a
break in training if the break exceeds 14 days. This imposes hardships on certain workers,
particularly over the winter holidays. In addition, since training is increasingly being provided
through community colleges and other institutions with breaks scheduled longer than 14 days,
this limitation will be increasingly problematic. The amendment would extend the
break-in-training period to 30 days, which would generally accommodate training institution
schedules while preserving the linkage of income support under the program to participation in
training.
Section 8 would provide a training cap for the consolidated program of $150 million.
Currently, the cap for the TAA program is $80 million and the NAFTA-T AA is $30 million.
The increase is intended to address the expansion of eligibility due to shifts in production, an
expected increase in the programs take-up rate due to the Department's administrative efforts to
expand outreach, and to account for the reduction in the number of training waivers expected
under the revised rules.
Section 9 would eliminate a quarterly report to the Congress on training expenditures.
The report appears to be of limited utility. The Department has been and will remain committed
to ensuring that Congress is fully informed regarding expenditures under the program, especially
19
�Automated Records Managemel1t Syst
Hex.Dump Conversion
err
where it is anticipated that the expenditures will reach the cap.
Section 10 provides for expanded coordination between the consolidated TAA program
and the dislocated worker program administered under the Job Training Partnership Act.
Specifically, section lO(a) provides that the coordination is to include common reporting systems
and elements, including elements relating to participant data and performance outcomes. This
infermatien will signifieantly enhanee the aeeetlntability ef the eenseliaatea pre gram ana
facilitate enhanced cooperation between and assessments of the two programs.
In addition, section 1O(b) provides that in ensuring workers are provided
employment·related services, the Secretary is to ensure such services include services at one-stop
career centers. These centers are being established throughout the country pursuant to
Department of Labor grants and will be an invaluable resource in providing information,
services, and referrals to TAA participants.
Section 11 provides that the Secretary may authorize funds under this chapter to be used
to provide supportive services to enable eligible workers to participate in or complete training.
These services, such as transportation and child care, may be critical to facilitating a worker's
participation in training and are authorized under JTP A training programs. While as under
current law this provision retains a requirement that the Secretary attempt to arrange for the
provision of these services by other programs, it allows the Secretary to authorize the use of
funds under this chapter to provide these services where such attempts are unsuccessful.
Section 12 provides that the agreement for administration of the program between the
State and the Secretary is to include a requirement that the State reports performance information
that the Secretary requests. At a minimum, this performance information is to include rates of
20
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
entered employment, wage replacement, and earnings and retention in employment six months
after termination from the program. These performance measures are consistent with JTP A and
will significantly enhance the accountability under the consolidated T AA program.
Section 11 provides that contingency funds are to be made available to the consolidated
T AA program if appropriated funds are exhausted in any fiscal year. This provision does not
supersede and is subject to the $150 million cap on training expenditures. These funds are to be
made available from funds in the Treasury that are not otherwise appropriated and will ensure
that the commitment to provide assistance to adversely affected workers is not breached.
Section 14 provides that the Secretary is to collect and maintain information identifying
the countries to which production is shifted and, to the extent feasible, from which articles are
imported that result in certifications under this chapter and in the number of certifications
relating to each such country. The provision qualifies the collection of information on imports
"to the extent feasible" because it is sometimes difficult to identify the primary source of
imported articles since such articles may have components produced in several different
countries or may be transshipped among countries.
These information collection requirements
will result in the availability of information relating to certfications based on shifts in production
to and imports from Mexico and Canada, which relatisg ta the RtlFRber af eertifieatiass issued
URder da the eassalidated TAl\. flragrarR that are based as the shift is flredueties te Me*iee aBed
Canada aRd, ta the
e~(test
feasible, as imflerts frem these twa eeURtries. SUefl isfermaties
would be useful to the Congress and other policy makers in assessing the adequacy of the
consolidated program. It would also maintain a commitment to account for program activity
relating to trade with Mexico or Canada and would facilitate eligibility determinations for related
21
�'.
Automated Records Management SysterHex-Dump Conversion
programs, such as the North American Development Bank and Community Adjustment and
Investment Program.
Section 15 would authorize appropriations of such sums as may be necessary for fiscal
years 1999-2003 for trade adjustment assistance for firms under chapter 3 of title II ofthe Trade
Act of 1974, which is administered by the Department of Commerce. This authorization period
is consistent with the authorization period for trade adjustment assistance for workers under
chapter II that is provided in section 2 of this bill.
Section lQ provides the effective date and transition provisions. Section 16(a) provides
that the provisions of the Act are to take effect on October 1, '1998. Section 16(b) authorizes the
Secretary to establish appropriate rules to facilitate or orderly transition from the separate T AA
and NAFTA-TAA programs to the consolidated program.
22
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:11-JUL-1998 03:48:56.00
SUBJECT:
Income/poverty mtg
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul Bugg ( CN=Paul Bugg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel D. Heath ( CN=Daniel D. Heath/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The next income/poverty meeting will be held Monday, July 20th at 2:00 PM
in Sally's office, Room 231.
Please confirm your attendance.
Thanks.
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
,.... ...
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN;Melissa N. Benton/OU;OMB/O;EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:13-JUL-1998 18:05:35.00
SUBJECT:
Reminder--comments on MNB199, Revised Labor Draft Bill on Trade Adjustment
TO: Laurence R. Jacobson ( CN;Laurence R. Jacobson/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon D. Haveman ( CN;Jon D. Haveman/OU;CEA/O;EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah S. Lee ( CN;Sarah S. Lee/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Louisa Koch ( CN;Louisa Koch/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
OMB 1 )
TO: Rodney G. Bent ( CN;Rodney G. Bent/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN;Cecilia E. Rouse/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN;Daniel J. Chenok/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO:. Randolph M. Lyon ( CN;Randolph M. Lyon/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN;Christopher D. Carroll/OU;CEA/O;EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donna M. Rivelli ( CN;Donna M. Rivelli/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy E. Schwartz ( CN;Nancy E. Schwartz/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN;Robert G. Damus/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN;Karen Tramontano/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN;Jonathan Orszag/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James C. Murr ( CN;James C. Murr/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN;Janet R. Forsgren/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�'. .
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
This is a reminder that your comments on the subject draft bill are due.
Please provide all comments no later than COB tomorrow, July 14th.
If I
do not hear from you, I will assume you have no comments and will proceed
with clearing the bill.
Please call (5-7887) if you have comments or questions.
Thanks!
�Page 1 of5
ARMS Email System
,.
l>
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. MaloneyjOU=WHOjO=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATIO~
SUBJECT:
DATEjTIME:15-JUL-1998 16:01:59.00
The President's Trip to ARjLA
TO: Maria E. Soto ( CN=Maria E. SotojOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ryland M. willis ( CN=Ryland M. WillisjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julianne B. Corbett ( CN=Julianne B. CorbettjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W.' Tobe ( CN=Amy W. TobejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. JenningsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. WilliamsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr.jOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher WaynejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael WaldmanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. TurnerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. TerrelljOU=CEQjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan TamagnijOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva SteinbergjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd SternjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Joshua SilvermanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. SchwartzjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa RobinsonjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. PasquiljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of5
ARMS Email System
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newrnan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
,.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig Hughes ( CN=Craig Hughes!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler!OU=WHO!O=·EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola!OU=CEQ!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey!OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: .Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 4 of5
ARMS Email System
,.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Friday afternoon, July 17, 1998, the President will travel to Little
Rock, Arkansas.
On Saturday, he will address the State Committee meeting,
have a photo-op with candidates and attend the Arkansas Victory '98 dinner
and the DSCC dinner for Blanche Lambert Lincoln. On Sunday, he will have
the day off and travel to New Orleans, Louisiana, in the evening.
On
Monday, he will address the American Federation of Teachers conference,
meet with African American law enforcement officials, and. attend the Jeffe
rson luncheon and a DNC dinner.
He will return to the White House late
Monday evening.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
AR & LA Background Memos:
DUE THURS., JULY 16, AT 3:00 P.M.
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
Political Memos
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
Economic One-Pager
AR Event Memos:
DUE THURS., JULY 16, AT 6:00 P.M.
State Committee Meeting
Arkansas Victory Dinner '98
DSCC Dinner
LA Event Memos:
DUE FRI., JULY 17, AT 6:00 P.M.
AFT Speech
African American Law Enforcement Drop-By
Jefferson Luncheon
DNC Dinner
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
"-.
Page 1 of 3
c.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 16-JUL-1998 19:09:36.00
SUBJECT:
Heads-up Memo
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�, ARMS Email System
'.
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The memo below was signed and sent to Erskine Bowles on Wednesday, July
15th.
MEMORANDUM FOR ERSKINE BOWLES
THROUGH:
FROM:
Jack Lew
Donald R. Arbuckle
SUBJECT:
Heads up on HHS Notice Defining Federal Public Benefit and
DOJ Proposed Rule on Verification of Eligibility for Public Benefits
HHS and DOJ are preparing to publish two documents in the Federal
Register (an HHS notice and a DOJ proposed 'rule) that will provide the
framework for implementing key provisions in the 1996 Welfare Reform Law,
banning the receipt of Federal public benefits for non-qualified (largely
illegal) aliens.
The HHS notice presents for the first time the Administr'ationD, s
interpretation of the definition of a Federal public benefit and provides
a list of the HHS programs so defined.
To date, programs have been
operating without knowing whether they fall under the definition.
In the
notice, only those Federal programs that have an explicit eligibility
determination process are defined as public benefit programs. This
definition thus includes programs like Medicare, child care and the Child
Health Insurance Program, but excludes public health clinics.
The DOJ proposed rule requires Federal public benefit programs to
verify alien and citizenship status. The rule is mandatory for Federal
Public Benefit programs, but is optional guidance for State and local
programs. Charities are exempt.
The law requires these programs to
conduct matches with an INS database of eligible aliens to verify alien
status. The rule would require applicants to provide written proof of
their citizenship, unless the agency already has regulations in place
governing citizenship verification. The rule also provides a temporary
waiver for those programs where written verification would present a
hardship, to allow programs time to comply with the new rule.
We believe that as a combined policy, the definition and the
verification requirements form a fairly middle ground position and should
be generally well received. We cannot, however, rule out a surprise
response, from Congress or the field.
cc:
Maria Echaveste
Rahm,Emanuel
Larry Stein
Ron Klain
Thurgood Marshall, Jr.
Ann Lewis
Sally Katzen
Minyon Moore
John Podesta
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Elena Kagan
Barry Toiv
�'. ARMS. Email System
Michael Waldman
Janet Yellen
Mickey Ibarra
Barbara Chow
Michael Deich
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of33
\
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 17-JUL-1998 11:29:06.00
SUBJECT:
REVISED HUD Conference Document on S462,HR 2 Public Housing Reform and Res
TO: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joanne Chow ( CN=Joanne Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles E. Kieffer ( CN=Charles E. Kieffer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan D. Breul ( CN=Jonathan D. Breul/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelly A. McAllister ( CN=Shelly A. McAllister/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maya A. Bernstein ( CN=Maya A. Bernstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen H. Walsh ( CN=Maureen H. Walsh/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Matthew McKearn ( CN=Matthew McKearn/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James F. Jordan ( CN=James F. Jordan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Hang T. Tran ( CN=Hang T. Tran/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alan B. Rhinesmith ( CN=Alan B. Rhinesmith/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of33
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. Carroll/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP. [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Zweig ( CN=Lisa Zweig/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN .
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=William P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Norwood J. Jackson Jr ( CN=Norwood J. Jackson Jr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mathew C. Blum ( CN=Mathew C. Blum/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Winifred Y. Chang ( CN=Winifred Y. Chang/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth L. Schwartz ( CN=Kenneth L. Schwartz/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph F. Lackey Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Joseph F. Lackey Jr./OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leanne A. Shimabukuro ( CN=Leanne A. Shimabukuro/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine L. Meredith ( CN=Katherine L. Meredith/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Carr ( CN=Susan M. Carr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S. Redburn/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of33
"
The document is attached following the LRM.
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 07/17/98
11:24 AM --------------------------Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: MNB203
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Friday, July 17, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395- 6148
SUBJECT:
REVISED HUD Conference Document on S462,HR 2 Public
Housing Reform and Responsibility Act of 1997
DEADLINE:
10 a.m.
Monday, July 20, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: To follow is the latest draft of HUD's letter to the Conferees
on public housing reform legislation.
This draft has been marked up to
show changes since the last draft.
please note the addition of the veto threat on p. 2.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
61-JUSTICE - L. Anthony Sutin - (202) 514-2141
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
EOP:
Michael Deich
Alan B. Rhinesmith
Francis S. Redburn
Hang T. Tran
Susan M. Carr
James F. Jordan
Katherine L. Meredith
Jose Cerda III
Leanne A. Shimabukuro
Diana Fortuna
Andrea Kane
Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
Sarah Rosen
Elena Kagan
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of33
Jack A. Smalligan
'Matthew McKearn
Larry R. Matlack
Maureen H. Walsh
Joseph F. Lackey Jr.
Maya A. Bernstein
Kenneth L. Schwartz
David J. Haun
Winifred Y. Chang
Shelly A. McAllister
Mathew C. Blum
Jonathan D. Breul
Norwood J. Jackson Jr
Broderick Johnson
William P. Marshall
Tracy Thornton
Kate P. Donovan
Charles E. Kieffer
Lisa Zweig
Joanne Chow
Christopher D. Carroll
,Janet R. Forsgren
James C. Murr
LRM ID: MNB203 SUBJECT:
REVISED HUD Conference Document on S462,HR 2
Public Housing Reform and Responsibility Act of 1997
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
FROM:
Melissa N.- Benton Phone:
395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of33
Concur
______ No Objection
______ No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
______ Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D20]MAIL40114510J.226 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750436E2A0000010A02010000000205000000F604010000020000CBB54CF183FDDAFA793CCD
FA2A3980126B1478B62758141FFE669A65251F6B80071E9279CC7EF3671B6E093116D063387CF6
28AA8E80A2559665EC900EOA7C72A8B296DC59046345C6A05DE7978EE452A3D176CCB4B428423E
BD7C7EFD025F85071EFB344FB2E22B1A2A82FA6A16090C8CD88F6ACCDD18FE7976FFB90ECF1FDB
653EOFFDCFBFC66AF22BDD5D2BD3B5D9973A9C498BFE1AE61EFB5C4C068822C0234E6C1E181022
DC29258F28E33843047437D905EE4BEF55D6C6AF415FEC3EA570A6C985Dl18DC38B660331F5DCD
3B6ED5FBA589D9CB41D7EC19EAA32D89D927946BF4F687549FDOBA59B947FFF74E857D5F8B88C5
4DCA7B7680B81AOBEC923E44D3F7DEB6DDE34E78FA98D7F5B55821208620B5332BFB82534B7BF4
FEE4AD3DEAFD86D7A043134F3AAC6EB77243CCEA779AF77FED0876E2E78C745F0038C9242C3E61
3DE8661FD79E3AB2B84DDD358561D71119C4954C830B12E2C917D9B04007B273DEB19419A88E71
OBEDAC478F41D5ABABCA558AE788827B39C0768AD2299CF15DB46A15D50701E5228051EE3DEACA
30764BF096CC552491ED092D7D73677B143886E022F6C7521BCE1952F557FEE33A3EF12B06A51A
E62D9FBD24A6C0176F5A2BBAE1F07A362F98AFDODA286DC82C81E199555A7976D16BF32CB752F4
D21FC5577902005D0000000000000000000000084D010000000400000016070000093102000000
690000001A07000000550D0000002E000000830700000B300100000098000000B10700000B3001
0000003D000000490800000B30010000003C000000860800000B3001000000CAOOOOOOC2080000
OB30010000003C0000008C0900000B300100000026000000C80900000B300100000094000000EE
0900000B30010000003A000000820AOOOOOB30010000003AOOOOOOBCOAOOOOOB30010000003AOO
0000F60AOOOOOB30010000003A000000300BOOOOOB30010000003A0000006AOBOOOOOB30010000
003AOOOOOOA40BOOOOOB30010000003COOOOOODEOBOOOOOB30010000003COOOOOOIAOCOOOOOB30
010000003C000000560COOOOOB30010000003A000000920COOOOOB30010000003COOOOOOCCOCOO
000B30010000003C000000080DOOOOOB30010000003C000000440DOOOOOB30010000003COOOOOO
800DOOOOOB30010000003COOOOOOBCODOOOOOB30010000003COOOO00F80DOOOOOB300100000063
010000340EOOOOOB300100000036000000970FOOOOOB300100000038000000CDOFOOOOOB300100
00003C000000051000000B30010000003C000000411000000B30010000003C0000007D1000000B
30010000003COOOOOOB91000000B30010000003COOOOOOF5100000OB30010000003C0000003111
00000B30010000003C0000006D1100000B30010000003COOOOOOA91100000B3001000000D50000
00E51100000B3001000000C8000000BA1200000B3001000000C8000000821300000B3001000000
C80000004A1400000B3001000000C8000000121500000B3001000000ADOOOOOODA1500000B3001
000000CE000000871600000B3001000000AD000000551700000B3001000000AD00000002180000
OB3001000000CCOOOOOOAF1800000B3001000000CC0000007B1900000B30010000008900000047
1AOOOOOB300100000035000000D01AOOOOOB30010000003COOOOOO051BOOOOOB30010000003COO
0000411BOOOOOB30010000003C0000007D1BOOOOOB30010000003C000000B91BOOOOOB30010000
003COOOOOOF51BOOOOOB30010000003C000000311COOOOOB30010000003C0000006D1COOOOOB30
010000003COOOOOOA91COOOOOB30010000003COOOOOOE51COOOOOB30010000003C000000211DOO
000B30010000003C0000005D1DOOOOOB30010000003C000000991D00000B30010000003COOOOOO
D51DOOOOOB30010000003C000000111EOOOOOB30010000003COOOO004D1EOOOOOB30010000003C
000000891EOOOOOB300100000068010000C51EOOOOOB30010000003C0000002D2000000B300100
00003C000000692000000B30010000003COOOOOOA52000000B30010000003COOOOOOE12000000B
30010000003C0000001D2100000B30010000003C00000059210000OB30010000003C0000009521
00000B30010000003COOOOOOD12100000B3001000000430100000D2200000B3001000000820000
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft 6/197/15198 I
1998 Public Housing Reform Bills
Letter to the Conferees
Dear Conferee:
I am writing to make you aware of the Administration's views on the public housing
reform legislation you are now considering in the conference to reconcile S. 462 and H.R. 2.
These bills propose major changes in the public housing and tenant-based Section 8 programs.
Over several years now, both the Congress and the Administration have put a great deal of
thought and hard work into the pursuit of sound reform legislation. As you move ahead in the
conference, I look forward to our continued collaboration, so that important and long-overdue
reforms may finally be enacted and implemented.
INTRODUCTION
The Administration strongly supports the goals of S. 462 and H.R. 2 -- to streamline and
reorganize the Nation's public housing system in a manner which will benefit public housing
residents, facilitate the efficient use of Federal resources, and increase accountability to the public.
The Administration also appreciates the willingness of both the House and Senate to draw upon
management reform and other provisions in the Administration's bill -- the Public Housing
Management Reform Act of 1997.
However, the Administration has a number of major concerns about S. 462 and H.R. 2
as-passed which, among other things, require the Conferees to take the following actions:
Provide more targeting of scarce housing assistance to the neediest families;
Delete the H.R. 2 provision allowing "fungibility" to meet income targeting requirements;
Delete or address the serious flaws in H.R. 2's "Home Rule Flexible Grant Option";
Delete the self-sufficiency agreements and the community work provisions in H.R. 2;
Delete the Housing Evaluation and Accreditation Board created by H.R. 2;
�Automated Records Management Systerp
Hex-Dump Conversion
Enact the Administration's provision for mandatory receiverships for troubled PHAs that
do not improve sufficiently within one year, as well as related management
assessment
provlSlons;
Further streamline "PHA Plan" requirements; allow small PHAs to use operating and
capital funds interchangeably; delete provisions constraining flexibility in the operating
subsidy formula; and make the Drug Elimination Program a formula-based program;
Delete the S. 462 provision authorizing PHAs to obtain medical information about
applicants for housing assistance; and
Delete the provisions of both bills allowing PHAs to set the payment standard in the
tenant-based Section 8 program higher than the Fair Market Rent established by HUD.
SUMMARY OF THE BILLS
The Senate and House bills make permanent a number of critical reforms that the
Administration and the Congress have been able to achieve only through year-to-year provisions
in appropriations legislation. Elements of the Senate and House bills would promote the
continuation and strengthening of the transformation of the public housing and Section 8
programs already underway, including: (1) replacing the worst public housing with scattered-site
. and townhouse developments and with portable tenant-based assistance through the HOPE VI
program, permanently repealing the one-for-one replacement requirement, and facilitating
demolition of obsolete developments and conversion to tenant-based assistance or appropriate site
revitalization; (2) turning around troubled PHAs through the use of various tools, including
mandatory receiverships for chronically troubled PHAs and enhanced powers afforded to HUD
and court-appointed receivers upon takeover; (3) promoting public housing communities with a
greater income diversity and allowing PHAs to implement rent policies that encourage and
reward work, and are coordinated with welfare reform; (4) demanding greater household
responsibility as a condition of housing assistance through more vigorous screening, eviction or
subsidy termination, and lease enforcement provisions; and (5) implementation of several of the
Administration's key management reforms. Important provisions for management reform
include program consolidation and streamlining, deregulation of well-managed PHAs and small
PHAs, increased reliance on physical conditions in assessing PHA performance and more certain
treatment of the most troubled PHAs.
DESCRIPTION OF ADMINISTRATION CONCERNS
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
As I am sure you are aware from my testimony last year and from other discussions in
recent months, however, the Administration has a number of major concerns about particular
provisions of both bills. Despite its support for the general goals of both bills, the
Administration believes that certain provisions go farther than is necessary to make the reforms
that are needed. Instead of making only reforms, some provisions -- particularly on income
targeting -- would move the program too far away from fundamental, prudent national standards
and appropriate federal oversight. Income targeting is a fundamental issue because it sets the rules
for access to assisted housing. A resolution orthis issue that provides insufficient protection for those
who most need assistance would lead me to recommend a veto orthis legislation.
Nevertheless,
the Administration is hopeful that our concerns can and will be addressed in the Conference,
clearing the way to enactment of sound public housing and Section 8 reform legislation.
The Administration's most important concerns about the bills are described below.
L
MAJOR CONCERNS
A.
INADEQUATE TARGETING OF HOUSING ASSISTANCE TO THOSE
FAMILIES MOST IN NEED
1.
Income Targeting in Public Housing
The Administration believes that the income targeting provisions of both bills must be
tightened to direct more housing assistance to families with the most pressing housing needs. In
particular, the Administration strongly opposes the House "fungibility" provision, which could mean
that PHAs in some cities would not have to offer any public housing units to extremely low-income
families. The Administration suppons the Senate requirement that 40% of avaiJable public housing
units go to extremely low-income families; however, the Administration also advocates increasing -from 70% (as in the Senate bill) to 90% -- the ratio ofnewly available units that must be offered to
families with income levels no higher than 60% ofmedian (which is approximately $22,600
nationally). The Administration also seeks a requirement that at least 40% of the units in each
public housing development be occupied by families with incomes below 30% of area median income.
This will ensure that the poorest families have housing opportunities at all developments, induding
those that may be most marketable to relatively higher income families.
The Administration believes that the income targeting provisions of both bills -- especially
the House's "fungibility" provision -- go much farther than is necessary to serve working families
and achieve a more diverse income mix in public housing. It is essential to the social and
financial health of public housing communities that more working families are admitted to public
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
housing. Today, the median family income in public housing is only $6,940 per year -- just
21 of median income nationally. By contrast, both bills would open up too many public
housing units to families at the upper end of the eligibility range -- families with incomes of up
to 80 of the area median income, or approximately $40,000 in the ten largest metropolitan
areas.
The Administration does not oppose admitting a small number of families at that income
level. However, the Administration believes that mixed-income communities that serve working
families can be attained without going as far as the House and Senate bills. This can be done
by ensuring that at least 40 of admissions are reserved for families with incomes up to 30 of
median (approximately $11,300) and that 90 of admissions are families with incomes at or
below 60 of the area median (approximately $22,600). In comparison, 60 of median
income is the absolute upper cap for the HOME and low-income housing tax credit programs.
In addition, the Administration urges the Conferees to adopt language that would require PHAs
generally to maintain !ill.occupancy distribution such that sf at least a forty percent certain
percentage of units in each public housing development are occupied by very poor extremely
low income families.
Not only are the income targeting percentages inadequate, but the House bill's fungibility
provision could undermine even that level of targeting which the bill proposes. This provision
would allow a PHA to admit even fewer very poor families to public housing if the PHA gave
more of its Section 8 certificates tenant-based assistance to such families than the minimal number
which the bill requires. +Because many communities' current levels of admissions of very poor
families to the certificate and voucher programs substantially exceed the House percentage
requirement the result almost certainly would be that some PHAs would not have to offer any
public housing units to families -- including many working families -- whose incomes are below
30 of the area median income. The Administration finds such a possibility to be unacceptable.
The Administration proposed its income targeting for public housing with the
understanding that the achievement of a more diverse income mix necessarily would result in
reduced access for those with the lowest incomes. Partly in recognition of this problem, the
Administration each year has proposed that Congress provide substantial additional vouchers.
Congress should recognize that these proposals are linked and that the loosening of public
housing income targeting needs to be done in conjunction with the provision of additional
vouchers. Any compromise between the Administration's income targeting and the Senate's
income targeting, for both public housing and Section 8, should occur only to the extent
additional vouchers are provided that compensate for the loss of access for those who most need
housing assistance. This would require an annual appropriation of 62,500 additional vouchers
if the Senate's income targeting levels are adopted.
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
With respect to income targeting by development, that concept already is part of current
law. The Administration proposal is a moderate proposal to ensure continuing access to all
developments by all eligible income groups.
2.
Income Targeting in the Tenant-Based Section 8 Rental Assistance Program
The Administration is opposed to the provisions of both bills on income targeting for the
tenant-based Section 8 program. Instead, the Administration beJieves that 75% of tenant-based
assistance which becomes avaiJable each year should be targeted to the very poor -- families with
incomes at or below 30% of median income (approximately $11,300) -- and that the remainder of
such assistance generally should go to families with incomes no greater than 50% ofmedian, as under
current law.
Both bills unnecessarily reduce the portion of Section 8 tenant-based assistance that would
go to families with severe housing needs. Current law generally limits eligibility for
tenant-based assistance to very low-income families with incomes below 50 of the area median
income. Moreover, federal preferences, which applied to 90 of new Section 8 recipients prior
to FY 1996 as opposed to only 50 of new public housing residents, have served to further target
assistance to extremely low income families. The median income of Section 8 certificate holders
is now approximately $7,550.
In contrast, H.R. 2 would require only that 40 of all Section 8 tenant-based assistance
go to extremely low-income families -- the income range which the program has primarily served
in the past. Relatively higher income families, with incomes up to 80 of median income,
would become eligible to receive such assistance. S. 462 is not as extreme as the House bill,
but would still require only that 65 of all tenant-based assistance go to -families with the most
severe housing needs and that 90 go to families with incomes under 60 of median.
The Administration contends that scarce federal rental subsidies for use in the private
market must be targeted to families with the lowest incomes, for the following reasons: 1) 5.3
million very low-income renters now have "worst-case housing needs'~, defined as paying more
than 50 of their income toward rent or living in substandard housing units, and these families
are concentrated at the lowest income levels (below 30 of the area median income); 2) relatively
few of the families with incomes in the upper ranges allowed under both bills who would
become eligible for admission to the Section 8 program (including 17.5 million unassisted
renters) have serious unmet housing needs; 3) federal preferences are being repealed; 4) both the
Senate and House bills propose opening up public housing admissions to families with relatively
higher incomes to promote mixed-income communities, which means fewer units will be
available for extremely poor families; and 5) tenant-based rental assistance integrates families with
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
low incomes into private, mixed-income housing of their choice and does not suffer from the
severe income concentration problems of project-based programs.
The Administration also sees no reason to expand tenant- based program eligibility limits
so that these scarce housing resources can be provided to households with incomes at 80 of the
median -- approximately $40,000 for families in the ten largest metropolitan areas -- who are
better able to afford private market housing without any subsidy. This income level, which is
equivalent to 250 of the poverty line, exceeds the income limits for virtually all other federal .
means-tested programs.
B.
HOME RULE FLEXIBLE GRANT OPTION
The Administration strongly opposes the Home Rule Flexible Grant Option in HR. 2, which
could transfer public housing funds from a PHA to a city government regardless of the city's ability or
experience in administering housing programs or the housing authority's management record.
Instead, the Administration believes that implementation of the current- MfWiRg to Moving-to- Work
demonstration will provide sufficient opportunity to' explore innovative local approaches in the public
housing and Section 8 programs.
The Administration has taken bold action to deal with chronically troubled PHAs and to
. demolish and replace the worst public housing. However, that is not what the House provision
is about. The House provision would allow a city government, regardless of its motives or its
track record in administering housing programs, to take over or replace even a high-performing
housing authority. Some of the most intractable management problems in recent years have
occurred in several chronically troubled PHAs that have been operated as part of city
government.
The provision also inexplicably provides cities that would administer public housing more
regulatory flexibility than PHAs (e.g., to charge rents exceeding Brooke amendment
requirements). There is no reason to link additional regulatory flexibility with the choice of the
entity to administer public housing.
If the goal of this provision is to address serious management problems in public
housing, one would expect it to be crafted as an alternative intervention strategy with respect to
troubledfailing PHAs. As a compromise, +!he provision could be applied where HUD agrees
that this is an acceptable alternative to court-ordered receivership (with the locality subject to the
Rather, -:fthe current provision instead
usual public housing and Section 8 regulations.)
would be applicable to all PHAS~ irrespective of the demonstrated quality of their management.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
With respect to the goal of testing additional regulatory flexibility, Instead, the
Administration instead supports continued implementation of the Moving to Work demonstration
authorized by the FY 1996 appropriations act. That demonstration program allows up to thirty
PHAs to design and test innovative ways to provide housing assistance and to link families to
work, through merging funding streams and testing new rent structures while retaining
reasonable income targeting. HUD has selected PHAs with diverse and potentially far-reaching
proposals. The demonstration is large enough to allow substantial experimentation, yet small
enough to permit a rigorous evaluation of program success and replicability.
C.
COMMUNITY WORK AND SELF-SUFFICIENCY REQUIREMENTS
The Administration opposes the self-sufficiency agreements and the community work
provisions in the House bill. Instead, the Administration believes that provisions emphasizing
collaboration between PHAs and local welfare agencies are a better and more productive approach to
addressing welfare reform and self-sufficiency issues. For example, the Administration supports the
provisions in both bills which require PHAs to describe in their annual plans the ways in which they
propose coordination with other local and state welfare and service agencies, and assure that
households who violate welfare program self-sufficiency rules are not rewarded with subsidized
housing rent decreases. The Administration also supports provisions if? both bills permitting PHAs
to set public housing rents "up to" 30% of a family's adjusted income, which allows for rent structures
that do not penalize increases in. earned income. Further, the Administration supports authorization
of additional Section 8 certificates for use with local collaboratives in welfare-to-work initiatives.
The Administration believes that public housing and Section 8 residents must assume
certain responsibilities in return for the benefits of their housing assistance. To this end, the
Administration supports many reforms in both the House and Senate bills which place a
premium on resident self-sufficiency and on linking the PHA with existing providers of services.
Additionally, the Administration supports provisions in both bills to toughen screening, lease
enforcement and eviction, and subsidy termination requirements.
However, the Administration opposes the House bill's mandatory self-sufficiency
contracts. This sweeping new requirement would fundamentally change the public housing and
Section 8 programs and would impose inordinate and costly burdens on 3,400 local PHAs
whose budgets and administrative capacities already have been stretched. A far more efficient
and effective approach is to encourage partnerships between PHAs and State and local welfare
agencies that promote self-sufficiency through initiatives such as the authorization of "Welfare to
Work" certificates, as proposed in the Administration's bill.
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
The Administration also opposes significant aspects of the community work provisions
included in the House bill. The Administration's bill includes a community service provision
because the Administration believes it is reasonable to ask each recipient of public housing or
tenant-based assistance to be engaged in some activity which benefits the community as a whole,
which includes working, attending school, or otherwise preparing for work. However, the
Administration's bill provides for much more reasonable exemptions than the House bill and
would not authorize eviction as an enforcement tool.
n
MANAGEMENT REFORM
1.
. Federal Oversight
The Administration supports several of the bills' revisions to the PHMAP system, induding
those that emphasize the importance of decent living conditions, and would support the establishment
of an advisory performance evaluation board or other task force to review various performance
evaluation systems and determine the need, if any, for an outside accreditation entity. The
Administration also supports the House and Senate bill provisions which give HUD or a receiver
enhanced powers for dealing with troubled PHAs; require PllAs; the takeover of se~re£e!y troubled
PHAs that fail to improve prompdy; and require the obligation and expenditure of capital funds
within certain time frames (which the Administration believes should be extended to the HOPE VI
program). The Administration does not support the Accreditation Board created by the House bill.
The Administration believes that it is critical to have an assessment tool which accurately
measures PHA performance and is consistent with the Administration's management reform plan
for HUD. IH the short nIH, this reqHires makiHg modificatioHs to This requires overhauling
lookiHg the current performance measurement system -- the Public Housing Management
Assessment Program (PHMAP). In particular, the Administration supports the bills' provision
adding an PHMAP indicator assessing the extent to which a PHA is providing acceptable basic
housing conditions and the House' provision making acceptable basic housing conditions a
precondition for a PHA to get a passing grade in the assessment system. This will support
HUD's efforts to make PHMAP the performance evaluation system more objectively verifiable
and reflective of the conditions under which public housing residents are living.
The Administration, however, strongly opposes the House bill's "Accreditation Board", a
new federal agency which would create an accreditation program for all public housing agencies
and other providers of federally assisted housing. This proposal, written prior to the
Administration's management reform efforts, runs directly counter to the Administration's plan for
improving and streamlining Federal oversight of the public housing program. It would not
reduce, but instead would redistribute and probably increase, the Federal bureaucracy.
�Automated Records Management SystelTl
Hex-Dump Conversion
Moreover, the proposal would appear to divorce Federal oversight and auditing responsibilities
which would be given to the Accreditation Board, from HUD's ongoing obligation to provide
Federal funds to PHAs. This would make it more difficult for HUD to hold PHAs
accountable.
Instead of the House bill's Accreditation Board, an advisory entity such as the
Administration's proposed Performance Evaluation Board should be given the opportunity to
review and make recommendations on implementation of HUD's management reform in this
area as well as various approaches to Federal oversight and assessment of PHAs, including
accreditation. Finally, the Justice Department advises that the proposed means of appointing the
Accreditation Board would unduly restrict the President and thus violate the Appointments Clause
of the Constitution.
The Administration already has taken the most aggressive actions in HUD's
history against chronically troubled PHAs, including direct takeovers and support for judicial
receiverships. In this regard, the Administration supports the Senate bill's provisions giving
HUD enhanced powers to deal with troubled PHAs (which are the same provisioRS as iR the
AdmiRistratioR's bill) PHAs. Those provisions require HUD to take certain actions against
any PHA that is still troubled after one year (including mandatory receivership for any large
PHA). Mter further consideration, the Administration believes that this provision should be
modified to give a troubled PHA one additional year before HUD will take action if that PHA
has made progress in the first year that is equal to at least half the difference between its PHM,AP
assessment score and the score necessary to be a "standard" performer.
In addition, the Administration supports the Senate bill provision requiring PHAs to
obligate capital funds within 24 months. It is critical in these times of fiscal restraint to ensure
that appropriated funds are used promptly for their intended p'urposes. Further, the
Administration urges the Conferees to adopt two additional provisions from the Administration's
bill: (1) requiring PHAs to spend capital funds within 48 months (in addition to obligating such
funds within 24 months); and (2) applying specific time frames to the HOPE VI program, such
that a PHA would have to sign a primary construction contract within 18 months of executing
the grant agreement, and would have to complete construction within 4 years from the grant
agreement.
2.
Consolidation and Streamlining
The Administration urges the Conferees to further streamline PHA plan requirements as in the
Administration's biJI. In addition, the Administration supports the House provision allowing small
PHAs to use operating and capital funds interchangeably. The Administration also advocates the
�Automated Records Management SysterHex-Dump Conversion
deletion of House provisions constraining flexibility in the operating subsidyJormula. Further, the
Administration urges the Conferees to convert the Drug Elimination Program into a formula-based
program, and to merge the TOP and EDSS programs.
The Administration supports and recognizes the benefits of consolidating PHA planning
and reporting requirements into a single annual plan, as provided in both the Senate and House
bills. However, the Administration is concerned that the scope of the annual plans be consistent
with HUD efforts to streamline PHA and HUD administration of the public housing and
Section 8 programs. The Administration strongly urges the Conferees to consider limiting the
number and scope of plan elements as described in the Administration's bill. Conferees also
should adopt the Senate provision permitting HUD by regulation to provide that elements of the
PHA plan other than the capital plan and civil rights shall be reviewed only if challenged.
The Administration also supports the House provision allowing small PHAs (less than
250 units) to use operating and capital funds fungibly, as provided in the House bill, because the
formula allocation of capital funds to such PHAs would be small and the additional flexibility
would simplify PHA operations and HUD administration. However, the Administration
opposes the provision of the House bill giving governors new responsibility to allocate half of
such funds.
In addition, the Administration supports the language in both bills authorizing HUD to
renegotiate the formula for allocating public housing operating subsidies to PHAs. The current
system has not been changed in many years. A renegotiation could result in a revised formula
that is simpler and more equitable, and that provides better incentives for sound, cost-effective
public housing management. However, HUD opposes the House provisions defining
treatment of vacant units, utility rates, and rental income. These provisions may hamstring and
substantially complicate the future formula and should be left to rulemaking (which will be
negotiated rulemaking under the House and Senate bills). The extent to which PHAs may
retain increases in rental income, in particular, should be left to rulemaking because: (1) rental
income has is increasedffig substantially throughout the program, for reasons that may be
unrelated to PHA administration of the program; and (2) such retention creates a strong financial
incentive for PHAs not to serve the poorest households. The House §204(d) interim allocation
provisions also are unnecessary.
Further, the Administration urges the Conferees to convert the Public Housing Drug
Elimination Program from a competitive to a formula-based program, to provide predictable
funding for PHAs and reduce the administrative burden on both HUD and PHAs of annual
competitions. The Administration also advocates permanent authorization of the supportive
�Automated Records Management Syslerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
service (EDSS) program and a merger of EDSS and the Tenant Opportunities Program (TOP),
as provided in the Administration's bill.
E.
The AJmiBistl'6tioR oppeses the HeHse BiO's pFmrisieR fJR efXUp6R€Y 5klBd6FEis eeC6f15e it
weHld redoce pF9tectieRs ruff/mil" «ifonJed te /emiJies with €hiJdr~ Hadel' the Jl6H H9Hsiag Act.
The HOHse provision on occHpancy standards wOHld imqte state adoption of absolHte
ocwpancy standards regardless of the facts of a partiwlar sitHation, or the e*istence of any health
or safety jHstifications. Enactment of this prO'oqsion co HId res Hit, for e*ample, in a State allO'o\qng
a hOHsing provider to refuse to rent a 2 bedroom Hnit to a family with three children, ev:en if: 1)
the bedrooms were HnHsHally large; 2) one of the children was an infant; or a) a den cOHld
reasonably be Hsed as a bedroom. This coHld contribHte to the shortage of affordable hOHsing
large enoHgh for families. HUD's CHrrent ocwpancy standard, which conforms to Congress's
direction in the FY 1996 HUD A:ppropriation Act, appropriately reqHires HUD to determine, on
a case by case basis, whether a standard is legal Hnder the Fair HOHsing Act, based Hpon a
'rariety of circHmstances.
EF.
RESIDENT EMPOWERMENT
The Administration strongly supports provisions in both bills, and retention of certain elements
of current law, which empower residents, ensure that residents are given the opportunity to participate
in decisions affecting their Jives, and protect residents from unwarranted intrusions.
In the Administration's view, the final bill must include, at least, the following:
The Senate bill's authorization of the supportive services funding originally
authorized in the FY 1996 appropriation (the EDSS program), which should
include elements of the Tenant Opportunity Program as
proposed in the Administration's bill
Resident membership requirements on the public housing boards of
commissioners, as provided in both bills, and the House bill's required plan
review period for affected residents;
The Senate bill's provisions protecting residents' rights to adequate notice and
consultation and ensuring adequate relocation assistance in the demolition and
disposition process; and
�Automated Records Management SystenHex-Dump Conversion
Retention of current law provisions on: (1) lease and grievance procedures (as
opposed to the House repeal); and (2) notice of lease termination (as opposed to
the House bill's preemption of any minimum notice requirements provided under
State law).
EG.
ACCESS TO MEDICAL RECORDS
The Administration strongly opposes the provision in the Senate bill that would authorize
PHAs to obtain medical information about applicants for housing assistance.
This provision could increase the potential that important antidiscrimination protections of
Federal fair housing laws could be violated and could discourage persons with drug problems
from seeking treatment. The Administration shares the Senate's desire to ensure safety and
security in public housing, and has proposed and implemented tough new policies, such as "One
Strike and You're Out", to achieve that goal. However, the Administration believes that the
Senate's medical records provision goes too far, weakening other important legal protections and
compromising efforts to encourage people with drug abuse problems to enter appropriate and
effective treatment programs. The Administration is concerned that this provision could have
negative consequences for individuals who have received treatment and are attempting to rebuild
their lives.
GH.
PAYMENT STANDARD
The Administration opposes the provisions of both bills allowing PHAs to set the payment
standard in the tenant-based Section 8 program at levels higher than the Fair Market Rent established
by HUD.
The Administration believes that the Payment Standard should be set at no higher than
the Fair Market Rent (FMR) or a HUD-approved exception rent up to 120 of FMR. H.R. 2
would permit PHAs to establish payment standards of 80 to 120 of FMR. The Senate bill
would allow PHAs to establish payment standards of 90 to 110 of FMR, though PHAs may
establish higher or lower payment standards with HUD approval.
The higher the payment standard, the greater the subsidy to each assisted household.
Consequently, fewer eligible families would receive housing assistance. The pressures on PHAs
to help the currently assisted at the expense of the unassisted are very high, and work against
national goals of helping more families in need. In addition, a higher payment standard would
encourage a .greater number of relatively higher-income and less needy families to apply for
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
housing assistance, further reducing the amount of housing assistance available to the poorest
families with the most severe housing needs.
II
OTHER CONCERNS
A. REPEAL OF THE U.S. HOUSING ACT OF 1937
The Administration urges Congress to find another means of signaling dramatic program
reform.
The Administration sees no compelling operational reason to repeal the 1937 Act. The
new law can be crafted so that it clearly calls for sweeping reform of the public housing and
tenant-based assistance programs, without including the complications of repealing the 1937 Act.
There are also practical concerns regarding repeal. At the request of the House Banking
Committee in the previous legislative session, the Administration conducted an extensive review
of the implications of the proposed repeal of the U.S. Housing Act of 1937. HUD determined
that there are, at a minimum, over 500 references to the 1937 Act in other statutes, located both
within and outside of the jurisdiction of the Congressional Banking Committees. Additionally,
the Administration identified a series of issues which the Conferees should address if the repeal is
accepted in the Conference. Moreover, coupling the 1937 Act repeal with a ban on new
regulations prior to the effective date of the law, as provided in the House bill, would inhibit the
ability of the Administration to ensure that the new law is carried out uniformly and with
adequate guidance.
B. RENT LEVELS
1.
Flat Rents
The Administration does not see the need for the House bill provision giving public housing
residents the choice of paying an income-based rent or a flat rent based on the market value of their
units.
This provision would be administratively burdensome to the 3,400 PHAs who will have
to determine the market value of well over one million public housing units, including units in
elderly housing developments. In addition,_ if the goal is to encourage residents to increase their
�Automated Records Management Syslerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
incomes or to encourage relatively higher-income families to move into or remain in public
housing, then the same thing can be accomplished by implementing a program of rent
incentives, including earned income disregards and ceiling rents. Both bills allow PHAs to
adopt innovative rent policies by permitting rents "up to" 30 of adjusted income (as opposed to
current law, which requires rents to be set "at" 30 of adjusted income).
2. Minimum Rents
The Administration opposes the minimum rent provisions in the bills, particularly the
authority in the House bill to set a minimum up to fifty dollars. Instead, the Administration supports a
minimum rent requirement of $25 per month, with an exemption for hardship categories to be
determined by the Secretary or the PHA.
The Administration generally agrees with the concept that every family receiving housing
assistance should make at least some rental payment. However, the Administration believes
such a minimum rent should not exceed $25 per month, an amount which is sufficient to make
the symbolic point that all residents should contribute something to maintenance of their
development without imposing an undue burden on the very poorest families. Thus, the
Administration opposes the House provision allowing PHAs to charge a minimum rent of up to
$50 per month. Further, the Administration believes that the Secretary of HUD must have the
authority to establish hardship exemptions for certain types of cases -- for example, for those
families awaiting public benefit eligibility determinations.
C.
HOME AND CDBG INCOME TARGETING
The Administration opposes the House bill~ unnecessarily loosened income targeting in both
the CDBG and HOME programs.
The Administration strongly objects to the changes which would preclude the Secretary
from capping median incomes at the national median income. Currently, the CDBG and
HOME funds are targetted to assure that low-income families are well served. This proposal
would immediately raise the income limit in thirty-seven relatively higher income metropolitan
areas. For example, in one community, the income limit for a four person family would exceed
$71,000 (Stamford, Connecticut). By allowing families with incomes even above moderate
income ranges to benefit from these programs, these changes would eviscerate the requirement
that those programs substantially benefit low and moderate income households.
D. DISCRETION TO SETTLE LAWSUITS
�Automated Records Management SYBte r
Hex-Dump Conversion
The Administration opposes the House bill's provision which requires the Secretary of HUD
to consult aD adjacent local governments, when settling any lawsuit involving HUD, a PHA, and a
local government.
This provision is an unnecessary intrusion into the federal government's ability to manage
its affairs. Moreover, the Justice Department represents HUD in settling lawsuits. It would be
unwise to require the Secretary of HUD to engage in particular consultations that may conflict
with or duplicate the efforts of the Justice Department. At a minimum, this provision could be
extremely costly for the Federal government, since it will hinder the ability to settle lawsuits in a
timely and cost-effective manner. Finally, the provision is overly broad, since it would require
such consultation for all matters, whether trivial or substantial.
E. CDBG SANCTION
The Administration opposes the House bill's CDBG sanction against local governments
contributing to the troubled status of a PHA.
H.R. 2 provides that the Secretary may withhold or redirect the CDBG funds of any local
government whose actions or inactions have substantially contributed to the troubled status of a
PHA. Current law, coupled with new sanctions included in both bills gives HUD a number of
other sanctions to deal with troubled PHAs, including receivership. The proposed CDBG
sanction could lead to substantial charges, countercharges, and litigation, without resulting in the
improvement of troubled PHAs.
F.
AVAILABILITY OF CRIMINAL CONVICTION RECORDS
The Administration opposes the apparent requirement in the House bill that private owners of
federally assisted housing be provided with information regarding criminal conviction records of adult
applicants or tenants of that housing.
The Administration opposes allowing any private citizens or entities, including the private
owners of federally assisted housing, to obtain criminal record information about other
individuals. The provision of such sensitive information to private individuals and entities raises
significant privacy concerns. The Administration will work with Congress to identify other
means of bolstering security efforts in privately owned, federally assisted housing.
G.
DESIGNATED HOUSING
�Automated Records Management Syster
Hex-Dump Conversion
The Administration opposes the changes HR. 2 makes to current law requirements for
designation ofhousing for elderly persons or persons with disabilities. These changes would weaken
current law provisions requiring PHAs to consider the housing needs ofpersons with disabilities, and
would not allow an adequate time period for proper review of designated housing plans.
Under current law, a PHA's plan to designate housing must meet two requirements.
First, the plan must be "necessary to meet the jurisdiction's Comprehensive Housing Mfordability
Strategy, "and" the plan must be "necessary to meet the low-income housing needs of the
jurisdiction." Under H.R. 2, a PHA would need to meet only one of these two prongs,
showing that a designation plan is necessary to meet either the CHAS "or" the low income
housing needs of the jurisdiction.
These changes are not necessary and are likely to have a detrimental impact on access to
housing for persons with disabilities. The current statutory framework is working effectively.
HUD has been successful in helping PHAs designate thousands of units for elderly persons,
while preserving housing access for persons with disabilities in those communities.
Allowing a PHA to rely solely on a CHAS, as H.R. 2 proposes, may lead to designations
which are inconsistent with the housing needs of persons served by the PHA. The CHAS is
written based upon Consolidated Plan regulations that are tailored to community planning and
development programs and that do not require communities to assess the housing needs of
persons with disabilities in general. Rather, they refer specifically only to persons with
disabilities who require service-connected or accessible housing. The vast majority of persons
with disabilities who apply to live in public housing are merely low-income individuals who also
have disabilities. They are neither looking for, nor need supportive housing.
In addition, the submission and review of designated housing plans should not be
incorporated into the PHA's !!local housing management plan!!, as under the House bill. The
Administration believes that, since they involve significant decisions that could permanendy limit
access to important housing resources for some low-income people, designated housing plans
should be considered separately from the many other administrative and management issues that
are addressed in the local housing management plan.
H
TOTAL DEVELOPMENT COSTS
The Administration urges the Conferees to indude language reflecting the Administration's
proposal on total development costs.
�•
Automated Records Management Sys!en"
Hex-Dump Conversion
The Conference staffs have beeR provided 'i..-ith are being provided HUD's proposal on
total development costs. The proposal would assure that capital costs allowed for HOPE VI
and other public housing development will produce sound and durable, but modest, housing that
fits into the community. It would also assure that the costs of community development and
supportive service activities are not confused with the costs of housing construction. HUD
urges the Conferees to include statutory language that reflects this proposal.
L OCCUPANCY STANDARDS
HUD opposes the House provision barring a national occupancv standard. solely
because the provision may cause confusion regarding HUD's authority.
HUD has ~o intention to establish, directly or indirectly, a national occupancy standard.
The Department continues to follow Congress's direction in the FY 1996 HUD Appropriations
Act which requires that HUD, in connection with a complaint under the Fair Housing Act
determine theat
legality of a State or local standard, on a case-by-case basis, considering a
circumstances.
variety of
11.
VOLUNTEER SER VICES
The Administration urges the Conferees to take this opportunitY to revise the volunteer
exception to the Davis-Bacon Act to conform to the language of the Community Improvement
Volunteer Act of 1994.
There is no policy reason to continue the differences in the definitions of volunteer
exemptions. The Administration included the necessary language in its public housing bill
(H.R. 1447, Section 121). Any volunteer provisions regarding resident management
corporations also need to be consistent with this definition.
KJ.
SEXUALLY VIOLENTPREDATORS
A rule barring "sexually Violent predators" from public housing probably would be difficult or
impossible to enfOrce. In addition. housing agencies already have access to the infOrmation
contained in the National Sex Offender Registry.
Section 641(c) of H.R. 2 and § 301 (0 of S.462 would require public housing agencies
to exclude "sexually violent predators" as defined in the Wetterling Act (42 U.S.G 14071).
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
•
The Wetterling Act contains standards for States sex offender registration programs. In the past,
those standards required states to determine convicted sex offenders are "sexually violent
predators" (using a partially legal and quash-psychiatric definition set out in the Act), for purpose
of imposing registration requirements. However, under recent amendment to the Act, States no
longer are required to make such determinations. Instead, they can adopt other measures to
protect the public from particularly dangerous sex offenders. Because it is predictable that many
states will not make "sexually violent predator" determinations, a rule barring "sexually violent
predators" from public housing will probably be difficult or impossible to enforce.
Section 644(a) of H.R. 2 and § 304(b) of S.462 require the FBI and state and local
agencies to provide public housing agencies with information collected under the National Sex
Offender Registry (NSOR) or a State registry. An an initial matter, these provisions refer to
language ("designated State law enforcement agency: and "local law enforcement agency
authorized by the State agency") that is no longer in the Wetterling Act. In addition, an NSOR
check alone will not to reveal whether' a sex offender is a "sexually violent predator." As it
currently exists, NSOR is a system for noting on an offender's criminal history record in the
FBI's records system if he or she is a convicted sex offender required to register in some State.
A person accessing the record can contact the State for more detailed information. If a State
uses the "sexually violent predator" classification, the State registry may reveal whether a sex
offender has been determined to be a sexually violent predator.
Finally, there already are procedures for housing agencies to obtain criminal history
record information on housing applications from the FBI. The agencies can use the existing
procedures to determine whether an applicant is a convicted sex offender, and then contact the
state for additional information.
I look forward to contributing to the constructive resolution of these issues.
please call upon me and the HUD staff for any assistance we can provide.
Sincerely,
Andrew Cuomo
As always,
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[07/07/1998 – 07/17/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 099 - Folder 004
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/fbfd71aa02f87c162bf993e6270dfc6e.pdf
ab3b106ee97c406face19da99c67ea4c
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC-KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 099 - FOLDER -003
[06/18/1998-07/07/1998]
�Withdrawal/Redaction Sheet
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
AND TYPE
00 I. email
SUBJECTrrlTLE
DATE
Email to Dorian Weaver et al from Stacie Spector. Subject: Invitation
RESTRICTION
06/18/1998
Personal Misfile
06/22/1998
Personal Misfile
06/24/1998
Personal Misfile
(3 pages)
002. email
Email to Dorian Weaver et al from Stacie Spector. Subject: Invitation
(4 pages)
003. email
Email to Vinca LaFleur et al from Stacie Spector. Subject: Invitation
(10 pages)
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management System [Email]
CEA ([Kagan])
ONBox Number: 950000
FOLDER TITLE:
[06/18/1998 - 07107/1998]
2009-1006-F
jm52
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act - 144 U.S.c. 2204(a)1
Freedom of Information Act - 15 U.S.c. 552(b))
PI National Security Classified Information l(a)(l) of the PRAI
P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office l(a)(2) of the PRAI
P3 Release would violate a Federal statute l(a)(3) of the PRAI
b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
financial information l(a)(4) of the PRAI
P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President
and his advisors, or between such advisors la)(5) of the PRAI
P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(a)(6) of the PRAI
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
of gift.
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.c.
2201(3).
RR. Document will be reviewed upon request.
b(l) National security classified information I(b)(i) of the FOtAI
an agency l(b)(2) of the FOIAI
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute l(b)(3) of the FOtAI
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial
information l(b)(4) of the FOtAI
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(b)(6) of the FOtAI
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes l(b)(7) of the FOtAI
b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
financial institutions l(b)(8) of the FOJAI
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
concerning wells l(b)(9) of the FOJAI
�..
ARMS Email System
Page I of2
-{~
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. GeisbertjOU=OPDjO=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:l8-JUN-l998 09:39:59.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: marti.thomas
READ: UNKNOWN
marti.thomas @ msOl.do.treas.sprint.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
Grundman-Stacey @ dol.gov @ inet
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: sheketoff-emily ( sheketoff-emily @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Grundman-Stacey
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: kburkel ( kburkel @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael CohenjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. TurmanjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. BeierjO=OVp @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAILARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAILARD C
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. RicejOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. JenningsjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. ToivjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby DonenfeldjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne LambrewjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. FreedmanjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JONATHAN.GRUBER ( JONATHAN.GRUBER @ MSOl.DO.treas.sprint.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer.moore ( Jennifer.moore @ justice.usdoj.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: guzy.gary ( guzy.gary @ epamail.epa.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: johara ( johara @ osophs.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�IA~S
Page 2 of2
Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William H. white Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=William H. White Jr./OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. Mendelson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Gina C. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
,
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (WHO)
CC: Sat ish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting is scheduled for today, June 18, at
2:45 in Room 211 OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
I..
Page 1 of5
_"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN:Rebecca M. Blank/OU:CEA/O:EOP [ CEA)
)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 18-JUN-1998 11:54:17.00
SUBJECT:
Poverty measurement
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: UNKNOWN
CN:Elena Kagan/OU:OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ) )
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN:Barbara Chow/OU:OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ) )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine K. Wallman ( CN:Katherine K. wallman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ) )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD)
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN:Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O:EOP @ EOP [ OMB ) )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Andrea Kane ( CN:Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ) )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Paul Bugg ( CN=Paul Bugg/OU:OMB/O:EOP @ EOP [ OMB )
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN:Cecilia E. Rouse/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD)
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TEXT:
Attached is a memo that tries to communicate a few points that I think are
key as we move into simulating program effects of alternative poverty
measures.
The memo also makes some recommendations for the first set of
simulations that OMB might want to produce.=::====::====:::==== ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
1
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D24)MAIL480492965.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043940400000l0A02010000000205000000E7200000000200006100370F70114FD5B1880D
EBB102A52EE6C8ACFE6230E3E19CA6F7EE74826F3D62F696C01C92AE7DEC0025880D120BC3C145
8804974C171B596938448BBEC5C5D6E3C34A4CA9DC41F88B64922FA025C74EB32C1B33696D6E2A
OE5796F94F55815C900A6E6C7C8AE490AF459F424FE70A95DD662C5345F89D454E109C8C8578F1
5E9F7A5AF7121D389B0271E4420F94009F43462AA3E434784EF6A446EEFOD42EE66ED189EEBEAO
BDA2AF62C92853C1B9C35481A49001F36DCA6D256849E1E6E285El61361E766F237EE28AA46D95
2096BFCEFCE08496ADBADFAEA2DB56782E82A838S20BC6S9C4F1D3SDFC1A190915182D13E143E2
253F0768F2E2BB37D20AFD8E13410382E6CB781SC1E44771FF35FCCOFDE8008CEA766A03BD869D
D680E1A649595S07364BAE5S0D18940C8429DC1924F4E8E21COASOA7AF21C9SC26E8BE6477SS09
4B99EC630639D78FOC79643C23A71S8C7C25CE9ED088B1ASC02BAB21A50CA67S90639416SBDF3B
8BD4FD6F3B1726D55AA70A72676948ES339836FD3A6172418409DCE2BB49694B55BA8A1DBF2C09
971BD80SS432FC5343SD6SC75724F6F2FB6C9BSC2C418EC611381B6DCBAFB7A4BFF80F8A017A8E
D18F2FBEB89186DOE071D41A29ADF6782C403F40CC9C36BB3BC10892343B761FA066A2F72BSECC
050D09B93B02000A00000000000000000000000823010000000BOl00008C02000000SS01000000
4E00000097030000092S0100000006000000ES0300000B300200000028000000EB030000087701
000000400000001304000008340100000014000000530400000802010000000F00000067040000
0805010000000800000076040000060801000000160000007E04000000984C006F00630061006C
�June 18, 1998
TO:
Poverty Measurement Working Group
FROM:
Automated R,
fiI ecorr/s M.
eX-Dump Canagement S
onversion ij'stem
Rebecca Blank
Because I thought there were still some misunderstandings in our meeting last Tuesday, I want to
provide a little background information and make a suggestion about how OMB should proceed
as it puts together some simulations of program effects.
Let me start with two comments that I believe might need clarifying:
(1) The primary way in which changes in the poverty measurement will affect program spending
is through changes in the Guidelines, the simplified poverty thresholds published by HHS. In
fact, most programs (and ALL the big programs) that are tied in any way to poverty measurement
are tied to the Guidelines. Since the Guidelines are NOT the same as the poverty thresholds
used by Census to calculate the actual poverty rate, but are tabulated by HHS and include a
variety of changes to those thresholds, it is impossible to simulate the program effects of a
change in poverty measurement without making some assumptions about what sort of Guidelines
HHS would issue under an alternative measure ofpoverty.
(2) There is no consistency across programs in how family income and eligibility is calculated.
In fact, it's quite amazing how very inconsistent even quite similar programs are. Programs
have dealt with the fact that they care about different income levels and concepts in part by using
different multiples of the poverty guidelines as part of their eligibility determination -- some
programs use 100%, some use 135%, some use 185%, etc. This means that conceptually it
really doesn't matter what the guidelines are because programs can always use whatever multiple
they find most convenient. Of course, in the real world, programs have specifically enacted
legislation that commits them to (say) setting the upper level of eligibility at households whose
countable income for that specific program is below 135% of the Guidelines. These specific
program rules are hard to change in the short run.
However, most programs use a measure offamily income that is much closer to "cash income"
than to the 'full income" measure proposed by the NRC for an improved measure ofpoverty.
(3) Programs are currently designed to use the existing Guidelines which assume family income
is defined as cash income. This suggests that at least one simulation we want to do is the
following "What are the program effects of a change in the poverty measure, if we translate the
alternative poverty thresholds (based on full income) into poverty thresholds that are closer to the
cash income concept utilized by the programs and use this "cash equivalent threshold" to
establish the Guidelines?" This essentially means recalculating the alternative thresholds to
"back out" the concepts not included in cash income. Specifically, one would take the
alternative thresholds (designed to be compared to "full income") and add back in average child
care and work expenses, MOOP, and taxes and subtract off average in-kind benefits. This gives
you the cash-equivalent threshold implied by the alternative threshold.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Now comes a key point that I felt wasn't understood in Tuesday's meeting: One of the Pros of
utilizing a benchmarked poverty rate is that the cash equivalent value of the alternative
thresholds under benchmarking must of necessity be very close to the current Guidelines. This
is because of the way benchmarking works -- the thresholds are the residual calculation once you
use a specific definition of family income and set an aggregate poverty rate. Essentially, the
thresholds under benchmarking are the poverty line that, given a definition of "full income",
results in the current poverty rate. If! were to ask "what is the cash equivalent to those
thresholds that provides the same poverty rate?" this must result in an answer very closer to the
current Guidelines since the current poverty line is a cash income threshold that results in the
current poverty rate. There's no funny business here. It must be true mathematically that, if we
say "We want the cash equivalent threshold implied by the alternative thresholds being used in
our new measure of poverty" and if those thresholds are coming from a benchmarked alternative
measure, then the cash equivalent thresholds will be very close to current poverty lines.
This suggests there are probably four program simulations that OMB wants to focus on:
1. Take the thresholds that result from a benchmarked alternative poverty measure and assume
they are blindly turned into Guidelines and calculate the program effects absent any other
program changes.
2. Take the thresholds that result from a benchmarked alternative poverty measure and assume
they are translated into their cash equivalent values and these cash equivalent values are used to
set the Guidelines (i.e., we try to produce Guidelines that reflect current program needs.)
3. Take the thresholds that result from a non-benchmarked alternative poverty measure (i.e., the
18% poverty rate calculated as the NRC alternative, or something close to it) and assume they are
blindly turned into Guidelines and calculate the program effects absent any other program
changes.
4. Take the thresholds that result from a non-benchmarked alternative poverty measure and
assume they are translated into their cash equivalent values and these cash equivalent values are
used to set the Guidelines (i.e., we try to produce Guidelines that reflect current program needs.)
Final note: Both procedures 2 and 3 are going to result in new Guidelines very close to the
current Guidelines and hence lead to quite small program changes, even in the absence of any
change in program rules or regulations. (This is true for procedure 3 only because -- quite by
accident -- the "full-income' thresholds that result from the alternative NRC poverty calculation
are very close to the current poverty line.) I think procedure 2 is much more defensible than
procedure 3, but leaving arguments over the merit aside this does suggest that there are quite
feasible calculations that are very conceptually defensible and that will result in only small
program changes and may require no adjustments to the program rules. Without prejudging at
all what our future recommendations might be, this is an important piece of information.
(All of this ignores changes in the composition of the poor that will result in changes in the
distribution of benefits across groups regardless of how the Guidelines are defined -- This is
obviously also a very important issue, but separable from the Guidelines issue discussed above.)
�Withdrawal/Redaction Marker
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
AND TYPE
001. email
DATE
SUBJECTrrITLE
Email to Dorian Weaver et al from Stacie Spector. Subject: Invitation
(3 pages)
0611 8/1998
RESTRICTION
Personal Misfile
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management System [Email]
CEA ([Kagan])
ONBox Number: 950000
FOLDER TITLE:
[0611811998 - 07/07/1998]
2009-1006-F
jm52
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act - [44 U.S.c. 2204(a)[
Freedom of Information Act - [5 U.S.C. 552(b)[
PI National Security Classified Information [(a)(l) of the PRAI
P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office [(a)(2) of the PRAI
P3 Release would violate a Federal statute [(a)(3) of the PRAI
b(l) National security classified information [(b)(I) of the FOIAI
b(l) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
an agency l(b)(2) of the FOIAI
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute [(b)(3) of the FOIAI
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or conlidential or linancial
information [(b)(4) of the FOIAI
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy [(b)(6) of the FOIAI
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes [(b)(7) of the FOIAI
b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
financial institutions [(b)(8) of the FOIAI
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
concerning wells [(b)(9) of the FOIAI
P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
financial information [(a)(4) of the PRAI
P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President
and his advisors, or between such advisors [a)(5) of the PRAI
P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy [(a)(6) of the PRAI
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
of gift.
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.c.
2201(3).
RR. Document will be reviewed upon request.
�" __ ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 4
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:18-JUN-1998 21:34:32.00
SUBJECT:
Tennessee Travel
TO: Julianne B. Corbett ( CN=Julianne B. Corbett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [.WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�A~.MS
Page 2 of4
Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/'O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig Hughes ( CN=Craig Hughes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�A~MS
Email System
Page 3 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
,..
Page 4 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda rrr·( CN=Jose Cerda rrr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel to Nashville on Monday to participate in the
Vice President's Family Conference.
Background and event memos are due on Saturday at noon (before the WH
Staff picnic).
Of course, r would appreciate it if you could get me
things Friday night.
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
�ARMS Email System
C"
Page 1 of5
11
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:22-JUN-1998 10:29:21.00
SUBJECT:
REVISED HUD Report on S462,HR 2 Public Housing Reform and Responsibility A
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. Carroll/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Zweig ( CN=Lisa Zweig/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan D. Breul ( CN=Jonathan D. Breul/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelly A. McAllister ( CN=Shelly A. McAllister/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard H. Kodl
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Richard H. Kodl/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Joseph F. Lackey Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Joseph F. Lackey Jr./OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Chin-Chin Ip ( CN=Chin-Chin Ip/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey A. Farkas ( CN=Jeffrey A. Farkas/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James F. Jordan ( CN=James F. Jordan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alan B. Rhinesmith ( CN=Alan B. Rhinesmith/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joanne Chow ( CN=Joanne Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles E. Kieffer ( CN=Charles E. Kieffer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin P. Cichetti ( CN=Kevin P. Cichetti/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB l. )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Norwood J. Jackson Jr ( CN=Norwood J. Jackson Jr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mathew C. Blum ( CN=Mathew C. Blum/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Winifred Y. Chang ( CN=Winifred Y. Chang/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maya A. Bernstein ( CN=Maya A. Bernstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pamela B. vanWie ( CN=Pamela B. VanWie/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen H. Walsh ( CN=Maureen H. Walsh/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Menard ( CN=Barbara A. Menard/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anil Kakani ( CN=Anil Kakani/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer C. Wagner ( CN=Jennifer C. Wagner/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea KanejOU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leanne A. Shimabukuro ( CN=Leanne A. Shimabukuro/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine L. Meredith .( CN=Katherine L. Meredith/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S. Redburn/OU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS·Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: MNB192
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Monday, June 22, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395 - 6148
SUBJECT:
REVISED HUD Report on S462,HR 2 Pubiic Housing Reform and
Responsibility Act of 1997
DEADLINE:
COB
Monday, June 22, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: To follow is a revised version of the HUD report on Public
Housing Reform, redlined to show the changes that were made in response to
comments received on the first draft.
We understand that significant portions of the public housing legislation
will be attached to the House VA/HUD appropriations bill, which is
scheduled to be marked up by the Appropriations Committee this Thursday.
HUD would like to send its letter before Appropriations Committee action.
The deadline is firm.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
7-AGRICULTURE - Marvin Shapiro - (202) 720-1516
61-JUSTICE - L. Anthony Sutin - (202) 514-2141
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
l18-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
l29-VETERANS AFFAIRS - John H. Thompson - (202) 273-6666
29-DEFENSE - Samuel T. Brick Jr. - (703) 697-1305
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
59-INTERIOR - Jane Lyder - (202) 208-4371
51-General Services Administration - William R. Ratchford - (202) 501-0563
89-0ffice of National Drug Control Policy - John Carnevale - (202) 395-6736
71-National Council on Disability - Andrew Imparato - (202) 272-2112
EOP:
�Page 4 of5
ARMS Email System
Michael Deich
Alan B. Rhinesmith
Francis S. Redburn
James F. Jordan
Katherine L. Meredith
Jose Cerda III
Leanne A. Shimabukuro
Diana Fortuna
Andrea Kane
Paul J. weinstein Jr.
Sarah Rosen
Elena Kagan
Jennifer C. wagner
Jeffrey A. Farkas
Ani I l<akani
Chin-Chin Ip
Barbara A. Menard
Larry R. Matlack
Maureen H. Walsh
Debra J. Bond
Pamela B. VanWie
Joseph F. Lackey Jr.
Maya A. Bernstein
Richard H. Kodl
Winifred Y. Chang
Shelly A. McAllister
Mathew C. Blum
Jonathan D. Breul
Norwood J. Jackson Jr
Broderick Johnson
Kevin P. Cichetti
Kate P. Donovan
. Charles E. Kieffer
Lisa Zweig
Joanne Chow
Christopher D. Carroll
Janet R. Forsgren
James C. Murr
LRM ID: MNB192 SUBJECT:
REVISED HUD Report on S462,HR 2 Public Housing
Reform and Responsibility Act of 1997
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Melissa N. Benton
Phone:
395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
�Page 5 of5
ARMS Email System
Office of Management and Budget Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
==================
END ATTACHMENT
1
==================
�Withdrawal/Redaction Marker
Clinton Library
DOCVMENT NO.
AND TYPE
002. email
SVBJECTrrlTLE
DATE
Email to Dorian Weaver et al from Stacie Spector. Subject: Invitation
(4 pages)
06/2211998
RESTRICTION
Personal Misfile
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management System [Email]
CEA ([Kagan])
ONBox Number: 950000
FOLDER TITLE:
[06118/1998 - 07/07/1998]
2009-1006-F
jm52
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act - 144 V.S.c. 2204(a)1
Freedom of Information Act - IS V.S.c. 552(b)l
PI National Security Classified Information l(a)(l) of the PRAI
P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office l(a)(2) of the PRAI
P3 Release would violate a Federal statute l(a)(3) of the PRAI
b(l) National security classified information [(b)(l) of the FOIAI
b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
an agency (b)(2) of the FOIAI
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute I(b)(3) of the FOIAI
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial
information (b)(4) of the FOIAI
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy [(b)(6) of the FOIAI
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes [(b)(7) of the FOIAI
b(S) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
financial institutions (b)(S) of the FOIAI
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
concerning wells [(b)(9) of the FOIAI
P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
financial information l(a)(4) of the PRAI
P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President
and his advisors, or between such advisors la)(5) of the PRAI
P6 Release would constitute a clearlY unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy [(a)(6) of the PRAI
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
of gift.
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 V.S.c.
2201(3).
RR. Document will be revie,",'ed upon request.
�Page 1 of3
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:22-JUN-1998 19:42:35.00
SUBJECT:
HUD Report on Public Housing Reform Conference--comments are due
TO: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joanne Chow ( CN=Joanne Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles E. Kieffer ( CN=Charles E. Kieffer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin P. Cichetti ( CN=Kevin P. Cichetti/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Norwood J. Jackson Jr ( CN=Norwood J. Jackson Jr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mathew C. Blum ( CN=Mathew C. Blum/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ : UNKNOWN
TO: Winifred Y. Chang ( CN=Winifred Y. Chang/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maya A. Bernstein ( CN=Maya A. Bernstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pamela B. VanWie ( CN=Pamela B. VanWie/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen H. Walsh ( CN=Maureen H. Walsh/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Menard ( CN=Barbara A. Menard/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anil Kakani ( CN=Anil Kakani/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer C. Wagner ( CN=Jennifer C. Wagner/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leanne A. Shimabukuro ( CN=Leanne A. Shimabukuro/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [.OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alan B. Rhinesmith ( CN=Alan B. Rhinesmith/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. Carroll/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Zweig ( CN=Lisa zweig/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Jonathan D. Breul ( CN=Jonathan D. Breul/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Shelly A. McAllister ( CN=Shelly A. McAllister/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard H. Kodl
READ: UNKNOWN
)
( CN=Richard H. Kodl/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB ] )
TO: Joseph F. Lackey Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Joseph F. Lackey Jr./OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB]
)
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Chin-Chin Ip ( CN=Chin-Chin Ip/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey A. Farkas ( CN=Jeffrey A. Farkas/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weiristein Jr.
READ: qNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD ] )
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD.]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Theodore Wartell ( CN=Theodore Wartell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB]
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
J ( J [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Katherine L. Meredith ( CN=Katherine L. Meredith/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James F. Jordan ( CN=James F. Jordan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB ] )
)
�.
ARMS Email System
Page 3 of3
,.
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This is a reminder that your comments on the subject report are due.
please provide all comments no later than 10 a.m. tomorrow.
If I do not
hear from you, I will assume you have no comments and will clear the
report.
Please call.(5-7887) if you have any comments or questions.
Thanks!
�ARMS Email System
(\.
Page 1 of4
(.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:23-JUN-1998 15:35:55.00
SUBJECT:
HHS RELEASE
TO: Anil Kakani ( CN=Anil Kakani/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil.E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura. Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
HHS/ACF did background briefing this morning on the two reports
referenced in release below. Michael Kharfen said it went well.
Reporters attending were: Laura Meckler, AP; Judy Haveman, Post; Rich
Wolf, USA Today; Ina Jaffe, NPR.
Barry, I wouldn't think you'd get press
questions, but if you want Q&As, let me know.
We did a weekly item
already on the MDRC study of Portland.
I'll do one this week on Urban
Institute 5-state study though it's primarily a snapshot, and not an
impact evaluation.
---------------------- Forwarded by Andrea Kane/OPD/EOP on 06/23/98 03:29
PM ------------~--------------
mhennegh @ OS.DHHS.GOV
06/23/98 02:32:56 PM
Please respond to mhennegh@os.dhhs.gov
Record Type: Record
To: HHSPRESS @ LIST.NIH.GOV
cc:
Subject: HHS RELEASE
�ARMS Email System
i,
Page 2 of4
,.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Tuesday, June 23, 1998
Contact:
Michael Kharfen
(202) 401- 9215
REPORTS EXAMINE SUCCESSFUL WELFARE-TO-WORK EFFORTS
HHS Secretary Donna E. Shalala today released two reports that
examine
successful programs in five states and one city helping welfare recipients
move into jobs.
"As states and localities develop their own welfare-to-work
programs,
they need to know how successful programs are achieving results," Secretary
Shalala said.
The efforts outlined in these reports are excellent examples
of programs that work."
One
System, "
prepared by
implemented
five states
average.
of the studies,
"Building an Employment Focused Welfare
the Urban Institute, examines how welfare reform is being
by Indiana, Massachusetts, Oregon, Virginia and Wisconsin
that have experienced caseload declines well above the national
The second report prepared by the Manpower Development Research
Corporation, "Implementation, Participation Costs, and Two-Year Impacts of
the Portland (Oregon) Welfare-to-Work Program," looks at Portland, Oregon's
welfare-to-work program, which reduced welfare expenditures by 17 percent
over a two-year period, while increasing recipients' earnings by 35
percent.
"I am encouraged that these programs report substantial numbers of
welfare parents working, and significantly in jobs paying more than the
minimum wage," said Olivia Golden, HHS Assistant Secretary for Children and
Families.
"Moving from welfare to work must mean opening new doors of
opportunity for families."
The five-state study focuses specifically on experiences
implementing
"Work First," the philosophy that most welfare recipients are capable of
obtaining employment, that any job is better than no job and that the best
way to succeed in the labor market is to join it.
The five states studied in the Urban Institute report were already
restructuring their welfare systems to emphasize work when Congress passed
major federal welfare reform in 1996. That legislation eliminated
traditional open-ended cash assistance provided by the Aid to Families with
Dependent Children (AFDC)
program and the Job Opportunities and Basic
Skills Training (JOBS) program. Congress replaced these programs with the
Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program, which provides block
grants to individual states, and which requires work for welfare
recipients.
"There has been a shift in welfare-to-work programs across the
country,
from relying on providing education and training as the major route to
self-sufficiency, to programs which embrace a Work First philosophy," said
Pamela A. Holcomb of the Urban Institute. "The point of this report is to
show how states are accomplishing this shift."
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of4
"
Typical practices, the researchers report, included (1) making a
job
search the first and central activity, (2) limiting participation in
education and training, (3) imposing stricter participation and work
requirements, including greater use of unpaid work experience (4) enforcing
stiffer penalties for noncompliance and (5) placing time limits on
assistance.
While the Work First programs in all five states shared common
features, each state combined elements to create its own unique version of
welfare reform.
For example:
u Virginia provided recipients with the greatest opportunity to combine
assistance with employment but also applied severe penalties for
non-cooperation;
u
Both Virginia and Massachusetts imposed work requirements sooner than the
other states and relied more extensively on community service programs to
engage recipients in some form of work;
u
Oregon developed the most successful program for creating subsidized
employment opportunities for welfare recipients.
By tracking a sample of recipients over a one year period, the
five-state study found that 31-44 percent of the participants at the end of
the year were still receiving cash assistance or back on welfare, with or
without a job.
"The Portland results provide valuable lessons on how to not only
get
more people working, but also get them better jobs, and on how to succeed
with those typically considered hard to place in jobs," said Gayle Hamilton
of the MDRC.
"The program emphasized getting a job quickly, but also used
some education and training as tools to get· there."
Portland, Oregon's efforts have been among the most effective among
large-scale mandatory programs, according to the report prepared by the
Manpower Demonstration Research Corporation. By the end of the study
period, just 41 percent of program group members were receiving welfare,
compared to 53 percent of control group members.
The proportion of people
working at full-time jobs increased by 13 percent, and the proportion with
employer-provided health benefits increased by 10 percent.
The Portland program used a mixed-services strategy: most people
participated in job search, but many also participated in short-term
education, vocational training, work experience, and life skills training.
Failure to participate resulted in welfare grant reductions.
- More -
3 -
One important feature of the Portland program is that it increased
job
quality.
Participants were encouraged to look for and take "good"
jobs--full-time jobs, paying more than the minimum wage, with benefits and
potential for advancement.
The studies suggest that states will need to adopt a greater range
�ARMS Email System
/.
and
mix of services and strategies to help the least employable welfare
recipients, Assistant Secretary Golden said.
###
Note: HHS press releases are available on the World Wide Web at:
http://www.hhs.gov.
Page 4 of4
�-'
ARMS Email System
Page I of2
\.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:24-JUN-1998 13:19:21.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meetings
TO, marti.thomas ( marti.thomas @ msOl.do.treas.sprint.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Grundman-Stacey ( Grundman-Stacey @ dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: sheketoff-emily ( sheketoff-emily @ dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: kburkel ( kburkel @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JONATHAN.GRUBER ( JONATHAN.GRUBER @ MSOl.DO.treas.sprint.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer.moore ( Jennifer.moore @ justice.usdoj.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
L UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: guzy.gary ( guzy.gary @ epamail.epa.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: johara
johara @ osophs.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
I'
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William H. White Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=william H. White Jr./OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. Mendelson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C @ Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Gina C. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN~Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY_MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TEXT:
The Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meetings scheduled every Thursday at 2:45 in
the OEOB will be suspended until further notice
�Withdrawal/Redaction Marker
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
AND TYPE
003. email
SUBJECTfflTLE
DATE
Email to Vinca LaFleur et al from Stacie Spector. Subject: Invitation
(10 pages)
06/24/1998
RESTRICTION
Personal Misfile
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management System [Email]
CEA ([Kagan])
ONBox Number: 950000
FOLDER TITLE:
[06118/1998 - 07/0711998]
2009-1006-F
jm52
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act -144 U.S.c. 2204(a)1
Freedom of Information Act - 15 U.S.c. 552(bll
PI National Security Classified Information l(a)(I) of the PRAI
P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office l(a)(2) of the PRAI
P3 Release would violate a Federal statute l(a)(3) of the PRAI
b(l) National security classified information l(b)(I) of the FOIAI
b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
an agency l(b)(2) of the FOIAI
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute I(b)(3) of the FOIAI
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial
information l(b)(4) of the FOIAI
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(b)(6) of the FOIAI
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes l(b)(7) of the FOIAI
b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
financial institutions l(b)(8) of the FOJAI
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
concerning wells l(b)(9) of the FOIAI
P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
financial information l(a)(4) of the PRAI
P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President
and his advisors, or between such advisors la)(5) of the PRAI
P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(a)(6) of the PRAI
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
of gift.
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.c.
2201(3).
RR. Document will be reviewed upon request.
�Page 1 of2
- ARMS Email System
. - ...
~
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:24-JUN-1998 17:54:35.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: "UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
,.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernst.ein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in rm 100. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
OPD 1 )
CREATOR: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP
CREATION DATE/TIME:25-JUN-1998 12:36:52.00
SUBJECT:
Income/poverty mtg
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul Bugg ( CN=Paul Bugg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ OMB 1 )
CC: Lisa D. Branch ( CN=Lisa D. Branch/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The next income/poverty meeting will be held Thursday July 9th at 11:00 am
in Sally's office. Room 231.
Please let me know of any conflicts.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 11
lNOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP
[ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:25-JUN-1998 17:40:23.00
SUBJECT:
For the income and poverty group
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul Bugg ( CN=Paul Bugg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sat ish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1
CC: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Any and all comments are welcome.
Please send to Ceci next week.
Thanks.
---------------------- Forwarded by Shannon Mason/OPD/EOP on 06/25/98
06:51 PM ---------------------------
Cecilia E. Rouse
06/25/98 05:32:28 PM
Record
Record Type:
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 11
To:
Shannon Mason/OPD/EOP
cc:
Subject:
For the income and poverty group
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D35] MAIL46095867U. 126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504332060000010A020100000002050000008753000000020000A2BIB743EICCEFC75B83Bl
8E930D8EE2D846752CB7E337A23COD4858A70F004289EOCA3C43478BF37F4A9B56362D7CF703El
42062E4C9C12A094EAA881903B9E351239F218872A0015AC93230DEBA86EBDOCIF08DBF4A2F673
A6F2E7ACIFIDBD8AIECCA1329258567EFDD335BC49BF73D202EE1336E75740DAFCBD3C0759A988
19F8464711FACE2D41F2CF4EOCOFIF4816B09564CB2D88AF4EAE15458B8484EBAFDID6B7A6C61B
7 4A3CIC2 9 9 96DOE6D4 3 C8BAC6 8A2 2 0 7 5FO 6 3BBB4 3 816 6 2 81D12 7 2EE9 5 7 8A 7 A'6 8 9BC4 2 96D3191D6
3AA74EB954F5FBD91C890307E83367FE371EB861A3B66F0098C8782COOD945372CD9EFCCOA8644
45228B8E396EB3F3A5ACB4FCF02AA86811674BC2D328C48A52C786B676C7BE9B9E14DA6DDCFFOO
9DFB303BADB78F4E7D58D440BIC937FCEB24F4FFD65EIFB29FDF665llAOAOC27BAE92EFA2999BO
CB686EA0074070B781C60BE3254A826127356B5BE6854DBIB646C8OCEBB5318A16D263A78FOADE
5C35559BB3A8B9D30EFE289E443AE294A2D523C56A291075E4AE678C2CAE5ACD28EA424F394D89
8F24FBDD12CACFDA73B2478F16C5D6BC683BA334F13FBBIEF843DEF599963301BOB09034BB95B2
F7F44BF227D9E3B9E3F429AF8E9103769381AF7019341F8C2249B57DF8D4C2B9BBB47D774CIFA4
80CF95841602002000000000000000000000000823010000000BOI0000C0030000005501000000
4EOOOOOOCB04000009250100000006000000190500000B3002000000280000001F050000081601
0000003200000047050000087701000000400000007905000008340100000014000000B9050000
0802010000000FOOOOOOCD05000008050100000008000000DC0500OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOODC
05000000000POOOOOOOOOOOOOODC05000000000000000000000000DC0500000000000000000000
0000DC05000000000000000000000000DC05000000000000000000000000DC0500000000000000
0000000000DC05000000000000000000000000DC05000000000000000000000000DC0500000000
0000000000000000DC05000000000000000000000000DC05000000000000000000000000DC0500
0000000000000000000000DC05000000000000000000000000DC05000000000000000000000000
DC05000000000000000000000000DC05000000000000000000000000DC05000000000000000000
000000DC05000000000000000000000000DC05000000000000000000000000DC05000000000000
000000000000DC0500000B30070000004EOOOOOOE405000000984C006F00630061006C00200050
00720069006E007400650072000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800C800
2C012C012C012COIC800C800300000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000BOI00002800C8196810480DOO0011090000005AOOOBOI0000
103600540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052006FOO6D0061006E00200052006500
670075006C006100720000000000000000000100020058020100000004U0280000000000000000
0000000000000000000000011202002400AI000000AI00000043003A005C00500052004F004700
53005C00570050005C005300540041004E0044004100520044002E0057005000540000000AOOOO
003507010048003607010002003707020002003807010045003907020002003A07010045003B07
010002003C07010048003D07010002003E0731006581369CC722000000004100600D940DI00060
ODF41F08337C007800000200003E0700000301000400020000000100000004003EOOOOOOOOOOOO
00100000000000000000000000031587A624002206000053006DOO61006C006C00200043006900
720063006C0065000000F02206FOE0300C0000000008070COOEODDOAI000830104000300020021
1000DDDDOBOB00030000040BOODDFI023E07F19BFI033E07FIFI003E07F19BFI013E07FIFI023E
07FIFI033E07FIDI0337008001000016009CE4010000000003000058020000000000000064FOOO
000000000000000000000000000000000064C8003700DIDI020DOO000100FDOOOAODOOD14A756E
6580FI003E07F19CFI013E07F132352CFI003E07F19BFI013E07FlFI023E07FIFI033E07F18031
393938D0041500000B00090001B0040000000001201500DOCCF20CF24452414654F30CF3804D45
4D4F52414E44554D80464F5280454F50805052494E434950414C53804D454554494E47D0041500
�June 25, 1998
DRAFT MEMORANDUM FOR EOP PRINCIPALS MEETING
FROM:
???
SUBJECT:
BENCHMARKING THE NRC-BASED INCOME AND POVERTY
MEASURES
As discussed at the last EOP Principals meeting, in early 1999 the Census Bureau will publish an
analysis of alternative measures of poverty based on the proposals contained in the 1995 National
Research Council (NRC) report, Measuring Poverty: A New Approach. Because OMB is the
statutory arbiter of the "official" poverty measurement methodology, the Census Bureau has
asked for advice on the proposed alternative measures to be highlighted (among many that will
be published as part ofthe analysis). Currently, the Census Bureau plans to benchmark all of its
highlighted poverty estimates to a recent (likely 1997) poverty rate. (Note, however, that
non-benchmarked estimates will appear in the analysis portion of the report.)
The purpose of this meeting is to decide whether we want to advise Census to highlight a few
series that are not benchmarked, to advise that only benchmarked estimates be highlighted, or
simply to remain silent on the issue (which will likely result in only benchmarked estimates
being highlighted). This decision does not settle the issue of whether we should not benchmark
the official poverty measure, but it would make selecting a non-benchmarked alternative more
difficult.
In order to develop fully the issues involved, this memo has two parts. The first part explains
the concept and presents the pros and cons of benchmarking. Much of this information was
contained in the background memo for the last Principals meeting, however we include it here
for ease of access. The second part outlines the potential implications of advising the Census
Bureau to highlight some series that are not benchmarked.
Part I: Background on Benchmarking
Poverty measurement involves two concepts: (1) a definition of family resources, and (2) a
"threshold" against which resources are compared to determine if a family is poor. The NRC
panel recommends basing the threshold on expenditures on "necessities" (food, shelter, and
clothing) plus a little more. However, the NRC panel cautioned that setting the level below
which a family is considered poor is more of an art than a science. The panel therefore
suggested a range of alternatives and left it to policymakers to determine the most appropriate
levels. Specifically, the NRC panel recommends selecting the 30th to 35th percentile in the
distribution of annual expenditures on food, shelter, and clothing among families of four (two
adults and two children), and then multiplying this expenditure level by between 1.15 and 1.25.
Thresholds for other family sizes and types would be determined by an equivalency scale
calculation.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
2
Because there is some discretion in the setting of the poverty threshold, Table 1 shows poverty
rates between 1991 and 1996 using the current methodology (column 1) and using three
alternative ways to determine the threshold for the NRC experimental measure -- one
benchmarked and two not benchmarked:
•
•
•
The "Benchmarked" measure is the NRC measure benchmarked to the 1996 poverty rate;
in this case the thresholds are "backed out" by first setting the new aggregate poverty rate
to the current rate and then setting the thresholds at the level that achieves this rate given
the new resource definitions. In this case, the threshold falls to approximately the 25th
percentile in the distribution of expenditures.
The "NRC Experimental (midpoint)" (column 3) is based on selecting approximately the
32.5 percentile in the distribution of annual expenditures and then multiplying this
expenditure .by approximately 1.2 -- the midpoints of the NRC recommendations;
The "NRC Experimental (lower bound)" (column 4) is based on selecting the 30th
percentile in the distribution of annual expenditures and then multiplying this expenditure
by 1.15 -- the lower bound of the NRC recommendations;
Both the NRC Experimental "midpoint" and "lower bound" estimates would not match the
current overall poverty rate and thus would be considered "not benchmarked."
It is important to understand that benchmarking only assures that the aggregate poverty rate is
identical for the official and the alternative measure in the benchmarked year. However, the
distribution of poverty among subgroups will change whether or not the estimates are
benchmarked (see Table 2). In general, working families and families with large out-of-pocket
medical expenses would more likely be measured as poor, and nonworking families with
substantial in-kind benefits would less likely be measured as poor with the NRC experimental·
series. This would have geographic as well as subgroup poverty rate implications. For
example, even though the relative proportion of poor who are Black declines under both
alternatives (not shown in Table 2), the estimated Black poverty rate falls with benchmarking but
rises or stays constant with a non-benchmarked measure. Similarly, both historical and future
trends would differ. For instance, the benchmarked measure would be identical to the current
rate in 1996 but higher in 1991. (The faster fall using the alternative measure is largely due to
the expansion in the EITC.)
Pros and Cons of Benchmarking and Not Benchmarking
Pros of benchmarking:
•
May provide an easier transition to the new official measure of poverty because there will
not be a change in the overall level of poverty. (Critics, of course, will still charge that
this level is arbitrary.) In addition, with a benchmarked measure it may be easier to
implement changes in the poverty guidelines issued by HHS for program purposes.
•
Focuses the arguments on the relative distribution of who is poor rather than on how
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
3
many people are poor; experts would say that the results on the distribution of who is
poor are more objective and scientific than those on the total number of poor.
Cons of benchmarking:
•
Violates the NRC recommendation that the threshold should be based on the 30th-35th
percentile in the expenditure distribution. In order to benchmark, the threshold falls to
about the 25th percentile of expenditures on food, shelter, and clothing. This may cost
us the political cover of following a nonpartisan expert panel, and may raise questions of
motive.
•
Will highlight the distributional consequences of moving to an NRC-based alternative
more clearly than under the non-benchmarked alternatives (although they have the same
distributional consequences); for instance the poverty rate for some groups would fall in
absolute terms with benchmarking.
•
There is a perceived illogic in using an overall poverty rate from a method we say is
flawed to determine a key part of a methodology we say is better.
Pros of not benchmarking:
•
Incorporates the recommendations of the NRC panel, based on their professional
judgement from the best available evidence (though, as noted, this judgement is
subjective), and therefore provides some limited political cover.
Cons of not benchmarking:
•
Results in a higher poverty rate (although the trends over time are similar.)
Part II:
Key Decision for this Meeting
There are basically three options: (1) Advise the Census Bureau to highlight some
non-benchmarked estimates along with benchmarked estimates; (2) Actively advise the Census
Bureau to highlight only benchmarked estimates; (3) Remain silent on the issue (with the likely
result that Census will only highlight benchmarked estimates).
Pros ofadvising the Census Bureau to highlight some non-benchmarked estimates
•
Keeps the option of non-benchmarked estimates in the public dialog, which may preserve
the option of not benchmarking when and if we decide to move to a new official measure
of poverty.
•
Narrowing the range of options in any dimension may be perceived as moving us closer
to a final decision, and might limit our flexibility.
•
The Census report may appear more credible if it includes a non-benchmarked
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
•
4
alternative, given that the NRC's recommendation did not involve benchmarking.
If we decide to chang<;: to an NRC-based measure as the official measure of poverty and if
we decide to benchmark the official measure, it may make the change look small
compared to selecting the non-benchmarked alternative. It gives us an ability to look
"reasonable" by adopting a less extreme change.
Cons ofadvising the Census Bureau to highlight some non-benchmarked estimates
•
Even if we're not certain that we want to change the official measure of poverty, we may
be held accountable for estimates that poverty is really higher than the current rate.
•
Even if the non-benchmarked estimates are simply among those highlighted, people could
focus on them and create an "uproar." Alternatively, some of our traditional allies may
like the non-benchmarked estimates and feel abandoned should we ultimately choose to
benchmark.
Pros ofadvising the Census Bureau to highlight only benchmarked estimates
•
It may raise less of a political "uproar." This would be particularly valuable if we
believe we are likely to benchmark any new official measure anyway.
Cons ofadvising the Census Bureau to highlight only benchmarked estimates
•
It may make it more difficult not to benchmark in the future.
•
If Census does not closely follow the NRC recommendation, it may appear that they had
been inappropriately influenced by political considerations, particularly since
non-benchmarked estimates are already in the public domain.
Pros of remaining silent on the issue of benchmarking
•
Given that, at this point, Census plans to only highlight benchmarked estimates this
contains all of the advantages of advising Census to only present benchmarked estimates
outlined above.
•
In addition, it may give us political cover by allowing another, independent statistical,
agency to make the judgement about how the level of poverty should be determined.
Cons of remaining silent on the issue of benchmarking
•
Likely (because Census currently plans to only highlight benchmarked estimates) contains
all of the cons of advising Census to present only benchmarked estimates.
•
We may not want Census to make the decision that non-benchmarked estimates will not
be highlighted without our input.
�1
1
5
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
�,.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
6
Table l. Poverty Rates and Thresholds under Alternative Measures, 1991-96, CPS
Official
measure
Poverty Rates
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
14.2
14.8
15.1
14.6
13.8
13.7
Thresholds for 2 adults
and 2 children (in dollars)
1991
13,812
1992
14,228
1993
14,654
1994
15,029
1995
15,455
1996
15,911
Benchmarked
to 1996
NRC
Experimental
(midpoint)
14.5
15.3
15.7
14.7
13.8
13.7
11,891
12,249
12,616
12,938
13,305
13,698
NRC
Experimental
(lower bound)
18.9
19.6
20.2
19.0
18.2
18.0
13,891
14,309
14,738
15,115
15,543
16,002
16.7
17.4
18.0
16.8
16.0
15.8
12,883
13,270
13,668
14,018
14,415
14,840
�•
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
7
Table 2. Poverty Rates under Alternative Measures, 1996, CPS
Official
measure
BenchmarkedNRC
to 1996
NRC
Experimental Experimental
(midpoint)
(lower bound)
AU persons
13.7
13.7
18.0
15.8
Children
Nonelderlyadults
Elderly
20.5
11.4
18.1
11.5
23.8
15.0
20.9
13.2
20.4
15.6
10.8
18.0
11.2
28.4
29.4
11.8
25.2
28.5
15.6
32.0
37.7
13.7
28.5
33.1
9.5
10.0
13.6
11.8
Persons in family of type:
Married couple
Female householder
6.9
35.8
7.8
32.3
11.1
40.4
9.5
36.3
Geographic regions:
Northeast
Midwest
South
West
12.7
10.7
15.1
15.4
14.3
10.3
14.2
16.1
18.8
13.8
18.3
21.0
16.5
12.1
16.2
18.5
Metropolitan/Central City
Not Central City
Nonmetropolitan
19.6
9.4
15.9
19.2
10.6
13.5
24.7
14.1
17.5
21.8
12.4
15.5
White
Black
Hispanic origin
One or more workers
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 5
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-JUL-1998 13:28:44.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to GA/FL
TO: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig Hughes ( CN=Craig Hughes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ryland M. willis ( CN=Ryland M. Willis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julianne B. Corbett ( CN=Julianne B. Corbett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1.)
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
,.
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN·
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Thursday, July 9, 1998, the President will travel to Atlanta, Georgia,
to launch the Anti-Drug Media Campaign and attend a DSCC luncheon.
He
will then travel to Daytona, Florida, to survey fire-damaged areas, before
proceeding to Miami for a DCCC dinner. Deadlines for the President's trip
book are as follows:
�ARMS
- ,-Email System
FL & GA Background Memos:
Page 5 of 5
DUE TUES., JULY 7, AT 6:00 P.M.
political Memos
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Economic One-Pager
Accomplishments
FL & GA Event Memos:
DUE WED., JULY 8, AT 6:00 P.M.
Anti-Drug Media Campaign Launch
DSCC Luncheon
Florida Fire Damage Tour
DCCC Dinner
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-JUL-1998 14:27:12.00
SUBJECT:
Income-Poverty
TO: Paul Bugg ( CN=Paul Bugg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Just a reminder:
there will be an Income/poverty meeting this Thursday,
July 9th at 11:00 am in Sally's office, Room 231.
Also, please remember to give your comments to Ceci within the next couple
of days.
If you need another copy of the memo, please email or call me at
6-2800.
Thank you.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
'!:.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert (
CN~Donna
L.
Geisbert/OU~OPD/O~EOP
[ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-JUL-1998 16:24:12.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: marti.thomas ( marti.thomas @ msOl.do.treas.sprint.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Grundman-Stacey ( Grundman-Stacey @ dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: sheketoff-emily ( sheketoff-emily @ dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: kburkel ( kburkel @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Michael
TO: Richard J. Turman (
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Richard
CN~David
TO: David W. Beier (
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
TO: Cynthia A. Rice (
READ: UNKNOWN
Cohen/OU~OPD/O~EOP
@
W.
Al
@
CN~Cynthia
J.
TO: Toby Donenfeld (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Barry
J.
Beier/O~OVP @
TO: Thomas L. Freedman (
READ: UNKNOWN
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
@
A.
Rice/OU~OPD/O~EOP @
@ EOP
EOP [ OPD 1 )
EOP [ OPD 1
[ WHO 1 )
OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
Lambrew/OU~OPD/O~EOP @
L.
(OPD)
Jennings/OU~OPD/O~EOP @
Toiv/OU~WHO/O~EOP
CN~Thomas
EOP [ OMB 1 )
OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CD
CN~Toby Donenfeld/O~OVP @
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
Turman/OU=OMB/O~EOP @
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv (
READ: UNKNOWN
@ EOP
EOP [ OPD 1 )
Freedman/OU~OPD/O~EOP
@ EOP
[ OPD 1 )
TO: JONATHAN.GRUBER ( JONATHAN.GRUBER @ MSOl.DO.treas.sprint.com @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer.moore ( Jennifer.moore @ justice.usdoj.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: guzy.gary ( guzy.gary @ epamail.epa.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: johara ( johara @ osophs.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
O-.~\
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William H. White Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=william H. White Jr./OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. Mendelson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_ C ( MARR C
READ: UNKNOWN
@
Al
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
@
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 }
TO: Joshua Gotbaum
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande (
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: UNKNOWN
R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
CN~Jerold
CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 }
CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 }
CC: Gina C. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
@
ustr.gov
@
INET
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting is scheduled for Thursday, July 9, at
2:45.
Conference room TBD.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[06/18/1998 – 07/07/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 099 - Folder 003
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/6fb20b7a2249c8e06d315be0c5ec15fb.pdf
947487e77470c8be5e74738313a1876e
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 099 - FOLDER -002
[06/10/1998-06/17/1998]
�Withdrawal/Redaction Sheet
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
AND TYPE
001. email
DATE
SUBJEcrrrlTLE
Email to Dorian Weaver et al from Stacie Spector. Subject: Invitation
(3 pages)
06/1711998
RESTRICTION
Personal Misfi(e
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management System [Email]
CEA ([Kagan])
OAiBox Number: 950000
FOLDER TITLE:
[0611 0/1998 - 06/17/1998]
2009-1006-F
jm51
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act - (44 U.S.c. 2204(a)l
PI National Security Classified Information (a)(I) of the PRA(
P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office (a)(2) of the PRA(
P3 Release would violate a Federal statute (a)(3) of the PRA(
P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
linancial information (a)(4) of the PRA(
P5 Release would disclose conlidential advice between the President
and his advisors, or between such advisors (a)(5) of the PRA(
P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy (a)(6) of the PRA(
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
of gift.
PRM. Personal record misfile delined in accordance with 44 U.S.c.
2201(3).
RR. Document will be reviewed upon request.
Freedom of Information Act -(5 U.S.c. 552(b)(
b(l) National security c1assilied information (b)(1) of the FOIA(
b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
an agency (b)(2) of the FOIA(
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute (b)(3) of the FOIA(
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or eonlidential or linancial
information (b)(4) of the FOIA(
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy (b)(6) of the FOIA(
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes (b)(7) of the FOIA)
b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
linancial institutions (b)(8) of the FOIA(
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
concerning wells (b)(9) of the FOIA]
�"
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:I0-JUN-1998 09:49:03.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to CAloR
TO: Julianne B. Corbett ( CN=Julianne B. Corbett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP
@
EOP [ WHO 1· )
�Page 2 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M.
READ: UNKNOWN
Edwards/OU~WHO/O=EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig Hughes ( CN=Craig Hughes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil
READ: UNKN9WN
( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�,.
ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Paul K. Engskov!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Friday, June 12, 1998, the President will travel to Northern California
to visit a marine research center, deliver remarks to the Oceans
Conference, and attend a reception for Senator Barbara Boxer.
Later that
day, he will travel to Portland, Oregon, and attend receptions for
Representative Darlene Hooley and the Coordinated Campaign, and tape the
radio address.
On Saturday, June 13, the President will deliver the
commencement address at Portland State University. He will then fly to
Los Angeles, where he will attend a DNC dinner.
On Sunday, June 14, the
President will return to the white House.
�,.
ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
CA & OR Background Memos:
DUE TRUR., JUNE 11, AT 4:00 P.M.
Political Memos
CEQ Rot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Rot Issues
Economic One-Pager
Accomplishments
CA & OR Event Memos:
DUE TRUR., JUNE 11, AT 6:00 P.M.
Visit to Marine Research Center
Oceans Conference
Boxer Reception
Hooley Reception
Coordinated Campaign Reception
Radio Address
Commencement Address
DNC Dinner
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�Page 1 of2
,. ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:10-JUN-1998 16:40:37.00
SUBJECT:
WOMEN"S MTG
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. MathewS/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�,.
.<
Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M, Liss ( CN=Susan M, Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in Room 100. Thanks.
�Page 1 of2
... ARMS Email System
',.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP
OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:10-JUN-1998 17:03:22.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Meeting
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. Mendelson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD_C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�;. ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Gina C. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY_MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TEXT:
The Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting is scheduled for Thursday, 6/11 at
2:45 in Room 211.
�I~
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ronald E. Jones ( CN=Ronald E. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:12-JUN-1998 11:43:23.00
SUBJECT:
House-passed Bankruptcy Bill
TO: Mark A. Weatherly ( CN=Mark A. Weatherly/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark D. Menchik ( CN=Mark D. Menchik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toni S. Hustead ( CN=Toni S. Hustead/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua H. Raymond ( CN=Joshua H. Raymond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melinda D. Haskins ( CN=Melinda D. Haskins/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John S. Radzikowski ( CN=John S. Radzikowski/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pamula L. Simms ( CN=Pamula L. Simms/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas P. Stack ( CN=Thomas P. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. Timberlake/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Himler
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Janet Himler/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. Carroll/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward A. Brigham ( CN=Edward A. Brigham/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet E. Irwin ( CN=Janet E. Irwin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gary L. Bennethum ( CN=Gary L. Bennethum/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edwin Lau ( CN=Edwin Lau/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S. Redburn/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen J. Balis ( CN=Ellen J. Balis/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne Upshaw ( CN=Wayne Upshaw/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Alice Veenstra ( CN=Alice Veenstra/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TEXT:
The House-passed text HR 3150 is available on the GPO website
(http://www.access.gpo.gov/su_docs/aces/aaces002.html) .
at
If you
I have also printed a copy and created a Wordperfect version.
would like a printed copy (it's 201 pages) or a WordPerfect file, let me
know.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:12-JUN-1998 12:24:47.00
SUBJECT:
Follow-up to today's meeting
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katherine K. Wallman ( CN=Katherine K. Wallman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
I thought today's poverty measurement discussion was very good and useful.
would it be useful to sketch out a good process by which we take up the
next set of questions regarding poverty measurement before the next
principal's meeting? Even a short (20 minute) shared conversation about
how to move forward might make it possible to give the Principals a set of
concrete ideas about next steps.
Becky
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 3
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:15-JUN-1998 13:54:28.00
SUBJECT:
Heads-up memo
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EO'P [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. Mendelson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�Page 2 of3
ARMS Email System
'.
June 15, 1998
MEMORANDUM FOR ERSKINE BOWLES
Jack Lew
THROUGH:
FROM:
Donald R. Arbuckle
SUBJECT:
Medicare+Choice program
HHSD,s interim final rule on
In the next few days, we will be completing review of a Department
of Health and Human Services (HHS) interim final rule that establishes the
new Medicare+Choice (M+C) program.
The rule is very time sensitive
because HHS has already missed its statutory deadline of June 1 required
by the Balanced Budget Act of 1997. The rule is expected to have budget
savings of $30 billion over the next five years.
One of the major provision in the rule is allowing Medicare
eligible individuals who opt for this program a choice about the type of
health care service they want.
The choices include M+C coordinated care
plans -- from health maintenance organizations (HMOs) and preferred
provider organizations (PPOs) to the new provider-sponsored organizations
(PSOs); M+C Medical Savings Accounts plans; and M+C private
fee-for-service plans.
The regulation requires Medicare beneficiaries to
receive comparative information to aid their plan selection. The Health
Care and Financing Administration will coordinate an annual election
period, the first one will begin November 1998, for initiation of the
program in January 1, 1999. In addition, the Medicare+Choice program will
reimburse plans on a capitated basis.
The health care industry is anxious for expeditious publication of
this rule, since the plans must be prepared for beneficiary enrollment in
November 1998. Many of the ruleD,s policies are identical or similar to
existing Medicare HMO,
private accreditation, and quality assurance
policies. However, the implementation of these policies in the
Medicare+Choice program is on a larger scale and the program marks the
first time that different service delivery options (including the new
PSOs) will be presented side-by-side to Medicare beneficiaries. We
believe this is a good rule implementing important and beneficial
policies. HHS expects significant comment on the rule, and anticipates
that future refinements may be necessary.
please let me know if you have any questions.
cc:
Maria Echaveste
Rahm Emanuel
Larry Stein
Ron Klain
Thurgood Marshall, Jr.
Ann Lewis
Sally Katzen
Sylvia Mathews
�ARMS Email System
"
John Podesta
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Elena Kagan
Barry Toiv
Michael Waldman
Janet Yellen
Mickey Ibarra
Danny Mendelson
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 16-JUN-1998 19:30:33.00
SUBJECT:
Poverty Meeting
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@ EOP
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
In an effort to please everyone, I am proposing that the next poverty
meeting be held on Thursday June 25th at 11:00 am in Sally's office.
please let me know if you are available.
Thank you.
�Withdrawal/Redaction Marker
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
AND TYPE
001. email
SUBJECTfflTLE
DATE
Email to Dorian Weaver et al from Stacie Spector. Subject: Invitation
(3 pages)
06/\7/\998
RESTRICTION
Personal Misfile
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management System [Email]
CEA ([Kagan])
OAlBox Number: 950000
FOLDER TITLE:
[06/10/\998 - 061171\998]
2009-1006-F
jm51
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act- 144 U.S.c. 2204(a)1
Freedom ofInformation Act- 15 U.S.c. 552(b)1
PI
P2
P3
P4
b(l) National security classified information l(b)(I) of the FOIAI
b(2) Release would disciose internal personnel rules and practices of
an agency l(b)(2) of the FOIAI
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute l(b)(3) of the FOIAI
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial
information l(b)(4) of the FOIAI
b(6) Release would constitute a ciearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(b)(6) of the FOIAI
b(7) Release would disciose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes ((b)(7) of the FOIAI
b(8) Release would disciose information concerning the regulation of
financial institutions l(b)(8) of the FOIAI
b(9) Release would disciose geological or geophysical information
concerning wells l(b)(9) of the FOIAI
National Security Classified Information l(a)(l) of the PRAI
Relating to the appointment to Federal office (a)(2) of the PRAI
Release would violate a Federal statute (a)(3) of the PRAI
Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
financial information (a)(4) of the PRAI
P5 Release would disciose confidential advice between the President
and his advisors, or between such advisors la)(5) of the PRAI
P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy (a)(6) of the PRAI
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
of gift.
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.c.
2201(3).
RR. Document will be reviewed upon requesl.
�Page 1 of 11
• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah RosenjOU=OPDjO=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:17-JUN-1998 12:16:34.00
SUBJECT:
Bankrupty Memo for Review by Principals
TO: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P, MaloneyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. EmanueljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John PodestajOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana FortunajOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura EmmettjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. BallentinejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. CarrolljOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. YellenjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward A. Brigham ( CN=Edward A. BrighamjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. MinarikjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria EchavestejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. MathewsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle CriscijOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn L. Smalls ( CN=Dawn L. SmallsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. TurnerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. GibsonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. SteinjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
�Page 2 of 11
• ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Jill M. Blickstein ( CN=Jill M. Blickstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice Veenstra ( CN=Alice Veenstra/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
)
[ OPD ]
TEXT:
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D16]MAIL428372861.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504370040000010A020100000002050000005852000000020000254600D25FB854B7512FOC
A651346190254600D2B6D32257C55DF5C2EBEEAAD.8317453A0034A1E51Bl14FA27D403A3B06C42
E1C89A9B6DFCOFC03C8A5B45FA70A13BFOEBOA43BEBE92FA5FOD95BAAECAA2AB37A1E76DBD9F83
OEB558D3D9ADAFD8CF908E7354869C43CD27D9F503D9EA5584C6B923DB89125BFCBD379A2EBD52
156369ABE4FDC02700FC6DBD15692958C5986AF3C13538EA8C37E285307EC665FCA5827D343E30
E7A7E12998FC452D5EE4298DB4079CD02C04F896BD41D8DAA078D504C26C1DE273A185413F9F5F
8DCEE8BC02880CF22D3FC65301832977A6B690D106A4EAA57C718A1C5E7E4CCD914551D0958DAA
OD3E7BFBDA196783087A92E43EC870CF724474A97597D70D6DFC44055FC101AEB1322F170F9898
E77A1BB7C92FAF3A75A3A33693D59963032AB7BD2B45F8ECCOEABBB9EA09F658BD64E82BOD49A9
32B98538CFBA1A6459F24D3B9BE0561D37EB14A5D42E954AF6D8EA9D37EE8A292C13ADB42AF367
OBD224923817E3888F550722E903FACl18FEF9A64376979C8414217B881AD8091C481C2CC4929D
6747FCEB77C03CF35296817B2A8948812E5D3FA80D833F4DA5F2B74C2D7B1031D9F87A9COAEF96
043520249D2287E78BD3AA9D07D7C59F31E6EEE38F297AE99348F5EA818A6F72879B8A230D10A4
8FF47865AD02000900000000000000000000000823010000000B0100007E020000005501000000
4E0000008903000009250100000006000000D70300000B300200000028000000DD030000087701
000000400000000504000008340100000014000000450400000802010000000F00000059040000
080501000000080000006804000000984800500020003400200028004C006F00630061006C0029
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800C8002C012C012C012C01C800
C80030000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000B0100002800C8196810480D000011090000005AOOOB010000103600540069006D0065
00730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E00200052006500670075006C0061007200
000000000000000001000200580201000000040028000000000000000000000000000000000000
00011202002400A1000000A10000000A0000005COD010002005DOD010044005EOD010044005FOD
01001700600D01000200610D01001700620D01005500630D01004400640D01004400650D010002
00C3BEC9240000000000000000000000000000D40008337C00780000020000650D000003010004
0002000000DDOA10008301040003000200211000DDDDOBOB00030000040BOODD9BD10337008001
000016000CB6010000580206000058020000000000000064FOOOOO000000000000000000000000
0000000064C8003700D1D1020D0000010001000AODOOD1CCF20CF2CCCCCCCCCCE0401200000000
�"
Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex.Dump Conversion .
June _, 1998 -- Draft
MEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT
FROM:
GENE SPERLING
SALLY KATZEN
RE:
BANKRUPTCY REFORM LEGISLATION
Last week, the House passed, by a veto-proof majority, a bankruptcy bill that your administration
said it "strongly opposes." A better, but still flawed, bill (voted out of committee 16-2) may be
taken up by the Senate before the July 4th recess or soon thereafter. Both bills were changed
recently to address concerns that"you, the First Lady, and others have raised about their impact on
debtors' capacity to pay child support and alimony, although some problems still rernain.
After an NEC interagency review, your advisors have reached a consensus that some bankruptcy
reform is important. These bills contain many provisions that are beneficial, including a cap on
state homestead exemptions, debtor education pilots, penalties for unjustified creditor activities,
measures to discourage bad-faith repeat filings, and provisions to improve data collection and
audit procedures. However, certain controversial provisions of the current bills need significant
changes to satisfy our objectives and concerns. We propose'to advance quickly an
Administration proposal in hopes of influencing the Senate bill on the floor and giving the
Administration greater leverage in conference. The proposal would address three issues: (1)
limitations on access to Chapter 7; (2) new nondischargeable debts and their impact on child
support and alimony payments; and (3) new provisions to protect against coercive creditor
behavior and to require more responsibility from creditors in extending credit. The group also
has identified alternatives to parts of this proposal on which we could compromise, if necessary.
1:
BACKGROUND
Rising Consumer Bankruptcies: Despite what Goldman Sachs recently called "the best
economy ever," personal bankruptcies have continued to rise sharply, from roughly 800,000 in
1994 to nearly 1.4 million in 1997. Recent figures for the first quarter of 1998 showed another
20 percent increase over 1997's pace.
Disputed Causes: There is much dispute about the cause of this increase, but little definitive
�..
Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex·Dump Conversion
evidence. Creditors assert that lawyer advertising, reduced social stigma, and increased
information about the financial advantages of bankruptcy have encouraged an increasing number
of consumers to walk away from debts they could pay back. Consumer advocates argue that
lenders have irresponsibly extended too much credit to families who are ill-prepared to handle it,
and that most bankruptcies happen when unexpected events push such a family over the financial
edge; indeed, rising bankruptcy rates track closely rising levels of unsecured debt, although
causation cannot be proven.
Potential/or Abuse: Under current rules, some debtors with high incomes walk away from
their debts entirely, even when they have the capacity to repay at least a portion of those debts;
other debtors file repeatedly without any intention of completing bankruptcy, for the purpose of
delaying bona fide collection activities; and generous state exemptions (including unlimited
homestead exemptions in eight states and exemptions for items like race horses and silver spoons
in Virginia) prompt some to shift assets to exempt categories prior to a bankruptcy filing to avoid
making payment to any unsecured creditors. Consumer advocates argue that these cases are not
the norm and should not prompt limits on those who genuinely need bankruptcy's fresh start.
Consumer Impact: Regardless of who is to blame, higher levels of debt charge-offs appear to
raise the cost of credit for everyone. One industry study suggests that bankruptcies cost every
American household between $300-400 per year. Higher credit costs disproportionately fall on
lower-income families, since they are more likely to carry a balance on their card. While in the
past credit card interest rates did not always rise and fall with market rates, the industry is now
more competitive, so that reduced bankruptcies are likely to translate to lower interest rates and
increased access to credit for those who pay their bills.
Legislative Momentum: The popularity of these bills can be explained by the system's
vulnerability to abuse and the apparent consumer costs, as well as an extremely effective and
well-financed industry campaign and legislators' fears of being labeled protectors of deadbeats.
II.
LIMITATIONS ON ACCESS TO CHAPTER 7 BANKRUPTCY
Current Law: Today, there is little limit on debtor's access to Chapter 7's full and immediate
discharge of debt (usually with no payments to unsecured creditors); however, in some circuits,
courts find, on their own motion, that it is "substantial abuse" for a debtor with the ability to
repay 20% of their unsecured debts over three years, after taking account of all necessary
expenses, to go through Chapter 7 rather than a Chapter 13 repayment plan,
House and Senate Bills: Both bills would require those with the capacity to repay a portion of
their debt to do so under a Chapter 13 plan. We opposed the House bill because it determines
access to Chapter 7 under a rigid "means test" that does not take into account the unique
circumstances of individual debtors. The Senate approach is more flexible, building on the.
abuse test in use in some circuits. The Senate bill would authorize a bankruptcy judge to apply
this test to any debtor with income above the median and, for the first time, allow creditors to file
2
�Automated Records Management Systerr,
Hex-Dump Conversion
the motion seeking a detennination of abuse. Creditors would have to pay debtors' attorneys
fees if their filings were not 'substantially justified' or were brought to coerce a debtor to waive a
right.
Administration proposal: We propose a variation on the Senate bill whereby the bankruptcy
court would have discretion to determine whether or not a debtor's use of Chapter 7 is
abuse; however, there would be a presumption of abuse if a debtor has an income above
the median and the capacity to repay either at least 30% of her debts or some specified
amount (such as $5000) over three years. (No debtor would be denied access to Chapter 7
unless she had the ability to repay a minimum of $50 a month in unsecured, nonpriority debt.
Any lesser amount is too small to merit the Chapter 13 administrative costs or to risk the chance
that the creditor was pursuing the motion to coerce the debtor to forgo another bankruptcy right.)
We also would provide that, if a debtor moved more than $50,000 from nonexempt to exempt
assets within one year of the filing, she would be subject to a presumption of abuse, regardless of
income. In determining a debtor's capacity to repay, we propose to explicitly exclude luxuries
(e.g., expensive cars or boats) from necessary expenses.
These presumptive guidelines could be overcome if the court determined, e.g., that the debtor
faced unusual but necessary expenses or could not be expected to maintain reliably her current
level of income. Such presumptive guidelines have proven to be highly effective in promoting
uniformity and fairness in establishing child support award amounts. Since the average debtor
under Chapter 13 repays 20% of her debts and has income below the national median, those who
meet this higher threshold are the most likely to succeed under a repayment plan.
III.
NONDISCHARGEABLE DEBT AND ITS IMPACT ON CHILD SUPPORT AND
ALIMONY
The Bankruptcy Code makes debts nondischargeable only where there is an overriding public
purpose, as with child support, alimony, educational loans, tax obligations, or debts incurred by
fraud. The House and Senate bills have provisions that would broaden the categories of
nondischargeable credit card debt, although the largest new category has been dropped and the
two remaining categories narrowed. These provisions raise two questions: (I) Do the
additional debts made nondischargeable by these bills rise to the same level of public priority as
other nondischargeable debts? and (2) What impact does the protection of new categories of debt
have on the ability of the debtor, post-bankruptcy, to repay existing categories of
nondischargeable debt (e.g., child support and alimony, educational loans, and taxes)? They
also force us to recognize that consumers use credit cards today for many purposes that were
inconceivable only a few years ago (e.g., groceries or paying student loans). This
Administration envisions -- and, in fact, encourages -- greater use of electronic commerce.
Debts incurred to pay other non dischargeable debts.
Current law: If a debtor uses a credit card to pay federal taxes, the credit card debt is
3
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
nondischargeable.
House and Senate bills: Both make a debt incurred to pay any nondischargeable debt
nondischargeable, although the Senate effectively eliminates the provision if the debtor is a
single parent or owes child support and/or alimony.
Administration Proposal: We propose that the current law remain unchanged; however, if a
debtor paid a nondischargeable debt with a credit card, it would be a factor in determining
whether the debtor's use of Chapter 7 was abuse.
Debts incurred in the period immediately before bankruptcy.
Current Law: Debts for luxuries over $1000 owed to a single creditor within 60 days of
bankruptcy are nondischargeable. There is some evidence that this provision and other
anti-fraud provisions do not prevent some debtors from running up debt knowing that a discharge
is likely.
House and Senate Bills: Both would make all debts incurred within 90 days of bankruptcy for
luxuries be presumptively nondischargeable. In addition, they would make presumptively
nondischargeable debt above ($250 in the House; $400 in the Senate) per credit card for
necessaries during the same period.
Administration Proposal: We propose to agree to make debt for luxuries within 90 days of
bankruptcy presumptively nondischargeable; however, a cap of $250 or $400 on necessary
expenses incurred prior to bankruptcy is inappropriate. One can easily imagine a family, in
the months prior to bankruptcy, paying for rent, school clothes, and even groceries on their credit
card. Courts can easily compare current spending patterns to prior spending and determine
whether charges are truly for necessary expenses.
Child Support and Alimony Considerations
We should note that the current bills have seven different new provisions designed to either
mitigate the impact of the additional nondischargeable debt on payment of child support and
alimony or to give child support and alimony additional protections in and after bankruptcy.
Some experts we have consulted argue that the benefits provided by these additional provisions
outweigh any modest harm to child support and alimony payments that remains from the
nondischargeability provisions. On the other hand, the women's groups continue their
opposition to these bills. Moreover, these provisions, which focus only on child support and
alimony, do not address our policy concern that new nondischargeable debt will now compete
with other types of existing nondischargeable debts, such as educational loans. For these
reasons, the Administration proposals described above would allow only one small category of
new nondischargeable debt (luxuries purchased 90 days before bankruptcy) where there is a
policy argument against allowing run-up prior to bankruptcy; for the remaining categories, we
would leave current law or address the problem a different way.
4
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
IV.
ADDITIONAL CONSUMER PROTECTIONS AGAINST PREDATORY
CREDITOR PRACTICES
Your advisors are particularly concerned about the unequal bargaining power of the creditor and
debtor and how the changes in bankruptcy rules could further shift the balance and create
opportunities for coercion and consumer harm. To address this concern, and to ensure
legislation requires responsibility of both debtor and creditor, we propose new consumer
protections.
Reaffirmations of Unsecured Debt
Although debtors in Chapter 7 have a right to have their unsecured debts discharged, some
debtors reaffirm one or more debts. While there may be some circumstances in which it is in the
debtor's best interest to do so (e.g.; as a condition of obtaining a line of credit needed for a small
business), those cases are few. The risk is real, however, that debtors are pressured into
reaffirming their debts by aggressive creditors. After Sears recently paid large penalties for such
practices, another Bankruptcy Judge (Fenning) said she scrutinized her court records and found
evidence of widespread coercive reaffirmations. Since debts reaffirmed survive bankruptcy,
they compete with child support and alimony in a post-bankruptcy world. Eliminating coercive
reaffirmations also would help to reduce the current level of competition child support and
alimony payments face.
Current Law: Disclosures are required and the court must determine that a reaffirmation does
not impose an undue hardship on the debtor or a dependant and is in the debtor's best interest;
however, an affirmation ofthe debtor's attorney to that effect suffices.
House and Senate Bills: No related provisions.
Administration Proposal: We propose to require the court itselfto find that there was a
compelling reason for the debtor to reaffirm a debt, without reliance on counsel affidavits. We
also propose to bar reaffirmation of debts that add attorneys' fees and costs to the debt, to
increase penalties on attempts to enforce invalid reaffirmations, and to clarify on that the
automatic stay bars threats to file abuse motions and solicitations of reaffirmations.
Credit Card Minimum Payment Disclosure
We also believe that some signal should be sent to creditors about lending practices that entice
debtors to get further and further into debt.
Current Law: Most debtors believe that by making the minimum payment on their credit card
they are slowing working off their debt. However, depending upon the interest rate, they may be
5
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
falling further and further behind. Creditors are increasingly offering minimum payment plans
that amortize debt over decades, if at all.
House and Senate bills: No related provisions.
Administration Proposal: We propose a process for subordinating debt if the creditor did not
disclose clearly to the debtor the time period over which the debt would amortize at the minimum
payment level. The subordinated debt would only be paid, in a Chapter 13 plan or a Chapter 7
liquidation, after all other unsecured, nonpriority debt. It most cases, this will mean it will never
be repaid.
Other Non-Bankruptcy Steps to Improve Consumer Credit Practices
We also are exploring whether there are other non-bankruptcy steps we can take to clamp down
on predatory lender practices and better help consumers to understand their own borrowing. We
have consensus on a proposal that requires all lenders to disclose the time period over which debt
is amortized by minimum payments. This proposal, and others under review, fall under the
jurisdiction of other committees. Thus, it is not feasible to insist that Congress include these
proposals in the bankruptcy bill at this time. However, we might unveil these proposals in
connection with a campaign to educate consumers about the use of credit, using the bully pulpit
the way we have done to encourage retirement savings.
V.
ADVISORS' RECOMMENDATIONS
All your advisors recommend we proceed as described, including CoS, NEC, Counsel, OPL,
OLA, OMB, CEA, DPC, First Lady, DoJ, Treasury, Commerce, and Education.
•
•
•
•
•
The NEC believes that requiring greater responsibility of both creditors and debtors is the
best way to address the ''unclean hands" of some of the legislation's proponents.
Treasury and CEA emphasize that needs-based reform will decrease the cost of, and
increase access to, credit for those debtors who do pay their bills by limiting opportunistic
bankruptcy among those higher income debtors who do not.
DoJ supports the plan and stresses that other provisions of these bills, like the cap on state
homestead exemptions, measures to discourage bad faith repeat filings, and provisions to
improve data collection and audit procedures, are important reforms.
OPL believes that, while consumer advocates oppose any bill, reforms limiting access to
Chapter 7 and stemming coercive reaffirmations appear valid. OPL wants to see us fight
for aspects of our proposal that protect against any impact on child support (before or
after bankruptcy) of new nondischargeable credit card debt.
The First Lady's Office strongly supports advancing proposals that achieve more
balanced reform by calling for responsibility on the part of the creditor as well as the
debtor, and recommends that we continue to focus on the child support issue to ensure
that protections in this area are as strong as possible.
6
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
•
VI.
OLA stresses the popularity of bankruptcy refonn and advises that we advance proposals
that have a realistic prospect of inclusion, or we may find ourselves faced with
overwhelmingly popular legislation that fails to satisfy our announced concerns.
DECISION
_ _ PROCEED AS DESCRIBED
LET'S DISCUSS
7
�.. ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 17-JUN-1998 18:45:46.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1. )
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet. Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�,- ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Leslie Bernstein ( CN=Leslie Bernstein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
[ CEA 1 )
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[06/10/1998 – 06/17/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 099 - Folder 002
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/dde3a9ad034a1472b2af1dbadcebc074.pdf
ef08abb94f5a3305233db6a6082fdcdf
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC-KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 099 - FOLDER -001
[06/05/1998-06/09/1998]
�,. ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 19
(,
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 5-JUN-1998 11:47:33.00
SUBJECT:
Latest Draft of Poverty Memo
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Attached is the latest draft of the poverty memo.
comments to Becky Blank by COB today.
Thanks.
-- Ceci==================== ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
)
[ OPD ]
Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:
)
)
)
Please give your
1 ====================
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D72] MAIL42016455F. 126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043760A0000010A020100000002050000006FA10000000200000283323FE6DA1F261E574F
EF03A11A5F85B6B92600B3EBA39410B431ABDDD4F6E8A692E4F564468913556549E50D3FFD4470
BE6599DA291AOF2A105717EAF1A53E1F1BDBAF1230BF65C9C25170D768E97434235521C321CC47
DC27B17634F920764EBBB0358CB23F96CEAAB7EOBF6DOD83796679E2D3F461D4BODF73D15CD147
05FB69E156F24452D11ACE460E4E3DEF606977332B63FE01A9CFC6528B1D5A2670D8994820FC27
910F2E9690E8A5E132C0624E7DFD4B3CE23FOB7DB946F125D02520516120B2FCE4412111B4AF18
CBABD6BC04C5FA24DE23E874472CED8E99E079016C4849A3925BFCD09C6DAEADDD07626A5EF702
437FA892D8AFE5C7986415515737A9E376279402E2F97DDB503113AOEE923A47F8D7356A2203B1
AB8D3A2E8B68C63194E4F7D2E68C769547F66811F6FDD9FD1F9CBBE9E95DF431764957C93E62F7
9988B45364F87B74B4E093EC555355E11DE6B8611B65F821B4948EDFEBCA7BDOFD3AOFOA9AOEB8
225A5B78DB5C4A5952568570EBE1051DBBDF6B9DDC8690225C2F2AAD139DB8D4B7C6190CFFCA3B
404E1DD9BA616D7B1AB259B034E4D53AD679F6CDOC64F4F7EEOODB16AA9355750B34F90D5F05DB
49FE7BAA50E0222B041AAC768C07838BD8950A1046D93389B55371CCE8E788351DC8704E3178F1
67642F345E02002B00000000000000000000000823010000000BOl00005A040000005502000000
4E0000006505000009250100000006000000B30500000B300400000028000000B9050000081601
00000032000000E105000008770100000040000000130600000834010000001400000053060000
0802010000000F000000670600000805010000000800000076060000081001000000020000007E
060000096D010000001700000080060000084D0100000004000000970600000B30020000006COO
00009B0600000B30020000004400000007070000080501000000080000004B0700000B30030000
0044000000530700000208010000006A000000970700000055010000004E000000010800000208
01000000460100004F080000020800000100760000009509000000000000000000000000950900
000000000000000000000095090000000000000000000000009509000000000000000000000000
950900000000000000000000000095090000000000000000000000009509000000000000000000
�(,
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 1
June 5,1998
DRAFT BACKGROUND MEMORANDUM FOR EOP PRINCIPAL'S MEETING
FROM:
REBECCA BLANK
ELENA KAGAN
SALLY KATZEN
JOE MINARIK
Subject:
Meeting on Income and Poverty Measures
Purpose of the Meeting
In early 1999, the Census Bureau will publish alternative measures of poverty based on the
proposals contained in the 1995 National Research Council (NRC) report, Measuring Poverty: A
New Approach. The current official poverty measure dates back to the 1960s, and while it has
been an important contributor to public debate and policymaking, the NRC report reflects a broad
consensus that the measure is out-of-date and in need of revision.
Poverty measurement involves two concepts: (1) A definition of family income; and (2) A
"threshold" against which income is compared to determine if a family is poor. Changes in
these two concepts will have a direct impact on statistics used by the public for informational
purposes. Changes will also likely have an effect on Federal programs as well.
Because of the importance of an independent statistical system, the Census Bureau plays the
major role in deciding technical issues regarding poverty measurement. However, because of
the important policy and political implications of the poverty concept, Census has asked for
advice from the EOP (which, through OIRA's Statistical Policy Office, is the statutory arbiter
of the "official" poverty measurement methodology) on the upcoming report.
In response to Census' request, CEA, DPC, NEC, and OMB formed a policy working group.
(Among the agencies, only the Deputy Assistant Secretary for Human Services Policy at HHS
was invited to participate because of her expertise on poverty measurement.) This working
group has held a series of meetings, and prepared the attached memo to outline its tentative
guidance to Census. The meeting ofEOP Principals is intended to review the working group's
conclusions before they are transmitted to Census. It is important to emphasize that we are only
being asked to give advice to the Bureau of the Census; what it actually publishes is its decision.
There are four global issues to be decided; the first two are most pressing because we need to
give guidance to Commerce as soon as possible:
1) Should the Census Bureau select or highlight a single alternative poverty measure, or present
several equally in its forthcoming report? Do the principals have a single preferred measure that
�Automated Records Management SysrerT.
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 2
they would like to see replace the current official measure? Would anointing a single measure at
this time be premature, and prejudge the analytical process? Would it raise ire in the Congress?
Ifwe do not anoint a single preferred measure at this time, will it be difficult to select one later
should we want to switch the "official" definition to one of the proposed alternatives?
2) There are also two technical issues (policy options 1 and 4 in the background memo) that
require careful consideration.
•
Should we advise Census to benchmark the new poverty measure to the old poverty rate
in the current year (so that the number of people classified as poor would remain the same
although the distribution would change)? Should Census implement the NRC
recommendations, which would result in a higher poverty rate (e.g., 18% rather than
13.7% in 1996).
•
If there is only one measure reported by Census, should it account for differences in
medical out-of-pocket (MOOP) expenditures among households in the way recommended
by the NRC, namely, subtracting them from income before a family'S poverty status is
calculated. (An alternative choice is to add them to the thresholds -- which of these
methodologies should be used is a technical choice best left to Census.) Ifwe believe
that several measures should or more be equally reported by Census, should one of them
account for medical expenditures using a different methodology?
3) How should the Administration proceed toward a new official measure of poverty? Should it
proceed along a timetable to replace the current official measure before the end of this
Administration? If so, what process do we need to establish to move forward on this in a timely
fashion? Or, should the Administration proceed more cautiously, letting a consensus build
around a preferred measure among the community of users of poverty statistics, but possibly
lessening the chances that the official measure is ultimately changed?
4) In addition to OMB's designation of the "official" poverty measurement, HHS also issues
administrative poverty guidelines, used in certain program eligibility calculations. If revised
poverty thresholds are adopted as part of a new poverty measure, would the Administration
continue the old administrative poverty guidelines, or make them consistent with the new
threshold measure? If the guidelines are made consistent, would the Administration make
programmatic changes to mitigate the effects on eligibility and spending of switching to the new
guidelines?
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 3
TECHNICAL BACKGROUND ON INCOME AND POVERTY MEASURES
The Current Poverty Measure
The methodology by which current poverty thresholds are determined was developed in the early
1960s by Mollie Orshansky, a staff economist at the Social Security Administration. She
developed a set of poverty thresholds that vary with the number of adults, the number of children,
and the age of the family head. These thresholds represent the cost of a minimum diet
multiplied by 3 to allow for non-food expenditures. The multiplier of3 was chosen because the
average family in 1955 spent one-third of its after-tax income on food. Since the late 1960s, the
thresholds have simply been updated annually to adjust for price inflation -- i.e., the measure of
poverty has remained virtually unchanged for 35 years, despite substantial changes in family
behavior and government policy.
The NRC panel identified several weaknesses in the current poverty measure:
•
The current poverty measure takes no account of changes in taxes (i.e., the expansion of
the EITC) or in-kind benefits (i.e., Food Stamps).
•
The current measure does not distinguish between the needs of working and non-working
families. In particular, it does not reflect the cost of child care and other work expenses
for working low-income families.
•
The current poverty measure takes no explicit account of medical care costs, which vary
significantly across families and have increased substantially since the current poverty
measure was developed.
The NRC Recommendations
In order to understand the NRC panel's recommended revisions, one must understand the basics
of determining poverty. A family is considered poor when its resources fall below a
predetermined poverty line or threshold. Therefore, one must develop a methodology for
estimating family resources and for defining the threshold resource level below which a family is
considered poor.
1.
Defining Family Resources
Under the current poverty calculation, the definition of family resources is cash income. The
NRC recommendations would estimate family resources as:
Family resources
Cash income + Near-money in-kind benefits - Taxes - Child care
costs - Work expenses - Child support payments - Out of pocket
�Automated Re 0rds
H
Management System
ex- ump Conversion
6
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 4
medical care expenditures (including health insurance premiums)
The rationale for subtracting taxes, work and medical expenses from family resources is that
these expenditures are typically not discretionary and reduce the family income available to
achieve a basic quality of life.
There is near consensus among researchers that adjusting for near-money in-kind benefits
(primarily Food Stamps and housing subsidies) and taxes would be an improvement in how
poverty is measured. There is slightly less agreement on whether child care costs, work
expenses, and child support payments should also be deducted because an unknown proportion
ofthese expenses is likely discretionary. (The NRC proposes to cap the amount of child care
and work expenses that can be subtracted to deal with this problem.) As discussed below, the
adjustment for out-of-pocket medical care expenditures is more controversial.
2.
Defining a Poverty Threshold
A threshold must be determined against which to compare a family'S resources. The NRC panel
recommends basing the threshold on expenditures on "necessities" (food, shelter, and clothing)
plus a little more. Specifically, the NRC panel recommends selecting the 30th to 35th percentile
in the distribution of annual expenditures on food, shelter, and clothing among families of four
(two adults and two children), and then multiplying this expenditure level by between 1.15 and
1.25. Thresholds for other family sizes and types would be determined by an equivalency scale
calculation.
The NRC recommends adjusting these thresholds to take into account geographic variation in
cost of living, based on differences in housing costs by region and by city-size. It also
recommends adjusting the thresholds over time by recalculating them from expenditure data on
an annual basis.
OPTIONS FOR DISCUSSION
1. Recommendation regarding determining the level of the poverty threshold.
The NRC panel acknowledges that the actual level at which the poverty threshold is set (and
hence the final poverty rate) is inherently arbitrary and cannot be determined on the basis of
purely statistical judgements. There are two primary options:
A. The NRC alternative. As described above, the NRC panel recommends establishing a
threshold based on the 30th-35th perceritile in the distribution of annual expenditures for a family
of four, with a small multiplier to account for additional small personal expenditures. As shown
in Tables 1 and 2, column 3, this would raise the 1996 poverty rate from 13.7% to 18%, and
increase poverty among all subgroups.
�Autom1ted R~C')rdR Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 5
B. Benchmarking. The NRC panel also considered poverty estimates that benchmark the
alternative poverty rate to equal the old poverty rate in a given year. The Census has done a
number of such benchmarked calculations for 1996, as shown in Tables 1 and 2, column 2.
(The report issued early next year would benchmark to 1997.) Benchmarking would assure that
the aggregate poverty rate is identical for the official and the alternative measure in the
benchmark year. But the distribution of poverty among subgroups within each measure would
differ (see Table 2). Similarly, both historical and future trends would differ. For instance, the
alternative measure is identical in 1996 but higher in 1991. (The faster fall using the alternative
measure is largely due to the expansion in the EITC.)
Pros of using the NRC measure:
•
Incorporates the recommendations of the NRC panel, based on their professional
judgement from the best available evidence.
•
Generates dollar threshold levels that are quite similar to the current dollar thresholds
(although the resources to which the thresholds would be compared are quite different).
Cons of using the NRC Measure:
•
Results in a higher poverty rate (although the trends over time are similar.)
Pros of Benchmarking:
•
May provide an easier transition to the new methodology because there will not be a
change in the overall level of poverty.
•
Focuses the arguments on the relative distribution of who is poor rather than how many
people are poor.
Cons ofBenchmarking:
•
Violates the NRC recommendation that the threshold should be based on the 30th-35th
percentile in the expenditure distribution. In order to benchmark, the threshold falls to
(about) the 25th percentile of expenditures on food, shelter, and clothing.
2. Recommendation regarding updating the thresholds over time
Currently the poverty threshold is updated annually using the cpr. This, however, does not
allow for adjustments that reflect changes in underlying consumption patterns that might affect
the revised thresholds. For instance, food prices have decreased relative to other goods over
time, while housing prices have increased. There are two options:
(A) Recalculate the thresholds annually as a share of consumption on food, shelter, and clothing.
(This is recommended by the NRC panel.)
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 6
(B) Update the thresholds on a year-to-year basis using a price index (preferably one based only
on food, shelter and clothing). Implement a regular process (every 5-10 years) of reviewing the
poverty measure and recalculating the thresholds.
Pros of Re-calculating the Thresholds:
•
Regular recalculation will allow the poverty thresholds to reflect more accurately changes
in consumption patterns and standards of living.
•
Without an expectation that the thresholds will be re-calculated regularly, it may be hard
to update them at all.
•
Under certain data circumstances, recalculation could move the threshold a large amount
or in an unexpected direction. This might raise substantive and political concerns.
Pros of Updating Using the CP/:
•
Using the NRC methodology, the poverty thresholds are somewhat relative (i.e., they are
affected by changes in the distribution of household expenditures.) As a result, they are
a moving target and do not provide an absolute standard of need. A CPI adjustment
would make it easier to compare poverty from year-to-year against a constant standard.
•
Because consumption patterns and standards of living change slowly, it may be better to
take them into account periodically rather than annually.
•
An update with a CPI for necessities only (food, clothing, and shelter) may capture most
of the relevant changes and would make it easier in the short-run to understand the
updating procedure.
•
The data may not be good enough for an annual re-calculation of the thresholds.
NOTE: The EOP Policy Working Group recommends Option (B).
3. Recommendation as to whether thresholds should be adjusted for geographic variation.
The NRC panel recommended adjusting the poverty thresholds for cost~of-living differences
across regions and by city size. Census proposes to make such adjustments based on housing
cost differences (which have much greater regional/city size variation than food or clothing.)
Pros ofAdjusting for Geographic Variation in Cost ofLiving:
•
Most statisticians and economists agree that such adjustments should be made if data are
available.
�Automated Records Management Sysrem
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 7
Cons ofAdjustingfor Geographic Variation in Cost ofLiving:
•
There is no one "right" way to make such adjustments and the issue could be highly
politicized.
•
The data available to make such adjustments are limited and may not be entirely reliable.
•
Implementing such an adjustment in the poverty line threshold could lead to pressure to
provide regional cost adjustments in a wide variety of other government programs, from
Social Security benefits to tax payments.
NOTE: The EOP Policy Working Group recommends against geographic price adjustments.
4. Recommendation regarding how to account for medical care expenditures.
Since the mid-1970s, analysts have been concerned that the official poverty rate overstates the
extent of poverty among beneficiaries of Medicare, Medicaid, and private health insurance. At
the same time, the official poverty rate may understate the extent of poverty among populations
with large medical expenditures. Most analysts agree that, in principle, medical care "needs"
should be incorporated into the calculations of the threshold and family resources (i.e., families
with higher medical needs should have higher thresholds; those with more generous medical
benefits should be considered to have more resources; and those who must spend more to
achieve "good health" should have those expenses subtracted from their resources). However
we cannot observe a family's medical need. In addition, it is not clear that one can simply
impute the cash value of insurance benefits and add this to income. The "extra" benefits received
from insurance to cover expensive medical services do not provide income that can be used for
. any other purpose.
To understand the difficulties, consider including medical benefits into the income calculations.
Adding medical benefits to income, without also adjusting the poverty threshold, has the perverse
·effect of making sicker individuals appear better off. Other proposals to adjust the poverty
threshold (without also adjusting resources) run into similar problems.
In the end, the NRC panel recommended subtracting all medical out-of-pocket (MOOP)
expenses (including health insurance premiums) from income, without trying to value health
insurance as a part of income or medical need as a part of the thresholds. Hence, family
resources are measured net ofMOOP. Those individuals with good insurance will have few
out- of-pocket expenses; those without insurance who face health problems will have lower
measured incomes as they pay more for medical care.
This adjustment accounts for the larger poverty rates using the NRC methodology. For example,
in 1996 the poverty rate was 13.7% using the current methodology; it would have been 18%
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 8
using the NRC methodology, but only 13.2% using the NRC methodology without the medical
expenses adjustment. This adjustment nearly doubles the poverty rate for the elderly, raising it
almost to the rate for children. This adjustment is one of the most controversial of the NRC
recommendations.
There is general agreement that ignoring medical care and medical expenses entirely is not a
good idea, particularly given the rapid increase in medical costs in the past 30 years, the extent of
uninsurance among the low-income population, and this Administration's concern with it. In
addition, if we do not adjust for medical care (in some way) now, it may be much harder to do so
in a few years when we will have better data (because the change will be so dramatic it will be
viewed as another big methodology change).
There are three approaches to incorporating medical care and expenses:
(A) Follow the NRC recommendation and subtract MOOP from family resources. This makes
families with unreimbursed medical expenses less well-off than other families.
(B) MOOP could be added to the thresholds rather than subtracted from resources. (The choice
between options (A) and (B) is a technical decision that Census should address.)
(C) Try to impute the value of health insurance to resources, so those with insurance have higher
resources. Health insurance should then also be imputed into the thresholds.
Pros ofAdjustingfor MOOP (either options (A) or (B)):
•
While not perfect, under the NRC recommended adjustment families with higher
unreimbursed medical expenditures will be "poorer." The NRC recommended
adjustment would also be sensitive to changes in health care financing that would
decrease MOOP and thereby increase disposable income and reduce poverty.
Cons ofAdjustingfor MOOP (either options (A) or (B)):
•
The data that are currently available are out-of-date (but we should have updated
information available in a more timely fashion within another year.)
•
The NRC recommended approach relies on the controversial assumption that all medical
care expenditures are nondiscretionary. (This concern could be mitigated to some extent
by imposing a cap on the amount of medical expenses.)
Pros ofImputing the Value ofHealth Insurance into Resources and Thresholds:
•
Provides a more complete accounting of all medical resources available to a family.
Cons ofImputing the Value ofHealth Insurance into Resources and Thresholds:
.•
There is no accepted "correct" way to do this. The data here are probably more
�Automated Records Management SYSlenHex-Dump Conversion .
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 9
unreliable than the data needed to impute the value of MOOP to families.
•
Many analysts agree with the NRC panel that the value of health insurance is quite
different than (say) the value of food stamps, which are far more fungible. Mixing in
health insurance coverage with economic need causes interpretational and conceptual
problems to a measure of economic need.
•
To date, Census has been following the NRC recommendation. If we asked them to
switch to this approach, it might require substantial additional work and seriously delay
their report.
NOTE: TheEOP Policy Working Group recommends that Census incorporate medical care in
some way and recognizes that option (A) is the most practical and realistic for the short-term.
However, the group strongly recommends that Census thoroughly investigate the impact of
option (B), and continue work on other approaches to incorporating medical care and
expenditures, such as by valuing medical health insurance (option (C».
5. Recommendations regarding which alternatives Census should publish and/or how
they should be presented.
The current plan is to publish a small number (maybe 3) of alternatives. For instance, the
Census could publish a 1997-benchmarked poverty rate and a NRC~alternative poverty rate,
providing two alternatives. Or it could publish a 1997-benchmarked poverty rate including all
of the NRC recommendations, and then publish the same thing without MOOP, or without
geographical price variation. (There will be extensive appendices in this report that will report a
wide variety of different poverty calculations, to demonstrate the statistical properties of the
poverty measurement recommended by NRC.)
•
Will it be confusing to publish multiple (even a small number of) alternatives, as opposed
to only one alternative? How will this affect how the report is received? How should
these be presented?
•
What problems will it create to have multiple alternatives if at some future point we want
to redefine the official poverty rate to one of these improved alternative measures?
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 10
Table 1. Poverty Rates and Thresholds under Alternative Measures, 1991-96, CPS
Official
measure
Benchmarked
to 1996
Poverty Rates
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
14.2
14.8
15.1
14.6
13.8
13.7
13.7
Thresholds for 2 adults
and 2 children (in dollars)
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
13,812
14,228
14,654
15,029
15,455
15,911
11,891
12,249
12,616
12,938
13,305
13,698
NRC
Experimental
14.5
15.3
15.7
14.7
18.9
19.6
20.2
19.0
18.2
13.8
18.0
13,891
14,309
14,738
15,115
15,543
16,002
�"
Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 11
Table 2. Poverty Rates under Alternative Measures, 1996, CPS
BenchmarkedNRC
to 1996
Official
measure
Experimental
All persons
13.7
13.7
18.0
Children
Noneideriyadults
Elderly
20.5
11.4
18.1
11.5
23.8
15.0
10.8
15.6
20.4
White
Black
Hispanic origin
11.2
28.4
29.4
11.8
25.2
28.5
15.6
32.0
37.7
One or more workers
9.5
10.0
13.6
Persons in family of type:
Married couple
Female householder
6.9
35.8
7.8
32.3
Geographic regions:
Northeast
Midwest
South
West
12.7
10.7
15.1
15.4
14.3
10.3
14.2
16.1
18.8
13.8
18.3
21.0
19.6
9.4
15.9
19.2
10.6
13.5
24.7
14.1
17.5
Metro/CC
NotCC
Nonmetro
11.1
40.4
�Automated Records Management Sysrerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 12
Attachment 1 (from DDS)
Use of the Federal Poverty Guidelines in Determining Program Eligibility and Benefits
The Federal poverty guidelines are a simplified version ofthe official poverty line thresholds
which are used for program purposes. They are issued by HHS annually, and are based on the
previous year's thresholds.
As Gordon Fisher, the analyst at HHS who oversees the production of the guidelines, notes in a
recent paper:
A number of people believe that the poverty guidelines affect many big entitlement
programs. That belief is an exaggeration of the actual situation. Most of the Federal
programs using the guidelines are medium-sized or small, with only a few big programs.
Moreover, most...are discretionary programs ... Only a few programs using the guidelines
are mandatory: Medicaid, the Food Stamp Program, and child nutrition programs (mainly
the National School Lunch Program.)!
As Fisher notes, spending under discretionary programs, which are appropriated each year, would
not be affected by any change in the guidelines, even if that change affected eligibility for the
program. If eligibility for these programs expands, the appropriated funds are able to serve a
smaller proportion of the eligible population, but total spending does not change. (Most of these
programs already serve only a small fraction of those estimated to be eligible.) Only the three
big mandatory programs Fisher mentions above would have spending changes associated with a
change in the guidelines.
Even within these three programs, the impact of changes in the poverty guidelines is less than
might be expected. In Medicaid, for example, most recipients qualify for coverage because of
their participation in other means-tested programs such as TANF and SSI--programs that do not
use the poverty line in their eligibility criteria. The major group whose coverage does depend on
the guidelines is children in families below 133% ofthe poverty line who are not current or
recent TANF recipients. In all, people whose eligibility for Medicaid is somehow related to the
poverty line are estimated to account for about 20 percent of Medicaid recipients. Since most
are in families with incomes well below the specified level, only a small fraction would actually
be affected by a poverty line change.
Impacts in the Food Stamp Program and the National School Lunch Program would probably be
, even smaller. The poverty guidelines are used in the Food Stamp Program to set gross income
eligibility--only families with gross incomes below 130% of the poverty line are eligible for food
!G. Fisher, "Disseminating the Administrative Version and Explaining the
Administrative and Statistical Versions of the Federal Poverty Measure." Clinical Sociology
Review, vol. 15 (1997), p. 165.
�Automated Records Management Systerr,
Hex-Dump Conversion
Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 13
stamps. Actual food stamp benefits are calculated based on net income, however--income after
deductions for work expenses and other items. Net income is compared to a specific benefit
allotment, determined nationally for each family size, and that benefit is reduced by 30 cents for
every dollar of net income the family receives. In practice, the benefit allotment would reach
zero for almost all families long before an income of 130 percent of poverty was reached. Thus,
the gross income eligibility cut-off for food stamps is more theoretical than real--families at or
near 130% of the poverty line will almost always be eligible only for zero benefits.
The National School Lunch Program has two cut-offs related to the poverty guidelines: Families
with incomes below 130% of poverty are eligible for free lunches, and those below 185% are
eligible for reduced-price lunches. Unlike the Food Stamp and Medicaid Programs, however,
the school lunch program does not collect and verify detailed information on recipients' family
incomes. Instead, families are asked at the beginning of each school year (or when their child
enters a new school) to fill out a form certifying that their incomes are below the specified level.
Because this process is relatively informal, it seems unlikely that small changes in the level of the
income cut-off would have big impacts on the number of children applying for and receiving free
and reduced-price school lunches. In any case, total spending on the school lunch program--a
significant proportion of which is not means-tested--is much smaller than spending on Medicaid
and food stamps. In 1996 Federal spending on the school lunch program was $5.4 billion,
compared to $25.4 billion for food stamps and almost $92 billion for the Federal share of
Medicaid.
�·1
'.
Page 1 of23
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 8-JUN-1998 17:08:01.00
SUBJECT:
Options paper
TO: pruggles ( pruggles @ osaspe.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
TO: Katherine K. Wallman (' CN=Katherine K. Wallman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Paul Bugg ( CN=Paul Bugg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Richard B. Bavier ( CN=Richard B. Bavier/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mark A. Wasserman ( CN=Mark A. Wasserman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ].)
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Attached is the final options paper for the Principal's meeting on poverty
measurement.
Sally Katzen's office will be scheduling this meeting in the
near future.
Note that the Appendix on program effects has been
substantially edited, after extended negotiation between OMB and HHS.
============
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D24]MAIL45527395X.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043CDOD0000010A020100000002050000008EC10000000200002926BB8FD9F0033FE4D58B
4E65CB23365F5C157103FC1E3DCB2CB62C609D40DEA4E2E423F9FD5F264279D867FC04029C67E3
CF6724 7EB46E8BODEDA5F4 7C962FA14 96CE4 61A8A12 99B23 7BC218C523'627F3 82 93BD99FA5CA94
C7FF51900AB1B807009331CF5091BCD43CC16004AD3475EB85C2CF53D2F906C562A49A69E965AA
CBB509A36D1785F535BD48EE1360F35ABBEF1C9C2D2D1DOF1A101523D4AF19E4174F65D1FB813B
99741CDOCE1C7COB6829CC808FD8F27E8E6DF545D763C35BEFEF9D19DE84077D19E9D5BECDAE5D
F6F3495F24A7674BF32E2ABD57FD53C1280FBD33F853AC13485F1A5986BE778D73D30463AC01F2
B6AFD6659A342CAABDBAF505607EF088DF6AFC965D6F9AA3B1E5655616621833983B2628B78741
A50DE7154FE1930DB2D4462A016EBB8EIC08BCFCFE33999DE312ABCFB731B77AFB909605D2BFF5
A23182A7D2DDC7790B6A2FE61823016C5B2F7851B22E0702D3DEOl97BAIC7EB14AOB3F9AD1CDBA
96A78DBA3929C90FD5F6449FA2BDCC24361965EF82EOF389BBC31988EA5DBB3F325A292A50B99F
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
"
CLOSE HOLD. Page 1
June 8, 1998
DRAFT BACKGROUND MEMORANDUM FOR EOP PRINCIPAL'S MEETING
FROM:
REBECCA BLANK
ELENA KAGAN
SALLY KATZEN
JOE MINARIK
Subject:
Meeting on Income and Poverty Measures
Purpose of the Meeting
In early 1999, the Census Bureau will publish alternative measures of poverty based on the
proposals contained in the 1995 National Research Council (NRC) report, Measuring Poverty: A
New Approach. The current official poverty measure dates back to the 1960s, and while it has
been an important contributor to public debate and policymaking, the NRC report reflects a broad
consensus that the measure is out-of-date and in need of revision.
Poverty measurement involves two concepts: (1) A definition of family income; and (2) A
"threshold" against which income is compared to determine if a family is poor. Changes in
these two concepts will have a direct impact on statistics used by the public for informational
purposes. Changes will also likely have an effect on Federal programs as well.
Because of the importance of an independent statistical system, the Census Bureau plays the
major role in deciding technical issues regarding poverty measurement. However, because of
the important policy and political implications of the poverty concept, Census has asked for
advice from the EOP (because OMB, through OIRA's Statistical Policy Office, is the statutory
arbiter of the "official" poverty measurement methodology) on the upcoming report.
In response to Census' request, CEA, DPC, NEC, and OMB formed a policy working group.
(Among the agencies, only the Deputy Assistant Secretary for Human Services Policy at HHS
was invited to participate because of her expertise on poverty measurement.) This working
group has held a series of meetings, and prepared the attached memo to outline its tentative
guidance to Census. The meeting ofEOP Principals is intended to review the working group's
conclusions before they are transmitted to Census. It is important to emphasize that we are only
being asked to give advice to the Bureau of the Census; what it actually publishes is its decision.
There are four global issues to be decided; the first two are most pressing because we need to
give guidance to Commerce as soon as possible:
1) Should the Census Bureau select or highlight a single alternative poverty measure, or present
s~veral equally in its forthcoming report? Do the principals have a single preferred measure that
�','
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
"
CLOSE HOLD. Page 2
they would like to see replace the current official measure? Would anointing a single measure at
this time be premature, and prejudge the analytical process? Would it raise ire in the Congress?
If we do not anoint a single preferred measure at this time, will it be difficult to select one later
should we want to switch the "official" definition to one of the proposed alternatives?
2) There are also two technical issues (policy options 1 and 4 in the background memo) that
require careful consideration.
•
Should we advise Census to benchmark the new poverty measure to the old poverty rate
in the current year (so that the number of people classified as poor would remain the
same, although the distribution would change)? Should Census implement the NRC
recommendations, which would result in a higher poverty rate (e.g., 18% rather than
13.7% in 1996)?
•
Ifthere is only one measure reported by Census, should it account for differences in
medical out-of-pocket (MOOP) expenditures among households in the way recommended
by the NRC, namely, subtracting them from income before a family's poverty status is
calculated? (An alternative choice is to add them to the thresholds -- which ofthese
methodologies should be used is a technical choice best left to Census.) Ifwe believe
that several measures should be equally reported by Census, should one of them account
for medical expenditures using a different methodology?
3) How should the Administration proceed toward a new official measure of poverty? Should it
proceed along a timetable to replace the current official measure before the end of this
Administration? If so, what process do we need to establish to move forward on this in a timely
fashion? Or, should the Administration proceed more cautiously, letting a consensus build
around a preferred measure among the community of users of poverty statistics, but possibly
lessening the chances that the official measure is ultimately changed?
4) In addition to OMB's designation of the "official" poverty measurement, HHS also issues
administrative poverty guidelines, used in certain program eligibility calculations. If revised
poverty thresholds are adopted as part of a new poverty measure, would the Administration
continue the old administrative poverty guidelines, or make them consistent with the new
threshold measure? If the guidelines are made consistent, would the Administration make
programmatic changes to mitigate the effects on eligibility and spending of switching to the new
guidelines?
�..
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 3
TECHNICAL BACKGROUND ON INCOME AND POVERTY MEASURES
The Current Poverty Measure
The methodology by which current poverty thresholds are detennined was developed in the early
1960s by Mollie Orshansky, a staff economist at the Social Security Administration. She
developed a set of poverty thresholds that vary with the number of adults, the number of children,
and the age of the family head. These thresholds represent the cost of a minimum diet
multiplied by 3 to allow for non-food expenditures. The multiplier of3 was chosen because the
average family in 1955 spent one-third of its after-tax income on food. Since the late 1960s, the
thresholds have simply been updated annually to adjust for price inflation -- i.e., the measure of
poverty has remained virtually unchanged for 35 years, despite substantial changes in family
behavior and government policy.
The NRC panel identified several weaknesses in the current poverty measure:
•
The current poverty measure takes no account of changes in taxes (i.e., the expansion of
the EITC) or in-kind benefits (i.e., Food Stamps).
•
The current measure does not distinguish between the needs of working and non-working
families. In particular, it does not reflect the cost of child care and other work expenses
for working low-income families.
•
The current poverty measure takes no explicit account of medical care costs, which vary
significantly across families and have increased substantially since the current poverty
measure was developed.
The NRC Recommendations
In order to understand the NRC panel's recommended revisions, one must understand the basics
of detennining poverty. A family is considered poor when its resources fall below a
predetermined poverty line or threshold. Therefore, one must develop a methodology for
estimating family resources and for defining the threshold resource level below which a family is
considered poor.
1.
Defining Family Resources
Under the current poverty calculation, the definition of family resources is cash income. The
NRC recommendations would estimate family resources as:
Family resources
Cash income + Near-money in-kind benefits - Taxes - Child care
costs - Work expenses - Child support payments - Out of pocket
�"
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 4
medical care expenditures (including health insurance premiums)
The rationale for subtracting taxes, work and medical expenses from family resources is that
these expenditures are typically not discretionary and reduce the family income available to
achieve a basic quality oflife.
There is near consensus among researchers that adjusting for near-money in-kind benefits
(primarily Food Stamps and housing subsidies) and taxes would be an improvement in how
poverty is measured. There is slightly less agreement on whether child care costs, work
expenses, and child support payments should also be deducted because an unknown proportion
of these expenses is likely discretionary. (The NRC proposes to cap the amount of child care
and work expenses that can be subtracted to deal with this problem.) As discussed below, the
adjustment for out-of-pocket medical care expenditures is more controversial.
2.
Defining a Poverty Threshold
A threshold must be determined against which to compare a family's resources. The NRC panel
recommends basing the threshold on expenditures on "necessities" (food, shelter, and clothing)
plus a little more. Specifically, the NRC panel recommends selecting the 30th to 35th percentile
in the distribution of annual expenditures on food, shelter, and clothing among families of four
(two adults and two children), and then multiplying this expenditure level by between 1.15 and
1.25. Thresholds for other family sizes and types would be determined by an equivalency scale
calculation.
The NRC recommends adjusting these thresholds to take into account geographic variation in
cost of living, based on differences in housing costs by region and by city-size. It also
recommends adjusting the thresholds over time by recalculating them from expenditure data on
an annual basis.
OPTIONS FOR DISCUSSION
1. Recommendation regarding determining the level of the poverty threshold.
The NRC panel acknowledges that the actual level at which the poverty threshold is set (and
hence the final poverty rate) is inherently arbitrary and cannot be determined on the basis of
purely statistical judgements. There are two primary options:
A. The NRC alternative. As described above, the NRC panel recommends establishing a
threshold based on the 30th-35th percentile in the distribution of annual expenditures for a family
offour, with a small multiplier to account for additional small personal expenditures. As shown
in Tables 1 and 2, column 3, this would raise the 1996 poverty rate from 13.7% to 18%, and
increase poverty among all subgroups. In addition, (as described furtherin Option B) this
�Automated Records Management Syster;Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 5
change will alter the composition of poverty among various subgroups.)
B. Benchmarking. The NRC panel also considered poverty estimates that benchmark the
altemativepoverty rate to equal the old poverty rate in a given year. The Census has done a
number of such benchmarked calculations for 1996, as shown in Tables 1 and 2, column 2.
(The report issued early next year would benchmark to 1997.) Benchmarking would assure that
the aggregate poverty rate is identical for the official and the alternative measure in the
benchmark year. But the distribution of poverty among subgroups within each measure would
differ (see Table 2). In general, working families and families with large out-of-pocket medical
expenses become poorer and non-working families with substantial in-kind benefits become less
poor. This has geographic as well as subgroup poverty rate implications. Similarly, both
historical and future trends would differ. For instance, the alternative measure is identical in
1996 but higher in 1991. (The faster fall using the alternative measure is largely due to the
expansion in the EITC.)
Pros of using the NRC measure:
•
Incorporates the recommendations of the NRC panel, based on their professional
judgement from the best available evidence.
•
Generates dollar threshold levels that are quite similar to the current dollar thresholds
(although the resources to which the thresholds would be compared are quite different).
Cons of using the NRC Measure:
•
Results in a higher poverty rate (although the trends over time are similar.)
Pros ofBenchmarking:
•
May provide an easier transition to the new methodology because there will not be a
change in the overall level of poverty.
•
Focuses the arguments on the relative distribution of who is poor rather than how many
people are poor.
Cons ofBenchmarking:
•
Violates the NRC recommendation that the threshold should be based on the 30th-35th
percentile in the expenditure distribution. In order to benchmark, the threshold falls to
(about) the 25th percentile of expenditures on food, shelter, and clothing.
2. Recommendation regarding updating the thresholds over time
Currently the poverty threshold is updated annually using the CPI. This, however, does not
allow for adjustments that reflect changes in underlying consumption patterns that might affect
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 6
the revised thresholds. For instance, food prices have decreased relative to other goods over
time, while housing prices have increased. There are two options:
(A) Recalculate the thresholds annually as a share of consumption on food, shelter, and clothing.
(This is recommended by the NRC panel.)
(B) Update the thresholds on a year-to-year basis using a price index (preferably one based only
on food, shelter and clothing). Implement a regular process (every 5-1 0 years) of reviewing the
poverty measure and recalculating the thresholds.
Pros 0/Re-calculating the Thresholds:
•
Regular recalculation will allow the poverty thresholds to reflect more accurately changes
in consumption patterns and standards ofliving.
•
Without an expectation that the thresholds will be re-calculated regularly, it may be hard
to update them at all.
•
Under certain data circumstances, recalculation could move the threshold a large amount
or in an unexpected direction. This might raise substantive and political concerns.
Pros a/Updating Using the CP[:
•
Using the NRC methodology, the poverty thresholds are somewhat relative (i.e., they are
affected by changes in the distribution of household expenditures.) As a result, they are
a moving target and do not provide an absolute standard of need. A CPI adjustment
would make it easier to compare poverty from year-to-year against a constant standard.
•
Because consumption patterns and standards of living change slowly, it may be better to
take them into account periodically rather than annually.
•
An update with a CPI for necessities only (food, clothing, and shelter) may capture most
of the relevant changes and would make it easier in the short run to understand the
updating procedure.
•
The data may not be good enough for an annual re-calculation of the thresholds.
NOTE: The EOP Policy Working Group recommends Option (B).
3. Recommendation as to whether thresholds should be adjusted for geographic variation.
The NRC panel recommended adjusting the poverty thresholds for cost-of-living differences
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 7
across regions and by city size. Census proposes to make such adjustments based on housing
cost differences (which have much greater regional/city size variation than food or clothing.)
Pros ofAdjustingfor Geographic Variation in Cost ofLiving:
•
Most statisticians and economists agree that such adjustments should be made if data are
available.
Cons ofAdjustingfor Geographic Variation in Cost ofLiving:
•
There is no one "right" way to make such adjustments and the issue could be highly
politicized.
•
The data available to make such adjustments are limited and may not be entirely reliable.
•
Implementing such an adjustment in the poverty line threshold could lead to pressure to
provide regional cost adjustments in a wide variety of other govemment programs, from
Social Security benefits to tax payments.
NOTE: The EOP Policy Working Group recommends against geographic price adjustments.
4. Recommendation regarding how to account for medical care expenditures.
Since the mid-1970s, analysts have been concerned that the official poverty rate overstates the
extent of poverty among beneficiaries of Medicare, Medicaid, and private health insurance. At
the same time, the official poverty rate may understate the extent of poverty among populations
with large medical expenditures. Most analysts agree that, in principle, medical care "needs"
should be incorporated into the calculations of the threshold and family resources (i.e., families
with higher medical needs should have higher thresholds; those with more generous medical
benefits should be considered to have more resources; and those who must spend more to
achieve "good health" should have those expenses subtracted from their resources). However
we cannot observe a family's medical need. In addition, it is not clear that one can simply
impute the cash value of insurance benefits and add this to income. The "extra" benefits received
from insurance to cover expensive medical services do not provide income that can be used for
any other purpose.
To understand the difficulties, consider including medical benefits into the income calculations.
Adding medical benefits to income, without also adjusting the poverty threshold, has the perverse
effect of making sicker individuals appear better off. Other proposals to adjust the poverty
threshold (without also adjusting resources) run into similar problems.
In the end, the NRC panel recommended subtracting all medical out-of-pocket . (MOOP)
expenses (including health insurance premiums) from income, without trying to value health
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 8
insurance as a part of income or medical need as a part of the thresholds. Hence, family
resources are measured net ofMOOP. Those individuals with good insurance will have few
out- of-pocket expenses; those without insurance who face health problems will have lower
measured incomes as they pay more for medical care.
This adjustment accounts for the larger poverty rates using the NRC methodology. For example,
in 1996 the poverty rate was 13.7% using the current methodology; it would have been 18%
using the NRC methodology, but only 13.2% using the NRC methodology without the medical
expenses adjustment. This adjustment nearly doubles the poverty rate for the elderly, raising it
almost to the rate for children. This adjustment is one ofthe most controversial of the NRC
recommendations.
There is general agreement that ignoring medical care and medical expenses entirely is not a
good idea, particularly given the rapid increase in medical costs in the past 30 years, the extent of
uninsurance among the low-income population, and this Administration's concern with it. In
addition, if we do not adjust for medical care (in some way) now, it may be much harder to do so
in a few years when we will have better data (because the change will be so dramatic it will be
viewed as another big methodology change).
There are three approaches to incorporating medical care and expenses:
(A) Follow the NRC recommendation and subtract MOOP from family resources. This makes
families with unreimbursed medical expenses less well-offthan other families.
(B) MOOP could be added to the thresholds rather than subtracted from resources. (The choice
between options (A) and (B) is a technical decision that Census should address.)
(C) Try to impute the value of health insurance to resources, so those with insurance have higher
resources. Health insurance should then also be imputed into the thresholds.
Pros ofAdjustingfor MOOP (either options (A) or (B)):
•
While not perfect, under the NRC recommended adjustment families with higher
unreimbursed medical expenditures will be "poorer." The NRC recommended
adjustment would also be sensitive to changes in health care financing that would
decrease MOOP and thereby increase disposable income and reduce poverty.
Cons ofAdjustingfor MOOP (either options (A) or (B)):
•
The data that are currently available are out-of-date (but we should have updated
information available in a more timely fashion within another year.)
•
The NRC recommended approach relies on the controversial assumption that all medical
care expenditures are nondiscretionary. (This concern could be mitigated to some extent
by imposing a cap on the amount of medical expenses.)
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 9
Pros ofImputing the Value ofHealth Insurance into Resources and Thresholds:
•
Provides a more complete accounting of all medical resources available to a family.
Cons ofImputing the Value ofHealth Insurance into Resources and Thresholds:
•
There is no accepted "correct" way to do this. The data here are probably more
unreliable than the data needed to impute the value ofMOOP to families.
•
Many analysts agree with the NRC panel that the value of health insurance is quite
different than (say) the value of food stamps, which are far more fungible. Mixing in
health insurance coverage with economic need causes interpretational and conceptual
problems to a measure of economic need.
•
To date, Census has been following the NRC recommendation. Ifwe asked them to
switch to this approach, it might require substantial additional work and seriously delay
their report.
NOTE: The EOP Policy Working Group recommends that Census incorporate medical care in
some way and recognizes that option (A) is the most practical and realistic for the short term.
However, the group strongly recommends that Census thoroughly investigate the impact of
option (8), and continue work on other approaches to incorporating medical care and
expenditures, such as by valuing medical health insurance (option (C»).
5. Recommendations regarding which alternatives Census should publish and/or how
they should be presented.
The current plan is to publish a small number (maybe 3) of alternatives. For instance, the
Census could publish a 1997-benchmarked poverty rate and a NRC-alternative poverty rate,
providing two alternatives. Or it could publish a 1997-benchmarked poverty rate including all
of the NRC recommendations, and then publish the same thing without MOOP, or without
geographical price variation. (There will be extensive appendices in this report that will report a
wide variety of different poverty calculations, to demonstrate the statistical properties of the
poverty measurement recommended by NRC.)
•
Will it be confusing to publish multiple (even a small number of) alternatives, as opposed
to only one alternative? How will this affect how the report is received? How should
these be presented?
•
What problems will it create to have multiple alternatives if at some future point we want
to redefine the official poverty rate to one of these improved alternative measures?
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 10
Table 1. Poverty Rates and Thresholds under Alternative Measures, 1991-96, CPS
Official
measure
Benchmarked
to 1996
Poverty Rates
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
14.2
14.8
IS.1
14.6
13.8
13.7
14.S
IS.3
IS.7
14.7
Thresholds for 2 adults
and 2 children (in dollars)
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
13,812
14,228
14,6S4
lS,029
lS,4SS
IS,911
11,891 .
12,249
12,616
12,938
13,30S
13,698
NRC
Experimental
18.9
19.6
20.2
19.0
13.8
18.2
18.0
13.7
13,891
14,309
14,738
IS, lIS
IS,S43
16,002
�,-
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 11
Table 2. Poverty Rates under Alternative Measures, 1996, CPS
Official
measure
BenchmarkedNRC
to 1996
Experimental
AU persons
13.7
13.7
18.0
Children
Nonelderlyadults
Elderly
20.5
11.4
18.1
11.5
23.8
15.0
20.4
15.6
10.8
White
Black
Hispanic origin
11.2
28.4 .
29.4
11.8
25.2
28.5
15.6
32.0
37.7
One or more workers
9.5
10.0
13.6
Persons in family of type:
Married couple
Female householder
6.9
35.8
7.8
32.3
Geographic regions:
Northeast
Midwest
South
West
12.7
10.7
15.1
15.4
14.3
10.3
14.2
16.1
18.8
13.8
18.3
21.0
Metro/CC
NotCC
Nonmetro
19.6
9.4
15.9
19.2
10.6
13.5
24.7
14.1
17.5
11.1
40.4
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 12
APPENDIX
The Effect of the Poverty Measure on Program Eligibility and Benefits
The Congressional Research Service has identified 26 programs that are affected by the
measure of poverty. Many of the program connections to the poverty definition are unique, and
many are highly complex. Hence, we do not yet have a precise estimate of how program costs
or coverage would be affected.
We should not leap to the conclusion that this large number of programs would dictate a
large Federal cost impact ofa new measure of poverty. Many ofthe affected programs are
small, and many ofthe programs may be affected to only a limited degree 9Y even a change in the
measured aggregate incidence of poverty. Some of the programs are discretionary, meaning that
their aggregate cost is set by appropriation; a change in the measure of poverty would affect only
the geographic distribution of those funds (though that could, in itself, be a matter of political
concern, if such reallocations should prove to be significant). However, where at least a few
large programs are involved, it is essential to investigate the potential impact carefully.
There are two schools of thought on the potential budgetary or allocational effect of a
change in the definition of poverty.
Gordon Fisher, the analyst at HHS who oversees the production of the poverty guidelines
used in some programs, presents one perspective in a recent paper:
A number of people believe that the poverty guidelines affect many big entitlement
programs. That belief is an exaggeration of the actual situation. Most of the Federal
programs using the guidelines are medium-sized or small, with only a few big programs.
Moreover, mosLare discretionary programs ... Only a few programs using the guidelines
are mandatory: Medicaid, the Food Stamp Program, and child nutrition programs (mainly
the National School Lunch Program).!
Offering a different perspective, a recent issue of Focus, the periodical of the Institute for
Research on Poverty, notes:
For example, the NRC study panel proposed that the measure take into account
work-related expenses in families where at least one person is employed. Such a change
could have important implications for the allocation of federal funds between local areas
where the proportions of working and nonworking families differ. Including geographic
variations in housing costs might have similar far-reaching effects. Before introducing a
new property measure for program purposes, policy makers must determine whether the
!G. Fisher, "Disseminating the Administrative Version and Explaining the
Administrative and Statistical Versions of the Federal Poverty Measure." Clinical Sociology
Review, vol. 15 (1997), p. 165.
�Auto~ated
Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 13
resulting redistribution of resources will be more equitable, or will have unexpected and
capricious effects.
As Fisher suggests, the discretionary - mandatory distinction is important. As noted
above, the issue for discretionary programs is not the amount of funding, which is determined by
appropriations (though Congress could change future appropriations under the influence of a
changed measure of poverty), but rather the geographic allocation of a fixed amount of
appropriations. The geographic allocation of relevant discretionary program funds can depend
upon the incidence of poverty in particular locations. Therefore, these programs are affected by
the actual poverty measure, based on the official thresholds and income concept. The ties
between these programs and poverty vary considerably, and staff are undertaking the task of
determining how much effect a change in the poverty concept could have. These allocations
. mayor may not change by much, depending upon the extent to which the new poverty measure
reallocated poverty geographically; the role of poverty in the allocation of the discretionary funds
(some programs use poverty as only one of several indexes by which to distribute funding); the
lag between the measurement of poverty and the actual effect on the program (some programs
use poverty as measured in the decennial census); and other factors that can be determined only
through a program-by-program search.
Besides the official poverty thresholds and the income definition, there are poverty
guidelines. The Federal poverty guidelines are the version of the official poverty measure used
for program purposes. They are issued by HHS annually, and are based on a simplified and
updated version of the previous year's Census poverty measure.
Staff are in the process of determining the potential effects of a change in the poverty
measure on the two largest programs affected by the poverty measure, Medicaid and the Food
Stamp Program, as well as the smaller programs. In Medicaid, while most recipients qualify for
coverage because of their participation in other means-tested programs such as TANF and SSI
(programs that do not use the poverty line in their eligibility criteria), changes in poverty
thresholds could affect at least three major Medicaid eligibility groups: women, infants and
children up to age 6 with family incomes below 133 percent of poverty and children from age 6
to 18 with incomes at or below the poverty level (this provision is being phased in for all poor
children under age 19 by FY 2002); families, children and other uninsured in the Medicaid
waiver States that have extended coverage beyond current law requirements based on income in
relation to the poverty guidelines; and new groups oflow-income Medicare beneficiaries who
qualifY for partial coverage under Medicaid. In all, people whose eligibility for Medicaid is
related to the poverty line are estimated to account for about 20 percent of Medicaid recipients.
Since most are in families with incomes well below the specified level, only a small fraction
would actually be affected by a poverty line change. Further, most of the new enrollees would
be children, whose average health care costs are low. Still, Medicaid is such a large program
that even a small proportionate change in costs could involve a significant number of dollars.
The poverty guidelines are used in the Food Stamp Program to set gross income
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 14
eligibility--only families with gross incomes below 130% of the poverty line are eligible forfood
stamps. Actual food stamp benefits are calculated based on net income, however--income after
deductions for work expenses and various other things. Net income is compared to a specific
benefit allotment, determined nationally for each family size, and that benefit is reduced by 30
cents for every dollar of net income the family receives. In practice, the benefit allotment for
most families with incomes near the gross income eligibility limit would be small. Many
families would be eligible only for zero benefits. Even where families are eligible for some
positive benefits, take-up rates among those eligible for small amounts of food stamp benefits
tend to be low--the hassle of getting and using food stamps exceeds their value for most such
eligibles. Thus, the gross income eligibility cut-offfor food stamps is more theoretical than
real--families at or near 130% ofthe poverty line will almost always be eligible only for very low
or zero benefits, and are unlikely to participate in the program. For these reasons, we would
expect the effect on Food Stamp costs to be smaller than that for Medicaid.
�'.. ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 oflO
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUN-1998 17:11:51.00
SUBJECT:
Internal Q&A to review on equal pay
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Amy N. Finkelstein ( CN=Amy N. Finkelstein/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO]
)
)
CC: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Here are the draft internal Q&A for the equal pay event.
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
==================== ATTAC
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D81]MAIL48970506T.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043730A0000010A02010000000205000000625100000002000047AAB9A438F061096842F5
A5F3763949A892887E4085384B563F0429C1DA03DF8767E32606DF80D841558EB18A6AAD4F4070
CD81400B1E600711D682513AB2DE3C4C8B1F44222BAF5E73790688C268F20B7929704F767EE652
FF4232ECFE3233D916C2913973AB8603164173A1EE65FBB85D49790644B7017DEAF82D4CD09ED5
BB933BDE3DF6A49071966215F50A93FE727AF04B082BDOC4B2FF22B5922F907D04FE7CD8AOF5EO
FB8811E9A625991BACF7B9BBDD321BOD93BD4F7404F1C853184B3F2A4E7CCFAC376E064B1D253D
87EB6C785B9E6AD83973D2752CC578F31231E85CA3F6784B49308642895D5045ACF9F068393107.
3A6BA1BEFF5B239F1C8D59109CEFFB950A58CFFFBEA96D75F3981A27333E1866755EE1FB2860A3
EOBD73748CAOOBC3FOBF373451FA4EC4594C034E04CAB7E3A33CC94AFE1643AF7333D9A071F04E
4E6FAB2578B93FC89FB2A27943B199FF31CB596C9F4027594AADB64BE23870AOB69AD92D41D9C7
EF73159B095F7C4815B6939979A8996426CBDADB091770216F12416C786B7CECD80472D6A3B534
B9FE4E2CBCAB9F5128928006156B5C787F108C54C1C8BCF644C584E525CE36B7BOF8189E5573C7
3150689A7AEA6FA93E1F3E17710CAOC2BDCD6C197E690A34A72F3FFE26B9C902E6BA6CAC878E04
BA8EC794A502006100000000000000000000000823010000000B0100004E070000005507000300
4E0000005908000009250100000006000000A70800000B300300000028000000AD080000087701
00000040000000D508000008340100000014000000150900000802010000000F00000029090000
080501000000080000003809000009440100000043000000400900000968010000000600000083
0900000055040001003C0000008909000006080100000016000000C50900000000000000000000
0000C509000000000000000000000000C509000000000000000000000000C50900000000000000
0000000000C509000006080100000015000000DB09000000000000000000000000DB0900000000
�"
Automated Records Management S
Questions And Answers on Equal Pay
June 10, 1998
Hex-Dump Conversion
ystem
Q:
What did the President announce today?
A:
Today the President commemorated the thirty-fifth anniversary of President Kennedy's
signing of the Equal Pay Act. The President called for passage of legislation to
strengthen the laws that prohibit wage discrimination against women and released a
Council of Economic Advisers' (CEA) report on the gender wage gap, which shows that
although the gap between women and men's wages has narrowed substantially since the
signing of the Equal Pay Act, there still exists a significant wage gap. He also
announced a Department of Labor report that provides a historical perspective of the
wage gap. The President was joined by Dr. Dorothy Height, President Emeritus of the
National Council of Negro Women, who was at the signing ceremony ofthe Equal Pay
Act in 1963.
Q:
What are the highlights of the legislation?
A:
The legislation, sponsored by Senator Daschle and Congresswoman DeLauro, seeks to
improve the enforcement of wage discrimination laws and to strengthen the remedy
provisions in the Equal Pay Act by permitting victims of wage discrimination to seek
compensatory and punitive damages. Currently, women who are the victims of wage
discrimination receive only backpay and liquidated damages, which may not fully
compensate them for their loss. This change will mean that the penalties for sex-based
wage discrimination will be the same as those for race-based wage discrimination. In
addition, the legislation contains a non-retaliation provision that prohibits employers from
penalizing employees for sharing information about their salaries with co-workers.
Finally, the bill provides for training for EEOC employees on matters involving the
discrimination of wages, research on discrimination in the payment of wages, and the
establishment of the "The National Award for Pay Equity in the Workplace,"
which will recognize and promote the achievements of employers that have made
strides to eliminate pay disparities.
Q:
What does the Council of Economic Advisers' report say?
A:
This report shows that a significant gap between the wages of women and men
remains today although it has narrowed substantially since the signing of the Equal
Pay Act. In 1963, the year that the Equal Pay Act was signed, women earned 58
cents for every dollar men earned. Today women earn about 75 cents for every
dollar men earn, a 29 percent increase over the 1963 levels. Despite these gains,
there continues to be a significant gap between men's and women's wages, even
after accounting for factors such as educational attainment, work experience, and
1
�Automated Records M,
Hex-Dump c;nagement System
nversfon
occupational choice.
Over the last twenty years, increases in women's accumulated labor market
experience and their movement into higher-paying occupations has played a major
role in increasing women's wages relative to men's. Even accounting for gender
differences in education, labor market experience, broad occupational and
industrial distributions, the female/male pay ration in the late 1980s rose only from
about 72 to 88 percent, leaving around an "unexplained difference" of about 12
percent as of the late 1980s. This "unexplained" difference may be explained, in
part, by continuing discrimination.
Q:
Why does the CEA report state that women earned more than 75 percent of what
men earned in 1997, and recent AP and USA Today stories say that women earn 76
percent of what men earn, up from 73 percent a year ago?
A:
The figures are consistent. Slight differences in numbers are due to the fact that the
numbers are based on different data sources. The CEA numbers are based on workers
aged 25 to 64, while those in the AP story are based on workers aged 16 and over.
Q:
Why is this legislation necessary?
A:
More than three decades after the passage of the Equal Pay Act and Title VII of the Civil
Rights Act, women and people of color continue to suffer the consequences of unfair pay
differentials. The average women works a full year, plus three more months, just to earn
the same pay that men earn it} one calendar year. According to the Department of Labor,
as of 1997, the average woman who works full-time earns just 74 cents for each dollar
that men earn. For women of color, the gap is even wider. On average, as of 1997,
black women earned only 63 cents, and Hispanic women earned only 53 cents for each
dollar earned by white men. Some wage differences exist due to differing levels of
experience, education, and skill. However, studies show that even accounting for
differences in education, experience, and occupation, there is still a significant wage
differential.
Q:
Since the data show that the gender wage gap didn't start to close until the last
1970s, doesn't that mean that the Equal Pay Act had no effect?
A:
The fact that the wage gap didn't start to close until sometime after the Equal Pay Act was
implemented does not mean that the Equal Pay Act had no effect.
First, it can take some time for legislation, like the Equal Pay Act, to have an effect on the
workforce. For example, if the Equal Pay Act made younger women know that they
would be protected against discrimination, it would provide an incentive for these women
to invest more in their skills -- which would have a pay-off over the long term.
2
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Second, as the CEA report makes clear, few studies have examined the effects of the
Equal Pay Act or other policies in the 1960s on the gender pay gap. Isolating the effects
of a single policy change from broader social and economic changes is difficult.
However, although no such studies of the effect of policies on the gender pay ratio exist,
it is clear that a role for these policy changes in both the increase in the gender pay ratio
and in the other changes that have served to increase the gender pay ratio cannot be ruled
out.
Third, what is important now is to strengthen the Equal Pay Act so that do more to
combat the negative forces of discrimination. That is why the President strongly
supports the Daschle-DeLauro bill.
Q:
What's wrong with the current scheme for collecting damages under the Equal Pay
Act?
A:
Currently, the EPA allows only for liquidated damages and backpay awards. Liquidated
damages usually are awarded in an amount equal to backpay. Such awards may not fully
compensate a woman for real losses, such as damages for pain and suffering. In
addition, women cannot receive punitive damages for wage discrimination, no matter
how intentional and egregious the employer's conduct. The legislation the
Administration is endorsing today will ensure that women are fully compensated when an
employer discriminates against them in setting wages.
Q:
What is the Administration doing with respect to data collection?
A:
The endorsed legislation contains a Sense of the Senate that the President should take
appropriate steps to increase the amount of information available with respect to wage
disparities, while maximizing the utility ofthe data and protecting individuals' privacy
and minimizing burdens on reporting entities. In addition, the Administration previously
announced an annual report on the pay gap, by sex, to be produced by the Department of
Labor. This easy-to-access report will raise the national prominence of wage disparities
and will highlight the issue every year in order to spur Americans to achieve increased
equ~l pay.
Q:
Is the Administration's policy on uncapped punitive and compensatory damages
consistent with its position in other areas of the law such as tort reform?
A:
Yes, this is consistent with Administration's position on tort reform. Our proposals on
tort reform have never sought to cap compensatory damages, which are necessary to
remedy actual harm. And except in very exceptional circumstances, we have approved
the use of punitive damage awards to deter intentional misconduct.
Q:
Why isn't the Administr~tion supporting comparable worth?
3
�.
A:
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
The Daschle-DeLauro bill is a significant step forward in solving the problem of unequal
pay. The Administration believes there is no excuse for not taking these obvious steps
towards providing better training and fuller remedies to help ensure women receive equal
pay, while building a consensus on other ways to make sure every person receives the pay
they deserve. The Administration is focusing on legislation that can be passed during this
congressional session.
Questions ofthe Federal Work Force
Q:
What are·some of the specific accomplishments of the Clinton Administration with
respect to women appointees?
A:
Here are some specific accomplishments:
Appointed the first women ever to serve as Attorney General (Janet
Reno) and Secretary of State (Madeleine Albright). Including the
Attorney General and Secretary of State, women make up 27 percent
of the Clinton Cabinet:. The Cabinet also include: Alexis Herman,
Secretary of Labor; Donna Shalala, Secretary of Health and Human
Services; Carol Browner, Administrator of the Environmental
Protection Agency; Janet YeUen,Chair of the Council of Economic
Advisors; and Charlene Barchevsky, United States Trade
Representative.
A third of aU judicial nominees are women, the highest proportion
ever.
Nominated the second woman to serve on the Supreme Court.
During his first year in office, President Clinton nominated Ruth
Bader Ginsberg to the United States Supreme Court. Justice
Ginsburg is only the second woman to serve on the nation's highest
court.
Q:
What is the representation of women in the federal work force?
A:
Women represented 42.8 percent of the Federal permanent workforce in 1997
compared to 46.4 percent of the Civilian Labor Force, a difference of a -3.6
percentage points.
Q:
What is the average salary of female political employees versus that of male
appointees? How does that average compare to comparable figures in the
previous Administration?
A:
In 1992, under President Bush, women made up 40 percent of the political ranks,
4
�"
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
and the average female political appointee's salary was 75 percent of the average
male appointee's salary. In 1997, in the Clinton Administration, the percentage
of women appointees increased to 45 percent, and the average woman's salary
shot up to 85 percent of the average man's.
Number and Average Salary of Political Appointments (by Gender):
1992 (Pres. Bush) Compared to 1997 (Pres. Clinton)
Gender
omen
92 (Bush)
Appts
97. (Clinton)
Appts
~g.
92 (Bush)
Pay ($)
97 (Clinton)
vg. Pay ($)
1,361
1,331
$61,554
$69,979*
n
2,055
1,628
$82,490
$82,860*
TAL
3,416
2,959
. Women
39.8%
45.0%
TE: Total Political Appointments
exclude Ambassadors but
include Noncareer SES,
Schedule C and Other.
* Rendered in constant' (FY 1992) dollars
5
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 oflO
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
CREATOR: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUN-1998 17:36:36.00
SUBJECT:
One update to internal equal pay Q&A to review
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T_ Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa G. Green ( CN=Melissa G. Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Amy N. Finkelstein ( CN=Amy N_ Finkelstein/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO]
)
TEXT:
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH_D75]MAIL44342506W.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043730A0000010A020100000002050000008450000000020000F23D9ECC6ECA1CB6720EEE
390AEF31C44D268C82C3FA787B000579969B3E04A60E4AD9F8A243B15E672CE5B8813A84EBB5C4
FA641D259FB1DB33D35E0732500FOl131B254C4EC08603B497A517C0624321323C2C9494BB8B2A
91794299BBAE9AACFOA4FB5EF360394505D1C5607C20860287675BD7A57644CEADF98E7C720C4E
9AA9397859BD0211D9C96F14D9C5092FD3E3CFAFB4DBA4EEA5F08CB3FE7265869FAB12E646CA1E
1CBCCBCE36DAABA1A37C92F3956FB73DA6F80457E906334787FF6BCBOE321468481CF439E5A554
31AC75CAE9ECF4F37E35EE2313814DC408BDF62E791AEA3C580EC333A2C8FE942A65A1C6783636
15C56FB2F18B33060A6A2748744E5F0390743033727ED3AOA9EBAFD3AA3B65E1FB913ED6368E5B
217179A9CEOC49FF52760A2DFBAD4FF823A9EC127EA622A11C70F637AD7D17DOC3F6F86940AAFA
9F23E9F6B2548BD5383F8A7B3CCEBD6783E12B2FEA2F23E90B41E417CF7964CC8EBOCA67CA3AD7
C5159AC22246AD8B19A064DADOOF47C71634A9727DEB2F70E02796457553F97B72195647F91735
340B6A94ACCE69DE3BEDAB5422FE09BE24CBBE8A906443F96E6720EF4422315F5A52D47BCA06CE
1A6D33AF3839C3900372EC5BE933FE8C7325FBEC597803229852CEF2A489F532CD73E10A3F31E9
4FE719873702006100000000000000000000000823010000000B0100004E070000005507000000
4E0000005908000009250100000006000000A70800000B300300000028000000AD080000087701
00000040000000D508000008340100000014000000150900000802010000000F00000029090000
080501000000080000003809000009440100000043000000400900000968010000000600000083
0900000055040000003C0000008909000006080100000016000000C50900000000000000000000
0000C509000000000000000000000000C509000000000000000000000000C50900000000000000
0000000000C509000006080100000015000000DB09000000000000000000000000DB0900000000
0000000000000000DB09000000000000000000000000DB09000000000000000000000000DB0900
0000000000000000000000DB09000000000000000000000000DB09000000000000000000000000
DB09000000000000000000000000DB09000000000000000000000000DB09000000000000000000
�Automated Records Management Systerr,
Hex-Dump Conversion
Questions And Answers on Equal Pay
June 10, 1998
Q:
What did the President announce today?
A:
Today the President commemorated the thirty-fifth anniversary of President Kennedy's
signing of the Equal Pay Act. The President cal1ed for passage of legislation to
strengthen the laws that prohibit wage discrimination against women and released a
Council of Economic Advisers' (CEA) report on the gender wage gap, which shows that
although the gap between women and men's wages has narrowed substantial1y since the
signing of the Equal Pay Act, there still exists a significant wage gap. He also
announced a Department of Labor report that provides a historical perspective of the
wage gap. The President was joined by Dr. Dorothy Height, President Emeritus of the
National Council of Negro Women, who was at the signing ceremony of the Equal Pay
Act in 1963.
Q:
What are the highlights of the legislation?
A:
The legislation, sponsored by Senator Daschle and Congresswoman DeLauro, seeks to
improve the enforcement of wage discrimination laws and to strengthen the remedy
provisions in the Equal Pay Act by permitting victims of wage discrimination to seek
compensatory and punitive damages. Currently, women who are the victims of wage
discrimination receive only backpay and liquidated damages, which may not ful1y
compensate them for their loss. This change wil1 mean that the penalties for sex-based
wage discrimination wil1 be the same as those for race-based wage discrimination. In
addition, the legislation contains a non-retaliation provision that prohibits employers from
penalizing employees for sharing information about their salaries with co-workers.
Final1y, the bill provides for training for EEOC employees on matters involving the
discrimination of wages, research on discrimination in the payment of wages, and the
establishment ofthe "The National Award for Pay Equity in the Workplace,"
which will recognize and promote the achievements of employers that have made.
strides to eliminate pay disparities.
Q:
What does the Council of Economic Advisers' report say?
A:
This report shows that a signifi<;ant gap between the wages of women and men
remains today although it has narrowed substantially since the signing of the Equal
Pay Act. In 1963, the year that the Equal Pay Act was signed, women earned 58
cents for every dollar men earned. Today women earn about 75 cents for every
dollar men earn, a 29 percent increase over the 1963 levels. Despite these gains,
there continues to be a significant gap between men's and women's wages, even
after accounting for factors such as educational attainment, work experience, and
1
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
occupational choice.
Over the last twenty years, increases in women's accumulated labor market
experience and their movement into higher-paying occupations has played a major
role in increasing women's wages relative to men's. Even accounting for gender
differences in education, labor market experience, broad occupational and
industrial distributions, the female/male pay ration in the late 1980s rose only from
about 72 to 88 percent, leaving around an "unexplained difference" of about 12
percent as of the late 1980s. This "unexplained" difference may be explained, in
part, by continuing discrimination.
Q:
Why does the CEA report state that women earned more than 75 percent of what
men earned in 1~97, and recent AP and USA Today stories say that women earn 76
percent of what men earn, up from 73 percent a year ago?
A:
The figures are consistent. Slight differences in numbers are due to the fact that the
numbers are based on different data sources. The CEA numbers are based on workers
aged 25 to 64, while those in the AP story are based on workers aged 16 and over.
Q:
Since the data show that the gender wage gap didn't start to close until the last
1970s, doesn't that mean that the Equal Pay Act had no effect?
A:
The fact that the wage gap didn't start to close until sometime after the Equal Pay Act was
implemented does not mean that the Equal Pay Act had no effect.
First, it can take some time for legislation, like the Equal Pay Act, to have an effect on the
workforce. For example, if the Equal Pay Act made younger women know that they
would be protected against discrimination, it would provide an incentive for these women
to invest more in their skills -- which would have a pay-off over the long term.
Second, as the CEA report makes clear, few studies have examined the effects of the
Equal Pay Act or other policies in the 1960s on the gender pay gap. Isolating the effects
of a single policy change from broader social and economic changes is difficult.
However, although no such studies of the effect of policies on the gender pay ratio exist,
it is clear that a role for these policy changes in both the increase in the gender pay ratio
and in the other changes that have served to increase the gender pay ratio cannot be ruled
out.
Third, what is important now is to strengthen the Equal Pay Act so that do more to
combat the negative forces of discrimination. That is why the President strongly
supports the Daschle-DeLauro bill.
Q:
What's wrong with the current scheme for coUecting damages under the Equal Pay
2
�Act?
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
A:
Currently, the EPA allows only for liquidated damages and backpay awards. Liquidated
damages usually are awarded in an amount equal to backpay. Such awards may not fully
compensate a woman for real losses, such as damages for pain and suffering. In
addition, women cannot receive punitive damages for wage discrimination, no matter
how intentional and egregious the employer's conduct. The legislation the
Administration is endorsing today will ensure that women are fully compensated when an
employer discriminates against them in setting wages.
Q:
What is the Administration doing with respect to data collection?
A:
The endorsed legislation contains a Sense of the Senate that the President should take
appropriate steps to increase the amount of information available with respect to wage
disparities, while maximizing the utility of the data and protecting individuals' privacy
and minimizing burdens on reporting entities. In addition, the Administration previously
announced an annual report on the pay gap, by sex, to be produced by the Department of
Labor. This easy-to-access report will raise the national prominence of wage disparities
and will highlight the issue every year in order to spur Americans to achieve increased
equal pay.
Q:
Is the Administration's policy on uncapped punitive and compensatory damages
consistent with its position in other areas of the law such as tort reform?
A:
Yes, this is consistent with Administration's position on tort reform. Our proposals on
tort reform have never sought to cap compensatory damages, which are necessary to
remedy actual harm. And except in very exceptional circumstances, we have approved
the use of punitive damage awards to deter intentional misconduct.
Q:
Why isn't the Administration supporting comparable worth?
A:
The Daschle-DeLauro bill is a significant step forward in solving the problem of unequal
pay. The Administration believes there is no excuse for not taking these obvious steps
towards providing better training and fuller remedies to help ensure women receive equal
pay, while building a consensus on other ways to make sure every person receives the pay
they deserve. The Administration is focusing on legislation that can be passed during this
congressional session.
Questions ofthe Federal Work Force
Q:
What are some of the specific accomplishments of the Clinton Administration with
respect to women appointees?
A:
Here are some specific accomplishments:
3
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Appointed the first women ever to serve as Attorney General (Janet
Reno) and Secretary of State (Madeleine Albright). Including the
Attorney General and Secretary of State, women make up 27 percent
of the Clinton Cabinet:. The Cabinet also include: Alexis Herman,
Secretary of Labor; Donna Shalala, Secretary of Health and Human
Services; Carol Browner, Administrator of the Environmental
Protection Agency; Janet Yellen, Chair of the Council of Economic
Advisors; and Charlene Barchevsky, United States Trade
Representative.
A third of all judicial nominees are women, the highest proportion
ever.
Nominated the second woman to serve on the Supreme Court.
During his first year in office, President Clinton nominated Ruth
Bader Ginsberg to the United States Supreme Court. Justice
Ginsburg is only the second woman to serve on the nation's highest
court.
What is the representation of women in the federal work force?
Q:
. A:
Women represented 42.8 percent of the Federal permanent workforce in 1997
compared to 46.4 percent of the Civilian Labor Force, a difference of a -3.6
percentage points.
Q:
What is the average salary of female political employees versus that of male
appointees? How does that average compare to comparable figures in the
previous Administration?
A:
In 1992, under President Bush, women made up 40 percent of the political ranks,
and the average female political appointee's salary was 75 percent of the average
male appointee's salary. In 1997, in the Clinton Administration, the percentage
of women appointees increased to 45 percent, and the average woman's salary
shot up to 85 percent of the average man's.
Number and Average Salary of Political Appointments (by Gender):
1992 (Pres. Bush) Compared to 1997 (Pres. Clinton)
Gender
92 (Bush)
Appts
97 (Clinton)
Appts
92 (Bush)
vg. Pay ($)
97 (Clinton)
,vg. Pay ($)
bmen
1,361
1,331
$61,554
$69,979*
~n
2,055
1,628
$82,490
$82,860*
4
�"
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
DTAL
. Women
3,416
39.8%
TE: Total Political Appointments
exclude Ambassadors but
include Noncareer SES,
Schedule C and Other.
2,959
45.0%
* Rendered in constant (FY 1992) dollars
5
�• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page I of 17
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUN-1998 19:02:52.00
SUBJECT:
Latest Draft of Poverty Memo
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Paul Bugg ( CN=Paul Bugg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TEXT:
Attached is the latest draft of the poverty memo.
The main change is that
the first three pages have been substantially re-cast in an effort to
better structure the main issues for the Principals.
(We've also moved
the placement of Tables 1 and 2.)
This attachment does not include the
Guideline appendix which will be sent under separate cover. However, you
may want to know that the new appendix does include a range of estimates
on potential budgetary impact of using the new poverty measures.
We would like to get this background memo to the Principals as soon as
possible. Therefore, please send Ceci your comments by 3pm tomorrow; the
full memo will be sent to the Principals at 5pm.
-- Ceci and Paul==================== ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
1 ====================
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D82]MAIL46307506R.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043B2080000010A02010000000205000000C8920000000200000A708D48F35797F36D8BD3
29E6B46BAOB557B499480AF33224376549819938EB4FFC5C5C833011DFDF2676E20883616903A5
100A18F52CCD76B90D24785D34D1F31E22154067152DACFE76895D4F41202EDF29483DA03DBB1A
87BFB3E0863781198ECOB830EOCB848BD7AB8E45D720FB363718D8131E835D8388C9F182CA6F22
8C11BOAC84956B01A43ECFDODCEOEA8206378AF4F611B1BDC3287459DCEDFB6EAD94C659B3802C
CF63A62E95E67BADC2B6E4E5CB89D0847FB435C49256D19088EF71D32EFC8210FC4B104FE07BC5
90D4D7A618E7CF16E370D1FB7DB6AF51C518AF492BEFFDC38BA1558072CA8752A803E3F17EC9B8
5C16718A95943CE13601235CEE943B4FB4EEE63E09503C721FE69218CBB40DODBCBCE5B6F64F8C
�Automated Records Manage'!1ent System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 1
June 9,1998
DRAFT BACKGROUND MEMORANDUM FOR EOP PRINCIPAL'S MEETING
FROM:
Income and Poverty Measurement Working Group
Subject:
Meeting on Income and Poverty Measures
This cover memo outlines the main issues related to revising our income and poverty measures to
be discussed at the Principals meeting, and the attached background paper explains the more
technical issues. The backgro~nd paper was prepared by a policy working group consisting of
CEA, DPC, NEC, and OMB. (Among the agencies, only the Deputy Assistant Secretary for
Human Services Policy at HHS participated because of her expertise on poverty measurement.)
Action Forcing Event and Purpose of the Meeting
In early 1999, the Census Bureau will publish alternative measures of poverty based on the
proposals contained in the 1995 National Research Council (NRC) report, Measuring Poverty: A
New Approach. Census has asked for advice from the EOP on their proposed alternative
measures (because OMB, through OIRA's Statistical Policy Office, is the statutory arbiter of the
"official" poverty measurement methodology). It is important to emphasize that we are only
being asked to advise the Bureau of the Census; what it actually publishes is its decision.
There are four questions to be discussed at the meeting: 1) At what pace should the
Administration proceed toward the adoption of a new official measure of poverty? 2) Should
the Administration initially propose a preferred option or a range of alternatives? 3) Should the
new measure be benchmarked to the most current poverty rate? 4) Ifhighlighting a preferred
option is selected, what are the components of that preferred option? In considering these
questions, it is critical that the Principals note that, at this time, we do not have definitive
analyses of the budgetary and programmatic impacts of NRC-based alternative measures of
poverty. We are unlikely to have such analyses before the Census publishes its report.
Background
The current official poverty measure dates back to the 1960s. And, although this measure has
been an important contributor to public debate and policymaking, the NRC report reflects a broad
consensus that the measure is out-of-date and in need of revision. .
Poverty measurement involves two concepts: (1) a definition of family resources, and (2) a
"threshold" against which resources are compared to detennine if a family is poor. Changes in
these two concepts will have a direct impact on statistics used by the public for infonnational and
analytical purposes. Changes will likely have an effect on both Federal program budgets and
participant eligibility as well.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 2
As discussed in the technical background paper, the NRC's recommended new poverty measure
has two important consequences for the poverty rate. First, it would increase the poverty rates of
all groups. For example, as shown in Table 1, in 1996 the poverty level was 13.7% using the
current measure; it would increase to 18% using the new measure.
Second, it would substantially alter the demographic composition of the poor as set out in Table
2. For example, the NRC measure nearly doubles the poverty rate among the elderly (from
10.8% to 20.4%), raising the rate to nearly that of children. Other groups with relatively large
increases are Whites and Hispanics, and married couples.
It is important to keep in mind that the NRC panel cautioned that setting the level below which a
family is considered poor is more of an art than a science. They therefore suggested a range of
alternatives and left it to policymakers to determine the most appropriate levels.
Issues for Consideration
1. At What Pace Should the Administration Proceed Toward the Adoption ofa New Official
Measure ofPovertv?
The most important issue to be decided is whether the Administration should attempt to adopt a
new official measure of poverty before the end of the second term. The advantage of acting
during this Administration is that the second term of an Administration with a strong economy is
an opportune time to make such a change. Also, the NAS made its recommendation three years
ago and some might question our delay in implementation. On the other hand, by proceeding
more cautiously, we would allow the community of users of poverty statistics to develop a better
understanding of the pros and cons, both analytical and programmatic, of the various alternative
measures. By establishing a more open process, we may also decrease the chance of a political
backlash and of Congressional intervention. In addition, it will take at least another 4 years to
develop fully the data needed to implement the NRC recommendations. Finally, selecting a
preferred alternative measure and analyzing its programmatic and budgetary impacts is likely to
be an iterative process that may take some time.
2. Should the Administration Initially Propose a Preferred Option or a Range of Alternatives?
Census' current plan is to publish a small number of alternatives. These would reflect the NAS
recommendation and analytically interesting variations. (There will be extensive appendices in
this report that will report a wide variety of different poverty definitions, to help demonstrate the
statistical and analytical properties of the poverty measure recommended by the NRC.)
We need to determine whether we will recommend that the Census Bureau select or highlight a
single alternative poverty measure, or present several equally in its forthcoming report. The
advantages of highlighting a single alternative measure is that it may be less confusing than
publishing multiple alternatives, and if we are correct in our choice, it may be easier for it to be
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 3
selected as the official poverty measure. In contrast, publishing a range of alternatives has many
of the same advantages of proceeding cautiously in the adoption of a new official measure of
poverty; that is, it would allow us more time to understand fully the analytical, programmatic,
and budgetary implications of the different alternative measures, preserve the Administration's
options to consider this issue further, and may be less likely to raise the ire of Congress.
3. If Highlighting a Preferred Option is Selected, Should the New Measure Be Benchmarked to
the Most Current Poverty Rate? (This is issue number 1 in the technical background paper.)
If we select a single measure, we will need to decide whether to recommend that Census
benchmark the new poverty measure to the old poverty rate in the current year (so that the
number of people classified as poor would remain the same, although the distribution would
change) or publish an NRC-like measure, which would result in a higher poverty rate (e.g., 18%
rather than 13.7% in 1996). Some argue that benchmarking to the current poverty rate would
diminish criticisms that the change is motivated by an effort to increase the estimated number of
people living in poverty, and would also focus attention on the distribution of who is poor, rather
than on how many people are poor. Others argue that since benchmarking to the current poverty
rate does not follow the NRC recommendation (which would result in a higher poverty rate), it
will be viewed as an effort to reduce artificially the estimated size of the poor population. Also,
it could be argued that benchmarking alters the composition of the poor. For example, the Black
poverty rate falls with benchmarking but rises with the NRC measure.
4. If Highlighting a Preferred Option is Selected, What are the Components of that Preferred
Option?
Issues relating to the choice of components are discussed in the technical background paper.
They include: how the poverty rate should be updated over time; whether the poverty thresholds
should be adjusted for geographic variation in the cost-of-living; and how to account for medical
care expenditures. Of these, how to adjust for medical expenditures is the most controversial.
At this time, the Census Bureau is prepared to account for differences in medical out-of-pocket
(MOOP) expenditures among households in the way recommended by the NRC, namely,
subtracting them from income before a family'S poverty status is calculated. However, there is
also interest in having medical expenditures added to the poverty thresholds. (Which of these
methodologies should be used is a technical choice best left to Census.)
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 4
Table 1. Poverty Rates and Thresholds under Alternative Measures, 1991-96, CPS
Official
measure
Benchmarked
to 1996
Poverty Rates
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
14.2
14.8
15.1
14.6
13.8
13.7
14.5
15.3
15.7
14.7
Thresholds for 2 adults
and 2 children (in dollars)
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
13,812
14,228
14,654
15,029
15,455
15,911
11,891
12,249
12,616
12,938
13,305
13,698
NRC
Experimental
18.9
19.6
20.2
19.0
18.2
13.8
18.0
13.7
13,891
14,309
14,738
15,115
15,543
16,002
�Automated Records Management Systerr,
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 5
Table 2. Poverty Rates under Alternative Measures, 1996, CPS
Official
measure
BenchmarkedNRC
to 1996
Experimental
AU persons
13.7
13.7
18_0
Children
Nonelderlyadults
Elderly
20.5
11.4
18.1
11.5
23.8
15.0
10.8
15.6
20.4
11.2
28.4
29.4
11.8
25.2
28.5
15.6
32.0
37.7
9.5
10.0
13.6
Persons in family of type:
Married couple
Female householder
6.9
35.8
7.8
32.3
11.1
40.4
Geographic regions:
Northeast
Midwest
South
West
12.7
10.7
15.1
15.4
14.3
10.3
14.2
16.1
18.8
13.8
18.3
21.0
Metropolitan/Central City
Not Central City
Nonmetropolitan
19.6'
9.4
15.9
19.2
10.6
13.5
24.7
14.l
17.5
White
Black
Hispanic origin
One or more workers
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 6
TECHNICAL BACKGROUND ON INCOME AND POVERTY MEASURES
The Current Poverty Measure
The methodology by which current poverty thresholds are determined was developed in the early
1960s by Mollie Orshansky, a staff economist at the Social Security Administration. She
developed a set of poverty thresholds that vary with the number of adults, the number of children,
. and the age ofthe family head. These thresholds represent the cost of a minimum diet
multiplied by 3 to allow for nonfood expenditures. The multiplier of 3 was chosen because the
average family in 1955 spent one-third of its after-tax income on food. Since the late 1960s, the
thresholds have been updated annually with the CPI to adjust for price inflation. Thus, the
definition of poverty has remained virtually unchanged for 35 years, despite substantial changes
in family behavior and govemment policy.
The NRC panel identified several weaknesses in the current poverty measure:
•
The current poverty measure takes no account of changes in taxes (e.g., the expansion of
the EITC) or in-kind benefits (e.g., Food Stamps).
•
The current measure does not distinguish between the needs of working and nonworking
families. In particular, it does not reflect the cost of child care and other work expenses
for working low-income families.
•
The current poverty measure takes no explicit account of medical care costs, which vary
significantly across families and have increased substantially since the current poverty
measure was developed.
The NRC Recommendations
In order to understand the NRC panel's recommended revisions, one must understand the basics
of determining poverty. A family is considered poor when its resources fall below a
predetermined poverty line or threshold. Therefore, one must develop a methodology for
estimating family resources and for defining the threshold resource level below which a family is
considered poor.
1.
Defining Family Resources
Under the current poverty calculation, the definition of family resources is cash income. The
NRC recommendations would estimate family resources as:
Family resources
Cash income + Near-money in-kind benefits - Taxes - Child care
costs - Work expenses - Child support payments - Out of pocket
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 7
medical care expenditures (including health insurance premiums)
The rationale for subtracting taxes, work, and medical expenses from family resources is that
these expenditures are typically not discretionary and reduce the family income available to
achieve a basic quality oflife.
There is near consensus among researchers that adjusting for near-money in-kind benefits
(primarily Food Stamps and housing subsidies) and taxes would be an improvement in how
poverty is measured. There is slightly less agreement on whether child care costs, work
expenses, and child support payments should also be deducted because an unknown proportion
of these expenses is likely discretionary. (The NRC proposes to cap the amount of child care
and work expenses that can be subtracted to deal with this problem.) As discussed below, the
adjustment for out-of-pocket medical care expenditures is more controversial.
2.
Defining a Poverty Threshold
A threshold must be determined against which to compare a family'S resources. The NRC panel
recommends basing the threshold on expenditures on "necessities" (food, shelter, and clothing)
plus a little more. Specifically, the NRC panel recommends selecting the 30th to 35th percentile
in the distribution of annual expenditures on food, shelter, and clothing among families of four
(two adults and two children), and then multiplying this expenditure level by between 1.15 and
1.25. Thresholds for other family sizes and types would be determined by an equivalency scale
calculation.
The NRC recommends adjusting these thresholds to take into account geographic variation in
cost of living, based on differences in housing costs by region and by city-size. It also
recommends adjusting the thresholds over time by recalculating them from expenditure data on
an annual basis.
TECHNICAL ISSUES
1. Determining the level of the poverty threshold.
The NRC panel acknowledges that the actual level at which the poverty threshold is set (and
hence the final poverty rate) is inherently arbitrary and cannot be determined on the basis of
purely statistical judgements. There are two primary options:
A. The NRC alternative. As described above, the NRC panel recommends establishing a
threshold based on the 30th-35th percentile in the distribution of annual expenditures for a family
offour, with a small multiplier to account for additional small personal expenditures. As shown
in Tables 1 and 2, column 3, this would raise the 1996 poverty rate from 13.7% to 18%, and
increase poverty among all subgroups. In addition, (as described further in Option B) this
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 8
change will alter the composition of poverty by changing the poverty rate among subgroups.
B. Benchmarking. The NRC panel also considered poverty estimates that benchmark the
alternative poverty rate to equal the old poverty rate in a given year. The Census Bureau has
done a number of such benchmarked calculations for 1996, as shown in Tables 1 and 2, column
2. (The report issued early next year could benchmark to 1997.) Benchmarking would assure
that the aggregate poverty rate is identical for the official and the alternative measure in the
benchmark year. But the distribution of poverty among subgroups within each measure would
differ (see Table 2). In general, working families and families with large out-of-pocket medical
expenses become poorer and nonworking families with substantial in-kind benefits become less
poor. This has geographic as well as subgroup poverty rate implications. Similarly, both
historical and future trends would differ. For instance, the alternative measure is identical in
1996 but higher in 1991. (The faster fall using the alternative measure is largely due to the
expansion in the EITC.)
Pros of using the NRC measure:
•
Incorporates the recommendations of the NRC panel, based on their professional
judgement from the best available evidence.
•
Generates dollar threshold levels that are quite similar to the current dollar thresholds
(although the resources to which the thresholds would be compared are quite different).
Cons of using the NRC Measure:
•
Results in a higher poverty rate (although the trends over time are similar.)
Pros ofBenchmarking:
•
May provide an easier transition to the new methodology because there will not be a
change in the overall level of poverty. Critics, of course, will still charge that this level
is arbitrary.
•
Focuses the arguments on the relative distribution of who is poor rather than how many
people are poor.
Cons of Benchmarking:
•
Violates the NRC recommendation that the threshold should be based on the 30th-35th
percentile in the expenditure distribution. In order to benchmark, the threshold falls to
(about) the 25th percentile of expenditures on food, shelter, and clothing.
2. Updating the thresholds over time
Currently the poverty threshold is updated annually using the CPI_U. This, however, does not
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 9
allow for adjustments that reflect changes in underlying consumption patterns that might affect
the revised thresholds. For instance, food prices have decreased relative to other goods over
time, while housing prices have increased. There are two options:
(A) Recalculate the thresholds annually as a share of consumption on food, shelter, and clothing.
(This is recommended by the NRC panel.)
(B) Update the thresholds on a year-to-year basis using a price index (preferably one based only
on food, shelter and clothing). . Implement a regular process (every 5-10 years) of reviewing the
poverty measure and recalculating the thresholds.
Pros ofRe-calculating the Thresholds:
•
Regular recalculation will allow the poverty thresholds to reflect more accurately changes
in consumption patterns and standards ofiiving.
•
Without an expectation that the thresholds will be re-calculated regularly, it may be hard
to update them at all.
Cons ofRe-calculating the Thresholds:
•
Under certain data circumstances, recalculation could move the threshold a large amount
or in an unexpected direction. This might raise substantive and political concerns.
Pros of Updating Using the CP/:
•
Using the NRC methodology, the poverty thresholds are somewhat relative (i.e., they are
affected by changes in the distribution of household expenditures.) As a result, they are
a moving target and do not provide an absolute standard of need. A CPI adjustment
would make it easier to compare poverty from year-to-year against a constant standard.
•
Because consumption patterns and standards of living change slowly, it may be better to
take them into account periodically rather than annually.
•
An update with a CPI for necessities only (food, clothing, and shelter) may capture most
ofthe relevant changes and would make it easier in the short run to understand the
updating procedure.
•
The data may not be good enough for an annual re-calculation of the thresholds.
Cons of Updating Using the CPL
•
Does not follow the NRC recommendations.
•
Needs to be supplemented by a periodic updating and recalculation process that could
prove difficult to implement.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 10
NOTE: The EOP Policy Working Group recommends Option (8).
3. Should thresholds be adjusted for geographic variation.
The NRC panel recommended adjusting the poverty thresholds for cost-of-living differences
across regions and by city size. Following the NRC recommendation, the Census Bureau
proposes to make such adjustments based on housing cost differences (which have much greater
regional/city size variation than food or clothing.)
Pros ofAdjusting for Geographic Variation in Cost ofLiving:
•
Most statisticians and economists agree that such adjustments should be made if data are
available.
•
The Administrative poverty guidelines that currently exist are already adjusted for Alaska
and Hawaii.
Cons ofAdjusting for Geographic Variation in Cost ofLiving:
•
There is no one "right" way to make such adjustments and the issue could be highly
politicized.
•
The data available to make such adjustments are limited and may not be entirely reliable.
•
Implementing such an adjustment in the poverty line threshold could lead to pressure to
provide regional cost adjustments in a wide variety of other government programs, from
Social Security benefits to tax payments.
NOTE: The EOP Policy Working Group recommends against geographic price adjustments.
4. How to account for medical care expenditures.
Since the mid-l 970s, analysts have been concerned that the official poverty rate overstates the
extent of poverty among beneficiaries of Medicare, Medicaid, and private health insurance. At
the same time, the official poverty rate may understate the extent of poverty among populations
with large medical expenditures. Most analysts agree that, in principle, medical care "needs"
should be incorporated into the calculations of the threshold and family resources (i.e., families
with higher medical needs should have higher thresholds; those with more generous medical
benefits should be considered to have more resources; and those who must spend more to
achieve "good health" should have those expenses subtracted from their resources) .. However
we cannot observe a family's medical need. In addition, it is not clear that one can simply
�·'
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 11
impute the cash value of insurance benefits and add this to income; the "extra" benefits received
from insurance to cover expensive medical services do not provide income that can be used for
any other purpose.
To understand the difficulties, consider including medical benefits into the income calculations.
Adding medical benefits to income, without also adjusting the poverty threshold, has the perverse
effect of making sicker individuals appear better off. Other proposals to adjust the poverty
threshold (without also adjusting resources) run into similar problems.
In the end, the NRC panel recommended subtracting all medical out-of-pocket (MOOP)
expenses (including health insurance premiums) from income, without trying to value health
insurance as a part of income or medical need as a part of the thresholds. Hence, family
resources are measured net ofMOOP. Those individuals with good insurance will have few
out- of-pocket medical expenses; those without insurance who face health problems will have
lower measured incomes as they pay more for medical care.
This adjustment accounts for the larger poverty rates using the NRC methodology. For example,
in 1996 the poverty rate was 13.7% using the current methodology; it would have been 1S%
using the NRC methodology, but only l3.2% using the NRC methodology without the medical
expenses adjustment. This adjustment nearly doubles the poverty rate for the elderly, raising it
almost to the rate for children. This adjustment is one of the most controversial ofthe NRC
recommendations.
There is general agreement that ignoring medical care and medical expenses entirely is not a
good idea, particularly given the rapid increase in medical costs in the past 30 years, the extent of
uninsurance among the low-income population, and this Administration's concern with it. In
addition, if we do not adjust for medical care (in some way) now, it may be much harder to do so
in a few years when we will have better data (because the change will be so dramatic it will be
viewed as another big methodology change).
There are three approaches to incorporating medical care and expenses:
(A) Follow the NRC recommendation and subtract MOOP from family resources. This makes
families with unreimbursed medical expenses less well-offthan other families.
(B) MOOP could be added to the thresholds rather than subtracted from resources. (The choice
between options (A) and (B) is a technical decision that Census should address.)
(C) Try to impute the value of health insurance to resources, so those with insurance have higher
resources. Health insurance should then also be imputed into the thresholds.
Pros ofAdjustingfor MOOP (either options (A) or (B)):
•
While not perfect, under the NRC recommended adjustment families with higher
�.7
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
CLOSE HOLD. Page 12
unreimbursed medical expenditures will be "poorer." The NRC recommended
adjustment would also be sensitive to changes in health care financing that would
decrease MOOP and thereby increase disposable income and reduce poverty.
Cons 0/Adjusting/or MOOP (either options (AJ or (BJJ:
•
The data that are currently available are out-of-date (but we should have updated
information available in a more timely fashion within another year.)
•
The NRC recommended approach relies on the controversial assumption that all medical
care expenditures are nondiscretionary. (This concern could be mitigated to some extent
by imposing a cap on the amount of medical expenses.)
Pros 0/Imputing the Value 0/Health Insurance into Resources and Thresholds:
•
Provides a more complete accounting of all medical resources available to a family.
Cons o/Imputing the Value o/Health Insurance into Resources and Thresholds:
•
There is no accepted "correct" way to do this. The data here are probably more
unreliable than the data needed to impute the value of MOOP to families.
•
Many analysts agree with the NRC panel that the value of health insurance is quite
different from (say) the value of food stamps, which are far more fungible. Mixing in
health insurance coverage with economic need causes interpretational and conceptual
problems to a measure of economic need.
•
To date, Census has been following the NRC recommendation. Ifwe asked them to
switch to this approach, it might require substantial additional work and seriously delay
their report.
NOTE: The EOP Policy Working Group recommends that Census incomorate medical care in
some way and recognizes that the Census Bureau of prepared for option (A). However, the
group strongly recommends that Census thoroughly investigate the impact of option (B), and
continue work on other approaches to incomorating medical care and expenditures, such as by
valuing medical health insurance (option (C»).
�,.
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of6
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
CREATOR: Mary L. Smith (
(NOTES MAIL)
CN~Mary
[ OPD 1 )
Smith/OU~OPD/O~EOP
L.
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUN-1998 19:49:00.00
SUBJECT:
Final One-pager for Equal Pay event
TO: Kara Gerhardt (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Kara Gerhardt/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
TO: Amy N. Finkelstein (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Amy
EOP [ WHO 1 )
Finkelstein/OU~CEA/O~EOP @
N.
OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Miguel M. Bustos (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Miguel
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Cecilia
Rouse/OU~OPD/O~EOP @
EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Joshua Silverman (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Joshua Silverman/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Nanda Chitre (
READ: UNKNOWN
M.
E.
CN~Elizabeth
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman (
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed (
READ: UNKNOWN
Bustos/O~OVp @
EOP [ CEA 1 )
CN~Bruce
CN~Nanda
N.
Newman/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
R.
Reed/OU~OPD/O~EOP
Chitre/OU~WHO/O~EOP
TO: Robin Leeds (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Robin Leeds/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
TO: Audrey Choi (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Audrey Choi/O~OVP @
TO: Audrey T. Haynes (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Audrey
TO: Chandler G. Spaulding (
READ: UNKNOWN
TO.: Jonathan Orszag (
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Chandler
[ WHO 1 )
EOP [ WHO 1 )
OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
G.
L.
@ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
EOP [ OPD 1 )
Freedman/OU~OPD/O~EOP @
EOP [ OPD 1 )
EOP [ OPD 1 )
CN~Laura Emmett/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
G.
EOP [ WHO 1 )
Spaulding/OU~WHO/O~EOP
Kagan/OU~OPD/O~EOP @
CN~Melissa
[ OPD 1 )
Haynes/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
T.
CN~Thomas
CN~Elena
CC: Melissa G. Green (
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
@ EOP
CN~Jonathan Orszag/OU~OPD/O~EOP @
TO: Thomas L. Freedman (
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan (
READ: UNKNOWN
@ EOP
EOP [ WHO 1 )
EOP [ WHO 1 )
Green/OU~OPD/O~EOP @
EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 6
This is the final one-pager that Gene has signed off on.
It needs to be
detached to wordperfect in order to see the text box at the top.
Thanks============
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D8)MAIL48798506M.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043EFOF0000010A02010000000205000000202B000000020000204F6D316120CE737FA47C
B40FE0675044CEEF1DB18881681E47A02541791D6F53D8BBAD7FD636FDE4481185ES51A109A31B
1787D3DA3F15C5CF60F8426D05B837E20896CD58BCA3C31ED2603F816CB553B167FF3756D82F97
09AB3 85D814 9FAE81E'1D067 53 3 6CD4 3E6AFBE2ACA2FFB9919F6C5B65341 7 68B9BOE2BD71 7 8E2FE
DOC4A3554E82D13F9BB911281CEOEB1773F383AD8EB4865598191F28D29C1DF07549EF4CAE6BAO
A3299347A24B1DBBF03498831D395FAF97B5EOC072044B13A92D700226AEFC6810EACFB13EF3D3
C866070A462DCEB0588448584E62F56C2B73283AB99A68A86110D96837A09D7C27E4745FDA218E
25DF19F9F1A17EB642B83D81432010E68C198F11225B9635F051645113B606AD67E7F8C303C2AD
9B400BDFAC8413589648D14FBFFC1D157856B1A17E6563855C64B431FB7C887ED1E3B150113183
4D4E58195CD6B545F69BD353AE3402CA068BE5DOBCF3A5DBA2333ASDC6CB0900C1A9F6D674S843
57EC8AA79C7926120F96D7288B7339BA161E281B89DD49D003D3302BD7DF31761AS6147FD7B40B
6084861604D18CBB14457B5D6FB3CFDE7SD83B60C41BEOCB1270CO12DD8D83E44EE420EE09B6F8
AA6C49A3E73362CD1F79C2ADE66DB2FE6716C488B9C944D8CFOC3737DFS6467750F0930177D749
31A4A929B802009300000000000000000000000823010000000B0100000AOAOOOOOOS504000000
4E000000150B0000092S0100000006000000630BOOOOOB300400000028000000690B0000087701
00000040000000910B000008340100000014000000D10B00000802010000000FOOOOOOE50BOOOO
080S0100000008000000F40B0000005S010000003COOOOOOFCOBOO000208010000001201000038
OC000000000000000000000000380C00000944020000003FO.000004AODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00004AOD0000000000000000000000004AODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO0000004AODOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00000000004AOD0000000000000000000000004AODOOOOOOOOOOOO0000000000004AODOOOOOOOO
00000000000000004AOD0000000000000000000000004AODOOOOOO0000000000000000004AODOO
00000000000000000000004AOD0000000000000000000000004AOD000000000000000000000000
4AOD0000000000000000000000004AODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO004AODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000004AOD0000000000000000000000004AODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000004AODOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000000000004AOD0000000000000000000000004AODOOOOOOOOOO000000000000004AODOOOOOO
0000000000000000004AOD0000000000000000000000004AODOOOO09410200000051000000890D
0000081102000000C6000000DAODOOOOOB300300000044000000AOOEOOOOOB3002000000440000
00E40EOOOOOB300200000044000000280FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO0000280F0000094402000000
2F0000006COF000009420S0000001D0000009BOF00000942030000001DOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOO
00000000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOO0000000000000000B80FOOOO
00000000000000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOO0000000000000000000000B8
OFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000B80FOOOOOOOO
0000000000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOO000000000000000000B80FOO
0000000000000000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80F000000000000000000000000
B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOO00000000000000B80FOOOOOO
000000000000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOO00000000000000000000B80F
000000000000000000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB8OFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO0000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOO0000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOO
00000000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOO0000000000000000B80FOOOO
00000000000000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOO0000000000000000000000B8
OFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO,
0000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000B80FOOOOOOOO
0000000000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOO000000000000000000B80FOO
0000000000000000000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80F000000000000000000000000
B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOB80FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000000B80FOOOOOOOOOOOO
�Automated Records Manage~ent System
Hex-Dump ConversIon
THE PRESIDENT CALLS FOR PASSAGE OF EQUAL PAY
LEGISLATION AND RELEASES COUNCIL
OF ECONOMIC ADVISERS' REPORT ON THE WAGE GAP
June 10, 1998
Today the President will commemorate the thirty-fifth anniversary of President Kennedy's
signing of the Equal Pay Act and will urge passage of legislation to strengthen the laws that
prohibit wage discrimination against women. In addition, the President will release a Council of
Economic Advisers' (CEA) report on the gender wage gap, and announce a Department of Labor
report that provides a historical perspective of the wage gap. The President will be joined by Dr.
Dorothy Height, President Emeritus ofthe National Council of Negro Women, who was at the
signing ceremony of the Equal Pay Act in 1963.
Legislation to Improve Enforcement of Wage Discrimination Laws. The President will call
on Congress to pass legislation, introduced by Senator Daschle and Congresswoman DeLauro, to
strengthen laws prohibiting wage discrimination. The highlights of this legislation include:
•
Increased Penalties for the Equal Pay Act (EPA). The legislation adds full compensatory
and punitive damages as remedies, in a,ddition to the liquidated damages and back pay
awards currently available under the EPA. This proposal would put gender-based wage
discrimination on equal footing with wage discrimination based on race or ethnicity, for
which uncapped compensatory and punitive damages are already available.
•
Non-retaliation provision. The bill would prohibit employers from punishing employees
for sharing salary information with their co-workers. Currently, employers are free to
take action against employees who share wage information. Without the ability to learn
about wage disparities, it is difficult for women to evaluate whether there is wage
discrimination.
•
Training, Research, and Pay Equity Award. The Daschle-DeLauro bill provides for
increased training for Equal Employment Opportunity Commission employees on matters
involving the discrimination of wages; research on discrimination in the payment of
wages; and the establishment ofthe "The National Award for Pay Equity in the
Workplace," which will recognize and promote the achievements of employers that
have made strides to eliminate pay disparities.
CEA Report on the Wage Gap. The President will announce a report by the CEA that shows
that a significant gap between the wages of women and men remains today although it has
narrowed substantially since the signing of the Equal Pay Act.
•
Gender Pay Gap Has Closed: Today, Women Earn 75 Cents for Every Dollar Men Earn.
In 1963, the year that the Equal Pay Act was signed, women earned 58 cents for every
dollar men earned. Today, women earn about 75 cents for every dollar men earn -- a
29-percent increase over the 1963 levels. The gender gap has narrowed faster among
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
younger women and among married women with children. And relative to all male
workers, wage gains have been faster for black and white women than for Hispanic
women.
•
Rise in Work Experience And Move To Higher-Paying Jobs Explain Part of Narrowing
of Wage Gap. Over the past 20 years, increases in women's average work experience
and movement into higher-paying occupations have played a major role in increasing
women's pay relative to men's. Changes in family status, in industry structure, and
unionization have also worked to narrow the wage gap, while the rising returns to skills
and increased wage inequality would have, by themselves, widened the pay gap.
•
Much of Gender Gap Is "Unexplained." In the 1980s, about one-third of the gender pay
gap was explained by differences in the skills and experience that women bring to the
labor market and about 28 percent was due to differences in industry, occupation, and
union status among men and women. This leaves over one-third of the gender pay gap
''unexplained'' by factors such as educational attainment, work experience, and
occupational choice.
•
Labor Market Discrimination Persists. The evidence is that labor market discrimination
against women persists. One indirect and rough measure of the extent of discrimination
remaining in the labor market is the ''unexplained'' difference in pay. And academic
studies -- whether looking at pay differences' between men and women in very similar
jobs or by comparing pay to specific measures of productivity -- have consistently found
evidence of ongoing discrimination in the labor market.
Department of Labor Report Provides a Historical Perspective on the Wage Gap. The
President also will announce a Department of Labor report that provides a thirty-five year
perspective on the wage gap. This report focuses on three periods since the signing of the Equal
Pay Act -- 1960-1975, 1975-1985, and 1985-1997 -- and highlights the increased participation of
women in the labor force, the changing occupations of women, and the emergence of more
women-owned businesses.
•
Women's Labor Force Participation Has Increased. Women's labor force participation
rate rose from 37.7 percent in 1960 to almost 60 percent in 1997.
•
Increased Contributions by Women to Family Income. Between 1995 and 1996 alone,
the number of families with two working parents increased by nearly half a million,
making equal pay even more of a family issue. In these years, both parents were
employed in 63.9 percent of married-couple families with children 18 and younger, while
28.2 percent of these families had an employed father and homemaker mother.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[06/05/1998 – 06/09/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 099 - Folder 001
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/17b84712b6ecb8f23ceec123d43cff86.pdf
164f7b8ec2b99331110f34a7e965a8e1
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 098 - FOLDER -010
[05/27/1998-06/04/1998]
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-MAY-1998 09:54:04.00
SUBJECT:
Principal's Meeting on Poverty Measurement
TO: Katherine K. Wallman ( CN=Katherine K. Wallman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald R. Arbuckle ( CN=Donald R. Arbuckle/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: pruggles ( pruggles @ osaspe.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mark A. Wasserman ( CN=Mark A .. wasserman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Paul Bugg ( CN=Paul Bugg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Sally and Elena, after you left the meeting yesterday Joe, Kathy, Pat and
I talked a bit about the principal's meeting.
We are concerned that a
full interagency principal's meeting somewhat violates the request from
the Department of Commerce.
They approached OMB at the beginning of this
process to say, "We're planning to publish some alternative poverty
measures based on the NAS recommendations. Do you (OMB or other policy
people at the WH) have any input you want to give us on those decisions
that involve policy issues as much as statistical issues?"
In short, the
request was a limited request -- not a request to set up a full
interagency working group to give advice to Commerce about what they
should publish.
The working group we established as a result was
explicitly EOP only (this was a very conscious decision) -- with Pat
Ruggles included because of her expertise on program eligibility issues.
Our advice is to call an EOP-only'principals meeting on the issues we
discussed yesterday, including NEC, DPC, OMB, and CEA.
(This can always
be broadened later -- but I think we shouldn't do that without explicitly
going back to the Dept of Commerce to talk with them about the process.)
On the other hand, a broader vetting of these poverty measure changes and
their possible implications with all of the relevant agencies also needs
�Page 2 of2
, ARMS Email System
•
to start immediately.
perhaps at a joint NEC-DPC Principal's meeting
sometime soon, we can do a short briefing on the new "alternative poverty
line" plans of the Census and from there set up a broad Working Group (our
existing policy working group plus whatever agencies want to be involved)
to discuss all of questions about how a new poverty measure might impact
program issues.
Unless I hear otherwise, I'll assume we're heading toward a limited
EOP-only principal's meeting.
I'll be getting an options paper to you for
comments (along with Pat's one-pager on eligibility) within the next
couple of days.
Becky
�~RMS
Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE!TIME:27-MAY-1998 11:16:47.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Meeting -- CANCELLED
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAILARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAILARD C
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings!OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld!O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew!OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. Mendelson!OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith
CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 2 of2
1\RMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD.l
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Gina C. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers!OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ :.UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
[ WHO 1 )
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (WHO)
CC: Sat ish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan!O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor!O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TEXT:
The Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting scheduled for Thursday, May 28 at 2:45
is cancelled
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sonyia Matthews ( CN=Sonyia Matthews/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-MAY-1998 11:26:08.00
SUBJECT:
Bankruptcy Meeting today
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice Veenstra ( CN=Alice Veenstra/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. Carroll/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ophelia D. West ( CN=Ophelia D. West/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The bankruptcy meeting scheduled for 3:00 today has been changed to 4:30
pm room 324.
Sorry for any inconveniences.
Thank'you.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sonyia Matthews ( CN=Sonyia Matthews/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-MAY-1998 13:04:17.00
SUBJECT:
Bankruptcy Meeting today
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice Veenstra ( CN=Alice Veenstra/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. Carroll/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ophelia D. West ( CN=Ophelia D. West/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The bankruptcy meeting has been changed back to its original time 3:00 pm
room 239 today.
Please except our apology for any inconveniences.
Thank
you.
�• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 18
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 28-MAY-1998 15:29:54.00
SUBJECT:
Draft options memo for principal's meeting on poverty measurement
TO: Katherine K. Wallman ( CN=Katherine K. Wallman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan!.OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: pruggles ( pruggles @ osaspe.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Mark A. Wasserman ( CN=Mark A. Wasserman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Richard B. Bavier ( CN=Richard B. Bavier/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cecilia.E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Paul Bugg ( CN=Paul Bugg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Attached is a draft options memo for the upcoming Principal's meeting on
poverty measurement.
Please return your comments to me as soon as
possible.
Thanks.
Becky Blank
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D45]MAIL40804315U.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043700B0000010A02010000000205000000779B00000002000046592509DE08AA3B791A3A
4E2A59B9D38480FE1E6A344897CCC32B2851684DFBA27BAF6A22C5EEAAB605489D9EC71AOC9FDB
5C2DOBD73984607F51A7248348DFB2FA6316AF57ABA4E1DB243502F868CB327A2935ACDE7F1928
D6CC7B90B37B03BEA288E0719169BEB7E6078FF4864526CBAACA96C9785BE5F2A7BF422B9C378C
4A8356FAFC74945270DA3ADF8876CB593C4403596E59E2ABB5F1C32EBEC3502B368C2245B7A1E1
D9806C7824FCB846AC56FC6DOB0382BF89D9AD86FB953AB5B6100CDC829418DF40F256FF2E59AF
FDBEBD522E254B6B9B710D340260C2455119C4B8F70A7D09C041EO35AF478FC9E2F78D24F19768
)
�Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 1
May 27, 1998
DRAFT MEMORANDUM FOR EOP PRINCIPAL'S MEETING
Jack Lew
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Janet Yellen
FROM:
I'
version
EOP Policy Working Group on Poverty Measurement
SUBJECT:
Automated Records M
Hex-Oumn coannage'!1ent System
Advice to the Bureau of the Census
BACKGROUND
In 1992, the Bureau of the Census commissioned the National Research Council of the National
Academy of Sciences (NAS) to establish a panel of experts to recommend improvements in the
measurement of poverty. The final NAS report was issued in 1995. Census has announced that
IT IS planning to release a report in late 1998 or early 1999 providing alternative poverty
measures, based on the NAS recommendations. Near the end of 1997 the Department of
Commerce approached OMB and indicated its willingness to receive any advice that OMB or
other WH policy offices might have regarding policy-related issues that the Bureau of the Census
will face in determining which alternative poverty measures to present. As a result of that
request, an EOP Policy Working Group on Poverty Measurement (composed of CEA, DPC,
NEC, and OMB) was established to review key policy-related questions. The Deputy Assistant
Secretary for Human Services Policy in HHS also attended these meetings because of her
expertise on programs. This memorandum presents a set of options discussed by that group on
topics where the NAS poverty measurement recommendations have major policy ramifications.
(Note that a broader interagency Technical Working Group on Poverty Measurement is also
meeting to consult with Census on statistical issues relating to alternative poverty measures.) It
is important to note that we are merely being asked to give advice to the Bureau of the Census;
what they actually publish is their decision.
The official measure of poverty has remained virtually unchanged for 35 years, despite
substantial changes in family behavior and government policy. For instance, the NAS panel
identified several weaknesses in the current poverty measure:
•
The current poverty measure takes no account of changes in government policy, such as
changes in tax laws (i.e., the expansion of the EITC) or changes in in-kind benefits (i.e.,
Food Stamps).
•
The current measure does not distinguish between the needs of working and non-working
families. In particular, it does not reflect the cost of child care and other work expenses
for working low-income families.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 2
•
The current measure takes no account of medical care costs which vary substantially
across families.
Note that the discussion to date only concerns the alternative measures that Census will publish.
The Statistical Policy Office in OIRA officially issues the regulation that determines what the
"official" poverty measurement methodology will be, while the Office of the ASPE in HHS
officially determines the "guidelines", which are a simplified form of poverty thresholds used by
some programs in the determination of eligibility. The last item for discussion is the process to
explore the possibility of adopting an improved alternative poverty definition as the new
"official" definition and utilizing it in program eligibility decisions. Attachment 1 (from HHS)
. provides a brief review of how program eligibility is (or isn't) tied to poverty line measurement.
The Current Poverty Measure
The methodology by which current poverty thresholds are determined was developed in the early
1960s by Mollie Orshansky, a staff economist at the Social Security Administration. She
developed a set of poverty thresholds that vary with the number of adults, the number of children,
and the age of the family head. These thresholds represent the cost of a minimum diet
multiplied by 3 to allow for non-food expenditures. The multiplier of 3 was chosen because the
average family in 1955 spent one-third of its after-tax income on food. Since the late 1960s, the
thresholds have simply been updated annually to adjust for price inflation.
The NAS Recommendations
In order to understand the NAS panel's recommended revisions, one must understand the basics
of determining poverty. A family is considered poor when their resources fall below a
predetermined poverty line or threshold. Therefore, one must develop a methodology for
estimating family resources and for defining the threshold resource level below which a family is
considered poor.
1.
Defining Family Resources
For purposes of the current poverty calculation, the definition of family resources is cash income.
The NAS recommendations would estimate family resources as:
Family resources
Cash income + Near-money in-kind benefits - Taxes - Child care
costs - Work expenses - Child support payments - Out of pocket
medical care expenditures (including health insurance premiums)
The rationale for subtracting taxes, work and medical expenses from family resources is that
these expenditures are typically not discretionary and reduce the income available to a family for
economic survival.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 3
There is near consensus among researchers that adjusting for near-money in-kind benefits
(primarily food stamps and housing subsidies) and taxes would be an improvement in how
poverty is measured. There is slightly less agreement on whether child care costs, work
expenses, and child support payments should also be deducted because an unknown proportion
of these expenses are likely discretionary. (The NAS proposes to cap the amount of child care
and work expenses that can be subtracted to deal with this problem.) As discussed below, the
adjustment for out-of-pocket medical care expenditures is more controversial.
2.
Defining a Poverty Threshold
A threshold must be determined against which to compare a family's resources .. The NAS panel
recommends basing the threshold on a fraction of expenditures on necessities (food, shelter, and
clothing) plus a little more. Specifically, the NAS panel recommends selecting the 30th to 35th
percentile in the distribution of annual expenditures on food, shelter, and clothing among
families offour (two adults and two children), and then multiplying this expenditure level by
between 1.15 and 1.25. Thresholds for other family sizes and types would be determined by an
equivalency scale calculation.
The NAS recommends adjusting these thresholds to take into account geographic variation in
cost of living, based on differences in housing costs by region and by city-size. It recommends
adjusting them over time by recalculating them from expenditure data on an annual basis.
OPTIONS FOR DISCUSSION
1. Recommendations regarding which alternatives the Bureau of the Census should adopt
to determine the level of the poverty threshold.
The NAS panel acknowledges that the actual level at which the poverty threshold is set (and
hence the final poverty rate) is inherently arbitrary and cannot be determined on the basis of
purely statistical judgements. There are two primary options:
A. The NAS alternative. As described above, the NAS panel recommends establishing a
threshold based on the 30th-35th percentile in the distribution of annual expenditures for a family
of four, with a small multiplier to account for additional small personal expenditures. As
shown in Tables 1 and 2, column 3, this would raise the 1996 poverty rate from 13.7% to 18%,
and increase poverty among all subgroups.
B. Benchmarking. The NAS also provides poverty estimates that benchmark the alternative
poverty rate to equal the old poverty rate in a given year. The Census has done a number of such
benchmarked calculations for 1996, as shown in Tables 1 and 2, column 2. (The report issued
early next year would benchmark to 1997.) Benchmarking would assure that the aggregate
poverty rate is identical for the official and the alternative measure in the benchmark year. But
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 4
the distribution of poverty among subgroups within each measure would differ (see Table 2).
Similarly, both historical and future trends would differ. For instance, the alternative measure is
identical in 1996 but higher in 1991. (The faster fall is largely due to the decline in the EITe.)
Pros of using the NAS measure:
•
Incorporates the recommendations of the NAS panel, based on their judgement from the
best available evidence.
•
Maintains threshold levels that are quite similar to the current thresholds (although they
have a very different interpretation.)
Cons ofusing the NAS Measure:
•
Results in a substantially higher poverty rate (although the trends over time are similar.)
•
Changes the relative poverty share of different groups.
Pros of Benchmarking:
•
May provide an easier transition to the new methodology because there will not be a
change in the overall level of poverty.
•
Focuses the arguments on the relative distribution of who is poor rather than how many
people are poor. Proposed changes in the relative well-being of different groups may be
more defensible than proposed changes in the levels of poverty.
Cons ofBenchmarking:
•
Violates the NAS recommendation that the threshold should be based on the 30th-35th
percentile in the expenditure distribution. In order to benchmark, the threshold falls to
(about) the 25th percentile of expenditures on food, shelter, and clothing.
2_ Recommendations regarding updating the thresholds over time
Currently the poverty threshold is updated annually using the CPI. This, however, does not
allow for adjustments that reflect changes in underlying consumption patterns that might affect
the revised thresholds. For instance, food prices have decreased relative to other goods over
time, while housing prices have increased. There are two options:
(A) Recalculate the thresholds annually as a share of consumption on food, shelter, and clothing.
(This is recommended by the NAS panel.)
(B) Update the thresholds on a year-to-year basis using a price index (preferably one based only
on food, shelter and clothing). Implement a regular process (every 5-1 0 years) of reviewing the
poverty measure and recalculating the thresholds.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 5
NOTE: The deputies recommend Option (B).
Pros ofRe-calculating the Thresholds:
•
Regular recalculation will allow the poverty thresholds to more accurately reflect changes
in consumption patterns and standards ofliving.
•
Without an expectation that the thresholds will be re-calculated regularly, it may be hard
to update them at all.
Pros of Updating Using the CPI:
•
Using the NAS methodology, the poverty thresholds are somewhat relative (i.e., they are
affected by changes in the distribution of household expenditures.) . As a result, they are
a moving target and do not provide an absolute standard of need. A CPI adjustment
would make it easier to compare poverty from year to year against a constant standard.
•
Because consumption patterns and standards of living change slowly, it may be better to
take them into account periodically rather than annually.
•
If updated with a CPI for necessities only (food, clothing, and shelter), this may capture
most of the relevant changes and will make it easier in the short-run to understand the
updating procedure.
•
The data may not be good enough for an annual re-calculation of the thresholds.
3. Recommendation as to whether thresholds should be adjusted for geographic variation.
The NAS panel recommended adjusting the poverty thresholds for cost-of-living differences
across regions and by city size. Census proposes to make such adjustments based on housing
cost differences (which have much greater regional/city size variation than food or clothing.)
NOTE: The Deputies recommend against geographic price adjustments.
Pros ofAdjusting for Geographic Variation in Cost ofLiving:
•
Most statisticians and economists agree that such adjustments should be made if data are
available.
Cons ofAdjustingfor Geographic Variation in Cost ofLiving:
•
There is no one "right" way to make such adjustments and legislators could try to
intervene on exactly how the "correct" regional price adjustments are done.
•
The data available to make such adjustments are limited and may not be entirely reliable.
•
Implementing such an adjustment in the poverty line threshold could lead to pressure to
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 6
provide regional cost adjustments ih a wide variety of other government programs, from
Social Security benefits to tax payments.
4. Recommendation regarding how to account for medical care expenditures.
Since the mid-1970s, analysts have been concerned that the official poverty rate overstates the
extent of poverty among beneficiaries of Medicare, Medicaid, and private health insurance. At
the same time, the official poverty rate may understate the extent of poverty among populations
with large medical expenditures. Most analysts agree that, in principle, medical care "needs"
should be incorporated into the calculations of the threshold and family resources (i.e., families
with higher medical needs should have higher thresholds; those with more generous medical
benefits should have higher income; and those who must spend more to achieve "good health"
should have those expenses subtracted from their resources). However we cannot observe a
family's medical need. In addition, it is not clear that one can simply impute the cash value of
insurance benefits and add this to income. The "extra" benefits received from insurance to cover
expensive medical services do not provide income that can be used for any other purpose.
To understand the difficulties, consider including medical benefits into the income calculations.
Adding medical benefits to income, without also adjusting the poverty threshold, has the perverse
effect of making sicker individuals appear better off. Other proposals to adjust the poverty
threshold (without also adjusting income), run into similar problems.
In the end, the NAS panel recommended subtracting all medical out-of-pocket (MOOP)
expenses (including health insurance premiums) from income, without trying to value health
insurance as a part of income or medical need as a part of the thresholds. Hence, family
resources are measured net ofMOOP. Those individuals with good insurance will have few
out- of-pocket expenses; those without insurance who face health problems will have lower
measured incomes as they pay more for medical care. (The NAS panel also recommends a
"medical care risk" index be developed, separate from an index of economic need, to measure
how well an individual is protected against medical problems.)
This adjustment accounts for the larger poverty rates using the NAS methodology. For example,
in 1996 the poverty rate was 13.7% using the current methodology; it would have been 18%
using the NAS methodology, but only 13.2% using the NAS methodology minus the medical
expenses adjustment. This adjustment has its largest impact on poverty rates for the elderly and
would have the effect of substantially narrowing the poverty gap between children and the
elderly. This adjustment is one of the most controversial of the NAS recommendations.
There is general agreement that ignoring medical care arid medical expenses entirely is not a
good idea, particularly given the rapid increase in medical costs in the past 30 years and the
extent of uninsurance among the low-income population. Ignoring this issue -- particularly
given this Administration's concern with it -- is not a credible option. There are two other
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 7
alternatives
(A) Follow the NAS recommendations and subtract MOOP from family resources. This makes
families without health insurance who face medical expenses less well-off than other families.
(Note, there is still an open discussion as to whether MOOP should be subtracted from family
resources or added to the thresholds. Either way, it will make little difference in aggregate.
This is clearly a technical decision best left to the Census.)
(B) Try to impute the value of health insurance to income, so those with insurance have higher
resources. Health insurance should then also be imputed into the thresholds.
NOTE: The Deputies recommend option A
Pros 0/Adjusting/or MOOP:
.•
While not perfect, under the NAS recommended adjustment families with higher medical
expenditures will be "poorer." The NAS recommended adjustment would also be
sensitive to changes in health care financing that would increase disposable income and
thereby reduce poverty.
•
If we do not adjust for medical care (in some way) now, it may be much harder to do so in
a few years when we will have better data (because the change will be so dramatic it will
be viewed as another big methodology change).
Cons 0/Adjusting/or MOOP:
•
The data that are currently available are out-of-date, (but we should have updated
information available in a more timely fashion within another year.)
•
The NAS recommended approach relies on the controversial assumption that all medical
care expenditures are nondiscretionary. (This concern could be mitigated to some extent
by imposing a cap on the amount of medical expenses.)
Pros o/Imputing the Value a/Health Insurance into Resources and Thresholds:
•
Provides a more complete accounting of all medical resources available to a family.
Cons a/Imputing the Value a/Health Insurance into Resources and Thresholds:
•
There is no accepted "correct" way to do this. The data here are probably more
unreliable than the data needed to impute the value of MOOP to families.,
•
Many analysts agree with the NAS panel that the value of health insurance is quite
different than (say) the value offood stamps, which are far more fungible. Mixing in
health insurance coverage with economic need causes serious interpretational and
conceptual problems to a measure of economic need.
•
To date, Census has been following the NAS recommendations. Ifwe asked them to
�Automated Records Management i:i
Hex-Dump Conversion ystern
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 8
switch to this approach, it might require substantial additional work and seriously delay
their report.
5. Recommendations regarding which alternatives Census should publish and/or how
they should be presented.
The current plan is to publish a small number (maybe 3) alternatives. For instance, the Census
could publish a 1997-benchmarked poverty rate and a NAS-alternative poverty rate, providing
two alternatives. Or it could publish a 1997-benchmarked poverty rate including all of the NAS
recommendations, and then publish the same thing without MOOP, or without geographical price
variation. (There will be extensive appendices in this report that will report a wide variety of
different poverty calculations, to demonstrate the statistical properties of the poverty
measurement recommended by NAS.)
•
Will it be confusing to publish multiple (even a small number) of alternatives, as opposed
to only one alternative? How will this affect how the report is received? How should
these be presented?
•
What problems will it create to have mUltiple alternatives if at some future point we
want to redefine the official poverty rate to one of these improved alternative measures?
6. Process from here
Among the options to be considered as we move forward from here:
•
Hold a joint DPC-NEC Principal's meeting to brief the broad group of interagency
principals about this process and it's potential implications.
•
An interagency working group should start discussing the implications of alternative
poverty measures on program eligibility.
•
Is there some preparation we should be sure happens on the Hill or among advocacy
groups to prepare people for the upcoming poverty report?
�Automate~e~~5~~~ ~~~~~~~~nt System
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 9
Table 1. Poverty Rates and Thresholds under Alternative Measures, 1991-96, CPS
Official
measure
Benchmarked
to 1996
Poverty Rates
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
14.2
14.8
15.1
14.6
13.8
13.7
14.5
15.3
15.7
14.7
Thresholds for 2 adults
and 2 children (in dollars)
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
13,812
14,228
14,654
15,029
15,455
15,911
11,891
12,249
12,616
12,938
13,305
13,698
NAS
Experimental
18.9
19.6
20.2
19.0
18.2
13.8
13.7 .
18.0
13,891
14,309
14,738
15,115
15,543
16,002
�Automate~e~~6~~~ ~anagement System
onvers/on
.
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 10
Table 2. Poverty Rates under Alternative Measures, 1996, CPS
Official
measure
BenchmarkedNAS
to 1996
Experimental
All persons
13.7
13.7
18.0
Children
Nonelderlyadults
Elderly
20.5
11.4
18.1
1l.5
23.8
15.0
20.4
15.6
10.8
White
Black
Hispanic origin
1l.2
28.4
29.4
11.8
25.2
28.5
15.6
32.0
37.7
One or more workers
9.5
10.0
13.6
Persons in family of type:
Married couple
Female householder
6.9
35.8
7.8
32.3
Geographic regions:
Northeast
Midwest
South
West
12.7
10.7
15.1
15.4
14.3
10.3
14.2
16.1
18.8
13.8
18.3
2l.0
Metro/CC
NotCC
Nonmetro
19.6
9.4
15.9
19.2
10.6
13.5
24.7
14.1
17.5
11.1
40.4
�Automate~ Records Management System
ex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 11
Attachment 1 (from HHS)
Use of the Federal Poverty Guidelines in Determining Program Eligibility and Benefits
The Federal poverty guidelines are a simplified version of the official poverty line thresholds
which are used for program purposes. They are issued by HHS annually, and are based on the
previous year's thresholds.
As Gordon Fisher, the analyst at HHS who oversees the production of the guidelines, notes in a
recent paper:
A number of people believe that the poverty guidelines affect many big entitlement
programs. That belief is an exaggeration of the actual situation. Most of the Federal
programs using the guidelines are medium-sized or small, with only a few big programs.
Moreover, most...are discretionary programs ... Only a few programs using the guidelines
are mandatory: Medicaid, the Food Stamp Program, and child nutrition programs (mainly
the National School Lunch Program.)1
As Fisher notes, spending under discretionary programs, which are appropriated each year, would
not be affected by any change in the guidelines, even if that change affected eligibility for the
program. If eligibility for these programs expands, the appropriated funds are able to serve a
smaller proportion of the eligible population, but total spending does not change. (Most of these
programs already serve only a small fraction of those estimated to be eligible.) Only the three
big mandatory programs Fisher mentions above would have spending changes associated with a
change in the guidelines.
Even within these three programs, the impact of changes in the poverty guidelines is less than
might be expected. In Medicaid, for example, most recipients qualify for coverage because of
their participation in other means-tested programs such as T ANF and SSI--programs that do not
use the poverty line in their eligibility criteria. The major group whose coverage does depend on
the guidelines is children in families below 133% of the poverty line who are not current or
recent TANF recipients. In all, people whose eligibility for Medicaid is somehow related to the
poverty line are estimated to account for about 20 percent of Medicaid recipients. Since most
are in families with incomes well below the specified level, only a small fraction would actually
be affected by a poverty line change.
Impacts in the Food Stamp Program and the National School Lunch Program would probably be
even smaller. The poverty guidelines are used in the Food Stamp Program to set gross income
eligibility--only families with gross incomes below 130% ofthe poverty line are eligible for food
IG. Fisher, "Disseminating the Administrative Version and Explaining the
Administrative and Statistical Versions of the Federal Poverty Measure." Clinical Sociology
Review, vol. 15 (1997), p. 165.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 12
stamps. Actual food stamp benefits are calculated based on net income, however--income after
deductions for work expenses and other items. Net income is compared to a specific benefit
allotment, determined nationally for each family size, and that benefit is reduced by 30 cents for
every dollar of net income the family receives. In practice, the benefit allotment would reach
zero for almost all families long before an income of 130 percent of poverty was reached. Thus,
the gross income eligibility cut-offfor food stamps is more theoretical than real--families at or
near 130% of the poverty line will almost always be eligible only for zero benefits.
The National School Lunch Program has two cut-offs related to the poverty guidelines: Families
with incomes below 130% of poverty are eligible for free lunches, and those below 185% are
eligible for reduced-price lunches. Unlike the Food Stamp and Medicaid Programs, however,
the school lunch program does not collect and verify detailed information on recipients' family
incomes. Instead, families are asked at the beginning of each school year (or when their child
. enters a new school) to fill out a form certifying that their incomes are below the specified level.
Because this process is relatively informal, it seems unlikely that small changes in the level of the
income cut-off would have big impacts on the number of children applying for and receiving free
and reduced-price school lunches. In any case, total spending on the school lunch program--a
significant proportion of which is not means-tested--is much smaller than spending on Medicaid
and food stamps. In 1996 Federal spending on the school lunch program was $5.4 billion,
compared to $25.4 billion for food stamps and almost $92 billion for the Federal share of
Medicaid.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-MAY-1998 18:17:44.00
SUBJECT:
The President's trip to TX/OH
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�., ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU;WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [
READ: UNKNOWN
WHO 1 )
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Tuesday, June 2, 1998, the President will travel to Houston, Texas, to
participate in a roundtable discussion on the Census and attend a DCCC
luncheon.
Later that day, he will fly to Dallas and attend a DNC dinner.
On Wednesday, June 3, the President will travel to Cleveland, Ohio,
participate in a roundtable discussion on national service, deliver
remarks to the City Year convention, and attend a reception for
gubernatorial candidate Lee Fisher.
He will return to Washington on
Wednesday night.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
TX & OH Background Memos:
DUE MON., JUNE 1, AT 4:00 P.M.
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
Political Memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Economic One-Pager
Accomplishments
TX & OH Event Memos:
DUE MON., JUNE 1, AT 6:00 P.M.
Census Roundtable
DCCC Luncheon
DNC Dinner
National Service Roundtable
City Year Convention
Lee Fisher Reception
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�" ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 4
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 1-JUN-1998 15:04:04.00
SUBJECT:
Trip Book Update
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @'EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�.' ARMS Email System
Page 2 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J: Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=BrendaM. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�,. ARMS Email System
Page 3 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN:Jon P. Jennings/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN:Cecily C. Williams/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN:Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN:Christopher Wayne/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN:Michael Waldman/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN:June G. Turner/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN:Michael V. Terrell/OU:CEQ/O:EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN:Jordan Tamagni/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN:Aviva Steinberg/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN:Todd Stern/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN:Joshua Silverman/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN:Laura D. Schwartz/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN:Christa Robinson/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN:John Podesta/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN:Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN:Mary Morrison/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN:Minyon Moore/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN:Megan C. Moloney/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN:Andrew J. Mayock/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN:Joseph P. Lockhart/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�.. ARMS Email System
Page 4 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO.: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
.TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We understand the President will now return to the White House tomorrow
night, before proceeding to Ohio on Wednesday morning. Accordingly, the
Ohio-related briefings for the President's trip book will now be due
tomorrow night at 4:00 p.m. (background) and 6:00 p.m. (event~),
respectively.
Thanks.
�· ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 18
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-JUN-1998 12:17:45.00
SUBJECT:
Poverty Measurement
TO: Donald R. Arbuckle ( CN=Donald R. Arbuckle/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: pruggles ( pruggles @ osaspe.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ:UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Katherine K. Wallman ( CN=Katherine K. Wallman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
CC: Paul Bugg ( CN=Paul Bugg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Richard B. Bavier ( CN=Richard B. Bavier/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mark A. Wasserman ( CN=Mark A. Wasserman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Attached is the latest version of the options paper for the principals.
It now cont"ains a two-page cover memo, with a more extensive background
paper.
I hope we're close to agreement on all of this "- I've tried to
integrate some very different comments into this draft.
Please send any
comments to me ASAP"
As soon as I hear from you that you approve this draft, I'll ask Sally
Katzen's office to schedule a Principal's meeting.
We need to move on
this -- Commerce knows this process is under way and wants to get us in
the room together with Census to talk about these issues very soon.
I
hope we can get this draft approved today, and aim for a Principal's
meeting no later than the beginning of next week.
As soon as a
Principal's meeting is scheduled, I'll schedule a meeting with Commerce a
few days later.
I assume you will all want to be invited to that meeting
with Commerce (Commerce will decide who comes from the Census) .
Note that I've made no changes to Pat's memo on eligibility.
Joe has
promised (threatened?) a set of revisions from his staff, but I haven't
�· ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 18
received them yet.
(I'm not sure that minor details need to be resolved
at this stage about the impact of the poverty thresholds on program
eligibility -- that will be the topic of any further work that goes
forward.
But do send me any potentially major disagreements.)
Becky==================== ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
o
00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D76]MAIL487786356.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750430COA0000010A020100000002050000006A980000000200003059FD1DB8309844BB627C
B6AAF1AE81516 6F1 0 F2 3A5FA9CD5 8 5 F8E6D52 5E81B9818D81C9E24 61B4 6.6 7D7B92 9 9 3ADA1 7 7C3 3
E8030B2D8635D5EFCDBOA10677195074940CA88D6288E7C7589CC9B6CEC30E185A91494C3B5E54
EF996854E773396DBE90FA063628BDA97691DAD8B8311D13EF807582D3DB3EBB4C7A63888782CD
E593FF31865CBD3CCOA8618B6DFE3237635D7F7FDF3DAC30026EA1C6FCC400014B02963A6F52DF
9E461D8359F59BF56F4B4B9540077938B540179FBD7C2DDE15C7AFD3DB4918DE4F88B4B77486D3
7D22BC982811F91EF2CC74FC913F561FA59421FB23CC102623374195604C6DB3125DA16479ADC4
60A55A981F2ECCBA52B57657F7A04822FCDEDBFE92E5D5FA18B15E9B40BDA3E5887EF5B988F2A5
F8F5A30C011B3958A08322DD964697378D1C0656912D85ECECED72B40D33C452A967593771CCA2
BD8BOEA03869BAE99211665ADAEC5DA8FDFCB3145BBOD8351F6AF6CFB6F9FCA749A43B085AE63B
861AB28AC449279E742589CB6DD1782DOF4BCE312E72E18F6C82773F14BA9175F8E30F74DAAEDB
57A2FCBC1B3D569A13DDEA9E84106F0874A196A4F4F7E21604E2032DA143CE61BE9E594E19573B
AF7C5EEA7E4E9CE6FA6C633C3C199A17E9C9C170AF567762D3D95FC29A16DA6889838DBB8891FA
3ABF4300AC02002B00000000000000000000000823010000000B0100005A040000005502000000
4E0000006505000009250100000006000000B30500000B300400000028000000B9050000081601
00000032000000E105000008770100000040000000130600000834010000001400000053060000
0802010000000F000000670600000805010000000800000076060000081001000000020000007E
060000096D010000001700000080060000084D0100000004000000970600000B30020000006COO
00009B0600000B30020000004400000007070000080501000000080000004B0700000B30020000
00440000005307000002080100000076000000970700000055010000004EOOOOOOOD0800000208
01000000460100005B080000000000000000000000005B080000000000000000000000005B0800
00000000000000000000005B080000000000000000000000005B08000000000000000000000000
5B080000000000000000000000005B080000000000000000000000005B08000000000000000000
0000005B080000000000000000000000005B080000000000000000000000005B08000000000000
0000000000005B0800000B30280000004EOOOOOOA109000000000000000000000000A109000000
000000000000000000A109000000000000000000000000A109000000000000000000000000A109
000000000000000000000000A109000000000000000000000000A1090000000000000000000000
00A109000000000000000000000000A10900000000000000000000OOOOA1090000000000000000
00000000A10900000942010000001DOOOOOOEF09000000984C006F00630061006C002000480050
0020004C0061007300650072004A0065007400200034004DOOOOOO000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800C8002C01
2C012C012C01C800C8003000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000B0100002800C8196810480D000011090000005AOOOB0100001036
00540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052006F006DOO61006E002000520065006700
75006C006100720000000000000000000100020058020100000004002800000000000000000000
000000000000000000011202002400A1000000A100000043003AOO5C00500052004F0047005300
5C00570050005C005300540041004E0044004100520044002E0057005000540000000AOOOOOOEA
0601000200EB0601000200EC0601004400ED0602000200EE0601004400EF0601004400F0060100
0200F10601004400F20601000200F306010044000457C324F80501000000200002000000000003
0008337C00780000020000F3060000030100040002000000020002000000000000000000000000
FF551A8BFFOOOOCOCOC001000000010000000400280000001COOOO002800000000000000000000
000133FCDD2400A4000000A4000000DDOA10008301040003000200211000DDDDOBOC0003010000
040COODDE0100C0000000008070COOEOF205F2DAOEOB0003010000OBOODA30DAOFOA000300000A
00DAF305F30100000004002800000003000000190000000000000000000000011323C324009000
000090000000F205F2DAOEOB00030100000BOODA30DAOFOA000300000AOODAF305F30100040002
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 1
June3, 1998
DRAFT BACKGROUND MEMORANDUM FOR EOP PRINCIPAL'S MEETING
Jack Lew
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Janet Yellen
FROM:
EOP Policy Working Group on Income and Poverty Measurement
Subject:
Meeting on Income and Poverty Measures
Purpose of the Meeting
In early 1999, the Census Bureau will publish alternative measures of poverty based on the
proposals contained in the 1995 National Research Council report, Measuring Poverty: A New
Approach. The current official poverty measure dates back to the 1960s, and while it has been
an important contributor to public debate and policymaking, the NRC report reflects a broad
consensus that the measure is out-of-date and in need of revision.
Poverty measurement involves two concepts: (1) A definition of family income; and (2) A
"threshold" against which income is compared to determine if a family is poor. Changes in
these two concepts will have a direct impact on statistics used by the public for informational
purposes. Through the poverty "guidelines" (a simplified form of poverty thresholds, issued by
the Office of the Assistant Secretary for Planning and Evaluation in HHS), a change in poverty
measurement is likely to have indirect effects on Federal programs as well.
Because of the importance of an independent statistical system, the Census Bureau plays the
major role in deciding technical issues regarding poverty measurement. However, because of
the important policy and political implications of the poverty concept, Census has asked for
advice from the EOP (which, through OIRA's Statistical Policy Office, is the statutory arbiter
of the "official" poverty measurement methodology) on their upcoming report. Note, if the
Congress had serious disagreement with the technical decisions made by Census, or saw a policy
or political opportunity, it could pass legislation to remove OIRA's legal authority to change the
official poverty concept. This could tum the concept of poverty into a political football, and
have adverse policy fallout as well.
In response to Census' request, CEA, DPC, NEC, and OMB formed a policy working group.
(Among the agencies, only the Deputy Assistant Secretary for Human Services Policy at HHS
was invited to participate because of her expertise on poverty measurement.) This working
group has held a series of meetings, and prepared the attached memo to outline its tentative
guidance to Census. The meeting ofEOP Principals is intended to review the working group's
conclusions before they are transmitted to Census. It is important to emphasize that we are only
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 2
being asked to give advice to the Bureau of the Census; what they actually publish is their
decision.
There are four global issues to be decided:
I) Should the Census Bureau highlight a single alternative poverty measure, or present several
equally in its forthcoming report? Do the principals have a single preferred measure that they
would like to see replace the current official measure? Would anointing a single measure at this
time be premature, and prejudge the analytical process? Would it raise ire in the Congress? If
we do not anoint a single preferred measure at this time, will it be difficult to select one later
should we want to switch the "official" definition to one of the proposed alternatives?
2) There are also two technical issues (policy options 1 and 4 in the background memo) that
require careful political consideration.
•
Should we advise Census to benchmark the new poverty measure to the old poverty rate
in the current year? What would be the implications of instituting the NAS
recommendations that would result in a significally higher poverty rate?
•
If there is only one measure reported by Census, the Deputies believe that measure should
account for differences in medical out-of-pocket (MOOP) expenditures among
households in the way recommended by the NAS, namely, subtracting them from income
before a family's poverty status is calculated. Ifwe believe that several measures should
be equally reported by Census, should one of them account for medical expenditures
using a different methodology?
3) How should the Administration proceed after the Census report is released? Should it
proceed along a specific timetable to replace the current official measure before the end of this
Administration? If so, what process do we need to establish to move forward on this in a timely
fashion? Or, should the Administration proceed more cautiously, letting a consensus build
around a preferred measure among the community of users of poverty statistics, but possibly
endangering the chances that the official measure is ultimately changed?
4) In addition to OMB's designation of the "official" poverty measurement, HHS also issues
administrative poverty guidelines, used in certain program eligibility calculations. If revised
poverty thresholds are adopted as part of a new poverty measure, would the Administration
envisage continuing the old administrative poverty guidelines with some fonn of updating, or
would the guidelines be changed to be consistent with the new threshold measure? If the
guidelines are made consistent, would the Administration envisage programmatic changes to
mitigate the effects on eligibility and spending of switching to the new guidelines?
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 3
TECHNICAL BACKGROUND ON INCOME AND POVERTY MEASURES
The Current Poverty Measure
The methodology by which current poverty thresholds are detennined was developed in the early
1960s by Mollie Orshansky, a staff economist at the Social Security Administration. She
developed a set of poverty thresholds that vary with the number of adults, the number of children,
and the age of the family head. These thresholds represent the cost of a minimum diet
multiplied by 3 to allow for non-food expenditures. The multiplier of 3 was chosen because the
average family in 1955 spent one-third of its after-tax income on food. Since the late 1960s, the
thresholds have simply been updated annually to adjust for price inflation -- i.e., the measure of
poverty has remained virtually unchanged for 35 years, despite substantial changes in family
behavior and govemment policy.
The NAS panel identified several weaknesses in the current poverty measure:
•
The current poverty measure takes no account of changes in taxes (i.e., the expansion of
the EITC) or in in-kind benefits (i.e., Food Stamps).
•
The current measure does not distinguish between the needs of working and non-working
families. In particular, it does not reflect the cost of child care and other work expenses
for working low-income families.
•
The current poverty measure takes noexplicit account of medical care costs, which vary
significantly across families and have increased substantially since the current poverty
measure was developed.
The NAS Recommendations
In order to understand the NAS panel's recommended revisions, one must understand the basics
of determining poverty. A family is considered poor when their resources fall below a
predetermined poverty line or threshold. Therefore, one must develop a methodology for
estimating family resources and for defining the threshold resource level below which a family is
considered poor.
1.
Defining Family Resources
For purposes of the current poverty calculation, the definition of family resources is cash income.
The NAS recommendations would estimate family resources as:
Family resources
Cash income + Near-money in-kind benefits - Taxes - Child care
costs - Work expenses - Child support payments - Out of pocket
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion .
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 4
medical care expenditures (including health insurance premiums)
The rationale for subtracting taxes, work and medical expenses from family resources is that
these expenditures are typically not discretionary and reduce the income available to a family for
economic survival.
There is near consensus among researchers that adjusting for near-money in-kind benefits
(primarily food stamps and housing subsidies) and taxes would be an improvement in how
poverty is measured. There is slightly less agreement on whether child care costs, work
expenses, and child support payments should also be deducted because an unknown proportion
of these expenses is likely discretionary. (The NAS proposes to cap the amount of child care
and work expenses that can be subtracted to deal with this problem.) As discussed below, the
adjustment for out-of-pocket medical care expenditures is more controversial.
2.
Defining a Poverty Threshold
A threshold must be determined against which to compare a family's resources. The NAS panel
recommends basing the threshold on expenditures on "necessities" (food, shelter, and clothing)
plus a little more. Specifically, the NAS panel recommends selecting the 30th to 35th percentile
in the distribution of annual expenditures on food, shelter, and clothing all).ong families of four
(two adults and two children), and then multiplying this expenditure level by between 1.15 and
1.25. Thresholds for other family sizes and types would be determined by an equivalency scale
calculation.
The NAS recommends adjusting these thresholds to take into account geographic variation in
cost of living, based on differences in housing costs by region and by city-size. It also
recommends adjusting the thresholds over time by recalculating them from expenditure data on
an annual basis.
OPTIONS FOR DISCUSSION
1. Recommendations regarding which alternatives the Bureau of the Census should adopt
to determine the level of the poverty threshold.
The NAS panel acknowledges that the actual level at which the poverty threshold is set (and
hence the final poverty rate) is inherently arbitrary and cannot be determined on the basis of
purely statistical judgements. There are two primary options:
A. The NAS alternative. As described above, the NAS panel recommends establishing a
threshold based on the 30th-35th percentile in the distribution of annual expenditures for a family
of four, with a small multiplier to account for additional small personal expenditures. As
shown in Tables 1 and 2, column 3, this would raise the 1996 poverty rate from 13.7% to 18%,
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
.
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 5
and increase poverty among all subgroups.
B. Benchmarking. The NAS panel also considered poverty estimates that benchmark the
alternative poverty rate to equal the old poverty rate in a given year. The Census has done a
number of such benchmarked calculations for 1996, as shown in Tables 1 and 2, column 2.
(The report issued early next year would benchmark to 1997.) Benchmarking would assure that
the aggregate poverty rate is identical for the official and the alternative measure in the
benchmark year. But the distribution of poverty among subgroups within each measure would
differ (see Table 2). Similarly, both historical and future trends would differ. For instance, the
alternative measure is identical in 1996 but higher in 1991. (The faster fall using the alternative
measure is largely due to the expansion in the EITC.)
Pros of using the NAS measure:
•
Incorporates the recommendations of the NAS panel, based on their judgement from the
best available evidence.
•
Generates dollar threshold levels that are quite similar to the current thresholds (although .
the resources to which the thresholds would be compared are quite different).
Cons of using the NAS Measure:
•
Results in a substantially higher poverty rate (although the trends over time are similar.)
Pros ofBenchmarking:
•
May provide an easier transition to the new methodology because there will not be a
change in the overall level of poverty.
•
Focuses the arguments on the relative distribution of who is poor rather than how many
people are poor. (Proposed changes in the relative well-being of different groups may be
more defensible than proposed change sin the total number of poor.)
Cons ofBenchmarking:
•
Violates the NAS recommendation that the threshold should be based on the 30th-35th
percentile in the expenditure distribution. In order to benchmark, the threshold falls to
(about) the 25th percentile of expenditures on food, shelter, and clothing.
The EOP Policy Working Group recommends benchmarking.
2. Recommendations regarding updating the thresholds over time
Currently the poverty threshold is updated annually using the CPI. This, however, does not
allow for adjustments that reflect changes in underlying consumption patterns that might affect
the revised thresholds. For instance, food prices have decreased relative to other goods over
�Automate~ Records Management Systerr
ex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 6
time, while housing prices have increased. There are two options:
(A) Recalculate the thresholds annually as a share of consumption on food, shelter, and clothing.
(This is recommended by the NAS panel.)
(B) Update the thresholds on a year-to-year basis using a price index (preferably one based only
on food, shelter and clothing). Implement a regular process (every 5-10 years) of reviewing the
poverty measure and recalculating the thresholds.
Pros ofRe-calculating the Thresholds:
•
Regular recalculation will allow the poverty thresholds to reflect more accurately changes
in consumption patterns and standards of living.
•
Without an expectation that the thresholds will be re-calculated regularly, it may be hard
to update them at all.
Pros of Updating Using the CPI:
•
Using the NAS methodology, the poverty thresholds are somewhat relative (i.e., they are
affected by changes in the distribution of household expenditures.) As a result, they are
a moving target and do not provide an absolute standard of need. A cpr adjustment
would make it easier to compare poverty from year-to-year against a constant standard.
•
Because consumption patterns and standards of living change slowly, it may be better to
take them into account periodically rather than annually.
•
An update with a CPI for necessities only (food, clothing, and shelter) may capture most
of the relevant changes and would make it easier in the short-run to understand the
updating procedure.
•
The data may not be good enough for an annual re-calculation of the thresholds.
The EOP Policy Working Group recommends Option (B).
3. Recommendation as to whether thresholds should be adjusted for geographic variation.
The NAS panel recommended adjusting the poverty thresholds for cost-of-living differences
across regions and by city size. Census proposes to make such adjustments based on housing
cost differences (which have much greater regional/city size variation than food or clothing.)
Pros ofAdjusting for Geographic Variation in Cost ofLiving:
•
Most statisticians and economists agree that such adjustments should be made if data are
available.
�Automated Records Management Systerr,
Prelimin~eD~~W-~oe:'f~g& HOLD.
Page 7
Cons ofAdjustingfor Geographic Variation in Cost ofLiving:
•
There is no one "right" way to make such adjustments and the issue could be highly
politicized.
•
The data available to make such adjustments are limited and may not be entirely reliable.
•
Implementing such an adjustment in the poverty line threshold could lead to pressure to
provide regional cost adjustments in a wide variety of other government programs, from
Social Security benefits to tax payments.
The EOP Policy Working Group recommends against geographic price adjustments.
4. Recommendation regarding how to account for medical care expenditures.
Since the mid-l 970s, analysts have been concerned that the official poverty rate overstates the
extent of poverty among beneficiaries of Medicare, Medicaid, and private health insurance. At
the same time, the official poverty rate may understate the extent of poverty among populations
with large medical expenditures. Most analysts agree that, in principle, medical care "needs"
should be incorporated into the calculations ofthe threshold and family resources (i.e., families
with higher medical needs should have higher thresholds; those with more generous medical
·benefits should have higher income; and those who must spend more to achieve "good health"
should have those expenses subtracted from their resources). However we cannot observe a
family's medical need. In addition, it is not clear that one can simply impute the cash value of
insurance benefits and add this to income. The "extra" benefits received from insurance to cover
expensive medical services do not provide income that can be used for any other purpose.
To understand the difficulties, consider including medical benefits into the income calculations.
Adding medical benefits to income, without also adjusting the poverty threshold, has the perverse
effect of making sicker individuals appear better off. Other proposals to adjust the poverty
threshold (without also adjusting income) run into similar problems.
In the end, the NAS panel recommended subtracting all medical out-of-pocket (MOOP)
expenses (including health insurance premiums) from income, without trying to value health
insurance as a part of income or medical need as a part of the thresholds .. Hence, family
resources are measured net of MOOP. Those individuals with good insurance will have few
out- of-pocket expenses; those without insurance who face health problems will have lower
measured incomes as they pay more for medical care.
This adjustment accounts for the larger poverty rates using the NAS methodology. For example,
in 1996 the poverty rate was 13.7% using the current methodology; it would have been 18%
using the NAS methodology, but only 13.2% using the NAS methodology minus the medical
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 8
expenses adjustment. This adjustment nearly doubles the poverty rate for the elderly, raising it
almost to the rate for children. This adjustment is one of the most controversial of the NAS
recommendations.
There is general agreement that ignoring medical care and medical expenses entirely is not a
good idea, particularly given the rapid increase in medical costs in the past 30 years and the
extent ofuninsurance among the low-income population. Ignoring this issue -- particularly
given this Administration's concern with it -- is not a credible option. There are two other
alternatives:
(A) Follow the NAS recommendations and subtract MOOP from family resources. This makes
families with unreimbursed medical expenses less well-off than other families. (Note, there is
still an open discussion as to whether MOOP should be subtracted from family resources or
added to the thresholds. Either way, it will make little difference in aggregate. This is clearly a
technical decision that Census should address.)
(B) Try to impute the value of health insurance to income, so those with insurance have higher
resources. Health insurance should then also be imputed into the thresholds.
Pros ofAdjustingfor MOOP:
While not perfect, under the NAS recommended adjustment families with higher
•
unreimbursed medical expenditures will be "poorer." The NAS recommended
adjustment would also be sensitive to changes in health care financing that would
decrease MOOP and thereby increase disposable income and reduce poverty.
•
Ifwe do not adjust for medical care (in some way) now, it may be much harder to do so in
a few years when we will have better data (because the change will be so dramatic it will
be viewed as another big methodology change).
Cons ofAdjustingfor MOOP:
•
The data that are currently available are out-of-date, (but we should have updated
information available in a more timely fashion within another year.)
•
The NAS recommended approach relies on the controversial assumption that all medical
care expenditures are nondiscretionary. (This concern could be mitigated to some extent
by imposing a cap on the amount of medical expenses.)
Pros ofImputing the Value of Health Insurance into Resources and Thresholds:
•
Provides a more complete accounting of all medical resources available to a family.
Cons ofImputing the Value ofHealth Insurance into Resources and Thresholds:
•
There is no accepted "correct" way to do this. The data here are probably more
unreliable than the data needed to impute the value of MOOP to families.
�Automated R d
H econ s Management System
ex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 9
•
Many analysts agree with the NAS panel that the value of health insurance is quite
different than (say) the value of food stamps, which are far more fungible. Mixing in
health insurance coverage with economic need causes serious interpretational and
conceptual problems to a measure of economic need.
•
To date, Census has been following the NAS recommendations. Ifwe asked them to
switch to this approach, it might require substantial additional work and seriously delay
their report.
The EOP Policy Working Group recommends option (A).
5. Recommendations regarding which alternatives Census should publish and/or how
they should be presented.
The current plan is to publish a small number (maybe 3) of alternatives. For instance, the
Census could publish a 1997-benchmarked poverty rate and a NAS-alternative poverty rate,
providing two alternatives. Or it could publish a 1997-benchmarked poverty rate including all
ofthe NAS recommendations, and then publish the same thing without MOOP, or without
geographical price variation. (There will be extensive appendices in this report that will report a
wide variety of different poverty calculations, to demonstrate the 'statistical properties of the
poverty measurement recommended by NAS.)
•
Will it be confusing to publish multiple (even a small number) of alternatives, as opposed
to only one alternative? How will-this affect how the report is received? How should
these be presented?
•
What problems will it create to have multiple alternatives if at some future point we
want to redefine the official poverty rate to one of these improved alternative measures?
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 10
Table 1. Poverty Rates and Thresholds under Alternative Measures, 1991-96, CPS
Official
measure
Benchmarked
to 1996
Poverty Rates
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
14.2
14.8
15.1
14.6
13.8
13.7
14.5
15.3
15.7
14.7
Thresholds for 2 adults
and 2 children (in dollars)
1991
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
13,812
14,228
14,654
15,029
15,455
15,911
11,891
12,249
12,616
12,938
13,305
13,698
NAS
Experimental
18.9
19.6
20.2
19.0
13.8
18.2
18.0
13.7
13,891
14,309
14,738
15,115
15,543
16,002
�Automat~d Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 11
Table 2. Poverty Rates under Alternative Measures, 1996, CPS
Official
measure
BenchmarkedNAS
to 1996
Experimental
All persons
13.7
13.7
18.0
Children
Nonelderlyadults
Elderly
20.5
11.4
18.1
11.5
23.8
15.0
15.6
10.8
20.4
White
Black
Hispanic origin
11.2
28.4
29.4
11.8
25.2
28.5
15.6
32.0
37.7
One or more workers
9.5
10.0
13.6
Persons in family of type:
Married couple
Female householder
6.9
35.8
7.8
32.3
Geographic regions:
Northeast
Midwest
South
West
12.7
10.7
15.1
15.4
14.3
10.3
14.2
16.1
18.8
13.8
18.3
21.0
Metro/CC
NotCC
Nonmetro
19.6
9.4
15.9
19.2
24.7
14.1
17.5
10.6
13.5
11.1
40.4
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 12·
Attachment 1 (from HHS)
Use of the Federal Poverty Guidelines in Determining Program Eligibility and Benefits
The Federal poverty guidelines are a simplified version of the official poverty line thresholds
which are used for program purposes. They are issued by HHS annually, and are based on the
previous year's thresholds .
. As Gordon Fisher, the analyst at HHS who oversees the production of the guidelines, notes in a
recent paper:
A number of people believe that the poverty guidelines affect many big entitlement
programs. That belief is an exaggeration of the actual situation. Most of the Federal
programs using the guidelines are medium-sized or small, with only a few big programs.
Moreover, most...are discretionary programs ... Only a few programs using the guidelines
are mandatory: Medicaid, the Food Stamp Program, and child nutrition programs (mainly
the National School Lunch Program.)1
As Fisher notes, spending under discretionary programs, which are appropriated each year, would
not be affected by any change in the guidelines, even if that change affected eligibility for the
program. If eligibility for these programs expands, the appropriated funds are able to serve a
smaller proportion of the eligible population, but total spending does not change. (Most of these
programs already serve only a small fraction of those estimated to be eligible.) Only the three
big mandatory programs Fisher mentions above would have spending changes associated with a
change in the guidelines.
Even within these three programs, the impact of changes in the poverty guidelines is less than
might be expected. In Medicaid, for example, most recipients qualify for coverage because of
their participation in other means-tested programs such as TANF and SSI--programs that do not
use the poverty line in their eligibility criteria. The major group whose coverage does depend on
the guidelines is children in families below 133% of the poverty line who are not current or
recent T ANF recipients. In all, people whose eligibility for Medicaid is somehow related to the
poverty line are estimated to account for about 20 percent of Medicaid recipients. Since most
are in families with incomes well below the specified level, only a small fraction would actually
be affected by a poverty line change.
Impacts in the Food Stamp Program arid the National School Lunch Program would probably be
even smaller. The poverty guidelines are used in the Food Stamp Program to set gross income
eligibility--only families with gross incomes below 130% ofthe poverty line are eligible for food
IG. Fisher, "Disseminating the Administrative Version and Explaining the
Administrative and Statistical Versions of the Federal Poverty Measure." Clinical Sociology
Review, vol. 15 (1997), p. 165.
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
Preliminary Draft -- CLOSE HOLD. Page 13
stamps. Actual food stamp benefits are calculated based on net income, however--income after
deductions for work expenses and other items. Net income is compared to a specific benefit
allotment, determined nationally for each family size, and that benefit is reduced by 30 cents for
every dollar of net income the family receives. In practice, the benefit allotment would reach
zero for almost all families long before an income of 130 percent of poverty was reached. Thus,
the gross income eligibility cut-offfor food stamps is more theoretical than real--families at or
near 130% of the poverty line will almost always be eligible only for zero benefits.
The National S~hool Lunch Program has two cut-offs related to the poverty guidelines: Families
with incomes below 130% of poverty are eligible for free lunches, and those below 185% are
eligible for reduced-price lunches. Unlike the Food Stamp and Medicaid Programs, however,
the school lunch program does not collect and verify detailed information on recipients' family
incomes. Instead, families are asked at the beginning of each school year (or when their child
enters a new school) to fill out a form certifying that their incomes are below the specified level.
Because this process is relatively informal, it seems unlikely that small changes in the level of the
income cut-off would have big impacts on the number of children applying for and receiving free
and reduced-price school lunches. In any case, total spending on the school lunch program--a
significant proportion of which is not means-tested--is much smaller than spending on Medicaid
and food stamps. In 1996 Federal spending on the school lunch program was $5.4 billion,
compared to $25.4 billion for food stamps and almost $92 billion for the Federal share of
Medicaid.
�.• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-JUN-1998 16:41:40.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to MA
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasguil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasguil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )"
�" ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K.
READ: UNKNOWN
~hang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @
EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 3 of5
, ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: 'Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
�Page 4 of5
· ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
- TO: Nancy V . Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda I I I ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Friday, JuneS, 1998, the President will travel to Boston,
Massachusetts, to deliver the commencement address at M.I.T.; tour the
Thoreau Institute; participate in a live video discussion with high schoolstudents; make remarks commemorating the Thoreau Institute's opening; and
tape the radio address. Deadlines for the President's trip book are as
follows:
Background Memos:
Political Memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
DUE THUR., JUNE 4, AT 4: 00 P. M.
�.' ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
Economic One-Pager
Accomplishments
Event Memos:
DUE THUR., JUNE 4, AT 6:00 P.M.
MIT Speech
Thoreau Institute Tour, Discussion, and Remarks
Radio Address
Please, call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�..
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-JUN-1998 17:13:31.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Daniel N. Mendelson ( CN=Daniel N. Mendelson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C
READ: UNKNOWN
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=ThomasL. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 2 of2
· ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Gina C. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
@
ustr.gov
@
INET
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1·
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY_MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting is scheduled for Thursday, June 4,
2:45 in Room 211.
�.
Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
+-
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-JUN-1998 19:44:01.00
SUBJECT:
WOMEN'S Mtg
TO: virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha·Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ~ UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [.OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
�,
'1
,.
Page I of5
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 4-JUN-1998 17:01:32.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to NY/CT
TO: Julianne B. Corbett ( CN=Julianne B. Corbett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison
CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�I,
k
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin· ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�, ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 4 of5
" ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Monday, June 8, 1998, the President will travel to New York City to
address the United Nations Special Session on Drugs. He will then proceed
to Westport, Connecticut, to attend a Coordinated Campaign Luncheon and a
Barbara Kennelly Reception.
Returning to New York City, the President
will meet with President Zedillo of Mexico and attend a DCCC Dinner,
before returning to Washington.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
Background Memos:
Political Memo
DUE FRI., JUNE 5, AT 3:00 P.M.
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Economic One-Pager
Accomplishments
Event Memos:
DUE FRI., JUNE 5, AT 5:00 P.M.
UN Special Session (if available)
Coordinated Campaign Luncheon
Kennelly Reception
Zedillo Meeting (if available)
DCCC Dinner
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[05/27/1998 – 06/04/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 098 - Folder 010
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/7a6c36bdb6384571eebd5733f6b67a6c.pdf
dee37e478ebec56a5eaff83af429a26a
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 098 - FOLDER -009
[05/12/1998-05/20/1998]
�"
.
" ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 0f7
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: M. Jill Gibbons ( CN=M. Jill Gibbons/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 12-MAY-1998 12:01:47.00
SUBJECT:
LRM MJG238 - Draft SAP on HR3534 - Mandates Information Act
TO: karen.dorsey ( karen. dorsey @ treas.sprint.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alan B. Rhinesmith ( CN=Alan B. Rhinesmith/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth L. Schwartz ( CN=Kenneth L. Schwartz/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sharon A. Barkeloo ( CN=Sharon A. Barkeloo/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark A. Weatherly ( CN=Mark A. Weatherly/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. Carroll/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Himler ( CN=Janet Himler/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bradley M. Campbell ( CN=Bradley M. Campbell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles M. Brain ( CN=Charles M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Fairweather ( CN=Robert S. Fairweather/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: T J. Glauthier ( CN=T J. Glauthier/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�" ARMS Email System
Page 2 of7
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Konigsberg ( CN=Charles Konigsberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jefferson B. Hill ( CN=Jefferson B. Hill/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Randolph M. Lyon ( CN=Randolph M. Lyon/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Harry E. Moran ( CN=Harry E. Moran/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard P. Emery Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Richard P. Emery Jr./OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
TO: Steven D. Aitken ( CN=Steven D. Aitken/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@S=JMD@7=Deborah@6=CLIFTON@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEMAIL@S=JMD@7=Deb
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Turco ( CN=Kathleen M. Turco/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David E. Tornquist ( CN=David E. Tornquist/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark E. Miller ( CN=Mark E. Miller/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry T. Clendenin ( CN=Barry T. Clendenin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice!OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: william P. Marshall ( CN=William P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Martha Foley ( CN=Martha Foley/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
[ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of7
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald L. Silberman ( CN=Ronald L. Silberman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin F. Neyland ( CN=Kevin F. Neyland/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald M. Cogswell ( CN=Ronald M. Cogswell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles E. Kieffer ( CN=Charles E. Kieffer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald R. Arbuckle ( CN=Donald R. Arbuckle/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Edward M. Rea ( CN=Edward M. Rea/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rosalyn J. Rettman ( CN=Rosalyn J. Rettman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
A hard copy will also be delivered.
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: MJG238
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Tuesday, May 12, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of7
FROM:
OMB CONTACT:
James J. Jukes (for) Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
M. Jill Gibbons
PHONE: (202) 395-7593 FAX: (202) 395-3109
SUBJECT:
Statement of Administration Policy on HR3534 Mandates
Information Act of 1998
DEADLINE:
3:30
Tuesday, May 12, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS:
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
7-AGRICULTURE - Marvin Shapiro - (202) 720-1516
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
19-Council on Environmental Quality - Judy Jablow - (202) 456-6448
30-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
32-ENERGY - Bob Rabben - (202) 586-6718
33-Environmental Protection Agency - John Reeder - (202) 260-5414
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
54-HUD - Jeff Lischer - (202) 708-1793
59-INTERIOR - Jane Lyder - (202) 208-4371
61-JUSTICE - Ann Harkins - (202) 514-2141
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
117 and 340-TRANSPORTATION - Tom Herlihy - (202) 366-4687
l18-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
l28-US Trade Representative - Fred Montgomery - (202) 395-3475
l29-VETERANS AFFAIRS - John H. Thompson - (202) 273-6666
EOP:
Robert G. Damus
Steven D. Aitken
Rosalyn J. Rettman
Richard P. Emery Jr.
Edward M. Rea
Harry E. Moran
Joseph J. Minarik
Randolph M. Lyon
Donald R. Arbuckle
Jefferson B. Hill
Charles E. Kieffer
Charles Konigsberg
Lisa M. Kountoupes
Kate P. Donovan
James C. Murr
T J.. Glauthier
Ronald M. Cogswell
Robert S. Fairweather
Kevin F. Neyland
Richard J. Turman
Ronald L. Silberman
Sally Katzen
Charles R. Marr
�Page 5 of7
ARMS Email System .
Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
Martha Foley
Charles M. Brain
William P. Marshall
Bradley M. Campbell
Elena Kagan
Janet Himler
Laura Emmett
Christopher D. Carroll
Janet R. Forsgren
Joshua Gotbaum
Cynthia A. Rice
Mark A. Weatherly
Barry T. Clendenin
Sherman G. Boone
Mark E. Miller
Thomas L. Freedman
Jerold R. Mande
Christopher C. Jennings
Peter G. Jacoby
LRM ID: MJG238 SuBJECT:
Statement of Administration Policy on HR3534
Mandates Information Act of 1998
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct. line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2). sending us a memo or letter
please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
M. Jill Gibbons Phone:
395-7593
Fax:
395-3109
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
FROM:
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
�ARMS Email System
Page 6 of7
______ No Comment
See proposed edits on pages __________
- - - - - Other:
FAX RETURN of ____ pages, attached to this response sheet===========
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D28]MAIL45390513I.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043D0040000010A020100000002050000005COC000000020000394371C0103B8A8B1CD1DO
149EE54E308567E228B27D97E3DC81115566C7466ED22D1745295AFOC08A8595B4A5541BADCBF1
74DFD61423C96EE66E4897849FA5D291F05F8BB58A824987095F1DE4011BA8C089F2Dl17064EEA
F52COF601F04C94F323CCBA49EC3B4A184C1CAB5407AD32BB80EA27112DDEOC009779AD34E3DB2
E49833F07AD362D69139DOEA229142E5FA013DD84A8E90D3582389FBFC326562EA5A2955960D49
OD418B947BAl15F650D4DF4185878F3C43A55F345E48E2409CE2E52CE492CDF026DA9F1B984D05
86CD0194AE3188B85C28DEA1D287ADE3D5173FC14AD4ED217E10032FO6C8A24AOAD4FDB37C19A1
916E804D40DA0411F1FA46ECCDCB6411687ABCA6F3C58A2ADAE7B9F8423B195A7D4533BE61956C
BBD3FB5E4360A09304D5BFC95DFABOC9129E9377D4398AE1B8B2D973818F8E3AA831A1347689BF
42BE5E4FODCA2F29A7F51683CA7AOD69DBD32E72919871459359EB9A2EA9EDB3086E733A04E5AC
5E6FA28A96D7AF9C73AD93DCD967192EADCD31780EB1F9D16718D7AA2FF4D4761AA32489A4716C
651D6D21924467ADCFC25DFE48C12DD14E158B212CD3FAEC919B50036BCFE928DCAOC0834D10A9
DB571152A7BD98F85D91C6AA9BDA553F22856FD963E19E6CC1630733FD4EBF423CA29B34BBOBF2
246831FB0902000A00000000000000000000000823010000000B0100008C020000005506000000
4E0000009703000009250100000006000000E50300000B300200000028000000EB030000005502
0000004E000000130400000055030000003C00000061040000087701000000100000009D040000
08340100000014000000AD0400000802010000000FOOOOOOC104000000985C005C004F004D0042
002D00500053002D00320038002D00320039005C00370032003200320041000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOO
C800C8002C012C012C012C01C800C8003000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000005EOO~7132800C8196810480D000011090000005AOO
OB010000103600540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E002000
52006500670075006C006100720000000000000000000100020058020100000004002800000000
000000000000000000000000000000011202002400A1000000A10000002800C8196810480DOOOO
11090000005AOOOB01008B143600540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052006F006D
0061006E00200052006500670075006C006100720000000000000000001BOOF41A5C121A090000
0000000000600018110000102400540069006D006500730020004E0065007700000052006F006D
0061006E0000000000000002000000010003001300020001004500OE9AA5240000000000000000
000000000000000008337C007800010200000200000003DDOA10008301040003000200211000DD
DDOBOB00030000040BOODDF1020100F1F20CF2F20EF2D41A1F008701050008005802CCC7000058
02000058020200580200001FOOD44452414654808484804E4F5480464F528052454C45415345F3
OEF3F30CF3D0041500000B00090001B0040000000001201500DOCCD3043000001C0001B0040800
2C0100580200B00400201COOEA2400CB2500D8278B580201B004020000009C58023000D3E0110C
00000000201COCOOE04D61798031322C8031393938CCE0110COOOO0000201COCOOE028486F7573
6529CCF1030100F1F1000200F1F1020100F1CCCCF1030100FIF1010200F1F1020100F1CCCCCCEO
4012000000002COC2COC1400EC131200EOF20CF2F20EF2482E522E80333533348084804D616E64
6174657380496E666F726D6174696F6E80416374806F668031393938F30EF3F30CF388D0041500
000B00090001400B9006070001201500DOF20CF2E0401200000000570E570E1AOOEC131200EOF3
OCF328436F6E6469748028442980434180616E6480393180636F73706F6E736F72732988D00415
00000B00090001300C8007080001201500DOCCD3044200001C0001B00408002C01005802835802
00201COOEA2400CB2500D8278B580201B00408002C0100580200BO0400201COOEA2400CB2500D8
278B58024200D3D41A23008601020008005802CCC7000058020000580205005802CCC726000000
2300D4CCD41AIF008701060008005802CCC7000058020000580202005802CCC71FOOD454686580
�DRAFT -- NOT FOR RELEASE
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
May 12, 1998
(House)
H.R. 3534 - Mandates Information Act of 1998
(Condit (D) CA and 91 cosponsors)
The Administration strongly opposes H.R. 3534. Although the Administration welcomes
the introduction of additional analytical information into the legislative process, there are
concerns that the bill creates an inappropriate procedural obstacle to the enactment of
legislation in the public interest, in particular that which is designed to protect human
health, safety, or the environment.
Further, the amendment added to the bill which would establish a point of order on the use
of revenues could delay or undermine funding for a number of well-established and
important programs and laws which have traditionally received bipartisan support,
including airline air traffic and ground safety, the Superfund program, the Senate-passed
version of the IRS reform bill, and legislation under consideration that provides relief to
tobacco farmers and additional resources for public health programs.
H.R. 3534 also fails to consider the benefits of legislation that protects the public health, the
environment, and the American consumer.
*******
�,;ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Gei'sbert!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE!TIME:13-MAY-1998 08:21:30.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C
READ: UNKNOWN
@
A1
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
@
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone!OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum!OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Emily Bromberg!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Toby Donenfeld
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Toby Donenfeld!O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Jeanne Lambrew
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Jeanne Lambrew!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier!O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande!OU=OSTP!O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 2 of2
'ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
cc:
Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jen~ifer ( haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
@
ustr.gov
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
INET
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
Thursday, May 14
2:45 pm
Room 211
�• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 13-MAY-1998 17:27:13.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/'OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of2
• ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO 1 )
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
�.t>.RMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna ·L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME.: 14-MAY-1998 10: 52: 50.00
SUBJECT:
POSTPONED -- Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD_C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby'Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C
READ: UNKNOWN
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP, [ CEA 1 )
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
)
�ARMS
. Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: ·Gina C. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
@
ustr.gov
@
INET
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CC: Sat ish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This meeting has been rescheduled for Friday, May 15, 2:45 in Room 211.
�• ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 4
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME:14-MAY-1998 10:52:59.00
SUBJECT:
Welfare to Work Formula Plan Update
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maureen H. Walsh ( CN=Maureen H. Walsh/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD ] )
CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
TO: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Anil Kakani ( CN=Anil Kakani/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TEXT:
Here's the latest update of state plans submitted to/approved by DOL.
plans submitted since last update: WA, AK, MD, CT.
====================ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
New
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D53] MAIL41987533X. l26 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043A9050000010A02010000000205000000131B0000000200OOCD7FA4C04735F6F6037B31
20454C7567AD201AF9EF4D11E1FBF6D9EFA753CB181562AECDEFEB448141062262EC3940A8FD2D
OB3E9823A16C50E249AOBF9261C12DDAEEEAAA259A264CCF4E2A88ED4D9316D55C794C37611A56
1DCFE2425BCC0369230COB093FAC53AF3960740BC04432EB7A9794295F9568FB9347D41516DD72
E124E2AF792B439205F580290D2243E1D3D5D6850DCBA8898C663A70314DA324E75A89E1A269BE
F5E038CD5E5CFB409D153D3E4A7596B34600D2ADF6089976BBE62250393321D13BOE9A6E46AD4B
lAD313C667B61B442EC746FCC172DEOB575CFE49926E14E474DEF4D1582FF9A6E1CBC386487A12
IDA6BBA7D37BOD1739987340173206095CC60314362F538A1A34DE6F80594B8631BE3390B18066
53265DD4F03A896E5F63863CF127A22869C7746B23B13DA2D96A50A885A16EOCF2F8FD7CC3EA84
2DD3DD72891EF237617EA80E5B10504C7D2COE9A6277D64764AA62E3449CACC0236B26417A36B6
4CB93F60D4B3C6AA904E444CF7ED299C6B9CODCCOEA24F414432D87AEF007EF14DBE79C25F938C
80855F7BE8B732B338F9A4210F8F76CB94B770545F9F2EDEFA05FDF6CBC1CDBC598996D6D1EC62
�Welfare-to-Work Formula Grant Status
5 States announced 1/29/98:
2 States announced 2/19:
3 States announced 3/2:
2 States announced 3/30:
1State announced 4/10?:
3 States announced 4/28-4/29
1 State announced 5/1
IL, LA,MI,NE,NV
MA,SC
KA,HI,MN
MO,TN
KY
AR, AL, DE
GA
$122 M
$33 M
$26 M
$40 M
$18 M
$19 M
$28 M
TOTAL TO DATE: 17 states (31% of states)
$287 M
States with pending plans:
CA
RI
MT
CO
NC
WI
FL
OK
VT
OR
IN
WV
PR
WA
AK
CT
MD
$190.4M
$4.4 M
$3.2 M
$9.9 M
$25.3 M
$12.9 M
$50.8 M
$11.7 M
$2.8 M
$8.6 M
$14.6 M
$9.8 M
$34.6 M·
$22.7 M
$2.9 M
$12.0 M
$14.9 M
TOTAL PENDING: 17 states (31% of states)
$432M
6 States indicate they don't plan to apply (11 %):
10, UT, OH, SO, WY, MS (DOL discussing further)
$71 M (6% of $)
TRIBAL PLANS
26 approved 3/19 .
33 approved 4/1
13 approved 5/1
$5.8 M
$4.4 M
$1.0 M
TOTAL TO DATE: 72
$11.2M
As of 5/14/98
(26% of $)
(39% of $)
�~
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE!TIME:13-MAY-1998 08:21:30.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_ C ( MARR C
READ: UNKNOWN
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone!OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum!OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone!OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld!O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew!OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier!O=OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C @ Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande!OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
[ OPD 1
�• ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: MURRAY_MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
@
ustr.gov
@
INET
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. Pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
Thursday, May 14
2: 45 pm
Room 211
�• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 13-MAY-1998 17:27:13.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia. F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN .
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of2
• ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN;Susan M. Liss/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN;Ellen M. Lovell/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN;Miriam H. Vogel/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN;Francine P. Obermiller/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Noa A. Meyer ( CN;Noa A. Meyer/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN;Jennifer L. Klein/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
OPD 1 )
CC: June G. Turner ( CN;June G. Turner/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN;Marjorie Tarmey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN;Mindy E. Myers/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN;Tania I. Lopez/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN;Marjorie A. Black/OU;PIR/O;EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN;Mona G. Mohib/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN;Nicole R. Rabner/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN;Laura Emmett/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN;Katharine Button/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
Page I of 2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:14-MAY-1998 10:52:50.00
SUBJECT:
POSTPONED -- Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv. ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C
READ: UNKNOWN
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Gina C. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
haverkamp_jennifer @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
A1
@
CD
@
[ WHO 1 )
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This meeting has been rescheduled for Friday, May 15, 2:45 in Room 211.
�.. ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 4
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 14-MAY-1998 10:52:59.00
SUBJECT:
Welfare to Work Formula Plan Update
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Maureen H. Walsh ( CN=Maureen H. Walsh/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD ] )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anil Kakani ( CN=Anil Kakani/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Here's the latest update of state plans submitted to/approved by DOL.
plans submitted since last update: WA, AK, MD, CT.
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
New
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D53] MAIL41987533X. 126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043A9050000010A02010000000205000000131B000000020000CD7FA4C04735F6F6037B31
20454C7567AD201AF9EF4D11E1FBF6D9EFA753CB181562AECDEFEB448141062262EC3940A8FD2D
OB3E9823A16C50E249AOBF9261C12DDAEEEAAA259A264CCF4E2A88ED4D9316D55C794C37611A56
1DCFE2425BCC0369230COB093FAC53AF3960740BC04432EB7A9794295F9568FB9347D41516DD72
E124E2AF792B439205F580290D2243E1D3D5D6850DCBA8898C663A70314DA324E75A89E1A269BE
F5E038CD5E5CFB409D153D3E4A7596B34600D2ADF6089976BBE62250393321D13BOE9A6E46AD4B
1AD313C667B61B442EC746FCC172DEOB575CFE49926E14E474DEF4D1582FF9A6E1CBC386487A12
1DA6BBA7D37BOD1739987340173206095CC60314362F538A1A34DE6F80594B8631BE3390B18066
53265DD4F03A896E5F63863CF127A22869C7746B23B13DA2D96A50A885A16EOCF2F8FD7CC3EA84
2DD3DD72891EF237617EA80E5B10504C7D2COE9A6277D64764AA62E3449CACC0236B26417A36B6
4CB93F60D4B3C6AA904E444CF7ED299C6B9CODCCOEA24F414432D87AEF007EF14DBE79C25F938C
80855F7BE8B732B338F9A4210F8F76CB94B770545F9F2EDEFAOSFDF6CBC1CDBC598996D6D1EC62
�5 States announced 1/29/98:
2 States announced 2/19:
3 States announced 3/2:
2 States announced 3/30:
1State announced 4/10?:
3 States announced 4/28-4/29
1 State announced 5/1
IL, LA,MI,NE,NV
MA,SC
KA,HI,MN
MO,TN
KY
AR, AL, DE
GA
TOTAL TO DATE: 17 states (31% of states)
States with pending plans:
CA
RI
MT
CO
NC
WI
FL
OK
VT
OR
IN
WV
PR
WA
$122 M
$33 M
$26 M
$40 M
$18 M
$19 M
$28 M
$287 M·
(26% of $)
MD
$190.4M
$4.4 M
$3.2 M
$9.9 M
$25.3 M
$12.9 M
$50.8 M
$11.7 M
$2.8 M
$8.6 M
$14.6 M
$9.8 M
$34.6 M
$22.7 M
$2.9 M .
$12.0 M
$14.9 M
TOTAL PENDING: 17 states (31% of states)
$432 M
6 States indicate they don't plan to apply (11 %):
10, UT, OH, SO, WY, MS (DOL discussing further)
$71 M (6% of $)
TRIBAL PLANS
26 approved 3/19
33 approved 4/1
13 approved 5/1
$5.8 M
$4.4 M
$1.0 M
TOTAL TO DATE: 72
$11.2M
AK
CT
As of 5/14/98
(39% of $)
�'ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of7
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN;Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU;OMB/O;EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 14-MAY-1998 17:05:58.00
SUBJECT:
LRM #IMS328 - Revised LABOR and JUSTICE Report on HR3736 Workforce Improve
TO: John A. Koskinen ( CN;John A. Koskinen/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen J. Balis ( CN=Ellen J. Balis/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN;Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ricardo M. Gonzales ( CN=Ricardo M. Gonzales/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=William P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
REAp: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine M. Tyer ( CN=Katherine M. Tyer/OU=OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Fox ( CN;Charles W. Fox/OU;OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN;Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald L. Silberman ( CN=Ronald L. Silberman/OU;OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�'ARMS Email System
Page 2 of7
TO: Evan T. Farley ( CN=Evan T. Farley/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Charles Konigsberg ( CN=Charles Konigsberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: S. A. Noe ( CN=S. A. Noe/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gregory G. Henry ( CN=Gregory G. Henry/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Jo Siclari ( CN=Mary Jo Siclari/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Louisa Koch ( CN=Louisa Koch/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�'ARMS Email System
Page 3 of7
TO: Joseph G. pipan ( CN=Joseph G. Pipan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Barbara
Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Darlene O. Gaymon ( CN=Darlene O. Gaymon/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
You will not receive a paper copy of this LRM.
Total Pages:
LRM ID: IMS328
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Thursday, May 14, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
James J. Jukes (for) Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
Ingrid M. Schroeder
.
PHONE: (202) 395 - 3883 FAX: (202) 395- 3109
SUBJECT:
Revised LABOR and JUSTICE Report on HR3736 Workforce
Improvement and Protection Act of 1998
FROM:
OMB CONTACT:
DEADLINE:
4:30pm
Friday, May 15, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: An earlier version of the attached letter was originally
circulated on May 11th under LRM #IMS321.
Please note that this version
of the letter contains an Attorney General and Secretary of Labor veto
recommendation.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
62-LABOR - Robert A .. Shapiro -
(202) 219-8201
�'ARMS Email System
Page 4 of 7
61-JUSTICE - Ann Harkins - (202) 514-2141
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
114-STATE - Paul Rademacher - (202) 647-4463
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
128-US Trade Representative - Fred Montgomery - (202) 395-3475
30-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
29-DEFENSE - Samuel T. Brick Jr. - (703) 697-1305
84-National Science Foundation - Lawrence Rudolph - (703) 306-1060
95-0ffice of Science and Technology Policy - Jeff Smith - (202) 456-6047
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer - (202) 395-5084
EOP:
Debra J. Bond
Larry R. Matlack
Barry White
Sandra Yamin
Barbara Chow
Steven M. Mertens
Daniel J. Chenok
Evan T. Farley
Joseph G. Pipan
Ronald L. Silberman
Louisa Koch
Richard J. Turman
Mary Jo Siclari
Charles W. Fox
Gregory G. Henry
Katherine M. Tyer
S. A. Noe
Jack A. Smalligan
Julie A. Fernandes
Elena Kagan
Thomas A. Kalil
Cecilia E. Rouse
Emil E. Parker
Sally Katzen
Gene B. Sperling
Peter G. Jacoby
Janet Murguia
Broderick Johnson
Tracey E. Thornton
Maria Echaveste
Robert N. Weiner
William P. Marshall
Karen Tramontano
Ricardo M. Gonzales
Rebecca M. Blank
Maria J. Hanratty
Kate P. Donovan
Lisa M. Kountoupes
Charles Konigsberg
Ellen J. Balis
James C. Murr
John Koskinen
LRM ID: IMS328 . SUBJECT:
LABOR and JUSTICE
Improvement and Protection Act of 1998
Report on HR3736 Workforce
�Page 5 of7
'ARMS Email System
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Fax:
395- 3109
Ingrid M. Schroeder Phone:
395-3883
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to
the above-captioned subject:·
you~
request for views on
Concur
No Objection
______ No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
______ Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
The Honorable Henry J. Hyde
Chairman
Committee on the Judiciary
U.S. House of Representatives
Washington, D.C.
20515
Dear Chairman Hyde:
Today, your Committee will mark-up H.R. 3736, the O&Workforce
Improvement and Protection Act of 199808 which is intended to address the
growing demand for skilled workers in the information technology (IT)
i~dustry.
H.R. 3736 enacts? temporary increase in the annual cap on the
�"ARMS Email System
number of visas for temporary foreign O&specialty08 workers under the H-1B
program, while also effecting reforms to the H-1B program that would help
target usage of H-1B visas to industries and employers that are actually
experiencing skill shortages.
The Administration believes that the first response for increasing
the availability of skilled workers for industry must be increasing the
skills of u.s. workers and helping the labor market work better to match
employers with u.s. workers. Therefore, additional efforts to increase
the skill level of U.S. workers and needed improvements to the H-1B
program are necessary prerequisites for the Administration to support any
short-term increase in the number of H-1B visas available for temporary
foreign workers.
Modifications to the H-1B program that appropriately
protect u.s. workers are fully consistent with the AdministrationO,s
longstanding support for legal immigration.
We are pleased that H.R. 3736 as reported from the Immigration and
Claims Subcommittee is consistent with one of our primary objectives,
insofar as it links a temporary increase in the H-1B cap to the enactment
of meaningful reforms to the H-1B visa program. H.R. 3736 would help
ensure that U.S. workers do not lose their jobs to temporary foreign
workers and that employers have made serious efforts to recruit u.s.
workers for open positions so that qualified u.s. workers have the
opportunity to fill a job before a temporary foreign worker is hired.
Moreover, H.R. 3736 expands .enforcement authority to help prevent employer
abuses of the H-1B program. These reforms will effectively target H-1B
visas to industries experiencing skill shortages.
Unfortunately, H.R. 3736 does not contain any provision to
encourage additional training of u.s. workers.
Training is a vital
component of our strategy to address the long-term demand for highly
skilled u.s. workers and to enhance the international competitiveness of
important u.s. industries. An effective training strategy would also work
to reduce the demand for H-1B visas. The Administration strongly supports
amending H.R. 3736 to provide for additional training opportunities for
U.S. workers and believes that this training should be funded, in part,
through a modest H-1B application fee paid by employers.
The Administration is also concerned that the increase in the
annual number of H-1B visas reflected in this bill is too large, although
we agree that the increase should last for only three years.
In addition,
the Administration does not support provisions in the bill that would
impose occupation-based restrictions on the first 65,000 H-1B visas.
The Administration believes that the reforms included in H.R. 3736
would substantially improve the current H-1B program.
With the addition
of a meaningful training provision, a modest reduction in the level of
increase in the annual H-1B visa cap, and modifications to make the bill
consistent with u.s. international trade obligations, H.R.3736 would
garner the AdministrationO,s strong support.
However, if amendments are
adopted that substantially weaken the reform or enforcement provisions of·
H.R. 3736 or if meaningful provisions for increasing the skill levels of
u.s. workers are not adopted, the Secretary of Labor and the Attorney
General would recommend that the President veto this legislation.
The Office of Management and Budget advises that there is no
objection to the submission of this report from the standpoint of the
AdministrationO,s program.
Page 6 of 7
�"ARMS Email System
Page 7 of7
Sincerely,
JANET RENO
Attorney General
ALEXIS HERMAN
Secretary of Labor
�· ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 15-MAY-1998 10:13:32.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�• ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Gina c. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY_MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
Friday, May 15
Room 476
2:45pm
�t.
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 15-MAY-1998 11:30:45.00
SUBJECT:
CANCELLED - Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAILARD C @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP@ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_ C ( MARR C @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�(~
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Gina c. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
@
ustr.gov
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
@
INET
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
[ WHO 1 )
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting is cancelled today at 2:45pm.
�• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of4
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 18-MAY-1998 17:47:42.00
SUBJECT:
Heads-up Memo
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael waldman ( CN=Michael
READ: UNKNOWN
Waldman/OU~WHO/O=EOP@EOP
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1·· )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Memo signed Monday, May 18th. ==================== ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
1 ==================
�~
"'
.
MEMORANDUM FOR ERSKINE BOWLES
THROUGH:
Franklin D. Raines
FROM:
Donald R. Arbuckle
SUBJECT:
FDA Proposed Rule on "Off-Label" Uses
We will be concluding review by COB Tuesday of a proposed FDA rule allowing the
dissemination of information on unapproved uses (commonly referred to as "off-label" uses) for
marketed drugs, biologics and medical devices. The proposal implements the off-label
provision of the Food and Drug Modernization Act of 1997 (FDAMA) which permits
manufacturers to disseminate certain written information on the safety, effectiveness, or benefits"
of a product's use that has not yet been approved by FDA. For example, an antibiotic may be
approved by FDA for
use in treating sinus infections but also may be widely used by doctors in treating ear infections -a use not yet approved for that particular drug. The proposal would require that sixty days
before disseminating the information, manufacturers must first submit to FDA for approval a
complete copy of the information and an application seeking approval for the new use.
The proposed rule also sets limits on the types of information that manufacturers can
disseminate: it must be in the form of an unabridged medical journal article and must disclose
that the use has not been cleared by FDA. And, the proposal limits who may receive the
information
doctors and insurance companies, for example, but not individual patients.
This provision was a key Administration concern during FDA reform that was resolved
during the legislative process. The rule adheres closely to that compromise. While it may gain
some attention in the press, we do not expect it to be highly controversial. FDA is anxious to
publish the proposed rule as soon as possible in order to meet a statutory deadline for publication
of a final rule by November 21st of this year.
Please let me know if you have any questions.
�cc:
Maria Echaveste
Rahm Emanuel
Larry Stein
Ron Klain
Thurgood Marshall, Jr.
Ann Lewis
Sally Katzen
Sylvia Mathews
John Podesta
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Elena Kagan
Barry Toiv
Michael Waldman
Janet Yellen
Mickey Ibarra
Danny Mendelson
�, ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 8
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Constance J. Bowers ( CN=Constance J. Bowers/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 18-MAY-1998. 18:02:17.00
SUBJECT:
LRM CJB 221 -- ED Report on HR 3248 (Dollars for the Classroom Act)
TO: Constance J. Bowers ( CN=Constance J. Bowers/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel I. Werfel ( CN=Daniel I. Werfel/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer Brown ( CN=Jennifer Brown/OU=ONDCP/O=EOP@EOP [ ONDCP 1 .)
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Justin D. Sullivan ( CN=Justin D. Sullivan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward M. Rea ( CN=Edward M. Rea/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward W. Correia ( CN=Edward W. Correia/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert M. Shireman ( CN=Robert M. Shireman/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tanya E. Martin ( CN=Tanya E. Martin/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne Upshaw ( CN=Wayne Upshaw/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra;Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
�, ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Winifred Y. Chang ( CN=Winifred Y. Chang/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pamula L. Simms ( CN=Pamula L. Simms/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rosalyn J. Rettman ( CN=Rosalyn J. Rettman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( cN=william P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan { CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Schnur ( CN=Jonathan H. Schnur/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary I. Cassell ( CN=Mary I. Cassell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP .[ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
URGENT:
CLEARANCE REQUESTED BY 3:00 P.M. TUESDAY
In the attached letter, Sec. Riley states he would recommend that the
president veto HR 3248 if it is presented to him. HR 3248, which would
convert ED programs to a block grant, is scheduled to be marked up by the
House Subcommittee on Early Childhood Education on Thursday, May 21st.
please review and provide any comments by 3:00 p.m., Tuesday, May 19th.
Click on ED draft letter:
Click here to access a list of ED programs that would go into the block
grant under HR 3248:
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: CJB221
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Page 2 of8
�, ARMS Email System
Page 3 of8
Washington, D,C, 20503-0001
Monday, May 18, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
SUBJECT:
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Constance J. Bowers
PHONE: (202) 395 - 3803 FAX: (202) 395 - 6148
EDUCATION Report on HR3248 Dollars to the Classroom Act
DEADLINE:
3:00 p.m.
Tuesday, May 19, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President,
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-Yo"u-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: HR 3248 is scheduled to be marked up by the House Subcommittee
on Early Education on Thursday, May 21st.
In this letter, Secretary Riley
states that he would recommend that the President veto HR 3248 if it is
presented to him.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
EOP:
Barbara Chow
Sandra Yamin
Barry White
Wayne Upshaw
Mary I. Cassell
Michael Cohen
Jonathan H. Schnur
Tanya E. Martin
Elena Kagan
Robert M. Shireman
William P. Marshall
Edward W. Correia
Broderick Johnson
Kate P. Donovan
Lisa M. Kountoupes
Robert G. Damus
Rosalyn J. Rettman
Edward M. Rea
Pamula L. Simms
Justin D. Sullivan
Winifred Y. Chang
Jennifer Brown
Daniel J. Chenok
Daniel I. Werfel
Diana Fortuna
Thomas A. Kalil
Sanders D. Korenman
Janet R. Forsgren
�· ARMS Email System
James C. Murr
LRM ID: CJB221
Classroom Act
SUBJECT:
Page 4 of8
EDUCATION
Report on HR3248 Dollars to the
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.' If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to ,leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Constance J. Bowers Phone:
395-3803
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
FROM:
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet===========
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
PRINTER FONT 12 - POINT- COURIER
DRAFT
MAY 18, 1998
1:20 PM
Honorable Frank Riggs
Chairman, Subcommittee on Early Childhood,
�Page 5 of8
· ARMS Email System
Youth, and Families
Committee on Education and the Workforce
United States House of Representatives
Washington, DC 20515
Dear Mr. Chairman:
I am writing to express my strong objections to H.R. 3248, the
"Dollars to the Classroom Act," which would convert a wide array
of Federal education programs to block grants.
The President
stated last fall that such a step is unacceptable, and that he
would use his veto power to prevent this approach from becoming
law.
If H.R. 3248 were presented to the President, I would
recommend that he veto it.
Block grants would halt many of our most successful efforts to
improve education, including our efforts to raise educational
standards, make computers available in every classroom, and keep
our schools safe and free of drugs.
H.R. 3248 could also
seriously harm the ESEA, Title I program, which provides extra
help to low
o
-income students so that they can master the basic
skills of reading and math, paving the way for them to reach high
academic standards.
The American people rightly look to the Federal Government to
focus its efforts not on general aid to school districts, but on
national priorities, such as improving educational opportunities
for poor children and other children with special needs,
combating youth drug abuse and school violence, and researching
and disseminating information on what works.
This Administration
has worked diligently to eliminate unnecessary regulations and
take other steps to promote State and local flexibility in
carrying out these targeted efforts, while supporting strong
accountability mechanisms, such as the Government Performance and
Results Act of 1993, that ensure program effectfveness and
results and that justify continued support by the taxpayers.
Block grants would replace these worthy efforts with general aid,
providing no focus, no accountability for results, and no
rationale for ongoing support.
The issue here is not about who controls public education -- we
all agree that that responsibility rests at the local and State
levels. The question, rather, is whether the Federal Government
will maintain its long
o
-standing, bipartisan commitment to helping
local communities strengthen accountability, raise standards, and
improve student achievement, by providing assistance that focuses
on our neediest children and schools and on activities in which
national leadership can playa critical role.
The Office of Management and Budget advises that there is no
objection to the submission of this report from the standpoint of
the Administration's program and that enactment of H.R. 3248
would not be in accord with the President's program.
Yours sIncerely,
Richard W. Riley
==================
END ATTACHMENT
====================
ATTACHMENT
1
2
==================
====================
�.. ARMS Email System
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
Page 6 of8
o
00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS EXT: [ATTACH.D95] MAIL49747773B. 126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
00001A0002100400000000002900000113001E00010AOOOOOOOOOO0000001F0008000000012F01
0029001F0008000001012F040027000300060001000000010004001C0001010100000001154504
040020202020202020002020202020202000050010000000974B2B000000240000000000000006
0005000000E14A0907000AOOOOOOE14A0048010E030D2100010000OB000100000E002000000000
000000000000000000000000000080FF3FOOOOOOOOOOOOF8FFOB4001000F005600010000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000010000000000000000010000000000000000000004004C000200020042004C004200
00001100B200010000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000010101010101000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000001000EOOOEOOOEOOOOOOOO000000000000007100002B71
00002B7100002BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001B001BOOFOOF08000COOOC
00000000000000002000000000FF417269616C001B001BOOFOOF20OOOCOOOCOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
2000000000FF417269616C001B001BOOFOOF21000COOOCOOOOOOOO000000002001000000FF4172
69616C001B008400E60F1000000110000E0000001221000000000C080000000000000013210000
00000800000000000000001400000000000C080000000000000017000000000008000000000000
00001921000000000408000000000000001A08000000000C08000000000000001B08200000000C
08000000000000001C08000000000000000000000000001B002200E7320100FF0000004E6F726D
616COOOOOCOOOC0000000000556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320200FF0000004E6F726D61
6COOOOOCOOOC0000000000556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320300FF0000004E6F726D616C
00000COOOC0000000000556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320400FF0000004E6F726D616COO
000COOOC0000000000556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320500FF0000004E6F726D616COOOO
OCOOOC0000000000556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320600FF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOC
000C0000000000556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320700FFOO00004E6F726D616COOOOOCOO
OC0000000000556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320800FFOOOO004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOC
0000000000556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320900FFOOOOOO4E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOCOO
00000000556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320AOOFF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOCOOOO
000000556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320BOOFF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOCOOOOOO
0000556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320COOFF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOCOOOOOOOO
00556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320DOOFF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOCOOOOOOOOOO
556E646566696E6564001B002200E7320EOOFF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOC000000000055
6E646566696E6564001B002200E7320FOOFF0000004E6F726D616C00000COOOC0000000000556E
646566696E6564001B002200E7321000000000004E6F726D616COO000COOOC0000000000556E64
6566696E6564001B007100302A0100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000100010000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000102
040110101000001300090000000100FF8004COOl13000C0000000200FF800440FF000540130008
00000203000000020013000C0000000400FF800440FF8006401300OC0000000500FF400640FFCO
064013000C0000000600FFOOOOOOCOC0054013000C0000000700FF000000C00000001300080000
020800000007001300080000020900000008001300080000020AOO000009001300080000020BOO
00000A001300080000020COOOOOOOB001300080000020DOOOOOOOC001300080000020EOOOOOOOD
001300080000020FOOOOOOOE00130008000002100000000F001300080000021100000010001300
080000021200000011001300080000021300000012001300080000021400000013001300080000
021500000014001300080000021600000015001300080000021700000016001300080000021800
000017001300080000021900000018001300080000021A00000019001300080000021B0000001A
001300080000021C0000001B001300080000021D0000001C001300080000021E0000001D001300
080000021F0000001E00130008000002200000001F001300080000022100000020001300080000
022200000021001300080000022300000022001300080000022400000023001300080000022500
0000240013000C0000002700FFC00440C00007401B003400D70700000100C001600002000200CO
01600002000300C001600002000400C001600002000500C001600002002700C001600002001300
OCO 0 00 0 10 0 0 07EO 0 0 0 0 027 0 0 0000160 02B.0 0 0 100 0 0 0 05E4 8 522 03 3 32343 82C2 044 6F6C6C61 7 2 7 3
20746F2074686520436C617373726F6F6D204163740016003900020000005E617320696E74726F
647563656420627920526570726573656E746174697665204A6F73657068205069747473202852
2D5041290018000600040000019COF1600470005000000274465706172746D656E74206F662045
�FOIA Number:
Elena Kagan
Systematic
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management
System [EMAIL]
This is not a presidential record. This is used as an
administrative marker by the William J. Clinton Presidential
Librarv Staff.
Hex Dump file is not in a recognizable format, has been incorrectly
decoded or is damaged.
Attachment Number: [ATTACH.D95]MAlIA97 47773B.l26 to ASCII
�· ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sonyia Matthews ( CN=Sonyia Matthews/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 19-MAY-1998 09:50:33.00
SUBJECT:
Bankruptcy Meeting today
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S .. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice Veenstra ( CN=Alice Veenstra/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. Carroll/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ophelia D. West ( CN=Ophelia D. West/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Sorry for the short notice, Sarah Rosen needs your attendance today at a
12:30 bankruptcy meeting taking place in room 239.
Please RSVP your
attendance bye-mail or by dialing ext. 65351.
Thank you
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ronald E. Jones ( CN=Ronald E. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:19-MAY-1998 12:00:35.00
SUBJECT:
Current (Noon) Bankruptcy SAP
TO: Mark D. Menchik ( CN=Mark D. Menchik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toni S. Hustead ( CN=Toni S. Hustead/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua H. Raymond ( CN=Joshua H. Raymond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melinda D. Haskins ( CN=Melinda D. Haskins/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John S. Radzikowski ( CN=John S. Radzikowski/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pamula L. Simms ( CN=Pamula L. Simms/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas P. Stack ( CN=Thomas P. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark A. Weatherly ( CN=Mark A. Weatherly/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice Veenstra ( CN=Alice Veenstra/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
WHO 1 )
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CEA 1 )
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet E. Irwin ( CN=Janet E. Irwin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gary L. Bennethum ( CN=Gary L. Bennethum/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edwin Lau ( CN=Edwin Lau/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S. Redburn/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen J. Balis ( CN=Ellen J. Balis/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne Upshaw ( CN=Wayne Upshaw/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. Timberlake/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Himler ( CN=Janet Himler/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher D. Carroll
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Christopher D. Carroll/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
OMB 1 )
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
DRAFT --- NOT FOR RELEASE
May 19, 1998
(House)
�ARMS Email System
H.R. 3150 - Bankruptcy Reform Act of 1998
(Gekas (R) Pennsylvania and 75 cosponsors)
The Administration supports bankruptcy reform that requires responsibility
of debtors who have the ability to repay a portion of their debts and
prevents abuse of the bankruptcy system.
However, the Administration
[strongly?] opposes H.R. 3150 One provision of the bill would establish a
rigid and arbitrary means test to determine whether a debtor could file
for bankruptcy under Chapter 7 or would be required to file under Chapter
13 rules.
Bankruptcy courts should have greater discretion to consider
the specific circumstances that brought a debtor to bankruptcy.
H.R. 3150 also would make nondischargeable certain credit card debt.
The
Bankruptcy Code generally makes nondischargeable debts only where there is
an overriding public purpose, as with debts for child support and alimony
payments, educational loans, tax obligations, or debts incurred by fraud.
These credit card debts do not rise to that level of public priority, nor
has there been sufficient finding that current protections against fraud
and debt incurred prior to bankruptcy are ineffective. Moreover, by
making these credit card debts nondischargeable, the bill puts them in
competition with payments to a former spouse or custodial parent after the
debtor leaves bankruptcy, which would diminish the ability of debtors to
fulfill their family obligations. Amendments made during the Judiciary
Committee mark-up do not effectively eliminate this problem.
The Administration looks forward to working with the Congress on a
balanced package of reforms that addresses these concerns and requires
responsibility on the part of both debtors and creditors.
Page 3 of3
�I,
, ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-MAY-1998 09:10:19.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to MD
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�, ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
I(
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps· ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
�Page 3 ofS
· ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Aviva S.teinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN·
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
�, ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP
..
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori'L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Friday, May 22, 1998, the President will travel to Annapolis, Maryland
to deliver this year's commencement address at the U.S. Naval Academy.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
Background Memos:
Political Memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
Economic One-Pager
DUE THUR., MAY 21, AT 6: 00 P. M.
�.. ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
DUE THUR., MAY 21, AT 6:00 P.M.
Event Memo:
Commencement Address
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�· ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 9
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-MAY-1998 14:33:52.00
SUBJECT:
MAY 26-POVERTY MEASUREMENT MEETING
TO: Shannon Mason ( CN=Shannon Mason/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anil Kakani ( CN=Anil Kakani/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine K. Wallman ( CN=Katherine K. Wallman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark A. Wasserman ( CN=Mark A. Wasserman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald R. Arbuckle ( CN=Donald R. Arbuckle/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [,OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul Bugg ( CN=Paul Bugg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ophelia D. west ( CN=Ophelia D. West/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard B. Bavier ( CN=Richard B. Bavier/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 2 of9
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: patricia ruggles ( patricia ruggles @ 690-6562 @ fax [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TEXT:
THIS IS A REMINDER THAT REBECCA BLANK'S NEXT POVERTY MEASUREMENT MEETING
WILL TAKE PLACE ON TUESDAY, MAY 26, 3:30-5:00PM, IN THE OLD EXECUTIVE
OFFICE BUILDING, ROOM 324.
THIS MEETING IS A DEPUTIES DECISION MEETING, AS DESCRIBED ON THE ATTACHED
AGENDA, , AND DR. BLANK URGES EVERYONE TO ATTEND.
==================== ATTACHMENT
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D13]MAIL47180693J.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504370040000010A020100000002050000001841000000020000AF6DF55FOOC4AE4D8EOD78
5BB87D2075CD97A622513B745FC80056A2722F1F2DOFBEOBB6E1038556D6412EC2C8E244F72342
B2EB4C490945B990D4A8F992A6CA9FOE66DBFE1BFOCC576A1437EFC5A8D903F8DA0987COEACE19
B07C8ADOA6FFAC4DED828FF98E13E74FD421E34C72E63142DDCE083621AD0646453A4AC48797A5
D2BD5BEDEE65A2AA6D3033F822288B03E848B28A9154E61BAD01A8EDC779066D90548D2F466099
D25E1817F80FAAC2488CFFC4FA6270C68FA9C540BF214ECD6BA79BC57DF7609EFA94E20F078BDE
7EACCC62760FE4E892B1E87A6F4C9FE4F5A8FC8D7038DODA4D959E75165662F24EA733336B623D
78556783E88EF5018433D2D7776DDE41BE91B5EOAD056BA354BB4B2ABBAA583537C012EDAA6CB5
98CB5E894566CBA6AOCE88719B419EE6C4207BEB3D7EBAC18A138B41DB11A96DBEFCD29147CEOF
7BC782ECFF796ED0122C68D2BD47806E4F3ABOF8A53B4992DFBAACF6F5BD7085F23E7905FE5749
4FB60FA59FD5DF01566B60BE9FC508A8D1659F81CC8B125C597978657EBDA7E35E2B70AOE35A37
EB7711BBBD3B1ECC508FA12880FFA398B9D0548A186761DDA80FODE2B756E3A684F3F40C51546A
2FB81BA8B1922EBOC9C096E5025AC04C07BOAF457EF8E6A191B2EC8328199457C9C736CEC888FB
AE5B650EF802000900000000000000000000000823010000000B0100007E020000005501000000
4E0000008903000009250100000006000000D70300000B300200000028000000DD030000087701
000000400000000504000008340100000014000000450400000802010000000F00000059040000
080501000000080000006804000000984C006F00630061006C0020004800500020004C00610073
0065006A0065007400200035004DOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800C8002C012C012C012C01C800
C80030000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOQOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000B0100002800C8196810480D000011090000005AOOOB010000103600540069006D0065
00730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E00200052006500670075006C0061007200
000000000000000001000200580201000000040028000000000000000000000000000000000000
00011202002400A1000000A10000000A000000400301000200410303000200420302005B004303
010002004403020002004503010045004603010002004703010044004803010002004903010002
00D37D04230000000000000000000000000000000008337C007800000200004903000003010004
0002000000DDOA10008301040003000200211000DDDDOBOB00030000040BOODD9BD2000E000002
00C003B0040EOOD2D2010E00000200C003B0040EOOD2D1000EOOOO0200C003B0040EOOD1DIOIOE
00000200C003B0040EOODIF20CF2CCF30CF3E0300C000000001806OCOOEOEOOOOCOOOOOOOOC003
OCOOEOE0301400000000180618061824180618241400EOEOOOOCOO000000C0030COOEOE0401AOO
000000A80AA80AIIOOEC13L8061824180618241AOOEOF20CF2506F7665727479804D6561737572
656D656E7480506F6C69637980576F726B696E67809C47726F7570F30CF3808484804D61798032
3688D0041500000B00090001B004FOOOOI0001201500DOE0401200000000EC13EC132AOOEC1312
00E088CC546865807072696D61727980707572706F7365806F668074686973806D656574696E67
80697380746F8074727980616E6480726561636880636F6E73656E7375738061726F756E648061
806B657980736574806F6680706F6C696379CF7265636F6D6D656E646174696F6E738072656C61
74656480746F8074686580697373756573806F75728067726F757080686173806265656E806469
7363757373696E67806F766572807468658070617374807468726565806D6F6E7468732E80CF54
6865736580617265807265636F6D6D656E646174696F6E7380746F807468658043656E73757380
�AlJtomated R,
L1
eCOrdsM,
ryex-DlJrn anagern,
'P ConVers' ent 8YSle
Poverty Measurement Policy Working Group -- May 26
IOn
rn
The primary purpose of this meeting is to try and reach consensus around a key set of policy
recommendations related to the issues our group has been discussing over the past three months.
These are recommendations to the Census about how they might present their alternative poverty
measurement calculations. Attached to this agenda is a one-page summary ofthe NAS
recommendations for a new poverty line measure, and a one-page summary of the four policy issues
we've discussed at our last four meetings.
AGENDA
I. Key issues to be discussed
A. How should the thresholds be determined in the first year an alternative measure is published?
To be specific: should the alternative poverty rate be benchmarked in 1997 to be identical to the 1997
official poverty rate or is there an alternative "benchmark" that makes more sense?
(Note: We appear to have a general consensus within the group from our earlier discussions to support
benchmarking the alternative poverty rate to the 1997 official rate.)
B. How should the poverty thresholds be updated over time? Specifically, (1) should they be
adjusted on an annual basis by the overall cpr or by a cpr for food shelter & clothing only and
revisited every 5-10 years for a more complete recalculation; or (2) Should they be completely
recalculated each year as a share of current expenditures on food, clothing, and housing?
(Note: There seemed to be general consensus for the first approach, particularly if a cpr for food,
shelter and clothing was used. OMB seemed reasonably confident that they and Census could
establish a process to assure that poverty measurement is reviewed on a regular basis.)
C. Should the poverty thresholds be adjusted for geographic variations in the cost of living?
(Note: There seemed to be general consensus that any "base" alternative poverty measurement should
not include geographical price variation, although Census may well want to publish an alternative that
includes this as part of the NAS recommendations.)
D. How (if at aU) should the adjustment for Medical out-of-pocket (MOOP) expenditures
occur? Specifically, should the Census follow the NAS recommendations to impute MOOP and
subtract it from individual income before calculating individual poverty status?
(Note: There is more disagreement on this issue than on any other. The three deputies present at our
last meeting generally agreed that the Census should follow the NAS recommendations for now, but
that further work refining these calculations (and considering other alternatives) should go forward.
But some of the staff present at the meeting were in less agreernent.)
E. Do we have any recommendations to Census about how to present their alternative poverty
calculations? Specifically, do we want to recommend they present a primary "base" alternative
poverty calculation (for instance: benchmarked to 1997, updated by the cpr for necessities, without
geographic price variation, and including MOOP), and then a few alternatives (with and without
MOOP, with and without geographic price variation)?
II. Process from here.
�NAS Recommendations on How to Measure Poverty
A poverty measure consists of two pieces: (1) A definition of family resources, and (2) A poverty
threshold against which resources are compared. If resources are below the threshold, a family is
considered poor.
(1) Derming Family Resources
Family resources = Cash income
+ Near money in-kind benefits (food stamps, housing subsidies, school lunch, LIHEAP, etc)
- Taxes
- Child care costs (for families in which there is no nonworking parent, with a cap, and not to
exceed the earnings of the parent with lower earnings)
- Work expenses (a flat amount per week of work)
- Child support payments
- Out of pocket medical care expenditures, including health insurance premiums.
(2) Derming a Poverty Threshold
The threshold should be determined for a family of four (two adults and two children) based on a point
in the distribution of annual expenditures by such families on food, clothing, and shelter, plus a small
multiplier. (This is based on Consumer Expenditure Survey data, probably using a three-year average
to guarantee adequate sample size.) The recommended percentage of annual expenditures is between
30 and 35 percent (i.e., 15 to 20 percentage points below the median); recommended multipliers are
between 1.15 to 1.25.
Thresholds for other family sizes should be determined based on an equivalence scale calculation.
The NAS panel recommends using
Scale value = (A + PKl
where A is the number of adults and K the number of kids. P is the scaling for children (ifP=I, kids
are treated the same as adults); and F is the scaling for family size. The NAS panel recommends
P=0.70 and F in a range of 0.65 to 0.75.
Geographic costs ofliving are taking into account, based on a regional index of housing costs (which
varies by size of metropolitan area and region of country) which is weighted by the share of housing
costs in the expenditure bundle.
Over time, new poverty threshold should be updated by recalculating annual expenditures on the most
recent three years of data, and reapplying these other calculations using the most recent data available
on housing costs.
�Policy Issue 1: Determining the Threshold
Agenda
I. How does the NAS propose to detennine thresholds?
How does this compare to the current poverty line?
2. Comments on the fundamental indetenninancy of the "right" threshold ...
Implies a range of thresholds are viable.
3. Benchmarking a threshold so poverty numbers in a specific year are unchanged.
A. How do this?
B. Why do this?
C. What are the implications of benchmarking?
a. Change history
b. Change who is poor, even if the aggregate number is unchanged
4. What are the alternatives to benchmarking?
NAS recommendations
5.
What are the criticisms ofthese different approaches?
**********************************
Pros of benchmarking:
There may be large political advantages to saying "We want to improve the measure of poverty, but to
show you that we're doing this in a non-political manner, we'll benchmark so there is no change in the
overall aggregate poverty rate in the year we implement this change." There are still those who will be
upset about the changes in the distribution of poverty or in the past history of poverty rates, which will
change (you can benchmark one year only.)
Cons of benchmarking
Backing out a threshold so that the current poverty rate is unchanged produces a threshold that is very
far down in the percentile distribution of expenditures on food, shelter and clothing -- somewhere
around 20-25% rather than the 30-35% range recommended by the NAS.
Pros of using the NAS alternative (which establishes a higher threshold and higher poverty rates)
Utilizes the recommendations of the NAS panel, based on their judgement about the accumulation of
evidence.
Maintains threshold levels that are very similar to the current thresholds (it's not clear how much this
matters given the resource definition has changed.)
Cons of using the NAS alternative
Results in a substantially higher poverty rate, which will draw an great deal of criticism. At the same
time, it has the same problems as benchmarking, in that it also changes history and it changes the
relative poverty share of different groups (although all subgroup poverty rates would go up.)
�Policy Issue 2:
Updating the Poverty Thresholds Over Time
Agenda
1. How have the poverty thresholds been updated?
CPI adjustments
2. What does the NAS recommend?
Recalculating the threshold
3. What are the implications of these different approaches?
Absolute poverty thresholds (current approach)
Relatively-absolutely poverty thresholds (NAS approach)
Relative poverty thresholds
4. What are the alternatives?
A. Adjust with CPI
B. Adjust with CPI but embed a commitment to recalculate thresholds
on a regular basis.
C. Utilize the relatively-absolute (NAS) technique annually
5. What are the criticisms of these different approaches?
*********************************************
Pros of a more relative approach (B or C above):
1. CPI-adjusted thresholds become obsolete over time. As standards ofliving change, so do social
norms.
2. If we don't create the expectation of a regular recalculation/update of the poverty line, we'll end up
in 30 years exactly where we are today, using an outmoded statistic.
3. Ifwe calculate the thresholds relative to some level ofrnedian expenditures on necessities, it is
most consistent if we update in the same way, i.e., with a procedure that changes the thresholds relative
to median expenditures on necessities.
Pros of CPI updating (A or B above):
I. Relative changes create a moving target of poverty. In the short run, one is most interested in
knowing how many people have purchasing power above a pre-set level. If the level changes with
standards ofliving, it's much harder to interpret the poverty statistics.
2. Standard ofliving changes (and social norm changes) occur only very slowly. Better to take them
into account every-so-often, rather than to embed them annually into the poverty rate.
3. Ifwe update with a CPI for necessities only (food, shelter, & clothing), we might capture most of
the relevant changes (since much of the change in expenditures on these items is due to price changes
rather than quantity changes) and have an easier time explaining the short run updating procedure.
�Policy Issue 3: Adjusting for Geographic Variations in Cost of Living4"fO/h
,
Agenda
"18/eel
Ii, "'ecorOj
'i9.t{),,1JJ. 'S 4181}8"
If) Cal} "'i9"'el}/
1. How does the Census propose to do this?
vel3'lO/J 8YSfe",
2. What are the results of such an adjustment?
3. What are the alternatives?
A. Adjust for the official poverty counts, but don't adjust the guidelines
B. Publish an adjustment index for researchers who want to use it, but adjust
neither the official poverty counts nor the guidelines
C. Adjust both the official poverty counts and the guidelines
4. What are the criticisms of these different approaches?
**************************************
Reasons to adjust for geographic variation:
If the poverty thresholds provide a measure of "income needs" they should reflect cost of living
differences across regions. Theoretically, most statisticians/economists agree that such adjustments
should be done if the data is available.
Reasons not to adjust for geographic variation:
Adjustments in the thresholds can lead to a "slippery slope", with advocacy groups arguing that such
price adjustments should be done in a wide variety of program benefit payments as well. This can also
lead to much greater efforts by legislators to intervene in exactly how the "correct" regional price
adjustments are done.
Researchers would not be able to duplicate poverty counts based on geographic price variation because
the detailed geographic information required to calculate these would violate privacy constraints in
some cases.
Tentative consensus among the group:
* If Census decides that they want to publish a poverty count based on thresholds with geographical
price variation, we recommend that such an adjustment not be part of the "base" alternative poverty
count, but one of the alternatives.
* At some point in the future, should we discuss changing the poverty guidelines used for program
purposes, these should not include geographical price variation.
�IiIJ!a a
'Il7 !edR,
Policy Issue 4: Accounting for Medical Out-of-Pocket (MOOP) Expenditures
liek~:~%anage""
Agenda
Onve"'· en! S/f~'
'';10" ""Iel!}
1. How does the NAS propose to deal with MOOP expenditures?
Why do it this way?
2. How does this affect poverty calculations?
3. What are the alternatives?
A. Account for MOOP in the resource count (NAS)
B. Account for MOOP in the thresholds
C. Ignore issue entirely
4. How does this issue interact with our measures and data concerning the broader question of health
and health care coverage?
5. What are the pros and cons of these approaches?
**********************************************
Pros of handling MOOP as recommended by the NAS (subtracting it from income):
* The NAS argues (and some of our group strongly agree) that it is better to remove MOOP from the
income side rather than add it into the threshold side.
* This is the approach that Census has investigated and can implement in a timely fashion.
* The alternative of ignoring MOOP entirely (neither taking account of it in the thresholds nor the
income side) has real credibility problems, given extensive attention to the problems of lack of
insurance and high out-of-pocket medical expenditures.
* Ifwe do this adjustment now, further changes that better take account ofMOOP in the future will
involve relatively small changes to the poverty numbers. If we don't do it now and want to take
account of MOOP in the base alternative in the future, it will involve a major realignment of numbers.
Cons of handling MOOP as recommended by the NAS:
* The data for imputing MOOP is not as recent as we'd like (although this will improve markedly in
the next few years.)
* Ifwe ignore MOOP entirely, benchmarking the poverty rate to the 1997 numbers will allow us to set
the thresholds at a share of expenditures that is closer to the NAS recommendations.
* Some of our group are strongly convinced that it would be better to include MOOP in the thresholds
rather than subtracting it from income, and would like to see this implemented.
�,....
• ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert
( CN=Donna L. Geisbert!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE!TIME:20-MAY-1998 16:5.4:30.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier!O=OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
A1
@
CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice (CN=Cynthia A. Rice!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld!O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C
READ: UNKNOWN
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone!OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum!OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande!OU=OSTP!O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�~
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Gina C. Mooers ( CN=Gina C. Mooers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
ustr.gov
@
INET
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Laura Emmett
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY MM
READ: UNKNOWN
@
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (WHO)
CC: Sat ish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TEXT:
The Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting is cancelled for Thursday, 5/21 at 2:45
�" ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-MAY-1998 17:36:47.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP { WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
WHO 1 )
�'.
• ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[05/12/1998 – 05/20/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 098 - Folder 009
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/7619f32e71ec54967ca83b2bf0c7fc9b.pdf
2e2ee93bd40619f138664c6f24ea514f
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 098 - FOLDER -008
[04/29/1998-05/11/1998]
�4 .
, ARMS Email System
Page 1 of5
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. MaloneyjOU=WHOjO=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:29-APR-1998 10:50:06.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to CAjIL
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip CaplanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=JonathanOrszagjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. AdashekjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel WexlerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. WeaverjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Ann F. WalkerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Beth A. Viola
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Beth A. ViolajOU=CEQjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. ToivjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie TarmeyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. StreettjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. StottjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. SmithjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake SiewertjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. RosenthaljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. ReberjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. PasquiljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. OrszagjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary MorrisonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�· ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C.
READ: UNKNOWN
Molo~ey
( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN;Amy W. Tobe/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN;Jon P. Jennings/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN;Cecily C. Williams/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN;Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN;Christopher Wayne/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman
READ: UNKNOWN
CN;Michael Waldman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: June G. Turner ( CN;June G. Turner/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN;Michael V. Terrell/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN;Jordan Tamagni/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN;Aviva Steinberg/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN;Todd Stern/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN;Joshua Silverman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN;Laura D. Schwartz/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN;Christa Robinson/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN;John Podesta/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN;Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN;Elizabeth R. Newman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN;Kevin S. Moran/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN;Linda L. Moore/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN;Anne E. McGuire/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�.. ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=sylvia M. Mathews!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler!OU=CEQ!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang!OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Friday, May 1st, the President will travel to Northern California where
he will tour the Thurma, Inc. facility, participate in a roundtable
discussion with workers, attend a luncheon with young entrepreneurs, tape
the radio address, and attend a DNC dinner. The President will not have a
public schedule on Saturday, May 2nd or Sunday morning, May 3rd. Sunday
afternoon, the President will travel to Los Angeles, where he will attend
�,.' ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
a DCCC dinner. On Monday, May 4th, the President will attend a climate c
hange event and a breakfast for the California Labor Initiative. He will
then travel to Chicago, Illinois, to attend a DSCC dinner, before
returning to the White House late Monday evening. Deadlines for the
President's trip book are as follows:
CA Background Memos:
DUE THUR., APR. 30, AT 3:00 P.M.
political Memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
Economic One-Pager
CA Friday Event Memos:
DUE THUR., APR. 30, AT 6:00 P.M.
Thurma, Inc. Tour
Roundtable with Workers
Young Entrepreneurs Luncheon
Radio Address
DNC Dinner
IL Background Memos:
DUE FRI., MAY 1, AT 5: 00 P. M.
Political Mem~
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
Economic One-Pager
CA & IL Sunday and Monday Event Memos:
DUE FRI., MAY 1, AT 5:00 P.M.
DCCC Dinner
Climate Change Event
Labor Initiative Breakfast
DSCC Dinner (ILl
please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
�" ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 7
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-APR-1998 13:31:18.00
SUBJECT:
LRM #IMS314 - NEC and DPC Report on HR3736 Workforce Improvement and Prote
TO: ogc_Iegislation
READ: UNKNOWN
ogc_Iegislation @ ed.gov @inet
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Rachel E. Levinson ( CN=Rachel E. Levinson/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm ( lrm @ nsf.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm ( lrm @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: collins~eter@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
collins~eter@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY
[ UNKN
TO: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@5=JMD@7=Deborah@6=Clifton@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEMAIL@5=JMD@7=Deb
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�.. ARMS Email System
Page 2 of7
TO: S. A. Noe ( CN=S. A. Noe/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gregory G. Henry ( CN=Gregory G. Henry/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Jo Siclari ( CN=Mary Jo Siclari/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald L. Silberman ( CN=Ronald L. Silberman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan T. Farley ( CN=Evan T. Farley/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey M. Smith ( CN=Jeffrey M. Smith/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: blue_gloria@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY ( blue_gloria@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: dodlrs ( dodlrs @ osdgc.osd.mil [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: montgomery_fred@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY ( montgomery_fred@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
[
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@3=GOV+TREAS@5=DO@4=MSOl@7=LLR@6=TREASURY@mrx@lngtwy ( l=US@2=TELEM
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: dol-sol-leg ( dol-sol-Ieg @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ricardo M. Gonzales ( CN=Ricardo M. Gonzales/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=William P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles M. Brain ( CN=Charles M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�,. ARMS Email System
Page 3 of7
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN;Janet Murguia/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN;Gene B. Sperling/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN;Cecilia E. Rouse/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O;EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN;Jack A. Smalligan/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine M. Tyer ( CN;Katherine M. Tyer/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Fox ( CN;Charles W. Fox/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Louisa Koch ( CN;Louisa Koch/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph G. Pipan ( CN;Joseph G. pipan/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN;Daniel J. Chenok/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN;Sandra Yamin/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN;Barry White/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 ),
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN;Debra J. Bond/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Darlene O. Gaymon ( CN;Darlene o. Gaymon/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN;James J. Jukes/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
You will not receive a paper copy of this LRM.
Total Pages:
LRM ID: IMS314
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
wednesday, April 29, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
�• ARMS Email System
TO:
Page 4 of7
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
James J. Jukes (for) Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
Ingrid M. Schroeder
PHONE: (202) 395- 3 883 FAX: (202) 395 - 3109
SUBJECT:
NEC and DPC Report on HR3736 Workforce Improvement and
Protection Act of 1998
FROM:
OMB CONTACT:
DEADLINE:
4:30pm
Wednesday, April 29, 1998
-- FIRM
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: The above deadline is FIRM. The House Judiciary immigration
subcommittee is scheduled to markup HR 3736 tomorrow, April 30th.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - Ann Harkins - (202) 514-2141
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
128-US Trade Representative - Fred Montgomery - (202) 395-3475
52-HHS - Sondra S. wallace - (202) 690-7760
29-DEFENSE - Samuel T. Brick Jr. - (703) 697-1305
84-National Science Foundation - Lawrence Rudolph - (703) 306-1060
95-0ffice of Science and Technology Policy - Jeff Smith - (202) 456-6047
114-STATE - Paul Rademacher - (202) 647-4463
30-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer - (202) 395-5084
EOP:
Debra J. Bond
Larry R. Matlack
Barry White
Barbara Chow
Sandra Yamin
Steven M. Mertens
Daniel J. Chenok
Evan T. Farley
Joseph G. pipan
Ronald L. Silberman
Louisa Koch
Mary Jo Siclari
Charles W. Fox
Gregory G. Henry
Katherine M. Tyer
S. A. Noe
Jack A. Smalligan
Julie A. Fernandes
Elena Kagan
Thomas A. Kalil
Cecilia E. Rouse
Sally Katzen
Gene B. Sperling
Peter G. Jacoby
�· ARMS Email System
Janet Murguia
Broderick Johnson
Charles M. Brain
Maria Echaveste
Emil E. Parker
Robert N. Weiner
William P. Marshall
Karen Tramontano
Ricardo M. Gonzales
Rebecca M. Blank
Maria J. Hanratty
James C. Murr
Kate P. Donovan
LRM ID: IMS314 SUByECT:
NEC and DPC
Improvement and Protection Act of 1998
Page 5 of7
Report on HR3736 Workforce
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Ingrid M. Schroeder Phone: 395-3883
Fax:
395-3109
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
�ARMS Email System
FAX RETURN .of _____ pages, attached te this respense sheet
DRAFT -- NOT FOR RELEASE
April 30, 1998
The Henerable Lamar Smith
Chairman
Subcemmittee en Immigratien
Judiciary Cemmittee
u. S. Heuse .of Representatives
washingten, D.C. 20510
Dear Mr. Chairman:
Teday, yeur Subcemmittee will mark-up H.R. 3736, the O&Workforce
Improvement and Protection Act of 199808 which is intended to address the
grewing demand fer skilled werkers in the infermation technelegy (IT)
industry by enacting a temperary increase in the annual cap en the number
of temporary visas for foreign 0&specialty08 workers under the H-1B
pregram, while alse effecting reforms to the H-1B program that would help
target their usage te industries and empleyers that are actually
experiencing skill shortages.
The Administratien believes that the first step in increasing the
availability .of skilled werkers must be raising the skills of u.S. werkers
and helping the laber market werk better te match empleyers with u.S.
workers. Therefore, substantial additienal efferts by industry to
increase the skill level .of u.S. werkers and needed imprevements in the
H-1B visa pregram are necessary prerequisites fer the Administratien te
support any shert-term increases in the number .of visas for temperary
fereign werkers.
We are pleased that H.R. 3736 is censistent with one .of .our
primary objectives, insefar as it cenditiens a temporary increase in the
H-1B cap on the enactment of meaningful reforms te the H-1B visa pregram.
Yeur bill weuld help ensure that no u.S. werker weuld lese their job te a
similarly qualified temperary fereign werker and that every qualified u.S.
werker would have the opportunity te fill a job before a temporary fereign
werker.
Moreever, yeur bill greatly strengthens program requirements and
enforcement te prevent employer abuses .of the H-1B pregram.
Unfortunately, H.R. 3736 dees net centain any previsien for
additienal training eppertunities fer u.S. werkers.
This training is a
vital cempenent of our strategy to address the leng-term demand for highly
skilled u.s. werkers and to enhance the internatienal cempetitiveness of
impertant u.S. industries. An effective training strategy weuld alse work
te lessen the need for more H-1B visas.
We are also cencerned that the
increase reflected in this bill is large and is not, in any event,
targeted to skill shortages being used te justify this change in pel icy
(i.e., advanced degrees or significant practical experience in math,
science, .or engineering).
Fer these reasens, the Administration believes that this
legislatien weuld substantially improve the current H-1B pregram and, with
the additien .of meaningful training strategies and a medest reductien in
the level .of increase in the annual cap, would garner the
AdministrationO,s strong support. We look forward te working with the
Congress en these and ether specific provisions in the bill.
Page 6 of7
�• ARMS Email System
The Office of Management and Budget advises that there is no
objection to the submission of this report from the standpoint of the
AdministrationO,s program.
Sincerely,
Bruce Reed
Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy
Gene B. Sperling
Assistant to the President for Economic Policy
Page 7 of 7
�,
~
.
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-APR-1998 17:41:38.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�"
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer
( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD
1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:
[ WHO 1 )
Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
�Page lof2
" ARMS Email System
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN;Donna L. Geisbert/OU;OPD/O;EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-APR-l998 08:00:28.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN;Cynthia A. Rice/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN;Christopher C. Jennings/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN;Peter R. Orszag/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN;Barry J.Toiv/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN;Barbara D. Woolley/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN;Donald H. Gips/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN;Jeanne Lambrew/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN;Thomas L. Freedman/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN;Peter G. Jacoby/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C
READ: UNKNOWN
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN;Charles F. Stone/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN;Joshua Gotbaum/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN;Sherman G. Boone/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN;Emily Bromberg/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN;Toby Donenfeld/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN;Jerold R. Mande/OU;OSTP/O;EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN;Mary L. Smith/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�•
• ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN;satish Narayanan/O;OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN;Dan J. Taylor/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
haverkamp_jennifer @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN;Laura Emmett/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN;Jill M. Pizzuto/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting is scheduled for today, April 30, at
2:45 in Room 211, OEOB.
�..
"
.
Page 1 of4
. ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ronald E. Jones ( CN=Ronald E. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-APR-1998 13:42:07.00
SUBJECT:
Draft Principles Letter on S1301 Consumer Bankruptcy Reform Act of 1997
TO: Melinda D. Haskins ( CN=Melinda D. Haskins/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John S. Radzikowski ( CN=John S. Radzikowski/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pamula L. Simms ( CN=Pamula L. Simms/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas P. Stack ( CN=Thomas P. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark A. Weatherly ( CN=Mark A. Weatherly/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice Veenstra ( CN=Alice Veenstra/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edwin Lau ( CN=Edwin Lau/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis S. Redburn ( CN=Francis S. Redburn/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 2 of4
· ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen J. Balis ( CN=Ellen J. Balis/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: wayne Upshaw ( CN=Wayne Upshaw/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Courtney B. Timberlake ( CN=Courtney B. Timberlake/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Himler ( CN=Janet Himler/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah Rosen
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa A. Hertzer ( CN=Lisa A. Hertzer/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The following letter was prepared following meetings involving NEC
Principals and Deputies.
Discussions continue on who will sign the
letter.
Please provide comments to me ASAP, but no later than 10:00 AM,
tomorrow, Fraidy, 5/1.
You will receive a hard copy of
DRAFT
Senator Orrin Hatch
Chairman
this request also.
�,. ARMS Email System
Page 3 of4
Senate Judiciary Committee
u.S. Senate
Washington, DC
Dear Mr. Chairman,
I am writing to express the AdministrationD,s general views on consumer
bankruptcy reform proposals currentiy under consideration in the
congress.
Over the past two decades, consumer bankruptcy filings have risen
sharply. While there are many contending theories on the cause of that
increase, it is clear that there is no single explanation. Nonetheless,
the growing number of filings, examples of abuse of Chapter 7 and state
exemptions, and evidence of imprudent extensions of credit suggest some
changes to the consumer bankruptcy laws are appropriate. The lack of
definitive evidence about the reasons for the rise in bankruptcies means
that it is difficult to predict the effect of reform efforts.
The
Administration, therefore, has developed the following set of principles
to guide its review of changes to the consumer bankruptcy laws.
1.
Access to Chapter 7 should not be governed by an arbitrary means
test; the court must have discretion to fairly account for the great
variations in circumstances that bring debtors into bankruptcy (including
medical expenses, unemployment, divorce, responsibility for the care of
others, etc.)
To promote more uniform application of bankruptcy
standards, this determination should take place within indicative or
presumptive guidelines established by Congress that take into account
factors such as the debtorD,s income and ability to repay a portion of the
debt.
2.
National bankruptcy policy can respect state variation in
exemption levels without allowing state exemptions to be used to shield
luxury assets from creditors.
3.
It is appropriate to expect
portion of their debts (taking into
act responsibly; but the bankruptcy
reward those who complete a Chapter
debtors who can afford to repay a
account all relevant circumstances) to
and credit reporting system should
13 plan.
4.
Bankruptcy reform should not create opportunities for creditors to
coerce debtors to forgo bona fide rights in bankruptcy.
5.
Bankruptcy rules should discourage bad faith repeat filings and
other attempts to abuse the privilege accorded by access to bankruptcy.
6.
Child support and alimony payments should be carefully protected.
We must ensure that reforms have no unintended adverse impact on
debtorsD, ability to meet these, and other, priority payments.
7.
Bankruptcy data collection and accuracy must be improved.
Analysis and understanding of the forces affecting bankruptcy
filings are impeded by the lack of high-quality, nationally uniform data.
Better data collection and verification procedures should be incorporated
in any reform proposals. Such data can be used to assess and monitor the
impact of reform legislation.
8.
Scrutiny must also be given to credit industry practices that
�" ARMS Email System
Page 4 of4
have led some borrowers to overextend themselves.
While some of these issues may fall outside of the Judiciary
CommitteeD,s jurisdiction, Congress and the Administration should consider
proposals to ensure that consumers are well informed about the dangers of
excessive debt accumulation and understand the implications of their
credit agreements.
The Clinton Administration is open to responsible consumer bankruptcy
reform that meets these principles. We have reluctantly concluded that we
cannot support H.R. 3150 in its present form.
We would look forward to
working with Congress toward legislation more similar to the approach of
S. 1301 -- with modifications necessary to meet the principles articulated
above.
Sincerely,
�· ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-MAY-1998 15:07:22.00
SUBJECT:
The President's trip to DE
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�· ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T: Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ': UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 3 of5
, ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasguil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasguil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�". ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler!OU=CEQ!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 ) .
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Anne M. Edwards!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang!OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura K. Capps!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Friday, May 8, 1998, the President will travel to Dover, Delaware, to
address the State Legislature, tour Dover Air Force Base, and speak to
Base personnel. Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
Background Memos:
Political Memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
DUE THUR., MAY 7, AT 6:00 P.M.
�'. ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
Economic I-Pager
Accomplishments
Event Memos:
DUE THUR., MAY 7, AT 6:00 P.M.
Address to the Legislature
Tour of Dover AFB & Remarks to Personnel
please call ,or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�·ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-MAY-1998 18:35:41.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of2
.ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in Room 100. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert
( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-MAY-1998 08:13:11.00
SUBJECT:
REMINDER -- Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David W. Beier ( CN=David W. Beier/O=OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAlLARD_C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ UNKNOWN· 1 )
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�,0
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: MURRAY MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
cc: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish NarayananjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. TaylorjO=OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
@
ustr.gov
@
INET
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura EmmettjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. PizzutojOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting is scheduled for today, May 7, 2:45pm
in Room 211, OEOB.
�,
-
" ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of7
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-MAY-1998 11:36:58.00
SUBJECT:
LRM #IMS319 - Statement of Administration policy on S1723 American Competi
TO: mjtaylor ( mjtaylor @ dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey M. Smith ( CN=Jeffrey M. Smith/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm ( lrm @ nsf.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm ( lrm @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: blue_gloria@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY ( blue_gloria@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@5=JMD@7=Deborah@6=Clifton@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEMAIL@5=JMD@7=Deb
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Konigsberg ( CN=Charles Konigsberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles M. Brain ( CN=Charles M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. 'Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�Page 2 of7
· ARMS Email System
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPO/O=EOP@EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine M. Tyer ( CN=Katherine M. Tyer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gregory G. Henry ( CN=Gregory G. Henry/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald L. Silberman ( CN=Ronald L. Silberman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan T. Farley ( CN=Evan T. Farley/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ogc_legislation ( ogc_legislation @ ed.gov @inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Rachel E. Levinson ( CN=Rachel E. Levinson/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: dodlrs ( dodlrs @ osdgc.osd.mil [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: collins-peter@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY ( collins-peter@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY [ UNKN
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@3=GOV+TREAS@S=OO@4=MS01@7=LLR@6=TREASURY@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEM
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: dol-sol-leg ( dol-sol-leg @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Claire Gonzales ( CN=Claire Gonzales/OU=PIR/O=EOP@EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�Page 3 of7
· ARMS Email System
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=william P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson .( CN=Broderick.Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOwN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: S. A. Noe ( CN=S. A. Noe/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Fox ( CN=Charles W. Fox/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Jo Siclari ( CN=Mary JoSiclari/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Louisa Koch ( CN=Louisa Koch/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph G. Pipan ( CN=Joseph G. Pipan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J.
READ: UNKNOWN
C~enok
( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry white/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Darlene o. Gaymon ( CN=Darlene O. Gaymon/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
You will not receive a paper copy of this LRM.
Total Pages: ____
�· ARMS Email System
Page 4 of7
LRM ID: IMS319
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Thursday, May 7, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
James J. Jukes (for) Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
Ingrid M. Schroeder
PHONE: (202) 395-3883 FAX: (202) 395-3109
SUBJECT:
Statement of Administration Policy on S1723 American
Competitiveness Act
FROM:
OMB CONTACT:
DEADLINE:
Noon
Friday, May 8, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: S. 1723 is scheduled for Senate floor action during the week of
May 11th.
Please note the veto recommendation in the first paragraph of
the SAP.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - Ann Harkins - (202) 514-2141
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
128-US Trade Representative - Fred Montgomery - (202) 395-3475
30-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
29-DEFENSE - Samuel T. Brick Jr. - (703) 697-1305
84-National Science Foundation - Lawrence Rudolph - (703) 306-1060
95-0ffice of Science and Technology policy - Jeff Smith - (202) 456-6047
114-STATE - Paul Rademacher - (202) 647-4463
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer - (202) 395-5084
EOP:
Debra J. Bond
Larry R. Matlack
Barry White
Sandra Yamin'
Barbara Chow
Steven M. Mertens
Daniel J. Chenok
Evan T. Farley
Joseph G. pipan
Ronald L. Silberman
Louisa Koch
Richard J. Turman
�· ARMS Email System
Mary Jo Siclari
Gregory G. Henry
Charles W. Fox
Katherine M. Tyer
S. A. Noe
Jack A. Smalligan
Julie A. Fernandes
Elena Kagan
Thomas A. Kalil
Cecilia E. Rouse
Sally Katzen
Gene B. Sperling
Peter G. Jacoby
Janet Murguia
Broderick Johnson
Charles M. Brain
Tracey E. Thornton
Maria Echaveste
Emil E. Parker
Robert N. Weiner
William P. Marshall
Karen Tramontano
Claire Gonzales
Rebecca M. Blank
Maria J. Hanratty
Kate P. Donovan
Lisa M. Kountoupes
Charles Konigsberg
James C. Murr
LRM ID: IMS319 SUBJECT:
American Competitiveness Act
Page 5 of7
Statement of Administration Policy on S1723
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT'the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
FROM:
Ingrid M. Schroeder Phone:
395-3883
Fax:
395-3109
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
�Page 6 of7
· ARMS Email System
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
DRAFT -- NOT FOR RELEASE
(Sen
May 7, 1998
S. 1723 - American Competitiveness Act
(Abraham (R) Michigan and 15 cosponsors)
S.1723, O&The American Competitiveness Act,OS is intended to respond to a
reported skills shortage in the information technology industry by
increasing the annual cap on the number of temporary visas for foreign
D&specialtyDS workers under the H-1B program. For the reasons outlined
below, the Administration strongly opposes Senate passage of S. 1723. If
S. 1723 were presented to the President, the Secretary of Labor would
recommend that the bill be vetoed.
Regrettably, S.1723 emphasizes providing opportunities for foreign workers
rather than providing opportunities for and protecting U.S. workers.
The
billO,s temporary increase in the annual number of H-1B visas is too large
(up to 115,000) and lasts too long (5 years).
In addition, the bill does
not help ensure that U.S. workers do not lose their jobs to temporary
foreign workers and that qualified U.S. workers have the opportunity to
fill a job before a temporary foreign worker is hired.
Moreover, rather
than strengthening program requirements and enforcement to prevent
employer abuses of the H-1B program, S.1723 undermines some of the
programO,s important enforcement provisions.
Since 1993 the Administration has sought reforms of the H-1B program,
including requiring employers to make bona fide efforts to recruit and
retain U.S. workers before hiring temporary foreign workers and
prohibiting lay-offs of U.S. workers to replace them with foreign
temporary workers.
These reforms, if enacted, would help target H-1B
usage to industries and employers that are experiencing skill shortages.
Also, the Administration believes that the first step in increasing the
availability of skilled workers for industry must be increasing the skills
of U.S. workers and helping the labor market work better to match
employers with U.S. workers. Although S.1723 includes an authorization
for a scholarship fund and a small fund to train dislocated workers, the
Administration believes that increased training opportunities for U.S.
workers should be funded through an H-1B application fee paid by employers.
�,_ ARMS Email System
Substantial additional efforts by industry to increase the skill level of
U.S. workers and needed improvements in the H-IB program are necessary
prerequisites for the Administration to support any short-term increase in
the number of H-IB visas available for temporary foreign workers.
The
Administration wants to work with the Congress to develop a bill that
addresses the growing. demand for highly skilled workers, while effectively
protecting and promoting the interests of U.S. workers and enhancing the
international competitiveness of important U.S. industries.
* * * * * * *
Page 7 of7
�, ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Jones ( CN=Lisa M. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-MAY-1998 16:32:57.00
SUBJECT:
Heads-up on EPA's Proposed Rule on the Identification of Lead Standard
TO: Linda Lance ( CN=Linda Lance/OU=CEQ/O=EOP@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of3
" ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Memo signed on Thursday, May 7th.
MEMORANDUM FOR ERSKINE BOWLES
THROUGH:
FROM:
SUBJECT:
Lead
Franklin D. Raines
Donald R. Arbuckle
Heads-up on EPAD,s proposed rule on the Identification of
Standard
We expect to complete our review this Friday of EPAD,s proposed
standards that identify hazardous levels of lead-based paint,
lead-contaminated dust, and lead-contaminated soil for residential
housing.
EPA estimates costs associated with this rule of more than $50
billion over the next 50 years. These costs represent the lead hazard
testing and abatement likely to occur in response to the new proposed
standard. EPA estimates the benefits to range from approximately $40
billion by one model to $160 billion by another model.
The benefits are
largely from the avoidance of IQ loss due to lead exposure.
In the course of our review, EPA agreed to expand their discussion
of key elements of the proposal, such as the effect of different levels of
soil standards, in order to set out alternative options for public
comment. EPA has also agreed to conduct further analysis of these
alternatives before submitting a final rule in order to provide a more
complete picture of their preferred option and the identified alternatives.
Environmental and child safety groups support a more stringent set
of hazard standards than that proposed by EPA. In contrast, associations
of real estate agents and multi-family dwelling owners support less
stringent options.
On balance, we believe the rule fairly describes
EPAD,s preferred standards while also preserving the option to go with
alternative standards if compelled by public comment or further analysis.
Please let me know if you have any questions.
cc:
Maria Echaveste
Rahm Emanuel
Larry Stein
Ron Klain
Thurgood Marshall, Jr.
Ann Lewis
Sally Katzen
Sylvia Mathews
John Podesta
Bruce Reed
Gene Sperling
Elena Kagan
Barry Toiv
Michael Waldman
Janet Yellen
Mickey Ibarra
�.,. ARMS Email System
Katie McGinty
Linda Lance
T.J. Glauthier
Page 3 of3
�· ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-MAY-1998 16:34:31.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to VA/MA
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�, ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ:UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN .
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�, ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan OrszagjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. AdashekjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. WalkerjOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. ViolajOU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. ToivjOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie TarmeyjOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. StottjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. SmithjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake SiewertjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. ReberjOU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Simeona F. PasquiljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. NewmanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. MoranjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. MoorejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuirejOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. MathewsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�· ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Saturday, May 9, 1998, the President will travel to Newport News,
Virginia, to address the Senate Democratic Issues Conference.
He will
then travel to Boston, Massachusetts, to attend a DNC dinner, before
returning to the White House late that night.
Deadlines for the
President's trip book are as follows:
MA Background Memos:
political Memo
DUE FRI., MAY 8, AT NOON
NOTE:
THE PRESIDENT WILL NOT
�" ARMS Email System
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Economic One-Pager
Accomplishments
VA & MA Event Memos:
Page 5 of5
REQUIRE VIRGINIA BACKGROUND
DUE FRI., MAY 8, AT 3:00 P.M.
Senate Democratic Issues Conference (VA)
DNC Dinner (MA)
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�.• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 4
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrea Kane ( CN;Andrea Kane/OU;OPD/O;EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 8-MAY-1998 11:14:02.00
SUBJECT:
WtW Formula Grant Update
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN;Lynn G. Cutler/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN;Diana Fortuna/OU;OPD/O;EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal ( CN;Fred DuVal/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN;Emil E. Parker/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN;Cynthia A. Rice/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN;Bruce N. Reed/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN;Sanders D. Korenman/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP[ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Anil Kakani
READ: UNKNOWN
)
( CN;Anil Kakani/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
CC: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN;Maria J. Hanratty/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Maureen H. Walsh ( CN;Maureen H. Walsh/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TEXT:
Attached is latest status of states and tribes applying for
Welfare-to-Work formula grants.
It looks like Ohio's decision to turn
down the grant does not reflect a trend.
Since then, at least 7 more
states have submitted plans. A total of 30 states have applied, 17 have
been approved, 6 have indicated they don't plan to apply, and 18 have not
yet applied.
;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; ATTACHMENT
1 ;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D8]MAIL40388772H.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043A8050000010A020100000002050000000018000000020000892051EED85CCCACEOB9B9
50490D7C4FD41979EA657F678066EOB82CD562201E6A8C176B65FF96E5F294012AD25DF569BCF5
DF23E80EF5CD560B1DBE83FB5082B58D8619175239C3D8COAF9CCDE6A1F915A37F03CB6F9FOFCF
74C2AD489444D3A76C9324721A79E0711B3A330315837483246CF669889D828873B37AA9A566FD
A8B26C9ED696076A4BE7FB2E3AD7FE3F5A14A25E7168D1FB680B41EE87304FC01273E60B95F016
�•
5 States announced 1/29/98:
2 States announced 2/19:
3 States announced 3/2:
2 States announced 3/30:
1State announced 4/10?:
3 States announced 4/28-4/29
1 State announced 5/1
IL, LA,MI,NE,NV
MA,SC
KA,HI,MN
MO,TN
KY
AR, AL, DE
GA
TOTAL TO DATE: 17 states (31% of states)
States with pending plans:
CA
RI
MT
CO
NC
WI
$122 M
$33 M
$26 M
$40 M
$18 M
$19 M
$28 M
$287 M
(26% of $)
PR
$190.4M
$4.4 M
$3.2 M
$9.9 M
$25.3 M
$12.9 M
$50.8 M
$11.7M
$2.8 M
$8.6 M
$14.6 M
$9.8 M
$34.6 M
TOTAL PENDING: 13 states (24% of states)
$379 M
6 States indicate they don't plan to apply (11%):
10, UT, OH, SO, WY, MS (DOL discussing further)
$71 M (6% of $)
TRIBAL PLANS
26 approved 3/19
33 approved 4/1
13 approved 5/1
$5.8 M
$4.4 M
$1.0 M
TOTAL TO DATE: 72
$11.2M
FL
OK
VT
OR
IN
WV
As of 5/8/98
(34% of$)
�· ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 7
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:l1-MAY-1998 15:42:01.00
SUBJECT:
LRM#IMS321 - LABOR and JUSTICE Report on HR3736 Workforce Improvement and
TO: lrm ( lrm @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey M. Smith ( CN=Jeffrey M. Smith/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm ( lrm @ ostp.eop.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: mjtaylor ( mjtaylor @ dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ogc_legislation ( ogc_legislation @ ed.gov @inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@5=JMD@7=Deborah@6=Clifton@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEMAIL@5=JMD@7=Deb
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen J. Balis ( CN=Ellen J. Balis/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ricardo M. Gonzales ( CN=Ricardo M. Gonzales/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=William P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN=Broderick Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�· ARMS Email System
Page 2 of7
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN;Jack A. Smalligan/OU;OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine M. Tyer ( CN=Katherine M. Tyer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Fox ( CN=Charles W. Fox/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald L. Silberman ( CN=Ronald L. Silberman/OU=OMBjO=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan T. Farley ( CN=Evan T. Farley/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN;Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm ( lrm @ nsf.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Rachel E. Levinson ( CN=Rachel E. Levinson/OU=OSTPjO=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: dodlrs ( dodlrs @ osdgc.osd.mil [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: dol-sal-leg ( dol-sol-Ieg @ dol.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O;EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Charles Konigsberg ( CN=Charles Konigsberg/OU=OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU;OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN;Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU;WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�" ARMS Email System
Page 3 of7
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: S. A·. Noe ( CN=S. A. Noe/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gregory G. Henry ( CN=Gregory G. Henry/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Jo Siclari ( CN=Mary Jo Siclari/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Louisa Koch ( CN=Louisa Koch/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph G. Pipan ( CN=Joseph G. Pipan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Darlene O. Gaymon ( CN=Darlene
READ: UNKNOWN
o.
Gaymon/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: IMS321
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
�" ARMS Email System
Page 4 of7
Monday, May 11, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
FROM:
OMB CONTACT:
James J. Jukes (for) Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
Ingrid M. Schroeder
PHONE: (202) 395- 3883 FAX: (202) 395 -3109
SUBJECT:
LABOR and JUSTICE Report on HR3736 workforce Improvement
and Protection Act of 1998
DEADLINE:
lOam
Tuesday, May 12, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before.advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: HR3736 is scheduled for markup in the House Judiciary Committee
on May 13th.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
61-JUSTICE - Ann Harkins - (202) 514-2141
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
114-STATE - Paul Rademacher - (202) 647-4463
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
128-US Trade Representative - Fred Montgomery - (202) 395-3475
30-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
29-DEFENSE - Samuel T. Brick Jr. - (703) 697-1305
84-National Science Foundation - Lawrence Rudolph - (703) 306-1060
95-0ffice of Science and Technology Policy - Jeff Smith - (202) 456-6047
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer - (202) 395-5084
EOP:
Debra J. Bond
Larry R. Matlack
Barry White
Sandra Yamin
Barbara Chow
Steven M. Mertens
Daniel J. Chenok
Evan T. Farley
Joseph G. pipan
Ronald L. Silberman
Louisa Koch
Richard J. Turman
Mary Jo Siclari
Charles W. Fox
Gregory G. Henry
Katherine M. Tyer
S. A. Noe
Jack A. Smalligan
Julie A. Fernandes
Elena Kagan
�· ARMS Email System
Thomas A. Kalil
Cecilia E. Rouse
Emil E. Parker
Sally Katzen
Gene B. Sperling
Peter G. Jacoby
Janet Murguia
Broderick Johnson
Tracey E. Thornton
Maria Echaveste
Robert N. Weiner
William P. Marshall
Karen Tramontano
Ricardo M. Gonzales
Rebecca M. Blank
Maria J. Hanratty
Kate P. Donovan
Lisa M. Kountoupes
Charles Konigsberg
Ellen J. Balis
James C. Murr
LRM ID: IMS321 SUBJECT:
LABOR and JUSTICE
Improvement and Protection Act of 1998
Page 5 of7
Report on HR3736 Workforce
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Ingrid M. Schroeder Phone:
395-3883
Fax:
395-3109
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
FROM:
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
�· ARMS Email System
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
The Honorable Henry J. Hyde
Chairman
Committee on the Judiciary
U.S. House of Representatives
Washington, D.C.
20515
Dear Chairman Hyde:
Today, your Committee will mark-up H.R. 3736, the O&Workforce
Improvement and Protection Act of 199808 which is intended to address the
growing demand for skilled workers in the information technology (IT)
industry by enacting a temporary increase in the annual cap on the number
of visas for temporary foreign 0&specialty08 workers under the H-1B
program, while also effecting reforms to the H-1B program that would help
target their usage to industries and employers that are actually
experiencing skill shortages.
The Administration believes that the first step in increasing the
availability of skilled workers must be raising the skills of U.S. workers
and helping the labor market work better to match employers with U.S.
workers. Therefore, substantial additional efforts to increase the skill
level of U.S. workers and needed improvements in the H-1B visa'program are
necessary prerequisites for the Administration to support any short-term
increase in the number of visas for temporary foreign workers.
We are pleased that H.R. 3736 as reported from the Immigration and
Claims Subcommittee is consistent with one of our primary objectives,
insofar as it links a temporary increase in the H-1B cap to the enactment
of meaningful reforms to the H-1B visa program. H.R. 3736 would help
ensure that U.S. workers do not lose their jobs to temporary foreign
workers and that qualified U.S. workers have the opportunity to fill a job
before a temporary foreign worker is hired. Moreover, H.R. 3736 modestly
expands enforcement authority to help prevent employer abuses of the H-1B
program. These reforms will effectively target H-1B visas to industries
experiencing skill shortages. The Administration strongly opposes
amendments that would weaken these reforms.
Unfortunately, H.R. 3736 does not contain any provision to
encourage additional training of U.S. workers.
Training is a vital
component of our strategy to address the long-term demand for highly
skilled U.S. workers and to enhance the international competitiveness of
important U.S. industries. An effective training strategy would also work
to reduce the demand for H-1B visas. The Administration strongly supports
amending H.R. 3736 to provide for additional training opportunities for
U.S. workers and believes that this training should be funded, in part,
through a modest H-1B application fee paid by employers. The
Administration is also concerned that the increase in the annual number of
H-1B visas reflected in this bill is too large, although we agree that the
increase should last for only three years.
Page 6 of7
�.. ARMS Email System
Page 7 of7
The Administration believes that H.R. 3736 would substantially
improve the current H-IB program and, with the addition of a meaningful
training provision and a modest reduction in the level of increase in the
annual H-IB visa cap, would garner the AdministrationO,s support. We look
forward to working with the Congress on these and other specific
provisions in the bill.
The Office of Management and Budget advises that there is no
objection to the submission of this report from the standpoint of the
AdministrationO,s program.
Sincerely,
Labor
Justice
�,~
.
,'ARMS Email System
Page 1 of5
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Tanya L. Miller ( CN=Tanya L, Miller/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: ll-MAY-1998 17:39:42.00
SUBJECT:
Reminder: SF 278 Filing Due Date
TO: Erskine B. Bowles ( CN=Erskine B. Bowles/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alan p, Sullivan ( CN=Alan P. Sullivan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B, Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Marsha
Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Sarah Rosen ( CN=Sarah Rosen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen A. Popp ( CN=Karen A. Popp/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Peterson ( CN=Michelle Peterson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN=Bob J. Nash/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl D. Mills ( CN=Cheryl D. Mills/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�"ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert D. Kyle ( CN=Robert D. Kyle/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN .
TO: Michael X. Imbroscio ( CN=Michael X. Imbroscio/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Terry W. Good ( CN=Terry W. Good/OU·=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
,
TO: Martha Foley ( CN=Martha Foley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nelson W. Cunningham ( CN=Nelson W. Cunningham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beverly J. Barnes ( CN=Beverly J. Barnes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael B. Waitzkin ( CN=Michael B. Waitzkin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�,. ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
{
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert M. Shireman ( CN=Robert M. Shireman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff ( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorothy Robyn ( CN=Dorothy Robyn/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karl A. Racine ( CN=Karl A. Racine/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dimitri J. Nionakis ( CN=Dimitri J. Nionakis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alex G. Nagy ( CN=Alex G. Nagy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MCLARTY T
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
MCLARTY T
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
TO: Doris o. Matsui ( CN=Doris O. Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
T'O: Michael D. Malone ( CN=Michael D. Malone/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Malcolm R. Lee ( CN=Malcolm R. Lee/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Adam W. Goldberg ( CN=Adam W. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�\. ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn M. Chirwa ( CN=Dawn M. Chirwa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lanny A. Breuer ( CN=Lanny A. Breuer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Brian D. Smith ( CN=Brian D. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa J. Prober ( CN=Melissa J. Prober/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia L. Cearley ( CN=Virginia L. Cearley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Demeo ( CN=Laura K. Demeo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Douglas J. Band ( CN=Douglas J. Band/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ora Theard ( CN=Ora Theard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Brigham C. Smith ( CN=Brigham C. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dawn L. Smalls ( CN=Dawn L. Smalls/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Gay L. Joshlyn ( CN=Gay L. Joshlyn/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
CC: Eleanor S. Parker ( CN=Eleanor S. Parker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia R. Canter ( CN=Virginia R. Canter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�'<
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
/
This is a reminder that your 1998 annual Public Financial Disclosure
Report (SF 278) is due to Virginia Canter in OEOB 136 on or before the
close of business this Friday, May 15. Extensions of time to file will be
granted only in extreme circumstances and only in advance.
Forms filed
late may be subject to a statutorily imposed $200 late fee.
Thank you.
Page 5 of5
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[04/29/1998 – 05/11/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 098 - Folder 008
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/0885b1d798da69fd0114d61a1df706bf.pdf
d92cddc42220267b30a6f7c9302a9f8a
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 098 - FOLDER -007
[04/17/1998-04/27/1998]
�WithdrawallRedaction Sheet
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
AND TYPE
001. email
DATE
SUBJECTffITLE
Mona Mohib to Sandra Thurman et al re Invitation (I page)
0412311998
RESTRICTION
Personal Misfile
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management System (Email)
CEA ([Kagan])
OAlBox Number: 950000
FOLDER TITLE:
[04117/1998-04/27/1999]
2009-1006-F
kcl84
RESTRICTIOl'l CODES
Presidential Records Act - [44 U.S.C. 2204(a»)
PI
P2
P3
P4
National Security Classified Information [(a)(I) of the PRA)
Relating to the appointment to Federal office [(a)(2) of the PRA)
Release would violate a Federal statute [(a)(3) of the PRA!"
Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
financial information [(3)(4) of the PRA)
P5 Release would disclose confidential advice between the President
and his advisors, or between such advisors [a)(5) oUhe PRA)
P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy [(0)(6) of the PRA)
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
of gift.
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.C.
2201(3).
RR. Document will be reviewed upon request.
Freedom of Information Act· [5 U.S.C. 552(b))
b(l) National security classified information [(b)(I) of the FOIA)
b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
an agency [(b)(2) of the FOIA)
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute [(b)(3) of the FOIA]
b(4) 'Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial
information [(b)(4) of the FOIA)
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy [(b)(6) of the FOIA)
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes [(b)(7) of the FOIA)
b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
. financial institutions [(b)(8) of the FOIA)
.
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
concerning wells [(b)(9) of the FOIA)
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of25
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 17-APR-1998 10:34:45.00
SUBJECT:
LRM #IMS 299 - LABOR Testimony on H1B Nonimmigrant Visa Program and,the Hi
TO: lrm ( lrm @ ostp.eop.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: LRM Health and Human Services ( LRM Health and Human Services [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@3=GOV+TREAS@5=DO@4=MS01@7=LLR@6=TREASURY@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEM
READ: UNKNOWN
TO:' dodlrs ( dodlrs @ osdgc.osd.mil [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: blue_gloria@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY ( blue_gloria@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Claire Gonzales ( CN=Claire Gonzales/OU=PIR/O=EOP@EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=William P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: S. A. Noe ( CN=S. A. Noe/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah G. Horrigan ( CN=Sarah G. Horrigan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of25
TO: Charles W. Fox ( CN=Charles W. Fox/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Louisa Koch ( CN=Louisa Koch/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph G. Pipan ( CN=JOseph G. Pipan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1. )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Rachel E. Levinson ( CN=Rachel E. Levinson/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ogc_legislation ( ogc_legislation @ ed.gov @inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm ( lrm @ nsf.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: collins-peter@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY ( collins-peter@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY [ UNKN
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@S=JMD@7=Deborah@6=Clifton@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEMAIL@S=JMD@7=Deb
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP@OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: John A. Koskinen ( CN=John A. Koskinen/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of25
TO: Katherine M. Tyer ( CN=Katherine M. Tyer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gregory G. Henry ( CN=Gregory G. Henry/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Jo Siclari ( CN=Mary Jo Siclari/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan T. Farley ( CN=Evan T. Farley/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Darlene o. Gaymon ( CN=Darlene o. Gaymon/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jeffrey A. Weinberg ( CN=Jeffrey A. Weinberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
You will not be receiving a paper copy of this LRM.
Total Pages:
LRM ID: IMS299
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Friday, April 17, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
FROM:
OMB CONTACT:
James J. Jukes (for) Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
Ingrid M. Schroeder
PHONE: (202) 395-3883 FAX: (202) 395-3109
SUBJECT:
LABOR Testimony on H1B Nonimmigrant Visa Program and the
High Technology Industry
DEADLINE:
4:30pm
Friday, April 17, 1998
�ARMS Email System
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: The attached testimony is for a House Judicary subcommittee
hearing on April 21st.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - Andrew Fois - (202) 514-2141
114-STATE - Paul Rademacher - (202) 647-4463
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
128-US Trade Representative - Fred Montgomery - (202) 395-3475
95-0ffice of Science and Technology Policy - Jeff Smith - (202) 456-6047
84-National Science Foundation - Lawrence Rudolph - (703) 306-1060
29-DEFENSE - Samuel T. Brick Jr. - (703) 697-1305
30-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer - (202) 395-5084
EOP:
Debra J. Bond
Larry R. Matlack
Barry White
Barbara Chow
Steven M. Mertens
David J. Haun
Daniel J. Chenok
Joseph G. Pipan
Evan T. Farley
Louisa Koch
Mary Jo Siclari
Charles W. Fox
Gregory G. Henry
Sarah G. Horrigan
Katherine M. Tyer
S. A. Noe
Jack A. Smalligan
Julie A. Fernandes
Elena Kagan
Thomas A. Kalil
Cecilia E. Rouse
Sally Katzen
Peter G. Jacoby
Janet Murguia
Maria Echaveste
Emil E. Parker
Robert N. Weiner
William P. Marshall
John A. Koskinen
Karen Tramontano
Donald H. Gips
Claire Gonzales
Rebecca M. Blank
Jim Murr
Page 4 of25
�Page 5 of25
ARMS Email System
LABOR
LRM ID: IMS299 SUBJECT:
and the High Technology Industry
Testimony on H1B Nonimmigrant Visa Program
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
395-3883
Fax:
395-3109
Ingrid M. Schroeder phone:
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
_ _ _ Concur
_ _ _ No Objection
_ _ _ No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
_ _ _ Other:
FAX RETURN of ___ pages, attached to this response sheet
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D91)MAIL413514606.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750434C120000010A02010000000205000000BFB0000000020000AB04D4CBE226FFEC3C4091
7DE5DEBCD4081735952CC43A91D5353D515765DEDD15FC8B372386478197F956E212BC86375600
�STATEMENT OF JOHN R. FRASER
DEPUTY WAGE AND HOUR ADMINISTRATOR
EMPLOYMENT STANDARDS ADMINISTRATION
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
BEFORE THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON IMMIGRATION AND CLAIMS
OF THE HOUSE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE
April 21, 1998
Mr. Chairman and Members of the Subcommittee:
We appreciate this opportunity to share the views of the
Administration on whether this country's important
high~technology industry should be afforded increased access
to foreign workers to meet its growing demand for high skilled
workers.
In doing so, I also want to again call your attention
to the pressing need for reform of the H-1B nonimmigrant visa
program through which increased numbers of foreign workers are
being sought by the high-technology industry.
The Administration believes that our information
technology (IT) industry is an essential element of our
continuing, strong economic growth and wider prosperity. Our
interest in the industry's strength is evidenced by our
participation in a recent convocation in Berkeley that assessed
IT work force needs.
Further, as you know from Administration
proposals advanced beginning in 1993, we believe that the H-1B
program needs fundamental reform.
I would like to commend the
Subcommittee for its interest in these issues.
We believe the issue of whether to afford the IT industry
increased access to foreign temporary workers should be
evaluated within the framework of the following three questions:
(1)
Is there a shortage of skilled U.S. workers to fill
jobs in the IT industry and meet future workforce needs?
(1)
What would be the consequences of raising the cap
on the number of foreign workers admitted under the H-1B
program?
�2
Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
(3)
Can the current H-1B program provide the IT industry
appropriate access to foreign workers while still protecting
the job opportunities, wages and working conditions of u.s.
workers?
I will address each of these in turn.
Tight Labor Markets Exist But
U.S. Skills Shortages Are Unclear
Proponents of allowing increased IT industry access to
foreign workers argue that this is necessary for the industry
to be able to overcome an acute shortage of skilled u. s. workers.
While there is no dispute that there is strong growth in demand
for workers in the IT industry, it is not at all clear that
there is a shortage of skilled U. S. workers to meet this demand
or that the domestic labor market won't be able -- as it has
over the last decade -- to satisfy projected job growth in the
next decade.
u.s.
employment has been growing rapidly, labor markets
are increasingly tight, and they are likely to remain so.
This is true for the national labor market as a whole -- given
our sustained economic expansion and low national unemployment
rate -- and IT labor markets appear to be particularly affected.
Employment of computer systems analysts, engineers, and
scientists has been growing by 10 percent a year -- well above
the growth of comparable occupations -- and is expected to
continue growing at a comparable rate through 2006. The Bureau
of Labor Statistics projects that the u.s. will require more
than 1.3 million new workers in IT core occupations between
1996 and 2006 to fill job openings projected to occur due to
growth and the need to replace workers who leave the labor force
or transfer to other occupations.
The underlying dynamics of the IT labor market and asserted
labor shortages are very controversial.
Industry advocates
say that more than three hundred thousand jobs cannot be filled
and that these vacancies are raising business costs and hurting
u.s. competitiveness. On the other hand, critics say the IT
industry:
•
drastically overstates any problem by producing
inflated job vacancy data and equating it to skills
shortagesi
�3
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
•
continues to layoff tens of thousands of workers - -e. g. ,
Intel, Netscape, Cypress Semiconductor and Silicon
Graphics recently announced large lay-offs; and
•
fails to tap reservoirs of available talent by insisting
on unnecessarily specific job requirements and not
providing more training to develop workers' skills.
The Subcommittee should also take into consideration other
factors that bear on the question of the scope and duration·
of any labor shortage in the IT industry:
•
The current "millennium problem" is certainly occupying
thousands of IT workers for the short-term;
•
new technologies are being introduced that are making
possible more efficient ways to produce software, store
and retrieve data, speed up computations and in other
ways improve the productivity of the IT work force;
•
the number of computer science degrees conferred
(bachelors, masters and doctorates) has been rising
since 1992; and
•
Most -- nearly three quarters -- of IT workers actually
got their education and training in other disciplines.
A point of contention is the equation of job vacancies
and actual skills shortages. An industry association sponsored
survey indicates that there may be as many as 350,000 job
vacancies in the IT industry.
However, aside from the concerns
about the usefulness of this survey that you will hear from
the GAO, this does not necessarily signal that there is an acute
shortage of skilled workers.
Most industries and firms have
job openings at any point in time reflecting worker turnover
and employment growth.
Wages growing substantially faster than average can be
a reliable indicator of skill shortages, but the wage growth
record for the IT industry is mixed.
BLS wage trends for broad
computer-related categories show average wage growth between
1988 and 1997 for all categories, with above-average growth
in wages only in 1996 and 1997 in the lower-skill
computer-related categories, particularly programmers. At the
same time, a variety of industry wage surveys show larger wage
increases in 1996 and 1997 in more specialized, high-skill
occupations.
Considering all of these indicators, we believe that there
�4
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
is simply no conclusive evidence of a shortage of skilled u.s.
workers to meet the labor demands of the IT industry.
The need
for further analysis of this question is underscored by the
recent conclusions of the Commerce Department and General
Accounting Office (GAO) that much more needs to be known about
the demand and supply of IT workers.
These conclusions were
reached by the Commerce Department in its September 1997 report,
and the GAO subsequent evaluation of that report.
Both Commerce
and GAO findings were inconclusive on the issue of an IT U.S.
worker shortage and found that more information and data are
needed to understand and properly characterize the IT labor
market.
Consequences of Raising the H-1B Visa CAP
In light of the highly ambiguous information about the
state of the IT labor market, we strongly urge that any decision
to raise the H-1B visa cap must carefully consider the probable
adverse impact of such a move on the normal process by which
the labor markets adjust to a growing demand for workers.
The
proper first response to tight labor markets should be, in the
Administration's view, to let the market react rather than
introducing artificial factors, such as increasing access to
foreign temporary workers, that will delay, if not prevent,
the normal labor market adjustments.
It is very important to remember that tight labor markets
are good for u.S. workers. A tight labor market causes
employers to raise wages, improve working conditions, and
provide increased training to enable currently employed workers
to keep pace with technology and induce more workers to enter
the labor market. The increased demand for trained workers
induces educational and job training institutions to teach new
skills. With more opportunities for training, workers acquire
skills needed to obtain better, higher-paying and more secure
jobs, thereby creating open jobs and career ladders for those
just entering or reentering the labor market -- young people,
welfare recipients, displaced workers, and other disadvantaged
groups.
Indeed, the IT labor market has begun to respond to
these signals of increased demand.
A survey of U.S. Ph.D.
departments of computer science and computer engineering showed
bachelor-level enrollments were up 46% in 1996, and another
39% in 1997 -- nearly doubling over the two year period.
Moreover, the high technology jobs at the center of this debate
are precisely the types of skilled employment Americans have
been led to expect will become available to them as a result
of globalization.
Therefore, tight labor markets create incentives for
employers and workers to react in ways needed to achieve many
�5
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
of the Nation's top priorities: moving welfare recipients,
out-of-school youth, and dislocated workers into jobs;
providing greater opportunities for lifelong learning; and
raising wages and reducing income inequality.
However, labor markets can sometimes be slow to respond
to skills shortages.
In these circumstances, it is often argued
that foreign temporary workers are needed in the short-term
to provide necessary skills while the labor market adjusts and
provides u.s. workers with the requisite
training.
Without needed foreign temporary workers, some argue
that the IT industry may adjust to skills shortages in ways
that do not serve the short-term or long-term priorities of
the country, either by reducing job creation or by moving jobs
overseas.
Further, the IT sector is so critical to our
competitive edge in an array of industries and services that
disproportionate harm could come to the u.s. economy if, in
fact, skill shortages do become problematic.
Even in such circumstances the expanded use of foreign
temporary workers may well interfere with labor market
adjustments and may make achieving our other priorities more
difficult.
The presence of more foreign workers may reduce
the incentive for u. S. workers to acquire new skills, and fewer
employers and institutions may be induced to increase training
and education.
Such impacts could only be exacerbated by
increasing the current H-IB visa cap, without needed reforms.
We must also be cognizant that raising the H-IB cap will
almost certainly increase both legal and illegal immigration.
We know that nearly half of the workers ,who obtain permanent
residency in the u.s. as employment-based immigrants convert
from H-visa nonimmigrant status. And according to Immigration
and Naturalization Service statistics, nearly one-half of all
illegal aliens resident in the u.s. are visa over-stayers.
With the attachments they will form in the u.s. during their
nonimmigrant stay of 6 years (or more), one can expect many
of the additional H-IB entrants will eventually join the ranks
of visa over-stayers.
�6
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Mr. Chairman, we have heard a lot from advocates of raising
the H-1B visa cap that this would be good for the IT industry,
enhancing its growth, productivity and international
competitiveness and, in turn, U.S. economic .growth and
prosperity.
We must pay close attention to these concerns.
But the public has heard little so far about the adverse impact
of raising the cap, such as the effect on workers who have lost
or are seeking jobs in the IT industry.
The Department,
however, has heard from many concerned individuals and groups
on this issue.
If I may, I would like to request that copies
of scores of letters we have received from opponents of raising
the cap be included in the record of today's hearing.
The Administration believes it is essential to meet the
workforce needs of the IT industry first through the education
and training of U.S. workers. Our first response should be
to provide the needed skills to U.S. workers to qualify them
for IT jobs to secure the growth and strengthen the global
leadership of this important industry.
The Administration already has taken significant steps
to increase our capacity to enhance workforce skills.
The
President continues to pursue comprehensive reform of the
Nation's employment and training system by working with Congress
to enact the principles embodied in his GI Bill proposal.
Moreover, in the historic balanced budget agreement of last
summer, the President insisted on and achieved the largest
increase in 30 years in the Federal investment to expand the
skills of American workers, including:
•
the largest Pell Grant increase in two decades;
•
Hope Scholarships to make the first two years of
postsecondary education universally available;
•
the Lifelong Learning Tax Credit for the last 2 years
of college and continuing adult education and training
to upgrade worker skills;
•
a maj or increase in employment and training resources,
including increases for dislocated workers and
disadvantaged adults and youth; and
•
a $3 billion program to help long-term welfare
recipients secure lasting, unsubsidized employment.
�7
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Further, the Administration announced several new
initiatives at the recent Berkeley Convocation to help address
the growing demand for IT workers:
•
A Labor Department Technology Demonstration project
to test innovative ways of establishing partnerships
between local workforce development systems,
employers, training providers and others to train
dislocated workers in needed high tech skills;
•
The expansion and integration of America's Job Bank
and America's Talent Bank to allow employers and workers
to list and access job openings and worker resumes in
one integrated system;
•
The convening of four town hall meetings by the Commerce
Department to discuss IT workforce needs, identify
innovative practices, and showcase successful models;
and
•
A joint Education and Labor grant program to expand
employer involvement in high technology school-to-work
programs_
Last week President Clinton and Secretary Herman announced
that grants totaling $1_ 6 million are being provided to proj ects
in four States to continue for another year highly successful
programs to train dislocated workers for high paying jobs in
information technology_
We believe that there is more that can be done to move
U_S. workers into high technology jobs, and we welcome the
discussions that may be sparked by this hearing.
We are
committed to pursuing a continued dialogue with the major
stakeholders in the IT workforce issue - - government, industry,
workers, and education and training institutions - - to better
define the workforce needs of the IT industry and develop
appropriate solutions to meet these needs domestically through
commitments from each of the stakeholders. Such a dialogue
is critical because increased immigration, if needed at all,
can be only a small part of the solution to the workforce needs
of the IT industry.
In sum, Mr. Chairman, our assessment of the likely effects
of raising the H-1B cap reconfirms our strong conviction that
our primary public policy response to skills mismatches due
to changing technologies and economic restructuring, including
in the IT industry, must be to prepare the U.S. workforce to
meet new demands.
Importing needed skills should, at most,
�8
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
be a short-term response to meet urgent needs while we actively
adjust to quickly changing circumstances.
Increased
immigration should be the last -- not the first -- public policy
response to skills shortages.
Given this broader context, let me now turn to the third
of the issues I listed -- the pressing need for reform of the
H-1B nonimmigrant program.
H-1B Nonimmigrant Program Must be Reformed
The current H-1B program is broken and desperately in need
of reform. As presently designed, it is simply not serving
its intended purpose.
The role of immigration programs, like
the H-1B program, in meeting temporary skills shortages is to
allow employers to have access to temporary foreign workers
with the requisite skills while the domestic labor market makes
appropriate adjustments -- not to interfere with or to frustrate
such adjustments.
The H-1B program does not focus available
visas on temporary skills shortages. Nor does the program
adequately protect the job opportunities and wages and working
conditions of u.s. workers.
The fundamental structural flaws in the current H-1B
program are well documented in a May 1996 audit report by the
Department's Inspector General (IG). The IG's major findings
illustrate the problems with the H-1B program and I would ask
the Subcommittee to accept the IG's full audit report in the
record of today's hearing.
The IG found that, despite the legislative intent:
"
the [H-1B] program does not always meet urgent,
short-term demand for highly-skilled, unique
individuals who are not available in the domestic work
force.
Instead, it serves as a probationary try-out
employment program for illegal aliens, foreign
students, and foreign visitors to determine if they
will be sponsored for permanent status."
The IG also found that "75 percent of the [H-1B
employees] .
worked for employers who did not adequately
document that the wage specified on the LeA [employer'S
application] was the proper wage, and 19 percent of the aliens
were paid below the wage specified on the LCA." The IG also
found that "some [H-1B] employers use alien labor to reduce
payroll costs either by paying less than prevailing wage to
their own alien employees or treating these aliens as
independent contractors, thereby avoiding related payroll and
administrative costs."
It found, in addition, that "other
�9
Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
[H-1B] employers are 'job shops' whose business is to provide
H-1B alien contract labor to other employers. " The IG concluded
that the H-1B program does little to protect the jobs or wage
levels of U.S. workers and it recommended eliminating the
current program and establishing a new program to fulfill
Congress' intent.
Mr. Chairman, any consideration of even temporary
increases in the H-1B visa cap as part of the answer for the
tight labor market faced by the IT industry must include
much-needed reforms of the program.
In this regard, certain
conditions would have to be met for the Administration to support
any such step.
More specifically, besides requiring
substantial additional efforts by the IT industry to increase
the pool of skilled U.S. workers, needed improvements in the
H-1B visa program are a prerequisite for Administration support
for any modest, short-term increase in the number of H-1B visas.
The H-1B program allows the admission of up to 65,000
workers each year (to stay for as long as six years), to meet
short-term, high-skills employment needs in the domestic labor
market.
In principle, this can be an appropriate purpose,
consistent with our overall goal of giving priority to improving
the skills of U.S. workers.
In practice, however, employers do not have to demonstrate
any type of employment need or any effort at domestic recruitment
prior to getting a foreign temporary worker.
In addition,
employers are entirely free to lay-off U.S. workers to replace
them with foreign temporary workers.
Employers obtain H-1B
foreign workers by filing a labor condition application with
the Department affirming that they have complied with four
requirements:
-that a wage (not less than the local prevailing rate)
will be paid to the foreign workers;
-that no strike or lockout exists involving the occupation;
-that notification has been provided to U.S. workers or
their union; and
-that the employment of H-1B nonimmigrants will not
adversely affect the working conditions of U.S. workers
similarly employed.
�10
Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
By law, the Labor Department can do no more than review
these attestations for completeness and obvious inaccuracies
-- to determine whether an employer checked all of the boxes,
made no flagrant errors, and signed the attestation -- and
must do so within 7 days of receipt.
As the IG found, the H-1B program often operates as a
"probationary" employment program where employers bring workers
to the u.s. (or convert them from student status) and, if they
perform well, later sponsor them for permanent admission.
In
these circumstances, u.s. workers are never afforded the
opportunity to compete for the job.
Many employers, to be sure, use the H-1B nonimmigrant
program for its intended purpose: to provide u.s. businesses
with timely access to the "best and the brightest" in the
international labor market to meet urgent but generally
temporary business needs.
I want to emphasize that the
Administration recognizes the need for this legitimate use of
the program.
But reform of the H-1B program is needed because
it simply does not provide the appropriate balance between
timely access to the international labor market and adequate
protection of U. S. workers' job opportuni ties, wages and working
conditions.
Greater protections for u.s. workers are needed because
many employers use the H-1B program to employ not the "best
and the brightest", but rather entry- and journey-level foreign
workers. Minimum education and work experience qualifications
for H-1B jobs are a 4-year college degree and no work experience,
or the equivalent in terms of combined education and work
experience.
While some H-1B jobs are very high-paying jobs,
nearly 80 percent of H-1B jobs pay less than $50,000 a year
-- a good salary, but certainly at the low-end of the pay scale
for IT occupations even at the entry-level.
The existing H-1B program is broken in several respects.
First, current law does not require any test for the
availability of qualified~S. workers in the domestic labor
market.
Therefore, many of the visas under the current cap
of 65,000 can be -- and are - - used by employers to hire foreign
workers for purposes other than meeting a skills shortage.
Second, current law allows aU. S. employer to layoff U. s.
workers and replace them with H-1B workers.
Third, current
law allows employers to retain H-1B workers for up to 6 years
to fill a presumably "temporary" need. We simply do not believe
this is right.
The Administration asked the Congress in 1993 to amend
�11
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
the H-1B nonimmigrant program to address these fundamental
structural problems. Unfortunately for many U.S. businesses
and workers, these amendments have not been enacted. The
amendments requested in 1993 were carefully designed to ensure
continued business access to needed high-skills workers in the
international labor market while decreasing the H-1B program's
susceptibility to misuse to the detriment of U.S. workers and
the businesses which employ them.
Briefly stated, the
amendments would.require employers which seek access to
temporary foreign "professional" workers to attest that:
•
they have taken timely and significant steps to recruit
and retain U. S. workers in these occupations'; and
•. they have not laid off or otherwise displaced U.S.
workers in the occupations for which they seek
nonimmigrant workers in the periods immediately
preceding and following their seeking such workers.
In addition, the Administration urged enactment of another
amendment to reduce the allowable period of stay under the H-1B
program from six to three years to better reflect the "temporary"
nature of the presumed employment need.
Enactment of these amendments will help employers actually
facing skills shortages, including those in the IT industry,
obtain needed workers through the H-1B program.
Under existing
law, employers facing skills shortages are disadvantaged
because they must compete for available visas (up to the cap
of 65,000) on a first-come, first-served basis with other
employers that do not face such shortages.
Enactment of the
proposed amendments would reduce pressure on the visa cap by
screening out employers that are not faced with skills shortages
but have no interest in recruiting U.S. workers.
If U.S. employers are to be delegated greater rights to
decide when to import foreign workers to fill jobs in the U. S. ,
then the people have the right to decide under what conditions
such authority should be conveyed.
It simply makes sense that
these conditions include trying first to fill the employment
need from eithin the U.S. labor market, and assuring that U.S.
workers are not removed in order for their jobs to be filled
by foreign temporary workers.
Neither of these simple, common
sense requirements exists in current law.
These Reforms Will NOT Cause Delays
Some employers contend that adding these requirements will
substantially slow down the admission process for foreign
�12
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
temporary workers and add many bureaucratic requirements to
approval of their application for H-1B nonimmigrant workers.
This contention is simply untrue.
The Administration's proposed reforms would add two more
boxes to be checked on the employer's one-page application.
The Labor Department would still be subject to the existing
requirements of law that the application be processed within
seven days and only rejected where incomplete or where there
are "obvious inaccuracies." There would be no new
pre-adjudication process that could cause delays in processing
and approval.
The employer would simply attest that it had
tested the u.s. labor market in attempting to fill the job(s)
qnd that, during certain times, it had not or would not lay
off U.S. workers in the same job.
Employers in the IT sector repeatedly assert that they
search exhaustively in the U.S. labor market to fill open jobs
and that the tight IT labor market does not allow layoff or
displacement of U. S. workers. Accordingly, attesting to these
two common sense reforms would impose no additional burden on
employers in the IT industry.
These Reforms Will NOT Cause Excessive Government Oversight
of Employers' Hiring and Termination Decisions
Some employers contend that these reforms would -- after
the application is approved and the nonimmigrants admitted -subject the employer's hiring and termination decisions to
"second guessing" by the government.
Such decisions are
already subject to review in the context of enforcement of
employment discrimination laws, including the
anti-discrimination provisions of the immigration law.
Employers' authority to import foreign workers is conditional.
There are few impediments to the exercise of this authority
by employers before the approval of the nonimmigrant admission.
Employers' hiring and termination decision-making must be
subj ect to scrutiny after-the- fact.
This scrutiny helps ensure
that the employers are not discriminating against U.S. workers
in favor of hiring foreign temporary workers.
�13
Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
This is a straight-forward law enforcement issue.
Employers that are delegated authority to decide to import
foreign workers need to be accountable for abiding by the
conditions attached; specifically, to give u.s. workers a
legitimate first chance at the jobs for which foreign temporary
workers are being sought.
If the Administration's reforms are not implemented and
the two new attestation elements are not added to the H-1B
program, then the Labor Department will not be able to assure
that the intended purposes of the program are actually served,
regardless of any new enforcement authority granted by Congress.
The H-1B program exists to assure that U. s. employers can access
the international labor market when they cannot find u.s.
workers. Under current law, as the Inspector General has
pointed out, the government is effectively powerless to assure
that employers use the H-1B program for its intended purpose,
and that purpose only.
Conclusion
Mr. Chairman, let me conclude by restating that the growing
workforce needs of the IT industry can only be met -- and the
strength and growth of the industry secured in the long run
-- if we take the steps needed to fully develop and utilize
the skills of U.s. workers.
Increased immigration acts at
cross-purposes with this goal, and therefore can at best only
be a very small part of the solution and must be viewed as a
minor complement to the development of the U.s. workforce.
Further, let me repeat that reform of the H-1B program is
integral and essential to eliminating abuses under the program
and providing appropriate protections for U.s. workers.
Enactment of these reforms would effectively allocate a greater
share of H-1B visas to employers facing actual skills shortages.
I appreciate the interest shown by the Subcommittee and
staff in our views, and your thoughtful consideration of them.
The Department looks forward to continuing to work closely
and cooperatively with you and your staff on these issues.
Mr. Chairman, that .concludes my prepared statement.
would be happy to respond to any questions.
I
�.'
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page I of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-APR-1998 10:06:05.00
SUBJECT:
WtW Formula Plan Update
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Here's latest status of state/tribal plans
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
o 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D211MAIL42379390V.126 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043A9050000010A020100000002050000000D140000000200003960311258273580E4E402
947F7E9C1D703C77E32C67648D006F9DEC68459F00426EA86B9CBE9786CADD904E4133DAE70B53
BB40868141C3417F2FFB3174BAD182CEE58454433BB734CDOCD3CAA52ECD313DD3A88A4E8A20D4
69A6F732142E9CD4D34686433E4FOAA6A6CA4322E3D98D88A95B9FF3262B2F85B7E12E264857F5
F953AA4B74EFB1F71B4EFC089DBA406A41D11F57A8557F3AF2F38429758C418B834620301374CF
5D4DAD555762855AE9B491FA78449675BF4BF7D2FC7B4F7A7FBDA052F2A6DFB8C50D4DF8D1698A
9614EE3104ED862A7E7F04A93CD059D8320CA368A49B2948AEECEECF0747024A3A3148F9CEOA11
A31C1207AFC091F3960D86A9C894F445FCAB45D97676A4C8E7E15326086572BDAE76BD24760EB8
03297FBA34DCA89E3280315D2E8FA8F85D5753CE8155B57AC86747E2BC26725F8387288F072248
9A5593D3B3C089A803EE23C69008B5726015044F8BE13D38A95316B4BE64F1B3FBE250B5FBA87B
62236518E9CF0330A6CC8205EA467971E537CAA8DA9940D1FOFF95131B9D672939E27B39E47C65
AEEDDB5B35AEF9676BF7971E60C95BFC57D1E61895EAFB5B298FCDF543DAB1084F2A4426989C4C
D7D96B14B4BF5B381805C9402F07844BD679B07CF148C45COA15FCA8B96D55894668FA48066B2C
659AA2D14802000D00000000000000000000000823010000000B010000B602000000550COOOOOO
4EOOOOOOC1030000092501000000060000000F0400000B30030000002800000015040000005502
0000003A0000003D04000002080000010031000000770400000055OB00000028000000A8040000
08770100000040000000D004000008340100000014000000100500000802010000000F00000024
05000002080100000032000000330500000B3003000000440000006505000000984C0061007300
�Automated R,
fi, ecorrts Ma
.
eX-Dump CO;:!rse'!lent SYstem
" Ion
Welfare-to-Work Formula Grant Status
5 States announced 1/29/98:
IL, LA,MI,NE,NV
$122 M
2 States announced 2/19:
MA,SC
$33 M
3 States announced 3/2:
KA,HI,MN
$26 M
2 States announced 3/30:
MO,TN
$40 M
1State announced 4/10?:
KY
$18 M
TOTAL TO DATE: 13 states
$240 M
States with pending plans:
AL ($14 M), AR ($8.5), DE ($2.8) -- week of 4/20
GA
CA
RI
MT
CO
NC
WI
$25
$28.4M
$190.4M
$4.4 M
$3.2 M
$9.9 M
$25.3 M
$12.9
TOTAL PENDING: 10 states
$300 M
States indicating they don't plan to apply:
10, UT, OH, SO, WY, MS (DOL discussing further)
$71 M
TRIBAL PLANS
26 approved 3/19
$5.8 M
. 33 approved 4/1
TOTAL TO DATE: 59
As of 4120198
$4.4 M
$10.2M
�, ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 11
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-APR-1998 12:26:46.00
SUBJECT:
LRM #IMS301 - REVISED LABOR Testimony on H1B Nonimmigrant Visa Program and
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@3=GOV+TREAS@S=DO@4=MS01@7=LLR@6=TREASURY@mrx@lngtwy
READ: UNKNOWN
1=US@2=TELEM
TO: dodlrs ( dodlrs @ osdgc.osd.mil [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rachel E. Levinson ( CN=Rachel E. Levinson/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: collins~eter@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY (
READ: UNKNOWN
collins~eter@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY
[ UNKN
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@S=JMD@7=Deborah@6=Clifton@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEMAIL@S=JMD@7=Deb
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ricardo M. Gonzales ( CN=Ricardo M. Gonzales/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=william P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: S. A. Noe ( CN=S. A. Noe/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah G. Horrigan ( CN=Sarah G. Horrigan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Fox ( CN=Charles W. Fox/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�· ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 11
TO: Louisa Koch ( CN=Louisa Koch/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph G. Pipan ( CN=Joseph G. Pipan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ogc_legislation ( ogc_legislation @ ed.gov @inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm ( lrm @ nsf.gov @ inet
READ:UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: lrm ( lrm @ ostp.eop.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ:UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John A. Koskinen
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=John A. Koskinen/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
WHO 1 )
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine M. Tyer ( CN=Katherine M. Tyer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
�· ARMS Email System
Page 3 of 11
TO: Gregory G. Henry ( CN=Gregory G. Henry/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Jo Siclari ( CN=Mary Jo Siclari/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan T. Farley ( CN=Evan T. Farley/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens' ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Darlene o. Gaymon ( CN=Darlene O. Gaymon/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
You will not be receiving a paper copy of this LRM.
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: IMS301
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Monday, April 20, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
FROM:
OMB CONTACT;
James J. Jukes (for) Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
Ingrid M. Schroeder
PHONE: (202) 395-3883 FAX: (202) 395 - 3109
SUBJECT:
REVISED LABOR Testimony on H1B Nonimmigrant Visa Program
and the High Technology Industry
DEADLINE:
3:30pm
Monday, April 20, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: The attached revised testimony was originally circulated under
�· ARMS Email System
Page 4 of 11
LRM #IMS299 on Friday, April 17th.
The testimony is for a hearing
TOMORROW - April 21st.
If we do not hear from you by the above deadline
we will assume that you have no objections to the attached testimony.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - Andrew Fois - (202) 514-2141
114-STATE - Paul Rademacher - (202) 647-4463
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
128-US Trade Representative - Fred Montgomery - (202) 395-3475
95-0ffice of Science and Technology Policy - Jeff Smith - (202) 456-6047
B4-National Science Foundation - Lawrence Rudolph - (703) 306-1060
29-DEFENSE - Samuel T. Brick Jr. - (703) 697-1305
3D-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
11B-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer - (202) 395-5084
EOP:
Debra J. Bond
Larry R. Matlack
Barry White
Barbara Chow
Steven M. Mertens
David J. Haun
Daniel J. Chenok
Joseph G. Pipan
Evan T. Farley
Louisa Koch
Mary Jo Siclari
Charles W. Fox
Gregory G. Henry
Sarah G. Horrigan
Katherine M. Tyer
S. A. Noe
Jack A. Smalligan
Julie A. Fernandes
Elena Kagan
Thomas A. Kalil
Cecilia E. Rouse
Sally Katzen
Peter G. Jacoby
Janet Murguia
Maria Echaveste
Emil E. Parker
Robert N. Weiner
William P. Marshall
John A. Koskinen
Karen Tramontano
Donald H. Gips
Ricardo M. Gonzales
Rebecca M. Blank
Maria J. Hanratty
James C. Murr
LRM ID: IMS301 SUBJECT:
REVISED LABOR
Program and the High Technology Industry
RESPONSE TO
Testimony on HIB Nonimmigrant Visa
�· ARMS Email System
Page 5 of 11
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Ingrid M. Schroeder Phone:
395-3883
Fax:
395-3109
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
STATEMENT OF JOHN R. FRASER
DEPUTY WAGE AND HOUR ADMINISTRATOR
EMPLOYMENT STANDARDS ADMINISTRATION
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF LABOR
BEFORE THE
SUBCOMMITTEE ON IMMIGRATION AND CLAIMS
OF THE HOUSE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE
April 21, 1998
Mr. Chairman and Members of the Subcommittee:
�· ARMS Email System
Page 6 of 11
We appreciate this opportunity to share the views of the
Administration on whether this countryO,s important high-technology
industry should be afforded increased access to temporary foreign workers
to meet its growing demand for highly skilled workers.
In doing so, I
want to again call your attention to the need to strengthen our education
and training system to provide U.S. workers with the opportunity to
acquire the skills needed to compete in our rapidly changing economy and
the need pressing for reform of the H-IB nonimmigrant visa program.
Our information technology (IT) industry is essential to our
continuing strong economic growth and wider prosperity. Our interest in
the industryO,s strength is evidenced by our participation in a recent
convocation in Berkeley that assessed IT work force needs.
Further, as
you know from Administration proposals advanced since 1993, we believe
that the H-IB program needs fundamental reform.
I would like to commend
the Subcommittee for its interest in these issues.
We believe the issue of whether to increase the IT industryO,s
access to temporary foreign workers should be evaluated within the
framework of the following three questions:
(1)
Is there a shortage of skilled U.S. workers to fill jobs in the
IT industry and meet future workforce needs?
(2)
What would be the consequences of raising the annual H-IB cap?
(3)
Does the current H-IB program need to be reformed in order to
provide industry appropriate access to temporary foreign workers while
protecting the job opportunities, wages and working conditions of U.S.
workers?
I will address each of these in turn.
Tight Labor Markets and IT Skills Shortages
Proponents of increasing the annual cap on H-IB visas argue that
this increase is necessary for the IT industry to be able to overcome an
acute shortage of skilled U.S. workers. While there is no dispute that
there is strong growth in demand for workers in the IT industry, it is
much less clear that there is a shortage of skilled U.S. workers to meet
this demand or that the domestic labor market wonO,t be able -0) as it has
over the last decade -0) to satisfy projected job growth.
U.S. employment has been growing rapidly, labor markets are
increasingly tight, and they are likely to remain so.
Though this is true
for the nation as a whole, IT labor markets appear to be particularly
affected.
Employment opportunities for computer systems analysts,
engineers, and scientists have been growing by 10 percent a year 0* well
above the growth of comparable occupations 0* and are expected to
continue growing at a comparable rate through 2006. The Bureau of Labor
Statistics (BLS) predicts that the U.S. will require more than 1.3 million
new workers in IT core occupations between 1996 and 2006 to fill job
openings projected to occur due to growth and· the need to replace workers
who leave the labor force or transfer to other occupations.
The IT skills shortage issue is very controversial.
Some industry
advocates assert that there exist more than three hundred thousand
unfilled jobs within the IT industry, and that these vacancies are raising
business costs and hurting U.S. competitiveness. On the other hand,
critics argue that the IT industry: (1) overstates the problem by
producing inflated job vacancy data and equating it to skills shortages;
(2) continues to layoff tens of thousands of workers (e.g., Intel,
Netscape, Cypress Semiconductor and Silicon Graphics recently announced
large lay-offs); and (3) fails to tap reservoirs of available talent by
insisting on unnecessarily specific job requirements and not providing
more training to develop incumbent workersO, skills.
Equating job vacancies and actual skills shortages is particularly
controversial. While an industry association-sponsored survey indicates
that there may be as many as 350,000 job vacancies in the IT industry, as
you will hear, the General Accounting Office (GAO) has concluded that this
�· ARMS Email System
Page 7 of 11
does not necessarily signal an acute shortage of skilled workers.
In
fact, most industries and firms (particularly those with rapid employment
growth and high worker turnover) will have large numbers of job openings
that do not indicate skills shortages.
While higher than average wage growth can be a reliable indicator
of skill shortages, the wage growth record for the IT industry is mixed.
Though BLS wage trends for broad computer-related categories show only
average wage growth between 1988 and 1997 for all categories, it only
shows above-average wage growth in 1996 and 1997 and only in the
lower-skill computer-related categories, such as programmers. At the same
time, a variety of industry wage surveys show larger wage increases in
1996 and 1997 in specialized, high-skill occupations.
The Commerce DepartmentO,s September 1997 report and the
subsequent GAO evaluation of that report both were inconclusive on the
issue of a shortage of U.S. workers with IT skills and both concluded that
more information and data are needed to understand and properly
characterize the IT labor market.
The Subcommittee should also take into consideration other factors
that bear on the question of the scope and duration of any labor shortage
in the IT industry:
The current O&Year 200008 problem is now occupying thousands of IT workers
for the short-term;
New technologies are being introduced that are creating more efficient
ways to produce software, store and retrieve data, speed up computations,
and generally improve the productivity of the IT work force;
The number of computer science enrollments has risen significantly in the
last two years and nearly three-quarters of all IT workers got their
education in other disciplines.
Consequences of Raising the H-1B Visa CAP
We strongly urge that any decision to raise the H-IB visa cap
carefully consider the possible adverse impact of such a move on the
normal process by which labor markets adjust to a growing demand for
workers.
The labor market should be permitted to adjust to this increased
demand without the introduction of artificial factors (such as increasing
access to temporary foreign workers) that could delay, if not prevent,
these normal market adjustments.
Indeed, the IT labor market has already
begun to respond to the signals of increased demand.
A survey of U.S.
Ph.D. departments of computer science and computer engineering showed
bachelor-level enrollments were up 46% in 1996, and another 39% in 1997
nearly doubling over the two year period (g: does this include foreign
students?) .
It is also important to remember that tight labor markets are good
for U.S. workers. A tight labor market causes employers to raise wages,
improve working conditions, and provide increased training to enable
currently employed workers to keep pace with technology. An increased
demand for trained workers induces educational and job training
institutions to teach new skills. With more opportunities for training,
workers acquire skills needed to obtain better, higher-paying and more
secure jobs, thereby creating open jobs and career ladders for those just
entering or reentering the labor market (e.g., young people, welfare
recipients, displaced workers, and other disadvantaged groups) .
Therefore, tight labor markets create incentives for employers and workers
to react in ways needed to achieve many of the NationO,s top priorities:
moving welfare recipients, out-of-school youth, and dislocated workers
into jobs; providing greater opportunities for lifelong learning; and
raising wages and reducing income inequality.
However, while tight labor markets are good for U.S. workers,
labor markets can sometimes be slow to respond to skills shortages.
In
these circumstances, it is often argued that temporary foreign workers are
needed in the short-term to provide necessary skills while the labor
�· ARMS Email System
Page 8 of 11
market adjusts to provide u.s. workers with the requisite training.
without needed foreign· temporary workers, industries experiencing genuine
skill shortages may adjust in ways that do not serve the short-term or
long-term priorities of the country, either by reducing job creation or by
moving jobs overseas.
Further, because the IT sector is so critical to
our global competitive edge, the u.s. economy could suffer
disproportionate harm if skill shortages do become acute.
Because the expanded use of foreign temporary workers may
interfere with labor market adjustments and may make achieving our other
priorities more difficult, we must make sure that any increase in the
annual number of foreign temporary workers is done with care to ensure
that the use of these foreign temporary workers is responding to a genuine
skill shortage and does not interfere with healthy adjustments in the
labor market.
We must also be cognizant that raising the H-1B cap will almost
certainly increase both legal and illegal immigration. We know that
nearly half of the workers who obtain permanent residency in the us as
employment-based immigrants convert from H-visa nonimmigrant status.
And
according to the INS statistics, nearly one-half of all illegal aliens
resident in the United States are visa over-stayers.
With the attachments
and equity they will form in the U.S. during their nonimmigrant stay of 6
years (or more), one can expect many of the additional H-1B entrants will
eventually join the ranks of visa over-stayers.
The Department of Labor has heard from many concerned individuals
and groups on the issue of the adverse impact on u.S. workers of raising
the annual cap on H-1B visas. I would like to request that copies of the
many letters we have received from these people be included in the record
of todayO,s hearing.
The Administration believes that our first response to meeting the
workforce needs of the IT industry should be to provide the needed skills
to u.S. workers to qualify them for IT jobs.
The Administration already
has taken significant steps to increase our capacity to enhance workforce
skills.
The President continues to pursue comprehensive reform of the
NationO,s employment and training system by working with Congress to enact
the principles embodied in his GI Bill proposal. Moreover, in the
historic balanced budget agreement of last summer, the President insisted
on and achieved the largest increase in 30 years in the Federal investment
to expand the skills of American workers, including:
the largest Pell Grant increase in two decades;
Hope Scholarships to make the first two years of post-secondary education
universally available;
.
the Lifelong Learning Tax Credit for the last 2 years of college and
continuing adult education and training to upgrade worker skills;
a major increase in employment and training resources, inc'luding increases
for dislocated workers and disadvantaged adults and youth; and
a $3 billion program to help long-term welfare recipients secure lasting,
unsubsidized employment.
Further, the Administration announced several new initiatives at
the recent Berkeley Convocation to help address the growing demand for IT
workers:
A Labor Department Technology Demonstration project to test innovative
ways of establishing partnerships between local workforce development
systems, employers, training providers and others to train dislocated
workers in needed high tech skills;
The expansion and integration of AmericaO,s Job Bank and AmericaO,s Talent
Bank to allow employers and workers to list and access job openings and
worker resumes in one integrated system;
The convening of four town hall meetings by the Commerce Department to
discuss IT workforce needs, identify innovative practices, and showcase
successful models; and
�" ARMS Email System
Page 9 of11
In addition, last week President Clinton and Secretary
Herman announced that grants, totaling $1.6 million, are being provided to
projects in four states to continue highly successful programs to train
dislocated workers for high paying jobs in information technology.
Finally, with the Technology Literacy Challenge and related
educational programs, the Administration has put strong emphasis on
effective use of educational technology to strengthen our nationD,s
schools and school-to-work transition.
Linking elementary/secondary
schools, institutions of higher education, and business can produce the
knowledge, know-how, and skills our nationD,s businesses and young people
need in IT. This creates opportunities for busin'ess and ArnericaD, s
students alike. [need more information on this to be able to answer
questions. )
We believe that there is more that can be done to move u.s.
workers into high technology jobs, and we welcome the discussions that may
be sparked by this hearing. We are committed to continuing to pursue a
dialogue with the major stakeholders on this critical workforce issue 0*
government, industry, workers, and education and training institutions 0*
to better define the workforce needs of the IT industry and develop
appropriate solutions to meet these needs domestically through commitments
from each of the stakeholders.
In sum, Mr. Chairman, our assessment of the likely effects of
raising the H-1B cap reconfirms our strong conviction that our primary
public policy response to skills mismatches due to changing technologies
and economic restructuring must be to prepare the u.s. workforce to meet
new demands.
Yet we recognize that short-term demands for skills may
require that we develop a balanced, short-term, response to meet urgent
needs while we actively adjust to rapidly changing circumstances.
However, increased numbers of temporary foreign workers should be the last
0* not the first 0* public policy response to skills shortages.
Given this broader context, let me now turn to the third of the
issues I listed 0* the pressing need for reform of the H-1B nonimmigrant
program.
H-1B Nonimmigrant Program Must be Reformed
The H-1B visa program allows the admission of up to 65,000 workers
each year (to stay for as long as six years), to meet short-term,
high-skills employment needs in the domestic labor market. Temporary visa
programs, like H-1B, are intended to allow employers who are faced with a
domestic skills shortage to have access to temporary foreign workers with
the requisite skills while the domestic labor market makes appropriate
adjustments.
However, there exist serious structural flaws in the current H-1B
program. These flaws are documented in a May 1996 report by the
DepartmentD,s Inspector General (IG).
I would ask the Subcommittee to
accept the IGD,s full report in the record of todayD,s hearing.
The IG found that, despite the legislative intent:
0&.
. the [H-1B) program does not always meet urgent, short-term demand
for highly-skilled, unique individuals who are not available in the
domestic work force.
Instead, it serves as a probationary try-out
employment program for illegal aliens, foreign students, and foreign
visitors to determine if they will be sponsored for permanent status.DS
The IG also found that D&some [H-IB) employers use alien labor to
reduce payroll costs either by paying less than the prevailing wage to
their own alien employees or treating these aliens as independent
contractors, thereby avoiding related payroll and administrative costs.DS
It found, in addition, that D&other [H-IB) employers are D+job shopsD,
whose business is to provide H-1B 'alien contract labor to other
employers.DS The IG concl'uded that the H-1B program does little to
protect the jobs or wage of u.S. workers and it recommended eliminating
�· ARMS Email System
Page 10 ofll
the current program and establishing a new program to fulfill CongressD,
intent.
Employers obtain H-1B workers by simply filing a labor condition
application (LCA) with the Department affirming that they have complied
with four requirements:
that the higher of the local prevailing rate or the wage paid to the
employer's similarly-employed workers will be paid to the foreign workers;
that no strike or lockout exists involving the occupation;
that notification has been provided to U.S. workers or their union; and
that the employment of H-1B nonimmigrants will not adversely affect the
working conditions of U.S. workers similarly employed.
By law, the Labor Department can do no more than review these
attestations for completeness and obvious inaccuracies 0* to determine
whether an employer checked all of the boxes, made no flagrant errors, and
signed the attestation 0* and must do so within 7 days of receipt.
Because current law does not require any test for the availability
of qualified U.S. workers in the domestic labor market, many of the visas
under the current cap of 65,000 can be used by employers to hire foreign
workers for purposes other than meeting a skills shortage.
In addition,
current law allows a U.S. employer to layoff U.S. workers and replace
them with H-1B workers, and allows employers to retain H-1B workers for up
to 6 years to fill a presumably D&temporaryD8 need.
We simply do not
believe this is right.
In 1993 the Administration asked the Congress to amend the H-1B
nonimmigrant program to address these structural problems. Unfortunately
for many U.S. businesses and workers, these amendments have not been
enacted. The amendments requested in 1993 were carefully designed to
ensure continued business access to needed high-skill workers in the
international labor market while decreasing the H-IB programD,s
susceptibility to misuse to the detriment of U.S. workers and the
businesses that employ them. Briefly stated, the amendments would require
employers which seek access to temporary foreign D&professionalDS workers
to also attest that:
they have taken timely and significant steps to recruit and retain U.S.
workers in these occupations; and
they have not laid off or otherwise displaced U.S. workers in the
occupations for which they seek nonimmigrant workers in the periods
immediately preceding and following their seeking such workers.
In addition, the Administration urged enactment of another
amendment to reduce the allowable period of stay under the H-1B program
from six to three years to better reflect the D&temporaryD8 nature of the
presumed employment need.
Enactment of these reforms will help employers actually facing
skills shortages, including those in the IT industry, obtain needed
workers through the H-1B program. Under existing law, employers facing
skills shortages must compete for available visas (up to the cap of
65,000) on a first-come, first-served basis with other employers that do
not face such shortages.
Thus, enactment of the proposed amendments would
reduce pressure on the visa cap by screening out employers that are not
faced with skills shortages and have no interest in recruiting U.S.
workers.
Some employers contend that adding these requirements will
substantially slow down the admission process for foreign temporary
workers and add many bureaucratic requirements to approval of their
application. This contention is simply untrue. The AdministrationD,s
proposed reforms would add two more boxes to be checked on the employerD,s
one-page application. The Labor Department would still be subject to the
existing requirements that the application be processed within seven days
and only rejected where incomplete or where there are D&obvious
inaccuracies.DS There would be no new procedures that could cause delays
�· ARMS Email System
Page 11 of 11
in processing and approval. The employer would simply attest that it had
tested the u.s. labor market in attempting to fill the job(s} and that,
during certain times, it had not or would not layoff u.s. workers in the
same occupation.
Many industry representatives assert that they search exhaustively
in the u.s. labor market to fill open jobs and that the tight IT labor
market does not allow layoff or displacement of u.s. workers.
Accordingly, attesting to these two common sense reforms should impose no
additional burden.
Some employers contend that any attempt to monitor the
truthfulness of these attestations 0* after the application is approved
and the nonimmigrants admitted 0* would subject the employerO,s hiring and
termination decisions to O&second guessing08 by the government.
Such
decisions are already subject to review in the context of enforcement of
employment discrimination laws, including the anti-discrimination
provisions of the immigration laws. Moreover, under existing law,
employersO; authority to import foreign workers is conditional and there
are few impediments to the exercise of this authority by employers before
the approval of the nonimmigrant admission.
Subjecting employersO, hiring
and termination decision-making to scrutiny after-the-fact is the least
burdensome way to ensure that the employers are not discriminating against
u.s. workers in favor of temporary foreign workers.
If the AdministrationO,s reforms are not implemented and the two
new attestation elements are not added to the H-IB program, the Labor
Department will not be able to assure that the intended purposes of the
program are actually served. The H-IB program exists to assure that u.s.
employers can meet short-term labor needs by limited access the
international labor market. Under current law, as the Inspector General
has pointed out, the government is effecti~ely powerless to assure that
employers use the H-IB program for its intended purpose, and that purpose
only.
Conclusion
Mr. Chairman, let me conclude by restating that the growing
workforce needs of the IT industry can only be met 0* and the strength and
growth of the industry secured in the long run 0* if we take the steps
needed to fully develop' and utilize the skills of U. s. workers.
Increased
reliance on temporary foreign workers should, at most, only be a small
part of the solution and must be viewed as a minor complement to the
development of the u.s. workforce.
Further, let me repeat that reform of
the H-IB program is essential to eliminating abuses under the program and
providing appropriate protections for u.s. workers.
Enactment of these
reforms would effectively allocate a greater share of H-IB visas to
employers facing actual skills shortages.
I appreciate the interest shown by the Subcommittee and staff in
our views, and your thoughtful consideration o.f them.
The Department
looks forward to continuing to work closely and cooperatively with you and
your staff on these issues.
Mr. Chairman, that concludes my prepared statement.
I would be
happy to respond to any questions.
�!.
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:22-APR-1998 08:22:21.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: DAlLARD_C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP·[ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C
READ: UNKNOWN
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
·TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�-ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY_MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=SatishNarayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett
READ: UNKNOWN
@
ustr.gov
@
INET
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having the Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting tomorrow, April 23,
at 2:45 in Room 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby ShamirjOU=WHOjO=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:22-APR-1998 18:08:34.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia ApuzzojOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. BlankjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie SpectorjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. HaynesjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha ScottjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. ThorntonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria EchavestejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. CutlerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. GillilandjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra ThurmanjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. WinstonjOU=PIRjO=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin LeedsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. GreenejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet MurguiajOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. SkeltonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. MathewsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon MoorejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner!.OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mindy E. Myers ( CN=Mindy E. Myers/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:00am in room 100. Thanks.
�WithdrawallRedaction Marker
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
AND TYPE
001. email
DATE
SUBJECTffITLE
Mona Mohib to Sandra Thurman et al re Invitation (I page)
04/2311998
RESTRICTION
Personal Misfile
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management System (Email)
CEA ([Kagan])
OAlBox Number: 950000
FOLDER TITLE:
[04/17/1998-04127/1999]
2009-1006-F
kcl84
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act - [44 U.S.C. 2204(a)]
Freedom of Information Act - [5 U.S.C. 552(b))
PI National Security Classified Information [(a)(I) of Ibe PRA]
P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office [(a)(2) of the PRA]
P3 Release would violate a Federal statute [(a)(3) of the PRA]
P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
financial information [(a)(4) of the PRA]
PS Release would disclose confidential advice between the President
and his advisors, or between such advisors [aleS) of the PRA]
P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy [(a)(6) of the PRA]
b(l) National security classified information [(b)(I) of the FOIA]
b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
an agency [(b)(2) of Ibe FOIAj
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute [(b)(3) of the FOIA]
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial
information [(b)(4) of the FOIA]
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy [(b)(6) of the FOIA]
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes [(b)(7) of Ibe FOIA]
b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
financial institutions [(b)(8) of Ibe FOIA]
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
concerning wells [(b)(9) of the FOIA]
c. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's .deed
of gift.
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in -accordance with 44 U.S.C.
2201(3).
RR. Document will be reviewed upon request.
�·-
, ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 10
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:24-APR-1998 15:13:11.00
SUBJECT:
LABOR Testimony on HR2871 A bill to amend the Occupational Safety and Heal
TO: lrm ( lrm @ ostp.eop.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@3=GOV+GSA2@7=GSALEGISLATION@6=GSA2@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEMAIL@3=
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: clrm ( clrm @ doc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: cIa ( cIa @ sba.gov
READ: UNKNOWN
@
inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: oshrc ( oshrc @ oshrc.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah S. Lee ( CN=Sarah S. Lee/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: John Kamensky ( CN=John Kamensky/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin P. Cichetti ( CN=Kevin P. Cichetti/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Derek A. Chapin ( CN=Derek A. Chapin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: CARNEVALE_J@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
CARNEVALE J@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (DON)
TO: ola ( ola @ opm.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: jwedekind ( jwedekind @ nlrb.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�· ARMS Email System
Page 2 oflO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@5=JMD@7=Deborah@6=Clifton@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2=TELEMAIL@5=JMD@7=Deb
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm ( lrm @ os.dhhs.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=william P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry T. Clendenin ( CN=Barry T. Clendenin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patricia S. Haney ( CN=Patricia S. Haney/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John F. Morrall III ( CN=John F. Morrall III/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori Schack ( CN=Lori Schack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
ce:
James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
CC: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 04/24/98
03:06 PM --------------------------Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: MNB151
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Friday, April 24, 1998
�· ARMS Email System
Page 3 of10
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395-6148
LABOR Testimony on HR2871 A bill to amend the Occupational
SUBJECT:
Safety and Health Act of 1970 to provide for the establishment of advisory
panels for the Secretary of Labor.
DEADLINE:
2 p.m.
Monday, April 27, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title.XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: To follow is draft Labor testimony to be delivered the morning
of Wednesday, April 29th before the Workforce Protections Subcommittee of
House Education and the Workforce.
The testimony addresses H.R. 2871, as
well as five other OSHA reform bills pending before the Committee (H.R.
2869, H.R. 2661, H.R. 2873, H.R. 2879, and H.R. 3519)
The deadline is firm.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
94-0ccupational Safety & Health Rev Comm - William J. Gainer - (202)
606-5380
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
61-JUSTICE - Andrew Fois - (202) 514-2141
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
80-National Labor Relations Board - Jeff Wedekind - (202) 273-2910
117 and 340-TRANSPORTATION - Tom Herlihy - (202) 366-4687
51-General Services Administration - William R. Ratchford - (202) 501-0563
92-0ffice of Personnel Management - Harry Wolf - (202) 606-1424
95-0ffice of Science and Technology Policy - Jeff Smith - (202) 456-6047
89-0ffice of National Drug Control Policy - John Carnevale - (202) 395-6736
EOP:
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Lori Schack
Derek A. Chapin
John F. Morrall III
Daniel J. Chenok
Patricia S. Haney
Kevin P. Cichetti
Barry T. Clendenin
Richard J. Turman
Emil E. Parker
David J. Haun
John E. Thompson
John Kamensky
OMB LA
�· ARMS Email System
Page 4 of 10
Kate P. Donovan
Sarah S. Lee
Elena Kagan
Karen Tramontano
William P. Marshall
Robert G. Damus
Sanders D. Korenman
Janet R. Forsgren
James C. Murr
LRM ID: MNB151 SUBJECT:
LABOR Testimony on HR2871 A bill to amend the
Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 to provide for the
establishment of advisory panels for the Secretary of Labor.
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call; please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:,
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
_______ No
Obje~tion
_______ No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
�• ARMS Email System
STATEMENT OF
OCCUPATIONAL
BEFORE THE
COMMITTEE ON
SUBCOMMITTEE
Page 5 of 10
ASSISTANT SECRETARY CHARLES JEFFRESS
SAFETY AND HEALTH ADMINISTRATION
EDUCATION AND THE WORKFORCE
ON WORKFORCE PROTECTIONS
UNITED STATES HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
APRIL 29, 1998
Mr. Chairman and Members of the Subcommittee:
Thank you for inviting me to testify about several proposals to
amend the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970.
I appreciate the
opportunity to express the views of the Occupational Safety and Health
Administration on H.R. 2869, 2661, 2871, 2873, 2879 and 3519. Mr.
Chairman, although we have known each other for many years and I
previously testified before you as head of North Carolina OSHA, this is my
first appearance before your subcommittee since my confirmation as OSHAD,s
Assistant Secretary.
I have appreciated your overtures to me and your
willingness to discuss OSHAD,s concerns about various OSHA reform
proposals.
I was glad to return those overtures and to join you in
supporting the passage of two earlier bills, H.R. 2864 'and 2877.
OSHAD,s core mission is to ensure a safe and healthy workplace for
every working man and woman in the Nation. We are making progress; the
Bureau of Labor Statistics announced last December that the rate of worker
injuries and illnesses was at 7.4 per 100 workers, the lowest point in the
history of the BLS occupational injury and illness survey.
But more must
be done to protect our NationD,s workers.
The Nation still suffers
approximately 7,000 fatalities per year from safety hazards and 50-60,000
fatalities from occupational disease. At the same time, we seek methods
that avoid placing unnecessary burdens on employers.
Through reinvention,
OSHA is developing new strategies that leverage the agencyD,s limited
resources and, in many cases, re-shape how OSHA interacts with employers
and workers to promote safe and healthy work environments.
The New OSHA
OSHA is changing the way it does business.
It has been three
years since President Clinton announced'the D&New OSHAD8 initiative.
Since then, we have developed a broad range of partnership programs that
promote cooperative efforts between employers, workers and government. We
are making enforcement programs smarter and fairer by spending more time
at the most hazardous workplaces and less time at safer ones. We are
treating responsible employers differently than neglectful ones.
OSHA is
simplifying standards by rewriting them in plain language, using
performance-based approaches wherever possible.
WeD,re focusing less on
individual, technical violations, and more on systematic approaches that
allow workers and employers to find and fix hazards on an ongoing basis.
And finally, weD,re measuring results, where possible, not by numbers of
citations or penalties, but by real improvements in the lives of working
people, such as reduced injury and illness rates.
I would like to express my appreciation to you, Mr. Chairman, and
to the rest of the Committee for your cooperative spirit during my short
tenure with OSHA.
I was pleased that we could reach compromises on H.R.
2864 and 2877, OSHA reform bills that you recently passed in the House.
However, while I appreciate your interest in working together on
OSHA-related legislation, I regret that we are unlikely to find common
�· ARMS Email System
Page 6 of 10
ground on the proposals on the subcommitteeD,s agenda today.
In OSHAD,s
view, the bills to be discussed today are either unnecessary or would
undermine OSHAD,s ability to protect workers.
H.R. 2869 -- Excluding Employer Audits from Discovery
H.R. 2869 would create an evidentiary privilege for employer self-audit
documents.
This extremely broad privilege would vastly complicate OSHA
enforcement.
It would force the agency to arrive at conclusions about
workplace hazards and accidents without critical information from safety
professionals and consultants with firsthand knowledge.
In many cases,
particularly in fatality and catastrophe investigations, self-audit
records and reports are the most reliable, and often the only means of
establishing the facts.
Under such circumstances, OSHA needs the ability
to gather all the information it can to explain why these accidents
happened and to help prevent them from happening again.
The fact that the bill contains an exception for "safety and
health assessments prescribed under section 6(b) (7)" of the OSH Act does
little to ameliorate the billD,s harmful effects on enforcement of OSHA
requirements. That section of the Act specifically addresses only a
limited class of requirements dealing with medical surveillance and
exposure monitoring, so the bill would leave the vast majority of
workplace health and safety assessments required by OSHA rules off-limits
to scrutiny by OSHA, the Review Commission and the courts. Furthermore,
many of OSHAD,s audit requirements are expressed in general,
performance-oriented terms, making it difficult if not impossible to
discern the line between mandatory and voluntary audit activity,
especially in workplaces administered by conscientious employers.
Finally, OSHA is required to demonstrate employer knowledge of a cited
hazard, and is required, in proposing penalties, to ascertain the extent
of an employerD,s good faith, inquiries which cannot fairly be resolved
without access to the very records which document knowledge and good
faith. .
.
Contrary to the belief of many businesses, disclosure of self
audit documents generally benefits good faith employers.
OSHA provides
penalty reductions where employers who receive citations have acted in
good faith to try and correct deficiencies identified in an audit.
For
example, in a hypothetical small muffler shop the owner keeps his mufflers
in a storage loft, but the loft does not have a railing. While conducting
a self audit, the employer discovers that the loft poses a serious fall
hazard to his employees. As a result, he moves the mufflers as far away
from the ledge as possible and puts cones along the ledge. When an OSHA
compliance officer comes to inspect this muffler shop, he immediately
spots the fall hazard: Under ordinary circumstances, failure to install a
guardrail would result in a $5,000 fine.
In this case, however, the
employer would receive a credit worth $3,875.
This is because, through
the self-audit documents, the employer can show that he acted in good
faith and that he did do something to try to reduce the likelihood of
injury to his employees.
If this small business has no history of serious
violations,
the $5,000 penalty would ultimately be reduced to $75.
The proposed evidentiary privilege would protect only bad actors
-- employers who have identified hazards, have failed to make good faith
efforts to correct them, and wish to hide the evidence.
H.R. 2661 and H.R. 2781 -- Additional Scientific and Economic Peer Review
H.R. 2661 and 2871 would both require the Secretary to create an
advisory panel to review scientific and economic data every time OSHA
proposes a new standard.
H.R. 2871 provides an exception where the
standard has been promulgated through negotiated rulemaking.
This
additional committee is unnecessary, duplicative and would create serious
delays in our rulemaking process -- a process that many already criticize
�· ARMS Email System
Page 7 of 10
as taking too long.
Today, major rules typically take as many as eight years to
publish.
In the meantime, workers are exposed to hazards every day.
During that time, OSHA has a variety of obligations:
engage in notice and
comment rulemaking; conduct economic and risk analyses; assess impact on
small businesses and, depending upon that impact, convene a small business
panel under the Small Business Regulatory Enforcement Fairness Act; survey
industries; and do extensive review of research on selected topics.
When
OSHA issues a proposal, the agency also engages in a rigorous public
hearing process. On standards where peer review of a part of the
supporting material is necessary, a peer review has been done.
For
example, the risk assessment for tuberculosis was peer reviewed.
Once the
proposed standard is published in the Federal Register, any interested
party can comment upon the standard itself as well as the underlying
scientific and economic data.
OSHAD,s public hearings allow for the fullest, most thorough
discourse on every subject relevant to a rule.
They provide the greatest
possible public access to the process -- scientists, economists, safety
and health professionals, representatives of potentially affected
industries and any other interested parties may and do participate. At
public hearings, interested parties can submit testimony and evidence,
cross examine OSHA experts and engage in debate with other participants.
For example, OSHA just completed nine days of hearings last week on the
agencyD,s proposed standard on occupational exposure to Tuberculosis.
Scientists and economists always present new data and test each otherD,s
theories through questioning and comment, a process from which OSHA has
gained valuable information. The entire discussion is conducted in full
public view, and enables participants to challenge one anotherD,s
positions.
Public hearings are often held around the country to make it
easier for interested parties to attend.
I invite members of this
committee to come attend one of our hearings and observe this critical
process in action.
A new committee, like the ones proposed in H.R. 2661 and 2871,
would provide selected persons an additional closed-door opportunity to
influence rulemaking after the public process is complete.
This would
give the committee members an unfair advantage.
In addition, the closed
nature of the committee proceedings would prevent the public from a full
and fair discussion on their rationale and decisions.
The billD,s failure
to require disclosure from this committee makes its already unnecessary
contribution suspect as well.
The President, consistent with Executive Order 12838 and the
National Performance Review, has asked Congress to show restraint in the
creation of new statutory committees.
In the interest of promulgating
rules that will best protect workers, this is an appropriate time to
exercise that restraint.
H.R. 2873 -- Risk Assessment and Cost-Benefit Analyses for Every Industry
H.R. 2873 would require OSHA to conduct an individual risk assessment and
cost-benefit analysis for each industry affected by a proposed standard.
OSHA cannot base its health standards on cost-benefit analyses and is
required by law to reduce significant risk to the extent feasible.
However, OSHA agrees that comprehensive and accurate risk assessments and
economic analyses are valuable informational tools, and devotes
considerable effort to making these documents clear and methodologically
sound.
For each rule, the Agency already conducts detailed risk
assessments, develops extensive significance-of-risk analyses,
demonstrates technological and economic feasibility,
evaluates benefits,
and assesses impacts (including small business impacts). Cost estimates
and feasibility analyses are commonly conducted at the industry level,
because data on the technological and financial status of each industry
�ARMS Email System
Page 8 of 10
that reflect real conditions in that industry are usually publicly
available. However, it is rarely the case that industry-specific data on
risk are available; even where such data are available, they generally
cannot be used to produce statistically meaningful results. Because
industry-specific risk data are not available, it is not possible to
develop industry-specific benefits analyses.
H.R. 2879 -- Limiting Liability at Multi-Employer Worksites
H.R. 2879 would limit the liability of certain employers, particularly
general contractors in the construction industry, at mUlti-employer
worksites. This bill would prohibit OSHA from citing an employer for a
violation if the employer has no employees exposed to the hazard and has
neither created the hazard nor assumed responsibility for ensuring that
the other employers at the worksite comply. This would create an
incentive for general contractors to give up their authority to ensure
that subcontractors comply with safety standards.
If we encourage the
employers in the best position to enhance workplace safety to reduce their
authority, workers will pay the price.
First, let me clear up some misunderstandings about liability
under the OSH· Act.
The OSH Act holds all employers responsible for
hazards under their control regardless of which employees are exposed.
Some employers have misconstrued our policy as limiting the liability of
the subcontractor by holding the general contractor liable instead.
This
is not the case. We do hold the subcontractor liable.
Where a general
contractor has failed to exercise due diligence in meeting its
responsibility, we then hold the general contractor liable as well.
That
way, we can ensure that both the subcontractor and the general contractor
have the incentive to coordinate their efforts in keeping the workers on
the site safe.
OSHAD,s mUlti-employer worksite policy reflects court decisions
that involved very serious accidents; workers were getting killed because
general contractors and subcontractors failed to coordinate their
responsibilities for ensuring worker safety and health.
The tragedy that
occurred at LD,Ambiance Plaza in Connecticut is a prime-example of the
origins of our rule.
In that case, 28 workers were killed when a high
rise under construction collapsed through the error of one
subcontractor.
Workers from several subcontractors were killed.
Where one subcontractor creates a hazard for the employees of
another subcontractor, only the general contractor may be in the best
position to get the problem corrected.
Just as general contractors have
the ultimate supervisory power of all other aspects of the work, the best
way to protect all of the workers at a particular site is for the general
contractor to have overall responsibility for coordinating efforts for
worker safety and health as well.
Under the case law, the liability of general contractors is not
absolute, but depends on the circumstances of the case.
Further limiting
the liability of the general contractor would be a step backward. None of
us wants to revisit the tragedies of the past.
In our experience, this
has proven the most effective method in reducing injuries and fatalities
at mUlti-employer worksites. The bottom line is that we need all of the
contractors to work together to make multi-employer worksites safe.
In
order to ensure the safety and health of the employees of both the general
contractor and the subcontractors we cannot limit the responsibility of
either.
H.R. 3519
Standard and Electronic MSDSD,s
H.R. 3519 proposes to amend the OSH Act to require electronic access to
Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDSD,s).
The bill would also require OSHA
to modify its Hazard Communication Standard (29 CFR 1910.1200) to require
a standard format for MSDSD,s.
These proposals are well intentioned, and
�· ARMS Email System
Page 9 of 10
OSHA is working along parallel lines. However, we believe that
legislation is unnecessary and unwise at this time.
OSHA supports allowing employers to provide their workers with
electronic access to MSDSD,s.
In fact, OSHA has allowed such electronic
access for some time. However, there has been confusion in some quarters
about OSHAD,s policy regarding electronic access.
consequently, OSHA
issued a new compliance directive clarifying the agencyD,s policy at
approximately the same time this bill was introduced.
Since the bill and
the modified compliance directive presumably were being drafted
simultaneously, it is entirely possible that the billD,s authors were
unaware of the impending clarification.
OSHA assumes that the
clarification should address the authorsD, concerns.
In the event the
subcommittee feels that additional action by OSHA is necessary to get the
word out, we are prepared to work with you to increase awareness.
The standardization of MSDSD,s is appealing.
In fact, OSHA is
participating in international discussions on how MSDSD,s might be
standardized. However, standardization is premature.
It is also more
difficult than it sounds.
MSDSD,s have a variety of users, with varying backgrounds and
needs. While workers have access to them and have a right to know the
information they contain, MSDSD,s are also used by physicians, nurses,
industrial hygienists, safety engineers, toxicologists, firefighters,
emergency responders, and others.
Because MSDSD,s serve such a broad
function, the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) developed a
consensus standard that recognizes the diversity of the MSDS audience by
requiring certain information that is of most use to workers to be placed
in the beginning of the document, and stated in simple language. ANSI
developed this "order of information" after extensive discussions with
experts revealed that there is no real consensus on how an MSDS should be
presented.
There is an ongoing and extensive international effort to
harmonize hazard communication requirements for hazard classification,
labeling, and material safety data sheets. OSHA has participated in this
effort for many years.
The ANSI "order of information" may be part of a
globally harmonized system by the year 2000. Therefore, OSHA believes the
wisest course is to wait until that system is complete before modifying
our hazard· communication standard.
It is far better to standardize
consistent with an internationally accepted approach, both from a worker
protection standpoint and trade perspective.
If Congress were to mandate
a change at this point, u.S. manufacturers would be required to change
their MSDSD,s in the short term, and then again in a few years.
This
would be costly for business and would have little benefit for workers.
Protecting Workers Better
Mr. Chairman,
there are a variety of ways to strengthen the
protection provided to workers under the OSH Act. We would, for example,
support legislation that strengthens the whistleblower protections of the
OSH Act.
It is fundamental that workers must feel free to inform their
employer or the government when dangerous working conditions threaten
their life or safety.
There is a good deal of evidence, however, that
many employees do not feel free to complain about unsafe conditions and
that too many employers feel they can retaliate against whistleblowers
with impunity. The provisions in place today in section ll(c) of the Act
are too weak and too cumbersome to discourage employer retaliation or to
provide an effective remedy for the victims of retaliation. A recent
report of the Inspector General of the Department of Labor found that
D&whistleblowersD8 frequently face retaliation for exposing unsafe or
unhealthy working conditions. A nurse at Skyline Terrace Nursing Home,
for example, complained about the homeD,s lack of gloves, which are
required to protect employees from bloodborne pathogens.
Four days after
�- ARMS Email System
Page 10 of 10
an inspection, ·she was fired in retaliation for the complaint. Another
company, Hahner, Foreman & Harness, Inc., fired an employee for refusing
to go up in a gondola three or four stories above the ground. The gondola
had been malfunctioning and the employee believed it to be unsafe.
When
the employee refused to risk his safety, his superintendent instructed him
that if he did not go back up into the malfunctioning gondola, somebody
else would.
He was fired for his refusal.
If you wish to strengthen the
safety and health protection available to workers, I suggest this as a
place to begin.
In North Carolina in 1993, the state legislature took several
steps that greatly strengthened whistleblower protections after the Hamlet
fire revealed the flaws in our State Plan.
The changes included a longer
statute of limitations, a private right of action and a provision for
treble damages.
I believe these changes have played an important part in
the progress North Carolina has made in reducing injury, illness and
fatality rates over the last five years.
In addition, the OSH Act does not effectively protect federal,
state and local employees (maintenance workers, construction workers,
firefighters, etc.). Consequently, with the exception of the few states
that actively provide public sector coverage, OSHA has little ability to
require positive change on the part of public employers. As a
consequence, this limited authority hinders OSHAO,s success in reducing
illness, injuries and fatalities on the job.
There are numerous examples of on-the-job tragedies that occurred
primarily because safety and health protections do not apply to public
employees.
These tragedies could have been prevented by compliance with
OSHA rules.
In addition, studies have shown that the overall cost of
providing OSH Act coverage for these employees is small, especially
compared with the amount of money which would be saved by reducing the
cost of worker injuries.
A third option for deterring action that places workers at risk is
increasing the criminal penalty for an employer whose willful conduct
causes the death of an employee. We would urge that these violations not
be classified as misdemeanors, but felonies.
We believe that the
possibility of incarceration for periods in excess of one year would serve
as a more effective deterrent to employers who would risk the safety and
health of their employees. The current classification for willful
workplace safety and health violations that lead to an employeeO,s death
are woefully inadequate to address the harm caused.
Classifying such
crimes as felonies would more justly reflect the severity of the offense.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the bills before us today would take us in the
wrong direction.
Prohibiting OSHA from gathering necessary information,
adding redundant and burdensome layers to our rulemaking process and
limiting employer liability is not the way to protect the working men and
women of this country.
Again, let me reiterate my appreciation for this
opportunity to testify before you today.
I look forward to continuing our
dialogue in our effort to improve OSHAO,s contribution to the safety and
health of American workers.
�,. ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-APR-1998 12:09:43.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to NY
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
.TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of5
" ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno { CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�, ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�,,, ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU 7 WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Tomorrow, Tuesday, April 28, 1998, the President will travel to New York
City to attend a DSCC dinner. Deadlines for the President's trip book are
as follows:
Background Memos:
DUE TODAY AT 6:00 P.M.
�'" ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
Political Memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Economic One-Pager
Accomplishments
Event Memos:
DUE TODAY AT 6:00 P.M.
DSCC Dinner
please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�'.
Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-APR-1998 13:54:42.00
SUBJECT:
LRM MNB 151--Labor testimony on OSHA Reform legislation
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=william P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Kamensky ( CN=John Kamensky/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David J. Haun ( CN=David J. Haun/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patricia S. Haney ( CN=Patricia S. Haney/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John F. Morrall III ( CN=John F. Morrall III/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
fo:
Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Derek A. Chapin ( CN=Derek A. Chapin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet R. Forsgren (. CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This is a reminder that your comments on the subject LRM are due at 2 p.m.
TODAY.
Please provide any comments to me by that time.
If I do not hear from
you, I will assume no comment and will proceed with clearing the testimony.
�ARMS Email System
Please call (5-7887) or e-mail if you have any questions.
Page 2 of 2
Thanks!
�.' ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page I of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton!OU=OMB!O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE!TIME:27-APR-1998 14:56:46.00
SUBJECT:
LRM MNB 150--Labor (BLS) testimony on Revision of the Consumer Price Index
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker!OU=OPD!O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Anderson ( CN=Robert B. Anderson!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Theodore Wartell ( CN=Theodore Wartell!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. Carroll!OU=CEA!O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard P. Emery Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Richard P. Emery Jr.!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark D. Menchik ( CN=Mark D. Menchik!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan!OU=OPD!O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald R. Arbuckle ( CN=Donald R. Arbuckle!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren!OU=OMB!O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This is a reminder that your comments on the subject LRM are due at 3 p.m.
today.
Please provide any comments by that time.
If I do not hear from you, I
will assume you have no comments on the testimony.
�.• ARMS Email System
please call (5-7887) or e-mail if you have any questions.
Page 2 of2
Thanks!
�(ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 12
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-APR-1998 18:22:47.00
SUBJECT:
LRM #IMS 309 - HIB Temporary Immigrant Visa Program Reforms
TO: lrm@nsf.gov ( lrm@nsf.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lrm@os.dhhs.gov ( lrm@os.dhhs.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: blue_gloria@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: clrm@doc.gov (
READ: UNKNOWN
clrm@doc.go~
blue_gloria@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN
@ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@S=JMD@7=Deborah@6=Clifton@mrx@lngtwy ( I=US@2=TELEMAIL@S=JMD@7=Deb
READ: UNKNOWN
'
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ricardo M. Gonzales ( CN=Ricardo M. Gonzales/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=William P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles M. Brain ( CN=Charles M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine M. Tyer ( CN=Katherine M. Tyer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gregory G. Henry ( CN=Gregory G. Henry/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Jo Siclari ( CN=Mary Jo Siclari/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of12
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald L. Silberman ( CN;Ronald L. Silberman/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan T. Farley ( CN;Evan T. Farley/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN;Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN;Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ogc_legislation@ed.gov ( ogc_legislation@ed.gov @inet
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: dodlrs@osdgc.osd.mil
READ:UNKNOWN
dodlrs@osdgc.osd.mil @ inet
TO: collins-peter@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 }
collins-peter@ustr.gov@INET@VAXGTWY [ UNKN
TO: US@2=TELEMAIL@3=GOV+TREAS@S=DO@4=MS01@7;LLR@6;TREASURY@mrx@lngtwy ( 1=US@2;TELEM
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: dol-sol-leg@dol.gov ( dol-sol-leg@dol.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James C. Murr ( CN;James C. Murr/OU;OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN;Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O;EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU;WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN;Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN;Maria Echaveste/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Broderick Johnson ( CN;Broderick Johnson/OU;WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN;Sally Katzen/OU;OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN;Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 3 of12
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: S .. A. Noe ( CN=S. A. Noe/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah G. Horrigan ( CN=Sarah G. Horrigan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Fox
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Charles W. Fox/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Louisa Koch ( CN=Louisa Koch/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph G. Pipan ( CN=Joseph G. Pipan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Darlene O. Gaymon ( CN=Darlene O. Gaymon/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
You will not receive a paper copy of this LRM.
Total Pages:
LRM ID: IMS309
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Monday, April 27, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
OMB CONTACT:
SUBJECT:
DEADLINE:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
James J. Jukes (for) Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
'Ingrid M. Schroeder
PHONE: (202) 395-3883 FAX: (202) 395-3109
HIB Temporary Immigrant Visa Program Reforms
COB
Tuesday, April 28, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of12
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: This document is intended to be characterized as an
Administration offer during discussions with Members of Congress this week.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
61-JUSTICE - Ann Harkins - (202) 514-2141
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
. 118-TREASURY - Richard S. Carro - (202) 622-0650
128-US Trade Representative - Fred Montgomery - (202) 395-3475
52-HHS - Sondra S. wallace - (202) 690-7760
29-DEFENSE - Samuel T. Brick Jr. - (703) 697-1305
84-National Science Foundation - Lawrence Rudolph - (703) 306-1060
95-0ffice of Science and Technology Policy - Jeff Smith - (202) 456-6047
114-STATE - Paul Rademacher - (202) 647-4463
30-EDUCATION - Jack Kristy - (202) 401-8313
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer - (202) 395-5084
EOP:
Debra J. Bond
Larry R. Matlack
Barry White
Barbara Chow
Sandra Yamin
Steven M. Mertens
Daniel J. Chenok
Evan T. Farley
Joseph G. Pipan
Ronald L. Silberman
Louisa Koch
Mary Jo Siclari
Charles W. Fox
Gregory G. Henry
Sarah G. Horrigan
Katherine M. Tyer
S. A. Noe
Jack A. Smalligan
Julie A. Fernandes
Elena Kagan
Thomas A. Kalil
Cecilia E. Rouse
Sally Katzen
Gene B. -Sperling
Peter G. Jacoby
Janet Murguia
Broderick Johnson
Charles M. Brain
Maria Echaveste
Emil E. Parker
Robert N. Weiner
William P. Marshall
Karen Tramontano
Ricardo M. Gonzales
Rebecca M. Blank
Maria J. Hanratty
�Page 5 of12
ARMS Email System
James C. Murr
LRM ID: IMS309
SUBJECT:
H1B Temporary Immigrant Visa Program Reforms
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Fax:
395-3109
395-3883
Ingrid M. Schroeder Phone:
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The followi~g is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
April 27, 1998
Draft Proposals Regarding Reform to the H-1B Visa Program
The Administration has. committed to pursuing both reforms to the H-1B visa
program and increased training opportunities for U.S. workers as part of
any legislation that would temporarily raise the annual cap on H-1B
visas. The following are some draft proposals for reform of the H-1B visa
program.
�ARMS Email System
Page 6 of12
I.
Recruitment and Non-displacement of United States Workers Prior
to Seeking Nonimmigrant Workers
(a) IN GENERAL -- Section 2l2(n) (l)of the Immigration and Nationality Act
(8 U.S.C. ll82(n) (l)) is amended by inserting at the end the following new
subparagraph:
(E) (I) The employer, prior to filing the application, has taken good
faith, timely and significant steps to recruit and retain sufficient U.S.
workers in the specialty occupation in which the non-immigrant whose
services are being sought will be employed. Good faith steps to recruit
and retain shall be defined as:
(a)
the employer taking the following two actions in a manner
reasonably designed to recruit and retain U.S. workers:
(i)
widespread advertising of the relevant job openings to both
current and prospective employees (e.g., through AmericaO,s Job Bank,
participation in job fairs, the Internet, employer newsletters and
electronic communications, general circulation publications, professional
journals and magazines); and
(ii)
offering meaningful monetary incentives to applicants (such as
paying above the prevailing wage, paying bonuses, or providing stock
options) above those already included in the base compensation package; or
offering training subsidies, or a training program, that provides the
means for its current employees to enhance their skills to qualify for
jobs in the specialty occupation in which the nonimmigrant will be (or is)
employed; and
(b)
The employer did not receive applications from any U.S worker
with at least substantially equivalent qualifications and experience to
the temporary foreign worker offered employment; or (ii) offered
employment to a U.S. worker with at least substantially equivalent
qualifications and experience to the temporary foreign worker offered
employment, but the offer of employment to the U.S. worker was refused;
and
(c)
Offering compensation at least at the amount required by
subparagraph (A).
(E) (II) The recruitment requirements of this subparagraph shall not
apply to aliens with extraordinary ability, aliens who are outstanding
professors and researchers, and certain multinational executives and
managers described in section 203(b) (l).
The recruitment requirements of
this subparagraph shall also not apply to a scientist, mathematician, or
engineer who has attained at least a masterO,s degree or its equivalent in
a scientific or engineering discipline, and who is coming temporarily to
the United States to participate in a cooperative joint scientific
activity carried out under an Agreement between the Federal Government and
the alienO,s Government.
(F) (I) The employer
(a)
has not and will not -- within the 90-day period immediately
preceding and the 90-day period immediately following the filing of the
application, and within the 90-day period immediately preceding and the
�ARMS Email System
90-day period immediately following the filing of any visa petition
supported by the application -- layoff or otherwise displace any united
States worker, including a worker obtained by contract, employee leasing,
temporary help agreements, or otherwise displace any United States worker,
including a worker obtained by contract, employee leasing, temporary help
agreement, or other similar basis, who has substantially equivalent
qualifications and experience in the specialty occupation in which the
nonimmigrant will be (or is) employed; and
(F) (II) For purposes of this subparagraph, the term O&laid off. 08
with respect to an employee, means the employeeO,s loss of employment,
other than a discharge for cause or a voluntary departure or voluntary
retirement.
The term O&laid off 08 does not apply to any case in which
employment is relocated to a different geographic area and the affected
employee is offered a chance to move to the new location with the same
wages and benefits, but elects not to move to the new location.
(G)
The employer offered compensation as required by subparagraph
(A) .
(b)
For purposes of this subsection, the term O&United States worker08
means
(I)
a citizen or national of the United States
(II)
an alien lawfully admitted to the United States for
permanent residence; or
(III)
an alien authorized to be employed by this Act or by
the Attorney General.
II.
Wage Comparability
Section 212 (n) (I) (A) (I) of such Act is amended by inserting 0& (including
the value of benefits and additional compensation}08 after 0&wages.08
Section 212 (n) (I) (A) (I) (I) is amended by inserting 0& (including the value
of benefits and additional compensation}08 after O&actual wage level.08
III.
Job Contractors
In the case of an employer that is a job contractor (within the meaning of
regulations promulgated by the secretary of Labor to carry out this
subsection), the contractor will not place any H-IB employee with another
employer unless such other employer has executed an attestation that the
employer is complying and will continue to comply with the requirements of
this paragraph in the same manner as they apply to the job contractor.
IV.
Enforcement
(a)
Independent Authority to Investigate
Section 212(n} of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1182(n)}
is amended -(I)
in paragraph (2) (A), by striking the first sentence and
inserting the following:
O&The Secretary may conduct investigations pursuant to a complaint or,
absent a complaint, where the Secretary has reasonable cause to believe
that:
(a)
there is a pattern or practice of: complaints by U.S. workers
Page 7 of12
�ARMS Email System
Page 8 of 12
against the employer; unsuccessful recruitment by the employer; or
violations by the employer;
(b)
the employerD,s U.S. workforce is comprised of more than 10%
nonimmigrant workers or the employer is making application that would
result in more than 10% nonimmigrant workers in its u.S. workforce;
(c)
an employer has laid off or otherwise displaced more than 10%
of its u.S. workforce or 100 U.S. workers (whichever is fewer) in anyone
year period (or has announced the intent to make such a lay-off) .
The Secretary shall establish a process for the receipt, investigation,
and disposition of complaints or other cases of noncompliance with this
section.DB
(II)
in paragraph (2) (C), by inserting 0&, or that the employer
failed to cooperate in the conduct of the SecretaryD,s investigation or
has intimidated, discharged, or otherwise discriminated against any person
because that person has asserted a right or has cooperated in an
investigation under this paragraphDB after D&a material fact in an
application.DB
(III)
in paragraph (2), by adding at the end the following new
subparagraph:
D&(E) The Secretary may issue subpoenas requiring the attendance and
testimony of witnesses or the production of any records, books, papers, or
documents in connection with any investigation or hearing, conducted-under
this paragraph.
In conducting a hearing, the Secretary may administer
oaths, examine witnesses, and receive evidence.
For the purpose of any
hearing or investigation provided for in this paragraph, the authority
contained in sections 9 and 10 of the Federal Trade Commission Act (15
U.S.C. 49 and 50), relating to the attendance of witnesses and the
production of books, papers, and documents, shall apply.DB
V.
Sanctions
section 212(n) (2) (C) is amended to read:
D&If the Secretary finds, after notice and opportunity for a hearing, a
failure to meet a condition of paragraph (1) (B); a substantial failure to
meet a condition of paragraphs (1) (C) or (1) (D); a willful failure to meet
a condition of paragraph (1) (A); a violation(s) of paragraphs (1) (E) or
(1) (F) that is willful, or reflects a pattern or practice of violations,
or is a violation that affects a significant number of individuals; or a
misrepresentation of a material fact in the application (but any misrepre
sentation of a material fact relating to paragraphs (1) (E) or (1) (F) must
be willful, or reflects a pattern or practice of
violations, or is a violation that affects a significant number of
individuals) 0*
(i)
the Secretary shall notify the Attorney General of such
finding and may, in addition, impose such other administrative remedies
(including civil monetary penalties in an amount not to exceed $5,000 per
violation) as the Secretary determines to be appropriate, DB
VI.
Application Fee
Section 212(n) of the Immigration and Nationality Act
(8 USC 1182(n)) is
�Page 9 of12
ARMS Email System
amended by adding the following new paragraph:
0& (3) (A)
The Secretary of Labor shall establish, by regulation, a fee to
be paid by an employer for each position for which an application is filed
for certification of a nonimmigrant. temporary worker under section
101 (a) (15) (H) (i) (b) and (c).
(B)
The fee shall be set at a level that --
(i)
will ensure recovery of the full costs of providing adjudication and
application services; and,
(ii)
finances activities authorized under Section
Industry Special Skills Training Fund) .
xxxxx
(the Regional and
(C)
During the period ending September 30, 2001, such a fee shall not
exceed $250 for each posi~ion.
(D)
(i)
It shall be unlawful for an employer to require, as a
condition of employment by such employer, that the fee prescribed under
this paragraph or any part of the fee be paid directly or indirectly by
the alien whose services are being sought.
(ii) Any person or entity that is determined, after notice and
opportunity for an administrative hearing, to have violated clause (I)
shall be subject to a civil penalty of $5,000 for each violation, to an
administrative order requiring the payment of any fee described in this
paragraph, and the disqualification for one year from petitioning for
temporary nonimmigrant workers under this subsection.
(iii) Any amount determined to have been paid, directly or indirectly,
toward the filing fee described in paragraph (3) (A) by the alien whose
services were sought, shall be repaid by the employer to such alien.
(E)
Notwithstanding any other provision of law, all fees, as described in
this paragraph as are designated by the Secretary of Labor in regulations
shall be deposited as offsetting receipts into a separate account entitled
O&Temporary Worker Fee Account08 in the Treasury of the United States.
All deposits into the O&Temporary Worker Fee Account08 shall remain
available until expended by the Secretary to reimburse any appropriation
for expenses related to activities described in subparagraph (B) .08
VII.
Training
At the appropriate place, insert the following new section:
SEC.
REGIONAL AND INDUSTRY SPECIAL SKILLS TRAINING GRANTS.
(a) IN GENERAL.-- Amounts available for carrying out this section
from the Temporary Worker Fee Account under paragraph (3) (A) of
section212(n) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. 1182(n))
shall be used in accordance with the provisions of this section.
From
such amounts, the Secretary of Labor, in consultation with the Secretary
of Commerce and the Secretary of Education, shall make competitive grants
to eligible entities described in subsection(b) , in order to enhance the
capabilities of industries with significant skill needs to utilize the
labor market in meeting their needs more effectively through-(1) improving the job skills of American workers as necessary for
employment in specific industries and occupations with significant skill
needs;
�ARMS Email System
Page 10 of 12
(2) assessing and developing strategies to address significant
skills needs at the local, State, regional, and national levels; and
(3) developing regional skills alliances to facilitate coordination of
activities at the local, State, and regional levels in developing
strategies to meet such needs.
(b) ELIGIBLE ENTITIES.
(1) IN GENERAL.-- For the purposes of this section, an eligible
entity is a consortium that consists of, but is not limited to, two or
more of the following:
(A) employers;
(B) labor organizations;
(C) State or local governments;
(D) private industry councils;
(E) postsecondary educational institutions;
(F) nonprofit organizations representing businesses or industries;
or
(G) nonprofit training organizations.
(2) ADDITIONAL REQUIREMENT.-- To the maximum extent practicable, each
business, organization, or governmental unit that joins in forming an
eligible entity under paragraph (1) shall be located in the same
geographic region of the United States.
(c) GRANT LIMITATIONS.-- A grant .may not be provided to any
eligible entity under this section for more than two annual grant
periods. Out of any grant made to an eligible entity, the portion to be
used for creating, 'planning, and developing the alliance may not exceed
$750,000 for any such annual grant period.
(d) APPLICATION.-- The Secretary may provide a grant to an
eligible entity under subsection (a) only pursuant to an application that
is consistent with the provisions of this section and contains such
information as the Secretary may deem reasonable.
(e) USE OF AMOUNTS.-- In making' grants under subsection (a), the
eligible entity may, to the extent that such activities build upon and
supplement on-going activities and will not duplicate or supplant current
activities, provide for:
(1) an identification of local, State, regional, and national skills
needs;
(2) an assessment of the extent to which workers in the United
States are being educated and trained in needed skills;
(3) the development of strategies to enhance the focus of training
and education investments on industries with significant skill needs and
rapidly expanding occupations;
(4) the provision of training or retraining for upgrading the
skills of workers, including retraining incumbent workers for continued
employment with an employer;
(5) the provision of improved occupational information and
projections;
(6) an assessment of training and job skill needs for specific
industries; and
(7) assistance in developing curriculum and training methods, and
identification of and assistance in developing training providers.
(f) ADDITIONAL CRITERIA FOR GRANTS.-- In making grants under
subsection (a), the Secretary shall provide that-(1) a peer review process shall be utilized to recommend awards
of grants;
(2) applications shall ensure that private industry councils and labor
organizations in the areas to be served have collaborated in the
development of such applications;
(3) preference be given to applications that demonstrate
significant collaboration with major stakeholders in the State and local
�i\RMS Email System
Page 11 of 12
workforce development systems;
(4) with respect to any application, any amount of Federal funds
to be used for training or retraining activities for incumbent workers as
described in subsection (e) (4) shall be matched by an equal amount from
non-Federal sources to be used for such purpose; and
(5) preference be given to applications for grants, based on the
extent to which non-Federal sources will provide amounts which match a
portion of the Federal funds to be made available for the grant.
(g) NATIONAL ALLIANCE FOR HIGH-TECHNOLOGY SKILLS.-(1) ESTABLISHMENT.-- In order to complement the program of grants
under this section, including the activities of regional skills alliances,
a National Alliance for High Technology Skills shall be established within
six months after the enactment of this Act, consisting of individuals who
are representative of private industry, organized labor, work-force
development systems, education, and government at the local, State, and
national levels.
(2) RECOMMENDATIONS AND REPORT.-- The National Alliance shall
develop and recommend strategies for the training of American workers to
meet future demands for high-technology skills.
The National Alliance
shall prepare and submit an interim report to the President and to the
congress, including its findings and recommendations, not later than
February 1, 2001, and a final report not later than September 30, 2003.
(3) MEMBERSHIP.-- The Secretary of Labor, in consultation with the
Secretary of Commerce and the Secretary of Education, shall establish
procedures relating to the appointment of members, the conduct of meetings
and public hearings, and the provision of staff assistance and support
resources for the National Alliance.
(4) LIMITATION.-- Out of the amounts available for use under this
section, not more than $1,000,000 annually shall be available for carrying
out the responsibilities of the Alliance under this subsection.
(h) DEFINITION.-- For purposes of this section:
(1) The term D&SecretaryD8 means the Secretary of Labor.
(2)The term D&private industry councilD8 means the entity
described under section 102 of the Job Training Partnership Act, or
similar entity under any successor Federal statute.
VIII.
New Visa Category Proposal
A new program (H-IC) that creates temporary visas for use only by
non-immigrants with very high skill levels.
In particular:
DO
The program would be authorized for four years beginning in
FY1998.
DO
There would be a maximum of 25,000 visas for FY1998, FY1999, and
FY2000, and a maximum of 15,000 visas for FY2001.
Only employers whose number of H-IB and D&H-1CD8 employees in the prior
year constitutes no greater than one-half of their U.S. based workforce
are eligible to apply.
DO
Only individuals with a minimum of a masterD,s degree (or
equivalent degree) in math, science, or engineering; or a bachelorD,s
degree in math, science, or engineering and five years of experience in
the specialty occupation; or who will earn at least $75,000 per year
(exclusive of benefits) are eligible for an D&H-lCD8 visa.
�,ARMS Email System
DO
Requires a $500 fee for each position for which an application
is filed for training, enforcement, and administration of the program.
DO
The D&H-lCD8 visas would be issued for a 3-year period, and
renewable for an additional 3 years.
DO
All of the requirements of the D&H-lCD8 visa program would be
the same as would exist under the reformed H-IB program.
Page 12 of 12
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[04/17/1998 – 04/27/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 098 - Folder 007
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/a929266e326404cbf7002c184562d637.pdf
fa02f9314ddd95ed6bda0f395b6aeb14
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 098 - FOLDER -006
[04/16/1998]
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 43
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 16-APR-1998 17:21:40.00
SUBJECT:
Statement of Administration Policy on HR2327 Drive for Teen Employment Act
TO: Alice E. Shuffield ( CN=Alice E. Shuffield/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ·Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori Schack ( CN=Lori Schack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kate P. Donovan ( CN=Kate P. Donovan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
CC: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 04/16/98
05:13 PM --------------------------Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: MNB148
�Page 2 of43
ARMS Emaii.System
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF T~E PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Thursday, April 16, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395 - 6148
SUBJECT:
Statement of Administration Policy on HR2327 Drive for
Teen Employment Act
DEADLINE:
2:00 p.m.
Friday, April 17, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: H.R. 2327 is scheduled to be considered by the House as a
Corrections Day item on Tuesday, April 21st.
For your reference, a copy of the bill as ordered reported follows the
draft SAP.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
117 and 340-TRANSPORTATION - Tom Herlihy - (202) 366-4687
61-JUSTICE - Andrew Fois - (202) 514-2141
62-LABOR - Robert A. Shapiro - (202) 219-8201
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
EOP:
Barbara Chow
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Lori Schack
Elena Kagan
Karen Tramontano
Jonathan Orszag
Sanders D. Korenman
Daniel J. Chenok
Robert G. Damus
Janet R. Forsgren
James C. Murr
LRM ID: MNB148 SUBJECT:
Statement of Administration Policy on HR2327
Drive for Teen Employment Act
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of43
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Melissa N. Benton Phone:
395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
DRAFT -- NOT FOR RELEASE
April 16, 1998
(House)
H.R. 2327 - Drive for Teen Employment Act
(Combest (R) TX and 75 others)
The Administration opposes H.R. 2327, which would weaken existing
restrictions on the employment of minors in jobs requiring the operation
of motor vehicles. The Administration is concerned that this legislation,
which would increase the permissible amount of on-the-job driving by
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of43
minors, could result in an increase in the number of automobile-related
injuries and fatalities involving young and inexperienced drivers.
* * * * * * * * * *
(Do Not Distribute Outside Executive Office of the President)
This position was developed by LRD (Benton) in consultation with HRD
(Matlack/Bond).
The Departments of Labor (), Justice (), Commerce (),
Transportation (), and Health and Human Services have reviewed the
proposed position and have either no comment or no objection.
Legislative History
H.R. 2327 was introduced on July 31, 1997. On March 5, 1998, H.R. 2327
was approved by the Workforce Protections Subcommittee by voice vote, with
an amendment in the nature of a substitute. The amendment made a number
of changes intended to clarify that the bill would not affect the
requirements of the Department of LaborO,s current regulations governing
jOb-related driving by teenagers.
On April 1, 1998, the Education and the
Workforce Committee ordered the bill reported without further changes.
The Committee report is not yet available.
Administration position to Date
The Department of Labor sent a letter to Representatives Ballenger and
Andrews on March 5, opposing H.R. 2327 as introduced.
In its letter,
Labor expressed its opposition to the bill and concern that the bill could
"increase the number of automobile-related injuries and deaths caused by
young and inexperienced drivers."
Labor sent a similar letter to Rep. Goodling on March 31, 1998, prior to
the full CommitteeO,s consideration of the bill.
Background and Summary of H.R. 2327 as Ordered Reported
Current Department of Labor regulations (29 CFR 5570.52) permit minors
between the ages of 16 and 18 to operate motor vehicles as part of their
jobs, if: (1) driving is "occasional and incidental" to the job; (2) all
dri ving . is performed during daylight hours;. (3) the dri viilg· does not
involve the towing of vehicles; (4) the minor has completed a
State-approved driverO,s education course and holds an appropriate
license; (5) the vehicle is equipped with an adequate number of seat belts
and the employer has instructed the minor employee to use them; and (6)
the vehicle being operated does not exceed 6,000 pounds gross vehicle
weight.
The billD,s sponsors argue that the regulations are poorly defined and
outdated, and have been too narrowly construed by Labor. According to the
billD,s sponsors, a number of employers have been fined for allowing their
teenage employees to perform limited jOb-related driving.
They argue that
LaborO,s current interpretation of the regulations restricts the ability
of teenagers to gain workplace experience and participate in
school-to-work activities.
H.R. 2327 is intended to clarify the amount of
job-related driving 16- and 17-year old employees are permitted to perform
as part of their jobs.
H.R. 2327 would amend section 13(c} of the Fair Labor Standards Act (29
U.S.C. 213(c)} to permit individuals between the ages of 16 and 18 to
operate automobiles or trucks as part of their job, provided that certain
�ARMS Email System
conditions are met.
With the exception of the "occasional and incidental;'
requirement, the bill would add to the FLSA all of the conditions
specified in the regulations.
In addition, the bill would establish two
additional limitations on job-related driving by minors: (1) the job
cannot involve driving beyond 50 miles from the minor employeeD,s
workplace, and (2) the amount of driving cannot exceed one-third of a
minorD,s workday and 20 percent of a minorD,s workweek.
Pay-As-You-Go Scoring According to HRD (Bond), H.R. 2327 would not affect
direct spending or receipts; therefore, it is not subject to the
pay-as-you-go requirement of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of
1990. CBO concurs.
LEGISLATIVE REFERENCE DIVISION DRAFT
April 16, 1995/2:30 p.m.
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
%PDF-1.1
%
1 0 obj
[/CalRGB
«
/WhitePoint [0.9505 1 1.0S9]
/Gamma [l.S 1.S 1.S]
/Matrix [0.4497 0.2446 0.0251S 0.3163 0.672 0.1412 0.lS45 0.OS334 0.9227]
»
endobj
2 0 obj
«
/Filter [/ASCIIS5Decode /LZWDecode ]
/Length 459
»
stream
J,g]g+e/h 1 gCtO=Of)$P%cIiSZdfc5&3j S$7g.@L'YKUJNGBP\poR= ;Dl'P(T
AA
(7BOO S:71(MN1ZQX/+Cbu.lK"p74pe1T%S.DY%&\lTdJhr54.M9au6>79n6'Q:4
PbLSZTLEE(SE@'*lmg *eTnN*;*'V3+gm-EEetX%;Bo$ur2ss*N'.-l .kG q6GDD'
dKoL 1 SKa#EV,@Vl \j SZFbp6EE<9cn=N6j <MSQ? [#7 "dq' l>Onf; (&; QU6bUo' ) c@\
9-d\DA=cZOQ>gIM$$;cd20@&a;X,Nn_a<?V-PVE%?Sf]idH6WRZqHGq]Zm<uCi"]?
Stg«gV-H9NB<SA\T=SN)Il%(BDIak7/H&mVlkmDUo4X;S;]V>P(]II aRc (K1 Aue>
gF/(+GaKo$qneLWDrQ#;5\S(\$q'LM9bYJX9N;hHO_e;>'Y"/'J:I->
endstream
endobj
4 0 obj
«
/Filter [/ASCIIS5Decode /LZWDecode ]
/Width 77
/Height 99
/BitsPerComponent S
/ColorSpace [/Indexed /DeviceRGB 255 2 0 R]
/Length 751
»
stream
J2Q7]3$]7K#D>EP:qOC-)%VNk@Sg'[:+[9@2«m.jE;+SJu]gTaXlOH-BCc,EX>A R
0.'G'@M9'4ee9mO:109BeEV<BRnr5] .MWGl7AEJS'U\PG+"+lYA9Aei[0'L2Q&=+L
] l<>]5h)Vek[]h_,*B[BcoX[na%W./,1:e. [Y\spgoh;OQ$OcGYLmV*kp?cEKtq-$
Page 5 of43
�ARMS Email System
EN?H%j_MGIW'G#n9,A T ,?R*'Qh@@)e_WRW8bj9NGH\gqZ&H,Y4(T1:'p+m Dc7-3&
DCW8uCeE<GblN'faVPa*Di!Mb'''Z!e=2U'')nKi!!,CRS:5cZV:=K A>.y=?lCHK/?O
%]rb A>#-411UZt)2jR4Z(=SJHo(!T(bsPBrZ)BbdgnO/!Yi%A146 jo%.@ON!XRM)Y
A
]O=R;;T?="aqXo1D3Nb85#'NngdH*JU8gJ?qCrVkEFWJ/ s4b2r1"=n?Au1X6o>n$
nQ]&fVbk;mp8ATDLkwa.Sl=q2X)\Xo2XX4oat6GC)W'QVAIIm/EU+gK5K16:/k>-3
: <Z+i/8gCm%%MT%V% [+'M+, [21IEhZKZ>=_Dl)4A: [kZ)auJt!;ZJjLd]tAXM@+I:
Uh\p"Ral:fkm=GsPl')\IB\@L'fgf>bKs2sr40*H%79pOd?P.07gkc,IWg7Air[_N
r7bN/FDNa3eCF'*:KLKF?SY9[FOOXM<a1S3YBGNfBeCOqR;460_MrC\BuP?W_tN21
B3#fm$nEGC->
endstream
endobj
5 0 obj
«
/Length 1876
/Fi1ter [/ASCII85Decode /LZWDecode ]
»
stream
J.RTgcqqB60c5]i,ssL#@Q4o-+u#sGaC7%D%#2V"YgdDl.N;cX,,*.K+> _AL,g*\
@36s>i.?R6%%A O?P"LEp.25$D.2#4k6Kk5DC4\a+Odp9"aTZF+Yf\3\8j?b%*!;o
&lC@LUJ + [JT04) '!amF+p!e AX"UR*j>/Ot8;9[> kAu5<$Z'0)iL\8!OZ[Q/\jA 8
A
<TI0f'KI.nO/-Kj-CYLH?NrB=LsOREX:;BNE)=DWOZD9DAqPBadV js%YfTaJ:_Vn
RuEhhERS'72klA4;]pV/H.d$;"Z*-6'c!c)9d'[WeD»bkJiVbBZC66)or;Kl:b'Y
CGU6pHW#F9hnql>%6\d"K<?=DQqg+,5_*Ui"tY:DU8 [?L%] lKYE*=O T+c8H!]HX,j
A
Y:3n\-E<hVi1E*oMV)AVIZ>QW)F)&if"%iuU@A;oam)g["Tg>nn(C%AM&fS 5+Ae06
_Dn>8MIN&%m\:r*YjT.qQt6ZFMMOP-_1-CH)6C!n5TOk]MRjK-Nl=;#IQe]=*%c3L
[$f!4A2,H(&FaT+#9gAdllk=CVBh#XF!d_=cq4Q]_AM&U[RS) PAr' (d, .\Psa?rd1
M#hQ\.8iHnB"$$)3Yak.1eGgi,>u$dNPu>\A/qjGR&Drs",#Aj%3m*4oSu3;_@Sqa
$Xh\rmRq:MNrpfaiBCaj5VkR@Dl,Xu"% ) (NlqMTo2W2CdQ,sTRjTGmaEk)t-)$R#
O>S8-c"2 AK#h) t6QBeBtNg7u4r="acK)1(349It 'p7nEB409tE16. !sblsuoZZO<H
A
A
JPo[O'/0@'LP,CNb5FN52/G(WUUSV>2 :<"NW *_B'Tp/.-*(r:VJY>Nh'AB2iLdV
b50shOQ8H]@p%kOllDA;dY%Z_*Km.+;C47FI2-*0, !os./W6QhaFXV"a?UWd+'kN'
l\Lk: Aq:n$#UuF&'F AheBOVtplJo>KN!BX@Ard,JMRue'G'o 5,QA; [,RNJ/VOnlS
2'SNG&cdf_La<.nC<G4KOOrI_?@E;PS)SM+jAZZQaOYaipt4 Ai"sL]?G@HMIX&*
-Roi1WfM&?f3M:Nds] <*Ll-#@a9M2T*NsTo"Gds@dS!3KFSkXC3DrOc7'b(/K%C5'
A
oX@p>YWVcpRtsrBWS+UOY]C!R'H tsa$S]]=p,USg,Y+e@*HXt 8?e\h'$HY7BsG!
A
7 W' Kg07) 84nL2s [R ("8; A : cTnH~= _c<ok" /-rN.] opmrgsQ3Vc [1 :d5c! ImE ( ( .2
29 [: T9Vp [; ,_D_/' XCY'H\3P* 3/ [MTWFW#Q (?d_ AkY40Yo" 999?u.] t] \ 'PmOq, ; 1
*XSLf.#&E#*.OYOAP1jpZR(nKc@OD)N#_A G@#GL A)_>*m.P@2[(rM7$jZMhToq?Jt
p<4ss" !'r4sNal@POkmJ]K[&Z'MANZq4<7R,P)H:<3NV@6QD#>V-NPrZbr3If[XJ
8FYPdNUj50k7$@Ne#!sLA5baIM41ejZj'07Jc105*OD[XK*y+ A!DT3j2PV["%(HWt
15;klA4X4d_Jq<mI#'1$&?8@15m.20,_Wt#VH[TI6gi@4.Mom7VJCNT'f944 [Aklr
K!Ja'eQ]»G7BjA AfX5@q1GFCZHqOU%#K859t-FfhKID;-DbCX2/91i6J#E1j'E,O
fXmEKn6Sc8HS:)t)qP?QRKO%OOU(*bfEoQ*N#@9\Gr!>UZP]BpNKOIM0 =?-dUY2?
GY%FXb+h1f>jT:p#ldJ4RDHII9_"'3"B\Q'nsjQOBSdR&5p$Db>6r%./d9%L&LSb<
$+3_X. :V!=Wm[: [o*,2jo!7CP+XAomjSb_&_!oR(+FZT&*>i2B$\N+FL5cAI0:V->
endstream
endobj
6 0 obj
«
/ProcSet [/PDF /Text]
/Co1orSpace «/Defau1tRGB 1 0 R»
/Font «
/F5 7 0 R
/FI0 8 0 R
/Fll 9 0 R
/F13 10 0 R
»
»
endobj
13 0 obj
Page 6 of43
�ARMS Email System
«
/Fi1ter [/ASCII85Decode /LZWDecode )
/Width 77
/Height 99
/BitsPerComponent 8
/Co1orSpace [/Indexed /DeviceRGB 255 2 0 R)
/Length 731
»
stream
J2Q7)3$)7K#D>EP:qOC-)%VNk@Sg'[:+[9@2<{m.jE;+SJu)gTaXlOH-BCc,EX>A R
0.'G'@M9'4$:Qh{bp017,jKXXS',Hkq'=Zk7?L1&Z8u8@QP#q;k-Z+1'i1,Y;J?j1
e=K05VUDIZ>9mt, <NFlt$HR=W" {&:eD"5)6c7sIF_l&/K<ITQZAWir)R %<4MJA'mE
=KB AoOV5Q;Z5G+J7'lICjDtmVenuE>U7cAqXVQpg%asRJp<?U026F;'F.)=%dTq+N
6*+-M1m$SagJFVk/1*l/I{s[s3;tHnHcW91Z1mT3slPXlms<[#'Uflk_-laYMdJha
fT1+P (2rQagUkg5 1=h, -) c'Z?M07&bg4k#A 2 =>D1Fb>&Pf? 1 "1 AZ<UDF4K)5tcih
mA' .HkmKdM)qqHnb%n10.kX'2Vo"7cOY>9fHU/7Y/u/-15VldgMa2.Nh%$FS_sn$q
nXMHY5L4,>qE A3r"X$>#+r{a3BOmL#aK'&&%SDWe_##9pMeObldAmK:W9QIWr3pWM
OY))%bZ9h+d)?Y%X:Dgk-"'$\L=-@"2'q\m\FPZ8 A?tdgqQecdksZn9C"K.d_+TN
;6 A A6_Q<BOeY'Z'Njn<ZF#ff7+DDj%B'bI?T,q\X[Q+;EeR{60Jh2j#K7BNpr+u;
O
,m>MkF_XuC5P/5S{/?B>I90P7'eIL1CmCI$=mcFa7b'/WP@*&4AZdO++9->
endstream
endobj
14 0 obj
«
/Length 2004
/Fi1ter [/ASCII85Decode /LZWDecode )
»
stream
J.RTgcqqB60c10#+p+I,#Vd5'+Y) :6J7 AJQ$\i/"l8M2p.N;cWP+g#f+>Ah;"lL64
eHCL5L2a)%3#lqa$\nh@R,A<T)oYF&8JnsI7tr&G6mF+1dW?$<9u[had)oll{lojC
Tq[uSW>KBelsuQC82m)7FOPN&5Z0A-%RsZ*\EI?:b@UOF40P/O{6$5M. '/Sf$5<ne
;Z\eurAL;,+uAK1e8Gc5Nl7*"Ui<;*'#T:7CS6:6>d"D?VWrS75Z>;FNd>J\"PREI
)GF')EO\8$2k,d#lS2h.'A30V7'r6I{OUqX-J; (W9/.o A9<j*tO%LK-1Tua A=@h{Z
224YQ=fg[S5:S+E87b+Z4I1fqCWQ_MO) l#AMLo5n{HL\8U7.e>Mnk4)+el$74UDHp
)8N=gB{#ao'<91[%{l,OZYAE ApmW./dbOF+W'E8".bM\:N,<=6jO)5- Ab?%Rb=EOQ
_g{6s%'#CS,)r@JfJejAbI$If1i)r_r3jp$F.sq,)X:"nqN1nlLq1k"V&'0&4Ih:
: {tF+>R'$Wo"5\cL9dSd"9D:4{5b5*"" X4;#k-c6u56M+hoGLa=<{.fVJQU+TRK#
"9N8" -U330 (aj t<Gb?7<63SM6dNWq88."* 3bPeG=A [, - [%Y) TLVc) : n 1 ) bs=Bm-p\l
OCXA6k1kTC#pL>1.Es_:qc,)-@MMsGY=_b5b)j:#-alla4$GGOg-%)T$Nd=b\2IIl
'F\I/;VFUIE5FHPiaBVX8'QAJZOA{?aV70<3+<k A
@DjYuYN'al1Uu%_rA?p1ZNi$b
dabYD4mYVW)$ 'i?"-W) lsfe"G:6C2.F'cg1, [5&a>+OV98'T#$L4{Z.iEL02EI"U
$5< 'NYN#A[ ~#CNKQ9ipm1X&B+-PQ%, [PJ) :U@VBgDm.TOs625qke&{i>?@/bWJ6
NO'-;'3Y"dtA~$)C PJ<66Q;2f.LeRQKO>:)Tpmb&9,3:tPZ DrJ1>ZVWR5<:1'tJo>
AtEqg/l/UL7/K&Y\0>&bkS>X'/<2j6/XYr_%I55#XGjPK)7m$krpZOWO$TBii&t)?
b3GK6Bg,2mT AO#hbt,)-[{"ID[%Te$6-'f=R-$463Y+am%LpFp3\&g=hkSJc:KGD"
\p""E@@a;lc-+\rhrsF-{rA=oK6Z*/N'g7+aiF9$17n9GR+sSM@n=f[lLeLb$jH#T
[d1g-o) T' 1J_@/L 'XNRO=: >Rr+L2" OrPLpuI1; T'U2WA; ) A2e =V / ak: 6s: N387rA4
dK,mu{=Z#6XA1A;BeU=k"'BOmF9010#;C?0;KN=TO<%L17+ht*$k? [CYTOoK+po70
-jWLtYI5"t)NkVr36TCJ'\H7:K5kZOlSQUiP-E[QX?\-&+pOmFTb3'@6?"Y1UFWa A
*<XL4>lg' .ldcROK6V2hKjg6l00XILJ[fQOh&2Md5k»JC+q@L{qmpl1f"g$L@%R(
A+s5ca\ZJqavzeM10*A[llt863AJ?'ph7pg;%/NB%NFY$%guw,DN*"<a\rht@tJf A
P&A"A 60=FlP2cgf:t1q%9G1&b+Y"YR3ej&'CRQ,H/:'8YQ7#3B)i/Nt;\l/".>&))
Pblhf6,JeXjr.G3Mbl,ra>W+{)NY6:112+i7Y&W)+N[qlO.jcUR3aLaM19F8C37["
ZGOn[WAuCF,YKltDaU#f.)Oe,\9{coVo- .&7*3#Gpu'cESH[&&1$D{Z4&'G.Rir[
qANs04Mr'c1nh:a'a.hK$WOu19,z55.se71pm\A u %[R13l_hU$;$'@>VTe{C1d'C{
1pL;a##OgDNGpcZJASTTln{5IN4Wd;P{)Y1cU/ZT1D=-k'#LJfEFThsRI'l'_O+D$
h)r?KmGo-P3f-JXWSetUPaR/FcEiHp7L)4u/d,pd{BPFL$+<YU'-Lfp 0) .PW)WC4
A
LQ$IlOK{8$I'N-i _geo*x3bCbv-2@nWt{L#>2KCloVc?QSHe1U A RD<&-->
endstream
endobj
Page 7 of43
�ARMS Email System
15 0 obj
«
/ProeSet [/PDF /Text)
/ColorSpaee «/DefaultRGB 1 0 R»
/Font «
/F1 16 0 R
/F5 7 0 R
/F10 8 0 R
/F13 10 0 R
/F23 17 0 R
/F24 18 0 R
»
»
endobj
20 0 obj
«
/Filter [/ASC1185Deeode /LZWDeeode )
/Width 77
/Height 99
/BitsPerComponent 8
/ColorSpaee [/1ndexed /DevieeRGB 255 2 0 R)
/Length 492
»
stream
J2Q7)3$)7K#D>EP:qOC-)%VNk@Sg-[:+[9@2«m.jE;+SJu)gTaX10H-BCe,EX>AR
0.-G-@M9'4$:Qh(bp017,j1$ASjOmQBtTa%-_nbYPaYT1NA16WB/M07C*u9/djl/9
rn;eshY=-UBC>9;YB;A))<N9=k -P-Xj#7f$@Y%aXh./<W-"\HFK[T<'X4?q88&&92
; /,*ru@8-EHp8 A.k<*hjJ4abG",7UO(C*9)bZVAPd91-Qq=-401t/+F05H%eDM<)
A
f;-h5Xr@OQhX-t@*Yt1fS@-ad(4&YEM72U60/1XW S@[lkkdAhhH.=Ln)X7@h[ReP
A,=6-=6mNnbPs;8)hA4*A M',9TYP:&$Fi>PHkOUgBP\U>_<MAy
f($dCrluNJgDKV8
ciR%np. Z_19 - %m3; E9' '_s (Dn&OA B@9*; ( (6)1; j OXs3= -JKO_QUY\ *C<T, 0) #>ZO
OZF'*l_lRJd)WC.XFPg->
endstream
endobj
21 0 obj
«
/Length 885
/Filter [/ASC1185Deeode /LZWDeeode )
»
stream
A
J. RTgeqqB60e10#+p+1, #Vd5' +Y) : 6J7 JQ$ \i/" 18M2p. N; eWP+g#f+> Ah; "#3AD
eHCL5L2a)%3#lq-$\nh@R,A<T)oYF&8JnsH3#faFntQ59\OrPf"X4&:eAe/5)pSXd
A A
ObDq42k,1)6 [=pY+? (7bJeeTSlu+d&N1pEJU?6PVSaE; "Cq 8 RR:J7 dAXQd'p;Dp
6@k-i?q-PIB#?_f<dd"1dV*-"JEE+H2jo=8,=/-FCpOWAfD&U&Cb<e<i)*?&b?$Ed
1 'VNOFo/Fbel/&$o$R$<2JU=[.6(HWE-*$X-MuSMTKJ;>-4+VL1$-+Y1N#%Hj8kS
A
)Ynee;TX)H,NdY?Vu-tT%h(FXE[=1".H\K&"9GM82N9:Te8,qtGhT_)_#t%NN 5_0
3" : KG-j rH" 16R4 : K6Zr&) T$Z@_7hLjeA [0' ,Ms) a; (1%i \lH8Hi \R\5 (, h, HE9J<q
1sm [; 6nFQnb/D\h: -@; 1bZOK) /e9 (s "V+X2, 1tssY4&r?&DXUnNlop. NtAhD1 (/Z#
A/1ij1C56L;)hAk8MUhk)pOOelCs#J$u1Dl_*HH3/0eQH\r@rll=Xo@EnW1h.leue
%;ss12\.)<=;K2AIY+7108Cj?717t)26J=oY05<OOe/q,KtET8.TK=3DFVFg-08?
A
AMX'\;*OTTeFV[k1sbHWe4E)L)QC6 «nB'69teR8?K7i.p4"B'*OfVE\*k'f/DGN
4&+:nmP9-r=BIMmiH6_he" [A#Pp$_JQ#33.C++aiad?raL8\QL-JD@W\lS' (-4V2U
ibf50-:*m\L'b%11qQX5ep<WJT-ufo,k_M40TK&@@N1#W:i[Q9.X5V1#&01_(Cd'Y
Ut ( : " (_hLN->
endstream
endobj
22 0 obj
«
/ProeSet [/PDF /Text)
/ColorSpaee «/DefaultRGB 1 0 R»
Page 8 of43
�ARMS Email System
/Font «
/F1 16 0 R
/F5 7 0 R
/F10 8 0 R
/F13 10 0 R
/F23 17 0 R
»
»
endobj
16 0 obj
«
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F1
/BaseFont /Times-Roman
»
endobj
7 0 obj
«
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F5
/BaseFont /He1vetica
»
endobj
8 0 obj
«
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F10
/FirstChar 32
/LastChar 251
/Widths [
259 259 331 769 519 829 609 259 359 359 500 833 259 312 259 278
519 519 519 519 519 519 519 519 519 519 259 259 833 833 833 403
986 655 704 639 748 697 676 694 796 385 558" 728 659 830 750 694
644 694 687 581 662 743 648 887 706 650 611 359 278 359 1000 500
259 479 490 410 506 421 325 488 516 262 292 505 252 771 525 456
506 490 391 398 345 525 433 639 458 458 417 500 500 500 833 280
280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280
280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280
280 259 519 519 167 519 519 500 606 170 449 417 248 248 539 539
280 500 500 500 259 280 500 590 259 449 449 417 1000 1216 280 403
280 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 280 500 500 280 500 500 500
1000 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280
280 917 280 359 280 280 280 280 682 694 1002 342 280 280 280 280
280 665 280 280 280 262 280 280 271 456 707 507]
/BaseFont /DeVinne
/FontDescriptor 23 0 R
»
endobj
9 0 obj.
«
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F11
/FirstChar 32
/LastChar 251
/Widths [
280 340 333 574 560 820 820 280 340 340 600 560 280 240 280 380
Page 90f43
�Page 10 of 43
ARMS Email System
560 560 560 560 560 560 560 560 560 560 280 280 560 560 560 500
747 720 660 660 720 600 540 760 780 340 540 680 560 860 700 780
640 780 680 540 620 680 660 980 660 680 600 360 560 360 560 500
280 540 620 500 620 540 340 540 620 320 260 580 320 880 620 580
600 620 440 440 340 600 560 800 560 560 500 389 560 389 560 280
280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280
280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280280 280
280 340 560 560 160 560 560 600 560 241 500 480 300 300 660 660
280 500 600 600 280 280 747 560 280 500 500 480 1000 1220 280 500
280 380 380 560 460 460 440 300 500 280 360 360 280 500 300 560
1000 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280
280 980 280 324 280 280 280 280 580 780 1020 348 280 280 280 280
280 820 280 280 280 320 280 280 360 580 900 700]
/BaseFont /Cheltenham-Bold
/FontDescriptor 24 0 R
»
endobj
10 0 obj
«
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F13
/FirstChar 32
/LastChar 251
/Widths [
278 296 389 556 556 833 815 204 333 333 500 606 278 333 278 278
556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 556 278 278 606 606 606 444
737 722 722 722 778 722 667 778 833 407 556 778 667 944 815 778
667 778 722 630 667 815 722 981 704 704 611 333 606 333 606 500
204 556 556 444 574 500 333 537 611 315 296 593 315 889 611 500
574 556 444 463 389 611 537 778 537 537 481 333 606 333 606 0
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000
o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 000 0 000
o 296 556 556 167 556 556 500 556 204 389 426 259 259 611 611
o 556 500 500 278 0 606 606 204 389 389 426 1000 1000 0 444
o 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 0 333 333 0 333 333 333
1000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
o 1000 0 334 0 0 0 0 667 778 1000 300 0 0 0 0
o 796 0 0 0 315 0 0 315 500 833 574]
/BaseFont /NewCenturySch1bk-Roman
/FontDescriptor 25 0 R
»
endobj
17 0 obj
«
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F23
/FirstChar 32
/LastChar 251
/Widths [
241 356 331 769
481 481 481 481
986 630 666 611
623 671 683 588
241 495 439 382
525 449 397 350
280 280 280 280
280 280 280 280
280 356 481 481
481
481
711
618
495
319
280
280
167
829
481
681
722
368
525
280
280
481
706
481
619
581
275
444
280
280
481
241
481
675
830
440
667
280
280
500
347
481
796
644
481
454
280
280
606
347
481
394
587
324
500
280
280
170
500
241
532
662
265
378
280
280
440
833
241
703
347
444
500
280
280
394
241
833
620
278
271
500
280
280
236
312
833
792
347
769
500
280
280
236
241 278
833 465
667 671
1000 500
537 424
833 280
280 280
280 280
536 536
�ARMS Email System
280 500 500 500 241 280 500 590 241 440 440 394 1000 1216 280 465
280 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 280 500 500 280 500 500 500
1000 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280 280
280 876 280 372 280 280 280 280 637 671 947 318 280 280 280 280
280 634 280 280 280 324 280 280 294 424 635 521]
/BaseFont /DeVinne-rtalic
/FontDescriptor 26 0 R
»
endobj
18 0 obj
«
/Type /Font
/Subtype /Type1
/Name /F24
/FirstChar 32
/LastChar 251
/Widths [
287 333 400 574 574 889 889 259 407 407 500 606 287 333 287 278
574 574 574 574 574 574 574 574 574 574 287 287 606 606 606 481
747 741 759 759 833 741 704 815 870 444 667 778 704 944 852 833
741 833 796 685 722 833 741 944 741 704 704 407 606 407 606 500
259 667 611 537 667 519 389 611 685 389 370 648 389 944 685 574
648 630 519 481 407 685 556 833 574 519 519 407 606 407 606 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
0 o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 o 0 o 0 o 0
0 333 574 574 167 574 574 500 574 287 481 481 278 278 685 685
0 500 500 500 287 o 650 606 259 481 481 481 1000 1167 o 481
0 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 333 0 333 333 o 333 333 333
1000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
o 889 0 412 0 0 0 0 704 833 963 356 0 0 0 0
o 815 0 0 0 389 0 0 389 574 852 574]
/BaseFont /NewCenturySchlbk-BoldItalic
/FontDescriptor 27 0 R
endobj
23 0 obj
«
/Type /FontDescriptor
/Ascent 656
/capHeight 661
/Descent -205
/Flags 34
/FontBBox [-135 -236 1163 936 ]
/FontName /DeVinne
/ItalicAngle 0
/StemV 67
/FontFile 28 0 R
/XHeight 416
endobj
28 0 obj
«
/Filter /ASCII85Decode
/Length 33841
/Length1 561
/Length2 25702
/Length3 0
»
stream
A
A
,p>'rDKJj'E+LaUOeP.@+@KdAB17g"+>F3X1E 4B@rri&AS5 p$84keDKJWAD.OhC
Page 11 of 43
�ARMS Email System
6tKDsDJj#.A7]?q$B4keDKJj'E+L.H+Co%q$B4keDKJ33Dg3CO/MT%=+>#?)2BX_/
2DZ191H'Y(Eb/ZiDfOB:+Co%q$B4keDKJT] FE2)?+BpNPOJG4 (OH'% 10Js%sOd&.m
OOsfAART+fDJXS@A7]?[02Q(kDKJj'E+L.G+Co%q$B4keDKJHfAoAeHl*C+A@rri(
F'B14ASs A
p$B6R6EcYrsDBL>]OJP160JP"lEb/ZiDfOB:+Co%q$Bs.mFDssr+=JZ]
Eb/ZiDfOB:+Co%q$B4kkChujTD.Oh<6tKDsDJj#7+ED%%ABc@%Gp$x/AdUl\@;TAp
GtqdbAKWBhAQEM_D1k7>Eb/ZiDfOB:+Co%q$B4tm@;KXf6#L=OAKWZLA7]?[OssJs
Bm=3":hb#]BHUnqCia/1A7] ? (03) n#ATDU$D1IX_F (o'lDf- [LOeb: (A7]?[03)n#
ATDU$D1ld\Bk(prATMoBlc?1eAS)9&=(Q)YBQP@F9k@jLF_rQMA7]?[Ol')gAOATU
FA?7] AKWBhAQEM_D1k7>A7] ? [ASu$$A7] ? [OlBbgDe,*R"B-: ,p@;] UaEb%UV@rGml
DJ()&AS)9ZF'MM6DKKE'@rri)D1a)aF'MM6DKKK)Ch4'#AU%cr$sksQWlY:E9#W3n
);Q_l]4;'EEpu\D:br(AG6ao./Qrnj>A s ;Tb60_jh&'W9U;Qrg.K#J]kD's\sV[pbC
A
q*=V<EDBJ/OB;N:Mo=.GsQC2gbYbbQljBQ'G jr3J(lq"SpXFaJ%aJlT$ms'G>NQA
%%s21#K@R14<BFXYM2*R]tOS$"9U,gessEr3?>db+Nsc]ReqAuVlplGD<UUGZMeX9
RLTeYF;?R. C%eZ6SK4>* , -a. PMcd [Hb$] Y6< "cmL1TC9jVBPDqL"] YsBn [. fNX (3 [
hrM7 A6P#Dld-?<;1HXVG=ilW'f/S16/<V_[ds/-["anik@3SYFWV2l3&s(hdG;to1
*j""gduOm1-eC*REibsBBCLJkb) l<uo2+u:L]sK#72Ll"#j\6#MgelrkfTn1,H9MP
"Yik=M]h+PjZThah-W@pE/(BFCW<3?SGR07\r@Ujq,LEXPJFEnA$#*bm=ipWeA#=4
=/-f=ge@7@X#UT]&sd]fOs(1jA\»Fhoc-#+pRK@n"um?ir(-lBuB/EP'lQfd;q=2
A, Bcse3; %t; 41_m:AC_L+MTADj /3Kd\XHZ< ;,CQ@<p#DuV$c@<L.D-1Cn01akRpObF
RqSp AbdgK<2q+>pNd]ZX,qSBm$Oo"J:. [c7Atj&17FGU:#Rs\;ff(qeOS;-iU*+]K
&soYEN A3,o#C'BEoM74%a,ls-GDrtM01Ec+S:cugh@]ZRFHD[gq9.H#<:N@>f&d"]
A
<#Ct AZg \t9Tln6'''piQ[MO;u*%U?$n2 >n.f.WP;jZqN]gNQUh-,hK's$u2K*T1S
'-ay9=3%gB[F=<lXCRR%V.+>lX'2j"/No:,AtPJsSMi$"Z9t1P?LMPR$Wd6u'dl*1
]B)sq@JMVV A2sWlGOqo07)a«,s<[eR_X%2W],EV"Me<VQlF-@_2YA>e,rMB?"lS:
g&gb\Ao[BOmO#/@"jgXHZo?jHh/4"NP[p12ilHC=s*B+sNNlF04V94PS'76KODFdO
'R A&l3Acs.@KGG@mX*TI1U4D7g A
DoY1'AOfTOWr'#QU,AUgYs] (C=F<cB2jaOAF",
/2'shOGcT4UGfn;3F-qu+TscLBW\jL2-+'6\c)d[>a*V:3H_kjZV1c;T;lo7%s>.rn
A
S#LSNrTFY(2+B'adeR,+9/ C2h_TOCb9-Kps'mZk+XR.B:tdWBdA'V%.O@f:k(Yhs
A
ob Al%M('-\j@&*7il:6#%?GA&XE)g=to+s@MZ$CO(09d-XecO'Bqgn?(uhB'(q+U
N6/Y%eBX)PJ:b"<4Va1\Gg7eU6TA.sRYc%K\QcUl"/'B L2AY1>P2H-;g4=V?/6L'
Qsnhh: &N4E+uQ?m lU [ [@] -L, ' 14/qa3 \Uu) ZNU3 "d: ,uFU 17S+?1 ALdYgRr7oR?oq
A
19crS14) +OOslPk#EBMbW\Q*A g -f31bB6YSjn\3,DRy slR<"] s6e<M 1'd2))s7pR
JY6 '79cm 1 lOGf :AV' 19%-N\ 'a: 2 *%YE/S7>JP'F] [6. 1 -cZLmfG*go*@$r: <] VStA
A
"GV6U' 1pJapcjJ41=sY[lK/cV k@,ldUSVq>4 d%oJ#)scdP7YEIRS2THW)?UYq+p
rYV/i.n/sFdbfY3k9nrogg92F*jaftn@eV"4m\q1<EEC2U*+<BH?Ab, j"tWFK
A
D[QA(CNse;=DEKr>/'%\kQIHP"F',UdBU/V f$A:/bOR]<3%3\]so;gtk\G='pJZ
q<t-F7mY+70BqQKDAc9GK\"f?FThjellq.>. 't_[s (kb4GVcs,PC;7ZM 'afGrkc.B
[@cSZP1L9R"Q: r7>$; (7/ -d<l_P (PK+DfL; (i1 l@%CC [BC_"@X$t\Ud@. "2ij R$&
(c.+-aua3Lp [d&V<7sF1#mElKSkHY60Ws/>_n<FGO?glX] m3srUgsnWVCe9&PW%MP
SAm*p"fC:k+lTH;RV6)AfZQ>M1JlPS(NBsU0719"lgBonBgo*lAnlR>]YF4Se$*h&
Q1sEs/U_+M#BmK14#ha'U.QUm+m$:6\LA,oliOB@Bto2edlsN,6--A6_r\u+u,tA
FqJc] <=;PfHsa4MbjKE/j9SBLWju[ls-2A_3LI1ECm)eH1ggGd>HZa +>OY'A?2n+.
@E A]sf[;g/a7([Oo_LmM3jd&Nf)H.tKqWL#+[B7F=;AC A
Nt1qA ru /&4AZTCg&.Br/
hJH6Qm<)Ns"L/VBSt*?7FB N#='OqDPO,UNU*rn(+eGV4f'kRH1,sBoZN.RR,A%2)
A
A
B=>, l,&Slsg/fJsk1 Zl'OtpZf)rn@nkW$F7oK 1/lUkEoR7%rL bj%CQu+"%7B"m*
6 «3TDLYY4*_l/les ltGp6kWLH(%21s<6 [;a>4ep9] ,iG%<d=&OGQoN.a*m,>&A_/
MK&1*ml- A .l;#MY-=F3Wssc]_"+tQ'hFjfJLeb4MXrG,=%BS[c>X A2r#AgJ+04Z@+
:171MJ>c'*Lb4==ao<AHnhU"k%g:Ri2pBhYlgJJ%C<9<;J+>BkNl#.i(tm\@QHUBQ
A
MdgHfG=N\NRtF@l ll<3WqJZ K*_g&CGcrOBaJHS20WLKsf.A6lrZa7$]sqt\<_mhi
eP; Bp_"_ [=#99rZ=6fBFsF_G>b>E (-mrtp1. G7B\s01>- $a=3X- [B, al_I4J; ; Du4
a' BLOs 1Q" BYg9YL1H-rpOF2F' *=@uGVB+fNJe--a .. ,dj E7f=NMIQ] g) ZU [? ZTj 53
n#M, [OZir+""LAh=31_DA04i7dc_B3qScZZOBdR9AP+?#SouL]1/]s*Bd1X1X='44
'6rraBlOBH_CkTaUt;Qs(l/J6gu@(2'.9c)CH7i/)m/U>sncRZ6#N*bXjTsK27G.V
GSJQXiQ\l;7$akql49,lZO:ic[fF<M%d>"#3e6*mB<971&'70e"FQS$\3Plsr%S'Q
A
NSC[LR211JLK2Rr1 ELXkiPF32_bfBHj@)tep]D46BD'uCcsn\@kC)ndq("aWOK\h
hdV]grQ.@lp]A_W'M:c\V'Gn:bT7bB'''Vq+-%fS.\AH''rS/DchS21JJl-qsd-,As6
&fE(c@s+q$c/\kAl'$_FJU:Ec/K13BQ'-C*[llPG@=L+lj9]C?_E*3DL.cCselZi@·
A. AbX7C"*uZaF(>J"2e>CTXS;30GtT&21%XEIOJt) S'k<*_1.GWXeUOlR@\)%qSK"
<+>Fs$r@C762s*s.?dXBbg]VlD"LbkAZ.+6/FhmGrRni?T14WZ=cN'B$ [Z/1e$an
mleV<GE$J=A Y1 \EmTb61U>lB$b63</FHRF;M[RQELAfdsA_R) l"EqflU>_m/rXLi4
Page 12 of 43
�ARMS Email System
#JfpW*dd#7ia7bSS"g)_Fqk9IZ":n*aS)nk-BqDuS$'UU>]uIJ+ke(Z<9'QI"CZ$1
CbbBfApe] qcQrJ==JNf 'W_+M;rZ (%IAKLrr-Tk$eIFqDNbol K#nB#XE , S_9"IH;R
JA/ioOkG] ClUJhbq"K:JBd) +V.TL\r"m&A o $ZsriJ'X2m"2I<OWtnIGD--j:IC:Pf
ibYiZYnmf47>.]a%\g<4-Sf;#SO<S9I<3(7=D:@dP3/]SKjS46#U<1WQnl7&(@rho
A
"-(k&"nq;l>$FRR;_]-<OZU-:26/9?UCGQC9IS:@SZRRqp@lC>bK k4%HWWkQ/:S#
l"U'MZ;:?&6)S<?ga?U-O>nf7<f6P%109] ,2Vp_[YXYDA+H=EN(LL#T9)OCT4KOt_
/&YVjQb<7 r'-Kl2ah2;oQQ,6. :I [WZOh*+9V7*] JId&$B7P$*n*Ur%lgA*I)Q'VA
BUS/(R. :fa2(bS'ouiSc/*OCESS,J'$@VQg6KZJ*_'m<IA<)r?#dAN>7EA9XdTUN
[Ce[KTUE2' (DNnEd2B-omJ/pk.-: '_G':FC,+IS#V3-\_.O[N?Nc'4tJi>%b[FRIO
>ZlS" :c["#SBBNSG[sgII_7S'as]/'>buubI@Pd.dhJp$O-%7:U/OoqGIT:+r@lr
:=is IC_nRmNBT_6aS, 3jV<#n(EisA+2) :M&]\s(mi-' [up?B++I AFfgqZSQAzuLrt
R]a:\N.imO;=r:ni"Sf<2XZijr[n#SMYWcENRiZ,EBJ3:@UIoM&AIGKfs;UF3K(W(
cKX=aiIX9] ns%e/Hko2qJ3XPoiQ9+&] Y749EuH&I3ts&"RNP<qJSMQO. )XIOdtVIu
A
>$4Z$3S?jOT>ZGBA7[9bD' [KpH%V @&IkQUppdX[+UV,Z,hd'2fE@X7k_i4,IaKch
Ap=RT]<GV2c"DPDK<N=&pAkXY%2d7[*;,QSc"WVu\O*9:m/(9#:<HODI)q]*TI%_b
>;4Z02PO/o'3jO&HaX=3Z9%Uu$tB4LA>c@@F2jSg("@or#SJiU/e2Sn>/#E+XLMXL
A
A
?(BGtcq>7Ddg[9<UE4S)M-r_aD&pAI,j/Cc_OiRy _AbIa&sV &07(1MifKea#I#Y
'[Q%W/c_.B>H#kR/@%e7SuqJOoK2SRJ,P._kVTJ(aj_BaoX()%Md/PJKS,TO_O\.G
Wkoa] rXgSURQ,Q9&Xmj3<rP7 [$ [cMnO'b92CTSYn) KaF*7,t"IPZldTO S/<TrlV<e
bFTI=T'PH/PgfMpJ" IHO' U, " ! RSI/ bIN; [lCW ( 10 (R] 9-; s) @NC" ,d>: S$W7hgQS
A
fI,Vs 'gg%3qkX [CJIG p7/hSvr6EgpJCH/lUBo+;nISd7+rfX>.OV4-S aZ:]GuE?_
A
r4:D ad/p,'O%-lQJdE/f7HL'kn>BF [p]jA U,2)rE'2d[="*&/=\3i e7%STlaZ
bCS&D?=fpAA;,kI2?k&IKms$YCVI#t%bm' :YjXdo [Fi7.0>7d3SXId#Y;,p%+;OY
A
c(ZnG&OhV03P-E6P[04%Da>L/CHJpnRPYS[SjZdG*Z*@3F nP*(QEITUjmmtBml74
"bWLJSDMU-S7rllPUS'S4"42"EOVJCS"<"R'CS74I/V;;$jC='KB%[916Y.q9+-S*
D@Z)jk*7&UGqSA-s+<EOn3CTPl,S#>kM(Of/BT-O.Z3M%I%+=4c$<c&SOI'X7Iiuu
A
<\-") a;IS/NS JaX?=/S' :aY.G\@2BHCGGFQSn ,QJBboE'HT7tMXF'k)YAmldr(
A
4dRKl4Pp?lIM#7%i#e_IL?4'LPIk/i'XH[ZV4TFC\6,p[Po.xo e+z(7\ELKHSres
n 'gt" jXNHZ20iuj 7Q]16VLJ&F<; AoEC (Jr?IHZ9G+i-] : : bFX< -$: - [@=<f] [SL=t
A
A
f- d-%WsQt#V2CIA+'plbMpYfSNbPSUeF-"oqy/ eFS A
A&A E jLo Dp@OUsNTa\O:O
T4\QeGFq') GOSW&VH,#6>'Bbr] PlR7HY,d\TrrJE'7C[bq=A 7 (6fS&n "2JMdp2,BO
*Pc[uBS6kRF\'96<nYF>,P\2S:I?,#FS"Ae,haV\"4HL[(bUU'D@9q@#@ooTF7fRk
GH6*.Sb#iDr'NdU,m6Rk)LnUuZOlOHqSIi=S]LMGS73M/3GBXqj"uoOVIV_O<LqQP
<40)S%&QS*i=PU%g7mGWY%eUm]mHRg3\)jRj)L3$O:BF<2,@@l&<GKg&hffAZBsZJ
A
\X_) IIXS 9:VS9c\Re?2j&iR?Z)Rjp"SCtqL%',n]uMKp[i7(oAlj3nk?-V4LGbl.
U80%GhS'TSLXfmk"X#?mX9+Ro/%YM>'T$jl'XO%&XMBO%/Ogl?hahTO?J]ANiXIF+
cAXD7kA:BJ[/bj?m9j7neAu#dbPher\L3@O"GPmtM)ZDH3(dICW?[f.%Xl2ZJ7<OU
cmcI?'PX=CjL",2SWH7BA'#SSgone'8RjO"IA:kr@+OK-IeKmliOg=S$EmKRirr6s
)QMFb+a#I@G,,)*A-/U7U[&NB=A7/KpC*T[L g'?OpS.EZEN++DGuO'X%HJ90i9d6V
A
A
1- I'MD R@OLKG46Pl;M- /Yg,igHu,BJn8A[mIpl<M;:'XBH.d(SP1 z\DL#aFsxb/
2/KEI>JrbX24TJ) \q)Y<IY[tLIOPuS'CuCmcUnMT:JDMf4n'<AjB [f8H sA&RX\/Y?
n"GiD?fC7>.<A P06bxeaEW#hHkP/?WHSnOmOYm<If&QTVD_6==_>d?)I#Tk8X'&->
.OR=EY IMYIgIZC6?XG\Tk&*\skDTpc= [; 'cTG)d) , *S?Me" :jGdKn-Y2UV"Sr70
A
)dr'UC;C)_OYZva*nL.If@@3?">'YehWDkP6[oi DIS&3/d-A).GJRn[;c/xAj\:o
$Sg6 [" </db@\@C) TRrAOaf (/Qk (@/qnW*UiF>cB$>->+4FH AfnKcMuhPZ_/ . jA4S'
"Ar+'RSHE]q; (oVkq49]"NpXlaZ/SlG@l@:&Q%_qmf8\JVnHdX(qRsNJ%(==:83 A7
A
TBOT. I (tKj7_GS\[kRr&+IFU'93?ib-)*UG<+hC:E<28nV 6$cGTo2DgLa&Q9@:me
$Udl%7qfsl#P3;T8sGMMb2npH*Sg$rf]p\&&"EI<@6V*edf$iIYu9k6 (]rnH\mSH'
g/009JUh7L) Sa@A<VsOa&'H+3QqeI]"k/@UH@ohglV/2?Sdf#Z@#EIO . UD) WcaIuql
P\T8NmqOSd&a <n7$E4XkT-'adI9S(H@I;C, :E\eG;rmT:)uFDKlqKSpSObOrojp/
A
[Oe4JMP$Eqp]tW K97r#m\S<U-M.S9T@Agch:HV&lHOKd(E.=PlG-ef"DAuKRckoW
A
[cr+"?&g9ShtrhX7D,i313iSEE=6g'PLYfVI>Wb,#'oea MC3 #an2'7VC ?3qYMJ
A
m-i2toUOjH]\.?e@S]M@:MhEn8bSR8jAfGnc m,YXoFoGf_SKrh:B$ZIHOHffk2LV
KSV.bml8+@P8dg>Lu<RqhqdJ'bX?[2_XT<g+$>mYB$/30%Nb,@T.793IP(;VIR&LS
A
Ic:/UbFT:p*FAZ WS6c/ZpTjG::fAem@pCCA'#\IUu:g.PEj=O@p"msIN\gHS?@VM
ad6tXN\hG<_TS9JiYEM#Z@SQiehTh)"tEVMIu)AS*Cm)G#OM?(jmoQ;=6NjY9H_#I
)CiS':#G4a"Q2?bKtb9BFFWIPB"AmZM370%2h'%\=O=N>@pfln'+PkFSM\B=pOIbY
H9\<Oaas@IHKj44StS/QkVW[t,ZA_AS[AA oEbWOQ/q@s904%@%K3PZ$bR) ;$T08r(
AkDbGSL8#C)ke'I/\?2oi6[AQleApLB:j8nJO+RZ'Cmo<@>nLWngeoMOYSVP(pVIb
eIE;C/Sue7j+cbK4Y, PSR<*oA>AtBp$?ll,FbIKRegl-SF'; *_jrqai Kmn\bOJlqe
Page 13 of43
�ARMS Email System
.L. [R*I) FU\j%Ooa"hJNS (,a)C$=PS>9gef/nqoK:$lruCdnr-&K?OnZcAj -6WXM?
pqH'Ikcf#DapU.)11#EfrncS-Fcl&4@RbGt47U'=SIIgA3ieiI%JF'=db)SIX@Mg4
YNp AY'<%X"aj,2?T3<GBT2ru#C@3)S4Ut<R"<D*dklM)4ZpO?-AI E %sCAde4K[paO
VMTqEpn2oQj6FJ7GnSSa+DRW/[a4@6>??'OMK/c7W&#e06.IYW')dfLV30uq#') (C
>kaTSO/A*alK%de "m~' *KqlZ- ?W79El *S?F' [Vd9GtT4kj sm/ 6 -LTAa&V" f?Huc\h
8WixI<n"W%cEgF>*R3A3IIPI;@:YMfOHluQST<%"V)GEmmsZ:FA39+=»a#SEkLi?
A
Z#170q6(sISknYB_UHI@ISS#;/AAojA[G_*dEE +DjTO%Y) '64YgkKWP\C=sOIJ<A
OMIbP@3b+OJV$CoHb,$M4)A Lu AT+"J'Ogb\I;%SOU7(,$Ncue\LK\7+j\TO\@V4Q,
NG'\cNI,BGe+Ct>#tNStVhlqT#[,cEr(uNHICA.h[PBc<jUEQ*FA)CAkhKm;)&)hl
A
)UHX'?IQlfma_SPogg;#>@"eQ:; [D*T<i9R+PrYS7LV?DAS;$Y'SWG o<e;L%D==K
_,"$O/'A"@\3Zon4%4(jC,a,-IXA9q%\21(tYrXiU/HOA,N%Gch?$PR@SQ<SHciq6M
*qiiBIW?>BcQRECU<S)Z\Q@bi"C/=f@&7fhi3VTX"d'N,fDjOi9SXrW<Jt9Z3@sn,
A
GVKbAI"NW\PIGpT3T D:;Kt6#L*?&2 IDg#<ZIL7\W39m3Z6;eZ/IJrrT">\)eU'*
A
mZ.TFb49cSZfSLQ,04') 2SD+$'$lSJSUffUlq*OOR\,f#=', il)ZUX $16/wv_rv b
A17[=T<
)MA:<E"CS: :qS'GmSj@Sk(7VfI6hY6LhgScR@m\hPF2Y)GI/Q%)DaeXELe
A
A
OA\:+?9knY\Oae3JF,ho(6iSIS'MT.I-+ I4ir?21U4s2 ;df=%RerS;So<*S?mS(
?fl'0)6:"'-L/@aO"L=*srgr"tC#o=_T2IDX3CCosrloZPfSMJPA6KS"bYTW+<[#=qW
Gimop'?JYnXMe:p?h4AgQ7Ih%21(gAp90ESWLhS*XHOM(@+aI3)lD>R%rOOTOcFse
JXRkti@JAuMF\) tpg"aBH-oWj epo7 ('t*d<ok\. u9$r; ?oj , $PH<XGK$fPSX/ 1is [
A
ZW3D%BI;fcAh'SjOX+7)Nd$I-/6kdF F>[HM+j SA2C \ckr?) ,0[&@7 O.mrKNNJ
A
L,QSS)k)O'?LnS_\Oph?"7S'jB3k4okDJID"eLI/e E?7) ;+mR&k9jT<&6+<cI=%e
-aCEIELV>I/ES=\7d)sb-;_Uollr6)N,eXOmL7D4P.j$*C,kOfRIIteH&k*AZdA#
rr6=Lp[>2p:PiYG<-ISmEK\js3g,V>K;&g:X9BQb/@dmNIVOoJI=S,VoYIZkY.I>_
A
A
'$.<?DTS MUHGKK;m:G3M>@$/$,J6\/o'a=6 KXnloe*s)60PB*/GTdFII+'''iOU9
4S3D<pY_b, [6dZB9,qN.Ima@OW79=02ic=Ji'mkiCo%,A BR&LBS'*_+q.RgdKF2'B
C3/%) d@NWIBt; 2j : j C\Fr 1Obo#nVa% 'C; a%lS 'pC\ 7Y"oDZ" . CWW>XN2iZ [; HQWn)
f "W$X49 "h' a9dT&$NT2) 'P+JU, luIcVH=LLNdSqa3qMs . A#mb' SS\DMI7MhqHno&
A
MEfjm*ODIC &6)qO"gQPg' I@L:I:?BMCLf<R?J nOnMN4K(M?HrUT»mRlfK=dL$h
A
#\LqI12:6k""76&hHf?aZ_l"=k@mC'hu_ U/G3P9d/ksa9qf+)U'AV>r, ($BFKlq(
0(>: Is%'SU94)YcMKO%o@oNm9;2[HSLnKadOiS;BgCWRTn@"XG'6Q,C>+,bW7MUIA
Yl-SBFGJITKMT>ApbRlt+;Gq;m.gn/pITHGb2e9A.2jYYk-Ec7omO"XRN06Spe)T>
D/p<IeNA(_OIAcVjfMpA[F$a&,gBYbiWalRJHQC"&mWI>m+"sqbVKE-GsEh)b-c$#
A
N)NS#Wj)N4KW?eF\rYb%%?R4HnDKE+Ho$Tu IJBpY*a?aCe*-'eI7Su#(ed@DH9k,
uqSO/ 9Jq A#&[E,Ph:m7Za%@DlgZb'4b,+sY:#I'VS9g9bXXi=epp'dBhFrl*9Y)AI
A
a MU4dc"@gF.JH",bL,BjhSoaL<J nmt>lbS)I[B@A cp ?N'9S:)S3XEoW lu> sZBJ
A
)lp H7kSOfB[INO*0">bl_A-li%Z)lc/a6Mh"Y:7:jATG ApL\SSRT"9""'M"_hP2
q" 1I TFbl$ : &OndCj QYI [ [Rt \hG* 7qa% I dJb-GkZ7hBi3 ST?d==KOYRI2L (Mn@hVUa
A
X,qOnO@c7S*?D-I+_cb\Sb>;Cn?B&+S4EI/ gXJW$sV)aMY,Pj+IS$ec\Y[)YKh?
c_EL>OSm7V$6K"iIL/KL@V#\S-gA:Z(rWlb,SqV2&[g:L2?OtSj;lKIX7?r_h*lb<
27BIs .. BlmH9D>?)3DRK'D#(dq+.do4tQkggtPs(GP&P:p_L A»YQIb«Apre?iM'
'UmMIk'Cb~E=7S$gS&Sc21$t7MnE;S'<*g"sq*mjDOrSZ>?:+$N/ b/oOEl(spSS
A
[Hb\%?SXC=E t2ZEb2#bmhR*. Z; , .) rGhX: s*e6+ (/#\B$NY36CU"O (+cqQSg+OK'
>c:ZSSYq6geZhS>RI A , :c((*6IRfo elr&Q'SrNG.NSbI>.=R%6UZ d"c?\qjM\u
A
8: '=RQU(2) s&VmM/ggeTV 9$p&C' *#7j-.S&$92dD*p.g$-K#D)AkV AZk[ s%#*kdg
[Q'&Z.tl\Klt@2k<Jb32@Jo#AiOBSL>aP'K,UT+2VfWl@e'FdROg.U&.W[NLe3 AIP
@BLdq()1(%lh@3=DIQA*;%0= [Z.q-4) QIQS [;" :=Y6: I"', 9PT<. B:EQYH%c. "CZI
A
d\m'k;b;>A#Ec3 '."oY)Fu[r3SUm2Psqjt"la-G@39AS&G\i6,LOItljlrqos\-W
jb$647=d[I<,NHp)r>O-(XV)j:+,i+MTW'CI/,2BSI.qYQIDZk-D'*_)nZ=MZe21+
LMJSVaL3Sf@) IrEi$OSESbDUBF"SOuQ rrTUa9SnH'c2'?tTY &PJE6G@4&S#bld=
A
);=HdXXO,<phlGm d6(+V>b'Xlj9W7.X173pe?[S%,-t%_/'V+X?(k\oHmdX9FIUb
;ij-U\<SSehGt<;*VlqT'eVH)EFXV) '$S/bFXtlgmj/q4i*0/NjRnZ06T-*m)m AD+
n'JU?)rOnc6YK$<0#/I%4ANM,/LSU[pgm/tZVkVopok/b"3SVoWI7XC=c+4*CI;21
=bZ.3%W,U=VOTsA=AuGX>-GDOgjr@qbOg,cSqOB'1[Am_NSlhA@qljFA+1j/i&VOc
9$E\bqX3?Sg7S1"F@7/uS*_;A7W+S'H?kF:09h:IIVB:I)jd=,MnAI=m.$k:4ucGS
<$SqAgYRo-K' <Nhj "hI. TV' :ps13ZhBk: ,#-9SX>4SBmDY%G: 37X [m#6$6aG4k+\#
A
N 1 'H 1a<I: bjV' <U*CSARrK' 3rIPJ. qAi2Ej T+Term-VtYE#t#t2\OPZ +) "- : 6Y&1
Id2BN'KqI9MOBud_B03r-d"*',S7(u.'aRs$u((PG_S\d)jitBS-G2keDSI92tU#B
HoS?) " .IE.b)R9. AGYeGg 0>'@nj9UVN$K) 'QAa/p'd%pql [V=hISlEXG3naXg*sP
nLrHTF(YC)=D_2M<,U,D30Rg%h%Aa&JRhj>?GnqAgzN.<q) \$<$$3 JfTbl$QtSR,
rMZI?0:A@?VCCLVr_Oem&dWOY/:N)m.7r)F'C.iU4j?)k-&Z3bp70E$i) .&i/Lqd>
Page 14 of43
�ARMS Email System
]MC.K7[&"albd9?\4jMrO:l&g$,Q4:d/&J44[ac>Yr%13RTU"C-ni@cV_%Ho>OoXa
TR ) 4 1TAj -cg, +OP<B- 19<); SUu [7D" ; +1 'Oh, .@06HMr*q$ehD9kV$K( laR*QF=
p=CZdBEmlfhq\ElZKJ(p4=pOEC4[AVS k@(61#VfN.E(Qp3j2,qXb\WSis+-tJ.YeE
A
hqDbYi AfQ4qA(aQTHWr>a]sfYHU60;.">(lPCS1&,Y-&#@&WokJ .g,$nB+K#r3u2
A)&gU=(CD4QO)-Xt%jd[ZVr>b36"X;FV-pVS+])OM>+USXV$-nUl#7S?
jn[edGolK
-G1--n19g0L'@/DY#S+/[<ShJLDtKj21t:Y[F64l".hm1Srrb?pP\jlp[lf7*%msS
34uDF3[UXOjmlS:%p?Q1r ALRQS$-b2fm$_sS1)DlrreCh_A1bE-4<SG+ClYe)@k)T
A
VS$i;ffm9LP4r6P0111pbMS3@_;Z2r4bU-J S]OAkS(ji7:CD#"3jlSUO' ,<=lRu1
A#) j (YOASfOk3sEAB; jM)) [) =/F" (a [U [<tr<+9"GkY/CG1Pc30n9*2eR
X2sV#%mt
j)_4daS$hbiS7,tnp$AR4AG-?%hRq1Hka+pYf*4JcAR&"ZbsbqAaA=t1_=[>#W@O_
maO(k62LD A;DOYd:SF4J-R9KLQ<\o921g#S*tfks-9K?"q$gU'/& ]Wc6plKC3Y %
RQQl*3StMr)Kt\=\, "lC$>q-S:cBKt#*=bV'j [SSZ?A UB A=@TC#9X>dU+D+jA[V-;-C
A
CS462#J74<XloTPN@+@+%us9bfc)HRDh[pX>;<GDfa3::p9=]t$]pZ<Te ]4T\KC)
h+3g77%10'X&hMJ90))cUAS@#=9Fd«70&*Vq>SeQG'GVlu(GOf&14_1eh]G>jr"A
mQdKO[C m20)ke:,VOF A7,&jMD;JV+-S&-o'jtO$&&A oBe <rrJim]713>r6Q2c M&
A
V.AMP)\AW
jF.Sdg1]/k#'grFoDbR[2,XDSl9iB7CNqitE ! :/TDFRnWlfmSE/kGOS
?-"rFSWLPq-(-Tt1] ;V2\AbfeYGc)U/QrE=A. LA*@GV@ql)B%amEpSe7FMN;HXJ\:
(4*p4DS'\Wb=@4X-: .%j7db*kl2f=cr>kC1S]*7B;O+>BmE&Th,*aB\>4Md#;A )6
A
04-U@Y[-=Ohs_"lV2[%dlT"ka@GB 6V"MOf-du.1Y-1GbAmOo17:\9>\UKrsa9$6k
L6:>CdX9[$gnK:mdPV*o41r_",a#bkll.Uc,a7ll0Eo*UPiD_(HtWJih3tW3B<HBQ
2SYrjo+- _XGM: 1 lWdOr) DB<OJ<XZT'!jGNQ>dMeKO. ZmkZGcZb_ -e (ta (g3*of: jU$
A
o\""rmE1Tr@-mDSDe7ZbB., :T'S>s(?bg,T7:AMGS&JX&.7.]PW_s 1#@o<R[OM$#
G= XCG&H>cf.+;*=Ak-MMKoYAdSe+B$MGK+ZSDgm) Z<#bRp<_A B, <4:/TKD Opa""/
A
&V$VD\UOOSTB%%H 1l*\dSL\(K7uL;+(>LZb'V] 4 QGaVM.X SSA4TPW/ANd03LJ
A
SlNoo-r)1.H2'32;L?lGBR>91DosnE1A>u.-qb1~md-e_SYK[01LUB?2C1/a;1 gG
'Giqolu9Z=%pY]t*lS4m-04fj&Ofgoj41A)n*C\mk'WdjnchALTqT$/X_@R1YOSiD
F$11-S9Q1k<llNli:/1prja c,SmTYV=Zi#lGl%,s)#FF)Ofh] $%] [.SLsj\S7,-0
A
k] (aOh+aQEcs:S+HVS AB"A7IC3f\BQ;a do*q/j*F-m69&>"Xdo1qn/&%Hs'#%m-%
TCAR1PSf#VGBV[106fUBQ9-1:FosASJ(UYb11c=@V>PFf QlgrF12fV@a-3FL(2i2
4?i&D2Kr6 A3,Z?,BJDpX4uV.S)t-X#-A' (Xr'M*F3uFoH?eS&o*\iC#Mdnq2aaF~
n"g?MJLmFAy ]bhRu\Su%c@'h*TNLMFl1$ieA1L90ug[fnE11q;;T+62go$; [ qlA
MCBg97k:mv+F:1RV&3WMO/34pl>OT.3] TZ=/?A:d>YWPe\&sZsP?NOuOW9sf.9n3T
<;A V6 ,6[&Pe1oE24r3j@7-%) :6 A->tSH-;?Tcjk<[&@fSjPLF?Tcd1]XC=juio;\<
ic-VtMB)U/3=K.NK+lqPC6R*@L@lFabBN9>RHh6K>hjrjd7.\VW>f)O/i?rDO/*SF
N_b-Ue .n?&CiibVC 1g?F$%AWVn#Lahs' M$LOh<l; ?F1; J' [. 03WONpcp 1s, / (F" 1& .
:q&S&jmSiE1FmRjUYpl1iSO"@?HaQ_Wpoe\SOsX1Tqp_mnLB(,;GEA7j\%G.Z#caJ
o9KdAk1»hDR:3TWK_)\FBLUa:JdSS'*@/uQOn[Y9_qYJZ<'Nf>d;A 9 ,rlAVld[],
pJc] ;m*nB$Sr7%S"K?nYTlrq(o>=Gn9S-1u&N(*EZSacmA)1&#lA*FB)=Qi"F1X1D
d#=;Z%+1$A ZOYbYDk-oS*]A 4 ;WVAls"l WMT&RrhW]Y s. (CTPodK?H*O+)#rLnAS
XA) lrAPj(EhJhh/\Nao_Vb.Rg'--Hd4E%VkYabY_(iS(lJ]U2 A6KS;a?<$&=UM$E
=(R: [R\a2-b,Xhck6J+Y1KWCZ$g$]t2.21]AbQ16-NSlnG,7QbMG A-(/7#D$>3/s1
?mCW:nT7-q' (]-* _/sWgTt] Kf"mm2*gQ: 9uoBqlOh(Nns%dZ>g\f<l..J1Ca* [n\Xbg
plf?»MSi/ A='F/Z]TlRV1mM1Bt4SJ7hOBAJ<Z+L7(pGOaWrbn?S60JYO=<YK#C@j
*E: =VaSRnh (qkTl [=g6 A l4S9iH?$MlF7%6[:j+J;M-9SE1)OZ3U%n/ l?ctb'4;TuE
]?RgLM(Dl##fWBH/g1yAgA#mD,@SWT==&$/;H>lV[oB\]J-Oei_d\jK2.uT)_q+VO
A
SMZ4#cRpFR[3 UOYTl6T9k-\\$h3=L+1\=k*u+'AcfZ?X=SohO]-uoS#Vjm)bNb=1
HL@-7pSD;Fj%mW]-"VniSC&uNq[:'KiSc-%,fSR[V&m2cn%-VWT=+GH+dHNg3c17g
SOC]Sn@E:+6t+1A*JHrX>[_:S;R+<JQs-$11)u,#1-An-Or41Y\T]1--HCrL.hg\T
A
4&,-,?A"#nZ9s"Pf1LJ;Qka ;qm$i--aDt]G%oA eH <DEXPbSB_fj4q\M9/j]d<1@.il1(lA WK6S @M1ii)-/"DZ>@S]>meRaF\R>3aQUN]$SU_f?&EJSVRb-KU64nqlLatK
J7T%-3m_?KXtsG2q[_(hSR=ui,tU2:;%$to=\9$*>V;;EaiW-KPKQLO>@Xm63S*Bd
.$YZCCP%A L6 ,H-@Zl+W$Npppn1t9Y2R1T AdBiVkns*ek03N>1?@Pa;cYLXQYm%qS>
9dfGrUm6[RZ9G4(H'#1o\H;<ZFKDV1s2V21dDq2Pno =pGLlC];hd(WqZTaV,"k7G
o lJK9. 6s"4Y- &. =. *2SCGQ<_?1 -mX=OVAgMYn+ [C-J#K9io@-60GE (/3%_BESMhuD
7,DQqArtcmWn=SFLFCi&Y9lA_<f$_B6DS/kL=:ZSSU$E[%*7spGT;cJUTq?Di[a,j
oq*LD?2q.S(*O-&\>dO:<T:i?em7)PTbX-o(SeoOWpfDQY,L$bR;K-q,+D04.&d+%
<%RKH\:';jSVGEh-<lreo)Eq7juOd$L-KrRY]9Fmd>.D A]HA\d;:,RDTPon_>%pQq
4Kq1lVB12f22jpr\aS A\?b.@'Wqn.GGS-&/lOBW[\,cS-7[%BG6Z12/?f7u9Dds>1
EUadZA*m21\cs<)Os) [rL,%l3&P3ptFXV-VgAaKqZJRKi$sA D/ LdsR:&lX<-1<lA q
A A
qH(soo#"B01)S:Y';nP21CO)bKa6[b11SSG+ T3lDNOMHB?VS &U ?DrK/)SSsAAA
Page 15 of 43
�ARMS Email System
,SD(Adf6fb6'?NWa\A]C=#=eJHd)AG1~#%fG4SUA,aRIAOe] ;YX1]9LSg->A,ik.O
Xn?ahnAkE ) 'eo+bY) gTO] Lq/+ 'GAPnbJmc [%+OD+$U B"Ll%O[R2aV]n'=]-neS/
ko AldWX1]74AlR.JdqrU&hl) ;a-11207L[)PkjOl,KC/LmSDTRJ@5WSJRi_I2CI@C
m]U97*3#6nm#Ln+F, 'OlUiP3da;iO/20p(HesOEF(G:K]W"OOQ:M7e-\e?SqW3tDGTOp3_2D4fQ=SlS+O#BfKRIYOH$IZ] .%7W*I\3+5<ob:NPbana)+?jI]pYg&<IC7m
mgRo$-ZB; 6C& [VSSd+>4MpShTOtTX\P<c_lOb-=gSSf?iUung (S3%5 ] ,t All A+%>_9
KLVWm'XWfs-:lAXNIsEfa*Kvl-iZbB;hAHlWsQ,XoW]AC-16[rO\F/,M;fIReQ?eW
A@D@* .A, "CnL?q. XMFql 3u+Jlqg: \Ndr%j_=Y9u_g6t;d3HiH2\ [=N- [3h [_q. QWJ
Wk%"uSWPl.fUG@%GR9mZYN;Zl*bWP3+$NS)F xioMV1:ROO klYWWcB*D@F\k2uCC
lCM4b;OA[HJAWOslS6oeUaSuM]kpi6 11 0-O'i&rNH' lJ400LWj*7DY4sb=h/ui7qZ'
A
mf] »a#+= "Q@Y#g 1nPE+H+l A] . k*e< -C@c+-I, fn6XB 1/$OCB4bccWWP7mBl [-6d
i]S - : eaR?79VSE>oDcEleS]] H; KH*: A-dJkoo) +K] g] t "bg- =R7$p6R< -EoGd] (pS
A
-EL=oQ*A_a'o/>h)JglLACpJaS_GdI1C E%(E\%2")r,O\=NBiSI2)CVkK\fQd-uC
A
fPgiB]jS+<&TAUSd=R<Li"D)%--+-RBjtcq>;P/tlV@Q AbPla_(bZX?@$(uSGD3B
Wh[Sg7;/MjobFB06USM4S%mlk4GV&MGVS*.Xf>blZ=F]f2M.KNV*)ZNk1\=@B.9SH
A[6]3%Ek-roK@@]WRq9SASX@h:Q?tdk9nc- [V5ZG$T6TdaP>G-#9#HZ&WKb)YD_+
$C12,jOp:L$.HO;h-KjQUHe-/*RV,&/h@Wt7N(6a'HmNS-Ab_T610hZ>Bdlg, __ jt
. $IlIdFlN/?O$nV#<7&]4#TYX"LXs: K$jrT* "EIZT: jH. $mAWsXQd [SMOm3ZRR «;
A
cm91Ric) lXUN015c\N%] j6">P_GZ/E_S-r]gEtQ-Rd;-T=h 3PJ*"$u (Y3Fl\1[Q4
;,*H90@/A#eNmWgCHm,ob?-;qSOFC:VDR(MN&+i(#?qtGOY6]ST40SrUNc6;LoaRf
]JhMBaQ5H:] :\\ZRXHtQ?KoFG,A=13-Z-@5H=6bL=Abn*A 1J<SB,SmplAXDXTS@/b
:jeJsBP,chXm-PS+HQL?RTgIPdSnW[j\? (YA1+md5>R<6jO= 'iQXL=p h39=HnTHgI
O+W.YfBI7"O#4usU12<J\n91"_+?[Oc-hiUp)B#R<MXfHcQu .. */nl+_IT\>J>_t"
A
BnO<'X?=kL/S)sKT'%YkQ&mP<-DAZ2gLALECVV-FTN 2,i"t,Z+DdoXSosLbljlK'
A
NIHe' J\ AOo"Da6hU] [MQGA?Wp%JSPRoLqIS>RO<K_>QhZd9-Cqg"NO/rNk SdE?<X
A.S(mPkSDbjNM&aSeMCOjH%SI:b:+Ea_d7;T AG7+mNd\=L4)aj7gnB<@]AZZc91
QX
A
n[SWF,4+9M H/R,#7Pom&*UBPhTO(U@NRuN/iglK[J)=V91oAgOk4?W/-uFtsSD"V
9ARxeWB4AEAMSZlkX@h7CRSOILZSAjOs@?jjT=3-7JAElXEQ_t'-E4?ZFa>b:#Abb
213-(mfO[,nF>egl%4@9>1+dNA?@;#'I#K5@)sO-W4%-MbiRLocgO<.di&kfOQ(gM
QDK.Y+EWfG@k'@Y+=bqPQ-n3>Zasl*s77/C1Cfi7huLo*T4:PW92YciaT?<jBV=91
OlSA VA&mlS$07=aTCT;Cp/_/-J<cXAp&TQ:DZ.H?$m)9amYV_47elubVZtnsI)BJG
@R:u*706$AZ<EA:1S*%14mK\rSk]]DOlp*,lYkb:Sl/«[#e.NKI,N1 IiSt&XVr\n
*I:fcEpd;cb9(I AllJ(cb_Lblf&*<mp%1*-N.Th_O.pSZ#SL#sAHXp<KYa$nGK%OlA
g=4n]WE@eLM9ATXM sMaCtVQ@A g - SilZAhjSSMfGlmp4IU"B(dY>,HHj3PA d9;mR
A
>-A,C&em+O-3BQUi:pM ,QFu_On\7=WDlfOK&VnPETQN*Ctpb\5=:/kr#+Wml>SMR
A
A
p;FG7L:Fl\r SDLa;D«/fhTF1>Z2@qT/%qg]&eI3"T>.,DD ?fP*b_SnX,qftsf*
7Y)WWWrS,IPk*4#VFNjZ>LteWHH1:p*41\"JZd_mR+gSEnX@eSB2mODWg] '2EqDnM
C/:@pj&fO[*jlkg-mXe"\$=t'OAD$Vlde<$B@3LV;RG>S'kLVOXd&UGO=9X)&3+[H J1Cdj%iemSZ SSFgL,-:q&UI"5] d%X"Z+aFkCUnSZ'R@/ l-[QOB[Ijc<GC./.
/WS@flWr3t<T2f5W'N5ejM*,jQCA7oM-4g1r+(19T+*-d?="Hd AJU@4+\&/AV>e>1
pg$;V_Kh623sf.\VmpitNY4sjlFW1I/bg21-.d9514(Zc>X-ijl"1XERk@:lir?T@
dD[ApI$-$Es,j7I=ZV/ O.@kA-a(]SPu*]j\D%'fS% MlqYVhQ$Z dl:uD@.oWIOL
A
ZC/B_IksT2;mAUbg3<j/9@)\dHlpGr#XS3I+SSqjepe2 6D\+kM?NTG]2ImbjMAmW
J*As264P3YSOBWTqiR+p"0'7f :2W,":Wkp\rU)Kr:2*F3;LluX-9IRLcSR-f'huK
<' ss -bZ] A=jqk, F_, : E) rF. *uj ?\dKe2G] t3 . WZ%L' eJ: lcW"D- ZV-pE20o&I3q+]
A
Pn5>#Qg4AKWjBNhRSLLOD\;n rXL) :n%#kNRlokU9g-Bt:S(POJh\u&XMHqKhl_u[
-3G?BQR*JEoK3<EIS(A*hj-PV ntlsKT71.]3&SS??A/ ET$E>/c9'r[$r'=SaKH&>
RJ_T;W)Zsd##@paS>I?K-N*drAADmY'faJ?AkW&p<F[LIOTZ>B;gl_A 1 ] Kh_GP[X,pd%. [-Gldg<5B,A HEHVifOMCQ&q<PMTMfiE-OJgP%dTuj*r*B/HRHO-<dh_S:Ga#
-gZcXV9HClm&S71--U+n]%mP+)3IO.'$3_M9.$d$?>Z(rZYSBK[M[V=7A'pj_(@U>
hNri*:)-Sf7at)OgjhM' :e61UBe+W,s+V#$IXn9QRikS-rA(3Bp$ROdUG[T<E]d@s
A
qD;nAPgS#ALFKdhUt[>Cp?9+Y <M#kk*tj#k9QfpZp30Cql"+ iYreU/jEi .7iO"
J'L' '#A@F-Cc</tD': 1995,+ID(opg?eMb.?]uJWKSl(L6@P/UCW"7\b%XS9YlbiR
ju<qB Af@6cilsFi,,*H.LHEWmEh-@-9?_b\4sGg-AZGcur7XF=lb#--l*l"DFSgDd
P+gVljj [\T\.-3McI>-lO.dQpYIWUSArIIO#klQb:&D[Uklk)OJ4&OnoSrlJD/ZMC
ge52V-<F4reOpi7pf4PS-&lcAGXoarJSZ-115tS@3QAulODCSAKO<pPHb;j=+a4*Ug
Y.-UaGmt\WNq12-.V6pqcPX#Vi-])h@n\c4IJohYT;sI4'%nEOO:Y69WrW; M@ge'
A
U#Ktd$quA 9 kgTs4 p$W$aD=I+-9p_gU%)uAfq7ZNBNxll@IWeS$MkG(bIOl17LqlU
;>NU2[4=T3S[ff#30V[WSp)*ml_)VWDY,KhEGAEO<edNd_h#Xdp%(nB/WG[W@]j+l
F?Q9WOl:$\H/, __O+6+N14eU<:2RQ41$>2>5DpF\_3P)eZ2Geb*ia:lS)+e%i7#R#
Page 16 of 43
�ARMS Email System
I:: 'TLW*LsVfMA:m\SM:b&Op+ljp.s$&6Xr;Vm$w*AQ-AkfkqebMktt/EY**>;9m9
WPt2JYT*KSG>A$&mt: (jraZJ/3b3r]R(H@6]3Qf8'qrf.2BG4fl+f)-\VjEhio]Z8
)lOhl*ns3G6f Ap ,-RZOI[Ve9? (FW'A9 tI<nk/GdANIQ(Y?*6 A
QK*=V/7+CbmVl
:_\#d_?<gdi$G(Hk,--\*ke:&dA4C_mWmle_&4Z11aSGC12>O?,tn:7>rlB,2MD17
rL*'PkOc2B%PG6S)".)?PwQCQ+)-O]T@+uNEoSBSY&[9">c=G4\fOYpX'USnP-cEl
A
['" (: ,X13hi,H?R AYIWXrlVASm.nOoSVdUE'mi&RS)U_Jf MSK\uV2FR;p8=SsOTC
IM-7V>eS/:TfO?cSs>DOFZ08;?' :?9Biqs/&sl?)*n(T'Ca]7p<.;&qWrq?HNFQ_V
A*un9.*1*pD##?(8Uqunl,Q6C[[g((R=Vt*OG;p321?#r7;:pY_.%QWQKHFBF@E)f
C+d%[K=dh-(2\J7k,uWHf*?;S:OhfeA-s\BcopC>VeYa?81tn.6;=f,IZVeAphP48
e:SK A74[kR Ah@DN#oB_/7f)BAmlSU-'gX4idm_TdNaKgC%&61s%fHZi-$ [9nC-Kn:
+(bS<)< (rl?6$Hl_NBkF[NqA16\uZA9I A6J4um2>SJ-GYLHll<E%Z$4?NBib"R8SZ
P9uo-m9J[+CNs6G2\_i',-pTr&(Ap[&p,+h+'$JRS8bRlhZ[g3YE4VS:30IY#[n9K
DX'@OkC9U_)"hOIN$-HbSl?B\h+OOS;/]_B7agT'41hj>-RORe[kJsScJnVCIQOar
4uKl Lk&k4of:Wt P:-8[D#jTrJ79t' gV+ODl?iWQXp\EQ *JB>C6Mq?Ga)"M<42
;TIO@DVl/Jpapo~@fMS7dBmh,=G\Cll\(\L9UQPFrdDcG2b.NeT-%+8?)n-l [/UM
1\, '<4m40S2U(Kk$NEa_Hoh]GK?fk4He\ji+s69TZtSe3fOhBCg, .OjCT@"jI"R2L
o:\$jkR%_<Cu]80@F4@lQ*'eh;)kE2' lrUg,S,c&#=GW&PG9C.]j#lQ8s0G4IeH[7
d<dh-RXnJYmokA-=-GD.I+UBbY'3+fOgY1M\QIHqZ&ao(J7&>-g9i;r2[»\JZ-4E
V-Y<Pll@-s4(ZS>X_oS"&fAWTE]minbVr$Q4?1&U@O;e,F<%fOmeVA AZY40b<T2CK
-+IZSMQ?a4mY17+Buu[@-lZH*NIQ13>.b/@F4&V)@YZ@uGIV7dH9p[E19KM@Fl.S9
YC6fl;) [QfYjtG>QBSk)]Z9\%q)K/$;gA/d?)V-NT]T Tnpf?a N;qNEHikAV-.R
~eFh$iJHW.@AV[Q4Dr]bE)ZjgrQXIF@Bhl»FlMPTjZreE,eEyA62ma$?PVKouTbS
HN*OPhE*q*%$M[\It*T1F>-+9PWf[rjSltVpM6Z#Zm2oS<mDgMASWnM,/eT8(GU/o
O-Z&[-"9%MWFj<6LpOHe*HMd<YsCE;-CLeOGmhS.G7MI;O+?-hnF6&JoI:qk-h,bu
j-;-19ZRbSTD)OBSZ8%ES.G$YoSbWpG:Ru_f.,UHSZQU8Ful<s78QWEZrje\$rcHo
4\Z>ap*.Z;B*(AA=rlcI4.cqTg2Xa-K]F/JU;.q#XhqlIlG<S9<bPt<r=Lb=WhQdd
2-ZcGe=%G>,CB-glq=AK-C\/d:#o9T)+lhG.<4dk+=N6KH%s&m@&)UFX.G'\80Hob
K=L/qpZdHO@:r+J&ei?Hl_a'g%2CGX79bdF;A>oTc]O[,3_qfdlpFL?b@]2-TI3W?
jG(uo@R%DLSe%I_8B>I60Rl>C8:,%e(TeSOp,O)4"F:;2r[I$'h<:AiIstUf--rfb
nS@8kQ\lH6WVH<qj$CkKl?qe=iM-:Ljbb/g/COa4$lNU>9[170-3QRKO?1[7/i8dD
A
OW[CC--lj'iQiO\X*(' :rAE-W\EUMS @h4"Cj#+2;-7Tj#lmtQ &IJE.#hi]C;n &
AjgCfXbMFR37Fg<OTt&AMOe
6\ (Y$2l>T, [FD-? (, RA 3XE@F-=8=$_G*#rgoEI&7B2
KsjE3;1>NRb"C7a>[ZFWq=%g4J?E/ji"J@CZprHIPu<M+7d%=3>MQG-@>%'Fh\O\G
pmup*]ni@OD+ZE$,A 2 ;)gkg;J$Ss@/D#hI/*;mOQ@oRWXU4V&SA) :iBrQPdASOV*
=RF\_L@bnnJelSeO A\l,Qq#XIcgqEppDmIg3$u.K<u]tRWJLJ[F8CDb+sqL]R'V/i
e$CtfnbuUMEj&quRmM-CJ6. [8nXs*FnU'AX4FU<9LIlmG%;6)L?W2jugt+BiOp-:J
;YpG, lZ:S#A3;hZ<EDmYC=%j#[@_OZP>A OKckWES#;%X/f:=1=IKS"j%J"*6\r'Kd
R' 8?>") FYLEOm#ZpWr' h_ <: : >Zn. : [ML3dVcF: YVJZJ"n -Ibn, Z: fb06mF2=9B+nW
Ubpmaq")u%:MCC._Kku*KT,uWeSQJ-*iXS2?' :Cl.8Zg(bLajIHJK6]3c?SPfn-bb
A iaVCfD(L/q%)2$;GE A$CWtkm)S@1'6cg;c«%O*CjHjeA:J214#K9/o]1<KbCFk
c
\Zcr3AVK%##/O+)<J+=-,QLVB>o)K%A t 6n20XHuXV\61beXUaKTjDl<S>Y)GF6u+
\p-UXApqAsX7S4$*c@nF6X'3kB4sgJXNllk./sQveDdWgu/go%NI'OH=c2&mQ+l>7
\&E2/VDJB)C(S+L]bPl#3F]=%24B] "A C+rO <cFW<A K]h>?;//V6WE3"P8/rXmg#UO
bk4H>.AQaqODUJS>TjS&40qe4klRU6TYE/31igM<F-)t*iZtuHck-aGHcSqo3LuIB
bSmoJq~lO(/-mDUG<-2)SA3AP+rDK-AGQW@Jht7CCD,ShkPSHS!.-RO-S-Wh+bj8-
pP8Sr8'nS7me%bp&/pq-pf>On2gbAWa/RNl+jtQRg',@4S6t] :E6nN]Or86TKNcpA
Tk;M-ZV2(%DDQrQB)VnO,#]I=V[tqbM#E A8:us-uW ZuVmD@KO' (sZciZeRG2\O$X
KI6, lKhUdCl;$mQkj<1-P%V/bouOQ2$8@sjh+_e%q?Idqfo8nTVd$"1@fF8?6M/,p
B20 ANZ: (ONQ>$YF7cbekZZp.B,$Wu$(">K?Q8GQicFlpgZkgOF&EBb9Fm?+<Yg?H'
TkS4,I A8J61 AR: [PQ[;thgi83p04/]XbdsS(+1\bl?mNpCFi9E7J8C<bU)]V> [YO>
p&FSHG@k-%ISm]bLX9G\=ddTO)#3M A6:IFa4\=M, ;jq&c?cuPEEeNu<A\<m<\Fh8h
Elqk/SR?rBau&F)&1<UV@U<a@1\%_XRFus/LA9@;Fcelk7iF%14EVnBRFJS&guU3q
b7=It?B4$ApF2 -d7\B3tQ[k.Sp2CnO:hS<7de&lZ24S81d%e%OF@r3HB88Df_#kPH
OOS?#a=WS<en.$a[JX6uS@]e=-]KC$d"fAh"#dnUh?7+VT/q@o=RU+iGefA,s.-qM
A
$-uj,:gJPu8t#\b&#_B-TO/sn6zw R_:*Z92CF&ZE_2$md'je=)PdU%/d;FqBHYLe
SZjkLPDlmOSqi,9*Xr2_4TUZLhTTUE<)+: .&?%ea?Y8K9rL+[$-#%Yr7-pXIM'2[r
fD$SLM?n-XaU\Eddlu[TOSpKV<K6q-Zc-lQREJ(:6--BQ3Rm:$GoAcK>sCUS*tpVE
'3BPLHiVi*02a6YZ.8r) OalM(WailM'p9) fnVYnc, <#G=fOCJOSAjA 1 Yp<s@Bfdr4
A
2] UVF-87aZ&X9"R[T=s#uJ'#\lcd]msWt"K?/k\kKklhM>6 ;m80V '$t*tS.TU<
W)lSb+oQUNo;r)3$sn4_LEd7A[ejHkTi$ae/.Q>AgeYMPve<s-Ftu>:";\*'Yl+FC
Page 17 of 43
�ARMS Email System
Qb=P+Z[NP1SS=As-meQNQsQE+"+7>kXSWf=k,@6j2?>9dbngS>CMp4CpA1)m<Ka\
S[=20.e-DSrbiOs&u<1-D)JWe:rPRuj+n;jC\9[r\EKJSJKDc)VuS09Yr/>.r,,*A,
A
pmVjf\+xd3\gGX#VtkD:C(OCSA_d:1?7 W(foFaKNC]&\_$k%3dOBKtV,XSGmXjKe
;SGqA%A?3@:2T7E)sC?&a"$-NZYqCSSD&L-AJmM-UaEo=-pSM?7Ie:?]mB-3qQ19"
9Qstu#aLi/OC=s(?rmBWC%SAh<W@C,_C-$g(I.U*LnM*s]\U:"7HsYW?4Y;OFsc*2
1A M&&ie.@)?SNET$<X<6BjkM]$--T[XB?PCZK@X?3U]2:p]i1]A 01_l\'?sigONJW
s3fgcXEpSIC9jh"PAF.V4p#2JiO>.IV$_S)=9S&SSt:dl (9D)<,WS++#Le+) 'k\KQ
L-MRVmT\)*r rI[%iZY#Sp ASVA3;-11oL#>*S#q(>;KtS6=M[A$G'>r6#lQ7-IS=X
#>ZI))d4HXXLj.]4#/VhaPAliLgZU@n&d?<M .. 67RQj,chSZV)#6f"oGNu@AKISAb
1 (B&&H&-F. lCA-An9] H1m\K(jA+-l_WX1KAec$p400:n6] duRSSNMR&'mT6MOTeA;
A
) : f4$&, Wk a23&V< SSldH,]' Hc, ZV=-n==U%: J] 9R\6N7 i. ' 17 JSFQ3 (E#P6rL]
«\L-R&lJ90R"f\L-:-n9=?Ri3S. (PkIFFAb(NqA/KEKFS<-@%MS*W(*#aSa.hVQ[b\
J977-&'.k:Baar[O-9jVC$T\,gNdOC/Y2Im*TKZEhE[T$"eOqb._oSM_ZMkslNd$k
/7o>'slsO&/76:tl\r-E'qGG62'>KO#6I/l@a;ln'G(Zo6u-o%jaD_9F3, l]MXr$M
?cJ%h<27Tu=iSH[aU3n,p]\G*X/TcO%)S@D/hoX?Zf%t/(n]%U6gep#, ''';NL7ihi
A
*?)/ZW-1Y=i'VPWMm3>NafjSUKV'd_A_nICB, (+4qg"bgOa@Db40-hXUS91<pMbK: (-1$q%>S,\mdJ;SA- SgPd2;>.4(+4WSM6nq=$X7a?E>'gt;W?%NK)IHK.UcJDB4
iYb%AoAu7m\s,I(*NgS>Vs#ONVZ1]Wq\?$If7aH,A.<S<HU3:S+[D-2c%3ZuHY19)
-\e7rLa,7Y4b\&BH)#,MBB=K'0] .BNSd)SI3+S<Y)1-Zeo@re[ljcIMjboG:=Wju9
J$URgFcHuR,pc#b$oYJoCV-$eHl %W-T$oW] mIcL-RSRWT.usYA_PGR& 1E\«A 2LD*
*Xt2Y/_J;hHY]?gj [Z%L/9Tu=+uSF1\&lA70&nnIM6)gip/@TD)@I$GoOmuSg9JV7
eg-fgge&J-E'NUMC\Xs3SAiPZF@Taf?AL#I\$ZO(CU]\PIK9&CIUIiVlkIe.*SKE)
A
WWE)@%XLBS6<AR"GY1?[oA ZTK 'eOO HdGe*4i:q6:#S[\S$DQl-9uCq3afry 7Cq>
AU06*@F<fZ6,A*7VAO%12R@QOZe2XfH6(d
MT[nOWKJiBP-i.DJO$?fq%I4pjihCWH
A
A.db7TbdZS9tSmjdOB]Al]KDj%W[HFLIE9f q6s]=>S<D)X] </&:#/G; [Al;Bs_eU
?upV3[qSmRpX RKSj&Ss"
lho9J/(K:@f J]LL;/JKpNbSU7T,fP4uJk-fAQ-CZb
G-#ENAIP 16 1%0 (ZY - : 3 Im A
::-I" 3&#j rcmS; [Q9%O+<4<, iaa- '3+7sVP- < [N6] SSMD
pV&#YZkM.6$19W-@,AuB#ee[S']pWS>c/J,SF(-17'<V#h;:VS7$#EYokKJbItDie
sSP, PG?hLOk"Q# 1E lBV1c) g] SSGp] @4Fu, \. 3gJY' \209W (AdNHSJaARJl. >#) 31U
A
oB@b.]sZ\m=&b' C<eEbBZS \+7E3<n/QQ?SH:l%-(+/T@lQQP\2ab /mn)PC[k:)
A
J03$H uW,)p[De5]MK@M1NT:;:"=(6+q"6nZ-N\n) 'A:juEY4h)S17-KUqC-d<SXjAm
zo\n.G_"[F&Y-C7JbQkelosuM194X"+HhN)Y-EP$NCOT,*V7\aVriA7?P*$#j-=\4
MF&:m4gG1HVOW]T(jl1D$r+WSeW:II=60T+%iXYcfN(_UcGiV#-Mbd@< "nRdmCEc2
4UOSSmD<]rJD&*GZPiS]PKStmWWY2=Z'U[JegfjuXF/hQhd_6%?'4R7"Uc=lOHPHL
(L3EOZmm+GWmdcE .. R#S' ,BS4S' K : PkT&3a*6EQK?YKk- ; p\) $. BG-2N/?O\P (j.R
$Be>fa6N9SrY;>e+kc,\pc;S@<G_9qV?A_,>.kqIh&JkA6"C) lb<;aAZ'Qt+Mb\Zm
2nN3$NNtl$K$Db\D4s@'QF1b(QZ"V-$#uMl%Bd*ZGrA3:iEtC;jS2rI.3cDM-F,HZ
$W-s3$k%&-1\@M-*]CS-LjDG+<*qfrhWPS[2reS]E?121fM<LSgAjA,H&Vl\: (*gl
A
".eK/rCWDu1lb*PF) ,S"=n.0'lE:%s;kd9;4[01hj6ilQ@/k?e S[q:S62E[EUAnm
J7YEUWjok:)SWrNhUi0992-YJSo\Zi.J>bi4e$] ASk-OS1-RLr3C,Pg kmDU.1-2 E
-adS&4_S$@) [q%L=,,-AmcM.W[/hcAI%t+JGB#Ji=,iK1F7'WVVYqQ&fDm-]MGOFq%
A
3"Sca.=\@cCBoBQd"b]hD2e3fe6S*dJ=%ZScm%&k?OAb4q*G<':-)$]j@HkE"Z6 %
A
k1alGSe001S#+)hm=B7C6Xd?AFDs+OT SAJZSYBc#fib6SB#_Bidn)W;IC@; (E\u+
4[;?accZ]$H[rP1Y$9iiCldsn07.C7r9iV$3.,e#\E.K:1f$14Hmf:O<",aHVjk,.
qroiES1F~V%>+[/N[g_bkq\-aFKH]ef6PgOAjSCJJ6f)A)GAQ7-sAS1A 2S *smDp1C
K+_Of>.*<>2#[VK(6pn)@[C:XS_jo7QIGY;Pk.SXmrg1R4R[prib AQ#-1 [AGOZ<D+
=Pa(WUDq("B\ICNZF/&/7boS;pX<Q'*IE071[J<2n#6@6p. (g#]6RR<eK@&a<nIXT
oYQ.nP/S9*GsXt"Pm.2mmP+\ISSVO%6ug7Z&_iQ$jl?)gUoD<ocrONH;dj*ajO$t:
RIh#KAsdjJ<9#P2r&S<ikB1pnLi,li;G10%d@H]3p7/D+eqlsAZkJ6:aQY2*a[Lol
'TMM/d$GAA27(SK,A$A+AS:TS.cR(j(Q,IYq2P1EOpPH*&@iPNi:,CC#A/kf[,jTi
oHD;vOlqaS:&W"S,mKfkB6S+KbH3[<HI)WK"(gS?~7JnbV\;@,,]Y@aK_,#A3g_0r
ek?E:bBR4RYtZ9FN#X"W-@n-kPpp]oHVjcXRs7,pejsn6SY1+)lA'T9poaEm=e<S<
A> _ -: > [pOoXp=d (H; 'ad+RRA"L@ [: <A1 ZP " 1#-: &UO ;uS9SZX-A) K" 9LbclJ&2PIf
'''4: >SQjq$m;NjncA2cM (EBL: $gXL" <J-?HnBng' ) iKVnH6?V$?] =SpLAVB#Sd' [j
Y"uho\q92S%X4.BDkrG$=INr&111g*U7&bHN, '/:,>=:#&EI,Ogt\"F#ONAtZJa'X
A
>b[/WP:1#U>X6c]StQWcXOILg$T\aH?MJ?1)Y6GJ#I)W Oq-m"-1#jq-N1KSq>C?T
Q/khfO)Daa77Y09iqWQlb[[i:&7mKM2+rTK1"+4]q,mMC'lFRj:1KGgSKC"V1SS2.
A
*I4N;&%dH"P+c%MA3DPOH1J=#-3R&VK]DK %"d\u:YSqlO;S-F;F-$;WA R9H-q$%
gVD>4mX-":4%[n\$;RPcgq2a=)VlaJ?Sj17H_b;Uh'Ccq?BF\$dHRhSq%DIkkJRj3
A
jFn7#n:/>*C3/6FjiJOmII RqeHT#pIKns66rJF-q($ZUduCX9&'AJe'Rm1Ay+UuP
Page 18 of 43
�ARMS Email System
SlqFkZsW$\1L; <EigKeuV-G_: l%m) ?nh&1ge7-rO. \uhL4adGaXo/: XjH->k3Cqn[
7 (SSNVNKr\P"pe/) HJ2tOe#=@db$\$) :m;, 1 . %e-*WG" 1 ,M1bYnh03Ml - «qgO*G2
A
M&nS) Au hR"D<m.f«om-q/rW)DFm\orHqp07 \aM,W?PL=blM] 'M:9,-GWb?;5MLi
A
$)';d?<R=H9Af"jlq#rO(qRAsokSs Clf?-O@p/sGl*D[Zp:)N[hnlO51+Z=cPl[>
K%jYFlnK#tl%Ws7>+Z=N=1#>_5K:UlX>hEt04jqlTJ5;O@A=F>#+\3T02%LsFN«D
A
)?<.k>p?u; .i'qfPum#GZqsuD5&Ol./JFGo :T<r'E"1XZ/@CCt-te%mAiLCPKg>
A
.b#110V&$U8fR-\jrnl:e] 'M@-$S]t$FCi]M3H[6r,1(5X\4N063 >A2sQmmO=UnR
8SGP[iW"MtG4oKS1ZboTd=b(R,dFf,oEE*+,R5?</fQK$*.@VVer:Ne=Oqk)WVTOq
A>CUL,?F'O$E$*=Y%1C$a_O<R(Ni2e-=*$3gCF9"_8ijQdm&h-17p3=2.EkdL"4Ll
f&WbJkC-,b6?lMT%QFN<g<,Lnh+P,si,V15Vc&$(mj@gXe'8tLb1E\@5MuUtrB:$r
A
PdjRoAOs@ekW\3%6nt-&Bi,n2L<s="/(1,f]?*MOj;D>KAWTlOb>cY?U $9<_-A)4
--e5<)B7%N9X/9)h )fl;\;odr%V%u'C;gqkmulKrpYcN/#5dHXr]o?eLo=jrL<F$
A
BCt$hElg$k3R)#A@2L@C/&$]8TNnpZ )*9j.9[qV)Mn50/;O)rOQl-K73q2<5;f$,
A
%F1PMBX2N6J9L<Zbgn-F9$.\">n7%qq+XJdc2XkR-C:bb IMYoFr A9(ml,E1'6if
Om+9FVlu1VOE?X)kZAt&*gn%mgB@g@afli>U:TAR3dT-.~rslNp;-DlOeXqCc:D>e
ihmiY;V-SIE1#J]2gG<"m6nR=*C)G-51d'<bdBDW1MOoaD)V50Yb9_:2ErXh8FAr*SrX',LM69Z-7X2nc:R6SR/=NW.eaYgBH'7ho.ap[Q#[XJ5Fp%euMgcq]?OMViqjK
A
BYPSC 1k>BBXb] $-;MuGD3$<* (rBeGm/aHF(*&m;Vn&ryAQPkl+\l#* '<g[lK 7-o3
A
%e#lA#@R ( [iiP9-5bpLhl-@rDg1<I*lVMO-:031Q15u13"T#Aq6$kE\R4n/>q21#
IJ9)bAu$tC1Y5-#-@Pa4>dh/Or456)ONMZ-,o-#a.7qq%/]fW5k7U)NBL@a>V-$?W
nbPmKef>a) 1c9*.3reM7fHj" , 'TW%D)T>Z"R6.P(cpPC'Cc/u//iQ/Z[SjGtXg"@\
16&ip\WrnXBd%$=C1-Po12>7sd@bo>bV1Yr]K%2'B)/eJmOj%Y6CpBs6gs-KKr,U?
A
95#U2'CB5SP+6#\7c9FHY6N&Sju+G*9NQNY50@)p,Sr1JOO 8jhQ%p) [lk3"J)*eb
A
A
q2sP1'kko +jlu.AOC*bK1 Vi*AXBD1GJLU04F21HC,s1<'CSVU-kisQ)B1Q23c5m
=4-ABSN(_diSJs)]?fU-?US[laL$V?@=.-e4tMJkJ#e<E ARm.c_m@RbS/or-K3>aD
lXnBNbBL9Un91 -H' "I - ud@Ob:r1P/=Ehg+H] :Ti OJ ((j8Q$=JQr&&[1 #MrV#4
A
IVLSC5RWV"nb=,&r3cKrlG6"2b.c px;zm>#S?KCSViD?Vlln+WbK=_2n2~rJ>1l:
.bMF=c:TQe+Z)XU+SNPUYZ%o.rWB&Bl<] uZ#jVU?TJO [k#TK>\9>3q=i 451-h&Y#*
FC9[j/t,PBJc-=WdS5Q>j-;rBO+Dkd:E;TR@fifCk=tE90L4"7eT@Vt8ThkEh@&NZ
A
WO hfNP>+BBF&MOP#uM,WG+sABn$2Z1&lKQG.g/d-o-1H5MKK=-4rY\=Y#l_QcEeO
7)' UgG Gh6a9&]pk6$j+9A+b6*Bp#BjG*/ZOo:?Y-eM911%+5; 'WjM'1 HUKoB)Z
LU.GK[Ci%Na*m[l%J:IPll:EvAaOfOr==g-:fSWS:R"SfB;AV-\P#n:<C%E:6H3s.
A A
T6Sc\b.HrH[1MOB=PBYfUF G YsqKA5Z) (VaEEm71*T".%@_LB_CW1@q;i?NBW/>Y
S >\Y<MX3m*lFc$j"OEF-7+*/>VB6k609BW=5GYGqr2=Hll '7. -\g+DY%1Z/niC)j
A
N;BW]NO N9)OB6-.069BemhzgE;GDH(@>1 [ul?Vh[u/5XgbC?P1DlZmkA[W.b=1.
A
bN5RH!uJdgeX (#YKr;02ZjbX8perfc5hbh!e-Kkp+;YN]QPuMj:An ]P(NIGDWdrh
A
A
;h ]VHBd4hga4/>;$-'%,q/,mTuKu(UBUAUXm V_"XB[@Q>be3@%H[tmSP&qF'Tk=
U&UO;U+YJpH[lm$139J_&1-<+'lS.+\u' >lJBA9m%fj ,J30RJEXB\t pT1#6NmO)7)
A
aj >j ( =g1*Kk [q 1Y%3cq; . bb9] EJ ; b; 1,9) F7c "Mt; V?%9BhTlee- : 62t+EEBO$q
S=&EIDIFrhE1(;Y6[Ogr2CsX@<L=M*A 3 ]fH3K)MWL-QUB"M$7Y/&UH1FEh\FM+G9<
$=W+) 7rR7@Kl *ZnG] eZJ; [lFc/80 (, g*] 2051Q4s [" 1APRB 6&9a=RB*' Z. t=iUO@
C;fUlpkO<:f"A=TC/HVCCUOCARYjKl 15] lrL#BRFU,R"1;TC7S%09jFlcj\j9TMA
A
D XuA9E#L4k[KlnRm h IE?-uB*n$Bc)/<XYqM*+J[e#T(kA1k <:F)=A/pR?4F#4
4DZB1:iF@cKY?Ui'Oo:]?rf2(lR4;sD\g%lOU%V:4r2sHJnCf4:&3(\G@Y3;?1*%g
\GHITL>Ls".?2F*J'Td@5%k)?=:%(=3ned3<c-dAI?Cb"501Q=W/"O.igO_@E#]DO
BV,ouosR[,]k?/9UBFOe9mgXi%-=E:17%CSBk«_T\Onk2XT9$U>BUtj [YsioM4Hs
V;OBSPJ$Ep_cYWIN\e-C_:M?c)A9J]qq#XD2-2($+(kT&30.7q7N3@;@9T[%d-<$<
A
7u'B991:]%kN."*; 1+[d;"OF]YR"1?"c7DD h\,]83FL\+sQhuo$?JY=-$O@'1[E8
b)Y+Q; RBeapaHH:%-S*3D5efgM2XRqLqlA$nkt-c8hR<D$A"$\WbLfTP>?O#&bYc
H*AU>o74%=dIB-hEp" 3 [oX9AuU,4?1N4*AUh'$a,ls7Q6?rUJ4UJ(A $»\(Yr>ba@
BdWp92elO=Fo@31<Y-tF3L*+UY;gD2T<c]pB1srHgmSq91Vj@+7&Th%$14dZl-Bt.
i;<A<\6G;g9-\d; (LC:6drrO)@lL#oq;n6t#/YKRHI1L7-J\pi6VOrcef%J@bdqk<
LO, . <g*ATN=S\2YaO [) J_BWo- "pY lW 13ImQ_5 "O#hlEj -MY_iQF" lc**DBJ9mBrBQ
\Ketq<%AH5A-W%C*PLcuWEjZ"ROj$)_Q/h31:p,3hB(\kDauBoV]qT6slF] MoYQfi
+B%] 'o3a]KC.o7FOU.mg=WFR-@*\ESYb.F*nmZk*@q<W[30af09S]&ce2"X1K--E%
A
@&f::>hng IEqWoknAO)M<H AF6h#*rk?(#,b-Q] "m7Cdp"9VC9ctta09MT(1\QO]'
.laMQ5L9EMe#4=LIZ4;rQg] t;F;Vu[5INK=b)dGQX] c6I<=9s%nmY< 3WO#h.$;ASt
HuZQM]@WnE]lA; D.X>p+I-YFrga)X::;)+54*X20 L*71]s?49#a2U@/ cC'A9pf
n?A d13 <s; I 1?Ks -;- - 9, d#$l ?bs$srYqE 1F5PXW? 1?vY 1*@j 5q=?oAXsdX$~] E] < [n"
A
P+?@"@qGKrM(AOt1gfZm_j , ! 5># [/gJfm]] "" a2 - Al Tps; 7NKE7 @5EQ' =lc5' 61q
-
Page 19 of43
�ARMS Email System
A
V@Aa=MiGKq6-PK d1s0ABggI*s11m>-+%%P/f?@>02QSZ[g?)fY5@Zd]LOe-\42#9
LO<iq44WaN#t&OO, pa%-) F. I% -U8JL (j 3g: +@"o=. rsHN1 [ (] 0 (i 1MEG« (j d*, nC
mJ<@<lGCtmD3U\Lh?A-;Mgb&V.a'UF:5i>W\]$nBZ,]&ZYDdCA+.B-?Af5]f2%Vgl
A
A
Li$V%D64Z2fhM9R%#nAl1W-tEi+ZZ' cJWcpc >+ (feY (CNrB\sq4c8 9b \dBW«D%
DoST4LSmH#3FIFs?]d-gUUY=\<'P<lAKI%cZH\$!JB5131DJe4bmO-ZpiOfH@KsFX
A
\i-UfXQ<?JpHE@kiXofS;3LEP*044[lHBe s$LT<@g*r-N)e20\IH,_&2.c8165#C
'iI[ZkF.rXAe;ALi/jS6)tqXCRp)-AR]M3S_tA28N<O$\OP8piGsDC2m\B(aq<KD[
\RGO) DWpa@RV#Dj ( 1 -TUL&#$ -MV7 [N 75/t1j. <BZ*s+Kh) / "h; # <VMEHB (?nN=a&
lO\PZ<M1W2mXO%(L9YbdWKDmdNjnoh[qLHp[>N,]Ii7pnp=Z Frb<na]pH3M,e-/l
<:NWN&e(,LZ:-Xt4oX4br=rmWWpMHLj1601Cm6@\OYStJojp7>\OJt#h#%5H@:Euk
7%&=b=jKFj\F AV8N1]B>:VfP'1=aG,%QQg1i?R9t>. ECYEqadmh2r-FmY23]+b' [
A
2am9YIBCYUg5rPI8)dm-dW111+16U"LOf15G9<&L.,5X6<q&8IB.+ ?A>YL/4Q\Qi
%-(Ogqeb4RUaoL_+:q)mO\gYr%jdedY/;4aBH9n/Bo+JJ@,;@pQ#(Ai52r/,NU._0
iaoGkV#<7nlb?B&RHHfW?/:?HMY<n'C)$r.' .Udb3pmlnR\r-hB2ZC2GHr;4GM*fq
&rBIE&ISEZI[582#-8KkhY<O_ma$a>r/T=7r)NLjjjs08+un\2.FH#;OcR;2Fe57C
lGY8S";-C?-.">r*31VtbWo2jC<\h\R6_VM\Y-c: 'kVcZ<t&?:fOL"-/le/&QMfdl
IOrWtN75u<d*A?6cnIE9ahSllCKgLXRn:K*AH" [qJ8s)I#2hPPiQLD;&$Pg+(QUFs
A
;i@Zq;>"r*RJM+S1FlpHr%&60f_ZtI C:q,kT*VnWV2Z9Snt#9=obO/"=[<_[R8os
I(Oui.,gnnAK(ZphH7e?F=-J[HqaW((TV;Q8nYR)#*LD%guD"CHg(mdniVQGc7DEZ
H'Bq>$$u?=cETjo<Kn4CJjM16h1M7*3-\#+g6) Qc;aLI&f8q"4raYLIB@BxATa-l;
A
Zd1J6S0YS@Y[EN9UQUe'*(A%6CJ7F6,*_P83M >,#'J<K-Je04C?m$LgeYOg[V\,N
75W1ADjrX@6+=e.B&*<$a8_L$dUsO*--LSI-Z3*A HLUS &/7<79SQeqjd=nF483$Q6
prPW*i_6bRO=ojU:j"4KkZ\Q9(_D2,"] 9 [W/-?k-l_*7NNo5C9ZklMg 7 \ FaAnORnu
H<9MDYYG@91RJIRl1jAd8)$UJhcP7MK<?hgmsCZV\. [taq>lL)a/.g.b03f1a'R$37[;*->
endstream
endobj
24 0 obj
«
/Type /FontDescriptor
/Ascent 710
/CapHeight 703
/Descent -218
/Flags 311346
/FontBBox [-176 -232 1194 948
/FontName /Cheltenham-Bold
/ItalicAngle 0
/StemV 158
/FontFile 29 0 R
/XHeight 485
»
endobj
29 0 obj
«
/Filter /ASCII85Decode
/Length 42192
/Length1 666
/Length2 32078
/Length3 0
»
stream
A
A
,p>-rDKJj'E+LaUOeP.@+@BgRCij6+BOPa06>p[N+>F3X1E 4B@rri&AS5 p$84ke
A
DKJW D.OhC6YL%IFCf?'@;RS_Derr,A7]?q$84keDKJj'E+L.H+Co%q$84keDKJ33
Dg3CO/MT1B+>#?) 1 *A; +3A_j =lcTn+Eb/ZiDfOB: +Co%q$84keDKJT.] FE2) ?+BpNP
OJG4(OH-%10J5%50d&.m005fAART+fDJXS@A7]?[02Q(kDKJj'E+L.G+Co%q$84ke
A
DKJHfAoAeH1*C+A@rri(F-814AS5 p$86R6EcYr5DBL>]OJP160JFpuEb/ZiDfOB:
+Co%q$85.mFD55r+=Kf\6QeaOAScI"DJ3Hq+DGm>@3BZ4@:Wqd@<--+De:+-DKKH1
DIIX$DfOl"+B3W*AS,@\AKX?YEc>r;@<?4%DD1@\Eb/ZiDfOB:+Co%q$84kkChujT
A
D.Oh<8Q8&"6YL%IFCf?'@;R,RDerr5+ED%%A8c@%Gp$X/AdU1\@;T pGtqdbAKWBg
A
BOu"%ASuOiD(-TJART+fDJXS@A7]?[01g7oCh[BFDJ*cs+>=pKAS)9&BlcaXG\(D
Blmiu+D,%uF(HJ)AS)9&<Gl>YEboH-APd;dBln'-DBLMcOJXb]AS)9 &<Gl>YEboH-
Page 20 of43
�ARMS Email System
AQ3>W@r#snF)rH-1*C+=AdU1mASGdjF<DtuDerr5+Co%q$84_SF(IgZDKJWAD.Oh<
6YL%IFCf?'@;RS_Derr5+Co%q$>"*c+Co%q$84hc@rGmlDJ«jFCB&t@<,mIDI[Tq
B17Q+A7]?[@s)g4ASuU#Bk)6-ASu#c@s)g4ASuU%Bl%?'AS$*t@gX)9H-.9,5>&mC
A iUi4EM&s) RU$F\jjnnok>617H.oAA30pX$Q#Y\e3rjqGOOjA 40 <D 4) [9RF/KPf
DY
V>3CLQ#TMZ'eb;&IZ) .p<BpNP_9>ca#;gVso6>b/pOCW_AY+9II=Jr A1CQH1Dg, $ ,
1A oeng ]th8J34il 6;TSCV@<H7g&OD40dHJ%lkZD/Ki"]/X1QA RAB =B8Tl\-OXCXo
Urn c&f5qc A
vePk,;b8q) .;I?#]"au]$&/>XFNC2:XPk#Iq<Ff33-o/?NaOHS[ZlfJ
%&/moQo)#8g'G<&S.KY,7+J.D@A 12 S l Ld1GBYVOCNLA1/081>hQhD; 'PY>L]P%_(=
oUte;#-C(bgP('D'ct.sU=2p$=(@*W_*'rbxEB-bE-&9E@_TW&"R&9RyAHFq[lA<V
A
:Q =%eG,<. -iG@nG-udZOuAZiS" [geh_OqD8$IiD(h$6gU%ln2_1cSoS7l 9lN<Ot
13@\<%T7<I[oA%sB8D+ah=cGQ98CfTjlon.7WB879#*:@gN:tC,b;<S#F»lPi,U$
A
>F#6rTlr%XXe\<7;3)]9f,nnYh6'cTB6.#W4k\E#7 EAk:lLq&>auK>a-=,l=LfG.
/+Q 9L6Pr]$-pj%-d7fd@iC*D"iQ9aOt9 Y>b7JL\lsA S ]i;hSVf%EG#jHsq8/(50
hXQP+R\_r#J*#NVO.Z,I*h,h&&_b A?[pDdiVTjeBP@+G\5B7eU<MkZsB*@%QmM7A)
A
2S9]?'FZr8U8T;rP,-OL6,2PS1VWb XW%4Pl4q<li\, lLo3CRq*#'3'&Xs+aXG(+P
JOKSB"jM) +SZ<3q-O%Oe4M,P>91 lA_?oG-%JY2\] TFD4#Vj 5ULj 96bThXoWkqbghE
4Y#NAOFBYk70"Y\=9HMd[BA)/nOYSkhJeB/24Xo )ddQ;j [CH)T9lZN+DZD>Ol&e#
U$-QT),WgXdY>$T]R>Oo[)G[KklK?AG,ES:]MRS]%A_AS,t:W1K,i\VHe+m+-d,/@
BZ A5SXs+oV*)n\ol\7%2b bR@nT(aI<7Cl-B;Uh8,$qq'#$g@NQ1Mgr42g?uoH:R7
qC]4=Mb9noIE%8%_eoAkl]ge#74-UV)&.mOAd\~24q%B\SpsI=Mr8')j18C<iKG+
Nj-)2[]J:@p: :8)9J.Nqi%cNrg"3d$.$LQ;ODtkMOP5;5ps]LA=VqZdGHG#'q+.aN
YGX3?\)qOOJ608X4B7Q;T-l38CT)qY%c@kslb A7.qR#\TLrXXSY[=VHO[L,,2I=*1
Qr, U7mq79] *lqp:dW?' o;@Bh/i8' "jWIVa@W1 [( ["n' lX#T%Gq$*dM@_cAJ>m>E]
pStOH"Nac+N?rP/.hO*PN.)lTVJEn_F' (I=9qs1/GEaLF9MRQVREd$Z-J.3%?_79A(,j9$dn%se%OP8-ttLYD]O;.G_44W/<DlhlmgECWi>TWJ"*Jji9/DEe+@.C<l]N4
pfkTQ)/b(ojj)3CIVJ28iHJQpSVdY6-fOrpQ*5[7$$A,?>o+>"53FXi33K\uK8>SL
]-s8Wb2[Wr=ub-)jqreG_P6+\rgE<ti>cF;5YO%?6$3N5p8/e+COCDJ$Q=ck#S>BT
GPgt#:bEf7coXu"-=F801IlGfO'?rUg;AF1%#i29#&nYNEqn4)Cs3&J(u,;m'RW1\
$rleHK]GoGkL@.«gUP[:-PF+.]4jP6=]KTnkpo+#%eo=(-,Fh=RYJ-OWod%5Rlk+
n2bpA-P [""/g<AE=jEt) c<cRSVX< (8#C A
_-S$,$kKAqs$fSs) :, l?WPTJfLtZ-luc
kL)lL-#[eK5#E3: [L41qnn-DS_cfEoohPJ)_[bk99 [d9uD+HU)b2c9 [lNk\lQ<mqh
+k4Z1,?SGX-L+)u3?SeT&=6X<itBm\rVdk5ROooO] 'U+lg5BUsL?9h%;cUUbOGeZH
OZZ&uZTlHf#l&(ke)9&/Njq'dOOPH+, '] .?b A
AM-\(r7./NLLS+I+q'>(HJps5 A>&
A
J@:49'AU_XTOi\;S=N<me1 sRP94jE=3c:m"GUU?Ji.Li%k@Re%-mQQ?Om-<@@nnL
@TPeoFZ31f,bM&@;H?sM#8asOJ%lbuiZ; [#Nc6)n*KW90@B,W+U<b+q;*&d$mdPsT
/9=A 1e "u/29Sm8*hA/g: *P"· [, c -7pgBL5W<Q3#Mdn%5<OJ' E4D$GtAG" . f [9_ *6E/
A
U2a"t<?qWS8PARG1<'VP32-[rD/sOhUM?:D r>E5M>_3c-2>T10&"?\GEZn-KL)tT
DAgprWQCE4jD4BJOcb%s168kO)H.FYd) .d,YQ4,oQG6WI:XQ84?U6P:-4_BVX-; [3
#<JAPknG5fKE1kp+$VHOTa2kP9IhSK*j@Ns+Z/K?Lplo)4:$#9,oUT-Uts3*#R]rG
9RqbOgA6C/1TBGD6*w]6p%GjnSX>chj3%11+t2r6Tk#t5B@fG7@88J3DmFFV9s>Qk
-pD6>/Hn.I?\"bdTPNA1IsFUmHCL%$#-JHrI 'RR=nL8Z0: * [HDf'8c :oA;$Hh7AuW
=iP'&[B>#9(RTJ=R;9Z9FgOs$kGDih(A 5G#3(G\XohJlrV7*IprSOF;@NQ1@g)7ui
T2l2uaGSO.F;Xi@+sS$u@6q'F%\u<%+j60cMI<MR$[>*?Fcr:02-EV\AJgaL"%C_d
KHDhOJsQ%EC>*F (J6M&g9] unKXZ1S3, +' -*GWo417 [2+R, ELf5] [mBm3A%iR (=6bO
[m13pD-aJ+7YAK+3-d&T;;\IIS7e>e&$SQ\YW SI?16[+-3*#3H8/g+Nh?L3hC8;:
A
%q]051@d_t eK+CFg9h$,2sdPmB-Y6"iD2G"5V\--,N46$5Hr,+6g.mX;RVs[5&dE
94 ?tXUASshHT_iZ+51WOpK$cUNO*&QGID6#$2=1*mrpAZQ4PU>%X2JKas(Qq;I#.&
k'+@@MNA6]fcIWRT>l'oXR-4R2CF3 ARgPTc/DkrT4()OLhn6j$'H(c\LlD5.3<?3B
SjpC%YT=WLgR;?Rn?L4m[\-/>.N)UjHiS-E:ec?OQ]e6/]hl;#J6-uPP%>,d\4P.j
FHes-O&OaU\PLqRCLfL6o"2qFXco-M-7uS AhXT,n9"*Fj]eWW5:Qd_=2M@1>2'04Y
"B1BKI]\7pdl\In=mp#"YH]bI?WtO?AI-Lpen<cN3YW>7.917 A
V-d4",83lJA10+2
Bg6\D,n+K:3+(O%J4%q-U+;4Zg1oLr'MtT*U~\CPn'lgWT-:?lqy(A1/9q,1?QsB
A
&H?ki3?@k]d$bmQHBN $OSS9 '''&k&Y;-&p4 BlW+sE)k%GZ?&2ZJ&ZYY9m2jL3q<
K-/23 A/ n <oAiDua3fOp,6 A8%-;-OPF11< .4q\E$]CxdqJRPe: AliDF+KlUOHf 9
Y)K8SYKgMHAW/K*8J[W, (qXu"Y51qS%> "U[re6taX3lY4e(i=$dYp[h@02e-7K»
A
#_g\ *F" iK\Xaok?JYhrI<qOci/Rr_9 [lIPd@, GJ: ' \hum 1bR?pErX 1 -C7N mm; l<S
Z=8jATqJH;mR.f>6:nOo@Sa=X%bOe5lmNrF%3-+E5b#LcVXmN- __h#tf_@. <Fp#X$
+*KtDTU?SAif AZuo.k4ZoI AjarD<h*:aM#D8#?A/gcVATcO(Fl6i.GVoVgpJGtL(D
LPl C-SIKtOLRobUE5l;h8*C\o@j7a=ZH;]m%/NOJISA*fZKFRFUZ#;IOtjSLAO(S
A
l)*3X=;h"EeFcgcfdy AH- A9H_gstk,A Ya '2cHeIMO$)k,2*D6BTU@'3pb $r7f>K4
Page 21 of 43
�ARMS Email System
M[)K;bnaR9L,q25.>sr-s7/S&$S<lOR3[%./G*pOZlq,C?RqMlYAOG;RB[*7QuP]G
U"EFVFj & :' iOr@c+nV"lf+eX+q;*Vr91>1,02r]WUY$4;QOQHaRd?KQf'lt2"3Pn
;(z.-Jf01P3+t>O-p__eUSA9tkk$<2U]Chv><@9<P?t>k\?#rOU@L=9L+40KkOqh1
p+_nI:l#E ADsM6a,e-3e?>SlQ3Rk+en]S) ;11-']p.hfgOrbCZ75W:' :4E\4)rm%)kM=A M Aj]F<Mp7co=lqj\oF\ntqhGMa?rKf$"Kg4B/]WPhmnOM=]+nYDcE_cfnC
@W
d-Q'o)6F'q3urg.4CF,A%>"6FmkS+]>19tCl(geliN-bBdOc-&6pVbSTINQA_nDE=
@N_GB,C&URnY06skAl"9=-SV&i_/#Rj3l3X"$ZS.SEEphVcX4:C_=LpLl?GA>fRT
A
p>Tnp$@]4pk5rN=@S3$<[4;966Haai,N"LQ%pD[&+O"@g-s"F#rKM -Sd3#7rM,Rh
A
qF$jn>3>-F_4)Qt5N?X"e3dOOG?Z/"a;JQQ>/[rnI,olC7-_is6lK4Vc+h t@:5Hm
4 [TeZ5jn95hl' /R+Tt41KlfL/16&u"IO 1mt*UQ-l$MJ=lo' - _c5_a" -b :Gpog; .12
6R09-om=eEOFRZtP4_'=C%S_9,S'C>PtAhh]Co?_ZDVnUW&LD?mml%gSm#&W-JPng
-Uh#ld-(9t=;HG$1,+R.>3k'L_s1BD&;P_4n;%D<]R&Y-7ME4c@O>1)6JAqhA.3m9
gl "S*R/T3m2li 1 -qTo_ql%] OhW? l) d]6n@lWJ=] h%HK#c (?h@] M5rnH\3 \, WIAZrHh
c)rnhrjK$r;BZ1-QTP.Zh(U-il) TG1BlTLKHBVX-c1hFt 'a]rn.dEOAl* &R?IMn_eU
"Ak] I) ju dOUEGFdH7 [9, ?t4q; tn\nnodQ$2A4= - reMVEIQ 1p%jWOB, A5r61l> (Q
k)U AR>Bi#;VoX[CMlcD\;bln-%S9ujqtD2rn, :rnJsSO\4u=+Wj96JKOQ,jIJr%1+4D
X*UTrnl+1b(9TjT#4c.SO]-i]Q-06%Q5qtY4k#_A>IY\XR?\Og021.-'-.?OXCIIV/
4HL\Qi)ZVOe&fmlSK,/o'XT35AhV.SDbe9.9*(rQ, :eX,#Kq6KRES"Y1P&9R7GsB6
A
n2HI A
_7,or3 A:sOprbtoctn(_[O%r/L m[JCCo>n9jjZp=Gk&)%C=T$M4TBuF/.<l
4IDu995u6?-M%2-J$)gDaGgSHFZ-t;RcG"2L7(?7"i&Ksrf3cB7[nJ?E'L\lQs7<V
ii[f4/P:*Q] $+ ("Zd55pK#icLh1nr_LPj$lE-E-A3/##YjEj>h(KXa$ :s\K1,B2EQ
T3EU@qcOW 'sQGE>*;Mj?sAZ ?(:tWAbpbl@]J"O-IASb<UqPta:UsZ 2UBE&&$2
:CA#r, [.*iU'jg#U&026LO)-t>JcY+bc'kkGsu09due=DErnMOtlo/POCW+pE"G49&
#5Q[;%lpfD20Bt9+jM\1))A3SJRQ+PP&OS_jlo) .g.Rm&9dE+54,#'LVkT:eBT9-p
\6]J5qA3-(Se62Sa\l9>kiHb5gHh/act(#nLSni;?1/#9>DN('lP&$AV-b\c[j9N'
rUjq<9SmrnrnJ,SGs%eo<Q5+RgdSSkn?IQPM\?VISso"AO.>,RoEY2MQIF)=(SFa?Sr
A
o&2SIGE.MhpHJ*.Hpf*GWf]nRU 5)U*Ru6_'-9h#ONrtZr=s=]T&i<E]bll2_'6>6
kh;*]Bb;]SWS+bc\E#,XlBog5pU2kP(FR['-32j7*4 '@Nj+FQmMA<T;QG#OnS>V7
A
2[aI<LA6%;,Uk7 \016@ %$MIAau->B+.aBA+fM(i+(K'PQPQ?6Xu]dQ\ud31hkT/
4lA7t6P,SLU\P_=lA 1P - D>qj?]CEi?13g2fi;-LE-ghXTbDVNc5'KVBCgYMY$Ot<3
@[n-_V(5"-3S'r\=J96a4lRes$iU<omH$IAUqDDq$XC&TgZn@6N;Qe:C.l\B$aT*G
;XLGL$HYDkIgCs,MU'Ol+/e+]HF)/%[lgM?-Slr J7FFeieMd(ho@2\&1112iR003
A
OT7216b9G'k102:3bg(T(##--/EQI-kh gX5UZ/;Hh#2s+<zmXbkE&3\49AGpLS?B
. P3h"$X=;-#-Tj43k2: .B*OA EMcr jL"f#3KfMQ%f<1: lOOh9[r X%r=F2Nlog5-g
A
,)rDRS$BfT'4jI#;]6"C-@O;6MKOe$7#N: ,9dJTMfDqT<SV9C;.Qi4&l 9@ColM
AK-NSt=I[Y#ilb=f,4ECGjZ3kS9.bHA[rn*23Nnt&$X-e"99-PHnOeADPf:kqZ
[ce1
6B@KS>4l. l5RD&2Z4-fl1F*O&2;dB1&tU:B2$IgBk*R-u[#]$?A OdjXe$I(cB6<c
A
&Y]SBk_ HAdKFjR9u,=3/?-fI%FlRt9&7%cfi-\Rl;6ZSGg[34eDYSa;Ds<LpI50)
(Du'J7iF\tM(Xe<VFL A*]OF?AM-@#o;-#HaOdK;sDb\C#6(fimKr]#Si«ka[@YU9
A
FTf&?Kqunf&1=B 4[>J@h-rsHb+iiU&r)X1jfY84MdAnKB<T:E(jJ5m9i:rI01]Y#
AYe2Ij&QF A%n7BL6FoTbJ] d6,EcDn1Vrol 9 [Ta+?UR AlZs (gd3?*3p/BBm_MWGk
A
l7QFkL-GSh@aNOM?\nIOl$,ZlmS5A_5crn<R2qr(5miTu , ;-O_[2c+n&X64Ylq/gb
) Vc' ArZ>O. AE&C_ <Bd] Qj?, A (\N&$] 1H) -Kj ; S AeA=lm"RqN@A%L, . 2 <GCULAGk-Q
$DeB; \ 1 l] Ps. u@NU$*3?EW' ) VHn' o304U>X5DYDeOrJ&u\ 7k, "rnZ#nLk- ?C&' : %:
A
RR-VqAdJ(*H-lSQjlG'I6W+1@-e%ki><QM,Mf" (2]CJ Ol uV\lr@91;L)?$A rN .
A
MqnqG2Ulr>"Fhf-=KgmI'@F[OeMuc%=D WdFXD:;;:/=#)FB"#EF*OV1$<_fg=-,+OYp
A
Hlg6r7M2>5fB=17FmOqffKrnmP +=SsKKk9U?,;)S]Z4-S0;u&;%]Arn =,KqARpg#s
A
A
ekg[cp7 - 3u\api%Jm"g>b2-T l>HYn<e]r/J$u40"9??ca(c] - *$FG"md BfC;3e%
HpHHTR@EC>B)9 2h2 :V1)]S;caE\;,C2'\@QgeldhrEYPl49Z-DcM=*cIM"ELVus
bPk+, i@2FjjmlbfjVQf (A <. OWsSO>VNluJ 1L" $F& A) AO#L, qZ-S "e; \IbJ+ _] 9, 1q
Ut A\7$lMf6453ca?6/Sm9Ef_4VuFZYXXX- [Hj?);] .C1UDP"b-P>cTQBRp$-] FSIS
gOIOE(D)ofXTO]7dlc. «#KK-qIM-9<&(h=[o*a-b%IE3\ R::9CWT$[DUc2dJZ;D
A
Q.?Y&;PS$#Kp*Rl%COPDESqmS14i<OFmKArrnVG)"D9 ?CS::::JN37 Ep3g9aIQ1iUal
?S?/7prn;YJf8LVN'Q1./-JKCXjIR&#Ea%a(-M?46kolpmsorJHEiO>c'%b64CfA#
NLL-Zbi6h;dS)WXa-_:-cE-ta=JfZS] kAA<MIKDI 's [Pdll"ugXqqY7 k\O=_mba'q
qOrbj+oP.5EhBahb70tXYl1IsB,ZO(gLB3p5-HQn"Xi#76D *,nX<qNEG2H>,MF.;
Ua[OsS:>Y+W,4Y==f:#:,)G/;fYOLSll$E[d/".lBd/@G&(\=jR".DNDWAT/(=CCL
[lW9)&T>, "F5gt,dan3E?d\$>OMO\tlP4Z] (HHr7lT&]]KCrsNI#qq;oYC2gW4<h]
A
6LVej«#n*c1 AE-M?-XuAX fOcPI_SOrE/p<Z:N4<:e7n_/LG>OXIDi*]fdM9:i&H
k5>RiLt= ?6me1e;@Dn2Dl7fDM[K_P-%t,+=F4.a:%Z%>2Bt-X>FL&a$< ?:-Yl]=
Page 22 of43
�ARMS Email System
$odH[J'QZ/-[L'=6PF/EK,V'1 =qhVO\A&ldM'gi,r6 $CE(S,T)OCA"n uJSOTBG
>MGeWd\H, bA] scb ( '04K307?Mgh; ?AD1qG] p_"AC1NL[iMKr 11&LeL1H <7+e5: iFN
A A
_]*_(Jr43j [Z6GZhH=E6 A*/s7a%OdmHZnnF<a\[ahDlKaGi@>1*i oa cMe*2,Xca
K9ZJ,b1=VCbZ@M+at-'dX7+<'g]P'VKLji#.VSmOp3Zq] ;V]b8'ORK*Qo"\,jA ZL4
q/L ?r\\FR-StKVs)e5LO'k7nCi5JqbNaY.%W:C=oCXerGN>2#hOB/lm3LAV(i1 ;
'Xs%+@- Y*3@QS An \ 7j [?g"n+1, WWXr% 1 '] FKPG*A CK ; 1 \ \ \ [>U [GK4 . D#, n&B" '7>
jK3cOS$s(Fn%Qj'<.&\2,/eE'QQ(TW, 'UKNXBHjp3DV;6M%r\j)MjBtPX70_>@o\5
,j:2ad'N'@8eSbLK@@W<6rB/ZJY)%i8]EN5e85:Jbi:Y,ZeNiEGX=I"8;U19+. '&b
2'a@.RTp8-00J.WQNkgn<c[II,kAB*VX)I;lkQ7H6a*p4PHDBqcj6kLHrsfAGTA*A
R'_IupRfZVjD]#(lG/6,>pm=/gNa"8E>\ZrUmFcM?=SE1-$njpO#_ae$U6b.*I<f+
Vld'QS-3A'lA=WP6rN@H;b@CcA**OZ;9THH,Be84b2KUGesB&MRopM 6ep6fo;A 5 "
),@A8$ES_QjF;Lfkh&GI>sEZr9%#LA&@UrX,AGSZNM]\<$n@p+JTOTB,9ZjNE?hU'
KK?&>KZ$lsTMP<jHK;d21XLl9'FmWYkR9d=g&R#jd[On(qY>u)lnS8[lmAO+?\J<q
A
b?coQH$Zls31;»mB2rg#ZiANjlKBCFjY@P-DZ[VW(P@5n I?DVF*1,7a,fNOe2ue
A
a[ [<>ug-\rC9m[n"N[kpW[Lknc/TP5%K\<Mm%324*=%Z)gno+WD@N[h +=(i7[9m
AA
DP!A87@/lXn(FPBN/a19p1fUVmQf(X FamC-/c%)3HUD*i3FZCY2Aa]VJJASNoUI
r>2I@Vr,##5V%WE4E9-r%lmSGZYTqK3SbJll@fg1D;C3NA\F4;JfoorO-'=5QcGpl
A
gOd4TrsCS#51F siFh#lKZ)-"RWIKGq<FJaY@ZDg)eAriRC'IX9_@qjZqa\K_gX\X
19mm] 'A.QOGcj<. [msmbgf\c5q86+3'[nNUa.t+?2k>nbLdVQ2H:E[l [26U'Cjf<1
s7i)*&'-VS65=VjGI7"AVEW3lkQ39@o@eU9j>-[*eZO@2(FQc;=A\n5>NGOYlbnKC
+kF1+1E(hOm1Eb/24p<5j:KBYG9,8>Q(,UTkcau:N&9C/(NJ8%e?@Xqc7#Xd[R .. $
UX8<,SrR)Vp'3nr+bO<Kq$KSh;2d(O=kRB+>o=9So="1'lA4++1Q2EXhkSOD[lOK/
AAmE'4bo-c/%a<MH=5d A=D.<F>lfBE8"lePMBLN%nsHo'(RQ\lKX6>qM7F;R.WW=[9
A
A3dS+$@(H-9H/_i9JmOOM K&q4BNOb1@4[:'QTF*-9a'Ds"f%rk//A2U\.i(MfOIA
'A nEgJ [m6Fjq'UgXY'5HoO>4uJ@.o [@LfB5jE]in&?lCZ5m85:/3hW#\'H7B"9M:
zqA4T/.IImL?fc:c%nK;o,8p@/(u*GeO<m-V3TMr'R72SbJ2pN-tZ*)Mj$7<#:A."
A
pkLg=%lq5B$UD1k@Jh:lL&./8Dh=dk+FP;72/ 7$c-nfG([#DLVO'Vg;urgEQde(P
SCdnk(S?eTG1Qju\BON$@"A.5-&R%':bR9\/6cU]OVU>JHb[mn#7/] 'bH67g:GCP#
Y4MnWj)CBpP6"$N2MG[O\@"'5Ro>1"Lb(RU/BP<]lc»*S7TPil>BOmd+=k'Y'FYV
/US6r. " : YF& (\F.] A<pckY5fAl UI/? -N. ,#Bj nNU<oA216Bcb9A? \ Y#L. ; jeW (] ; T
UuJ47joBgs,Up8*8/sRI*RG"bSZWDdGsHW#kQ/FnqOhP1m'uk9,2<#,frT#uF&lZJ
A
c?[fU=E5tsRW,@2(D)kqB Dad"EcZ*6UQEACq' :Ud@q+INkSVkclJ2BX9ue3(N?c
A
A
4&&eXQYZJ>-Co[J(-oL1K==2dgWr<oSS'b&('B@pSRPkmm)Z50c '7LHHIj d8d\Z
p12J, :VHY_&WQeYn&?Z"6.bgC<\YKtI] 9% [a9Z0onc3h_% [/Je2MeFn8$+H+ +g]A
A
q1Tn4f [' 4* :XZk7' CGa, %': J"OFnMOUdU?a ( '@lk7TT54*) >XLd&VGeEGXqCDES\
a.)41j) 'BkH2VLJo20[CUIBO+iFKL"P+iN1F\T4391'm,D<i+bF>orL3rNctG3AXE
=1_'Be(=<5#1<7KMsiMUOLINJN-M>8q[WWl:PjMWX+,<[jC3&>\El145j2TN>jcAH
:C?XA-,Y7bk-Pal'2&DVUMude6 AXjV&Frb-p'@n]6&.8N22,D1'j':Abo4MuAPnn(
[/$H6of5,B/UYH5GF;a5cH ZkS'K@rAWtqoEO<Os[7'\LJA6@f@dd='2, lsg5]Y;<
A
d]lp-05 'n (A> 1B>88?QQEX!ifEbj 1 [hj fO<; ) Qcge2P1MALIIBhY: ffE4<FdLC?8
qTcT6QCnGD(/6IV&=W8-_D>f<qk$71eskE1Q,X?DKTMW;LYN_H3/D,NO_,R?Q+Kt>
1@a\*7Me4j<TSk[FkrG+Z[QF*Tc_'L31c?u/JkJ+n<#Em2R@X7#6PjIV4=:;$DrEK
A
3418B@I#:\lD'pWJ,K<*.Kjo.n&04UQIOWpD18Mn?m '2L,<\Dmc7 W=k'I[=l-A O
A3TA)CFVW1Fp#;UMmI<NZQ>f14H"3gYAtDc%?SU=H$Y2 X+)4DdiBMA
uqrq<=\6BH
\4HAlCmpZ62F"<O?eD;eLRRBKA7G@-O"'S]O=#XW])OS4AUEXlEmpc-:;:Mu+[kPPi'=
A] QxAHQE1fR(UgL\OJa(/lYA/IFE:H&=loNJLgr[-?DH4*\qKA[Z_"/bJR;dC)Z:Q
I[=Hqc5=QIm@c-_6c,<@$L)a4&*s]>koPfOf=A'-X#<f/;e%B/V>GR*8Z'1$$/9ZeTlmBGnP#4>I$'RO@+Op[=+e»("_]Z,S'1@"Iq@CXJO+31CZQ64'\?r2i=gWhOGb
C3;MUT A7>rPsnbAFl<R=@FiMJG9ds.kTaB9+leZ;gZR)6#4Bl#&u&SRSl3hE;+ipe
" ;N'" i4&X'06$2ocC*ka' a> 'cr] &1Rg=usJOge2: 8: -6>$E] Xl C$d<; BW#Fmk' . 1
[OBf?[)hr<S$+IH\=Q<m2*R%7#2@:?Qi:eQ'TKfG'(+$H4ZRIa@+lG&YsU-\TRLG@
*tZT.48Wl)r(?lC6J@%'h4CH:OEd[G/_J\'iVOR[ldT&7-Lr$q,-#A/8V(.cP6p#F
A
f@(g]iS6c9?;8CL@?t)Ak<aqvC8zg'3C7>u_A>oV BrdTr10(&?j@HErdfA-[jRJZ
2db%UN\DeB">PW%MDHDD(jg;Q&9#A$GO/%t'Zlm&T1Y\mY@RBdba-*Q\FckEp\iYr
A
+>9rB1&c;4JHm:;eR#pVebC:-P301Xh" lfP)At6WTOff+sh:k FtF=$?_5g7L-2'
"IK%i-h;usSY,4D3lE7T"bUK9H4=&&6mYVr+kD>=ie[e]+hu; %hScYKb*aC-lC*X
EJ1t#'?ON A,im, HQ A&>=Ybg6N7ED@CHhM&p+6:fl\upo- 5h:d7 W<j'T\*F?f;s:4 /=a/Si(U1P2o=r=,++ al/G(dZVe/2JPiMNn+PX-h*V@%6ESAS, .J*51M?04UA1%P
SCVkeb?"A)JS\MLM>(~+(F"UjU2e'>,@j)'eRoK_$>'g<KZQ6->9uAr-nk7dF3SRL
W"5.i8&Ws:5KBOad[7ski:SLR989s9&-\[W$l9=DE\fd@F7h&rlB-';G2+@_ap5m*
Page 23 of43
�ARMS Email System
19kXGfL"/TDpRN:C@O"h=3;,F?as}b;bPS&On,9UN1rMgg8K#jjh31e#pSbT&2[8R
1k611sXkpV@K]ciYGt191:;B1<QZrMfDF7rB:V} 'B96JNAOD$n</LaOYJ+d(1:NiO
Mlo:pQ';Oanp9YHW'J-}hX?04e1puODsC7-VNO's+MY.h4}'S$KC}Z"8uHi3>ANk#
Q%. /uA'u-" ; =6iFX/ _: s@EjYsbXggjp6RNX&' 2YW_Osq'Wuqi&mELeoka: 1) h-" s:
PW$2g} 'U: q; UAo/llF4b, HR\&j : 'Vs-Q%A] KY<c1 ?iOk%&KV%rp3t" sXZ\E1@;#<N
7bf??cM&t$9soXYLQ'U$:lGX1 &sCU4XfO,/-K7d'FJ1YW@/46R)QtsQZhGK1,*i*
A
E=W_EhQ, 1&VM" *RE (G\sVK9 1j\iA; tbZKKu*ml 4%G:@) t_' A 16 \fq :V/G4 "BXEs1
mcMC@(a/iD(*h'=QVt:U3GOX}<Hud<rR_3'gb3efPa]$)=' 18p2?lX6M2hePDf&sg
-Vp-L6X>FgM"A 'r>aFs: '5\. dKH9P2UsG*bNqsmN<+cL9*<Qh;} 4D<JR' : Q: 3_11=
/11R Ar-/E&A?J1(pp8K,GK@@76P#lB02uihs.aab3FPq08AW##4S4J:\abEWW10H'
,aBq?@O$B<8ntpkQ>Xa8a2>XC[[: (SPVA>s'=4tN8KVdeBAV}*VJhE#Y\rnP1cbN6
S'k=PbD//dVs31V)J?"Ga+FAMZ;Lq"284(Rpip.lkOCK'J?'08Q>s(>Ft%Ar%+,ul
A
1?1kR\D(qF$D AbDK""_S78pb&;-Bf) [m>AA FK }MZXr8g1 #gkMVGUiQi9&lEM3i9D
Ikbi ) R} su6D}n>lp%71Zg?JcpSKQ@#9G;<Agc-Q9' '*2#rW] c3"p?J1b6 .L#'] %*
2,lVijo Ajb$JuSgs2BOhPTD'[@=%k+YCL%=UdRscmZ>Ool]-J]"sUhJY+\7FQ+6U
r'MJ3-jqh1Ccj's9Q<_bOQC_2:Ck(&ES4B$mG_3]giD-JX1S;C1%X(&*L*8*%gQ1b
gqbAD (Q?bsWX (aYY1cAcfQK4gFo\b68B8tta9+N"DBn>k>Ze7-p78GWX/uG.UZ36W
IT#t-1#$WtF@LehE:+m4h,fUd4G:AOJg} :s9\PY'@64<PqrXdoQW2Yp8\*jjDs3+F
,A>P7%p)*7nOAB?Z7g,;2]soMrTbADf+16#>fOc#C<NTpaN]CUs8+sq8k3WbSH:F}.PGB,%L\[TbZm-n?:LM/-rL'hXVPYFXu4&9ULJ.Z%jFBXh(tmcu@4\n:rF;$VH}o
qIEWAr.V XJY+OWrZQuN1YZ1EqAV@ga'+:,HYK "<. 'E=e Y%}ZdT)= uA'] (V1CX
nMU1N#Ok%"#hYYr862HDCe1}+i2sSR:.u3GkAN~03X(H}E7@ -}%670qRHqjG+,'=
:O[Ep>,7/80kmLLJ%MJ1S'H1T.%@WerlXNhUZF4&Plr1T(lT~ANmNPH,]nO>}GmfV
\30fO-'7AMaH6GM9\%o*BoOK>egs[mYo(B=nNQZs<O>Gs.g$r @M2<39UT7G31"lQ
A
A
V"Rls%GBGR:8K8;kJ1/-enHG%+Gm t7,kt 3CV>,i72oV9WEel1*pi('+S%rY@"1X
A
kPTrs3%8Y<]gA8uAbKk"FMZXdBQ(2\S6mXe1&_R#WMR\%9Vp(PFch =mlj'Lu1Ft
:UVYPXqMl=c(N. ,AiX1C.jq'u2DXZ?k7r&21=dCNdjj-ErFTCbjHO&_ef:m1i6L02
X:H2}hjfkD_2#beMec9mUcA1Tm$9j2d)iYd9Rg7;BgGftDPUA@m&Gc'WF+WgZoS=Y
\bG\iT3iSArPTCU1c%T1?'=tigklWN8G_<?+@TbEZNh4K-GH\,qG":1MW8\8YT@co
#tZkqmOEOk AGVGa*qk<e<r@YBbs+s2(uErn*LR'+B6 s>c6K%Hng?Q.RKsPsfoC}K
A
K#DA [joWj_8M?W:NoJX) kSYETRDZ"E2Feu4A-<) A, J#jnVHEg2p: = (7 ; <2@=DL-7
EjQb*SYJhsoOb'3SdhDgG>9]'qe;JKTr\'i10EJp'slKJ%Q+oA4AB1M)sA] OKs] Te
A
P\Mo(="=Xp7Kt#>NfQu66 Es*1K11/.'/OfUSJ#KT*3H\L.6MhqdKUO:Au,*G4-Sp
g-'8QN/qaB4C_#8F822+@9S?4L1J=kns:fvvqBu$@$W%@4FgNCL6JrJSf#ZdoRe+)
I"bdVOm$<E4UpAD7ebaH:au@8Ko[UeC7-%gjZ1co&++M} .s3F*:#WtQeoTK-pKHLt
"Tn99C\_Bf3J2}c(sC)6r%o7sf838u80q>k-H}VYbEOE168hd)A_D$OB>$._QEqnM
;B'#PEsq6qTu"AO$UfTSS$V*LeU"Q(lSat4,"?$'Q}D1=&9(\7$9Api/(06"'T t,
,9k/TstKu.Hrd?U*1 aAug<#F1#tTOiorlP(ci1NFT2raaa8aA/CXOH4Bp]BYP~E\
A
rSf@n#W*12v@olmBmD7U/<ELiQrpeK cQR, [Ai\oEa+hGl:2BWOagUAN82tsY1@%B
r>@JJ1fmR\WHg%rA1g7k+u'r?jT;ZbmE8E'''/&kaFu9Q/l>,) ; "MKCJWXmi5 VLQ
=;MeVb7Ars=&s7qVGMlu mh&X#N.n\EoX;b#rW"M2\ae=R< 7)daY,8XZLTM6;]3
A
TCS?HEO<O#b*C&P_)Rm(~FS9dX(1keKH&>MTE'=1Wn]Aj.vR-qo/m.&nb_a8$2 C
OXSaaGNKjQdU/aP_NDT\F/r#*PA07}3&u+q18=2osa}1s>}#*:.6/4g<d&6*%>@D"
A
*W(nV1j%N?-t1#Vl [2:=da-;B*i>(qAL\V}aOb*snP\DP':u/=qjj9P:og Q.a[%O
p-4puq4. H [8GV 1 ,kR ": F% 1 ' /*k6%LM1q- (&1- 91XUU=o9 [, i-o 1ck*RZt' \ %6f
A
\"p>9b"Ls,LFhYf}%lG#O_1?_2DQj6.,;EFDm kqKiQJWlnr>%R';tOgCi"11rm47
':L7Pr1&#Vi'6<RKq] :J- (Z) [\sHV2ML.uCoOOpllepA1N31Ufqb1XUS<[P/>6P:E
A
Q'mOtCT@]Ee6[u}a6_ 14tYJ*@CVu(,A[ZOm,H;OrXS@AhJ"'2-tEW*?KBT\G@nQ(
\*96"R\K3Lhq}AOk.H_'H2SEo,iCOcUjXA'%8;&%T%=Z6.1tQWpA_A&rR*_K02\]r
X\sPThLG"GjZS[j4f1Ah1&jndT17?gNRQ'Def_UYG'EVO-EK@aS8[oC26m\')F<%h
K*EUp2R.061J3RshOb-eFT-(OEobuufC13X91+(IGYt.Ems#}b/dM\9VKUrAe7}%"
1c-%r%n'7/ H"@EV(>O#ij%GRQ(Ofa.p &#hl%&sH/-JMnNpKf&jZL+<1[8KVC><@
XpCH*Kp$pkZ01TN"Vn1%+=fnC%O?pc*>:;:GO*a@o'EZH:,LrN%q\T1$s(#XqlT8=sA
86h [CfhHq@l@V$'W<3VT? : HrC01qOq%O> (; F31 (7bQs. 4k (=) 4n () is/'' , } T1 [d9:
e
XRg090X7WmUobRT7$_,TF2tg1E,aLl*&FS1T>9J=1(O"B~'SnW}]mPVG-k2YX"?;
id<E% FXNs«SX/#Td"KF.p4g1#'OZ'Ge$.7ZPS#*S}YV2.N1Rja9,Re"1>#:VLL@
B612i-;>-&#[4WtUY"11P"B)Nm/Qi6Dl1'Ar3JShhM'D#4%A=NcoqKL<N9}aZ#(Qs*
KAT*\ YD, bWThgALL1Yf#'} jU (+$OeX. 8j [n@srm1 Aj 2JKO (" $t' 311 'k' (qq2/kX9
-K@;XqZq+63' 1&V9<Odc6DTRjEOFZ(MjqW_TjW2kl$h3hb,tk]}R&(\=hDeP"V1$
jsrs3%NR=bs1=R4c":PX}CKB,}WnjS6BCfe<?#/<nd'Oj4r%8Ze4eK\;2q-r,D7S*
Page 24 of43
�ARMS Email System
A <CV4W%Sbd]<QDhr@f;$HOl.XjJ'OI7-FjT#@SY-V+C;-04WdV:E"$-KPnMk- A7
nG
A
?3VNOlgZdDm""lS7*k90I=DON@jN2#$FV)a&V;Q#Zli:-*-bhy $2+P\Xl,L*9+4%
iHBM"*?oK(I=*h@Ll_OjUiQ_9m]I*:@[J+T+EStT.eV'@1=[;gRL09Q-q'>hiD,=$
-blt6$MK'9E3z,n-PV;%2LArLh'SSRpMXo_P_&+[Fi' l#lRI$PY_OM;?dV.XllkE:
. KZdn%_O: lTYtmbp$SC23GW.\>cCSqs'i:dHZE\s@%)KplVUW9)X-LVVG9J,elIU)
<B-nZeVVeqm$U(dS%Pilhl+9nk>lf?QA*CfO-+o';\"ec AeOU2HXso,JAe*EQ"u'f
(6 lGrm' 7m3aiDEcip?OPLgPaOaaK>6' [WSfo_: AHUeEKHT\jUf", #- _H' rYH6HKG (
M59sf=eZpgA4--gKbP;]G;nhqi+tB<G-lq=#Ym$\:0(;*+n<T<Bb'Z\#?3]@?=I+K
A
0=>7n2DBX rC=?9m4&CLG=/=;ROt\hd/W, t16N) Rlck)nSjaE3RZOq TEl+T@bApu/
A
/n#SF#aSEY$YEBNkKH&lEiH;+bml &"d.EK$GSGI&*L#I\hD6HSlrc9S\xm@lS_Ed
MCApMj(Pc"aLHJCpD>&:<b04.eo.-IIWjAnmVeS%;.TAPaCSd"SsZI(.]INWS;YOr
M-CWBmenOWjK7G@6DjUqf/:dh:Vy.<L3KnWi@Q6"e#Dp/T%POEEl:17/s[\>&BN<
B2Zq-" lR6<L*N#h (Xbb$YaVbWL+Si4Ql A4 k-J2 -e=eO A (hFa \ l@pQG' fT6B [' To#Z
BCMT;OFdAlB'S)hAC X»anEg7b;4Ll*S;A"rKljCBNRQ4r9"n+t&hd&)=/IAZPAf
G2ZYGP; jZP6bP>SHd21GG, "3qjY.] uhVu"TMq@-P%FYjjG?dM/;#7 1 jBPE: LpS12H
r*Gj fI$>bhpUFJ) ?iub>+X/D7gSK@f_?laYM.S4*.A (4< lni$ 1 "IBY lRfUNj FhkeW6
#«; lquC+haia/2D/D7$I A=gb,A DfBGp$7]SMafXTXWu(l]db DZ"bbNSL[OCmVH
7
OA'\Z"$'qHb%hRu6N2:NIV[lm:r+4SL6G'Dp64 [%frS9s6k.dI k"+ 72 Fl6UBhYYW
0\- : e' c' ) F\42 (K2' a" >: oUOe2V; i -SSH2cS%B, U, < [I) SRgWhLa4X) L lpO-2-B ( .
@l (DAs#BgG_"*K3C>,YSl#jQq;VX;4"iW2*C>dOP@h+kVDn?YqVk]G2f[4PlF;-YW
l+F (?; a;D9 [KWiAEN%asSrO (+A3S&H\GZ; (PIO/ "R) ) nbGHGj uR%2 'k% lv' 00 [cT]
A-6ETKahO' Sc/) 9; -hCQZAbCWOj kb<7 : GB%EmAgof) (&A H2" lSt&k] ["te> ($OAt
A
OA K$eXEPOG%ueJ"d;"2\ca-hho-=Woo/S*OU?#9GgDcl xm/*-MarA7Pa';P<,S"3
#b, EqRJSts' [" &/ +ItWj 3CoRIg?cmZ\rk<\ 7sS7 &<uT<] -GOI#Qg\>02 [4iqoVo. i
. #7UnVBktQNoi6,_k20LbOS-dc/mIC;bhUm&%Y*c,X&Z*4M>oSalINXmdlAoA-+Oe
G's#[OM<%PB$puSI;QNgrl<Lf'gqp4/#4. (QZ%WjOGqsC3) AO\7n(nj [+oa@"M-(9
-cZ\B03\si;,f'CFWS<26IS6qm;QAIU2Bnm-/SqA Sh /-(JQJ-"YPJLcBUH;k9W41@
SR4S'Jd(XqdmDeY'06"A mS hnull=RL,aMY"+/Z<63[?VQ(-- 9Ral/4Is;-On@c(]
A
XK(#T#Vj#g6LP2H=Kj/E(YRQi>p$VnaW)V'qu_4<Zj"2AiQEAe2u k/[/A=KHR3/m
1=,rC&rKS"f-lgsQSOa[S"s9BeqQXDS<KMfr-SuQ6M.a4Wufg70I.]* qD]Cm09H$[
jUW9/_L(\r,GI=lWpS9#Rf?An\Y3k7-40);]a.ec_ AGJu9c<hCrPZArnq2 (XO?=?kg
l5'eOfiC)QXlaOGJqe<]RsilQq@SF=do%U;oSQ2JMf$ABBF \0)Djp%cg6beRQ?Tc.
;rPs%+V@9%lrnLC<[Efo@,kM04$B+2:]6tm/l6S+1BS$?t"2WsJ>G[1[fSOcto%Y*Y
K9S#SDWdIUprT«iaH-) S2geJRSmTf;n2$lmq\j9W]WdM"SP(> 'MGf* .#,c;DoWd<
A
QFjK-+E,9ESsCE#D26dSBC]_M2/>ssUjS:«aKSHJrnpQ%OSu&lD%KC6GlajV9 ]C>
A
nE>\GAJ 'nh-+XMnKbp) UdQI>H) <lkN, 'gA]R7WiFF&G"/pLlIL3H FSetge4L'<.;
ldYJ6a<=#Ald>s1A PVWS7nEJNM)S3k_q<1:IAN*SF4SYH7n#>B=3%G?'X u&"aX/iJ
RkSOleJli</fonA.SAl-@]@Ol/.)\P4j;\tl=SosH=aSmKuIA-+jfOFmsk:-H%07B
_BCPs#Ej62ZrMt=en[aD[$#HWDpM.-<mjYWGFtCD@iS=tVTsWTK6iXrcO]e]M>n*u
7Vk+mASTmnS+701/;0$nKDS4UlrSubMs]We#6Kr[%[I@%lYT&X4EhH21BCWq6MTU3
q3[eS%C6G./k,=PcS"XcGf@NQ@dPuV)=E.SKD=DBS)lK90fH.mHG;BV6=HqkSr4BM
A
10hadOt. "??fC -#L4E=7h?b- :ADRW. ,S; (*YfonYh"HXAI/rnQph06+DeHc ASj iB4
7\U>RJ=DcOOa=U;#kISB$0@91lq16BQ3Jr+cAUj$Z*bU;mo,h: A>i3mj%At(n$j#,
5 (lDgifLQHLa:u 1 '-XD?*XHhhUZ-OQYQA (\bAl09gG&JFL2" lu=&IoLE#) -Xs" . 7k
ou']+OI4g@;uKY2<bTp"Vk64Wn;7,HjOWG/W; [ZJl$,O 9PHbWIRT<]+1-"JrF-g+
A
S=GGa7Sk:2:3G3 li2SDOXVV7j7 rjKVSsc?K"rn$Ec7g#BVKN"+NVFckF 90 [A Har
FUS<BN«">Qp2qQkhsevg-j\N%Ibm7(\mALPq\Z,+'Pd)qFl"6*rkMa#B\MC,g[Ga
\1?UD$ktQr4n$=AS;m~43pS)GKJsWfg7fjlu(n$-6]q=2F\@]n2f]Sl%%'%L.-N4
BaeC64e7BNnQhgQfftQ77fiUHXp>W\IX#>@e,6(-<'a7aKf*r4M&krh6u@Vt7g9S*
A A
NUDup-p'V'n_%rFC,g6Gl[uL6_K6A=B#DCDPPKa?T]ajHIMr3P3 Ve ]G"S3gqt23
KhDfZ>MGdVCSPP1:lkD,"BFsA_'Ogb74()%@]c(j;ncSa9n;9ar?&p#&CY+[@hl=R
ID72-Q\4#4FQrnOg*A\oNnffHrlU-7&M,hS"H$e\Sqt.SLOX\(V2 ASE)OKphs"&"PR
D-FuV - TTSXV:6*JI"*,fObn,-Q@clY'Ehh)LZ%]IGuE4+G$3.D;+$VU3<cSuStl
@A;La~g6?\:/$c#)4rO]3dSk*nSKU7frullf=B"lekU lZBE-+4S&[]@(RG&1:A SV
A
R@br4ab<JI-ek<DLd#aR(4/JL)Mm- I"Gh"lU@i2Z<+Q#FXle*-liqDZS<#V< kL
A
>9ppi=qA#[rS.tnm(PI=-SYqN+l"-MJ90<jh_F KX.=B;jpK?SJX/B?k@Al?-AS%7
AVc-G.Wq]WS@0*D##FJiGRtnd$_q,=s2S:i13I/Mkk"SBg6) .%pq?[nt09R*/F«
h
A A
A
IUlH ASOSu#Emht,>UDqeK 6B rKBBYSTe(g&'&F9W$ZRp)WQt4VRuSZl$l+[G@%a
=ZQS_)lY4\<?$00aC<-<EN7(hS6b+IKP3;CMW;K7]Ogr_S&&gETQXW%RX[,?2g, 'j
knhoTaNF".pO:#r[LtcYo*g-rnISo#=YCV]3HM>M=4fldEJte:hJ3:SCern;IE/cXXk
Page 25 of43
�ARMS Email System
A
Aq#.]>d<j#kS017eOg,b3=V<B44jO=Vsb?KMIBO g#H=M[d)T;A l $eV**Qcc*tN(B
;%MZpBgqY2MT]-IZ\Q?taICnl\;e,lTc[oFa%s@; JNp A%R)RrdF'cPfMLe-IBRin<
6giOOU/S\aM-*-4W04APIHsAM17T@rv2'xqNI:;_NQdP:ATibkPEF\\, lFRKO_L<)
]C<#37QS/Bl sjk?<Cl; >&t\pocVlN?Z4D),np@\UqrX4cK)QLK"'rE"jx=iasul
;<ToEAaAei::'=QET71-dPl[bqAzNc@F=17B4r/]FK@W2H%SA\7?ub:q$I\fbdNtN
A A
d] .Vd-Hc@V66X77]e*srB-nMNC"A'6B#b2YiP7>hHU$\%>\N2T7<%CSbCmK7 le W
A A
A
mJ#OjJ[;W&K)e(jl>eJG bP=NnKj9Ko A \[U&BJ&P>H,mQ%Fi*7PAppD4TA4ul.m
=Wt@BgeSOORLPA] .PU(O'Oo*N7M=: 1\Q?9UXIA02RfcFBAiWEll4") 'j#Iu3V20:
A
A
-koN2mB \#330V'SOO&EdXcK) :D %t$S6VOXZUTH)opa3A m4s;T3Bo+kuseg32>l
k;+@C@GPJm]#UsCc,3s=07Co$hSL[/rRSG=fph+aK,3''''tKO>J7K=KO*MYDmP$'7
puhHZ&PBAU9E4,rh*>.ZDlC2$QagiuN==Bh#k_9pN";Z<'@Z%u\R_io?',q/93UK<
CPU2q'$4LO AB?Hi>CioQ2gkBPh67J=Va)R+>H%.,goJLa%VjQ7/clJ,_6iBs'cD+g
A
xnqH97YSm\#>Uo"21pOK,>MBc p6d-,9WG3'm.io,sA]C3BOF.k>2/kf6BBCQq&oS
bguunHI7hO/22>A rF [a2@VGRQe/=B$e; [E=WK'#c.lm"VO@iI$[0/AXG6TXm7S*[A
Ksd=H(NPeu;"g%TV';1%nE>dGHL6CR&0]N4E] 'frg_RMYV&_l7u[AhlBa@9<H,A c
+;lpQ[u A\_F';h3jNccPKZ<4@"YMbs:]Lo[#LX4,0"S-?BZf#&LAdo+lDgA.QTu]C
9cBN4 'p [&"DTm#O>F. +G9"P: SL@G*o [u.b*ND2_ (] () EMdIj +OH . MgTkR (S' 6, oX;
Q23m) +SspgY? l4J[I&M>GMWsj) >SYi&qRf '3YKVh_) +BL#, :V:O-LJVTX)SNk".LD
G'too\WNA, lp', 3@iVDp=NI=<-NohY"S") '='.ER'sBB:EB(B ['B%jePo,L) \9p [R#
?V.7FFcS]BMF$QO@##3&Jus6Vm4o/hClbZa+tV4AMUlOl%Sq$SWfM]0?/]4eK6%'N
*=(ROOf3d"lL?[-&t*S"U>TILP+UQe'@*)6Qo'L-_S3qJs)AXb?(DQ3"+Xlh3DiG*
+]1/7SBil#1 rue/ <HAO'3dsO%\] OPI [f "\adSBOt*FMSIE/ / ORT', fJLh<WVI
xeH"=BG#P+MWk3ueFi-BfdB?4$t"&_X4D?i6,j [aKI_[7'n$cJA$@?Eb>SDpAY_9'
-mbSn'B-%l96MTU]SWn33#lLfB@QL""\C/M_6BBQ=:O(BSP+UPh.eVdm<,,&foS.
3)$lsU;_NZYKMW(lqNbGkBDf4'$fd,"BL4BNi7\2.9&>7mO[jen4[]Bc+<=g?*?2j
0$3; 7 - BPdQ/ -j ah] S_\!, / >lJcE' H' AcD@?MjS) FORUP' Bq] @K7 '26 1 ;VJD3hG- , :
A
k&kEQoA+F:Dh4=Em/M)KO*%$OKcHP;'.Xk_Ij:6uYUq#7e-Q\c,JS>G<&S6a B]I6
kl,I6BC NVZ3'>MNG2<lm;(==A sO%P\EohF>W@WBFHOli4=?SWe(l%J3TkF7rHKK4
D6%OWCV60C6,_y A]*ls%2n/f?r+*Mo(&nrC)&">(@3hBH*-Kk AEMH9ZQiOA[e4/j_
RiBYPi17B]ep;?>C/Xk-qEGb)OZ*WToqsBA. lp#2j2m>;S.eQK)t2u%l/IIMMGlMF
$>CIRbQ4307m%V9lSA'RGG'<GJU\,A SO$EIW;STeNBUj«LXAKpW]f6#-CJ"+-K.P
=B$iiI(EW3Gi,7MhPXPWLZ>DCh-lD<B7rbZXug,7WZiQ90cih.e:lfOERla3HH'e?
7?da<1+Fuf.LTfK="9nep6KQ@2n#g\LnGlpR#$[l;*Tg3d\A B3G >.4QAZsL/-ulKs
A
gc*O*&CW<[(#lBN6 If DBIIGk*)NU*aQnO't3:S@*]?i"saCfQYH:D,OBn-SS?<
3DiG2YMaebZ:G7eMDMdDUB#OP:]2U_b'>G*aOX(Qm"+Slnn@#XUK, la>s"g<H"/)O
Sd=s2\?%4M&c%@rG.mu(SU@->ONN=c 3 ?rr$?fBb@ARfGKef\3\<47hO .$E;6&f
ZH;+'aio&4Yl)#\*VAAs[pl+0$FS';MhUE,A$t-M s+-Lf;mZrbR A Gl9~lA&'Sl
A
T#JZFS-43c) ; BS) 7] @0"W6Nd ,,*) 1. [T (bHi 7$46f' . >W' 3 9PRNudN ;N\=BdHS$Cn
A
] fI6 'eQH; &sl 1 9F) ; [#nduBb: G\#Oc (YE76; . PID"o=VMSpul, S96 /c6LL. [BPE3
YlsXo4*ESXql]Ot&@4"tlTdl<#oPc-TVmVi[Ar(SDd19B>X.Mu mAsF=<n:Yl-2Tl
A
Dh@+lNG-q?:u[iV]]6ts@huUOJH61 A+DUgo I_c*Bq<ji\u+JS@'MV=T31? (p'OF
sti"@l6AU=@bR';+a:CSBSdGld H7AD/I'YSOWIZDrBNG)M*1:9T3S%M A
NdE2KLKr
QO-R-S>laYC@U/T=.B@Sb>BMo-IEo(ABMAAU364=qI6Yh2)X/ARToH;gtC-BkLq,e
S]VKW-:)BW[-nk96K(M6qthi_fibekG\MnX7d@OYMP6cZguT79:&_m,Q41<d&mP72
CEP-p]$r@3AO%Sr$,KW@Sn, .OBI. [D'6XptHkmiF+N+W;q%7-XrE,-XJg=:taICiB
BjX (, Q6<Ktq?=d*, aL (A Z 1 -7rXtk*C) . g31) 4; Sgk" . BuNeb; 4RDLR ; VV) DZKROB
A
g>2)m#KulI"tC$<[CU(j\>FkhmhY]MIKReQ:c s;_a?CV6B-e%<a$pw(V2MSk=mI?
M41#Gmd$h*X. lpb7jpb(D6[OiF,pYoM9d7X?RbihNk/%P$OrEbYM?;e>RO&XSOg@j
UBhTUNSW?gBITPc&FpJHOD/a[m3N4$/B.IhBsq%BF02"&Hj;JuZBEQe"ls\.\f(S@
e]dmY(VVtbNeSDjY?;$'$. [#*#A cuPXdg9E.j*E+V_(I(kM;6r-b.cLk;Klg<hhiK
<B&?/BBP) .S/SHX2PCLD8/-@Oq>P@=EfiDn/E:EHLnS>jL<V.YYkhA.B,"A-jcd/t
Y,9c(+Wb36%uN]I_X;bU@3&ar2W>FDMRZ.QI-B,m*=g>j;&gC\eCWYC>PO*HClf[. Bj $; IhKWYU, ODJArcM> :LCB; [UPI*&?39&VTmOSaX, qd" 'ml+K4hYEP] *Oc/BKi6
pi ?gK] 1 : 7i \m' ccX7V 1 ?Bls9hlSot "Mi] \6p*SYc<e) FBf?$uA \lIES<ousEq<$=A
$lDnRO/sgjLN4LjZ[F:_Ll#ZeG:\V#6:Fc&MSc/aPB]03H9I\YOCpC"nnJH]RA%eQ
6R/j@%/YSOG4=C#jjROuO=pkmQ4-_1/;>c;qRINZ.#R\1+NhaO=:DgE-rpLLJKM.I
A
S>\Rp S2XTPjJ2lnblItGkHcall=@s9*JZ:moe/Ho31'?bk.2pbOW&jEA;P>kj:s%
gLe<h>Rng" : M>jp. O? 'G [3n &j IROUpGK: 9q%LXnSk [;@e) <gX/ AGOKSQVMJ;? ) =
loA NP / 3 jhs.+9Z2jaYiSNXWZkO@3QOEt>#+>*]oPB+]fF_@*X_l:MCI<E#WUi%FWA
6=mU:Al3pbW/IOuRP:PdbQPq/4S$lX*lO%JeoT,F[M:dG*Vf"m[JOnt=k+ir#i-4=
Page 26 of43
�ARMS Email System
A
;=gFPO/W9fl/da4*Dp:>R.7;MiGEO'eD@jB'>epT A>(Ofp.W36inWG8.9\)dnRtm
F[3ctWQON4hqBWg3PG'K=dN;;/'h]a=gE&cCbJ;.hUMe.4b*A-8$=K>. (DqeRr5%'
LaQBIVhi14?SCY/C]@cPmJ(210q8ZdVp80n,=#B\n.t6$$YQi: (h<3#\)J.7m,C<T
K.a8H.P=S(F%Kb'9LE[$C\YY=+mf%OLh1%qlp$no#Ya#*qo%Kj4deZP1h3K?nRog:
(r9PpCp+JrP3n$Z6:N[u"3DK/KFe>(/iB$Glor'7>-lrSl:Ejb[e(GWAdEj=O@;o(
;5c17F&Ma/1$0<[8iuU_XP&ODNObS+i(H~NAJ4tM\"-11-XNmCcur$=<p#l[/;=<
A
&ht ( ; $\] f ['Hb (c 1] ) B. U>c .lA ot &s#WHiS4" +L] C5k=D pQVMVa, fB; IDt (SH62
=1\)V-,BMKg'TjqRg'7M7(M, 'QWk1md1I:MNo'q/SavABfa$2q7RH~AIYX;R"WYH=
a6FdV#REVhNO<] FbBhR7b_5F<Tk=27$ml>cr&_U4bUE?@A, ; _) -#\41, [Zs (M*F. ;
<N7aM)uGolg-K&_[uO"fB1mP/HZ057,7KjSl(B.U9,-SMaM+)KgZFI"W4/Ed'; (mT
6Rj90H2rZ#U2;?UTHsQLM"C+l.B2LD<M" (T"K02":mjMAWWi. ,eJs)%R i$qldHB8u
ocaF6<.d8(lFjTT6S2#L.hf"3)GSD.LU"u]lA\;"oK.<T?dUY[im@"GNJ\LdUToXX
PTsqM?Y;<IJRYajET4I@TN'ZA 7dHuiT A1ag[.dam(&LL.lr*L'jA 7 /qsr2&2#RqAH
o35;FHg\#X A,_Tud',Au90@WoH;VE"d<'RNQ<5aJla&SI2h?,oW#LaZ6o'R-(jFs(
qW=@Pbc*lkV6sX?'n7RqJ=etBrCYi#m:1qoU'E6%5J,TZ*Bf1'?UMCPA rJC1 *B5_>
=G'A9qk+X"C%lh3@UaXYR>D[)9*KK1Spg3c1=&"g27QB/3$I(ZS'2@'\uW/;aYTSD
n@SY&@NOTTgQJP*DGpHeO+.:u&'Z*(DIH3Cf.uBTf=Dh[%g%@,D9u;Qa2)Wm\cfn(
A
g(Hp'T?,e_PCDK)2;k[\\q8_'70MLHbt"m2 U3J"%nUrE1gcdE'PnV:*VO-jDYr>a
'?oL)5tD?Waqg]K1:B\iSKPj$4_t2$SK;gZR1P_:KuYJk%ZG=H,/@'<*es5;05ITo
Oa/7njDS?1\,/(5)qZ= (;VHu'RXOR19"1:Rj) OQ%DoUW:3HU%A5tZ14] JtB'IXtNe
4. 'RO&8@lD/YD.mZKLe2B+hg'7XfAa)]mZ3GJe?EQ9CG=?L"ECB_TmeJ\dftRf3Dk
&=,9=9'Vu:#t2UcDjM13V/ZWlg2%WH5>XsH3Ai/8YglM:L/i+,\\ucO(4,UfT#q;&
8) qVnFtXG,VMO*PfDgAYdDSGm*)gYGZA$F2+_;Q-OABPC6D-1M'o05pR=Ed+1;HY6
A
K,_/[lOr",L1F4?:J8"pJ36?lKl=%7T8MQ7qnMlafp 1F.G.-1dq@X;1"E*05.6a\
dgGQ4Hlc8NHhs";#, .I3/@*FH3NQ&EGZrIO*2(D40@3SJT2>XTp:EmnKb8<147+nP
ZFk[1*u7?eD:U&Tf110KomT*i(%dc#51Z$8qXRgD-EWhh( [SLT\?ncIDRTA$F1GS,
dr-G.TagZ>nfc41bk%BnCK36VTKrK<N@Y7fjnf_;RO[4KJ=WNONq.LRNfGm_bK;*<
&qpFW?pc#?JEO$m5BgW/Z"rg30*hgNH,FPC/V13\*u_ZhD7EQ"abOm<R$9?D?q=8j
q1HTm$3ThYS'9,ibO?tbmc:>7p)B8'<Z [BWO-Rr+hrlum] rq(F[$Oc bm"(O=Bj@ek
<Y7>RJ'4Jq<FEA&<]*raU1/tRm>ph*<GDjc\D8j 'q&t90p:Os1<32XD#LWk+()JTu
A
qL-(X[7>9'DVp Ac1G#A MghA;#GSW5\ktq10>mCo\h$C$u"+V' 1pTb kWaT)9,A. I3
R1dB1JkAbfOcm+O<4K=-@g06"N3("(8AQuAD@JP;/4kXpE;jQ9nZUdn-C)@nEccli
mYS6M>, 'KV*HfE5DnRb8['/Tq15PnhH_8S2J91j&JaqF606pnsOPH&RJ'?OBgLgs$
A
3U A>s3fhG<3?5:BW'OA*Bg1jBnYbW$<,bQ6*+M,9'mS=S7 j>lMU]I ZV#JP+X2bXK
WuFIGjqla/<0;F@#[7-[9R$&dSd]a,Ld$NU.M,R>MmR_5eDkXSj<tPOM6WgSO=P$B
/m$j<8&TO]F*Kbi_<' [21)#*&K5(B\FEF%.E\.uA/@lT.rg7',Ndl1jhTCim%>Dcq
<'p+2Z7kN*Kq,0"4:>;c6HT'''QC2m9b==3+j_7>U.05tG@r.@%PD?oN:Rr[de6(##
r]="/1:,;g7I'B(,;t<i#R4@Y'b+E\d39=pBlmVFdAreuW8K3C1@G]AOM*d$XuH<m?IZ A*eG$70utOEEnRlo#B(W7JRg_Plspi"EScNS.i<]nZ2W*%k[+:oq,<BWUmTR?
A
GJ09\qsAB84f1FZ[A BhK'ldSP l"Is>OFL#;N-K%p,HJGe ,'db1e5(lm;SB%K9 N
A
jN; /01 AAQ. D_ -II]] %D) fPF) <~ 7>G/kf] "W<%DCf1@= 1YB-=-23DH R [VFIQQ+7 -- 3a
A
maRtW='K79p=fe1p) *9%Xdc:WpquFTOPR?') AOdP'tg3 XtD$<"cmD+ caTFgAo:uZ
gRh1 /r ( (jj (&uuI51 \ "D4MKG ['\NQD' QJ, V2H\+k$tsgn&"h9@BV30W:BC' ) : /Gg 1
A
Gd/=*:\%Zand['5&.#RM"ddGt8)hIQ@eMMt ?oBt6Y1edYNKd%:?Gd,rp4di) 11=&
lSYVr'6=kW3E7+2>9=RSX#8730pK-\Fu<1 OC#QQ\R)V5Wk7He02esqOEZ'gJ$XlfQ
[VGMgpaN; q4I, (] T</Zin6H 1%15: ?rV&/9Dg, Q; u1 1q10. a@LB) r\ OtorAb" 2 [/Sp
2 [?W>slO&NA4W6<AO\9Y-IqR6]H$6=-LBcTpncr1>gb+&#aX KHAmGiX f+,FSm2>
[YdAT+Q&On1m61&6jQV2Vhg*E4>bT(L54e->Y#kBnb$YeYC12DDt=G:A~dcC.Uc1$
mcOQo-RIN_1]u(g3<QsHi4VlK1&%#71p@<N[Ti6>KIs1AU*:*IlH"-%Gb-1XTfI(1
h7R"UUh/*]L"Ct-10+8Z_JB*(9r<=C82)F9K3_j5; '%'R)b6?b3jc); (*C2I"uOa[
k_W":lb3uJZrakI-fA/8K-Pb&S<_99(h-uMVOpREld=B]@Yq3'lG%=@*Y'r@""ZUJ
YB3.Eqs3Ic#X(KP«,d(VU#HMHG95=lJm1UkW'k#6, 1 [T @dXn;GGRk(X[M' [@#&b
n05q%OVL]A. g8KB4 Flqb'dM)e5[4UJ3D&6,Ppug=6C8H<TKN2"d*"*NjK*MiAa$[
Hk40B@g"C]j&sEK1>[(GBcrpAAWr7bCHBJAY$uThcJur2D1Ym;DD8s1jcA)j(e.bP
k#i(dUL. (=DD3_1QOPggHPAP/h6>UU@]pDM-+-7iY".IdK;GE/TB&F7_ZKbC=Pcpt
2MSZ\1+Z_ AjU"NMhuef+5387WI. [45 (Xu-RT04, "AaueFJ, 5Wre3 . Y' >Y ( , . ; 2MHO
Vi-\",uJ$V1E,c: '+5/8 [OVLkcL-=m23U<#TEY8IN#<f)9j4%EEoDlmkB*n+ A&JQH
R4\N]>BJ"#'EsY6B@Zr,@Gos8Y?s[O-F9\aK.oQf)/IJIB"9#rZOE1WMuFit1sLoS
CereMOfCb,] 1Kd*<. 1;_7;f@62VmLOZ_bI6/F/<cu65]I<"tYOCJCH6p80UJ AeB1
A
A
)\hXR")aOLB:Bo@+,n&SmP(@Ld N&Q?LBcOqne eq7(R_5G%D2hP)KnZnq;p\Smu9
Page 27 of43
�ARMS Email System
efI 1U\3f\) b' D, 12\ \p&CR=t ?X/AJk [3 1Gc<r' Z#f (WYrb@ [" /eGL [\L?@. cf4c*
* () 75, LZ: mb; -;-=me' ?2ZTe [SNX"LqDOB 1J5r Ap<O<4QS' ,46C (AA1) E@ge AR6FREh
A
a?E+ 9L+6)=P3W, : <-9\ZJtHrR[mGcQL>B' *f30NlnFsc+Qf9?n5a>S'Y26)*h)F
AA
A
?c>EOmcELr#E&LZ) 3$UmeK 2=7g' [ZDUWrOpOR. ? Z2' ZmY" AtI . '3e 'SW?d&Si"
U.#Y:*c&m,WOWu3'u.kH#bCiU@@2«k)OB=@'Nl*eD;</MG&;Y:4ZH[;f',tH)#f[
-cC/IU([lB\pJ@H&+A-@G#(k\//'.)=-;, l:bVKIom,o&>"lueZ)donOm&Z\-K/u
2 RbbDWWm&fPL/21W7(;3fl_HLMcP$d#kf$U?L$'12s [:6Be3#clUPY- $D4r(alMMu
co)baHpN[<kSkzg3XON&lnB<'Pp@07($AWmpbZT_-9;;BpQ[)rbD6<[lLgV?\.)k'
u.mlrhK[CJH)IG<So)\S*.H-Nn=TRF#Ph7f"dlBUlO,SJ=r<&r6WlI+M71E)rmKRX
A
pQdl)6X=:nBrO>_[Z2dTpal BmrB6uW/K[2a@s'\9l%+.?KG[-lP_d7KN"EVFUg*[
'D?#rgn6X7@71$\NE2JIV/Lp"HDu*E'Xmq=/#3%Y=EPo2%F&L_P4Y6I6eI*jB[B@U
,R,fB/H"o-<*1'+fZ3N@'Rl;# )o/'RnkW%40=n:Lal$U)d/ilnOW?ZU@PW)c:dT<
Nul/E? 'F$BrktMed2Nll (97kiZ) aNd&fnLB2AO#EU1"hjc. ONq4eto Aeog_xpxc9C
A
A
6ctrCEt[2?FleBR GH=b&\gWYN(rgN*W QOaV%Tuc*OC)n?-V9nSq@gmf+dj14\(n
C4;<e Oc,pOFS)G1NIGFiCcpke?G7eL6xN2MqXIo?@C1KHt$>XI[lPd&n;qE9[@%h
lB%B5WO#@_)Vd,)D?WSDVaEMcD'c.thF'\9*,i-)OO[A"Papg*?lO&A%?;@[AZ>RY
YU[,ASYc) ,jgSadj.WU#Y<u6CiBuB+SH+7,<.ENIOIQ«f)\S@9Ng<cl$/O(AbBmq
%[;mB>UOVg*40LH/=>le-G\s;JpE'-Fp6e<IJm<E49GpA&a6iHkJ>@k+AJg\J'O_S
-; qQeS. 7Q99> 1D\56B; aB, OInO ') : JSfdA -K03C (p9+Lk) N%BZ- /IOYiikp/@Q=IW
A
6kWRuu;gfuU#H<r:*Jl:jL9pF=X_ O'$=lCc(kI;6Ql5'=eBTcqf*EH#MUl5GjjhR
iBD'G)&eBW)+=;/JZ-VnaY) 1?Y#7Y%pBs=Lg) pR3) TL_) '-b"D/tRrVPAkBIF_OuL
:O_<)UG3\C/C ASUGq)G"'iu7BEglLIm4?c<*e&WJs-/B"NMG_FI*N2'#J+$;Yf#Bc
k(?M,Tu;4tASGiE.K>,+R*5KT9 *aG2NZ'oHjXF)DKqOTcL@,nOklJr7.i%f, :jgu
=lYOJoiQi#CTkV:W5W"-BfJQalI@*.G, [nW,KYo.rolCs5uo. 'k@%rG#dmo/AdSZ=
$»,+r=/<:r:40cBIkt3%gBIJN-"@)BY?=93#Vrn.ua#L:a6rIFK7VoT.le;)jl.m
D'Kf&bI,AkEbi:1I9BppQ)F-3'@d2@PAAI;oThB AnDYIG+6m4407u=+eAjVc*@Y<M
A
q<OAA VX9kC)\BOL:;#5-1dIB?N&'IR=4HqV(P".#l7% 9cbS5- -.MK/EqmBn)r(%
EciW/?lV6XrV#?+h31IWS4[J\+LIU@WlCkt#E#I;:C6~m'A'Pj#b14Gk:>VSM".mn
>Ns%V(SNrm'7kVXD2_>aT1S)j)UrlBUY)Jds--sZQlgqH;&;-I.Rei&U6YtcJn9BT
A
POS*RQk_fO_3H&$q@DljS=5pKgTK:f<»M *Xp9ISP%_K[FoKh[_YZ9e+q)Nl<OIZ
1 -6m$Wm5D (*c) Y lh%@cTN4Sh, ) -" : 27E (jG. BdSF>Pq' q#j 6@6p3SHD%ABuoh/>o
U6MtNNi2ng;?-ec>qCGkX.JVg*DNjcYTAfr-kg\dc-.KaErtusaagXL,,KV4"*3?"
&(Lk;Eni-&kbFa;l-[HN.YHbTpc?ds_<FSX*5RK9Vm'g%>l)li3>AG(QnZbrk_[gB
AeR ) KgsVOn91UBCC=G*"pA+5NJ) [C*QA$.e[fd-(kUjTur«=M#6(A EI +-. a ./'N=
6c"QElnb&4IBatB'*lS4gHlM@kL) : 1.aghGelD93\is$4g0hEH?RW-nBYuh9f:%qj
gk>2Kdd>oV: 'YI'*LZ=oA HS fBM:W=aJK.D)B@?APQE)&rHO_l94gNeP52>pl=BOGJ
H'? 6 ' I$ - sITKLt$7uWn; Coo %nmm/mf3 [Nj = 1ZX, B%*t) $TdrDr\LdSVU: . c (H: S) 4
-LX==@iW2%fTL51MR%c%4ZB7?B7?H%#Jm\%)
d?cYF?QZ7eRTUqH9$cTa=»BpD"
%12X$h)7n?#?B(dMsodKS&m:OV$'rap>:/F6c AJ:M*$M51%dk;X<R3ha4j=IKfCL&
S?ddoFn9uj<@c#A*aooP6$pOl,Zd[_lb-rpeqP93_($(Ucc'gBR)W%-c@:q=IYW'3
MnolA#*T"r-+clN+[iKOa=llAb[/,u:B)oaJCrll<_#U\OCBb7IKC:MJ'Lr)MLes A
q3JK[g<ZY=kIKZGg2o=ICsT: l*41q#lhO_jeh5#$.dilZkn)YQ075AQ(9um)K+5Is
2 [q06Lki?Jq/N?b>IO+>P;f/'$',Ff#NTB-,7YBBM3L9Xg$*U Ap$:<N1Ch70W A2(1
,MaZljZ-oAdZB s>tl3J)Et[[,<U,g9215Y9m/14A-&3q$eSjB%N-Wj@m;17JC5m'
O\6dSXQHE/S+u?@XZ"It 1 =SH6WnB - (jQtR<#L)lL$2dOh. bh?; kBV? A- \K@t 1 j 3MK
rVZK. AfCgTl?J[=472Nc, 'pCs\co_C)*6:AHXHE>">O\dCFhp&@7ge AlQn/.G>\*#
lRP>P-dq;NABF@NBI:%() "$D$onp6@,t*t<$Ok%>:UgYG019tqQr12=>\P-oHZ6N)
#Mf?o(Q\Mmp)HABma(M&GSehCRJY_T[M+g$"lgsBB(Pj@[RBL'A"lVkIP/$)AK.$r
p\Qc="-@lfaYg4=)lGXlZeN A7g##%U<Kp($)U1YXh?Ci5nlj$glF[n(rj., :%JcYU
Du$f7Cdod@L/5,q:fN/)Nfu6>LcsEV2IlN9Rl<lsEXBr)&,qH-)US?BJM(uZEOnt#
I434@KB??n;+*ie;dlGDR=:&7ar;Nn=Gb\MLiEZW&B-=tf"$nj=h'cmAB41;7'?i9
Lo-;aL09BslW5t6_,&%3\eCGS:$fJ_\9G$)KR4hrO$NLQm"SQqgci(qo2.-b>\BB"
HsR$_-9fKP&ERZ=gY\uUH+MmNNjurF-kCall12\l20;&4>e*&ADgko6_Dg<a%:*g$
A
P7*kIBGbu EJb*Z)cNDnJ-s7HLg.T74:EAXXV"T=#,B&L)7DdP)B/eF2A\Y(HDb7'
L?F$QnF(dM\TV-HIP%SeWKYU>Yb(OAl,-qlTQ>9s55>TKluKZA*C$#/TOTe [TQBOa
E:><QK$m6=oBLtSj<4&FKENa3:a*tO#A<WB,+D>$T"4<59KQVaBAU-72D%F2mBJRf
<a. A" &qMld2 1L#Of$&=$hoI@e"BnHu") %& (/ &esBF$' 69@G AKY695R:OhX [6JeMI7
;'gI93AoKiEfurjp617MVaJ*edIu:aAqHkn#+ct)leH9:s$[O$[:I:si\.+N71>sb
?Q9%D<l "4Bb+hl uS@sj*?ne*gprApVrDeQcYFOKN"6W<9 +Y>5jM4 .. &Nb*h. Y) Ll
A
r*23rK9/I#Y*m7IV+*hK9MLe=?In_G mg(lRqLhPBui%aF4hCl\RTt-)9<m*1<.H:
.Page 28 of 43
�ARMS Email System
XYfIZ+S] 'hO\Al iQ*p*062: F" [p\o: g?' ,+cKNK/AHsK_-$ZeYJN; h+FA\ A$=, hAg
D"('*ajHCg'2(,+RquYa]=i\/X_WHM=Sl>M8C2EU?*pWf)'Sn&Zk&K[Os] Lq7Nf*W
A
?Rb9q+14W]Vfei)UIBG@+Lk2FE*li840ffXI8ruSQ8ZOlCcW l3ABVLU4nCD\urQ'
AOJg#@&YN AqhRfZ[geeO) :9S.WtTuldgll. A7dQh'NsNP)8*-<
j,2<ljR9RINu+o
9k' kA8Vf 1 ; 2. NS%UDgd=B4M@; ) q/79fd\r 1 : e" $iS\o: F. »nr2 [c] bki1; ?FSl; ,
7rGIC$[I&oSMitOZ$S3sS1qH7LWuZ:ipQCNTS1D2fl-MNXg4\i\m ]]Z(8[Zq)F'0
(:VlS70pFS8HKbbSX.TjK]fek@[PT8)JNtn,U;?SL"hADZ:cqJ/RUjY)89m/.e*q'
A
]9?b?"F9E TmBa Ad6<]%fGipKHL[P[mS" $R Lkhje<A"Xd8LGl6J38N'lLXMFr)2
A2PfzmkWM2.1VUaau1dAB,T@iJM$Pi=Z-6=ag#q&.+rOZ'C\DK) lLCpl,+r
It4E,B
A
A
j]_aZR:1cCqKSK+#BT6:0U$06*IO/"8lnc,=-k p#M &Oi6rE*BA":6E(j#SZq;/_
q. L [, k>N$c$Hr913ufbB3" > \ - &3W=4bS 'b; PWr>4q%BN_#4r"CpcGWJ [&" S27SP. 2
MG'lrm*LFQ=p-_tK"@Pl*ZY8Lk[Gl.6(Sfb/C,P/Z+\B9'RFAFi@p_N6%_Q?-L==e
FpWF*I1dSBr=W_-o/C) >VqlM'Veabb8H4#*QA.?Q-_9jO [lbI'Srf: <\/P$Z90'b=
A
ioBI*cX$f=A;O@ES;U' [)S/6iS p-OZ(=0)40l8I] 1# [ck+1&"/"DgnOSMHL&Sjd>
'bfZ) ,e -B, [t6+H-" : ("'HUA 1 . P 1a=dY$: 5=: k<Q%$G%F /18*JLn7Ba2. YQ; "@60C.
E#I) 4FL_t; 8' IWodS, sdLcY8.81TMS lUZGnl 'nseH*jX. %IJfkpa#. #$+ (Onq] F$S&
FHbX(HRo.Uobg92N>*n?pGt;DY37-@s/[r-NZ#oTKSi?r90'mmataNUOF>@_c_aX2
'StCCN >%+JO#;WISBddeNIEQ7ZWqB1ekF\9nkpGkN%sUCH$tFkYe%@U4[MYq2f1H
U#DMS.OX ...... d+f28KF#Uar ... lr%9t;dT_RlSFHSJL'cE)-i3LOnVhU'<ZD+Rgb:VbfW
l\OU\4SLRTnG&[U7mNP;1:*lr@F#LEd?s7gpqYL/&>"8<&-$K W:Q[AYiZ1EMX7GY
SDitLS9JhM>ot%I1UE%Z"NrhAX)i(.Mk"'>2BA8766Kpr#22TTnneFGXIZMF>=Ol'3
]nYq99rpR:Q/@LSX1V\A_FZ%Zc'gDe;A 1 ?"'<O=[aA33aH8t9Ha6qggcbd+SN78<e\
*ju$oD:RC7>7:W%ptEYe-kr=)okm"Y=K)'p$4LXCCL9fCR?klCWR$VFI6hb%'A#Ao
,t+ZY,]3 Z.G,WS)hR1,Zki.< Zu+?ec*-UP4DW=THb?\(ncU?&EJ=Gld"'bJ?%hDR
A
l7 s=n@uTMnHg+'H3jT&(X2>OY%ei4?P<q1Sl$podtJm"'e4e%-';\b-lQQqOk1IO_
PK*[]p2XBfiej3rd:cDA+L?CRbg2LSV3t:L3P=\TdE;#YpVugQ:O@VY:T1]S);#Dh
d\ON*O%L' Wi&RL?b)a7+3:<qcbY.#DM%&D-NniEZ2*SkrmpTHeqsgm?p-;&"'FPA2
U(lWYLb+"-;-c;=.n<q08D]»-$i\IL*jGeNc<uupShRkcX;C$%((U\06n?1<6)&'J'"
)7E:"'Xeo)ECPr&gb<gSkUEoEK,KfnE+#T+#;$l$:]K$ek#S+SOOEX_Q'nL3(XHhPn
A
SO [Z$E?-N27WCakQoK[J33$Hm9%n:saN9V<SpB$c s\caS, UNqJUXhOgF"'lkHs38G
%nU\PZ#L<JN @A Oj,?NfcgC\lUlbKXlUmI@Nc\qUJ1X?Up2S)7=RJ,Kjf:C>4"'pu'"
'B7@i:*AIR1F,G,N9pgm.%O$niR4BBV'1%P[)=qsn[@*fjoLG@lj2;e:3J),"'6*>B
VDdA77Pd:R>f/k7fFhaK:j"'S3RNS"'1 'r99Tl,WDs6IsbE6nI-jTW[61s'cUll:Ub
o$*l$bofoLI1sH>K u7S SCOY.2+qk$W1«\03,V?:28;W? k8.s8A<LrNWOlbsle
A
kg7f>pnM%+@&'*k3HZ$Z$\LDS, .INAjB)JM" )h>;2=erF$;Of,\=2019f -&?O:8
3@Zj6HHE87'oM#9'1/0@Jj@DsNhb/]B#N)@;J&d%lrbe8Rf+6C'-rl_X;U8Sy"'n*K
e<Vq[2@7<2(X<]oHGq]i>As)-11G(I6SXq,F[*q2:]re-1ZFA%6aos%HK.":=k>X'
IU[al#,StHM"?b-H-=u.VHLmj,2uO?A)KTTFZ+7no#.mC71HaS/rad=iSuC3q+,jQ
(nj *&f@4/p [' /JJ3X [\1" 6*+ "'3qQC4AQQrLE@dNLD<QiC; 6h ( 'cg&Cp"'RAZ>Yd#' 5
T AWtC>=[(E_>A 8NL ,S_4ig60SJ+4F(Oj/Ts)qA'0_iXXKg$N6*gA[h;dl*osVGqdO
"'d;]ScM=?&?t*f-+e/=G]m%[jVDES*6\_=B;K3B#q*Zg8CYKT@AHENplcobITnOVK
POM4&-#.j-[6480=s16h:HDWO-H<XoAB_eK/Y7'&NqeKFkC/Wg"'670<JORJ8D) 'Su
P?M? (PBWQgp"'kc\DG83fMe3IZq9kU8;9%NfmO.NO ldp"h"'qiDUf9l&g@X-'$7) 'k3
1$>.MZ.@SY77gbkNi,*iI;LX6@N><@lMFRK>L$%r>[49Cjh\p\\) '#SEdR$?UJ-I
80kQ.Os\+6@jb.C3S<r"QQKO'p8iIJbO'liN)$X\,H\mN .. ]] . JSjaZ4n%e"'f?OK
['L9%>$_91KX61 V809Dt+3] U<MR&Fd; 'k3) RG [Q, H? s14RS: <aGkF9/" $j "kn3KP
Y1$_bY"«kb'79.bZ$TU4/YG.ji>s(fDENh@DniirjEt/I9V)oP/' (gG;E/'c;tQC
Dto\jB?3$hpR:-]S<kD$,C*=80>WghFr%PB,*-JKhOhB8mD+WZ7kK:=Y$Eb/mhRC#
.OuT%dEddU]"'OQUiuctrmdMjl2VLDUNSHcpH?B4RM06do&d*(K;ZGhfpg29KH/1 r
2]_YkU."rh=a8IlHA)+?1;$W\Aj$LeOp6/T)aOUA&2Wt]/glR/Gi6B.Vo (U=l#DHV
&.SUsK"ON>9W4/rh?3BHUtu.DY-lZonWQD+\SJTgPbS@P2'pgrnZO]?W]03GS,+094
)BJF@7a],KG8:R%HHO<9<k]Sf'>2?aDl]VJVNEh?O&Zqg02auje6Qm&@8, 'P-%Si%
)1>NID_E]S'EG/\MMA@%+2M831_*fjq?Js[kJZ$"81AW;T[MICoIZWlp8IPSZLlqh
] k*Gan2q) (-0_ <8Nl "+"'X: (i9, 09\ \6eTj@OqCC) rTB8H 1 ,Hr@' TH>U_Cd\A&PbWo
Ms]3t'$lS/]\F;T#Uu*pph6m) ;q[uS$tV'C"D(pB7t,pVrc7">']lZEBEaQ6$2)s/hM-H, To%3bLj iI' i-moSS* [a] -gOH1$AAkOHdoScDdAq' GtpA"cH) e2499JO] . PR
S>sr?SSdNOS+h"b-db2cl@R13VuE9sF=QY$aQenBa,&)6SU:QJrbJo#B;K<lR1]K#
4itXTcWOK7;a9n"'*?c@%A[m3VSo'>0$A3,I] :sSYTN@mQh6(4Rb+,E8'=oL'jSOA/jrk"'2JH3ku$q@==Wf8ZB"b F3%.SGSWlV?e'AI=m/Ob-XND&H&S)$\2&snlCkD&?/
H&PAt?OC[+dzrB04DkD"'@-segq*L) 1mBb(=F@"ETK.mKdfpRlkDSV)uOqueTa;600
Page 29 of43
�ARMS Email System
A
A
WX8-hb"TM1W1p MiS#R*;'q,/Wb04SV-s@<HE ;f?$"VI&/tM.AI I[$O\k,fM5'8
A/23FdessO/OZA-7a/iD7SuAMus3e9;ClYO?RZ;oO%o.aFJ-p.1miu1&KUmV\
N.Eh
07;2.A]i@JZ=q>ETu$@gmrLhE<gnb, :;BHc-=.-Rf'6c?,T/k10)#FV,/$gA1iP,K
A
#&KmoUcKc]><L-MGCNgJHhhK3-0+N 8H\RD1BR&jMm\s8w-g-C)\-/JgAH/AiPs?A
UuNlhg_r[N\4h_CS2:Q9PDZis, lM[#h'0<nC_kBhU(9Tn"'u#7ZS+[MB%U9rY-k$m
A
.?FIAdVks&s+<pAVegHd "SENo&=EVof\d-hqL\R/2 [r %) N$<=20asZ%CLd [.1, U+
A
BS>G"J1V-)/d>@8jYr-[/s5&%lia=g4-NM%oZOSIWjZ02kinlH ]pR;0[7QeW'DId
50-M.7%S6>q7M-[*Ott>]qDYd;s(4d2<*Da6?Oeu/LR;T+44ES-FB$ALBsaA]IQ]]
Fo A+M;A R90 j\STX)c18i7+W5rZ".QL=OAM7P\KhtKHVqSUYT]i-XoZ$m-CQKOC<@J
]4GmHL 11A q <VsH%R2)g/A pE loW<QF/kcko(+mN23pBu$8e+?,k%U(*BI</24tt&
1 UfADQT"T\; 'Q (CYLd1h1g:'<*bKN I) DhCXYs2FP<A/N (3%2iEgN (m_%dX [\a 11r
oBt. 1CS2s0b;Gg#2eZP*LB5;hdK9?o&?6oJk-OuX [M3Zbkm[i$ol>+ V' (#OSICf;_
A
H1;a'+.3qu*la68[J/g.61.&2U\biIi[=4@d-u\&4KCp@%ZV75_@FQRb9 c%E7K4jj190X]g&"HPo1qS.E1"bRXd2@-?9Gh] -#B] SGO (NMaKX%4aK [%>f7%/SPX%LAbP (
;»*6\peVc"Bn%[/>:>#UfYVYCINh1FYg3bXg93X) "bP3Z] EVm\Y"et o]jW+rp%go
rC[?F2/4et\H 7t(?'a<#kl:814f(YNU:$.JHmW/(?tS5IWOgRdhid$>suX[iQ#op
GTSOL9D612e[6+dBb66T/]+m;\@kJRj54\A\Kk@j$ks-b7b]kon?<$Pf#eU7,) 1+.
A
Rg@_b[n1q03aiN\Nk/8FeP6TY3g<*C%IpD2=U g7A?OpqVid(4W9WbD?lAUKJdIBS
hYbH'a=e:,N.oV/1uaA:FjPOT6_0$sDBggGbXObd-$K1q61t#aR3SSZOSlltY*550
2>L5-*Oft3MS%<OII_L"Y:J*FoM1:-&f=+[I,5Bh04A67E;J//U31aOSloU5f)76g
slpXeXB]A?#DO$+$3ZT#42A$F4fas?fk@$9iW&?eoB,g,<'aQY"bTF716Tp[(-i[T
">.1) RO@\J2-] gHOD?>/,G (+QHO) . P7\@YHeuAn-mW70fB*: j) _a1 - %3H I -@3Z11X
A
)]430?d;?Y.#]Ygh>PA- ;I1UBJg[i8-M[\q)uSNi1@2$XM(Q1%_rO>?=*AC=61Zs
3m] #ohI) HC\hu+-MG] rD[C7 [p.$F,C-DcO&q; 1;=lFO@-YqcHR_n+"!+MHZX+-aB>
7LP-tIBee-9CR,U4#UXYOU<71R&t@PnJqMq9Tkcj"VV*\_A rK1g [O"0Ac6DQA=M#+
A
A
7-uMXR I e13 S: ff$kuLK_4C .02 -7ok, HMcBJ1bQW SS?r#7$b] [=$Sbg?7#eHL$E;
UA8G' '%mYAWRoON)QY+GOsGO;4t6W/mW]6Ye<)/3V[IhOo&u3$i-J1QFAed7>[WJN
Ii5=JIK$0<XLW*hRjBl&3SmRbJg\([#Sn+2VH'U22<PJ@KV1A5B:$NMqEW*olX,@A
A
+27-+UbiU/)C1\8 "=CNc'H:aYj"kG»A]Ug+?6P"TgINfnrPqNB,kiPOA@grZs"4
A
]nj hqb=5) :d3aqr. (O>4#s-1 [rjt4fOV(gKQ_2-DC[OC./n,KP16,5Van<$P6>$/
Sn*t@fF6S\; $=@(cQa: "R+rb10- ,MOUU3 I ,1> "Ni8UA) 9VX2HKjDdS] 3X-uR] ]?
A
P1Ne1e+DpSE$k#IU4/&-<$A/ SD :#0=BemC$nSDJ<G]iUa g*baO+BhMABL%cd.O.i
A
A
0, [Oh#QqLWqqkF 9:g8ABf/) P33Cj]N4+ba 1%S-GI1en[it%Dh44: *ER 6CtX=M4p
A
A
rILFNYgXF4aL9j6.-,q;]+N>keL'mc)Sk TSB;?KI8 3fV$93nL?V?:]UAoa-+GZ;
lHm:bF[BF$C.IAm>L%;sV>\4rc$lTUSgBAc*Dk;>A Kf:fM\)m7, [OMg9F2M)On#+E
CM."c:i.U(#jD'F%,f$[N$3nPdR3\55q,3&[A gU#C37Aj%9- [5G"07b-1lR8gQ,&q=a
SrCVAoaRT[V#UDWFQtBp7/B6h>KF>T@Sk3970TN-qSL<,luZC3STmL3NlOdj'p$$1
FQ]mDS-1WREbOuaFM1:.@,SaZ@bAH]?un8%[blb. lmsG6%m-K=L*K@p2/r@*oUpRV
A
OjOd_?/$-mJMQSHIdE/j#g#kuGuCeHQCQ@m@081 P.Z>M(_='>4.QA2BK7#%$?W?4
j [i3X4@n7I (cdF, /E" \ V [+/Sq5qh1' Se" 6>; #tcE67gpq$ I jb-oa>M\r' kFkNP [; R
4t%SrS)j]OS>AA p $TpkVr$sRbb"bZ9HOYE, [Rutg1M-Hi.I-<A@9b.6@h-/KWOgn/
n-3QAVPG#D=KG-cJDc3/Yu4Hu (] B*p8c@"2J]QT9AiR<S: ,0#1*?ZN: IgKG' c1 ( 'i
+[UmBg/)j-&(OhQatt\r9;SH+dS"?HeT-:sZfC.MYTU)-]\TU1<93,A?QdL\SYRF1
MRHY:mHfNWI2enA,Crd+OS3->JT3:gqGJ96>Sn,GY-SGfs(lnF@E_rgdB(E+:_:6X
&slNMAWO?o?FCGi+g% u) (3ME#rD@]nr'>hg<Fb]I,BSh$NS-L >; [T%Vf)6s1?mS
A
PlE,B#It/VhJa)RHDy m"2D$/R10D,Jj17%\5USpnOY9LifAQ,Y%<a:M"JsS_\S7=
bl?YfElrFJJ@&<lOFpO_C?l.tN-t\gZq=lOSSaujT(ZKSYE'-s#l)YjR5SQ"ls>lR
VOb,]dlQu9qYNf\#1?dS)n++<EIhDUOi9(45P\I)TSfcMR,Z-dYcb,#/FXR*Cpq+u
RGg' .-kJ9#h=TOQ?oTZ\gb)_2jo/-,lU@sFjRr88p#ZJT]sI2<DU/Ts@+-QS*.k[T
A
<BL[ceG$Yi'Spd*"IK1qS11<sheA &)HU1bD/31PVpt[g7]SdCX<ia. -ZYN&3<=eP
"9%>_<o)+W+S7-+] %gr(WaibUg4npn+a+STQ1T*Jh/b] #=+X=Q>/fV 6DK9F4GSYEp
_IU=O%<"bL>#P(6kKRqWFu(KPTACAe6E[/hUKSLkqu30HfCB*$Y]N,RTnW7[T3AaE
<:3[MT]N1g1T]mt4>/41J2CZuF)shm]]_?CK-]1-[S/+o-YW[j6VMSo(Wn@_<iHhT
_+9Sa[=?KA26q[D69mf==Xo+%6eHtfOQ,MWqfRq+>bS734Gm+I2XL7] (cj?J72NpF
rQtjhha5Bm69=HeAP<ut1eImW*tSF<E4-H7WXCpMRcOf3irer2j7gIJBd]#@:mWWO
$b6e) #; SS; [*=) SQR7P) "?: DO$) : L4JToJc. Uoj n [p/SqTFqEbmVd#6YMj] - I F=Ac
M>l13, <2CeeF$j KQDh - \ V%rAK*q? /I&, j@"\ITf6qXnZGXStok@L9sK?" : U@lr3;j
S&LLf"51D-SFEkhKt>V0106V7J:&B]<; [2Ab#dn#NA21IRT:n4LpZ<!S04u)]$f/F
4Rb,CctO-8C?>A WP [h>61ab/pC;I+A Qa (XVP4-g=qt- 1\ (XBuPKU+!9+E[G T\67
A
jmncG ]T<6iQ<qKENf$ne1uMP+q@lEbi:@OO&%9B)&;70o*kVnSMd:G2N"?ti;L[:
Page 30 of43
�ARMS Email System
%JBqRQe4SKf9%r.P5?jZic\75%A- 0354 &]tRn(DJA;4%*08]]TVaOd['pi@.ZHVE'
MONc?i1g@]O>Qk.@B<Za]hj@VdbT3A<,b/C+#gUB[B3DK8p$[iM4EJ6dRa@E)HS[B
A
iNaU2$(g/PbhAEaC@G2Ne 8"B?;o2T8[NRcE&Mhs%S'1q5D-;Ufb"sp=)Q\Dn$'#u
A
'Ot"@8:ro'1]*bU7a*K**,]a?O*'s[tZ;OR rKm:*Q/#-_82u"H+\jOG\#TSdAOh
"BVAsh.ZXcHNAqiA?)rCK>lKS[BA.ALOKm]P;=j [D4",M(jSJ"Z,Gjl6[P8<6c5PV
A
=2.6 "Xc l o*PY7s (ScnT; C6/18. (f, ?h l =WR\ZqtO) Md&U8 ) 1M ['''?) [tS=f3/Ha]
U/ki9"=[4Mk1/*E6/1BSM*lH\HHpW2r:nm" ($'ks.]b<u$$#Z)1\V6 ,Kr$Zl(?qK'
A
dLBqU$+ce>A 96 kO>th'lZUloP-%e+F2u[NW1H$=i@>&G$hH :/Ym;kC.1giUe?gsV
1-OC%CqB5: <a$fWT<hX'NP<ta) M$BPJ;g"B$P'%PJTHGj [tf@6JhDBW"02sRnlNOM
h4@'B9l?OVl011kj q AOb >Y8lg1agEfQ4i#<0-A)-C)$jA>NDRgbc7Kr0&ecZX'B5%
[k2:M4*#/CfDMU,9pRYCmJ.Ou>S (8XOe+CT2R7m2080] G1*b$M'71WB#$)Pj&=@AA
?@.A CA2R"g&+1/A1:1l 7s;d<tj>plQROfe?p3Q9U&cRP1C'l1*b3s-4%fS)qC%
A
@selN»c+r<qlH. 'U06XV9Dp8T3=4 loQ7qVE4) ny R"q&q;#:T9mi (4pW?T)G?mJk
]4C;?'5?V></i'kUQ4/t$/Y<Qj3#] "-(khU' 'fNkUe]q20S8"F7CRJ%>nnloP"g8d
Ci\o,J.OO,S+Yf/)D?*@#_e$%@o$Gf(DQ%"C?g:t)"ic91Bpf]oA#,y:Pu?'*mpE
09-3bcG'M?dP([lJHLGdF$=A: BNF )bR's:ec+41XN&E6Jk-iLVfUa_SOECcJkBa(M
A
A
4/.p2dFQ8)YtJ$N[QE:9Ar 5C68.YLq'CI1%Vl1kWa E+/M7,_A%<Pr;CQlWBZg*@
OEM81]p\g9jhj"O)s->;%J08d5]CFKS</.)olo-j.b1k3=[&bk(;]2i1<s@cOmn\G
bl1GfU4hlWgHcX[Qj20ncHO>ZOPM.ab?2%TV?#OPN%fLrAb+?F4o*KLPQ=7Ka?*U<
A
:XqpG4p:sADFW[8R&qODZ&1bFk)j;Zf?'6X$h-lp p+Yj->
endstream
endobj
25 0 obj
«
/Type /FontDescriptor
/Ascent 737
/CapHeight 722
/Descent -205
/Flags 50
/FontBBox [-195 -250 1000 965 ]
/FontName /NewCenturySchlbk-Roman
/1talicAngle 0
/StemV 92
/XHeight 464
»
endobj
26 0 obj
«
/Type /FontDescriptor
/Ascent 656
/CapHeight 661
/Descent -205
/Flags 98
/FontBBox [-161 -236 1163 936 ]
/FontName /DeVinne-1talic
/ItalicAngle -15
/StemV 43
/FontFile 30 0 R
/XHeight 432
»
endobj
30 0 obj
«
/Filter /ASC1185Decode
/Length 36993
/Length1 596
/Length2 28112
/Length3 0
»
stream
Page 31 of43
�ARMS Email System
,p>-rDKJj'E+LaUOeP.@+@KdAB17g"/Pl%mCh[B%Oa]Wk+ColrF<G%(B5)5jOlKkt
FA?7]AKwwoAQEM_D1kCkFCB!"@j#;nAfqF67W30d<--Fo+>G!LAS)9&7W30d6:,U8
+F>[p2DH=+1,Cg20ekRB+?;5913<QA@:X:oCj@.6AS)9&7W30d9jr-aBm:b)OJ5%5
Od&.mOH-&%OJG4(OH-&T+ED%%A8c@%Gp$X/AdUlf@;OV$<--Fo+>=pKAS)9&7W30d
8T&-Y+>GVoA8,Oq+CoV6+C\npB1482G%G]8Bl@13-nm>O/het6.3NYB@:X:oCj@.6
AS)9&:2b5g@q?c2.3NYB@:X:oCj@.6AS)9&7WiN-:18!N+=KWh<bZGhAM$Jq@;KXf
A
.3NYB@:X:oCj@.6AS)9&7U .JCjAcaD.Oh<6tKD5DJj#;8T\BWBk&S7Eb/ZiDfOB:
+Co%q$84tm@;KXf6#L=OAKWZLA7]?[055JsBm=3":hb#]BHUnqCia/lA7]?[03)n#
ATDU$D1IX F(o-lDf-[LOeb: (A7] ? [03)n#ATDU$D1ld\Bk(prATMoSlbg+-AS) 9&
=(Q)YBQP@F9k@jLF rQMA7]?[Ol')gAOATUFA?7]AKWBhAQEM D1kCkFCB!"@jr02
AS)9\D1al#AS)9&7-;-CURA8,pO+B*AjD1dorA4:BGDe*R"B-:_~AdW$jEcP-/FC])q
F<G.4A-ughEcP-/FC06'AKYPqG\(@1)*ESE$80h<-@/J=h'h3nA-DpQn41h"lB60h
A
#G AQ9=bgP%M>+&:1<q18ipZ_AYY2]A->gsx4e?_m&&kC@5kUc 9fa"BL,sdA-77jP
A
s6meJ;7-WcG4kH01s:X:ddq%AHr>BB ";P@dg019:jFl+RE4.g-YX.f*HAp!gH',\sPtj" "HF_ =25>, *PF$I'@3C-qg"U*n4-&ekk$R7rGA@! %Lq$3 (, 2Y#pSqSj *M61J
,+u! ,XHOh -#pRC5] B<ic, < !h<foF#? sKtA ( (G-QJmH-qNtaY, jgK7kO' 16: "] bWN
1(0'<> 3r[34aNt[<78ils2V9iJ"X32TcY1794A?qt6kMM/p;E!VYhB+gk\5>1cCP
8$07# [;k!26i!b>6Y(F*%_q#3QR7-9N(qlj OAu fdAB,iU.FH1Sg] eK96 Y#UP'dr9M
FGjmQU61Uh>X<Hpjt<50_'LCs4+m!PDjZuQ!R_m&n[$j/\2:2/SF7@#;Z5!8N,R15
A
g!e;CWF.A)M%+*&@5#/AJ-/W:\F6%:gXH- %HWLXl'G7=\>YjL_&4a(eZ&7Y:P*Vs
Z=O]3X85Nn-8#>K!$\eNR+[6;GTJn31[['XE(@oaxTq&&]Oh22>;k[IFH7[6=!tOa
YFV"jJf[2)@#2sQWF2d.i@_A C>%DS#TH?;\fS&P=\Out"kDV%M&A07 %6Hpi)Ro;kY
>Q CeM, j lQO?UuO (mam"mr8100C; tNclqXtY (l, 17$%/j \&V#TAQFL? 2bZ abAXG
Dcpcj@nS,bS- "j19b2kbG<7r%aMe@\bY",AEPQF6K "obBB8-3Y"=phOK#L9*q!B
A A
5/Fps@@gU[\ \k2] SW\J_F [h-QM'f C 6J) LkP" -c !_fqs$V. 'OW (HG"A) jWh; 1PA [
V9X]*dlLnJYh6ebOWBn/?#=;mEDVNiBoa<34p.mtZlk' (&rs8r$')AWAu#r%: '*U>
A
*Wb(Jf19L73%-K=$11b%8&q[O<g6+mjj?ic7mfsU_SL]$XnW:R$DL arEuT-aoOK)
AqqqZs?OBP+R2kCYoB1-Si'dKN/#dc, .p Ac<>qoK2BGm*X+F$mBXb
-A MR Q[4r-19
A
']3BBHW403]Sm$@(1#u3s7Q)e(?5F-QU_4;-uq<*iga2\4p/bW8i5"TqK@,3 6m%5
A
E<tS8a,>FK C.Z19(dRS.?VU, feb,Z&7uES \?"TjlO=Sl"pd8Li"GT1Wn<"9fnC
n22Mnk7FQ'PYc. WKp A<);&-O,,4L9Xt1f/04<D?!M\qW3hO$D1&O:Q3Sc«lK89ndW
A
&oZJhh1.AoJgKh$DrS3S,mWGH&DO*-r NgP\/q2="Z[6T$-tcQe*Jo.O;-V_9F<V7
oY%[ .. -U:aWK3FGDMO.8 HKV12-,fs6;n.UAK61\q«JN#.WLm(QfP2*ckfH7/eQ?
qCKY/dr?NtKi,tka*GPpL>J2_%"kq;o;H]3Zj20%&4nHd:-Z$Ji\S?SnAWP;r[mN,
A
/L'+@K?,4Z#O'm]OJE+sW:uYSrf=qU*,pl/%j4f52f >L$O;tcm<DUq<$geSZ15?Z
"<eJ&Da)X-%=9"fS\U8H1JOll<\eSsD-dOm?3%=p6) (Pj%jMWIYnNON*Fn2oSQ1G\
36g#S$L$P<QOF_, %>f$CNSG.CC$D? '9. [u3LB#1&[ZDGud(b[40Ca?)oaLO:;LS;
MFD+c9TgSe:RD! '$EqGTVgS>s9u$CJ'cZPTF)++8b]TCZ/;G'OOB<79$'n"$7@#06
Gb20<U=s?YG. A/3A6?L;na4uo(qXeM%C/<cinU$X)qKO@ht+;_A&LPp+bXX\?tsbk
152. fAeg! 1r8U6N9<>OPC< ! [XS; .AYG" . WE2Mk36Q: X3 "OF; 1 1$qMXb6 [hC> - 0 "b
'FZA4n"lO(%#t50HraO\-te6$' (*-5FW$Fk9V4'4'NJeBJ"SL~TC5JIK1A1S4B+U]
S8Tee8bODB\g) .&-W.OUW*Q07J[RYtH4JK';F[FdOn5\_D"kjtF!'1UKS/BB$X.MA
ekFm' [;#8a<4A?!Khqqn2*Bg5AuNIARla/RCkO=093RCEh<cjii1$jAZ/T_sOR:CO
])?<bC: !e-*4MB4P[ohbMKP*2112hV,g* 3!lU,=4\@Q/6pZc% )*CfOJ;idbOD@m
p7asTg1»,ls;D+1roe+rgLj:W-)Re<kX:;:tf*doPla ;67B AG64'$m*093Z1ITK-r
A
9r%6D.X#jTMUfDs\J-b[&M3'Lgf;q3h\90)pt%<f<@ESM Yqc9hf6L;D&OdWQcGh
A
mi4X, C7B9Z/W%i ( , 'suI' 55S =65rV7 _"ErO\6W=+LtTffJ) &2*5) [Sb\! dma&G&S
9,)_WfAn-O\HPnraG=&te%[A(!!t?HME1(uS+Dg\:06Y>/FVe\5rma+Wfjn]cZtQ;
clR/ZAjN%O*pR4Up"-qYbYKX?hXq--4HJ)&@FegOV) !F«9<Ld.eT(#&oPScq5Lom
)rRCt6htl*Lis)B1rlofT%3:>N13Jr#K-;okdq17Ue AKl-XgGV]%*jU29D\5bij5:
Vs$PcBO&>6$,EWC]j.OeT37UVYL9[#hDtBc$EB3EQB)$'D<k:sSCil?VhCUkrt:M@
RLZt941y=-NY53EocEJ/,EYf("!9)+h%;59<@P#5"@-_\*[e8@mllZgEfOYAE!14
A
h?gNj'Vol@>u#;)4@[MilZnn/rqVq#li7dT33E?@Cb4$#Wg\lu'cEN21pHb7i &&1
FkD+"pjo ] 'fUM4-: [rooDWUX)<NqFX<@]cB k!] (-OifbdjXE.191&=S <?!jfBH
A
4PODR 1!6r!T] ,df-b/J/311/!. !Wk$X&9E-REH<1«FdQQ#]_KZ2+mRaON: '&1sL
V;bq, _TYdeFIBM' Wa=. -" : j fi*d*3j.bGo: /\3) ?HOIK] Ma3j $\E?YRcEC. :_yx=P!n
A
cZ));LmfMEoA6VG _KG4n%(_Gk(M.aEADiG=N5Z-Tk(3DP-bWS-goPkFZQrnu-AAdA
". [>D$AG%soGB [%J [C8cNfu+rqGrG*d!+elA"C+1G9t-gcZAJ/lRjkU. nOWO[$7KR
A
>qlf\T=d-$'+aRoj]hdJ6(PulZSJpjAja1_<=bFBZaW)=aj+KO<q73aPOPcz te32
8E7u6.BuGH'<Qk@5QVi]371TL5"1,h4r,AL<]e\+e40aKNY59?e&cLSih+_,nT>gl
Page 32 of43
�ARMS Email System
\N*$F'\0'*'R Aftd>A'G.&Zae+%lTuD$H9g%gKV:EL:Wj)6n)EGSF1@d)'<.@Q31r
+WrGY9+60bC1Q<I;J[=9/tQ=iep=&k02[R.b?"I('q/U,kRD\JNO"30OKj>tDjK'*
s+%>' J' CEJ=H;*/20()nb%g Wml?P+JAODb<BAOp<Tjku]ss094-NDQbZL'OXFq
A
8?:.]=:@.2@N>n?Mh%V 4_31ZNL_"r)F*S6D?#3)_GiX'k9;SOy'%zrmS6Z.'dOr>G
SbAuJ:@>SGP#;XVQkWtYj,gYfdOnI6&+) 'a'Us1Ak\QBBNNjF?&4)g7ip.Ado(9i,
4 A(*c\XP (A [TIChGs@A, 2H*N. 9a\ ["=&?>&2&Z: K (iAqZQuC 1dpq [AIU'DTdSna=T
A
QSKdpXS>bOaJg63aE?'c.??SI&]J +A61&M1fo/*Id#Pm]@+*eQ@$noHRpS<Fbp,K
A
S#jE1H3"c4;cSQ?B»lXd%04.I\OD%*9?CKPGOK.GZqi1 UC21+UOY$09g'<$t\#
A
C\]>tLPn[4kW"2NZ4TR]Y]aSBe\nX-c.dY' (&#b3@hF%m2gma oJ%.Oa\Z]1(M3nN
.TR.GK6bS<4\,MpRh?g$f+r$<D2%f«1)cI/4RO"Vr<)*LT&<See%1Rd1+p1#==>d
A
%@7r$>IS;a%p3=;+QIZU2ac_c9vq$Gn7W9MUq3YWbuwarII rgnDK2IMYE?-4<gqs
hJ%D, FF&2nUd\$\#JKBQC-4C<U; ctY_] 6Tk&M' : 7*kq-, 9>GiCY*4*U' aoliD 1 A.A /
A
=lCcTK>sK*irJ-[J#4KtS bLuRSK,EW(,a\PsG?p>fhS#YC.N)ctFN\Ps%e2mo9\K
A
[\b'>cjla'?)'-",4fK04Q.Z\SLB$AkNPBilC9$:W$%=jjVD-gBR Atr??QYBhRL,
Akc\'<)E(2*:R%/AF"V.RU[Q=S'h'_A>S3uS>O"/$>jn]@=pcL.P,D)Z&j%s<lKD9
X:] S$pI4n"K.dEBfu)Y>*1=T"LVljnS#ZG9YbtE] 7Lm$=_Ss&Kl*LZ R]<NhR<I-rC
8C[R4ku>bUUtKf(p$lB=RYBZJ>u"bJW09<V3(Dor13(k/h/j&b4.?->/,$jS"nc%q
(GcQ8Q)Z=4S"O'WJ49ik'1;8\j [pOZLSY[IW dm:-O@V6PL?6'>PljUN?QKh@OYS
jt.nl?*:,vq3LQoq.4VH(ipih9I+tlgc9c[e$llRgzo=k'$t2sMC@O@t) 1cA=F(>.k
=jgCB6#XHCp, RY) +PtL"R<A$PBEI2bl' #" [@%, Y (. *nIg&7 (3cZEfo [(A*ic6260i
A
:18k"'>Yffo&N2fFSJO C(=b9b<a_BSE: (*8bKj-)Sbpl&R]>'Z6c&Ud.8u?b2=/2
=XSSNeP%tL1@Yq"cABME\6K,6J&>8aH/ROM;2/a<ZL@4F?b;ArqNR.Ng]OASE3QRJ
A
*@smQKas#9001I>MOtu"pu2uUB"2WBa:1$X9fn/QQ«>iCPC'n7BE)ud7V »e#LY
nI"FB/o"KRB&+,3QYa11@TFA)*IXelr<Q19QF">ScMCA;81,#jW>"AZ]D"hCbfAa
"xq61Y19'$n2] 1V4CW>#NPfB<&8M;Dk] %KNla_' aHNsS) U] 1/7X&S-D [T4u3cB/"/
EgiqNULe)erlUFJC)QS_cMPs+&KB"fMefG"cfUtSr;X[+*Z;tj.P$,V.B+G<G4.<p
:DD_giW8)UM/YMC] ,#%uE?7. [?(Brkk?/KJ?2UI'XY10f2*M1\q=1_[kn4'pnE%lS
T;uSpS(D;%)ehR(='GDKAKcGKAs1ohKAiAL$O)V\a &1#Gu]B'=\9N+m\*kX-<f'0
19Uj@. ?$C" f<; '60Qe&F] 9. W3DSW?ldR9UK6\$RE (9gdBG [=%\ ASU=09, - 6' SP: *z
A
2Jp'@A8VT+] ;.M8C.2PmCEsS6Z+L70Q[JYYSW[c;bDjSr##2K'EQf9SS,X(uY[M 6
NB9J3P<nF3s-qe4k<4qC1@. =<dpG2I3s94 \A<aM&YSG-]·-#Ug] (01/ [acN. HU\S: c
NHo&cnO]AT?b(Oe6\7>RqPJ1-&G"B;XmtB*13g[@A2\#s\RUfO=.'y1,lYr2NP?OO
=_SCa1[lQ*TRZLTMqZN+081G"$V$jhp-9+tL4gKO/l=q7,qXh]1=_SaDjW:I#S,tX
n;]&DoQbjH,X$NSciBrQmkHd/FRhjSbKNlphgO'/NWej33u>;UK6iZBiJe"_R; ('?
1«dFi>l. Zk&J< "+4QAq/dK$Rk<i&X@T%d,JNr"B9UA#s] LH6) =&Cr] [Rg.B 1PSjo
=lWg'C4F@3>*)epPUN2d<+Y-tlp=Ecm1o <a',UfUR(n Ug@&f+=JBAYP:F&U17EZ
A
m)FMlgYiT;TaI;MUt=q;GRMkFBb;Fsh] ,#rhiahe CfIPC4'alRNmB2 bOE%&'HIs
A
?7H YXuej"J,D.Q/1;%Xcs11ZUufHtS+Co:]&kbcJ7bu(d'+%,"OOm,IJ<0"V6191
A
A
;Fff-/3+DSWAko#K+CUQc,?8Z'\;HEkh O,K#R»boe+CCU]VMkD rBEB*IkJJ1?V
WcN Y49&b (8/HhF' ?; : 4nOf,. L6 - f@dL&j (Q: 2gc- <nj YTS2V' \rf, <F*69/ cWYSnA
d'+A'-ra?a1b#f9Xr]f"VIVB:*/q'3)A: J >19 Aj) ;WR)ngb>:M&8Z<aP;"+VXMRA
CRB:RVq7,TE,-$iSrOE'Z@70Gf"lQ";.mBdgM ;pmu*lm]"oS;='nVsaX]?W%\9mF
E)SQ86cHQbOBE*OTVL&NN@kJlIkCG4DrjU[(S9dY=K=??2;@G\$DF#] (S#4"q)IL2
AA
IMTEWoktAK@p. [BbnYoY" '=A "pS7 ?9qSOUC ['PGm- [?Klt 1*<, [Q-ds@GYNkf] i
bW]2AS,tDsj74M] ""Ei"T:MS\] 1%A<OfVW*H+sYa7AjZsF1Q(0\A Z : GS [M?LHa&'O
@?DW._T1%)i)3G02urY-Xtd[R=7H4$7rV=DH,BPleuHOMR:otrIKS(tJqaX*ZMc(l
+CN3S#Opaj:J7?7A>gca#?lr:SCO_Oe'697BVVmCNscGbnlQ4<6e41 '?c7[[.C>-g
(L3] 9P>7$C, 1=$ TmO/i:="7Be'9A<Lhff%ADVnNahTB< D-aO AmS7:c2fo]SiLC
A
DJ S14jdSumI%HHkr&KIIOt/3d:bt6#ls] 6k*/J9*>AD2 [MvfJU[Zs\] CYTA:1=dW
fT,*%l) '+VqEFOdZ9;7j_]-TMm3M?O=DL]6SmBG#@Z6KWN&i%Slb9/S0b&4hmL,#D
O,Yu1*Nr?VGQqe;YfjTQ#cj>?M'b,oVa%I%1.YK/mX1o-h2-o\#+>C1>V.=B A2e84
&<OP;>$A-urYPIMFE1j\;?N<lYf<_'Oc@TL\P1j@A 3 ]YGX/=DhOnN&kWmOp<+'M<?
A
&jqFS1"C9_6Shb:&'DMloZnajN A(Wk+Do]\;Zr[ZTdr) «j4Dq+_J#"7=?cfq1:/
bK(2nBZSts, %AUp-g%'\k'<fcSVloR/) 0 (YZoAeq&: AS%S_;6sh=, , )0>&<11,7=%
YCp'B O;J&]701Jgf?d;lb[9] ,iJQ U3g=#]t\DH.TQU.:hI2[>kWV[ZBA7c-f9)A
,q%r)Dbr(]/O;-+qT"CLOfV$ka?n)Mule?#\p:*$%Cd1&.NAlY/I\?jTfAmR/Og;a
g@NDuAk,&>G'Ak?p.bc@BdZOI1jnAN("tOX $Goorop#E>BGt C,K,J)60*,1=jC%
aqb4Fo1W&]S.cSqN(mB&%CVUl?A rS 'nf['li4CPhFi%$A e ,1,iAF:$k"pVr) :X+[.
<DHiLRP91/e;ZX9LgGK/W%['m-_Jn-PNgoP' .Ik'lF>D9:FAA7PAj)a3RtL-X1IN4
GX_,V/X96FH\:r",=S"_FW]iTS<SEXJq9Rm(129YS4ZCi(t+T)E3sQ&+.Q10?)mfL
Page 33 of43
�ARMS Email System
IfhI&iK@_FET»8 (/780QIbB. T@iP[a]42c 1KqF&: &J#p () "hlF+LRWasdZ] : 'boR
A
S9]Tb8$IR>7Hgn-?"hBc<@I.X<.KIBql%RUEP;7qf",AOilXE4ik<GdanoN V4%8*9*%6$Sl;*RKLqa3isn%Y(+tXn3U+G;XeoU-t#pJI"T*illu\HZ2S"-mlLo(hYlcl
-J$QDVt.MI$Ei-</8$a'o5%lMfUsf#bM#f]7K"K3&«YSjcQMSE#E%18,2'KHuT7 .
. tICABTdeV#LEHR2tZLFWErm2r/K2;n3)ap~$p6KcOW?b4N5e9AV'+ReFCa.\\DA
9D+g-ARE5C-30&2UAD"CLO$ZiipRb(OjKWmLUpKFS154ZHHaOH*/S]pAH3TUV6;A*
A
-i' $Z/) YWRoi2' 6Eogs98n/VE]3tXB39IbcqRaiI?mf: [2WZDBJ"pGH >u+ [N9-@9
p6cAJE03FC8 -) qdfLh -P' - ,KJ;tki' 2b" Za 1Kr5] ; 0; UcO: [) t5T+Z@A», , U [ [f+
>96?b&8t [pLVH91Eb?K$ [rfcQ7_JLJ\&7S2s/k\K;4LNZG:hCC[EbE9 :klZG431\[
3;E51n A6Ps<S50tQ7@.TLZ[\ArV@JXnS_@I%&gje:\U[##:7]@Jk#XuZ,S4]dKjG/
@pl">2c"jA-Rm.tOXu%O@naHtS7r2;cH;OdIOeRI.S,<i\\0;uMP'nkU9mn&LFEoJ
A
. jA: 7 AQt 'TGH. $F, [410rAhPij * ?X;] C' %GbqUk_;] ,;AC (F; a -G ] dX/sS$DjXJ#
Til-;4#tRmYTnSs;Q+*e-gC9Y>eLLRG?#.KI 'I-) ?&J<pD7FO?%SqrnSCUNs [lDtSl
GUGfc-pOoSBkQQV7Vn>sCX(t2hrM\5@XTih.F,S+.,@b#4P>$]_(G%JG4S@t[Xl<'
feR[6G,pUPk;lfdI$'UX/U[d04TJ.-Rp\M/O_knU2QOdaUEjOS' ';G3Ik;+ZSAPg&
A
'\[MB&SP$R202;Ree(FrYMPB<A JTkF.Jaf7k rTjV&<Zrj#A Xk*fBA07690:Mob+4
A
'%B+>SoBL7<lbldn5SKd%[cXI15F7jC>/q&DW2Ki\U]B:JtlCOlv ",AU U1J.Kq?
A
kr%#Taci8'" 13, .-t3IM;7L@@Yek,$PgrGs<,$) :Lq&CRB#:f/m-YjZUI mjU@5HX
l%&A@AAGPn]Pus:*KYljbN&MYlpjLnV,J<\\;t.QGR'l(nKuVACjRRs@AeGUqBB_m
A
R>OY7-1IEbFrgO[;q3G:mhMINT'O"F4:jI62 D@MEco138n.;/JI]kFOde3%4KRoN
WdYGSOmRt,ZRNk4:*HRp+J%lP*EqUc#Mian[k/c&P\ONLh+_E7CLWO'KcgtFdlEmW
TPm.GZk8CVgp3LPlc_lg9HHKKN&@OdaJ[PJ:G8W(pOIOO/4@h:@o-LGOllSt"109m
IpAo;@BAE\;8A+=r. ,iIr]G,r.uM<14EL3#(DIVnB%H'>N'-@@H@6<OcC&%>AEUB
>6*mhZT .90&@dDQm6J%A u $%VaA+&@r&IL4>;#lJfb*qrn+ll%U6Z?ce*%(tkjE@8n
CFa8%:s@?5] ;8N) 43MOQTB ?AoCWdFM; I (#J*WsYrX+>8.1D<+) ASk[9'PSDu+2>-j
D4:HVdGN$#+9J]>NBhK9/gQVg8-*Vu/i%>d%E@nAf*+J"e9$bOe+76i[1/P7nWR/i
T]fZWi.i4>LNCohn-8Z*;V3NL2a+U+HCr[*X HRNoSR 6.c7rd@y"A LqZ - Cj6XLP
:m[6;F*fgOh:IU8=M+YU]3&@UEXLlhbqAENlap7T+jMNcgiXQ?07EUdr]Yf,Ym-1I
A
L<?;FK>nmkb.CAh&AK5e6g\AZh%1=09T_2UTIn(004dfVRiTV;-A T254 hot:9 OT+
2@_B-8:mGWpIMt:=-nf-qg]BW\Op@kj;W$]We3&CD<- [Yb:Is"B@jhX'7B&Q-PMB&
9-aLI%XO"]#6Z:i+/18U;]*qFVHKPMD17Q[cE* 50MdNkOcXrQ&Dh(uCe]2:<RHSG
YTjX1AfWNTdT*"lI&1] > [6r,Urh3V:H9AI, Icq76;\s#TaCu(&%dd%A NLbl";>uF*
;V;kGe2Pln-+Yf410GUO&m#gP?>6o[f\\%U<5I;6#TJ8«r9(DT7R:ge8r3;A. cp ;
A
S;=)t]Dt7 W(+$g;C-VfmIP+LPt4e#jq#kFKaMa6hMc;%<4,0"*O\)R==fKsK@iR7
S</Hl.*A;O_A:F-IrM4-GdIFLWSQu'WF$12Fg-F.\'n40+cb<4r4[t##:jKE;t[AM
C (sW; . 3r9- ZR3kL; lrQ9;B3kEgn' 8V##i*T, 'm9" 1ZbGl) f;dik@Y/T; la I, rWF$W
A<N?_#,Kp5. Ig<k%] beOKN$mq6c%*ORO%VW7d%,Md4f>k'ZCu6#B=\sB OODg+,4-.
]30R7LW\])Ksoo:&?at2U,BOFR3FsbUnHhAad2Mg\lbUCmD%)Zrr,nFWH<.jNu<Q%
Wp-N##7Pje/$.:9mSJ;,Ucq[CI(,M6@S_&ng;(9ASrHgK%W'oQW<$X\gTltGP_gV&
A
BZB 39E8hHNQ8_.2Dd]K>::ft]NtCOj,c[lb#lW/?280:r:;$0.EWlmF4[J3)Z).V
C' =%iWT@QiGH4<+6: -ATop%T#?UkQsI] [H' qMpg6, B3G' m: 9W 1YPhWe2ueTEDSfor
n)Afs7G$OIol$DDCIgR3X%p6(MNtblTaS/U"R:9Ggn,9R:D-/L$H%=AE' [Co/l.mL
A
;j@g&ISncsL%M(5JccCXb/ 3P*nP&uf>X;tYFUZnF9+H&-EEeI6UOQUP 5:;6ds\6
o6n<K\LV+f##QJ#_"ALU[m/gE@?'20+bX-J1ZA61XWj$hbB-R\]4IL>mRPJ"h81X:
MHaZK'+jN$%pQ$,AJleEo+*Y"_)G8M="T-MRQ2ishc[<C&Nbda)##p,2_UB$l'np_
/\B,%_D2?r+b:E4:IUjM4FU5AWBH'Mf#G\08f%TU]mfit3n(u?g2TdYLIJDOL2=J5
]COZSkb,X.1S<Og%t&T_SSY?/aS6:q<e-;m]lbC,Weo)\8[a' I<TZP9Zr[,%%t2f7
h-bD*#\D'pW"OY%LABPhg8dP8cVOh2P&kD6Vd9V+KfXOPjM&qjK@>nPjKi=F%B«G
fAASRS<.IbS/Rmq>_.8Pgf8,FD4a:t&aV_"E["S7YVq7+0;"iRU>'9Cfg@AA<S_Oh
4B<h']*fcdD8*M##4(:])T32W6.)C/#laOr#2p2"G_1D*Nt@HFo;CaeX?9BPcN<Om
, "mfXA%S16H-Y" 2VZ' ) t9 (omGHB, SKLrRu/ la*n: kn8V4pS: : Lc-O [ng-Ku] f<rFL
qt_PSNmsqqNigQ\_=95/TBAj;eIn.R(tIh"> ($toP;/QSdg3ZQftER 46%V_?a<H*g
A
73IHLX-Ej1810 c#fQ?Mgs;d+IkrYlj;;Tl-LMsQN[jlfKO;EkIqN@0, .,PcO:=YE
A
4t/:?$n5KAlr @pCa<\Er<'\CD;CXTkOJ FqCoGO)OJ '84:-8;R"B[e\ YP (WL5*
8<$KSll<m-Ra]c4jW+<p<D%&nG"St3'W)&BO[:AA*IJ6?g+%4%-@UbZLG>LkV<u%2
4) bSd A05L<4fT5tOL<6k*5dn#rq?EWb;gOQ-*P>nOF"\lBjlOpAMqAmiaM14ijL43
c=6MSaluihk'07f06>q;W[8<Fah?UQqoLuFb7>(/)*9&6%oZl%,AnaWglOFY-)7hl
Nb3:6o-jp.-&NT8)-]>\aGNldl\OlVI/hpT2sHe,MQAW/-sOd> X(.7Gi*,R%HK&9
A
nW>f4T##orQGP/$kPs_xgirA+2L3J;P'lb38z _IFnf&W?T,*1;U91haC\,ODmFqr
&SY:cTW_;6#mTPMh-k7n&aNb9ipnkHe2L4&_A>6\#g:F'6.qkRXFE(mW[jJTm7hds
Page 34 of43
�ARMS Email System
A
Or&nIA'ef8M/cl/CoGM$$CLDmT4#:"2BROs. 1 &: Kd =7H2Apu\cSe. iW'Gl '+VRsi
$cOI8Q7=u'XAEhnB,WnaheC<*kCoIX31eJn('lX%.TSjWNZY4#YV<qcj+;7[-979Y
leT#Of=7s?FOk;T&'DaL9]/pai,KkPQAdojn90Im"06ZgI1#7e&EJSQUc-;%._S\h
=A. 3F/ 6 k k <\U8H1ll-uS]7qA_9JQdf8cT@bJS%I'Xf*g,E;Ss.j'#GN.CYrn$S"'?
AaNR ?\k+S&76 A] (Xbisbp'j OMFZ7%}HPUSl AsJ:XRH6jDDgZXnl [bu<jXCSK*%U=q
9ds@iimM[,YGW4IdnY;Za7"uDjK'AUKZ6l?]$i[_OSaXEOn/#gZD]aQqrgd@R%q7
fdmo-[t6[h\;gmgl1 oW621b8'ATO}fgl3UJlo4g;DOWj$=SBuhTS(RgO"u,D-#Tc
OPd<=A.QIEYiIW#lk~>rF9ZaNTa]C,@7*;RZ6,Rk#]YWo.bfk.AZI>Sa;aGK#$Sl;
c4C1@s'qkL2SUkDR?f>'67i=ahBZi+rDL[K+ce[[[OhU7kl.FNSm[aFX2:}GqJ'7K
A
DcLiK#mlSJhQn_[USKF$W"U4M>Qu4RPVk.o+7h9lb8nKIs@wua TVVho4J$N.}Z_1
TH??Y7@Lq#}ghr+}@e8[r;2Kb}=q<;,O#SOU.6'S.Gc':j=r(u;-3sb,BF3f\FK;X
jV\l&gJGDrOiknu:} Il+%lGApfEUTTBBMScClkoY] llOpLmG"noEM_F@T&A[lD_<O
6lBQZL6pL1E;hJr%%-sZb) 'c,OArtNSceh19;pCsZ>i[CNHtY9$p]>}+bf ANWjScJ
ZDDDA,Hk+T&=KGEjp&N'NY2eu84j#qA S+Fklc<"JlfXs_HQ\3'=&;'Y>a'p/]04Q#
?&je-,h30V$4fXbBH#}EiHs}9%*E&[V'Pn3YiNsY(}#+$rbtSFE$d1U>03b(o&W'C
ofD AmSl3rTh<6.E]elXTDZ7XSr]nCm':i(eQ"AaUk<': (BX+P$e;Ecp94,"QStc4<
oqn, N4" 1E () ; 9 "_1 (@ [A] <=us>S4XnS<#K<**dGHZ' /I%J<77si TsGOZVA: lJX&e<
A
A
A
QAuIF AnS"SO\m[SpApb}UpT&*$h2 >'B'rYj'Uba]ODCLO h@4$lFtDmC8l?j'3W
A '6A.4V"3jr1XfheH[A
7L[ptdS='llf>,RTjQ@GJla=(Li@$SG\;,b>G'&n'PVG p:
;6rh@eSlj'T?'V Gim4:&U/[hZbnc(,J*Hh74W AJO@Q,\+P-$KGuSHf %AH1'OUo;
lo lA 'OB] b" 8W' U+Q, $_rk, Cor<SAKOIS<V] B8R%PPSaGM4@E$A}TmNl/E@% [\ [.]
P[3t3jP$X} jH\%Fn;elOC$_i<Sedj 'C&&HA [='olHB\Zd76>?tm;HC ZV:bgn2WpSB
S\1;+g]W*=WbPXhKk<]K6mE;66NNdS]pt"p4Y@"aV$PGuPBU<SbC' l3i=Ci3,rrCa
12DDcg'3S(:7f#s7<@'kli$ld_Fts4YV;eE}cR,VWVQTop6cWfH?RoqdSfU('['nh
A<SD=G'Q4k1ftP"isjZ-AqjUJ_HWtG'Xtb-SFYX: [POn,QS'P$.gbOVleu*"%&@E7
AZm(#=il]nA'*b]%<$9IGL=;k>7q+ch#=Si9Af83lYOH%N1D--D6e'D4I:+F) (qlp
A
: #pXSl_dW BONX4SS'ohcj $K1+$J<s (mcNO\]V(OJ#7'Up9U"8661i "6l<GgeGtB&
Apnf#}e<pn9XA%SZVniKrlf>9N-:. 'a=Wl08UH@n+<8VEq;toF'rWAEl$L/KI;u;l
Ab$'S;?lbHrrjkhBeG#OE2=6:q'q7Z]nDOZilcl,S*(4X.YeQnEl[lh%\_f(*(Brh
m07U.:?jl*J7n%r/nB4Lg.rM}S8LgRiGj"7A7uG9Dp3\3L:'lNPba33YDEaX%} '41
A
c$>0]gb02>;Cg77DC]j ZAZ<mac:QF \DOhTKnkATM':4;_+/X; 'WYj63M;4Rs}>'c
A%%A DkCX's-Pdp7]OfC9kYHZf_L'-703HtHWZNRSq3HP-dtl:alp,ib'@037KaODH
XYhn>NS#G3FC#=Ybk4-3"Ab,so&S'-> (jX<XA='U?*J1'/StRDJJ9Ic ot#V*cPZ.V
Df2oAY2F\u.&&O$Kmd/L6j/]9;V7l<Fb%:Une>VZ4SmY$bKT([XoE4EEq#u:&LZ"+
hciDrYI=A%qE?,7?rdMP:Qq(>9S0kYehoDZfOoEf>.t2,\:o.t(ZddhRYp$;U+LCF
TFZES@d[Ee$]6G/knSS>Glud#-@1$,>9@s_%OI"N?k4dlb}SjEKap1GG3fW"/lEg
<]N;/]j$9W>6RKhS<M93a9'SqUI" ZAA'<f3+:$RJHl\;:Z}2" (]EXR7 XEs3"\$K@6
%ISsf7UPGh4AT7GIO]V(A<&39s-U6tO.B,8K-M\pl1lAh.K"b/FuKjmG;]Ei'?t>/
oNhrSh/eL@aT2dEl?; [WVkMuE2aUm11gb?=K'/AQ.I<t'7g6%l39X\,lpce+GhhKZ
*QAm9 #c.=Ir1<qhVSLE_Q.+:QGWd$lMr6D?fMJ@4>OKs?eSZJ&<a A&%WCb;EjG_X&
Sq"%87FSJIL" / _./Jlj3Iqui ABL2 1 - lsU, : ' :Lr;S#"7F4L*r AAiu"C>A /sq] Z4C>
'''@+sl/}@FAicllj&'Tre6l7}Wm$#@EKJ<KruTc\kos3B@3g%lbj\h;?QIXFCnkqi
A6?c? WSO}D42YpX62,OiIH AeM#cq6/DHq-QCPt.P7j+bJXBA34/e$D$aQsJ# :S@
A
B'n6EQHuaaOlhfc \XINRJ4"A EVE }EPC8@>A9(LblUo;ao90T99b+fGD A7S971/6c
@QtmhViPpXS't?Kc-?+ORFOamTn:Wr [gOP=>dqD/.#juT-} Pm7N2X.S] jKS6"4dJ
1 S7uPA$=N-FuAQ=S (s072, %Blo-@=o#EFdjk:aI\4 1CElS: VRN=$=P, (" 3 * ?o>6MA
AAbas2KHlCknUR,ji,G\d4EWpO+/lNOY<24D@NOtFPuZ "tE.FN8+E??u;fdaMOXS
mEEs&/,H"T_@s6n.Sq}pYSCZZ}TJ3uH+U@X}VSJc&tIg6<.EWek8VZFf) ;QlrNcFE
<Qkq*FMde>:Yr9!6'$GBZL7NMcOr'r1s_umetSuQI@(ilCQZ1SJbPuO$'>uSNah'&
A
V_38*NS+&L'EQc r-]] ,Pd>-C-bSU+'_uJ"O,\}Oc?(4L&&REM/$fqOoiF}@a#HQL
mrC*'cFuluQAf@[mEaWDSqEllhKR-XNOng+@VLntbcPc+-cqH#f?&$BVu7W(WEAf
&aj]pH+B='ZIaeqS=eLs""//q}JFSKnlAI9=;Q1=0[Fm:PgQ[CoGb_-P}pi/F7v i9
<c1ekf,KR3$i,4%A+7SGe'Qbw2b'''fOFDU'h\F+.%fX'OAQoA}Km7PL;<a]eH[H<R
0&7A>}hTT}}kN>cHGU;}j&9[P[=jOl2<D(4gNmVKarbIQ+d2,Yg'9Q4dlq,dni72'
/?_[hlOS&19T%t[#ObcG*3h[3<lU+$d/dgC,MpTK,*;SEP@]H<1'W8LH3SSu%ULVQ
>n=%A(tl:#rll$4#M:Yt(Jmd40aHNZUKUj9(\[PX;$-6T=oj=lm_UaR#%prTVh(R?
6 [$_M;mu-30g[gBp&l ,#_S"SnW] f; 19INVOl \i; iWEm [H/+RC*+4l*$ $@Al?>@lTX
cK006J=lpS#kI uP@S2l}OAR:Yj']Jb;.RO/V?m>nmlU- 02VP;dG=}E]?#@D TJa
0>NM3l'Vak&#N~9}PKn#JZ_7WVY-l/FSHkpir-;2Munlop#,IkLRD}m>ko3$;XOXR
N/?n;k'}qtP9IMcSr\>POZp#3G4bN<#"'%>hlS?MU\A@Z(UmPW6cPO9'->OT[C20q
Page 35 of43
�ARMS Email System
NIE3-""(+C\@30kYWaPQ-KY1-m[Vn%-\UYKY»P)B3An3qnhO;p1SVA.Q]1 (Go_CGS
HC3Sb.?1-UQK)qqBJ\OlrE'.gu:I\XuHDsrS,Y]>lM-=T"f90V&A#*9uJdrrK@bQ.X
-4\NqU7b@]U7 A 1r7"CKVf?3\Uk7RS#SF,d-*rJKYPHAc 9]+SJ/GXh4C$\.dkfJk7
: SNR (NJ [-eDEY>bT+ [Z=Mh: Og?AA. :_KlBcS] [KpSu" A-;HWHC>; snJN 19 ["SQYMS 1
A
SAX/U1H3C/,>I%-CraO%-3V140h<1:tppUdV D4%-1-SEB+jTccNAP17D_M[pQt:Ls?$
20>, *jUb?bRSAmLrAo [j Q7MKXS$k#j a] L; [ec_i *" *t@lbS: 1 -p7K@4Vr\ "joOUYp
UX&$YX&.CUjeYamZAH\)4">Tnr9hS+AO=gPQd]&FCj_QjVS-qdU6m/D.@lO[@S79'
FILhIs/'D7XMkWHOa:MoPKRa[IGXk[=OD1++$lQrnhhDRH*\k6mHa(#_cl«=*SiAe
1UFPCgs1cp?&ii.2<6V"'\;*9-.S)aZSVFC($%-Z&OLig;ro:O%-7m:l?o*l$V?IRVO
[t#hoSLS AU/Rk#2a/32rF:r#oBp[e*-?[gC6gSTE-FWlZdlYG+_%-\r#lnOSOKSulP
JrnDj2jDP#'S+;)j,r]Qa-c1;104QH=XYWi#4nFNQiXR%-]e&M;Xabh"jO\"SGbW">J
6Z&$ap62cVIF"61h?Ot/L6'U9+nQrS1#KIL#f'<kR"sue-1COi[S' .kaS[lSPL-DN
A
K(I"A#]SJmM#=\MI(>C<)2 DRJqA\b[3Sf*ToYY.BBbaY@//fYRjKL04 [Ef+OGE7J
f TXm M(2S&F EUKPn$lhM1XEmDW2dOktn<L\k7C OfdqTKA$(gkZ6r,)n-+Y<Y-N
fB+::lt4gBOSVU?AAjK'ih*[<Is2gsZ0?e-S=me967JF?Z/L[+IlOj-hB1%-UhktFR
47FR&EmW>?D;DBS((1-<K#=W::uRqgnf'0:h)6S-1cR:r=W'h]D?*Cc1+F?@:--um
)pm4e-\+MOZ<,d1l,+f,Z-7cj) 1] Ddn-i2pWjHjgPEOmVH+2?c?g_gV %-El>W.;",A
F6+T;;3>lKmun1+eN)d)+4 '2N+%-VYS,U2,>] ;u%-@-$[dOAfQm*l+%PT)?s\@(EMk
60Srtho<ES&-,A BOa ]S\fP:j1+-1»%O+M3@-7V'OrdJ?Ikh#-V-mXp6$ApA2-M*/
kep;&b.;L"QTb+VAcPtHCHcVT3)k$gX7&g?lFJAEr;QU1KXlr1UQ%-lHCN>ZcX#b6>
A
-] #6) lRf&OGcHSF*, 3#a$9SU-lVkST/P1mo' [" 4JVi -FIc@fSP9) -W:mZoT' 7 S\
#C>mJT: n] MoY' -03V; D-jA=fX; 'RL A=, kTcn+=:;:-' " : 6 -Pi [ 'Ek] UJ%JE*6K#A R 17K
O$hcq]kIbT>LV"opoISjNh$uTN'XDRK-fXSd(GF?Sdh<B>c [<*tCpLIC$lN:GmOT
s'Y) 'h*/) AWONU+Z6-Xs.OGOp>S'UA\EBC2cftO[30J>uqHdV>O'4B=] %- $hnsj9k
O";?i)])&S3iLS;X/UYi2TeIdF;Ut3\T%K&SmW+uOc_q1e"4(?-SUMd\S&haAq#PO
GHXtoSOB [- <Xb; 1rtV /L. : eSl" 2GGK=%>@Z;n2"Zn- (iRcVBW421j /D3etWI1 1U&W
T:cZ$T//OTn/S-=gA) 9%Mad:tafajSDZRhfH] <' qpncH.g<SS6?S'c]71&e. [ZlK
$J(f2nMW:U6t,gdK&Nju A ("lGUC/-E1/>L1)d[39@lYtp]QUe((A(EHrltE)S#*Uq
A
1 'kcTW) ?kLXB=ZqI&J#X*O [IYeiekSqf9@. F«) slR&Y ;m_ (O/6Zj -" . lSlJ 6N"B
qZ/DjE#t+ZVScc-U'poGhC]"lk?7qlZchOnTnWS(r7.ifa&j1[r@iimSiPiCK#d%9
jYL_SS&B2.6fu+2a%mS1J*,Z_S$;%\jVZl]R6kaA,7jNh09>I#d207faIU_-,mm"#
41 ,A Sc =3-%-PFiE%&K\mN-n@AOMp"\&D,UXpd]H("gVibh3S2+IaM2'j(rkV,H@UF7
OS_kDE'Z)LNt&_[?] P='161t6 [*AaB6ZSY:Ej#ZQ4BH1Y:nA"rT2K/A :-lIA?=-jH
17I] :rC#3cD,b&H'L_.fh=Jp(&CS=BSlsVP-J[-gjPDVZr;fT"HpSW_>//Z_>TCST
NAb&*<d ?aN; c, >%Y: tW (hgNquXLB- -OqPo@D3H'R?Um\h. \iTq"e@fRioqGobdG
A,Q$;TXiU%gU: 'NOH bJDKVUAq:D2gRD6X(jiR? ci'Fl$%Z+GjIGn.hJf4: ]SAd
dO$q*@ip_N@GS/=?%~ju3S-ZV'DW02eWQFTJSFL;N4qOkD#-BFblRA9't#=B[O-V3
] 't) WJ71p .0\@;J_ha20; [t+>] pU: gXh4NbhZhIEh, 1 AOd" $) G2. Q$] +V= (\OUhAY
A
SD4LP eYCT>Q bFRn[G:X4QYa. '''LnM%:YI&«<u)uPC''aArdc>TklV9tZY$\A<t;
7
A
] 2X01 ,Y;3R>/J?wg)BXBrIg7CG6dak.rC VEc>ZY"fjr)40\eRG1Q(n?[TCIT'OQ
lWe9&d24--jDQKcVKMI\B[&9/'dusSSVs1hEsBX$c?/JSTa<Q@H4L+eg+6VE[7L"O
\das7]eAl#' . [7qRsn>S/\Q(>Vu)aJ2Ss<+,aPr%?:-LWKtS:FHr"SDc>lmP(-eBJ
7+4)V'*NE7]DS07j$7dEOhcQZY#Lo12iF6iIMf=kO#lW/HlTjpe=Un/d6?&71U9$>
$Ui[RlMiOT?;? @$b-%JJU; [&rWQ$rrbj E]s ? KcbYU93Zr3?g--J>Si\mB(S-I
VO?\\<SL(t61%d/m]7gEd*) ,/S>D) AoNBH< %MLrqMo , 1Xj.I+Z#(lJ]OZ-h@+>\'f
A
?Bd.M<SA SP6 ?eMqb_?L;c4Qe31Gc=hNkDYAQ7NS.LKYt.m /><_n7J1$$\e?Ih-XI
: Ou: Sa' \kK#Wh; #_OsH () %dOiKr1W: CVAAYg&R==HU*j ; 7b-D=@Z"KgXu6Apb]OQ=
O:%=>Se#;WO'n)P*S(m jFCOK*S,OfHCTch4tR +/laAnT40iY6lNkJ?9.*j 3ip.
d: 2RZKFTG:] $$if. 'XGOSfS - *" 'Ek. 7/hrV2 - 1"+92) 2IT ($ik#SM ( .1 \ 1, Ab2sIm
A
?]]m/ONE@-,&3.d+H7tPQJ(/XcDg_hpjQB(StM gS]9W[.,Ld-:&Q)OXpB.C*O/.]
W/Gl]ffZ,Kk]Y<a] .j3/TccXRkPA; 1IHtl+>K7*O\eTnSMO] ?:cT&+QS=%IZ(A. Tg
W>MV; ; T_#sopt A4 , . \" \oMiu. 7>#KlSq;] 1] bED>YXDJ\F1Eca7Q7] Yc] KOqJ (OMS
X=WdOFS,YMm[aI971Eo=e%M D3nRRo&Tj-D3RGMW\O-Sr<s#eO+1U"ASY"7Yj$=pAa] '''=h02tKR1aojZdD9SC4~3M[Om;LotP6&2c,<R+<iB1pANSogLORSJhH$SL*nB
MjffuN"XZ3(,?f=fL19s@+_kq=H7GAlCi>nhWTTt32"D7Ie=RuOgl<\-di.#W1)*I
=-m'@OS&%BkC.*O;ZXYSN1S3D=+ENTS??11A KO :j*)maCm>R_ZVrE&JK&7$.fPh?W
A
l6R;F7VF=krc [pm4uGKboq[NH.?JXYA>NZTPE?s,&/;o.rook+SpIVRHbnlmKfG
=Sb. S\EMt%UC4FNEj (r<f "DO&: t70;- . aiR$Dr3] Ta#? [eP* *0 [lCJe; <V-D. ) C>R
A
/">Pl$D/nK+Y3ps620L?h\?Y'NjSH6Se Sg-XOSlS;j3+cr2;R@]c)2I\Dl]k(tr/
:gJ&f2A2-nS:Mj&Mmk-kS/) (:-p+j[QOl:@UZbtA@irDPD-($=n'p44T$HtLDsbVX
Page 36 of43
�ARMS Email System
=H_MLn%Whb]AA1$VX"c-("kO, :PWed-XmSp]&&?PO=f1\mj9GUg#(S<+@"R(PiE;S
?jP8F?04>9=«(;A\2pCd9zNqDbY7<FWhpjAFF;TectpGhKse->$"eY-<tl=@#UQQ
Dp[3VF?UT"=i4Te1gmm*TOpiP*W\#t"BnV?ljUFX,j]SHjifF"\X'i7kRdd$] <mHm
HhS ASrU\M-B.QoPP>uV1nZ#;tX?/n.8+C@43PIKE'd(Y/ZOSSLP-9=SgS[<TiUO
,5+5qxeooro; . &X4s17J" . O?lp@>, A/N%SmTAS><: &FmlJXFD<PJ>+ -CK ApSMOQ8N
A
>A 4 ?--T'LnU'+-bfZ=163?XF nX-dh6,i)nS\'a"7-mD$M,a9AYX)#Bk$+I)H*6.G
gUqnmVZ$pfktoj YVK; P 1 >YlfRi. 62IW 1] 0 (9Z1u "@f2Lb-fS2;W=N\WWX-) k [* [j C
A
C@ua ] 14_?Va3e;AAp*ZdJUb2/Hh;a(ShP=lkU<8aOsr/;g3Pk=KL]E1'B.DL/#s2
X\fYUNQ]5"YU-6S2NLl:O=W]qH)F*=fMlhjjL<'N[8)kO\"Q(H]Li7-- [LEIO(?7t
c4:c8?$,VF\Th7$k]g8/:q$QK&[$)&2?r-Z';k*s%"/?@&kjL>rQ7N)jQ\;"J6HhN
&NC A .o<TkXeMfEa21/db<S+s>ILMS[RHl"D-;VO<Tq>t*K-@YUM3'\#kto/gjk[VQ
A
;KfN+:UZOGi>Oo&#]Bp/2:D,3S=Es -rhS&SRq#>Set4K,k?cMXU-i7H3mKge.>"0
A
Q$P04,O/A2JKMZk:p402dE[p#IOolkSYs\%4jA:/ XI ]#/Sq01T4hc @:WBAcjQ-a:
A
0+OAjpRk.d@?=g?--#U_FYS Xboiad-1KE=mMo?4CmNYGn3fc8CTHiFD$36?SX6Mf
)K,lAA_SQZ,A08h@iS*?A>GCAS/7K6&IL,2+0$ZOFs13c7j1H'd/Y+N:KTH3*V4hj
g@UR]+JCc+kY3)MO"c+BflL.rDk/1@<8W]IW1u?d:f1W'n63) (U-d+RI]U[pFOBq]
>-A?IT*84gA&hD, I*N\ "_: ,ljqsgRElt40-h1 S) ?0<Tp21_ -um%8C>m/' hiXiWX@_
[sLF: J@&57 [@4\8@Y/ZaQO<Pd=,miQR"aV39NiW+: -ucs<O%O-n$>qZjA+LU [3%@d
<KA\k/;r*;3#)qZ_EjWLS<XO<O?uI\iOnEROTfm@aRA+Cnh#16/dA+j>TrNl*VCVB
7[GM-L2BB<")c%b;p ARO@ZZfea@%VUX3_BhTErti/#%*&YmO/)U9\;biXZ"_\, (mU
h1 '$_U=lU ( '8foE] &i] moSt@QE"#/g64Mdl, 6J$] SU<q1W: ,FiQtEFq: K*t [rJc7
fR=V04ndmS19"6rS1u/dEsgOhLkSUSdd2b,3ZLd?pY--Hmu=BcX&1.rf(i*T=rL@S
>2qD»cq%D+c[+UJm"a(- )or'MD,]>t\#Cs$rJ.f/j20DSo&(299\TmuH-(I?3Z/
KDqUqL (U*Hdd$7s1G/Hh% -bu; >aJlid6J%A\: "HAh; ; ApnA8NRF3. K=aM20-rKdk]
J@cV* &a1SYnAAc'pX+S$AD7CqZj-)W1D#ujCD/7?6MSFSuWKfmnUnfmpZXG,$2?q
@/9Pppr+HG%QL(1(6'OEC=IB+4+Xf)oC]]A$1\f9TPOuKIBM;\JA>3GJ@00A Z9p =H
CS7Kke]U,<._ciKre;T1T]i[;ql:g7-ST2G"G/7p30m@M] :OL;;g-UhC"A?\2ko/<
mS] S&P (legcc6TF*G3G] *C [0, (2)@E"Ikq;3GC_S<K3gPZ6VT_TO/<Fd-e%7W@'MO
A
(Wljl#InkU#90Q-#Kf6-' [?M<GL/Z&,L3I168L'2+<-YpbSj6MZ- 6$B?<JlmBG,A
A
4qA@oNMPecBVY32&($dO#hL]@;nCL&G/#e'e%qTGS5t6»um?HL -Wg='lM%#lqC#
Qlb ( . +/@816;YTJ-Z'p&%TgYr:<qXh@$fN9Q?fI) [K [] tKgq$8MLCZICiUWBZT-V+
A
-70 ITkWE'Fami4aRHAL@tQJb8V\,Lfc*e3$Oi:MOWghJB1[.Cm%+T;Y(t(6DDMkj
9h\&okq9X-BHP8KGs_F7eV2KW; >-Y, dMc1/_7di?A"*uPKG=Z"YoA?M gn.h=*_VKO
I)7a(K3@]<fg3/<odp:Q"_-M,@rmDtb$1'L1Y7p@SFPYbc&ljA<,@--54 (csUQAsO
&H7XrZrmomDaWRiUY%1?jDLk-q;k95Zbc%,KlmLnl1Z?a150G@NO%;]Ros1G$13U&
&B (/ 458J@8&s/3gq;HpOYrRB*A1%2. =X" *2MnaEo: o=K] K@\ : 3/ 4Qa1>U< (. eWt *I
,%XMQl] :u@7E'?aX&Et%1(]&61Gc=HS3LlkOg_&W1.WH6iBS$YHSqsKVFWJ2-OpN)
poDP#$S, GD$gC%9/n6-qHtEkt2Ii%1=L. 8$*#poAJeh\OAnD: P. elDlV"%. > [:oAn
qU?l=-r\UY; (sb@qD5XS-6-JKodm)h:h2I:Ic(*6=:-4[pq1)p2b[-0&IALjDtLHO
A
A
-hD;adc1$1\t 1p(sco\c1ecV7HL3X S:*g=DsR"Z2B;9bW?ubV8kCUHeLpf"7E-1
A
bUHG32C'/OWpiB,V8h$ai/X\lW (r4\CEr,N"+ZS=_ogP'*_«/NJbd&$'-EYkUJ&
]NV.d4+VHnmJDZ*6\U@lcK8h[i,8c.&S18+ju$oC7A@310_Ver'U2&i,-4W>-JH2&
rgL*1]$G"&S2FY-@D)Y&C"LoPnPpnQ63no?'%*,a1UPnb+]5'0:Xb-3g\\$XHAEtR
=H:G8ZdTn_</hT801Hs@ItJ02R'*Hd-OQHY>aLPCpu*/@m<T3/%4Yj=_BVtS_;qOt
gOC)12S6fa;Qij:g;1\_V+le4F3'LGNLAA_g%.Sk#5d@@:#S-_Q-"KQjqr";b6tmf
,[COjNso?ej, 1,Q<T]U A,jSP*G8,K=S)OSD-6RQiitkml@?I\-Q9)ShD'0)&?iFcM
f>RsZob9Z83-hsuGilZ(gIaUlBR[iCh8f\=\Sh#jADoLO"f6%TOH8@"nNV_Z\GO\?
pgeN>1'-FW7P\3ELgFYfEcF%\IC&"lA8K&D@c-BoEnm071\sT,kOfFI*ub'35c+#=
g<A=TkBXpoK) opB (#M<IMT=FgKn [&Z> 1tU&#·$G5h8?2 (= ( POIOg. & fk63h*K2& [
A
.n.e ">JBba[G@od4Y:IR[nmmGq*2FFn/1[\_GKL#pX<>WFOO:HJb+N[OfjO<JO-A
3b7Rjs+fpJ"MBY%Xt:qWr#33f$]@lmO@qX1)T.AS<OE X*R"?c8Z;177 ($J+A%RB:
A
A
d,LStUJ:ms9hof6I>/] i?SHV=B(UR-f2 (Q3jHOVndmMR-O-h5 &>U OSgjLumZiE+
aDPi*\nJ8\Shb. -'2:%lSsOV;On:m6+d=Ss&AF+WXrAG<g#G%ojXoq*AV2 h1B)Y'9
)h[Ru$;ML>140eF<0, '<%b:-LfXGGjm98>L/afa;Te\#PWp%\7C.G)j.13-0Kmh&,
U%M*Acf=*SB@@ (14, ;O<OL"MI> Aj : SB: bH5Ka&1ge" AAZ$/p: ri T, ($PG?M9P; - P]
A A
A
PM9F%Rs2cHJ KY>OO[;iKU=WKO: 'Tc6,cd=Bpei 13 T1V) ;Q16'N1] ;\orq/)O#H
A
FkDE"7MSL ( 1M- (, As] FR$VCd81H: J/' 78uKJrN 08ANOD?] CnI] 05] OVsU@FkXLU?
V_(G3c$Z.8%+R1e]] "6--_$D*R:t(UqB\J$s")3-<GoBh10jJS8=&@BzmRq=_';s*
Ybr3(Yr[rT%\it?)AK/&?b"n$(FB*TYWIMChLd80#.@8?c2'aG'U%aUDikhJYh-3r
A
A
MAFB %6$VRY=nI />kcs)ChfI@AiPuG6UFsbEsW_-g00261CE+_1XS_B(tqsp%-;:
Page 37 of43
�ARMS Email System
A
T#3't$"S'Ac3e\"bS@ZqpIZQ,SNC%-»ktM)B/+2[O#pM8S'_Kb%XTE ckl+LLg<9
Gl)/?%>VbLb[Eecs'Ok($/1-%RY,peDg6ReKcQR\SSkL<4tHar\"F84fY*f<@A)-f
A
7IICRREYIED\d1[K?F]6@oRCH]P4h]rbRJhEl6Eel ')I:S4/LQi?8sCN\%e 4Msd6
2Nl@oc'20'f?[l8'+rm%'nIjWEK2\.,SK\IF]9S. lH@cNmjrAr8p1lBK\\', (dUZO
BTP3?g>&Ar'S64h;Jm<T9%]S=JjKNXTm"EIJh[ns*fN'IlfnSY#*T\/TS3L\Q+kTk
)A O*"hec?WVEq$S#QP)i:V#A La [aJdp6EcUg]a?'ZTfB[bA]-W8UR%=pa"eDS6agS
QJ&P_3g=cP3KOOd$I7QZB-8dL*'JYiQi*rS3C3*\-A%%"P@/feq/cO+N,t360iW1%
TQf,d/m:*dab$XSR(uJOIq+Og4aff6B"LT*<gog?>F8#psO$&XoSiJ7NrQ+S[Op)
A
A
G%e)6-F2:l<YA+tR<A(DBb3s61qY>V1G :tjRFI(\8 b:>pBSS'u,=S[H#'13MoTh
Dp] a9VtU-EJHmrmc-?MaASd82 l<\+s'U_T=FS#%%e (dF9(UaCIlU(Q ]qHBoT,lc.j
PO?AU'<F?g] :f7Y)qpGpZ3@<MS3Bl6YqiN=d3hgzvtI=Pbc;ma4CJ9*+)MD',//qo
A
A
]':'+Zlnnb Al\VrR .hK,mu#g=QQck7,qNEVpGi=p iZh7RC(L<RKbu_V'kG[&lul
A
gt03&c8[kV] (AS (4*CR ;T'FWPKsr$+LCtW_F\mYa?U#Z&S$$OT1c=h;W: 9pN3bbQ
\AYDK:/042YaW7:8qU3C+B#Tl1(,Sn"Bnl%-?a6ZqWA@[Y$Lu'mlZt4#GWl@#GSjh
L[QZr(C3SdV8pFa&]@/gh:?Q;h/qb<-6fG8A+CA;jALh[04,03s2nTG3Zo\njgHNJ
Kc-fB*]qKH*.%c=PM#@OcgW01%Z&juK AO/"'<pq.Z6-+0-7kmTY\K"Heniu?UC162
8: A%7f1UWuT4TV1;qHl?Y#;,?+1*7/JW(A"UUVD_.%K8RBL:@WcM?4]F.?'&d]Y>Q
b4X A 4D7DM7jAiP;] -dr] '+e-Sbt#6"S=2++isuQ9jB+IFhlm('WnSsV<-;PK)ZhK
A
17 AvR1S24e(AONI$R«A r ]p[_lW97CHM@'\-/OPX?«qp<mE b6[fUh?u(6fQG2F.
Tu/Jh:ala&nFVGT:h[E$?XKfhn11U:QOgeaK)Fh&it aZ+ndN;Eula@&O @&nF?lG
\/ _Pi 2 [e·ct82*\ZKfa [M86%VmhXL-8m_: <L - 'aXo04708fXOR] 4) ; %: / "rhdFYBg@
m8l6pRO"M.TPTtS<b<*=lP600Hk6WiM+cLk#sfWT A%[\Dqqln:CE1.orFa'FOsSK'
iSN[T1G@R A%, :H3=O#P/4@)QG/\*Z:'7;'8>i14rK$lo>$=T Aofb'QR\JH&Ac"d]
Atl \Efb3F6n[KB Aa*@r/68H)UQ(LTK_iikKS9RS&8V)?/S6cFrP+YRqhJo A6V1ZB;
A
gQ#73l 'RS) 'CgY196U[-2igbfhPFSB"'?7 'V8s>cKqIDodNd@/$ZDG:, (t4*nZM
A98EH AAYKKfNBEKbYg-%hiO<l=k])97R$Pb-;-$EF1V"FnV7LA?:-CS9BS74$j\+hr
A A
;hCl (iDpUMK<==:Ej#yy c XkI[LXH>4Bi/BI7Gl lB@J=cj,M/i@hV.,'c_M'M$@t
7ERH,Hm>sEYMCDH@8=q]RHQojA1KeSIQ]V&nrcRQe-3&OHL@E?JW/2l8Bfui=*h]1
YeTW8S<1. [JIMpMq,gllcq<A[lqn6%X/-&J,ld01NT1'AmN#d] 'NV&),ZO(e1LKpQ
eS;_Ik07g:a<?Oj"NAAD@KX4#g8#[*199"cQYj\e**qCiiR?/bUc\GcUGf+20_0L8
&U']-rK08I<ZZm<a<RT$S_$KHKA\'L6SV3L\m%kr.p&g[mt1PPS+EFU'S$]QGD\Y@
@\\40MRF4]$TPE%hG=,I.U6l s8GI%H/KP04l8Kf8b&>A)81#kN3En1D6k# XOJH<
3F]77W#MBW>9RLenn_lw_nFxEg;_K:F A 1-W?")-['CHfu8m+m:31VA>XO<K~F.-<J
8iNe'L%d1;hl;by'LcT«n:Scb:c#3n2d"krk24#>;<l*"piHrY<L@RiD40Zd*X<l
GDuZ1_PHqW(8; "ABMeIm?Fo. ITlkurd2:R6E4'Yb"q\p3+_qX&7 A'Wn 9RW@CSK-[p
:gL1SFZXL<Q'CqYYOnSS>V%SfpZp60bHHaipXBpNO<ldH88c?Ae1<6)eC.%ZC(q'R
Pq9U')'iq*)cIQ&FtV:OkMl09dD,"EEAudRY%pW3HVYV]A4qmr=sM\0;a6U)-OIeR
AX2geL.6A(;Oa1N\+XBag?lUEQ02LL]_PA;q"$'P8;6D/V3H9Hk4'JYm;s_(BjVtl
7\b8IFeHKQOQCr7W+P>/0"l61V30=l,<+oTheTS"p=8+Ue;XPuSBZ=0: (c'cUo??k
B'/:C, (E'O&2U_d3XAgcah$OfkC6-]@4e(3*J)B)N[h"a'4b(l?CAg*%=@7PWE-7j
S7mS(n?aCjl#H]s@]36C#shOq2] :@V42"il;tGrs-$unor.SUHMmEYp2RpO*("MK3
SM@rLe:X\dUSa"7/B07 AR"ih%YR>=&m6VYXL6XBU:'E.SlfMGe$pfM#+VqFY',d9Z
/l?h&_)ONH (? "Fh3ZFUVi\SuN-Sr=mn-UX A\O%A/?VS: T7; &6N)AQC; (Dj-*lDd2C
3%&ZfA2j8=-T+O%HN\DG>SQHWWVilL'V:Y[&Zo]K</,TVK%7qO;uj.Km\=?%PEUAg
@fUCmY=gCV9S(72ICh3$TKHPI.HA(bS-lirI.uNilVZ8".@lSEhlPr)]QdAhMIClX
khri,)&hA8.ssqX;M2hI07p9l0>SoF=>B;T8/L$fhMW9<[9$K'6/in[L>,pV3HNh1
NW=M&j4-DV;08<V,m]%s<$T:ck@02WP#bMSOad9nhC+fnQgNe6D$h/bS"2n86*BZD
[EINTAGfK-GflGMY /) 'FDMgfD: [1 "0$nE2b-LTFdgU) pP [; ) - OU" , (tHZ. NAOGNM A
cP:1UgD07KeROtMGdaXr**ogjYKbHP%kgeIR=4W;2,k). [Bcr' (JhYO??oHOcke[l
(G:D8EEV"tEY+S[(LWd,='A04PtKVMO&ika2AQS<IBi%dLC=GP=%U H'''= %DQ>«
EU)QSB"*r A.])NF>erl"0[ScpH42PT+1VVa4tZ'6T+Si$mGNn7-81+:E"d?JdRSA
)@)0*TZ1l;34#,M8;Q;eeFYEc[n\OeLqKUt A]B ArJ@?'bq6mP,2tX*(LpCk4$*DiC
Kf=Y2/F"irPGdBAYW2',hSuS-$YSO\#%d@a[T7dj'T9"Q;Yjd,UdmDsdB3R7-h)BD
A
A
/SF. AI+nOVV+Id*TuOjm#q%c7\##GWrB=q3smUYb hAmaXiF?+g,NbfSXHsY.6H<
A
A
gNJiKdJ<H+j_MrBp QT3IA\>oTf9RM",&=F(TDi3R ZQH9dlO>ACFOJ/[KL1$UMqN
b9#SfOA>SpjdbBM A,3SCrDI@=oE#\0@[CCIbeZpK\JEC$hfq-h=B&l708XMc2%pO
n'*mKb)CSM.3qdR~,npc'\RJWl [:E Ak&D&Y*'mO<PVgipJ4tJQ171@JKnD;@@E(LL
[SPR'V&3QtSP-]uq2 (Ht,TkYNo$lAXSF"m,p4%:phRZP.f4hX*e\? (a83 d\SU\ZUa
k) bjbM [' &CIh4?#-la) M\ >; Z- . ; 1 'u3j f<9"AJ" =QCRoV@j$BQH [NHO: iBk- 'qX>]
Af@\kbUMG%RZ A
p37REj:jIF3C*BGY]Z?E;l:2muopua9mJ3eJMcASKIe%902[oeFQ
Page 38 of43
�ARMS Email System
\i?ZON'k;C&KSoJSdBLXSAlb+*A6+mSlLr#] fTQTRg4 [Y#": lAh6,S@&,*Ja(:J#
4BNS+06iSjYAf,S&sWZ\8rQtsSl+7/-uApN'n$e$N]H7,CA8f-G84=Y'Qtrt;FG-g
oZ] :k.7baNmieOf)bLF,G[R@d#nP)O=p[63K2%&m;l+sJYmM AkpA@P(C"NS?'7LIK
D'dTi,qcs<]d/a,<mw_9PD"9MZW*.O';,ZEl&O)6@<6dc_POTIP&;A@BIP1(lR+EA
] .ItMIA.FI A,6H +>?[Anm&/ebY$nB:'bfS%CPS<XSR U?A l %Bg4;TSp)A'LJ8im;
@-nr'@";swsOXp~.=Ag(nlbO[%WC,<r:adOlrS3;eJb7e?Mp?VJgig3nhk/OU'aFM
#dMp8b*A>\-k>«NFQ",>q6S]-,>Pq>,h?$,tOll'UUj2I%=%lWa*iRCb&\'Vlt;'
PlchMI,#,S:mu8>8_[G2ZuAI AOX=@$T@F'bMF7RelE4i*@Q26kT%H'SUE92g<9U<W
ilmUi734Pk>L))ST[&kZB>4[p7qaY-0\C?#8$IYL.@_#GQ1*H$%XOl;T*Z[>7CfGf
K:*h] ,%cDklU?6JXf Ard=YA&mm+W)u[60-4YiEuMVmTtSdS<dN70'OPSXjq,Rp*0<
F&HUR.U#.r4.&6+JFJKQf9J*PF3Am,\A6SZ%nX;V@qPsA*tBFc=FRcV]a.EkK.BuS
H;.nH+:4XnP$eKOOum#W«2U,C,&3MT$#[lFG/QAhX>eL%2-f+hI,m) lGddhX)TQ>
k Xh[kN L>f]*BO&uh<lZtj\u#rbr%AAN\H:I-O, l2XHbGjlC:DC?ik@30e87rY[F
97S'OGnJ,JlwDqA3SbYUAN(/-xOZ2?gr>$aosV(r'\YlxlgbqH9M;'V;WVL1,\G(I
ABf6$AK]RBrH]d-L7S A\3l;sgjpd'T+==Ll\Vd,A OD 'Fi497p**fPl<JfYr$c?f(; (uaSDNAfld) : IaBP?FN) OS_Z/'02607g>9C" +8H8343S3 AFNoC$ql. 30] &M?pj s;
h'D/j#K[Oq;RXS2JM07f@t3/2Y[(kt:,q.D7E%>aXMfumAS' ['<Qn2NHIWZq(Il:C
A
A-V)\,@[Vt3Kg%h>#>7F$PeL%C_c&K]mS$s#t"_(6rAM-nl%R''',m o'(:uJuQU6
Tg/tO[Zls.:B/q6G=J6']_Z*U[=FZ_Tl>du_sUQpTH=)$<YlY("Jf=Kj"cDTPNbpR
:/#]A JW4 [8/fKl+%Bl'3")F9s7gjUG*Oumg.?mnI#ntCOQV,qV&D]apFbkSc)*oUQ
A3id72Pt78'MT[_Bb_'iQKt\$gh/n,)n42KNNE)?Ap%JX\7tX&:smNe9GHc+jh/ig
YBTW-DM*4 Af'B/l"2JYi[hplfqQH;;CFM\S0932KHIVRRZccagE3EA2Y"tUno'Oo\
S%%'kPSZKBM9/Z;ib;<ET46BoooS8@cdJqQ['*V(;U[3 MRmj':.=Uuga3jWCdl*r
+,WIVlqu>GKZD/Jj>uas2mBp64, 'dD_AOuY>3Ma_C4XA~0\A=$ODqu*RQDJ#&G(_3ZRnK 4$ne'pH3UNY*)F7/=0*LKkqR;BuUOSjDL+; «29V@607%,sOAqkcON B9ua
Ij,ngT@Q67;%aClkVrYbY>u<%[m/ze=>_+97,f)~MeR.2J,XmJZBA) [7M(./~<VBk
WDCdVq(USIG<SH (-rOr8$W (FIKXla3=P& [$hMD2,6#$,S)k31a\Odd== n2]Ffu,)O
K[paN4u'cp8BJT'@CYsA.t<2_Z#FIQG8'+qXnjXinEt[kp]Nl>@phqAbu7Gh=jUdg
O@' CL/e:1XgBiR=$%g03S7 A.?20r)Ypl=Pc-&@Z%BgO,j,/r.b[y'cqF"S1 RUkFm
A
sO.tVP2'A+c08jeJST\FNQU+<WpbI CiYWeARj;&)PM/SJ+hhjS,>;VVOZgF *72$
A
bi4B)EY/\2a+UK?]/:\10gVK<B@S?7Lbj@c pka ga40HOGOm$U30I>gS9\Vi3mBV
sWW'j9jA[+F39N)RZt[gmQi'Q?WL/P?Pq'j<?%nP9aUfJ+h(>(Ta)Pl [:rf'3%@'U
;nPHD@;g=1+cSmXqlsflh.\l?etX4*ELFMoOq)8MSAKX;4A/lV,3=*9h'4bOF(Aq,
bB6_,NpuiU(?Rs9d%sF)LZpL.dYYKDAr\c,::pplUhC(.,bI"=)q9JZ@Ha_*9uMCLHE
42V@*6_gAbfkEI.007PR/Rlqq8gjH$eUD'k_cLsiFQsZ(giC_-&k?=$\EQH*$OBEF
hQ4Ac[N&8Y+\4ND2KlL"kqde/=/muN"WO%lN@rI&) 'LeE$$B(YBs'R9<*3uTSE2qT
[qfAOL&kdYiOcn&e=VSjMe2S'\r AIGmZq A
AOnfG.ZVpL(?;fmm3[h AqGZB;q'MXX+
)eu2'[S]k\*1,Q*Q_WR$XBe\OVnhD.cKOtacS3pMhFO] "FDVF6,@'fCp, []S2ppJ>
/[,Utk2]ncdKcs2W:F*t2j [Jo$O&VlR] .?TRN\g.CFV17hR+qclj4D$_6P) l<ZXc7
pr89 ["?9<GcY2-UUIBF7eaoOSOLYpOJ(tt13Y"O*EPie6T$a\Z'$Xuf I=hjOB8S>8
J&<ms&DSouHla3H8(S)') "S'&G(H7Ln A%a3kl#Kp9/e;Y;:%OS'/Ta-e8:L@ArZLg
?l$T$-ncB; 6fVI .lqq: (?oukSo* /Uf9d=Q. Lbg] 8T, ,bFBU\>4XhEHZE" S7tP4; ba
dgQbI=t#NlSJhYK9WJ[u@njq8M#b>WbgACIOlaU:doRX. (lNk_2/\hTIEJkVY)M+(
'V. %YV+9 'URlNO=hZ A2C7e$;SqAJ"4W#CVkO (Zh) <2'A>O=lLF'cD31?P L@/@:=?%
ilbO] #&\> (1 r3olo I : MrEVlnLNZ91TS*%Gi.DO\ 3j "Wb ['GO]4V\fe (lI>FAf
kGBSMR=\A 2NU]aL@ib6g\Y=:V61lH/k'JW-h'dOJlhW#WbOR&AC') 'TEV"R"\=@C
;Z9"%Q#-gf=V&DOQU7UU'/SoUSJOIOSIBS;BbJLB2@sT;]U3cAbc$WPY/>DaQrh[3
&>s:nd:e)JGFF2UAB'r/=mTfa,3MY-a7)sa'L"bh9t'Z6QK,c/V,S&h:lS9PMgg9N
=TB'*s"6Pi?JAZ#cRkWglqV1q3ndD(SBe>67A)OqP"'kt],UtLllRU#M&\pW+GCkk
CMJNM)N_VVk[*Q_'%r>pjd@M/kT#SG'+E;b%pEJA<*lb%#2)lVjlqdX*\Ur%i1)'F
6SI\qPc&,/*,%;ua'Hh;EFPWu:io"?l@NCr7D<VeUlqo"VU-s]nG'XfrK\kcBjOK?
3hWB/liLi9&/G: '$nBnElctbeEBC$EAj*A?kA>:P_&==*)A,S [M9blS A8 [Arf$?+g
<Sja@8[aE)?OP?#Pu2d'$JoqA ZZ =b8.SZj&gI\cg7"h_Z)bCNl?a+P81E/QB8KV=D
+h&(IdAO*O>Oo(h"iAC?OLIg-" [i: lW-19ic\=HAhXBSl%A- E-,=@RRSliNH:qgPl
,&KCmSfLjLf8mqi:U<1<fmXUR7\A F *g8_sdoSKLt'R+6c(9jQ./h>M AeX&UKpS*A a
FQ*I-k%cl=Cb3U&>Z*BZ,pWB\?j) :3r'g' [I&f69TWRu[Q9-#[G& T[&Iu#OY:BB<
lEBul'JRSQ#3f*Q) [nn/T?q] iI'SFcbY&jsrSBNBN8$0"M%d@6Qa~-18>A&%D&AO(
A
KZZ8+_FM'.11IF +YUCo+/_3M*C9WOAVB\Ipn'O*-+8THj6k8DjsgPO)d'tujOldJ
9&t8,7)*69]Ct9F'%M@F*&.<ZWd@@nZ'K/YQUCu6-#+@p/LB\h@;MDce(nlm2XC=Y
4_"qi;P.MG9]A,=lU;OfeA%XodT]%]SsT, '7S#'iU9LU&9UM'3Nu;f4hn9gW9bY*4
Page 39 of43
�ARMS Email System
DOq4:]Vm*7qbBA@,P=.UOM1=]HG4YS*90;l_gl'23cStXI2Bg_3/A1u#)<Ci>,aMN
&*mhb. lrHroYh6nlMGDRRngie?ATb'&(Zs"dHr"he96X@\@'\A 2pgR$AJKqsLgCYG
A
HQqLZQ's, >mW(ThF Aqq6AwC"P(Y11V>$UKSp a3 (p?BuON AhuVO(D1oLA,HZD=Cm
rf<:*FAVS'@SU)lK,@cuIBsgP+p,%/'@.olI\RJt]BJ,HjdY1k7:]6Ng\]='J$9]i
iaiX[-7R\c&,2e+cCV@kF<*$.ouCr"7qU[jHeLB*O/"A s ; h7$e3W7eUfm9%G'Sa1
-VJ3JD?OM'Gr@qs6>EMe*vdsurIDf(C+9L3<./24'=$ey?L:Q-D4>Emn#V>TDX,&%
,EO;Y(kMUWOHoR'FNk$I>:bEHm1_?ALLt8[BoRa([d%8NTY]$3r83%MF4nWe2A8U3
1BK,KG' :z);ag)pYU$+8X=]H;Kth:J?&b8@<W12oj#@t7h)AOz 'qp8b1mRI<2mG[d
'@6Nq])rN9Y?\@$_l&WSmSECK8#Ph_nZ\,GApfKqnb<e80YX%Dr2]U&$Kkok#=VJ;
A
qL-WoN7'/S:,g&tOpe A6jcA178&qi)eL#@IE Tm]]KO"G&.i7VkM'l_Qi/X4»aX+
%]O-:<OQ$OCp\Il#TNV1T&r.-%Wj8*;O*,"-2R?B\mY=2C]lK#83AF6L7\Tj1ogK
]?mC@&de4pYc\3ZM.,6FG_V*,jbP<cbn8TL'1'a7ec/OOOG'C9m)cfEC6NAn_QQWZ
NU@'R<\nmj2%W'EVdj&WI]GI08e=Sk:Fdhd2<'qgK%m3?"eg1L<@P_Z=/-3M%am4S
+M*h T(i,,#,#A'@'?Nfr1Y39J>rSM<MbO:fScS.THb7qf14[RO"m1,9&SU1hHQfEL
A
AaZ %987 [Qd[(4#SCW%cSFI-X,7D+7SpZVLX)c)u$b6bLX2;t 9rg=7* /:kb$W=c<6
MH_iZU&+@&,%\A\"2tuSgQ\?p/ed800SS[;#*smo04w><d42/%<'>cn*tQg'H$OM,
V-1o/Xnd$[+Sb"9[DS(GHii9<RV[)L'Nof]k28C,=Fhbb46.Z.X:u(HOOIRQiVY<W
au8$m AWk AZ.4\Sa3s'@UF=g%/Q3+=bqO;j,VhQgp/AOZ[b3"c ch<"jn\W) :RVlU
Mh+jPWX@W?' "RkGB38 [1' 348 la$W67W3M\BHMQJiNQP. (H?*' <FY1UnK@;m-Zt1AD
%E'>6[, [uQ*31iW+#SZ_lMa7E7a?]2a"bH_h8&Q]B?pL3p38eP+&rJsDkWUp7sV;N
?@YiUH?[pDiJ?O%BH*Ps6NPfL,%IaKKC'lqWH>Vd1XA2CS?/\?YOUCY/JGY; lJSV
;@FaemS3rk@M8et+@n: [Sg;coenS>#JouTY?Hu#=;tY3]p3Q11 ApL2 jFJbWITJ90J
gg)3i_.gdZep/$OleU6[S\'kAJI7S8d06#, ($ue:B]ehA6+g'Yl (?@2/97'4gU/9,
hfX] *BSLAsk-+kJh) 'RmAM;78#MKZtoK_:d"8I;A [lKVQ'D<$n$'*i6i [2 dP.pRrp
A
j+g]e&KViqTS,]2-Qk3 lB%S<.OEq+\lglQr*A1 YX )jj3L80;c/D",OS>mB7k1f.#
G11HhOY6VHlr@+q)8P\lUK/l$'Q1I]+SX[BRUq;GK2I/\._'o#;X-DbmrtAln_n6=
A
>YHk*I3+p-o:S\R%m<.omGYf.6W&)K['08@Sd8PAE"TNo ';HaU[C'''B\Ou?_9»Y
g$CM#s,-lNQ<&=a3dEEMi>o$s4AP/'JPZ$9fi=NH/:1IBOLKnW&[CIV3#3a.Dg&:e
A
'b(lU$*>AbS1)i4/rZ@O/O)8G:ktf_EGCS6RHbS;A<%KSJ3CS<XSuX1 (Hpt%UEd7
4p1q] [;lB<_Kq&a-SB,lL<a#G] 'WHV) Ma-/m2L) n\lq>O&u3u'b1oFolurB lHO>qN
Wu82N:=7nBmTDG/cfic"o.)I2L2/u;dCmNH;o.SB08P$RqNV,4A-4:1E2KS7)-OUY
21?S<:3 P 9)1%mA\<"(B1fJI'9#4'6N2,WN?f'7/[)@sanJA]F(-3"KSm +*'c3%
rm+":" (A<"S\W@C3X=mJ4nJiQ[ogF*AaM] )n%CqK;MO +PBF\D [-1 'gA, Iak) 1 6
WD61F&Tb81=Y_6W@'NZE",$WM<4ZkODjjVAbcsnhBB?~<»7K7AU)S34A)cZbm897
rkl9D.;u?8Mht=lB'p%4Umod\3bSj_Ui>I>$;c/Q6c_20i88fgG3\//"s4"p01N[9
4]h<piL9YR@+64b*Ncb9/b=f8JN7BWqFC=J@ljJN[<hWr-$,BK\flFrXqWTu07ESJ
KRAJ20#[N]Vp')#?f ALHN<&+N<kA)am?V YLsEe+S;$%FL3] : 641htM$KO -UH@H
/a@JVr; [R-9'RhSFpC1j-?SM_kJhL AXMS4SM9X9lcoGmfQid*ak11FV=@:-IqBGu(
A
\Bt .4;lSCdmO]pAh?tYYhca_3LXZ7m"ZB/O*MC/o1'hd$2+-SaXSPc @=na4;c4_
m@;NCBAcC$'$'i#L?9u'2Vm8urLWViNGtUUOJ%ujR'C/jU:@dqZmmL8=EmZpgTS$6
=4#V.YdWQm[11cCAG48r*O'iYLNg]SFeQ40h[)_*YP?W@>:p+b*J"3XHFOKS&73Q*
A
OH*JH7)PKSfua+"9M] 3?N82ke6S [u'k%F"co1n42/USRE_?F <-QEE f4/++RNn+r4
H)/EuLd[$DKXfYG@F[WL"lEV/=3D9gI@s]VSBKhcGns<bPoOF/3=Do[1]+'Z"KMhC
7441WXq'&qAG+8me6SkH)CK&CX1sNWoIJ=OESODuZmm':Xa]oO+TkF#$&#nOe3@G6
>8'Q,o#qr@rdW7)D+X\9C@ HFo AlrB\dAafBLg6?n?GUJ=tJ,OjFS,,*A Yg )YWV/A
;'NFAk#G#S@R%-IaU,2fY8YgA-m?G2apT=q%?*A.R<A98'POBZY<@jqPn?f4116T$
'2]_@_4bZc;aLP,\CO.;'+Gt1X*u43#Le:@6(V,R=?O+K7N]G:=/6U:?WeRD,7N@'
*Y30p]q3f(F-_>(?c*ch4uB"q(>3:ZiDd_\I[<m_n'1<GN:%B@'@H+LknH1smG$A$
+LMSY1Blo%>i\Y+,j2.f/<ONC>tnM>B@6NJO*+GUq>D=lTV X[*Dl'mUX7Gd&Gp#<
>li(X&REPq$309$3SnB)&V]/o*6) [d,NmF=S;u8M#2)Kr?CI/8%PE)lH*<AAeeSR%
V)6PYBhaW,m'SStrFD.j#9*$9D/e\W AD&sE AS2Z$V':6"2FT2k'CO@P lSA\7&+)?
qIlVJHei2MW2A\HRXe23VEUA'"p#nIf;9dkiISg7%n/s86*"OJI?XT]SZ'S';jR1
196eWbBmr,rSpZLOm$l?MUh'+TQ@YMb;g6]NMT3$UAccW4R8'U3G+&=JBQV$&"6';
s/f9LB:#q$j;n8:G AXOk?Brq&@MEbAeR@@4qGq#OS?sMkH3rcCKXTH, [.eB'/$%"C
,Rp[HhMY:e"qh-g*'Z_jYf=.D*%Z=Ak$60kL.T>G'V$P/>YR2?C7fp<%UX1HSF4nj
g.Ti3ag$j4f-s"PT4-CCG=s>:YE[S$.?&XAR_O-N6;jYo'L8j,;HX=7<UsMK(#]c'
A
U$' .L"ro\bR'@6_7S>\48gW%8UkXq/GLjHGgX:ilrqGH?]BfZf(p [k:F-TH)R+,E
A#V['B.EALpk4.rYN[_t1COEdtk
*Jgjic/(LTA; (mlIX6'nkk&?l,W[RJIsJsZWct
E&80q&dj87jq&7"gq;bG_G1MF&lk[(IjRk01"h-M,=JuBJ>hn#pkL1[; "X7B=jM<*
A
A
P1]Q=Z\moQ.P2 %Gb'47, ,QqS'20P9rKn*+&m(c7 [s"8Kbr/.L*ba. Qm>fOf$,Q:
Page 40 of43
�ARMS Email System
Erg=T'pemRY(72Y4mefC<&,W?B>tTSM?ST%+pK#VaW+\S.30R;+»ZqRX-R(gEB-Q
c(ptt04Q'?c$f+U"Oq*4A.YAGiBGtef%JSo+"e"2UhTT,A F@\*)hUO3 (7elq16+Rs
.4 \OHI#' it3 - ?JIEN6qtSs I 6H) K/Rc$6: #G#+>Snjp<2Q\>qQRi02 ' : a \ [j K, 'BH [A
amp\i7cdaNgKOF"IJEQ,%#[03%#%oM->Vc_k#6gcJOK;'kEom-AZe] .cl<*'Ab%h2
A
Q)FE%.OT_Km+o6$liH='V4C\+QBtLESi_K)?6oI :B:aj9tSY\SI[p@F%6dI9: (&s
rP'122pAlfnouNXqa-JOlkOselcS\umgbOW@T:d9#%IVL9T>a(2dJ,dDM'@SJEtH2
-7El jD'q@\BM'Y'Z,iiLE>?3VqW$1 [PB ?$oBGMISkVS4>MO<#a20Bq74dQG(7T .
. JRRTC*Sqj'J\<O#?FrJ'VN6h9@<A co j/&DB3ke\rp<dAkTXiPBSlto[ttg@?mm?S322X: lISEN) R" Z%EN6Q. &=ef "RK##7 (p: B] - 'JE=VNa%*B- $GDB" /S; KSEec' &h@
BdPjE_gaaLZpf*P]m6p\pKu67T,pCg"W-lP>tb6nW4,m%'BSpBRAejcY] (c(=.:..OPO
i2*E]J4>XW*=ql&-F.k9'WDL.VYKt*TNpS:*\iE@V<rS/,41Hc*KDB<Lmc.j>-RSs
/unhgDO"rDS<?UteH9*T(B)EI;bBmn6,rUgSHtb?ra*gkT>-EH<$gKmro%Y+\?,at
lGkKb->
endstream
endobj
27 0 obj
«
/Type /FontDescriptor
/Ascent 737
/CapHeight 722
/Descent -20S
/Flags 27B642
/FontBBox [-20S -2S0 1147 991 ]
/FontName /NewCenturYSchIbk-Boldltalic
/ItalicAngIe -16
/StemV ISO
/XHeight 477
»
endobj
3 0 obj
«
/Type /page
/Parent 11 0 R
/Resources 6 0 R
/Contents S 0 R
/Thumb 4 0 R
»
endobj
12 0 obj
«
/Type /Page
/Parent 11 0 R
/Resources IS 0 R
/Contents 14 0 R
/Thumb 13 0 R
endobj
19 0 obj
«
/Type /page
/Parent 11 0 R
/Resources 22 0 R
/Contents 21 0 R
/Thumb 20 0 R
»
endobj
11 0 obj
«
/Type /Pages
/Kids [3 0 R 12 0 R 19 0 R ]
Page 41 of43
�ARMS Email System
Page 42 of43
/Count 3
/MediaBox [0 0 612 792 1
»
endobj
31 0 obj
«
/Type /Catalog
/Pages 11 0 R
»
endobj
32 0 obj
«
/CreationDate (D:19980317163416)
/Producer (Acrobat Distiller 2.1 for Windows)
»
endobj
xref
o 33
0000000000
0000000017
0000000182
0000128580
0000000736
0000001671
0000003643
0000008885
0000008973
0000010039
0000011112
0000128897
0000128683
0000003788
0000004704
0000006805
0000008794
0000012052
0000013125
0000128790
0000006977
0000007654
0000008635
0000014068
0000048251
0000090798
0000091011
0000128355
0000014284
0000048480
0000091236
0000129003
0000129060
trailer
65535
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
00000
f
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
n
«
/Size 33
/Root 31 0 R
/Info 32 0 R
/ID [<2cbec7a33813ef79d9d77c38c6dc4ee5><2cbec7a33813ef79d9d77c38c6dc4ee5>1
»
startxref
129167
�ARMS Email System
Page 43 of43
%%EOF
================== END ATTACHMENT
1
==================
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[04/16/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 098 - Folder 006
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/c62aea06c0426e2fc0115a17546586b5.pdf
e5077a94d3b3b3c8563d92487d52e46a
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 098 - FOLDER -005
[03/26/1998-04/15/1998]
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL- (NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN:Donna L. Geisbert/OU:OPD/O:EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-MAR-1998 09:33:30.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN:Cynthia A. Rice/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN:Christopher C. Jennings/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN:Peter R. Orszag/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN:Gene B. Sperling/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN:Barry J. Toiv/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN:Barbara D. Woolley/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN:Donald H. Gips/O:OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN:Jeanne Lambrew/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN:Thomas L. Freedman/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN:Charles F. Stone/OU:CEA/O:EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN:Joshua Gotbaum/OU:OMB/O:EOP @ EOP[ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN:Sherman G. Boone/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN:Bruce R. Lindsey/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN:Emily Bromberg/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN:Toby Donenfeld/O:OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN:Jerold R. Mande/OU:OSTP/O:EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN:Mary L. Smith/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN:Elena Kagan/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP
[ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Sat ish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: weinstein_dena
READ: UNKNOWN
weinstein_dena @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: PANERALI K
READ: UNKNOWN
PANERALI K
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Melissa M. Murray ( CN=Melissa M. Murray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having the Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting today, March 26, at
2:45pm in Room 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP [ CEQ 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-MAR-1998 12:48:11.00
SUBJECT:
Climate Change,
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Forrister d
READ: UNKNOWN
Forrister d @ btgcinema.com @ inet
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Rosina M. Bierbaum ( CN=Rosina M. Bierbaum/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leon S. Fuerth ( CN=Leon S. Fuerth/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nelson W. Cunningham ( CN=Nelson W. Cunningham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Monica M. Dixon ( CN=Monica M. Dixon/o=oVp @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roger S. Ballentine ( CN=Roger S. Ballentine/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
[ OPD 1 )
. TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�,.
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: T J. Glauthier ( CN=T J. Glauthier/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nelson Reyneri ( CN=Nelson Reyneri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal ( CN=Fred DuVal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Tuesday, March 31 - from 9:15-11:15 a cast of several will offer a
briefing to all comers on Climate Change in the Indian Treaty Room.
As you know - this is an issue of interest to the President and Vice
President and we are offering some of the finest briefers we have in house
to inform you (and yours - all interested permanent staff are invited)
about the science of climate change, the history of the issue, our
economic analysis, domestic and diplomatic actions following Kyoto and
information about the White House's role.
Come hear Todd Stern, Katie McGinty, Dirk Forrister, Rosina Bierbaum and
more.
You'll be glad you did.
please note - the invitation can be extended to others in your shop.
Cabinet agency Chiefs of Staff and those who cover the issue in their
agency are also invited (through Cabinet Affairs) .
people not in the complex who need clearance can call the White House
Climate Change Task Force to give their information (ask for Mary or Lisa
343-1060) .
If you have questions - call Kris Balderston (or me) .
Page 2 of2
�Page 1 of2
J<ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. FernandesjOU=OPDjO=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:26-MAR-1998 14:43:49.00
SUBJECT:
IMMIGRATION WORKING GRP. MEETING -- CANCELLED
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael BrainardjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. HanrattyjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ricardo M. Gonzales ( CN=Ricardo M. GonzalesjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. weinerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leanne A. Shimabukuro ( CN=Leanne A. ShimabukurojOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: LETTS K ( LETTS K
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: WARNATH S
READ: UNKNOWN
@
A1
WARNATH_S
@
@
CD
A1
@
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CD
@
(NSC)
LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(CPC)
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. BondjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria EchavestejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jim Kohlenberger ( CN=Jim KohlenbergerjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet MurguiajOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Doris O. Matsui ( CN=Doris O. MatsuijOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. parkerjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. MertensjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. JacobyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. SchroederjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. MatlackjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�,0
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Victoria A. Lynch ( CN=Victoria A. Lynch/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The immigration working group meeting set for 3:00pm today is cancelled.
will reschedule for next week.
Thanks.
Julie
�~
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 4
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-MAR-1998 12:50:52.00
SUBJECT:
Changes to Daschle Bill on Equal Pay
TO: Amy N. Finkelstein ( CN=Amy N. Finkelstein/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles M. Brain ( CN=Charles M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=william P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Carr ( CN=Susan M. Carr/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janelle E. Erickson ( CN=Janelle E. Erickson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jess A. Gupta ( CN=Jess A. Gupta/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�• ARMS Email System
Page 2 of4
We met with Daschle's staff yesterday, and they pretty much agreed to the
changes we proposed. Attached is a draft of our proposed changes.
The
changes are essentially the following:
.
1.
We are removing the data collection section (Sec. 4),
and replacing it with a Sense of the Senate to be placed at the end of the
bill that recognizes the need to collect data.
This sense of the Senate
does not reference any particular agency, form, or method of collecting
the data.
2.
The Department of Justice proposed some new language in
the Findings (Sec. 2)
3.
The Federal Government will be exempt from punitive
damages.
Under Title VII and other fair employment statutes, punitive
damages are not available in actions against the united States.
4.
Also we need to look into ways to reference funding, if
at all, in Section 8. Remember that Sec. 5 on training; Sec. 6 on
Research, Education, and Outreach; and Sec. 7 on the Award are still in
the bill.
There is no proposed language drafted on this yet.
OMB could
you all provide some input on this.
We are supposed to provide any changes to Daschle's staff by COB today.
Please get any comments to me this afternoon.
If you do not have a copy
of the Daschle bill, please let me know and I can get you a copy.
FYI -- The event is tenatively scheduled for 2 p.m. on Thursday, April 2,
with the Vice President.
;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;; ATTACHMENT
1 ;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D9] MAIL40428458A. 026 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750435A050000010A020100000002050000004912000000020000A52EA7B4E48B8F048A4568
2CEBBE11A8A57CC253E43D5E8C3C7EBC6DD2B6EOD06C55EFE7F21D54738D4B87871A6565337B90
F8942DFCE6CCE9241BEFA53CD41A4D2544E5F2DA624AFC7C80D261835D6BOEACC9729D66D28B89
OC7FOC36D187E2539533CAODD9803E3BE3054544594C637F53735FF64A054AFBFDBABC94C5803E
330153D623A6FC14E2078374E920CBCEC057FOB18F48FB05D96530lA592C857E7A2405CFD21D76
EEE302AOC92393C49AA1D47B2D771D2B1C591926E2AD7EAAA1E5BA9F65F7B22F56484DD21C8DED
B31475796D09EF56FFEE2AEB1743B1F71DOEBC98D67840F2B5799EC973160D127DF403E26392EO
B948E23718083EB62F4ACE8E0457EA616EAF5B565ABF6D4E1F056AFB40FF4B0170665431603E89
68E2B742F4EB4DF8E1A223E54448C6385CF4D7CAOA9CA36C041C96A99COD695D46B23D440669AE
9F9B4710F22660B1055907CB91E57D7F2F8AD9C909ADOA23A365D9E998324FA1A3B087E316CC88
D390111B80CC0125B6BEF404622A69AD95467D0889A73905AE853FEC5D7FB93B3C54FDFA7C3818
917326DE6C2BOE44ECBD23473F667A3BC1633542CA510E9BD2D9BC367F830C4463A8B640A17E27
5B43CE612BB458CF63EODFC8A2BD845E9C60F2E163069A3C947D35ABDEAAB35A087F4BF83D7C6D
EFA49D710902000D00000000000000000000000823010000000B010000B6020000005505000000
4EOOOOOOC1030000092501000000060000000F0400000B30020000002800000015040000087701
000000400000003D040000083401000000140000007D0400000802010000000F00000091040000
08050100000008000000A004000000000000000000000000A00400000055020000003COOOOOOA8
04000000550300000028000000E40400000055010000004EOOOOOOOC05000000984C006F006300
61006C0020004800500020004C0061007300650072006A00650074002000350000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOO
000000C800C8002C012C012C012C01C800C8003000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000009000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000B0100002800D61EC30F3908000011090000
005AOOOB01008B143600540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E
00200052006500670075006C006100720000000000000000000100020058020100000004002800
000000000000000000000000000000000000011202002400A1000000A10000000AOOOOOOB40001
�Auromsreo Recoros
Hex·D Management S
Proposed Changes to Daschle's Bill on Pay Equity
ump Conversion ystem
Sec. 2. Findings
Para. (2): Revise to read, "Even in the 1990s, women earn significantly lower pay than men
for work on jobs that require equal skill, effort,and responsibility and that are performed
under similar working conditions. These pay disparities exist in both the private and
governmental sectors. In many instances, the pay disparities can only be due to continued
intentional discrimination or the lingering effects of past discrimination."
Para. (3): Add a subparagraph reading, "in many instances, may deprive workers of equal
protection on the basis of sex in violation of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments"
Para. (4)(B): Add two subparagraphs, "remedying the effects of past discrimination on the
basis of sex and ensuring that in the future workers are afforded equal protection on the
basis of sex" and "in the private sector, ensuring equal protection pursuant to Congress'
power to enforce the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments"
Para. (5): Revise to read, "With increased information about the provisions added by the
Equal Pay Act of 1963 and generalized wage data, along with more effective remedies,
women will
be better able to recognize and enforce their rights to equal pay for work on jobs that
require equal skill, effort, and responsibility and that are performed under similar working
conditions.
Sec. 3. Enhanced Enforcement of Equal Pay Act Requirements
Subsection (3)(a)(I): revise by adding, "; except that the United States shall not be liable
for punitive damages." after "appropriate"
Section 4 regarding collection of data will be removed from the bill and a Sense of the
Senate will be added at the end of the bill:
SEC. xxx
SENSE OF SENATE REGARDING INCREASED INFORMATION ON PAY
DISPARITIES
It is the Sense of the Senate that the President should take appropriate steps to increase the
amount of information available with respect to wage disparities. In so doing, the President, or
his designees, should consider ways of collecting this data that:
(1) maximize the utility of the information for both the government and the public; while
(2) protecting individuals' privacy and minimizing the burdens on reporting entities.
�;. ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-MAR-1998 16:48:31.00
SUBJECT:
Meeting With The Eisenhower Foundation re: The Eisenhower Report
TO: Gene B. Sperling
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lin Liu ( CN=Lin Liu/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: sjarvis ( sjarvis @ gwis2.circ.gwu.edu @ inet [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter Rundlet ( CN=Peter Rundlet/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD']
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: John M. Goering ( CN=John M. Goering/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TEXT:
Judith Winston has requested that each of you be invited to a meeting with
representatives from the Eisenhower Foundation to discuss the Eisenhower
Report. The meeting will occur on Tuesday, April 14, 1998 @ 2:00 - 4:00
)
�.• ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
in the PIR Conference Room (Rm. 3236).
Lynn Curtis of the Eisenhower Foundation, which issued the Millenium
Breach report commemorating the 30th Anniversary of the Kerner Commission
Report,
requested this meeting with Judy Winston and WH officials to
discuss the report findings and its policy recommendations.
please let me know, via e-mail, if you will be able to attend.
and have a wonderful day!! :)
Thank you
�\~
.,. ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 1-APR-1998 18:38:29.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
()
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
)
)
)
)
�• ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:00am in room 100. Thanks.
�,.
fA
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert
( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 2-APR-1998 09:41:29.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�,. ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
"
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
haverkamp_jennifer @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
CC: Melissa M. Murray ( CN=Melissa M. Murray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. Pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: PANERALI K
READ: UNKNOWN
PANERALI K
@
Al
@
CD
@
@
EOP [. OMB 1 )
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ:UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Peter A. weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having the Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting today, April 2, at
2:45 in Room 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 5
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 2-APR-1998 18:18:48.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to MO/IL
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian v. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [.WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason.S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ:UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
~
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby.E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/Ou=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shel,ley N. Fidler /OU=CEQ/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ CEQ 1 )
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�·.
ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Tuesday, April 7, 1998, the President will travel to Kansas City,
Missouri to attend a Social Security Regional Conference, during which he
will deliver remarks and participate in a panel discussion at Penn Valley
Community College.
That evening, he will proceed to Chicago, Illinois,
where he will attend a Democratic Business Council Dinner.
On Wednesday,
April 8, the President will participate in a school construction event
before returning to Washington.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
MO & IL Background Memos:
DUE MON., APR. 6, AT 6:00 P.M.
Political Memos
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
Economic One-Pager
MO & IL Event Memos:
DUE MON., APR. 6, AT 6:00 P.M.
Social Security Remarks
Satellite Address
Panel Discussion
DBC Dinner
School Construction Event
please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 3
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-APR-1998 11:35:25.00
SUBJECT:
Meeting With The Eisenhower Foundation reo The Eisenhower Report
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Rebecca M. Blank
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lin Liu ( CN=Lin Liu/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: sjarvis ( sjarvis @ gwis2.circ.gwu.edu @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter Rundlet ( CN=Peter Rundlet/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John M. Goering ( CN=John M. Goering/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jonathan E. Smith ( CN=Jonathan E. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of3
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Please be advised that the Presidential Conversation on Race is scheduled
to occur on April 14, 1998. Therefore, the meeting with the Eisenhower
Foundation has been rescheduled.
It will occur on Thursday, April 16,
1998 @ 2:00 - 4:00 in the PIR Conference Room (Rm. 3236).
please mark your calendars accordingly and let me know via e-mail whether
or not you will be able to attend.
Please accept my apology for any
inconvenience this change may cause you.
Thank you and have a wonderful
day.
---------------------- Forwarded by.Marjorie A. Black/PIR/EOP on 04/06/98
11:18 AM ---------------------------
Marjorie A. Black
03/30/98 04:48:33 PM
Record Type:
Record
TO:
See the distribution list at the bottom of this message
cc:
See the distribution list at the bottom of this message
Subject:
Meeting With The Eisenhower Foundation reo The Eisenhower Report
Judith Winston has requested that each of you be invited to a meeting with
representatives from the Eisenhower Foundation to discuss the Eisenhower
Report.
The meeting will occur on Tuesday, April 14, 1998 @ 2:00 - 4:00
in the PIR Conference Room (Rm. 3236).
Lynn Curtis of the Eisenhower Foundation, which issued the Millenium
Breach report commemorating the 30th Anniversary of the Kerner Commission
Report,
requested this meeting with Judy Winston and WH officials to
discuss the report findings and its policy recommendations.
Please let me know, via e-mail, if you will be able to attend.
and have a wonderful day!! :)
Thank you
Message Sent
To: __________~--~--~------------------------------------------------John M. Goering/PIR/EOP
Lin Liu/PIR/EOP
Elena Kagan/OPD/EOP .
Julie A. Fernandes/OPD/EOP
Maria Echaveste/WHO/EOP
Minyon Moore/WHO/EOP
Peter Rundlet/WHO/EOP
Rebecca M. Blank/CEA/EOP
Sidney Blumenthal/WHO/EOP
Gene B. Sperling/OPD/EOP
sjarvis @ gwis2.circ.gwu.edu @ inet
Message Copied
�ARMS Email System
TO:~~________~__~~__________________________________________
Marjorie Tarmey/WHO/EOP
Peter A. Weissman/OPD/EOP
Francine P. Obermiller/CEA/EOP
Angelique Pirozzi/WHO/EOP
Laura Emmett/WHO/EOP
Page 3 of3
�" ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-APR-1998 18:55:33.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to KY
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newrnan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�· ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: .Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�" ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian v. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell
READ:UNKNOWN
( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP
[ CEQ 1 )
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�" ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=ShelleyN. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. €hang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�,. ARMS Email System
I
Page S ofS
'
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Thursday, April 9, 199B, the President will travel to Northern Kentucky
to participate in a round table discussion on tobacco and deliver remarks
at a local high school.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
Background Memos:
DUE WED., APRIL B, AT 6:00 P.M.
political memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
Economic One-Pager
Event Memos:
DUE WED., APRIL B, AT 6:00 P.M.
Round Table Discussion
Remarks at High School
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�(. ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 8-APR-1998 12:03:36.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg - CANCELLED
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: sylvia M. Mathews ( CN 7 Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�(-ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
cc:
)
Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ:UNKNOWN
)
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett. ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Thursday morning's Women's Mtg is cancelled because of Bella Abzug's
memorial tomorrow morning at the National Press Club [which many will be
attending]. Thanks.
)
)
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 8-APR-1998 15:09:15.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAILARD C @ Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C @ Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
J
Page 2 of2
.
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: MURRAY MM
READ: UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett
READ: UNKNOWN
@
ustr.gov
@
INET
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Jill M. pizzuto
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Jill M. PizzutO/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
TEXT:
We will be having the Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting tomorrow, April 9,
at 2:45 in Room 211, OEOB.
�,.
Page 1 of3
'" ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrea Kane ( CN:Andrea Kane/OU:OPD/O:EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 8-APR-1998 17:15:17.00
SUBJECT:
Latest status of WtW Formula Grants
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN;Diana Fortuna/OU;OPD/O:EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN;Cynthia A. Rice/OU:OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN;Bruce N. Reed/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD ] )
CC: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN:Sanders D. Korenman/OU:CEA/O:EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN;Maria J. Hanratty/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Emil E. Parker ( CN;Emil E. Parker/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
:;:::;;::;:::;;::;;; ATTACHMENT
1 ;;;;;::;;:;;;;;;:;;;
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D98]MAIL454686799.026 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043A6050000010A02010000000205000000740C000000020000F31EC61D57F81DC9947F8E
389401166E84771BF53B81E262EB3BA2DBC9EOB9E1592ADODCB88F6EE2FAFE7112A9C96206D22F
B4DAE79E4AF8729A3973FEA2AD57A17A26C8482CB7C55D753DOF044A1F2D375CFE62958B04260C
AOCD1D09D9D37D4E1E451B08AOD8051AE1A757494B8AD275567EF4D8CA8C8FAA010E51122B879C
B1CE60D4AF8C2A9C1DDC142ACEOC577F1F6F25BDFAE883648FD321336DOC760CE311B81F272E76
183197927EECE29322F953D38D471BC4B6AA695FEBDB33373EE4B767E82CAF8EC198AAEOD8A97B
4C8910BB236BF63B1A6FBFA157A550EAB4DA3685EOF4FE2DA5EA31FD33DA0611A356331E75880B
948C2E29BFFAOB243F78D62F8DE91BDE39DE2E871A40E73B4B590EC13FC5ACB397FB2DFB35537E
B7DD40377A03B0549902505F816E6C5EF7CD3DD5BD18FFOEE64DB16625BEA9773D5B7E2483FA74
2926C8F77947CAC204587369704E432FD2630E5DOOOACB209DB301B1628564F990E4A08E1C7166
88725FE48FOE318BEB9A34F09C648803D07DA845469B9E294315D13481276BA4CEOBBA39B2CD24
CD7BADF1F721136A22BA5C9E7BEC86A345D5730AAD89824F0998C5BD1E397B660A043A1A5475C6
94ADD090046E18E8F8E85EB92F2E296B947F5E1CE9466FD23FE19CE17538113F843A33B950319E
D9B2AAB53F02000D00000000000000000000000823010000000B010000B6020000005508000000
4EOOOOOOC1030000092501000000060000000F0400000B30030000002800000015040000005502
0000003A0000003D0400000208000001002F0000007704000000550700000028000000A6040000
08770100000040000000CE040000083401000000140000000E0500000802010000000F00000022
05000002080100000031000000310500000B3003000000440000006205000000984C0061007300
650072004A006500740020003400200070006C007500730020002800440065006600610075006C
007400290000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOO
000000C800C8002C012C012C012C01C800C8003000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
�,.
.
Welfare-to-Work Formula Grant Status
5 States announced 1/29/98:
IL, LA,MI,NE,NV
$122M
2 States announced 2/19:
$32.6 M
MA,SC
3 States announced 3/2:
KA,HI,MN
$26.3 M
2 States announced 3/30:
MO,TN
$40 M
TOTAL TO DATE: 12 states
$221 M
States with pending plans:
KY (probably week of 4/6)
DE (close)
GA
CA
OH
AR
AL
RI
MT
CO
NC
States indicating they don't plan to apply:
ID, UT, MS (DOL discussing further)
TRIBAL PLANS
26 approved 3/19
$5.8 M
33 approved 4/1
$4.4 M
TOTAL TO DATE: 59
As of4/8/98
$10.2M
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of5
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 10-APR-1998 16 :"43: 30.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to TX
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=CynthiaM. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ('CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O~EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�,.
ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
•
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Tuesday, April 14, 1998, the President will travel to Houston, TX,
where he will tour the Johnson Space Center and participate in a town hall
meeting on sports and race.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
Background Memos:
DUE MON., APR. 13, AT 6:00 P.M.
Political Memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
Economic One-Pager
Event Memos:
DUE MON., APR. 13, AT 6:00 P.M.
Tour of Johnson Space Center
Town Hall Meeting
please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�~
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
<0'
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:15-APR-1998 12:30:45.00
SUBJECT:
RESCHEDULED -- Weekly 'Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: DAlLARD C
READ: UNKNOWN
DAlLARD C
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
(OPD)
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 ),
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MARR_C ( MARR C
READ: UNKNOWN
@
A1
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�~
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
"
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: MURRAY MM
.READ : UNKNOWN
MURRAY MM
@
Al
@
CD
@
VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CC: Satish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan!O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor!O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: haverkamp_jennifer ( haverkamp_jennifer @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto!OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting normally held Thursday at 2:45 will be
held 5:00 on Thursday April 16th.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby ShamirjOU=WHOjO=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE!TIME:15-APR-1998 17:22:09.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia ApuzzojOU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. BlankjOU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie SpectorjOU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes!OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha ScottjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. ThorntonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan!OU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste!OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler!OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland!O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman!OU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston!OU=PIRjO=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin LeedsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. GreenejOU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E.
READ: UNKNOWN
SkeltonjOU~WHOjO=EOP
@ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews!OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon MoorejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. LissjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. LovelljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. LopezjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. BlackjOU=PIRjO=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. GibsonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. KleinjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. TurnerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie TarmeyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. vogel ( CN=Miriam H. VogeljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. ObermillerjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. MeyerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. MohibjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. RabnerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura EmmettjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine ButtonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday morning at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[03/26/1998 – 04/15/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 098 - Folder 005
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/499d8c2ad6ae78f35a7141384fde858e.pdf
01cf89186dfe95b11fd3b5f129e8ea6a
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 098 - FOLDER -004
[02/24/1998-03/25/1998]
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 5
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:24-FEB-1998 09:01:41.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to FL/CA
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J.
READ: UNKNOWN
Reber/OU~CEA/O=EOP @
EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN;Peter R. Orszag/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN;Mary Morrison/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore (. CN;Minyon Moore/OU;WHO/O;EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
[ WHO 1 )
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN;Megan C. Moloney/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN;Andrew J. Mayock/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN;Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN;Ann F. Lewis/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN;Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN;Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: .Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN;Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU;WHO/O;EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN;Phu D. Huynh/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN;Russell W. Horwitz/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN;Jason S. Goldberg/OU;WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN;D. Stephen Goodin/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN;Karen E. Finney/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN;Paul K. Engskov/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN;Maria Echaveste/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN;Brenda B. Costello/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN;Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN;Jose Cerda III/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 3 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul A. Tuchmann ( CN=Paul A. Tuchmann/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver· ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�,ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP
@
EOP [ WHO 1· )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N.
~idler
( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale
CN=Suzanne.Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
I .
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Wednesday, February 25, 1998, the President will travel to central
Florida to survey the recent storm damage. He will then proceed to San
Francisco, California where he will attend a DCCC reception and dinner.
On Thursday, the President will address a technology conference and may
tour certain flood-damaged areas.
On Friday, he will not have a public
schedule. On Saturday, he will attend a dinner for Senator Barbara Boxer
in Los Angeles. On Sunday, he will return to the White House.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
FL & CA Background Memos:
DUE TODAY AT 6:00P.M.
Political Memos
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
FL & CA Event Memos
(WED & THUR):
DUE TODAY AT 6:00 P.M.
Aerial Damage Survey (FL)
Street Walk/Community Meeting (FL)
DCCC Reception
DCCC Dinner
Remarks to Technology Conference
possible Flood Damage Survey
CA Event Memo (SAT):
Senator Boxer Dinner
DUE FRIDAY AT 3:00 P.M.
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN:Cathy R. Mays/OU:OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:24-FEB-1998 14:03:03.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU:OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
"TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU:OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O:EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU:CEA/O:EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN:Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN:Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ OPD 1
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
"
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Melissa M. Murray ( CN=Melissa M. Murray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: weinstein dena
READ: UNKNOWN
weinstein dena @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting on Thursday, February 26,
at 2:45 p.m. in Room 211, OEOB.
�.. ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O~EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:25-FEB-1998 18:35:53.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=E;0P @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @'EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�~
Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO ]- )
cc: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Meeting on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
�Page I of5
"ARMS Email System
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean p, Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-FEB-1998 19:21:28.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to NY
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F, Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B, Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/0l!=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD
i )
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K, Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J, Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�-ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag!OU=OPD!O=EOP@ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�-ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul A. Tuchmann ( CN=Paul A. Tuchmann/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian v. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP .@ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 4 of5
·ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R.
READ: UNKNOWN
Ne~an/OU=WHO/O=EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O~EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�.ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN;Laura K. Capps/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN;Debra'D. Bird/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN;Barbara A. Barclay/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN;Kris M Balderston/OU;WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN;Lori L. Anderson/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Tuesday, March 3, 1998, the President will travel to New York City to
attend Time Magazine's 75th anniversary celebration.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
NY Background Memos:
DUE MONDAY, MAR. 2, AT 6:00 P.M.
Political Memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
NY Event Memo:
DUE MONDAY, MAR. 2, AT 6:00 P.M.
Time Magazine 75th Anniversary
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 5
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 4-MAR-1998 11:49:27.00
SUBJECT:
LABOR Report on HR2327 Drive for Teen Employment Act
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice E. Shuffield ( CN=Alice E. Shuffield/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori Schack ( CN=Lori Schack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne H. Lewis ( CN=Anne H. Lewis/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena. Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 03/04/98
11:44 AM --------------------------Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: MNB117
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Wednesday, March 4, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:.
Reference
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
�ARMS Email System
OMB CONTACT:
SUBJECT:
Page 2 of5
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395-6148
LABOR Report on HR2327 Drive for Teen Employment Act
3:30 p.m.
DEADLINE:
Wednesday, March 4, 1998
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: The Workforce Protections Subcommittee of House Education and
the workforce is scheduled to mark up H.R. 2327 on Thursday at 9:30 a.m.
The deadline is firm.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
117 and 340-TRANSPORTATION - Tom Herlihy - (202) 366-4687
61-JUSTICE - Andrew Fois - (202) 514-2141
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
EOP:
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Debra J. Bond
Lori Schack
Elena Kagan
Karen Tramontano
Anne H. Lewis
OMB LA
Sanders D. Korenman
Daniel J. Chenok
Janet R. Forsgren
LRM ID: MNB117 SUBJECT:
Act
LABOR
Report on HR2327 Drive for Teen Employment
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Melissa N. Benton phone: 395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
(Date)
FROM:
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
DRAFT
The Honorable Cass Ballenger
Chairman
Subcommittee on Workforce Protections
Committee on Economic and Educational
Opportunities
O.S. House of Representatives
Washington, D.C.
20515
Dear Chairman Ballenger:
I am writing to provide you with the views of the Department of Labor on
H.R. 2327.
The Department of Labor is committed to helping this nationD,s youth find
meaningful and productive employment; however, their safety and health
must not be placed at risk by such employment. H.R. 2327 would
substantially weaken existing restrictions on the employment of 16- and
17-year olds in jobs that require driving.
It will increase the
on-the-job driving time of young workers.
The Department is concerned
that the result of this legislation would increase the number of
automobile-related injuries and deaths caused by very young and
inexperienced drivers on the job.
The existing rules governing occupational driving for young workers, set
forth in Hazardous Occupations Order No. 2 (HO 2)', prohibit anyone under
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
the age of 18 from being employed to drive--with limited exception for
"incidental and occasional" driving of automobiles (and trucks weighing
6,000 pounds or less) under certain circumstances. H.R. 2327 would
greatly expand the exemption and allow teenagers--many of whom will have
just been licensed to drive--to spend as much as one-fifth of their
workweek behind the wheel on public roads and highways.
Sixteen and
17-year old youths could be employed to deliver pizzas or to shuttle
passengers to and from hotels, for example, as long as they did not exceed
the 20 percent limitation.
Although we realize that the proposed legislation seeks to reduce the risk
to teen drivers and the public by limiting their driving to a 50-mile
radius, we do not believe this offers sufficient protection.
Statistics
show that 80 percent of fatal accidents occur less than 25 miles from home.
The need to protect young workers in an increasingly fast-paced highly
competitive workplace is as real as when the child labor laws were first
enacted. According to a National Institute for Occupational Safety and
Health (NIOSH) study, automobile crashes are the number one cause of
occupational deaths for 16- and 17-year olds despite the fact that most
occupational driving is prohibited for this age group. At least a third
of all occupational fatalities involving young workers involved driving.
Newly licensed drivers are especially at risk, with higher crash rates
than any other age group. The American Automobile Association, the
National Safety Council and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety
publicly support greater restrictions on teenage driving.
The Department
of Labor is aware of several examples of 16- and 17-year olds injured or
killed while driving.
The Department opposes the legislative changes proposed in H.R. 2327. We
believe that responsible public policy dictates that any modifications to
weaken child labor protections be carefully weighed against the potential
harm to the health and safety of these young workers.
We have heard concerns about the current regulations from those who
advocate more driving by teenage workers. We are looking at the
regulations to determine if there are changes that can be made to
accommodate these concerns without jeapordizing the safety and well-being
of these young workers.
The Office of Management and Budget advises that there is no objection to
the submission of this report to the Congress from the· standpoint of the
AdministrationD,s program.
Sincerely,
Alexis M. Herman
cc: Major Owens, Ranking Minority Member
BILL TEXT:
FILE h2327.ih
HR 2327 IH
105th CONGRESS
1st Session
To provide for a change in the exemption from the child labor
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 for minors
between 16 and 18 years of age who engage in the operation of
automobiles and trucks.
RULE
IN THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
July 31, 1997
Mr. COMBEST (for himself, Mr. GREEN, and Mr. MARTINEZ) introduced
the following bill; which was referred to the Committee on
Education and the Workforce
RULE
A BILL
To provide for a change in the exemption from the child labor
provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 for minors
between 16 and 18" years of age who engage in the operation of
automobiles and trucks.
[Italic->]
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of
Representatives of the United States of America in Congress
assembled, [<-Italic]
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the -Drive for Teen Employment Act'.
SEC. 2. AUTHORITY FOR MINORS TO OPERATE MOTOR VEHICLES.
In the administration and enforcement of the child labor
provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938, the
secretary
of Labor, in implementing the exemption (published at 29 C.F.R.
570.52(b) (1»
for minors between 16 and 18 years of age who
operate
automobiles or trucks not exceeding 6,000 pounds gross vehicle
weight, shall-(1) not allow such operation to exceed 50 miles from the
minor's place of employment; and
(2) not limit the number of such operations but require
that
such operations may not exceed-(A) one third of a minor's work in any work day; and
(B) 20 percent of a minor's work in any workweek.
�t'
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 4-MAR-1998 19:27:49.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews (CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of2
,. ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday morning at 9am in Room 100. Thanks.
�.f
Page 1 of5
• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-MAR-1998 18:28:58.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to CT/OH
TO: Paul A. Tuchmann ( CN=Paul A. Tuchmann/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian v. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP,@ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie'S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of5
., ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN;Elizabeth R. Newman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN;Kevin S. Moran/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN;Linda L. Moore/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN;Anne E. McGuire/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN;Sylvia M. Mathews/OU;WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN;Bruce R. Lindsey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN;Christopher J. Lavery/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN;Karin Kullman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN;Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN;Katherine Hubbard/OU;WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN;Nancy V. Hernreich/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN;Laura A. Graham/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN;Karen E. Finney/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN;Paul K. Engskov/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO.: Maria Echaveste ( CN;Maria Echaveste/OU;WHO/O;EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN;Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN;Jose Cerda III/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN;Emily Bromberg/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 3 of5
"ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beauhaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Br~nda
M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP
CEA 1 )
�~ARMS
Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N.
READ: UNKNOWN
Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�"ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Tuesday, March 10, 1998, the President will travel to Westport,
connecticut to attend a child care event and a Democratic Business Council
luncheon. He will then travel to Cincinnati, Ohio, to attend a DNC dinner.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
CT & OH Background Memos:
DUE MON., MAR. 9, AT 6:00 P.M.
Political Memos
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
CT & OH Event Memos:
DUE MON., MAR. 9, AT 6:00 P.M.
Child Care Event
DBC Luncheon
DNC Dinner
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�,. ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 8
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 11-MAR-1998 10:17:32.00
SUBJECT:
LRM #IMS263 - LABOR Report on HR2377 Temporary Agricultural Worker Act of
TO: vancell@usda.gov ( vancell@usda.gov @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: jonesgre@justice.usdoj.gov@inet ( jonesgre@justice.usdoj.gov@inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice E. Shuffield (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Al~ce
E. Shuffield/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=william P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph G. ·Pipan ( CN=Joseph G. Pipan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Noah Engelberg ( CN=Noah Engelberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: silasadr@justice.usdoj.gov ( silasadr@justice.usdoj.gov @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Charles M. Brain ( CN=Charles M. Brain/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven D. Aitken ( CN=Steven D. Aitken/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: WARNATH S@A1@CD@VAXGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
WARNATH S@A1@CD@VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Evan T. Farley ( CN=Evan T. Farley/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
(CPC)
�Page 2 of8
" ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Darlene o. Gaymon ( CN=Darlene
READ: UNKNOWN
o.
Gaymon/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
CC: Julia E. Yuille ( CN=Julia E. Yuille/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: IMS263
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
washington, D.C. 20503-0001
wednesday, March 11, 1998
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
OMB CONTACT:
SUBJECT:
of 1997
DEADLINE:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
James J. Jukes (for) Assistant Director for Legislative Reference
Ingrid M. Schroeder
PHONE: (202) 395-3883 FAX: (202) 395-3109
LABOR Report on HR2377 Temporary Agricultural Worker Act
2:30pm
Wednesday, March 11,
1998 - TODAY
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: H.R. 2377 is scheduled for markup in the House Judiciary
Subcommittee on Immigration tomorrow - 3.12.98.
Please note that the attached Labor letter contains a veto recommendation
(page 2 last paragraph) .
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
�· ARMS Email System
Page 3 of8
7-AGRICULTURE - Marvin Shapiro - (202) 720-1516
61-JUSTICE - Andrew Fois - (202) 514-2141
114-STATE - Paul Rademacher - (202) 647-4463
76-National Economic Council - SonyiaMatthews - (202) 456-6630
Council of Economic Advisers - Liaison Officer - (202) 395-5084
EOP:
Steven M. Mertens
Debra J. Bond
Larry R. Matlack
Barry White
Barbara Chow
Noah Engelberg
Daniel J. Chenok
Joseph G. Pipan
Evan T. Farley
Julie A. Fernandes
WARNATH S
Elena Kagan
Emil E. Parker
Lael Brainard
Steven D. Aitken
William P. Marshall
Peter G. Jacoby
Alice E. Shuffield
Charles M. Brain
Scott Busby
LRM ID: IMS263 SUBJECT:
Worker Act of 1997
LABOR
Report on HR2377 Temporary Agricultural
RESPONSE TO
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g., concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
FROM:
Ingrid M. Schroeder Phone:
395-3883
Fax:
395-3109
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-3454
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
�.. ARMS Email System
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
No Objection
No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of ______ pages, attached to this response sheet
Honorable Lamar Smith
Chairman, Subcommittee
Immigration and Claims
committee on the Judiciary
House of Representatives
Washington, D.C. 20515
Dear Chairman Smith:
This letter presents the views of the Department of Labor on H.R.
2377, entitled O&Temporary Agricultural Worker Act of 1997.08 This bill
would establish a pilot program to provide another means to bring foreign
workers into the United States to provide temporary or seasonal
agricultural services.
The Department of Labor opposes enactment of H.R. 2377. As the
General Accounting Office (GAO) has recently reported, the existing
temporary foreign agricultural worker program already assures an adequate
and dependable labor supply for agricultural producers, while it seeks to
protect the employment, compensation and working conditions of the U.S.
agricultural labor force.
As with any program, there are difficulties in
implementing the H-2A program.
However, none of these difficulties
require legislation; all can be effectively addressed administratively.
The GAO made several such recommendations that the administering agencies
have agreed to take the necessary steps to implement.
Consistent with the findings and recommendations of two
bi-partisan commissions -- the Commission on Agricultural Workers and the
Commission on Immigration Reform -- the President opposes a new
guestworker program. He has, however, directed that, if efforts to halt
illegal immigration contribute to agricultural labor shortages, the
Departments of Agriculture and Labor should work cooperatively to improve
and enhance existing programs to meet the labor requirements of our vital
agricultural industry consistent with our obligations to American
workers.
The recent GAO report found that O&le supplies of farm labor
appear to be available in most areas,08 although there is some possibility
Page 4 of8
�Page 5 of8
· ARMS Email System
of localized shortages relating to specific crops or geographic areas.
In response to concerns regarding localized shortages, the
Departments of Agriculture and Labor have held discussions under the aegis
of the Domestic Policy Council to determine means of streamlining the
current H-2A program to make it more responsive to the needs of
agricultural producers, and more effective in protecting U.S. workers.
In
addition to changes in the program that respond to GAO recommendations
such as shortening the lead time on submitting H-2A applications from 60
to 45 days, other possible H-2A program changes are being considered that
address issues contained in H.R. 2377. These include reducing the lead
time for completing housing inspections from 30 to 20 days prior to date
of need; providing expedited certification for employers who reduce their
use of H-2A workers by 25 percent or more over the previous year; and
other changes to strengthen worker protections and enforcement.
In view of the PresidentO,s position, the GAOO,s findings and
accepted recommendations, and the cooperative efforts of the Departments
of Agriculture and Labor to develop ways to administratively restructure
the H-2A program, the Administration is strongly opposed to H.R. 2377.
Furthermore, if H.R. 2377 were passed by the Congress and presented to the
President, I would recommend that he veto the bill.
The Office of Management and Budget advises
Sincerely,
Alexis M. Herman====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
o
00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS EXT: [ATTACH.D16]MAIL42490496X.026 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FFS7S0435COB0000010A0201000000020S000000B4190000000200001FEE79SC952844BE6296E7
7EAES8FE12FC49871CFF7E9BBCEAB81F6Dl14495617EE22075471DOF90809E90B58538662197C6
DFBB89C5329B19E1AD8B80ECE1F6S2AS7026F95D56B9FFOD76084E3C882A5016E9D9203E4B29AS
82A7477E9883SFAEOFDC968AIE928BDADC46ES2F6213S2AD3C3EBDEEEOCBDD4S0B1BCFCECS1616
6D1B61C96EFC6ED59EB8BFBB73AC3BECDB04F518D86DD53E46B204OD96D488AD790C9SBE3BD189
1905SFE9CC1D4002791443S206459C91633AC3ECF8273BA7CE6D6E4CE3486SBCC3D4670087B2FC
096F620931226BE02D17A39C3E01E222S5EAIOE95FD8AABD82C7393C58BD6186DD51147AD12D38
C3ADOF97FBDSDAAC5C7CB73517DEB01DS2AE9248B76FF90572657685F11FEECE38D52E12AACASC
BD8962C8EBEBB3DC01S81FF62B2672886C6D6C8D93774196F2F0973BE4S8F6DC9A344ACFSB9197
09D06F7B2D211527E9AC40390EF2DA1628FED84CEEC2275A505242B9341ADA207362C1E3F79BSD
C1722D90371B1CA02A329B48B2BB182F54BBEA1SCCS2A564F3F1CC6B8126C14B64lFS4FFF371FB
7E19A6318F318S4672FF4ECC2474258EC8188F4F4F1S2393326CBCIA934AF5A7537DCD6E8331A4
DF7F74C487D440BB9CB496EDAEOES97EAACA789EAA2EBECE07D8EC2A2F7FA738B47C7305CBAFA9
9A8750B11102001700000000000000000000000823010000000B01000042030000005501000000
4E0000004D040000092S01000000060000009B0400000B300200000028000000A1040000085E01
0000000COOOOOOC904000008770100000004000000DS04000008340100000014000000D9040000
0802010000000FOOOOOOED04000008100100000002000000FC040000096D0100000017000000FE
0400000B3003000000630000001S0S0000080S0100000008000000780S00000B30030000007700
0000800500000B30030000008AOOOOOOF70500000B3003000000AO000000810600000B30030000
00B4000000210700000B3003000000C7000000DS0700000B3003000000DB0000009C0800000B30
03000000EF0000007709000009310100000087000000660A00000931010000006DOOOOOOEDOAOO
00084E01000000020000005AOB000000984800S00020004C00610073006S0072004A006S007400
2000S3006500720069006500730020004900490000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000048S0S0434C00000000000000002C01C8002C012.C012C012C012C
�Honorable Lamar Smith
Chairman, Subcommittee
Immigration and Claims
Committee on the Judiciary
House of Representatives
Washington, D.C. 20515
Automated Records Manage,!,ent System
Hex-Dump ConversIOn
Dear Chairman Smith:
This letter presents the views of the Department of Labor on H.R. 2377, entitled
"Temporary Agricultural Worker Act of 1997." This bill would establish a pilot program to
provide another means to bring foreign workers into the United States to provide temporary or
seasonal agricultural services.
The Department of Labor opposes enactment ofH.R. 2377. As the General Accounting
Office (GAO) has recently reported, the existing temporary foreign agricultural worker program
already assures an adequate and dependable labor supply for agricultural producers, while it
seeks to protect the employment, compensation and working conditions of the U.S. agricultural
labor force. As with any program, there are difficulties in implementing the H-2A program.
However, none of these difficulties require legislation; all can be effectively addressed
administratively. The GAO made several such recommendations that the administering
agencies have agreed to take the necessary steps to implement.
Consistent with the findings and recommendations of two bi-partisan commissions -- the
Commission on Agricultural Workers and the Commission on Immigration Reform -- the
President opposes a new guestworker program. He has, however, directed that, if efforts to halt
illegal immigration contribute to agricultural labor shortages, the Departments of Agriculture and
Labor should work cooperatively to improve and enhance existing programs to meet the labor
requirements of our vital agricultural industry consistent with our obligations to American
workers. The recent GAO report found that "ample supplies offann labor appear to be available
in most areas," !1lthough there is some possibility oflocalized shortages relating to specific crops
or geographic areas.
In response to concerns regarding localized shortages, the Departments of Agriculture and
Labor have held discussions under the aegis of the Domestic Policy Council to determine means
of streamlining the current H-2A program to make it more responsive to the needs of agricultural
producers, and more effective in protecting U.S. workers. In addition to changes in the program
that respond to GAO recommendations such as shortening the lead time on submitting H-2A
applications from 60 to 45 days, other possible H-2A program changes are being considered that
�address issues contained in H.R. 2377. These include reducing the lead time for completing
housing inspections from 30 to 20 days prior to date of need; providing expedited certification
for employers who reduce their use of H-2A workers by 25 percent or more over the previous
year; and other changes to strengthen worker protections and enforcement.
In view of the President's position, the GAO's findings and accepted recommendations,
and the cooperative efforts of the Departments of Agriculture and Labor to develop ways to
administratively restructure the H-2A program, the Administration is strongly opposed to H.R.
2377. Furthermore, ifH.R. 2377 were passed by the Congress and presented to the President, I
would recommend thathe veto the bill.
The Office of Management and Budget advises ...
Sincerely,
Alexis M. Herman
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
�• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 11-MAR-1998 16:56:29.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 2 of2
• ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sat ish Narayanan ( CN=Satish Narayanan/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Melissa M. Murray ( CN=Melissa M. Murray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman. ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: weinstein dena
READ: UNKNOWN
weinstein dena @ ustr.gov @ INET @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having the Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting tomorrow, March 12,
at 2:45 p.m. in Room 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: 'Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 11-MAR-1998 18:08:09.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Meeting
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO.l
)
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: ·Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Meeting on Thursday at 9:00am in Room 100. Thanks.
�Page 1 of5
ARMS Email System
,.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. MaloneyjOU=WHOjO=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:13-MAR-1998 17:46:39.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to NV
TO: Paul A. Tuchmann ( CN=Paul A. TuchmannjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan OrszagjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. AdashekjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel WexlerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian v. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. WeaverjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher WaynejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael WaldmanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. UmhoferjOU=CEQjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. ToivjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie TarmeyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. StreettjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. StottjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. SmithjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua SilvermanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. SchwartzjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa RobinsonjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John PodestajOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri (
C~=Jennifer
M. PalmierijOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ:UNKNo.WN
TO': Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN;Elizabeth R. Newman/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P
READ: UNKNo.WN
@
Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN;Kevin S. Moran/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P
READ: UNKNo.WN
@
Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN;Linda L. Moore/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P
READ: UNKNo.WN
@
Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN;Anne E. McGuire/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P @ Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNo.WN
Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN;Sylvia M. Mathews/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P
READ: UNKNo.WN
@
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN;Bruce R. Lindsey/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P
READ: UNKNo.WN
Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
@
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN;Christopher J. Lavery/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P
READ: UNKNo.WN
@
Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
TO.: Karin Kullman ( CN;Karin Kullman/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P @ Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNo.WN
TO.: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/o.U;o.PD/o.;Eo.P
READ: UNKNo.WN
@
Eo.P [ OPD 1 )
TO.: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN;Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P @ Eo.P [ WHO.
READ: UNKNo.WN
TO.: Katherine Hubbard ( CN;Katherine Hubbard/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P @ Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNo.WN
TO.: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN;Nancy V. Hernreich/o.U;WHo./O;Eo.P @ Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNo.WN
TO.: Laura A. Graham ( CN;Laura A. Graham/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P @ Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNo.WN
TO.: Karen E. Finney ( CN;Karen E. Finney/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P @ Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNo.WN
TO.: Paul K. Engskov ( CN;Paul K. Engskov/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P @ Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNo.WN
TO.: Maria Echaveste ( CN;Maria Echaveste/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P
READ: UNKNo.WN
@
Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
TO.: Brenda B. Costello ( CN;Brenda B. Costello/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P, @ Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNo.WN
TO.: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN;Carolyn E. Cleveland/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P @ Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNo.WN
TO.: Jose Cerda III ( CN;Jose Cerda III/o.U;o.PD/o.;Eo.P @ Eo.P [ o.PD 1 )
READ: UNKNo.WN
TO.: Emily Bromberg ( CN;Emily Bromberg/o.U;WHo./o.;Eo.P'@ Eo.P [ WHO. 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: -Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. PasquiljOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon MoorejOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Phu·D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/Ou=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne DalejOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris MBalderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Wednesday, March 18, 1998, the President will travel to Las Vegas, NV,
to tour an apprenticeship training facility and meet with the AFL-CIO
Executive Council.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
Background Memos:
DUE MON., MAR. 16, AT 6:00 P.M.
Political Memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
Event Memos:
DUE TUES., MAR. 17, AT 6:00 P.M.
Tour
AFL-CIO Meeting
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Gay L. Joshlyn ( CN=Gay L. Joshlyn/Ou=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 18-MAR-1998 11:54:27.00
SUBJECT:
ISTEA Deputies Meeting
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan weiss ( CN=Jonathan Weiss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: 1199595@SKYTEL ( 1199595@SKYTEL [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1· )
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Stein ( CN=Lawrence J. Stein/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Morley A. Winograd ( CN=Morley A. Winograd/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Duncan T. Moore ( CN=Duncan T. Moore/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Lance
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
CN=Linda Lance/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP
[ CEQ 1 )
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale
CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
Ii
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Demond T. Martin ( CN=Demond T. Martin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Scott R. Hynes ( CN=Scott R. Hynes/O=Ovp @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Patricia E. Romani
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Patricia E. Romani/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
CC: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer R. Muller ( CN=Jennifer R. Muller/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Franklin F. Urteaga ( CN=Franklin F. Urteaga/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Sally Katzen will chair a NEC Deputies meeting to discuss ISTEA on Monday,
March 23 at 3:00 pm in OEOB Room 239. An agenda will be sent to you later
this week.
Please give me a call at 456-2801 if you have any questions.
�.ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 18-MAR-1998 16:44:36.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: sat ish narayanan ( CN=satish narayanan/O=ovp @ ovp [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: weinstein dena
READ: UNKNOWN
weinstein dena @ ustr.gov @ inet @ vaxgtwy [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: dan j. taylor ( CN=dan j. taylor/O=ovp @ ovp [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C.
READ: UNKNOWN
Jennings/OU~OPD/O=EOP @
EOP [ OPD 1
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: donald h. gips
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=donald h. gips/O=ovp @ ovp [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia Dailard ( CN=Cynthia Dailard/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa M. Murray ( CN=Melissa M. Murray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 2 of2
.,ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: toby donenfeld ( CN=toby donenfeld/O=ovp @ ovp
READ:UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPO/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPO/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will have our weekly tobacco strategy meeting Thursday at 2:45 in room
211.
�A
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 18-MAR-1998 17:38:31.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
�.• ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey (" CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOwN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R: Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
�• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:24-MAR-1998 11:00:31.00
SUBJECT:
Immigration working group
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ricardo M. Gonzales ( CN=Ricardo M. Gonzales/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ :UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leanne A. Shimabukuro ( CN=Leanne A. Shimabukuro/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: LETTS_K ( LETTS K @ Al @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: WARNATH S
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
WARNATH S @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (CPC)
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jim Kohlenberger ( CN=Jim Kohlenberger/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Doris O. Matsui ( CN=Doris O. Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�~
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN;Cecilia E. Rouse/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Victoria A. Lynch ( cN;Victoria A. Lynch/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN;Laura Emmett/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN;Miriam H. Vogel/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a meeting of the WH immigration working group on Thursday
March 26th at 3:00pm in Room 476.
I hope you can make it.
Julie
Page 2 of2
�• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 11
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:24-MAR-1998 15:23:43.00
SUBJECT:
Updated Pay Equity Memo
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ,( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra J. Bond ( CN=Debra J. Bond/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy N. Finkelstein ( CN=Amy N. Finkelstein/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald R. Arbuckle ( CN=Donald R. Arbuckle/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Carr ( CN=Susan M. Carr/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia E. Rouse ( CN=Cecilia E. Rouse/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jess A. Gupta ( CN=Jess A. Gupta/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
[ CEA 1 )
�'ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 11
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Attached is an updated memo on the policy initiatives for a pay equity
event.
Please look it over and return any comments by COB today so that
we can meet with the women's groups to evaluate their reactions to our
proposal.
Thanks, Mary ==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D61]MAIL40740628K.026 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504314070000010A020100000002050000000552000000020000D9394B12AA174D9B72B053
1E220B6A14A77EB15A5CEA67E8C4DBF2BB225E8B30B41DECFEF5134A9B731F331A05D717FB3D7A
5Dl1471385F2EF25FE5569DEF95393FDE64FA272C25EDB7C547CC48714646BAF54198977B17856
5FE21B3B84825A6AE25DAB12620088EC35D863C8704A369F998DE2FEED2E6817813EE67F8C2DD8
F449EE931F85FC30838031C7592A1D2D49322CDA7802507F567E75A6923C698973C9C81CD127EF
AF09E232A94D951F298E1D8470A1C02A7B7BE3D71CEFFAF8250BBD49CA3374FDD6BF5CDD6EBEF1
3D96CEAB997A996E9B7115F6F8D14507A527BA9F1D4D3847C426464FFED10371452E9B05F6EED1
B66743E5E3F72979EBBDCE4000F699255F2C160DE14B7D03A2789FE420A9C31A834599B6F00571
21008A964B5AD105120115416F4D46900A682F7720300A42E4F825586ADDCOEEBE76FOA87D1A2E
39AC91AD23CEA81F488D4F7223F499FAC8BE3302216A64957E38A9E835FF145D1FCF9584DBEE6F
2D9CD903B1D7E8EB3273119B148D61EB9DF1F8031A4C862DA629BE9059E2B84DB90DAA78C9ADAF
3443FE63F50C81FB68F19E34672D2C474B1CA598742B2450F51DE3989940470DFFFC986D814AED
5F2C806CE028CD4971E1EB53CB6BCB52'5912086D15622663E2A7E3DAFEE7EB9D6905FB00980022
8398B2305802002B00000000000000000000000823010000000B0100005A04000000550BOOOOOO
4E0000006505000009250100000006000000B30500000B300200000028000000B9050000087701
00000040000000E105000008340100000014000000210600000802010000000F00000035060000
0805010000000800000044060000094401000000430000004C060000060801000000160000008F
06000000550A0000003COOOOOOA506000006080100000016000000E10600000000000000000000
0000E106000000000000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000E10600000000000000
0000000000E106000000000000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000E10600000000
0000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000Ei0600
0000000000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000
E106000000000000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000E106000000000000000000
000000E106000000000000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000E106000000000000
000000000000E106000000000000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000E106000000
000000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000E106
000000000000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000E1060000000000000000000000
00E106000000000000000000000000E106000000000000000000000000E1060000000000000000
00000000E10600000942020000001DOOOOOOF706000000984C006F00630061006C002000480050
0020004C0061007300650072006A00650074002000350000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800C8002C01
2C012C012C01C800C8003000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000B0100002800D61EC30F3908000011090000005AOOOB01008B1436
00540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052006F006DOO61006E002000520065006700
75006C006100720000000000000000000100020058020100000004002800000000000000000000
000000000000000000011202002400A1000000A10000000AOOOOOO481E01004400491E01000200
4A1E010044004B1E010002004C1E010044004D1E010002004E1E010044004F1E01000200501E01
004400511E1A006581045192230000000001004900490044000000000008337C00780000020000
511E000003010004000200000001002A003D001AOOOOOl16005400680069006E00200042006FOO
740074006F006D001F000800000010001000100010001000100010001000000000640078000000
006401000AOOOOOOOCOOOOOOD1010C00000200C0030COOD11BOOF41A5C121A0900000000000000
600018110000102400540069006D006500730020004E0065007700000052006F006D0061006EOO
00000000000001000AOOOOOOOCOOOOOOD1010C00000200C0030COOD10000190004000001000011
00001000010B000010001000000000640000DDOA10008301040003000200211000DDDDOBOB0003
�AUlomated Reo Management System
COrds
H ump Conversion
exMarch 24, 1998
DRAFT MEMORANDUM FOR THE DPC/ NEC
FROM:
DPCINEC STAFF
SUBJECT:
Equal Pay Initiative
This memorandum outlines the "Equal Pay" initiative the Vice President could announce
on April 3rd. Many organizations around the country hold events on April 3rd, which is "Equal
Pay Day," the day designated as the date on which women's earnings, added to their previous
year's earnings, are said to equal what men earn in one calendar year. This event would be the
message event of the day, and it is expected that representatives from the Department of Labor,
OPM, and other departments will attend the event with the Vice President.
There are numerous studies attempting to determine the degree of wage differences
between men and women. A recent brief review of existing studies in the area by the Council of
Economic Advisors concludes that while wage differentials have narrowed steadily since the late
1970s, there is still a significant wage differential; even after controlling for education,
experience, and occupation. The raw differential in terms of female and male wage ratios is
72.4. Taking into account education and experience, the differential becomes 80.5. The wage
differential further narrows to 88.2, controlling for occupation, industry, and union status. A
more popular figure, cited for instance by the Department of Labor, states women earn on
average only 75 cents for each dollar a man earns.
On April3rd, the Vice President could announce: (1) the Administration's endorsement
of Senator Daschle's pay equity bill with some changes; (2) an annual study on pay discrepancies
to highlight this important problem; and (3) other executive branch initiatives in the areas of
enforcement, technical assistance, and outreach.
I.
Endorsement of Daschle Bill
The most prominent (and mainstream) bill in Congress regarding fair pay is Senator
Daschle's. Congresswoman DeLauro has introduced the companion bill to Senator Daschle's in
the House. Rep. Gephardt is looking to support an equal pay initiative and is likely to introduce
whatever bill we support. There is agreement with almost all of the provisions in the Daschle
bill. However, there are two issues that raise some concern. We set forth below the provisions
in the Daschle bill, along with a discussion of the issues that warrant further discussion. You
1
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
should know that Senator Harkin also has a bill on equal pay, but there is little support for his
approach because it incorporates "comparable worth" which would be difficult, if not impossible,
to administer.
A.
Provisions in Daschle's bill that the Administration supports:
•
Non-retaliation Provision. The Daschle bill includes a Non-retaliation provision
that amends the Equal Pay Act (EPA) to prohibit employers from penalizing
employees for sharing information about their salaries with coworkers. Lack of
ability to share such information makes it more difficult for women to evaluate
whether there is evidence of wage discrimination.
•
Class Actions. The bill amends the procedures for ftling class actions under
the EPA to conform with the general procedural rules for filing federal class
actions in other areas ofthe law.
•
Training, Research, Education, and Outreach. The Daschle bill provides for
training, research, education, and outreach. The bill requires the EEOC to
provide training for its employees, subject to the availability of funding, on
matters involving discrimination in the payment of wages. The bill also
enhances programs already in place at the Department of Labor, requiring
DOL to undertake research in the area of sex-based pay disparities;
disseminate that information to members of the interested public; provide
information on means of eradicating such disparities; assist State and local
information and educational programs; recognize and promote the
achievements of employers that have made strides to eliminate pay
disparities; and convene a national summit to discuss and highlight the issue
of sex-based pay disparities.
•
Pay Equity Award. The bill establishes "The National Award for Pay
Equity in the Workplace," to be administered by the Women's Bureau of the
Department of Labor, to recognize and promote the achievements of
employers that have made strides to eliminate pay disparities.
B. Provisions in Daschle's bill that raise some concerns:
1. Enhanced Enforcement.
Daschle's bill would amend the EPA to allow for compensatory and punitive damages.
Currently, the EPA only allows for liquidated damages and back-pay awards. Liquidated
damages typically are awarded in an amount equal to back pay. And typical recoveries are
double back-pay awards.
2
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
An individual can me suit for wage discrimination under Title VII as well as the
EPA. Title VII allows for compensatory and punitive damages, in addition to back pay, as
a result of the Civil Rights Act of 1991. Under Title VII, however, these damages are
capped -- to no more than between $50,000 and $300,000, depending on the size of the
employer -- not the severity of the offense (e.g., for firms with between 15 and 100
employees, combined damages are capped at $50,000).
Victims of racial or ethnic discrimination in employment can also sue for wage
discrimination under Section 1981, which allows unlimited damages. This leaves victims of
discrimination based on sex, religion or disability limited in the relief they can receive.
The Daschle bill adds unlimited compensatory and punitive damages to the Equal
Pay Act. This provides more than is currently authorized under Title VII, but achieves
parity with racial and ethnic discrimination awards under Section 1981.
A number of advocates believe that increasing the damages available under the EPA
would encourage the private bar to bring more suits under the statute, encourage
employers to devote more attention to their pay practices, and encourage victims to come
forward. Adding unrestricted damages to equal pay cases would not necessarily lead to a
huge proliferation of frivolous actions or excessive awards. An examination of cases under
Section 1981 found that between 1980 and 1990 plaintiffs won 121 cases -- eleven per year.
There were no compensatory and punitive damages in 52 of the cases; in 42, damages
awarded were less than $50,000. Total damages exceeded $200,000 in only two cases
during the eleven-year period. Note: this study was limited to reported decisions, and did
not include cases settled before trial.
The women's groups have long advocated lifting the caps in Title VII and view any
limits on damages in the EPA as an abandonment of their position for equal relief and as
an affront to women rights generally. In fact, if the Administration did not support
uncapped damages in the Daschle bill, the women's groups would feel betrayed, preferring
no bill at all. In addition, they have indicated that they would publicly attack the
Administration on this issue.
The Departments of Labor, Treasury, Justice, and the Commissioner of the EEOC all
support endorsing adding uncapped compensatory and punitive damages to the EPA, with the
exception that the Department of Justice believes that punitive damages should not be available
against the Federal Government. The NEC, DPC, Women's Office, CEA, and OMB agree.
Commerce remains concerned.
2. Data Collection
Daschle's bill also provides for the collection of pay information by the EEOC.
Daschle's bill is somewhat vague on exactly how the wage data would be collected. In
particular, it does not specifY that the data needs to be collected on the EEO-l form, which is the
3
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
fonn used by the EEOC to collect employment data. Because of the concerns set forth below,
we believe we need to work with Daschle's staff to remove this section of the bill.
Data collection could improve pay equity in two ways. The first is by increasing public
awareness of pay inequities and enabling women to evaluate whether they have been victims of
wage discrimination; the second is by enhancing enforcement of anti-discrimination laws.
The EEOC currently collects annual data regarding the demographic breakdown of the
workforces of private employers with 100 or more employees and of federal contractors with 50
or more employees on the EEO-l fonn. The EEOC does not currently collect salary data with
respect to private employers.
The EEO-I fonn has remained virtually unchanged for the past 30 years, despite its
review every 3 years for OMB paperwork clearance (most recently in 1997). Since the 1960s,
the occupation and racial categories have become outdated; what was once confusing is now
potentially misleading. As a result, many in the business community perceive the EEO-I fonn
as a waste of time and money. (OMB estimates suggest that it takes each finn 10 hours to fill
out the fonn; adding wage data would likely increase the compliance costs dramatically -possibly by several hundred-fold -- although creating a supplement to the fonn or limiting it to a
subset ofthe reporting universe could mitigate some of these costs.)
Nonetheless, the EEOC believes that collecting wage data on the EEO-l fonn would
greatly improve its ability to target and prioritize discrimination cases. It also would assist the
Department of Labor (DOL) in targeting its enforcement efforts and monitoring affinnative
action programs. Because DOL thought that the EEO fonn would not be amended to include
wage infonnation, it has been working on a proposed rule to gather such data from federal
contractors though an OFCCP fonn. That work has been in process for almost three years; we
now understand that it may be ready to be sent to OMB during this fiscal year.
There is consensus that any attempts to add wage data to the EEO-l fonn will draw
immediate fire from the Republicans and the business community. Indeed, any announcement
of a process to detennine the best way to gather this data would likely provoke a rider and risk
the increase in funds requested for the EEOC in our FY99 budget. (The budget requests $279
million for the EEOC -- $37 million or 15 percent more than enacted in the 1998 budget.
More than one-third of the proposed increase, $13 million, goes to expansion of the
agency's Alternate Dispute Resolution [ADR] program.)
Since the EEO-l fonn is up for revision in the year 2000, as part of the Paperwork
Reduction Act, the consensus among the working group is that we should work to remove the
data collection provision from the Daschle bill and should work quietly to evaluate the options
for addressing the existing problems with the fonn (e.g., the outdated occupational and racial
categories, and the lack of wage data).
4
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
II.
Data Collection - Annual Report By Department of Labor
In order to increase public awareness of pay inequities, the Vice President could
announce an annual report on the pay gap by sex produced by the Department of Labor. This
annual report would be based on data that already exist, but are very difficult for most people to
utilize. Publishing the infonnation on pay inequities in an easy-to-access report would make it
easier for interested parties to raise the national prominence of this problem. And because
attitudes and awareness are keys to reducing wage disparities, highlighting the issue every year
would likely have a powerful effect on public consciousness and be an effective way to achieve
increased gender pay equity. This announcement will not be politically charged since it would
not impose additional burdens on business. This option would not enhance enforcement efforts
and would not involve significant costs.
II.
Other Executive Branch Announcements
A.
Private-Sector Enforcement
Enforcement of anti-discrimination laws by the EEOC and OFCCP have traditionally
played an important role in easing discrimination in our labor market. Therefore, a key
component to our equal pay initiative is to improve enforcement by both agencies.
1.
A Memorandum Of Understanding (MOU) between EEOC and DOL to
Cross Train. The EEOC and the Department of Labor could enter into an
agreement to train each other's staff to be sensitive to potential violations of the
statutes they enforce, including the Equal Pay Act. The agencies would refer
infonnation concerning potential violations of the agency's statutes to the
applicable EEOC or Labor Department office for appropriate action.
2.
A MOU Between EEOC and DOL to Collect Damages. OFCCP would be
designated to serve as the EEOC's agent for purposes of collecting damages that
are not otherwise collectible under OFCCP's authority under its executive order.
OFCCP then could obtain full relief for intentional discrimination. This change
would not require any legislative action. There are no costs anticipated for this
option.
B. Private-Sector Technical Assistance
There are several areas in which the federal government could provide technical
assistance to make private employers aware of wage disparities.
1.
Federal Contractor Best Practices. Currently, federal contractors must
conduct self-audits as part of their federal contract obligations. OFCCP has
begun to publicize successful programs through its best practices honor roll.
The agency plans to place these Best Practices suggestions on its web site.
5
�'.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
2.
lO-Step Voluntary Self-Audit for Businesses and Employees. The
Department of Labor would develop and make available a 10-step package that
would give companies guidelines to determine whether they offer equal pay,
hiring, and promotional opportunities. The Department would also develop a
similar checklist for employees. DOL would put these self-audits on the Internet.
This would require no additional funding.
3.
Awards. The Department of Labor has an Exemplary Voluntary Efforts (EVE)
and Secretary's Opportunity 2000 Awards program that recognizes best corporate
practices. This year's event will be held on September 17. This existing vehicle
could be used to highlight the best practices in furthering pay equity. There is
also an award proposed in the Daschle bill.
C.
Federal Government As A Role Model
For any equal pay initiative to be credible, we must make the Federal government the role
model for other employers. To this end, we would propose the following four initiatives to put
the Federal government in the lead on this issue and address discrimination within the Federal
government:
1.
lO-Step Voluntary Self-Audit for Agencies. The federal agencies will agree to
take the 10-step self-audit that the Department of Labor would develop and use
the results from the self-audit to monitor their efforts on equal pay.
2.
Best Practices. OPM could work with the other Federal departments and
agencies to develop best practices, from both the public and private sectors, for
recruiting and retaining women.
3.
Guide to Recruitment and Retention of Women. OPM is producing a new
Guide on Recruitment and Retention of Women in the federal government that
would contain information to make agency managers aware of career
opportunities for women and to provide guidance on recruitment and career
development for women. This could be prepared by April 3rd.
4.
Outreach. OPM, in conjunction with other agencies, could expand outreach
efforts, including working with professional groups, participating in women's
conferences, and visiting college campuses so that talented women may be
recruited for jobs in the Federal government.
6
�,. ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:25-MAR-1998 17:46:34.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Tracey E. Thornton
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�"
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Bobbie Greene
will be leading it tomorrow. Thanks.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[02/24/1998 – 03/25/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 098 - Folder 004
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/d5baf98771f677412710251c954c1fea.pdf
ab60db1fcb43b5571700132599383872
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC-KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 098 - FOLDER -003
[01/28/1998-02/17/1998]
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: CAPLAN P@A1@CD@LNGTWY ( CAPLAN_P@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CREATION DATE!TIME:28-JAN-1998 19:48:12.00
SUBJECT:
Denver and California
TO: ROBINSON_C@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
ROBINSON C@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Minyon Moore@eop@LNGTEY@LNGTWY ( Minyon Moore@eop@LNGTEY@LNGTWY [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK_D@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Cecily C. Williams@eop ( Cecily C. Williams@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.@EOP ( Paul J. Weinstein Jr.@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne@eop ( Christopher Wayne@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher F. Walker@eop ( Christopher F. walker@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman@eop ( Michael Waldman@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Marjorie Tarmey@eop ( Marjorie Tarmey@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews@eop ( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham@eop ( Sara M.'Latham@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern@eop ( Todd Stern@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN .
TO: Craig T. Smith@eop ( Craig T. Smith@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman@EOP ( Joshua Silverman@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal@eop ( Dan K. Rosenthal@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag@eop ( Peter R. Orszag@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin Moran@eop ( Kevin Moran@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Megan C. Moloney@eop ( Megan C. Moloney@eop [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lorraine L. Wytkind@eop ( Lorraine L. Wytkind@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Julie E. Mason@eop ( Julie E. Mason@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart@eop ( Joseph P. Lockhart@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery@eop ( Christopher J. Lavery@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard@eop ( Katherine Hubbard@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan@eop ( Elena Kagan@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson@eop ( Brian J. Johnson@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh@eop ( Phu D. Huynh@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich@eop ( Nancy V. Hernreich@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: D. Stephen Goodin@EOP ( D. Stephen Goodin@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines@eop ( Jeremy M. Gaines@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler@eop ( Shelley N. Fidler@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole Elkon@eop ( Nicole Elkon@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley@eop ( Jennifer D. Dudley@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius@eop ( Catherine A. Cornelius@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland@EOP ( Carolyn E. Cleveland@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Capps@eop ( Laura Capps@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird@eop (Debra D. Bird@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay@eop ( Barbara A. Barclay@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Kris M Balderston@EOP ( Kris M Balderston@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: NOTESREFLECT@Al@CD@LNGTWY ( NOTESREFLECT@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MILLISON C@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAVIES G@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MILLISON C@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
DAVIES_G@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Dorian V. Weaver@eop ( Dorian.V. Weaver@eop [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman@eop ( Kathleen M. Wallman@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Ann F. Walker@eop ( Ann F. Walker@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner@eop ( June G. Turner@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Tamagni@eop ( Lisa Tamagni@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie Sariford@eop ( Stephanie Sanford@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett@eop ( Stephanie S. Streett@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg@eop ( Aviva Steinberg@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton@eop ( Karen E. Skelton@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman@eop ( Stephen B. Silverman@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber@eop ( Sarah J. Reber@eop [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Terrell@eop ( Michael Terrell@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Moore@eop ( Linda Moore@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: April Mellody@eop ( April Mellody@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire@eop ( Anne E. McGuire@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz@eop ( Laura D. Schwartz@eop [ WHO 1 )
(NSC)
(NSC)
TO: Daniel Wexler@eop ( Daniel Wexler@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(SYS)
�Page 4 of5
ARMS Email System
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey@eop ( Bruce R. Lindsey@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO J )
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin@eop ( Kirk T. Hanlin@eop [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King@eop ( Angus S. King@eop [ UNKNOWN J
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta@eop ( John Podesta@eop [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso_Rotunno@eop ( Cynthia M. Jasso_Rotunno@eop [ UNKNOWN J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz@eop ( Russell W. Horwitz@eop [ OPD J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green@eop ( Julia R. Green@eop [ UNKNOWN J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg@EOP ( Jason S. Goldberg@EOP ['WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly@eop ( Andrew Friendly@eop [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm Emanuel@eop ( Rahm Emanuel@eop [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards@eop ( Anne M. Edwards@eop [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
Marilyn DiGiacobbe@EOP [ UNKNOWN J )
TO: Michael Cohen@EOP ( Michael Cohen@EOP [ OPD J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III@eop ( Jose Cerda III@eop [ OPD J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alison E. Bracewell@eop ( Alison E. Bracewell@eop [ UNKNOWN J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire@eop ( David S. Beaubaire@eop [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick@eop ( Nicholas R. Baldick@eop [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders@eop ( Brenda M. Anders@eop [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel to Denver for the Summit of the Eight and then
to
California for several events.
The President will have three trip books:
�ARMS Email System
one for pre-Summit activities on June 19; one for the duration of the
Summit;
one for California.
Deadlines for these books are as follows:
Pre-Summit activities: DUE WEDNESDAY, JUNE 18 at 6:00 PM
Background memos
-Political memo
-Economic background
-Cabinet issues
-CEQ issues
Event memos
-Event TBD (NEC)
Summit: handled by NSC
California: DUE FRIDAY, JUNE 20 at 6:00 PM
Background memos
-Political memo
-Econ background
-Cabinet issues
-CEQ issues
Event memos
-Conf of Mayors (Lynn Cutler)
-San Francisco $ lunch (Political)
-Event in LA TBD (LULAC/Kaiser)
-LA $ events (Political)
please note that all paper for Monday's events in California must be to
our
office by Friday evening so that we can have the President's trip book
flown to
him on Saturday.
PageSofS
�., ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 5
J
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: CAPLAN P@A1@CD@LNGTWY ( CAPLAN_P@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-JAN-1998 19:48:13.00
SUBJECT:
California travel
TO: ROBINSON_C@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
ROBINSON C@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
TO: Minyon Moore@eop@LNGTEY@LNGTWY ( Minyon Moore@eop@LNGTEY@LNGTWY [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK_D@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Cecily C. Williams@eop ( Cecily C. Williams@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler@eop ( Daniel Wexler@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver@eop ( Dorian V. Weaver@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman@eop ( Kathleen M. Wallman@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
,TO: Ann F. Walker@eop ( Ann F. Walker@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner@eop ( June G. Turner@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Tamagni@eop ( Lisa Tamagni@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham@eop ( Sara M. Latham@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern@eop ( Todd Stern@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith@eop ( Craig T. Smith@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman@EOP ( Joshua Silverman@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal@eop ( Dan K. Rosenthal@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag@eop ( Peter R. Orszag@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin Moran@eop ( Kevin Moran@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney@eop ( Megan C. Moloney@eop [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of5
ARMS Email System
I..
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lorraine L. Wytkind@eop ( Lorraine L. Wytkind@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Julie E. Mason@eop ( Julie E. Mason@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey@eop ( Bruce R. Lindsey@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
Kirk T. Hanlin@eop [ WHO 1 )
TO: Angus S. King@eop ( Angus S. King@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1
TO: John Podesta@eop ( John Podesta@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso_Rotunno@eop ( Cynthia M. Jasso_Rotunno@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz@eop ( Russell W. Horwitz@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green@eop ( Julia R. Green@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg@EOP ( Jason S. Goldberg@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly@eop ( Andrew Friendly@eop [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm Emanuel@eop ( Rahm Emanuel@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards@eop ( Anne M. Edwards@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe@EOP· ( Marilyn DiGiacobbe@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen@EOP ( Michael Cohen@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Capps@eop ( Laura Capps@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird@eop ( Debra D. Bird@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay@eop ( Barbara A. Barclay@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston@EOP ( Kris M Balderston@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: PALMIERI_J@Al@CD@LNGTWY
PALMIERI_J@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MILLISON_C@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAVIES_G@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MILLISON_C@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
DAVIES_G@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Diane M. Whitmore@eop ( Diane M. Whitmore@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.@EOP ( Paul J. Weinstein Jr.@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne@eop ( Christopher Wayne@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher F. Walker@eop ( Christopher F. Walker@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman@eop ( Michael Waldman@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey@eop ( Marjorie Tarmey@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews@eop ( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett@eop ( Stephanie S. Streett@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg@eop ( Aviva Steinberg@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton@eop ( Karen E. Skelton@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
. TO: Stephen B. Silverman@eop ( Stephen B. Silverman@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber@eop ( Sarah J. Reber@eop [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Terrell@eop ( Michael Terrell@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Moore@eop ( Linda Moore@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: April Mellody@eop ( April Mellody@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. MCGuire@eop ( Anne E. McGuire@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Laura D. Schwartz@eop ( Laura D. Schwartz@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery@eop ( Christopher J. Lavery@eop [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
t-
I>
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard@eop ( Katherine Hubbard@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan@eop ( Elena Kagan@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson@eop ( Brian J. Johnson@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: phu D. Huynh@eop ( Phu D. Huynh@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich@eop ( Nancy V. Hernreich@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin@EOP ( D. Stephen Goodin@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines@eop ( Jeremy M. Gaines@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler@eop ( Shelley N. Fidler@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole Elkon@eop ( Nicole Elkon@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley@eop ( Jennifer D. Dudley@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius@eop ( Catherine A. Cornelius@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO:' Carolyn E. Cleveland@EOP ( Carolyn E. Cleveland@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alison E. Bracewell@eop ( Alison E. Bracewell@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire@eop ( David S. Beaubaire@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick@eop ( Nicholas R. Baldick@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders@eop ( Brenda M. Anders@eop [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel to San Diego on Friday to deliver the
commencement
address at UC-San Diego on Saturday, June 14.
Deadlines for the trip book are as follows:
Background papers, DUE WEDNESDAY, JUNE 11 at 6:00 PM
-Political background
Page 4 of5
�Page 5 of5
· ARMS Email System
t-
. -
-Economic background
-cabinet hot issues
-Environmental hot issues
Event memos, DUE THURSDAY, JUNE 12 at 6:00 PM
-Commencement address and photo line
-Lunch
-Interviews TBD
Please call with any questions.
Thanks.
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
(.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-JAN-1998 19:54:52.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 .)
READ: UNKNOWN
. TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
I,
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 }
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
'CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP@ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
�• A~~ Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: HOWELL H@A1@CD@LNGTWY ( HOWELL_H@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-JAN-1998 19:57:48.00
SUBJECT:
West Virginia Trip
TO: ROBINSON C@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
ROBINSON C@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
TO: MILLISON C@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MILLISON C@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: DAVIES G@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
DAVIES G@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Cecily C. Williams@eop ( Cecily C. Williams@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler@eop ( Daniel Wexler@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Dorian V. weaver@eop ( Dorian V. Weaver@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Kathleen M. wallman@eop ( Kathleen M. Wallman@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker@eop ( Ann F. Walker@eop
READ:UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ WHO 1 )
TO: June G. Turner@eop ( June G. Turner@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Tamagni@eop ( Lisa Tamagni@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie Sanford@eop ( Stephanie Sanford@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett@eop ( Stephanie S. Streett@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg@eop ( Aviva Steinberg@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith@eop ( Craig T. Smith@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman@eop ( Stephen B. Silverman@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal@eop ( Dan K. Rosenthal@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Peter R. Orszag@eop ( Peter R. Orszag@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Moore@eop ( Linda Moore@eop [ WHO 1 )
�ARM~
Page 2 of5
Email System
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: April Mellody@eop ( April Mellody@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Floydetta McAfee@eop ( Floydetta McAfee@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey@eop ( Bruce R. Lindsey@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard@eop ( Katherine Hubbard@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan@eop ( Elena Kagan@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jackson Dunn III@EOP ( Jackson Dunn III@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso_Rotunno@eop ( Cynthia M. Jasso_Rotunno@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz@eop ( Russell W. Horwitz@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green@eop ( Julia R. Green@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg@EOP ( Jason S. Goldberg@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines@eop ( Jeremy M. Gaines@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Shelley N. Fidler@eop ( Shelley N. Fidler@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole Elkon@eop ( Nicole Elkon@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley@eop ( Jennifer D. Dudley@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius@eop ( Catherine A. Cornelius@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland@EOP ( Carolyn E. Cleveland@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alison E. Bracewell@eop ( Alison E. Bracewell@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire@eop ( David S. Beaubaire@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston@EOP ( Kris M Balderston@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: PALMIERI J@Al@CD@LNGTWY
PALMIERI J@Al@CD@LNGTWY
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
�.ARMS Email System
.
Page 3 ofS
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: CAPLAN P@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK_D@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CAPLAN P@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
(WHO)
TO: Diane M. Whitmore@eop ( Diane M. Whitmore@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.@EOP ( Paul J. Weinstein Jr.@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne@eop ( Christopher Wayne@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher F. Walker@eop ( Christopher F. Walker@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman@eop ( Michael Waldman@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey@eop ( Marjorie Tarmey@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews@eop ( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham@eop ( Sara M. Latham@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern@eop ( Todd Stern@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Wendy Smith@eop ( wendy Smith@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman@EOP ( Joshua Silverman@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz@eop ( Laura D. Schwartz@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber@eop ( Sarah J. Reber@eop [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Terrell@eop ( Michael Terrell@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney@eop ( Megan C. Moloney@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire@eop ( Anne E. McGuire@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Julie E. Mason@eop ( Julie E. Mason@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin@eop ( Kirk T. Hanlin@eop [ WHO 1 )
�Page 4 of5
ARM.S Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King@eop ( Angus S. King@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta@eop ( John Podesta@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson@eop ( Brian J. Johnson@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh@eop ( Phu D. Huynh@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich@eop ( Nancy V. Hernreich@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin@EOP ( D. Stephen Goodin@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Glynn@eop ( Mary E. Glynn@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly@eop ( Andrew Friendly@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm Emanuel@eop ( Rahm Emanuel@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards@eop ( Anne M. Edwards@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe@EOP ( Marilyn DiGiacobbe@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen@EOP ( Michael Cohen@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Capps@eop ( Laura Capps@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird@eop ( Debra D. Bird@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick@eop ( Nicholas R. Baldick@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders@eop ( Brenda M. Anders@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TEXT:
The President will travel to West Virginia on Thursday, May 22.
All materials for his trip book are due on Weqnesday, May 21 at 4:00 p.m.
BACKGROUND MATERIALS are due on WEDNESDAY, MAY 21 at 4:00 p.m.
political Background
Economic 1-pager
Local Issues
�ARMS Email System
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Crime I-pager
Environmental Hot Issues
EVENT MEMOS are due on WEDNESDAY, MAY 21 at 4:00 p.m.
Thanks! ! ! ! ! !
Page 5 of5
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 11
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: OASISMGR@A1@CD@LNGTWY ( OASISMGR@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OA)
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-JAN-1998 21:35:09.00
SUBJECT:
Document Requests
MATERA M@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: MATERA_M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
MARSHALL B@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: MARSHALL_B@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
TO: MARKSZ_D@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MARKSZ D@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: MALLEY R@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MALLEY R@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
(WHO)
LUZZATTO A@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: LUZZATTO A@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
TO: LINGENFELTER@A1@CD@LNGTWY ( LINGENFELTER@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
READ: UNKNOWN
LINDAHL S@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (WHO)
TO: LINDAHL S@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LEWIS AP@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: LEWIS AP@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(OA)
TO: rlevinso@OSTP.EOP.GOV.INET@CD@LNGTWY ( rlevinso@OSTP.EOP.GOV.INET@CD@LNGTWY [ OS
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: LEE T@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LEE T@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
TO: LEARY W@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LEARY W@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
LAWRENCE W@A1@CD@LNGTWY
TO: LAWRENCE W@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
LANGLEY J@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: LANGLEY J@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(OA)
(NSC)
TO: KRISTOFF S@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KRISTOFF S@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: KORENMAN S@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KORENMAN S@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(CEA)
TO: KINSERKIDA B@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KINSERKIDA B@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: KELLY S@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KELLY S@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: KAZEL J@A1@CD@LNGTWY
KAZEL J@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OMB)
(NSC)
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 11
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KASASKERIS O@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
JUTTON P@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: JUTTON P@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JOY M@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KASASKERIS O@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
JOY M@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: JORDAN JF@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(OA)
(OA)
JORDAN JF@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OMB)
TO: Cathy R. Mays@EOP ( Cathy R. Mays@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emory L. Mayfield@eop ( Emory L. Mayfield@eop [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sonyia Matthews@eop ( Sonyia Matthews@eop [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack@EOP ( Larry R. Matlack@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mia V. Masten@EOP ( Mia V. Masten@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele C. Marx@eop ( Michele C. Marx@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Demond T. Martin@eop ( Demond T. Martin@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall@eop ( William P. Marshall@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Capricia P. Marshall@eop ( Capricia P. Marshall@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen A. Maris@EOP ( Karen A. Maris@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Heather M. Marabeti@OVP@EOP ( Heather M. Marabeti@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alex D. Mandl@eop ( Alex D. Mandl@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UN!(NOWN
TO: Kimberly A. Maluski@EOP ( Kimberly A. Maluski@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. Malone@eop ( Michael D. Malone@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen D. Malliarakis@eop ( Kathleen D. Malliarakis@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Margaret A. Malanoski@eop ( Margaret A. Malanoski@eop [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of 11
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ira C. Magaziner@EOP ( Ira C. Magaziner@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart W. Maberry@eop ( Stuart W. Maberry@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Randall W. Lutter@eop ( Randall W. Lutter@eop [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell@eop ( Ellen M. Lovell@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tania I. Lopez@eop ( Tania I. Lopez@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce D. Long@eop ( Bruce D. Long@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard C. Loeb@eop ( Richard C. Loeb@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patrick G. Locke@eop ( Patrick G. Locke@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Lin Liu@eop ( Lin Liu@eop [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christine J. Lindsey@eop ( Christine J. Lindsey@eop ['OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark F. Lindsay@eop ( Mark F. Lindsay@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susanne D. Lind@eop ( Susanne D. Lind@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Henry E. Lilienthal@EOP ( Henry E. Lilienthal@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard Lichtenberger@eop ( Richard Lichtenberger@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sharon R. Lewis@eop ( Sharon R. Lewis@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne H. Lewis@eop ( Anne H. Lewis@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew@eop ( Jacob J. Lew@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cameron M. Leuthy@eop ( Cameron M. Leuthy@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith E. Leonard@eop ( Judith E. Leonard@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alexandra Lehr@EOP ( Alexandra Lehr@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 4 of 11
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher S. Lehane@OVP@EOP ( Christopher S. Lehane@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah S. Lee@eop ( Sarah S. Lee@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ha Yan Lee@eop ( Ha Yan Lee@eop [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Corey G. Lee@eop ( Corey G. Lee@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael G. Lawrence@eop ( Michael G. Lawrence@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ ONDCP 1 )
TO: Keith E. Laughlin@EOP ( Keith E. Laughlin@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham@eop ( Sara M. Latham@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Meredith A. Lane@eop ( Meredith A. Lane@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Betty G. Lambuth@EOP ( Betty G. Lambuth@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James A. Laity@EOP ( James A. Laity@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Briggitte R. LaFontant@eop ( Briggitte R. LaFontant@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph F. Lackey Jr.@eop ( Joseph F. Lackey Jr.@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steve L. Kwast@OVP@EOP ( Steve L. Kwast@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Heidi Kukis@OVP@EOP ( Heidi Kukis@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul Kriebel@eop ( Paul Kriebel@eop [ OA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori K. Krause@eop ( LoriK. Krause@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Konigsberg@EOP ( Charles Konigsberg@EOP [ OMB 1 )'
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alicia K. Kolaian@eop ( Alicia K. Kolaian@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Raymond P. Kogut@eop ( Raymond P. Kogut@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: LOUISA KOCH@EOP ( LOUISA KOCH@EOP [ OMB 1 )
[ OMB 1 )
�Page 5 of 11
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: andrew w. kleine@eop ( andrew w. kleine@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain@OVP@EOP ( Ron Klain@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Catherine T. Kitchen@eop ( Catherine T. Kitchen@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Kirchgraber@eop ( Katherine Kirchgraber@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis X. Kinney@eop ( Francis X. Kinney@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert W. Kilpatrick@eop ( Robert W. Kilpatrick@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles E. Kieffer@eop ( Charles E. Kieffer@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald Keohane@eop ( Ronald Keohane@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth S. Kelly@EOP ( Kenneth S. Kelly@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alexander S. Keenan@EOP ( Alexander S. Keenan@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Sally Katzen@eop ( Sally Katzen@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan@EOP ( Jonathan A. Kaplan@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Kapla@eop ( Robert S. Kapla@eop [CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Kamensky@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
John Kamensky@eop [ OMB 1 )
TO: David E. Kalbaugh@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
David E. Kalbaugh@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Phyllis Kaiser-Dark@EOP ( Phyllis Kaiser-Dark@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara F. Kahlow@eop ( Barbara F. Kahlow@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan@eop ( Elena Kagan@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gay L. Joshlyn@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
Gay L. Joshlyn@eop [ OPD 1 )
TO: Wayne A. Jones@EOP ( Wayne A. Jones@EOP [ OA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 6 of 11
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ronald e. jones@eop ( ronald e. jones@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MAXFIELD N@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MAXFIELD_N@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: MARTIN_BM@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MARTIN BM@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
TO: MARSDEN H@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MARSDEN H@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(DON)
TO: Dalton L. Mann@eop@INGTWY@LNGTWY ( Dalton L. Mann@eop@INGTWY@LNGTWY [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MACK J@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MACK J@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OMB)
LIZIK C@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
TO: LIZIK C@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LINDSEY W@Al@CD@LNGTWY
TO: LINDSEY W@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
UNKNOWN 1 )
(DON)
LEWIS J@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (DON)
TO: LEWIS J@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LEVITT A@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: LEVITT A@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(DON)
TO: LETTS K@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LETTS K@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: LEAVY D@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LEAVY D@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: LAWSON J@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LAWSON J@Al@CD@LNGTWY
UNKNOWN 1 )
(OA)
TO: LAPHAM N@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LAPHAM_N@Al@CD@LNGTWY
UNKNOWN 1 )
(CEQ)
TO: KYLE R@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KYLE_R@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: KOUBA J@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(OPD)
KOUBA J@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
TO: KNEPPER C@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KNEPPER C@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: KERRICK D@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: hkelly@ostp.eop.gov@INET@LNGTWY ( hkelly@ostp.eop.gov@INET@LNGTWY [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KAUFMANN K@Al@CD@LNGTWY
KAUFMANN_K@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OA)
�ARMS Email System
Page 7 of 11
READ: UNKNOWN
TO,: KALNINS _A@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JURITH E@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JOSHI M@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KALNINS A@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OA)
JURITH E@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (DON)
JOSHI M@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: Shelly A. McAllister@EOP ( Shelly A. McAllister@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock@eop ( Andrew J. Mayock@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Valerie S. Matthews@eop ( Valerie S. Matthews@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Doris O. Matsui@eop ( Doris O. Matsui@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews@eop ( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason@eop ( Julie E. Mason@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tanya E. Martin@eop ( Tanya E. Martin@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bernard H. Martin@EOP ( Bernard H. Martin@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr@eop ( Thurgood Marshall Jr@eop
READ:UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Charles R. Marr@eop ( Charles R. Marr@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura S. Marcus@eop ( Laura S. Marcus@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christy M. Manso@eop, ( Christy M. Manso@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande@eop ( Jerold R. Mande@eop [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sean P. Maloney@eop ( Sean P. Maloney@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aimee M. Malnati@OVP@EOP ( Aimee M. Malnati@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alphonse J. Maldon@eop ( Alphonse J. Maldon@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Allison J. Major@eop ( Allison J. Major@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
�Page 8 of11
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eric L. Macris@eop ( Eric L. Macris@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Randolph M. Lyon@EOP ( Randolph M. Lyon@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nguyen-Phuong K. Lu@eop ( Nguyen-Phuong K. Lu@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sue Lou@eop ( Sue Lou@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ranelle A. Lopez@eop ( Ranelle A. Lopez@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell F. Loiselle@eop ( Russell F. Loiselle@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart@eop ( Joseph P. Lockhart@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neil Lobron@EOP ( Neil Lobron@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss@OVP@EOP ( Susan M. Liss@oVP@EOP
READ:UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey@eop ( Bruce R. Lindsey@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John F. Lindsay@eop ( John F. Lindsay@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judy C. Lin@eop ( Judy C. Lin@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: linn m. ligon@eop ( linn m. ligon@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas S. Lewis@EOP ( Thomas S. Lewis@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Lewis@eop ( Lisa Lewis@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis@eop ( Ann F. Lewis@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa J. Levin@eop ( Lisa J. Levin@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Lesmez@eop ( Daniel Lesmez@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Kathy D. Leodler@eop ( Kathy D. Leodler@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ ONDCP 1 )
TO: Kelley A. Lehman@eop ( Kelley A. Lehman@eop
[ OMB 1 )
�Page 9 of 11
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robyn Leeds@eop ( Robyn Leeds@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Malcolm R. Lee@eop ( Malcolm R. Lee@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Earlene C. Lee@eop ( Earlene C. Lee@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra o. Lawson@eop ( Sandra
READ: UNKNOWN
o.
Lawson@eop
[ ONDCP 1 )
TO: Christopher J. Lavery@eop ( Christopher J. Lavery@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edwin Lau@eop ( Edwin Lau@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: SARAH A. LASKIN@EOP ( SARAH A. LASKIN@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Lance@EOP ( Linda Lance@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew@eop ( Jeanne Lambrew@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leonard L. Lainhart@EOP ( Leonard L. Lainhart@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Cecilia D. Lafoe@eop ( Cecilia D. Lafoe@eop [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Agustin A. Labrador@eop ( Agustin A. Labrador@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Karin Kullman@EOP ( Karin Kullman@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen C. Kucik@eop ( Karen C. Kucik@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori A. Krauss@EOP ( Lori A. Krauss@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes@eop ( Lisa M. Kountoupes@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Randy J. Kolton@eop ( Randy J. Kolton@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jim Kohlenberger@OVP@EOP ( Jim Kohlenberger@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard H. Kodl@EOP ( Richard H. Kodl@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Sarah S. Freeman@eop ( Sarah S. Freeman@eop [ WHO 1 )
�Page 10 of 11
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein@EOP ( Jennifer L. Klein@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carole Kitti@eop ( Carole Kitti@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy Kirkendall@eop ( Nancy Kirkendall@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Benjamin J. Kirby@eop ( Benjamin J. Kirby@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William R. Kincaid@eop ( William R. Kincaid@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gerald P. Kiernan@eop ( Gerald P. Kiernan@eop [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Farooq Khan@EOP ( Farooq Khan@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann Kendrall@EOP ( Ann Kendrall@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John W. Kelly@EOP ( John W. Kelly@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ : UNKNOWN
TO: Stanley Kaufman@EOP ( Stanley Kaufman@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart R. Kasdin@eop ( Stuart R. Kasdin@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jody J. Kaplan@eop ( Jody J. Kaplan@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane@eop ( Andrea Kane@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil@eop ( Thomas A. Kalil@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1
TO: Anil Kakani@eop ( Anil Kakani@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aram H. Kailian@OVP@EOP ( Aram H. Kailian@OVP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian G. Kahin@eop ( Brian G. Kahin@eop [ OSTP 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James J. Jukes@eop ( James J. Jukes@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Walter F. Jones@eop ( Walter F. Jones@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OA 1 )
TO: Mary E. Jones@EOP ( Mary E. Jones@EOP [ CEA 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 11 of 11
'"
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This is a reminder that two document request memoranda dated December 30,
1997
were sent by the Counsel's Office to all EOP staff.
One is related to the
White
House Database and the other is related to the Hudson casino matter.
Both
memoranda request that staff provide all responsive documents to the
designated
Counsel's Office contact person by Thursday, January 8, 1998.
If you have any questions regarding the White House Database request,
please
contact Sally Paxton at x65079 or Dimitri Nionakis at x65814.
If you have
any
questions regarding the Hudson casino matter, please contact Dimitri
Nionakis at
x65814.
Thank you.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 2-FEB-1998 09:37:25.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to NM
TO: Paul A. Tuchmann ( CN=Paul A. Tuchmann/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel W·exler/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Dorian v. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of5
.ARMS.Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO:. Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B.. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�'. ARMS.Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN;Emily Bromberg/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN;David S. Beaubaire/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN;Nicholas R. Baldick/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN;Brenda M. Anders/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN;Phillip Caplan/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN;Amy W. Tobe/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN;Jon P. Jennings/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 .)
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN;Cecily C. Williams/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN;Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN;Chr'istopher F. Walker /OU;WHO/O;EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN;Ann F. Walker/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN;Beth A. Viola/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN;June G. Turner/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN;Michael V. Terrell/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN;Jordan Tamagni/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN;Aviva Steinberg/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN;Todd Stern/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN;Stephen B. Silverman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN;Jake Siewert/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN;Dan K. Rosenthal/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�..ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
.,~
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN;Sarah J. Reber/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN;Simeona F. pasquil/OU;WHOI.0;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN;Peter R. Orszag/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN;Mary
READ: UNKNOWN
Morr~son/OU;WHO/O;EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Minyan Moore ( CN;Minyon Moore/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN;Megan C. Moloney/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN;Andrew J. Mayock/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN;Joseph P. Lockhart/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN;Ann F. Lewis/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN;Sara M. Latham/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN;Kirk T. Hanlin/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN;Phu D. Huynh/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz' ( CN;Russell W. Horwitz/OU;OPD/O;EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN;Jason S. Goldberg/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN;D. Stephen Goodin/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN;Andrew Friendly/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN;Shelley N. Fidler/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale
READ: UNKNOWN
CN;Anne M. Edwards/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CN;Suzanne Dale/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN;Michael Cohen/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 5 of5
ARMS Email System
<II
r,.~
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO:. Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Tuesday, February 3, 1998, the President will travel to New Mexico to
tour the supercomputer center at Los Alamos National Laboratory and to
deliver remarks to the workers there and, later, to the people of
Alburqurque .
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
NM Background Memos:
DUE MONDAY, FEB. 2 AT 6:00 P.M.
Political Memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
NM Event Memos:
DUE MONDAY,
FEB. 2 AT 6:00 P.M.
Tour of Los Alamos Nat'l Laboratory
Remarks to the Workers
Remarks to the People of Alburqurque
please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�, ,.
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa N. Benton ( CN=Melissa N. Benton/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-FEB-1998 18:05:39.00
SUBJECT:
LABOR Report on H.R. 2864, the Occupational Safety and Health Administrati
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel J. Chenok ( CN=Daniel J. Chenok/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice E. Shuffield ( CN=Alice E. Shuffield/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William F. Wiggins ( CN=william F. Wiggins/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori Schack ( CN=Lori Schack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
By now you should have received the subject LRM (copy attached).
Please
note that the time frame for review is short--the deadline for comments is
tomorrow, 10 a.m.
I apologize for the tight deadline.
Please call (5-7887) or e-mail if you have any questions or do not receive
the document.
---------------------- Forwarded by Melissa N. Benton/OMB/EOP on 02/03/98
04:59 PM --------------------------Total Pages: ____
LRM ID: MNB93
EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
OFFICE OF MANAGEMENT AND BUDGET
Washington, D.C. 20503-0001
Tuesday, February 3, 1998
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM:
Reference
OMB CONTACT:
Legislative Liaison Officer - See Distribution below
Janet R. Forsgren (for) Assistant Director for Legislative
Melissa N. Benton
PHONE: (202) 395-7887 FAX: (202) 395-6148
SUBJECT:
LABOR Report on H.R. 2864, the Occupational Safety and
Health Administration Compliance Assistance Authorization Act of 1997; and
H.R. 2877, to Amend the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970.
DEADLINE:
10:00 a.m.
Tuesday, February 4, 1997
In accordance with OMB Circular A-19, OMB requests the views of your
agency on the above subject before advising on its relationship to the
program of the President.
Please advise us if this item will affect
direct spending or receipts for purposes of the "Pay-As-You-Go" provisions
of Title XIII of the Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act of 1990.
COMMENTS: The Workforce Protections Subcommittee of House Education and
the Workforce is marking up H.R. 2864 and H.R. 2877 tomorrow, so the noted
deadline is firm.
For your reference, the two bills follow the draft
letter.
Note: these two bills are similar to proposals that are included in
comprehensive OSHA legislation (Safety Advancement for Empoloyees, or
SAFE), H.R. 2579 and S. 1237.
DISTRIBUTION LIST
AGENCIES:
92-0ffice of Personnel Management - James N. Woodruff - (202) 606-1424
107-Small Business Administration - Mary Kristine Swedin - (202) 205-6700
61-JUSTICE - Andrew Fois - (202) 514-2141
52-HHS - Sondra S. Wallace - (202) 690-7760
94-0ccupational Safety & Health Rev Comm - William J. Gainer - (202)
606-5380
25-COMMERCE - Michael A. Levitt - (202) 482-3151
76-National Economic Council - Sonyia Matthews - (202) 456-6630
EOP:
Barry White
Larry R. Matlack
Lori Schack
Daniel J. Chenok
William F. Wiggins
Elena Kagan
OMB LA
Robert G. Damus
Sanders D. Korenman
Sara M. Latham
Janet R. Forsgren
LRM ID: MNB93
SUBJECT:
LABOR Report on H.R. 2864, the Occupational Safety
and Health Administration Compliance Assistance Authorization Act of 1997;
and H.R. 2877, to Amend the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970.
RESPONSE TO
�.,
ARMS Email System
Page 3 of3
LEGISLATIVE REFERRAL
MEMORANDUM
If your response to this request for views is short (e.g .• concur/no
comment), we prefer that you respond bye-mail or by faxing us this
response sheet.
If the response is short and you prefer to call, please
call the branch-wide line shown below (NOT the analyst's line) to leave a
message with a legislative assistant.
You may also respond by:
(1) calling the analyst/attorney's direct line (you will be
connected to voice mail if the analyst does not answer); or
(2) sending us a memo or letter
Please include the LRM number shown above, and the subject shown below.
TO:
Melissa N. Benton Phone: 395-7887
Fax:
395-6148
Office of Management and Budget
Branch-Wide Line (to reach legislative assistant): 395-7362
. FROM:
(Date)
(Name)
(Agency)
(Telephone)
The following is the response of our agency to your request for views on
the above-captioned subject:
Concur
______ No Objection
_______ No Comment
See proposed edits on pages
Other:
FAX RETURN of _____ pages, attached to this response sheet
�'I
• ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-FEB-1998 14:36:59.00
SUBJECT:
Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�J
•
•ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: weinstein_dena
READ: UNKNOWN
weinstein dena @ ustr.gov @ INET @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
ce:
Melissa M. Murray ( CN=Melissa M. Murray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura.Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having the Tobacco Strategy Meeting Thursday, February 5, at
2:45 p.m. in Room 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 4-FEB-1998 17:50:40.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�.ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa'A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:00am in room 100. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of I
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP [ OSTP 1
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-FEB-1998 13:36:08.00
SUBJECT:
Rumors about MN settlement
TO: Sarah A. Bianchi ( CN=Sarah A. Bianchi/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
At yesterday's tobacco strategy meeting several people mentioned rumors
about a possible settlement in the MN case.
I have checked with a couple
of senior members of Humphrey's staff and they told me that there are
currently no discussions with the industry about a settlement of their
case nor are they expecting any, that Humphrey has been on record for some
time about what it would take to settle the case (I'll let you just
imagine the terms), and that the state has at least another month to go in
presenting its case.
While I hadn't heard any MN rumors, I have heard rumors about a major
announcement in the next 2 months from the Justice criminal investigation.
�,
"
, ARMS Email System .
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Phyllis Kaiser-Dark ( CN=Phyllis Kaiser-Dark/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-FEB-1998 14:31:27.00
SUBJECT:
NEC Deputies Meeting
TO: Jsteinberg@4569490@fax ( Jsteinberg@4569490@fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alverez@2056802@fax ( Alverez@2056802@fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: fisher_richard@ustr.gov@INET@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
fisher_richard@ustr.gov@INET@LNGTWY [ UNKN
TO: Frankel@3956958@fax ( Frankel@3956958@fax [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: SEizenstat@6479763@fax ( SEizenstat@6479763@fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: EMoler@5866828@fax ( EMoler@5866828@fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: FHansen@4013764@fax ( FHansen@4013764@fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lane@5011262@fax ( lane@5011262@fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KHiggins@2197659@fax ( KHiggins@2197659@fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: lang@3954549@fax ( lang@3954549@fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey A. Frankel
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Jeffrey A. Frankel/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Frank@3956958@fax ( Frank@3956958@fax [ ONDCP 1 )
�..
• ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KThurm@6907755@fax ( KThurm@6907755@fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DRobinson@7082706@fax ( DRobinson@7082706@fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MSmith@4013095@fax ( MSmith@4013095@fax [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MDowney@3663937@fax ( MDowney@3663937@fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: mallett@5011262@fax ( mallett@5011262@fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: summers@6221800@fax ( summers@6221800@fax
READ: UNKNOWN
OPD 1 )
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
OPD 1 )
CC: Sandra L. Via ( CN=Sandra L. Via/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
J
TEXT:
Sally Katzen has offically begun her duties as Deputy Director of the NEC
today.
She would like to have a one hour meeting with other NEC deputies
as a meet/greet, review process, review agenda(s) totally unstructured
meeting. We have reserved room 180, on Tuesday, February 10 at 5:00pm.
please respond bye-mail or phone (395-4852) to provide your clearance
information.
�, ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 5
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:10-FEB-1998 13:42:59,00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to Pennsylvania
TO: Paul A. Tuchmann ( CN=Paul A. Tuchmann/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ .EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael waldman ( CN=Michael waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�· ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E .. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
)
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNI\NOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal
( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�,
.
.. ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. ReberjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. PasquiljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. OrszagjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary MorrisonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon MoorejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. MoloneyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. MayockjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. LockhartjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. LewisjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. LathamjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. HanlinjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. HuynhjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. HorwitzjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. GoldbergjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen GoodinjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN=Andrew FriendlyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. FidlerjOU=CEQjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. EdwardsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne DalejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael CohenjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�...
. . ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Friday, February 13, 1998, the President will travel to Philadelphia to
address the American Association for the Advancement of Science, tape the
weekly radio address, and attend a DCCC dinner.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
PA Background Memos:
DUE WED., FEB. 11, AT 6:00 P.M.
Political Memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
PA Event Memos:
DUE THURS., FEB. 12, AT 6:00 P.M.
AAAS Address
Radio Address
DCCC Dinner
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�'(
"
• ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:11-FEB-1998 18:06:53.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler /OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 .)
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�.
.
• ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ("CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Meeting on Thursday at 9am in room 100. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:11-FEB-1998 18:38:44.00
SUBJECT:
Benchmarking Meeting on Tuesday
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard L. Hayes ( CN=Richard L. Hayes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn M. Chirwa ( CN=Dawn M. Chirwa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff ( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter Rundlet ( CN=Peter Rundlet/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Phyllis Kaiser-bark ( CN=Phyllis Kaiser-Dark/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
GC: Debra A. Schiff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Debra A. Schiff/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Wendy A. Taylor ( CN=Wendy A. Taylor/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Eleanor S. Parker ( CN=Eleanor S. Parker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ora Theard ( CN=Ora Theard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Benchmarking meeting with Erskine on Tuesday, February 17
at 5:00 pm in the Roosevelt Room.
Invited Attendees:
�,
.
)\RMS Email System
Erskine Bowles
Sylvia Mathews
John Podesta
Frank Raines
Chuck Ruff
Janet Yellen
Gene Sperling
Larry Stein
Elena Kagan
Doug Sosnik
Paul Begala
Rahm Emanuel
Maria Echaveste
Mike McCurry
Sally Katzen
Ann Lewis
Dawn Chirwa
Rob Weiner
Richard Hayes
Minyon Moore
Page 3 of3
�• ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melinda D. Haskins ( CN=Melinda D. Haskins/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:12-FEB-1998 15:16:30.00
SUBJECT:
Comments on LRM MDH 131 -- SSA Testimony on "Preparing for Retirement"
TO: Richard B. Bavier ( CN=Richard B. Bavier/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edwin Lau ( CN=Edwin Lau/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Himler ( CN=Janet Himler/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Anderson ( CN=Robert B. Anderson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. Carroll/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Oliven Silberfarb ( CN=Laura Oliven Silberfarb/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher M. Sauer ( CN=Christopher M. Sauer/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra Yamin/Ou=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jill M. Blickstein ( CN=Jill M. Blickstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet R. Forsgren ( CN=Janet R. Forsgren/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�j
•
, ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robert J. Pellicci ( CN=Robert J. Pellicci/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
You will receive shortly LRM MDH 131, SSA Commissioner Apfel's testimony
for the Senate Special committee on Aging's February 18th field hearing on
"Preparing for the Retirement of the Baby Boomers." Comments are due
tomorrow (2/13/98) at 11 a.m.
The comment deadline is firm.
If we do not hear from you, we will assume
that you have no objection to the testimony.
Page 2 of2
�•
l
"
"ARMS Email System
Page I of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. Fernandes/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 17-FEB-1998 17:03:26.00
SUBJECT:
Immigration meeting
TO: Jim Kohlenberger
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: WARNATH S
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Jim Kohlenberger/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
WARNATH S @ A1 @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(CPC)
TO: Steven M. Mertens ( CN=Steven M. Mertens/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: LETTS_K ( LETTS K @ A1 @ CD @ VAXGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Doris o. Matsui ( CN=Doris
READ: UNKNOWN
o.
Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Jack A. Smalligan ( CN=Jack A. Smalligan/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
[ WHO 1 )
�I
'
·ARMS Email System
The immigration working group meeting tomorrow at 3:00pm will be held in
Room 365.
Thanks.
Julie
Page 2 of2
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[01/28/1998 – 02/17/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 098 - Folder 003
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/f58861787c0926c482943ae659d0af0c.pdf
6fd43b29e48d997496e3efd083796302
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 098 - FOLDER -002
[01/07/1998-01/21/1998]
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of28
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Neera Tanden ( CN=Neera Tanden/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-JAN-1998 10:56:03.00
SUBJECT:
New and Revised paper
TO: Amy N. Finkelstein ( CN=Amy N. Finkelstein/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 .)
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of28
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Thes have a small change, but is more correct.
want to redistribute.
==================== ATTACHMENT
o 00:00:00.00
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
You can decide whether you
1 ====================
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH. Dl1] MAIL45470460U. 026 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043A40FOOOOOIOA02010000000205000000D45C00000002000014COD2F42CD750E20D2DFB
D9EA172E3A900736C09Dl18B84ACBCF4827CA7C5C6FB62F4658DBO2D81213534F382FA4403FOC3
76E4C774E9175F5ACAD1A2B3E23CCEF37FE7A974C43F9EA31421EC8OB7685467A94E2056BFDD86
EA02712E361721E7AD8377E7A13442F3D79COFCA59E73BED339A55E59FF9DCB980034547B2A1DA
AEOEEF3DE383786CCD09506BC07AE5956AD6EBFE654583B95F7C9B40E5814198BA5829D305EE7E
40340F0662DDF5F556CFCED514CF7E54592F49052A462E07FC460579BDEC14A05C2A3A6700C8AF
8621578069679825C82F08078B0088123F83399C143726F1B4A95035DFF42CB715778E26DC51B8
C2615CEC9ED346E5EB39DC5CED9FOBB66BFE2C91793553426B3EA83BD22E48253CBF8A67A95033
OB9496489EF1445760CB319BC1BA9C7B2229A80995EDB8A81A446FADE5C8F45E106BEC3A6956C9
ED3114DOl12AC18B026E69C653AC70DFD7AIF936704A415BB19057DD5FD62144B9C08B8CB1EC36
. D12E5A89E31B8EFE2BE048316178807783EFAAE7DAB67A306E8A5D7D4ACBF981EC41CC190126AD
29D8BE34D2CC3BED9DF99E91DD2F8DE3F49508C57EEFEE696668353752FE7B226204E85E400977
BDD75E2C12B064CF053C8364965DD4A2DD2307DB42C2C5A61011BF786AE0577E24F4C16BC9CA22
El14F664770200B700000000000000000000000823010000000B010000020C000000555FOOOOOO
4EOOOOOOODOD0000092501000000060000005BODOOOOOB300300000028000000610D0000081D01
00000000000000890D000000000000000000000000890D00000055OD0000004E000000890DOOOO
08770100000040000000D70D000008340100000014000000170EOO000802010000000F0000002B
OE0000080501000000080000003AOEOOOOOB300100000044000000420E00000055290000003COO
0000860E000000000000000000000000860EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000860EOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000000000860E000000000000000000000000860EOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000860EOOOOOOOO
0000000000000000860E000000000000000000000000860EOOOOOO000000000000000000860EOO
0000000000000000000000860E000000000000000000000000860E000000000000000000000000
860E000000000000000000000000860EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00860EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000860E000000000000000000000000860EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000000860EOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000000000860EOOOOOB300D0000004EOOOOOOC20EOOOOOOOOOO00000000000000C20EOOOOOO
000000000000000000C20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOC20EOOOO00000000000000000000C20E
000000000000000000000000C20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOC2OEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00C20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOC20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO0000C20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00000000C20E00000942050000001DOOOOOOIOOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOlOOFOOOOOOOOOO
00000000000000100F000000000000000000000000100FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOlOOFOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOlOOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOIOOFOO000000000000000000000010
OF000000000000000000000000100FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO100FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000100F000000000000000000000000100F0000094402000000330000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOO0000000000002DOFOOOOOOOO
00000000000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOO0000000000000000002DOFOO
00000000000000000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOF000000000000000000000000
2DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOO000000000000002DOFOOOOOO
0000000000000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOO000000000000000000002DOF
0000000000000000000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOO
000000000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOO00000000000000002DOFOOOO
�-4~
17-?!q~
..s::11~e"o.
PRESIDENT CLINTON ANNOUNCES CHILD CARE
January 7, 1998
INITIATI~-?!~~",
CO"v:~-?!e"/Jl
vo" ~Sle-?!
President Clinton today announced an historic initiative to improve child care for
America's working families. The President's FY 1999 budget will include approximately
$20 billion over five years for child care, the largest single investment in child care in the
nation's history. President Clinton's initiative responds to the struggles our nation's
working parents face in finding child care that they can afford, trust, and rely on. The
President's proposal will help working families pay for child care, build the supply of good
after-school programs, improve the safety and quality of care, and promote early learning.
•
Doubles the number of children receiving child care subsidies to more than two
million by the year 2003 by increasing funding for the Child Care and
Development Block Grant by $7.5 billion over 5 years.
•
Increases tax credits for three million working families to help them pay for
child care by investing $5.2 billion over 5 years in the Child and Dependent Tax
Credit. The President's proposal also provides a new tax credit for businesses
that offer child care services for their employees.
•
Provides after-school care for up to half a million children per year by
expanding the 21st Century Community Learning Center program by $800
million over 5 years to provide funds to school-community partnerships to
establish or expand programs for school-age children.
•
Improves child care safety and quality and enhances early childhood
development by establishing a new Early Learning Fund as well as supporting
enforcement of state child care health and safety standards, providing
scholarships to up to 50,000 child care providers per year, and investing in
research and consumer education.
$7.5 billion over five years
$5.2 billion over five years
$500 million over five years
$800 million over five years
$3 billion over five years
$3.8 billion over five years
$500 million over five years
$250 million over five years
$150 million over five years
Child Care Block Grant Increase
Child and Dependent Tax Credit Reform
Tax Credit for Businesses
After-School Prograrn
Early Learning Fund
Head Start Increase
Standards Enforcement Fund
Child Care Provider Scholarship Fund
Research and Evaluation Fund
ITOTAL:
$21.7 billion over five years
�4utomated R,
Ii; eCOfds M.
MAKES CHILD CARE MORE AFFORDABLE FOR WORKING FAMILIES
eX-Dump Canagement S
onversion 'YSterr
Doubles the Number of Children Receiving Child Care Subsidies to More than Two
Million. The President proposes to expand the Child Care and Development Block Grant to
help working families struggling to meet the costs of child care. This block grant is the
primary federal subsidy program to pay for child care, enabling low-income parents to work.
Funds are distributed by fonnula to the states to operate direct child care subsidy programs,
as well as to improve the quality and availability of care. The President's initiative will
more than double the number of children served from the one million served in FY 95 (the
latest year for which data are available). The President's budget will increase funding for the
block grant by $7.5 billion (with a match) over five years, which will enable states to provide
subsidies for more than two million children by 2003.
Increases Tax Credits for Child Care for Three Million Working Families. The Child
and Dependent Tax Credit provides tax relief to taxpayers who pay for the care of a child
under 13 or a disabled dependent or spouse in order to work. The credit is equal to a
percentage of the taxpayer's employment-related expenditures for child or dependent care,
with the amount ofthe credit depending on the taxpayer's income. The President's proposal
increases the credit for families earning under $60,000, providing an additional average tax
cut of$358 for these families and eliminating income tax liability for almost all families with
incomes below 200% of poverty ($35,000 for a family offour) that take the maximum
allowable child care expenses under the law. The President's budget will include $5.2
billion over five years to expand the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit for three million
working families.
Provides New Business Tax Credits. The child care initiative includes a tax credit to
businesses that provide child care services for their employees, by building or expanding
child care facilities, operating existing facilities, training child care workers, reserving slots
for employees at child care facilities, or providing child care resource and referral services to
employees. The credit covers 25% of qualified costs, but may not exceed $150,000 per year.
The President's budget will include approximately $500 million over five years for these tax
credits.
PROMOTES EARLY LEARNING AND HEALTHY CHILD DEVELOPMENT
Promotes Early Learning. Research shows that children's experiences in the earliest
years are critical to their development and future success. The President's proposed
Early Learning Fund provides challenge grants to communities (distributed by states)
to support programs to improve early learning and the quality and safety of child care
for children ages zero to five. Funds may be used for the following activities: providing
basic training to child care providers (including first aid and CPR); connecting individual
child care providers to centers for education and support; assisting child care providers to
meet accreditation and licensing requirements; linking child care providers with health
professionals; reducing group sizes and child-to-staffratios; and providing home visits,
parent education, and consumer education about child care. The President's Early Learning
Fund builds on state initiatives such as North Carolina's Smart Start, which helps North
�Automate~ Reo Management System
cords
ex- ump Conversion
Carolina's children enter school healthy and ready to succeed. Smart Start funds a broad
variety of local efforts, including improving staff-to-child ratios, health linkages that have
raised immunization rates, and parent education and mentoring programs to give new parents
support. The President's budget will include $3 billion over five years for this fund.
Increases Investment in Head Start and Doubles the Number of Children Served by
Early Head Start. Head Start provides early, continuous and comprehensive child
development and family support services, preparing children for a lifetime ofleaming and
development. The President is committed to reauthorize Head Start and reach one million
children by 2002. The President's budget will invest $3.8 billion over five years to keep
on track his commitment to serving one million children by 2002, and to double the
number of infants and toddlers in Early Head Start to 80,000.
IMPROVES THE QUALITY OF CHILD CARE
Steps Up Enforcement of State Health and Safety Standards. Building on the
military's model child care program, this proposed initiative will fund state efforts to improve
licensing systems and enforce child care health and safety standards, including by increasing
unannounced inspections of child care settings. The President's budget will include $500
million over five years for this program.
Facilitates Background Checks on Child Care Providers. On the day of the White House
Conference on Child Care, the President transmitted to Congress the National Crime
Prevention and Privacy Compact, which will facilitate effective background checks on child
care providers by eliminating state law barriers to sharing criminal history information for
non-criminal purposes. Although the vast majority of child care providers are dedicated to
the teaching and nurturing of children, one tragedy in child care is too many. Background
checks are an important way to ensure that the people watching our children are fit for this
responsibility.
Increases Scholarships and Training for Child Care Providers. At the White House
Conference on Child Care, the President proposed establishing a Child Care Provider
Scholarship Fund to enable states to provide scholarship funds to students working toward a
child care credential. Eligible child care workers must commit to remaining in the field for
at least one year for each year of assistance received and will earn increased compensation or
bonuses when they complete their course work. The President proposed a federal
investment of$250 million over five years, which will support 50,000 scholarships per year.
The President is also proposing to expand the Department of Labor's Child Care
Apprenticeship Program to fund the training of child care providers.
Invests in Research. Because too little is known about our child care system, the
President's budget will increase support for data, research, and evaluation. This research
fund will also support a National Center on Child Care Statistics and a child care hotline that
parents can call to get information about how to find child care in their communities and how
to identify appropriate, quality care for their children. In addition, the research fund will
support demonstration projects to test approaches to help new parents who choose to stay
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
home to care for their newborns or newly adopted children. The President's budget will
include $150 million over five years for this fund.
EXPANDS AND STREAMLINES AFTER-SCHOOL CARE
An estimated five million school-age children spend time as "latchkey kids" without adult
supervision during a typical week. Research indicates that during these unsupervised hours
children are more likely to engage in at-risk behavior, such as crime, drugs, and alcohol use.
To meet this pressing demand, the President is proposing a dramatic expansion of
after-school care.
Provides After-School Care for up to Half a Million Children a Year. The President
proposes a dramatic expansion of the 21st Century Community Leaming Center Program to
provide start-up funds (with a local match) to school-community partnerships to establish or
expand before- and after-school programs for school-age children. The program increases the
supply of after-school care in a cost-effective manner primarily by funding programs that use
public schools and their existing resources, such as computers, gymnasiums, and sports
equipment. The program also includes a set aside to fund programs run by community
organizations. The President's budget will request $800 million of entirely new money for
this program, for a total of $1 billion over five years.
Improves Coordination of Federal After-School Initiatives to Help Communities Make
Best Use of Existing Resources. The President will put in place a collaborative effort
involving numerous federal agencies to eliminate duplication and better coordinate federal
funding for after-school programs in three to five pilot cities, including the District of
Columbia.
�The President's Child Care Initiative
January 7, 1998
Internal Questions & Answers
1. What is the President announcing today?
President Clinton today announced an historic initiative to improve child care for
America's working families. The President's FY 1999 budget will include approximately
$20 billion over five years for child care, the largest single investment in child care in the
nation's history. President Clinton's initiative responds to the struggles our nation's
working parents face in finding child care that they can afford, trust, and rely on. The
President's proposal will help working families pay for child care, build the supply of good
after-school programs, improve the safety and quality of care, and promote early learning.
•
Doubles the number of children receiving child care subsidies to more than two
million by the year 2003 by increasing funding for the Child Care and
Development Block Grant by $7.5 billion over 5 years.
•
Increases tax credits for three million working families to help them pay for
child care by investing $5.2 billion over 5 years in the Child and Dependent Tax
Credit. The President's proposal also provides a new tax credit for businesses
. that offer child care services for their employees.
•
Provides after-school care for 500,000 children per year by expanding the 21st
Century Community Learning Center program by $800 million over 5 years to
provide funds to school-community partnerships to establish or expand
programs for school-age children.
•
Improves child care safety and quality and enhances early childhood
development by establishing a new Early Learning Fund as well as supporting
enforcement of state child care health and safety standards, providing
scholarships to up to 50,000 child care providers per year, and investing in
research and consumer education.
Child Care Block Grant Increase
Child and Dependent Tax Credit Reform
Tax Credit for Businesses
After-School Program
Early Learning Fund
Head Start Increase
Standards Enforcement Fund
Child Care Provider Scholarship Fund
Research and Evaluation Fund
ITOTAL:
1
$7.5 billion over five years
$5.2 billion over five years
$500 million over five years
$1 billion over five years
$3 billion over five years
$3.8 billion over five years
$500 million over five years
$250 million over five years
$150 million over five years
$21.7 billion over five years
�Avlomafed Records Management System
Hex-Oump Conversion
2. The President has been in office for five years. Why is he proposing a child care
initiative now? Is this a new problem?
The child care initiative underscores President Clinton's commitment to strengthening
America's families. As the President has said, child care is "the next great frontier if we're
going to make sure all Americans can succeed at home and at work." (7/28/97) The initiative
that the President announced today builds on the Earned Income Tax Credit, the Family
Medical Leave Act, the Child Tax Credit, the new children's health insurance program, and a
host of other legislation the President has fought for to help American families.
The initiative also builds on President Clinton's continuing efforts to improve and increase
funding for child care. Under President Clinton, federal funding for child care has increased
by 70%, helping parents pay for the care of about one million children. The 1996 welfare
reform law increased child care funding by $4 billion over six years to provide child care
assistance to low-income working families moving from welfare to work.
3. How are you going to pay for this big package?
The President's budget carefully pays for each and every element of his child care initiative.
The package is funded in a variety of ways -- some on the mandatory and others on the
discretionary side of the budget. The offsets for the mandatory items include -- but are not
limited to -- expected revenues from a national tobacco settlement, which the President hopes
and believes Congress will pass this year.
4. Since much of the funding of this proposal is based on the tobacco settlement, aren't
you counting your chickens before they've hatched? What will you do if the tobacco
settlement does not go through?
First, the initiative is paid for in a number of ways -- only one part comes from tobacco
revenues. Second, and more important, we believe that a national tobacco settlement will
pass. The President strongly supports legislation consistent with his principles, and many
Republicans and Democrats alike are working vigorously to craft comprehensive legislation.
Of course, no offset proposed in a budget is guaranteed; the Congress can reject any proposed
way of financing a program. If Congress does not pass comprehensive tobacco legislation,
we will work with Congress to find other offsets. This is a high Administration priority, and
we will find an effective funding mechanism.
5. Aren't you just creating a new federal bureaucracy?
The President's child care initiative creates no new federal bureaucracy. Rather, it relies on
states and communities to decide for themselves how best to address the child care challenges
they face. Indeed, the funds for each major initiative flow either to states or communities, or
in the case of tax credits, to individuals themselves.
2
�Automated Records M
Hex-Dump canagef!!ent System
onvel'S/on
6. The White House Conference on Early Learning and Development highlighted the
crucial development that takes place in the first years of a child's life. Given that the
best caregiver is a parent, what are you doing to help parents stay at home with their
children during this important time?
The program announced today is primarily oriented toward families where both caregivers go
. to work, usually for reasons of financial necessity. It is designed to ensure that children in
these families receive quality care even though their parents are in the workforce.
The President believes strongly, however, that we should support parents who can and
choose to stay home. Today's announcement also includes two proposals that will help
these parents stay at home. First, the Administration will support demonstration projects in
states and communities to test policies to help new parents who choose to stay home to care
for their newborns or newly adopted children. Second, the President's Early Learning Fund
supports parents who stay at home by supporting home visits and parent education.
These initiatives build on President Clinton's record of providing real choices and
opportunities for parents. He has fought for: a $500 per child tax credit for families with
children; the Earned Income Tax Credit that gives 15 million working families tax relief;
health insurance for children; increases in the minimum wage; and the Family and Medical
Leave Act. President Clinton is committed to helping parents make the choices that are
right for their families, whether that means working or staying home to care for their
children.
7. What role
~id
the First Lady have in developing this initiative?
The First Lady has been a strong voice for children and families for over twenty-five years
and continues to work on these issues. Mrs. Clinton played an important role in developing
the White House Conference on Early Learning and Development and the White House
Conference on Child Care. During the policy development process for the child care
initiative, the President looked to the First Lady for her advice and expertise on the problems
with the child care system and on possible solutions.
8. How do you expect to get Republican support for this initiative?
Child care traditionally has been a bipartisan issue. In fact, two of the central elements of
the President's child care initiative were strongly supported by previous Republican
Presidents and Members of Congress. Both Presidents Reagan and Bush supported the
expansion of the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit, and President Bush supported the
creation of the Child Care and Development Block Grant.
Many Members of the House and Senate from both sides of the aisle have shown a
commitment to taking action by introducing legislation that would improve the quality of
child care, make it more affordable, and promote early leaming. We look forward to
3
�working with them to pass significant child care legislation this year.
AutomatedR
ecords M,
HeX-Dump c~nage'!lent System
version
TAX CREDITS
9. Today, the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit (CDCTC) favors middle-income
taxpayers and offers less relief to lower-income taxpayers. Wouldn't it be more fair to
make the CDCTC refundable?
The President's proposed expansion of the CDCTC would wipe out tax liability for most
families with incomes under 200% of poverty (e.g., $35,000 for a family of four) who have
the maximum allowable child care expenses. In addition, the President's proposal
significantly expands the Child Care and Development Block Grant, which is an effective
mechanism to help low-income working families with child care costs. The two proposals
together offer significant reliefto both low- and middle-income parents.
10. Wouldn't eliminating the marriage penalty help millions of working families with
children? Why aren't you supporting eliminating the penalty as part of your child
care initiative?
The Administration believes that proposals currently on the table to eliminate the marriage
penalty are prohibitively expensive in the context of a balanced budget. The President chose
instead to provide targeted tax cuts to assist American families struggling to meet child care
costs. These tax cuts will help more than three million families to pay for high-quality child
care.
Helping working families, especially those with children, has been the centerpiece of the
President's agenda on tax cuts. In 1993, the President expanded the Eamed Income Tax
Credit to give the average recipient with two children more than $1,000 in tax relief In 1997,
the President signed into law a $500 per child tax credit that will help 27 million families
meet the costs of fllising their children. In addition, his $1,500 HOPE Scholarship Tax Credit
and Lifelong Learning Tuition Tax Credit will help nearly 13 million students meet the costs
of college and higher education. The President will continue to focus tax and overall
economic policy on helping working families.
11. Won't the employer credit for child care expenses that the President is proposing
create a windfall for companies already operating child care centers or otherwise
subsidizing employee child care?
Very few for-profit employers are currently making child care services available to their
employees. The credit will provide a real incentive to employers to create new employee
child care programs. Also, for those employers who already have a child care program, the
credit will help support expansion of services.
.
4
�SUBSIDIES
12. Why are you expanding the Child Care and Development Block Grant (CCDBG)
when states aren't using all oftheir child care subsidy money now?
In fact, we are very encouraged by state reports which show they have obligated over 99 of
the child care fund available under the new welfare law for FY 1997.
This demonstrates
the tremendous need states have for child care, and President Clinton has continued to urge
states to invest their dollars into helping these working families. But let's be clear-this
current initiative is not aimed at mothers on welfare. It's aimed at working parents who·
desperately need this assistance. For example, working families with annual incomes under
$14,400 that pay for care for children under five spend 25 of their income on child care -and even then it's difficult finding accessible, quality care.
13. According to some news stories, states have big surpluses which they could spend on child
care. Rep. Clay Shaw recently issued a report saying that states have significant and growing
surplus federal welfare dollars. The report also said that given the surpluses and the increase in
child care funding under the new welfare law, there isn't a need now for more child care
money. Why are you proposing to add to CCDBG?
The Administration is very pleased that a strong economy and state welfare reform efforts
have helped families move from welfare to work. But let's be clear-this initiative is not
aimed at mothers on welfare. It's aimed at working parents. For example, working families
with annual incomes under $14,400 that pay for care for children under five spend 25% of
their income on child care. Currently, we're serving only a small percentage of eligible
children from working families: there are approximately 10 million children who are eligible
for federal child care assistance, but we are able to serve only over a million of these children.
For America's working families to succeed in the workplace, they need quality choices in
affordable and accessible child care. The President's initiative, with its combination of
increased subsidies for low-income families and tax credits for moderate- and middle-income
families, will provide working parents the opportunity to remain self-sufficient and succeed
both at home and at work.
14. When the President signed the welfare bill, he claimed that the big increase in
CCDBG would make welfare reform work. Now that he is proposing adding to it, is he
admitting that his previous child care efforts were not sufficient?
No. The President fought to spend $4 billion more on child care in welfare reform
legislation to help mothers on welfare go to work, and he continues to believe that child care
is a critical component of welfare reform. However, low-income parents who have never
been on welfare are also struggling to afford child care, and all working families want their
5
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
.
children to be in safe, healthy settings where they can learn and grow. These initiatives
address the concerns and needs of all working families in this country. In particular,
expansion of the block grant will enable many states to provide subsidies for the first time to
the non-welfare working poor.
15. In order to keep up with the additional need for child care under welfare reform,
aren't states creating new slots at the expense of quality? What protection do you have
against states just increasing slots without regard to quality if you simply increase the
block grant?
The President believes that we must make child care more affordable as well as improve
quality because he believes that both are important. That is why his child care initiative
includes investments in both, and that is why the President fought hard during the welfare
debate to preserve 4% of funding through the child care block grant for state investments in
quality.
QUALITY
16. What does the Early Learning Fund actually do? How will you measure results?
Recent scientific research has demonstrated that experiences during the earliest years of life -before children reach school age .- are critical to their cognitive, emotional, and physical
development. Nurturing and stimulating children in the first years of life help their brains
develop and prepare them for the challenges of school and later life. We also know that too
much child care for infants and toddlers is inadequate: one respected study found that 13% of
regulated and 50% of unregulated family child care providers offer care that is inadequate for
children ages zero to three. President Clinton's proposed Early Learning Fund is designed to
improve early learning and development for our youngest children; to ensure health and
safety in child care; and to support parents as they raise their children.
The President's Early Learning Fund builds on state initiatives such as North Carolina's
Smart Start, which helps North Carolina's children enter school healthy and ready to succeed.
Smart Start funds a broad variety oflocal efforts, including improving staff·to-child ratios,
health linkages that have raised immunization rates, and parent education and mentoring
programs to give new parents support.
17. How is the Early Learning Fund different from Early Head Start?
Early Head Start is a relatively small program that reaches only certain poor families. The
new initiative will promote early learning and provide parent support and education to
parents at a wider range of income levels. The Early Learning Fund also differs from Head
Start and Early Head Start because it targets support to communities that have developed
innovative approaches to foster early learning and meet the child care needs of families.
6
�ilYtom6ted Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
18. Wasn't the President already committed to serving one million children by 2002?
What's new in this Head Start initiative?
The President's child care initiative proposes an additional $1 billion targeted to Early Head
Start to double the number of infants and toddlers served, in addition to his commitment to
reauthorize all of Head Start to reach one million children by 2002. The total cost is $3.8
billion.
19. Much of the research the White House has highlighted tells us what we need to do
to ensure healthy child development. Given that these practices are the same
everywhere, why have you not proposed national standards?
We do know what works. As we learned at the White House Conference on Child Care, safe
facilities, ongoing guidance from health professionals, and child care providers who are well
trained and adequately compensated result in quality care. However, we also learned at the
conference that many states have go<;>d quality standards, but do not have the resources to
fund enforcement of those standards. The President's Standards Enforcement Fund will
help states improve licensing, enforce standards, and increase unannounced inspections
of child care settings. In addition, particularly when it comes to the youngest children,
different states face different challenges in their child care systems. That is why the
President's Early Learning Fund gives states a menu of allowable activities to promote early
learning and development so that states can concentrate on those areas where they are falling
behind. In this way, the quality of care will improve across the country.
20. At the White House Conference on Child Care, you championed the National
Crime Prevention and Privacy Compact. What happened to the Compact?
The National Crime Prevention and Privacy Compact has been transmitted to Congress. The
Compact is an important part of the President's child care initiative, and the President will
push for its passage when Congress returns.
21. Won't the scholarship fund raise the wages of child care workers, and in turn,
increase the cost of child care and make it un affordable for many families?
This proposal is modeled after North Carolina's T.E.A.C.H. program; North Carolina has not
seen higher costs since it put T.E.A.C.H. in place. Because child care workers are likely to .
stay in their jobs longer if they are trained and better compensated, any additional costs of
increased wages will be offset to some extent by savings associated with reduced staff
turnover.
22. If you are proposing a huge increase in federal research of child care issues,
shouldn't you wait to make policy based on what you learn from the research?
7
�Automated Records Management Systerr'
Hex-Dump Conversion
Whilethere is much we don't know about our child care system, we do know enough to act.
Child care is a pressing problem in America: 45% percent of all children under the age of one
are in child care on a regular basis; much of this is inadequate; and families with annual
incomes under $14,400 that pay for care for children under five spend about 25% oftheir
income on child care. We cannot afford to wait to improve the quality of care these children
receive.
AFTER- SCHOOL PROGRAMS
23. Your after-school proposal requires programs to be run in the schools. What do
you do for those children in communities where the school will not or cannot provide an
after-school program?
While a major purpose of the 21st Century Learning Centers Program is to make use of
underutilized school facilities, the program includes a set aside to fund programs run by
community groups. In addition, the President's FY 1999 budget includes $95 million for
after school and other prevention programs administered by the Department of Justice.
Innovative programs that are run by community groups in museums, recreation centers or
other places outside schools may receive funding fro~ this after-school initiative.
GENERAL
24. Much attention has been given to the au pair system since nineteen year old Louise
Woodward was tried for killing a baby in her care. What are you doing to reform the
au pair system?
The U.S. Information Agency (the agency that runs the au pair program) announced in
September updated regulations on the screening and placement of au pairs. Under the new
regulations: au pairs who care for children under two years old must have 200 or more
documented hours of infant-care experience; au pair training will include 24 hours of
child-devclopment instruction; au pairs will be limited to working 10 hours a day and 45
hours a week; their pay will be increased from $115 to $139 a week; and the screening and
selection process will be improved.
25. What are the child care options for parents who work at the White House?
Employees of the Executive Office of the President (EOP) can enroll their children in the
nearby U.S. Kids Child Development Center, a center accredited by the independent National
Association for the Education of Young Children. Additionally, White House parents may
enroll their children in any of the 27 other Federal child care centers in the greater
Washington, D.C. area.
26. What is the child care system for federal employees?
8
�Automated Records M
Hex-Dump cg~:g~~~nt SystefTI
There are more than 230 child care centers for civilian government employees in federal
buildings in as many as 36 states, including 108 centers overseen by the General Services
Administration (GSA). Seventy-three percent of GSA sponsored centers are accredited by
the independent National Association for Education of Young Children, and GSA is working
to reach 100 accreditation within two years. Striving to meet the needs of parent workers,
89 of GSA centers have infant care, 74 have drop-in/emergency care, and 42 provide
summer programs for school-aged children. In addition, more than 80 of centers are open
11 or more hours per day. Notably, nearly 70% of the child care center directors have ten or
more years of experience in early childhood education.
27. Apparently many low-income federal employees cannot afford the federal child
care system. What are you doing to help them?
The federal government, like the private sector, still faces challenges in providing affordable
care to lower paid employees. GSA has studied this problem intensively this year and has
released a report to Congress outlining a plan to increase revenues and enrollment, reduce
operating costs, and expand the availability of tuition assistance for parents who can't afford
to pay full fees.
28. You have touted the military's child care system as a model for the nation. Isn't it
good because they spend so much?
While the military does invest significant resources into their child care system, they also set
and enforce high quality standards (including through unannounced inspections), support
family day care networks, offer a strong resource and referral system, and provide a wide
variety of care options, all of which increase quality without large investments.
The Department of Defense's Child Care System serves over 200,000 children daily (age
zero to 12), making it the largest employer-sponsored child care program in the nation.
Through this system, the military offers full-day, part-day, and hourly child care, part-day
preschools, before- and after-school programs for school age children, and extended hour
care. Because of the Department of Defense's commitment to excellence in child care, since
1992, the number of military child care facilities that are accredited by the independent
National Association for the Education of Young Children has risen from 55 to 353.
Currently, over 75% of military child care programs are accredited, as compared to only 7%
of other child care facilities nationwide.
29. Washington D.C.'s child care system is in crisis. What are you doing to improve
the child care system in this city?
Administration officials, concemed over the state of child care in the District, have met with
D.C. officials on several occasions to discuss ways to hnprove the quality of care the children
who live in the District receive. A working group including major stakeholders -- the
Department of Health and Human Services, the Office of Management and Budget, the office
9
�I ••
of the Mayor, the D.C. Council, the Control Board, and other city agencies have forged a
partnership to improve the quality of child care services in the District. The District's
Department of Consumer and Regulatory Affairs has issued a draft Strategic Plan to improve
child care quality.
In addition, the President will include D.C. as one ofthree to five pilot cities involved in an
interagency effort to eliminate duplication and better coordinate federal funding streams for
after-school programs.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
10
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 13
(ALL-IN-1 MAIL)
CREATOR: OASIS Manager ( OASISMGR )
(OA)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-JAN-1998 12:09:08.38
SUBJECT: Document Request Reminder
TO: Mary E. Jones
READ:NOT READ
JONES ME ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Ronald E. Jones
READ: NOT READ
JONES RE ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Wayne A. Jones
READ: NOT READ
JONES W ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Wal ter F. Jone's
READ: NOT READ
JONES WF ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: James F. Jordan
READ: NOT READ
JORDAN JF
TO: M. Kay Joshi
READ: 7-JAN-1998 12:21:22.33
JOSHI M
TO: Gay L. Joshlyn
READ: NOT READ
JOSHLYN G ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Michele R. Joy
READ: 7-JAN-1998 13:05:57.18
JOY M)
TO: James J. Jukes
READ: NOT READ
JUKES J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Edward H. Jurith
READ: NOT READ
JURITH E
(DON)
TO: Paul A. Jutton
READ: 7-JAN-1998 18:27:08.32
JUT TON P
(OA)
TO: Elena Kagan
READ:NOT READ
KAGAN E ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Brian G. Kahin
READ: NOT READ
KAHIN B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Barbara F. Kah1ow.
READ: NOT READ
KAHLOW B ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Aram H. Kailian
READ: NOT READ
KAILIA A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Phyllis Kaiser-Dark
READ:NOT READ
(OMB)
(NSC)
(OA)
( KAISERDARK P ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Anil Kakani
READ: NOT READ
KAKANI A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: David E. Kalbaugh
KALBAUGH D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
�Page 2 of 13
ARMS Email System
READ:NOT READ
TO: Thomas A. Kalil
READ: NOT READ
KALIL T ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Andris Kalnins
READ: 7-JAN-1998 12:09:48.03
KALNINS A
TO: John Kamensky
READ: NOT READ
KAMENSKY J
TO: Andrea Kane
READ:NOT READ
KANE A 1 Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Robert S. Kapla
READ: NOT READ
KAPLA R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Jody J. Kaplan
READ: NOT READ
KAPLAN J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan
READ:NOT READ
KAPLAN JA ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Olga H. Kasaskeris
READ: 7-JAN-1998 12:23:38.94
KASASKERIS 0
TO: Stuart R. Kasdin
READ: NOT READ
KASDIN S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address·
TO: Sally Katzen
READ: NOT READ
KATZEN S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Stanley Kaufman
READ:NOT READ
KAUFMAN S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Karen E. Kaufmann
READ: 7-JAN-1998 12:10:31.23
KAUFMANN K
TO: James B. Kazel
READ: 7-JAN-1998 16:58:31.23
KAZEL J
TO: Alex S. Keenan
READ:NOT READ
KEENAN A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Henry C. Kelly
READ:NOT READ
KELLY H ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: John W. Kelly
READ:NOT READ
KELLY J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Kenneth S. Kelly
READ:NOT READ
KELLY K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Sandra L. Kelly
READ:NOT READ
KELLY S
TO: Ann L. Kendrall
READ:NOT READ
KENDRALL A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Ronald T. Keohane
KEOHANE R 1 Autoforward to: Remote Addres
(OA)
) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
(OA)
(OAl
(OMB)
(NSC)
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of 13
READ: NOT READ
TO: Donald L. Kerrick
READ: 8-JAN-1998 08:46:23.20
KERRICK D
TO: Farooq A. Khan
READ: NOT READ
KHAN F ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Charles E. Kieffer
READ:NOT READ
KIEFFER C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Gerald P. Kiernan
READ: NOT READ
KIERNAN G ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Erica L. Kilpatrick
READ: NOT READ
KILPATRICK E
TO: Robert W. Kilpatrick
READ: NOT READ
KILPATRICK R ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: William R. Kincaid
READ: NOT READ
KINCAID W ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Francis Kinney
READ: NOT READ
KINNEY F ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Brenda J. Kinser-Kidane
READ: NOT READ
KINSERKIDA B
TO: Benjamin J. Kirby
READ: NOT READ
KIRBY B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Katherine Kirchgraber
READ:NOT READ
KIRCHGRABE K ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Nancy Kirkendall
READ: NOT READ
KIRKENDALL N ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO:-Catherine T. Kitchen
READ: NOT READ
KITCHEN C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Carole Kitti
READ: NOT READ
KITTI C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Ron Klain
READ:NOT READ
KLAIN R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Jennifer L. Klein
READ:NOT READ
KLEIN J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Andrew W. Kleine
READ: NOT READ
KLEINE A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Charlotte D. Knepper
READ: 7-JAN-1998 14:51:23.27
KNEPPER C
TO: Sarah S. Knight
READ:NOT READ
KNIGHT S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Louisa Koch
KOCH L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(NSC)
(NSC)
(NSC)
�Page 4 of 13
ARMS Email System
READ: NOT READ
TO: Richard H. Kodl
READ: NOT READ
KODL R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Raymond P. Kogut
READ: NOT READ
KOGUT R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: James Kohlenberger
READ: NOT READ
KOHLEN J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Alicia K. Kolaian
READ: NOT READ
KOLAIAN A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Randy J. Kolton
READ: NOT READ
KOLTON R ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Charles Konigsberg
READ: NOT READ
KONIGSBERG C ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Sanders D. Korenman
READ: NOT READ
KORENMAN S
TO: Joseph G. Kouba
READ: 7-JAN-1998 13:53:27.73
KOUBA J
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes
READ: NOT READ
KOUNTOUPES L ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Lori K. Krause
READ: NOT READ
KRAUSE L ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Lori A. Krauss
READ: NOT READ
KRAUSS L ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Paul Kriebel
READ: NOT READ
KRIEBEL P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Sandra J. Kristoff
READ: NOT READ
KRISTOFF S
TO: Karen C. Kucik
READ: NOT READ
KUCIK K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Heidi Kukis
READ: NOT READ
KUKIS H ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Karin Kullman
READ: NOT READ
KULLMAN K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Steve L. Kwast
READ: NOT READ
KWAST S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Robert D. Kyle
READ: NOT READ
KYLE R
TO: Agustin A. Labrador
READ: NOT READ
LABRADOR A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Joseph F. Lackey Jr.
LACKEY J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
(CEA)
(OA)
(NSC)
(OPD)
�Page 50f13
ARMS Email System
READ: NOT READ
TO: Cecilia D. Lafoe
READ: NOT READ
LAFOE C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Briggitte R. LaFontant
READ:NOT READ
LAFON~ANT_B
TO: Leonard L. Lainhart Jr
READ:NOT READ
LAINHART L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: James A. Laity
READ:NOT READ
LAITY J
TO: Jeanne Lambrew
READ: NOT READ
LAMBREW J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Betty G. Lambuth
READ:NOT READ
LAMBUTH B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Linda L Lance
READ: NOT READ
LANCE L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Meredith A. Lane
READ: NOT READ
LANE MA ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Janice M. Langley
READ: 8-JAN-1998 13:18:29.05
LANGLEY J
TO: Nicholas Lapham
READ: NOT READ
LAPHAM N
TO: Sarah Laskin
READ:NOT READ
LASKIN S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Sara M. Latham
READ:NOT READ
LATHAM S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Edwin Lau
READ:NOT READ
LAU E ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Keith E. Laughlin
READ: NOT READ
LAUGHLIN K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Christopher J. Lavery
READ: NOT READ
LAVERY C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Michael G. Lawrence
READ: NOT READ
LAWRENCE M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Wanda L. Lawrence
READ: 7-JAN-1998 13:22:04.56
LAWRENCE W
TO: Jackie D. Lawson
READ: 9-JAN-1998 13:54:11.56
LAWSON J
TO: Sandra O. Lawson
READ: NOT READ
LAWSON S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: William H. Leary
LEARY W
) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
(NSC)
( CEQ)
(OA)
(OA)
(NSC)
�ARMS Email System
Page 6 of 13
READ: 7-JAN-1998 14:27:04.73
TO: David C. Leavy
READ: NOT READ
LEAVY D
TO: Corey G. Lee
READ: NOT READ
LEE C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Earlene C. Lee
READ: NOT READ
LEE EC ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Ha Yan Lee
READ:NOT READ
LEE H ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Malcolm R. Lee
READ: NOT READ
LEE M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Sarah S. Lee
READ: NOT READ
LEE SS ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Thomas D. Lee
READ: 7-JAN-1998 16:53:41.48
LEE T
TO: Robyn Leeds
READ: NOT READ
LEEDS R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Christopher S. Lehane
READ: NOT READ
LEHANE C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kelley A. Lehman
READ: NOT READ
LEHMAN K ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Alexandra Lehr
READ:NOT READ
LEHR A ) Autoforward to: Remote
TO: Kathy D. Leodler
READ: NOT READ
LEODLER K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Judith E. Leonard
READ:NOT READ
LEONARD J
TO: Daniel Lesmez
READ: NOT READ
LESMEZ D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kelly J. Letts
READ: NOT READ
LETTS K
TO: Cameron M. Leuthy
READ: NOT READ
LEUTHY C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: LisaoJ. Levin
READ: NOT READ
LEVIN L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Rachel E. Levinson
READ: NOT READ
LEVINSON R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Alan M. Levitt
READ: 7-JAN-1998 19:17:30.81
LEVITT A
TO: Jacob J. Lew
LEW J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(NSC)
(OA)
Ad~ressee
) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
(NSC)
(DON)
�ARMS Email System
Page 7 of 13
READ: NOT READ
TO: Ann F. Lewis
READ: NOT READ
LEWIS_AF ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne H. Lewis
READ:NOT READ
LEWIS AH ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Annette P. Lewis
READ: 8-JAN-1998 08:29:25.30
LEWIS AP
TO: Jeanette A. Lewis
READ:NOT READ
LEWIS J
TO: Lisa Lewis
READ: NOT READ
LEWIS L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Sharon R. Lewis
READ: NOT READ
LEWIS S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Thomas S. Lewis
READ:NOT READ
LEWIS TS ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Richard A. Lichtenberger
READ:NOT READ
LICHTENBER R ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Linn M. Ligon
READ:NOT READ
LIGON L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Henry E. Lilienthal
READ:NOT READ
LILIENTHAL H ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Judy C. Lin
READ: NOT READ
LIN J
TO: Susanne D. Lind
READ: NOT READ
LIND S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Susan D. Lindahl
READ:NOT READ
LINDAHL S
TO: John F. Lindsay
READ: NOT READ
LINDSAY JF ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Mark F. Lindsay
READ: NOT READ
LINDSAY M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey
READ: NOT READ
LINDSEY B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Christine J. Lindsey
READ: NOT READ
LINDSEY C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Wanda D. Lindsey
READ: 8-JAN-1998 09:11:46.51
LINDSEY W
TO: Michael Lingenfelter
READ: 7-JAN-1998 13:00:52.74
TO: Susan M. Liss
(OA)
(DON)
) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(WHO)
(DON)
( LINGENFELTER )
(OA)
LISS S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
�ARMS Email System
Page 8 of 13
READ: NOT READ
TO: Lin Liu
READ: NOT READ
LIU L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Cynthia J. Lizik
READ: 8-JAN-1998 08:13:00.14
LIZIK C
TO: Neil R. Lobron
READ:NOT READ
LOBRON N ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Patrick G. Locke
READ:NOT READ
LOCKE P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart
READ:NOT READ
LOCKHART J
TO: Richard C. Loeb
READ:NOT READ
LOEB R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Russell F. Loiselle
READ: NOT READ
LOISELLE R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Bruce D. Long
READ: NOT READ
LONG B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Ranelle A. Lopez
READ: NOT READ
LOPEZ R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Tania I. Lopez
READ:NOT READ
LOPEZ T ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Sue Lou
READ: NOT READ
LOU S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Ellen M. Lovell
READ: NOT READ
LOVELL E ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Nguyen-Phuong K. Lu
READ: NOT READ
LU N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Randall W. Lutter
READ: NOT READ
LUTTER R ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne R. Luzzatto
READ: 7-JAN-1998 20:08:09.54
LUZZATTO A
TO: Randolph M. Lyon
READ: NOT READ
LYON R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Stuart W. Maberry
READ: NOT READ
MABERRY S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Joslyn G. Mack
READ: 7-JAN-1998 14:52:51.26
MACK J
TO: Eric L. Macris
READ: NOT READ
MACRIS E ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Ira C. Magaziner
MAGAZINER I ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
(OA)
) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
(NSC)
(OMB)
�ARMS Email System
Page 9 of 13
READ:NOT READ
TO: Allison J. Major
READ: NOT READ
MAJOR A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Margaret A. Malanoski
READ:NOT READ
MALANOSKI M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Alphonso J. Maldon
READ:NOT READ
MALDON A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Robert Malley
READ:NO:r READ
MALLEY R
TO: Kathleen D. Malliarakis
READ:NOT READ
MALLIARAKI K ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Aimee M. Malnati
READ: NOT READ
MALNAT A ) Auto"forward to: Remote Address
TO: Michael D. Malone
READ:NOT READ
MALONE M ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Sean P. Maloney
READ:NOT READ
MALONEY S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Kimberly A. Maluski
READ: NOT READ
MALUSKI K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Jerold R. Mande
READ: NOT READ
MANDE J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Alex D. Mandl
READ: NOT READ
MANDL A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Dalton L. Mann
READ:NOT READ
MANN D ) Autoforward to:
TO: Christy M. Manso
READ:NOT READ
MANSO C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Heather M. Marabeti
READ:NOT READ
MARABE H ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Laura S. Marcus
READ: NOT READ
MARCUS LS ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Karen A. Maris
READ:NOT READ
MARIS K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: David C. Marksz
READ:NOT READ
MARKSZ D
TO: Charles R. Marr
READ:NOT READ
MARR C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Henry H. Marsden
READ:NOT READ
MARSDEN H
TO: Betty A. Marshall
MARSHALL B
(NSC)
Remote Addressee
(WHO)
(DON)
(NSC)
�ARMS Email System
Page 10 of 13
READ:12-JAN-1998 07:47:28.53
TO: Capricia P. Marshall
READ: NOT READ
MARSHALL C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Thurgood Marshall
READ: NOT READ
MARSHALL T ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: William P. Marshall
READ: NOT READ
MARSHALL W ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Bernard H. Martin
READ: NOT READ
MARTIN B ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Bryan M. Martin
READ: NOT READ
MARTIN BM
TO: Demond T. Martin
READ: NOT READ
MARTIN D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Tanya E. Martin
READ: NOT READ
MARTIN T ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Michele C. Marx
READ: NOT READ
MARX M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Julie E. Mason
READ: NOT READ
MASON J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Mia Masten
READ: NOT READ
MASTEN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Michael A. Matera
READ: NOT READ
MATERA M
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews
READ: NOT READ
MATHEWS SM ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Larry R. Matlack
READ: NOT READ
MATLACK L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Doris o. Matsui
READ: NOT READ
MATSUI D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Sonyia Matthews
READ: NOT READ
MATTHEWS S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Valerie S. Matthews
READ: NOT READ
MATTHEWS V ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Nancy H. Maxfield
READ:12-JAN-1998 09:21:28.77
MAXFIELD N
TO: Emory L. Mayfield
READ: NOT READ
MAYFIELD E ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Andrew J. Mayock
READ: NOT READ
MAYOCK A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Cathy R. Mays
MAYS C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(OA)
(NSC)
(NSC)
�.
Page 11 of 13
ARMS Email System
READ: NOT READ
TO: Shelly McAllister
READ: NOT READ
MCALLISTER S ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TEXT:
As a reminder and for everyone's convenience, attached are the two December 30,
1997 directives that have already been delivered in hard copy.
The memoranda
request that staff respond by tomorrow, January 8, 1998.
December 30, 1997
MEMORANDUM FOR ALL STAFF OF THE EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
CHARLES F. C. RUFF
FROM:
COUNSEL TO THE PRESIDENT
SALLY P. PAXTON
SPECIAL ASSOCIATE COUNSEL TO THE PRESIDENT
REQUEST FOR DOCUMENTS
SUBJECT:
We have received Congressional subpoenas for documents from the House Government
Reform Committee which relate to the White House Office Database ("WhoDB") and
other matters. Every employee is responsible for searching all of his or her
own White House records for materials (whether in hard copy, computer or any
other form) to ensure a comprehensive search.
The head of each office must also provide a signed certification that all staff
within that office have searched their records and provided copies of any
responsive materials in their possession. Additionally, the Counsel's Office
has been working with the staff of the Office of Records Management to find
responsive material located in storage.
If you believe materials that you have
sent to Records Management may contain responsive information, please let us
know so that we can ensure that all responsive materials are found.
In responding to'the following requests, "EOP" includes any person employed by
or assigned to any office of the Executive Office of the President, including
the White House.
"Malone" includes W.P. Malone, Inc. or Percy Malone.
REQUESTS:
1.
All materials reflecting involvement or communications by EOP
personnel, from January 20, 1993 through the present,
regarding
,any database implemented or discussed, contemplated or planned
to be implemented, by or on behalf of Clinton/Gore, the DNC, or
any Clinton Presidential campaign entity, for the purpose of
maintaining any list of, or information about, supporters or
contributors.
2.
All materials reflecting contracts or terms of contracts
(including "use agreements"), whether in draft or final, between
the EOP and any vendor, the DNC, Clinton/Gore or any other party
with respect to the 1993, 1994, 1995 or 1996 White House holiday
cards.
3.
All materials reflecting any restrictions on the use by either
the DNC or Clinton/Gore of information contained in any White
House database.
4.
All materials relating to PeopleBase. This request includes any
documents, whether in draft or in final, which reflect any
agreements between either (1) the EOP and Malone, or (2)
Clinton/Gore and Malone.
5.
All materials which reflect the non-disclosure statement between
the EOP and Malone for information contained in PeopleBase.
6.
All materials relating to Malone.
7.
All materials relating to guidelines for the payment for use of
the President or the Vice President's residences for nonofficial
purposes.
8.
All copies of a Kevin O'Keefe memorandum written on or about May
�Page 12 of 13
ARMS Email System
24, 1994 regarding early supporters.
All materials which reflect efforts to respond to or comply with
all previous requests for documents or materials related to the
WhoDB, including directives sent by Jack Quinn dated August 7,
1996 and September 12, 1996.
please provide copies of any responsive materials to Sally Paxton, OEOB Room
148, by January 8, 1998.
If you anticipate any difficulty in meeting this
deadline, or if you have any questions, please call either Sally Paxton at ext.
65079 or Dimitri Nionakis at ext. 65814.
Thank you very much for your cooperation with this request.
9.
December 30, 1997
MEMORANDUM FOR ALL EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT STAFF
CHARLES F.C. RUFF
FROM:
COUNSEL TO THE PRESIDENT
SUBJECT:
Document Request
We have received a subpoena for materials related to the Department of
Interior's (DOI) decision to deny an application to place a 55 acre parcel of
land located in Hudson, Wisconsin, in trust for gaming purposes (hereinafter the
"Hudson casino proposal") .
In an effort to comply fully with this subpoena, please search your records for
all materials (whether in hard copy, computer or other form) responsive to the
requests listed below. Every employee is responsible for searching all of his
or her own files and records to ensure a comprehensive search.
The head of each office also must provide a signed certification that all
employees have searched their files and provided copies of any responsive
materials in their possession. Additionally, the Counsel's Office has been
working with the staff of the Office of Records Management to find responsive
material located in storage.
If you believe that you have sent files to Records
,Management that may contain responsive information, please let us know so that
we can ensure that all responsive materials are found.
If you have previously provided to the Counsel's Office, pursuant to an earlier
directive, materials that are responsive to this request, you need not provide
the same materials again.
Please be sure, however, that you have searched your
files thoroughly for any documents that are responsive to the specific items in
this request.
Requests:
1.
All materials reflecting communications (including telephone
conversations) or meetings between anyone at DOI or the White House and
any lobbyist, including Paul Eckstein, for the following Native Indian
Tribes:
A.
Sokaogon Chippewa Community (Mole Lake Band of Lake Superior
Chippewa) ;
B.
Lac Courte Oreilles Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians of.
'Wisconsin; and,
C.
Red Cliff Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians of Wisconsin.
2.
All materials reflecting any communications or meetings relating to any
actual or possible political contributions by any of the following
tribes or entities, or the effect, if any, of such contributions on DOI
policy, including, but not limited to, the decision related to the
Hudson casino proposal:
A.
The Minnesota Indian Gaming Commission;
B.
St. Croix Chippewa Indians of Wisconsin;
C.
Oneida Tribe of Indians of Wisconsin;
D.
Ho-Chunk Community; and,
E.
·Any other Native Indian tribe, organization, or individual that
you know in any way opposed the Hudson casino proposal.
Please provide copies of any responsive documents to Dimitri Nionakis, 477 OEOB,
�ARMS Email System
Page 13 of 13
BY NOON ON JANUARY 8, 1998.
If you have any questions about any requests or if
you need additional time to respond to this directive, please call Dimitri at
X65814.
Thank you for your assistance.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 14
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: OASISMGR@A1@CD@LNGTWY ( OASISMGR@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-JAN-1998 12:24:06.00
SUBJECT:
Document Request Reminder
MATERA M@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: MATERA M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MARSHALL B@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: MARSHALL B@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
TO: MARKSZ D@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MARKSZ D@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (WHO)
TO: MALLEY R@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MALLEY R@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
LUZZATTO_A@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: LUZZATTO A@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
TO: LINGENFELTER@A1@CD@LNGTWY ( LINGENFELTER@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
READ: UNKNOWN
LINDAHL S@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: LINDAHL S@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(WHO)
LEWIS AP@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
TO: LEWIS AP@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: rlevinso@OSTP.EOP.GOV.INET@CD@LNGTWY ( rlevinso@OSTP.EOP.GOV.INET@CD@LNGTWY [ OS
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: LEE T@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LEE T@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
TO: LEARY W@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LEARY W@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
LAWRENCE W@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: LAWRENCE W@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LANGLEY J@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: LANGLEY J@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(OA)
(NSC)
TO: KRISTOFF S@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KRISTOFF S@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: KORENMAN S@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KORENMAN S@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(CEA)
TO: KINSERKIDA B@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KINSERKIDA B@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: KELLY S@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KELLY S@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: KAZEL J@A1@CD@LNGTWY
KAZEL J@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OMB)
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of 14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KASASKERIS O@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
JUTTON_P@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: JUTTON P@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JOY M@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KASASKERIS O@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
JOY M@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: JORDAN JF@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(OA)
(OA)
(OA)
JORDAN JF@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OMB)
TO: Cathy R. Mays@EOP ( Cathy R. Mays@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emory L. Mayfield@eop ( Emory L. Mayfield@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sonyia Matthews@eop ( Sonyia Matthews@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack@EOP ( Larry R. Matlack@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mia V. Masten@EOP ( Mia V. Masten@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele C. Marx@eop ( Michele C. Marx@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Demond T. Martin@eop ( Demond T. Martin@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall@eop ( William P. Marshall@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Capricia P. Marshall@eop ( Capricia P. Marshall@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen A. Maris@EOP ( Karen A. Maris@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Heather M. Marabeti@ovP@EOP ( Heather M. Marabeti@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alex D. Mandl@eop ( Alex D. Mandl@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kimberly A. Maluski@EOP ( Kimberly A. Maluski@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. Malone@eop ( Michael D. Malone@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen D. Malliarakis@eop ( Kathleen D. Malliarakis@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Margaret A. Malanoski@eop ( Margaret A. Malanoski@eop [ OMB 1 )
�Page 3 of 14
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ira C. Magaziner@EOP ( Ira C. Magaziner@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Stuart W. Maberry@eop ( Stuart W. Maberry@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Randall W. Lutter@eop ( Randall W. Lutter@eop [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell@eop ( Ellen M. Lovell@eop [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tania I. Lopez@eop ( Tania I. Lopez@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce D. Long@eop ( Bruce D. Long@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard C. Loeb@eop ( Richard C. Loeb@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1
TO: Patrick G. Locke@eop ( Patrick G. Locke@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lin Liu@eop ( Lin Liu@eop [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christine J. Lindsey@eop ( Christine J. Lindsey®eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark F. Lindsay@eop ( Mark F. Lindsay@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susanne D. Lind@eop ( Susanne D. Lind@eop [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Henry E. Lilienthal@EOP ( Henry E. Lilienthal@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard Lichtenberger@eop ( Richard Lichtenberger@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sharon R. Lewis@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
Sharon R. Lewis@eop [ WHO 1 )
TO: Anne H. Lewis@eop ( Anne H. Lewis@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew@eop ( Jacob J. Lew@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cameron M. Leuthy@eop ( Cameron M. Leuthy@eop [ OMB 1 ),
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith E. Leonard@eop ( Judith E. Leonard@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alexandra Lehr@EOP ( Alexandra Lehr@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher S. Lehane@OVP@EOP ( Christopher S. Lehane@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah S. Lee@eop ( Sarah S. Lee@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ha Yan Lee@eop ( Ha Yan Lee@eop [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Corey G. Lee@eop ( Corey G. Lee@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael G. Lawrence@eop ( Michael G. Lawrence@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Keith E. Laughlin@EOP ( Keith E. Laughlin@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham@eop ( Sara M. Latham@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Meredith A. Lane@eop ( Meredith A. Lane@eop [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Betty G. Lambuth@EOP ( Betty G. Lambuth@EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James A. Laity@EOP ( James A. Laity@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Briggitte R. LaFontant@eop ( Briggitte R. LaFontant@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph F. Lackey Jr.@eop ( Joseph F. Lackey Jr.@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steve L. Kwast@OVP@EOP ( Steve L. Kwast@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Heidi Kukis@OVP@EOP ( Heidi Kukis@oVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul Kriebel@eop ( Paul Kriebel@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori K. Krause@eop ( Lori K. Krause@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles Konigsberg@EOP ( Charles Konigsberg@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alicia K. Kolaian@eop ( Alicia K. Kolaian@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Raymond P. Kogut@eop ( Raymond P. Kogut@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: LOUISA KOCH@EOP ( LOUISA KOCH@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of 14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: andrew w. kleine@eop ( andrew w. kleine@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain@OVP@EOP ( Ron Klain@OVP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Catherine T. Kitchen@eop ( Catherine T. Kitchen@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Katherine Kirchgraber@eop ( Katherine Kirchgraber@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francis X. Kinney@eop ( Francis X. Kinney@eop
READ: UNKNOWN .
[ OMB 1 )
[ ONDCP 1 )
TO: Robert W. Kilpatrick@eop ( Robert W. Kilpatrick@eop
. READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Charles E. Kieffer@eop ( Charles E. Kieffer@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronald Keohane@eop ( Ronald Keohane@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth S. Kelly@EOP ( Kenneth S. Kelly@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alexander S. Keenan@EOP ( Alexander S. Keenan@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen@eop ( Sally Katzen@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan@EOP ( Jonathan A. Kaplan@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Kapla@eop ( Robert S. Kapla@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Kamensky@eop ( John Kamensky@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David E. Kalbaugh@EOP ( David E. Kalbaugh@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phyllis Kaiser-Dark@EOP ( Phyllis Kaiser-Dark@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara F. Kahlow@eop ( Barbara F. Kahlow@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan@eop ( Elena Kagan@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gay L. Joshlyn@eop ( Gay L. Joshlyn@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne A. Jones@EOP ( wayne A. Jones@EOP [ OA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 6 of 14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ronald e. jones@eop ( ronald e. jones@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MAXFIELD N@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MAXFIELD N@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: MARTIN BM@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MARTIN_BM@Al@CD@LNGTWY· [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OA)
TO: MARSDEN H@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MARSDEN H@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(DON)
TO: Dalton L. Mann@eop@INGTWY@LNGTWY ( Dalton L. Mann@eop@INGTWY@LNGTWY [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
MACK J@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OMB)
TO: MACK J@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LIZIK C@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
TO: LIZIK C@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: LINDSEY W@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LINDSEY W@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
LEWIS J@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: LEWIS_J@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(DON)
LEVITT A@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: LEVITT A@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
(DON)
(DON)
TO: LETTS K@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LETTS K@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: LEAVY D@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LEAVY D@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
(NSC)
TO: LAWSON J@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LAWSON J@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OA)
TO: LAPHAM N@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
LAPHAM N@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(CEQ)
TO: KYLE R@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KYLE R@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
TO: KOUBA J@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KOUBA J@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OA)
TO: KNEPPER C@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KNEPPER C@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: KERRICK_D@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D@Al@CD@LNGTWY
UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: hkelly@ostp.eop.gov@INET@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KAUFMANN K@Al@CD@LNGTWY
hkelly@ostp.eop.gov@INET@LNGTWY [ OSTP 1 )
KAUFMANN K@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OA)
�ARMS Email System
Page 7 of14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KALNINS A@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JURITH E@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JOSHI M@Al@CD@LNGTWY·
READ: UNKNOWN
KALNINS A@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
JURITH E@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
JOSHI M@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Shelly A. McAllister@EOP ( Shelly A. McAllister@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
(OA)
(DON)
(NSC)
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Andrew J. Mayock@eop ( Andrew J. Mayock@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Valerie S. Matthews@eop ( Valerie S. Matthews@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Doris o. Matsui@eop ( Doris o. Matsui@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews@eop ( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason@eop ( Julie E. Mason@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tanya E. Martin@eop ( Tanya E. Martin@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bernard H. Martin@EOP ( Bernard H. Martin@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr@eop ( Thurgood Marshall Jr@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Charles R. Marr@eop (Charles R. Marr@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura S. Marcus@eop ( Laura S. Marcus@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christy M. Manso@eop ( Christy M. Manso@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Jerold R. Mande@eop ( Jerold R. Mande@eop [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sean P. Maloney@eop ( Sean P. Maloney@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aimee M. Malnati@OVP@EOP ( Aimee M. Malnati@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alphonse J. Maldon@eop ( Alphonse J. Maldon@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Allison J. Major@eop ( Allison J. Major@eop
[ ONDCP 1 )
�Page 8 of 14
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eric L. Macris@eop ( Eric L. Macris@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Randolph M. Lyon@EOP ( Randolph M. Lyon@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Nguyen-Phuong K. Lu@eop ( Nguyen-Phuong K. Lu@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sue Lou@eop ( Sue Lou@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ranelle A. Lopez@eop ( Ranelle A. Lopez@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OA 1 )
TO: Russell F. Loiselle@eop ( Russell F. Loiselle@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart@eop ( Joseph-P. Lockhart@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neil Lobron@EOP ( Neil Lobron@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss@OVP@EOP ( Susan M. Liss@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey@eop ( Bruce R. Lindsey@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: John F. Lindsay@eop ( John F. Lindsay@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judy C. Lin@eop ( Judy C. Lin@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: linn m. ligon@eop ( linn m. ligon@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Thomas S. Lewis@EOP ( Thomas S. Lewis@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Lewis@eop ( Lisa Lewis@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis@eop ( Ann F. Lewis@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1
TO: Lisa J. Levin@eop ( Lisa J. Levin@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Lesmez@eop ( Daniel Lesmez@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathy D. Leodler@eop ( Kathy D. Leodler@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ ONDCP 1 )
TO: Kelley A. Lehman@eop ( Kelley A. Lehman@eop
[ OMB 1 )
�Page 9 of14
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robyn Leeds@eop ( Robyn Leeds@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Malcolm R. Lee@eop ( Malcolm R. Lee@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Earlene C. Lee@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
Earlene C. Lee@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
TO: Sandra O. Lawson@eop ( Sandra O. Lawson@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ ONDCP 1 )
TO: Christopher J. Lavery@eop ( Christopher J. Lavery@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edwin Lau@eop ( Edwin Lau@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: SARAH A. LASKIN@EOP ( SARAH A. LASKIN@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Lance@EOP ( Linda Lance@EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew@eop ( Jeanne Lambrew@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leonard L. Lainhart@EOP ( Leonard L. Lainhart@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecilia D. Lafoe@eop ( Cecilia D. Lafoe@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
[ OSTP 1 )
TO: Agustin A. Labrador@eop ( Agustin A. Labrador@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Karin Kullman@EOP ( Karin Kullman@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen C. Kucik@eop ( Karen C. Kucik@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori A. Krauss@EOP ( Lori A. Krauss@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes@eop ( Lisa M. Kountoupes@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Randy J. Kolton@eop ( Randy J. Kolton@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jim Kohlenberger@OVP@EOP ( Jim Kohlenberger@OVP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard H. Kodl@EOP ( Richard H. Kodl@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah S. Freeman@eop ( Sarah S. Freeman@eop [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 10 of 14
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein@EOP ( Jennifer L. Klein@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carole Kitti@eop ( Carole Kitti@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy Kirkendall@eop ( Nancy Kirkendall@eop
[ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Benjamin J. Kirby@eop ( Benjamin J. Kirby@eop [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William R. Kincaid@eop ( William R. Kincaid@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gerald P. Kiernan@eop ( Gerald P. Kiernan@eop [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Farooq Khan@EOP ( Farooq Khan@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann Kendrall@EOP ( Ann Kendrall@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John W. Kelly@EOP ( John W. Kelly@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stanley Kaufman@EOP ( Stanley Kaufman@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart R. Kasdin@eop ( Stuart R. Kasdin@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jody J. Kaplan@eop ( Jody J. Kaplan@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane@eop ( Andrea Kane@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil@eop ( Thomas A. Kalil@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anil Kakani@eop ( Anil Kakani@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aram H. Kailian@OVP@EOP ( Aram H. Kailian@OVP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian G. Kahin@eop ( Brian G. Kahin@eop [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James J. Jukes@eop ( James J. Jukes@eop [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Walter F. Jones@eop ( Walter F. Jones@eop [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Jones@EOP ( Mary E. Jones@EOP [ CEA 1 )
UNKNOWN
1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 11 of 14
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
As a reminder and for everyone's convenience, attached are the two
December 30,
1997 directives that have already been delivered in hard copy.
The
memoranda
request that staff respond by tomorrow, January 8, 1998.
December 30, 1997
MEMORANDUM FOR ALL STAFF OF THE EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
CHARLES F. C. RUFF
COUNSEL TO THE PRESIDENT
FROM:
SALLY P. PAXTON
SPECIAL ASSOCIATE COUNSEL TO THE PRESIDENT
SUBJECT:
REQUEST FOR DOCUMENTS
We have received Congressional subpoenas for documents from the House
Government
Reform Committee which relate to the White House Office Database ("WhoDB")
and
other matters.
Every employee is responsible for searching all of his or
her
own White House records for materials (whether in hard copy, computer or
any
other form) to ensure a comprehensive search.
The head of each office must also provide a signed certification that all
staff
within that office have searched their records and provided copies of any
responsive materials in their possession. Additionally, the Counsel's
Office
has been working with the staff of the Office of Records Management to
find
responsive material located in storage.
If you believe materials that you
have
sent to Records Management may contain responsive information, please let
us
know so that we can ensure that all responsive materials are found.
In responding to the following requests, "EOP" includes any person
employed by
or assigned to any office of the Executive Office of the President,
including
the white House.
"Malone" includes W.P. Malone, Inc. or Percy Malone.
REQUESTS:
1.
All materials reflecting involvement or communications by
EOP
personnel, from January 20, 1993 through the present,
regarding
any database implemented or discussed, contemplated or
planned
�Page 12 of 14
ARMS Email System
to be implemented, by or on behalf of Clinton/Gore, the
DNC, or
any Clinton Presidential campaign entity, for the purpose
of
maintaining any list of, or information about, supporters
or
contributors.
2.
All materials reflecting contracts or terms of contracts
(including "use agreements"), whether in draft or final,
between
the EOP and any vendor, the DNC, Clinton/Gore or any other
party
with respect to the 1993, 1994, 1995 or 1996 White House
holiday
cards.
3.
All materials reflecting any restrictions on the use by
either
the DNC or Clinton/Gore of information contained in any
White
House database.
4.
All materials relating to PeopleBase.
This request
includes any
documents, whether in draft or in final, which reflect any
agreements between either (1) the EOP and Malone, or (2)
Clinton/Gore and Malone.
5.
All materials which reflect the non-disclosure statement
between
the EOP and Malone for information contained in PeopleBase.
6.
All materials relating to Malone.
7.
All materials relating to guidelines for the payment for
use of
the President or the Vice President's residences for
nonofficial
purposes.
8.
about May
All copies of a Kevin O'Keefe memorandum written on or
24, 1994 regarding early supporters.
9.
comply with
All materials which reflect efforts to respond to or
all previous requests for documents or materials related
to the
WhODB, including directives sent by Jack Quinn dated
August 7,
1996 and September 12, 1996.
Please provide copies of any
Room
148, by January 8, 1998.
If
deadline, or if you have any
ext.
65079 or Dimitri Nionakis at
responsive materials to Sally Paxton, OEOB
you anticipate any difficulty in meeting this
questions, please call either Sally Paxton at
ext. 65814.
�ARMS Email System
Page 13 of14
Thank you very much for your cooperation with this request.
December 30, 1997
MEMORANDUM FOR ALL EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT STAFF
FROM:
SUBJECT:
CHARLES F.C. RUFF
COUNSEL TO THE PRESIDENT
Document Request
We have received a subpoena for materials related to the Department of
Interior's (DOl) decision to deny an application to place a 55 acre parcel
of
land located in Hudson, Wisconsin, in trust for gaming purposes
(hereinafter the
"Hudson casino proposal") .
In an effort to comply fully with this subpoena, please search your
records for
all materials (whether in hard copy, computer or other form) responsive to
the
requests listed below. Every employee is responsible for searching all of
his
or her own files and records to ensure a comprehensive search.
The head of each office also must provide a signed certification that all
employees have searched their files and provided copies of any responsive
materials in their possession. Additionally, the Counsel's Office has
been
working with the staff of the Office of Records Management to find
responsive
If you believe that you have sent files to
material located in storage.
Records
Management that may contain responsive information, please let us know so
that
we can ensure that all responsive materials are found.
If you have previously provided to the Counsel's Office, pursuant to an
earlier
directive, materials that are responsive to this request, you need not
provide
the same materials again.
Please be sure, however, that you have searched
your
files thoroughly for any documents that are responsive to the specific
items in
this request.
Requests:
1.
All materials reflecting communications (including telephone
conversations) or meetings between anyone at DOlor the White
House and
any lobbyist, including Paul Eckstein, for the following Native
Indian
Tribes:
�ARMS Email System
Page 14 of14
A.
Sokaogon Chippewa Community (Mole Lake Band of Lake
B.
Chippewa) ;
Lac Courte Oreilles Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians
Superior
of
C.
Wisconsin.
2.
to any
Wisconsin; and,
Red Cliff Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians of
All materials reflecting any communications or meetings relating
actual or possible political contributions by any of the following
tribes or entities, or the effect, if any, of such contributions
on DOl
policy, including, but not limited to, the decision related to the
Hudson casino proposal:
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
The Minnesota Indian Gaming Commission;
St. Croix Chippewa Indians of Wisconsin;
Oneida Tribe of Indians of Wisconsin;
Ho-Chunk Community; and,
Any other Native Indian tribe, organization, or individual
that
you know in any way opposed the Hudson casino proposal.
Please provide copies of any responsive documents to Dimitri Nionakis, 477
OEOB,
BY NOON ON JANUARY 8, 1998.
If you have any questions about any requests
or if
you need additional time to respond to this directive, please call Dimitri
at
X65814.
Thank you for your assistance.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-JAN-1998 17:01:55.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Meeting
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M.
READ: UNKNOWN
Lovell/OU=~HO/O=EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
cc:
Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kim B. Widdess ( CN=Kim B. Widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Meeting on Thursday at
9:00am in room 100. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 12-JAN-1998 10:24:19.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to New York
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN;Mary Morrison/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN;Minyon Moore/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN;Megan C. Moloney/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN;Andrew J. Mayock/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN;Joseph P. Lockhart/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN;Ann F. Lewis/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN;Sara M. Latham/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN;Joshua A. King/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP. [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN;Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN;Katherine Hubbard/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN;Nancy V. Hernreich/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN;Laura A. Graham/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN;Jeremy M. Gaines/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN;Karen E. Finney/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN;Paul K. Engskov/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN;Maria Echaveste/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN;Brenda B. Costello/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN;Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN;Jose Cerda III/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul A. Tuchmann ( CN=Paul A. Tuchmann/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian v. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @·EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 4 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN;John podesta/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN;Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN;Elizabeth R. Newman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN;Kevin S. Moran/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L.. Moore ( CN;Linda L. Moore/OU;WHO/O;EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN;Anne E. McGuire/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN;Sylvia M. Mathews/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN;Bruce R. Lindsey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN;Christopher J. Lavery/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN;Karin Kullman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN·;Kirk T. Hanlin/OU;WHO/O;EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN;Phu D. Huynh/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN;Russell W. Horwitz/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN;Jason S. Goldberg/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN;D. Stephen Goodin/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN;Andrew Friendly/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN;Shelley N. Fidler/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN;Anne M.Edwards/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN;Suzanne Dale/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN;Michael Cohen/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�.ARMS Email System
'.
Page 5 of5
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Thursday, January 15, 1998, the President will travel to New York City
to attend the Wall Street Project conference.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
New York Background Memos:
DUE WED., JAN. 14TH, AT 3:00 P.M.
Political Memo
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
New York Event Memo:
DUE WED., JAN. 14TH, AT 6:00 P.M.
Wall Street Project Event
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
.
Page 1 of3
:,
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr.jOU=OPDjO=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:12-JAN-1998 14:23:46.00
SUBJECT:
MLK Day Volunteer activities
TO: Julie A. Fernandes ( CN=Julie A. FernandesjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Essence P. Washington ( CN=Essence P. Washington!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Neera Tanden ( CN=Neera Tanden!OU=WHO!O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd A. Summers ( CN=Todd A. Summers!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice!OU=OPD!O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. ReedjOU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William R. Kincaid ( CN=William R. Kincaid!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane { CN=Andrea Kane!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda I I I ( CN=Jose Cerda III!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. FreedmanjOU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leanne A. Shimabukuro ( Leanne A. Shimabukuro @ EOP @ LNGTWY [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett!OU=WHO!O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen!OU=OPD!O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
�,..
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah A. Bianchi ( CN=Sarah A. Bianchi/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( Christa Robinson @ EOP @ LNGTWY [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( Cathy R. Mays @ EOP @ LNGTWY [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: BALDERSTON'A
READ: UNKNOWN
BALDERSTON A @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
CC: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We are the department most tied to Service. Please do these if you can.
---------------------- Forwarded by Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OPD/EOP on
01/12/98 02:19 PM ---------------------------
Michele Jolin
01/12/98 01:33:38 PM
Record Type: Record
To: Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OPD/EOP
cc:
subject: MLK Day Volunteer activities
paul,As I'm sure you know all to well, the President is calling MLK
Day a day of national service and asking folks to do some kind of
volunteer work.
I am organizing an activity for WH staff (see below) .
Would you help me recruit by circulating the information to DPC?
Thanks.
Michele
HORTOND,S KIDS - Join children. from the HortonD,s Kids mentoring/tutoring
program as they serve their community.
Children from the HortonD,s Kids
program will celebrate MLK Day by preparing food for the homeless at
MarthaD,s Table.
Up to 15 WH staff volunteers can join children from HortonD,s Kids to
prepare food for the homeless at MarthaD,s Table. Volunteers can join the
HortonD,s Kids children from 10:00-12:00 or from 1:00-3:00 PM.
Up to 30 WH staff volunteers also can join the younger children from
HortonD,s Kids for a D&scavenger huntD8 at the Museum of Natural History
from 1:00-4:00PM.
Each volunteer.will be responsible for helping 2
children (ages 4-9) find answers to questions about dinosaurs, bugs and
�ARMS Email System
animals.
Horton's Kids is a volunteer-run, non-profit organization that provides
tutoring, mentoring and other support to roughly 200 children living in
the Wellington Park housing project in the Anacostia section of
Washington, D.C.
If you are interested, please contact Michele Jolin (5-5084)
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP
[ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 12-JAN-1998 17:15:38.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Strategy Meeting
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Murchinson ( CN=Jonathan Murchinson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Kathryn B. Stack ( CN=Kathryn B. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lee Ann Brackett ( CN=Lee Ann Brackett/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O~EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. KorenmanjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Morley A. Winograd ( CN=Morley A. WinogradjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. parkerjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. RicejOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily BrombergjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. EmanueljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robin J .. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. BachmanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. GibsonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lisa M. Mallory ( CN=Lisa M. MalloryjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique PirozzijOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura EmmettjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie TarmeyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle CriscijOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. GeisbertjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sandra Yamin ( CN=Sandra YaminjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
OMB 1 )
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. RustiquejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. CappsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby DonenfeldjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. VogeljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN;Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN;Peter A. Weissman/OU;OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having the weekly Welfare Reform Strategy Meeting tomorrow,
January 13, at 4:00 p.m. in Room 211, OEOB.
[ WHO 1
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of3
...
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. TurnerjOU=WHOjO=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:12-JAN-1998 14:41:09.00
SUBJECT:
Meeting with Erskine Bowles reo Benchmarking
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. YellenjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. WeinerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally KatzenjOU=OMBjO=EOP @EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. LewisjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurryjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria EchavestejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. SosnikjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. SperlingjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon MoorejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard L. Hayes ( CN=Richard L. HayesjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 .)
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn M. Chirwa ( CN=Dawn M. ChirwajOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. RainesjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. HilleyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. EmanueljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. BegalajOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff ( CN=Charles F. RuffjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:
Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. TingenjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Alice H. Williams ( CN;Alice H. Williams/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Phyllis Kaiser-Dark ( CN;Phyllis Kaiser-Dark/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
CC: Ruby Shamir ( CN;Ruby Shamir/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lori L. Anderson ( CN;Lori L. Anderson/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN;Marjorie Tarmey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN;Michelle Crisci/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN;Peter A. Weissman/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN;Sara M. Latham/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debra A. Schiff ( CN;Debra A. Schiff/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN;Janet L. Graves/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN;Angelique Pirozzi/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Wendy A. Taylor ( CN;Wendy A. Taylor/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN;Laura Emmett/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN;Virginia N. Rustique/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. vogel ( CN;Miriam H. Vogel/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Eleanor S. Parker ( CN;Eleanor S. Parker/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ora Theard ( CN;Ora Theard/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN;Carole A. Parmelee/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Benchmarking meeting with Erskine on Tuesday, January 13
at 2:00 pm in the Roosevelt Room.
�ARMS Email System
.
,
Invited Attendees:
Erskine Bowles
Sylvia Mathews
John Podesta
Frank Raines
Chuck Ruff
Janet Yellen
Gene Sperling
John Hilley
Elena Kagan
Doug Sosnik
Paul Begala
Rahm Emanuel
Maria Echaveste
Mike McCurry
Sally Katzen
Ann Lewis
Dawn Chirwa
Rob Weiner
Richard Hayes
Minyon Moore
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 12-JAN-1998 17:30:46.00
SUBJECT:
Time Change - Meeting with Erskine re: Benchmarking
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Richard L. Hayes ( CN=Richard L. Hayes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn M. Chirwa ( CN=Dawn M. Chirwa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff ( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Phyllis Kaiser-Dark ( CN=Phyllis Kaiser-Dark/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debra A. Schiff ( CN=Debra A. Schiff/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Wendy A. Taylor ( CN=Wendy A. Taylor/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ : UNKNO~
CC: Eleanor S. Parker ( CN=Eleanor S. Parker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ora Theard ( CN=Ora Theard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EQP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The Benchmarking meeting is now at 1:15 pm Tuesday in the Roosevelt Room.
I apologize for the short notice.
************************************************************************************
�ARMS Email System
.
There will be a Benchmarking meeting with Erskine on Tuesday, January 13
at 2:00 pm in the Roosevelt Room.
Invited Attendees:
Erskine Bowles
Sylvia Mathews
John Podesta
Frank Raines
Chuck Ruff
Janet Yellen
Gene Sperling
John Hilley
Elena Kagan
Doug Sosnik
Paul Begala
Rahm Emanuel
Maria Echaveste
Mike McCurry
Sally Katzen
Ann Lewis
Dawn Chirwa
Rob Weiner
Richard Hayes
Minyon Moore
Page 3 of3
�"
-
Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
.
(~
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:14-JAN-1998 18:00:11.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Meeting
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN;Susan M. Liss/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN;Ellen M. Lovell/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Tania I. Lopez ( CN;Tania I. Lopez/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN;Marjorie A. Black/OU;PIR/O;EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN;Angelique Pirozzi/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kim B. Widdess ( CN;Kim B. Widdess/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN;Jennifer L. Klein/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN;June G. Turner/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN;Marjorie Tarmey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN;Miriam H. Vogel/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN;Francine P. Obermiller/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN;Noa A. Meyer/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN;Jessica L. Gibson/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN;Mona G. Mohib/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN;Nicole R. Rabner/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett
READ: UNKNOwN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN;Katharine Button/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Meeting on Thursday at 9:00am in Room 100. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:21-JAN-1998 18:06:06.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Kim B. Widdess (CN=Kim B. Widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:00am in room 100. Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:2I-JAN-1998 20:00:40.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
,
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will use this opportunity to talk about Thursday's NARAL breakfast.
---------------------- Forwarded by Ruby Shamir/WHO/EOP on 01/21/98 07:59
PM ---------------------------
Ruby Shamir
01/21/98 06:05:28 PM
�ARMS Email System
Record Type:
Record·
See the distribution list at the bottom of this message
To.:
cc:
See the distribution list at the bottom of this message
Subject:
Women's Mtg
There will be a Women's Mtg on Thursday at 9:00am in room 100. Thanks.
Message Sent
TO: __~~~__~~~~~~___________________________________________
Ellen M. Lovell/WHO/EOP
Lucia F. Gilliland/OVP @ OVP
Susan M. Liss/OVP @ OVP
Lynn G. Cutler/WHO/EOP
Minyon Moore/WHO/EOP
Maria Echaveste/WHO/EOP
Susan A. Brophy/WHO/EOP
Sylvia M. Mathews/WHO/EOP
Elena Kagan/OPD/EOP
Karen E. Skelton/WHO/EOP
Tracey E. Thornton/WHO/EOP
Janet Murguia/WHO/EOP
Marsha Scott/WHO/EOP
Roberta W. Greene/WHO/EOP
Audrey T. Haynes/WHO/EOP
Robin Leeds/WHO/EOP
Stacie Spector/WHO/EOP
Judith A. Winston/PIR/EOP
Rebecca M. Blank/CEA/EOP
Sandra Thurman/OPD/EOP
Message Copied
TO:~~
__________~__~_____________________________________________
Katharine Button/WHO/EOP
Marjorie Tarmey/WHO/EOP
Laura Emmett/WHO/EOP
June G. Turner/WHO/EOP
Nicole R. Rabner/WHO/EOP
Jennifer L. Klein/OPD/EOP
Mona G. Mohib/WHO/EOP
Kim B. Widdess/WHO/EOP
Jessica L. Gibson/WHO/EOP
Angelique Pirozzi/WHO/EOP
Noa A. Meyer/WHO/EOP
Marjorie A. Black/PIR/EOP
Francine P. Obermiller/CEA/EOP
Tania I. Lopez/WHO/EOP
Miriam H. vogel/WHO/EOP
Page 3 of3
�·-
.
Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:21-JAN-1998 09:28:20.00
SUBJECT:
Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. sperling/OU="OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily
READ: UNKNOWN
Bromberg/OU=WHO/O~EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�,..
ARMS Email System
"
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Donna L. Geisbert ( CN=Donna L. Geisbert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: weinstein dena
READ: UNKNOWN
weinstein dena @ ustr.gov @ INET @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kristen E. Panerali ( 'CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD 1 )
CC: Melissa M. Murray ( CN=Melissa M. Murray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. Pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having the Tobacco Strategy Meeting Thursday, January 22, at
2:45 p.m. in Room 211, OEOB.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[01/07/1998 – 01/21/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 098 - Folder 002
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/16b827ec3588310305f89e97bf17fcd9.pdf
92fd6b763bc616ceda5327bbbdebfd6a
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 098 - FOLDER -001
[01/02/1998-01/07/1998]
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 3
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN;Jason S. Goldberg/OU;WHO/O;EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 2-JAN-199B 12:59:41.00
SUBJECT:
IMPORTANT: POTUS REPORTS
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl D. Mills ( CN=Cheryl D. Mills/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN;Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CEA 1 )
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
WHO 1 )
TO: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN;Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN;Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby'Shamir/OU;WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN;Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brooks E. Scoville ( CN=Brooks E. Scoville/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eleanor S. Parker ( CN=Eleanor S. Parker/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN;Ellen M. Lovell/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN;Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elisabeth Steele ( CN;Elisabeth Steele/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN;Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jill M. Blickstein ( CN=Jill M. Blickstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
Page 2 of3
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MILLISON C
READ: UNKNOWN
MILLISON C @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We are actively seeking POTUS report today for the POTUS to read over the
weekend, prior to returning to DC.
If your office is submitting a weekly
report, please let me know ASAP.
Even if your office is not submitting a weekly report, all office should
please consider submitting a few bullets on issues your office is tracking.
please contact me either way.
Thanks.
Jason
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 5
i{
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 5-JAN-1998 15:23:14.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to NY & TX
TO: Paul A. Tuchmann ( CN=Paul A. Tuchmann/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian v. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
I
Page 2 of5
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN;Elizabeth R. Newman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN;Kevin S. Moran/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN;Linda L. Moore/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN;Anne E. McGuire/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN;Sylvia M. Mathews/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN;Bruce R. Lindsey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN;Christopher J. Lavery/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN;Karin Kullman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN;Kirk T. Hanlin/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN;Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN;Phu D. Huynh/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN;Russell W. Horwitz/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
REAp: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN;Jason S. Goldberg/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN;D. Stephen Goodin/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN;Andrew Friendly/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN;Shelley N. Fidler/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN;Anne M. Edwards/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN;Jennifer D. Dudley/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN;Brenda B. Costello/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN;Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�{
Page 3 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 4 of5
ARMS Email System
{
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EQP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 ).
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�,
Page 5 of5
ARMS Email System
,"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP·@ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Thursday, January 8, 1998, the President will travel to New York City
and attend a DNC luncheon and dinner, before proceeding to Texas.
On
Friday, January 9, the President will attend an education event in
Mission, Texas and a luncheon for Rep. Hinojosa in McAllen; deliver an
address to the people of Brownsville; make remarks on education in
Houston; tape the weekly radio address; and attend a dinner for Rep.
Sheila Jackson Lee, before returning to Washington.
Deadlines for the President's Trip Book are as follows:
NY & TX Background Memos:
DUE TUES., JAN. 6, 1998 AT 6:00 PM
Political Memos
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
NY & TX Event Memos:
DUE WED., JAN. 7, 1998 AT 6:00 PM
DNC Luncheon (NY)
DNC Dinner (NY)
Education Event (TX)
Hinojosa Luncheon (TX)
Brownsville Address (TX)
Houston Education Address (TX)
Radio Address (TX)
Jackson Lee Dinner (TX)
please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 11
(ALL-IN-1 MAIL)
CREATOR: OASIS Manager ( OASISMGR )
(OA)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-JAN-1998 10:02:12.91
SUBJECT: Document Requests
TO: Mary E. Jones
READ: NOT READ
JONES ME ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Ronald E. Jones
READ: NOT READ
JONES RE ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Wayne A. Jones
·READ : NOT READ
JONES W ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: walter F. Jones
READ: NOT READ
JONES WF ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: James F. Jordan
READ: NOT READ
JORDAN JF
TO: M. Kay Joshi
READ: 6-JAN-1998 17:09:41.30
JOSHI M
TO: Gay L. Joshlyn
READ: NOT READ
JOSHLYN G ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Michele R. Joy
READ: 6-.JAN-1998 10:02:44.87
JOY M ) (OA)
TO: James J. Jukes
READ: NOT READ
JUKES J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Edward H. Jurith
READ: NOT READ
JURITH E
(DON)
TO: Paul A. Jutton
READ: 6-JAN-1998 14:09:02.76
JUTTON P
(OA)
TO: Elena Kagan
READ:NOT READ
KAGAN E ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Brian G. Kahin
READ:NOT READ
KAHIN B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Barbara F. Kahlow
READ: NOT READ
KAHLOW B ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Aram H. Kailian
READ: NOT READ
KAILIA A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Phyllis Kaiser-Dark
READ: NOT READ
KAISERDARK P ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Anil Kakani
READ: NOT READ
KAKANI A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: David E. Kalbaugh
KALBAUGH D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
(OMB)
(NSC)
�Page 2 of 11
ARMS Email System
READ: NOT READ
TO: Thomas A. Kalil
READ:NOT READ
KALIL T ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Andris Kalnins
READ: 6-JAN-1998 10:06:47.18
KALNINS A
TO: John Kamensky
READ:NOT READ
KAMENSKY J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Andrea Kane
READ:NOT READ
KANE A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Robert S. Kapla
READ:NOT READ
KAPLA R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Jody J. Kaplan
READ:NOT READ
KAPLAN J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan
READ:NOT READ
KAPLAN JA ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Olga H. Kasaskeris
READ: 6-JAN-1998 13:50:14.67
KASASKERIS 0 )
TO: Stuart R. Kasdin
READ: NOT READ
KASDIN S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Sally Katzen
READ: NOT READ
KATZEN S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Stanley Kaufman
READ: NOT READ
KAUFMAN S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Karen E. Kaufmann
READ: 6-JAN-1998 10:43:16.17
KAUFMANN K
TO: James B. Kazel
READ: 6-JAN-1998 10:24:21.57
KAZEL J )
TO: Alex S. Keenan
READ:NOT READ
KEENAN A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Henry C. Kelly
READ: NOT READ
KELLY H ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: John W. Kelly
READ: NOT READ
KELLY J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Kenneth S. Kelly
READ: NOT READ
KELLY K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Sandra L. Kelly
READ: NOT READ
KELLY S
TO: Ann L. Kendrall
READ: NOT READ
KENDRALL A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Ronald T. Keohane
KEOHANE R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
(OA)
(OA)
(OA)
(OMB)
(NSC)
�Page 3 of 11
ARMS Email System
READ: NOT READ
TO: Donald L. Kerrick
READ: 8-JAN-1998 08:45:35.17
KERRICK D
(NSC)
TO: Farooq A. Khan
READ: NOT READ
KHAN F ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Charles E. Kieffer
READ: NOT READ
KIEFFER C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Gerald P. Kiernan
READ: NOT READ
KIERNAN G ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Erica L. Kilpatrick
READ: NOT READ
KILPATRICK E
TO: Robert W. Kilpatrick
READ: NOT READ
KILPATRICK R ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: William R. Kincaid
READ: NOT READ
KINCAID W ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Francis Kinney
READ: NOT READ
KINNEY F ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Brenda J. Kinser-Kidane
READ: NOT READ
KINSERKIDA B
TO: Benjamin J. Kirby
READ: NOT READ
KIRBY B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Katherine Kirchgraber
READ: NOT READ
KIRCHGRABE K ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Nancy Kirkendall
READ: NOT READ
KIRKENDALL N ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Catherine T. Kitchen
READ: NOT READ
KITCHEN C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Carole Kitti
READ: NOT READ
KITTI C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Ron Klain
READ: NOT READ
KLAIN R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Jennifer L. Klein
READ: NOT READ
KLEIN J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Andrew W. Kleine
READ: NOT READ
KLEINE A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Charlotte D. Knepper
READ: 6-JAN-1998 15:09:11.27
KNEPPER C
TO: Sarah S. Knight
READ: NOT READ
KNIGHT_S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Louisa Koch
KOCH L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(NSC)
(NSC)
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of 11
READ:NOT READ
TO: Richard H. Kodl
READ:NOT READ
KODL R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Raymond P. Kogut
READ: NOT READ
KOGUT R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: James Kohlenberger
READ: NOT READ
KOHLEN J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Alicia K. Kolaian
READ:NOT READ
KOLAIAN A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Randy J. Kolton
READ: NOT READ
KOLTON R ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Charles Konigsberg
READ: NOT READ
KONIGSBERG C ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Sanders D. Korenman
READ: NOT READ
KORENMAN S
TO: Joseph G. Kouba
READ: 6-JAN-1998 10:03:20.87
KOUBA J
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes
READ:NOT READ
KOUNTOUPES L ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Lori K. Krause
READ:NOT READ
KRAUSE L ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Lori A. Krauss
READ:NOT READ
KRAUSS L ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Paul Kriebel
READ:NOT READ
KRIEBEL P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Sandra J. Kristoff
READ: NOT READ
KRISTOFF S
TO: Karen C. Kucik
READ:NOT READ
KUCIK K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Heidi Kukis
READ:NOT READ
KUKIS H ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Karin Kullman
READ: NOT READ
KULLMAN K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Steve L. Kwast
READ: NOT READ
KWAST S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Robert D. Kyle
READ: NOT READ
KYLE R
TO: Agustin A. Labrador
READ: NOT READ
LABRADOR A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Joseph F. Lackey Jr.
LACKEY J
(CEA)
(OA)
(NSC)
(OPD)
) Autoforward to: Remote Address
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of 11
READ:NOT READ
TO: Cecilia D. Lafoe
READ: NOT READ
LAFOE C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Briggitte R. LaFont ant
READ:NOT READ
LAFONTANT B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Leonard L. Lainhart Jr
READ:NOT READ
LAINHART L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: James A. Laity
READ:NOT READ
LAITY J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Jeanne Lambrew
READ:NOT READ
LAMBREW J
TO: Betty G. Lambuth
READ: NOT READ
LAMBUTH B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Linda L Lance
READ:NOT READ
LANCE L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Meredith A. Lane
READ: NOT READ
LANE MA ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Janice M. Langley
READ: 8-JAN-1998 13:16:33.86
LANGLEY J
TO: Nicholas Lapham
READ: NOT READ
LAPHAM N
TO: Sarah Laskin
READ:NOT READ
LASKIN S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Sara M. Latham
READ: NOT READ
LATHAM S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Edwin Lau
READ: NOT READ
LAU E ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Keith E. Laughlin
READ: NOT READ
LAUGHLIN K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Christopher J. Lavery
READ: NOT READ
LAVERY C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Michael G. Lawrence
READ: NOT READ
LAWRENCE M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Wanda L. Lawrence
READ: 6-JAN-1998 10:17:36.26
LAWRENCE W
TO: Jackie D. Lawson
READ: 6-JAN-1998 12:24:54.81
LAWSON J
TO: Sandra O. Lawson
READ: NOT READ
LAWSON S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: William H. Leary
LEARY W
) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
(NSC)
( CEQ)
(OA)
(OA)
(NSC)
�ARMS Email System
Page 6 of 11
READ: NOT READ
(NSC)
TO: David C. Leavy
READ:13-JAN-1998 12:18:39.93
LEAVY D
TO: Corey G. Lee
READ: NOT READ
LEE C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Earlene C. Lee
READ: NOT READ
LEE EC ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Ha Yan Lee
READ:NOT READ
LEE H ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Malcolm R. Lee
READ:NOT READ
LEE M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Sarah S. Lee
READ: NOT READ
LEE SS ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Thomas D. Lee
READ: 6-JAN-1998 16:48:11.46
LEE T
TO: Robyn Leeds
READ: NOT READ
LEEDS R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Christopher S. Lehane
READ: NOT READ
LEHANE C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kelley A. Lehman
READ: NOT READ
LEHMAN K ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Alexandra Lehr
READ: NOT READ
LEHR A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Kathy D. Leodler
READ: NOT READ
LEODLER K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Judith E. Leonard
READ: NOT READ
LEONARD J
TO: Daniel Lesmez
READ: NOT READ
LESMEZ D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kelly J. Letts
READ: NOT READ
LETTS K
TO: Cameron M. Leuthy
READ:NOT READ
LEUTHY C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Lisa J. Levin
READ:NOT READ
LEVIN L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Rachel E. Levinson
READ: NOT READ
LEVINSON R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Alan M. Levitt
READ: 6-JAN-1998 14:07:12.03
LEVITT A
TO: Jacob J. Lew
LEW J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(OA)
) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
(NSC)
(DON)
�ARMS Email System
Page 70f11
READ: NOT READ
TO: Ann F. Lewis
READ: NOT READ
LEWIS AF ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne H. Lewis
READ:NOT READ
LEWIS AH ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Annette P. Lewis
READ: 6-JAN-1998 12:03:54.46
LEWIS AP
TO: Jeanette A. Lewis
READ:NOT READ
LEWIS J
TO: Lisa Lewis
READ:NOT READ
LEWIS L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Sharon R. Lewis
READ:NOT READ
LEWIS S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Thomas S. Lewis
READ:NOT READ
LEWIS TS ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Richard A. Lichtenberger
READ: NOT READ
LICHTENBER R ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Linn M. Ligon
READ:NOT READ
LIGON L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Henry E. Lilienthal
READ: NOT READ
LILIENTHAL H ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Judy C. Lin
READ:NOT READ
LIN J
TO: Susanne D. Lind
READ: NOT READ
LIND S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Susan D. Lindahl
READ: NOT READ
LINDAHL S
TO: John F. Lindsay
READ: NOT READ
LINDSAY JF ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Mark F. Lindsay
READ: NOT READ
LINDSAY M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey
READ:NOT READ
LINDSEY B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Christine J. Lindsey
READ:NOT READ
LINDSEY C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Wanda D. Lindsey
READ: 6-JAN-1998 17:39:46.32
LINDSEY W
TO: Michael Lingenfelter
READ: 6-JAN-1998 10:02:17.22
TO: Susan M. Liss
(OA)
(DON)
) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(WHO)
(DON)
( LINGENFELTER)
(OA)
LISS S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
�ARMS Email System
Page 8 of 11
READ: NOT READ
TO: Lin Liu
READ: NOT READ
LIU L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Cynthia J. Lizik
READ: 6-JAN-1998 10:16:52.04
LIZIK C
TO: Neil R. Lobron
READ: NOT READ
LOBRON N ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Patrick G. Locke
READ: NOT READ
LOCKE P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart
READ: NOT READ
LOCKHART J
TO: Richard C. Loeb
READ: NOT READ
LOEB R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Russell F. Loiselle
READ: NOT READ
LOISELLE R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Bruce D. Long
READ:NOT READ
LONG B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Ranelle A. Lopez
READ:NOT READ
LOPEZ R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Tania I. Lopez
READ:NOT READ
LOPEZ T ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Sue Lou
READ: NOT READ
LOU S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Ellen M. Lovell
READ:NOT READ
LOVELL E ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Nguyen-Phuong K. Lu
READ:NOT READ
LU N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Randall W. Lutter
READ:NOT READ
LUTTER R ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne R. Luzzatto
READ: 7-JAN-1998 20:05:45.84
LUZZATTO A
TO: Randolph M. Lyon
READ:NOT READ
LYON R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Stuart W. Maberry
READ: NOT READ
MABERRY S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Joslyn G. Mack
READ: 7-JAN-1998 14:51:25.96
MACK J
TO: Eric L. Macris
READ:NOT READ
MACRIS E ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Ira C. Magaziner
MAGAZINER I
(OA)
) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
(NSC)
(OMB)
) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
�Page 9 of 11
ARMS Email System
READ: NOT READ
TO: Allison J. Major
READ: NOT READ
MAJOR A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Margaret A. Malanoski
READ: NOT READ
MALANOSKI M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Alphonso J. Maldon
READ: NOT READ
MALDON A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Robert Malley
READ: NOT READ
MALLEY R
TO: Kathleen D. Malliarakis
READ: NOT READ
MALLIARAKI K ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Aimee M. Malnati
READ: NOT READ
MALNAT A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Michael D. Malone
READ: NOT READ
MALONE M ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Sean P. Maloney
READ: NOT READ
MALONEY S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Kimberly A. Maluski
READ: NOT READ
MALUSKI K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Jerold R. Mande
READ: NOT READ
MANDE J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Alex D. Mandl
READ: NOT READ
MANDL A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Dalton L. Mann
READ: NOT READ
MANN
TO: Christy M. Manso
READ: NOT READ
MANSO C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Heather M. Mar.abeti
READ: NOT READ
MARABE H ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Laura S. Marcus
READ:NOT READ
MARCUS LS ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Karen A. Maris
READ:NOT READ
MARIS K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: David C. Marksz
READ: NOT READ
MARKSZ D
TO: Charles R. Marr
READ: NOT READ
MARR C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Henry H. Marsden
READ: NOT READ
MARSDEN H
TO: Betty A. Marshall
MARSHALL B
(NSC)
D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(WHO)
(DON)
(NSC)
�ARMS Email System
Page 10 0f11
READ: NOT READ
TO: Capricia P. Marshall
READ: NOT READ
MARSHALL C } Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Thurgood Marshall
READ: NOT READ
MARSHALL T } Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: William P. Marshall
READ: NOT READ
MARSHALL W } Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Bernard H. Martin
READ: NOT READ
MARTIN B } Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Bryan M. Martin
READ: NOT READ
MARTIN BM
TO: Demond T. Martin
READ: NOT READ
MARTIN D } Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Tanya E. Martin
READ: NOT READ
MARTIN T } Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Michele C. Marx
READ: NOT READ
MARX M } Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Julie E. Mason
READ: NOT READ
MASON J } Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Mia Masten
READ: NOT READ
MASTEN M } Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Michael A. Matera
READ: NOT READ
MATERA M
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews
READ: NOT READ
MATHEWS SM } Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Larry R. Matlack
READ: NOT READ
MATLACK L } Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Doris O. Matsui
READ: NOT READ
MATSUI D } Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Sonyia Matthews
READ: NOT READ
MATTHEWS S } Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Valerie S. Matthews
READ: NOT READ
MATTHEWS V } Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Nancy H. Maxfield
READ: 6-JAN-1998 10:10:23.85
MAXFIELD N
TO: Emory L. Mayfield
READ:NOT READ
MAYFIELD_E } Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Andrew J. Mayock
READ:NOT READ
MAYOCK A } Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Cathy R. Mays
MAYS C } Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(OA)
(NSC)
(NSC)
�ARMS Email System
Page 11 of 11
READ: NOT READ
TO: Shelly McAllister
READ: NOT READ
MCALLISTER_S ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TEXT:
This is a reminder that two document request memoranda dated December 30, 1997
were sent by the Counsel's Office to all EOP staff. One is related to the White
House Database and the other is related to the Hudson casino matter.
Both
memoranda request that staff provide all responsive documents to the designated
Counsel's Office contact person by Thursday, January 8, 1998.
If you have any questions regarding the White House Database request, please
contact Sally Paxton at x65079 or Dimitri Nionakis at x65814.
If you have any
questions regarding the Hudson casino matter, please contact Dimitri Nionakis at
x65814.
Thank you.
�ARMS Email System
t.
Page 1 of 3
"'''f
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-JAN-1998 16:02:14.00
SUBJECT:
IMPORTANT NOTE
TO: Douglas Matties ( CN=Douglas Matties/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl D. Mills ( CN=Cheryl D. Mills/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ruby Shamir ( CN':Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brooks E. Scoville ( CN=Brooks E. Scoville/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eleanor S. Parker ( CN=Eleanor S. Parker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elisabeth Steele (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Elisabeth
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
Steele/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
I.
Page 2 of3
'..
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jill M. Blickstein ( CN=Jill M. Blickstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 3 of3
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MILLISON C
READ: UNKNOWN
MILLISON C @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Michael waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S.Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The morning Senior Staff Meeting at 7:45 will be held in Erskine's office
on Wednesday morning due to setup in the Roosevelt Room for another
meeting.
Please spread the word.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of28
".
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Neera Tanden ( CN=Neera Tanden/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-JAN-1998 00:55:40.00
SUBJECT:
Child Care Policy Announcement and Q & A
TO: Neera Tanden ( CN=Neera Tanden/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy N. Finkelstein ( CN=Amy N. Finkelstein/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ : UNKNOWN
TO: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman { CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of28
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ :,UNKNOWN
)
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Attached please find the policy announcement paper and the Q & A for the
child care event.
==================== ATTACHMENT
l ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D85]MAIL43l24060C.026 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043A40FOOOOOlOA020l00000002050000009D5C000000020000995044CD02047DE82E4A8F
CB49A876BE57F0542209792Fl4FA9A45E6BE052ACAF1B78FA510BBEDC11CFFB6EFD9D9438AC4DB
48B024405CA678l3310B6FB5lD1EAE8530B01880344BE577AB181A921077FCB4D8DE7B246B47F8
7FC06D10E45CE93D35F143B2B13AFF10DE047B54B79B72BD4DF6E9868FB90BA794418A5BCD49A9
C55881AEC3F4B9D2569590749662733449D32E10BA68D8A8FD23BC8E9496C3E6DB3F50EF7A2214
B126COB5C98EE203904F9C376AD2906D697F2B29COAA1D93980E12D9E8ADB9B38COE9D552FFF4E
EF7CD4508CFFAE8C900COB02EFD1A58DA8C435429484F6A2BF020A51483A2D6B35A7E555FDCC8D
2D5CD762CD08F5CD5C676C87496C7C135E25E6419E8C1A86DAAAE07Bl774E5285CD1EBEl30614B
FEFEA59784B50B49620C60E7EE1E3C414641C3E4858D6D981293625BA9A3AD417670F2A2878251
OF6420EE1D15E0541A9528AC939440F2FF837CA33867A1A9E07C2A586E9F6ECAAC7509497C81lE
BD1B49353C6DCB7A15AOB4B871FDDFD337D45E593E6577Bl129599B2F8CFA28D442E8FDF3C1BFl
F91F36099B40A7E6F6F7BCC6E6C345E5E58452E7F151A31DDOE38E96E39F765BB7EA14016B20Bl
9A4926FFE57A249662ABA8C19F872F99EOFD7C428AB123B69FBAAB98CO50A7CC05E041DOOCA3B4
C5AB051C880200B700000000000000000000000823010000000B010000020C000000555FOOOlOO
4EOOOOOOODOD0000092501000000060000005BODOOOOOB300300000028000000610D0000081D01
00000000000000890D000000000000000000000000890D00000055OD0000004E000000890DOOOO
08770100000040000000D70D000008340100000014000000170EOO000802010000000F0000002B
OE0000080501000000080000003AOEOOOOOB300100000044000000420E00000055290001003COO
0000860E000000000000000000000000860EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000860EOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000000000860E000000000000000000000000860EOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000860EOOOOOOOO
0000000000000000860E000000000000000000000000860EOOOOOO000000000000000000860EOO
0000000000000000000000860E000000000000000000000000860E000000000000000000000000
860E000000000000000000000000860EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00860EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000860E000000000000000000000000860EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000000860EOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000000000860EOOOOOB300D0000004EOOOOOOC20EOOOOOOOOOO0000000000000tiC20EOOOOOO
000000000000000000C20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOC20EOOOO00000000000000000000C20E
000000000000000000000000C20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOC2OEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00C20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOC20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO0000C20EOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00000000C20E00000942050000001D000000100FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOlOOFOOOOOOOOOO
00000000000000100F000000000000000000000000100FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOlOOFOOOO
00000000000000000000100F000000000000000000000000100FOO000000000000000000000010
OF000000000000000000000000100FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO100FOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000100F000000000000000000000000100F0000094402000000330000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOO0000000000002DOFOOOOOOOO
00000000000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOO0000000000000000002DOFOO
00000000000000000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOF000000000000000000000000
2DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOO000000000000002DOFOOOOOO
0000000000000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOO000000000000000000002DOF
0000000000000000000000002DOF0000000000000000000000002DOFOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
PRESIDENT CLINTON ANNOUNCES CHILD CARE INITIATIVE
January 7, 1998
President Clinton today announced an historic initiative to improve child care for
America's working families. The President's FY 1999 budget will include approximately
$20 billion over five years for child care, the largest single investment in child care in the
nation's history. President Clinton's initiative responds to the struggles our nation's
working parents face in finding child care that they can afford, trust, and rely on. The
President's proposal will help working families pay for child care, build the supply of good
after-school programs, improve the safety and quality of care, and promote early learning.
•
Doubles the number of children receiving child care subsidies to more than two
million by the year 2003 by increasing funding for the Child Care and
Development Block Grant by $7.5 billion over 5 years.
.•
Increases tax credits for three million working families to help them pay for
child care by investing $5.2 billion over 5 years in the Child and Dependent Tax
Credit. The President's proposal also provides a new tax credit for businesses
that offer child care services for their employees.
•
Provides after-school care for up to half a million children per year by
expanding the 21st Century Community Learning Center program by $1 billion
over 5 years to provide funds to school-community partnerships to establish or
expand programs for school-age children.
•
Improves child care safety and quality and enhances early childhood
development by establishing a new Early Learning Fund as well as supporting
enforcement of state child care health and safety standards, providing
scholarships to up to 50,000 child care providers per year, and investing in
research and consumer education.
Child Care Block Grant Increase
Child and Dependent Tax Credit Refonn
Tax Credit for Businesses
After-School Program
Early Learning Fund
Head Start Increase
Standards Enforcement Fund
Child Care Provider Scholarship Fund
Research and Evaluation Fund
$7.5 billion over five years
$5.2 biIlion over five years
$500 million over five years
$1 billion over five years
$3 billion over five years
$3.4 billion over five years
$500 million over five years
$250 million over five years
$150 million over five years
ITOTAL:
$21.5 billion over five years
�MAKES CHILD CARE MORE AFFORDABLE FOR WORKING FAMILIES
Automated ReCOrds M
HeX-Dump c;na e SYstem
g '!1ent
nVerslon
Doubles the Number of Children Receiving Child Care Subsidies to More than Two
Million. The President proposes to expand the Child Care and Development Block Grant to
help working families struggling to meet the costs of child care. This block grant is the
primary federal subsidy program to pay for child care, enabling low-income parents to work.
Funds are distributed by formula to the states to operate direct child care subsidy programs,
as well as to improve the quality and availability of care. The President's initiative will
more than double the number of children served from the one million served in FY 95 (the
latest year for which data are available). The President's budget will increase funding for the
block grant by $7.5 billion (with a match) over five years, which will enable states to provide
subsidies for more than two million children by 2003.
Increases Tax Credits for Child Care for Three Million Working Families. The Child
and Dependent Tax Credit provides tax relief to taxpayers who pay for the care of a child
under 13 or a disabled dependent or spouse in order to work. The credit is equal to a
percentage of the taxpayer's employment-related expenditures for child or dependent care,
with the amount of the credit depending on the taxpayer's income. The President's proposal
increases the credit for families earning under $60,000, providing an additional average tax
cut of$358 for these families and eliminating income tax liability for almost all families with
incomes below 200% of poverty ($35,000 for a family of four) that take the maximum .
allowable child care expenses under the law. The President's budget will includ'e $5.2
billion over five years to expand the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit for three million
working families.
Provides New Business Tax Credits. The child care initiative includes a tax credit to
businesses that provide child care services for their employees, by building or expanding
child care facilities, operating existing facilities, training child care workers, reserving slots
for employees at child care facilities, or providing child care resource and referral services to
employees. The credit covers 25% of qualified costs, but may not exceed $150,000 per year.
The President's budget will include approximately $500 million over five years for these tax
credits.
PROMOTES EARLY LEARNING AND HEAL THY CHILD DEVELOPMENT
Promotes Early Learning. Research shows that children's experiences in the earliest
years are critical to their development and future success. The President's proposed
Early Learning Fund provides challenge grants to communities (distributed by states)
to support programs to improve early learning and the quality and safety of child care
for children ages zero to five. Funds may be used for the following activities: providing
basic training to child care providers (including first aid and CPR); connecting individual
child care providers to centers for education and support; assisting child care providers to
meet accreditation and licensing requirements; linking child care providers with health
professionals; reducing group sizes and child-to-staffratios; and providing home visits,
parent education, and consumer education about child care. The President's Early Leaming
Fund builds on state initiatives such as North Carolina's Smart Start, which helps North
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Carolina's children enter school healthy and ready to succeed. Smart Start funds a broad
variety oflocal efforts, including improving staff-to-child ratios, health linkages that have
raised immunization rates, and parent education and mentoring programs to give new parents
support. The President's budget will include $3 billion over five years for this fund.
Increases Investment in Head Start and Doubles the Number of Children Served by
Early Head Start. Head Start provides early, continuous and compreI:tensive child
development and family support services, preparing children for a lifetime of learning an~
development. The President is committed to reauthorize Head Start and reach one million
children by 2002. The President's budget will invest $3.4 billion over five years to keep
on track his commitment to serving one million children by 2002, and to double the
number of infants and toddlers in Early Head Start to 80,000.
IMPROVES THE QUALITY OF CHILD CARE
Steps Up Enforcement of State Health and Safety Standards. Building on the
military's model child care program, this proposed initiative will fund state efforts to improve
licensing systems and enforce child care health and safety standards, including by increasing
unannounced inspections of child care settings. The President's budget will include $500
million over five years for this program.
Facilitates Background Checks on Child Care Providers. On the day of the White House
Conference on Child Care, the President transmitted to Congress the National Crime
Prevention and Privacy Compact, which will facilitate effective background checks on child
care providers by eliminating state law barriers to sharing criminal history information for
non-criminal purposes. Although the vast majority of child care providers are dedicated to
the teaching and nurturing of children, one tragedy in child care is too many. Background
checks are an important way to ensure that the people watching our children are fit for this
responsibility.
Increases Scholarships and Training for Child Care Providers. At the White House
Conference on Child Care, the President proposed establishing a Child Care Provider
Scholarship Fund to enable states to provide scholarship funds to students working toward a
child care credential. Eligible child care workers must commit to remaining in the field for
at least one year for each year of assistance received and will earn increased compensation or
bonuses when they complete their course work. The President proposed a federal
investment of $250 million over five years, which will support 50,000 scholarships per year.
The President is also proposing to expand the Department of Labor's Child Care
Apprenticeship Program to fund the training of child care providers.
Invests in Research. Because too little is known about our child care system, the
President's budget will increase support for data, research, and evaluation. This research
fund will also support a National Center on Child Care Statistics and a child care hotline that
parents can call to get information about how to find child care in their communities and how
to identify appropriate, quality care for their children. In addition, the research fund will
support demonstration projects to test approaches to help new parents who choose to stay
�Automated Records Management S
Hex-Dump Conversion ystem
home to care for their newborns or newly adopted children. The President's budget will
include $150 million over five years for this fund.
EXPANDS AND STREAMLINES AFTER-SCHOOL CARE
An estimated five million school-age children spend time as "latchkey )<ids" without adult
supervision during a typical week. Research indicates that during these unsupervised hours
children are more likely to engage in at-risk behavior, such as crime, drugs, and alcohol use.
To meet this pressing demand, the President is proposing a dramatic expansion of
after-school care.
Provides After-School Care for up to Half a Million Children a Year. The President
proposes a dramatic expansion of the 21 st Century Community Leaming Center Program to
provide start-up funds (with a local match) to school-community partnerships to establish or
expand before- and after-school programs for school-age children. The program increases the
supply of after-school care in a cost-effective manner primarily by funding programs that use
public schools and their existing resources, such as computers, gymnasiums, and sports
equipment. The program also includes a set aside to fund programs run by community
organizations. The President's budget will include $1 billion over five years for this
program.
Improves Coordination of Federal After-School Initiatives to Help Communities Make
Best Use of Existing Resources. The President will put in place a collaborative effort
involving numerous federal agencies to eliminate duplication and better coordinate federal
funding for after-school programs in three to five pilot cities, including the District of
Columbia.
�The President's Child Care Initiative
January 7, 1998
Automated l>
fTecol'ds M.
Hex-Dump Canagement S
on version rstem
Internal Questions & Answers
1. What is the President announcing today?
President Clinton today announced an historic initiative to improve child care for
America's working families. The President's FY 1999 budget will include approximately
$20 billion over five years for child care, the largest single investment in child care in the
nation's history. President Clinton's initiative responds to the struggles our nation's
working parents face in finding child care that they can afford, trust, and rely on. The
President's proposal will help working families pay for child care, build the supply of good
after-school programs, improve the safety and quality of care, and promote early learning.
•
Doubles the number of children receiving child care subsidies to more than two
million by the year 2003 by increasing funding for the Child Care and
Development Block Grant by $7.5 billion over 5 years.
•
Increases tax credits for three million working families to help them pay for
child care by investing $5.2 billion over 5 years in the Child and Dependent Tax
Credit. The President's proposal also provides a new tax credit for businesses
that offer child care services for their employees.
•
Provides after-school care for 500,000 children per year by expanding the 21st
Century Community Learning Center program by $1 billion over 5 years to
provide funds to school-community partnerships to establish or expand
programs for school-age children.
•
Improves child care safety and quality and enhances early childhood
development by establishing a new Early Learning Fund as well as supporting
enforcement of state child care health and safety standards, providing
scholarships to up to 50,000 child care providers per year, and investing in
research and consumer education.
Child Care Block Grant Increase
Child and Dependent Tax Credit Refonn
Tax Credit for Businesses
After-School Program
Early Learning Fund
Head Start Increase
Standards Enforcement Fund
Child Care Provider Scholarship Fund
Research and Evaluation Fund
lTOTAL:
1
$7.5 billion over five years
$5.2 billion over five years
$500 million over five years
$1 billion over five years
$3 billion over five years
$3.4 billion over five years
$500 million over five years
$250 million over five years
$150 million over five years
$21.5 billion over five years
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
2. The President has been in office for five years. Why is he proposing a child care
initiative now? Is this a new problem?
The child care initiative underscores President Clinton's commitment to strengthening
America's families. As the President has said, child care is "the next great frontier if we're
going to make sure all Americans can succeed at home and at work." (7/28/97) The initiative
that the President announced today builds on the Earned Income Tax Credit, the Family
Medical Leave Act, the Child Tax Credit, the new children's health insurance program, and a
host of other legislation the President has fought for to help American families.
The initiative also builds on President Clinton's continuing efforts to improve and increase
funding for child care. Under President Clinton, federal funding for child care has increased
by 70%, helping parents pay for the care of about one million children. The 1996 welfare
reform law increased child care funding by $4 billion over six years to provide child care
assistance to low-income working families moving from welfare to work.
3. How are you going to pay for this big package?
The President's budget carefully pays for each and every element of his child care initiative.
The package is funded in a variety of ways -- some on the mandatory and others on the
discretionary side of the budget. The offsets for the mandatory items include -- but are not
limited to -- expected revenues from a national tobacco settlement, which the President hopes
and believes Congress will pass this year.
4. Since much of the funding of this proposal is based on the tobacco settlement, aren't
you counting your chickens before they've hatched? What will you do if the tobacco
settlement does not go through?
First, the initiative is paid for in a number of ways -- only one part comes from tobacco
revenues. Second, and more important, we believe that a national tobacco settlement will
pass. The President strongly supports legislation consistent with his principles, and many
Republicans and Democrats alike are working vigorously to craft comprehensive legislation.
Of course, no offset proposed in a budget is guaranteed; the Congress can reject any proposed
way of financing a program. If Congress does not pass comprehensive tobacco legislation,
we will work with Congress to find other offsets. This is a high Administration priority, and
we will find an effective funding mechanism.
5. Aren't you just creating a new federal bureaucracy?
The President's child care initiative creates no new federal bureaucracy. Rather, it relies on
states and communities to decide for themselves how best to address the child care challenges
they face. Indeed, the funds for each major initiative flow either to states or communities, or
in the case of tax credits, to individuals themselves.
2
�Automated Records M
Hex-Dump canage'!'ent System
onverslon
.
6. The White House Conference on Early Learning and Development highlighted the
crucial development that takes place in the first years of a child's life. Given that the
best caregiver is a parent, what are you doing to help parents stay at home with their
children during this important time?
The program announced today is primarily oriented toward families where both caregivers go
to work, usually for reasons of financial necessity. It is designed to ensure that children in
these families receive quality care even though their parents are in the workforce.
The President believes strongly, however, that we should support parents who can and
choose to stay home. Today's announcement also includes two proposals that will help
these parents stay at home. First, the Administration will support demonstration projects in
states and communities to test policies to help new parents who choose to stay home to care
for their newborns or newly adopted children. Second, the President's Early Learning Fund
supports parents who stay at home by supporting home visits and parent education.
These initiatives build on President Clinton's record of providing real choices and
opportunities for parents. He has fought for: a $500 per child tax credit for families with
children; the Earned Income Tax Credit that gives 15 million working families tax relief;
health insurance for children; increases in the minimum wage; and the Family and Medical
Leave Act. President Clinton is committed to helping parents make the choices that are
right for their families, whether that means working or staying home to care for their
children.
7. What role did the First Lady have in developing this initiative?
The First Lady has been a strong voice for children and families for over twenty-five years
and continues to work on these issues. Mrs. Clinton played an important role in developing
the White House Conference on Early Learning and Development and the White House
Conference on Child Care. During the policy development process for the child care
initiative, the President looked to the First Lady for her advice and expertise on the problems
with the child care system and on possible solutions.
8. How do you expect to get Republican support for this initiative?
Child care traditionally has been a bipartisan issue. In fact, two of the central elements of
the President's child care initiative were strongly supported by previous Republican
Presidents and Members of Congress. Both Presidents Reagan and Bush supported the
expansion of the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit, and President Bush supported the
creation of the Child Care and Development Block Grant.
Many Members of the House and Senate from both sides of the aisle have shown a
commitment to taking action by introducing legislation that would improve the quality of
child care, make it more affordable, and promote early learning. We look forward to
3
�Automated Records Man
working with them to pass significant child care legislation this year.
Hex·Dump Con:g~~~nt System
TAX CREDITS
9. Today, the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit (CDCTC) favors middle-income
taxpayers and offers less relief to lower-income taxpayers. Wouldn't it be more fair to
make the CDCTC refundable?
The President's proposed expansion of the CDCTC would wipe out tax liability for most
families with incomes under 200% of poverty (e.g., $35,000 for a family offour) who have
the maximum allowable child care expenses. In addition, the President's proposal
significantly expands the Child Care and Development Block Grant, which is an effective
mechanism to help low-income working families with child care costs. The two proposals
together offer significant relief to both low- and middle-income parents.
10. Wouldn't eliminating the marriage penalty help millions of working families with
children? Why aren't you supporting eliminating the penalty as part of your child
care initiative?
The Administration believes that proposals currently on the table to eliminate the marriage
penalty are prohibitively expensive in the context of a balanced budget. The President chose
instead to provide targeted tax cuts to assist American families struggling to meet child care
costs. These tax cuts will help more than three million families to pay for high-quality child
care.
Helping working families, especially those with children, has been the centerpiece of the
President's agenda on tax cuts. In 1993, the President expanded the Earned Income Tax
Credit to give the average recipient with two children more than $1,000 in tax relief. In 1997,
the President signed into law a $500 per child tax credit that will help 27 million families
meet the costs of raising their children. In addition, his $1,500 HOPE Scholarship Tax Credit
and Lifelong Learning Tuition Tax Credit will help nearly 13 million students meet the costs
of college and higher education. The President will continue to focus tax and overall
economic policy on helping working families.
11. Won't the employer credit for child care expenses that the President is proposing
create a windfall for companies already operating child care centers or otherwise
subsidizing employee child care?
Very few for-profit employers are currently making child care services available to their
employees. The credit will provide a real incentive to employers to create new employee
child care programs. Also, for those employers who already have a child care program, the
credit will help support expansion of services.
4
�AutomatedRecordsM
Hex-Dump c;;:ffrse'!lent SYstem
SUBSIDIES
" Ion
12. Why are you expanding the Child Care and Development Block Grant (CCDBG)
when states aren't using aU oftheir child care subsidy money now?
In fact, we are very encouraged by state reports which show they have obligated over 99 of
the child care fund available under the new welfare law for FY 1997.
This demonstrates
the tremendous need states have for child care, and President Clinton has continued to urge
states to invest their dollars into helping these working families. But let's be clear-this
current initiative is not aimed at mothers on welfare. It's aimed at working parents who
desperately need this assistance. For example, working families with annual incomes under
$14,400 that pay for care for children under five spend 25 of their income on child care -and even then it's difficult finding accessible, quality care.
13. According to some news stories, states have big surpluses which they could spend on child
care. Rep. Clay Shaw recently issued a repon saying that states have significant and growing
surplus federal welfare dollars. The repon also said that given the surpluses and the increase in
child care funding under the new welfare law, there isn't a need now for more child care
money. Why are you proposing to add to CCDBG?
The Administration is very pleased that a strong economy and state welfare reform efforts
have helped families move from welfare to work. But let's be clear-this initiative is not
aimed at mothers on welfare. It's aimed at working parents. For example, working families
with annual incomes under $14,400 that pay for care for children under five spend 25% of
their income on child care. Currently, we're serving only a small percentage of eligible
children from working families: there are approximately 10 million children who are eligible
for federal child care assistance, but we are able to serve only over a million of these children.
For America's working families to succeed in the workplace, they need quality choices in
affordable and accessible child care. The President's initiative, with its combination of
increased subsidies for low-income families and tax credits for moderate- and middle-income
families, will provide working parents the opportunity to remain self-sufficient and succeed
both at home and at work.
14. When the President signed the welfare bill, he claimed that the big increase in
CCDBG would make welfare reform work. Now that he is proposing adding to it, is he
admitting that his previous child care efforts were not sufficient?
No. The President fought to spend $4 billion more on child care in welfare reform
legislation to help mothers on welfare go to work, and he continues to believe that child care
is a critical component of welfare reform. However, low-income parents who have never
been on welfare are also struggling to afford child care, and all working families want their
5
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
children to be in safe, healthy settings where they can learn and grow. These initiatives
address the concerns and needs of all working families in this country. In particular,
expansion of the block grant will enable many states to provide subsidies for the first time to
the non-welfare working poor.
15. In order to keep up with the additional need for child care under welfare reform,
aren't states creating new slots at the expense of quality? What protection do you have
against states just increasing slots without regard to quality if you simply increase the
block grant?
The President believes that we must make child care more affordable as well as improve
quality because he believes that both are important. That is why his child care initiative
includes investments in both, and that is why the President fought hard during the welfare
debate to preserve 4% of funding through the child care block grant for state investments in
quality.
QUALITY
16. What does the Early Learning Fund actually do? How will you measure results?
Recent scientific research has demonstrated that experiences during the earliest years oflife -before children reach school age -- are critical to their cognitive, emotional, and physical
development. Nurturing and stimulating children in the first years of life help their brains
develop and prepare them for the challenges of school and later life. We also know that too
much child care for infants and toddlers is inadequate: one respected study found that 13% of
regulated and 50% of unregulated family child care providers offer care that is inadequate for
children ages zero to three. President Clinton's proposed Early Learning Fund is designed to
improve early learning and development for our youngest children; to ensure health and
safety in child care; and to support parents as they raise their children.
The President's Early Learning Fund builds on state initiatives such as North Carolina's
Smart Start, which helps North Carolina's children enter school healthy and ready to succeed.
Smart Start funds a broad variety oflocal efforts, including improving staff-to-child ratios,
health linkages that have raised immunization rates, and parent education and mentoring
programs to give new parents support.
17. How is the Early Learning Fund different from Early Head Start?
Early Head Start is a relatively small program that reaches only certain poor families. The
new initiative will promote early learning and provide parent support and education to
parents at a wider range of income levels. The Early Learning Fund also differs from Head
Start and Early Head Start because it targets support to communities that have developed
innovative approaches to foster early learning and meet the child care needs of families.
6
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
18_ Wasn't the President already committed to serving one million children by 2002?
What's new in this Head Start initiative?
The President's child care initiative proposes an additional $1 billion targeted to Early Head
Start to double the number of infants and toddlers served, in addition to his commitment to
reauthorize all of Head Start to reach one million children by 2002. The total cost is $3.4
billion.
19. Much of the research the White House has highlighted tells us what we need to do
to ensure healthy child development. Given that these practices are the same
everywhere, why have you not proposed national standards?
We do know what works. As we learned at the White House Conference on Child Care, safe
facilities, ongoing guidance from health professionals, and child care providers who are well
trained and adequately compensated result in quality care. However, we also learned at the
conference that many states have good quality standards, but do not have the resources to
fund enforcement of those standards. The President's Standards Enforcement Fund will
help states improve licensing, enforce standards, and increase unannounced inspections
of child care settings. In addition, particularly when it comes to the youngest children,
different states face different challenges in their child care systems. That is why the
President's Early Learning Fund gives states a menu of allowable activities to promote early
learning and development so that states can concentrate on those areas where they are falling
behind. In this way, the quality of care will improve across the country.
20. At the White House Conference on Child Care, you championed the National
Crime Prevention and Privacy Compact. What happened to the Compact?
The National Crime Prevention and Privacy Compact has been transmitted to Congress. The
Compact is an important part of the President's child care initiative, and the President will
push for its passage when Congress returns.
21. Won't the scholarship fund raise the wages of child care workers, and in turn,
increase the cost of child care and make it un affordable for many families?
This proposal is modeled after North Carolina's T.E.A.C.H. program; North Carolina has not
seen higher costs since it put T.E.A.C.H. in place. Because child care workers are likely to
stay in their jobs longer if they are trained and better compensated, any additional costs of
increased wages will be offset to some extent by savings associated with reduced staff
turnover.
22. If you are proposing a huge increase in federal research of child care issues,
shouldn't you wait to make policy based on what you learn from the research?
7
�Automated Records Management Sysren'
Hex-Dump Conversion
While there is much we don't know about our child care system, we do know enough to act.
Child care is a pressing problem in America: 45% percent of all children under the age of one
are in child care on a regular basis; much of this is inadequate; and families with annual
incomes under $14,400 that pay for care for children under five spend about 25% of their
income on child care. We cannot afford to wait to improve the quality of care these children
receive.
AFTER- SCHOOL PROGRAMS
23_ Your after-school proposal requires programs to be run in the schools. What do
you do for those children in communities where the school will not or cannot provide an
after-school program?
While a major purpose of the 21 st Century Learning Centers Program is to make use of
underutilized school facilities, the program includes a set aside to fund programs run by
community groups. In addition, the President's FY 1999 budget includes $95 million for
after school and other prevention programs administered by the Department of Justice.
Innovative programs that are run by community groups in museums, recreation centers or
other places outside schools may receive funding from this after-school initiative.
GENERAL
24. Much attention has been given to the au pair system since nineteen year old Louise
Woodward was tried for killing a baby in her care. What are you doing to reform the
au pair system?
The U.S. Information Agency (the agency that runs the au pair program) announced in
September updated regulations on the screening and placement of au pairs. Under the new
regulations: au pairs who care for children under two years old must have 200 or more
documented hours of infant-care experience; au pair training will include 24 hours of
child-development instruction; au pairs will be limited to working 10 hours a day and 45
hours a week; their pay will be increased from $115 to $139 a week; and the screening and
selection process will be improved.
25. What are the child care options for parents who work at the White House?
Employees of the Executive Office of the President (EOP) can enroll their children in tl}e
nearby U.S. Kids Child Development Center, a center accredited by the independent National
Association for the Education of Young Children. Additionally, White House parents may
enroll their children in any ofthe 27 other Federal child care centers in the greater
Washington, D.C. area.
26. What is the child care system for federal employees?
8
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
There are more than 230 child care centers for civilian government employees in federal
buildings in !is many as 36 states, including 108 centers overseen by the General Services
Administration (GSA). Seventy-three percent of GSA sponsored centers are accredited by
the independent National Association for Education of Young Children, and GSA is working
to reach 100 accreditation within two years. Striving to meet the needs of parent workers,
89 of GSA centers have infant care, 74 have drop-in/emergency care, and 42 provide
summer programs for school-aged children. In addition, more than 80 of centers are open
11 or more hours per day. Notably, nearly 70% of the child care center directors have ten or
more years of experience in early childhood education.
27_ Apparently many low-income federal employees cannot afford the federal child
care system_ What are you doing to help them?
The federal government, like the private sector, still faces challenges in providing affordable
care to lower paid employees. GSA has studied this problem intensively this year and has
released a report to Congress outlining a plan to increase revenues and enrollment, reduce
operating costs, and expand the availability of tuition 'assistance for parents who can't afford
to pay full fees.
28. You have touted the military's child care system as a model for the nation. Isn't it
good because they spend so much?
While the military does invest significant resources into their child care system, they also set
and enforce high quality standards (including through unannounced inspections), support
family day care networks, offer a strong resource and referral system, and provide a wide
variety of care options, all of which increase quality without large investments.
The Department of Defense's Child Care System serves over 200,000 children daily (age
zero to 12), making it the largest employer-sponsored child care program in the nation.
Through this system, the military offers full-day, part-day, and hourly child care, part-day
preschools, before- and after-school programs for school age children, and extended hour
care. Because of the Department of Defense's commitment to excellence in child care, since
1992, the number of military child care facilities that are accredited by the independent
National Association for the Education of Young Children has risen from 55 to 353.
Currently, over 75% of military child care programs are accredited, as compared to only 7%
of other child care facilities nationwide.
29. Washington D.C.'s child care system is in crisis. What are you doing to improve
the child care system in this city?
Administration officials, concerned over the state of child care in the District, have met with
D.C. officials on several occasions to discuss ways to improve the quality of care the children
who live in the District receive. A working group including major stakeholders -- the
Department of Health and Human Services, the Office of Management and Budget, the office
9
�of the Mayor, the D.C. Council, the Control Board, and other city agencies have forged a
partnership to improve the quality of child care services in the District. The District's
Department of Consumer and Regulatory Affairs has issued a draft Strategic Plan to improve
child care quality.
In addition, the President will include D.C. as one of three to five pilot cities involved in an
interagency effort to eliminate duplication and better coordinate federal funding streams for
after-school programs.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
10
�Page 1 of28
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Neera Tanden ( CN=Neera Tanden/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-JAN-1998 09:10:58.00
SUBJECT:
NEW & REVISED Q & A
ANn
POLICY ANNOUNCEMENT
TO: Amy N. Finkelstein ( CN=Amy N. Finkelstein/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner (CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of28
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
PLEASE DISREGARD EARLIER PAPER
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D94]MAIL40193360R.026 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FFS7S043D20EOOOOOI0A0201000000020S000000FS920000000200002F030FB8498BFEOE29BCDC
EF3E3032C87907AAB86CAD298S9E09S04A418733E6FSSS032DEC842F34FFED319S62C9A87F7E38
EB701F3B7ECF163CAOCSB891AS6021F2ED927390C8BB3B24A31B63737BESDIElS01404DE909F21
08CAB69S17361FA7BF7AOIDB73B04F7F901096FB4E6ECS71B26CDS3S9AB78S7432COC438A8DB82
lA3069AD93F28C806AS4S1EEB16BF8F87F26C012EF18E3EB8F6116238FEFEF6E769DlS68C08AD8
6A42E9F40B9637733B4DCF19FC9690064CFD4613BB96A9CE4CS19FD~DIAFF39C64F93DSFD71729
FAASD8E87FE7B4BCEC1764BD7C971E94AAl13ACDAID49896ECOCFB7B9C7EE811B6AEB12BF98BBO
37816AlS6729D9211186E4E198D67E419442C30D88DAElF2BOlFlDOF190CSE3397208789496EB9
S106F76D64418COBICECECICEA74896DllS69S97DD379DBC63347908DD40EB173SD61B19961F6C
4BC131348CB8BFD32CSA7331EFBBA88137693604FDAC71D13CE9CA0726F73B28BF6BAFC93CB064
A7SC3BFDFSBDS799426F77BBE831EB49FFEAFBF029820778186EF9648SDDAD948C3C8SB6374833
FD67BS608B43AFCCF933B2919FC4SDB32683B230F72AD78B09134S7CSE7848481SS39C7BF4B081
IBC2A43E3D7A616464639C9FAEBFFFF811EDF3A8DAIFSE3CC03B704SC80BC8D6FC926097COS4D9
87A8S4FS9S0200AI00000000000000000000000823010000000BOI0000CEOAOOOOOOSS31000000
4EOOOOOOD90B0000092S0100000006000000270COOOOOB3002000000280000002DOC0000081601
00000032000000SS0C000008770100000040000000870C000008340100000014000000C70COOOO
0802010000000FOOOOOODBOC0000080S0100000008000000EAOCOO0000SS190000004EOOOOOOF2
OCOOOOOOSS0700000042000000400DOOOOOOSS130000003COOOOOO820DOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000820DOOOOOOSSOI00000032000000BEODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBEODOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOBEODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBEODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBEODOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBEODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBEODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBEODOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBEODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBEOD000000000000000000000000
BEODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBEODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBEODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOBEODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBEODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOBEODOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000000000BEODOOOOOB300D0000004EOOOOOOFOODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOFOODOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOFOODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOFOODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOFOOD
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOFOODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOFOODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOFOODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOFOODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOFOODOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00000000FOOD000009420S0000001D0000003EOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00000000003EOEOOOOOOOOOO
000000000000003EOE0000000000000000000000003EOEOOOOOOOO00000000000000003EOEOOOO
000000000000000000003EOE0000000000000000000000003EOEOO00000000000000000000003E
OE0000000000000000000000003EOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO3EOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
00003EOE0000000000000000000000003EOE000009440200000033OOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOE000000000000000000000000
SBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOE
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOO
OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSBOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSB
�The President's Child Care Initiative
January 7, 1998
Internal Questions & Answers
AYt@ffl§fed R.co
HftN-DuZ; M;nage'!lent System
nverslon
1. What is the President announcing today?
President Clinton today announced an historic initiative to improve child care for
America's working families. The President's FY 1999 budget will include approximately
$20 billion over five years for child care, the largest single investment in child care in the
nation's history. President Clinton's initiative responds to the struggles our nation's
working parents face in rmding child care that they can afford, trust, and rely on. The
President's proposal will help working families pay for child care, build the supply of good
after-school programs, improve the safety and quality of care, and promote early learning.
•
Doubles the number of children receiving child care subsidies to more than two
million by the year 2003 by increasing funding for the Child Care and
Development Block Grant by $7.5 billion over 5 years.
•
Increases tax credits for three million working families to help them pay for
child care by investing $5.2 billion over 5 years in the Child and Dependent Tax
Credit. The President's proposal also provides a new tax credit for businesses
that offer child care services for their employees.
•
Provides after-school care for 500,000 children per year by expanding the 21st
Century Community Learning Center program by $800 million over 5 years to
provide funds to school-community partnerships to establish or expand
programs for school-age children.
•
Improves child care safety and quality and enhances early childhood
development by establishing a new Early Learning Fund as well as supporting
enforcement of state child care health and safety standards, providing
scholarships to up to 50,000 child care providers per year, and investing in
research and consumer education.
Child Care Block Grant Increase
Child and Dependent Tax Credit Reform
Tax Credit for Businesses
After-School Program
Early Learning Fund
Head Start Increase
Standards Enforcement Fund
Child Care Provider Scholarship Fund
Research and Evaluation Fund
ITOTAL:
1
$7.5 billion over five years
$5.2 billion over five years
$500 million over five years
$1 billion over five years
$3 billion over five years
$3.4 billion over five years
$500 million over five years
$250 million over five years
$150 million over five years
$21.3 billion over five years
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
2. The President has been in office for five years. Why is he proposing a child care
initiative now? Is this a new problem?
The child care initiative underscores President Clinton's commitment to strengthening
America's families. As the President has said, child care is "the next great frontier if we're
going to make sure all Americans can succeed at home and at work." (7/28/97) The initiative
that the President announced today builds on the Earned Income Tax Credit, the Family
Medical Leave Act, the Child Tax Credit, the new children's health insurance program, and a
host of other legislation the President has fought for to help American families.
The initiative also builds on President Clinton's continuing efforts to improve and increase
funding for child care. Under President Clinton, federal funding for child care has increased
by 70%, helping parents pay for the care of about one million children. The 1996 welfare
reform law increased child care funding by $4 billion over six years to provide child care
assistance to low-income working families moving from welfare to work.
3. How are you going to pay for this big package?
The President's budget carefully pays for each and every element of his child care initiative.
The package is funded in a variety of ways -- some on the mandatory and others on the
discretionary side of the budget. The offsets for the mandatory items include -- but are not
limited to -- expected revenues from a national tobacco settlement, which the President hopes
and believes Congress will pass this year.
4. Since much of the funding of this proposal is based on the tobacco settlement, aren't
you counting your chickens before they've hatched? What will you do if the tobacco
settlement does not go through?
First, the initiative is paid for in a number of ways -- only one part comes from tobacco
revenues. Second, and more important, we believe that a national tobacco settlement will
pass. The President strongly supports legislation consistent with his principles, and many
Republicans and Democrats alike are working vigorously to craft comprehensive legislation.
Of course, no offset proposed in a budget is guaranteed; the Congress can reject any proposed
way of financing a program. If Congress does not pass comprehensive tobacco legislation,
we will work with Congress to find other offsets. This is a high Administration priority, and
we will find an effective funding mechanism.
5. Aren't you just creating a new federal bureaucracy?
The President's child care initiative creates no new federal bureaucracy. Rather, it relies on
states and communities to decide for themselves how best to address the child care challenges
they face. Indeed, the funds for each major initiative flow either to states or communities, or
in the case of tax credits, to individuals themselves.
2
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
6. The White House Conference on Early Learning and Development highlighted the
crucial development that takes place in the first years of a child's life. Given that the
best caregiver is a parent, what are you doing to help parents stay at home with their
children during this important time?
The program announced today is primarily oriented toward families where both caregivers go
to work, usually for reasons of financial necessity. It is designed to ensure that children in
these families receive quality care even though their parents are in the workforce.
The President believes strongly, however, that we should support parents who can and
choose to stay home. Today's announcement also includes two proposals that will help
these parents stay at home. First, the Administration will support demonstration projects in
states and communities to test policies to help new parents who choose to stay home to care
for their newborns or newly adopted children. Second, the President's Early Learning Fund
supports parents who stay at home by supporting home visits and parent education.
These initiatives build on President Clinton's record of providing real choices and
opportunities for parents. He has fought for: a $500 per child tax credit for families with
children; the Earned Income Tax Credit that gives 15 million working families tax relief;
health insurance for children; increases in the minimum wage; and the Family and Medical
Leave Act. President Clinton is committed to helping parents make the choices that are
right for their families, whether that means working or staying home to care for their
children.
7. What role did the First Lady have in developing this initiative?
The First Lady has been a strong voice for children and families for over twenty-five years
and continues to work on these issues. Mrs. Clinton played an important role in developing
the White House Conference on Early Learning and Development and the White House
Conference on Child Care. During the policy development process for the child care
initiative, the President looked to the First Lady for her advice and expertise on the problems
with the child care system and on possible solutions.
8. How do you expect to get Republican support for this initiative?
Child care traditionally has been a bipartisan issue. In fact, two of the central elements of
the President's child care initiative were strongly supported by previous Republican
Presidents and Members of Congress. Both Presidents Reagan and Bush supported the
expansion of the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit, and President Bush supported the
creation of the Child Care and Development Block Grant.
Many Members of the House and Senate from both sides ofthe aisle have shown a
commitment to taking action by introducing legislation that would improve the quality of
child care, make .it more affordable, and promote early learning. We look forward to
3
�working with them to pass significant child care legislation this year.
Automated ReCOrds Man
Hex-Dump Con~ege,!,ent System
IS/on
YI
TAX CREDITS
9. Today, the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit (CDCTC) favors middle-income
taxpayers and offers less reliefto lower-income taxpayers. Wouldn't it be more fair to
make the CDCTC refundable?
The President's proposed expansion of the CDCTC would wipe out tax liability for most
families with incomes under 200% of poverty (e.g., $35,000 for a family offour) who have
the maximum allowable child care expenses. In addition, the President's proposal
significantly expands the Child Care and Development Block Grant, which is an effective
mechanism to help low-income working families with child care costs. The two proposals
together offer significant relief to both low- and middle-income parents.
10. Wouldn't eliminating the marriage penalty help millions of working families with
children? Why aren't you supporting eliminating the penalty as part of your child
care initiative?
The Administration believes that proposals currently on the table to eliminate the marriage
penalty are prohibitively expensive in the context of a balanced budget. The President chose
instead to provide targeted tax cuts to assist American families struggling to meet child care
costs. These tax cuts will help more than three million families to pay for high-quality child
care.
Helping working families, especially those with children, has been the centerpiece of the
President's agenda on tax cuts. In 1993, the President expanded the Earned Income Tax
Credit to give the average recipient with two children more than $1,000 in tax relief. In 1997,
the President signed into law a $500 per child tax credit that will help 27 million families
meet the costs of raising their children. In addition, his $1,500 HOPE Scholarship Tax Credit
and Lifelong Learning Tuition Tax Credit will help nearly 13 million students meet the costs
of college and higher education. The President will continue to focus tax and overall
economic policy on helping working families.
11. Won't the employer credit for child care expenses that the President is proposing
create a windfall for companies already operating child care centers or otherwise
subsidizing employee child care?
Very few for-profit employers are currently making child care services available to their
employees. The credit will provide a real incentive to employers to create new employee
child care programs. Also, for those employers who already have a child care program, the
credit will help support .expansion of services.
4
�SUBSIDIES
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
12. Why are you expanding the Child Care and Development Block Grant (CCDBG)
when states aren't using aU of their child care subsidy money now?
In fact, we are very encouraged by state reports which show they have obligated over 99 of
the child care fund available under the new welfare law for FY 1997.
This demonstrates
the tremendous need states have for child care, and President Clinton has continued to urge
states to invest their dollars into helping these working families. But let's be clear-this
current initiative is not aimed at mothers on welfare. It's aimed at working parents who
desperately need this assistance. For example, working families with annual incomes under
$14,400 that pay for care for children under five spend 25 of their income on child care -and even then it's difficult finding accessible, quality care.
13. According to some news stories, states have big surpluses which they could spend on child
care. Rep. Clay Shaw recently issued a report saying that states have significant and growing
surplus federal welfare dollars. The report also said that given the surpluses and the increase in
child care funding under the new welfare law, there isn't a need now for more child care
money. Why are you proposing to add to CCDBG?
The Administration is very pleased that a strong economy and state welfare refonn efforts
have helped families move from welfare to work. But let's be clear-this initiative is not
aimed at mothers on welfare. It's aimed at working parents. For example, working families
with annual incomes under $14,400 that pay for care for children under five spend 25% of
their income on child care. Currently, we're serving only a small percentage of eligible
children from working families: there are approximately 10 million children who are eligible
for federal child care assistance, but we are able to serve only over a million of these children.
For America's working families to succeed in the workplace, they need quality choices in
affordable and accessible child care. The President's initiative, with its combination of
increased subsidies for low-income families and tax credits for moderate- and middle-income
families, will provide working parents the opportunity to remain self-sufficient and succeed
both at home and at work.
14. When the President signed the welfare bill, he claimed that the big increase in
CCDBG would make welfare reform work. Now that he is proposing adding to it, is he
admitting that his previous child care efforts were not sufficient?
No. The President fought to spend $4 billion more on child care in welfare refonn
legislation to help mothers on welfare go to work, and he continues to believe that child care
is a critical component of welfare refonn. However, low-income parents who have never
been on welfare are also struggling to afford child care, and all working families want their
5
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
children to be in safe, healthy settings where they can learn and grow. These initiatives
address the concerns and needs of all working families in this country. In particular,
expansion of the block grant will enable many states to provide subsidies for the first time to
the non-welfare working poor.
15. In order to keep up with the additional need for child care under welfare reform,
aren't states creating new slots at the expense of quality? What protection do you have
against states just increasing slots without regard to quality if you simply increase the
block grant?
The President believes that we must make child care more affordable as well as improve
quality because he believes that both are important. That is why his child care initiative
includes investments in both, and that is why the President fought hard during the welfare
debate to preserve 4% of funding through the child care block grant for state investments in
quality.
QUALITY
16. What does the Early Learning Fund actually do? How will you measure results?
Recent scientific research has demonstrated that experiences during the earliest years of life -before children reach school age -- are critical to their cognitive, emotional, and physical
development. Nurturing and stimulating children in the first years of life help their brains
develop and prepare them for the challenges of school and later life. We also know that too
much child care for infants and toddlers is inadequate: one respected study found that 13% of
regulated and 50% of unregulated family child care providers offer care that is inadequate for
children ages zero to three. President Clinton's proposed Early Learning Fund is designed to
improve early learning and development for our youngest children; to ensure health and
safety in child care; and to support parents as they raise their children.
The President's Early Learning Fund builds on state initiatives such as North Carolina's
Smart Start, which helps North Carolina's children enter school healthy and ready to succeed.
Smart Start funds a broad variety oflocal efforts, including improving staff-to-child ratios,
health'linkages that have raised immunization rates, and parent education and mentoring
programs to give new parents support.
17. How is the Early Learning Fund different from Early Head Start?
Early Head Start is a relatively small program that reaches only certain poor families. The
new initiative will promote early learning and provide parent support and education to
parents at a wider range of income levels. The Early Learning Fund also differs from Head
Start and Early Head Start because it targets support to communities that have developed
innovative approaches to foster early learning and meet the child care needs of families.
6
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
18. Wasn't the President already committed to serving one million children by 2002?
What's new in this Head Start initiative?
The President's child care initiative proposes an additional $1 billion targeted to Early Head
Start to double the number of infants and toddlers served, in addition to his commitment to
reauthorize all of Head Start to reach one million children by 2002. The total, cost is $3.4
billion ..
19. Much of the research the White House has highlighted tells us what we need to do
to ensure healthy child development. Given that these practices are the same
everywhere, why have you not proposed national standards?
We do know what works. As we learned at the White House Conference on Child Care, safe
facilities, ongoing guidance from health professionals, and child care providers who are well
trained and adequately compensated result in quality care. However, we also learned at the
conference that many states have good quality standards, but do not have the resources to
fund enforcement of those standards. The President's Standards Enforcement Fund will
help states improve licensing, enforce standards, and increase unannounced inspections
of child care settings. In addition, particularly when it comes to the youngest children,
different states face different challenges in their child care systems. That is why the
President's Early Learning Fund gives states a menu of allowable activities to promote early
learning and development so that states can concentrate on those areas where they are falling
behind. In this way, the quality of care will improve across the country.
20. At the White House Conference on Child Care, you championed the National
Crime Prevention and Privacy Compact. What happened to the Compact?
The National Crime Prevention and Privacy Compact has been transmitted to Congress. The
Compact is an important part of the President's child care initiative, and the President will
push for its passage when Congress returns.
21. Won't the scholarship fund raise the wages of child care workers, and in turn,
increase the cost of child care and make it un affordable for many families?
This proposal is modeled after North Carolina's T.E.A.C.H. program; North Carolina has not
seen higher costs since it put T.E.A.C.H. in place. Because child care workers are likely to
stay in their jobs longer if they are trained and better compensated, any additional costs of
increased wages will be offset to some extent by savings associated with reduced staff
turnover.
22. If you are proposing a huge increase in federal research of child care issues,
shouldn't you wait to make policy based on what you learn from the research?
7
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
While there is much we don't know about our child care system, we do know enough to act.
Child care is a pressing problem in America: 45% percent of all children under the age of one
are in child care on a regular basis; much of this is inadequate; and families with annual
incomes under $14,400 that pay for care for children under five spend about 25% of their
income on child care. We cannot afford to wait to improve the quality of care these children
receive.
AFTER- SCHOOL PROGRAMS
23. Your after-school proposal requires programs to be run in the schools. What do
you do for those children in communities where the school will not or cannot provide an
after-school program?
While a major purpose of the 21 st Century Leaming Centers Program is to make use of
underutilized school facilities, the program includes a set aside to fund programs run by
community groups. In addition, the President's FY 1999 budget includes $95 million for
after school and other prevention programs administered by the Department of Justice.
Innovative programs that are run by community groups in museums, recreation centers or
other places outside schools may receive funding from this after-school initiative.
GENERAL
24. Much attention has been given to the au pair system since nineteen year old Louise
Woodward was tried for killing a baby in her care. What are you doing to reform the
au pair system?
The U.S. Information Agency (the agency that runs the au pair program) announced in
September updated regulations on the .screening and placement of au pairs. Under the new
regulations: au pairs who care for children under two years old must have 200 or more
documented hours of infant-care experience; au pair training will include 24 hours of
child-development instruction; au pairs will be limited to working 10 hours a day and 45
hours a week; their pay will be increased from $115 to $139 a week; and the screening and
selection process will be improved.
25. What are the child care options for parents who work at the White House?
Employees of the Executive Office of the President (EOP) can enroll their children in the
nearby U.S. Kids Child Development Center, a center accredited by the independent National
Association for the Education.ofYoung Children. Additionally, White House parents may
enroll their children in any of the 27 other Federal child care centers in the greater
Washington, D.C. area.
26. What is the child care system for federal employees?
8
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
There are more than 230 child care centers for civilian government employees in federal
buildings in as many as 36 states, including 108 centers overseen by the General Services
Administration (GSA). Seventy-three percent of GSA sponsored centers are accredited by
the independent National Association for Education of Young Children, and GSA is working
to reach 100 accreditation within two years. Striving to meet the needs of parent workers,
89 of GSA centers have infant care, 74 have drop-in/emergency care, and 42 provide
summer programs for school-aged children. In addition, more than 80 of centers are open
11 or more hours per day. Notably, nearly 70% of the child care center directors have ten or
more years of experience in early childhood education.
27. Apparently many low-income federal employees cannot afford the federal child
care system. What are you doing to help them?
The federal government, like the private sector, still faces challenges in providing affordable
care to lower paid employees. GSA has studied this problem intensively this year and has
released a report to Congress outlining a plan to increase revenues and enrollment, reduce
operating costs, and expand the availability of tuition assistance for parents who can't afford
to pay full fees.
28. You have touted the military's child care system as a model for the nation. Isn't it
good because they spend so much?
While the military does invest significant resources into their child care system, they also set
and enforce high quality standards (including through unannounced inspections), support
family day care networks, offer a strong resource and referral system, and provide a wide
variety of care options, all of which increase quality without large investments.
The Department of Defense's Child Care System serves over 200,000 children daily (age
zero to 12), making it the largest employer-sponsored child care program in the nation.
Through this system, the military' offers full-day, part-day, and hourly child care, part-day
prescl).ools, before- and after-school programs for school age children, and extended hour
care. Because of the Department of Defense's commitment to excellence in child care, since
1992, the number of military child care facilities that are accredited by the independent
National Association for the Education of Young Children has risen from 55 to 353.
Currently, over i5% of military child care programs are accn:dited, as compared to only 7%
of other child care facilities nationwide.
29. Washington D.C.'s child care system is in crisis. What are you doing to improve
the child care system in this city?
Administration officials, concerned over the state of child care in the District, have met with
D.C. officials on several occasions to discuss ways to improve the quality of care the children
who live in the District receive. A working group including major stakeholders -- the
Department of Health and Human Services, the Office of Management and Budget, the office
9
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
of the Mayor, the D.C. Council, the Control Board, and other city agencies have forged a
partnership to improve the quality of child care services in the District. The District's
Department of Consumer and Regulatory Affairs has issued a draft Strategic Plan to improve
child care quality.
In addition, the President will include D.C. as one of three to five pilot cities involved in an
interagency effort to eliminate duplication and better coordinate federal funding streams for
after-school programs.
10
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
PRESIDENT CLINTON ANNOUNCES CHILD CARE INITIATIVE
January 7, 1998
President Clinton today announced an historic initiative to improve child care for
America's working families. The President's FY 1999 budget will include approximately
$20 billion over five years for child care, the largest single investment in child care in the
nation's history. President Clinton's initiative responds to the struggles our nation's
working parents face in finding child care that they can afford, trust, and rely on. The
President's proposal will help working families pay for child care, build the supply of good
after-school programs, improve the safety and quality of care, and promote early learning.
•
Doubles the number of children receiving child care subsidies to more than two
million by the year 2003 by increasing funding for the Child Care and
Development Block Grant by $7.5 billion over 5 years.
•
Increases tax credits for three million working families to help them pay for
child care by investing $5.2 billion over 5 years in the Child and Dependent Tax
Credit. The President's proposal also provides a new tax credit for businesses
that offer child care services for their employees.
•
Provides after-school care for up to half a million children per year by
expanding the 21st Century Community Learning Center program by $800
million over 5 years to provide funds to school-community partnerships to
establish or expand programs for school-age children.
•
Improves child care safety and quality and enhances early childhood
development by establishing a new Early Learning Fund as well as supporting
enforcement of state child care health and safety standards, providing
scholarships to up to 50,000 child care providers per year, and investing in
research and consumer education.
Child Care Block Grant Increase
Child and Dependent Tax Credit Reform
Tax Credit for Businesses
After-School Program
Early Learning Fund
Head Start Increase
Standards Enforcement Fund
Child Care Provider Scholarship Fund
Research and Evaluation Fund
$7.5 billion over five years
$5.2 billion over five years
$500 million over five years
.$800 million over five years
$3 billion over five years
$3.4 billion over five years
$500 million over five years
$250 million over five years
$150 million over five years
ITOTAL:
$21.3 billion over five years
�Automate~e~~g:/mr1pS M gef!1ent System
ana
con versIOn
MAKES CHILD CARE MORE AFFORDABLE FOR WORKING FAMILIES
Doubles the Number of Children Receiving Child Care Subsidies to More than Two
Million. The President proposes to expand the Child Care and Development Block Grant to
help working families struggling to meet the costs of child care. This block grant is the
primary federal subsidy program to pay for child care, enabling low'-income parents to work.
Funds are distributed by formula to the states to operate direct child care subsidy programs,
as well as to improve the quality and availability of care. The President's initiative will
more than double the number of children served from the one million served in FY 95 (the
latest year for which data are available). The President's budget will increase funding for the
block grant by $7.5 billion (with a match) over five years, which will· enable states to provide
subsidies for more than two million children by 2003.
Increases Tax Credits for 'Child Care for Three Million Working Families. The Child
and Dependent Tax Credit provides tax relief to taxpayers who pay for the care of a child
under 13 or a disabled dependent or spouse in order to work. The credit is equal to a
percentage of the taxpayer's employment-related expenditures for child or dependent care,
with the amount of the credit depending on the taxpayer's income. The President's proposal
increases the credit for families earning under $60,000, providing an additional average tax
cut of$358 for these families and eliminating income tax liability for almost all families with
incomes below 200% of poverty ($35,000 for a family of four) that take the maximum
allowable child care expenses under the law. The President's budget will include $5.2
billion over five years to expand the Child and Dependent Care Tax Credit for three million
working families.
Provides New Business Tax Credits. The child care initiative includes a tax credit to
businesses that provide child care services for their employees, by building or expanding
child care facilities, operating existing facilities, training child care workers, reserving slots
for employees at child care facilities, or providing child care resource and referral services to
employees. The credit covers 25% of qualified costs, but may not exceed $150,000 per year.
The President's budget will include approximately $500 million over five years for these tax
credits.
PROMOTES EARLY LEARNING AND HEAL THY CHILD DEVELOPMENT
Promotes Early Learning. Research shows that children's experiences in the earliest
years are critical to their development and future success. The President's proposed
Early Learning Fund provides challenge grants to communities (distributed by states)
to support programs to improve early learning and the quality and safety of child care
for children ages zero to five. Funds may be used for the following activities: providing
basic training to child care providers (including first aid and CPR); connecting individual
child care providers to centers for education and support; assisting child care providers to
meet accreditation and licensing requirements; linking child care providers with health
professionals; reducing group sizes and child-to-staff ratios; and providing home visits,
parent education, and consumer education about child care. The President's Early Learning
Fund builds on state initiatives such as North Carolina's Smart Start, which helps North
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Carolina's children enter school healthy and ready to succeed. Smart Start funds a broad
variety of local efforts, including improving staff-to-child ratios, health linkages that have
raised immunization rates, and parent education and mentoring programs to give new parents
support. The President's budget will include $3 billion over five years for this fund.
Increases Investment in Head Start and Doubles the Number of Children Served by
Early Head Start. Head Start provides early, continuous and comprehensive child
development and family support services, preparing children for a lifetime of learning and
development. The President is committed to reauthorize Head Start and reach one million
children by 2002. The President's budget will invest $3.4 billion over five years to keep
on track his commitment to serving one million children by 2002, and to double the
number of infants and toddlers in Early Head Start to 80,000.
IMPROVES THE QUALITY OF CHILD CARE
Steps Up Enforcement of State Health and Safety Standards. Building on the
military's model child care program, this proposed initiative will fund state efforts to improve
licensing systems and enforce child care health and safety standards, including by increasing
unannounced inspections of child care settings. The President's budget will include $500
million over five years for this program.
Facilitates Background Checks on Child Care Providers. On the day of the White House
Conference on Child Care, the President transmitted to Congress the National Crime
Prevention and Privacy Compact, which will facilitate effective background checks on child
care providers by eliminating state law barriers to sharing criminal history information for
non-criminal purposes. Although the vast majority of child care providers are dedicated to
the teaching and nurturing of children, one tragedy in child care is too many. Background
checks are an important way to ensure that the people watching our children are fit for this
responsibility.
Increases Scholarships and Training for Child Care Providers. At the White House
Conference on Child Care, the President proposed establishing a Child Care Provider
Scholarship Fund to enable states to provide scholarship funds to students working toward a
child care credential. Eligible child care workers must commit to remaining in the field for
at least one year for each year of assistance received and will earn increased compensation or
bonuses when they complete their course work. The President proposed a federal
investment of$250 million over five years, which will support 50,000 scholarships per year.
The President is also proposing to expand the Department of Labor's Child Care
Apprenticeship Program to fund the training of child care providers.
Invests in Research. Because too little is known about our child care system, the
President's budget will increase support for data, research, and evaluation. This research
fund will also support a National Center on Child Care Statistics and a child care hotline that
parents can call to get information about how to find child care in their communities and how
to identify appropriate, quality care for their children. In addition, the research fund will
support demonstration projects to test approaches to help new parents who choose to stay
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
home to care for their newborns or newly adopted children. The President's budget will
include $150 million over five years for this fund.
EXPANDS AND STREAMLINES AFTER-SCHOOL CARE
An estimated five million school-age children spend time as "latchkey kids" without adult
supervision during a typical week. Research indicates that during these unsupervised hours
children are more likely to engage in at-risk behavior, such as crime, drugs, and alcohol use.
To meet this pressing demand, the President is proposing a dramatic expansion of
after-school care.
Provides After-School Care for up to Half a Million Children a Year. The President
proposes a dramatic expansion of the 21 st Century Community Learning Center Program to
provide start-up funds (with a local match) to school-community partnerships to establish or
expand before- and after-school programs for school-age children. The program increases the
supply of after-school care in a cost-effective manner primarily by funding programs that use
public schools and their existing resources, such as computers, gymnasiums, and sports
equipment. The program also includes a set aside to fund programs run by community
organizations. The President's budget will request $800 million of entirely new money for
this program, for a total of $1 billion over five years.
Improves Coordination of Federal After-School Initiatives to Help Communities Make
Best Use of Existing Resources. The President will put in place a collaborative effort
involving numerous federal agencies to eliminate duplication and better coordinate federal
funding for after-school programs in three to five pilot cities, including the District of
Columbia.
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
.'
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-JAN-1998 09:23:04.00
SUBJECT:
Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Ma'ry L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�. ARMS Email System
.
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: weinstein dena
READ: UNKNOWN
weinstein dena @ ustr.gov @ INET @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
cc: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa M. Murray ( CN=Melissa M. Murray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having the Tobacco Strategy Meeting on tomorrow, January 8, at
2:45 p.m. in Room 211.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[01/02/1998 – 01/07/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 098 - Folder 001
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/dd4c0236d116b08702a929644df6d058.pdf
5ebde67b338a69284b713ea3e08849e3
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 097 - FOLDER -009
[12/03/1997-12/22/1997]
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
. ,.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-DEC-1997 12:35:09.00
SUBJECT:
Reminder -- SOTU outreach
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John H. Gibbons ( CN=John H. Gibbons/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/Ou=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
. <.
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
As I have mentioned to some of you, we will submit to the President for
his Christmas reading a book compiling memos and speech draft submissions
by outsiders (authors, academics, policy experts, artists, business
leaders). We are gathering up the names of people we will contact.
Please let me know if you have any suggestions for people to contact, as
soon as you can.
Thanks!
Page 2 of2
�· ARMS Email System
(t
Page 1 of28 .
h
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Robert M. Shireman ( CN=Robert M. Shireman/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-DEC-1997 17:33:59.00
SUBJECT:
Memos - tight timeline
TO: Tanya E. Martin ( CN=Tanya E. Martin/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M.Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob
READ: UNKNOWN
J.
Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Lin Liu ( CN=Lin Liu/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Schnur ( CN=Jonathan H. Schnur/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dario J. Gomez ( CN=Dario J. Gomez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne H. Lewis ( CN=Anne H. Lewis/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVp @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KAGAN_E ( KAGAN E
READ: UNKNOWN
@
Al
@
CD
@
LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
�Page 2 of28
ARMS Email System
r,
'"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Scott R. Palmer ( CN=Scott R. Palmer/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ricardo M. Gonzales ( CN=Ricardo M. Gonzales/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne Upshaw ( CN=Wayne Upshaw/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William R. Kincaid ( CN=William R. Kincaid/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD. 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William H. White Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=William H. White Jr./OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TEXT:
Attached are memos that are being faxed out now on both the Hispanic
Action plan, and the College-School Early Intervention partnerships (also
known as "mentoring" or "Fattah-plus"). They ask for comment by noon
tomorrow because they will be going to the President by COB tomorrow.
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D511MAIL40725663X.316 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750439D150000010A02010000000205000000AF68000000020000F6E49D44E59C5C217524BA
OC88E4615E82D456729EA9B1622B2D7576EB2CFA508B505B361009F084F03475A679CFICEACF60
1371003C2AD2A7DIF8F55D300731681412BBA3482BICEACIAB6A3751789012FCC120AE5A791B7F
EBEED49251133684C6872339AD200CAB9320E5232C672D8ADB7AF6D6D8305511C301083FIB4347
EBC7D4AA76A46A9B325C4A2BF335335B9A4490BCCBE73EIC2FE58ClC77D46670726D470F707DDD
072779422477BIDBFE92016604A32CIF6F8144AAE991894FEAC43EE25C2A38472A34CFF066AEEI
91E8980006F329531EB08375411383FC93800FF7309E50EE3B0086OCICBE4575E7AB43EA7E52CE
OBA76E137B9E9B0694CC82F38926277D34FICEOF9B5070EEA90ECl7228AC7E2786E17BD2344291
5DFOOE528ABD7A3F94405669BBE8ECECBB82FA39396BA29324DF3FF84A3445FFDA891D53E16BAF
AD479B62220992B03EBCD47AC3D04COE13A9A99E83F062FDC42EA7D2957931D22325896135CD6A
5A7FE5DEIC139BE9A461806CA3468C7B640CBEBD035DFE2FBDB58459C37999A8B8B9FB85ABA9A2
FD7A8740C227780B2DA4AFEF3F4C6AOF62ADIC9795D5DC04A7E96EC7372709071E445CBBF6496D
237E9325E23B6A32348C7FB909676301295405D38FF852434FBCA717ADID581201A862C040DOD5
04B4DE6FID02002B00000000000000000000000055120000003AOO00005A040000092501000000
0600000094040000081201000000720200009A0400000608000001OOA50000000C070000060801
000000A5000000BI0700000B30030000008D00000056080000060801000000A5000000E3080000
OB30020000008D0000008809000000551000000042000000150AOO000B30020000004300000057
�December 3, 1997
MEMORANDUM TO:
FROM:
RE:
SECRETARY RILEY
DIRECTOR RAINES
BRUCE REED
GENE SPERLING
BOB SHIREMAN
MENTORING INITIATIVE
The attached draft memorandum follows up on the principals meeting of October 14, and
the consultation and analysis that has gone on since that time.
A final memo will go into the President by COB tomorrow, so I need your changes and
recommendations, if any, by noon tomorrow, Thursday, December 4. Please get your
changes to Bob Shireman by fax (456-2223) or e-mail and call him (456-2803) to make
sure he has received them.
CC:
Mr. Bowles
Secretary Rubin
Dr. Yellen
Ms. Mathews
Mr. Podesta
Mr. Klain
Mr. Hilley
Acting Deputy Secretary Smith
Mr. Lew
Ms. Kagan
Ms. Winston
Mr. Cohen
Mr. Shireman
�(,
r,
MEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT
RE:
COLLEGE-SCHOOL EARLY INTERVENTION INITIATIVE
In preparation for the budget decisions that will need to be made in the next few
weeks, this memorandum is intended to provide you with a status report on the
development of a possible college-school early intervention initiative, and an opportunity
for you to provide direction to our continuing efforts. In order to move forward on the
budget, there are three issues that need to be settled: (1) the basic parameters of the
early intervention programs, (2) the issue of early notification (the "guarantee" of aid),
and, of course, (3) funding.
With the approach described in this memo, you would be able to announce a
new 21st Century Scholars program that would:
•
Provide families at high-poverty middle schools (and possibly others as well) with
an official notification of the $20,000 or more that is available for their children to
go to college; and,
•
Through colleges and other partners, provide intensive, long-term early
intervention and support services to 250,000 new children each year (at 2200
high-poverty schools) -- 1.5 million children over six years.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Background
As you remember, this initiative began with your interest in the "21st Century
This legislation, which continues to garner
Scholars Act" by Rep. Chaka Fattah.
significant support, including some Republicans, would guarantee sixth graders at
high-poverty schools a maximum Pell Grant when they got to college; send a notice to
them annually from the Secretary of Education reminding them of the availability of aid;
and make them automatically eligible for the counseling, academic support, and other
services provided by TRIO programs (such as Upward Bound) in high school and
college.
.
Working with OMB and Education, we analyzed the specifics of the Fattah
approach and found a number of problems: higher-than-expected costs and
inefficiencies; inequities and perverse incentives; and the difficult issue of a new
entitlement. Most important, the research on early intervention programs indicated that
in order for them to be successful, it is critical that mentoring, counseling and tutoring be
provided to students. Simply making them eligible for TRIO is not enough. As you
know, Rep. Fattah is aware of these concerns and is flexible on the design of a program.
We felt strongly that the Administration needed a strong early intervention
initiative that goes well beyond a notification about financial aid. Research demonstrates
that programs that start early and are sustained for a number of years are effective. For
example, in the rigorously-evaluated Quantum Opportunities Program, 42 percent of the
participants attended college, compared to 16 percent in the control group. To have a
significant impact on college enrollment of disadvantaged youth, it is clear that we need a
full-fledged early intervention program.
Our idea is to center this effort on colleges reaching out to high poverty schools.
College involvement is critical for a number of reasons. First, this approach creates an
ethic of responsibility: it reminds colleges that they are responsible for helping to build a
pool of disadvantaged youth -- disproportionately minorities -- who are well-prepared for
college. Second, if college is to be the goal that sixth graders see, they need to have
some connection to the institution. Third, colleges are best able to tell students -- and
the schools they attend -- what types of courses and skills they need to succeed. Indeed,
an ancillary benefit of this approach should be higher standards. l And finally, a stable,
lIn fact, in response to our consultations on this issue, we already have a proposal from colleges in the
California State University system for an early intervention program that would focus on math as the
gateway to college.
�"
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
long-term institution needs to be there to ensure the quality and staying power of a
program like this one,
In October, principals discussed options (DPC, Education, PIR, COS, and OLA
were represented). At that meeting, there was strong support for the concept of Federal
aid to partnerships between colleges and needy schools, to provide sixth graders with
mentoring and other support that would be sustained through high school graduation.
There was also strong support for getting early information to families about the
availability of Federal financial aid for college. But there was concern about any new
entitlement to aid: first, it creates budget complications, both politically and practically;
second, it creates the impression that the current programs are not secure -- contrary to
the "universal access" message that we are sending in the wake of victories on HOPE and
Pel!.
Since the principals meeting, we have accelerated our consultations and research.
I have spoken with more than 200 college presidents, both individually and in groups,
and the response has been quite positive. Many of them have provided examples of
their own efforts to tap into K-12 schools to recruit and offer help early. Education is
reviewing all of the research literature, and with my staff has carried out an effort to
identify model programs with the characteristics that we discussed at the principals
meeting. Both Mike Smith and I have spoken with Eugene Lang, founder of the "I
Have a Dream" program, and he agrees that we are on the right track. Even though he
is best known for his promise of aid to Harlem sixth graders, he feels strongly that the
early and sustained support services are the most important determinant of a successful
program (and he agrees with the need for college involvement).
Basic Parameters of the College-School Partnerships
Some of the colleges with whom we have consulted want the program to very
flexible, to incorporate a wide variety of program models. But we have pressed that
while we support flexibility, there needs to be a vision -- some common elements that
give the proposal an identity that will propel it to success both legislatively and, ultimately,
programmatically. We recommend the following core components:
Whole Classes/Cohorts at High-Poverty Schools. Programs must start providing
services to all of the. children in a grade, class, or schoo!. Many programs focus
on students who have been pre-judged to have college "potentia!." But middle
school is too early to rule anyone out. In addition, a whole-class approach is
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
more likely to involve the school (rather than just the students) in a way that will
bring about improvements in the curriculum.
College as a Goal.
The programs must hold out college as a primary goal.
Special consideration would be given to partnerships that guarantee enrollment in
a college for participating students who reach particular milestones, and/or for
programs that guarantee additional financial aid to cover the full costs of the
college.
Start Early and Stay with Kids through High School Students should begin in the
program not later than the seventh grade. The program must continue to
provide services through high school graduation (or at least for six years).
(There will be some attrition due to dropping out of school or of the program,
moving out, or participating in another program.)
An Intensive Element.
Programs must provide intensive assistance to students at
least during some part of the program (cost estimates assume that this happens in
the first year).
For example, this may be a residential summer component at a
college.
Community Involvement.
Community organizations and businesses should be
tapped to offer mentors, guarantees of additional financial aid in exchange for
student performance, exposure to careers, and other support.
Note on relationship to TRIO programs. Some colleges already have Federal
TRIO grants with some of the above characteristics, and/or they have other similar
programs. The largest Federal investment, Upward Bound, provides counseling and
intensive academic support to selected disadvantaged high school students who show
aptitude for college. The Talent Search program provides a one-shot program of early
information about college to middle school students. Those programs do not come
close to addressing all of the need, so there would not normally be a problem with them
duplicating some part of this new program. Applicants for the college-school
partnership funds would have to describe how their existing early intervention programs
would be coordinated with the new program. It is expected that some partnerships
would apply for the new grants to extend and expand their programs, so that Upward
Bound, for example, .could essentially create a grade 4-10 feeder program, and Talent
Search could add a more intensive component with follow-up during the high school
years. Others might simply focus on high-poverty schools where the students are not
�being served by any current program.
Automated RecOrds Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Early Notification/Guarantee
The early intervention effort would be joined with Rep. Chaka Fattah's concept of
providing children and their families with early, official notification of their eligibility for
college financial aid. Because of the combination of student loans, Pell Grants, and
HOPE Scholarships, virtually everyone is eligible for at least $20,000 of aid for four
years of college. While a legally enforceable "guarantee" to Pell Grants six years in the
future has too many problems, we can still adopt the basic concept by making a firm
statement about college aid generally. (As with Federal pensions and some military
benefits, the actual amounts would depend on the continuation of the programs.)
This would be part of the larger information campaign on access to higher
education. While the focus would be on getting the notifications to families at the
highest-poverty schools, we would not need to be that restrictive and could reach a larger
number than the Fattah legislation proposes. It would not be unreasonable for us to
have a goal of reaching a million students with information and an official notification
(double the number that would have been reached by Fattah).
As already noted, we would encourage partnerships to supplement Federal aid
with additional financial assistance and/or guaranteed admission to a particular college if
the student takes the right classes and works hard.
Funding
We are discussing two possible approaches. The first would make a simple offer
to colleges in a competitive program: tell us how you would use a grant of $200,000 to
$1 million to create or expand partnerships with the characteristics outlined above. A
$300 million investment would fund 400 colleges, if the average grant size was $750,000.
They might have partnerships with up to 2000 schools, with 226,000 students (if only
one grade level was being served at all of the schools). This would leave it up to the
college to determine whether and how to add new cohorts. In providing grants, we
would have the flexibility to take into consideration the institution's own resources, so that
Ivy League schools would be expected to take most of the costs themselves, while a
Tribally Controlled Community College would not.
The other approach would be tied more specifically to the need for an intensive
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
start, and the cost of adding new cohorts of students each yea~. It would also requir~ a
growing local match.. A $300 million Federal investment in FY 1999 would allow us to
serve 250,000 seventh graders through competitive grants to partnerships with 2200
high-poverty schools, assuming a 20 percent local match and a $1,500 per participant
cost. These funds would provide mentoring to about half of the schools and students
that would have been provided the guarantee under Fattah (students at schools with
poverty rate of 75 percent or greater). It is five times as many as are now served by
Upward Bound.
The average per-student cost would be significantly lower ($800) in the remaining
years, but additional cohorts -- new groups of seventh graders -- would continue to be
added each year until there is a full complement. If we assume that the local match can
be increased by 10 percent with each new cohort, until the Federal government is
covering only 30 percent of the cost, then (assuming some attrition) the funding would
reach a steady state at $619 million in FY 2004. (See line [aJ on the table). Over the
six years, 1.5 million kids would be served
Federal Cost of Early Intervention Program (in millions of dollars)
FY99
FYOO
FYOl
FY02
FY03
FY04
a. Full
300
415
502
565
604
150
339
430
534
595
FY06
619
b. Phase-in
FY05
632
c. Smaller
If we need to reduce FY 1999 appropriations requests, the best way to do so
would be to phase in the number of partnerships over two or three years, rather than
assuming that all of them would be established in the first year (line b). If the out-years
are a problem, then we would need to reduce the total number of schools/partnerships
that we are aiming for (line c).
Add at least $30 miIlion. The TRIO programs have a strong, organized
constituency. We are working with the association on this proposal, and so far they are
supportive. But they are concerned that our interest in this new proposal may weaken
our resolve as far as increases for the TRIO programs. Therefore, it is critical that an
increase of at least $30 million be included in the Budget for TRIO if we move forward
with the school-college mentoring partnerships.
�Automated Records Management Systerr'
Hex-Dump Conversion
Current program authorities and the question of a State role. Weare currently
assuming that this would be a new direct grant program from the Department of
Education, probably part of our proposal for reauthorization of the Higher Education
Act. Education is exploring a couple of current (unfunded) authorities to determine
whether we could use one of them for this program. The benefit of doing so is that it
makes it easier to get appropriations, because we don't have to wait for an authorization
of a new program in order to get appropriations.
Some of the Committee leadership on the Hill and the student association are
expected to pursue a state-based model, making use of a program authorized in 1992
called the National Early Intervention and State Scholarship Program. It is funded at
$3.2 million now and funds some useful models. Education opposes using this
authority, however, because it would be more difficult to maintain a high-quality, highly
targeted effort.
Next Steps
If you are comfortable with the general approach, then we will continue to draft
the descriptions that will need to be included in the Budget, if funding is to be included.
We will then continue to vet the idea, and will begin to develop a roll-out strategy.
Views and Recommendations
�Automated Records Mana
Hex-Dump Conv~~~~nt Systerr,
December 3, 1997
MEMORANDUM TO:
FROM:
SECRETARY RILEY
SECRETARY SHALALA
SECRETARY HERMAN
DIRECTOR RAINES
BRUCE REED
GENE SPERLING
BOB SHIREMAN
RE:
HISPANIC EDUCATION INVESTMENTS AND ACTIONS
As you know, the President asked us to develop strategies for improving education opportunities
for Hispanic Americans, particularly to reduce the dropout rate. All of you have contributed to
this effort. The attached draft memorandum to the President lays out some of the actions we are
prepared to take, as well as a proposal for investments in the FY 1999 Budget.
The possible investments will be compared against other requests, in the context of the budget
process over the next two weeks. Please let me know by noon tomorrow, Thursday, December 4,
if you have any suggested changes to the memo, or recommendations to add. Please focus
particularly on the investments in section I. Please contact Bob Shireman at 456-2803.
cc:
Mr. Bowles
Dr. Yellen
Ms. Mathews
Mr. Podesta
Ms. Murguia
Ms. Echaveste
Mr. Ibarra
Mr. Klain
Mr. Hilley
Acting Deputy Secretary Smith
Deputy Secretary Thurm
Deputy Secretary Higgins
Mr. Lew
Ms . . Kagan
Ms. Winston
Mr. Cohen
�Mr. Shireman
Dr. pompa
Ms. S. Brown
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
�Automated (")
llecordsM
Hex-Dump coanagement Sysr .
nVerslOn
Ie
DRAFT MEMORANDUM TO THE PRESIDENT
This memorandum provides you with background on our efforts to improve educational
opportunities for Hispanic Americans, and a possible further investment strategy for the FY 1999
Budget. Once budget decisions are made, we will have a comprehensive package of
research-based recommendations, new investments, and administrative actions ready for an
announcement. The announcement would include:
•
a report on the Hispanic dropout problem by researchers named by Secretary Riley two
years ago (in response to a request by Sen. Bingaman). The report includes advice for
schools, families, and all levels of government, but does not include any new data;
•
investments in programs that address the needs of Hispanic and LEP children;
•
a list of administrative and other actions -- including a Conference on Staying in School
-- that Education, Labor and HHS are taking to improve Federal programs so that they
better serve the Hispanic (and LEP) community; and,
•
the Secretary of Education's plan describing how current programs and our agenda of
research, standards and testing, teacher training, and outreach address the needs of
Hispanic and LEP children.
Section I of this memo describes the consultations that have taken place and the legislative
and appropriations actions that we have already taken. Section II is a reminder of some of the
planned or possible FY 1999 investments that are generally important for minorities, but are not
explicitly part of the Hispanic plan. Section III Jays out a possibJe investment strategy for
Hispanics and LBP children and families for the FY 1999 Budget. Section IV describes the other
actions that agencies would announce as part of the Hispanic Action Plan. Section V presents
the views of your advisors.
�Automated R .
H eo Management System
cords
ex- ump ConvelSion
I. Background
In response to your request that we look into the what we can do to address the Hispanic
dropout rate and to generally improve the educational opportunities of Hispanic Americans, we
set out to identify possible actions in three areas:
•
Then-pending Administration initiatives and reauthorization proposals that could
be improved in ways that benefit Latinos (for example, funding fonnulas that do
not adequately take into consideration growth areas).
•
Appropriation items in the FY98 Budget that have a disproportionate impact on
the Latino population, so that we would be sure to take that into consideration in
the continuing budget process.
•
Additional administrative and legislative proposals that could be aimed at
increasing Hispanic educational opportunities.
As a foundation for our efforts, we were able to use a report and recommendations
released last year by the President's Advisory Commission on Educational Excellence for
Hispanic Americans. We met with constituency groups, and held a series of meetings with
Hispanic Caucus members and staff, where officials from Education, Labor, HHS, and USDA
discussed their programs and some of the concerns and recommendations that have been raised.
Most recently, we have been able to review the not-yet-released report of the Hispanic Dropout
Project, by a group of researchers named by Secretary Riley at the suggestion of Senator
Bingaman. We have also reviewed legislation proposed by Congressman Hinojosa and Senator
Bingaman.
These efforts yielded results this year:
•
We insisted that our 35% increase for Bilingual and Immigrant Education be
an explicit part of the Bipartisan Balanced Budget Agreement, a very exclusive
list (only 13 items government-wide).
•
The $199 million in Bilingual Education includes $25 million for training
teachers to help limited English proficient (LEP) kids, a proposal that
Republican appropriators fought last year. (Thank Delia for working with the
appropriators this year to assure their support).
.
•
We took another look at our America Reads legislation and added provisions to
make doubly sure that States would have to make a particular effort to serve LEP
children.
�Automate~ Reo Management Syster
cords
ex- ump Conversion
•
Our proposal for Adult Education reauthorization -- a program that provides
adult ESL -- includes a new formula that targets states with large numbers of
LEP adults. (Unfortunately, no one in Congress is pushing the formula).
•
We proposed and received an 11 % increase for Hispanic-Serving Institutions
(HSIs).
•
In a reversal from our position to eliminate the program a few years ago, we
proposed and received a small increase for HEP-CAMP (migrant college
support services and early intervention program).
•
Other selected FY 1998 Appropriations that help Hispanics:
--Job Corps -- an effective program in which 70 of the participants are minorities
-- got $92 million increase (to $1.246 billion).
30 Job Corps Centers teach ESL.
-- Youth Opportunity Areas: $250 million to the highest poverty areas to help
out-of-school youth (age 16-24) become employable. (Currently six cities are
funded. In NYC, 67 of those served are Hispanic; in Houston, 65 ; in Los
Angeles, 50 .)
--$1.4 billion increase in Pell Grants for low-income college students.
--Obey's Comprehensive School Reform provides funds that will go to schools
that need to be transformed -- first in line should be those with high dropout rates.
II. Generic Issues
It is important that our overall campaign for high standards and accountability remains to
be seen as an important part of the answer for all children, particularly those who are at risk.
For the announcement of the Hispanic Action Plan, Education has developed a document that .
describes how the key education programs work for Hispanic and LEP children.
There are also other new initiatives that have already been announced or are being
considered that are oriented toward needs that have been identified in our work on Hispanic
Education, including:
•
Teacher Training and Recruitment. Your five-year, $350 million teacher training and
recruitment proposal is aimed at improving teacher preparation particularly for
�Automated Records Management SystelT'
Hex-Dump Conversion
harder-to-serve populations, and recruiting more minority teachers.
•
Education Opportunity Zones.
This new investment is aimed at spurring and rewarding
effective reform efforts in school districts that tend to be predominantly minorities.
•
College-School Early Intervention Partnerships. This is a proven response to 'the dropout
problem: it takes children at high-poverty schools by the seventh grade, delivers a firm
message about college opportunity, and then provides them with support through to high
school graduation. We consider this a major initiative that should be announced in a
broader context.
III. Decision: Added Investments
For FY 1999, we recommend that you consider increasing funding in some key programs
that are important to Latinos.
Investment (in millions):
FY1998
Increase
FY 1999
Bilingual Education - Teacher Training
$25
$25
$50
TRIO College Preparation Programs
$530
$30-70
$560
Hispanic-Serving Institutions [non-add; already approved]
$12
[$16J
$28
Adult Education - Model ESL Programs
n/a
$20
$20
Migrant Education Program
$305
$30-80
$365
Migrant Education: HEP and CAMP
$9.7
$5.3
$15
TOTAL:
$110.3-$2
00.3
This package addresses five of the six highest-priority items identified by the Hispanic
Education Coalition. The only program identified by the coalition but not included above is
Title I. (If the budget process yields a substantial increase in Title I, that could be included as
well. ) The program above that was not identified by the coalition is Adult
Education/English-language training for adults.
1. Bilingual Education - Teacher Training.
This program provides current teachers with
the skills they need to address the English language deficiencies of their students. (Despite the
�Automated Records Management Syster
Hex-Dump Conversion
name, it does not require a bilingual program). By doubling the FY 1998 investment and
sustaining. that level over five years, we could train 20,000 teachers. The need in this area is huge
-- California alone has a reported shortfall of 20,000.
2_ TRIO College Preparation Programs. A recent evaluation of the Upward Bound
program (support for promising disadvantaged kids to go to college) showed dramatically
positive results for Hispanics. This is an opportunity to showcase this success. We will also be
making changes to the TRIO statute to encourage more funding to areas that are under-served,
such as the Hispanic community. Even though we may be proposing an earlier mentoring
program, it is important that we propose an increase in TRIO so that the very strong TRIO
constituency does not see the new program as a threat. $30 million is the same increase that the
programs received in FY 1998; $60 million would receive a more enthusiastic response.
3. Hispanic-Serving Institutions. These funds go to strengthen colleges where at least 25
percent of the student body is Hispanic and a large portion are needy. This substantial increase
is already slated, as a result of Higher Education Act reauthorization and other discussions.
4. Adult Education - Model ESL Programs. The largest single source of English-as-aSecond-Language funding comes from the Adult Education program (which also promotes adult
literacy and GED attainment). There are a plethora of approaches, and huge demand for these
programs. But there is little information about what types of programs are most effective for
different populations. This five-year $100 million investrrient would go toward improving the
ESL programs that we now fund through identification and dissemination of proven and
promlsmg practices. It could also be used to provide more training for adult ESL instructors,
and/or to expand the use of the televised ESL series "Crossroads Cafe," if the evaluations of that
program are as positive as expected.
5. Migrant Education Program. Because of their mobility, migrant children -- more than 80
percent of whom are Hispanic -- often do not "belong" to anyone school system or even one
State. That is why the Federal role in this area is critical. Funded at $305 million in FY 1998,
MEP is a State formula program that supports an extremely wide range of interventions
specifically tailored to the needs of the local population it serves. Services range from the
identification and recruitment of kids into schools, to all kinds of school-based interventions, to
after school programs and summer sessions.
The 1994 reauthorization (of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act) focused MEP
on the most mobile families, and resulted in more services are now being provided in the
summer and between school sessions. Despite a narrowing of eligibility rules, the number of
participating children has been increasing since the reauthorization, in part because of
�Automated RecOrds Management SysterP
Hex-Dump Conversion
partnerships between MEP and several major agribusiness partners. These partnerships have led
to improved service and coordination by local providers (education, health, public safety, library).
Increased funding would help to address the growing population of children who are
being referred to the program, and to continue to provide a richer array of supplemental
educational services. A $60 million investment is included in the proposal to address Child
Labor issues.
�IV. Administrative Actions and Program Improvements
Based on our review of the Advisory Commission recommendations, other reports, and
our meetings with the constituency groups and the Caucus, the agencies have signed off on a
number of changes to, or enhancements in, current programs to better serve the Hispanic
population. They are described below:
Dropout Prevention:
•
Comprehensive School Reform.
As part of this new $150 million program aimed toward
transforming failing schools, the Education Department will identify model approaches
that show promise in reducing high dropout rates, and that address the needs of
limited-English proficient children. The Department's guidelines to States will encourage
funds to go to schools that need to address a dropout problem.
•
White House Conference on Staying in School. The President and the Administration
Will participate in a conference to share solutions -- lessons from successful efforts to
reduce dropout rates and to provide youth with alternatives to traditional high schools.
•
Clearinghouse on Successful Models for Dropout Prevention. The Education Department,
through is various research centers (and other clearinghouses), has a great deal of
resources relating to dropout prevention. This would provide school and community
leaders with "one-stop shopping" for ideas and information on best practices for keeping
kids in schoo!.
General:
•
Public Service Announcements in Spanish.
Univision has agreed to produce a series of
public service announcements on education, such as encouraging parents to read to their
children at an early age, and telling families about college financial aid.
•
Toll-Free Number and More Information in Spanish. The Education Department is
developing criteria to systematically determine what publications should be translated so
that Spanish-speaking parents have better access to the information. In addition, the
Department will establish a toll-free number that is answered in Spanish (or change the
current number to prompt non-English speaking callers earlier), to ensure that there are
no barriers to parents who want to find out how to better help their children succeed in
schoo!.
�Automated Records Management Systerr
f./ex-Dump Conversion
•
Model High Schools: Working with the National Council of La Raza and ASPIRA, the
Education Department's New American High Schools Initiative will focus attention on
schools that better prepare all students for college and careers.
Four of the ten schools
initially selected have a Hispanic population of 20 percent or more. In addition, the
Department has awarded a two-year contract to improve student preparation at six urban
high schools and to serve as models for other high schools. Three of the six have
substantial Hispanic student participation.
Early Childhood and Parental Involvement
•
Early Head Start: [Checking whether new funding in FY 1998 can be geared toward the
needs of Hispanic community]
•
Head Start: The Bipartisan Balanced Budget includes continued expansion of the
program, toward the goal of serving one million children by 2002. The Department of
Health and Human Services will implement an outreach plan to ensure that programs are
reaching the Hispanic community. As a part of that effort, the Department will identify
and disseminate a "best practices" guide for serving limited-English proficient (LEP)
children.
•
Title I/parent training: Parents who do not speak English well need extra care and support
to gain their active participation in the schooling of their children. The Department of
Education is compiling a set of "best practices" for implementing family literacy and
parent involvement programs. This will include guidelines for working with LEP
parents.
Improving teaching and learning
•
America Reads: The Education Department and Scholastic, Inc., have developed and are
distributing, posters featuring the message "Reading is PowerjLeer es Poder." The back
of the poster provides reproducible reading activities for classroom use. Spanish language
tutoring kits have been developed and will be distributed to Hispanic communities.
LULAC has been an active partner in America Reads effort.
•
Bilingua/(Teacher Training: The Bipartisan Balanced Budget Agreement secures a 27
percent increase for the bilingual education program. As part of that increase, the
Education Department will dedicate $25 million to increase the number of teachers who
are qualified to teach LEP children, and to improve teacher preparation programs so that
�"
Automate~ Reo Management Systerr,
cords
ex- ump Conversion
all teachers can meet the needs of LEP students.
•
Technology. To ensure that all schools take advantage of the funding available through the
$2 billion Technology Literacy Challenge Fund and the discounts of up to 90 percent
(for the poorest schools) that will be available through the FCC's Universal Service Fund,
the Education Department will conduct a series of technical assistance workshops,
including some that are targeted to communities with large populations of Hispanic
students. [Mention VP's leadership of outreach effort?]
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Migrants
•
Technology. The Education Department has awarded six grants, at $15 million over five
years, for projects that apply the use of technology to improve teaching and learning for
migrant children.
•
Coordinated eligibility. The Education Department is exploring the possibility of waiving
eligibility requirements for Migrant Even Start and other education programs so that
children of participants in the Job Training Partnership Act's migrant program (section
402), who have already been judged needy, will be automatically eligible.
Second chance and job training
•
Youth Opportunity Areas:
$250 million has been appropriated for FY 1999, targeted to
the highest poverty areas in the country to help out-of-school youth (age 16-24) become
employable.
(Currently six cities are funded. In NYC, 67 of those served are
Hispanic; in Houston, 65 ; in Los Angeles, 50 .)
•
Bilingual Contextual Learning. The Labor Department is currently evaluating the results
of an innovative approach for training individuals for the burgeoning home health care
field. The Department will broadly disseminate the "lessons learned" from this
expenence.
•
ESL in Job Training.
The Labor Department will include guidance for providing
services to limited-English-proficient populations in JTPA or successor programs.
College opportunity
•
TRIO programs: The Education Department's reauthorization proposal will include
measures designed to make the programs more available in areas that are now
under-served by TRIO, including those with substantial Hispanic populations.
•
Information about college financial aid The largest Spanish language newspaper in the
country, La Opinion, is publishing and distributing a Spanish-language version of the
Education Department's guide, "Getting Ready for College Early." The Department is
seeking out other opportunities to better reach Latino families.
•
Hispanic-Serving Institutions: The Education Department's reauthorization of the Higher
Education Act will include the creation of a new part under Title III for Hispanic-Serving
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Institutions.
Other efforts: The Education Department will release a plan that includes a number of other
items, and improvements in data collection and research relating to Hispanic and LEP students.
V. Views and Recommendations
�Page 1 of3
ARMS Email System
..
'I'
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-DEC-1997 19:03:13.00
SUBJECT:
WOMEN'S MTG
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Claire Gonzales ( CN=Claire Gonzales/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of3
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Maria E. Soto ( CN=Maria E. Soto/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Whitney S. Staley ( CN=Whitney S. Staley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO 1.)
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kim B. Widdess ( CN=Kim B. Widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's meeting Thursday morning at 9:00am in room lOO.
Sorry for the late notice. Thanks.
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Email System
,.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 4-DEC-1997 11:38:46.00
SUBJECT:
Benchmarking meeting
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP[ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn M. Chirwa ( CN=Dawn M. Chirwa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ora Theard ( CN=Ora Theard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Wendy A. Taylor ( CN=Wendy A. Taylor/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Phyllis Kaiser-Dark ( CN=Phyllis Kaiser-Dark/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Benchmarking meeting on Friday, December 5 at 1:00 pm.
am trying to reserve the Ward Room and will send another e-mail to
confirm.
I hope this time works because we're locked into it.
Attendees:
Sylvia Mathews
Chuck Ruff
Janet Yellen
Elena Kagan
Maria Echaveste
Gene Sperling
I
�ARMS Email System
,.
Sally Katzen
Dawn Chirwa
Rob Weiner
Thanks.
Page 2 of2
�ARMS Email System
.
Page 1 of2
~.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 4-DEC-1997 14:47:33.00
SUBJECT:
Benchmarking meeting
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn M. Chirwa ( CN=Dawn M. Chirwa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ora Theard ( CN=Ora Theard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Wendy A. Taylor ( CN=Wendy A. Taylor/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Phyllis Kaiser-Dark ( CN=Phyllis Kaiser-Dark/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The Benchmarking meeting on Friday, December 5 at 1:00 pm will be in Chuck
Ruff's office.
Attendees:
Sylvia Mathews
Chuck Ruff
Janet Yellen
Elena Kagan
�ARMS Email System
Maria Echaveste
Gene Sperling
Sally Katzen
Dawn Chirwa
Rob Weiner
Thanks.
Page 2 of2
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
(.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 5-DEC-1997 11:21:21.00
SUBJECT:
TIME CHANGE: Benchmarking meeting
TO: Richard L. Hayes ( CN=Richard L. Hayes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorothy Robyn ( CN=Dorothy Robyn/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn M. Chirwa ( CN=Dawn M. Chirwa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally Katzen/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ora Theard ( CN=Ora Theard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Wendy A. Taylor ( CN=Wendy A. Taylor/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Phyllis Kaiser-Dark ( CN=Phyllis Kaiser-Dark/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This meeting has been moved to 4:00 pm.
Ruff's office. Sorry for the change.
It will still be held in Chuck
************************************************************************************
�ARMS Email System
..
~
The Benchmarking meeting on Friday, December 5 at 1:00 pm will be in Chuck
Ruff's office.
Attendees:
Sylvia Mathews
Chuck Ruff
Janet Yellen
Elena Kagan
Maria Echaveste
Gene Sperling
Sally Katzen
Dawn Chirwa
Rob Weiner
Thanks.
Page 2 of2
�ARMS Email System
f.
_
Page 1 of5
..
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN;Sean P. Maloney/OU;WHO/O;EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 8-DEC-1997 10:13:15.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to NY/FL
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN;Jonathan Orszag/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN;Jonathan H. Adashek/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN;Daniel Wexler/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN;Dorian V. Weaver/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN;Christopher Wayne/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN;Michael Waldman/OU;WHO/O;EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP' [ WHO 1 )
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN;Peter G. Umhofer/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN;Barry J. Toiv/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN;Marjorie Tarmey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN;Stephanie S. Streett/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN;Darby E. Stott/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN;Craig T. Smith/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN;Joshua Silverman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN;Laura D. Schwartz/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN;Christa Robinson/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN;John Podesta/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN;Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R .. Newman ( CN;Elizabeth R. Newman/OU;WHO/O;EOP
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ :,UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO:, Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 3 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
•
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ BOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO.: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
Page 4 of5
�Page 5 of5
..
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Tuesday evening, December 9, 1997, the President will travel to New
York City to tour the Jewish Heritage Museum and attend a Human Rights Day
reception.
On Wednesday, December 10, the President will tour a South
Bronx neighborhood and attend a DCCC dinner and a DNC Hispanic gala,
before flying to Miami, Florida.
In Miami on Thursday, December 11, the
President will attend a Coast Guard drug seizure event, a lunch for Buddy
Mackay, a DNC gala and a DNC dinner, before returning to the White House.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
DUE MON. DEC. 8 AT 6:00 P.M.
NY & FL Background Memos
Political Memos
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
NY Event Memos
DUE MON. DEC. 8 AT 6:00 P.M.
Human Rights Day Museum Tour and Reception
Charlotte Gardens Neighborhood Tour & Remarks
DCCC Dinner
DNC Hispanic Gala
FL Event Memos
DUE TUE. DEC. 9 AT 10 A.M.
Coast Guard Drug Seizure Event
Buddy Mackay Luncheon
DNC Gala
DNC dinner
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�Page 1 6f2
ARMS Email System
,.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-DEC-1997 14:51:45.00
SUBJECT:
Does anyone know anything more about this "new study"?
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sky Gallegos ( CN=Sky Gallegos/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
I'm trying to track it down.
---------------------- Forwarded by Cynthia A. Rice/OPD/EOP on 12/09/97
02:51 PM ---------------------------
Robin J. Bachman
12/09/97 02:42:44 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Cynthia A. Rice/OPD/EOP
cc:
Subject:
Did you see this?
From today's McCurry briefing:
Q
On welfare, there'S a new study out today that says
that jobs exist for only about half of the displaced welfare workers
and there are protests being planned tomorrow in 50 states. Does the
�ARMS Email System
'. "
President have any plans or ideas to find jobs for these displaced
workers?
MR. MCCURRY: We've been working ceaselessly on that, as
you know.
From the efforts that we've made to encourage a response
by the private sector to the works that we're doing with state
governments to assure that there are services, training, placement
services available -- there's a considerable amount of effort both in
the public sector and the private sector to get the kind of response
we need and we need -- we have an economy, remember, that's now
created almost 14 million jobs in the last five years, so the jobs
are there.
Matching people who we're formerly dependent on welfare
to the job opportunities that exist has to be part of the effort, but
also encouraging private sector employees to take a chance on someone
who has been welfare-dependent has been a major part of the
President's effort.
He's worked on this, done lots of events.
I
think you've all been at some of those events.
Q
Does that mean that he's done everything he can and
it's up to the private sector now?
MR. MCCURRY:
Well, he's has not done everything he can
because he plans to do more and has been doing a great deal to
stimulate that kind of response. We've been working on this I think
-- I don't think anyone can challenge the notion that the President
has devoted a considerable amount of time. to making sure that this
transition that has to occur in our economy away from a model of
dependency through the cycle of welfare that existed prior to reform
-- we'.ve made it clear that we've got to change the whole culture and
the ethic of how employers and those who are welfare-dependent
approach their own responsibilities as we implement welfare reform.
Page 2 of2
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:10-DEC-1997 12:29:07.00
SUBJECT:
CEA Childcare Whitepaper
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Janet asked me to give you a blurb about the CEA Childcare Whitepaper.
The following is a description she signed-off on:
With more mothers en
�ARMS Email System
..
Page 1 of2
I.f
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:10-DEC-1997 16:58:28.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Meeting
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
I'
•
.~.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/0 7 EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:· Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Kim B. Widdess ( CN=Kim B. Widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [.WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Whitney S. Staley ( CN=Whitney S. Staley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Meeting on Thursday at 9:00am in room 100.
Linda Tarr-Whelan will be coming in to brief the group about the Women's
Economic Summit. Thanks.
�;.
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
.,
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 17-DEC-1997 10:17:49.00
SUBJECT:
Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Ston'e/OU=CEA/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel C. Tate ( CN=Daniel C. Tate/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande (CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Melissa M. Murray ( CN=Melissa M. Murray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: weinstein dena
READ: UNKNOWN
weinstein dena @ ustr.gov @ INET @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having the Tobacco Strategy meeting tomorrow, December 18, at
2:45 p.m. in Room 211, OEOB.
This will be the last Tobacco Strategy
meeting for the year.
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
\.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:17-DEC-1997 17:22:39.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Meeting
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kim B. Widdess ( CN=Kim B. Widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Tania I. Lopez ( CN=Tania I. Lopez/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Whitney S. Staley ( CN=Whitney S. Staley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Women's Meeting Thursday at 9:00am in room 100. Thanks.
�Page 1 of6
ARMS Email System
"
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Laura A. Graham ( CN=LauraA. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:22-DEC"1997 16:01:24.00
SUBJECT:
,NYC - TX Trip Meetings
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas D. Janenda ( CN=Thomas D. Janenda/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO:' Kara Gerhardt ( CN=Kara Gerhardt/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Antony J. Blinken ( CN=Antony J. Blinken/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer C. Poole ( CN=Jennifer C. Poole/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James M. Teague ( CN=James M. Teague/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nelson Reyneri ( CN=Nelson Reyneri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan Ryan ( CN=Evan Ryan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of6
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Murchinson ( CN=Jonathan Murchinson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams
READ: UNKNOWN
Turner/OU=WHO/O=~OP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kimberly H Tilley ( CN=Kimberly H Tilley/O=Ovp @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa A. Berg ( CN=Lisa A. Berg/O=Ovp @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ : UNKNOWN
TO: Wendy Hartman ( CN=Wendy Hartman/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Setti D. Warren ( CN=Setti D. Warren/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jaycee A. Pribulsky ( CN=Jaycee A. Pribulsky/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary MorrisonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. MoorejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuirejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. HanlinjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle A. Enger ( CN=Michelle A. EngerjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. EdwardsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael CohenjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip CaplanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey A. Forbes ( CN=Jeffrey A. ForbesjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. WeissmanjOu=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet MurguiajOU=WHojO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael BrainardjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anthony R. Bernal ( CN=Anthony R. BernaljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura S. Marcus ( CN=Laura S. MarcusjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa M. Murray ( CN=Melissa M. MurrayjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorinda A. Salcido ( CN=Dorinda A. SalcidojOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. AndersjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. StreettjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie o. Huffman ( CN=Julie
READ: UNKNOWN
o.
HuffmanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby ShamirjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas J. Band ( CN=Douglas J. Band/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. Malone ( CN=Michael D. Malone/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNI<l><OWN
TO: Brian A. Alcorn ( CN=Brian A. Alcorn/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ansley Jones ( CN=Ansley Jones/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joe Keohan ( CN=Joe Keohan/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 5 of6
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca A. Cameron ( CN=Rebecca A. Cameron/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel to NYC and Texas January 8-9 for political and
official events. The trip meetings/conference calls will be scheduled as
follows.
All meetings will be held in room 188.
I will be out of town
1/23 - 1/29 and will return to the office on 1/30.
If you have any
questions regarding the trip, please page me through signal. Thanks and
Happy Holidays!!!!!
Note:
A conference call number is unavailable at this time, so if
you need to call in, please contact me at x62349 prior to the start of the
meeting and I will conference you in.
Thanks.
January 2
pm
January 5
January 8
- 4
-
7
1:00
NYC-Texas
2:30 pm
Time TBD
NYC-Texas
Texas
�ARMS Email System
,.
Page 6 of6
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[12/03/1997 – 12/22/1997]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 097 - Folder 009
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/483c38855e84a5be72cf8ef3f30fb8ea.pdf
6095d40c3015ebb9f4bac9d05cfcc323
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC-KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 097 - FOLDER -008
[11/10/1997 -12/03/1997]
�Page 1 of3
ARMS Email System
. "
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/.o=EOP [ .oMB 1 )
CREATI.oN DATE/TIME:10-N.oV-1997 11:25:04.00
SUBJECT:
TIME CHANGE: .oMB Director's Review discussions: Mandatories in HHS:ACF/A.oA
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry white/OU=OMB/.o=EOP@E.oP [ .oMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=.oPD/.o=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ananias Blocker III ( CN=Ananias Blocker III/OU=WH.o/O=EOP@E.oP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wayne Upshaw ( CN=Wayne Upshaw/.oU=.oMB/.o=E.oP@EOP [ .oMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert M. Shireman ( CN=Robert M. Shireman/OU=OPD/.o=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=E.oP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/.o=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Weiss ( CN=Jonathan Weiss/.o=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ:UNKN.oWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=.oPD/.o=EOP@E.oP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
T.o: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/.oU=.oPD/.o=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/.oU=OPD/O=EOP@E.oP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/.oU=WH.o/O=E.oP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/.oU=.oPD/O=E.oP@EOP [ .oPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jill M. Pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=.oMB/O=EOP@EOP [ .oMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan .orszag/OU=OPD/O=E.oP@EOP [ .oPD 1 )
READ: UNKN.oWN
TO: Anne H. Lewis ( CN=Anne H. Lewis/.oU=OPD/.o=E.oP@E.oP ,[ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William R. Kincaid ( CN=William R. Kincaid/OU=.oPD/.o=EOP@E.oP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 2 of3
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN;Maria J. Hanratty/OU;CEA/O;EOP@EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Iratha H. Waters ( CN;Iratha H. Waters/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN;Keith J. Fontenot/OU;OMB/O;EOP@EOP [ OMB 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. K?renman ( CN;Sanders D. Korenman/OU;CEA/O;EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN;Barbara Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
UNKNOWN 1 ) (WHO)
TEXT:
RE: MONDAY, NOV. 10TH MEETING / TIME CHANGE:
The OMB Mandatory Spending in HHS/ACF, Ag/FCS, etc.
meeting that was
originally scheduled for today at 5:00p will now be today at 2:00pm, OEOB
RM 260 (original note below) .
please email me if you are NOT able to attend.
thanks.
---------------------- Forwarded by Jill M. Pi,zzuto/OMB/EOP on 11/10/97
11:14 AM ---------------------------
Barry White
11/04/97 05:01:23 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Gene B. Sperling/OPD/EOP@EOP, Bruce N. Reed/OPD/EOP@EOP
cc:
See the distribution list at the bottom of this message
Subject:
OMB Director's Review discussions: Education; Mandatories in
HHS:ACF/AOA; Ag/FCS
These are the last of these, I promise.
This is an invitation to you and
your staffs to sit down with me and my staff to go over the big issues for
the remaining OMB Director's Reviews in my area.
We will do Education, discretionary programs and student aid, on Friday,
November 7th, at 4 pm.
We will do mandatory spending in HHS/ACF, Ag/FCS, and the mUltiple-agency
child care proposals on Monday, November 10th, at 5 pm.
Both meetings will be in 'room 260 OEOB.
Our goal is to be able to reflect fairly your views on the agency
�ARMS Email System
.
.
proposals in these areas, and other options you may have, when we meet
with the Director.
Please inform my secretary, Iratha Waters (ext. 5-6150) of your
availability.
Thanks.
Message Copied
TO: ____________________________________________--------------------FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
Diana Fortuna/OPD/EOP@EOP
Cynthia A. Rice/OPD/EOP@EOP
Emil E. Parker/OPD/EOP@EOP
Barbara Chow/WHO/EOP@EOP
Elena Kagan/OPD/EOP@EOP
Sanders D. Korenman/CEA/EOP@EOP
Jonathan Weiss/OvP@OVP
Keith J. Fontenot/OMB/EOP@EOP
Jennifer L. Klein/OPD/EOP@EOP
Iratha H. Waters/OMB/EOP@EOP
Rebecca M. Blank/CEA/EOP@EOP
Maria J. Hanratty/CEA/EOP@EOP
Michael Cohen/OPD/EOP@EOP
William R. Kincaid/OPD/EOP@EOP
Robert M. Shireman/OPD/EOP@EOP
Anne H. Lewis/OPD/EOP@EOP
Wayne Upshaw/OMB/EOP@EOP
Jonathan Orszag/OPD/EOP@EOP
Ananias Blocker III/WHO/EOP@EOP
Jill M. PizzutO/OMB/EOP@EOP
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 6
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:10-NOV-1997 18:24:56.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to NV/CA/KS/MO
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOwN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S., Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N; Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R.,Baldick!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H.Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian v. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola!OU=CEQ!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell!OU=CEQ!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 40f6
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
•
Page 5 of6
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel
READ: UNKNOWN
K~
Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Friday, November 14, 1997, through Monday, November 17, 1997, the
president will travel to Nevada, California, Kansas, and Missouri.
On
Friday, he will attend a WLF rally and a DNC dinner in Las Vegas.
On
Saturday, he will attend an environmental event and a DNC luncheon in
Sacramento. On Sunday, he will attend a Rock the Vote event and a DNC
dinner in Santa Monica. On Monday, he will attend a welfare-to-work event
in Wichita, deliver the Alf Landon Lecture at Kansas State University, and
attend a DSCC event in St. Louis.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
ALL Background Memos (NV,CA,KS,MO)
DUE THOR, NOV. 13 AT 6:00 PM
Political Memos
Economic 1-Pagers
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
NV & CA Event Memos
DUE THOR, NOV. 13 AT 6:00 PM
WLF Event
DNC Dinner
Environmental Event
DNC Luncheon
Rock the Vote Event
DNC Dinner
KS & MO Event Memos
DUE FRI, NOV. 14 AT 6:00 PM
�Page 6 of6
ARMS Email System
.
"'
...
Welfare to work Event
Alf Landon Lecture
DSCC Dinner
please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
.
Page I of2
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:12-NOV-1997 12:34:09.00
SUBJECT:
Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Stone.( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel C. Tate ( CN=Daniel C. Tate/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith
CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
,
Page 2 of2
.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TEXT:
We will be having our Tobacco Strategy Meeting tomorrow, Thursday,
November 13, at 2;45 p.m. in Room 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
. ,.
Page 1 of3
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:12-NOV-1997 17:58:08:00
SUBJECT:
WOMEN'S MTG
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Claire Gonzales ( CN=Claire Gonzales/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/QU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
.TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
�Page 2 of3
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Maria E. Soto ( CN=Maria E. Soto/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Whitney S. Staley ( CN=Whitney S. Staley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP
@
EOP
[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kim B. Widdess ( CN=Kim B. Widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�ARMS Email System
There will be a Women's Meeting Thursday morning from 9:00a-9:30a in room
100. Thanks.
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 4
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Eric R. Biel ( CN=Eric R. Biel/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:13-NOV-1997 18:47:55.00
SUBJECT:
Fast track to Commerce
TO: DESOUZA P
READ: UNKNOWN
DESOUZA P @ Al @ CD@ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: Jonathan Weiss ( CN=Jonathan Weiss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: kfreiberg ( kfreiberg @ ustr.gov @ INET @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: rnovick ( rnovick @ ustr.gov @ INET @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael W. Williams ( CN=Michael W. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert N. Weiner ( CN=Robert N. Weiner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen Tramontano ( CN=Karen Tramontano/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sonyia Matthews ( CN=Sonyia Matthews/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne H. Lewis ( CN=Anne H. Lewis/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon D. Haveman ( CN=Jon D. Haveman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janelle E. Erickson ( CN=Janelle E. Erickson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
TO: Raymond E. Donnelly III
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nelson W. Cunningham ( CN=Nelson W. Cunningham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lanny A. Breuer ( CN=Lanny A. Breuer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MITSLER_E
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: SCHWARTZ E
READ: UNKNOWN
MITSLER E @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
SCHWARTZ E @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: sesserman ( sesserman @ ustr.gov @ INET @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: LEAVY D
LEAVY D
@
Al
@
CD
@
LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
�Page 3 of4
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lowell A. Weiss ( CN=Lowell A. Weiss/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ : UNKNOWN
TO: David B Sandalow ( CN=David B Sandalow/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP 1 OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Peter O'Keefe ( CN=Peter
READ: UNKNOWN
O'Keefe/O~=WHO/O=EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: R. Scott Michaud ( CN=R. Scott Michaud/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce W. McConnell ( CN=Bruce W. McConnell/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura S. Marcus ( CN=Laura S. Marcus/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Malcolm R. Lee ( CN=Malcolm R. Lee/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD 1. )
TO: Charles Konigsberg ( CN=Charles Konigsberg/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gay L. Joshlyn ( CN=Gay L. Joshlyn/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David T. Johnson ( CN=David T. Johnson/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert F. Housman ( CN=Robert F. Housman/OU=ONDCP/O=EOP @ EOP [ ONDCP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark R. Hopkins ( CN=Mark R. Hopkins/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wendy E. Gray ( CN=Wendy E. Gray/OU=NSC/O=EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
�ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sky Gallegos ( CN;Sky Gallegos/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey A. Forbes ( CN;Jeffrey A. Forbes/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN;Laura Emmett/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anna E. Cushing ( CN;Anna E. Cushing/OU;WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Casella ( CN=Michael Casella/OU;OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU;WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU;CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Antony J. Blinken ( CN;Antony J. Blinken/OU;NSC/O;EOP @ EOP [ NSC 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Victoria Radd ( cN=Victoria Radd/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Eric R. Biel ( CN=Eric R. Biel/OU;WHO/O;EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Although my last official day over here won't be for another week or so
(nothing like easing out slowly), beginning Monday I ' l l be spending the
bulk of my time at the Commerce Dept. -- building on my one week of
experience from late August as Deputy Director of the Office of Policy and
Strategic Planning in the Office of the Secretary.
So now is as good a
time as any to say that, although the result was less than optimal, I have
really enjoyed my almost three months here working on fast track. After
seven years on the Hill and with a Congressionally-created commission,
this has been a great opportunity to get initiated in a hurry into the
Executive Branch.
I look forward to keeping in touch and continuing to
work with many of you -- maybe even on fast track, the continuing saga, in
early 1998.
If you're coming over to DoC, I'll be wandering around the
fifth floor there and can be reached at 482-4127. Best of success with
all of your work.
Page 4 of4
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME:14-NOV-1997 14:26:00.00
SUBJECT:
Briefing
TO: Ann F. Walker
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
)
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
)
CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
)
TO: Richard L. Hayes ( CN=Richard L. Hayes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Beverly J. Barnes ( CN=Beverly J. Barnes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO·]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter Rundlet ( CN=Peter Rundlet/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA ]
)
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Elisabeth Steele ( CN=Elisabeth Steele/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Eleanor S. Parker ( CN=Eleanor S. Parker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Sandra F<. Daigle ( CN=Sandra F. Daigle/OU=CEA/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ CEA 1 )
CC: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Aimee M. Malnati
( CN=Aimee M. Malnati/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Maria E. Soto ( CN=Maria E. Soto/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi
( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett
CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Debra A. Schiff ( CN=Debra A. Schiff/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a briefing from Graham Gregory Bozell (this company is
partly owned by Oprah Winfrey), a minority marketing firm that prepared a
recently released study "The New Multicultural American Dream Index" on
Monday at 3:00pm in the Roosevelt Room.
You are welcome to attend.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1
CREATION DATE/TIME:17-NOV-1997 10:48:55.00
SUBJECT:
CEA Childcare Whitepaper
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Amy N. Finkelstein ( CN=Amy N. Finkelstein/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Since the staff of Sec Rubin's CEO Childcare working group is meeting the
week of Dec 5, we thought CEA could release the CEA Childcare paper that
week. Tenatively, our plan is that Janet Yellen would hold a press
briefing to formally release the paper, and then we'll send it out w/ a
letter from Janet to the CEO's in the Rubin Childcare working group, the
people who attended the WH Childcare Conf, the Board on Children and
Families, the NICD, and others ( any suggestions?). Do you think this
will be a problem? Do you have any other suggestions about timing,
method, etc of release?
Thanks.
Michele
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
[ OPD 1 )
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP
CREATION DATE/TIME: 18-NOV-1997 12:05:09.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Strategy Meeting
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Jonathan Murchinson ( CN=Jonathan Murchinson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. Pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle
READ: UNKNOWN
Crisci/OU=WHO/O~EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having the weekly Welfare Reform Strategy Meeting today at 4:00
p.m. in Room 211.
�ARMS Email System
.
Page 1 of5
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:18-NOV-1997 17:29:34.00
SUBJECT:
The President's trip to CO/WA/BC
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. 'Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of5
ARMS Email System
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. MoranjOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. CostellojOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F·. Walker /OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: simeona F .. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP
@
EO'P [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�.
Page 5 of5
ARMS Email System
..
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO.: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ CEA 1
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Saturday, November 22, 1997, the President will travel to Denver,
Colorado for a DNC luncheon and reception, and to Seattle, Washington for
a dinner with Senator Patty Murray.
The President will then proceed to
Vancouver, British Columbia in preparation for the ASEAN and APEC meetings.
Deadlines for the Colorado/Washington portion of the President's trip book
are as follows:
CO & WA Background Memos
DUE THUR. NOV. 20 AT 6:00PM
political Memos
Economic 1-Pagers
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
CO & WA Event Memos
DUE FRI. NOV. 21 AT 6:00 PM
DNC Luncheon and Reception
Sen. Murray Dinner
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
1'>..
•
Page 1 of3
I._
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO!O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:19-NOV-1997 17:41:48.00
SUBJECT:
WOMEN'S MTG
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Claire Gonzales ( CN=Claire Gonzales/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta
READ: UNKNOWN
w:
Greene!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston!OU=PIR!O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=stacie Spec·tor/OU=WHO!O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�'.
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Maria E. Soto ( CN=Maria E. Soto/OU=PIR/O=EOP.@ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Whitney S. Staley ( CN=Whitney S. Staley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ : UN~OWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kim B. Widdess ( CN=Kim B. widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�'.
ARMS Email System
There will be a Women's Meeting on Thursday morning at 9:00am in Room 100,
Thanks,
Page 3 of3
�h
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of4
•••
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lawrence J. Haas ( CN=Lawrence J. Haas/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 19-NOV-1997 18:03:20.00
SUBJECT:
Line-item veto briefing
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John H. Gibbons ( CN=John H. Gibbons/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ,( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
TO: Doris O. Matsui ( CN=Doris O. Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
, READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVp@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
[ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Foster ( CN=Jonathan Foster/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: LynnG. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal ( CN=Fred DuVal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP ["CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. MCCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Bell ( CN=Robert S. Bell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Susanne Bachtel ( CN=Susanne Bachtel/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
"CC: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�.
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisabeth Steele ( CN=Elisabeth Steele/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
OMB will brief the senior White House staff on Thursday, November 20, at
9:30 a.m. in the Roosevelt Room, about line-item veto announcements for
that day on the Interior and Agriculture appropriations bills. As per our
Page 3 of4
�.,
.
ARMS Email System
,
established process, White House offices will need to work with White
House legislative affairs on the question of when you can inform your
constituencies about the President's decisions.
Page 4 of4
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:21-NOV-1997 18:47:11.00
SUBJECT:
The Evidence on effects of Head Start quality investments
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ :. UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Leslie S. Mustain ( CN=Leslie S. Mustain/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Amy N. Finkelstein
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Amy N. Finkelstein/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
CC: Edwin Lau ( CN=Edwin Lau/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Wayne Upshaw ( CN=Wayne Upshaw/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
CC: Janet Himler ( CN=Janet Himler/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
CC: Jennifer Friedman ( CN=Jennifer Friedman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Following the last Deputies meeting, in response to HHS' statement that
they have evidence of the positive effect of the Head Start quality
investments on Head Start quality, I asked my staff to obtain from HHS the
evidence to which HHS referred.
HHS did not have a document to share, but
did hold a lengthy conference call with my examiners. This is a report of
that call.
In sum, HHS does not have data demonstrating that the investments in
"quality" and the related COLAs since the law was revised in 1994 have
�ARMS Email System
f.
••
resulted in a higher quality program.
What they do have is the first round of findings from an evaluation
("FACES" -- Family and Child Experiences Survey), which provides some
indication that Head Start projects are of "minimal to good quality."
(They did not find any "inadequate" programs.)
The programs were evaluated on the "ECERS" (Early Childhood Environmental
Rating Scale): it measures the use of materials, scheduling, facilities,
interaction between teachers/staff and children.
This is a tool in
general use for assessing child care centers. Eventually this
longitudinal study will report on the children's experiences in
kindergarten.
OMB is insisting that HHS carry the study into lower grades to try to get
a handle on whether Head Start affects learning in school, but HHS is
resisting strongly. We aren't sure why.
They do not have data showing a causal relationship between quality and
investments in quality, because they did not establish baseline data for
the evaluation or from the period before the new law.
The contractors (Westat and Abt) will eventually try to find a correlation
between quality and the higher salaries and benefits, more education for
staff, length of teacher time in the programs. HHS had not planned to do
this any time soon, but given the OMB (and working group) interest, HHS
will now try to produce this data in the next few months.
They did find some correlation (not clear how strong) between new teachers
and quality program, vs. the quality of programs with longer tenured
teachers.
This suggests that newly trained teachers may have a greater
benefit for students.
This provides some preliminary support for our new teacher preparation
scholarship.
In the conversation, it came up that since 1992, average Head Start
salaries have increased from $10,000 to $17,000, an increase of 70%.
The
Head Start Director asserts, however, that this salary level is a "moral
disgrace."
This report does not provide a ringing endorsement for spending more money
on child care in the same ways in which it is spent in Head Start if, in
fact, we want to do something serious about improving the quality of child
care.
It also isn't much support for Head Start's set-asides.
OMB staff would much prefer investing in directed State monitoring of
health and safety conditions, State publication of "report cards" on child
care center quality, giving the States money to help centers meet
accreditation standards by the national body (NAEYC), and otherwise
supporting specific activities to correct flaws found by the' monitoring.
$50 m/year, $250 mover 5, might be sufficient to get States to engage
more aggressively in such activity.
Page 2 of2
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of7
-.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Peter R. orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME:25-NOV-1997 21:24:40.00
SUBJECT:
Handout for tomorrow's 11:30 POTUS meeting
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAVID. WILCOX ( DAVID. WILCOX
. READ: UNKNOWN
@
MS01.DO.treas.sprint.com
@
INET
@
LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alan.Cohen ( Alan.Cohen
READ: UNKNOWN
@
MS01.DO.treas.sprint.com
@
INET
@
LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN]
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. Blickstein ( CN=Jill M. Blickstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This draft incorporates the comments from tonight's meeting.
If you have
any further corrections or comments, please let me know by 9:30 tomorrow
morning.
Thanks.==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D78]MAIL400577824.316 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
)
�Automated ReCOrds Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
Social Security and the Unified Budget Surplus
November 26,1997
Overview
Proiectedbd
a
i
u t~et blance, $bUion
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
Trust funds
115
123
131
138
153
161
172
Non-trust funds
-122
-60
-69
-55
-46
-25
-5
Unified budget
-7
63
62
83
109
136
167
Source: OMB, Mld·SesslOn ReView cycle
•
Unified surplus projected for 2002 to 2026. Between 2002 and 2007, unified surplus is
"working man" surplus. In 2008, non-trust component of budget shifts to surplus.
•
The surpluses raise national saving, which helps to raise productivity in the future and
therefore ease the bur~en on future workers imposed by demographic trends.
Options
1.
Bolster the Social Security Trust Fund
A)
Alternatives:
•
•
B)
Purchase Treasury securities
-- Has same economic effects as retiring government debt
-- Would extend the life ofthe Trust Fund
-- Under current scoring rules, leaves surplus on the books
Purchase private securities
-- Would extend the life of the Trust Fund significantly
-- Market risks and "social" investing concerns
-- Would eliminate the surplus
Key issues
•
Whether elite leaders would view as increase in national saving, or as. accounting
maneuver.
•
Could emphasize down-payment, not complete solution. Present plan (e.g.,
commission or high-level group to report by January 1999) for effecting other
steps.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
2: Fund individual retirement accounts
This option would use the unified surplus to fund a set of mandatory individual retirement
accounts. If creating private accounts does not affect individuals' behavior any differently than
bolstering Social Security, the effect on national saving would be the same as above -- but private
saving would be higher and public saving would be lower.
A)
Key elements:
•
•
B)
Funding tied to surplus
Progressive as possible -- progressive match or system not linked to wages. For
example: 1 percent of wages, plus lump sum per person depending on size of
surplus (e.g., 1 percent of wages, plus $500 per person).
Policy issues:
•
•
Market risk: Risk borne by individuals, not shared by society as a whole
•
Pressures that could reduce national saving:
-- Withdraw early for special needs?
-- For employers to reduce pensions?
•
Pressure to reduce future role of government
•
Support for Social Security: Will private accounts undermine support for S.S.?
•
C)
Administrative costs
Government involvement: Should some government entity manage the accounts,
as under Thrift Savings Plan?
Political issues
•
•
D)
Will approach be seen as partial privatization and split Democrats?
How closely should the approach be tied to "Social Security"? Separation could
reduce problem for Dems. But Social Security "problem" then remains.
Allow withdrawals for layoffs
•
Could define a new type of social security
•
Pressure to be expanded for medical care, home purchases, etc.
�3. Social Security and retirement needs exclusively
Automated Records Management System
. Hex·Dump Conversion
A)
100 percent of surplus for Social Security Trust Fund, but leave open Treasury versus
private securities. 100 percent of surplus as down-payment on Social Security, with
commission or bipartisan process to decide split between Treasury securities and private
securities. Could be linked with broader Social Security reform effort, with reporting
date by January 1999.
B)
Leave split between Trust Fund and individual accounts undecided at this point. Declare
that 100 percent of the SUrplus would be used for helping to address demographic and
retirement challenges, but leave split between Trust Fund and individual accounts to be
decided by commission or bipartisan process.
C)
50 percent Social Security, 50 percent individual accounts. Specify now that 50 percent
of the SUrplus would be used for the Trust Fund, and 50 percent for individual accounts.
Decide now or later the details of both.
4. Mix Social Security with other priorities
Another approach would be to expand the potential uses of the surplus beyond Social
Security and retirement. The advantage of such a broader approach is that it allows us to
address other priorities; the cost is that it blurs the message.
Illustrative example: One illustrative example would be to use 50 percent of the surplus for the
Social Security Trust Fund, 25 percent for tax reform (which could include individual accounts),
and 25 percent for an Investment in the Future fund.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 1-DEC-1997 10:29:03.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Strategy Meeting
TO: Andrea Kane ( CN=Andrea Kane/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP .[ OPD 1 )
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: 'Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
OVP
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Murchinson ( CN=Jonathan Murchinson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn B. Stack ( CN=Kathryn B. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN~Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 ).
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
ce: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: uNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having the weekly Welfare Reform Strategy Meeting tomorrow,
December 2, at 4:00 p.m. in Room 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of5
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 1-DEC-1997 12:26:27.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to OH & IL
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 }
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry·J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa
READ: UNKNOWN
Robinson/OU=OP~/O=EOP @
EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III
( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 30[5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @'EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ:UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann.F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UN.KNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J.
READ: UNKNOWN
Mayock/OU=WHO/O~EOP
@ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 5 of5
ARMS Email System
.
.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Wednesday, December 3, 1997, the President will travel to Akron, Ohio
to attend a Race Initiative town meeting.
He will then proceed to
Chicago, Illinois to attend DCCC and DNC dinners.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
OH & IL Background Memos
DUE TUE. DEC. 2 AT 6:00 PM
Political Memos
Economic I-Pagers
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
OH & IL Event Memos
DUE TUE. DEC. 2 AT 6:00 PM
Town Meeting
DCCC Dinner
DNC Dinner
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 4
- I'
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lawrence J. Haas ( CN=Lawrence J. Haas/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 1-DEC-1997 12:48:59.00
SUBJECT:
Line-item veto for today
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John H. Gibbons ( CN=John H. Gibbons/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
TO: Doris o. Matsui ( CN=Doris o. Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 j
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore
CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
,.
Page 2 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Foster ( CN=Jonathan Foster/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hi~ley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal ( CN=Fred DuVal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Bell ( CN=Robert S. Bell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Susanne Bachtel ( CN=Susanne Bachtel/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 3 of4
ARMS Email System
i-
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jordan Tamagni
( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO
1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisabeth Steele ( CN=Elisabeth Steele/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=Ovp@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci
( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will announce his final line-item vetoes later
today, in a paper release through the White House press office.
To give
everyone a quick heads-up, I've arranged a conference call for 1:30 p.m.
�. ..
ARMS Email System
You can call in at 7-2104, code #2460. We will begin promptly, so please
be on time if you're interested.
I'd be surprised if this took more than
5 minutes. And that will be it for the year on line-item veto.
By the way, we've got a limited number of slots on the call.
If
we get the same people who've been attended the Roosevelt Room briefings,
we'll be fine.
But please don't get on unless you're really interested.
Thanks.
Page 4 of4
�Page 1 of6
ARMS Email System
(...
-
{,
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: l-DEC-1997 14:40:13.00
SUBJECT:
CORRECTION -- TIME CHANGE: Daily SENIOR STAFF MEETINGS
TO: Sidney Blumenthal
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [WHO 1 )
TO: Wendy Hartman ( CN=Wendy Hartman/O=Ovp @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ana M. Duque ( CN=Ana M. Duque/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patricia A. McHugh ( CN=Patricia A. McHugh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Amy W. Tobe ( CN=Amy W. Tobe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen K. Horn ( CN=Stephen K. Horn/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of6
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Scott R. Hynes ( CN=Scott R. Hynes/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Victoria Radd ( CN=Victoria Radd/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christine K. Baer ( CN=Christine K. Baer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brooks E. Scoville ( CN=Brooks E. Scoville/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ansley jones ( CN=ansley jones/O=ovp @ ovp
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: kimberly h tilley ( CN=kimberly h tilleyjO=ovp @ ovp [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: debbie b bengtson ( CN=debbie b bengtsonjO=ovp @ ovp [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: mchugh_l ( mchugh_l @ al @ cd @ lngtwy [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: kerrick d
READ: UNKNOWN
kerrick d @ al @ cd @ lngtwy [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Elisabeth Steele
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan Ryan
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
CN=Elisabeth SteelejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CN=Evan RyanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Cheryl D. Mills ( CN=Cheryl D. MillsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ora Theard ( CN=Ora TheardjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. LewisjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca A. Cameron ( CN=Rebecca A. CameronjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. ClevelandjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eleanor S. Parker ( CN=Eleanor S. ParkerjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. LovelljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patricia Solis-Doyle ( CN=Patricia Solis-DoylejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: elisabeth s. steele ( CN=elisabeth s. steelejO=ovp @ ovp [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey A. Forbes ( CN=Jeffrey A. ForbesjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly IIIjOU 7 WHOjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: millison c
READ: UNKNOWN
millison c @ al @ cd @ lngtwy [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: ron klain ( CN=ron klainjO=ovp @ ovp [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria EchavestejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
[ WHO 1
�Page 4 of6
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
)
TO: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO.]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Heather M. Marabeti
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Heather M. Marabeti/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
TO: Lisa A. Berg ( CN=Lisa A. Berg/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joel Velasco ( CN=Joel velasco/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
)
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason ( CN=Julie E. Mason/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Miriam H. Vogel ( CN=Miriam H. Vogel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Jill M. Blickstein ( CN=Jill M. Blickstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Harrington ( CN=Elizabeth Harrington/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Jeffrey M. Smith ( CN=Jeffrey M. Smith/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
)
)
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Michael waldman/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
TO: Michael Waldman (
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Douglas
TO: Alice H. Williams (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Alice
CN~Robert
TO: Robert S. Kapla (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Laura
TO: Laura K. Capps (
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison (
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
Williams/OU~CEA/O~EOP @
EOP [ CEA 1 )
B.
H.
Sosnik/OU~WHO/O~EOP
Kapla/OU~CEQ/O~EOP @
S.
Capps/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
K.
CN~Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O~EOP @
TO: June G. Turner (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~June
G.
Turner/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
CN~Virginia Apuzzo/OU~WHO/O~EOP
TO: Jonathan Foster (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Jonathan
@
a1
EOP [ CEQ 1 )
EOP [ WHO 1 )
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Virginia Apuzzo (
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: sperling_g ( sperling_g
READ: UNKNOWN
EOP [ WHO 1 )
EOP [ WHO 1 )
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
Foster/OU~OSTP/O~EOP @
@
cd
@
EOP [ OSTP 1 )
lngtwy [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
TO: Phillip Caplan (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Phillip Caplan/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Nelson Reyneri (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Nelson Reyneri/OU~WHO/O~EOP
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Paul E. Begala (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Paul
Begala/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal (
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN~Dan
CN~John
TO: Stephanie S. Streett (
READ: UNKNOWN
E.
K.
L.
Rosenthal/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
Hilley/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
CN~Stephanie
S.
EOP [ WHO 1 )
EOP [ WHO 1 )
Streett/OU~WHO/O~EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TEXT:
1.
The Daily 7:45 a.m. Senior Staff Meeting has been moved to 8:00 a.m.
every day.
2.
The weekly 8:30 a.m. Deputies Meeting on Mondays, has been moved
back to 8:45 a.m.
Please spread the word, as appropriate.
�ARMS Email System
Thanks.
Jason
Thanks.
Jason
Page 6 of6
�..
Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-DEC-1997 11:17:10.00
SUBJECT:
Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA'l
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel C. Tate ( CN=Daniel C. Tate/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
,'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa M. Murray ( CN=Melissa M. Murray/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Jill M. Pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: weinstein dena
READ: UNKNOWN
weinstein dena @ ustr.gov @ INET @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Peter A. Weissman ( CN=Peter A. Weissman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having the Tobacco Strategy Meeting tomorrow, December 4, at
2:45 p.m. in Room 211, OEOB.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[11/10/1997 – 12/03/1997]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 097 - Folder 008
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/12889d9a454832eadda58206dcf2ca5e.pdf
c4ca976c926bda4cd84f774cb2f018c5
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 097 - FOLDER -007
[10/14/1997-11/05/1997]
�'.
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lawrence J. Haas ( CN=Lawrence J. Haas/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:14-0CT-1997 09:27:52.00
SUBJECT:
IMPORTANT -- Heads up on line-item veto
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: FOLEY M@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
FOLEY M@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Doris o. Matsui ( CN=Doris
READ: UNKNOWN
o.
(WHO)
Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 2 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal ( CN=Fred DuVal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Bell ( CN=Robert S. Bell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Apologies.
9:30 a.m.
In case you don't already know, the meeting has been moved to
---------------------- Forwarded by Lawrence J. Haas/OMB/EOP on 10/14/97
09:18 AM ---------------------------
Lawrence J. Haas
10/13/97 06:03:08 PM
Record
Record Type:
To:
See the distribution list at the bottom of this message
Page 3 of5
�ARMS Email System
cc:
See the distribution list at the bottom of this message
Subject:
IMPORTANT -- Heads up on line-item veto
Although this is NOT yet public information, the White House plans to
announce on Tuesday, October 14, that the President has used his line-item
veto authority on the Defense appropriations bill.
To help you explain the President's decision to your constituencies, OMB's
Jack Lew and Gordon Adams will hold a briefing on Tuesday morning, 9 a.m.,
in the Roosevelt Room, to outline the particulars.
We hope you find the briefing useful. We are trying to respond to the
concerns that many of you raised about having a sufficient heads-up and
understanding beforehand, so you can better do your own thing.
Please let me know whether you think we've left anyone off this list.
Message Sent
TO: __________~--~------------------------------------------------John podestajWHOjEOP@EOP
Sylvia M. MathewsjWHOjEOP@EOP
Robert S. BelljOMBjEOP@EOP
Rahm I. EmanueljWHOjEOP@EOP
Paul E. BegalajwHOjEOP@EOP
Gene B. SperlingjOPDjEOP@EOP
Michael D. McCurryjWHOjEOP@EOP
Barry J. ToivjWHOjEOP@EOP
Joseph P. LockhartjWHOjEOP@EOP
Ron KlainjOVP@OVP
Janet L. YellenjCEAjEOP@EOP
Michele JolinjCEAjEOP@EOP
Michael WaldmanjWHOjEOP@EOP
Ann F. Lewis/WHOjEOP@EOP
Sidney BlumenthaljWHOjEOP@EOP
Mickey IbarrajWHOjEOP@EOP
Fred DuValjWHOjEOP@EOP
Emily BrombergjWHOjEOP@EOP
Lynn G. CutlerjWHO/EOP@EOP
Maria EchavestejWHOjEOP@EOP
Robert B. JohnsonjWHOjEOP@EOP
Doris O. MatsuijWHOjEOP@EOP
John L. HilleyjwHOjEOP@EOP
FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
Barbara ChowjWHOjEOP@EOP
Thurgood Marshall Jr/WHOjEOP@EOP
Stephen B. SilvermanjWHOjEOP@EOP
Bruce N. ReedjOPDjEOP@EOP
Elena KaganjOPDjEOP@EOP
Craig T. SmithjwHOjEOP@EOP
Minyan MoorejWHOjEOP@EOP
Karen E. SkeltonjWHO/EOP@EOP
Message Copied
TO: __~__~~~__~__~~~~~________--________________________
Jason S. GoldbergjWHO/EOP@EOP
Carole A. ParmeleejWHOjEOP@EOP
Sara M. LathamjWHOjEOP@EOP
June G. TurnerjWHOjEOP@EOP
Page 4 of5
�ARMS Email System
Michelle Crisci/WHO/EOP@EOP
Russell W. Horwitz/OPD/EOP@EOP
Lori L. Anderson/WHO/EOP@EOP
Elizabeth R. Newman/WHO/EOP@EOP
Debbie B Bengtson/OVP@OVP
Jordan Tamagni/WHO/EOP@EOP
Laura K. Capps/WHO/EOP@EOP
Kevin S. Moran/WHO/EOP@EOP
Suzanne Dale/WHO/EOP@EOP
Elisa Millsap/WHO/EOP@EOP
Stacey L. Rubin/WHO/EOP@EOP
Kris M Balderston/WHO/EOP@EOP
Anne E. McGuire/WHO/EOP@EOP
David S. Beaubaire/WHO/EOP@EOP
Angelique Pirozzi/WHO/EOP@EOP
Marjorie Tarmey/WHO/EOP@EOP
Page S ofS
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
..
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 15-0CT-1997 16:55:02.00
SUBJECT:
Discussion of Dept. of Labor Budget issues for the OMB Director's Review
TO: Jonathan Weiss ( CN=Jonathan Weiss/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ananias Blocker III ( CN=Ananias Blocker III/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne H. Lewis ( CN=Anne H. Lewis/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
OPD 1 )
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara
READ: UNKNOWN
Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP@~OP
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Iratha H. Waters ( CN=Iratha H. Waters/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 }
CC: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
In the absence of a PAD, I invite you to sit down with me and Larry
Matlack to go over the issues to be presented to the Director in the Labor
Director's Review for the FY 1999 Budget.
This will be your opportunity
�ARMS Email System
.~
to hear how we are thinking about the issues and to influence that
thinking by sharing your advice and counsel, which we will reflect in our
materials for the Director (even if, perchance, we don't agree with you).
At the session, we will show you the Department's request in total and for
"major items, compared to recent budget history, to the current estimate of
the outcome of the FY 1998 appropriation, and to the OMB Planning
Guidance. We will also want to hear your views on some issues on the
mandatory side, especially UI and perhaps TAA.
You will also, of course,
be free to raise any DOL issues not on our list that you believe should be.
Given the timing for preparation of the Director's Review materials, we
need to do this sometime Friday afternoon, preferably around 3 pm. We
will use Ken's old office, 260 OEOB.
Please contact Iratha Waters in my office bye-mail or phone (5-6150) to
confirm your attendance.
If enough people need a later or a bit earlier
time that afternoon, we can do that as well.
If I have missed anyone in the White House staffs with an interest in
Labor budget issues, our apologies; please share this invitation with them
and let me know of their interest.
For those with interests in other agencies in my Division, rest assured, I
will offer the same opportunities before those Review materials are
completed.
Page 2 of2
�ARMS
-. Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN;Cathy R. Mays/OU;OPD/O;EOP
[ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 16-0CT-1997 15:51:40.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Tobacco Strategy Meetings
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN;Charles F. Stone/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN;Joshua Gotbaum/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN;Sherman G. Boone/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN;Gene B. Sperling/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul R. Carey ( CN;Paul R. Carey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN;Barry J. Toiv/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN;Barbara D. Woolley/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN;Donald H. Gips/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN;Jeanne Lambrew/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN;Thomas L. Freedman/OU;OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN;Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN;Peter R. Orszag/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN;Daniel K. Tarullo/OU;OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU;WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel C. Tate ( CN;Daniel C. Tate/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN;Emily Bromberg/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN;Toby Donenfeld/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN;Jerold R. Mande/OU;OSTP/O;EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
[ OPD 1
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will NOT be having a Tobacco Strategy Meeting next week. Our next
meeting will be on Thursday, October 30, at 2:45 in Room 211, OEOB.
These
meetings will now be held EVERY OTHER THURSDAY.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of3
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lawrence J. Haas ( CN=Lawrence J. Haas/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 16-0CT-1997 17:09:30.00
SUBJECT:
OMB briefing on Energy and Water line-item veto
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Doris O. Matsui
READ: UNKNOWN
FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
( CN=Doris O. Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [.WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Fred DuVal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. MCCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Bell ( CN=Robert S. Bell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
. CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This is not public information, but -- the President plans to use his
line-item veto'authority on the Energy and Water appropriations bill on
Friday, October 17, probably in the early afternoon.
Back by popular demand, OMB will hold a briefing for senior White House
staff on the items in question on Friday, at 9:30 a.m. in the Roosevelt
Room. T.J. Glauthier, OMB's "PAD" in this area, will probably lead the
briefing -- although Frank Raines will be there if he can.
This is your
opportunity to learn what the President is doing, so you can give an
appropriate heads-up to your constituency.
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ronald E. Jones ( CN=Ronald E. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-0CT-1997 16:37:56.00
SUBJECT:
Justice Letter on HR 2292, IRS Improvements Act
TO: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce W. McConnell ( CN=Bruce W. McConnell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Raymond P. Kogut ( CN=Raymond P. Kogut/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Maya A. Bernstein ( CN=Maya A. Bernstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Turco ( CN=Kathleen M. Turco/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: James C. Murr ( CN=James C. Murr/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: G. E. DeSeve ( CN=G. E. DeSeve/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert G. Damus ( CN=Robert G. Damus/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas A. Kalil ( CN=Thomas A. Kalil/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Louisa Koch ( CN=Louisa Koch/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Glenn R. Schlarman ( CN=Glenn R. Schlarman/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alexander T. Hunt ( CN=Alexander T. Hunt/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary C. Barth ( CN=Mary C. Barth/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas P. Stack ( CN=Thomas P. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Harry G. Meyers ( CN=Harry G .. Meyers/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Randolph M. Lyon ( CN=Randolph M. Lyon/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher D. Carroll ( CN=Christopher D. Carroll/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice E. Shuffield ( CN=Alice E. Shuffield/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph J. Minarik ( CN=Joseph J. Minarik/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jim Kohlenberger ( CN=Jim Kohlenberger/O=OVP@Ovp
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1
TO: Ananias Blocker III ( CN=Ananias Blocker III/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: James J. Jukes ( CN=James J. Jukes/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
A revised version of the DOJ letter that was circulated as LRM REJ289 on
Thursday, 10/16 is being distributed/faxed at this time. DOJ would like
clearance by early tomorrow AM.
�,
~
Page 1 of5
ARMS Email System
,.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME:23-0CT-1997 19:47:07.00
SUBJECT:
The President's trip to Chicago
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ:UNKNOWN
)
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
)
)
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD·]
)
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber /OU=CEA/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
)
EOP· [ CEA]
)
)
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
)
)
)
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison (CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M.
READ: UNKNOWN
Latham/OU~WHO/O=EOP @
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP .[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 4 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO:" Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN=Julia R. Green/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Monday, October 27, 1997, the President will travel to Chicago,
Illinois to attend the First Lady'S birthday celebration. On Tuesday, he
will attend an education event before returning to Washington.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
Illinois Background Memos:
DUE SUNDAY, OCT. 26 AT 3:00 PM
Political Memo
Economic I-Pager
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
Illinois Event Memos:
DUE SUNDAY, OCT 26 AT 3:00 PM
Birthday Party
Education Event
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
...
Page 1 of 6
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Beverly J. Barnes ( CN=Beverly J. Barnes/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:23-0CT-1997 18:15:55.00
SUBJECT:
Draft Talking Points on Race Initiative
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn M. Chirwa ( CN=Dawn M. Chirwa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nelson Reyneri ( CN=Nelson Reyneri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Demond T. Martin ( CN=Demond T. Martin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lin Liu ( CN=Lin Liu/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Claire Gonzales ( CN=Claire Gonzales/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter Rundlet ( CN=Peter Rundlet/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�A~S
Page 2 of6
Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Robert Wexler ( CN=Robert Wexler/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael J. Sorrell ( CN=Michael J. Sorrell/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Maria A. Westfried ( CN=Maria A. Westfried/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
In the meeting today, Sylvia asked everyone to review the talking points
and let give us their feedback.
Please call or email me with your
changes.
Thanks for your time.
bb==~================= ATTACHMENT
1 =============
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D36]MAIL43100759T.216 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504370040000010A02010000000205000000A4210000000200005FC378COOAB3EAD264827A
OF675A07F1F1260D5008CB6798EA62C32C43F214C4ACC7D31EB2127291FF1789D8A338EC864659
BB8B74F4D0230CBAB2489471AF14AF1105E22FA8DBC373907F9433FACBD3DAB0674DA8BA4016F1
CCEA257828142623FA98C30F363EED9FE91E5A239D47A6F98482148CC053FE295EE02AB1761E2C
746BFE48712E2106D441995E9ABOCA44E55638321E61EAD3873DB4916285241F5A845903E6041E
E19BC4A207A67C8C21FFA58D5C07A7855730F87569CF3ABE16A1CAE8ABBC83BOC4C61410D35986
A584DA80A2C85E29A7D64FA0450697E1F814AA99553D4E5DCD895AA3C2890232EOA2695A3AACE4
C3E580A5A2ADA152909496B07BBD9532BFBB40F6F2BAl15E2F1E6213DA900A93785574A1F48CFF
1957CC9A9C915A7F2381B7A7912D1383D6EF6452577C11C92F5E83B69106BF4B606EC81E5E8C23
DEDD496CCAE1E6E37F3A1BDC4FA470B81353C65C90041130AFB217182886BA956AC2B36560718F
D5EB5487F081D3CEA65714944CA62F1FF21FCE56F823E098B757652E6F3EEAC54F128A3EC85C55
7C1056F6E1D8F1E6F04458612A377C4C41DE188D3650960241D2277B58E836FEE9FE3FEA420EEB
FF3FA7F6986BA9BA3C3067D8DDE9CAAD467156D11CDC75E4FFA898BF51B2DEC6B951880CCE2137
A582D8DAA402000900000000000000000000000823010000000B0100007E02000000550FOOOOOO
4E0000008903000009250100000006000000D70300000B300200000028000000DD030000087701
000000400000000504000008340100000014000000450400000802010000000F00000059040000
080501000000080000006804000000985C005C004F0041005F0038005C005C005C005700450053
0054005F00570049004E0047005C003100360034005F0041005FOO480050003400000000000000
00000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800C8002C012C012C012C01C800
C80030000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
�AutomatedR
Il eCOrds Man
eX-Dump Convers(onnt S"s' .
agef!7e I' ,em
DRAFT
One America:
The President's Initiative on Race
Direction
The President has used several recent national addresses to call attention to his Initiative on
Race. Those occasions include his remarks to the US Conference of Mayors, the AFL-CIO, the
NAACP, and the anniversary of the integration of Little Rock High School.
.
We know it's going to be hard, and we know we have to do it together. But it is a solemn duty we
owe to our young people.
We have to join hands with all of our children to walk into this era, with excellence in education,
with real economic opportunity, with an unshakable commitment to one America that leaves no
one behind .... the most important thing is I'm an American. I'm bound together. I'm part of this
country. I believe in the Constitution and the Bill of Rights. I have an equal chance.
And we know we have to do certain things that are government policy, but we also know that this
is an affair of the mind and the heart, as well. -- from President's NAACP speech
Advisory Board members have recommended to the President that the work of the Initiative
be focused first and foremost on education and economic opportunity. Furthermore, the
board recommended the Initiative pay special attention to America's youth.
Study
At its meeting in September, Advisory Board members heard from experts on demographic
trends, on the gap in public perception about the status of minorities in America and best
methods for promoting discussions that bring people of different races together.
Governor Thomas Kean is working with the Carnegie Corporation on its effort to fund
research into interracial and interethnic youth relations, as part of the board's challenge to
make the Initiative relevant to America's youth.
Dialogue
In his effort to encourage a national dialogue on the issue of race, over the summer the President
met at the White House with white ethnic leaders as well as leaders from national civil
rights organizations.
Advisory Board members have undertaken both individual and group efforts to help the
President stimulate a nation-wide dialogue. The activities in which several members have
participated include:
•
A conversation sponsored by the National Conference that originated in Little Rock, on
the occasion of the 40th Anniversary of Little Rock High School, and was linked by
satellite to several cities around the country -- in September; and
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
•
The American Council on Education's conference of 1500 educators, during which board
members joined with ACE and the Association of American Colleges and Universities in
calling for educators to sponsor special projects on race and inclusiveness at college
campuses around the country .. in October.
In October, Executive Director Judy Winston participated in the conference of Associated Press
Managing Editors, in which she called on the media to be a resource in fostering racial
harmony and to close the racial divide in their own workplaces.
In November, the President will use a White House conference to bring individuals of diverse
backgrounds, from around the country, together to plan ways to end hate crimes.
December's Presidential Town Hall will provide an opportunity for President Clinton to ta~
directly with Americans in the Midwest and across the country about the importance of
uniting across racial and ethnic lines to build one America for the 21 st century.
Also in December (??), Advisory Board members (71) will announce the first group of leaders
who have committed to conduct three activities during 1998 that are designed to increase
the understanding and respect for differences among people of different backgrounds.
Solutions/Action
Following the Advisory Board's recommendation that the work of the initiative concentrate on
education and economics, the President in July called for a new, national effort to attract.
quality teachers to high-poverty communities by offering scholarships for those who will
commit to teach in such communities for three years.
Addressing both the economics of where people can afford to live as well as the educational
concern of which schools their children attend, the President in September directed the
Department of Housing and Urban Development literally to double its efforts to fight
housing discrimination. HUD will issue $15 million in grants to help almost 70 private,
non-profit housing groups investigate housing discrimination, provide counseling on home
buying and promote fair housing.
Continuing to concentrate on improving economic opportunity, in October SBA Administrator
Aida Alvarez set a goal of $2.5 billion in new lending to Hispanic-owned businesses over the
next three years. The SBA will rely on established Hispanic businesses and civic groups, as
well as on Spanish-language materials to help attract small Hispanic business owners or potential
business owners to SBA's programs.
In (November or December), the Race Initiative will start disseminating, through its web site and
numerous other channels, the first set of practices which have been shown to foster racial
harmony in individual communities. Advisory board members, Cabinet Secretaries, other
Administration officials and local leaders will highlight these practices as steps that can form the
foundation for activities in communities across the country.
�'.
A~S
Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-0CT-1997 14:43:36.00
SUBJECT:
Weeky Strategy Meeting
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana
READ: UNKNOWN
Fortuna/OU=OPD/O~EOP @
EOP [ OPD ]
)
)
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Jonathan Murchinson ( CN=Jonathan Murchinson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Kathryn B. Stack ( CN=Kathryn B. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
)
�Page 2 of2
'., AR¥.S Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. Pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. PizzutojOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lisa J. Levin ( CN=Lisa J. Levin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO -]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having our weekly Welfare Strategy Meeting TODAY at 4:00 pm in
Room 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Sharnir ( CN=Ruby Sharnir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-0CT-1997 18:59:56.00
SUBJECT:
CHANGE-Women's Mtg
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Claire Gonzales ( CN=Claire Gonzales/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
.
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman· ( CN=Sandra Thurrnan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
OPD 1 )
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�'.
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Maria E. Soto ( CN=Maria E. Soto/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Whitney S. Staley ( CN=Whitney S. Staley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kim B. Widdess
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Kim B. Widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: 'June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
EOP [ WHO 1 )
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�.
ARMS Email System
The 9:30am portion of the Women's Meeting will take place in room 100 as
planned, but the lOam portion will be probably be moved to another time
[to be determined at the meeting]. Sorry, and thanks for your patience.
-Ruby
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-0CT-1997 19:09:58.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip FL/NY/NJ
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P .. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN.
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN;Kevin S. Moran/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN;Linda L. Moore/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN;Anne E. McGuire/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN;Sylvia M. Mathews/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN;Bruce R. Lindsey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J.'Lavery ( CN;Christopher J. Lavery/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN;Karin Kullman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN;Kirk T. Hanlin/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN;Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN;Phu D. Huynh/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN;Russell W. Horwitz/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN;Jason S. Goldberg/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN;D. Stephen Goodin/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN;Andrew Friendly/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN;Shelley N. Fidler/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN;Anne M. Edwards/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN;Jennifer D. Dudley/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN;Brenda B. Costello/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN;Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN;Jose Cerda III/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
[ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
..
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Friday, October 31, and Saturday, November 1,
the President will
travel to Florida to attend education and fast track events and a number
of DNC functions.
On Sunday, November 2, the President will travel to New
York and New Jersey to attend politi·cal rallies for Eric Vitaliano, Ruth
Messinger and Jim McGreevey.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
FL, NY & NJ Background Memos:
DUE THUR., OCT. 30 AT 6PM
Political Memos
Economic I-Pagers
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
FL Event Memos:
DUE THUR., OCT. 30 AT 6PM
Fast Track Event
Education Event
DNC Lunch (Friday)
Radio Address
DCCC Dinner
DNC Breakfast, Break-Out Sessions, Lunch, Dinner
(Saturday)
NY & NJ Memos:
DUE FRI., OCT. 31 AT 6PM
Vitaliano Rally
Mcgreevey Rally
Messinger Reception & Rally
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�Page I of3
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-0CT-1997 14:18:59.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Meeting
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Claire Gonzales ( CN=Claire Gonzales/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of3
ARMS Email System
•
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O~EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Maria E. Soto ( CN=Maria E. Soto/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Whitney S. Staley ( CN=Whitney S. Staley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kim B. Widdess ( CN=Kim B. Widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TEXT:
Thursday's Women's Meeting in Room 100 will have two components. At 9:30am
we will discuss pending business [Breast Cancer Web Site, Women's
Museum]. Then at 10:00am Chris Jennings from the Domestic Policy Council
)
�.ARMS., Email System
will be joining the group to discuss women's health care issues. Please
let me know if you cannot make it . Thanks.
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
' .. __ ---'to
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP
[ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-0CT-1997 16:14:33.00
SUBJECT:
Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD.J
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Paul R. Carey ( CN=Paul R. Carey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey (" CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel C. Tate ( CN=Daniel C. Tate/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
[ OPD J
�'..
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
~.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura.Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having a Tobacco Strategy Meeting tomorrow, October 30, at 2:45
p.m. in Room 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
;., \~
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Iratha H. Waters ( CN=Iratha H. Waters/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-0CT-1997 16:43:47.00
SUBJECT:
Re: Issues for the OMB Director's Review: HHS/ACF, HHS/AOA, Ag/FCS, SSA
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan weiss ( CN=Jonathan Weiss/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: FOLEY_M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
-l·I.
~\
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This meeting is now set for Thursday, October 30 at 4pm in room 260
OEOB ..... unless something else comes up.
Page 2 of2
�ARMS Email System
•
Page 1 of3
.j.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lawrence J. Haas ( CN=Lawrence J. Haas/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-0CT-1997 15:50:52.00
SUBJECT:
Briefing for VA/HUD, Transp. line-item vetoes
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
TO: Doris o. Matsui ( CN=Doris O. Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
••
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=wHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Fred DuVal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
WHO 1 )
TO: Michael waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Bell
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Robert S. Bell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: John Podesta
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of3
..
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz!OU=OPD!O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner
( CN=June G. Turner!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A.
Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. parmelee!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisabeth Steele ( CN=Elisabeth Steele!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP
[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale
( CN=Suzanne Dale!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson!O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CCo Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP
[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg!OU=WHO!O=EOP@EOP [.WHO
1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The White House plans to announce the President's use of his line-item
veto on the VA!HUD and Transportation appropriations bills this Saturday.
We plan to issue paper in Washington and on the road with the President.
To prepare you, OMB will once again hold a briefing on the specifics -this time on Friday, at 3 p.m., in the Roosevelt Room.
We are squeezing in the briefing between other events in the Roosevelt
Room, so we should start on time or close to it.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 10
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lawrence J. Haas ( CN=Lawrence J. Haas/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 31-0CT-1997 17:22:10.00
SUBJECT:
Final LIV list
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Ske1ton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John H. Gibbons ( CN=John H. Gibbons/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce·N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (WHO)
TO: Doris o. Matsui ( CN=Doris o. Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/OTEOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP'[ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyan Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARJvlS Email System
Page 2 of 10
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Foster ( CN=Jonathan Foster/OU=OSTP/O=EOP@EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD I
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal ( CN=Fred DuVal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU7 WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Bell ( CN=Robert S. Bell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of 10
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Kevin S. Moran ( CN;Kevin S. Moran/OU;WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jordan Tamagni ( CN;Jordan Tamagni/OU;WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU;WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU;OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU;WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisabeth Steele ( CN=Elisabeth Steele/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O;EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Per the OMB briefing this afternoon on tomorrow's line-item veto
announcements, attached are the final list of items.
I urge you to please
review it carefully, because a few items have moved around since we spoke.
IMPORTANT: Although you can talk from this paper to make whatever heads-up
calls you need to, please do not distribute any of it until the President
�Page 4 ofl0
ARMS Email System
makes his formal announcement tomorrow morning.
====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
ATTACHMENT
0 00:00:00.00
1
====================
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D901MAIL45593630V.316 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
00001A0002100400000000005COOOOFA4E012000010AOOOOOOOOOO0000001F000800000001300C
002D001F00080000010130080032001F0008000002013000002FOO1F0008000004013006003200
1F0008000006013006002D001F0008000007013006002D001F0008000009013005002D001F0008
00000A013006002D000300060001000000010004001C0001010100000005164504040000000000
0000000000000000000000000500100000005F171700000006000300040000000600050000009F
OC090700180000009FOC000501020230030405020633070A080509OEOA1521000100000B000100
000E002000000000000000000000000000000000000080FF3FOOOO00000000F8FFOB4001000FOO
560001000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000010000000000000000010000000000000000000004004C000200
020042004C00420000001100B20001000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001010101
01010000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001000EOOOEOOOEOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000007100002B7100002B7100002BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001BOOIB
00FOOF08000COOOC00000000000000002000000000FF417269616C001BOOIBOOFOOF20000COOOC
00000000000000002000000000FF417269616C001BOOIBOOFOOF21OOOCOOOCOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
2001000000FF417269616C001BOOIBOOFOOF22000COOOCOOOOOOOO000000002000000000FF4172
69616C001BOOIBOOFOOF23000AOOOA00000000000000002000000000FF417269616C001B001BOO
FOOF24000COOOC00000000000000002001000000FF417269616COO1BOOBF01E60F100000011000
OEOOOOOOl121000000000C08000000000000001222000000000C08000000000000001322000000
000000000000000000001421200000000400000000000000001521000000080000000000000000
001621000000000200000000000000001720000000080400000000000000001808200000000000
000000000000001921200000000000000000000000001A24000000000000000000000000001B20
000000000600000000000000001C23000000000000000000000000001D20000000000000000000
000000001F21000000000400000000000000002020000000000601000000000000002220000000
080000000000000000002420000000000A0000000000002B002520000000000400000000000000
002620000000000200000000000000002720200000000000000000000000002921000000000000
000000000000002C21000000000C00000000000000002D20000000000C00000000000000002E20
000000080C00000000000000002F21000000000601000000000000003123000000000C08000000
000000004220200000000400000000000000004320200000000800000000000000004420200000
000C00000000000000001B002200E7320100FF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOC000000000055
6E646566696E6564001B002200E7320200FF0000004E6F726D616C00000COOOC0000000000556E
646566696E6564001B002200E7320300FF0000004E6F726D616COO000COOOC0000000000556E64
6566696E6564001B002200E7320400FF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOC0000000000556E6465
66696E6564001B002200E7320500FF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOC000C0000000000556E646566
696E6564001B002200E7320600FF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOC0000000000556E64656669
6E6564001B002200E7320700FF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOC0000000000556E646566696E
6564001B002200E7320800FF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOCOO00000000556E646566696E65
64001B002200E7320900FF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOCOOOO000000556E646566696E6564
001B002200E7320AOOFF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOCOOOOOO0000556E646566696E656400
1B002200E7320BOOFF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOCOOOOOOOO00556E646566696E6564001B
002200E7320COOFF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOCOOOOOOOOOO556E646566696E6564001BOO
2200E7320DOOFF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOC0000000000556E646566696E6564001B0022
00E7320EOOFF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOC0000000000556E646566696E6564001B002200
E7320FOOFF0000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOC0000000000556E646566696E6564001B002200E7
321000000000004E6F726D616COOOOOCOOOC0000000000556E646566696E6564001B007100302A
010000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000010001000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000010204011010100000130016000000
0000FF00008001FF400440FF8004C006FFC0044013000800000201000000000013001200000002
00FF00008001FF8004C007FFC004401300130000000300FF0007CO01FF400CC007FF0007COOE13
�FOIA Number:
2007-0624-F
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management
System [EMAIL]
This is not a presidential record. This is used as an
administrative marker by the William J. Clinton Presidential .
Librarv Staff.
Hex Dump file is not in a recognizable format, has been incorrectly
decoded or is damaged.
Attachment Number: [ATTACH.D90]MAIL45593630V.316 to ASCII
�FOIA Number:
2007-0624-F
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management
System [EMAIL]
This is not a presidential record. This is used as an
administrative marker by the William J. Clinton Presidential
Librarv Staff.
Hex Dump file is not in a recognizable format, has been incorrectly
decoded or is damaged.
Attachment Number: [ATTACH.D90]MAIL46593630W.316 to ASCII
�ARMS Email System
'.-
_
Page 1 of5
.c.t
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-NOV-1997 09:22:41.00
SUBJECT:
The President's Trip to Texas
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Wa1ker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP .[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. MoranjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuirejOU=WHojO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. MathewsjOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHojO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Karin KullmanjOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CN=Kirk T. HanlinjOU=WHO/O=EOP
@EOP
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-RotunnojOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. HuynhjOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. HorwitzjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen GoodinjOU=WHojO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHojO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. FidlerjOU=CEQjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. EdwardsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. DudleyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. CostellojOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda IIIjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg (CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Orszag ( CN=Jonathan Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian v. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=PeterR. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
Page 4 of5
�ARMS Email System
,
Page 5 of5
..
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Thursday, November 6, 1997, the President will travel to Houston, Texas
to attend the dedication ceremonies of the George Bush Presidential
Library.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
Texas Background Memos:
DUE TUES., NOV. 4 AT 6PM
Political Memo
Economic I-Pager
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
TX Event Memos:
DUE WED., NOV. 5 AT 6PM
Dedication Ceremony
Bush Luncheon
please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-NOV-1997 10:51:57.00
SUBJECT:
An invitation ...
TO: Alison Muscatine ( CN=Alison Muscatine/OU=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jody J. Kaplan ( CN=Jody J. Kaplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice J. Pushkar ( CN=Alice J. Pushkar/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Setti D. Warren ( CN=Setti D. Warren/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie o. Huffman ( CN=Julie o. Huffman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan Ryan ( CN=Evan Ryan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patricia Solis-Doyle ( CN=Patricia Solis-Doyle/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Claire Gonzales ( CN=Claire Gonzales/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dawn M. Chirwa ( CN=Dawn M. Chirwa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Capricia P. Marshall ( CN=Capricia P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen L. Ochs ( CN=Ellen L. Ochs/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. YellenjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. WinstonjOU=PIRjO=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Doris O. Matsui
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Doris O. MatsuijOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha ScottjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon MoorejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. LovelljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Victoria Radd ( CN=Victoria RaddjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. CostellojOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Theresa A. Thibadeau ( CN=Theresa A. ThibadeaujOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. Barry ( CN=Kathleen A. BarryjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Huma M. Abedin ( CN=Huma M. AbedinjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason ( CN=Julie E. MasonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robyn G. Dickey ( CN=Robyn G. DickeyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jaycee A. Pribulsky ( CN=Jaycee A. PribulskyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kelly Craighead ( CN=Kelly CraigheadjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha E. Berry ( CN=Marsha E. BerryjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sally Katzen ( CN=Sally KatzenjOU=OMBjO=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. HaynesjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kim B. Widdess ( CN=Kim B. WiddessjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. ThorntonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 30[3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patsy L. Thomasson ( CN=Patsy L. Thomasson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kay Casstevens ( CN=Kay Casstevens/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl D. Mills ( CN=Cheryl D. Mills/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Lynn Cutler would like to cordially invite you to join us for a reception
in honor of newly elected women state legislators sponsored by the Center
for the American Woman in Politics.
The reception will be held in the Indian Treaty Room on Thursday, November
6 and will take place from 5:30 - 7:30 p.m.
We would be honored if you could attend ana show support.
Please contact Mona to RSVP or with any questions at 6-2896.
�ARMS Email System
, '0
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 4-NOV-1997 14:19:39.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Strategy Meeting
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 .>
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman (CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A". Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Murchinson ( CN=Jonathan Murchinson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn B. Stack ( CN=Kathryn B. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique. Pirozzi (
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Ang~lique
Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Lisa J. Levin ( CN=Lisa J. Levin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Reminder -- We will be having a weekly Welfare Reform Strategy Meeting
TODAY at 4:00 p.m. in Room 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 5-NOV-1997 18:39:05.00
SUBJECT:
Women's Mtg
TO: Rebecca M. Blank ( CN=Rebecca M. Blank/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Claire Gonzales ( CN=Claire Gonzales/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robin Leeds ( CN=Robin Leeds/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Roberta W. Greene ( CN=Roberta W. Greene/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lucia F. Gilliland ( CN=Lucia F. Gilliland/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacie Spector ( CN=Stacie Spector/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Audrey T. Haynes ( CN=Audrey T. Haynes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marsha Scott ( CN=Marsha Scott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan M. Liss ( CN=Susan M. Liss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen M. Lovell ( CN=Ellen M. Lovell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Maria E. Soto ( CN=Maria E. Soto/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Whitney S. Staley ( CN=Whitney S. Staley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mona G. Mohib ( CN=Mona G. Mohib/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie A. Black ( CN=Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Noa A. Meyer ( CN=Noa A. Meyer/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kim B. Widdess ( CN=Kim B. Widdess/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
�ARMS Email System
There will be a Women's Meeting Thursday morning at 9:00am in room 100.
please let me know if you will not be able to make it. Thanks.
Page 3 of3
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[10/14/1997 – 11/05/1997]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 097 - Folder 007
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/f826013e70e99c1905d61ebf3f19fc63.pdf
304bd64cc42491aedbc4879109d4908a
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 097 - FOLDER -006
[09/22/1997 -10/14/1997]
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
~,
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:22-SEP-1997 14:33:24.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Welfare Strategy Meeting
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Murchinson ( CN=Jonathan Murchinson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn B. Stack ( CN=Kathryn B. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP '[ CEA 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�~RMS
Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth S. Apfel ( CN=Kenneth S. Apfel/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan.( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
cc: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Toby Donenfeld
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Linda R. Cooper ( CN=Linda R. Cooper/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lisa J. Levin ( CN=Lisa J. Levin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having our weekly welfare strategy meeting tomorrow, September
23, at 4:00 p.m. in ROOM 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 1
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewer't/oU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:25-SEP-1997 16:25:04.00
SUBJECT:
Food Safety
TO: Russell W. Horwitz
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: LEAVY_D ( LEAVY D @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(NSC)
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia M. Terzano ( CN=Virginia M. Terzano/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Q
Any kind of. FDA announcement today,
announcement?
food safety
MR. MCCURRY:
There's no food safety announcement
today.
I think it's been reported various places that the White
House is considering a new initiative to ensure the safety of
fruits and vegetables consumed by the American public, especially
those that come from foreign sources.
The White House is
considering that, and I do expect the White House will announce
something soon about steps the President wants to take to direct
the FDA to issue better guidance on agricultural practices and
good manufacturing practices. And the President will likely have
some things to say about legislation that will improve the FDA's
authority to regulate imported fruits and vegetables coming from
other countries in a way similar to what the USDA already does
with respect to meat products -- meat and poultry products,
Q
When might that be?
MR, MCCURRY:
Sometime next week perhaps.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
~~
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-SEP-1997 10:42:54.00
SUBJECT:
Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel C. Tate ( CN=Dariiel C. Tate/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul R. Carey ( CN=Paul R. Carey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
TO: Mary L. smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Lois E. Altoft ( CN=Lois E. Altoft/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sonyia Matthews ( CN=Sonyia Matthews/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be holding our weekly Tobacco Strategy Meetings each Thursday at
2:45 p.m. in Room 211 of the OEOB.
The next meeting will be Thursday,
October 2.
)
)
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP
[ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-SEP-1997 14:33:22.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Strategy Meeting
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Murchinson ( CN=Jonathan Murchinson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn B. Stack ( CN=Kathryn B. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips!O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�',.
Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna" ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Kenneth S. Apfel ( CN=Kenneth S. Apfel/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lisa J. Levin ( CN=Lisa J. Levin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We are having a weekly Welfare Strategy meeting TODAY at 4:00 p.m. in Room
211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
~;:;
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-SEP-1997 12:08:50.00
SUBJECT:
Tobacco Strategy Meeting
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel C. Tate ( CN=Daniel C. Tate/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sherman G. Boone ( CN=Sherman G. Boone/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul R. Carey ( CN=Paul R. Carey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley (CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
...
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lois E. Altoft
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Lois E. Altoft/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
CC: Kristen E. Panerali ( CN=Kristen E. Panerali/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sonyia Matthews ( CN=Sonyia Matthews/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The strategy meeting for this Thursday is cancelled.
�Page 1 of5
ARMS Email System
I.
..
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-0CT-1997 14:43:08.00
SUBJECT:
The President's trip to NJ/PA
TO: Virginia Apuzzo ( CN=Virginia Apuzzo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP '[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�.,
Page 2 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J, Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�.
ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN:Jose Cerda III/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN:Emily Bromberg/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN:David S. Beaubaire/OU:WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN:Nicholas R. Baldick/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN:Brenda M. Anders/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN:Jon P. Jennings/OU:WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN:Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN:Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN:Christopher F. Walker/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN:Ann F. Walker/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN:Michael Waldman/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN:Peter G. Umhofer/OU:CEQ/O:EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN:Barry J. Toiv/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN:Marjorie Tarmey/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN:Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN:Darby E. Stott/OU:WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN:Craig T. Smith/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN:Joshua Silverman/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN:Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 ).
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN:Christa Robinson/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN;John podesta/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN;Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN;Elizabeth R. Newman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN;Kevin S. Moran/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN;Linda L. Moore/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN;Anne E. McGuire/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN;Sylvia M. Mathews/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN;Bruce R. Lindsey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN;Christopher J. Lavery/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN;Karin Kullman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN;Kirk T. Hanlin/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN;Phu D. Huynh/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
( CN;Russell W. Horwitz/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN;Julia R. Green/Ou;wHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN;Laura A. Graham/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN;Jeremy M. Gaines/OU;wHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN;Karen E. Finney/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN;Paul K. Engskov/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN;Maria Echaveste/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN;Suzanne Dale/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page S ofS
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Wednesday, October 8, 1997, the President will travel to New Jersey for
a child care event, a luncheon and a reception.
He will then travel to
Philadelphia for a meeting with Mayor Rendell and several DNC events.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
NJ & PA Background Memos:
DUE MONDAY, OCT. 6 AT 6:00 P.M.
Political Memos
Economic I-Pagers
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
NJ & PA Event Memos:
DUE TUESDAY, OCT. 7 AT 6:00 P.M.
Child Care Event
McGreevy Luncheon
DNC Reception
Mayor Rendell Meeting
Young Democrats Reception
DNC Reception and Dinner
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�'.
..
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of4
.J;'
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lin Liu ( CN=Lin Liu/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-0CT-1997 19:42:04.00
SUBJECT:
Draft policy Workplan
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter Rundlet ( CN=Peter Rundlet/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D.
READ: UNKNOWN
Korenman/OU~CEA/O=EOP @
EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Dawn M. Chirwa ( CN=DawnM. Chirwa/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Cavataio ( CN=Michele Cavataio/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michael Wenger ( CN=Michael Wenger/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michael J. Sorrell ( CN=Michael J. Sorrell/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Claire Gonzales ( CN=Claire Gonzales/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jacinta Ma ( CN=Jacinta Ma/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Per our discussion this afternoon on Race Initaitive next ,steps, Judy
mentioned that the Initiative Staff will distribute a draft one-page
workplan in·eachof the different areas to serve as starting points for
discussion. Attached is a draft workplan for the policy working group
with some ideas on goals, process, products, and resources.
Please take a
look and give me any comments so that I can incorporate your ideas before
our Wed. 1PM meeting. Thanks.
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
�AutomAtad ~8cords Management System
Hex.l)ump Conversion
Draft Work Plan
Policy
Goals:
•
Identify and rollout concrete policy action items
•
Coordinate Initiative, WH and Departmental policy deliberation and announcement
processes
•
Focus like a laser beam on education and economic opportunity as priority issues
Process:
•
Immediately, convene DPC working groups in education and economic opportunity areas
- take stock of existing achievements (talk about them often) and brainstorm new ideas.
Also focus concurrently on health and administration of justice issues.
•
Cabinet agencies to come up with list of policy proposals (updated monthly) for WH and
PIR discussion and coordination - identify tough questions and re-examine existing issues
or beef up enforcement of current law - goal is to identify three issues by end of this
month for concrete next steps
•
DPC and PIR to develop comprehensive list of policy options in education and economic
opportunity areas
•
Identify specific actions possible for each policy option:
•
administrative
•
regulatory
•
legislative
•
budget
•
Executive Order
•
enforcement
•
Identify and coordinate opportunities for regular and targeted policy events - bi-weekly or
monthly - develop policy message consistent with communications strategy
•
Identify special problem areas in education and economic opportunities needing further
analysis and study right away - announce research efforts for longer term issues
Products:
•
Policy and budget announcements -list of three ideas for this month
•
Legislative proposals
•
New regulations
•
Executive orders - i.e. draft E.O. creating Interagency Forum on Race Statistics and
Indicators
•
Statistics fact book - quick fact book and larger resource book from Interagency Forum
•
Reports on problems or achievements
Resources:
•
•
•
•
Agencies - Cabinet officials as surrogates
Contract out special topics for expert analysis
National Academy of Sciences, think tanks and outside groups
FY99 budget process - expanding enforcement
�,-
LL (10/6/97)
Automated Records Manage'!lent System
Hex-Dump.Converslon
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
..
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-0CT-1997 11:30:49.00
SUBJECT:
weekly Welfare Reform Strategy Meeting
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP. [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Murchinson ( CN=Jonathan Murchinson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn B. Stack ( CN=Kathryn B. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lisa J. Levin ( CN=Lisa J. Levin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a weekly Welfare Reform Strategy Meeting TODAY at 4:00 p.m.
in Room 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lin Liu ( CN=Lin Liu/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 8-0CT-1997 15:06:24.00
SUBJECT:
PIR Staff
TO: William R. Kincaid
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=william R. Kincaid/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Sarah A. Bianchi ( CN=Sarah A. Bianchi/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tanya E. Martin ( CN=Tanya E. Martin/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: John M. Goering ( CN=John M. Goering/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Scott R. Palmer ( CN=Scott R. Palmer/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michele Cavataio ( CN=Michele Cavataio/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: David Campt ( CN=David Campt/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP' [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ana Lopez ( CN=Ana Lopez/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
I have used the DPC policy teams as the basic structure to assign
individuals on my Policy Planning and Research staff to different policy
areas as follows:
Education - David Campt and Scott.Palmer
Economic Opportunities (including housing) - John Goering and Ana Lopez
Health - David Campt
Administration of Justice - John Goering
�.
ARMS Email Sy.stem
..
These are preliminary assignments but I think it will help us get
started.
please include me in the various subgroup meetings for the time
being so that I can get a broad sense of where we are going.
But I will
generally depend on our staff here for more detailed feedback.
Thanks.
We are all looking forward to working with you on these ·issues.
Page 2 of2
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 4
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lawrence J. Haas ( CN=Lawrence J. Haas/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:13-0CT-1997 18:03:15.00
SUBJECT:
IMPORTANT -- Heads up on line-item veto
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN
(WHO)
TO: Doris O. Matsui ( CN=Doris o. Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
WHO 1 )
TO: FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 2 of4
'ARMS Email System
,.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara ·Chow
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Barbara Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal ( CN=Fred DuVal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Bell ( CN=Robert S. Bell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan. Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Gordon Adams ( CN=Gordon Adams/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Jill M. Blickstein ( CN=Jill M. Blickstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Although this is NOT yet public information, the White House plans to
announce on Tuesday, October 14, that the President has used his line-item
veto authority on the Defense appropriations bill.
�ARMS Email System
To help you explain the President's decision to your constituencies, OMB's
Jack Lew and Gordon Adams will hold a briefing on Tuesday morning, 9 a.m.,
in the Roosevelt Room, to outline the particulars.
We hope you find the briefing useful. We are trying to respond to the
concerns that many of you raised about having a sufficient heads-up and
understanding beforehand, so you can better do your own thing.
Please let me know whether you think we've left anyone off this list.
Page 4 of 4
�\ ARMS Email System
'\ J.
Page 1 of 33
f..
\
R~CORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
'.~
CREATOR: Lawrence J. Haas ( CN=Lawrence J. Haas/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:14-0CT-1997 12:25:15.00
SUBJECT:
URGENT -- update on line-item veto
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
FOLEY M@A1@CD@LNGTWY[ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
TO: Doris o. Matsui ( CN=Doris O. Matsui/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WH-O 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J.
READ: UNKNOWN
Toiv/OU=WHO/O=~OP@EOP
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 ) •
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System'
Page 2 of33
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred DuVal ( CN=Fred DuVal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP@EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=JOseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Bell ( CN=Robert S. Bell/OU=OMB/O=EOP@EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of33
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP@EOP [ OPD ]
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
cc: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
cc: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
cc: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
cc: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP@OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
CC: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
)
CC: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP@EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TEXT:
Due to last-minute changes, the specific line-item veto details have
changed a bit since Jack Lew briefed the senior White House staff this
morning.
The attached is the actual press paper that will go out later
today. You can educate yourselves about where we are by referring to it.
PLEASE DO NOT DISTRIBUTE this paper outside of the White House, however,
until at least Raines, et. al., brief the press at 1:30 p.m.
Thank you.
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D12]MAIL46707468M.216 to ASCII,
�~Uf8fflgtBB ~@:8ff1§ Management System
--Fmi--t1Ump Conversion
PRESIDENT CLINTON USES LINE-ITEM VETO
ON DEFENSE APPROPRIATIONS ACT OF 1998
October 14, 1997
•
President Clinton used the line-item veto today to cancel 13 projects in the Defense
Appropriations Act of 1998.
•
The President's action will save $144 million in budget authority in 1998.
•
The Defense Appropriations Act included funding for over 750 projects, costing about
$11 billion, that the President did not request in his 1998 budget.
-- The Administration carefully reviewed those unrequested projects and found
that while most of them have merit, some do not.
•
The Administration has chosen criteria that are appropriate to each appropriations bill
under review.
•
For the Defense Appropriations Act, the President considered such factors as:
-- whether he requested the projects in his 1998 budget,
-- whether they contribute to our national security, and
-- whether they fit with our long-range defense plans.
•
The President's action will in no way adversely affect our military capability, the
readiness of our forces, or their operations in defense of our Nation.
-- The Defense Department has determined there is no national security
requirement for these projects.
•
The President left thousands ofprojects in the bill, including the vast majority that
Congress added, reflecting his commitment to the military readiness of American forces
and Congress' role in shaping appropriations bills.
-- In fact, his actions mean that he has agreed to a net addition of about $1 billion
in Defense Department funding above the level in the Bipartisan Budget
Agreement.
�Automated ReCOrds Management System
THE LINE ITEM VETO ACT
Hex·Dump Conversion
o
Scope of Authority. President may cancel any item of discretionary or direct
spending or any limited tax benefit, if he sends a special message to Congress
identifying the item within 5 days (excluding Sundays) of signing the bill
containing the item.
o
Cancellations transmitted to Congress are effective upon receipt by Congress,
and remain effective unless overturned by a disapproval law.
o
The item veto may only be used on items in bills the President signs --he may not
veto items that become law without his signature.
o
Defmition of Item. The President may cancel (not reduce) whole individual
"items" of discretionary spending --defmed as any dollar amount in an
appropriations bill or report, or any amount required to be allocated by a
specific proviso in a bill or represented separately in explanatory text in a
report.
o
President may cancel only the amount of spending --not conditions or
restrictions on spending.
o
The President may also cancel any "item of new direct spending" --defmed as a
specific provision of law estimated to result in an increase in direct spending,
relative to the baseline.
o
Limited Tax Benefits. "Limited tax benefits" that may be canceled include only
revenue-losing provisions applying to 100 or fewer beneficiaries in a fiscal year
(where the beneficiaries are not similarly treated), or transitional relief to 10 or
fewer beneficiaries. Congress may specify in tax legislation whether the bill
contains any provisions subject to cancellation authority.
o
discretionary cancellations
Lockbox.
Includes a "lockbox" mechanism:
trigger automatic cap reductions, and paygo savings from cancellations are not
put on paygo scorecard.
o Congressional procedure. The Congress has 30 session days following a
cancellation message to consider disapproval legislation, under expedited
procedures.
o
Disapproval bills introduced in the House must disapprove all cancellations
made with respect to a particular law. Bills introduced in the Senate may select
particular cancellations. However, the bills may be amended in both chambers
to alter the list of cancellations.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
o
Effective dates. Item veto authority became effective on January 1, 1997 and
will sunset on January 1,2005.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-42
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation: "Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
1(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $30,000 thousand for
Operation and Maintenance, Air Force project "SR-71" on page 75 of House Report
105-265 dated September 23, 1997.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will not
impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national interest.
1(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project would provide manning,
operations and support to sustain SR-71 training requirements during fiscal year 1998 and
provide for a 30-day operational deployment capability. The SR-71 is a high-speed,
high-altitude, long-range, multi-sensor, all-weather, wide-area surveillance aircraft.
There is no military requirement to continue to operate the SR-71. The project is
being canceled because it was not requested iIi the President's FY 1998 Budget and
the Department of Defense has determined that it would not make a significant
contribution to US military capability.
1(D). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This will
have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent, will have a
beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1998
-$21,870
FY 1999
-$6,480
FY 2000
-$900
FY 2001
-$270
FY 2002
-$120
Total
$30,000
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority:
-$30,000 thousand in FY 1998
The estimated outlay effect for each year is
Outlays:
shown above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures:
If a sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are
reduced by the amounts above.
�Automated RecOrds Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
2(A). Bureau: Operation and Maintenance
2(A). Governmental FunctioniProject (Account): SR-71 (Operation and
Maintenance, Air Force)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: California, 21 st Congressional
District
2(C). Total Number of Cancellations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State
and District identified above: California: five; 21st District: one
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-43
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET.AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation:
"Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
1(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $9,000 thousand for
Aircraft Procurement, Air Force, project "SR-71 Mods" on page 103 of House
Report 105-265 dated September 23,1997.
I(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will
not impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national
interest.
1(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project would modify cameras, enhance
radar processing, install a Global Positioning System navigation system, and
improve electronic intelligence for the SR-71 reconnaissance aircraft. The SR-71 is a
high-speed, high-altitude, long-range, multi-sensor, all-weather, wide-area
surveillance aircraft. There is no military requirement to continue to operate the
SR-71. The project is being canceled because it was not requested in the
President's FY 1998 Budget and the Department of Defense has determined that it
would not make a significant contribution to US military capability.
1(D). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This
will have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent,
will have a beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of
dollars)
FY 1998
-$711
FY 1999
-$2,169
FY 2000
-$2,961
FY 2001
-$1,782
FY 2002
-$765
Total
-$9,000
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority:
-$9,000 thousand in FY 1998
The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown
Outlays:
above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures:
If a sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are reduced
by the amounts above.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
2(A). Bureau: Aircraft Procurement
2(A). Governmental Function/Project (Account): SR-71 Modifications (Aircraft
Procurement, Air Force)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: California, 25th Congressional
District.
2(C). Total Number of Cancellations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State
and District identified above: California: six; 25th District: one
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-44
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation:
"Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
1(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $4,000 thousand for the
Research, Development Test and Evaluation, Army project titled "Gallo Center" on
page 112 of House Report 105-265 dated September 23,1997, and page 166 of House
Report 105-206 dated July 25,1997.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will
not impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national
interest.
l(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: The President's FY 1998 Budget supports
ongoing work to demonstrate and export new environmentally acceptable
technology to the industrial base and to train the industrial base on the use of new
technology. The appropriated increase would support life-cycle environmental and
manufacturing technologies research specifically related to weapons systems and
munitions technology assessment and analysis. The Army does not believe this
additional research merits funding at this time.
1(0). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This
will have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent,
will have a beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1999
FY 1998
-$2,320
-$1,320
FY2000
FY2001
FY 2002
Total
-$212
-$72
-$32 -$4,000
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority:
-$4,000 thousand in FY 1998
The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown above.
Outlays:
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures: If a
sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are
reduced by the amounts above.
�Automated ReCOrds Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
2(A). Bureau: Research, Development, Test and Evaluation
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
2(A). Governmental Function/Project (Account): Gallo Center (Research,
Development, Test and Evaluation, Army)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: New Jersey, 11th Congressional
District
2(C). Total Number of Cancellations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State
and District identified above: New Jersey: one; 11 th District: one
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-45
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, PoL. 104-130
Bill Citation:
"Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
1(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $6,000 thousand for the
Research, Development Test and Evaluation, Army project "Molten Carbonate Fuel
Cells Technology" on page 113 of House Report 105-265 dated September 23,1997.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will
not impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national
interest.
1(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project would research and develop
alternative fuel cell technology that converts chemical energy to electricity. It has
primary applications for the Department of Energy which has responsibility for
alternative energy research. The project is being canceled because it was not
requested in the President's FY 1998 Budget and the Department of Defense has
determined that it would not make a significant contribution to US military
capability.
1(D). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This
will have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent,
will have a beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1998
FY 1999
-$3,480
-$1,980
FY 2000
FY 2001
FY 2002
Total
-$108
-$318
-$48 -$6,000
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority:
-$6,000 thousand in FY 1998
Outlays:
The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures: If a
sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are
reduced by the amounts above.
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
2(A). Bureau: Research, Development, Test and Evaluation
2(A). Governqtental Function/Project (Account): Molten Carbonate Fuel Cells
Technology (Research, Development, Test and Evaluation, Army)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: Unknown
2(C). Total Number of Cancellations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State
and District identified above: Unknown
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-46
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation:
"Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
I(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $3,000 thousand for the
Research, Development Test and Evaluation, Army project "Periscopic
Minimally-Invasive Surgery" on page 113 and 116 of House Report 105-265 dated
September 23, 1997.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will
not impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national
interest.
I(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project would research less-invasive
surgery techniques that could potentially result in faster healing, less hospital time,
and reduced costs. However, the Department already funds microsurgery
programs with specific military applications. The project is being canceled because
it was not requested in the President's FY 1998 Budget and the Department of
Defense has determined that it would not make a significant contribution to US
military capability.
1(D). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result ofthe cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This
will have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent,
will have a beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1998
-$1,740
FY 1999
FY2000
FY 2001
FY 2002
Total
-$990
-$159
-$54
-$24 -$3,000
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority:
-$3,000 thou~and in FY 1998
Outlays:
The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures: If a
sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are
reduced by the amounts above.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
2(A). Bureau: Research, Development, Test and Evaluation
2(A). Governmental Function/Project (Account): Periscopic Minimally-Invasive
Surgery (Research, Development, Test and Evaluation, Army)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: Unknown
2(C). Total Number of Cancellations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State
and District identified above: Unknown
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-47
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation: "Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
1(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $4,000 thousand for the
Research, Development Test and Evaluation, Army project "Proton Beam" on page
113 of House Report 105-265 dated September 23,1997.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will
not impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national
interest.
1(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project would research a new machine
that delivers radiation therapy for cancer treatment. The appropriated funds
constitute a grant to a private organization for medical research that should be
funded through a peer review process. The project is being canceled because it was
not requested in the President's FY 1998 Budget and the Department of Defense has
determined that it would not make a significant contribution to US military
capability.
1(D). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This
will have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent,
will have a beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1998
-$2,320
FY 1999
-$1,320
FY 2001
FY 2002
Total
FY 2000
-$212
-$72
-$32 -$4,000
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority:
-$4,000 thousand in FY 1998
Outlays:
The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures: If a
sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are
reduced by the amounts above.
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
2(A). Bureau: Research, Development, Test and Evaluation
2(A). Governmental Function/Project (Account): Proton Beam (Research,
Development, Test and Evaluation, Army)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: California, 40th Congressional
District
2(C). Total Number of Cancellations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State
and District identified above: California: seven; 40th District: three
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-48
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation: "Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
1(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $3,000 thousand for a
Research, Development, Test, and Evaluation, Navy project "Terfenol-D" on pages 119
and 122 of House Report 105-265 dated September 23, 1997.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will not
impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national interest.
1(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project is intended to enable the Navy to
achieve further cost reductions in the application of a magnetorestrictive,
iron/terbium/dysprosium alloy for new high performance sonar systems. This effort is to
be undertaken through a partnership between any entity which has made a financial
commitment and has experience in the production of the alloy and the National Center of
Excellence in Metal Working Technology. The Navy has no military requirement for
this technology. This project is being canceled because it was not requested in the
President's FY 1998 Budget and the Department of Defense has determined that it would
not make a significant contribution to US military capability.
leD). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This will
have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent, will have a
beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1998
-$1,603
FY 1999
-$1,008
FY 2000
-$253
FY 2002
FY 2001
-$33
-$60
Total
-$3,000
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority:
-$3,000 thousand in FY 1998
Outlays:
The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures: If a
sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are reduced by
the amounts above.
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
2(A). Bureau: Research, Development, Test, and Evaluation
2(A). Governmental Function/Project (Account): Terfenol-D (Research, Development,
Test, and Evaluation, Navy)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: Pennsylvania, 12th Congressional
District
2(C). Total Number of CanceUations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State and
District identified above: Pennsylvania: three; 12th District: two
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-49
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation: "Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
1(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $3,000 thousand for a
Research, Development, Test, and Evaluation, Navy project for "COTS airgun as an
acoustic source" on page 120 of House Report 105-265 dated September 23, 1997.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will not
impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national interest.
1(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project would continue development,
testing, and calibration of components for a mobile, high power broadband acoustic
surveillance source that is based upon the adaptation of commercial air-gun technology.
Technical review in the Department of Defense has concluded that this technology will
not be effective, except in shallow water regions where there are no current requirements.
The project is being canceled because it was not requested in the President's FY 1998
Budget and the Department of Defense has determined that it would not make a
significant contribution to US military capability.
1(D). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This will
have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent, will have a
beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1998
-$33
FY 1999
-$1,603
FY 2000
-$1,008
FY 2001
-$253
FY 2002
-$60
Total
-$3,000
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority:
-$3,000 thousand in FY 1998
Outlays:
The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures: If a
sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are reduced by
the amounts above.
�Automated Records Management Systerr
Hex-Dump Conversion .
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
2(A). Bureau: Research, Development, Test, and Evaluation
2(A). Governmental Function/Project (Account): COTS airgun as an acoustic source
.
(Research, Development, Test, and Evaluation, Navy)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: Unknown
2(C). Total Number of Cancellations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State
and District identified above: Unknown
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-50
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation: "Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
1(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $10,000 thousand for
Research, Development, Test and Evaluation, Air Force project "Military
Spaceplane" on page 125 of House Report 105-265 dated September 23,1997.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will
not impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national
interest.
1(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project would fund research into
hypersonic technologies and is intended to complement NASA's reusable launch
vehicle program. However, NASA, not the Department of Defense, is responsible
for the development of reusable launch vehicles. The project is being canceled
because it was not requested in the President's FY 1998 Budget, and because the
Department of Defense has determined that it would not make a significant
contribution to US military capability.
1(D). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This
will have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent,
will have a beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1998
FY 1999
FY 2000
FY 2001
FY 2002
-$4,272 -$4,272
-$887
-$357
-$10,000
-$116
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority: -$10,000 thousand in FY 1998
Outlays:
The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown
above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures:
If a sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are
reduced by the amounts above.
Total
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Duf!lp Conversion
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
2(A). Bureau: Research, Development, Testing and Evaluation
2(A). Governmental Function/Project (Account): Military Spaceplane (Research,
Development, Testing and Evaluation, Air Force)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: New Mexico, 1st Congressional
District.
2(C). Total Number of Cancellations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State
and District identified above: New Mexico: three; 1st District: two
�Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-51
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation:
"Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
I(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $30,000 thousand for
Research, Development, Test and Evaluation, Air Force project "Clementine" on
page 125 of House Report 105-265 dated September 23, 1997.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will
not impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national
interest.
1(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project would test and demonstrate
microelectronics for acquisition tracking and intercept of an asteroid in space using
a mothership integrated with three microsatellites. The scientific objective of the
mission is to obtain data on the asteroid. The project's key military application
would be for space-based missile defense. The project is being canceled because it
was not requested in the President's FY 1998 Budget; it was not in the Department
of Defense Future Years Defense Plan; and its key military application is not part of
the Department's national missile defense readiness plan.
1(D). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This
will have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent,
will have a beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1998
FY 1999
FY 2000
FY 2002
FY 2001
-$12,817 -$12,820
-$2,662
-$1,071
-$347
-$30,000
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority: -$30,000 thousand in FY 1998
Outlays:
The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown
above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures:
If a sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are
Total
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
reduced by the amounts above.
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
2(A). Bureau: Research, Development, Testing and Evaluation
2(A). Governmental Function/Project (Account): Clementine (Research,
Development, Testing and Evaluation, Air Force)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: New Mexico, 1st Congressional
District.
2(C). Total Number of Cancellations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State
and District identified above: New Mexico: four; 1st District: three
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-52
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation:
"Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
I(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $1,500 thousand for
Research, Development, Test and Evaluation, Air Force project "Optical Correlator
Technology" on page 125 of House Report 105-265 dated September 23, 1997.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will
not impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national
interest.
I(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project would conduct research and
development to attempt to improve optical correlator technology. The project is
being canceled because it was not requested in the President's FY 1998 Budget, and
because the Department of Defense has determined that it would not make a
significant contribution to US military capability.
1(D). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This
will have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent,
will have a beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1998
FY 1999
FY 2000
FY 2002
FY2001
-$641
-$641
-$133
-$54
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority: -$1,500 thousand in FY 1998
Outlays:
The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown
above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures:
If a sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are
reduced by the amounts above.
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
2(A). Bureau: Research, Development, Testing and Evaluation
2(A). Governmental Function/Project (Account): Optical Correlator Technology
Total
-$17
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
(Research, Development, Testing and Evaluation, Air Force)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: Unknown
�Automated Records Management SystefT1
Hex·Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-53
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation:
"Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
I(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $37,500 thousand for
Research, Development, Test and Evaluation, Defense-wide project "ASAT" on
page 130 of House Report 105-265 dated September 23,1997.
.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will
not impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national
interest.
I(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project would fund a technology
demonstration experiment to prove the feasibility of launching a seeker that would
smash into an enemy's satellite, thereby disabling it. However, alternative means
exist for addressing a satellite threat, such as destroying ground stations or
disrupting satellite communications links. This item is being canceled because it
was not requested in the President's FY 1998 Budget; it was not in the Department of
Defense Future Years Defense Plan; and there are alternative ways to disrupt enemy
satellite capabilities.
1(D). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This will
have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent, will have a
beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1998
-$16,313
-$37,500
FY 1999
FY 2000
FY 2001
-$15,000
-$4,500
FY 2002
-$563
Total
-$563
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority: -$37,500 thousand in FY 1998
Outlays:
The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures:
If a sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are reduced
by the amounts above.
�· Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
2(A). Bureau: Research, Development, Testing and Evaluation
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
2(A)_ Governmental Function/Project (Account): ASAT (Research, Development,
Testing and Evaluation, Defense-wide)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: California, 23rd and/or 24th
Congressional Districts.
2(C). Total Number of Cancellations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State
and District identified above: California: eight; 23rd District: one; 24th District: one
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-54
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation:
"Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
l(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $2,000 thousand for
Research, Deveiopment, Test and Evaluation, Defense-wide project "Risk-based
toxic chemicals research" on page 133 of House Report 105-265 dated September
23,1997.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will
not impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national
interest.
l(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project would address questions
relating to establishment of cleanup criteria for toxic chemicals associated with base
operations and for remediation of waste sites. It would duplicate ongoing research
being conducted by the Department of Defense. The project is being canceled
because it was not requested in the President's FY 1998 Budget and the Department
of Defense has determined that it would not make a significant contribution to US
military capability.
1(D). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This
will have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent,
will have a beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1998
FY 1999
-$870
-$30
-$2,000
FY 2000
-$800
FY 2001
-$240
FY 2002
-$30
Total
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority: -$2,000 thousand in FY 1998
Outlays: The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures:
If a sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are
reduced by the amounts above.
�Automated R d
cor
H eo s Management System
ex- ump Conversion
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
2(A). Bureau: Research, Development, Testing and Evaluation
2(A). Governmental Function/Project (Account): Risk-based toxic chemicals
research (Research, Development, Testing and Evaluation, Defense-wide)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: Unknown.
2(C). Total Number of Cancellations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State
and District identified above: Unkown
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Cancellation No. 97-55
CANCELLATION OF
DOLLAR AMOUNT OF DISCRETIONARY BUDGET AUTHORITY
Report Pursuant to the Line Item Veto Act, P.L. 104-130
Bill Citation:
"Department of Defense Appropriations Act, 1998" (H.R. 2266)
I(A). Dollar Amount of Discretionary Budget Authority: $1,000 thousand for
Research, Development, Test and Evaluation, Defense-wide project "Defense
Techlink rural technology transfer" on page 133 of House Report 105-265 dated
September 23,1997.
1(B). Determinations: This cancellation will reduce the Federal budget deficit, will
not impair any essential Government functions, and will not harm the national
interest.
1(C),(E). Reasons for Cancellation; Facts, Circumstances, and Considerations
Relating to or Bearing upon the Cancellation; and Estimated Effect of Cancellation
on Objects, Purposes, and Programs: This project would develop a rural technology
model of a five state rural region of Montana, North Dakota, South Dakota,
Wyoming and Idaho. The project is being canceled because it was not requested in
the President's FY 1998 Budget and the Department of Defense has determined that
it would not make a significant contribution to US military capability.
1(D). Estimated Fiscal, Economic, and Budgetary Effect of Cancellation: As a
result of the cancellation, Federal outlays will not increase, as specified below. This
will have a commensurate effect on the Federal budget deficit and, to that extent,
will have a beneficial effect on the economy.
Outlay Changes (in thousands of dollars)
FY 1998
FY 1999
-$435
FY 2000
-$400
FY 2001
-$120
FY 2002
-$15
-$15
-$1,000
1(F). Adjustments to Defense Discretionary Spending Limits
Budget Authority: -$1,000 thousand in FY 1998
Outlays:
The estimated outlay effect for each year is shown
above.
Evaluation of Effects of These Adjustments upon Sequestration Procedures:
If a sequestration were required, such sequestration would occur at levels that are
reduced by the amounts above.
Total
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
2(A). Agency: Department of Defense
2 (A). Bureau: Research, Development, Testing and Evaluation
2(A). Governmental Function/Project (Account): Defense Techlink rural
technology transfer (Research, Development, Testing and Evaluation, Defense-wide)
2(B). States and Congressional Districts Affected: Idaho, Montana, North Dakota,
South Dakota, Wyoming; Congressional Districts unknown.
2(C). Total Number of Cancellations (inclusive) in Current Session in each State
and District identified above: Idaho: three; Montana: two; North Dakota: one; South
Dakota: two; Wyoming: one
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[09/22/1997 – 10/14/1997]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 097 - Folder 006
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/36a9e7ecb3cdcf6cfaff19302b5f0c90.pdf
83dc80a11af333f139cc250843104423
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 097 - FOLDER -005
_ [08/07/1997 -09/22/1997]
�Withdrawal/Redaction Sheet
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
AND TYPE
001. email
DATE
SUBJECTfflTLE
08/07/1997
Phone No. (Partial) (1 page)
RESTRICTION
P6/b(6)
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management System [Email]
CEA ([Kagan])
OAiBox Number: 950000
FOLDER TITLE:
[08/0711997 - 0912211997]
2009-1006-F
jm50
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act - 144 U.S.c. 2204(a)1
Freedom of Information Act - 15 U.S.c. 552(b)l
PI National Security Classified Information l(a)(l) of the PRAI
P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office l(a)(2) of the PRAI
P3 Release would violate a Federal statute 1(0)(3) of the PRAI
b(l) National security classified information l(b)(l) of the FOIAI
b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
an agency l(b)(2) of the FOtAI
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute l(b)(3) of the FOtAI
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial
information I(b)(4) of the FOtAI
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(b)(6) of the FOtAI
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes l(b)(7) of the FOtAI
b(8) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
financial institutions I(b)(8) ofthe FOIAI
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
concerning wells l(b)(9) of the FOtAI
P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
financial information l(a)(4) of the PRAI
PS Release would disclose confidential advice between the President
and his advisors, or between such advisors la)(5) of the PRAI
P6 Release would constitute a clearlY unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(a)(6) of the PRAI
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
of gift.
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.c.
2201(3).
RR. Document will be reviewed upon request.
�Withdrawal/Redaction Marker
Clinton Library
DOCUMENT NO.
AND TYPE
001. email
DATE
SUBJECTffITLE
08/07/1997
Phone No. (Partial) (I page)
RESTRICTION
P61b(6)
COLLECTION:
Clinton Presidential Records
Automated Records Management System [Email]
CEA ([Kagan])
ONBox Number: 950000
FOLDER TITLE:
[08/0711997 - 0912211997]
2009-1006-F
jm50
RESTRICTION CODES
Presidential Records Act - 144 U.S.c. 2204(a)1
Freedom of Information Act - IS U.S.c. SS2(b)l
PI National Security Classified Information l(a)(l) of the PRAI
P2 Relating to the appointment to Federal office l(a)(2) of the PRAI
P3 Release would violate a Federal statute l(a)(3) of the PRAI
b(l) National security classified information l(b)(I) of the FOIAI
b(2) Release would disclose internal personnel rules and practices of
an agency l(b)(2) of the FOIAI
b(3) Release would violate a Federal statute l(b)(3) of the FOIAI
b(4) Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential or financial
information l(b)(4) of the FOlAI
b(6) Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(b)(6) of the FOIAI
b(7) Release would disclose information compiled for law enforcement
purposes I(b)(7) of the FOIAI
b(S) Release would disclose information concerning the regulation of
financial institutions l(b)(8) of the FOIAI
b(9) Release would disclose geological or geophysical information
concerning wells l(b)(9) of the FOIA)
P4 Release would disclose trade secrets or confidential commercial or
financial information l(a)(4) of the PRAI
PS Release would disclose confidential advice between the President
and his advisors, or between such advisors la)(S) of the PRAI
P6 Release would constitute a clearly unwarranted invasion of
personal privacy l(a)(6) of the PRAI
C. Closed in accordance with restrictions contained in donor's deed
of gift.
PRM. Personal record misfile defined in accordance with 44 U.S.c.
2201(3).
RR. Document will be reviewed upon request.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 1
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-AUG-1997 11:23:09.00
SUBJECT:
Friendly reminder
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD 1 )
TEXT:
Would you please call me today 5-4597? Also, in case you don't reach me
today, I want to give you my home number (I may have to be home in NJ
Friday).
I
PSI/bUS)
Thanks.
L
'"
11
00 l
Clinton Library Photocopy
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: FEDERAL
Page I of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-AUG-1997 08:56:35.00
SUBJECT:
TO: ELENA (Pager) #KAGAN ( ELENA (Pager) #KAGAN [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
please call Eli at Jordan's office 6-5701
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: FEDERAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jordan Tamagni ( CN;Jordan Tamagni/OU;WHO/O;EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-AUG-1997 10:36:59.00
SUBJECT:
TO: ELENA (Pager) #KAGAN ( ELENA (Pager)
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
goodin says he "already forgot about it."
#KAGAN [ UNKNOWN 1 )
jt
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Michele Cavataio ( CN;Michele Cavataio/OU=PIR/O=EOP [ PIR 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 11-AUG-1997 14:29:15.00
SUBJECT:
Collecting the Facts on Race
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN;Sanders D. Korenman/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Robert Wexler ( CN=Robert Wexler/OU=PIR/O;EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Audrey M. Hutchinson ( CN=Audrey M. Hutchinson/OU;PIR/O;EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Elena and Sandy,
We have been discussing the need to move ahead rapidly on collecting data
for the Race Initiative. We have set up a meeting with Judy Winston for
Wednesday and hope that some work can be done between now and then.
I reviewed the draft outline that Sandy prepared using Chris Edley's
framework.
I think that it is a good start, but it needs more detail.
We
would like for you all to identify one person with expertise to be our
main contact for each of the broad categories we are researching.
Jose
Cerda had mentioned that the DPC had identified some staff members to
serve in this capacity.
The categories where we need a contact are:
health
education
housing
crime & the criminal justice system
economic status / labor markets
political participation
public attitudes about race relations
Under each of these categories, it would be helpful to identify the
following information:
key indicators of progress
trends in disparities among races
where have positive changes occurred (especially those where government
intervention has made a difference)
where are disparities growing
costs of discrimination
data sources, upcoming studies, other resources of information
We would expect the contacts to work closely with the federal agencies to
gather this information.
Is it possible that you could bring to the Wednesday meeting the key
contacts for each of the 7 areas and have each of them bring a list of
the key data elements they would expect to collect?
please feel free to call (5-1013) or email me if you have any questions or
concerns.
Thanks very much.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page I of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Marjorie A. Black ( CN;Marjorie A. Black/OU=PIR/O;EOP [ PIR 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 11-AUG-1997 12:25:44.00
SUBJECT:
Meeting reo The Race Initiative & The Data Collection Effort
TO: Michele Cavataio ( CN=Michele Cavataio/OU=PIR/O;EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert Wexler ( CN=Robert Wexler/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN;Sanders D. Korenman/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Judith A. Winston ( CN=Judith A. Winston/OU=PIR/O=EOP @ EOP [ PIR 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Please be advised that this meeting has been scheduled to occur on
wednesday, August 13, 1997 @ 10:30.
It will take place in the PIR
Conference Room -- NEOB, Room 3236.
If the scheduled time conflicts with
anyone's schedule, please let me know ASAP.
Other attendees for this meeting include:
Michael Wenger - Deputy Director for Outreach, PIR
Claire Gonzales - Deputy Director for Communications and Media
Strategy, PIR
Thank you and we'll see you on the 13th.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Linda R. Cooper ( CN=Linda R. Cooper/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 14-AUG-1997 11:00:00.00
SUBJECT:
HHS Welfare Research and Evaluation plans mtg
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice (CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Iratha H. Waters ( CN=Iratha H. Waters/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The meeting will be on Monday, August 18th from 11:00-12:00pm, in rm 211.
Please call Linda Cooper at ext. #6-5593 if you have any questions ar
concerns.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Linda R. cooper ( CN=Linda R. Cooper/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 14-AUG-1997 14:47:33.00
SUBJECT:
HHS Welfare Research and Evaluation plans mtg
TO: Barry White ( CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria J. Hanratty ( CN=Maria J. Hanratty/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Iratha H. Waters ( CN=Iratha H. Waters/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The meeting has been rescheduled from Monday, August 18th from
11:00-12:00pm, in rm 211, to Wednesday, August 20th from 1- 2:00pm in rm.
476.
Please call Linda Cooper at ext. #6-5593 to confirm your attendance.
/
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 4
.U
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
,(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 18-AUG-1997 13:17:49.00
SUBJECT:
REMINDER: Daily Reports to POTUS
TO: Kimberly HTilley ( CN=Kimberly H Tilley/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven J. Ronnel ( CN=Steven J. Ronnel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. Malone ( CN=Michael D. Malone/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MILLISON C
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
MILLISON C @ A1 @ CD @ LNGTWY
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan Ryan ( CN=Evan Ryan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl D. Mills ( CN=Cheryl D., Mills/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1
�Page 2 of4
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Victoria Radd ( CN=Victoria Radd/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 }
TO: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
>@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patricia A. McHugh ( CN=Patricia A. McHugh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 3 of4
ARMS Email System
.'
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jill M. Blickstein ( CN=Jill M. Blickstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Harrington ( CN=Elizabeth Harrington/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: WILLIAMS A
READ: UNKNOWN
WILLIAMS A @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
(WHO)
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nelson W. Cunningham ( CN=Nelson W. Cunningham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Foster ( CN=Jonathan Foster/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ronda H. Jackson ( CN=Ronda H. Jackson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D
READ: UNKNOWN
KERRICK D @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff ( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of4
•
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ CEA 1 )
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Edward F. Hughes ( CN=Edward F. Hughes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Rebecca A. Cameron ( CN=Rebecca A. Cameron/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ana M. Duque ( CN=Ana M. Duque/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
WHO 1 )
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason ( CN=Julie E. Mason/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Himler ( CN=Janet Himler/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JOLIN_M ( JOLIN M @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(WHO)
TEXT:
We will be sending a daily memo to the President from the Chief of Staff,
updating him on issues the White House is working on / tracking while he
is on vacation.
please submit information to me via e-mail by 4pm today and everyday.
Thanks.
�f.
Page 1 of 7
ARMS Email System
, ..
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:22-AUG-1997 10:15:32.00
SUBJECT:
Long-Term Strategic Planning
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Kamensky ( CN=John Kamensky/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lael Brainard ( CN=Lael Brainard/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Chase ( CN=Cynthia M. Chase/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey M. Smith ( CN=Jeffrey M. Smith/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: TARULLO D
READ: UNKNOWN
TARULLO D @ A1 @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of7
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marc A. Silverman ( CN=Marc A. Silverman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bob A. Stone ( CN=Bob A. Stone/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Holly L. Gwin ( CN=Holly L. Gwin/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John H. Gibbons ( CN=John H. Gibbons/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Attached is a memo from Erskine to the strategy team.
e-mail is to do the following:
The purpose of this
further explain Erskine's request for a separate memo on prioritizing the
pillars;
try to frame this mOdifying-your-pillars process;
inform you of deadlines and drop-offs;
provide the modified table of contents (or "table of pillars" which is
attached); and
provide the memo, in case you have not seen it yet (attached).
First off, apologies for the lousy timing of this whole project.
The
first round with the 48-hour deadline was difficult, and this round, while
not as time sensitive, is just as vexing with so many people on vacation.
However, this round should afford some time for groups to work together.
Separate Memo on Prioritizing the Pillars
The third paragraph of EBB's memo requests that each member of the
strategy team individually rank the pillars in order of perceived
importance and briefly describe the reasoning behind their
prioritization. This request is for the core members of the strategy team
to spend some time individually thinking about their recommended vision
for the next three and one half years.
It should stimulate some creative
and thoughtful ideas for moving forward.
These memos will go directly to
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of7
Sylvia and Erskine.
I do not think that these memos will be circulated
among the group, but I will follow up on this point later.
Modifying Your Pillars
In modifying your pillars, please pay attention to the third paragraph
regarding timing, prioritizing and costs. While this process may seem not
exactly clear (understatement), I think it is useful keep in mind the
goal: On September 2, we must provide paper to the President which clearly
and succinctly provides the pillars and the choices within them and among
them.
Therefore, in modifying your pillar ask yourself 'How do I
accomplish this with my pillar?' That is, can the President see that my
pillar is prioritized? Is the time for initiating and/or completing a
particular building block clear? Can he see that the cost is already in
the budget or that it requires new spending or reprioritization of budget
funding? etc.
Deadlines & Details
As the memo states, the deadline for pillars and memos is Tuesday, August
26.
Please forward 25 copies of your pillar to me in room 164 OEOB.
Please make the deadline, as it will greatly help the Wednesday's meeting
generally (and your pillar specifically) if the participants have the
afternoon and evening to review the materials. Due to the tight deadlines
of last meeting, we were not able to distribute the pillars before the
first meeting and some of the meeting time was eaten up by the group
reading and deciphering pillars. With vacation schedules, I realize this
will be difficult too.
Modified Table of Contents
The table of contents (attached) was modified by adding campaign finance
reform and merging "Renewal of Families" and "Children."
Thank you.
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D3]MAIL456783338.216 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043B0040000010A020100000002050000001611000000020000EC7BCA7BF53C06F176B095
61095A6CD349FE91EA05799BCF94711E9AE1624009753787BCC92613F8C3CA4D527DBF898720CF
OC98B7E648AA0229B7EF084242C743738790F816D7305E267DA7E92810FED8320408FBA8AD0872
C6E88CDA25E9CDA9C3366B52742A9D99FC863F7FA9BC3DOA852EF7599266F01EBEED8CB14F746D
975BCFEF2666EC8A6BB141CFOE982A574BCE5710D4DDA5CB3046AE9901ADF4859E4BAE21373EF7
22F3EE1B49D030F523D345B41E33F447372CD7664AD2AFB59EB4E858438E44069DEED77201B19A
D69B9EOC300FCEC006041415A579EF73C87287552D2D9F7D3D2242859CBE54A7ECCB5C912B79D7
F910EAD5237631F68054F30778F1AD14F1E783EAF96876C6B1D244EAAA1C8AC008C8603732E70A
9B2C233665B3CE95E1D30F5FE5DF230CD9350F64BD8E2EF6F3AE97CC4AF7437D4E92FC7F36849C
A76153AE03EEA664386AFD214222077EE299627F1113424EB9C2CD2A963EF29CC1CA30340021F2
F479CBD9BOD65662F012AF70B09685281520E211283AFC4FC4C583A9A2C42EA70C4B7A24E108CD
325D6025B6F72F6DFDE49EBEAOOA30CCF9CD561155BB69275C47C1ABB2F6109EODA1941B020C3C
657A69980348B83DF5A6111EC7EDF7F70C7643571980CBB74B34838D31B739D56140C5F62301CA
C7D4176D2902000A00000000000000000000000823010000000B0100008C02000000550BOOOOOO
4E0000009703000009250100000006000000E50300000B300200000028000000EB030000081601
000000320000001304000008770100000040000000450400000834010000001400000085040000
0802010000000F0000009904000008050100000008000000A804000000985C005C004F0041005F
0038005C005C005C0057004500530054005F00570049004E0047005C003100360034005F004100
5F0048005000340000000000000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOO
C800C800FOOOFOOOFOOOFOOOC800C8003000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
�AUfoms"'Jo d:
'r;rJ 'leCOf'
.
LONG-TERM STRATEGY MEETING
. HeX'DlJm;~anagements
onVersion 'YStem
Pillars
1.
Education - Reed, Sperling
2.
Renewing our Cities, Welfare, Underclass - Sperling, Reed, Klain
3.
Environmental Protection - McGinty, Sperling, Gibbons
4.
Crimeillrugs/Prisons - Reed
5.
Children and Renewal of Family - Verveer, Echaveste, Reed, Sperling,
6.
Gifts to the Future - Verveer
7.
International Economic Leadership - Tarullo, Summers, Sperling
8.
Savings/Entitlement Reform - Sperling, Summers
9.
Health Care/Improving Health Status - Jennings, Reed
10. American Leadership Abroad - Berger, Steinberg
11. Science/Technology - Gibbons, Podesta, Gips, Sperling
12. Racial Reconciliation - Echaveste
13. Rego/Effectiveness of Government - Stone
14. Campaign Finance Reform - Waldman, Emanuel
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of7
1F00001500130001FEOC4E0808000102720628237206282302201F00DOCC342E80E0300COOOOOO
0072060COOE04372696D652F44727567732F507269736F6E7380848052656564D0041F00001500
130001020F520AOA000102720628237206282302201FOODOCC352E80E0300C0000000072060COO
E04368696C6472656E80616E648052656E6577616C806F668046616D696C798084805665727665
65722C804563686176657374652C80526565642C80537065726C696E672C80D0041F0000150013
00010611560COC000102720628237206282302201FOODOF20EF2CCF30EF3362E80E0300COOOOOO
0072060COOE04769&6747380746F807468658046757475726580848056657276656572D0041FOO
0015001300010A135AOEOE000102720628237206282302201FOODOCC372E80E0300C0000000072
060COOE0496E7465726E6174696F6E616C8045636F6E6F6D6963804C6561646572736869708084
80546172756C6C6F2C8053756D6D6572732C80537065726C696E67D0041F000015001300010E15
5E1010000102720628237206282302201FOODOCC382E80E0300COO00000072060COOE053617669
6E67732F456E7469746C656D656E74805265666F726D808480537065726C696E672C8053756D6D
657273D0041F000015001300011217621212000102720628237206282302201FOODOCC392E80EO
300C0000000072060COOE04865616C746880436172652F496D70726F76696E67804865616C7468
805374617475738084804A656E6E696E67732C8052656564D0041F000015001300011619661414
000102720628237206282302201FOODOF20EF2CCF30EF3D304360000160001B00406002C010058
0200B00482C20100B80B97580201B00406002C0100580200B0040072060060099858023600D331
302E80E0300C0000000072060COOE0416D65726963616E804C656164657273686970804162726F
61648084804265726765722C80537465696E62657267D0041FOOOO15001300011A1B6A16160001
02720628237206282302201FOODOCC31312E80E0300C0000000072060COOE0536369656E63652F
546563686E6F6C6F6779808480476962626F6E732C80506F64657374612C80476970732C805370
65726C696E67D0041F000015001300011E1D6E1818000102720628237206282302201FOODOCC31
322E80E0300C0000000072060COOE052616369616C805265636F6E63696C696174696F6E808480
80456368617665737465D0041F00001500130001221F721A1A000102720628237206282302201F
00DOCC31332E80E0300C0000000072060COOE05265676F2F4566666563746976656E657373806F
6680476F7665726E6D656E7480848053746F6E65D41B230086010200080058021C880000580202
008A0202008A02C715F70500002300D4D41B1F00870102000800260214D60A0026020000580202
0058021C881FOOD4D0041F000015001300012621761C1C000102720628237206282302201FOODO
CCD41B230086010200080058021C88000058020A0026020200260214D6860B00002300D4D41B1F
008701020008008A02C71502008A0200005802020058021C881FOOD431342EE0110C0000000072
060COOE043616D706169676E8046696E616E6365805265666F726D80848057616C646D616E2C80
456D616E75656CD41B230086010200080058021C880000580202008A0202008A02C715E80BOOOO
2300D4F30CF3
================== END ATTACHMENT
1 ==================
==================== ATTACHMENT
2 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
COMMENT
AUTHOR : Elizabeth Nichols
OPERATOR : Elizabeth Nichols
COMMENT :
PRINTER FONT 10 POINT ROMAN
Possible GPO Reports To Access from Dept. Of Education:
AUfomafe~e~~~rdmpS Mcanage'!lent System
1.
on versIon
[HEHS
o
-94
o
-169BRl Early Childhood Programs: Many Poor Children and Strained
Resources Challenge Head Start
SUMMARY:The number of children under age five who are at risk of school
failure
increased greatly during the 1980s. Education reform and the reauthorization
of Head Start-
o
-the centerpiece of federal early childhood programs-
o
-have
�ARMS Email System
".
Automated Records Management SystelJ1
Hex-Dump Conversion
Page 6 of7
focused attention on improving the quality of early childhood programs and
increasing the number of children being served.
This report highlights the
major themes and policy implications for implementing Head Start and other
early childhood programs.
GAO concludes that efforts to improve the quality
of the Head Start program and expand it to include more children are
complicated by several factors: the growing numbers and changing
characteristics of poor children, rising costs of services, and limited
community resources.
2.
[HRD
o
-94
o
-21] School
o
-Linked Human Services: A Comprehensive Strategy for
Aiding
Students at Risk of School Failure
SUMMARY: Since 1980, at least 8 states and more than 200 localities have been
delivering a variety of health, social, and educational services to
students-
o
-many of whom are at risk of failing in school or dropping out. These
comprehensive school
o
-linked programs are trying to improve the academic
performance and well
o
-being of at
o
-risk students by addressing their many needs
in a coordinated manner at schools.
Some policymakers view these programs as
an efficient, cost
o
-effective way to link at
o
-risk children and their families
with prevention and early intervention services.
literature to determine the kinds of school
This report (1) reviews the
o
-linked approaches involving
students and their families, the relative strengths and weaknesses of these
approaches, and the circumstances under which each appears most appropriate;
(2) identifies the problems encountered when using the school as a hub for
delivering services; and (3) determines the role that the federal government
could
play in promoting promising school
o
-linked approaches.
3. [HEHS
o
-95
o
-4FS] Early Childhood Programs: Multiple Programs and Overlapping
Target
Groups
SUMMARY: This report responds to a congressional request for information on
early childhood programs-
o
-that is, preschool and child care programs for
�ARMS Email System
Page 7 of7
children from birth through age five. In
Automated Records Managem!lnl Sy§t@m
Hex-Dump Conversilm ~ . ' '
summary, GAO found that in fiscal years 1992 and 1993, the federal government
funded more than 90 early childhood programs in 11 federal agencies and 20
offices. Of these programs, 34 were key programs-
o
-early childhood programs"for
which early childhood education or child care is the key to the program's
mission. These key programs delivered services to at least two million
children below age five and spent at least $3.66 billion in fiscal year 1992.
However, data are limited on the exact number of children served and the
dollars spent on children below age five. Although these programs have some
similarities, they may target different populations, use different eligibility
criteria, and provide a different mix of services to children and their
families.
4.
[HEHS
o
-95
o
-21] Early Childhood Centers: Services to Prepare Children for
School Often
Limited
SUMMARY:More than a third-
o
-2.8 million-
o
-of the nation's children aged three
and
four were from poor families in 1990, a growth of 17 percent since 1980. This
trend continues. These disadvantaged youngster often live in homes that
provide little intellectual stimulation, as well as inadequate health care and
nutrition. Lagging behind their middle- and upper'
o
-income peers when they enter
school, many disadvantaged children never catch up.
Early childhood centers
funded by federal and state government prepare children from school and help
them to overcome their disadvantages.
This report answers the following
questions: What
services do disadvantaged children need to be prepared for,school? To what
extent do these children receive these services from early childhood centers?
If disadvantaged children do not receive these services from early childhood
centers, why not?
==================
END ATTACHMENT
2
==================
�AJ3MS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:25-AUG-1997 11:27:47.00
SUBJECT:
Strategic Planning Team Meeting
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
'READ : UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: John H. Gibbons ( CN=John H. Gibbons/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 2 of3
ARMS Email System
,.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Sidney BlumenthaljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. SosnikjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John PodestajOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Sandra L. Via ( CN=Sandra L. ViajOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. TaylorjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine ButtonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. RustiquejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisabeth Steele ( CN=Elisabeth SteelejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. WilliamsjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura EmmettjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. KaplajOU=CEQjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. CappsjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. TingenjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. MoranjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Susanne Bachtel ( CN=Susanne BachteljOU=OSTPjO=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. GravesjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Evan Ryan ( CN=Evan RyanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne DalejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie TarmeyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B BengtsonjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�•
ARMS Email System
"
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a meeting on the above subject on Wednesday, August 27 at
10:00am in the Roosevelt Room. This meeting should last 1-1/2 - 2
Please direct any questions that you may have to Andrew Mayock
hours.
at 6-7492.
Attendees:
Sylvia Mathews
John Podesta
Rahm Emanuel
Doug Sosnik
Paul Begala
Ann Lewis
Sid 'Blumenthal
Michael Waldman
Gene Sperling
Sandy Berger
Katie McGinty
Jack Gibbons
Bruce Reed
Elena Kagan
Ron Klain
Don Gips
Melanne Verveer
Frank Raines
Jack Lew
Secretary Rubin/Deputy Secretary Summers
Janet Yellen
Maria Echaveste
Goody Marshall
,Mickey Ibarra
John Hilley
Page 3 of3
�Page I of2
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:25-AUG-1997 17:25:25.00
SUBJECT:
Memos on Strategic Planning
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John H. Gibbons ( CN=John H. Gibbons/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Holly L. Gwin ( CN;Holly L. Gwin/OU;OSTP/O;EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN;Katharine Button/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN;Debbie B Bengtson/O;OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN;Russell W. Horwitz/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ruby Shamir ( CN;Ruby Shamir/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN;Shelley N. Fidler/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN;Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robert S. Kapla ( CN;Robert S. Kapla/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN;Marjorie Tarmey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN;Cathy R. Mays/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN;Melissa Green/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
This e-mail is to inform you about the process of reviewing your strategic
planning memos, (which prioritize the pillars and give a brief description
of the reasons for your prioritization) :
The content of these memos will be shared with the strategic team.
However, the authors' names will NOT be shared with the strategic team.
Thanks.
Page 2 of2
�.
Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
~
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN:Andrew J. Mayock/OU:WHO/O:EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:25-AUG-1997 17:28:44.00
SUBJECT:
Reminder: pillars and Memos due Tomorrow.
TO: Ruby Shamir ( CN:Ruby Shamir/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN:Cynthia A. Rice/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Kamensky ( CN:John Kamensky/OU:OMB/O:EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lael, Brainard ( CN:Lael Brainard/OU:CEA/O:EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN:Peter R. Orszag/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN:Michael Waldman/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN:Christopher C. Jennings/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN:Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Holly L. Gwin ( CN:Holly L. Gwin/OU:OSTP/O:EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN:Kathleen A. McGinty/OU:CEQ/O:EOP@ EOP [ CEQ 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katharine Button ( CN:Katharine Button/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN:Debbie B Bengtson/O:OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN:Russell W. Horwitz/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN:Shelley N. Fidler/OU:CEQ/O:EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey M. Smith ( CN:Jeffrey M. Smith/OU:OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: TARULLO D
READ: UNKNOWN
TARULLO D @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU:WHO/O:EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marc A. Silverman ( CN:Marc A. Silverman/OU:OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
[ OPD 1
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
,.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN;Sara M. Latham/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Chase ( CN=Cynthia M. Chase/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OSTP 1 )
TO: Robert S. Kapla ( CN;Robert S. Kapla/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN;Donald H. Gips/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN;Marjorie Tarmey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN;Cathy R. Mays/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa Green ( CN;Melissa Green/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The deadline for pillars and memos is tomorrow Tuesday, August 26 by noon
please forward 25 copies of your pillar and one copy of the memo to me in
room 164 OEOB.
Again, please make the deadline, as it will greatly help Wednesday's
meeting generally (and your pillar specifically) if the participants have
the afternoon and evening to review the materials.
Thank you.
�'..
ARMS Email System
.
Page 1 of2
~')"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE!TIME:2"6-AUG-1997 13:32:41.00
SUBJECT:
Strategic Planning Memos
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed!OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB!O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty!OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John H. Gibbons ( CN=John H. Gibbons/OU=OSTP!O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
••
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Holly L. Gwin ( CN=Holly L. Gwin/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Regarding your memos that prioritize the pillars and describe the reasons
for your prioritization, please send a signed hard copy and e-mail a soft
copy to me.
The hard copy is for Erskine, Sylvia and John.
The soft copy will allow your memos to be merged into one document for
dissemination among the strategic planning team.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 4
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-AUG-1997 11:24:14.00
SUBJECT:
Strategic Planning Team Meeting
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John.L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr (CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John H. Gibbons ( CN=John H. Gibbons/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: coolcatmat ( coolcatmat @ aol.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Sandra L. via ( CN=Sandra L. Via/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisabeth Steele ( CN=Elisabeth Steele/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Demond T. Martin ( CN=Demond T. Martin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Susanne Bachtel ( CN=Susanne Bachtel/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Evan Ryan ( CN=Evan Ryan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Debra A. Schiff ( CN=Debra A. Schiff/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a continuation of this morning's Strategic Planning meeting
from 4:00-6:00 pm (today)
in the Roosevelt Room.
Attendees:
sylvia Mathews
John Podesta
Rahm Emanuel
Doug Sosnik
Paul Begala
Ann Lewis
Sid Blumenthal
Michael Waldman
Gene Sperling
Sandy Berger
Katie McGinty
Jack Gibbons
Bruce Reed
Elena Kagan
Ron Klain
Don Gips
Melanne Verveer
Frank Raines
Jack Lew
Secretary Rubin/Deputy Secretary Summers
Janet Yellen
Maria Echaveste
Page 3 of4
�ARMS Email System
Goody Marshall
Mickey Ibarra
John Hilley
Chris Jennings
Mark Penn
Page 4 of4
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 4
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-AUG-1997 13:04:31.00
SUBJECT:
Strategic Planning Team Meeting
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN '
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
[ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John H. Gibbons
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=John H. Gibbons/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
. READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: coolcatmat ( coolcatmat @ aol.com @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Sandra L. Via ( CN=Sandra L. Via/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisabeth Steele ( CN=Elisabeth Steele/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Alice H. Williams
( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett
( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC:
CC: Demond T. Martin ( CN=Demond T. Martin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Susanne Bachtel ( CN=Susanne Bachtel/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet L. Graves
( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 3 of4
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Evan Ryan ( CN=Evan Ryan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be another meeting on Strategic Planning tomorrow (Thursday)
from 9:00 to 10:30 am in the Roosevelt Room.
Attendees:
Sylvia Mathews
John Podesta
Rahm Emanuel
Doug Sosnik
Paul Begala
Ann Lewis
Sid Blumenthal
Michael Waldman
Gene Sperling
Sandy Berger
Katie McGinty
Jack Gibbons
Bruce Reed
Elena Kagan
Ron Klain
Don Gips
Melanne Verveer
Frank Raines
Jack Lew
Secretary Rubin/Deputy Secretary Summers
Janet Yellen
Maria Echaveste
Goody Marshall
Mickey Ibarra
John Hilley
�ARMS Email System
Chris Jennings
Mark Penn
Page 4 of4
�~RMS
Email System
Page 1 of 4
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-AUG-1997 08:27:32.00
SUBJECT:
Strategic Planning Team Meeting
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Micke~
Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO 1 )
CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John H. Gibbons ( CN=John H. Gibbons/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
coolcatmat ( coolcatmat @ aol.com @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
cc:
Sandra L. Via ( CN=Sandra L. Via/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Dan J. Taylor
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
cc:
Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Elisabeth Steele ( CN=Elisabeth Steele/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UN)CNOWN
CC: Demond T. Martin ( CN=Demond.T. Martin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Susanne Bachtel ( CN=Susanne Bachtel/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�Page 3 of4
1RMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Evan Ryan ( CN=Evan Ryan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU='WHO/O=EOP
READ:UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Debra A. Schiff ( CN=Debra A. Schiff/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be another installment of the Strategic Planning meetings from
10:00am -12:00 noon (today) in the Roosevelt Room.
Attendees:
sylvia Mathews
John Podesta
Rahm Emanuel
Doug Sosnik
Paul Begala
Ann Lewis
Sid Blumenthal
Michael Waldman
Gene Sperling
Sandy Berger
Katie McGinty
Jack Gibbons
Bruce Reed
Elena Kagan
Ron Klain
Don Gips
Melanne Verveer
Frank Raines
Jack Lew
Secretary Rubin/Deputy Secretary Summers
Janet Yellen
Maria Echaveste
�~RMS
Email System
Goody Marshall
Mickey Ibarra
John Hilley
Chris Jennings
Mark Penn
Andrew Mayock
Page 4 of4
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of4
...
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-AUG-1997 13:01:47.00
SUBJECT:
Strategic Planning Team Meeting
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. Begala/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall Jr/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Franklin D. Raines ( CN=Franklin D. Raines/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J .. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John H. Gibbons ( CN=John H. Gibbons/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney Blumenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
cc: Demond T. Martin ( CN=Demond T. Martin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Susanne Bachtel ( CN=Susanne Bachtel/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Janet L. Graves ( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Evan Ryan ( CN=Evan Ryan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: coolcatmat ( coolcatmat @ aol.com @ inet
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
CC: Sandra L. Via ( CN=Sandra L. Via/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Elisabeth Steele ( CN=Elisabeth Steele/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Debra A. Schiff ( CN=Debra A. Schiff/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a Strategic Planning meeting from 1:00 - 2:30 pm on Tuesday,
September 2 in the Roosevelt Room.
Attendees:
Erskine Bowles
Sylvia Mathews
John Podesta
Rahm Emanuel
Doug Sosnik
Paul Begala
Ann Lewis
Sid Blumenthal
Michael Waldman
Gene Sperling
Sandy Berger
Katie McGinty
Jack Gibbons
Bruce Reed
Elena Kagan
Ron Klain
�.,
ARMS Email System
Don Gips
Melanne Verveer
Frank Raines
Jack Lew
Secretary Rubin/Deputy Secretary Summers
Janet Yellen
Maria Echaveste
Goody Marshall
Mickey Ibarra
John Hilley
Chris Jennings
Mark Penn
Michael McCurry
Andrew Mayock
Page 4 of4
�.
ARMS Email System
1
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. TurnerjOU=WHOjO=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:29-AUG-1997 13:02:09.00
SUBJECT:
Pillars Document Return
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jenningsjou=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. MayockjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey IbarrajOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria EchavestejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron KlainjO=Ovp @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. ReedjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGihtyjOU=CEQjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael WaldmanjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. LewisjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. EmanueljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul E. Begala ( CN=Paul E. BegalajOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. HilleyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thurgood Marshall Jr ( CN=Thurgood Marshall JrjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen ( CN=Janet L.YellenjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: John H. Gibbons ( CN=John H. GibbonsjOU=OSTPjO=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. SperlingjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sidney Blumenthal ( CN=Sidney BlumenthaljOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: coolcatmat ( coolcatmat @ aol.com @ inet [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Sandra L. Via ( CN=Sandra L. Via/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Dan J. Taylor ( CN=Dan J. Taylor/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisabeth Steele ( CN=Elisabeth Steele/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Robert S. Kapla
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ CEA 1 )
[ WHO 1 )
CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Demond T. Martin ( CN=Demond T. Martin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Susanne Bachtel
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Susanne Bachtel/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
CC: Janet L. Graves
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Janet L. Graves/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
CC: Evan Ryan ( CN=Evan Ryan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
1 )
CC: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�A~S
Email System
/.
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ruby Shamir ( CN=Ruby Shamir/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Reminder: If you have not done so already, please return your pillars
document to Andrew Mayock in room 164 no later than 6:00 pm today.
Thanks.
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Einail System
-
Page 1 of5
~~
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 14-SEP-1997 18:25:04.00
SUBJECT:
The President's CA/NY trip
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO.: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews (. CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN=Julia R. Green/OU=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius ( CN=Catherine A. Cornelius/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E: Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 3 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN;Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel to San Francisco, California on Thursday,
September 18, 1997, for personal/family time and education and DNC
events. On Saturday night, September 20, he will travel from California
to New York for the opening session of the United Nations General Assembly.
Deadlines for the President's Trip Book are as follows:
CA Background Memos:
CA Event
DUE, TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 16 at 6:00 P.M.
Political Memo
Economic I-Pager
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
Memos:
DUE, WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 17 at 6:00 P.M.
Education Event
DNC Luncheon/Dinner and Saxophone Club Reception
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 15-SEP-1997 17:58:53.00
SUBJECT:
Weekly Strategy Meeting
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Murchinson ( CN=Jonathan Murchinson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn B. Stack ( CN=Kathryn B. Stack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
,
TO: Donald H. Gips ( CN=Donald H. Gips/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of2
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana FortunajOU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth S. Apfel ( CN=Kenneth S. Apfel/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jessica L. Gibson ( CN=Jessica L. Gibson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Linda R. Cooper ( CN=Linda R. Cooper/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. RustiquejOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Angelique PirozzijOU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
CC: Lisa J. Levin ( CN=Lisa J. Levin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We will be having our weekly Welfare Reform Strategy Meeting tomorrow,
Tuesday, September 16, at 4:00 p.m. IN ROOM 211, OEOB.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:22-SEP-1997 09:44:40.00
SUBJECT:
Trip to Pittsburgh, Little Rock and Houston
TO: Jon P. Jennings ( CN=Jon P. Jennings/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=CecilyC. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh. ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN=Julia R. Green/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Fi·nney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU~WHO/O=EOP @ EOP[ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
WHO 1 )
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius ( CN=Catherine A. Cornelius/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 3 of5
ARMS Email System
,.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan H. Adashek ( CN=Jonathan H. Adashek/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola!OU=CEQ!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Michael V. Terrell!OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP
CEQ 1 )
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber!OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 ).
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN .
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
Page 4 of5
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
On Wednesday, September 24, the President will travel to Pittsburgh to
address the AFL-CIO Convention and attend a DNC lunch.
From there he will
travel to Little Rock, where, on Thursday, he will lead the 40th
anniversary commemoration of the Central High desegregation and attend a
Congressional Medal of Honor Society Reception.
On Friday, the President
will travel to Houston, TX for a message event and a DNC dinner. He will
then return to Little Rock.
Over the weekend of September 27-28, the
President will attend a number of events in Arkansas and then return to
Washington on Sunday evening.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are as follows:
PA, AR and TX Background Memos:
DUE TUESDAY, SEPT. 23 AT NOON
Political Memos
Economic 1-Pagers
CEQ Hot Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Accomplishments
PA & AR Event Memos:
DUE TUESDAY, SEPT. 23 AT 6:00 PM
AFL-CIO Event
DNC Lunch (Pittsburgh)
Central High and Related Events/Meetings
Cong'l Medal of Honor Reception
TX & AR (Part II) Event Memos:
DUE THURSDAY, SEPT. 25 AT 3:
Houston Message Event
Houston DNC Dinner
Radio Address
Arkansas weekend events, as warranted
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[08/07/1997 – 09/22/1997]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 097 - Folder 005
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/0e8eb2d06cc5bd86b1cc316ebb1b36a2.pdf
69a791a77802e081b87c54299ffeec6a
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 097 - FOLDER -004
[07/01/1997-08/06/1997]
�,.ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Lisa M. Kountoupes ( CN=Lisa M. Kountoupes/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 1-JUL-1997 19:25:22.00
SUBJECT:
URGENT REVIEW OF BUDGET LETTER NEEDED
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: FOLEY_M ( FOLEY M @ A1 @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
(WHO)
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Barbara Chow ( CN=Barbara Chow/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet L. Yellen' ( CN=Janet L. Yellen/OU=CEA/O~EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN·
CC: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lawrence J. Haas ( CN=Lawrence J. Haas/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mark J. Mazur ( CN=Mark J. Mazur/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
FYI
you should have received in hard copy the following memo delivered
to your offices
with followup phone calls.
July 1, 1997
MEMORANDUM TO SYLVIA MATHEWS
JOHN PODESTA
JANET YELLEN
GENE SPERLING
JOHN HILLEY
MARTHA FOLEY
BARBARA CHOW
BRUCE REED
ELANA KAGAN
FROM:
Larry Haas
Lisa- Kountoupes
RE:
URGENT -- Budget ConfereesO, Letter
Enclosed is the draft conference letter. Unfortunately, we need
you to turn this around
in short order.
Congress has requested that we deliver it as soon
as possible, and we
want to do so by mid-day.
Please provide us with any mark-ups of
hard copy by 9 a.m.
tomorrow (Wednesday) -- at the latest. Unfortunately, we wonO,t
be able to use electronic
comments. Larry is in Room 253 or at fax 5-6818.
Lisa is in Room
249 or at fax 5-3729.
We apologize for the short turn-around, but our staffs have been
crashing all day just
to get this draft done for your perusal and, for many reasons, we
believe it will help our ,
efforts to deliver our views as specifically and as quickly as
possible.
Thank you for your help.
cc:
Jack Lew
Josh Gotbaum
�\
ARMS Email System
r _
Page 1 of34
_ ! ..'
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD ]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 2-JUL-1997 15:55:00.00
SUBJECT:
Products memo
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB']
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Timothy J. Brennan ( CN=Timothy J. Brennan/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=william P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven D. Aitken ( CN=Steven D. Aitken/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Brown ( CN=Lisa M. Brown/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
)
)
TEXT:
These are the cover memo for the products memo and the memo itself.
Melissa (Gene's assistant) is sending the memo directly to the
addressees.
PLEASE NOTE THE TIGHT TIMEFRAME.
I'd really appreciate your
continued help in moving this along. You've all been great so far.
Thanks so much.
Ellen==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D47]MAIL46338528Y.116 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750439A040000010A0201000000020500000049130000000200007BBA36A3EBA9E1041127EF
FE68EB1B646AC1F4E939085E73145AC9650D4FCAE8577918C3D2595CE6D2AFC1DD81E1CA4F1A9F
EA664B741FE6A3E0241B9AEDF10FBD9C81974499E8DAAD4587CFDFF236E059FD61CDECBB70A95A
418FCE444E713EOC84CE9D1DF1CA2D653D4D8CCB976AB3BD133813F1FEB016FAD96DA49C70A08B
ODDl12824DADF5BB0684ABF4C3A8321D3F677D2E1CF6F26BB25A385E9090382E1DC540407F2616
A36E21454EA525EB2D6A31EC8433149BF1F48DOCC2E1914592E81279D31B03B1F2B71503C13542
7AFEF09CA4EFOCEBFD3DB069821DF53E90152206382BA06E1A8E53FF729A598DA70710AB138423
OAE71D5D99C7E3443820E879ABC8E19152C5EF89208488EB2C563DFB8B00772743123927782899
C6C3B67EA01B5648BF29C407B6558401D4AODB8E39B363B5F763F4CF3B593EE6567E3909DCA157
28DDE53B70D9368B67409ABE15120E049F4E9EC19BFC9FF1EEDB656705054DB487DFF77208C169
942462E783C604191D85FB94686A8626BE30AA122E4EC9555B4DEFFBF52C18DOC477F483FF6CE9
�.,
July 2,1997
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
MEMORANDUM FOR
SECRETARY RUBIN
SECRETARY DALEY
SECRETARY SHALALA
ADMINISTRATOR ALVAREZ
DIRECTOR RAINES
CHAIR YELLEN
CHAIR BROWN
DEPUTY SECRETARY SUMMERS
JOHN DWYER
JOHN HILLEY
CHARLES RUFF
BRUCE LINDSEY
BRUCE REED
ELENA KAGAN
ERSKINE BOWLES
JOHN PODESTA
SYLVIA MATTHEWS
RONKLAIN
CHARLES BURSON
FROM:
GENE SPERLING
SUBJECT:
Draft product liability memo
Attached is a draft memo to the President on federal product liability law, based on our discussions last week.
We ask two things: (i) your comments, edits and thoughts; and (ii) your choice among the three
recommendations set out.
Ideally, we would like your response by noon tomorrow, July 3. Please forward comments to Ellen
Seidman of my staff, who can be reached at 456-5359 or by fax at 456-1605. We apologize for the short
timeframe, but we are attempting to get this memo in to the President before he leaves Washington tomorrow
evening. Even noon is going to be hard; we hope the memo is sufficiently reflective of our discussions that
turning it around in time is feasible. Please call me if you have any serious problems with this time frame.
Thank you all for your help, and for that of your staffs, in getting through this process.
cc:
Andrew Pincus
Jeffrey Hunker
Fran Allegra
Donald Remy
Tom McGivern
Ed Murphy
Ron Matzner
Pam Gilbert
Michael Deich
Steve Aitken
Tim Brennan
Tracey Thornton
Peter Jacoby
Bill Marshall
Lisa Brown
�.,
Automa~ Recorda Management System
H~mp Conversion
Draft:March 2,2010 (1 :16PM)
SUBJECT:
Product liability legislation
I. ACTION FORCING EVENT: On May 1, on a strict party line vote, the Senate Commerce
Committee reported out S.648, Senator Gorton's revision of the product liability bill you vetoed
last year. Senator Rockefeller not only voted against S.648, but has made it very clear that he
will not join until your concerns are satisfied, and Senator Gorton understands that without
Senator Rockefeller's support, the bill cannot pass. On the other hand, Senator Lott has been
pushing to bring the bill to the floor, leading Senator Rockefeller (together with Mr. Dingell) to
press us to negotiate changes in the bill to meet your concern. Senator Lott may well want to
move soon after the July 4 recess. Meanwhile, Senator Breaux is urging us to work with him on
an alternative to the Gorton bill.
II. BACKGROUND: The 104th Congress passed product liability reform law -- a part of the
Contract with America -- by a vote of259 to 158 in the House and 59 to 40 in the Senate. The
bill would have partially preempted state law as to both standards of liability for sellers and
manufacturers of products that cause bodily harm and measures and allocation of damages. On
May 2, 1996, you vetoed the bill, citing eight issues:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Interference with state prerogatives in tort law
One-way preemption, where pro-consumer state laws were preempted, but laws that
limited consumer rights were not
The cap on punitive damages, particularly in light of the Statement of Managers, which
virtually directed judges not to use the "additur" provision included in the bill under
which caps could be superseded
Several -- not joint -- liability for non-economic damages
A too-short (15 years), too-broad (all products) statute of repose
Preemption of state negligent entrustment statutes, which make sellers of dangerous
goods (e.g., firearms and liquor) responsible for certain actions of the buyers
Failure to toll the statute of limitations during the period of a stay issued by a bankruptcy
court
Application of the limits on liability of biomedical materials suppliers to negligent
suppliers
The House failed to override your veto by a vote of258 to 163 to override. The House having
failed to override, the Senate never took a vote.
III. CURRENT CONGRESSIONAL ACTIVITY
A. S.648
�Automated Records Managel!1ent System
Hex-Dump Conversion
.
-2-
Draft:March 2,2010 (1 :16PM)
S.648 fixes the bankruptcy tolling problem, and makes an honest -- although not complete -attempt to respond to the negligent entrustment issue. Moreover, it lengthens the statute of
repose to 18 years, and establishes two-way preemption for the statute of repose, so that shorter
state statutes would be lengthened (all state statutes that are set in years are shorter than 18
years). The bill does not respond to the two major problems you cited -- the cap on punitives
and several liability for non-economic damages -- nor does it change the biomedical materials
provision.
B. Senator Rockefeller and Mr. Dingell
Senator Rockefeller and Mr. Dingell are clearly looking for guidance on how to resolve the
remaining issues (punitive damages, several liability for non-economic damages, statute of
repose and biomedical materials) to meet both the concerns and fact patterns in your veto
message. They have said they will engage in negotiations with us (clearly they do not expect to
be able to accept our initial proposal) to develop legislation that will pass and will not be vetoed.
Senator Rockefeller, in particular, has said he has no interest in another veto.
C. Senator Breaux
Senator Breaux would like to deal with this issue in an entirely different way. He has developed
a bill focused far more on reducing frivolous lawsuits and less on substantive product liability
standards. Senator Breauxls bill would include a statute of repose that is more flexible than that
in S.648, would establish uniform federal standards for punitives damages but no cap, and would
do nothing to change state law concerning joint and several liability for non-economic damages. 1
His bill would also set stricter pleading standards for federal and state court product liability
actions, restrict multi-state product liability class actions, enact a very weak form of alternative
dispute resolution, and require a study by the Attorney General of the product liability system. It
is unclear how far Senator Breaux can get in moving support off the Gorton bill without the
Administration's support for his approach.
D. Consumer groups and other advocates
Consumer groups and others are strongly opposed to any legislation in this area, and have stated
that they view you as "the last bastion against tort deform." The American Bar Association has
written you in opposition to any federal legislation primarily on federalism grounds, but also
raising concerns that overlaying partial tort law preemption on the legal systems of fifty states
will cause more confusion and uncertainty, not less.
III. MAJOR ISSUES PRESENTED:
1 As discussed below, many states, including California, already have several liability for
non-economic damages.
�.,
AlitoiMtM fteeo!Os Manage,!,ent System
Hex.t)\lmp Conversion
-3-
Draft:March 2,2010 (1:16PM)
Over the past eight weeks, we have jointly run an interagency process to consider whether there
might be ways to alter S.648 to respond to the concerns in your veto message in a manner that
could be acceptable to at least Democratic proponents of the legislation. Participants in the
process included: OVP, NEC, DPC, OMB, CEA, White House Counsel, White House
Legislative Affairs, Justice, Treasury, Commerce, and SBA and the Consumer Product Safety
Commission as an advisor. FDA is participating in the discussion of biomedical materials. The
working group surveyed the law in all the states on the critical issues of punitive damages, joint
and several liability and statute of repose, and developed a number of alternatives in each area
that we believe could move the bill.closer (and in some cases, all the way) to your goals but may
have a chance of not being rejected out of hand byproponents.z Two meetings of the NEC
principals were held, on June 24 and 26.
A. Whether there should be federal legislation in this area at all
The arguments of the business community in favor of national legislation rest on three
propositions:
• Concern about product liability litigation, and particularly concern about disproportionate
awards for non-economic damages and punitive damages, is sapping American
productivity by misdirecting management time and energy and capital and by putting an
excessive -- and frequently non-insurable tax -- on innovation.
• In a national economy, subjecting products and manufacturers to 50 different liability
regimes is not only inefficient but also -- because of the opportunities for forum shopping
by plaintiffs, particularly in class actions, unfair.
• Manufacturers are the deep pocket focus ofliability suits that are in fact generated by the
activities of those who repair and service products; making manufacturer liability more
limited an predictable -- as occurred when the 18-year statute of repose was instituted for
aircraft -- will put the burden of care of those most responsible for and able to accomplish
it.
Consumer groups, as well as lawyers (the ABA as well as ATLA), argue against the need for
federal legislation based on:
• The lack of any explosion of product liability suits, and in particular, excessive punitive
damage awards that survive judicial remittitur, suggesting there's no problem to be fixed.
• The fact that all recent proposals in this area would cut back on traditional principles of
tort law that benefit plaintiffs, suggesting that what the manufacturers want is not
uniformity but a tilt in their direction
• The traditional role of the states in tort law, combined with the fact that all existing
proposals would only partially preempt state tort law, leading to even more
2 Based on discussions with the Center for Violence Policy, we have also crafted a more complete
fix to the negligent entrustment provision. We believe there will be no problem getting the proponents to
adopt this.
�'.
Automated Records Manage'!lent System
Hex.Dump Conversion
-4-
•
Draft:March 2,2010 (1 :16PM)
non-unifonnity and uncertainty as this law is overlaid on, e.g., state medical malpractice
law.
Whatever limitations are initially included in federal product liability legislation will be
vulnerable to cutbacks in future Congresses; the time to stop erosion is before it starts
B. One-way or two-way preemption
One of the most contentious issues that runs through the legislation is whether federal standards
should preempt all state laws ("two-way preemption") or whether they should function solely as
a floor, with states free to establish more defendant-friendly standards ("one-way preemption").
For example, if the federal statute of repose were 18 years, two-way preemption would both
lengthen shorter statutes and impose the 18-year limitation in states that have no statute of
repose; one-way preemption would only lengthen shorter statutes. Similarly, if the federal
government were to enact standards for awarding punitive damages, two-way preemption would
both tighten the standard in states that, for example, allow punitives to be awarded for reckless
behavior and require states that do not allow punitives at all to allow them according to the
federal standards. One-way preemption would only tighten standards in some states, leaving
others free to bar punitives entirely.
The bill you vetoed last year was almost entirely one-way preemptive. In your veto message you
said, "As a rule, this bill displaces State law only when that law is more favorable to consumers;
it defers to State law when that law is more helpful to manufacturers and sellers. I cannot
accept, absent compelling reasons, such a one-way street of federalism. As noted above, S.648
is two-way preemptive as to the statute of repose (as well as with respect to the general standards
of manufacturer and seller liability and the statute of limitations) but retains one-way preemption
on punitive damages. 3
While one of the arguments manufacturers and sellers make in favor of national legislation is the
desire to create unifonn federal standards, which would support uniform two-way preemption, on
the two issues where they have made serious headway in the states -- limitations on punitive
damages and imposition of several liability -- they are far more interested in a federal floor than
in unifonnity. We have been told, for example, that establishing the right to punitive damages
in states where it does not exist, or limiting several liability for non-economic damages where
state law has established it, would be totally unacceptable.
Consumer groups argue in favor of two-way preemption, ostensibly on the ground that the only
good reason for federal standards is uniformity. However, many of these same groups regularly
argue that federal environmental and consumer protection standards should function only as a
floor, allowing states to impose more rigorous rules. It is conceivable that the consumer
argument for two-way preemption is more an effort to highlight the inconsistency in the
3 In fonn, S.648 is two-way preemptive on several liability for non-economic damages.
However, since it imposes the least plaintiff-friendly rule possible (totally several liability), it is effectively
one-way preemptive.
�Automated Records Manage~ent System
Hex-Dump Conversion
-5-
Draft:March 2, 2010 (1:16PM)
manufacturers' position -- and perhaps to raise an insurmountable barrier to legislation -- than a
finnly held constitutional principle.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
-6-
c.
ESDraft:March 2, 20 10 (I :16PM)
Several liability for non-economic damages
Over the last several years, tort refonTI at the state level has essentially done away with the
traditional rule of no comparative fault and full joint and several liability. (Only Alabama,
Maryland, North Carolina and Virginia retain this combination.) Nine states4 have full joint and
several liability, but include comparative fault, thereby reducing the defendants' joint
responsibility by the measure of the plaintiffs responsibility. Thirteen states 5 have pure several
liability, for both economic and non-economic damages, and 24 states have various hybrid fOnTIs.
Both last year's vetoed bill and S.648 limit a defendant's responsibility for non-economic
damages "in direct proportion to the percentage of responsibility of the defendant for the harm to
the claimant." The trier offact is required to assign this percentage taking into account the
responsibility of all persons responsible, including those not before the court, such as settling
defendants.
In vetoing last year's bill with respect to this issue, you cited the provision's general effect of
preventing "many persons from receiving full compensation for injury," noting in particular the
problems created by insolvent defendants. You also cited the particular impact of a several rule
for non-economic damages as unfairly discriminating against "the most vulnerable members of
our society." You said, "Noneconomic damages are as real and as important to victims as
economic damages."
Manufacturers assert that the problem with joint liability for non-economic damages is that such
damages -- unlike economic damages -- are totally unpredictable and subject to the whim of the
jury, thereby making any assessment of the risk, or the purchase of insurance against the risk,
virtually impossible. They are particularly concerned about the potential for a large award
against the only solvent defendant in a case in which that defendant is only marginally at fault.
Opponents make the argument that non-economic damages are as real and as important -particularly to the poor, the young and the old -- as economic damages, and should not be treated
differently. Some also contend that the different state standards represent the innovation and
experimentation that is the role of the states, and this should not be preempted.
D. Punitive damages
4 Arkansas, Delaware, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South
Carolina and West Virginia
Alaska, Arizona, Colorado, Illinois, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, North Dakota, Tennessee, Utah,
Vennont and Wyoming
5
�Automated Records Manage,!,ent System
Hex-Dump Conversion
-7-
ESDraft:March 2, 20 I 0 (I: 16PM)
The process of awarding punitive damages and the amount of such damages have been the
subject of some of the most intense controversy. Both last year's vetoed bill and S.648 cap
punitive damages -- at the greater of two times compensatories (including non-economic
damages) or $250,000 for most companies and the lesser of these two amounts for individuals
and small businesses. Upon consideration of a list of eight factors 6, a judge could award
damages in excess of the large business cap (but not the small business cap), up to the amount
awarded by the jury, which would not be informed of the cap.? The "additur" provision
explicitly constitutes one-way preemption -- it does not permit additur where state law otherwise
limits punitive damages.
The bills would also: (i) establish a uniform federal standard of proof of "clear and convincing";
(ii) establish a uniform standard for award that conduct "carried out with conscious, flagrant
indifference to the rights or safety of others was the proximate cause" of the harm; and (iii)
authorize any party to request that punitive damages be considered in a separate proceeding
(generally so that evidence of the defendant's financial condition would not be allowed into
evidence during the liability and compensatory damages phase ofthe trial). While these rules are
meant to apply in all states that have punitive damages, they would not apply in states where
punitive damages are prohibited by law. 8
In vetoing last year's bill, you stated that you "oppose arbitrary ceilings on punitive damages,
because they endanger the safety of the public. Capping punitive damages undermines their very
6 The factors are: "(i) the extent to which the defendant acted with actual malice; (ii) the
likelihood that serious harm would arise from the conduct of the defendant; (iii) the degree of the
awareness of the defendant of that likelihood; (iv) the profitability of the misconduct to the defendant; (v)
the duration of the misconduct and any concurrent or subsequent concealment of the conduct by the
defendant; (vi) the attitude and conduct of the defendant upon the discovery of the misconduct and
whether the misconduct has terminated; (vii) the financial condition of the defendant; (viii) the cumulative
deterrent effect of other losses, damages, and punishment suffered by the defendant as a result of the
misconduct, reducing the amount of punitive damages on the basis of the economic impact and severity of
all measures to which the defendant has been or may be subjected ... "
? The judge would be required to hold a separate proceeding on awarding an additional amount,
consider each of the items, and state the court's reasons for an award above the cap in findings of fact and
conclusions of law. A separate finding on each factor is not explicitly required. The conference report
on last year's bill, of course, virtually directed judges not to use this authority.
In seven states punitive damages are generally forbidden; in 16 others, they are capped in one
way or another. Twenty-seven states allow unlimited punitive damages in product liability cases. Most
states that allow punitive damages have adopted the "clear and convincing" evidentiary standard. While
the liability standards are less uniform, only a few states allow the award of punitive damages for reckless
behavior without some other aggravating factor. We have not found any state that requires that the
conduct leading to the punitive damages be the "proximate cause" of the plaintiff's harm, although the
words "cause" and "result" are used. Bifurcated trials -- at least on the issue of the defendant's financial
condition -- are allowed or required in 15 states.
8
�.,
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
-8-
ESDraft:March 2, 2010 (I :16PM)
purpose, which is to punish and thereby deter egregious misconduct. " You noted that the
additur provision might have mitigated this concern,. but the Statement of Managers virtually
directing it not be used made it ineffective in that respect.
Manufacturers assert that unpredictable and unjustifiably large punitive damage awards have
driven them out of markets and irp,pinged on innovations. Consumer advocates assert that only
potentially unlimited punitive damages can deter harmful misconduct by large companies.
Surveys suggest that neither the award ofpunitives nor the amount is skyrocketing in products
cases. 9
E. Statute of repose
At its starkest, a statute of repose bars litigation after a product has been in service a specified
period of time. Twenty-two states and the District of Columbia currently have statutes of repose
for product liability; 17 of the states and the District restrict lawsuits after a specified number of
years (ranging from 5 to 15) and the remainder use some variation of ''useful life" as the bar. In
1994, you signed legislation establishing a preemptive 18-year statute of repose for general
aviation.
The bill you vetoed last year included a preemptive IS-year statute of repose for all products.
The statute would, however, only have preempted states without any statute of repose, or with a
statute longer than IS years. Shorter state statutes would have remained effective. Your veto
message referenced the length of the statute, the fact that it was broadly inclusive (you cited
handguns), and the fact that the preemption was only one way. The Senate bill from the 104th
Congress had covered only durable goods in the workplace and had an 18-year one-way
preemptive statute.
S. 648, as reported out of the Senate Commerce Committee on a voice vote, includes a fully
(two-way) preemptive 18-year statute of repose, covering all products except: (i) motor vehicles,
vessels, aircraft and trains used to transport passengers for hire; (ii) products that cause toxic
harm; and (iii) products with express written warranties that exceed 18 years.
Manufacturers assert that a firm, and broad, statute of repose is necessary not only to provide
them some certainty, but also to put the risk of injury from long-lived products on those most
able to prevent it -- owners, up graders and servicers. They argue that the 18-year statute of
repose for general aviation you signed in 1994 has not only increased the willingness of
manufacturers to produce the aircraft, but has made owners and servicers far more careful,
9 A recently-released Rand study has found an increase in the number and amount of punitive
damage awards in financial fraud cases, such as cases involving insurance or fmancial products
misrepresentation. This does not appear to extend to cases involving products as defined in the bill, which
is limited to physical goods.
�Automated Records Manage,!,ent System
Hex-Dump Conversion
-9-
Draft:March 2, 20 10 (I: 16PM)
because they understand the deep pocket of the manufacturers will not be available to bail them
out.
Consumers, on the other hand, argue that injuries from long-lived products -- including those that
have not been altered or do not need service -- are common, and often the manufacturer should
have foreseen and prevented the problem that caused the injury. They argue it is particularly
important that those injured by long-lived consumer goods (such as camping equipment and
cedar chests) not be barred from court completely by a strict statute of repose. Workers, they
note, at least can collect worker's compensation for injuries caused by long-lived defective
goods in the workplace.
IV. ALTERNATIVES
Working from the alternatives developed by the working group in each of the three major areas
identified, your advisors concluded that the choice.of alternatives really depends on another
decision, whether the Administration should:
• take the position that state law developments and the lack of strong evidence of major
problems in this area that are caused by lack of national standards leads us to conclude no
federal legislation is appropriate at this time;
• put forward a series of proposals that are fully consistent with both your veto statement
and the principle of promoting national uniformity, even if such proposals have little or
no chance ofleading to'a bill that can be enacted; or
• put forward a series of proposals that product liability legislation proponents will regard
as an acceptable place to start negotiations and that can, albeit with some difficulty, be
squared with your veto message.
Some of your economic advisors believe the business community may be correct in asserting that
the current tort liability system, and in particular the issues raised in this legislation, over-deter
businesses in their development and production of innovative products. In our discussions with
the business community, we have asked them to provide empirical evidence that innovation has
been stymied by litigation in general or the issues that particularly concern us: punitive damages
and several liability for non-economic damages. Unfortunately, empirical evidence is not
available, and the anecdotes relate to pharmaceuticals or related products, and often to the issues
raised by mass tort claims for economic compensatory damages, not non-economic damages or
punitive damages ..
As your advisors looked into the issue, we came to the following conclusions:
• While logically there might be some impact on manufacturing innovation and
productivity from the tort system,
• there is no empirical evidence
• all the anecdotal evidence is from one sector -- pharmaceuticals, including vaccines -but the legislative proposals are far broader
• there is no explosion of either litigation or punitive damages
�Automated Records Manage~ent System
Hex-Dump ConversIon
-10•
•
•
•
Draft:March 2,2010 (1: 16PM)
• the economy is booming and productivity is rising
Over the past several years ~- indeed, even since the start of the 104th Congress -- the
states have made major moves toward making the tort system more defendant-friendly,
ranging from the virtual abandonment of traditional principles of joint and several
liability to the imposition of caps on punitive damages
If federal legislation is not to lead to uniform national standards, there is little justification
for it; there is little or no justification for one-way preemption
Overlaying'limited product liability preemption on the tort law and civil procedure of 50
states will likely increase confusion and uncertainty, not decrease it
Recent Supreme Court decisions, including the Brady bill decision, may call into question
the constitutionality of federal legislation that attempts to mandate changes in state law
and judicial procedure
Thus, while there continues to be sentiment among your economic advisors for "doing
something" to improve the tort system, it is mild and tempered by the recognition that current
proposals may do as much harm as good. Your legal advisors do not believe the current
proposals should be supported. Both groups of advisors feel strongly that if there is to be any
federal legislation, it should establish uniform national standards, and should -- in the areas
explicitly covered -- completely preempt the field. There is no justification for one-way
preemption in this area.
This position can be manifest in two ways: taking a strong against any legislation, or developing
an Administration bill that is consistent with both the veto statement and the current state of the
law, even ifthat bill cannot be reconciled with the prime tenets of the Gorton bill.
A. Oppose federal product liability legislation at this time
-=-__:--_____--,--__--:---,----,-_----:-_[, names of advisors] recommend that you take a
firm and overt stance against any federal product liability legislation at this time. Recent
changes in state law as well as in federal constitutional law, combined with the lack of t:vidence
of serious widespread problems suggest that the burden of showing why traditional state
prerogatives in this area should be overruled and state law overlaid with potentially incompatible
federal law has not been met. Iflegislation is needed in the area of pharmaceuticals (including
vaccines), then it should be pursued on a targeted basis, taking advantage of -- and protecting-the strong federal regulatory system for drugs.
B. Develop an Administration bill we can support, consistent with both the veto statement
and the current state of the law
The hallmarks of this option are: (i) full two-way preemption, such that states with currently
more defendant-friendly laws would be brought to a uniform national level as well as states
whose laws are currently more pro-plaintiff; (ii) consistency with your veto message in all
�Automated Records Manage~ent System
Hex.Dump Conversion
-11-
Draft:March 2, 2010 (1:16PM)
respects; and (iii) inclusion of items that were not part of either the vetoed bill or S.648 that can
enhance the effectiveness of the legal system for injured plaintiffs.
This option does not include any provision on joint and several liability for non-economic
damages. Since part of the focus of your veto message was on the unfairness of distinguishing
between economic and non-economic damages, no provision that deals only with non-economic
damages can be fully consistent with the veto message. Moreover, we have reason to believe
some proponents oflegislation would be willing to put forward an alternative without any change
in joint and several liability. However, we also know the business community regards this as an
important issue but, given current trends in state law toward several liability, they will be
extremely unlikely to accept two-way preemption in this area. Appendix A contains alternative
formulations of joint and several liability for non-economic damages that were developed by the
working group, together with pros and cons.
This option would consist of the following:
Punitive damages - Advisory jury opinion with judicial determination and a breach able
cap for small businesses, two-way preemption
• The jury would render a solely advisory opinion on punitive damages
• The actual determination of punitive damages would be made by the judge
• The judge would be required to consider the factors in S.648, and would be required to
explain why the judge's award differs (either higher or lower) from the jury's advice
• The judge could allocate a portion of punitive damages to the state rather than to the
plaintiff
• Cap punitive damages at the lesser of twice compensatories or $250,000 for firms that
have 10 or fewer employees and annual revenues of $1 million or less. The jury would
not be told of the cap, and the judge could award damages in excess of the cap only upon
a specific finding that damages in excess of the capped amount were not only needed "to
punish or deter," but also that the financial impact of the higher award had on the
defendant and its employees had been explicitly considered by the judge.
• Couple this with procedural changes to set the evidentiary standard at "clear and
convincing evidence," the substantive standard at "willful and wanton" (excluding
recklessness), and to require bifurcation of the damages determination if requested by any
party
Pros
• Is analogous to criminal law, by keeping the jury involved but placing the decision on
what is essentially a punishment in the hands of the person most experienced in deciding
such issues, the judge
• Since historically, punitive damage awards that seem unjustified have stemmed from jury
decisions, may increase rationality in the system
• Provides some protection for truly small businesses, responding to one ofthe complaints
about the capriciousness ofpunitives
�Automated Records Manage~ent System
Hex-Dump Conversion
-12 -
Draft:March 2, 2010 (1:16PM)
Since businesses of the size described are rarely hit with significant punitive damages,
since in most states the defendant's financial condition is already taken into
consideration, there may be little practical negative effect.
• Allows the Administration to agree with some sort of cap
• By adopting the S.648 factors, may be seen as a good faith offer
Cons
• Agreeing to any cap at all breaks through a clear line we established last year of "no caps
on punitives"; it may be very difficult to hold the line against expansion of this cap, either
to larger businesses, or by limiting the judge's discretion
• Any proposal that limits punitive damages in any way may be seen as tipping our hand -or limiting our options -- with respect to the tobacco settlement
• Takes away from the jury what has been regarded as a traditional jury function
• While judges may determine punitive damages in many states in cases where they are the
trier of fact, only Connecticut and Kansas provide for initial judicial determination (in
contrast to appellate review or remittitur) where a jury has sat
• Unlikely to solve concerns of either proponents or opponents of caps; consumer groups
and lawyers have not favored judicial determination
• May raise difficult Seventh Amendment issues ("no fact tried by a jury shall be otherwise
reexamined in any court of the United States than according to the rules of common law")
• Making it fully two-way preemptive, thus forcing some states to allow punitive damages
that do not currently do so, is likely to be regarded as both unacceptable and
inflammatory by the business community
•
Statute of repose
• Two-way preemption of state law (as in S.648)
• 18 year statute of repose (as in S.648)
• Which a plaintiff may overcome by clear and convincing evidence that the product had a
longer useful safe life (not included in S.648, and responsive to the victim of the
hay-baler accident cited in the veto message and to accidents involving products clearly
intended to be longer-lived, such as elevators and most firearms)
• Covering only durable goods in the workplace (narrower than S.648, retaining plaintiff
rights concerning consumer goods in states without any statute of repose and responding
to your concern about handguns)
• With further exceptions for toxic substances, vehicles used in transportation for hire, and
express warranties (as in S.648)
• And with a provision that extends the statute to allow full benefit of the two-year statute
oflimitations after injury or discovery of harm in, for example, year 17 (not in S.648, but
not expected to be a problem)
Pros
• By building on S.648, demonstrates good faith to proponents of that legislation
• Two-way preemption is responsive to principles of veto message, and also lengthens
statute in the 22 states that have them
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
-13•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Draft:March 2, 2010 (1: 16PM)
Number of years is longer than in any current state statute
Rebuttable presumption protects workers injured by products clearly intended to be
longer-lived
Bright line number of years, combined with clear and convincing standard, means
manufacturers will be free from arguments about whether something was intended to
have a useful life slightly longer than 18 years
By restricting statute to durable goods in the workplace, consumers in states without
statutes of repose retain their access to court for injuries from long-lived or
intermittently-used consumer goods such as cedar chests and camping and baby products
Until late last year, all formulations of this statute had been limited to durable goods in
the workplace, in part because those injured in such accident will at least have received
some compensation through workers compensation
Expands on an already-existing federal liability scheme -- workers compensation
Exceptions protect access to court in latent defect cases
Cons
Opponents of product liability reform will oppose any statute of repose as limiting
plaintiffs' rights in states without such statutes
Combination of two-way preemption and bright line (even with rebuttable presumption
and limitation only to durable goods in the workplace), will restrict the access of some
injured parties to court
Proponents of S.648 may regard rebuttable presumption and limitation to durable goods
in the workplace as unacceptable limitations, particularly given that they extended the
statute from 15 to 18 years and made preemption two-way in response to the veto
message
In addition to these proposals, we recommend that option 1 include items plaintiffs believe could
make a real difference in their ability to recover, as well as provisions in the Breaux draft:
• Provision for alternative dispute resolution for small claims that both defendants and
plaintiffs would find appealing
• Limitations on the use of protective orders where disclosure of the information is relevant
to the public health or safety unless disclosure is clearly outweighed by a substantial
interest in maintaining the confidentiality of the records
• Stricter pleading requirements and limitations on multi-state class actions where parties
allege different types of damages
• A requirement for a study of the product liability system by the Attorney General
The first of these items might -- depending on how it is drafted -- gain the support of both
plaintiffs (who cannot find lawyers to take small claims through the traditional legal system for a
contingency fee) and defendants. The second (based on a bill that has been introduced by
Senator Kohl) would be strongly supported by consumer groups and -- in light of the tobacco
revelations probably could generate strong public support -- but would certainly be opposed by
defendants and perhaps even by the plaintiff bar. The third and fourth provisions are from the
Breaux draft. The class action may not be giving up much from the plaintiffs' perspective given
the Supreme Court's recent decision overturning the asbestos settlement.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
_ 14 _
Draft:March 2, 2010 (1 : 16PM)
This option is recommended by _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ,[names of advisors]
c.
Make a proposal that has a viable chance of starting negotiations with proponents
As described in the specific pros and cons below, the items in this option cannot be completely
squared with your veto statement. On the other hand, they represent real movement toward
responding to your objections. However, it is critical to recognize that once these options are
on the table, negotiations may take them even farther afield, and lead to a negative
dynamic in which bill supporters think they've come "most of the way" toward your
position and assert that refusal to support their bill amounts to "moving the goalposts."
The danger with this option rests far less in its particular parameters than in the slippery slope it
sends us down.
Again, no provision on several liability for non-economic damages is included, based on
indications some proponents may be willing to move without such a provision. Appendix A
contains options developed by the working group, of which only Proposal2B is likely to be
acceptable at all to the business community.
This option would consist of:
Punitive damages - Cap with easier breakthrough, one-way preemption
• Cap punitive damages at the greater of $250,000 or twice compensatories (the lesser of
the two for small businesses)
• Do not tell the jury of the cap
• Allow the judge to award punitive damages above the cap (for both small and large
businesses) without an additional proceeding and on a simple finding that the capped
amount is "insufficient to punish or deter," the standard in 8.648, with no consideration
of specified factors
• Insist that there be no legislative history suggesting this authority is to be used any more
sparingly than implied by the statutory standard
• Couple this with procedural changes to set the evidentiary standard at "clear and
convincing evidence," the substantive standard at "willful and wanton" (excluding
recklessness), and to require bifurcation of the damages detennination if requested by any
party
• This would be two-way preemptive, except with respect to states that do not allow
punitives in products cases at all
Pros
• Closest to both 8.648 and earlier versions of bill, and thus likely to be most easily
regarded as acceptable by proponents
• Particularly given that there are few punitive damage awards in excess of the cap and that
judges now have remittitur authority, this would likely have little practical impact on
actual awards
• The procedural changes may produce more unifonnity across the country
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
-15 -
Draft:March 2,2010 (1 :I6PM)
•
Making the additur provision two-way preemptive is a real improvement for plaintiffs
compared to S.648
Cons
• This looks like a cap on punitive damages, which you said you opposed; "no caps on
punitives" has been used as a shorthand description ofthe Administration's firmest
position
• It may actually be a cap with judges reluctant to award punitives
• Holding the line on the legislative history can be very difficult, particularly if the statute
is acceptable in.all other respects
Statute of repose
The proposal would be the same as under option 1, which we believe will be regarded as a
good faith offer to negotiate.
The primary dangers with this strategy are the likelihood that opponents will not believe even the
initial positions are consistent with the veto statement, and that it will be relatively easy for the
other side to make what look like cosmetic changes that may in fact be quite significant. For
example, deleting the plaintiff s option to breach the 18-year statute of repose by a clear and
convincing showing that the useful safe life was intended to be longer -- a likely demand of the
manufacturing community -- would look minor, but in fact would work a major change in that it
completely shut the courtroom door on plaintiffs in the many states with no statute of repose.
This option is recommended by _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ [names of advisors]
V. DECISIONS:
Let's take the offensive against any federal product liability legislation
Propose option B to Senator Rockefeller, understanding he will not regard it as a
serious offer.
Discuss the offer with Senator Breaux before making it public, and make
common cause with him ifhe's interested
Make the offer public to head off claims by bill proponents that we did not
have anything to offer
Propose option C to Senator Rockefeller, making explicit that this is a best and final
offer and any further movement will result in a veto
Propose option C to Senator Rockefeller, being prepared to negotiate
None of the options is good. We need to talk.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
-16-
Draft:March 2,2010 (1:16PM)
APPENDIX A
Options on Joint and Several Liability for Non-Economic Damages·
The fonnulations described below reduce the negative impact of imposing several liability for
non-economic damages. However, any fonnulation that does not guarantee the plaintiff 100%
of non-economic damages (where there is any solvent and available defendant) is discriminatory
against non-economic damages in those states that retain joint liability for economic damages.
Assuming you do not want to put several liability for economic damages into play, you should be
aware that all of the options described -- except pure reallocation -- have this flaw.
Infonned by various state law provisions concerning joint and several liability, your advisors
considered fonnulations for federal preemption involving the following concepts:
• Several liability with reallocation among remaining defendants (and plaintiff if the
plaintiff is at fault) in the event the amount allocated to any defendant is uncollectible
(thus guaranteeing plaintiffs 100% recovery for the portion of the damage not their fault,
but sparing low-fault, deep-pocket defendants the need to sue for contribution)
• Setting a level of fault below which only several liability will apply (thus responding to
the concerns oflow-fault deep-pocket defendants)
• Setting a threshold offault below which several liability will apply, but with a multiplier
(thereby guaranteeing the plaintiff some recovery where only the low-fault defendants are
solvent)
• Guaranteeing the plaintiff a specified percentage of recovery of non-economic damages
• The extent to which plaintiff fault will be taken into account to reduce recovery for
non-economic damages
• Special rules for small businesses, particularly as to responsibility for more than their
share of damages
• Two-way preemption, which would be meaningful if federal law were less pro-plaintiff
than some state laws
Working on the assumption that you wished us to develop proposals that include several liability
for non-economic damages -- so as to be able to convince those favoring product liability of our
good faith, but that are least restrictive of the rights ofplaintjffs, your advisors developed the
following alternative fonnulations relating only to non-economic damages:
Proposall- ReaUocation lO
• Joint and several if the plaintiff is fault-free
10
This is based on the statute currently in effect in Missouri.
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
-17 -
D~aft:March
2, 2010 (1: 16PM)
•
If the plaintiff is at all at fault, liability is several, but if the plaintiff cannot collect from
one or more defendant after a specified period of time I I , the plaintiff can petition the
court for reallocation of damages not attributable to the plaintiff among the remaining
defendants, but no defendant less at fault than the plaintiff may be charged with more
than twice his proportionate share of damages
• This would be two-way preemptive
Pros
• Preserves balance between faultless plaintiff and defendant with any fault in favor of the
plaintiff
• Is generally consistent -- or at least not less pro-plaintiff -- with the laws of most states l2
• Where plaintiff is at fault, less culpable defendants -- even if they are deep pockets -- will
have their damages limited
• Of all the potential limitations, is most likely to retain 100% recovery for non-economic
damages
• By retaining joint and several liability in many situations, should encourage settlement
Cons
• May be viewed as excessively pro-plaintiff, and thus not a good-faith offer, particularly if
it is two-way, thus increasing defendants' responsibility in states, such as California, with
several liability for non-economic damages
• May limit plaintiff s recovery where plaintiff is at fault and there are multiple defendants
• Requires fact-finders in (the 13) states that currently do not have comparative fault or
several liability to assign degrees of responsibility
• Shifts from defendants to plaintiffs the responsibility for collecting from each defendant,
potentially adding to delay in recovering and increased expense
• As among defendants, it is unclear why the extent ofthe plaintiffs responsibility should
have an impact on defendants' responsibility to pay the judgment
Proposal 2A - Guaranteed recovery, two-way preemption
• Joint and several liability of any defendant is than 30% at fault (taking into account the
fault of the plaintiff and settling defendants)
• If any defendant is less than 30% at fault, that defendant's responsibility would be limited
to a maximum oftwice the defendant's proportionate share of non-economic damages
except where a greater multiplier was needed to ensure the plaintiff recovery of at least
50% of the assessed non-economic damages.
11 In Missouri it is 30 days, which may be too short to actually encourage the plaintiff to try to
collect; in Connecticut it is one year, which may be too long.
Only plaintiffs with some degree of fault in the four states that retain traditional no comparative
fault/joint and several liability would be significantly disadvantaged; plaintiffs in the nine states with
comparative fault and joint and several liability could be somewhat disadvantaged. Plaintiffs in states
with any further restrictions would likely benefit.
12
�•
Automated Records Management System
Hex.()ump Conversion
-18 -
Draft:March 2, 2010 (1: 16PM)
Proposal2B - Guaranteed recovery, one-way preemption
• Joint and several liability of any defendant is than 10% at fault (taking into account the
fault of the plaintiff and settling defendants)
• If any defendant is less than 10% at fault, that defendant's responsibility would be limited
to a maximum of twice the defendant's proportionate share of non-economic damages
except where a greater multiplier was needed to ensure the plaintiff recovery of at least
60% of the assessed non-economic damages.
Pros
• Should be seen by proponents of limitation as a good-faith offer, with real limits
• Preserves joint and several liability for defendants with significant degree of fault
• Ensures that no low-fault defendant will have to pay more than 50% (or 60%, if one-way)
of total non-economic damages, and that in most cases they will be limited to their
proportionate share
• Although it limits responsibility oflow-fault defendants, it guarantees that plaintiff will
collect substantial portion of assessed non-economic damages (if there are any solvent
and available defendants)
• The two-way preemption version would increase plaintiff's guaranteed level of recovery
in states with several liability for non-economic damages (such as California and Illinois),
and thus might be considered an acceptable tradeoff for limitation on guaranteed recovery
in other states
Cons
• Setting the guaranteed recovery level at 50% or 60% (or, in fact, any level lower than
100%) may be viewed as non-responsive to both the objections in the veto statement-not full recovery, and discrimination against non-economic damages
• Will require fact-finders in the 13 states that don't have both comparative negligence and
several liability to make additional determinations
• Defendants who view themselves as likely to be low-fault deep pockets will object that
their potential for payment of non-economic damages is so high that they cannot take
limitations into account in either settlement discussions or purchase of insurance
• Small degrees of differentiation of fault -- e.g., between 9% and 11 % -- could have major
repercussions on responsibility to pay damages
Your advisors recommend that proposal 1 be the first one we explore with proponents of product
liability. It is by far the most consistent with the veto statement. If, however, it is rejected out
of hand by product liability proponents, and you believe it is essential that we continue to
negotiate, we would recommend Proposal 2A, which includes two-way preemption. We should
make it very clear that if forced to one-way preemption, we would only accept a proposal with a
significantly higher level of guaranteed recovery for the plaintiff (e.g., 60%), and a significantly
lower threshold offor imposition of several liability (e.g., 10%).
Areas where we believe some negotiation could be possible include:
�'.
Automated Records Management System
Hex·Dump Conversion
•
•
-19 -
Draft:March 2, 201 0 (1: 16PM)
Some decrease in the minimum level of recovery for two-way preemption (we would
put an absolute floor at 50% for one-way preemption and 40% for two-way preemption)
Some increase in the threshold for imposition of joint and several liability (we would put
an absolute ceiling of 35% for two-way preemption and 15% for one-way preemption)
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 8-JUL-1997 15:19:39.00
SUBJECT:
race initiative meeting
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Elena,
I have written he table of contents/outline for the background report
discussed at the meeting with Chris Edley.
Peter, Alicia and Ed
Montgomery provided input. How would you like to proceed?
Sandy
we
�Page 1 of 4
ARMS Email System
_fo
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUL-1997 19:00:01.00
SUBJECT:
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD ] )
TEXT:
Elena,
Attached is a draft of the outline/table of contents for the race
initiative chapter I mentioned in my last e-mail message to you.
Sandy
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D19]MAIL455396983.116 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF57504370040000010A02010000000205000000681B0000000200002C89350056134617D8CD9A
AC2303894B557AD235364FEF4478BFAE14125C172A18BCE5164057B9A8586120ACB6BA33DAD091
E299FAB500D405157932E07CA6180BEF0960B89E36CB1DA8F88DB3A88DCBFOF2AD1593528DDCAC
E657AE885D612707552B4E015084E9C6D93CE4F8674BFA213E81A0562CCD448B9D4A2143031E67
OA635EEA54215DC585A64A7EOC16A6ECE446EOOB83D4C59EF92FAOE6FFFA7917B6F15438C53EAE
23BD5B42F005AE753A2238059348724D4A9C52F8CFEOABD38DDCl154617A1F02BFD7B7F53D460A
10D4F7347AOFDF69DCAD2AA5C71737C457D193E2D6B5590CC48142D138AFF5293C46D9F7A331B4
81380519CA73E2B470360732807F4BB60555D1E90DA2D6ED108F6AFD51A1A92BFOFDBBABB67EEA
6085F2B0987D86174F3098902125D614C7E1354B966E95E245AF47B406CF5BFF404A8FE566347D
1EF09C79EA31168FE6BC5BOC68E350FE9FE249711782DB24BDD918OCCA55F847E8C92B73FFAA15
068AB5B8A597A1905E1626516AOEB5F8D109A14E95555C30F3F76C2OC29012B6039C6CBF5CF4BO
5E17DEFCE9F34F02910F698069AFE309046DB2B922B5873E1F4253FEC6DB4CE7E4A1276E088E40
883EFA96F6AA6EF3DDE52F8BF2B9376587543CBD313DDOB6EB299ABC42EE4663E8CFECD339A5D5
48475EF3E602000900000000000000000000000823010000000B0100007E020000005501000000
4E0000008903000009250100000006000000D70300000B300200000028000000DD030000087701
000000400000000504000008340100000014000000450400000802010000000F00000059040000
OB0501000000080000006804000000985C005C004F0041005F0036005C005C005C004300450041
005F0032005C003300320038005F00410000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800C8002C012C012C012C01C800
CB0030000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000B0100002800C81968104BOD000011090000005AOOOBOI0000103600540069006D0065
00730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E00200052006500670075006C0061007200
000000000000000001000200580201000000040028000000000000000000000000000000000000
00011202002400A1000000A10000000A0000000606010045000706010045000806010002000906
020002000A06010045000B06010002000C06030045000D06020017000E06010017000F06010002
005A5458210000000000000000000000000000000008337C007800000200000F06000003010004
0002000000DDOA10008301040003000200211000DDDDOBOB00030000040BOODDF1000E06F19BCC
D3050C0007010002000COOD39C4A756C7980399B2C8031393937CCD305100006010000021DOOOO
001000D3CCCC544F3AE0110COOOOOOOOOB070COOEOE0110COOOOOOO060090COOE04A616E657480
9C59656C6C656E9BD0041500000B000900017008C003040001201500DOCC46524F4D3AE0110COO
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Part I: Demography·
.1. Racial composition of the US population: 1990s and historical trends
2. Geographic distribution
3. Components of change: birth, death and immigration
4. Projections
Part II: Disparities in the 1990s and trends in disparities
1. Economic status
a. Income and Poverty
b. Labor markets
employment, unemployment, non-employment
hours
wages and non-wage compensation
occupation/industry
non-wage characteristics of jobs (e.g., working conditions, healths risks)
disability
c. Wealth/credit
financial
business ownership
home ownership
retirement wealth
credit and credit institutions
2. Educational status
a. Enrollment
Drop out rates; college enrollment and completion rates
b. Quality of schooling
c. Achievement
d. Training
3. Health status and health care
a. Health status
Pregnancy and infancy
Child hood and young adulthood
Adulthood
Older ages
{Specific diseases or conditions}
b. Health care
Insurance
Availability of health services
Health behaviors
�4. Political status
a. Voting
b. Holding public office
c. Other political participation
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
5. Criminal justice
a. Offenders and victims
b. Criminal justice process (sentencing etc.)
6. Family organization
a. Family structure
b. Other family patterns (fostering, adoption, extension etc.)
c. Living arrangements and family support of the older population
7. Impact of immigration
a. Labor markets
b. Education
c. Other
Part III: Race relations
1. Racial attitudes and behaviors
(ACD is very good on history of black white attitudes/opinions. Needs to be
expanded to other groups and updated.)
2. Racial segregation
Residences
Schools
Workplaces
Other
3. Bias crimes, etc.
4. Developments in the 1990s
Rodney King beating trials and riots
OJ Simpson trials
The Bell Curve controversy
Challenge to Affirmative Action in California
Part IV: Discrimination
1. Measurement/methods: econometric vs. audit studies
2. Links between discrimination and outcomes.
(Issue: Audit studies prove discrimination exists, but how much of the disparities
documented in Part II can be attributed, directly or indirectly, to discrimination?)
3. Causes of discriminatory behavior
4. Consequences of discrimination for society
Has the nature of discrimination changed?
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP [ OSTP 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:10-JUL-1997 12:45:00.00
SUBJECT:
Copies of the Final Koop-Kessler Report
TO: Elizabeth Drye ( CN=Elizabeth Drye/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Toby Donenfeld ( CN=Toby Donenfeld/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Daniel K. Tarullo ( CN=Daniel K. Tarullo/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Richard J. Turman ( CN=Richard J. Turman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mark J. Mazur ( CN=Mark J.
READ: UNKNOWN
Mazur/OU=CEA/O~EOP @
EOP [ CEA 1 )
CC: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone!OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
I can get additional copies of the report if they are needed.
available at: www.science-policy.com!tobacco/report.htm
It is also
�(.
ARMS Email System
u
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of6
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 11-JUL-1997 14:00:23.00
SUBJECT:
Pittsburgh/Chicago travel
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart M. Schear ( CN=Stuart M. Schear/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=·EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�"
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire.( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson ( CN=Brian J. Johnson/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN=Julia R. Green/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius ( CN=Catherine A. Cornelius/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lorraine L. Wytkind ( CN=Lorraine L. Wytkind/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Anna C. White ( CN=Anna C. White/OU=WHO/O=EOP @EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ:UNKNOWN
WHO 1 )
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 4 of6
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stefanie Sanford ( CN=Stefanie Sanford/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: April K. Mellody ( CN=April K. Mellody/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King ( CN=Angus S. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 5 of6
ARMS Email System
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 ) .
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Drye ( CN=Elizabeth Drye/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe ( CN=Marilyn DiGiacobbe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel to Pittsburgh (NAACP Convention) and Chicago
(Natl Assn of Black Journalists) on Thursday, July 17.
Deadlines for the tripbook are as follows:
Background Material - both Western PA and Illinois - DUE TUESDAY, JULY 15
at 6: 00 PM
Political memo (2)
Economic background (2)
Cabinet issues (2)
CEQ issues (2)
�•
ARfiS Email System
Event memos - DUE WEDNESDAY, JULY 16 at 6:00 PM
NAACP - Ben Johnson
Black Journalists - Ann Walker
Please call me or Sean Maloney with any questions. Sean has just joined
our office as the second Deputy Staff Secretary and will be working on
trips as well.
Page 6 of6
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 1
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman!OU=CEA!O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE!TIME:14-JUL-1997 08:58:19.00
SUBJECT:
Re :
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Elena,
I am in all day.
Sandy
My phone is 395-4597.
�ARMS Email System
.,
Page 1 of 3
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Elizabeth Drye ( CN=Elizabeth Drye/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 15-JUL-1997 17:35:29.00
SUBJECT:
URGENT: USDA draft letter supporting Tobacco crop insurance
TO: Mark J. Mazur ( CN=Mark J. Mazur/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Jerold R. Mande/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary L. Smith ( CN=Mary L. Smith/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
USDA wants immediate clearance of a letter opposing a Lowey amendment that
would deny crop insurance and crop disaster relief for tobacco crops.
USDA's position is outlined below.
Their position makes sense to me, but
we should word it carefully.
I'll get the letter. What do you think?
---------------------- Forwarded by Elizabeth Drye/OPD/EOP on 07/15/97
05:30 PM ---------------------------
Alecia Ward
07/15/97 05:23:02 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Elizabeth Drye/OPD/EOP
cc:
Subject:
URGENT: USDA draft letter supporting Tobacco crop insurance
Elizabeth,
Just wanted to make sure that you are aware of this.
TJ is fine
supporting the USDA position, but wants to weigh in with others in the EOP
to see if there are problems of which he is not aware.
Thanks.
Al
---------------------- Forwarded by Alecia Ward/OMB/EOP on 07/15/97 05:22
PM ---------------------------
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
Mark A. Weatherly
07/15/97 04:44:58 PM
Record
Record Type:
To:
See the distribution list at the bottom of this message
cc:
Ronald M. Cogswell/OMB/EOP, Alecia Ward/OMB/EOP, Jim R.
Esquea/OMB/EOP, Stephen M. Frerichs/OMB/EOP
Subject:
URGENT: USDA draft letter supporting Tobacco crop insurance
House Ag Appropriatons Subcommittee Chairman Skeen has asked Sec.
to send a letter to counter an expected floor amendment tomorrow,
Secretary would like to send the letter today.
The amendment, to
offered by Congo Lowey (D-NY), would prohibit USDA from offerring
insurance or crop disaster assistance for tobacco - starting with
year's crop and forevermore thereafter.
Glickman
and the
be
crop
next
The draft USDA post ion is that "USDA is strongly opposed to this amendment
The letter states that crop insurance is the principal remaining
safety net for farmers who suffer crop losses; that most tobacco farmers
operate small farms and form an important part of the economy of many
rural areas; and that the Administration supports a "safety net" (as the
President cited when he signed the 1996 Farm Bill). It also recalls the
hurricanes of last year that hit tobacco growers hard in North and South
Carolina and Virginia, for which crop insurance provided significant
indemnity payments.
The Administration has not quite broached the fate of tobacco farmers in
the current tobacco company settlement talks.. However, there has been
some talk of ensuring any adverse affects on their livelihood are offset
(USDA currently does not forecast adverse affects: while domestic demand
may decrease from the deal, export demand is growing).
In addition, in a
March 1994 ACB News Special that featured the President answering
questions from young people at the White House, the President stated,
"There are a lot of good people in America who still raise tobacco. And
we should have funds set aside for them (in the cigarette tax) to help
them convert away from raising tobacco to doing other kinds of farming so
they can actually make a living."
(This is about all we've got on the
President's potential views on this issue.)
In our view, some version of the safety net argument for preserving crop
insurance for tobacco, and opposing the Lowey amendment, would appear a
consistent Administration position. But this issue is clearly above our
heads-, and so request any guidance you can offer as soon as possible.
Thanks.
Message Sent
To:
T J~.~G71-a-u~t~h~i-e-r~/~O~M=B~/=E=O~P~----------------------------------------Charles E. Kieffer/OMB/EOP
Lisa M. Kountoupes/OMB/EOP
Barbara Chow/WHO/EOP
Lucia A. Wyman/WHO/EOP
Joseph J. Minarik/OMB/EOP
---------------------- Forwarded by Alecia Ward/OMB/EOP on 07/15/97 05:22
PM ---------------------------
�.
ARMS Email System
Joseph J. Minarik
07/15/97 04:50:45 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Mark A. Weatherly/OMB/EOP
cc:
See the distribution list at the bottom of this message
Subject:
Re: URGENT: USDA draft letter supporting Tobacco crop
insurance
For what it's worth, I think the President's statement speaks for itself;
and we have certainly made crop conversion a part of our economic
response.
Therefore, I see no way that we can back cutting off crop
insurance -- certainly not now, and probably even after we get a
substantial part of the land base to convert.
Message Copied
To:
T J-.~G~l-a-u~t~h~i-e-r~/~O~M=B~/=E~O~P------------------------------------------Charles E. Kieffer/OMB/EOP
Lisa M. Kountoupes/OMB/EOP
Barbara Chow/WHO/EOP
Lucia A. Wyman/WHO/EOP
Ronald M. Cogswell/OMB/EOP
Alecia Ward/OMB/EOP
Jim R. Esquea/OMB/EOP
Stephen M. Frerichs/OMB/EOP
Page 3 of3
�ARMS Email System
Page I of I
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:21-JUL-1997 15:51:47.00
SUBJECT:
McCurry's Daily Briefing
TO: Alicia H. Munnell ( CN=Alicia H. Munnell/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Below find today's Q&As on the race initiative from McCurry's briefing (I
included Alicia and Elena on this e-mail to alert them to the new study
referenced in first question) :
On another issue, there's a new study out today'
Q
that says there's been a change in the racial culture in the deep
South. What's the President's feelings on that, especially with this
race initiative and Thursday with his two stops at the NABJ and the
NAACP?
MR. MCCURRY:
Q
A change in the culture?
The racial culture in the last 30 years since
MR. MCCURRY: That's a report that's been issued?
just not familiar with it.
Q
I'm
Yes, the University of Illinois --
MR. MCCURRY:
I'm not familiar enough with the report to
comment on it, but I'm sure, depending on how it's been generated or
who generated it, if it's got some serious thinking in it, it will be
of interest to the President's advisory board.
Q
And also, do you think that the word "tolerance" is
not race-relations-friendly in using the race initiative -MR. MCCURRY:
I've heard
no one has suggested that
the President's call for tolerance is anything but encouragement to
all Americans to be respectful of the views of others, even though
you might not necessarily share those views, as the word implies.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of6
A'
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:21-JUL-1997 16:04:02.00
SUBJECT:
The President's trip to Nevada, California and Nevada
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian v. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart M. Schear ( CN=Stuart M. Schear/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
·TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�f-RMS Email System
Page 2 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C.' Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson ( CN=Brian J. Johnson/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN=Julia R. Green/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius ( CN=Catherine A. Cornelius/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Lorraine L. Wytkind ( CN=Lorraine L. Wytkind/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anna C. White ( CN=Anna C. White/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stefanie Sanford ( CN=Stefanie Sanford/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
.READ : UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
T9: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: April K. Mellody ( CN=April K. Mellody/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Joseph P. ,Lockhart ( CN=JOseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO']
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King ( CN=Angus S. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Cynth~a M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
)
)
�~RMS
Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendl~ ( CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Drye ( CN=Elizabeth Drye/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe ( CN=MarilynDiGiacobbe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D, Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Mickey Ibarra ( CN=Mickey Ibarra/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Angelique Pirozzi ( CN=Angelique Pirozzi/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Fred Duval ( CN=Fred Duval/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel to Lake Tahoe (Lake Tahoe forum), Los Angeles
(DCCC fundraiser), and to Las Vegas (NGA Convention) on July 26-28.
Page 5 of6
�.
ARMS Email System
Page 6 of 6
The President will leave very early on the morning of the 26th -approximately 6:00 AM.
We have been asked to get him his briefing book
early on Friday evening -- 7:00 PM at the latest.
Therefore, deadlines for the President briefing book are as follows:
Background memos: DUE THURSDAY, July 24 at 6:00 PM.
(sep. memos for each state)
-political background (NV and so. CA)
-CEQ issues (NV and so. CA)
-Cabinet affairs issues (NV and so. CA)
-Economic I-pagers (NV and CA)
Event memos: DUE FRIDAY, July 25 at 3:00 PM (3 hours earlier than normal)
-Lake Tahoe events:
-boat ride - CEQ
-speech and roundtable - CEQ/Political
-DCCC fundraiser - Political
-NGA Convention - IGA
-Event memo - IGA
-Governor-by-Governor issues/concerns - IGA
-NGA policy concerns/major issues - IGA
-Gubernatorial races update -Political
There is ample time to begin working on this material now and no reason
not to have it in to my office by the above deadlines so that we can get
the President his briefing book early.
Please call me or Sean Maloney if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of8
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD ] )
CREATION DATE/TIME:29-JUL-1997 09:44:12.00
SUBJECT:
Tobacco deal and incentives to innovate
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
TO: Elizabeth Drye ( CN=Elizabeth Drye/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Charles F. Stone ( CN=Charles F. Stone/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TEXT:
Please find attached a final draft of the memo on the tobacco settlement
and incentives.
It reflects the work of CEA, Treasury, and NEC.
I hope
it's helpful.==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D71]MAIL45885390V.216 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF575043870B0000010A02010000000205000000263F0000000200008F1B6AE53ADB99DE2692D9
158CA97372CECFA6D910C7656E630DDD348319052248EBF6FD69B43FD70211323F92B330D9FCF2
4B3E2Fl1948EE14B9D56AC864F9A56050416B235FE16702BB44CED11CCFF5D5E7D30EOFD9AB61A
C5A67031EOEF3FB669A98EE92E2C188142690445E02F7B6437B138D6005DFC2825CBF6D37E1D4C
FC72D6598DA9BEC9ACE8AFFD28DA3294F7E3F8A852FC133538316CD23FOF4AFD24636610D39D45
E739734A69CD81EF2Cl17137E76F997D77B14D30BECD8BA78536901EE79887A42B34E70698ED67
CD80F91D6570D5D91FE8624COABB381E13956258A2E9939327E73F9E0719855E77DD9960595F46
C557AOD9EC42E22BF24B4F5DD41304F7501C64FDE2945F8D867C8092330600CCF04EA401CBB20B
A031E7E0519CBBF0400C804E165C4574025FB54D3AC983FBB16ADCOFDC489CE50212095812B2AD
FB5B3EBE6F52FE5363B21C4D8B7EBF806EBDABE7FF2AA34FF838E17A58713EC98A77C50036122F
SDC9DD77EBOOF332DE6A8B3E120426BCFBF1AE253AD8E97202176467CE389F9EB4E59BA133EAD3
2E549A43BAEE2C1DE24A279CAOD6DF63C77D347DA54E98C726B605A6C049E53BB269FAD3C66BAC
7FDODB5733F35979A67DD1D258AOE4A8A4F84B5B98C4A98DC5F4E1E7996EA92BF9CFA24DC8776F
DE19F9E9EA02002B00000000000000000000000823010000000B0100005A040000020801000000
4F0100006505000009250100000006000000B40600000B300300000028000000BA060000087701
00000040000000E206000008340100000014000000220700000802010000000F00000036070000
OB10010000000200000045070000096D010000001700000047070000081103000000C60000005E
0700000B3001000000650000002408000008050100000008000000890B00000055090002004EOO
0000910800000208010000009F010000DF0800000B30030000006C0000007EOAOOOOOB30030000
0044000000EAOAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOEAOAOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOEAOAOOOOOOOO
0000000000000000EAOA00000055040000003C0000002EOBOOOOOO0000000000000000002EOBOO
00000000000000000000002EOB0000000000000000000000002EOB000000000000000000000000
2EOB0000000000000000000000002EOBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO002EOBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000002EOB0000000000000000000000002EOBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO000000002EOBOOOOOOOOOOOO
0000000000002EOB0000000000000000000000002EOBOOOOOOOOOO000000000000002EOBOOOOOO
0000000000000000002EOB0000000000000000000000002EOBOOOO000000000000000000002EOB
0000000000000000000000002EOB0000000000000000000000002EOBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
002EOB0000000000000000000000002EOBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO00002EOBOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO
000000002EOB00000942010000001D0000006AOB000000985C005C004F0041005F0036005C005C
005C004F00500044005C003200330039005F004100000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOOOOC800C8002COl
2C012C012C01C800C8003000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
�Automated Records Management System
Hex.Dump Conversion
The Tobacco Settlement and Incentives to Develop Reduced-Risk Tobacco Products
July 29, 1997
I. Background
In the past, the tobacco industry has not developed many innovative, reduced risk
products -- in large measure because to develop and promote safer products would have been to
acknowledge the harm done by existing products. But some innovations, like filters and
reduced-tar cigarettes, do appear to have followed the release of adverse health news about
smoking. In the current environment, in which companies are admitting that their products' are
harmful and consumer awareness of smoking's risks is heightened, individual companies may be
more likely to view the development of reduced risk products as a profitable endeavor.
The Settlement includes provisions intended to speed the introduction of reduced risk
products. According to the Settlement, the goal of these provisions "is to guarantee that a
mechanism exists to ensure that products which appear to hold out the hope of reducing risk are
actually tested and made available in the marketplace and not held back." The types of
innovations expected to be introduced include the removal of toxic constituents from cigarettes, a
reduction in the nicotine content in cigarettes, and alternative delivery devices for nicotine that
remain attractive to consumers.
II. Provisions of the Settlement
Provisions relating to reduced risk products are in Title I, Section E, Part 4 of the
Settlement. Manufacturers will be required to:
•
Notify FDA of arty technology that they develop or acquire and that reduces the risk from
tobacco products, and
•
For a "commercially reasonable" fee, cross license all such technology to those
companies also covered by the same obligations. Procedural protections will be,built in
to resolve license fee disputes.
Other provisions include:
•
If the technology is in early development stages, manufacturers will be provided
confidentiality during the development process.
•
The FDA will have the authority to mandate the introduction ofless hazardous products
that are technologically feasible by requiring the manufacturer who owns the technology
to introduce the product or to license the technology to another producer. If no
manufacturer or licensee brings such products to market in a reasonable time frame set by
FDA, the U.S. Public Health Service may produce the product, either itself or through a
1
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
licensing arrangement.
III. The economic tradeoff between dissemination and incentives for R&D
One concern with these provisions is that they effectively eliminate the patent system for
tobacco products. Economistshave long struggled with the optimal design of a patent system.
If new innovation occurred spontaneously -- without the need to invest in R&D -- society's
interest would be best served by requiring immediate, full disclosure and licensing of new
products and technologies without fee. But innovation generally does require investment -- and
full disclosure coupled with free adoption by other firms provides little or no incentive for such
investment to be undertaken. The patent system therefore grants a property right to the inventor
"to exclude others from making, using or selling the invention."! The fundamental tradeoff in
the patent system -- inherent in designing the length and comprehensiveness of the patent
protection -- is to balance the need to encourage R&D with the desire to disseminate new
discoveries as quickly as possible.
IV. The Settlement and incentives
The Settlement's provisions, especially the cross-licensing requirement, are near one
extreme of possible patent systems. They ensure rapid dissemination of new discoveries, but
provide little incentive for firms to invest further in the processes that could lead to such
discoveries. A crucial question to answer is how much of the total possible R&D has been
undertaken, and how much remains to be done. In the area of removing toxins from
cigarettes, much -- though not aU -- is apparently already technologically feasible. Some
analysts believe that current knowledge would also allow a reduction of the nicotine
content in commercially viable cigarettes within a relatively short period (e.g., 6 months);
others believe that such products are a decade away. A critical technical question for FDA
and others to answer is to gi~e a best guess as to how much research remains to be
undertaken, and in what specific areas.
To the extent that most of the relevant R&D has already been undertaken, the incentive
problems are not significant. Enforcing full and even free cross-licensing ofextant R&D may
not pose the same incentive problems as enforcing cross-licensing offuture R&D. Two
potential dangers with cross-licensing existing R&D are (1) it may damage the government's
credibility that such a requirement will not be repeated in the future, thus reducing incentives for
future R&D; and (2) it may be difficult to def'me an "existing" innovation (how would a
prototype be classified, where the bulk of the costs are bringing it to market?). Despite
these potential problems, it may be useful to draw a distinction between cross-licensing of
existing R&D and future R&D.
Another important incentive question is to what extent the firms will be allowed to
! Patents are granted for a tenn of 17 years (14 years for design patents), which may be extended only by a
special act of Congress (except for certain phannaceutical patents). After expiration of the tenn, the patentee loses
rights to the invention.
2
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
market their innovations. The FDA and others raise legitimate concerns about allowing
marketing of reduced risk tobacco products: by providing a government imprimatur of reduced
health risks, allowing such advertising may induce more smoking (either by non-smokers or by
those who had intended to reduce their smoking levels). So even if each cigarette is "safer," the
public health risk may be expanded because of the increase in total smoking relative to the
baseline. To the extent that advertising of reduced risk products is not allowed, however, firms
will have little interest in developing such products.
One possibility -- which may not be technically feasible -- would be to allow firms to
publish "health hazard ratings." For example, cigarette packages could carry health hazard
ratings of 90, 95, or 100 depending on the risks profile of the product. 2 It seems unlikely that a
product carrying a health hazard rating of"90" would be much more attractive to a non-smoker
than one carrying a rating of"100." Such a system could provide firms with some incentives to
develop safer products -- because extant smokers would pay attention to the health hazard rating
-- while minimizing the potential for perverse results. The system would also facilitate a
CAFE-like regulation that cigarette sales by each individual producer could have a mean health
hazard rating of no more than some level.
V. Options
The above discussion suggests several possible options:
1. Maintain current provisions. The current provisions provide limited incentives for
innovation, but strong incentives for diffusion. This solution is acceptable if we believe that
most of the knowledge about developing safer products already exists -- and there is therefore
more to be gained from disseminating what is known than from trying to develop new knowledge
and new products and technology.
2. Require full (and perhaps free) cross-licensing of existing knowledge but not future
discoveries. As noted above, this option would efficiently diffuse the existing stock of
knowledge without affecting firms' incentives for future investments in R&D. Future R&D
efforts could be governed by the regular patent system, or one of the options below. One
important detail in such a system would be the delineation of existing R&D from future R&D.
3. Grant patents for a limited period. The Settlement effectively eliminates the patent period.
An intermediate position, which would provide more balance between incentives and
dissemination, would shorten the patent period from 17 years to perhaps a few years. At the end
of the patent period, other firms would have free access to the knowledge.
4. Grant patents for a limited period and then have the tobacco fund buyout the patent holder
(could be combined with #2). One solution to the tradeoff between dissemination and incentives
2 Given the difficulty of distinguishing real health benefits, the scale should only include a few discrete
levels -- perhaps 90, 95, and 100 -- instead of being continuous.
3
�Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
is to have the government buyout the patent holder and then license the knowledge to other
producers (perhaps for a nominal fee). For example, we could grant a 2-year patent for tobacco
products. At the end of the 2-year period, the tobacco fund would compensate the patent holder
for some multiple (e.g., 3) of profits from the patent over that period -- a proxy for the present
value of the profits from the patent itself. The patent will then expire, and the knowledge could
be distributed to other firms for free or for a nominal fee, ensuring relatively rapid dissemination.
This structure would maintain incentives for future R&D, encourage patent holders to market
their innovations aggressively during the patent period, and ensure dissemination after the end of
the patent period.
5. Eliminate cross-licensing requirements. Eliminating the cross-licensing provisions would
allow companies to profit from innovation as they would in any other industry, thus encouraging
future R&D. Concerns about strategic withholding of innovations and the related lack of
diffusion could be alleviated by the settlement's provision allowing the FDA to set performance
standards. In that way, a minimum level of safety could be set for the entire industry and
adjusted as major innovations occurred.
VI. Summary of key points and questions
•
Innovation generally requires investment -- and full disclosure coupled with free adoption
by other firms provides little or no incentive for such investment to be undertaken.
•
Enforcing full and even free cross-licensing of extant R&D may not pose the same
incentive problems as enforcing cross-licensing of future R&D. But the government's
credibility may suffer, and it may be difficult to define "existing" R&D.
•
To the extent that the FDA does not allow advertising of reduced risk products, firms will
have little interest in developing such products. To counter the potential risk to public
health from allowing advertising of "safer" cigarettes, one possibility -- which may not be
technically feasible -- would be to allow firms to publish "health hazard ratings."
•
The cross-licensing requirements embodied in the Settlement are near one extreme of
possible patent systems. Modifications could include limiting cross-licensing to existing
R&D, allowing a shorter-than-usual but non-zero patent period, or simply eliminating the
cross-licensing requirements and relying on FDA regulations to encourage dissemination.
4
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-AUG-1997 12:18:27.00
SUBJECT:
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
I am following up on our conversation regarding the race initiative.
you get a chance to talk to Judy Winston?
Sandy
Did
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN:Sanders D. Korenman/OU:CEA/O:EOP [ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-AUG-1997 14:58:46.00
SUBJECT:
Re:
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN:Elena Kagan/OU:OPD/O:EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Am I missing a meeting?
Elena· Kagan
08/06/97 02:57:23 PM
Record
Record Type:
To:
Sanders D. Korenman/CEA/EOP
cc:
Subject:
Re:
3:00 meeting.
�ARMS Email System
-
Page 1 of6
to
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Sean P. Maloney ( CN=Sean P. Maloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-AUG-l997 15:23:10.00
SUBJECT:
St. Louis Trip
TO: Robin J. Bachman ( CN=Robin J. Bachman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian v. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart M. Schear ( CN=Stuart M. Schear/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil
( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�..
Page 2 of6
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPO/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPO/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson ( CN=Brian J. Johnson/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu o. Huynh ( CN=Phu o. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPO/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPO 1 )
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN=Julia R. Green/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius ( CN=Catherine A. Cornelius/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas D. Janenda ( CN=Thomas D. Janenda/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lorraine L. Wytkind ( CN=Lorraine L. Wytkind/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anna C. White ( CN=Anna C. White/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
( READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=,wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stefanie Sanford ( CN=Stefanie Sanford/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: April K. Mellody ( CN=April K. Mellody/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King ( CN=Angus S. 'King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
'TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of6
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN=Andrew Friendly!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler!OU=CEQ!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Drye ( CN=Elizabeth Drye!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe ( CN=Marilyn DiGiacobbe!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang!OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan!OU=WHO!O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel to St. Louis on Tuesday, August 12, 1997, t9
attend a Welfare-to-Work Partnership event and a DNC luncheon.
Deadlines for the President's Trip Book are as follows:
Background memos:
DUE, MONDAY, AUGUST 11 at 6:00 PM
�ARMS Email System
Page 6 of6
c.
-Political memo
-Economic I-pager
-CEQ Hot Issues
-Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
-Accomplishments
Event memos:
DUE, MONDAY, AUGUST 11 at 6:00 PM
-Welfare-to-work event (Christa Robinson)
-DNC Event (Craig Smith)
Please call or e-mail me if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[07/01/1997 – 08/06/1997]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 097 - Folder 004
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/c4cb257d6664614ba3dfe4ee24bf96a0.pdf
15fd4e1919468fd632f0c37133c7eae6
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC-KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 097 - FOLDER -003
[06/07/1997 -06/30/1997]
�.
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of2
t•
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-JUN-1997 10:37:39.00
SUBJECT:
Meeting today
TO: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven D. Aitken ( CN=Steven D. Aitken/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Brown ( CN=Lisa M. Brown/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Dwyer ( John Dwyer @ 514-0238 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fran Allegra ( Fran Allegra @ 514-1724 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tom McGivern ( Tom McGivern @ 622-1188 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald Remy ( Donald Remy @ 514-8071 @ fax
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=william P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Timothy J. Brennan ( CN=Timothy J. Brennan/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Burson ( CN=Charles W. Burson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pam Gilbert ( Pam Gilbert @ 301-504-0121 @ fax
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Matzner ( Ron Matzner @ 205-6846 @ fax
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Ed Murphy ( Ed Murphy @ 622-1294 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Pincus ( Andrew Pincus @ 482-0042 @ fax
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
...
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
cc:
Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The meeting today will be at 1:30 in Room 476.
ellen
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
-'"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN;Ellen S. Seidman/OU;OPD/O;EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-JUN-1997 18:13:59.00
SUBJECT:
Monday's meeting
TO: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN;Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN;William P. Marshall/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Timothy J. Brennan ( CN;Timothy J. Brennan/OU;CEA/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN;Peter G. Jacoby/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Burson ( CN;Charles W. Burson/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Dwyer ( John Dwyer @ 514-0238 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fran Allegra ( Fran Allegra @ 514-1724 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tom McGivern ( Tom McGivern @ 622-1188 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald Remy ( Donald Remy @ 514-8071 @ fax
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN;John E.
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
~hompson/OU;OMB/O;EOP
@ EOP
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN;Ellen S. Seidman/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN;Bruce R. Lindsey/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven D. Aitken ( CN;Steven D. Aitken/OU;OMB/O;EOP @ EOP [ OMB J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN;TraceyE. Thornton/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Brown ( CN;Lisa M. Brown/O;OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey Hunker ( Jeffrey Hunker @ 482-4636 @ fax
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Pam Gilbert ( Pam Gilbert @ 301-504-0121 @ fax [ UNKNOWN J )
�ARMS Email System
.,
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Matzner ( Ron Matzner @ 205-6846 @ fax
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Ed Murphy ( Ed Murphy @ 622-1294 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Pincus ( Andrew Pincus @ 482-0042 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
cc: Melissa Green ( CN;Melissa Green/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Monday's meeting will run from 1:30 to 3:00 and will be in room 231 of the
Old Executive Office Building.
ellen
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: FEDERAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 7-JUN-1997 15:52:56.00
SUBJECT:
TO: ELENA (pager) #KAGAN ( ELENA (Pager) #KAGAN [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
i lost you; please call 456-5701
�ARMS Email System.
RECORD TYPE: FEDERAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 8-JUN-l997 l3:20:33.00
SUBJECT:
TO: RACHEL (Pager) #LEVINSON ( RACHEL (Pager) #LEVINSON [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ELIZABETH E.
READ: UNKNOWN
(Pager) #DRYE ( ELIZABETH E.
(Pager) #DRYE [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: ELENA (Pager) #KAGAN ( ELENA (pager) #KAGAN [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
I e-mailed new clone draft; awaiting comments.
JT 6570l
�Page 1 of5
ARMS Email System
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(ALL-IN-1 MAIL)
CREATOR: Phillip Caplan ( CAPLAN P )
(WHO)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUN-1997 16:21:55.03
SUBJECT: California travel
TO: Brenda M. Anders
READ:NOT READ
ANDERS B ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kris Balderston
READ: NOT READ
BALDERSTON K ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick
READ: NOT READ
BALDICK N
Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Barbara A. Barclay
READ: NOT READ
BARCLAY B
Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: David S. Beaubaire
READ: NOT READ
BEAUBAIRE D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Debra D. Bird
READ: NOT READ
BIRD D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Alison Bracewell
READ:NOT READ
BRACEWELL A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Dennis Burke
READ:NOT READ
BURKE D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Laura Capps
READ:NOT READ
CAPPS L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland
READ: NOT READ
CLEVELAND C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Michael Cohen
READ: NOT READ
COHEN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius
READ:NOT READ
CORNELIUS C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Glyn T. Davies
READ: NOT READ
DAVIES G
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe
READ: NOT READ
DIGIACOBBE M ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley
READ: NOT READ
DUDLEY J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne M. Edwards
READ: NOT READ
EDWARDS A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Nicole Elkon
READ:NOT READ
ELKON N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Rahm Emanuel
EMANUEL R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
(NSC) .
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ:NOT READ
TO: Shelley N. Fidler
READ: NOT READ
FIDLER S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: ·AndreW Friendly
READ: NOT READ
FRIENDLY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO; Jeremy M. Gaines
READ:NOT READ
GAINES J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Mary Ellen Glynn
READ: NOT READ
GLYNN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Jason S. Goldberg
READ: NOT READ
GOLDBERG JS ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: David S. Goodin
READ:NOT READ
GOODIN D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Julia R. Green
READ: NOT READ
GREEN J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich
READ: NOT READ
HERNREICH N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Russell W. Horwitz
READ:NOT READ
HORWITZ R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Phu D. Huynh
READ: NOT READ
HUYNH P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno
READ: NOT READ
JASSOROTUN C ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Brian J. Johnson
READ: NOT READ
JOHNSON BJ ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: John Podesta
READ: NOT READ
( John podesta@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX·)
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: NOT READ
KAGAN E ) Autoforward to: Remote. Addresse
TO: Donald L. Kerrick
READ:1l-JUN-l997 13:47:04.57
KERRICK D
TO: Angus S. King
READ:NOT READ
KING A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(NSC)
TO: Katherine Hubbard
READ:NOT READ
( Katherine Hubbard@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Kirk Hanlin
READ: NOT READ
( Kirk T. Hanlin@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Christopher J. Lavery
READ: NOT READ
LAVERY C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey
LINDSEY B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: NOT READ
TO: Gordon Li
READ: NOT READ
TO: Laura D. Schwartz
READ: NOT READ
LI G ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
( Laura D. Schwartz@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Julie E. Mason
READ: NOT READ
MASON J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Floydetta McAfee
READ: NOT READ
MCAFEE F ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne E. McGuire
READ: NOT READ
MCGUIRE A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Lorraine McHugh
READ: NOT READ
MCHUGH L ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: APRIL K. MELLODY
READ: NOT READ
MELLODY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Cathy L. Millison
READ: 9-JUN-1997 17:05:47.69
MILLISON C
TO: Megan C. Moloney
READ: NOT READ
MOLONEY M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Linda L. Moore
READ: NOT READ
MOORE L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Minyon Moore
READ: NOT READ
MOORE MI
Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kevin Moran
READ: NOT READ
MORAN K1
Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Ruby G. Moy
READ: NOT READ
MOY R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Michael Terrell
READ: NOT READ
(NSC)
( Michael Terrell@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Peter R. Orszag
READ: NOT READ
ORSZAG P ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Jennifer Palmieri
READ: 9-JUN-1997 16:27:05.41
PALMIERI J
TO: Sarah J. Reber
READ:NOT READ
REBER S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Christa T. Robinson
READ: NOT READ
ROBINSON C
TO: Dan Rosenthal
READ: NOT READ
ROSENTHAL D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Stephen B. Silverman
SILVERMAN S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
(WHO)
(OPD)
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: NOT READ
TO: Joshua Silverman
READ: NOT READ
SILVERMAN J
) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Karren E. Skelton
READ: NOT READ
SKELTO K ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Craig T. Smith
READ: NOT READ
SMITH CT ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Wendy L. Smith
READ: NOT READ
SMITH WL ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Aviva Steinberg
READ: NOT READ
STEINBERG A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Todd Stern
READ: NOT READ
STERN T ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Stephanie Streett
READ:NOT READ
STREETT S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Sara M. Latham
READ: NOT READ
( Sara M. Latham@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews
READ: NOT READ
( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Lisa Jordan Tamagni
READ: NOT READ
TAMAGNI L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Marjorie Tarmey
READ: NOT READ
TARMEY M ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: June G. Turner
READ:NOT READ
TURNER J
TO: Michael Waldman
READ:NOT READ
WALDMAN M ) Autoforward to: ·Remote Addres
TO: Ann F. Walker
READ:NOT READ
WALKER A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Christopher F. Walker
READ:NOT READ
WALKER C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman
READ:NOT READ
WALLMAN KM ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Christopher Wayne
READ:NOT READ
WAYNE C
TO: Dorian v. Weaver
READ: NOT READ
WEAVER D
TO: Paul J. Weinstein, Jr
READ: NOT READ
WEINSTEIN P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Daniel Wexler
WEXLER D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
) Autoforward to: Remote Address
Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
Autoforward to: Remote Address
�.
ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: NOT READ
TO: Diane M. Whitmore
READ: NOT READ
WHITMORE D ) 'Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Cecily C. Williams
READ:NOT READ
WILLIAMS CC ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TEXT:
The President will travel to San Diego on Friday to deliver the commencement
address at UC-San Diego on Saturday, June 14.
Deadlines for the trip book are as follows:
Background papers, DUE WEDNESDAY, JUNE 11 at 6:00 PM
-Political background
-Economic background
-Cabinet hot issues
-Environmental hot issues
Event memos, DUE THURSDAY, JUNE 12 at 6:00 PM
-Commencement address and photo line
-Lunch
-Interviews TBD
please call with any questions. Thanks.
�A}}MS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUN-1997 16:42:33.00
SUBJECT:
meeting on wednesday
TO: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: william P. Marshall ( CN=william P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
WHO 1 )
TO: Timothy J. Brennan ( CN=Timothy J. Brennan/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Burson ( CN=Charles W. Burson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeff Bromme ( Jeff Bromme @ 301-504-0121 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Dwyer ( John Dwyer @ 514-0238 @ fax
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Fran Allegra ( Fran Allegra @ 514-1724 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tom McGivern ( Tom McGivern @ 622-1188 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald Remy ( Donald Remy @ 514-8071 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven D. Aitken ( CN=Steven D. Aitken/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Brown ( CN=Lisa M. Brown/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Spotila ( John Spotila @ 205-6096 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
"f
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey Hunker ( Jeffrey Hunker @ 482-4636 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pam Gilbert ( Pam Gilbert @ 301-504-0121 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Matzner ( Ron Matzner @ 205-6846 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ed Murphy ( Ed Murphy @ 622-1294 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Pincus ( Andrew Pincus @ 482-0042 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Reminder: there will be a meeting on Wednesday at 1:30
room 231, OEOB.
ellen
(until 3:00), in
�Page 1 of2
ARMS Email System
".
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ronald E. Jones ( CN=Ronald E. Jones/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:10-JUN-1997 14:50:11.00
SUBJECT:
Treasury Draft Bill for Clearance this afternoon
TO: William B. English ( cN=william B. English/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Should have included you on the attached.
---------------------- Forwarded by Ronald E. Jones/OMB/EOP on 06/10/97
02 : 49 PM - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -'- - - - - - - -
Ronald E. Jones
06/10/97 02:48:55 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
See the distribution list at the bottom of this message
cc:
James C. Murr/OMB/EOP, James J. Jukes/OMB/EOP
Subject:
Treasury Draft Bill for Clearance this afternoon
You will shortly receive a Treasury legislative proposal entitled,
Termination of Thrift Depositor Protection Oversight Board (LRM REJ 130) .
Treasury reports the House Banking Committee is willing to consider the
proposal at its reconciliation markup tomorrow.
They also report the
proposed legislation has been endorsed by HUD and the Federal Reserve.
Copies of memoranda endorsing the abolition of the Oversight Board
signed by the Under Secretary Hawke, Chairman Greenspan, and Sec. Cuomo,
and a letter from Sec. Cuomo to Sec. Rubin endorsing this legislative
proposal, will be attached to the draft bill.
IF WE DO NOT HEAR FROM YOU BY THE DEADLINE, WE WILL ASSUME YOU HAVE NO
OBJECTION TO THE PROPOSED DRAFT BILL.
Message Sent
To:~~--~~~--~----------------------------------------------
Michael Deich/OMB/EOP
Ellen S. Seidman/OPD/EOP
Alice E. Shuffield/OMB/EOP
Lisa M. Kountoupes/OMB/EOP
Charles Konigsberg/OMB/EOP
Daniel M. Tangherlini/OMB/EOP
Alan B. Rhinesmith/OMB/EOP
Edward A. Brigham/OMB/EOP
Michelle A. Enger/OMB/EOP
Daniel C. Tate/WHO/EOP
Ellen J. Balis/OMB/EOP
Paul R. Carey/WHO/EOP
Francis S. Redburn/OMB/EOP
�ARMS Email System
.'
Page 2 of2
�.
ARMS Email System
"'
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: CAPLAN P@A1@CD@LNGTWY ( CAPLAN_P@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 16-JUN-1997 13:18:12.00
SUBJECT:
Denver and California
TO: ROBINSON C@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
ROBINSON_C@A1@CD@LNGTWY
TO: Minyon Moore@eop@LNGTEY@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
Minyon Moore@eop@LNGTEY@LNGTWY [ WHO 1 )
KERRICK D@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Cecily C. Williams@eop ( Cecily C. Williams@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.@EOP ( Paul J. Weinstein Jr.@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne@eop ( Christopher Wayne@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher F. Walker@eop ( Christopher F. Walker@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman@eop ( Michael Waldman@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Marjorie Tarmey@eop ( Marjorie Tarmey@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews@eop ( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham@eop ( Sara M. Latham@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern@eop ( Todd Stern@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith@eop ( Craig T. Smith@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman@EOP ( Joshua Silverman@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal@eop ( Dan K. Rosenthal@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag@eop ( Peter R. Orszag@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Kevin Moran@eop ( Kevin Moran@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney@eop ( Megan C. Moloney@eop [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lorraine L. Wytkind@eop ( Lorraine L. Wytkind@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason@eop ( Julie E. Mason@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart@eop ( Joseph P. Lockhart@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery@eop ( Christopher J. Lavery@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard@eop ( Katherine Hubbard@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan@eop ( Elena Kagan@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson@eop ( Brian J. Johnson@eop [ CEQ 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh@eop ( Phu D. Huynh@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich@eop . ( Nancy V. Hernreich@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin@EOP ( D. Stephen Goodin@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines@eop ( Jeremy M. Gaines@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler@eop ( Shelley N. Fidler@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole Elkon@eop ( Nicole Elkon@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley@eop ( Jennifer D. Dudley@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius@eop ( Catherine A. Cornelius@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland@EOP ( Carolyn E. Cleveland@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Capps@eop ( Laura Capps@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird@eop ( Debra D. Bird@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay@eop ( Barbara A. Barclay@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston@EOP ( Kris M Balderston@EOP [ WHO 1 )
Page 2 of5
�Page 3 of5
f\RMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: NOTESREFLECT@Al@CD@LNGTWY ( NOTESREFLECT@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MILLISON C@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAVIES G@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MILLISON C@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
DAVIES G@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (NSC)
TO: Daniel Wexler@eop ( Daniel Wexler@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver@eop ( Dorian V. Weaver@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman@eop ( Kathleen M. Wallman@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker@eop ( Ann F. Walker@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner@eop ( June G. Turner@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Tamagni@eop ( Lisa Tamagni@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie Sanford@eop ( Stephanie Sanford@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett@eop ( Stephanie S. Streett@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg@eop ( Aviva Steinberg@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton@eop ( Karen E. Skelton@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman@eop ( Stephen B. Silverman@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber@eop ( Sarah J. Reber@eop [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Terrell@eop ( Michael Terrell@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Moore@eop ( Linda Moore@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: April Mellody@eop ( April Mellody@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire@eop ( Anne E. McGuire@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Laura D. Schwartz@eop ( Laura D. Schwartz@eop [ WHO 1 )
(SYS)
�;\RMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey@eop ( Bruce R. Lindsey@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin@eop ( Kirk T. Hanlin@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King@eop ( Angus S. King@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta@eop ( John podesta@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso_RotUnllO@eop ( Cynthia M. Jasso_Rotunno@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz@eop ( Russell W. Horwitz@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green@eop ( Julia R. Green@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg@EOP ( Jason S. Goldberg@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly@eop ( Andrew Friendly@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm Emanuel@eop ( Rahm Emanuel@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards@eop ( Anne M. Edwards@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe@EOP ( Marilyn DiGiacobbe@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen@EOP ( Michael Cohen@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III@eop ( Jose Cerda III@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alison E. Bracewell@eop ( Alison E. Bracewell@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire@eop ( David S. Beaubaire@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick@eop ( Nicholas R. Baldick@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders@eop ( Brenda M. Anders@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel to Denver for the summit of the Eight and then
to
California for several events.
The President will have three trip books:
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
"
one for pre-Summit activities on June 19; one for the duration of the
Summit;
one for California.
Deadlines for these books are as follows:
Pre-Summit activities: DUE WEDNESDAY, JUNE 18 at 6:00 PM
Background memos
-Political memo
-Economic background
-Cabinet issues
-CEQ issues
Event memos
-Event TBD (NEC)
Summit: handled by NSC
California: DUE FRIDAY, JUNE 20 at 6:00 PM
Background memos
-Political memo
-Econ background
-Cabinet issues
-CEQ issues
Event memos
-Conf of Mayors (Lynn Cutler)
-San Francisco $ lunch (Political)
-Event in LA TBD (LULAC/Kaiser)
-LA $ events (Political)
Please note that all paper for Monday's events in California must be to
our
office by Friday evening so that we can have the President's trip book
flown to
him on Saturday.
,
�"
..ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of4
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:19-JUN-1997 10:39:42.00
SUBJECT:
DAILY REPORTS TO POTUS
TO: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Teresa Wildman ( CN=Teresa Wildman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MILLISON C
READ: UNKNOWN
MILLISON C @ A1 @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 }
(NSC)
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John L. Hilley ( CN=John L. Hilley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MCHUGH L
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: SPERLING G
READ: UNKNOWN
MCHUGH L @ A1 @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (WHO)
SPERLING G @ A1 @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (OPD)
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Victoria Radd ( cN=Victoria Radd/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK D
KERRICK D @ A1 @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 }
(NSC)
�'.
Page 2 of4
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles F. Ruff
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Odetta S. Walker ( CN=Odetta S. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth M. Toohey ( CN=Elizabeth M. Toohey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN=Carole A. Parmelee/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca A. Cameron ( CN=Rebecca A. Cameron/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: BLINKEN A
READ: UNKNOWN
BLINKEN A @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cameron L. Cobden ( CN=Cameron L. Cobden/OU=.WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
TO: Jonathan Foster ( CN=Jonathan Foster/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP
EOP [ WHO 1 )
[ OSTP 1 )
�.ARMS Email System
Page 3 of4
"
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Demeo ( CN=Laura K. Demeo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David M. Strauss ( CN=David M. Strauss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason ( CN=Julie E. Mason/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gordon Li ( CN=Gordon Li/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl D. Mills ( CN=Cheryl D. Mills/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eli G. Attie ( CN=Eli G. Attie/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JOLIN_M ( JOLIN M @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1
READ: UNKNOWN
(WHO)
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Jeffrey A. Forbes ( CN=Jeffrey A. Forbes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jodie R. Torkelson ( CN=Jodie R. Torkelson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kimberly H Tilley ( CN=Kimberly H Tilley/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
[ WHO 1
�ARMS Email System
,~
Page 4 of4
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. McCurry ( CN=Michael D. McCurry/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King ( CN=Angus S. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M.Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan Ryan ( CN=Evan Ryan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alice H. Williams ( CN=Alice H. Williams/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert S. Kapla ( CN=Robert S. Kapla/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps
�'.
J~ARMS
Page 1 of5
Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Elizabeth Drye ( CN=Elizabeth Drye/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-JUN-1997 16:43:53.00
SUBJECT:
Q&A on settlement
TO: April B. Abdulmalik ( CN=April B. Abdulmalik/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy A. Min ( CN=Nancy A. Min/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark J. Mazur ( CN=Mark J. Mazur/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ·Daniel C. Tate ( CN=Daniel C. Tate/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Gotbaum ( CN=Joshua Gotbaum/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jerold R. Mande ( CN=Jerold R. Mande/Ou=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN .
TO: Barbara D. Woolley ( CN=Barbara D. Woolley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�.,ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD )
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO )
)
)
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO)
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TEXT:
==================== ATTACHMENT
1 ====================
ATT CREATION TIME/DATE:
0 00:00:00.00
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [ATTACH.D39)MAIL47480607X.116 to ASCII,
The following is a HEX DUMP:
FF5750439A050000010A02010000000205000000A5190000000200000A84BE3BEEB3ACBD625C5D
FFOA74649B033031BD3FDFC73401A80E01C42CB443B7121F176E09419D77349504E562D98D0926
33D47109DD6377329DADCOA2C2FEA10BAD79369FF1A6B7DC30525EAO459E9D2E549A70060B76A2
087A663224B78233D253595694C4BF29D4124B22976D46CB40A99FBF3C6CFC393226FD92C3A4AD
9E105CCFDFA363AD9AED64B8AD6B7A96A4FCC21CD81A70279F39AD4A2F27D85A3DAC4FC7383558
BIB5CC9539F71AA9270769E5676ECBDA253219B9B1A4AAC5F6A6CD8802B5DAOC71F77175E29218
C7C52089CC207A63BC9B6D51992B9DE6D8F05D62F3298624655ABBF335095282D23B8CD42D664C
5EA87214FE2C1AC68882BD794EEFOBDD75C47E97A44510B118B3D560B5C6DE49927D7C754A9B2E
52474FCBD8F7F8CE22F44233D994CC8454F2E198DOF5A78D61FE945842F1F12829CA3430D67E55
9CDF333A86677BB02A3759D2655CAB8884C9A861AFDEB34DDB3786C59C61EC8489C49F4EA315F6
0923194A4E6013D6B0213C2F05DCOCACC9834968829E75A5229F088B9AA7D9A97FD14B1CCCC728
BCCFD58CA10977CD07ACC8DCFFE4DD65484289AD03B3D1D1558F10D78932A4A403B4DF1DOEA592
589497B89C42AOE9CA8735324F0222E5DEDFC6BA1DD5CFAB46A5EBD7D8BD487AACOC1EA71A2A6A
FABC05F66F02000C00000000000000000000000823010000000B010000A802000000550FOOOOOO
4EOOOOOOB303000009250100000006000000010400000B30040000005900000007040000087701
000000400000006004000008340100000014000000A00400000802010000000FOOOOOOB4040000
08050100000008000000C304000000550B0000004EOOOOOOCB0400000B7B020000002800000019
0500000B7B02000000590000004105000000985C005C004F0041005F0038005C005C005C004FOO
500044005C00320046004C004F00500044005F0041000000000000000000000000000000000000
00000000000000000000000000000057494E53504F4F4COOOOOOOO00C800C8002C012C012C012C
01C800C80030000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
ooooooooooooooooooooooqOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO 000000000000000000000000
000000000000000B0100002800C8196810480D000011090000005A000B01000010360054006900
6D006500730020004E0065007700200052006F006D0061006E00200052006500670075006C0061
007200000000000000000001000200580201000000040028000000310000000000000000000000
00000000011259202400A1000000A1000000D41B1F008001020008004502062718004502000058
020200580200001FOOD4D301120000040077F80000000001001200D30AOOOOOOE10601000200E2
0604000200E30601004500E40601000200E50601004400E60601004500E70601000200E8060100
1700E90601004500EA06010002005495CA2200000000550400000B3002000000280008337C0078
0000020000EA0600000301000400020000002800D61EC30F3908000011090000005AOOOB01008B
143600540069006D006500730020004E0065007700200052006FOO6D0061006E00200052006500
670075006C00610072000000000000000000010000000400280000000000000000000000000000
0000000000011202002400A1000000A10000000100000004002800000031000000000000000000
0000000000000112D02D2400A1000000A1000000D41B1F00800102000800F70249FBOEOOF70200
0058020200580200001FOOD4D30112000004001F440100000001001200D3DDOA10008301040003
005920211000DDD41B1F00800102000800450206CA01004502000058020200580200001FOOD4D3
01120000040077F80000000001001200D3DDOBOB00030000040BOODD9BD4540F00800204000BOO
00000FOOD4D4540F00800204000AOOOOOOOFOOD4E0401200000000360F360F1DOOEC131200EOF2
OCF2512641806F6E80546F626163636F80536574746C656D656E748088D0041500000B00090001
�.,
Q&A on Tobacco Settlement
June 20, 1997
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
Q.
Did the Administration help close the deal?
A.
No. My staff monitored the talks closely so that we would be in a position to evaluate and
respond to any possible settlement. We consistently told the parties that they would have to
close an agreement on their own, and they were able to do so without any help from the
Administration.
Q.
How will you proceed?
A.
I have asked my Domestic Policy Advisor, along with the Secretary of Health and Human
Services, to undertake a thorough public health review of this agreement. They will consult
with all interested agencies, members of Congress, and the public health community.
Q.
How long will the review take?
A.
The review will take as long as necessary to conduct a careful analysis, but we will seek to
work promptly and expeditiously. We expect this to be a matter of weeks, not months.
Q.
Dr. Kessler and Dr. Koop have asked in a letter to you that you give them 30 days to
complete their own review before signing off on anything. Are you going to wait?
A.
. I intend to consider closely the views of the public health community, including Drs. Koop
and Kessler, before rendering any judgment on the settlement. But it is premature to commit
to any firm timetable for reaching my conclusion.
Q.
What will you look at in evaluating this agreement?
A.
We will evaluate whether this agreement protects the public health -- and particularly the
health of our children. We will pay special attention to the part of the agreement dealing with
FDA jurisdiction. The actions the FDA has taken under this Administration forced the
industry to the bargaining table, and we will insist that the FDA has all necessary authority to
regulate nicotine and tobacco products. We also will carefully review the financial terms of
the settlement, including whether the money will go toward protecting the health of our
children and the general public.
Q.
The final deal limits punitive damages -- a key concession to the tobacco industry.
Won't you oppose that given your previous opposition to caps on punitive awards?
A.
The limitation on punitive damages for past misconduct is not a deal-breaker for us. We
understand that the attorneys general extracted substantial concessions from the tobacco
companies for this limitation, and we will evaluate whether the agreement as a whole
advances the nation's public health interests.
Q.
Are you taking a political risk in considering approval of this settlement?
A.
This isn't about politics; it's about protecting the public health. We didn't think about
politics when we took on the tobacco companies last year with our announcement of the FDA
�rule. And we won't look to politics now in evaluating this agreement.
Automated Records Management System
Hex-Dump Conversion
�Page 1 of5
A.RMS Email System
,.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-JUN-1997 10:12:57.00
SuBJECT:
California travel
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine K. Wallman ( CN=Katherine K. Wallman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
CWHO
1 )
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stefanie Sanford ( CN=Stefanie Sanford/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�A~S
Page 2 of5
Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN;Peter R. Orszag/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN;Kevin S. Moran/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN;Linda L. Moore/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: April K. Mellody ( CN;April K. Mellody/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
.TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN;Andrew J. Mayock/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN;JosephP. Lockhart/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham
READ: UNKNOWN
CN;Ann F. Lewis/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 }
CN;Sara M. Latham/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 }
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN;Kirk T. Hanlin/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN;Elena Kagan/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Brian J. Johnson ( CN;Brian J. Johnson/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN;Phu D. Huynh/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN;Russell W. Horwitz/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN;Julia R. Green/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN;Laura A. Graham/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN;Jeremy M. Gaines/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN;Karen E. Finney/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN;Paul K. Engskov/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole Elkon ( CN;Nicole Elkon/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Drye ( CN;Elizabeth Drye/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�A~S
Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe ( CN=Marilyn DiGiacobbe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Michaei Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 }
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lorraine L. Wytkind ( CN=Lorraine L. Wytkind/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anna C. white ( CN=Anna C. White/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein
Jr./OU~OPD/O=EOP @
EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO:. Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
�A~S
Page 4 of5
Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU;OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Stuart M. Schear ( CN=Stuart M. Schear/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King ( CN=Angus S. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�.
Page 5 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius ( CN=Catherine A. Cornelius/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
T9: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Reminder that all paper for the President's trip to California on Monday
is due to my office by COB today.
Please call if you have any questions.
�ARMS Email System
\.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of6
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-JUN-1997 15:29:57.00
SUBJECT:
Nashville, Chicago and NYC travel
TO: Lorraine L. Wytkind ( CN=Lorraine L. Wytkind/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anna C. White ( CN=Anna C. White/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stefanie Sanford ( CN=Stefanie Sanford/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter.R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�Page 2 of6
{>.RMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[WHO 1 )
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson ( CN=Brian J. Johnson/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN=Julia R. Green/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole Elkon ( CN=Nicole Elkon/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Drye ( CN=Elizabeth Drye/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�~RMS
Page 3 of6
Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Marilyn DiGiacobbe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Brenda B. costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ E,OP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine K. Wallman ( CN=Katherine K. Wallman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�~RMS
Page 4 of6
Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart M. Schear ( CN=Stuart M. Schear!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: April K. Mellody ( CN=April K. Mellody/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock!OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King/OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King ( CN=Angus S. King/OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M., Jasso-Rotunno!OU=WHO!O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�~RMS
Page 5 of6
Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly ( CN;Andrew Friendly/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ : UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN;Shelley N. Fidler/OU;CEQ/O;EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN;Anne M. Edwards/OU~WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN;Maria Echaveste/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN;Jennifer D. Dudley/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN;Suzanne Dale/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius ( CN;Catherine A. Cornelius/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN;Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN;Laura K. Capps/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN;Debra D. Bird/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN;Barbara A. Barclay/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN;Kris M Balderston/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN;Lori L. Anderson/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel next week to Nashville (VP's Family Conference),
Chicago (Moseley-Braun dinner) and NYC (UN Special Session on environment.
All material for the President's briefing book is due Tuesday night at
6:00 PM.
Given the volume of material, anything that you can submit by
Monday night or Tuesday morning would be most appreciated.
Nashville:
Background
-Political briefing
with VP's staff)
-econ I-pager
-cabinet issues
-environmental issues
Event memos
-Family conference (DPC working
Chicago
Background
-Political briefing
Event memos
-Moseley-Braun dinner/photo line
�.
ARMS Email System
(Political)
-econ I-pager
-cabinet issues
-environmental issues
NYC
UN Speech, bi-Iats and background -- to be handled by NSC
Please don't hesitate to call if you have any questions.
Page 6 of6
�ARMS Email System
"
Page 1 of5
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-JUN-1997 10:26:41.00
SUBJECT:
Boston/New York City travel
TO: Lorraine L. Wytkind ( CN=Lorraine L. Wytkind/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anna C. White ( CN=Anna C. white/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry 'J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO l )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stefanie Sanford ( CN=Stefanie Sanford/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO, 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: April K. Mellody ( CN=April K. Mellody!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Sara M. Latham!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A. King!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King ( CN=Angus S. King!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Andrew Friendly!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler!OU=CEQ!O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Drye ( CN=Elizabeth Drye!OU=OPD!O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe ( CN=Marilyn DiGiacobbe!OU=WHO!O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 3 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OPD 1 )
TO: Jose Cerda I I I ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine K. Wallman ( CN=Katherine K. Wallman/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michael V. Terrell/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ CEQ 1 )
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
[ OPD 1 )
�·ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart M. Schear ( CN=Stuart M. Schear/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson ( CN=Brian J. Johnson/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN=Julia R. Green/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 5 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engsk6v ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius ( CN=Catherine A. Cornelius/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ : UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel to Boston and New York City on Monday, June 30.
All material for the trip book is due Saturday, 3:00 PM. Anything
submitted earlier would be most appreciated.
Background - Boston, NYC
Political memo
Economic I-pager (language needs updating)
Cabinet hot issues
CEQ hot issues
Event memos AND GUEST LISTS
-$ event - Boston (Political)
-$ events - NYC (Political)
Please call if you have any questions.
Thanks.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-JUN-1997 11:59:58.00
SUBJECT:
Today's principals' meeting
TO: Cristian J. Santesteban ( CN=Cristian J. Santesteban/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ingrid M. Schroeder ( CN=Ingrid M. Schroeder/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=william P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Timothy J. Brennan ( CN=Timothy J. Brennan/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Burson ( CN=Charles W. Burson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeff Bromme ( Jeff Bromme @ 301-504-0121 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Dwyer ( John Dwyer @ 514-0238 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UN.KNOWN
TO: Fran Allegra ( Fran Allegra @ 514-1724 @ fax
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Tom McGivern ( Tom McGivern @ 622-1188 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Donald Remy ( Donald Remy @ 514-8071 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John E. Thompson ( CN=John E. Thompson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Steven D. Aitken ( CN=Steven D. Aitken/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa M. Brown ( CN=Lisa M. Brown/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 20f2
\.
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: John Spotila ( John Spotila @ 205-6096 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeffrey Hunker ( Jeffrey Hunker @ 482-4636 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Pam Gilbert
READ: UNKNOWN
( Pam Gilbert @ 301-504-0121 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Ron Matzner ( Ron Matzner @ 205-6846 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ed Murphy ( Ed Murphy
READ: UNKNOWN
@
622-1294
@
fax [ UNKNOWN 1 .)
TO: Andrew Pincus ( Andrew Pincus @ 482-0042 @ fax [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The meeting -- which HAD been scheduled for 2:00 -- is now scheduled for
4:00 in the Roosevelt Room.
If you were cleared in for Tuesday's meeting,
you're cleared in for 4:00.
If there are questions, please call me or
Melissa Green on 456-5804.
ellen
�'.
•.ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-JUN-1997 17:01:16.00
SUBJECT:
Sperling/Emanuel Rollout Mtg
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne D. Cutler ( CN=Anne D. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO:. William H. White Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN=william H. White Jr./OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Haas ( CN=Lawrence J. Haas/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert M. Shireman ( CN=Robert M. Shireman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson ( CN=Brian J. Johnson/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dale L. Murray ( CN=Dale L. Murray/OU=OA/O=EOP @ EOP [ OA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of3
.ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. OrszagjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. HorwitzjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jill M. Blickstein ( CN=Jill M. BlicksteinjOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. ParkerjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily BrombergjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele JolinjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ CEA 1 )
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. JohnsonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. BrophyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria EchavestejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael CohenjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. ToivjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. ViolajOU=CEQjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eli G. Attie ( CN=Eli G. AttiejOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. SkeltonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beverly J. Barnes ( CN=Beverly J. BarnesjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Erin E. Green ( CN=Erin E. GreenjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah A. Bianchi ( CN=Sarah A. BianchijOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia M. Terzano ( CN=Virginia M. TerzanojO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. MoranjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. MarrjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�,ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Gene Sperling (and Rahm Emanuel via phone) will co-chair a Budget/Tax
Rollout Mtg tomorrow at 11:00am in room 231 to help prepare for Monday's
Event.
Thanks
Page 3 of3
�•
. ARMS Email System
Page 1 of3
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-JUN-1997 09:46:52.00
SUBJECT:
Budget/Tax Rollout Mtg has been pushed back to 2:30pm this afternoon. Room
TO: Lynn G. Cutler
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 }
TO: Virginia N. Rustique ( CN=Virginia N. Rustique/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MCHUGH L
READ: UNKNOWN
MCHUGH L @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 } (WHO)
TO: Robert M. Shireman ( CN=Robert M. Shireman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson ( CN=Brian J. Johnson/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beverly J. Barnes ( CN=Beverly J. Barnes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN=Julia R. Green/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�A.RMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP@ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jill M. Blickstein ( CN=Jill M. Blickstein/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca R. Culberson ( CN=Rebecca R. Culberson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale ( CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah A. Bianchi ( CN=Sarah A. Bianchi/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Haas ( CN=Lawrence J. Haas/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eli G. Attie ( CN=Eli G. Attie/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�t.\RMS Email System
Page 3 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Virginia M. Terzano ( CN=Virginia M. Terzano/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Victoria Radd ( CN=Victoria Radd/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Unable to convert ARMS_EXT: [MESSAGE.D53]MAIL493063770.116
The following is a HEX dump of the file:
)
OPD]
)
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 5
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO]
)
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-JUN-1997 14:51:29.00
SUBJECT:
Baltimore travel
TO: Cecily C. Williams ( CN=Cecily C. Williams/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ:UNKNOWN
)
TO: Daniel Wexler ( CN=Daniel Wexler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver ( CN=Dorian V. Weaver/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
TO: Christopher Wayne ( CN=Christopher Wayne/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner ( CN=June G. Turner/OU=WHO/O=E·OP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
)
)
EOP [ WHO]
)
TO: Michael V. Terrell ( CN=Michae1 V. Terre1l/0U=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jordan Tamagni ( CN=Jordan Tamagni/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ UNKNOWN]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg ( CN=Aviva Steinberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
)
TO: Todd Stern ( CN=Todd Stern/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Si1verman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stuart M. Schear ( CN=Stuart M. Schear/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO ] )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber ( CN=Sarah J. Reber/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA]
READ: UNKNOWN
)
)
TO: Simeona F. Pasquil ( CN=Simeona F. Pasquil/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO]
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD ] )
)
)
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney ( CN=Megan C. Moloney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin ( CN=Kirk T. Hanlin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson ( CN=Brian J. Johnson/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh ( CN=Phu D. Huynh/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN=Julia R. Green/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Laura A. Graham ( CN=Laura A. Graham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
·TO: Jeremy M. Gaines ( CN=Jeremy M. Gaines/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Finney ( CN=Karen E. Finney/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul K. Engskov ( CN=Paul K. Engskov/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Suzanne Dale
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Suzanne Dale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius ( CN=Catherine A. Cornelius/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland ( CN=Carolyn E. Cleveland/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=JoseCerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire ( CN=David S. Beaubaire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick ( CN=Nicholas R. Baldick/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders ( CN=Brenda M. Anders/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lorraine L. Wytkind ( CN=Lorraine L. Wytkind/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anna C. White ( CN=Anna C. White/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN .
( CN=Paul J. weinstein Jr./OU=OPD/O=EOP @EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher F. Walker ( CN=Christopher F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP ['WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Walker ( CN=Ann F. Walker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman ( CN=Michael Waldman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Umhofer ( CN=Peter G. Umhofer/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Darby E. Stott ( CN=Darby E. Stott/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman ( CN=Joshua Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz ( CN=Laura D. Schwartz/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stefanie Sanford ( CN=Stefanie Sanford/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Jennifer M. Palmieri ( CN=Jennifer M. Palmieri/OU=wHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: April K. Mellody ( CN=April K. Mellody/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joseph P. Lockhart ( CN=Joseph P. Lockhart/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN·
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ :.UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua A. King ( CN=Joshua A, King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King ( CN=Angus S. King/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno ( CN=Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin ( CN=D. Stephen Goodin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Andrew Friendly/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Shelley.N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards ( CN=Anne M. Edwards/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Drye ( CN=Elizabeth Drye/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe ( CN=Marilyn DiGiacobbe/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda B. Costello ( CN=Brenda B. Costello/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel K. Chang ( CN=Daniel K. Chang/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Capps ( CN=Laura K. Capps/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird ( CN=Debra D. Bird/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barbara A. Barclay ( CN=Barbara A. Barclay/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston ( CN=Kris M Balderston/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel to Baltimore on Wednesday, July 2 to attend a
Baltimore Orioles game and launch a PSA on educational standards.
All material for the briefing book is due to my office by 6:00 PM
tomorrow, Tuesday, July 1.
Background
Political memo
- DPC/Christa/Cohen
Economic background
guests)
Cabinet issues
CEQ issues
Schmoke issues? (IGA?)
Event memos
-PSA launch
(including box
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Collin Brown III ( CN=Collin Brown III/OU=OMB/O=EOP [ OMB 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:30-JUN-1997 17:26:04.00
SUBJECT:
CBI21: Defense Report on HR 1050, A Living wage, Jobs For All Act
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Jo Siclari ( CN=Mary Jo Siclari/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Justine F. Rodriguez ( CN=Justine F. Rodriguez/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phebe N. Vickers ( CN=Phebe N. Vickers/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The purpose of this e-mail is to draw your attention to an LRM that I
circulated last week.
This LRM, CBI21, asked for your views on a Defense
Report on HR 1050, A Living Wage, Jobs for All Act.
Comments were due at
2pm today (6/30).
If I have not received your comments by 11:00am
tomorrow (7/1), I will assume that you have no comment on this Defense
report.
Collin (x-57562)
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[06/07/1997 – 06/30/1997]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 097 - Folder 003
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/acc2a89f3e33ad2fdee91149752b30c4.pdf
bfe4cf0d175e54f4ca4f29488bb11751
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 097 - FOLDER -002
[03/03/1997-06/02/1997]
�- .. ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 5
(ALL-IN-1 MAIL)
CREATOR: Helen P. Howell ( HOWELL_H)
(WHO)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-MAR-1997 09:56:57.06
SUBJECT: Arkansas Trip
Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Brenda M. Anders
READ:NOT READ
ANDERS B
TO: John C. Angell
READ:NOT READ
ANGELL J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kris Balderston
READ: NOT READ
BALDERSTON K ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: David S. Beaubaire
READ: NOT READ
BEAUBAIRE D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Elizabeth Berman
READ: NOT READ
BERMAN E
TO: Debra D. Bird
READ: NOT READ
BIRD D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Alison Bracewell
READ:NOT READ
BRACEWELL A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
.TO: Dennis Burke
READ:NOT READ
BURKE D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Phillip M. Caplan
READ: 3-MAR-1997 10:25:29.19
CAPLAN P
TO: Laura Capps
READ: NOT READ
CAPPS L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland
READ: NOT READ
CLEVELAND C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Michael Cohen
READ: NOT READ
COHEN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius
READ: NOT READ
CORNELIUS C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Amanda Crumley
READ:NOT READ
CRUMLEY A
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe
READ: NOT READ
DIGIACOBBE M ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: J. Fred Dohse
READ:13-MAR-1997 09:16:30.04
DOHSE J
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley
READ: NOT READ
DUDLEY J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne M. Edwards
(WHO)
(NSC)
(.EDWARDS A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
�· ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: NOT READ
TO: Nicole Elkon
READ: NOT READ
ELKON N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Rahm Emanuel
READ: NOT READ
EMANUEL R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Shelley N. Fidler
READ: NOT READ
FIDLER S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Andrew Friendly
READ: NOT READ
FRIENDLY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines
READ: NOT READ
GAINES J
Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Mary Ellen Glynn
READ:NOT READ
GLYNN M
Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Jason S. Goldberg
READ: NOT READ
GOLDBERG JS ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: David S. Goodin
READ: NOT READ
GOODIN D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Julia R. Green
READ: NOT READ
GREEN J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Karen L. Hancox
READ: NOT READ
HANCOX K
TO: Cookab Hashemi
READ: NOT READ
HASHEMI C
TO: Anne Hawley
READ: NOT READ
HAWLEY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich
READ: NOT READ
HERNREICH N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Russell W. Horwitz
READ: NOT READ
HORWITZ_R') Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Phu D. Huynh
READ:NOT READ
HUYNH P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Brian J. Johnson
READ: NOT READ
JOHNSON BJ ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Jackson T. Dunn
READ:NOT READ
( Jackson Dunn III@EOP@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: John Podesta
READ: NOT READ
( John Podesta@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX
TO: Elena Kagan
READ:NOT READ
KAGAN E ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Angus S. King
KING A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
�· ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: NOT READ
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey
READ:NOT READ
LINDSEY B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Gordon Li
READ: NOT READ
LI G ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Julie E. Mason
READ: NOT READ
MASON J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Floydetta McAfee
READ: NOT READ
MCAFEE F ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne E. McGuire
READ: NOT READ
MCGUIRE A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Lorraine McHugh
READ: 3-MAR-1997 10:01:49.80
MCHUGH L
TO: Kathy McKiernan
READ:NOT READ
MCKIERNAN K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: APRIL K. MELLODY
READ: NOT READ
MELLODY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Cathy L. Millison
READ: 3-MAR-1997 14:41:53.37
MILLISON C )
TO: Linda L. Moore
READ: NOT READ
MOORE L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Ruby G. Moy
READ: NOT READ
MOY R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Michael Terrell
READ: NOT READ
(WHO)
(NSC)
( Michael Terrell@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Lucie F. Naphin
READ: NOT READ
NAPHIN L ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Peter R. Orszag
READ:NOT READ
ORSZAG P ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Jennifer Palmieri
READ: 3-MAR-1997 11:39:04.87
PALMIERI J
TO: Sarah J. Reber
READ: 3-MAR-1997 10:37:40.27
REBER S
TO: Christa T. Robinson
READ: NOT READ
ROBINSON C )
TO: Rica F. Rodman
READ: NOT READ
RODMAN R
TO: Dan Rosenthal
READ: NOT READ
ROSENTHAL D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Lee A. Satterfield
SATTERFIEL L ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
)
(WHO)
(CEA)
(OPD)
�Page 4 of5
.' ARMS Email System
READ:NOT READ
TO: Laura D. Schwartz
READ: NOT READ
SCHWARTZ L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Joshua Silverman
READ: NOT READ
SILVERMAN J
) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Stephen B. Silverman
READ: NOT READ
SILVERMAN S
Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Wendy L. Smith
READ: NOT READ
SMITH WL ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Patrick M. Steel
READ: NOT READ
STEEL P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Todd Stern
READ: NOT READ
STERN T ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Stephanie Streett
READ: NOT READ
STREETT S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Sara M. Latham
READ: NOT READ
( Sara M. Latham@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Stefanie Sanford
READ:NOT READ
( Stephanie Sanford@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews
READ:NOT READ
( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Lisa Jordan Tamagni
READ:NOT READ
TAMAGNI L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: June G. Turner
READ:NOT READ
TURNER J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Sharon E. Wagner
READ:NOT READ
WAGNER S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Michael Waldman
READ:NOT READ
WALDMAN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Ann F. Walker
READ:NOT READ
WALKER A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Christopher F. Walker
READ:NOT READ
WALKER C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman
READ:NOT READ
WALLMAN KM ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Dorian V. Weaver
READ:NOT READ
WEAVER D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Paul J. Weinstein, Jr
READ:NOT READ
WEINSTEIN P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Daniel Wexler
WEXLER D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
�.
• ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: NOT READ
TO: Diane M. Whitmore
READ: 3-MAR-1997 10:09:46.62
WHITMORE D
(WHO)
TEXT:
The President will travel to Little Rock and Arkadelphia, Arkansas tomorrow,
,March 4, to survey tornado damage.
Deadlines for the President's trip book are:
BACKGROUND MATERIALS -- Due today, MONDAY, MARCH 3 at 6:00 p.m.
Political memo
Economic I-pager
EVENT MEMOS -- Due today, MONDAY, MARCH 3 at 6:00 p.m.
Thanks! ! ! ! ! !
�p,-RMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page I of5
(ALL-IN-1 MAIL)
CREATOR: Helen P. Howell ( HOWELL_H)
(WHO)
CREATION DATE/TIME: 12-MAR-1997 08:51:42.86
SUBJECT: REMINDER -- North Carolina and Florida Trip
TO: Brenda M. Anders
READ:NOT READ
ANDERS B
Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: John C. Angell
READ: NOT READ
ANGELL J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kris Balderston
READ:NOT READ
BALDERSTON K ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: David S. Beaubaire
READ:NOT READ
BEAUBAIRE D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Debra D. Bird
READ:NOT READ
BIRD D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Alison Bracewell
READ:NOT READ
BRACEWELL A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Dennis Burke
READ: NOT READ
BURKE D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Phillip M. Caplan
READ:15-MAR-1997 09:20:07.34
CAPLAN P
TO: Laura Capps
READ: NOT READ
CAPPS L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland
READ: NOT READ
CLEVELAND C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Michael Cohen
READ: NOT READ
COHEN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius
READ:NOT READ
CORNELIUS C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe
READ:NOT READ
DIGIACOBBE M ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: J. Fred Dohse
READ:13-MAR-1997 09:50:36.82
DOHSE J
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley
READ: NOT READ
DUDLEY J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne M. Edwards
READ:NOT READ
EDWARDS_A) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Nicole Elkon
READ:NOT READ
ELKON N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Rahm Emanuel
Autoforward to: Remote Addres
(WHO)
(NSC)
�'.
Page 2 of5
,.ARMS Email System
READ: NOT READ
TO: Shelley N. Fidler
READ: NOT READ
FIDLER S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Andrew Friendly
READ:NOT READ
FRIENDLY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines
READ:NOT READ
GAINES J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO:· Mary Ellen Glynn
READ: NOT READ
GLYNN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: . Jason S. Goldberg
READ: NOT READ
GOLDBERG JS ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: David S. Goodin
READ:NOT READ
GOODIN D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Julia R. Green
READ: NOT READ
GREEN J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Anne Hawley
READ: NOT READ
HAWLEY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich
READ: NOT READ·
HERNREICH N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Russell W. Horwitz
READ:NOT READ
HORWITZ R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Phu D. Huynh
READ:NOT READ
HUYNH P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno
READ:NOT READ
JASSOROTUN C ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Brian J. Johnson
READ:NOT READ
JOHNSON BJ ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Jackson T. Dunn
READ: NOT READ
( Jackson Dunn III@EOP@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: John Podesta
READ: NOT READ
( John Podesta@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Elena Kagan
READ:NOT READ
KAGAN E ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Angus S. King
READ:NOT READ
KING A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey
READ: NOT READ
LINDSEY B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Gordon Li
READ: NOT READ
LI G ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Julie E. Mason
MASON J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
�Page 3 of5
.ARMS Email System
READ: NOT READ
TO: Floydetta McAfee
READ: NOT READ
MCAFEE F ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne E. McGuire
READ: NOT READ
MCGUIRE A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Lorraine McHugh
READ:12-MAR-1997 09:12:29.05
MCHUGH L
TO: Kathy McKiernan
READ: NOT READ
MCKIERNAN K ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: APRIL K. MELLODY
READ: NOT READ
MELLODY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Cathy L. Millison
READ:12-MAR-1997 09:09:17.63
MILLISON C
TO: Megan C. Moloney
READ: NOT READ
MOLONEY M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Linda L. Moore
READ: NOT READ
MOORE L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Ruby G. Moy
READ: NOT READ
MOY R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Michael Terrell
READ: NOT READ
(WHO)
(NSC)
( Michael Terrell@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Lucie F. Naphin
READ: NOT READ
NAPHIN L
Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Peter R. Orszag
READ: NOT READ
ORSZAG P
Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Jennifer Palmieri
READ:17-MAR-1997 12:11:16.96
PALMIERI J
TO: Sarah J. Reber
READ:12-MAR-1997 09:15:14.16
REBER S
TO: Christa T. Robinson
READ: NOT READ
ROBINSON C
TO: Dan Rosenthal
READ:NOT READ
ROSENTHAL D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Lee A. Satterfield
READ: NOT READ
SATTERFIEL L ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Laura D. Schwartz
READ: NOT READ
SCHWARTZ L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Stephen B. Silverman
READ:NOT READ
SILVERMAN S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Joshua Silverman
SILVERMAN J
(WHO)
(CEA)
(OPD)
) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
�.ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ:NOT READ
TO: Craig T. Smith
READ:NOT READ
SMITH CT ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Wendy L. Smith
READ: NOT READ
SMITH WL ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Patrick M. Steel
READ: NOT READ
STEEL P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Todd Stern
READ: NOT READ
TO: Stephanie Streett
READ:NOT READ
( STERN_T ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
STREETT S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Sara M. Latham
READ: NOT READ
( Sara M. Latham@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Stefanie Sanford
READ: NOT READ
( Stephanie Sanford@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews
READ: NOT READ
( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Lisa Jordan Tamagni
READ: NOT READ
TAMAGNI L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: June G. Turner
READ: NOT READ
TURNER J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Sharon E. Wagner
READ: NOT READ
WAGNER S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Michael Waldman
READ: NOT READ
WALDMAN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Ann F. Walker
READ: NOT READ
WALKER A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Christopher F. Walker
READ: NOT READ
WALKER C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman
READ: NOT READ
WALLMAN KM ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Dorian V. Weaver
READ: NOT READ
WEAVER D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Paul J. Weinstein, Jr
READ: NOT READ
WEINSTEIN P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Daniel Wexler
READ: NOT READ
WEXLER D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Diane M. Whitmore
READ:12-MAR-1997 08:53:29.14
WHITMORE D
TEXT:
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
c·
Page 5 of5
please note that all EVENT MEMOS and REMARKS for the President's trip to North
Carolina and Florida are due today at 4:00 p.m.
Tarmac Greet with DOD crowd -- Christa Robinson
Greet with Educators at Capitol -- Christa Robinson
Remarks to NC Legislature and
Photo Receiving Line
Cecily Williams
REMARKS -- Jordan Tamagni
DSCC Reception and Dinner -- Cynthia Jasso Rotunno
(Please remember to include the lists of attendees and diagram
of seating at POTUS' table)
REMARKS -- Laura Capps
Saxophone Club Event -- Cynthia Jasso Rotunno
(Need list for the greet/photo line on arrival)
REMARKS -- Laura Capps
School Construction Event -- Jake Siewert
(Will POTUS need a special fact sheet or backgrounder in addition?)
REMARKS -- Jonathan Prince
Thanks! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
�Page 1 of5
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(ALL-IN-1 MAIL)
CREATOR: Phillip Caplan ( CAPLAN_P )
(WHO)
CREATION DATE/TIME:21-APR-1997 14:08:39.76
SUBJECT: North Dakota
TO: Brenda M. Anders
READ: NOT READ
ANDERS B } Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kris Balderston
READ: NOT READ
BALDERSTON K } Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick
READ: NOT READ
BALDICK N } Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: David S. Beaubaire
READ: NOT READ
BEAUBAIRE D } Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Debra D. Bird
READ: NOT READ
BIRD D } Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Alison Bracewell
READ: NOT READ
BRACEWELL A } Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Dennis Burke
READ: NOT READ
BURKE D } Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Laura Capps
READ: NOT READ
CAPPS L } Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland
READ: NOT READ
CLEVELAND C } Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Michael Cohen
READ:NOT READ
COHEN M } Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius
READ: NOT READ
CORNELIUS C } Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Glyn T. Davies
READ: NOT READ
DAVIES G
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe
READ:NOT READ
DIGIACOBBE M } Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley
READ:NOT READ
DUDLEY J } Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne M. Edwards
READ:NOT READ
EDWARDS A } Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Nicole Elkon
READ: NOT READ
ELKON N } Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Rahm Emanuel
READ:NOT READ
EMANUEL R } Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Shelley N. Fidler
FIDLER S } Autoforward to: Remote Address
(NSC)
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
,.
READ: NOT READ
TO: Andrew Friendly
READ: NOT READ
FRIENDLY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines
READ: NOT READ
GAINES J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Mary Ellen Glynn
READ:NOT READ
GLYNN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Jason S. Goldberg
READ: NOT READ
GOLDBERG JS ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: David S. Goodin
READ: NOT READ
GOODIN D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Julia R. Green
READ: NOT READ
GREEN J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich
READ: NOT READ
HERNREICH N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Russell W. Horwitz
READ: NOT READ
HORWITZ R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Helen P. Howell
READ: NOT READ
HOWELL H ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Phu D. Huynh
READ: NOT READ
HUYNH P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno
READ: NOT READ
JASSOROTUN C ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Brian J. Johnson
READ: NOT READ
JOHNSON BJ ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Jackson T. Dunn
READ: NOT READ
( Jackson Dunn III@EOP@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: John Podesta
READ: NOT READ
( John Podesta@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: NOT READ
KAGAN E ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Donald L. Kerrick
READ:21-APR-1997 17:39:12.24
KERRICK D
TO: Angus S. King
READ: NOT READ
KING A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(NSC)
TO: Katherine Hubbard
READ: NOT READ
( Katherine Hubbard@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Kirk Hanlin
READ: NOT READ
( Kirk T. Hanlin@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey
LINDSEY B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
�~RMS
Page 3 of5
Email System
READ: NOT READ
TO: Gordon Li
READ: NOT READ
TO: Laura D. Schwartz
READ: NOT READ
LI G } Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
( Laura D. Schwartz@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Julie E. Mason
READ: NOT READ
MASON J } Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Floydetta McAfee
READ: NOT READ
MCAFEE F } Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne E. McGuire
READ: NOT READ
MCGUIRE A } Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Lorraine McHugh
READ:21-APR-1997 14:29:41.13
MCHUGH L
TO: APRIL K. MELLODY
READ: NOT READ
MELLODY A } Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Cathy L. Millison
READ:21-APR-1997 14:38:00.93
MILLISON C
TO: Megan C. Moloney
READ: NOT READ
MOLONEY M } Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Linda L. Moore
READ: NOT READ
MOORE L } Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Kevin Moran
READ: NOT READ
MORAN K1 } Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Ruby G. Moy
READ: NOT READ
MOY R } Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Michael Terrell
READ: NOT READ
(WHO)
(NSC)
( Michael Terrell@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Peter R. Orszag
READ:NOT READ
ORSZAG P
(OPD)
TO: Jennifer Palmieri
READ:21-APR-1997 16:14:34.61
PALMIERI J
TO: Sarah J. Reber
READ:21-APR-1997 16:01:53.99
REBER S
TO: Christa T. Robinson
READ:21-APR-1997 16:46:17.13
ROBINSON C
TO: Dan Rosenthal
READ: NOT READ
ROSENTHAL D } Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Stephen B. Silverman
READ: NOT READ
SILVERMAN S } Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Joshua Silverman
SILVERMAN J
(WHO)
(CEA)
(OPD)
} Autoforward to: Remote Addr
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: NOT READ
TO: Craig T. Smith
READ: NOT READ
SMITH CT ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Wendy L. Smith
READ: NOT READ
SMITH WL ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Aviva Steinberg
READ: NOT READ
STEINBERG A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Todd Stern
READ: NOT READ
STERN T ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Stephanie Streett
READ: NOT READ
STREETT S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Sara M. Latham
READ: NOT READ
( Sara M. Latham@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews
READ: NOT READ
( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Lisa Jordan Tamagni
READ:NOT READ
TAMAGNI L
Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Marjorie Tarmey
READ:NOT READ
TARMEY M
Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: June G. Turner
READ:NOT READ
TURNER J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Michael waldman
READ: NOT READ
WALDMAN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Ann F. Walker
READ: NOT READ
WALKER A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Christopher F. Walker
READ: NOT READ
WALKER C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman
READ:NOT READ
WALLMAN KM ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Christopher Wayne
READ: NOT READ
WAYNE C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Dorian v. Weaver
READ: NOT READ
WEAVER D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Paul J. Weinstein, Jr
READ:NOT READ
WEINSTEIN P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Daniel Wexler
READ: NOT READ
WEXLER D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Diane M. Whitmore
READ:21-APR-1997 14:58:40.60
WHITMORE D
TO: Cecily C. Williams
WILLIAMS CC ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
"
READ: NOT READ
TEXT:
There will be a trip book for tomorrow's travel to North Dakota.
It will
include the following:
Background:
Political background
Economic 1-pager
Flood updates
Event memos:
TBD at trip meeting.
Understanding the scramble we're all under, I'd like to have this material as
soon as possible.
Thank you.
�'.
ARMS Email System
Page 1 of5
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
CREATOR: Helen P. Howell
(ALL-IN-1 MAIL)
( HOWELL_H)
(WHO)
CREATION DATE/TIME:22-APR-1997 17:47:09.00
SUBJECT: Philadelphia Trip
TO: Brenda M. Anders
READ: NOT READ
ANDERS B ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kris Balderston
READ: NOT READ
BALDERSTON K ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick
READ: NOT READ
BALDICK N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: David S. Beaubaire
READ: NOT READ
BEAUBAIRE D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Debra D. Bird
READ: NOT READ
BIRD D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Alison Bracewell
READ: NOT READ
BRACEWELL A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Dennis Burke
READ: NOT READ
BURKE D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Phillip M. Caplan
READ:22-APR-1997 17:54:25.96
CAPLAN P
TO: Laura Capps
READ: NOT READ
CAPPS L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland
READ:NOT READ
CLEVELAND C
TO: Michael Cohen
READ: NOT READ
COHEN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius
READ: NOT READ
CORNELIUS C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Glyn T. Davies
READ:NOT READ
DAVIES G
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe
READ: NOT READ
DIGIACOBBE M ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley
READ: NOT READ
DUDLEY J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne M. Edwards
READ:NOT READ
EDWARDS A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Nicole Elkon
READ: NOT READ
ELKON N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Rahm Emanuel
EMANUEL R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
(WHO)
Autoforward to: Remote Addr
(NSC)
�..
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
"
READ: NOT READ
TO: Shelley N. Fidler
READ: NOT READ
FIDLER S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Andrew Friendly
READ: NOT READ
FRIENDLY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines
READ: NOT READ
GAINES J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Mary Ellen Glynn
READ: NOT READ
GLYNN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Jason S. Goldberg
READ: NOT READ
GOLDBERG JS ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: David S. Goodin
READ: NOT READ
GOODIN D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Julia R. Green
READ:NOT READ
GREEN J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich
READ: NOT READ
HERNREICH N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Russell W. Horwitz
READ: NOT READ
HORWITZ R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Phu D. Huynh
READ: NOT READ
HUYNH P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno
READ: NOT READ
JASSOROTUN C ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Brian J. Johnson
READ: NOT READ
JOHNSON BJ ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Jackson T. Dunn
READ: NOT READ
( Jackson Dunn III@EOP@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: John Podesta
READ: NOT READ
( John Podesta@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Elena Kagan
READ: NOT READ
KAGAN E ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Donald L. Kerrick
READ:23-APR-1997 07:45:03.35
KERRICK D
TO: Angus S. King
READ: NOT READ
KING A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(NSC)
TO: Katherine Hubbard
READ:NOT READ
( Katherine Hubbard@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Kirk Hanlin
READ: NOT READ
( Kirk T. Hanlin@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey
LINDSEY B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
�Page 3 of5
ARMS Email System
,
READ: NOT READ
TO: Gordon Li
READ: NOT READ
LI G ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Julie E. Mason
READ: NOT READ
MASON J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Floydetta McAfee
READ: NOT READ
MCAFEE F ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne E. McGuire
READ: NOT READ
MCGUIRE A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Lorraine McHugh
READ:22-APR-1997 17:50:53.19
MCHUGH L
TO: Kathy McKiernan
READ: NOT READ
MCKIERNAN K
TO: APRIL K. MELLODY
READ: NOT READ
MELLODY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Cathy L. Millison
READ:22-APR-1997 21:05:17.14
MILLISON C
TO: Megan C. Moloney
READ:NOT READ
MOLONEY M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Linda L. Moore
READ: NOT READ
MOORE L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Ruby G. Moy
READ:NOT READ
MOY R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Michael Terrell
READ:NOT READ
(WHO)
(NSC)
( Michael Terrell@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Lucie F. Naphin
READ:NOT READ
NAPHIN L
TO: Peter R. Orszag
READ: NOT READ
ORSZAG P ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Jennifer Palmieri
READ:22-APR-1997 18:14:03.01
PALMIERI J
TO: Sarah J. Reber
READ:22-APR-1997 18:52:04.22
REBER S
TO: Christa T. Robinson
READ: NOT READ
ROBINSON C
TO: Dan Rosenthal
READ:NOT READ
ROSENTHAL D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Lee A. Satterfield
READ:NOT READ
SATTERFIEL L ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Laura D. Schwartz
SCHWARTZ L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
(WHO)
(CEA)
(OPD)
�,.
~S
Page 4 of5
Email System
READ: NOT READ
TO: Stephen B. Silverman
READ: NOT READ
SILVERMAN S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Joshua Silverman
READ:NOT READ
SILVERMAN J
TO: Craig T. Smith
READ: NOT READ
SMITH CT ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Wendy L. Smith
READ: NOT READ
SMITH WL ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Aviva Steinberg
READ:NOT READ
STEINBERG A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Todd Stern
READ:NOT READ
STERN T ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Stephanie Streett
READ:NOT READ
STREETT S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Sara M. Latham
READ:NOT READ
( Sara M. Latham@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX
TO: Stefanie Sanford
READ:NOT READ
( Stephanie Sanford@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews
READ:NOT READ
( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Lisa Jordan Tamagni
READ:NOT READ
TAMAGNI L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Marjorie Tarmey
READ:NOT READ
TARMEY M ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: June G. Turner
READ:NOT READ
TURNER J
TO: Michael Waldman
READ:NOT READ
WALDMAN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Ann F. Walker
READ:NOT READ
WALKER A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Christopher F. Walker
READ: NOT READ
WALKER C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman
READ:NOT READ
WALLMAN KM ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Christopher Wayne
READ: NOT READ
WAYNE C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Dorian V. Weaver
READ: NOT READ
WEAVER D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Paul J. Weinstein, Jr
WEINSTEIN P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
) Autoforward to: Remote Address
�.
ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
READ: NOT READ
TO: Daniel Wexler
READ:NOT READ
WEXLER D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Diane M. Whitmore
READ:23-APR-1997 09:02:38.93
WHITMORE D
TO: Cecily C. Williams
READ: NOT READ
WILLIAMS CC ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
(WHO)
TEXT:
The President will travel to Philadelphia on Sunday, April 27 and Monday, April
28 for the Presidents' Summit for America's Future.
Deadlines for his trip book are as follows:
BACKGROUND MATERIALS are due on FRIDAY, APRIL 25 at 4:00 p.m.
- Political Backgrounder
- Economic I-pager
- Local Issues
- Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Crime I-pager
- Environmental Hot Issues
EVENT MEMOS are due SATURDAY, APRIL 26 at 12:00 NOON.
Thanks! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !
�ARMS Email System
- "
Page 1 of3
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
'(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-MAY-1997 17:05:42.00
SUBJECT:
Budget Rollout
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beverly J. Barnes ( CN=Beverly J. Barnes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Maria Echaveste ( CN=Maria Echaveste/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green { CN=Julia R. Green/OU=WHO(O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: WEINSTEIN P
READ: UNKNOWN
WEINSTEIN P @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ EOP 1 )
TO: Jeanne Lambrew
READ: UNKNOWN
(OPD)
CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Christopher C. Jennings { CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alison E. Bracewell ( CN=Alison E. Bracewell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eli G. Attie ( CN=Eli G. Attie/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Douglas B. Sosnik ( CN=Douglas B. Sosnik/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O~EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn O. Higgins ( CN=Kathryn O. Higgins/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�'.
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca R. Culberson ( CN=Rebecca R. Culberson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ron Klain ( CN=Ron Klain/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth S. Apfel ( CN=Kenneth S. Apfel/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert M. Shireman ( CN=Robert M. Shireman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah A. Bianchi ( CN=Sarah A. Bianchi/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia M. Terzano· ( CN=Virginia M. Terzano/OU=WHO/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Marcia L. Hale ( CN=Marcia L. Hale/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN=Russell W. Horwitz/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�, ARMs Email System
Page 3 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jacob J. Lew ( CN=Jacob J. Lew/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Victoria Radd ( CN=Victoria Radd/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm I. Emanuel ( CN=Rahm I. Emanuel/OU=WHO/O.=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ WHO 1
TEXT:
Gene Sperling and Rahm Emanuel would like to compile a report of all of
the activities undertaken as a part of the budget rollout since Friday,
May 2.
please send a reply email to me by noon tomorrow (Wednesday) with a list
of what you, your office, and your principal have accomplished since
Friday. Specifically, your list should include a report on those
activities and calls listed on the strategy document that was circulated
on Friday as well as any other activities or calls that you have completed
(e.g., press calls, outreach calls, documents faxed).
Please also list the activities that you, your office, and your principal
plan to conduct in the days ahead (e.g., constituency briefings,
conference calls, follow-up press calls).
Following up on this effort
and on your reports -- we plan to hold a meeting later in the week to
discuss further budget rollout activities.
Thanks very much, both for your timely response to this email, as well as
for your patience and efforts on Friday.
Jon Kaplan
NEC
6-5360
�Page 1 of5
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: HOWELL H@A1@CD@LNGTWY ( HOWELL_H@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 14-MAY-1997 18:00:19.00
SUBJECT:
Morgan State Commencement/Baltimore Trip
TO: PALMIERI J@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
PALMIERI_J@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ EOP 1 )
(WHO)
TO: MCHUGH L@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MCHUGH L@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ EOP 1 )
(WHO)
TO: DAVIES G@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
DAVIES G@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ EOP 1 )
(NSC)'
TO: Cecily C. Williams@eop ( Cecily C. Williams@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler@eop ( Daniel Wexler@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver@eop ( Dorian V. Weaver@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman@eop ( Kathleen M. Wallman@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Ann F. Walker@eop ( Ann F. Walker@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner@eop ( June G. Turner@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Tamagni@eop ( Lisa Tamagni@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie Sanford@eop ( Stephanie Sanford@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett@eop ( Stephanie S. Streett@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg@eop ( Aviva Steinberg@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith@eop ( Craig T. Smith@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman@eop ( Stephen B. Silverman@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal@eop ( Dan K. Rosenthal@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag@eop ( Peter R. Orszag@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Moore@eop ( Linda Moore@eop [ WHO 1 )
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: April Mellody@eop ( April Mellody@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Floydetta MCAfee@eop ( Floydetta McAfee@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey@eop (Bruce R. Lindsey@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Katherine Hubbard@eop ( Katherine Hubbard@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan@eop ( Elena Kagan@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jackson Dunn III@EOP ( Jackson Dunn III@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso_Rotunno@eop ( Cynthia M. Jasso_Rotunno@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz@eop ( Russell W. Horwitz@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green@eop ( Julia R. Green@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg@EOP ( Jason S. Goldberg@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines@eop ( Jeremy M. Gaines@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Shelley N. Fidler@eop ( Shelley N. Fidler@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole Elkon@eop ( Nicole Elkon@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley@eop ( Jennifer D. Dudley@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius@eop ( Catherine A. Cornelius@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland@EOP ( Carolyn E. Cleveland@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alison E. Bracewell@eop ( Alison E. Bracewell@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire@eop ( David S. Beaubaire@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston@EOP ( Kris M Balderston@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ROBINSON_C@Al@CD@LNGTWY
ROBINSON C@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ EOP 1 )
(OPD)
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MILLISON C@Al@CD@LNGTWY
MILLISON C@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ EOP 1 ) (NSC)
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK_D@Al@CD@LNGTWY
KERRICK_D@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ EOP 1 ) (NSC)
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: CAPLAN_P@Al@CD@LNGTWY
CAPLAN P@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ EOP 1 )
(WHO)
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diane M. Whitmore@eop ( Diane M. Whitmore@eop [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. weinstein Jr.@EOP ( Paul J. Weinstein Jr.@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne@eop ( Christopher Wayne@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher F. Walker@eop ( Christopher F. Walker@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman@eop ( Michael Waldman@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey@eop ( Marjorie Tarmey@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews@eop ( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham@eop ( Sara M. Latham@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Todd Stern@eop ( Todd Stern@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wendy Smith@eop ( Wendy Smith@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman@EOP ( Joshua Silverman@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz@eop ( Laura D. Schwartz@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber@eop ( Sarah J. Reber@eop [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Terrell@eop ( Michael Terrell@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney@eop ( Megan C. Moloney@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire@eop ( Anne E. McGuire@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason@eop ( Julie E. Mason@eop [ WHO 1 )
�Page 4 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin@eop ( Kirk T. Hanlin@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King@eop ( Angus S. King@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta@eop ( John Podesta@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson@eop ( Brian J. Johnson@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh@eop ( Phu D. Huynh@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich@eop ( Nancy V. Hernreich@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin@EOP ( D. Stephen Goodin@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Glynn@eop ( Mary E. Glynn@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly@eop ( Andrew Friendly@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm Emanuel@eop ( Rahm Emanuel@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards@eop ( Anne M. Edwards@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe@EOP ( Marilyn DiGiacobbe@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen@EOP ( Michael Cohen@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Capps@eop ( Laura Capps@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird@eop ( Debra D. Bird@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick@eop ( Nicholas R. Baldick@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders@eop ( Brenda M. Anders@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The President will travel to Baltimore to deliver the Morgan State
commencement
address on Sunday, May 18.
Deadlines for his trip book are as follows:
�..
Page 5 of5
ARMS Email System
BACKGROUND MATERIALS are due on FRIDAY, MAY 16 at 4:00
political Background
Economic I-pager
Local Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Environmental Hot Issues
Crime I-pager
EVENT MEMOS are due on SATURDAY, MAY 17 at 12:00 NOON.
Thanks! ! ! ! ! ! !
~.m.
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 1
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Kathleen M. Wallman ( CN=Kathleen M. Wallman/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 15-MAY-1997 12:07:32.00
SUBJ'ECT:
products liability
TO: Jeffrey A. Frankel ( CN=Jeffrey A. Frankel/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey,E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Burson ( CN=Charles W. Burson/O=OvP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa Green
READ: UNKNOWN
Dudl~y/OU=WHO/O=EOP
@ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TEXT:
(This is intended to be a reminder notice, but a couple of people to whom
I've spoken were unaware of the following meeting -- )
We are scheduled to meet in Room 231 ,at 11 tomorrow (Friday 5/16) to
discuss further products liability legislation.
I propose that we discuss
the following
1.
2.
3.
Status of legislation (Tracey and Peter)
Volunteer Liability legislation (Tracey and Peter)
Veto statement objections
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/Ou=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 16-MAY-1997 14:04:50.00
SUBJECT:
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia·R. Green ( CN=Julia R. Green/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alison E. Bracewell ( CN=Alison E. Bracewell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO. 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth M. Toohey ( CN=Elizabeth M. Toohey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca R. Culberson ( CN=Rebecca R. Culberson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ OMB 1 )
TO: Victoria Radd ( CN=Victoria Radd/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beverly J. Barnes ( CN=Beverly J. Barnes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth S. Apfel ( CN=Kenneth S. Apfel/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�A-RMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=ElenaKagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia M. Terzano ( CN=Virginia M. Terzano/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John o. Sutton ( CN=John O. Sutton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN=Peter R. Orszag/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn o. Higgins ( CN=Kathryn
READ: UNKNOWN
o.
Higgins/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN=Elizabeth R. Newman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[WHO 1 )
TO: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Rahm and Gene will hold a budget rollout meeting today at 4:15 in the
Ward Room.-Michelle 62531/Melissa 65804
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 5
(ALL-IN-1 MAIL)
CREATOR: Helen P. Howell ( HOWELL_H)
(WHO)
CREATION DATE!TIME:18-MAY-1997 14:04:56.11
SUBJECT: West Virginia Trip
TO: Brenda M. Anders
READ: NOT READ
ANDERS B ), Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kris Balderston
READ: NOT READ
BALDERSTON K ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick
READ: NOT READ
BALDICK N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: David S. Beaubaire
READ: NOT READ
BEAUBAIRE D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Debra D. Bird
READ: NOT READ
BIRD D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Alison Bracewell
READ: NOT READ
BRACEWELL A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Dennis Burke
READ: NOT READ
BURKE D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Phillip M. Caplan
READ:22-MAY-1997 08:23:33.71
CAPLAN P
TO: Laura Capps
READ: NOT READ
CAPPS L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland
READ: NOT READ
CLEVELAND C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Michael Cohen
READ: NOT READ
COHEN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius
READ: NOT READ
CORNELIUS C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Glyn T. Davies
READ: NOT READ
DAVIES G
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe
READ: NOT READ
DIGIACOBBE M ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley
READ: NOT READ
DUDLEY J
TO: Anne M. Edwards
READ: NOT READ
EDWARDS A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Nicole Elkon
READ: NOT READ
ELKON N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Rahm Emanuel
EMANUEL R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
(WHO)
(NSC)
) Autoforward to: Remote Address
�ARMS Email System
Page 2 of5
"
READ: NOT READ
TO: Shelley N, Fidler
READ:NOT READ
FIDLER S ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Andrew Friendly
READ:NOT READ
FRIENDLY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines
READ: NOT READ
GAINES J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Mary Ellen Glynn
READ: NOT READ
GLYNN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Jason S. Goldberg
READ: NOT READ
GOLDBERG JS ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: David S. Goodin
READ: NOT READ
GOODIN D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Julia R. Green
READ: NOT READ
GREEN J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich
READ: NOT READ
HERNREICH N ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Russell W. Horwitz
READ: NOT READ
HORWITZ R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Phu D. Huynh
READ: NOT READ
HUYNH P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso-Rotunno
READ: NOT READ
JASSOROTUN C ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Brian J. Johnson
READ: NOT READ
JOHNSON BJ ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Jackson T. Dunn
READ:NOT READ
( Jackson Dunn III@EOP@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: John Podesta
READ: NOT READ
( John Podesta@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Elena Kagan
READ:NOT READ
KAGAN E ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Donald L. Kerrick
READ:19-MAY-1997 19:53:20.97
KERRICK D
TO: Angus S. King
READ: NOT READ
KING A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
(NSC)
TO: Katherine Hubbard
READ: NOT READ
( Katherine Hubbard@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX
TO: Kirk Hanlin
READ: NOT READ
( Kirk T. Hanlin@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey
LINDSEY_B ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: NOT READ
TO: Gordon Li
READ: NOT READ
LI G ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Julie E. Mason
READ: NOT READ
MASON J ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Floydetta McAfee
READ: NOT READ
MCAFEE F ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Anne E. McGuire
READ:NOT READ
MCGUIRE A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Lorraine McHugh
READ: NOT READ
MCHUGH L
TO: APRIL K. MELLODY
READ: NOT READ
MELLODY A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Cathy L .. Millison
READ: NOT READ
MILLISON C
TO: Megan C. Moloney
READ:NOT READ
MOLONEY M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Linda L. Moore
READ:NOT READ
MOORE L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Ruby G. Moy
READ:NOT READ
MOY R ) Autoforward to: Remote Addressee
TO: Michael Terrell
READ:NOT READ
(WHO)
(NSC)
( Michael Terrell@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO; Peter R. Orszag
READ:NOT READ
ORSZAG P ) Autoforward to; Remote Address
TO: Jennifer Palmieri
READ:20-MAY-1997 12:00:07.78
PALMIERI J
TO: Sarah J. Reber
READ: NOT READ
REBER S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Christa T. Robinson
READ:NOT READ
ROBINSON C
TO: Dan Rosenthal
READ:NOT READ
ROSENTHAL D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
(WHO)
(OPD)
.TO: Lee A. Satterfield
READ: NOT READ
SATTERFIEL L ) Autoforward to: Remote Add
TO: Laura D. Schwartz
READ:NOT READ
SCHWARTZ L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Stephen B. Silverman
READ:NOT READ
SILVERMAN S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Joshua Silverman
SILVERMAN J
) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of5
READ: NOT READ
TO: Craig T. Smith
READ: NOT READ
SMITH CT ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Wendy L. Smith
READ: NOT READ
SMITH WL ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Aviva Steinberg
READ: NOT READ
STEINBERG A ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Todd Stern
READ: NOT READ
STERN T ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Stephanie Streett
READ: NOT READ
STREETT S ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Sara M. Latham
READ: NOT READ
( Sara M. Latham@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Stefanie Sanford
READ: NOT READ
( Stephanie Sanford@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews
READ: NOT READ
( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop@LNGTWY@EOPMRX )
TO: Lisa Jordan Tamagni
READ: NOT READ
TAMAGNI L ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Marjorie Tarmey
READ: NOT READ
TARMEY M ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: June G. Turner
READ: NOT READ
TURNER J ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Michael Waldman
READ: NOT READ
WALDMAN M ) Autoforward to: Remote Addres
TO: Ann F. Walker
READ: NOT READ
WALKER A ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Christopher F. Walker
READ: NOT READ
WALKER C ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman
READ: NOT READ
WALLMAN KM ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
TO: Christopher Wayne
READ: NOT READ
WAYNE C ) Autoforward to: Remote Addresse
TO: Dorian v. Weaver
READ: NOT READ
WEAVER D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Paul J. Weinstein, Jr
READ: NOT READ
WEINSTEIN P ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TO: Daniel Wexler
READ: NOT READ
WEXLER D ) Autoforward to: Remote Address
TO: Diane M. Whitmore
WHITMORE D ) Autoforward to: Remote Addre
�ARMS Email System
Page 5 of5
'.
READ: NOT READ
TO: Cecily C. Williams
READ:NOT READ
WILLIAMS CC ) Autoforward to: Remote Addr
TEXT:
The President will travel to West Virginia on Thursday, May 22.
All materials for his trip book are due on Wednesday, May 21 at 4:00 p.m.
BACKGROUND MATERIALS are due on WEDNESDAY, MAY 21 at 4:00 p.m.
Political Background
Economic 1-pager
Local Issues
Cabinet Affairs Hot Issues
Crime 1-pager
Environmental Hot Issues
EVENT MEMOS are due on WEDNESDAY, MAY 21 at 4:00 p.m.
Thanks! ! ! ! ! !
�'.
ARMS Email System
.'
Page 1 of2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:19-MAY-1997 13:44:52.00
SUBJECT:
Tomorrow's DPC Staff Meeting
TO: Eric P. Goosby
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: WEINSTEIN P
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Eric P. Goosby/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
WEINSTEIN P @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (OPD)
TO: Christa Robinson ( CN=Christa Robinson/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole R. Rabner ( CN=Nicole R. Rabner/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeanne Lambrew ( CN=Jeanne Lambrew/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William R. Kincaid ( CN=William R. Kincaid/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Thomas L. Freedman ( CN=Thomas L. Freedman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth Drye ( CN=Elizabeth Drye/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jose Cerda III ( CN=Jose Cerda III/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark J. Mazur ( CN=Mark J. Mazur/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sandra Thurman ( CN=Sandra Thurman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Leanne A. Shimabukuro ( CN=Leanne A. Shimabukuro/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Prince ( CN=Jonathan Prince/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer L. Klein ( CN=Jennifer L. Klein/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
�ARMS Email System
'.
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah A. Bianchi ( CN=Sarah A. Bianchi/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Tomorrow's'DPC Staff meeting will start at 9:45 a.m. in Room 211.
Page 2 of2
�-
~,
ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 3
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:20-MAY-1997 15:22:12.00
SUBJECT:
Budget RollOut
TO: MCHUGH L
READ: UNKNOWN
MCHUGH L @ A1 @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: WHITE_W ( WHITE W @ A1 @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(OMB)
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN=Robert B. Johnson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A .. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen ( CN=Michael Cohen/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Barry J. Toiv ( CN=Barry J. Toiv/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beth A. Viola ( CN=Beth A. Viola/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eli G. Attie ( CN=Eli G. Attie/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl M. Carter ( CN=Cheryl M. Carter/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth S. Apfel ( CN=Kenneth S. Apfel/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Virginia M. Terzano ( CN=Virginia M. Terzano/O=Ovp @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles R. Marr ( CN=Charles R. Marr/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jake Siewert ( CN=Jake Siewert/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
[ OPD 1 )
�'.
ARMS Email System
Page 2 of3
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire ( CN=Anne E. McGuire/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca R. Culberson ( CN=Rebecca R. Culberson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Victoria Radd ( CN=Victoria Radd/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ECHAVESTE M
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
ECHAVESTE M @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
TO: Linda L. Moore ( CN=Linda L. Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah A. Bianchi ( CN=Sarah A. Bianchi/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lawrence J. Haas ( CN=Lawrence J. Haas/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert M. Shireman ( CN=Robert M. Shireman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson ( CN=Brian J.
READ: UNKNOWN
Johnson/OU=CEQ/O~EOP @
EOP [ CEQ 1 )
TO: Jonathan A. Kaplan ( CN=Jonathan A. Kaplan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith ( CN=Craig T. Smith/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beverly J. Barnes ( CN=Beverly J. Barnes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green ( CN=Julia R. Green/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Christopher C. Jennings ( CN=Christopher C. Jennings/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alison E. Bracewell ( CN=Alison E. Bracewell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
[ OPD 1
�ARMS Email System
•
Page 3 of3
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag ( CN;Peter R. Orszag/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN;Russell W. Horwitz/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn O. Higgins ( CN;Kathryn O. Higgins/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN;Elizabeth R. Newman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa Green ( CN;Melissa Green/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
There will be a budget roll-out meeting tomorrow, Wednesday, May 21, from
2:00 to 3:00 PM in OEOB Room 180.
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Mark J. Mazur ( CN=Mark J. Mazur/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1
CREATION DATE/TIME:25-MAY-1997 15:11:43.00
SUBJECT:
proper taxation of workfare benefits
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Folks,
I brought up the idea of a joint DPC/NEC decision process with Gene
Sperling at the NEC staff meeting on Friday and he said we should go ahead
and get this started so we can corne to an agreement in relatively short
order.
My thinking on this is that we should let the current process involving
IRS, Labor, and HHS and focussing on administrative solutions chug along
to determine the appropriate interpretation of current law.
But we should
set up a parallel process with these agencies (and any other interested
ones) to develop a legislative solution to this issue. There is a chance
that such a legislative fix can be added to whatever tax bill will be
constructed this summer.
I suggest that we try to convene a group from
Labor, HHS, Treasury, DPC, NEC, OMB, and CEA this corning week to get this
process started. What do you think?
Mark
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of5
._ J.
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: CAPLAN P@A1@CD@LNGTWY ( CAPLAN_P@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(WHO)
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-MAY-1997 12:05:30.00
SUBJECT:
West Point travel
TO: PALMIERI_J@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: KERRICK_D@A1@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
PALMIERI J@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
KERRICK D@A1@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Cecily C. Williams@eop ( Cecily C. Williams@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Daniel Wexler@eop ( Daniel Wexler@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dorian V. Weaver@eop ( Dorian V. Weaver@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen M. Wallman@eop ( Kathleen M. Wallman@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Ann F. Walker@eop ( Ann F. Walker@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: June G. Turner@eop ( June G. Turner@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lisa Tamagni@eop ( Lisa Tamagni@eop [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham@eop ( Sara M. Latham@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Todd Stern@eop ( Todd Stern@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Wendy Smith@eop ( Wendy Smith@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Joshua Silverman@EOP ( Joshua Silverman@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal@eop ( Dan K. Rosenthal@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter R. Orszag@eop ( Peter R. Orszag@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kevin Moran@eop ( Kevin Moran@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Megan C. Moloney@eop ( Megan C. Moloney@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Lorraine L. Wytkind@eop ( Lorraine"L. Wytkind@eop
[ WHO 1 )
(WHO)
(NSC)
�i\,RMS Email System
Page 2 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Floydetta McAfee@eop ( Floydetta McAfee@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura D. Schwartz@eop ( Laura D. Schwartz@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kirk T. Hanlin@eop ( Kirk T. Hanlin@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King@eop ( Angus S. King@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: John Podesta@eop ( John Podesta@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brian J. Johnson@eop ( Brian J. Johnson@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phu D. Huynh@eop ( Phu D. Huynh@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz@eop ( Russell W. Horwitz@eop [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julia R. Green@eop ( Julia R. Green@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jason S. Goldberg@EOP ( Jason S. Goldberg@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jeremy M. Gaines@eop ( Jeremy M. Gaines@eop [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler@eop ( Shelley N. Fidler@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicole Elkon@eop ( Nicole Elkon@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley@eop ( Jennifer D. Dudley@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Catherine A. Cornelius@eop ( Catherine A. Cornelius@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland@EOP ( Carolyn E. Cleveland@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alison E. Bracewell@eop ( Alison E. Bracewell@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David S. Beaubaire@eop ( David S. Beaubaire@eop [ WHO J )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kris M Balderston@EOP ( Kris M Balderston@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: ROBINSON C@Al@CD@LNGTWY
ROBINSON C@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OPD)
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of5
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MILLISON C@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: DAVIES G@Al@CD@LNGTWY
READ: UNKNOWN
MILLISON_C@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
DAVIES G@Al@CD@LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Diane M, Whitmore@eop ( Diane M. Whitmore@eop [ CEA 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.@EOP ( Paul J. Weinstein Jr.@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher Wayne@eop ( Christopher Wayne@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Christopher F. Walker@eop ( Christopher F. Walker@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Waldman@eop ( Michael Waldman@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marjorie Tarmey@eop ( Marjorie Tarmey@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews@eop ( Sylvia M. Mathews@eop [ WHO 1 )"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett@eop ( Stephanie S. Streett@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Aviva Steinberg@eop ( Aviva Steinberg@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Craig T. Smith@eop ( Craig T. Smith@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman@eop ( Stephen B. Silverman@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sarah J. Reber@eop ( Sarah J. Reber@eop [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Terrell@eop ( Michael Terrell@eop [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Linda Moore@eop ( Linda Moore@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: April Mellody@eop ( April Mellody@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne E. McGuire@eop ( Anne E. McGuire@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason@eop ( Julie E. Mason@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey@eop ( Bruce R. Lindsey@eop [ WHO 1 )
(NSC)
�Page 4 of5
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard@eop ( Katherine Hubbard@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan@eop ( Elena Kagan@eop [" OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jackson Dunn III@EOP ( Jackson Dunn III@EOP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia M. Jasso_Rotunno@eop ( Cynthia M. Jasso_Rotunno@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Helen P. Howell@eop ( Helen P. Howell@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich@eop ( Nancy V. Hernreich@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: D. Stephen Goodin@EOP ( D. Stephen Goodin@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary E. Glynn@eop ( Mary E. Glynn@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew Friendly@eop ( Andrew Friendly@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rahm Emanuel@eop ( Rahm Emanuel@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne M. Edwards@eop ( Anne M. Edwards@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe@EOP ( Marilyn DiGiacobbe@EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Cohen@EOP ( Michael Cohen@EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Capps@eop ( Laura Capps@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debra D. Bird@eop ( Debra D. Bird@eop [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nicholas R. Baldick@eop ( Nicholas R. Baldick@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Brenda M. Anders@eop ( Brenda M. Anders@eop
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
[ WHO 1 )
TEXT:
The President is scheduled to travel to West Point on Saturday, May 31 to
deliver the commencement speech.
Deadlines for the trip book are as follows:
Background papers: DUE FRIDAY, MAY 30 at 6:00 PM
�A"RMS Email System
-political memo
-Economic background
-NSC hot issues (if any)
-Cabinet Affairs hot issues (if any)
-Environmental hot issues (if any)
Event memos: DUE FRIDAY, MAY 30 at 6:00 PM
-Commencement speech - NSC
-Reception - NSC
I'll be travelling with the President this week, but feel free to call my
office
with any questions.
I'll be checking in frequently.
Thank you.
Page 5 of5
�ARMS Email System
Page 1 of4
"
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Jason S. Goldberg ( CN=Jason S. Goldberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP [ WHO 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-MAY-1997 10:20:02.00
SUBJECT:
REMINDER: DAILY REPORTS TO POTUS while he is traveling.
TO: MILLISON C
READ: UNKNOWN
MILLISON C @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Christopher J. Lavery ( CN=Christopher J. Lavery/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Dan K. Rosenthal ( CN=Dan K. Rosenthal/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elisa Millsap ( CN=Elisa Millsap/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [.WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Evan Ryan ( CN=Evan Ryan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Betty W. Currie ( CN=Betty W. Currie/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Nancy V. Hernreich ( CN=Nancy V. Hernreich/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Timothy L. Newell ( CN=Timothy L. Newell/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathleen A. McGinty ( CN=Kathleen A. McGinty/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ CEQ 1 )
TO: Bob J. Nash ( CN=Bob J. Nash/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Debbie B Bengtson ( CN=Debbie B Bengtson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephanie S. Streett ( CN=Stephanie S. Streett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Julie E. Mason ( CN=Julie E. Mason/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gordon Li ( CN=Gordon Li/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cheryl D. Mills ( CN=Cheryl D. Mills/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michelle Crisci ( CN=Michelle Crisci/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Alison E. Bracewell ( CN=Alison E. Bracewell/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ann F. Lewis ( CN=Ann F. Lewis/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
[ WHO 1 )
�Page 2 of4
ARMS Email System
"
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Phillip Caplan ( CN=Phillip Caplan/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Katherine Hubbard ( CN=Katherine Hubbard/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Rebecca R. Culberson ( CN=Rebecca R. Culberson/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stacey L. Rubin ( CN=Stacey L. Rubin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Anna M. Gomez ( CN=Anna M. Gomez/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TO: Jim Kohlenberger ( CN=Jim Kohlenberger/O=OVP @ OVP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ UNKNOWN 1 )
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. Dudley/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Teresa Wildman ( CN=Teresa Wildman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Gene B. Sperling ( CN=Gene B. Sperling/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michele Jolin ( CN=Michele Jolin/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lynn G. Cutler ( CN=Lynn G. Cutler/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mark Hunker ( CN=Mark Hunker/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Minyon Moore ( CN=Minyon Moore/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. Latham/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Terri J. Tingen ( CN=Terri J. Tingen/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Beverly J. Barnes ( CN=Beverly J. Barnes/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Andrew J. Mayock ( CN=Andrew J. Mayock/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sylvia M. Mathews ( CN=Sylvia M. Mathews/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 3 of4
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: BLINKEN A
READ: UNKNOWN
BLINKEN A
@
Al
@
CD
@
LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(NSC)
TO: Katharine Button ( CN=Katharine Button/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jonathan Foster ( CN=Jonathan Foster/OU=OSTP/O=EOP @ EOP [ OSTP 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Shelley N. Fidler ( CN=Shelley N. Fidler/OU=CEQ/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEQ 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura K. Demeo ( CN=Laura K. Demeo/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: David M. Strauss ( CN=David M. Strauss/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karin Kullman ( CN=Karin Kullman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Karen E. Skelton ( CN=Karen E. Skelton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth M. Toohey ( CN=Elizabeth M. Toohey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa 'Green/OU=OPD/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ OPD 1 )
TO: Cameron L. Cobden ( CN=Cameron L. Cobden/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Mary Morrison ( CN=Mary Morrison/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Lori L. Anderson ( CN=Lori L. Anderson/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: MCHUGH L
READ: UNKNOWN
MCHUGH L
TO: Charles F. Ruff
READ: UNKNOWN
@
Al
@
CD
@
LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 ) (WHO)
( CN=Charles F. Ruff/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Marjorie Tarmey ( CN=Marjorie Tarmey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Eli G. Attie ( CN=Eli G. Attie/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Kevin S. Moran ( CN=Kevin S. Moran/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Stephen B. Silverman ( CN=Stephen B. Silverman/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�Page 4 of4
ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: JOLIN_M ( JOLIN M @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
(WHO)
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN;Susan A. Brophy/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Russell W. Horwitz ( CN;Russell W. Horwitz/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce N. Reed ( CN;Bruce N. Reed/OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael D. Malone ( CN;Michael D. Malone/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jodie R. Torkelson ( CN;Jodie R. Torkelson/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Fred Duval ( CN;Fred Duval/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
[ WHO 1 )
TO: Laura S. Marcus ( CN;Laura S. Marcus/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Robert B. Johnson ( CN;Robert B. Johnson/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Carole A. Parmelee ( CN;Carole A. Parmelee/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elizabeth R. Newman ( CN;Elizabeth R. Newman/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Angus S. King ( CN;Angus S. King/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Victoria Radd ( CN;Victoria Radd/OU;WHO/O;EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Paul J. Weinstein Jr.
READ: UNKNOWN
( CN;Paul J. Weinstein Jr./OU;OPD/O;EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
TEXT:
Per standard procedure, we will submit a memo to the POTUS each day this
week while he is traveling.
Each office should submit their reports via e-mail or disk to me please by
4:00 p.m. each day.
Thank you.
Tuesday 5/27 at 8:30 a.m ..
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Mark J. Mazur ( CN=Mark J. Mazur/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-MAY-1997 12:00:49.00
SUBJECT:
Re: proper taxation of workfare benefits
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Elena,
Thanks for your note.
I think that a decision process on the taxation of
workfare benefits should not pre-judge the outcome, and so I respectfully
disagree with your proposal to limit the process to filling in the details
of how workfare benefits should be non-taxable (for income and FICA
purposes). The DPC/NEC work group is likely to end up with this
conclusion, but I would prefer to hear this issue out (I know Treasury has
done some thinking about the appropriate tax treatment and that some NEC
staffers feel very strongly that workfare benefits should be subject to
income tax, so that recipients can qualify for the EITC).
Personally, my
feeling is that the benefits are akin to welfare (AFDC) benefits and
should be treated the same, but if presented with persuasive evidence to
the contrary, my beliefs could also change.
Is there a problem with seriously looking at this issue anew?
Mark
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Melissa Green ( CN=Melissa GreenjoU=OPDjO=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATEjTIME:30-MAY-1997 09:43:29.00
SUBJECT:
TO: Timothy J. Brennan ( CN=Timothy J. BrennanjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Patricia E. Romani ( CN=Patricia E. RomanijOU=OMBjO=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. ThorntonjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura EmmettjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen.S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. SeidmanjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Sara M. Latham ( CN=Sara M. LathamjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Burson ( CN=Charles W. BursonjO=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. ObermillerjOU=CEAjO=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. JacobyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena KaganjOU=OPDjO=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Jennifer D. Dudley ( CN=Jennifer D. DudleyjOU=WHOjO=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Kathy Wallman is chairing a Product Liability Meeting on 6j2 at 1:15pm in
Room 211.
Please let me know if you can not attend.
Thanks
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Mark J. Mazur ( CN=Mark J. Mazur/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA 1
CREATION DATE/TIME: 1-JUN-1997 15:11:07.00
SUBJECT:
Re: proper taxation of workfare benefits
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Elena,
Any word from Bruce on this? As I mentioned to you, there are some NEC
staffers with a very keen interest in this issue and they will be bringing
it up with Gene at Monday's NEC staff meeting.
It would be helpful to
have some indication of where we stand on this.
Thanks,
Mark
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page I of I
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Rachel J. Shapiro ( CN=Rachel J. Shapiro/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 2-JUN-1997 09:01:45.00
SUBJECT:
Product Liability
TO: Timothy J'. Brennan ( CN=Timothy J. Brennan/OU=CEA/O=EOP
READ: UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ CEA 1 )
TO: Jeffrey A. Frankel ( CN=Jeffrey A. Frankel/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: John Podesta ( CN=John Podesta/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Peter G. Jacoby ( CN=Peter G. Jacoby/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Ellen S. Seidman ( CN=Ellen S. Seidman/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: William P. Marshall ( CN=william P. Marshall/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Charles W. Burson ( CN=Charles W. Burson/O=OVP @ OVP [ UNKNOWN 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Michael Deich ( CN=Michael Deich/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Tracey E. Thornton ( CN=Tracey E. Thornton/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Bruce R. Lindsey ( CN=Bruce R. Lindsey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
The product liability meeting scheduled for today has been moved from Rm.
211 to Rm. 180.
�_ ."ARMS Email System
Page 1 of 2
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 2-JUN-1997 12:09:34.00
SUBJECT:
Meeting
TO: Barry White
READ: UNKNOWN
CN=Barry White/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
TO: Phillip B. Levine ( CN=Phillip B. Levine/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn O. Higgins ( CN=Kathryn O. Higgins/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: BUDGET CD
READ: UNKNOWN
BUDGET CD @ Al @ CD @ LNGTWY [ UNKNOWN 1 )
(OMB)
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth S. Apfel ( CN=Kenneth S. Apfel/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Anne H. Lewis ( CN=Anne H. Lewis/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lisa J. Levin ( CN=Lisa J. Levin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elizabeth M. Toohey ( CN=Elizabeth M. Toohey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
�.,ARMS Email System
Page 2 of2
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
You are invited to attend a meeting TODAY at 1:00 p.m. in Room 211,
OEOB.
This meeting will be a dicussion of the new Ways and Means
proposal on welfare to work.
(Note:
if any of you were previously invited to a 1:00 p.m. meeting on
child support enforcement in Room 211, that meeting will be RESCHEDULED
for a later time.)
�(-ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of2
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Cathy R. Mays ( CN=Cathy R. Mays/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 3-JUN-1997 06:25:58.00
SUBJECT:
Conference Call
TO: Anne H. Lewis ( CN=Anne H. Lewis/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kenneth S. Apfel ( CN=Kenneth S. Apfel/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Larry R. Matlack ( CN=Larry R. Matlack/OU=OMB/O~EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emily Bromberg ( CN=Emily Bromberg/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Diana Fortuna ( CN=DianaFortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Susan A. Brophy ( CN=Susan A. Brophy/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Emil E. Parker ( CN=Emil E. Parker/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Keith J. Fontenot ( CN=Keith J. Fontenot/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Kathryn o. Higgins ( CN=Kathryn
READ: UNKNOWN
o.
Higgins/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
TO: Phillip B. Levine ( CN=Phillip B. Levine/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/Ou=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
TO: Janet Murguia ( CN=Janet Murguia/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Elizabeth M. Toohey ( CN=Elizabeth M. Toohey/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Raymond E. Donnelly III ( CN=Raymond E. Donnelly III/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Laura Emmett ( CN=Laura Emmett/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Lisa J. Levin ( CN=Lisa J. Levin/OU=WHO/O=EOP @ EOP [ WHO 1 )
READ: UNKNOWN
CC: Jill M. pizzuto ( CN=Jill M. Pizzuto/OU=OMB/O=EOP @ EOP [ OMB 1 )
�(.ARMS Email System
READ: UNKNOWN
TEXT:
We're going to have another conference call tomorrow at 11:00 a.m. to
discuss with welfare to work proposal. The conference code will be the
same:
Phone 757-2104 and Code 6234.
Page 2 of2
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[03/03/1997 – 06/02/1997]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 097 - Folder 002
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/4a55e6b0def5ba322625db9044be06b6.pdf
f579f866a9d6846643a84027f7dd407e
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS RECEIVED
ARMS - BOX 097 - FOLDER -001
[01/16/1997]
�· ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 51
(ALL-IN-1 MAIL)
CREATOR: OASIS Manager ( OASISMGR )
(OA)
CREATION DATE/TIME:16-JAN-1997 14:09:41.34
SUBJECT: Document Request
TO: All ALL-IN-1 users on this node
READ:NOT READ
( SUBSCRIBERS:
)
IND TO: James M. Treadway
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:37.45
TREADWAY J
(WHO)
IND TO: Lee S. Bennett Jr.
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:40.75
BENNETT L
IND TO: William F. McIntosh
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:25.10
MCINTOSH W
IND TO: Evett F. Gardner
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:18.30
GARDNER E
IND_TO: Gregory G. Henry
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:17.41
HENRY G )
(OMB)
IND_TO: Ada L. Posey
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:11.13
POSEY A
(OA)
IND TO: Sharon L. Solomon
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:21.90
SOLOMON S
IND_TO: Wayne Purser
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:18.99
PURSER W
IND TO: Mark D. Menchik
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:19.78
MENCHIK M
(OMB)
IND_TO: Lycia Sibilia
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:19.32
SIBILLA L )
(WHO)
IND_TO: Cynthia R. Tarr
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:35.05
TARR C
IND_TO: Lorraine McHugh
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:28.65
MCHUGH L )
IND_TO: Tom Vellenga
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:41.36
VELLENGA T
IND_TO: Jaycee A. Pribulsky
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:44.86
PRIBULSKY J
IND_TO: Stephen A. Weigler
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:02.38
WEIGLER S )
IND TO: Karen L. Barbuschak
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:03.17
BARBUSCHAK K
IND TO: Bruce L. Overton
OVERTON B
(DON)
(OA)
(OMB)
(OA)
(DON)
(OA)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(OA)
(OA)
�Page 2 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:03.20
(OPD)
IND TO: Malcolm R. Lee
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:06.47
LEE M
IND_TO: Anne Shelley Walker
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:09.45
WALKER AS
IND_TO: Nicolette Highsmith
READ:16"JAN-1997 14:10:22.21
HIGHSMITH N )
IND TO: Elizabeth A. Kaminski
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:22.83
KAMINSKI E
IND_TO: Raymond P. Kogut
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:23.80
KOGUT R
( OMB)
IND TO: Daniel Rader
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:34.80
RADER D
(OA)
IND TO: Martha B. Schiele
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:37.41
SCHIELE M
IND TO: Carla B. Stone
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:39.66
STONE C
IND_TO: Steven J. Naplan
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:45.94
NAPLAN S )
IND_TO: Ophelia D. West
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:47.70
WEST 0
IND_TO: Lynnae C. Roscoe
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:47.69
ROSCOE L
IND_TO: Edward Brigham
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:58.77
BRIGHAM E
IND_TO: Jarrell F. Nowlin
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:10:59.79
NOWLIN J
IND_TO: David Rostker
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:11:00.73
ROSTKER D
(OMB)
IND_TO: R S. Michaud
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:11:03.50
MICHAUD R
(WHO)
IND TO: Doris o. Matsui
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:11:14.52
MATSUI D
IND TO: Daren K. Wong
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:11:17.10
WONG D
IND_TO: Darlene o. Gaymon
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:11:19.91
GAYMON D
(OMB)
IND_TO: Phillip Caplan
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:11:25.33
CAPLAN P
(WHO)
IND TO: Michael J. Costic
COSTIC M
(GSA)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OA)
(OMB)
(NSC)
(OMB)
(OA)
(OMB)
(OA)
(WHO)
(OMB)
�ARMS Email System
Page 3 of 51
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:11:33.95
(WHO)
IND TO: Jennifer D. Dudley
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:11:39.47
DUDLEY J
IND_TO: Richard S. McKay
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:11:43.32
MCKAY R
(OA)
IND_TO: Chrishania Berry
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:11:58.83
BERRY C
(OA)
IND_TO: Elisabeth Blaug
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:11:59.09
BLAUG E
(CEQ)
IND_TO: April K. Mellody
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:11:59.78
MELLODY A
IND_TO: Diane Regas
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:12:16.55
REGP.S_D
IND_TO: Stephen R. Seidel
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:12:21.91
SEIDEL S
INn_TO: Mark A. weatherly
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:12:24.23
WEATHERLY M
(OMB)
IND_TO: G. Timothy Saunders
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:12:25.41
SAUNDERS GT )
(WHO)
IND TO: Francine P. Obermiller
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:12:25.91
OBERMILLER F
IND_TO: Lauren E. Wright
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:12:36.25
WRIGHT L
IND TO: Michael S. Skerl
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:12:45.20
SKERL M
IND_TO: Kate P. Donovan
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:12:47.83
DONOVAN KP
INTI_TO: David Shipley
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:12:48.17
SHIPLEY D
IND_TO: Michele R. Joy
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:12:53.89
JOY M
IND TO: Rochelle D. Gomes
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:12:54.70
GOMES R
IND_TO: Christopher T. Dyke
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:12:59.12
DYKE C
INTI TO: Kristen E. Panerali
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:13:04.18
PANERALI K ) (OPD)
INTI TO: Michael Cohen
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:13:05.41
COHEN M
IND_TO: Edwin R. Thomas III
THOMAS ER )
(WHO)
(OPD)
(CEQ)
(WHO)
(OA)
(OA)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OA)
(OA)
(OA)
(OPD)
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
Page 4 of 51
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:13:18.21
IND_TO: Ursula Sanville
SANVILLE U ) (OPD)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:13:21.97
IND_TO: Nancy E. Schwartz
SCHWARTZ N
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:13:41.72
IND TO: Sandra L. Bublick-Max
BUBLICKMAX S
(OPD)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:13:43.45
IND TO: Jennifer Palmieri
PALMIERI J ) (WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:13:45.35
IND_TO: Donald P. Daugherty
DAUGHERTY D ) (DON)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:13:49.67
INn TO: Linda C. Corbelli
CORBELL I L ) (OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:14:02.60
IND TO: Francis S. Redburn
REDBURN F ) (OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:14:17.32
IND_TO: Elisa Millsap
MILLSAP E ) (WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:14:17.52
IND TO: Linda M. Tolkan
TOLKAN L
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:14:17.89
IND_TO: Nellie W. Doering
DOERING N
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:14:36.64
IND_TO: Cynthia J. Lizik
LIZIK C
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:14:46.21
IND_TO: William C. Haymes
HAYMES W )
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:14:53.00
IND_TO: Sandra L. Via
VIA S
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:14:56.27
IND_TO: Dorothy Crumling
CRUMLING D
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:15:18.93
IND_TO: William B. English
ENGLISH W )
(CEA)
FLEMING P )
(WHO)
MITSLER E )
(NSC)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:15:00.64
IND_TO: Patsy Fleming
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:15:04.65
IND TO: Elaine M. Mitsler
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:15:04.86
IND TO: Pamela B. VanWie
VANWIE P ) (OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:15:18.35
IND_TO: Valerie Hopkins
HOPKINS V)
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:15:35.98
IND TO: Maureen F. Lewis
LEWIS M
(WHO)
�Page 5 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:15:43.63
IND_TO: Margaret M. Suntum
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:15:50.89
SUNTUM M ) (WHO)
IND TO: Deloris K. Pletcher
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:15:51.35
PLETCHER D
IND_TO: Joseph G. Pipan
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:15:58.70
PIPAN J )
IND_TO: Angelia D. Cliff Johnson
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:16:07.80
JOHNSON AD
IND TO: David S. VanTassel
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:16:11.28
VANTASSEL D
(NSC)
IND TO: Daniel W. Burkhardt
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:16:24.46
BURKHARDT D
(WHO)
IND TO: David L. Sunding
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:16:26.89
SUNDING D
(CEA)
IND TO: Richard P. Theroux
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:16:29.31
THEROUX R
(OMB)
IND TO: S. Lael Brainard
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:16:45.28
BRAINARD L
IND_TO: Kelly Hyland
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:54:10.26
(OA)
(OMB)
(OA)
(WHO)
(. HYLAND_K ) (CPC)
IND TO: Annie B. Calhoun
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:17:09.28
CALHOUN A
(OA)
IND_TO: Mary Jo Siclari
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:17:12.34
SICLARI M
(OMB)
IND_TO: Larry R. Matlack
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:17:20.37
MATLACK L
(OMB)
IND TO: William R. Walker
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:17:25.29
WALKER W )
IND_TO: Philip R. Dame
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:17:46.82
DAME P
IND TO: Susan P. Powell
READ:16-JAN-19.97 14:18:00.85
POWELL S ) (OA)
IND TO: Bernardene B. Walford
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:18:01.01
WALFORD B
IND TO: Rebecca A. Cameron
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:18:34.79
CAMERON RA
(WHO)
IND TO: Patricia Williams
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:18:36.30
WILLIAMS P
(WHO)
IND TO: Miriam S. Braganca
BRAGANCA M
(GSA)
(OA)
(OMB)
(OA)
�Page 6 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:18:43.39
IND_TO: William H: VanHorn
VANHORN W
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:18:47.51
IND_TO: Stephen R. Nolet
NOLET S ) (WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:18:54.48
IND TO: David M. Pritzker
PRITZKER D
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:19:00.04
IND_TO: Manoj M. Paulson
PAULSON M
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:19:05.79
IND TO: Sharon A. Warner
WARNER S ) (OMB )
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:19:09.30
IND_TO: Margaret L. Snyder
SNYDER M
(WHO)
MCKAIG B
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:19:24.88
IND TO: Brian P. McKaig
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:19:31.52
IND TO: Carrie S. Cihak
CIHAK C ) (WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:19:46.84
IND TO: Katherine J. Fertakis
FERTAKIS K
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:19:49.84
IND_TO: Reginald D. Young
YOUNG RD
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:19:52.91
IND_TO: Katherine M. Tyer
TYER K ) (OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:20:01.11
IND_TO: Joseph G. Kouba
KOUBA J )
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:20:03.51
IND_TO: Carol R. Dennis
DENNIS C
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:20:32.15
IND TO: Diane M. Whitmore
WHITMORE D
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:21:09.35
IND TO: Marsha L. Dimel
DIMEL M ) (NSC)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:21:40.92
IND TO: Elizabeth M. DiGennaro
DIGENNARO E
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:21:59.18
IND TO: Alice J. Pushkar
PUSHKAR A
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:22:18.11
IND_TO: Nancy K. Hatamiya
HATAMIYA N
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:22:16.73
IND TO: Leanne A. Shimabukuro
SHIMABUKUR L ) (OPD)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:22:26.27
IND TO: Nelson W. Cunningham
CUNNINGHAM N
(OA)
�Page 70f51
ARMS Email System
READ: 16-JAN-1997 14: 23: 22.36
INn_TO: Molly Brostrom
BROSTROM M
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:23:30.74
INn TO: Robert W. Schroeder III
SCHROEDER R
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:24:00.40
INn_TO: Karl E. Debus
DEBUS K
(OA)
DIXON M
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:24:29.14
INn_TO: Mary'A. Dixon
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:24:47.04
INn TO: Kathleen M. Whalen
WHALEN K
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:24:58.88
INn_TO: Signe G. Rhea
RHEA S
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:25:19.95
INn TO: Michael J. Sullivan
(WHO)
SULLIVAN M
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:25:32.25
INn TO: Matthew A. Beck
BECK M
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:26:06.98
INn TO: Jamie B. Schwartz
SCHWARTZ J
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:26:35.22
INn TO: Marvella T. Patton
PATTON M ) (OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:26:40.67
INn TO: Steven N. Simon
(NSC)
SIMON S
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:26:43.60
INn_TO: Mary A. Thomas
THOMAS M ) (WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:27:01.47
INn TO: Ellen S. Seidman
SEIDMAN E
(OPD)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:27:23.60
INn TO: Sara B. Weider
WEIDER S
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:27:26.51
INn_TO: Stephanie Whitmore
WHITMORE S
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:27:30.40
IND_TO: Charles L. Sigman
SIGMAN C
)
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:27:54.40
INn TO: Cheri M. Carter
CARTER CM
(WHO)
WALLMAN K
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:27:55.11
INn TO: Katherine K. Wallman
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:28:04.44
INn_TO: Gregory B. Garvin
GARVIN G
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:28:21.53
INn TO: Anne E. McGuire
MCGUIRE A
(WHO)
�Page 8 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:28:21.75
IND_TO: Sigrid N. Smith
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:28:32.32
SMITH SN
(OA)
IND_TO: Allison M. Wright
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:29:04.73
WRIGHT A
(NSC)
IND TO: DesireeC. Noble
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:29:09.19
NOBLE D
IND TO: Jennifer A. Jordan
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:29:40.10
JORDAN JA
(WHO)
IND_TO: Bunny Connell
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:29:44.26
CONNELL B
(CEQ)
IND_TO: Stephanie A. Alonzo
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:30:03.77
ALONZO S
IND TO: Janie L. Jeffers
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:30:05.15
JEFFERS J
IND TO: Robert J. Pellicci
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:30:08.99
PELLICCI R
IND_TO: Martha Foley
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:30:26.71
FOLEY M } (WHO)
IND TO: Catherine S. Barker
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:30:27.40
BARKER C
IND TO: Robert J. Tuccillo
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:31:01.23
TUCCILLO R
IND TO: Tilman Dean
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:31:13.24
DEAN T
IND_TO: Cynthia K. Gustafson
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:31:15.42
GUSTAFSON C
IND_TO: Jenise Littlejohn
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:31:30.09
LITTLEJOHN J } (OMB)
IND_TO: Ruby M. Brown
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:32:02.30
BROWN RM
IND TO: Kenneth K. Hembree
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:32:34.10
HEMBREE K
(OA)
IND_TO: Jurg E. Hochuli
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:32:39.04
HOCHULI J
(OA)
IND TO: Steve Ronnel
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:32:40.83
RONNEL S
IND_TO: Darby E. Stott
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:32:41.31
STOTT D
(WHO)
IND TO: M. Kay Joshi
JOSHI M
(NSC)
(OMB)
(OA)
(CPC)
(OMB)
(DON)
(OMB)
(DON)
(WHO)
(OA)
(WHO)
�Page 9 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:33:56.69
IND_TO: Avelino Rodriguez
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:34:55.81
RODRIGUEZ A
(OA)
IND TO: Elizabeth R. Ubbens
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:34:59.77
UBBENS E
IND TO: Jill Pizzuto
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:35:35.88
PIZZUTO J
IND_TO: Mary A. Nowell
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:36:20.96
NOWELL M
IND_TO: Joyce A. Ford
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:36:31.12
FORD J
IND TO: Irene H. McGowan
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:36:37.45
MCGOWAN I
IND TO: Gordon Li
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:36:39.81
LI G
IND TO: Mark J. Mazur
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:36:43.61
MAZUR M
(WHO)
IND_TO: Philip H. Cogan
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:36:43.87
COGAN P
(DON)
IND TO: Eric N. Gioia
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:37:08.32
GIOIA E
(WHO)
IND TO: Sarah G. Horrigan
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:37:29.20
HORRIGAN S
IND_TO: Stephen L. Jewell
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:37:31.31
JEWELL S )
IND TO: Melinda L. Alter
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:37:34.16
ALTER M
(OA)
IND_TO: Mary N. Blair
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:37:36.53
BLAIR M
(OA)
IND_TO: Cheryl L Sweitzer
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:37:46.83
SWEITZER C
IND TO: Patricia A. Smith
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:38:16.43
SMITH P
IND TO: David S. Beaubaire
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:38:21.29
BEAUBAIRE D
IND TO: Karen S. Dooley
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:39:33.59
DOOLEY K )
IND TO: Debra S. Wood
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:39:38.08
WOOD D
IND TO: Sara C. Emery
EMERY S
(WHO)
(OMB)
)
(OA)
(OA)
(OA)
)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(OA)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(WHO)
( OMB)
(WHO)
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
Page 10 of 51
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:39:45.57
(OA)
IND_TO: Wayne A. Jones
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:40:50.22
IND TO: Mark E. Frownfelter
FROWNFELTE M
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:42:09.71
IND_TO: Cathy L. Millison
MILLISON C
(NSC)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:42:15.50
IND TO: Karl H. Heissner
C HEISSNER_K
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:42:33.33
IND TO: Elizabeth Simmons
SIMMONS E
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:42:48.17
IND TO: Brian J. Johnson
JOHNSON BJ
(CEQ)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:43:08.32
IND TO: Bruce D. Long
LONG B
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:43:15.66
IND TO: Alison E. Bracewell
(WHO)
BRACEWELL A
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:43:21.83
IND TO: Dinah Bear
BEAR D
(CEQ)
ABEL R
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:43:33.84
IND TO: Rein Abel
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:43:38.62
IND TO: Brian A. Amorosi
AMOROSI B ) (WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:43:52.38
IND_TO: Elizabeth Berman
BERMAN E ) (WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:43:58.32
IND_TO: Janice H. Vranich
VRANICH J
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:44:32.32
IND_TO: John B. Moore
MOORE J
(OMB)
WHITE W
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:45:21.26
IND TO: William G. White
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:45:25.79
IND TO: Daniel Wexler
WEXLER D )
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:45:40.87
IND TO: John Carnevale
CARNEVALE J
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:45:46.25
IND TO: Berit Dean
DEAN B
(OA)
PARK D
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:45:56.76
IND TO: Darrell Park
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:46:07.17
IND TO: Mary C. Beck
BECK MC ) (OA)
(DON)
�ARMS Email System
Page 11 of 51
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:47:12.58
IND_TO: Douglas J. Band
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:47:14.45
BAND D)
(WHO)
IND TO: R. Vickie Rasin
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:47:29.45
RASIN R )
IND_TO: Wayne A. Reynolds
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:47:54.54
REYNOLDS W
IND_TO: Ashby D. Dunning
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:48:02.11
DUNNING A
(OA)
IND_TO: Kimberley R. Stanley
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:49:03.70
STANLEY K
(OA)
IND_TO: Stephen C. Warnath
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:50:21.60
WARNATH S ) (OPD)
IND_TO: Diane Ikemiyashiro
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:50:58.22
IKEMIYASHI D
IND TO: Patricia A. Clark
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:51:01.73
CLARK P )
(WHO)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OA)
IND TO: Lisa D. Branch
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:51:02.70
(WHO)
IND TO: Alicia H. Munnell
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:52:44.81
MUNNELL A
IND_TO: Mary E. Jones
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:52:51.98
JONES ME ) (WHO)
IND TO: Daniel J. Gunia
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:52:57.74
GUNIA D ) (OA)
IND_TO: Lori E. Abrams
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:53:26.54
ABRAMS L ) (WHO)
IND TO: Ronald L. Silberman
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:55:42.81
SILBERMAN R
IND TO: Katharine M. Button
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:56:32.60
BUTTON K ) (WHO)
IND_TO: Pauline M. Abernathy
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:56:36.42
ABERNATHY P
IND_TO: Dorothy K. Craft
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:56:48.60
CRAFT D ) (OPD)
IND_TO: Jeffrey A. Frankel
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:57:27.48
FRANKEL J
IND TO: Kathleen E. Dyer
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:57:40.54
DYER K )
IND TO: Steven D. Aitken
AITKEN S ) (OMB)
(OMB)
(OPD)
(CEA)
(OA)
�ARMS Email System
Page 12 of 51
READ:21-JAN-1997 09:18:14.52
IND TO: Jonathan Foster
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:58:22.93
FOSTER J
(STP)
IND TO: Patricia E. Romani
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:58:27.46
ROMANI P
(OMB)
IND_TO: Noah Engelberg
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:58:30.35
ENGELBERG N
IND TO: McGavock D. Reed
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:58:34.48
REED M
(OMB)
IND_TO: Wendy E. Gray
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:58:39.62
GRAY W )
(NSC)
IND TO: Annie R. Bonner
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:59:17.60
BONNER A
(OA)
IND_TO: Cary M. Havert
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:59:45.09
HAVERT
(OA)
IND TO: Ronald T. Keohane
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:00:11.76
KEOHANE R
IND TO: Bonnie J. Houchen
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:00:23.16
HOUCHE B
IND TO: Earl L. Ashton Jr.
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:00:24.66
ASHTON E
IND_TO: Mary M. Chuckerel
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:00:34.38
CHUCKEREL M
IND_TO: Jeff Blaylock
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:01:48.24
BLAYLOCK J
IND TO: Bruce N. Reed
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:01:58.24
REED B
IND_TO: Barbara E. Washington
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:02:16.90
WASHINGTON B
IND TO: Jonathan M. Prince
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:02:59.80
PRINCE J
IND TO: Cristian J. Santesteban
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:03:05.59
SANTESTEBA C
IND TO: Franklin E. Bautista
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:03:32.19
BAUTISTA F )
IND TO: Barbara E. Doran
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:04:05.58
DORAN B
IND TO: Kathleen M. McGrath
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:04:10.52
MCGRATH K )
IND TO: Bessie M. Weaver
WEAVER B
(OMB)
C
(DON)
(VPO)
(OA)
0)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(OPD)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(CEA)
(OA)
(OA)
(OA)
(OMB)
�Page 13 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:05:19.97
IND TO: victoria A. Spears
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:05:21.36
SPEARS V )
(DON)
IND_TO: John C. Angell
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:05:27.32
ANGELL J
(WHO)
IND_TO: Judith A. Spangler
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:06:15.95
SPANGLER J
IND_TO: Betsy Quint-Moran
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:06:24.95
QUINTMORAN~B
IND_TO: Daniel C. Montoya
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:07:10.36
MONTOYA DC
IND_TO: Delphine C. Motley
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:07:52.19
MOTLEY D
IND TO: John Gribben
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:07:54.66
GRIBBEN J
IND_TO: Justine F. Rodriguez
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:08:30.17
RODRIGUEZ J
IND TO: Cookab V. Hashemi
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:09:17.18
HASHEMI C
IND TO: Michelle Crisci
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:09:29.51
CRISCI M
IND_TO: Therese A. Taylor
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:09:30.06
TAYLOR TA
IND_TO: Sheila Conley
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:09:44.03
CONLEY S
(OMB)
IND_TO: Brenda J. Farmer
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:09:55.25
FARMER B
(DON)
IND_TO: Sonyia Matthews
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:10:28.22
MATTHEWS S
IND_TO: Gordon P. Agress
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:10:57.42
AGRESS G
IND TO: Valerie G. Walters
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:11:14.12
WALTERS VG
IND TO: Denise M. Vines
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:11:25.94
VINES D )
(OA)
IND_TO: Ronald C. Kelly
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:11:58.88
KELLY R )
(GSA)
IND TO: Albert F. Stidman
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:12:07.09
STIDMAN A
IND TO: Alex G. Nagy
NAGY A
)
(WHO)
(OPD)
(OPD)
( OMB)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(GSA)
(OPD)
(OMB)
(OA)
(OMB)
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
Page 14 of 51
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:12:40.85
(OMB)
IND TO: Jennifer C. Wagner
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:12:50.51
WAGNER J )
IND TO: Michelle A. Houston
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:13:33.70
HOUSTON M
IND TO: Jeanine D. Smartt
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:14:04.62
SMARTT J )
IND TO: John P. Hart
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:14:09.33
HART J
IND_TO: Courtney B. Hopkins
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:14:30.11
HOPKINS CB
IND_TO: William R. Pepal
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:14:35.79
PEPAL W
IND TO: Ellen E. Olcott
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:14:53.89
OLCOTT E
IND_TO: Christopher R. Deane
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:15:04.29
DEANE C
IND TO: Laura C. Jones
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:15:42.67
JONES LC
IND_TO: Stacey L. Rubin
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:15:52.19
RUBIN S
IND_TO: Jeff P. Dailey
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:16:49.72
DAILEY J
IND_TO: Lynne M. Winslow
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:17:18.35
WINSLOW L
IND TO: Christina Barnes
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:18:17.27
BARNES C
IND_TO: Carolyn Swinney
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:18:41.63
SWINNEY C
IND_TO: Danilo Deguzman Jr.
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:19:11.58
DEGUZMAN D
IND_TO: Catherine A. Cornelius
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:19:45.34
CORNELIUS C
INn_TO: Lynne D. Scheib
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:21:12.31
SCHEIB L
IND_TO: Christopher J. Ruhm
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:22:10.68
RUHM C
IND_TO: Thomas L. Taylor
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:22:45.43
TAYLOR T
IND TO: Thomas A. Sculimbrene
(WHO)
(OPD)
(WHO)
(OA)
(OA)
(WHO)
(OA)
(OA)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OA)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(DON)
(WHO)
(OA)
(CEA)
(OA)
(NSC)
�ARMS Email System
Page 15 of 51
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:24:56.71
IND_TO: Floydetta McAfee
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:25:11.74
MCAFEE F ) (WHO)
IND_TO: Charles C. Easley
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:25:36.89
EASLEY C ) (OA)
IND_TO: Barbara A. Ferguson
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:26:03.84
FERGUSON B
IND TO: Charles B. Nash
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:26:10.46
NASH C
IND TO: James A. Hawkins
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:27:23.00
HAWKINS J
IND_TO: Susanne Giglio
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:28:01.38
GIGLIO S ) (WHO)
IND_TO: Denise E. Ryan
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:28:38.46
RYAN D
IND_TO: Barbara A. Tyler
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:29:28.56
TYLER B )
IND TO: Patricia v. Woodfolk
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:30:10.91
WOOD FOLK P
IND TO: Edward H. Chase
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:30:33.22
CHASE E ) (OMB)
IND TO: Thomas J. Suarez
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:30:44.30
SUAREZ T ) (OA)
IND_TO: Julia E. Yuille
15:31:45.80
YUILLE J ) (OMB)
IND_TO: Rudolph J. Schuhbauer
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:35:50.11
SCHUHBAUER R
IND_TO: virginia R. Canter
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:35:50.22
CANTER V)
IND TO: William A. Halter
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:36:01.40
HALTER W ) (OMB)
IND TO: Pamela Cicetti
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:36:06.88
CICETTI P
IND TO: Brian G. Scott
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:36:54.15
SCOTT B
IND_TO: Ray Ann Thompson
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:37:43.24
THOMPSON RA
IND TO: Carol Morris
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:37:49.72
MORRIS CZ
(OA)
IND TO: Marilyn R. Jacanin
JACANIN M
(WHO)
(STP)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(DON)
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1~97
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OPD)
(WHO)
(GSA)
�Page 160f51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:38:06.06
(WHO)
IND TO: Diane Faulkner
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:38:25.45
FAULKNER D
IND TO: James A. Bessin
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:38:26.31
BESS IN J )
(OMB)
IND_TO: Carolyn Mosley
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:38:43.10
MOSLEY C )
( CEQ)
IND TO: Odetta S. Walker
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:39:13.66
WALKER 0
)
(WHO)
IND TO: Chris Dorval
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:39:20.53
DORVAL C )
(OPD)
IND TO: Carmena Parris
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:39:53.12
PARRIS C )
(OPD)
IND TO: John W. Ficklin
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:40:25.52
NSC RMO
IND_TO: Virginia M. Terzano
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:41:15.87
TERZAN V
IND_TO: Virginia A. Huth
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:42:31.62
HUTH V
IND TO: Clifford J. Mauton Jr.
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:43:54.66
MAUTON C )
IND TO: Joan S. Hunerwadel
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:44:11.23
HUNERWADEL J
IND_TO: Michael F. Crowley
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:44:42.36
CROWLEY M
IND_TO: Thomas A. Rhoads
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:44:50.17
RHOADS T
IND TO: Karin J. Abramson
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:44:53.05
ABRAMSON K
IND TO: Justin D. Sullivan
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:45:02.86
SULLIVAN JD
IND_TO: Robert J. Donnelly
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:45:36.81
DONNELLY R
IND TO: Suzanne M. Murrin
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:45:41.21
MURRIN S
IND TO: Barbara L. Bernstein
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:45:45.76
BERNSTEIN B
IND_TO: Betty Currie
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:46:30.03
CURRIE B
IND TO: Josie R. Dade
DADE J
(NSC)
(VPO)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(NSC)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(STP)
(WHO)
(OMB)
�Page 17 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:46:31.07
IND_TO: William A. Burkey
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:46:40.22
BURKEY W
(OA)
IND TO: Michelle A. Enger
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:47:07.01
ENGER MA
(OMB)
IND TO: David J. Rivait
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:47:38.27
RIVAIT D
(DON)
IND TO: Dorotha S. Smith
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:49:27.39
SMITH DS
(WHO)
IND TO: Michele M. Jolin
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:49:34.12
JOLIN M
IND_TO: Rachel K. Kinney
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:49:51.82
KINNEY R
IND_TO: Wayne C. Raabe
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:51:11.38
RAABE W
IND TO: Victoria A. Wachino
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:52:15.29
WACHINO VA
IND TO: Keith E. Fuller
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:52:16.44
FULLER K
IND TO: John R. Pfeiffer
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:55:14.75
PFEIFFER J
IND_TO: Roger D. Trogdon
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:56:06.32
TROGDON R
IND TO: Dan K. Rosenthal
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:56:51.47
ROSENTHAL D
IND TO: Thomas S. Lewis
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:57:30.41
LEWIS TS
IND TO: Lewis W. Oleinick
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:58:12.29
OLEINICK L
IND TO: Lorraine Day
READ:16-JAN-1997 15:58:29.92
DAY L )
IND TO: David E. Kalbaugh
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:03:23.69
KALBAUGH D
IND TO: James A. Dorskind
16:03:25.31
(WHO)
(OA)
(DON)
(OMB)
(OA)
(OMB)
(OA)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(OMB)
( DORSKIND J
(WHO)
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN~1997
IND TO: Andris Kalnins
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:04:11.84
KALNINS A
IND TO: Kevin P. Varney
READ:16-JAN-1997.16:04:23.45
VARNEY K
IND TO: Kimberly S. Anderson
ANDERSON K
(OA)
(OPD)
(OA)
�ARMS Email System
Page 18 of 51
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:04:43.41
IND TO: Valerie G. Rich
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:07:23.34
DESK 3
(OA)
IND_TO: Susanna M. Ludwig
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:07:26.29
LUDWIG S )
IND_TO: Nashingda Hart
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:08:20.97
HART N
(OMB)
IND_TO: Sheryl L. Hall
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:08:22.90
HALLS
(OA)
IND TO: Barbara F. Kahlow
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:09:19.65
KAHLOW B
IND TO: Catherine A. Bohn
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:09:51.35
BOHN C
IND TO: Lisa M. Salvetti
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:10:49.78
SALVETTI L
IND TO: Patrick G. Locke
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:11:43.15
LOCKE P
IND TO: Suzanne Dale
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:12:43.99
DALE S
IND TO: Sarah J. Reber
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:12:44.39
REBER S
IND TO: Demetrius A. Reid
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:15:52.93
REID D
(OA)
IND_TO: Lloyd A. Bryan
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:16:05.19
DESK 1
(OA)
IND_TO: Cornelius F. Johnson
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:17:43.23
JOHNSON C
IND TO: Erica L. Kilpatrick
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:17:43.83
KILPATRICK E ) (DON)
IND TO: Kristin A. Schneeman
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:19:29.16
SCHNEE K
IND TO: Kathleen E. O'Halloran
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:19:34.80
OHALLORAN K
IND_TO: Cameron M. Leuthy
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:20:52.79
LEUTHY C
(OMB)
IND_TO: Mary D. Gorham
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:22:13.67
GORHAM M
(OA)
IND TO: Paula M. Sherry
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:23:35.70
SHERRY P
(OA)
IND TO: Antonio E. Chavez
CHAVEZ A
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(WHO)
)
(NSC)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(CEA)
(OA)
(VPO)
(OA)
�Page 19 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:23:38.54
IND_TO: Sandra J. Toomey
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:24:01.58
(STP)
TOOMEY S
(WHO)
IND TO: David S. Goodin
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:24:20.23
IND TO: James T. Engelhardt
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:24:57.48
ENGELHARDT J
(WHO)
IND TO: Melinda D. Haskins
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:25:13.01
HASKINS M
IND TO: Rochester M. Johnson
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:26:02.65
JOHNSON RM
IND_TO: Carolyn Huber
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:26:07.12
HUBER C
(WHO)
IND TO: James B. Kazel
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:26:16.19
KAZEL J
(OMB)
IND_TO: Olga H. Kasaskeris
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:26:31.35
KASASKERIS 0
IND TO: Lee R. Johnson
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:27:01.07
JOHNSON LR
IND_TO: Eugene M. Ebner
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:27:07.57
EBNER E
IND TO: Thomas A. Shea·
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:27:16.27
SHEA T
IND TO: Michael Terrell
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:27:26.23
TERRELL M
IND TO: Eli G. Attie
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:29:14.51
ATTIE E
IND_TO: Kathy McKiernan
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:29:44.11
MCKIERNAN K
IND_TO: Joseph B. McKay III
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:31:19.38
MCKAY J
(GSA)
IND TO: Dennis Burke
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:31:45.14
BURKE D
(OPD)
IND_TO: Anne W. Hawley
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:32:15.87
HAWLEY A
IND TO: Thelma B. Toler
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:33:01.27
TOLER T
IND TO: David M. Luna
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:33:13.70
LUNA D
IND TO: Richard E. Dew
DEW R
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OA)
(WHO)
( OMB)
(WHO)
(CEQ)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OA)
(WHO)
(DON)
�ARMS Email System
Page 20 of 51
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:34:36.43
IND TO: Carole Kitti
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:35:33.37
KITTI C )
IND_TO: Courtney B. Timberlake
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:36:11.25
TIMBERLAKE C
IND_TO: Dorothy Robyn
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:36:45.25
ROBYN D )
IND_TO: Margaret B. Christian
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:37:09.62
CHRISTIAN M
IND TO: Mia Masten
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:43:25.58
MASTEN M ) (OPD)
IND_TO: Phillip B. Levine
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:38:00.75
LEVINE P ) (WHO)
IND TO: Marsha Scott
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:38:10.80
SCOTT M
IND_TO: John W. Kelly
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:41:18.02
KELLY J
IND_TO: Cathy R. Mays
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:43:12.25
MAYS C
IND_TO: La'Wan A. Sweetenberg
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:44:15.87
SWEETENBER L
IND TO: Ellen W. McCathran
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:44:54.58
MCCATHRAN E
IND TO: Charles F. Stone
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:45:33.27
STONE CF ) (WHO)
IND_TO: Elgie Holstein
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:46:18.25
HOLSTEIN E
IND_TO: Shelby J. Atum
16:47:16.69
ATUM S
IND_TO: Stephen B. Silverman
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:48:07.61
SILVERMAN S
IND TO: Rosemarie W. Dale
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:49:23.48
DALE R
IND_TO: John D. Montgomery
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:50:21.67
MONTGOMERY J
IND_TO: Robert F. Epplin
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:50:22.78
EPPLIN R )
IND_TO: David Belsky
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:50:54.37
BELSKY D ) (WHO)
IND TO: Michael Warren
WARREN M
(OMB)
(OMB)
(OPD)
(OMB)
(WHO)
)
(OMB)
(OPD)
(DON)
(WHO)
(OPD)
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-~997
(WHO)
(OMB)
(CEA)
(OMB)
(OPD)
�Page 21 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:51:05.61
IND TO: M. Catherine Fibich
FIBICH M
(WHO)
MACRIS E
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:52:00.74
IND TO: Eric L. Macris
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:52:26.47
IND_TO: Betty A. Marshall
MARSHALL B
(NSC)
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:53:21.40
IND TO: John Stoner
STONER J
(VPO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:53:35.04
IND_TO: Gwendolyn I: Schroeder
SCHROEDER G
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:53:42.13
IND_TO: Henry F. Baley
BALEY H
(DON)
SEIDL F
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:54:48.00
IND TO: Frank J. Seidl III
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:56:14.49
IND TO: Karen L. Hancox
HANCOX K
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:56:34.48
IND TO: Richard C. Crum
CRUM R
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:56:54.26
IND TO: Nevada Williams
WILLIAMS N
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:57:09.66
IND TO: Lawrence R. Jurcich
JURCICH L
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:57:41.74
IND TO: Ronald K. Peterson
PETERSON RK
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:57:56.20
IND TO: Loree K. Sutton
SUTTON L ) (DON)
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:59:35.48
IND_TO: Lois E. Altoft
ALTOFT L ) (OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 16:59:57.78
IND TO: John R. See
SEE J
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:01:13.34
IND_TO: Betsy Myers
MYERS B
(WHO)
ROACH D
(NSC)
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:02:04.74
IND TO: Darren S. Roach
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:02:20.97
IND TO: Brooks Scoville
SCOVILLE B
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:02:29.94
IND TO: Linda A. Reilly
REILLY L
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:05:52.88
IND TO: Alexander J. McClelland
MCCLELLAND A
(OMB)
�Page 22 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:05:55.97
IND TO: Jonna M. Long
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:07:11.65
LONG_J
(OMB)
IND TO: Norman R. Deck
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:09:28.49
DECK N
(DON)
IND_TO: Philip T. Calbos
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:10:07.64
CALBOS P
IND TO: Jane E. Baker
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:10:41.32
BAKER JE
IND_TO: Neil K. Shapiro
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:11:24.58
SHAPIRO N
(OMB)
IND TO: Donna I. Coleman
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:14:18.19
COLEMAN D
(STP)
IND_TO: Rebecca J. Hardy
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:19:52.27
HARDY R
IND TO: William D. Palmer
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:25:45.74
PALMER W )
IND TO: James P. Christopoulos
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:27:02.03
CHRIS TOP J
IND_TO: Douglas S. Sheorn
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:27:30.33
SHEORN D )
IND TO: David L. Plummer
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:28:06.03
PLUMMER D )
(WHO)
IND TO: Natalie S. Wozniak
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:28:29.76
WOZNIAK N )
(NSC)
IND_TO: James M. Teague
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:29:48.85
TEAGUE J
)
(WHO)
IND TO: Marc Garufi
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:30:16.65
GARUFI M
)
(OMB)
IND_TO: Jerry L. Coffey
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:31:59.68
COFFEY J
)
(OMB)
IND TO: James A. Nix
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:35:44.37
NIX JA
(OMB)
IND TO: Bruce D. Harding
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:37:09.51
HARDIN B
)
IND TO: Peter J. Boynton
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:37:40.90
BOYNTON P
(NSC)
IND TO: Joann R. Miller
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:38:45.47
MILLER JR
(OA)
IND TO: Barbara D. Woolley
WOOLLEY·B
(WHO)
(OMB)
(NSC)
)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(VPO)
�Page 23 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:38:48.07
IND TO: William C. Danvers
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:39:15.40
IND_TO: Jay K. Footlik
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:39:40.20
FOOTLIK_J
(WHO)
IND TO: Richard C. Loeb
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:42:44.25
LOEB R
IND_TO: Beverly B. Thierwechter
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:46:06.57
THIERWECHT B
IND TO: Jaha F. Norman
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:46:42.88
NORMAN J
IND TO: Stefanie Sanford
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:46:53.13
SANFORD S
IND TO: Robert L. Wilbon
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:49:11.50
WILBON R
IND_TO: Roger L. Goldblatt
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:53:17.27
GOLDBLATT R
IND TO: Melissa Y. Cook
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:54:58.40
COOK MY
IND TO: Michael B. Feldman
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:56:27.72
FELDMA M
IND TO: Sarah S. Freeman
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:56:53.72
FREEMAN S
(WHO)
IND TO: Linda L. Mesaros
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:58:20.92
MESAROS L
(OMB)
IND_TO: Hugh T. Connelly
READ:16-JAN-1997 17:58:51.35
CONNELLY H
IND TO: Adrienne C. Erbach
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:03:17.39
ERBACH A
IND TO: Andre Winkfield
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:05:51.91
WINKFIELD A
IND TO: Carol H. Rasco
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:10:46.68
RASCO C
(WHO)
IND_TO: Marguerite D. Dyson
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:13:05.73
DYSON M
(OMB)
IND TO: Edward H. Jurith
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:13:49.36
JURITH E
IND TO: Jennifer Brown
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:14:19.41
BROWN J
IND TO: Michael D. Gerich
GERICH M )
(OMB)
(OMB)
( OMB)
(WHO)
(OA)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(VPO)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(OA)
(DON)
(DON)
(OMB)
�ARMS Email System
Page 24 of 51
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:16:22.37
IND_TO: Carolyn E. Cleveland
CLEVELAND C )
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:18:58.16
IND TO: David E. Katague
KATAGUE D ) (OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:20:58.91
IND- TO: LAWRENCE J. HAAS
.
HAAS L )
(OMB)
IND TO: Andrew D. Sens
SENS A )
(NSC)
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:22:20.37
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:26:40.11
IND_TO: Terri Tingen
TINGEN T ) (WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:28:39.81
IND TO: Carol A. Bergman
BERGMAN C)
(DON)
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:34:24.92
IND TO: Jason L. Furman
FURMAN J ) (CEA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:35:49.39
IND_TO: Stephen K. Horn
HORN S )
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:37:59.35
IND_TO: Mary S. Chadick
CHADICK S )
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:38:47.95
IND TO: Richard E. Green
GREEN R ) (OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:41:19.30
IND TO: Katharine Cox
COX K )
(DON)
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:50:06.13
IND TO: Lucia A. Wyman
WYMAN L ) (WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:58:37.97
IND_TO: Elena Kagan
KAGAN E ) (OPD)
READ:16-JAN-1997 18:59:13.08
IND_TO: Paul K. Engskov
ENGSKOV K)
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:00:16.52
IND_TO: Miguel M. Bustos
BUSTOS M ) (WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:00:25.43
IND_TO: Alan R. Einisman
EINISMAN A)
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:00:30.89
IND_TO: Peter G. Umhofer
UMHOFER P)
(CEQ)
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:04:27.18
IND TO: Alice H. Williams
WILLIAMS A)
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:14:23.23
IND TO: Tatana Sahanek
SAHANEK T)
(OA)
TARULLO D)
(OPD)
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:17:02.36
IND TO: Dan Tarullo
�Page 25 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:19:36.23
IND_TO: Christopher Baron
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:04:51.38
BARON_C
)
(OA)
IND TO: Steven N. Braun
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:04:54.36
BRAUN_S
)
(WHO)
IND_TO: Hugh D. Campbell
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:05:02.24
CAMPBELL H
IND_TO: Lauren J. Boyd
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:05:20.70
BOYD L
(OA)
IND TO: .Jeenifer Daskal
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:05:20.93
DASKAL J
)
(CEA)
IND TO: John D. Burnim
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:05:23.15
BURNIM J
)
(OMB)
IND TO: Jennifer R. Atkin
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:05:24.03
ATKIN J )
IND TO: Ann E. Cronin
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:05:27.81
CRONIN A )
IND_TO: Paul Bugg
READ:23-JAN-1997 12:01:57.92
BUGG P
IND TO: Donna J. Baker
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:05:49.69
BAKER DJ )
IND TO: Deborah L. Fine
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:05:55.74
FINE D
IND TO: Michelle Denton
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:05:56.36
DENTON M )
IND_TO: Carol E. Ehrlich
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:05:59.47
EHRLICH C
IND TO: Debra R. Dunson
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:06:00.17
DUNSON D ) (OA)
IND_TO: Wendy J. Einhellig
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:06:04.54
EINHELLIG W
IND_TO: Stephen M. Frerichs
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:06:15.49
FRERICHS S
IND_TO: Elyse H. Fitter
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:06:18.53
FITTER E ) (OMB)
IND TO: Daniel E. Bernal
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:06:29.13
BERNAL D ) (WHO)
IND TO: James T. Edmonds
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:06:29.71
EDMONDS J
IND TO: Ronald M. Cogswell
COGSWELL R
(OA)
(OPD)
(OA)
(OMB)
(OA)
(OPD)
(CEQ)
(OA)
(OPD)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OMB)
�Page 26 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:06:35.10
IND_TO: Deborah W. Gomes
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:06:35.24
GOMES D
IND~TO: Walter S. Groszyk Jr.
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:06:36.18
GROSZYK W
IND TO: Steven A. Cohen
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:06:47.17
COHEN SA
IND_TO: Wendy A. Heistad
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:06:50.77
HEISTAD W
IND_TO: Noel C. Clay
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:06:58.60
CLAY N
IND TO: Michael E. Harman
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:08.18
HARMAN M
IND TO: Michelle Y. Johnson
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:08.69
JOHNSON M
IND TO: Brenda I. Hilliard
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:09.48
HILLIARD B
IND_TO: Gay L. Joshlyn
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:10.90
JOSHLYN G
IND TO: Daniel J. Chenok
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:19.12
CHENOK D
IND TO: Jack S. Fox
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:20.56
FOX J
IND TO: Wanda L. Lawrence
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:33.21
LAWRENCE W
IND TO: Paul R. Dimond
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:33.52
DIMOND P
IND_TO: Darcel D. Gayle
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:38.69
GAYLE D
(OMB)
IND_TO: "E. Irene James
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:40.05
JAMES E
(OMB)
IND TO: Ann L. Kendrall
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:41.73
KENDRALL A
IND_TO: Michael Lingenfelter
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:42.75
(OA)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(CPC)
(OA)
(OA)
(NSC)
(OPD)
(OMB)
(OA)
(OA)
(OPD)
(OMB)
( LINGENFELTER)
IND TO: Karin Kullman
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:43.96
KULLMAN K
IND TO: Susan C. Hawthorne
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:46.40
HAWTHORNE S
IND TO: Timothy J. Brennan
BRENNAN T
(OA)
(WHO)
(OA)
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
Page 27 of 51
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:51.16
IND_TO: Eli Mark
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:53.62
MARK E )
(WHO)
IND_TO: Farooq A. Khan
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:07:56.29
KHAN F )
(OMB)
IND TO: Katherine L. Meredith
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:01.53
MEREDITH K
IND TO: Susan E. Alesi
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:06.29
ALESI S )
IND TO: Chris Fairhall
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:11.45
FAIRHALL C
IND_TO: Jacqueline C. Cragg
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:12.67
CRAGG J )
IND TO: James D. Mietus
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:14.15
MIETUS J )
(OMB)
IND TO: Joanna M. Meador
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:15.84
MEADOR J )
(OA)
IND TO: Melinda Malico
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:16.50
MALICO M
(WHO)
IND TO: Thomas D. Lee
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:18.17
LEE T
IND TO: Brian W. Morton
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:26.78
MORTON B )
IND TO: Loren F. Magruder
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:28.86
MAGRUDER L
IND_TO: James P. Heath
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:33.91
HEATH J
IND_TO: Claudia M. Rayford-Williams
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:37.74
RAYFORDWIL C
(OPD)
IND TO: Catharine M. Moscatelli
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:39.22
MOSCATELLI C
(WHO)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(OA)
(OA)
(DON)
(DON)
(DOJ)
IND_TO: All Operators
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:39.07
( OPERATOR )
(OA)
IND TO: Christa T. Robinson
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:40.25
ROBINSON C
IND TO: Juancara Bennett
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:42.65
BENNETT J
(OA)
IND TO: Leslie S. Mustain
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:50.91
MUSTAIN L
(OMB)
IND TO: Judith F. Mann
MANN J )
(WHO)
(OMB)
�ARMS Email System
Page 28.of51
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:51.67
IND_TO: Douglas A. Norwood
(OMB)
NORWOOD_D )
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:08:53.32
IND_TO: Lyndell Hogan
(OPD)
HOGAN L
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:01.11
IND TO: Diana M. Fortuna
FORTUNA_D
(OPD)
SHOGREN J )
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:03.76
IND TO: Jason F. Shogren
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:06.60
IND TO: Mark J. Schwartz
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:06.56
IND TO: Victoria L. Schaefer
SCHWARTZ-. )
M
(OMB)
SCHAEFER V
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:09.33
IND TO: Susan P. Shepard
SHEPARD S ) (OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:10.01
IND TO: Julie J. Sonier
SONIER J ) (OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 14:09:10.49
IND TO: Linda G. Williams
WILLIAMS LG
(OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:34:22.29
IND TO: Peter G. Jacoby
JACOBY P
(WHO)
RAMSEY D
(OA)
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:36:26.44
IND_TO: Dewitt Ramsey
READ:21-JAN-1997 23:31:43.89
IND_TO: Nancy L. Brandel
BRANDEL N ) (OMB)
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:45:51.89
IND_TO: Gordon L. Bendick
BENDICK G
(NSC)
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:46:47.14
IND TO: Patricia Solis-Doyle
SOLIS P
(WHO)
KAPLA R
(CEQ)
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:47:25.88
IND_TO: Robert S. Kapla
READ:16-JAN-1997 19:54:34.65
IND_TO: Tracy A. Bare
BARE T
(DON)
READ:16-JAN-1997 20:12:05.97
IND TO: Jodie R. Torkelson
TORKELSON J
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 20:24:56.42
IND_TO: Barry Toiv
TOIV B
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 20:40:23.02
IND TO: Caroline M. Thompson
THOMPSON CM
(WHO)
READ:16-JAN-1997 20:41:36.71
IND TO: Janice A. Enright
ENRIGHT J
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
Page 29 of 51
READ:16-JAN-1997 20:42:08.85
(WHO)
IND TO: Victoria Radd
READ:16-JAN-1997 20:51:00.74
RADD V
IND_TO: Cheryl D. Mills
READ:16-JAN-1997 20:51:14.84
MILLS C
IND_TO: Michael Tinsley
READ:16-JAN-1997 22:29:58.47
TINSLEY M
IND TO: Melissa G. Green
READ:16-JAN-1997 22:53:05.40
GREEN MG
IND TO: John A. Glodo
READ:17-JAN-1997 06:01:36.29
GLODO J
(DON)
IND TO: Morton D. Cohan
READ:17-JAN-1997 06:34:21.83
COHAN M
(OA)
IND TO: Howard Reinstein
READ:17-JAN-1997 06:42:10.70
REINSTEIN H ) (OA)
IND TO: Charlene C. Bolinski
READ:17-JAN-1997 06:54:56.45
BOLINSKI C ) (NSC)
IND TO: James E. Clark
READ:17-JAN-1997 07:05:29.46
CLARK J
IND TO: Helen N. Studgeon
READ:17-JAN-1997 07:13:16.99
STUDGEON H
)
(OA)
IND_TO: Patrick L. Drenning
READ:17-JAN-1997 07:16:57.39
DRENNING P
)
(OA)
IND TO: John W. McGinnis Jr.
READ:17-JAN-1997 07:18:10.26
MCGINNIS J )
(OA)
IND_TO: Manuel A. Mendoza
READ:17-JAN-1997 07:24:51.90
MENDOZA M )
(WHO)
IND_TO: Fulton T. Armstrong
READ:17-JAN-1997 07:33:26.94
ARMSTRONG F
IND TO: Michael P. Smith
READ:17-JAN-1997 07:34:08.46
SMITH MP
(NSC)
IND TO: James M. Reagan
READ:17-JAN-1997 07:48:50.96
REAGAN J
(WHO)
IND_TO: Jerry A. Bowers
READ:17-JAN-1997 07:51:37.58
BOWERS J
(OA)
IND TO: Kevin M. Harkins
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:01:21.72
HARKINS K
IND_TO: Barry W. Napear
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:03:07.95
NAPEAR B
IND TO: Rodrigo D. Buenaflor
BUENAFLOR RD
(WHO)
(OA)
(OPD)
(WHO)
(NSC)
(OA)
)
(OA)
(OA)
�ARMS Email System
Page 30 of 51
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:03:12.78
IND TO: James G. Cole
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:03:27.11
COLE JG )
(OA)
IND TO: Nellie M. Herbert
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:04:55.37
HERBERT N
IND_TO: Richard Hayes
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:05:13.05
HAYES R
IND_TO: Evelyn S. Lieberman
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:10:18.20
LIEBERMAN E
IND TO: Michael D. Stanton
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:12:59.08
DESK 4
IND TO: Kristin A. Savercool
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:17:04.53
SAVERCOOL K
IND TO: James T. Taylor
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:17:05.80
TAYLOR J
IND_TO: Cheryl A. Reynolds
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:17:41.01
REYNOLDS C
IND TO: Susan K. Brown
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:22:36.19
BROWN S )
IND_TO: Sandra F. Daigle
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:26:27.23
DAIGLE S
IND TO: William C. Menth
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:26:35.03
MENTH W
(OMB)
IND_TO: Julia Payne
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:28:41.14
PAYNE J
(VPO)
IND TO: Rafael A. Sein
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:29:29.52
SEIN R )
IND_TO: Mary U. Binns
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:29:36.04
BINNS M ) (WHO)
IND TO: Deborah L. Shaw
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:34:40.06
SHAW D ) (OMB)
IND_TO: Benjamin J. Kirby
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:39:39.93
KIRBY B ) (DON)
IND_TO: Christopher C. Jennings
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:42:42.56
JENNINGS C
IND_TO: Briggitte R. LaFontant
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:44:43.66
LAFONTANT B
IND_TO: Kelly Skoloda
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:48:43.55
SKOLODA K
IND TO: Gail S. Zimmerman
ZIMMERMAN G
(WHO)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OA)
(OA)
(OA)
(OA)
(OA)
(WHO)
(OA)
(WHO)
(DON)
(OA)
(OMB)
�Page 31 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:51:54.23
IND_TO: Stephen M. Madison
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:52:43.17
MADISON S
(OMB)
IND_TO: Maryanne B. Green
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:53:44.22
GREEN M
IND_TO: Daniel Schecter
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:54:58.64
SCHECTER D
IND_TO: Madge H. Henning
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:55:32.60
HENNING M
IND TO: Rosalind Delancy-Mosley
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:?7:41.19
DELANCYMOS R ) (WHO)
IND TO: Lisa J. Bruce
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:57:43.92
BRUCE L )
IND TO: Sharon L. Mitchell
READ:17-JAN-1997 08:58:20.60
MITCHELL S
(OA)
IND TO: Nathan A.· Marceca
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:04:20.32
MARCECA N)
(WHO)
IND TO: Kevin B. O'Meara
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:05:14.68
OMEARA K ) (OA)
IND TO: Mark H. Bartholomew
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:06:54.03
BARTHOLOME M
IND_TO: Arunik A. Snguon
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:08:52.31
SNGUON A ) (OA)
IND_TO: Douglas D. McCormick
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:10:29.20
MCCORMICK D )
IND TO: Carmen B. Fowler
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:14:33.07
FOWLER C ) (WHO)
IND TO: Zach Church
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:15:09.95
CHURCH Z ) (OMB)
IND_TO: William L. Dorotinsky
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:15:17.44
DOROTINSKY W
IND TO: Katrina A. McDonald
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:16:03.20
MCDONALD K)
IND_TO: Joseph J. Bradley
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:16:23.83
BRADLEY J
IND TO: Leticia Whitaker
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:18:56.40
WHITAKER L ) (OMB)
IND TO: David Worzala
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:24:09.30
WORZALA D
IND TO: William R. Feezle
FEEZLE W ) (OMB)
( OMB)
(DON)
(WHO)
(DON)
(OA)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(OA)
(OMB)
�ARMS Email System
Page 32 of 51
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:25:14.05
IND TO: Charles F. Lewis
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:26:26.64
LEWIS C )
IND TO: Dianne M. Ham
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:34:59.44
HAM D
IND TO: Robert D. Helms
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:35:44.68
HELMS R )
IND TO: Brenda D. Emanuel
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:36:16.28
EMANUEL B )
IND TO: J C. Crutchfield
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:37:59.68
CRUTCHFIEL J )
IND TO: Ann T. Eder
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:40:33.37
EDER A)
IND_TO: Shirley E. Woolridge
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:41:54.94
WOOLRIDGE S )
IND TO: Ananias Blocker III
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:47:31.26
BLOCKER A)
(WHO)
IND_TO: Darlene B. Fleming
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:49:22.06
FLEMING D )
(OMB)
IND_TO: Joslyn G. Mack
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:51:02.80
MACK J
IND_TO: Timothy J. David
READ:17-JAN-1997 09:53:49.0.6
DAVID T )
IND TO: Diane M. Smith
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:02:05.76
SMITH D ) (OA)
IND_TO: Donald P. Bradford
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:06:48.99
BRADFORD D )
IND_TO: Brenda F. Harper
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:12:41.79
HARPER B )
IND_TO: Guild L. Taylor
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:12:50.19
TAYLOR G ) (WHO)
IND_TO: Holly H. Holt
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:16:11.68
HOLT H )
IND TO: Kevin M. O'Keefe
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:16:36.47
OKEEFE K)
(WHO)
IND TO: Alan M. Levitt
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:19:06.70
LEVITT A)
(DON)
IND TO: Valon J. Wadsworth
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:19:09.17
WADSWORTH V)
IND TO: James E. Pickens
PICKENS J)
(OA)
(OMB)
)
(OA)
(OA)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OA)
(OMB)
(DON)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(NSC)
(OA)
�ARMS Email System
Page 33 of 51
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:19:29.91
IND TO: Patricia A. Hutt
HUTT P )
(OA)
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:24:07.31
IND TO: Iratha H. Waters
WATERS I ) (OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:30:29.52
IND_TO: Donald Goldberg
GOLDBERG D)
(WHO)
READ:21-JAN-1997 15:42:40.99
IND_TO: Tracy A. Hamblet
HAMBLET T)
(DON)
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:40:10.34
IND TO: Ronda A. Albert
ALBERT R ) (NSC)
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:46:21.25
IND TO: John T. Schuhart
SCHUHART J)
(OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:49:33.71
IND TO: Sarah H. Brau
BRAU S ) (WHO)
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:50:14.70
IND_TO: Timothy R. Fain
FAIN T ) (OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:51:27.41
IND TO: Anna C. White
WHITE A ) (WHO)
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:54:40.13
IND TO: VanessaG. Golden
GOLDEN V)
(DON)
READ:17-JAN-1997 10:54:52.91
IND_TO: Kelley A. Lehman
LEHMAN K ) (OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:01:11.84
IND TO: Deborah S. Smith
SMITH DO ) (VPO)
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:03:18.86
IND_TO: Keith E. Laughlin
LAUGHLIN K
(CEQ)
BRIATICO A
(OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:06:06.45
IND TO: Anna M. Briatico
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:08:06.92
IND TO: Peter A. Selfridge
SELFRIDGE P )
(WHO)
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:09:03.70
IND TO: Phalia Johnson
JOHNSON P)
(OA)
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:22:36.17
IND_TO: Lisa M. Wiederlight
WIEDERLIGH L )
(DON)
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:23:46.76
IND TO: J. Fred Dohse
DOHSE J )
(NSC)
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:26:51.99
IND_TO: Shelley N. Fidler
FIDLER S ) (CEQ)
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:34:46.21
IND TO: LouAnn B. Stovall
STOVALL L)
(OA)
�ARMS Email System
Page 34 of 51
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:38:36.10
IND_TO: Nancy V. Dublin
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:44:06.68
DUBLIN N
IND TO: Lawrence J. Scherer
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:44:54.42
SCHERER L
(DON)
IND TO: Dorinda A. Salcido
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:46:06.91
SALCIDO D
(WHO)
IND_TO: Reuben L. Musgrave Jr.
READ:17-JAN-1997 11:48:19.68
MUSGRAVE R )
IND TO: Christine P. Holmes
READ.:17-JAN-1997 12:03:37.05
HOLMES C
(OMB)
IND_TO: Lana Dickey
READ:17-JAN-1997 12:05:35.81
DICKEY L )
(WHO)
IND_TO: Kathryn W. Jackson
READ:17-JAN-1997 12:10:01.72
JACKSON KW ) (OA)
IND_TO: Paul J. Weinstein, Jr
READ:17-JAN-1997 12:11:13.35
WEINSTEIN P ) (OPD)
IND TO: Sarah M. Urquidez
READ:17-JAN-1997 12:13:55.78
URQUIDEZ_S ) (DON)
IND TO: Debra A. Schiff
READ:17-JAN-1997 12:22:18.31
SCHIFF D ) (WHO)
IND_TO: Phyllis Kaiser-Dark
READ:17-JAN-1997 12:23:22.04
KAISERDARK_P)
IND TO: Ardenia R. Hawkins
READ:17-JAN-1997 12:28:41.34
HAWKINS AR
IND TO: William White
READ:17-JAN-1997 12:39:59.12
WHITE WI )
(WHO)
IND TO: Sherron R. Duncan
READ:17-JAN-1997 12:45:44.66
DUNCAN S
(OMB)
IND_TO: Karl Simpson
READ:17-JAN-1997 12:48:11.47
SIMPSON K ) (OA)
IND TO: Patricia A. Ferrell
READ:17-JAN-1997 12:50:08.90
FERRELL P ) (OMB)
IND TO: Nicole Elkon
READ:17-JAN-1997 12:51:59.01
ELKON N
IND_TO: Pamela A. Reynolds
READ:17-JAN-1997 13:09:56.51
REYNOLDS P)
(WHO)
GREEN P )
(OMB)
(NSC)
(WHO)
(OA)
(OMB)
IND_TO: Iqbal Qazi
READ:17-JAN-1997 13:15:11.49
IND TO: Pamela B. Green
(DON)
(OMB)
�ARMS Email System
Page 35 of 51
READ:17-JAN-1997 13:24:32.89
IND TO: Ariel B. Winter
WINTER A ) (OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 13:24:52.19
IND TO: Barbara T. Roberts
ROBERTS B
(DON)
MCCLURE K
(WHO)
READ:17-JAN-1997 13:36:28.57
IND TO: Kelli R. McClure
READ:17-JAN-1997 13:51:13.50
IND_TO: Edward F. Hughes
HUGHES E ) (WHO)
READ:17-JAN-1997 13:52:19.10
IND TO: William N. McLeod
MCLEOD W ) (OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 13:59:12.31
IND TO: Deborah F. Kramer
KRAMER D ) (OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 14:01:33.01
IND TO: Arielle M. Krebs
KREBS A ) (WHO)
READ:17-JAN-1997 14:04:31.68
IND TO: Robert S. Dotson
DOTSON R ) (OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 14:06:04.70
IND TO: David P. Hicks
HICKS D )
(WHO)
READ:30-JAN-1997 09:15:02.83
IND TO: Michelle S. Richman
RICHMAN M)
(OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 14:11:16.69
IND TO: Earl G. Wilkerson
WILKERSON E )
(OA)
READ:17-JAN-1997 14:15:09.41
IND_TO: Sheila K. Stepp
STEPP S ) (DON)
READ:17-JAN-1997 14:30:59.56
IND_TO: Jeffrey D. Goldstein
GOLDSTEIN J )
(OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 14:33:49.73
IND_TO: Adam W. Goldberg
GOLDBERG A
(WHO)
COLLINS TL
(OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 14:37:33.63
IND TO: Teresa L. Collins
READ:17-JAN-1997 14:49:58.66
IND_TO: Thomas B. Samburg
SAMBURG T
(OA)
READ:17-JAN-1997 14:53:07.87
IND_TO: William D. Reynolds
REYNOLDS WD )
(OA)
READ:17-JAN-1997 14:57:22.73
IND_TO: Kathryn M. McKeown
MCKEOWN K
(WHO)
DUYKERS N)
(OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 14:59:06.94
IND_TO: Nancy J. Duykers
READ:17-JAN-1997 15:23:45.52
IND TO: Dena B. Weinstein
WEINSTEIN D ) (OPD)
�ARMS Email System
Page 36 of 51
READ:17-JAN-1997 15:23:48.80
IND_TO: James Bradford, Jr.
BRADFORD J
(OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 15:33:19.36
IND TO: Deborah L. Benoit
BENOIT D
(OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 15:35:34.91
IND TO: Sandra E. Van Namee
VANNAMEE S
(WHO)
READ:17-JAN-1997 15:42:19.61
IND TO: Karen C. Fahle
FAHLE K )
(WHO)
READ:17-JAN-1997 16:08:51.37
IND TO: Russell W. Horwitz
HORWITZ R
(WHO)
READ:17-JAN-1997 16:13:20.97
IND TO: Thaddeus J. Hunt
HUNT T
(OA)
READ:17-JAN-1997 16:37:10.25
IND TO: Linda K. Remick
(OA)
REMICK L )
READ:17-JAN-1997 16:41:48.61
IND_TO: Timothy J. Atkin
ATKIN T
(DON)
READ:17-JAN-1997 16:45:33.66
IND_TO: Jaime Vega
VEGA J
(DON)
READ:17-JAN-1997 16:46:58.34
IND_TO: Andrea M. Esquer
ESQUER_A
(WHO)
SPIVEY B
(OA)
READ:17-JAN-1997 16:49:54.32
IND_TO: Robert A. Spivey
READ:17-JAN-1997 16:58:46.11
IND TO: Dale F. Miller
(OA)
MILLER DF
READ:17-JAN-1997 17:06:14.54
IND TO: Pamela S. Barr
BARR P
(OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 17:14:57.46
IND_TO: Jackie D. Lawson
LAWSON J
(OA)
READ:17-JAN-1997 17:15:22.52
IND TO: David E. Tornquist
TORNQUIST_D
(OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 17:25:59.31
IND TO: Carol D. Jenkins
JENKINS C
(OMB)
WIDDESS K
(WHO)
READ:17-JAN-1997 17:26:31.97
IND TO: Kim B. Widdess
READ:17-JAN-1997 17:33:10.50
IND TO: Nilda Mesa
MESA N
(CEQ)
READ:17-JAN-1997 17:33:28.31
IND TO: James W. Gatling
GATLING J
(OA)
MCQUAID_W
(OMB)
READ:17-JAN-1997 17:43:01.97
IND TO: William J. McQuaid
�ARMS Email System
Page 37 of 51
READ:17-JAN-1997 17:45:04.64
IND TO: Heather A. Johnston
READ:17-JAN-1997 17:52:27.87
JOHNSTON H
(OMB)
IND TO: William P. Curtis
READ:17-JAN-1997 18:11:17.32
CURTIS W
IND TO: Helen E. veit
READ:17-JAN-1997 18:35:18.71
VEIT H
IND TO: Naomi M. Tinklepaugh
READ:17-JAN-1997 18:46:"32.57
TINKLEPAUG N
IND TO: David T. Johnson
READ:17-JAN-1997 19:33:57.07
JOHNSON DT
IND_TO: Stephen C. Donehoo
READ:17-JAN-1997 19:44:36.60
DONEHOO S
IND TO: Thomas A. Kalil
READ:17-JAN-1997 19:53:41.81
KALIL T
IND_TO: Charles Konigsberg
READ:17-JAN-1997 21:53:16.50
KONIGSBERG C } (OMB)
IND_TO: William E. Chapman
READ:17-JAN-1997 23:08:59.62
CHAPMAN W
IND TO: Kathleen Peroff
READ:18-JAN-1997 11:34:07.00
PEROFF K
IND_TO: Laura Capps
READ:18-JAN-1997 13:01:04.46
CAPPS L
(WHO)
IND TO: Patrick M. Steel
READ:18-JAN-1997 13:02:18.68
STEEL P
(WHO)
IND TO: Eric P. Hothem
READ:18-JAN-1997 14:34:26.50
HOTHEM E
IND TO: Kim S. White
READ:18-JAN-1997 15:37:22.10
WHITE K
IND TO: Laventa M. Henderson
READ:18-JAN-1997 23:12:58.25
HENDERSON L } (OA)
IND_TO: Vander Williams, Jr.
READ:19-JAN-1997 08:51:39.35
WILLIAMS V
IND_TO: Kenneth S. Apfel
READ:19-JAN-1997 10:42:35.73
APFEL K
IND TO: Lisa E. Jacobson
READ:19-JAN-1997 11:03:08.81
JACOBSON LE } (OMB)
IND TO: Kevin Moran
READ:19-JAN-1997 15:02:54.44
MORAN K1
IND TO: Gail D. Maine
MAINE G
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(NSC)
(DON)
(OPD)
(OA)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(OA)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OA)
�ARMS Email System
Page 38 of 51
READ:19-JAN-1997 16:05:55.10
(WHO)
IND TO: Marc A. Hoberman
READ:19-JAN-1997 17:46:09.20
HOBERMAN M
IND_TO: Ricky D. Washington
READ:19-JAN-1997 23:44:46.64
WASHINGTON R
(OA)
IND_TO: Mark G. Schoenberg
READ:19-JAN-1997 23:54:02.66
SCHOENBERG M )
(GSA)
IND TO: William W. McCathran
READ:20-JAN-1997 09:20:24.37
MCCATHRAN W )
IND_TO: Terry W. Good
READ:20-JAN-1997 09:35:00.00
GOOD T
IND TO: John A. Koskinen
READ:20-JAN-1997 11:47:28.28
KOSKINEN J
IND TO: Sherman A. Williams
READ:20-JAN-1997 11:51:46.76
WILLIAMS SA
IND TO: Kenneth Baldwin
READ:20-JAN-1997 12:07:39.52
BALDWIN K
IND TO: Stuart R. Kasdin
READ:20-JAN-1997 16:00:12.94
KASDIN S
IND TO: Donald J. Plummer
READ:20-JAN-1997 17:23:42.12
PLUMMER DJ
IND TO: Carlos C. Jones
READ:21-JAN-1997 04:45:57.40
JONES
cc
(OA)
IND TO: Michael L. Morris
READ:21-JAN-1997 06:03:08.37
MORRIS M
(OA)
IND TO: Rolando S. De Castro
READ:21-JAN-1997 07:07:33.97
DECASTRO R
IND TO: Bernice W. Smith
READ:21-JAN-1997 07:15:10.49
SMITH BW )
IND TO: Richard Y. Yamamoto
READ:21-JAN-1997 07:41:14.12
YAMAMOTO R )
IND_TO: Roy Chasez
READ:21-JAN-1997 07:43:14.73
CHASEZ R
(OA)
IND_TO: Una A. Cooper
READ:21-JAN-1997 08:03:48.91
COOPER U
(OA)
IND TO: Deborah J. McGovern
READ:21-JAN-1997 08:23:09.68
MCGOVERN D )
IND_TO: Mary A. Haines
READ:21-JAN-1997 08:24:49.94
HAINES M
IND TO: Paul A. Buccelli
BUCCELLI P
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(NSC)
(OMB)
(GSA)
(OA)
(WHO)
(DON)
(STP)
(NSC)
(OA)
�Page 39 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:21-JAN-1997 08:29:49.45
(OMB)
IND_TO: Kathy M. Hudgins
READ:21-JAN-1997 08:53:08.48
HUDGINS K
IND TO: JoAnn Ward
READ:21-JAN-1997 09:02:01.81
WARD J
IND TO: Robert L. Foster
READ:21-JAN-1997 09:14:23.60
FOSTER R )
IND TO: Janet M. Philips
READ:21-JAN-1997 09:15:54.99
PHILIPS J
IND TO: Jefferson B. Hill
READ:21-JAN-1997 09:28:03.83
HILL J
IND TO: Annette P. Lewis
READ:21-JAN-1997 09:29:23.40
LEWIS AP
IND_TO: Wayne C. Johnson
READ:21-JAN-1997 09:29:50.86
JOHNSON WC ) (OA)
IND TO: Marita McNamara
READ:21-JAN-1997 09:41:35.74
MCNAMARA M)
IND_TO: Mark J. Doyle
READ:21-JAN-1997 09:43:51.96
DOYLE M
IND TO: Debra L. Williams
READ:21-JAN-1997 09:52:25.71
WILLIAMS DL
IND TO: Miriam R. Nemetz
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:00:56.00
NEMETZ M
IND_TO: William H. Leary
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:03:05.77
LEARY W
IND_TO: Michael P. Massey
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:08:35.07
MASSEY M ) (WHO)
IND TO: Peter C. Erichsen
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:08:54.20
ERICHSEN P
(WHO)
IND TO: Jean W. Holcombe
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:10:11.06
HOLCOMBE J )
(OMB)
IND_TO: L. Bradley Hittle
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:11:45.92
HITTLE L )
(DON)
IND TO: Richard M. Allen
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:15:42.81
ALLEN RM )
(OMB)
IND TO: Charles B. Dietzel
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:22:33.52
DIETZEL C ) (OA)
IND TO: Lisa M. Jones
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:25:04.36
JONES L )
IND TO: Tina Robertson
ROBERTSON T
(STP)
(OA)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(OA)
(OA)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(NSC)
(OMB)
(OA)
�ARMS Email System
Page 40 of 51
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:34:26.11
IND TO: Nicholas F. D'Apice
DAPICE N ) (OA)
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:35:56.57
IND_TO: Stacy E. Reynolds
REYNOLDS S
(WHO)
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:36:50.53
IND TO: Barbara Zelenko
ZELENKO B ) (WHO)
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:37:10.90
IND TO: Lori R. Schack
SCHACK L ) (OMB)
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:44:12.55
IND TO: Richard E. Anderson
ANDERSON R
(OA)
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:44:37.48
IND TO: Maria F. Salcedo
SALCEDO M ) (OMB)
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:46:14.86
IND TO: Lori A. Wiener
WIENER L ) (WHO)
READ:21-JAN-1997 10:59:19.70
IND TO: Jamie S. Williams
WILLIAMS JS
(WHO)
READ:21-JAN-1997 11:00:30.36
IND TO: Helen P. Robinson
ROBINSON H
(WHO)
READ:21-JAN-1997 11:02:33.79
IND TO: Areletha L. Venson
VENSON A)
(OMB)
READ:21-JAN-1997 11:03.:51.29
IND_TO: Denise Aydelotte-Wodesky
WODESKY D
(DON)
HOPKINS E
(OMB)
READ:21-JAN-1997 11:04:42.57
IND TO: Edith D. Hopkins
READ:21-JAN-1997 11:09:16.94
IND TO: Susan L. Hazard
HAZARD S
(!'lHO)
READ:21-JAN-1997 11:09:21.23
IND_TO: Dorian F. Pannell
PANNELL D
(OA)
READ:21-JAN-1997 11:19:53.67
IND_TO: Susan McNay
MCNAY S ) (WHO)
READ:21-JAN-1997 11:27:50.62
IND TO: Mabel E. Echols
ECHOLS M ) (OMB)
-READ:21-JAN-1997 11:44:31.25
IND_TO: Bronya H. Clark
CLARK B ) (NSC)
READ:21-JAN-1997 12:13:59.45
IND TO: Pamula Simms
SIMMS P ) (OMB)
READ:21-JAN-1997 12:19:36.52
IND_TO: Wendy L. Smith
READ:21-JAN-1997 12:32:24.95
IND TO: Randall W. Lutter
(OMB)
�Page 41 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:21-JAN-1997 12:58:29.53
(WHO)
IND TO: Ann M. Cattalini
READ:21-JAN-1997 13:04:33.31
IND TO: Michael A. Saunders
READ:21-JAN-1997 13:08:49.85
SAUNDERS M ) (OA)
IND TO: Paul E. Busick
READ:21-JAN-1997 13:14:26.92
BUSICK P )
IND TO: Marvis G. Olfus
READ:21-JAN-1997 13:20:02.67
OLFUS M
IND_TO: Marc R. D'Anjou
READ:21-JAN-1997 13:28:42.10
DANJOU M ) (VPO)
IND TO: Carmen Lomellin
READ:21-JAN-1997 13:30:43.03
LOMELLIN C )
IND TO: David M. Cornelissen
READ:21-JAN-1997 13:32:35.19
DESK 2
IND TO: Andre U. Banks
READ:21-JAN-1997 13:33:29.13
BANKS A
IND TO: Sheila D. Newman
READ:21-JAN-1997 13:37:35.05
NEWMAN S ) (OMB)
IND TO: Lori L. Anderson
READ:21-JAN-1997 14:06:20.17
ANDERSON L
IND_TO: DeVere R. Patton, Jr.
READ:21-JAN-1997 14:08:25.07
PATTON D ) (OA)
IND TO: John A. Gunter
READ:21-JAN-1997 14:29:21.41
GUNTER J
IND_TO: Rosemary B. O'Shea
READ:21-JAN-1997 14:43:58.24
OSHEA R ) (WHO)
IND_TO: John E. Spriggs
READ:21-JAN-1997 14:45:15.58
SPRIGGS J )
IND TO: Janet L. Himler
READ:21-JAN-1997 14:46:00.45
HIMLER J ) (OMB)
IND_TO: Richard A. Mertens
READ:21-JAN-1997 15:40:15.88
MERTENS R)
IND_TO: James M. Reid
READ:21-JAN-1997 15:57:31.50
REID J
IND TO: Robert G. Damus
READ:21-JAN-1997 16:02:40.45
DAMUS R ) (OMB)
IND_TO: Nguyen-Phuong K. Lu
READ:21-JAN-1997 16:05:20.90
LU N
IND TO: C. Patricia Cogdell
COGDELL C
(NSC)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OA)
(WHO)
(WHO)
) (OA)
(OA)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(DON)
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
Page 42 of 51
READ:21-JAN-1997 16:08:53.14
IND_TO: Wendy W. Showers
READ:21-JAN-1997 16:09:27.22
SHOWERS W
(WHO)
IND TO: Mark A. Wasserman
READ:21-JAN-1997 16:17:44.32
WASSERMAN M
IND TO: Bernard H. Martin
READ:21-JAN-1997 16:19:43.62
MARTIN B
IND_TO: Tracy B. LaBrecque
READ:21-JAN-1997 16:24:47.74
LABRECQUE_T
IND TO: Maureen A. Hudson
READ:21-JAN-1997 16:25:30.45
HUDSON M
IND TO: Alan B. Rhinesmith
READ:21-JAN-1997 16:27:14.65
RHINESMITH A
IND_TO: Annette E. Rooney
READ:21-JAN-1997 16:56:17.88
ROONEY A
IND_TO: Kelly J. Letts
READ:21-JAN-1997 17:34:42.34
LETTS K
(NSC)
IND TO: Dianne M. Wells
READ:21-JAN-1997 17:43:15.62
WELLS D
(OMB)
IND_TO: Kimberly A. Newman
READ:21-JAN-1997 17:55:19.36
NEWMAN KA
IND_TO: Marie-Therese Dominguez
READ:21-JAN-1997 19:10:33.11
DOMINGUEZ M
IND TO: Allan Villabroza
READ:22-JAN-1997 09:19:40.12
VILLABROZA A
IND_TO: Rachel E. Levinson
READ:22-JAN-1997 10:03:39.30
LEVINSON R
IND_TO: Benjamin J. Bornstein
READ:22-JAN-1997 10:06:28.54
BORNSTEIN B
IND TO: Lori K. Krause
READ:22-JAN-1997 10:16:42.66
KRAUSE L
(WHO)
IND TO: Wanda J. Foster
READ:22-JAN-1997 10:18:43.14
FOSTER W
(OMB)
IND TO: Tawana F. Webb
READ:22-JAN-1997 10:31:31.34
WEBB T
IND TO: Genevieve F. Gordon
READ:22-JAN-1997 10:34:21.47
GORDON G
IND_TO: Joyce M. Wakefield
READ:22-JAN-1997 11:09:41.32
WAKEFIELD J
IND TO: Kathleen A. Barry
BARRY K
(OMB)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OMB)
( OMB)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(STP)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(OA)
(OMB)
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
Page 43 of 51
READ:22-JAN-1997 11:18:20.72
IND TO: Beth A. Viola
READ:22-JAN-1997 11:34:50.82
VIOLA B )
(CEQ)
IND TO: Kim I. Johnson
READ:22-JAN-1997 11:45:06.79
JOHNSON KI
IND TO: John B. Emerson
READ:22-JAN-1997 11:50:54.65
EMERSON J )
IND_TO: Anthony B. Wu
READ:22-JAN-1997 11:55:42.65
WU A
IND TO: Edward P. Valentine
READ:22-JAN-1997 12:12:00.43
VALENTINE E
IND TO: Lisa M. Williams
READ:22-JAN-1997 12:21:59.76
WILLIAMS L ) (WHO)
IND TO: Vanna J. Shields
READ:22-JAN-1997 12:34:35.59
SHIELDS V)
IND TO: Susan A. Brophy
READ:22-JAN-1997 12:46:29.20
BROPHY S
IND_TO: Eileen M. Upperman
READ:22-JAN-1997 12:54:12.93
UPPERMAN E
(WHO)
IND_TO: Daniel S. Benjamin
READ:22-JAN-1997 12:55:18.35
BENJAMIN D
(NSC)
IND TO: Laura Oliven Silberfarb
READ:22-JAN-1997 13:10:28.34
OLIVEN L ) (OMB)
IND TO: Donna M. Rivelli
READ:22-JAN-1997 13:21:13.68
RIVELLI D
IND TO: David P. Jacobeen
READ:22-JAN-1997 13:28:46.73
JACOBEEN D
IND_TO: Timothy J. Keating
READ:22-JAN-1997 13:48:56.23
KEATING T
IND_TO: Nancy E. Brown
READ:22-JAN-1997 13:53:21.69
BROWN N
IND TO: Steven L. Ottenstein
READ:22-JAN-1997 14:02:29.20
OTTENSTEIN S
IND TO: Walter A. Holton
READ:22-JAN-1997 14:08:38.66
HOLTON W )
IND TO: matthew E. Lorin
READ:22-JAN-1997 14:16:16.36
LORIN M ) (NSC)
IND TO: Lee Ann Brackett
READ:22-JAN-1997 14:49:53.90
BRACKE L
IND TO: John B. Montgomery
MONTGOMER J
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(OA)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(OA)
(WHO)
(NSC)
(WHO)
(DON)
(VPO)
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
Page 44 of 51
READ:22-JAN-1997 14:54:11.02
IND TO: Aurelia L. Tucker
READ:22-JAN-1997 15:02:41.64
TUCKER_A
(OMB)
IND_TO: Carolyn R. Phelps
READ:22-JAN-1997 15:21:37.32
PHELPS C
(OMB)
IND TO: Robert J. Nassif
READ:22-JAN-1997 15:41:21.32
NASSIF R
(OMB)
IND TO: Ravindra Baddeliyanage
READ:22-JAN-1997 15:48:22.31
BADDELIYAN R
IND TO: Sandra S. Coleman
READ:22-JAN-1997 17:02:59.63
COLEMAN S
IND_TO: Gary Waxman
READ:22-JAN-1997 17:18:26.45
WAXMAN G
IND_TO: Virlena L. Cooper-Briscoe
READ:22-JAN-1997 17:32:56.28
COOPERBRIS V
IND TO: Dianna M. Gerwitz
READ:22-JAN-1997 17:35:17.13
GERWITZ D
IND_TO: Wayne A. Wittig
READ:22-JAN-1997 17:46:56.31
WITTIG W
IND TO: Ana Lee Sanchez
READ:22-JAN-1997 18:11:15.18
SANCHEZ A
IND TO: Nicole R. Rabner
READ:22-JAN-1997 18:34:05.99
RABNER N
IND TO: Patricia M. McMahon
READ:22-JAN-1997 18:59:11.18
MCMAHON P
IND TO: Lee A. Satterfield
READ:22-JAN-1997 19:08:38.88
SATTERFIEL L
IND_TO: Marilyn DiGiacobbe
READ:22-JAN-1997 19:30:30.76
(OA)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(DON)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(DON)
)
(WHO)
. ( DIGIACOBBE M )
(WHO)
IND_TO: James Briscoe
READ:22-JAN-1997 20:46:03.39
BRISCOE J
(OA)
IND_TO: Rosina M. Bierbaum
READ:22-JAN-1997 21:28:45.57
BIERBAUM R )
IND_TO: Sterling o. Fennell II
READ:22-JAN-1997 22:59:50.55
FENNELL S
IND_TO: Daniel J. Motherway
READ:23-JAN-1997 06:54:37.89
MOTHERWAY D
IND_TO: Philip C. Droege
READ:23-JAN-1997 07:59:49.03
DROEGE P
(WHO)
IND TO: Walter F. Jones
JONES WF
(OA)
(STP)
(OA)
(NSC)
�Page 45 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:23-JAN-1997 08:02:36.93
IND_TO: Ashley L. Raines
READ:23-JAN-1997 08:08:00.78
RAINES A ) (OA)
IND TO: Vernetta Tanner
READ:23-JAN-1997 08:50:14.56
TANNER V ) (OMB)
IND_TO: Crystal B. Jones,
READ:23-JAN-1997 09:04:52.52
JONES CB ) (WHO)
IND TO: Glenn R. Schlarman
READ:23-JAN-1997 09:07:36.64
SCHLARMAN G
IND TO: Lawrence E. Prince
READ:23-JAN-1997 09:56:04.29
PRINCE L ) (OA)
IND_TO: Troy Hammond
READ:23-JAN-1997 09:58:23.8'1
HAMMOND T
(OA)
IND_TO: Jacquelyn B. Parrish
READ:23-JAN-1997 10:13:43.63
PARRISH J
(OMB)
IND TO: Janet S. Piller
READ:23-JAN-1997 10:24:26.13
PILLER J
IND TO: Confrence Center Volunteer
READ:23-JAN-1997 10:24:49:37
VOLUNTEER C
IND TO: Leonard L. Lainhart Jr
READ:23-JAN-1997 10:45:12.15
LAINHART L
IND TO: Brian Gillis
READ:23-JAN-1997 11:28:12.35
GILLIS B )
IND_TO: Yvonne T. Bowlding
READ:23-JAN-1997 11:54:15.68
BOWLDING Y
IND TO: Karen A. Maris
READ:23-JAN-1997 12:08:23.14
MARIS K
IND TO: Susan P. Clements
READ:23-JAN-1997 12:47:03.15
CLEMENTS S
IND_TO: Nancy V. Hernreich
READ:23-JAN-1997 12:52:34.37
HERNREICH N
IND TO: Patricia S. Haney
READ:23-JAN·1997 13:14:58.85
HANEY P
IND TO: Lisa F. Western
READ:23-JAN-1997 13:22:14.04
WESTERN L
(OMB)
IND TO: Shaun D. Spencer
READ:23-JAN-1997 13:23:19.27
SPENCER S
(OA)
IND TO: Sarah J. Vogelsberg
READ:23-JAN-1997 13:26:06.63
VOGELSBERG S )
IND TO: Barbara E. Swann
SWANN B )
(OMB)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(OA)
(DON)
�ARMS Email System
Page 46 of 51
READ:23-JAN-1997 14:10:02.40
IND TO: Daniel L. Moore
READ:23-JAN-1997 14:36:33.06
MOORE D
IND TO: Alexander R. Vershbow
READ:23-JAN-1997 14:54:36.93
VERSHBOW A
IND TO: William K. Davis
READ:23-JAN-1997 15:09:23.44
DAVIS W
IND TO: Richard H. Kodl
READ:23-JAN-1997 15:22:51.31
KODL R
IND TO: Maron T. Flowers
READ:23-JAN-1997 15:54:37.25
FLOWERS M
)
(OA)
IND TO: Conrad J. Ribeiro
READ:23-JAN-1997 16:13:23.99
RIBEIRO C
)
(OA)
IND TO: Richard DalBello
READ:23-JAN-1997 16:22:13.31
DALBELLO R
IND_TO: Patsy L. Thomasson
READ:23-JAN-1997 16:23:58.68
THOMASSON P
IND TO: Edward M. Rea
READ:23-JAN-1997 16:41:42.80
( REA E
(OA)
(NSC)
(NSC)
(OMB)
(STP)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(WHO)
IND_TO: Frederick C. Haggard
READ:23-JAN-1997 16:48:02.60
HAGGARD FC
IND TO: Kerri C. Sheehan
READ:23-JAN-1997 17:12:29.10
SHEEHAN K
(WHO)
IND TO: Steven M. Mertens
READ:23-JAN-1997 17:27:12.28
MERTENS S
(OMB)
IND_TO: Jaqueline A. Dycke
READ:23-JAN-1997 17:34:36.29
DYCKE J
IND_TO: Capricia P. Marshall
READ:23-JAN-1997 18:00:48.07
MARSHALL C
(WHO)
IND TO: Susan E. Walitsky
READ:23-JAN-1997 18:29:23.61
WALITSKY S
(WHO)
IND TO: David F. Montoya
READ:23-JAN-1997 19:33:27.50
MONTOYA D
(WHO)
IND TO: Teresa Wildman
READ:23-JAN-1997 19:53:56.08
WILDMAN T
(WHO)
IND_TO: Evan Ryan
READ:23-JAN-1997 19:54:09.25
RYAN E
IND TO: John Podesta
READ:23-JAN-1997 19:54:21.39
PODESTA J
IND TO: Michael A. Fitzpatrick
FITZPATRIC M
(VPO)
)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OMB)
�ARMS Email System
Page 47 of 51
READ:23-JAN-1997 20:08:03.78
(WHO)
IND_TO: Raymond E. Donnelly III
READ:24-JAN-1997 08:19:59.05
DONNELLY RE
IND TO: David C. Childs
READ:24-JAN-1997 08:38:13.39
CHILDS D ) (OMB)
IND_TO: Paul F. Dagenais
READ:24-JAN-1997 08:44:57.26
DAGENAIS P
(OA)
IND TO: Leanne I. Johnson
READ:24-JAN-1997 09:07:33.44
JOHNSON L)
(WHO)
IND_TO: Gwyn M. Parker
READ:24-JAN-1997 09:27:55.69
PARKER G ) (NSC)
IND TO: William P. Frazier
READ:24-JAN-1997 09:59:09.87
FRAZIER W)
IND TO: Jennifer H. Yoon
READ:24-JAN-1997 10:23:54.56
YOON J
IND_TO: Agustin A. Labrador
READ:24-JAN-1997 10:29:22.28
LABRADOR A
IND_TO: Pearlie M. Myers
READ:24-JAN-1997 11:01:42.31
MYERS PM ) (OA)
IND TO: Kris M. Balderston
READ:24-JAN-1997 11:24:09.42
BALDERSTON K
IND_TO: Mary C. Barth
READ:24-JAN-1997 12:11:38.53
BARTH M ) (OMB)
IND TO: Bruce R. Lindsey
READ:24-JAN-1997 13:13:44.40
LINDSEY B
(WHO)
IND_TO: Angela C. Simmons
READ:24-JAN-1997 13:35:13.29
SIMMONS A
(OMB)
IND TO: David S. Adams
READ:24-JAN-1997 13:57:33.05
ADAMS D ) (OA)
IND_TO: Barry T. Clendenin
READ:24-JAN-1997 14:04:07.60
CLENDENIN B
IND TO: Anne M. Schramm
READ:24-JAN-1997 14:13:56.56
SCHRAMM A
IND_TO: Bobby Strickland
READ:24-JAN-1997 14:35:28.34
STRICKLAND B
IND_TO: Steve Ackley
READ:24-JAN-1997 14:38:14.05
ACKLEY S ) (OA)
IND_TO: Susan Clampitt
READ:24-JAN-1997 14:44:59.44
CLAMPITT S
IND TO: Gillian J. Foster
FOSTER G ) (OMB)
(OMB)
(CEA)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(GSA)
(OA)
(WHO)
�ARMS Email System
Page 48 of 51
READ:24-JAN-1997 15:44:07.22
IND_TO: Jennifer A. Meyers
READ:24-JAN-1997 16:15:44.79
MEYERS J
(CEA)
IND TO: Edward H. Clarke
READ:24-JAN-1997 16:33:24.01
CLARKE_E
(OMB)
IND_TO: Robyn G. Dickey
READ:24-JAN-1997 16:42:08.58
DICKEY_R )
(WHO)
IND_TO: Ray Clark
READ:26-JAN-1997 08:56:50.03
CLARK R
IND TO: Chantale Y. Wong
READ:26-JAN-1997 09:22:07.88
WONG C
IND_TO: Arturo S. Bayona
READ:27-JAN-1997 09:27:26.53
( BAYONA_A
IND TO: Bonnie Galvin
READ:27-JAN-1997 09:29:32.89
GALVIN B
(OMB)
IND_TO: Douglas B. Sosnik
READ:27-JAN-1997 09:57:50.75
SOSNIK D
(WHO)
IND TO: Laura A. Naide
READ:27-JAN-1997 10:13:21.79
NAIDE L
IND_TO: Leroy Jones Jr
READ:27-JAN-1997 10:28:54.68
JONES LE
IND_TO: Andrew Friendly
READ:27-JAN-1997 10:58:04.54
FRIENDLY A
IND TO: Edwin Lau
READ:27-JAN-1997 12:21:55.94
LAUE
IND TO: Diane M. Goldberg
READ:27-JAN-1997 12:46:42.51
GOLDBERG DM
IND TO:. Janet R. Forsgren
READ:27-JAN-1997 13:27:34.22
FORSGREN J
IND TO: Patricia A. Brink
READ:27-JAN-1997 13:34:38.88
BRINK P
IND_TO: Margaret E. Evans
READ:27-JAN-1997 13:43:06.73
EVANS ME ) (OMB )
IND_TO: Holly B. Nichols
READ:27-JAN-1997 14:53:43.33
NICHOLS H
IND_TO: Thomas Hanley
READ:27-JAN-1997 15:04:16.34
HANLEY T
IND TO: David J. Hawes
READ:27-JAN-1997 15:24:17.39
HAWES D
IND TO: Michael J. Discenza
DISCENZA M
(CEQ)
(OMB)
(OA)
(WHO)
(DON)
)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OA)
(NSC)
(OMB)
�Page 49 of 51
ARMS Email System
READ:27-JAN-1997 15:42:15.95
IND TO: David B. Des Roches
READ:27-JAN-1997 15:43:12.22
DESROCHES D
IND_ TO: Ana M. Duque
READ:27-JAN-1997 16:17:08.48
DUQUE_A )
IND TO: Julie Haas
READ:27-JAN-1997 17:03:40.21
HAAS J
IND_TO: Lisa M. Duffey
READ:27-JAN-1997 17:49:34.06
DUFFEY L ) (STP)
IND_TO: Stephanie M. Gowen
READ:27-JAN-1997 18:27:49.34
GOWEN S
IND_TO: Gregory T. Trainor
READ:27-JAN-1997 18:46:22.62
TRAINOR G ) (WHO)
IND_TO: Ruby G. Moy
READ:27-JAN-1997 19:49:20.03
MOY R
IND TO: Susanne Bachtel
READ:27-JAN-1997 23:49:27.83
BACHTEL S ) (STP)
IND TO: Darrell A. Johnson
READ:28-JAN-1997 08:54:54.66
JOHNSON D ) (OMB)
IND_TO: Ann A. McCoy
READ:28-JAN-1997 09:17:35.87
MCCOY A ) (WHO)
IND TO: Jonathan D. Breul
READ:28-JAN-1997 09:25:08.87
BREUL J
IND TO: Diane A. Stumpf
READ:28-JAN-1997 09:31:39.38
STUMPF D ) (DON)
IND_TO: Yvonne A. McCoy
READ:28-JAN-1997 11:13:31.54
MCCOY Y ) (OMB)
IND_TO: Alejandro L. DeLeyos Jr,
READ:28-JAN-1997 11:15:40.99
DELEYOS A
IND TO: Barbara J. Maddox
READ:28-JAN-1997 12:05:15.84
MADDOX B ) (WHO)
IND_TO: Daniel M. Tangherlini
READ:28-JAN-1997 12:19:38.85
TANGHERLIN D
IND TO: Sarel Kromer
READ:28-JAN-1997 13:43:30.49
KROMER S ) (WHO)
IND TO: Brenda B. Costello
READ:28-JAN-1997 13:48:51.64
COSTELLO B
IND_TO: Paul R. Carey
READ:28-JAN-1997 14:10:58.73
CAREY P ) (WHO)
IND TO: Robert B. Anderson
ANDERSON RB
(DON)
(WHO)
(OMB)
(DON)
(WHO)
) (OMB)
(OA)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(OMB)
�ARMS Email System
Page 50 of 51
READ:28-JAN-1997 14:55:11.29
INDTO: John Y. McInnis
READ:28-JAN-1997 14:56:48.53
MCINNIS J
(OA)
IND_TO: Anita Chellaraj
READ:28-JAN-1997 15:22:07.27
CHELLARAJ A
IND_TO: Tamara B. Kelly
READ:28-JAN-1997 15:48:28.13
KELLY T
IND_TO: Elizabeth K. Harrington
READ:28-JAN-1997 16:27:31.21
HARRIN E
IND TO: Ellen T. Davis
READ:28-JAN-1997 16:49:28.79
DAVIS E
(WHO)
IND_TO: Phu D. Huynh
READ:28-JAN-1997 20:50:17.59
HUYNH P )
(WHO)
IND_TO: John E. Thompson
READ:29-JAN-1997 09:24:29.21
THOMPSON J
IND_TO: Arecia A. Grayton
READ:29-JAN-1997 10:05:46.71
GRAYTON A
(OMB)
IND TO: Clifford G. Preston
READ:29-JAN-1997 10:10:44.93
PRESTON C
(OA)
IND TO: Barbara A. Gates
READ:29-JAN-19.97 10:22:25.66
GATES B
IND TO: Christina L. Burrell
READ:29-JAN-1997 10:52:17.52
BURRELL C
IND TO: Nathaniel Wood Jr.
READ:29-JAN-1997 11:02:06.18
WOOD N
IND_TO: Aurelia A. DeRubis
READ:29-JAN-1997 11:03:16.64
DERUBIS A
(OMB)
IND TO: Edward E. Stelzer
READ:29-JAN-1997 11:48:52.77
STELZER E
(DON)
IND_TO: Katharine S. Rogers
READ:29-JAN-1997 13:34:38.90
ROGERS K
IND_TO: Ardy D. Scott
READ:29-JAN-1997 14:26:23.75
SCOTT A )
IND TO: Patricia A. McHugh
READ:29-JAN-1997 15:55:18.51
MCHUGH P
IND TO: Florence M. Williams
READ:29-JAN-1997 16:06:42.58
WILLIAMS F
IND_TO: Irwin Raij
READ:29-JAN-1997 17:15:49.38
RAIJ I
IND TO: Valerie S. Matthews
MATTHEWS V
(OMB)
(OMB)
(VPO)
(OMB)
(DON)
(NSC)
(DON)
(CEA)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(DON)
(WHO)
(DON)
�ARMS Email System
Page 51 of 51
READ:30-JAN-1997 09:20:13.14
IND TO: Irma L. Martinez
READ:30-JAN-1997 09:33:15.55
MARTINEZ II,
(WHO)
IND TO: Janet L. Graves
READ:30-JAN-1997 09:50:28.42
GRAVES J )
IND TO: Linda L Lance
READ:30-JAN-1997 11:02:26.03
LANCE L
IND TO: Jason R. Orlando
READ:30-JAN-1997 11:28:44.80
ORLANDO J
IND TO: M. Elise Neil
READ:30-JAN-1997 11:38:03.81
NEIL M
(NSC)
IND_TO: Francho J. Gray
READ:30-JAN-1997 11:43:52.73
GRAY F
(OA)
IND._TO: Patrick E. Briggs
READ:30-JAN-1997 12:09:42.41
BRIGGS P
)
IND_TO: Theresa F. Granger
READ:30-JAN-1997 13:22:51.99
GRANGER T
IND TO: Debra D. Bird
READ:30-JAN-1997 15:17:23.75
BIRD D
(WHO)
IND_TO: Joseph W. Canady
READ:30-JAN-1997 16:11:08.67
CANADY J
)
IND TO: Louisa Koch
READ:30-JAN-1997 16:28:17.45
KOCH L
(OMB)
IND_TO: Jacqueline A. Corsetty
READ:30-JAN-1997 18:26:09.04
CORSETTY J
(OMB)
(CEQ)
(OMB)
(WHO)
(WHO)
(OA)
(OMB)
TEXT:
Reminder that all documents in response to the January 9, 1997 document
request from Jack Quinn are due by 12 NOON today, Thursday, January 16th to
Cheryl Mills in Room 128, OEOB.
This should include all responsive documents from January 20, 1993 to January 9,
1997.
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[01/16/1997]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
CEA
Automated Records Management System
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Received by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 097 - Folder 001
574745
-
https://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/files/original/d7ec81e3561d74087db70648c5372273.pdf
793407d5980b147fa5c4f5c2f928ab9c
PDF Text
Text
NLWJC - KAGAN
EMAILS CREATED
ARMS - BOX 015 - FOLDER 009
[5/26/1997 - 09/28/1998]
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD I )
CREATION DATE/TIME:26-MAY-1997 10:35:49.00
SUBJECT:
Re: proper taxation of workfare benefits
TO: Mark J. Mazur ( CN=Mark J. Mazur/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA I
READ:UNKNOWN
)
CC: Diana Fortuna ( CN=Diana Fortuna/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD I )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Bruce N. Reed ( CN=Bruce N. Reed/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD I )
READ:UNKNOWN
CC: Cynthia A. Rice ( CN=Cynthia A. Rice/OU=OPD/O=EOP @ EOP [ OPD I )
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Yes, but only if the understanding is that we will seek a legislative fix
(if needed), consistent with our position since 1994, that workfare
benefits are not subject to FICA and do not qualify for EITC.
This is
what we are going to tell the governors starting this week, in an attempt
to dissuade them from attacking our decision on FLSA.
The function of a
working group i~ only to work out the details. Does everyone agree?
Mark J. Mazur
OS/25/97 03:12:27 PM
Record Type:
Record
To:
Cynthia A. Rice/OPD/EOP, Elena Kagan/OPD/EOP
cc:
Subject:
proper taxation of workfare benefits
Folks,
I brought up the idea of a joint DPC/NEC decision process with Gene
Sperling at the NEC staff meeting on Friday and he said we should go ahead
and get this started so we can come to an agreement in relatively short
order.
My thinking on this is that we should let the current process involving
IRS, Labor, and HHS and focussing on administrative solutions chug along
to determine the appropriate interpretation of current law.
But we should
set up a parallel process with these agencies (and any other interested
ones) to develop a legislative solution to this issue. There is a chance
that such a legislative fix can be added to whatever tax bill will be
constructed this summer.
I suggest that we try to convene a group from
Labor, HHS, Treasury, DPC, NEC, OMB, and CEA this coming week to get this
process started.
What do you think?
Mark
http://172.28.127.30:8082/ARMS/servlet/getEmailArchive?URL] ATH=/n1cp-21Anns404/cealC...
411612009
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:27-MAY-1997 12:51:09.00
SUBJECT:
Re: proper taxation of workfare benefits
TO: Mark J. Mazur ( CN=Mark J. Mazur/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
I think I have to talk with Bruce about this.
I believe he would feel
strongly the other way given (1) where we were in our 94 bill and (2)
where the governors are now.
But let me check.
http://172.28.127.30:8082/ARMS/servletigetEmaiIArchive?URL]ATH=/n1cp-2/ Arms404/cealC...
411612009
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 9-JUL-1997 19:43:25.00
SUBJECT:
Re:
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
Fantastic.
And thanks.
I'll look at it tonight.
http://172.28.127.30:8082/ARMS/servletigetEmaiIArchive?URL] ATH=/n1cp-21Arms404/cea/C...
4117/2009
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME:13-JUL-1997 19:06:12.00
SUBJECT:
Re:
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
sorry not to get back to you until now.
monday.
this is terrific.
let's talk on
http://l72.28.127.30:8082/ARMS/servletigetEmaiIArchive?URL]ATH=Inlcp-2/Arms404/cealC...
411712009
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD I )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-AUG-1997 14:57:37.00
SUBJECT:
Re:
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP
READ:UNKNOWN
@
EOP [ CEA I )
TEXT:
3:00 meeting.
http://172.28.127.30:8082/ARMS/servlet/getEmaiIArchive?URL] ATH=/nlcp-21Arms404/cea/C...
412012009
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES MAIL)
CREATOR: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD 1 )
CREATION DATE/TIME: 6-AUG-1997 17:08:57.00
SUBJECT:
Re:
TO: Sanders D. Korenman ( CN=Sanders D. Korenman/OU=CEA/O=EOP @ EOP [ CEA 1 )
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
nope; that was when my meeting with judy was.
i ' l l call you.
http://172.28.127.30:8082/ARMS/servletigetEmaiIArchive?URL_PATH=/nlcp-21Anns404/cea/C...
4/2012009
�ARMS Email System
RECORD TYPE: PRESIDENTIAL
Page 1 of 1
(NOTES READ RECEIPT)
CREATOR: Elena Kagan ( CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP [ OPD I
)
CREATION DATE/TIME:28-SEP-1998 14:48:34.00
SUBJECT: RECEIVED: OCT 14-CPI BRIEF BY KATHARINE ABRAHAM
TO: Francine P. Obermiller ( CN=Francine P. Obermiller/OU=CEA/O=EOP [ CEA I
READ:UNKNOWN
TEXT:
RETURN RECEIPT
Your Document:
OCT 14-CPI BRIEF BY KATHARINE ABRAHAM
was successfully received by:
CN=Elena Kagan/OU=OPD/O=EOP
at:
09/28/98 02:46:46 PM
)
�
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
Elena Kagan
Description
An account of the resource
<div>
<p>Elena Kagan worked as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999.</p>
<p>During her work at the White House Justice Kagan worked on many topics including, but not limited to: AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, Native Americans, and welfare.</p>
<p>In 1999 President Clinton nominated Kagan to the U.S. District Court of Appeals, no hearing was ever scheduled and she was thereby never confirmed.</p>
<p>Note: These records were made available in response to a <a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/freedom-of-information-act-requests">Freedom of Information Act (FOIA)</a> request, FOIA 2009-1006-F. This collection contains both records created by Elena Kagan and records concerning Elena Kagan. </p>
<p><strong>Descriptions of the Sub Collections:</strong></p>
<ul><li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+White+House+Counsel+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Counsel Files</a></strong><br /> These records consist of files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Associate Counsel to President Clinton from 1995 to 1996. The files include but are not limited to records concerning Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, and welfare. The records include memoranda, notes, correspondence, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Domestic+Policy+Council+Files&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Domestic Policy Council Files</a></strong><br />These records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan when she served as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. The files include records concerning domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, campaign finance reform, education, health, labor, race, tobacco, and welfare. The records include memoranda, correspondence, articles, and reports.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Staff+%26+Office+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Staff Files re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records are compiled from a variety of staff office files including the Chief of Staff, Personnel, Office of First Lady, Counsel, and DPC and include correspondence, memorandum, forms, and reports all concerning or having to do with Elena Kagan.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=White+House+Office+of+Records+Management+Files+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">White House Office of Records Management Files (WHORM)</a></strong><br />These records are from the White House Office of Records Management (WHORM) subject file series. The Clinton Presidential Library inherited a document-level index maintained by WHORM during the Clinton Administration which tracked some incoming correspondence and other documents as they were circulated throughout the White House and filed by WHORM. The records contain files created and received by Elena Kagan that were tracked by the WHORM Subject File index. The files include records related to a variety of topics such as memoranda, correspondence, and Domestic Policy Council weekly reports. The records are tracked by an alpha/numeric code, and are listed as such.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+1999+Nomination+to+U.S.+Court+of+Appeals&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's 1999 Nomination to U.S. Court of Appeals</a></strong><br />After serving as the Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council, Elena Kagan was nominated to serve on the U.S. Appeals Court for the District of Columbia (D.C. Circuit) in1999. Her nomination expired in 2000 without Senate action. The files in this opening contain records from the White House Staff and Office Files, Counsel’s Office and Presidential Personnel, concerning her nomination. The records consist of Senate Judiciary Committee questionnaires, correspondence, law review files, news articles, briefs, and press briefings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Received+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Received by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email received by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Email+Sent+by+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Email Sent by Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records consist of email sent by Elena Kagan during her time as Associate White House Counsel from 1995-1996 and Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (DPC) from 1997-1999. In addition to the email proper, these messages include forwards, reply chains, and attachments. The attached documents include notes, memorandum, articles, reports, executive orders, bills, and directives. These email concern a myriad of topics including but not limited to Amtrak, campaign finance reform, gaming/gambling (especially as it relates to Native Americans), timber, regulatory reform, welfare and domestic policy topics such as AIDS, budget appropriations, education, health, labor, race, and tobacco.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Elena+Kagan%27s+Records+re+Native+Americans&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Elena Kagan's Records re Native Americans</a></strong><br />These records were created or received by Elena Kagan during her service as Deputy Assistant to the President for Domestic Policy and Deputy Director of the Domestic Policy Council (1997-99). These ten folders were previously opened as part of a Freedom of Information Act request related to Native Americans (FOIA case <a href="http://www.clintonlibrary.gov/Documents/Finding-Aids/2006/2006-0197-F%28seg%203%29.pdf" target="_blank">2006-0197-F</a>).These records consist of memoranda, emails, reports, notes, and clippings.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Additional+Materials+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Additional Materials re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />These records were taken from the files of Elena Kagan. They include memos to, from, and relating to Elena Kagan’s work on Domestic Policy issues. The records include some memos from Elena Kagan to President Clinton.</li>
<li><strong><a href="http://clinton.presidentiallibraries.us/items/browse?search=&advanced%5B0%5D%5Belement_id%5D=70&advanced%5B0%5D%5Btype%5D=is+exactly&advanced%5B0%5D%5Bterms%5D=Federal+Email+re+Elena+Kagan&range=&collection=&type=&user=&tags=&public=&featured=&exhibit=&submit_search=Search+for+items">Federal Email re Elena Kagan</a></strong><br />The federal email re: Elena Kagan consists of 114 email messages that were part of the Federal side of the Clinton White House. The email generally consists of summaries of meetings or telephone conversations in which Elena Kagan was a participant.</li>
</ul></div>
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Clinton Presidential Records: White House Staff and Office Files
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Office of the Counsel to the President
Domestic Policy Council
First Lady's Office
White House Office of Records Management
Chief of Staff
White House Office for Women's Initiative and Outreach
Automated Records Management System
Tape Restoration Project
Security Office
Presidential Personnel
Date
A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource
1995-1999
Extent
The size or duration of the resource.
2945 folders
Text
A resource consisting primarily of words for reading. Examples include books, letters, dissertations, poems, newspapers, articles, archives of mailing lists. Note that facsimiles or images of texts are still of the genre Text.
Original Format
The type of object, such as painting, sculpture, paper, photo, and additional data
Magnetic Disk: Hard Drive
Dublin Core
The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.
Title
A name given to the resource
[05/26/1997 – 09/28/1998]
Creator
An entity primarily responsible for making the resource
Automated Records Management System
CEA
Identifier
An unambiguous reference to the resource within a given context
2009-1006-F
Is Part Of
A related resource in which the described resource is physically or logically included.
Email Sent by Elena Kagan
<a href="http://catalog.archives.gov/id/574745" target="_blank">National Archives Catalog Description</a>
Provenance
A statement of any changes in ownership and custody of the resource since its creation that are significant for its authenticity, integrity, and interpretation. The statement may include a description of any changes successive custodians made to the resource.
Clinton Presidential Records: Automated Records Management System
Format
The file format, physical medium, or dimensions of the resource
Adobe Acrobat Document
Publisher
An entity responsible for making the resource available
Clinton Presidential Library & Museum
Medium
The material or physical carrier of the resource.
Reproduction-Reference
Date Created
Date of creation of the resource.
6/18/2010
Source
A related resource from which the described resource is derived
ARMS - Box 015 - Folder 009
574745